Latest / No Way Out / Rethinking Market Narratives: Mastering Trend Following with Alex Krainer
Transcript
- 0:21Mark McGrath: So I think you're the second person I've ever met that lives in Monaco, so we want to welcome you to the show.
- 0:28Mark McGrath: We know it's not a very big area and, of course, all we know about it is Princess Grace and the Grand Prix.
- 0:34Mark McGrath: It's also a pretty good port of call, if you're stopping.
- 0:39Mark McGrath: Alex, you look at the world through a much different lens.
- 0:43Mark McGrath: When years ago, when I read your trend following Bible and your book about uncertainty and commodities, it resonated with me and I know it would resonate with Ponch and others that we talk about, because it provides basically a framework of how to look at things differently, knowing that you can't know the future, you can't know what's going to happen.
- 1:02Mark McGrath: You can only anticipate and be ready to make moves and involved with that, and we're going to recommend your sub stack and people look at your trend compass and things like that.
- 1:12Mark McGrath: I mean you clearly look at the world in a much different way, which is interesting because I think it challenges assumptions, and a lot of the assumptions that we get in the mainstream from the media and others need to be challenged and I think that you do a very good, a very consistent job of that.
- 1:28Mark McGrath: So that's how I knew of you and we're grateful that you come in and spend time with us and share some of that insight.
- 1:35Mark McGrath: And what would you share with our listeners and hopefully help them to shatter their models of what they think things actually are and start to be more curious and ask more questions about what, the way things actually are, not what's portrayed to them, if that makes sense?
- 1:51Alex Krainer: well, okay, so I'll rewind the clock to me graduating from a university, and I was.
- 1:58Alex Krainer: I was the geek's geek, you know, I was the nerd I that graduated magna cum laude, top of the class, and I thought, you know, I applied myself because I believed all the crap that we were being taught in school.
- 2:11Alex Krainer: Right, I thought it made sense, it was well packaged up, my parents paid for it through their nose and then I got into the world.
- 2:21Alex Krainer: And then, you know, you get slapped in the face, you get slapped around a little bit and then you realize that everything you were taught isn't exactly what you need to know.
- 2:31Alex Krainer: And then, the farther you go, the farther what they teach you in school and what you experience in life diverges.
- 2:39Alex Krainer: And well, eventually I found myself in a job of market analyst for an oil trading company.
- 2:45Alex Krainer: Well, it was principally oil trading, but we traded other commodities as well.
- 2:49Alex Krainer: And so here I was.
- 2:51Alex Krainer: You know I got everything I needed.
- 2:54Alex Krainer: You know the computer systems, the subscriptions to this, and that I was immersed in a lot of.
- 3:00Alex Krainer: You know fundamentals data and I was going to work it out how to trade the markets supply, demand.
- 3:04Alex Krainer: You know fundamentals data and I was going to work it out, how to trade the markets, supply, demand.
- 3:08Alex Krainer: You know this and that, and of course none of it worked.
- 3:13Alex Krainer: And it was a particular point in time.
- 3:17Alex Krainer: That was, you know, it was a.
- 3:20Alex Krainer: It was a.
- 3:20Alex Krainer: It was a teachable interval, not moment, but interval.
- 3:24Alex Krainer: It was 1990s.
- 3:27Alex Krainer: I started working at this oil trading company in Monaco in 1996.
- 3:31Alex Krainer: And so in 97, the company was started by guys who you know have been trading since the 70s, old hands, and they barely knew how to switch on the computer.
- 3:43Alex Krainer: And they asked me, since I was the most computer literate, to tell them no, to figure out a way to analyze the markets more systematically, because what they had in mind is to produce, let's say, high probability, short-term forecasts of where the price might go.
- 4:02Alex Krainer: So I don't know, oil price is 75 bucks a barrel today.
- 4:06Alex Krainer: If we could know with an 80% probability what it might be over the next week, then hey, we could trade that.
- 4:12Alex Krainer: And so I very quickly realized that that didn't make any sense at all.
- 4:16Alex Krainer: There's just simply no way to predict future events with any degree of probability.
- 4:22Alex Krainer: You can calculate all those things on the basis of past data, but there's no way that you can project that into the future and say, because of that old data, then the future is going to look like this.
- 4:37Alex Krainer: But what was happening at that time?
- 4:39Alex Krainer: So in 1997, crude oil was trading in the, let's say, low 20s $20, $22, $23 a barrel and you'll recall that that was the time of the dot-com boom and so the economy was going on all cylinders, it was growing.
- 4:59Alex Krainer: It was really a good time for the economy, really a good time for the economy.
- 5:03Alex Krainer: And so we in the oil industry sat there and thought there's no way that the crude oil was going anywhere but up, because also at the same time, the capital was favoring technology investments and internet and biotech and communications and all of these things related to the emergence of the internet, and so the investments in oil exploration, refining, distribution, all of this was constrained.
- 5:34Alex Krainer: So everybody in the oil industry but everybody knew that the oil prices were going nowhere but up.
- 5:44Alex Krainer: And then, over the next two years until the start of 1999, they more than halved, they went into single digits.
- 5:50Alex Krainer: It was almost a straight line.
- 5:53Alex Krainer: So if you can imagine going to work to an oil trading company for two years, and for two years you're wrong and you're getting your teeth kicked every day, it's not a whole lot of fun.
- 6:12Alex Krainer: And then also, in this same teachable interval, we had the NASDAQ go practically vertical and since the day I started in the job everybody was complaining that the equities were overpriced, that it's all going to crash.
