Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S5 Ep6: GRD057: Should I Count on Social Security Being There for Me?
Transcript
- The Great Retirement Debate: When is the Best Time to Begin Taking Social Security? All right, everyone. Welcome back to the Great Retirement Debate. I'm Jeff Levine, joined as always by my friend and colleague Ed Slott. Ed, good to be back with you again. Great to be here on season five. This is a topic today that affects every senior, I have to say every family. When is the best time, the age old question, to begin taking Social Security tied with should I count on Social Security being there? Well, that could be part of the answer to the question. If you believe that Social Security is not going to be dared down in in the long run, then there is a little bit of a bias towards taking it sooner while you know it's here. But, you know, I think let's let's go back before we dive into our answers here and sort of set the stage as to why this is a question to begin with. So for the most part, if we're talking about someone's own Social Security benefit, if they have worked for ten years or longer and they've got their quote, unquote forty credits and they're sixty two or older, they are entitled to a retirement benefit. And this retirement benefit can be built, if you will, from as many as thirty five years worth of work. And in fact, whether you work thirty five years or not, Social Security looks at your highest thirty five years of earnings when calculating your benefit. So if you only work ten years, you get a bunch of zeros in there. But if we think about it, right, at sixty two, if you're gonna live to let's say you're gonna live to ninety five, that's thirty three years. You can also claim Social Security later at your quote unquote full retirement age, which for a lot of people today is sixty seven. But you can claim it even later than that. In fact, you can claim it as late as seventy. I guess, technically, you could claim it later than seventy, but there'd be no reason to do so. And and so Well, explain why. I mean, that caps it out. Yeah. Exactly. So basically, from sixty two to seventy, say, well, why wouldn't I take it early at sixty two? That's more years. Well, the reason why is from sixty two to seventy, using different mechanisms actually, the first part, it's a penalty for taking it early. In the second part, meaning after your full retirement age, it's a bonus, if you will, for not taking it sooner. But effectively, from sixty two to seventy, the longer you wait, the higher your Social Security benefit will be. Once you reach age seventy, there's no longer a benefit for waiting beyond that. So the question really becomes, if I'm entitled to take Social Security at sixty two, should I do so, or should I wait until sometime later, perhaps as late as age seventy, to do so? Here's the reason I think this is a key question, because I have my feelings on this. And I've seen people that I respect as financial advisors and tax advisors totally opposite on this. I'm taking it at sixty two, I want every dime, And I have other people, and this is the camp I'm in, which I did, wait till age seventy to get the largest check for life. Yeah, so I think, look, at the end of the day, there's a couple of ways you can look at Social Security. One is you can try to optimize to get the most money out of the system. And to do that, it's very simple. If you tell me the day you die, I will tell you exactly the day you could claim Social Security and you can optimize it. Now, of course, I say that with, you know, ingest somewhat, but the reality is that's it. Like, you have to make a a prediction as to when you're going to die if you want to make sure that you are optimizing the maximum dollar amount out of system. Now on the other hand, there is a longevity insurance factor to Social Security. And just like other insurances, you may not necessarily the goal is not necessarily to try and optimize dollars. It is to minimize risk. Right? Meaning, if you wait longer to claim your Social Security, then no matter how long you live, you will have more income per year than if you had taken it sooner. So, yes, it's true that if you wait until seventy and you get the highest possible Social Security check for that starting period, right, for seventy and then you die at seventy one, it is true that in retrospect, you would have gotten more dollars out of the system had you taken Social Security at sixty two. Right. The reality is most people don't know they're gonna die at seventy one when they make that decision. And if you died at seventy one You don't need anymore. You probably didn't run out of money. Right. That's okay. I mean, it's very sad that you died at a younger age, but you the the whole idea is you don't wanna run out of money. Delaying Social Security is probably the single greatest way to help avoid running out of money that there is in our system because it's guaranteed income by the federal government. We'll talk about solvency, I'm sure, in a bit. But guaranteed by the federal government. It is comparably tax efficient to most other things, which we'll talk about. And it's inflation adjusted, meaning as the cost of living goes up, so too do your Social Security payments. Maybe not exactly keeping pace with inflation, but at least helping to keep pace with inflation as the cost of goods and services rises throughout your potentially twenty, thirty plus year retirement. Right. I like the idea of personally