- 6:30Alex Krainer: It was in December 1996 that Alan Greenspan gave that speech about irrational exuberance, right, and then from that moment until the peak, I think that the NASDAQ went up something like four or five times and it added 110% in the last five months of that rally.
- 6:56Alex Krainer: So again, even on stocks we were wrong this whole entire interval from 96 until 2000.
- 7:04Alex Krainer: And I was there with know I was, I was given a budget, I hired some you know some software people and some science, you know math guys, and we were working all these theories and trying to somehow integrate the fundamentals and discern probabilities and and nothing was really you know like nothing really seemed compelling, except that these huge trends were staring us in the face the oil price going down even though everybody knew that it had to go up, and the equity prices going up, even though everybody knew they were overvalued and they had to crash.
- 7:46Alex Krainer: And so I thought what's the point of complaining that the markets are wrong, because we got it right when we're losing money right?
- 7:54Alex Krainer: Isn't the whole point of trading to make money?
- 7:57Alex Krainer: And so I said look, it's moving with the trend.
- 8:02Alex Krainer: You think everybody's stupid.
- 8:04Alex Krainer: But the price is going down, the oil price and the stock prices are going up, so why don't we try to make money rather than trying to prove how we're right and the whole market is wrong?
- 8:19Alex Krainer: And so you know, that's when the light bulb went off in my head, and then, from that point on, we started thinking like okay, so if markets move in trend, then what are trends?
- 8:32Alex Krainer: And so, of course, there were already hedge funds out there who were using trend following for decades.
- 8:40Alex Krainer: I just didn't know anything about this.
- 8:42Alex Krainer: I was in the commodity space, but physical, you know.
- 8:45Alex Krainer: We were literally moving tankers around, and so we didn't know anything about this.
- 8:50Alex Krainer: So we basically started from a blank sheet of paper and my take was okay, if I look at a price chart of something and I arrive at a judgment that this is an uptrend or this is a downtrend, then I assume that my brain must be doing some kind of a trigonometry in my head that produces this judgment.
- 9:13Alex Krainer: So I said let's try to work it out what it is and reverse, engineer something that is maybe similar, but with the advantage that it can work numerically, without distraction, without fear, without greed, you know, without any kind of emotional distortion.
- 9:32Alex Krainer: And so that's what we did, and we kind of came up with like five tentative definitions of what could make a trend, and then we designed algorithms around it that did those calculations.
- 9:51Alex Krainer: And then we tested it and the system was doing what we wanted it to do.
- 9:56Alex Krainer: And then you know, obviously you know this was, I would say it's a form of artificial intelligence because it generates judgment first, and judgment is something that fluctuates.
- 10:08Alex Krainer: It's not a yes or no answer.
- 10:11Alex Krainer: It fluctuates on a range of confidence.
- 10:15Alex Krainer: You can be certain about something or you can be completely ambivalent.
- 10:20Alex Krainer: So we said, okay, certainty is going to be one, ambivalent is going to be zero, and every day we're going to have some value that goes between one and zero.
- 10:31Alex Krainer: And so we you know, this trend confidence function ended up doing what we wanted it to do, except now that we made it numeric, it had the advantage that we could now say like okay, so let's now see what level of confidence justifies risk taking.
- 10:50Alex Krainer: And so we set the thresholds and we said like, okay, when confidence is this or higher, then we go long.
- 10:57Alex Krainer: And then you know, in the inverse, if the trend is down, if it falls below some threshold, then we start trading short.
- 11:05Alex Krainer: And what turned out, what came out of this, is that the best trading results we got when the confidence was less than 50% right Now.
- 11:18Alex Krainer: This is the advantage of the machine, because as a human, it's very hard for me to take risk when my confidence is very low.
- 11:24Alex Krainer: As a human, it's very hard for me to take risk when my confidence is very low.
- 11:26Alex Krainer: So, as a human, you know you sit there.
- 11:28Alex Krainer: And when your confidence is full on, that's when you're ready to trade.
- 11:31Alex Krainer: But that's maybe when you're too late, when most of the you know the trend is obvious, so you risk coming in near the peak.
- 11:41Alex Krainer: So that's you know.
- 11:43Alex Krainer: That's how I went into trend following and it made perfect sense to me.
- 11:48Alex Krainer: So I pretty much remained committed to trend following the rest of my life, and I still am.
- 11:54Alex Krainer: And not only is this now my bread and butter, my daily bread and butter, I've also found that trend following is an excellent school of life in general.
- 12:09Mark McGrath: Tell us more about that.
- 12:10Mark McGrath: Unpack that a little bit.
- 12:12Alex Krainer: Okay, I'm glad you asked.
- 12:13Alex Krainer: Well, you know, first of all, any worthy endeavor in life that you want to tackle, that you want to give yourself as a challenge, you have to take risks right.
- 12:26Alex Krainer: So, with trading, if you want any profits, if you want to generate positive returns, you have to take risks.
- 12:34Alex Krainer: Risk-free returns are what everybody gets, the illusory let's call it three percent that you can get from, I don't know, treasury bonds.
- 12:50Alex Krainer: Maybe it's a bit more now four, four percent, but you know that's that.
- 12:53Alex Krainer: And then you don't move, except that inflation is eating at that.
- 12:57Alex Krainer: So you're mute.
- 12:59Mark McGrath: You're mute mark yeah, so basically just like holding your cash and doing nothing.
- 13:03Mark McGrath: Yeah, exactly, that's the risk-free.
- 13:05Alex Krainer: Risk-free is like mattress so long as it doesn't catch on fire Right.
- 13:08Alex Krainer: And so, if you want to generate positive returns, you have to take risks.
- 13:12Alex Krainer: And then, if you take risks, you have to make certain decisions, hopefully formulate some kind of a strategy about how you're going to go about this strategy, about how you're going to go about this.
- 13:26Alex Krainer: And then, when you implement that strategy, maybe you're going to get lucky and things are going to go your way and you're going to be redeemed.
- 13:33Alex Krainer: Or maybe you're going to hit a lousy period and it's going to go against you.
- 13:38Alex Krainer: And now you're going to have to ask yourself well, crap, either I went out at the wrong time, so the market conditions are unfavorable and I'm losing, or my strategy is wrong, my strategy doesn't work, so you're going to have to.
- 13:55Alex Krainer: You know like it's a time of deep introspection.
- 13:59Alex Krainer: And then you know, you do your homework, you revise your strategy, you look into all assumptions that you made, you look at the algorithms that you built.
- 14:10Alex Krainer: Is everything, do I still believe everything that I have in my autopilot programmed in?
- 14:18Alex Krainer: And then, if you still agree with yourself, right, if you haven't lost faith, if you still agree with yourself, right, if you haven't lost faith.
- 14:30Alex Krainer: Then you have to decide do I persevere or do I quit?
- 14:35Alex Krainer: Do I want to not do this anymore, because it's painful to be losing money in the markets, right?
- 14:37Alex Krainer: So you have to decide do I persevere or do I quit?
- 14:39Alex Krainer: And if you quit, you cut it off at a loss and you go do do something else, defeat it.
- 14:46Alex Krainer: Or if you persevere, maybe you reverse the losses and you carry on.
- 14:52Alex Krainer: And then you have to also decide how much do I risk on every individual bet?
- 14:58Alex Krainer: What do I expect to get back?
- 15:01Alex Krainer: How long does my dry powder have to stay dry?
- 15:05Alex Krainer: How long is the famine interval going to last?
- 15:10Alex Krainer: When is the feast beginning?
- 15:12Alex Krainer: How do I manage the feast?
- 15:14Alex Krainer: You know, like it's all, it's I.
- 15:18Alex Krainer: When I was a kid, I used to play water polo.
- 15:21Alex Krainer: Water polo was my sport, you know, and you know I went, we went into competitions and tournaments and played.
- 15:27Alex Krainer: It's very similar.
- 15:29Alex Krainer: You know you have to work hard, you have to train, you have to practice, you have to be prepared, and then you have to play and face adversity and the uncertainty Are you going to win, are you going to lose?
- 15:42Alex Krainer: And then you know, you manage the euphoria of winning and then you manage the let's call it the distress in losing and you have to learn how to digest that.
- 15:55Alex Krainer: And you have to learn how to stay focused and centered and keep true to your strategy, what you're doing, not succumb to despair, not lose your head in successful days.
- 16:11Alex Krainer: And you have to earn the success by sitting through maybe long periods of adversity and doubt and soul searching and all of that.
- 16:22Alex Krainer: And then you also learn that it has a different temporal scale from what you envision in your mind, because in your mind you think like, okay, I trade and make money.
- 16:34Alex Krainer: Yeah, okay, but that's a long time that might take.
- 16:40Alex Krainer: Many, many Trend followers are reliable over periods of time that are three years or longer, whereas any given year or six-month period or month could be negative.
- 16:54Alex Krainer: So let's say, to have success you have whether you do sports, whether you do music, whether you're a stand-up comedian or a lawyer or anything you have to go through that and to become successful you have to kind of know what you stand for, what you're doing.
- 17:19Alex Krainer: You have to present yourself as that to the market, to the potential clients, to present yourself as that to the market, to the potential clients, and you have to face the reality that they're not going to all fall for your offer and become clients on your first attempt.
- 17:33Alex Krainer: You might have to circle around many times, take many rejections and digest many failures before you start to see the thing turn around and then grow more robust and more, let's say, more resembling of a success.
- 18:50Mark McGrath: It's now avoiding the risk or the work, in other words.
- 18:54Alex Krainer: That's right, and you realize that if you want to avoid the risk and the work, then it's slow death.
- 19:01Alex Krainer: You know what I mean.
- 19:03Alex Krainer: You're already losing, because I think it seems to me that life, at least in the matrix in which we live, life is kind of a slow river that's always taking you downstream.
- 19:18Alex Krainer: Where you want to go is upstream, and so if you don't exert yourself, even if you don't notice yourself, even if you don't notice it, even if you're momentarily comfortable, chilled, it's still going backwards slowly.
- 19:32Brian Rivera: Yeah.
- 19:32Brian Rivera: So I want to recap a few things that I heard from Alex and just back and forth with Mark right now.
- 19:37Brian Rivera: So allostasis is the ability to stability through change.
- 19:41Brian Rivera: Right, you have to do the work.
- 19:42Brian Rivera: You have to do that.
- 19:43Brian Rivera: We talk about that all the time.
- 19:44Brian Rivera: So I'm glad Alex brought that up.
- 19:46Brian Rivera: There's resulting and outcome bias where things happen that may go against what your decision process is.
- 19:52Brian Rivera: We know that to be true in the OODA loop, where your internal orientation and your internal processes doesn't guarantee you a certain outcome, a positive outcome.