having that big check and guaranteed everything you just said for life. And I'm also in that camp, what if you happen to die early? Well then you're fine, Right, you're okay, you didn't run out of money, congratulations. So look, I I a lot of times, every everybody's situation is different. Right? Single people have very different factors that go into this than married couples. But a lot of times, it's married couples looking at this as a a decision together. When should we claim Social Security? And there, what I what I think is really important for individuals to understand is it's if you're the higher earner especially, then it's not necessarily about when will I die. It's when will the second of us die. Right. The higher earner should stop focusing on their lifetime. They really should focus on the the last to die. So if maybe you're, you know, maybe you're sixty five years old today and your spouse is is also sixty five. You say, well, I'm in in terrible health, but my spouse, they're gonna live until, you know, they're a hundred and forty, healthy as a horse. Well, if you're the higher earner, even though even if you died at seventy in one day, like, you got your first Social Security check, you were so excited that, boom, you dropped dead of a heart attack right there on the spot, it wouldn't maximize your lifetime income. But if your surviving spouse lived long enough, it could still actually maximize income for the two of you. So in married couple situations, what I often encourage people to do is the higher earner should think more about when the second death will occur, and that lower earner can think a little bit more like if the couple as a whole wants to get a a taste, if you will, of Social Security income. Right? They wanna start nibbling at Social Security income. Then do it with the lower earner's check because that lower earner's check goes away no matter who dies first. If the higher earner dies first, the higher earner's check goes to the lower earner. The lower earner's check goes away. If the lower earner dies first, the higher earner keeps on receiving their check for the rest of their life. So it's sometimes not just looking at your lifetime, but over the longer of the lifetimes for a married couple. And you have to look at the other assets available, say, during your sixties. That's right. In many cases, you know, people might choose to use portfolio income, let's say IRA money Right. And trade it, if you will, for more dollars of Social Security later on. And look, even in that, if you if you could promise me that I could have an equivalent amount of dollars later in life in Social Security income by spending more in IRA money today, I would take that because in general, my IRA income is gonna be taxed dollar for dollar as I take it out. Whereas Social Security in a worst case scenario is only taxed eighty five cents on the dollar. And I know some people listening are like, that's eighty five cents more than they promised. Maybe so. But it's still not a dollar for every dollar you take you receive in Social Security. So it's still more tax efficient than other forms of income. Not only that, it's seventy well, at seventy three or whatever the RMD age is, RMDs will be lower. Alright. All all of that true. But Yeah. You know, we are about presenting things in an unbiased objective manner. Right. Looking at both sides of the coin. So so far we've talked a lot about why someone might wait to take it. Let's talk a little bit more about why someone might take it. Well, two reasons, health and lack of other funds. Okay. Yep. And so health, certainly, like if you're pretty confident that you're you have a shorter life expectancy, and let's say you're not married, and you're not the or you're not the higher earner. Because if you're married in the higher earner, it still might pay, as we just talked about, to delay. But, yep. If your life expectancy is ancy is short and you're either single or you're the lower earner in a married couple, then yes, it certainly could pay to take that Social Security earlier. As you said, you might really wanna wait, but you may not have a choice. Right, you might have got laid off at age sixty, you need the money. Yep. Sometimes it it just is it is what it is and you have to make the best of an unfortunate situation. My my question to people in those situations is always, well, if you're in this situation now, how is it going to be any easier when you're eighty five or ninety? And look, sometimes people just go, I don't know, but I don't care. You know, I know where I am right now. I don't know that I'll be here at eighty five or ninety. And look, I I I get it. Those are difficult decisions. And as long as people make it with full information and eyes wide open, people are entitled to make the decisions that they feel are are best for them. But but I think it's fair to say if you need the money now, you might need it even more later when it's going to be even harder to go back to work. I'll throw one more in there as well, and and you mentioned it, and that is solvency. Right. There's actually three reasons. I need the money, health, I won't live that long, and I wanna get it while it's here. That's right. There are look, there's a reasonable reasonable people can disagree on how likely it is that Social Security will be here in its current form for the long term. But as is as we sit here today, what we can say with with a high degree of confidence is that if there are no changes made between