- 20:02Brian Rivera: Right, so you have to look at the external environment and go okay, what am I doing?
- 20:05Brian Rivera: Right or wrong?
- 20:06Brian Rivera: And luck always has a say in an outcome.
- 20:11Brian Rivera: Right, so your process may be right.
- 20:13Brian Rivera: You got to go back and evaluate that.
- 20:14Brian Rivera: And then we lightly touched on process here, which would be the trend following Over time.
- 20:19Brian Rivera: It seems to work.
- 20:20Brian Rivera: So, Alex, in what I just shared with you and Mark, is there anything you can add to that or maybe that I have wrong in what I just shared back?
- 20:28Alex Krainer: Not really, Ponch.
- 20:29Alex Krainer: I think you got it exactly right.
- 20:31Alex Krainer: I mean, in different words, you just said exactly what I tried to lay out as my thinking in this.
- 20:39Alex Krainer: So if you're wrong, then we're both wrong.
- 20:43Brian Rivera: No.
- 20:43Brian Rivera: And then the idea of a river is a flow system, right?
- 20:45Brian Rivera: So we want to increase the flow of information in a system the market, if you will is a flow system.
- 20:51Brian Rivera: It's a living system.
- 20:52Brian Rivera: It's a complex adapted system.
- 20:53Brian Rivera: So the physics of flow systems still apply to markets.
- 20:58Brian Rivera: I'm curious about forgive me for not knowing this, but why does the period have to be over three years?
- 21:02Brian Rivera: To Let me give you an analogy first.
- 21:04Brian Rivera: So blackjack, when you play blackjack, it's what?
- 21:07Brian Rivera: 51% in your favor if you go by the rules, right?
- 21:09Brian Rivera: So if trend following is working, if I understand you correctly, the rule says over a period of three years, you should be winning right.
- 21:18Alex Krainer: Well, the reason is because markets don't always trend.
- 21:21Alex Krainer: You know, among CTAs, among trend followers, there's this consensus, which I think is broadly correct, that markets trend about one third of the time and then they correct and consolidate about two thirds of the time.
- 21:37Alex Krainer: I think that's about right, and the nature of trend following is such that during market trends I like to call them large scale price events During large scale price events, you almost invariably make money.
- 21:52Alex Krainer: So when the markets take off you know at present time, you know we could relate this to the bull market in equities, which maybe just ended yesterday.
- 22:01Alex Krainer: We don't know.
- 22:02Alex Krainer: We could relate to Bitcoin, things like Nvidia, Tesla, Apple, a lot of these things you see that they go and then everybody who's long, they make money.
- 22:18Alex Krainer: Or if something collapses in price and if you're short, then you're doing well.
- 22:25Alex Krainer: I don't know.
- 22:25Alex Krainer: I had short positions on US treasuries not just US, also German and British pretty much since 2020.
- 22:35Alex Krainer: It shifted from net long to net short, but mostly it was net short.
- 22:41Alex Krainer: Long to net short, but mostly it was net short.
- 22:46Alex Krainer: And so in that period you almost invariably make money.
- 22:48Alex Krainer: But then you will have long periods of time when nothing happens.
- 22:51Alex Krainer: Prices consolidate, they drift in a horizontal range and, as a trend follower, in those conditions you're almost certain to at best not make any money, but most likely you're going to be losing money.
- 23:05Alex Krainer: Why?
- 23:05Alex Krainer: Because trend following reacts to price fluctuations.
- 23:09Alex Krainer: Right, it doesn't predict them, it reacts to them.
- 23:12Alex Krainer: So when the price of something starts to move higher, you make the judgment oh look, this is an uptrend, I'm going to go long.
- 23:21Alex Krainer: So if the large-scale price event unfolds and the price goes much, much higher, then you made money.
- 23:30Alex Krainer: But in a consolidation, what happens is the price goes up and then it corrects back down, and then maybe there you go like oh no, it's a downtrend, you go short, and then it goes back up, you lose again and it goes back down after you go long again, and so forth.
- 23:48Alex Krainer: So if you I don't know if you go to investingcom today and you take a look at the price of Cocoa over the last two years, you'll see that Cocoa has done phenomenal.
- 24:02Alex Krainer: So it's been trading between $2,000 and $3,000 a ton for more than 10 years, I think.
- 24:13Alex Krainer: And then I think in 2022 or 23, it starts to go up, and so at that point you're going to go long.
- 24:23Alex Krainer: Well, this time it went into an accelerating uptre, and so at that point you're going to go long.
- 24:25Alex Krainer: Well, this time it went into an accelerating uptrend.
- 24:27Alex Krainer: It reached $10,000, right.
- 24:30Alex Krainer: So now you made a huge windfall from that move.
- 24:35Alex Krainer: And then it goes into a consolidation, into a correction and consolidation that lasted the best part of the last year, and then that consolidation finished and in this consolidation you got whipsawed badly, you know.
- 24:50Alex Krainer: You went short near the bottom and then you went long again near the top and you got whipsawed there, and then it launched into an uptrend again from about $8,000 a ton and I think that now it's close to $13,000.
- 25:12Alex Krainer: And so you're never going to be able to trade this in a way that you buy it there at $2,000 a ton and then you're going to stay long until $10,000, and you're going to sell at the top and then you're going to be optimal and make $10 trillion on this curve.
- 25:32Alex Krainer: But let's say that through this whole long period of time, if you've done your homework correctly, if your strategy is okay, then you should have made more money in these large-scale price events than you lost during the corrections and consolidations, and so it's not a terribly sexy strategy.
- 25:54Alex Krainer: It's not exciting, like I don't know, gambling in a casino and getting a big win or something like this, but it's a process that, over long periods of time, should just generally allow you to generate positive returns.
- 26:13Alex Krainer: And then I think that one of my favorite things about trend following is that you're only basing all your decisions on the price curve, on the analysis of the price fluctuations, so that you learn the rules of when do we go long and when do we go short and when are we out.
- 26:33Alex Krainer: And so once you've mastered navigating the trends, then you can apply it to anything, to anything.
- 26:49Alex Krainer: If I'm an expert on oil markets and I'm analyzing fundamentals, then I know that market and I can trade oil market, but I can't trade coffee or cotton or cocoa or Bitcoin right, you can't know everything about everything Well with trend following.
- 27:05Alex Krainer: If you're just analyzing the price curve, you can trade anything at all, and in my career, most of the things that I've traded and I trade I have no idea I know what coffee tastes like, but that's about it.
- 27:22Mark McGrath: In other words, you're not letting your bias or your knowledge of something override the judgment.
- 27:27Mark McGrath: To get in or out, or stay out of it.
- 27:30Alex Krainer: Yes, you don't Right Exactly.
- 27:33Alex Krainer: You just execute every decision as it comes out of the machine, you agree, you disagree, it doesn't matter.
- 27:42Alex Krainer: As it comes out of the machine, you agree, you disagree, it doesn't matter, Because you know the gains.
- 27:51Alex Krainer: Here's the difference between fundamentals orientation and the systematic trend following orientation.
- 27:53Alex Krainer: When you do fundamental analysis, you basically analyze the conditions and you try to understand what the consequences of those conditions might be.
- 28:01Alex Krainer: So let's say, in the 90s we analyzed the conditions of those conditions might be.
- 28:04Alex Krainer: So let's say, in the 90s we analyze the conditions of the oil market.
- 28:06Alex Krainer: It's getting constrained, the supply is shrinking, the demand is growing, so therefore oil prices should go up.
- 28:15Alex Krainer: And then you have a certain conviction to go long and to trade long to buy oil, anticipating price rises.
- 28:25Alex Krainer: With systematic trend following, you simply apply a set of pre-formulated rules.
- 28:30Alex Krainer: So you formulated a set of rules and now you apply them.
- 28:34Alex Krainer: And you apply them knowing that roughly every other trade is going to be a loser.
- 28:40Alex Krainer: So you're not putting on a trade because you have a conviction that that trade is going to make you money.
- 28:46Alex Krainer: You're just simply relying on the process in which any individual trade might be a loser, but a long sequence of these trades you trust will ultimately gain you more profits than what you're going to have in losses and crap.
- 29:10Alex Krainer: I'm sorry, a mosquito just flew in.
- 29:12Alex Krainer: Can you believe that it's December?
- 29:14Mark McGrath: Huh, his ambush Could be a drone.
- 29:20Alex Krainer: Yeah, it could be.
- 29:21Mark McGrath: That size.
- 29:22Alex Krainer: You think, yeah, I love Joe Biden, it's could be a drone.
- 29:25Alex Krainer: Yeah, it could be that size.
- 29:26Alex Krainer: You think, yeah, I love Joe Biden, it's not moving, anyway, yeah.
- 29:28Mark McGrath: Now it's not going to detonate, we'll edit this part out.
- 29:32Alex Krainer: You know the approach is completely different, in the sense that you're not engaging in trades because you think you understand what's going to happen Right.
- 29:40Alex Krainer: You're just putting them on because that's what your rule set suggests, and you know that any individual trade might be a loser, but you know that over a long sequence of these trades in, out, in, out, in, out, in out you're going to make more than what you're going to lose, and so, therefore, your performance is going to be positive.
- 30:01Alex Krainer: Your performance is going to be positive and then, as trend following allows you to diversify, because you're no longer constrained by your narrow expertise of a certain industry or a certain geography or whatever you can trade any curve you want.
- 30:17Alex Krainer: You can trade Bitcoin, you can trade coffee, you can trade crude oil or dollar markets.
- 30:22Alex Krainer: Basically all markets, basically all markets.
- 30:25Alex Krainer: You know, diversification is pretty much the only free lunch in speculation.
- 30:31Mark McGrath: That and compounding interest right.
- 30:33Alex Krainer: Well, compounding interest, yeah, but it works both ways, in the sense that if you're in debt, that's not good.
- 30:40Alex Krainer: It's not good.
- 30:42Mark McGrath: It's not good when it goes south.
- 30:43Mark McGrath: No, I mean, you know a lot of the trend following talk.
- 30:50Mark McGrath: I mean, certainly I think it's the minority of people that would ever do trend following, because it does require the ability to let go a lot of your cognitive biases, a lot of your um uh just, you know a lot of the things that we're overcoming psychologically or emotionally.
- 31:02Mark McGrath: You eradicate that by having a rules-based trend following system.
- 31:07Alex Krainer: You don't have to be an expert on, as you say, you don't have to be an expert on any of the commodities and you're functioning on the one known truth that you can see the price right, the price action Exactly, and the price is the only type of information in the market that is concrete, it's not subject to interpretation, it's true and it's timely, so it doesn't have to wait for somebody at the Fed or somebody at the labor department to tally up all these things and tabulate them and then report them in a finalized form.
- 31:45Alex Krainer: You get the prices in real time practically for free, so that raw material is available there to you.