now and the time that, twenty thirty three ish comes along, that Social Security will no longer be able to fully pay the benefits that it has promised folks. It will likely deliver benefits about eighty cents on the dollar. And so there are folks out there who believe that if my income is going to get cut, well, I should probably take it now sooner so that I get more years of a benefit before it is cut. I would also, in the interest of being balanced here, say if Social Security is going to be cut in the future, isn't there an argument to be made that waiting and having an even higher amount is more important? Because if you're only going to get a portion of it I'm have eighty percent of a A eighty percent of a bigger number is still a bigger number than eighty percent of a smaller number, yep. And then you talk about the day, and they change it all the time, when Social Security's supposed to go insolvent. I think what you said is two thousand and thirty three. So I'm thinking about my license renewal. That's longer now than when Social Security, twenty six. It's scary how close it's It's thirty years away. It is. Now, but in fairness, look, I I do like to point out that we've been here before when it comes to Social Security. Back in the nineteen eighties, Social Security was running out of money. And the government formed the Greenspan Commission to try and figure out how to resolve this, and they did so. And they made changes back in nineteen eighty three. I remember that always because it's the year I was born. And the changes And you were thinking of Social Security then? The moment I came out, I was thinking about Social Security. And here we are, you know, somewhere forty three years later. Yes. But, you know, the the changes made in nineteen eighty three were projected to, at that time, help Social Security last for another fifty years. Well, if we look at what it's supposed to run out of money, it's basically fifty years to the day. Yeah. And those changes that they made are still only impacting people today. For instance, back in nineteen eighty three, that's when they made the change to the full retirement age where it would gradually rise from sixty six to sixty seven, which is currently the phase we're in for those retiring. So it it is likely that our politicians at some point before twenty thirty three, maybe not too far before, but before twenty thirty three, we'll get their act together and do something to keep Social Security solvent. And I think most people are on the side that says people receiving benefits today or those close to it will probably not have much change to their benefits. You don't know that for sure, but there's a good likelihood, at least most experts believe that. I agree with that. Older people tend to vote more, and they call it the third rail. They don't call it the third rail for nothing. Absolutely. It is a third rail for Congress. That would be a very tough one. They would find it, my opinion again, they would find other money to make it whole or somewhat whole. Yeah, so we're talking about the best time to take Social Security. It really does revolve around a lot of different dynamics. Whether you're married, whether you're single. It could impact, whether you're planning to get remarried can actually impact whether you take Social Security. There are opportunities sometimes to get remarried at a later date simply to continue to receive payments based on a deceased spouse. So they like, there are all these wrinkles, but ultimately, it comes down to everybody's situation is different. And some people should wait more. Some people should claim earlier. We can't say for definitively what anyone per one we can't say definitively what any one person should do from from this position. But what I think, Ed, we can say with relative confidence is that when you look at the statistics, far too many people claim too early. Right? That that I think we can say. And so more people should wait. Exactly what you should do, well, that's different. But we know what you we know one thing you should do for certain, and that is get yourself educated. Right? Make sure you know the rules. Listen to programs like this. Read books. Read articles. You know, we can't say for certain when any one individual should take Social Security. But what we can say for certain is that based on the statistics, there are far too many people who claim Social Security early. So hopefully, we can encourage more people to at least think about this and with better information. And ultimately, Ed, that is what we are about here. Believers that consumers with more information make better decisions, and that better decisions on the whole lead to better outcomes. And Ed, that's the mission that you and I are on, helping more of you get to better outcomes in retirement for you and your family. So thanks so much for joining us here on this episode of the great retirement debate, and we'll see you real soon. Jeffrey Levine is chief planning officer at Focus Partners. This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as specific investment, accounting, legal, or tax advice. Certain information mentioned may be based on third party information which may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice. Third party information is deemed to be reliable, but its accuracy and completeness cannot be guaranteed. The topic discussed and corresponding arguments are those of the speakers and may not accurately reflect those of focused partners.