- 31:54Alex Krainer: It's true, because that's what the prices that you see are, prices at which transactions have been concluded.
- 32:04Alex Krainer: So this is what the buyers were willing to pay and the sellers willing to accept to sell.
- 32:09Brian Rivera: Yeah, you get instant feedback from that, that's the.
- 32:11Alex Krainer: Thing.
- 32:12Brian Rivera: You get instant feedback.
- 32:13Brian Rivera: You don't have to wait.
- 32:14Alex Krainer: Exactly, it's the price discovery process.
- 32:17Alex Krainer: How do you call it?
- 32:18Alex Krainer: It's one of the most essential mechanisms of the modern society, one of the most relevant mechanisms in modern society that you know, ideally, should decide how we allocate capital, how we make our investment decisions, our purchase decisions, our, you know, short-term and long-term life strategies, and everything.
- 32:45Brian Rivera: I'm curious, alex, are you familiar with anybody combining traditional analysis with trend following?
- 32:49Brian Rivera: And let me give you some context here.
- 32:52Brian Rivera: In the cockpit, when I used to fly, we had multiple systems to look at.
- 32:56Brian Rivera: Right, you have a primary thing you need to look at and all that.
- 32:58Brian Rivera: So, if you think about like multi-sensory integration or multi-sensory observations from the external world, that gives you information about what's going on in and around the cockpit, I'm curious is trend following just focused on one dial in the cockpit or do you see it being more looking at a broader picture?
- 33:17Alex Krainer: Well, the dial I look.
- 33:18Alex Krainer: I look at two dials, let's call it that way.
- 33:21Alex Krainer: One is the trend confidence right.
- 33:24Alex Krainer: So for any given market, are we in an uptrend or are we in a downtrend, and how confident are we that this is in fact what we're seeing at the moment?
- 33:32Alex Krainer: And then that dial is the product of a network of algorithms, so it's like a neural network that you know, like you have a number of experts feeding the information to like an executive process that questions every expert and every day calculates a weighted average of these answers and says like okay, this is what I think we're seeing today.
- 33:57Alex Krainer: And then the other dial is when it tells me buy or sell, and that one is okay.
- 34:04Alex Krainer: So let's say the first dial says it's an uptrend.
- 34:07Alex Krainer: Then, when the other one says buy, that's a signal to enter long into the market, right.
- 34:15Alex Krainer: When it says sell, it's a signal to exit the market.
- 34:19Alex Krainer: Whereas if the dial is signaling downtrend, then a buy would be a signal to close a short position, if any, and a sell would be a signal to open a short position.
- 34:31Alex Krainer: That's the two dials.
- 34:33Alex Krainer: Now you asked me if I know anybody who tried to combine the traditional market analysis and trend following, and I do, and that's me.
- 34:40Alex Krainer: So when we built our model, I thought that we need to leave the system open to human judgment and human expertise.
- 34:50Alex Krainer: So we created an algorithm that would, let's say, poll a number of experts.
- 34:58Alex Krainer: So I thought, okay, so we have a couple of oil market experts in our company and we can ask them every day to say do you think the trend is up or down?
- 35:09Alex Krainer: How confident do you feel?
- 35:11Alex Krainer: And then include that input with all the other algorithms to calculate the final decision.
- 35:20Alex Krainer: Right to calculate the final decision right Now.
- 35:25Alex Krainer: I gave up on that idea in the end because I looked at a lot of research about how people actually perform in markets and there's an overwhelming tendency for human decision-making to actually destroy value rather than to add it.
- 35:38Alex Krainer: And we've seen a lot of examples of outright groupthink, which is a real thing, especially among experts, because not only are they always anchored around the current price.
- 35:58Alex Krainer: So let's say, if oil price today is at around, let's call it $75 a barrel, and if you ask any expert, you know people that publish reports and get paid for that.
- 36:13Alex Krainer: If you ask them for a forecast 12 months out, they will all fall within $10.
- 36:20Alex Krainer: You know, with $5 up, $5 down from the current price.
- 36:25Alex Krainer: So if it's 75 now, you know, the bearish guys are going to say like, ooh, you know, 71, 72.
- 36:34Alex Krainer: Maybe somebody really ballsy will say 69 or 68.
- 36:38Alex Krainer: And then the bullish guys are going to say like, ooh, I go to 80, 81.
- 36:45Alex Krainer: And the ballsy, ballsy guys are going to say like, ooh, it's going to be between 90 and 100.
- 36:49Alex Krainer: But let's go back to 2020.
- 36:52Alex Krainer: The oil price was at $60 a barrel more or less All the experts, but like all of them were looking at the next four years, all pretty much between $60 and $70.
- 37:04Alex Krainer: And the first thing that happened in January, in March and April of 2020, is that oil crashed.
- 37:11Alex Krainer: To what?
- 37:13Alex Krainer: Was it below $30?
- 37:14Alex Krainer: No, there was even reportedly a negative oil price in March of 2020, right, it just absolutely cratered.
- 37:26Alex Krainer: I don't know a single fundamentals guy who predicted this.
- 37:30Alex Krainer: Not a one came on my radar.
- 37:33Alex Krainer: And then, when the oil crashed like that, I think Cathie Wood said oil's going down to 12.
- 37:46Alex Krainer: And what did oil do?
- 37:48Alex Krainer: It went to 120.
- 37:50Alex Krainer: And again, nobody predicted it.
- 37:53Alex Krainer: So you know, I've become.
- 37:54Alex Krainer: My view on human expertise has dimmed a lot, and it's not always that they don't get it that they don't understand.
- 38:01Alex Krainer: It's that they don't want to stand out.
- 38:07Mark McGrath: don't understand is that they don't want to stand out, because if you get it wrong but you stay in the, in the with the herd, then nothing happens it's so true yeah it's so true if you say, like oil price is going to go down 75 percent and you get that wrong, then they laugh at you forever well, and then there's, then there's, then there's the analyst that quote unquote, got it right one time and then everybody listens to them for the rest of their careers as if they were gurus and they're wrong.
- 38:32Mark McGrath: I had a long career in corporate asset management before I got into consulting with the crew here, and it was amazing to me.
- 38:38Mark McGrath: To your point, everybody heard.
- 38:40Mark McGrath: So they heard when they buy, they heard when they sell, they even heard when they predict, because they would rather be wrong together with a bunch of people rather than right on their own.
- 38:51Alex Krainer: Yeah.
- 38:51Mark McGrath: People don't like that situation.
- 38:54Alex Krainer: Yeah, but then you know the implication of that is that you're always paying for advice from people who don't dare stand out Because they might jeopardize their business if they get it wrong right, and so they all like to be there kind of very close.
- 39:13Alex Krainer: It doesn't matter.
- 39:14Alex Krainer: You know, pay my newsletter, pay for my speeches and conferences, and that's my business model.
- 39:21Alex Krainer: I don't have time to speculate and make money off of the markets.
- 39:27Alex Krainer: I make money off of my subscribers, and so it's much, much safer to be in the herd, and so you're really unlikely to get good feedback from human experts.
- 39:38Mark McGrath: Talk about that.
- 39:39Mark McGrath: You see a lot of people selling price signals and subscription and publishing and things like that, and, to your point, they're making money on their subscription, not on their calls.
- 39:48Mark McGrath: They get subscription fees, but they may or may not have any skin in the game or they may or may not be eating their own cooking, and you know, you see these.
- 40:00Mark McGrath: I mean, we all know who they are.
- 40:01Mark McGrath: I mean, especially in the retail world, there's all these gurus that sell their picks and whatever, and people walk away and they're like I can't believe, I lost everything.
- 40:08Mark McGrath: I mean, I did everything that he said.
- 40:10Mark McGrath: I paid all that money per month for the subscription service.
- 40:13Mark McGrath: What do you think of those things?
- 40:15Mark McGrath: I mean, because here's what I would say If it's not just tracking prices to your point, everything else is just speculation, right?
- 40:22Alex Krainer: Yes, it is.
- 40:23Mark McGrath: And not speculation.
- 40:24Mark McGrath: In a good way I mean speculation.
- 40:25Mark McGrath: I might as well be throwing darts at a board.
- 40:28Alex Krainer: And speculation as in closer to gambling than investing.
- 40:32Alex Krainer: Yeah, unfortunately, that's how it is, you know, and I think that this is why I kind of moved away from all that towards systematic trend following, because you need to have a strategy.
- 40:45Alex Krainer: If you're investing, if you're taking risk, you need to have a strategy, and so then you need to formulate one.
- 40:53Alex Krainer: And if you're going to rely on stock picks and, let's say, forecasts and predictions by market experts, then you're not.
- 41:02Alex Krainer: This is not a strategy, this is guesswork.
- 41:06Alex Krainer: And you're hoping that that person is so smart and better than others that you're going to be okay and you're going to make money.
- 41:17Alex Krainer: But you know, we have reams and mountains of empirical data that show that the vast majority of retail investors underperform and underperform pretty badly.
- 41:32Alex Krainer: So you know, the stock markets historically generate let's call it 10%, right, professional active investors underperform by let's call it their 6%, 7%.
- 41:49Alex Krainer: So they underperform by 5%, 6%, 3%, 4%, 5% ballpark the average retail investor underperforms by 6%, 7%, 8%.
- 42:02Alex Krainer: They're at about 2% to 4% per annum.
- 42:06Alex Krainer: So that tells you that something's not right.
- 42:10Alex Krainer: The mechanism, the approach to making decisions, is simply not appropriate to the challenge at hand.
- 42:21Alex Krainer: And then you have again mountains of empirical data that show conclusively that even professional active investment managers have a very, very robust tendency to underperform.
- 42:34Alex Krainer: So they have your typical Cathie Woods right.
- 42:40Alex Krainer: They have all the analytics, all the expertise that money can buy, the data, the software, the computers, the quants, the PhDs, the economists, everything.
- 42:57Alex Krainer: And still they have over long periods of time.
- 43:04Alex Krainer: They have over long periods of time.
- 43:05Alex Krainer: They have close to 90% or even more percent probability that they will underperform the markets.
- 43:10Alex Krainer: And in the short term let's say any given 12-month period they have about 65% to 70% probability of underperforming.
- 43:21Alex Krainer: So that means that whatever expertise you're cultivating there, whatever you learned about the markets, whatever goes into your decision-making process, is inadequate to the task at hand because you're destroying value, you're not adding it.
- 43:42Alex Krainer: And then if you look at the old hands in the trend following sphere, you see that they have outperformed the S&P 500 for 20, 30, 40, 50 years.
- 43:56Alex Krainer: Dunn Capital Management is now, I think, very close to 50 years track record 50 years track record and they outperform the S&P 500 on a compound basis by, I think, about 4% or 5% or 6%.
- 44:13Alex Krainer: Yeah, so let's say, s&p is 10% or 11% and they are at about 16%.
- 44:18Alex Krainer: And you know, it's not some kind of a deep mystery.
- 44:25Alex Krainer: Like you know, rentech Medallion Fund, it's just a strategy that they apply with great perseverance and discipline and a certain, you know, approach to managing risk.
- 44:38Alex Krainer: And they, you know I like to mention Dunn Capital Management because they have always been, as long as I know of them they have been completely transparent about their drawdowns and their drawdowns in some cases look pretty scary.
- 44:54Alex Krainer: And they had a big one practically right out of the gate when they started in 1974, it just went downhill and I think they lost pretty much half the money, but they didn't quit.
- 45:08Alex Krainer: They stayed in the game they persevered they eat their own cooking too.
- 45:13Mark McGrath: Sorry, they eat their own cooking, they have skin in the game.
- 45:16Mark McGrath: Exactly.
- 45:17Mark McGrath: I've had the privilege of going to their office in Stewart Florida and meeting them and I get their reports everywhere.
- 45:24Mark McGrath: I mean, yeah, they have meeting them and I get their reports everywhere.
- 45:26Mark McGrath: I mean, yeah, they have a discipline, they stick to it.
- 45:28Alex Krainer: Yeah, yeah.
- 45:29Alex Krainer: And then that gives results.
- 45:31Alex Krainer: And again, it's not sexy, it's about as fun as watching paint dry but generates results, and it generates results in bull markets and in bear markets and in any market.
- 45:44Alex Krainer: And so you know, that's to me that's certainly an indication that the process of decision-making is appropriate and adequate to the challenge at hand, whereas among these fundamentals people Kathy Woods and Jeff Gondlachs and all of these people, it's not appropriate.
- 46:09Alex Krainer: And I'm sorry to mention Jeff Gondlach because I don't really know a lot about his performance track record, but I read his newsletter sometimes and he's one of these guys who is always predicting a market crash, and he's been predicting a market crash, I think, for the last five years.
- 46:25Alex Krainer: And then when the market crash eventually and he's been predicting a market crash, I think, for the last five years and then when the market crash eventually happens at some point, then everybody's going to say like, oh, my God, you know he got it exactly right, he predicted the market crash, but how long has been doing it?
- 46:38Mark McGrath: You know it's like a broken call.
- 46:39Mark McGrath: I think was it Charlie Bunger or Warren Buffett says.
- 46:44Mark McGrath: You know, eventually, those that keep predicting the end of the world, eventually they'll be right.
- 46:50Alex Krainer: Exactly exactly.
- 46:51Alex Krainer: And then there's a number of these people who keep predicting market crashes.
- 46:56Alex Krainer: And wait.
- 46:59Alex Krainer: What's the other name?
- 47:01Alex Krainer: Not John Molden?
- 47:03Alex Krainer: Well, it doesn't matter, you know they predicted the.
- 47:06Alex Krainer: Oh yeah, robert Schiller is one of them as well.
- 47:09Alex Krainer: You know he predicted the 2008 housing crash, except that he predicted it already in 2005.
- 47:16Alex Krainer: And now he's been predicting a market crash since 2019, right, a market crash since 2019, right.
- 47:29Alex Krainer: He gave a speech to a group of investors in Los Angeles in I think it was in October 2019.
- 47:32Alex Krainer: He was.
- 47:32Alex Krainer: I see bubbles everywhere.
- 47:33Alex Krainer: And, yeah, okay, sure, you're right, it's all bubbles everywhere.
- 47:38Alex Krainer: But six years later, five years later, it's still bubbles everywhere.
- 47:43Alex Krainer: They didn't go away.
- 47:44Alex Krainer: The markets had some severe corrections along the way, but not a 50% crash, not a bear market.
- 47:53Mark McGrath: Meredith Whitney, I remember, was saying all munis are going to default.
- 47:56Mark McGrath: Yes, I remember that too.
- 48:00Alex Krainer: You cannot predict stuff.
- 48:01Alex Krainer: So you know you cannot predict stuff, yeah, and I was maybe fortunate that I started as a market analyst exactly in this teachable interval.
- 48:12Alex Krainer: You know, severe bear market in oil markets and this spectacular bull market in stocks, the dot-com boom.
- 48:19Alex Krainer: And I just sat there staring at the screen listening to all these traders moan and complain about the oil prices, about the stock prices, about everything.
- 48:27Alex Krainer: And I had to.
- 48:29Alex Krainer: I had to make sense out of it all, and the only sense I could make out of it is that market moving, markets moving trends, and whatever we think we understand, we don't, we we have, maybe we don't or maybe we do, but you have to get your prediction right, you have to get your timing right and then again, you have to be able to act before your confidence is very, very high, before things are obvious.
- 48:59Alex Krainer: And that's all very hard to do.
- 49:01Alex Krainer: And so if you're doing it, if you're a discretionary trader, you have to generally make the right decision every day, day after day after day after day, and there are very, very, very, very few who are capable of doing that successfully over a career.
- 49:21Alex Krainer: And then there are many who do it successfully for a long time and then crash at some point.
- 49:29Alex Krainer: But completely I don't know if the name Victor Niederhofer rings a bell.
- 49:36Alex Krainer: Okay, so, victor Niederhofer, he wrote the book the Education of a Speculator, and so for many years he ran a very, very successful hedge fund out of New York and I think in 1997, he was the world number one yen trader and he had these spectacular returns every year no negative years, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
- 50:04Alex Krainer: Returns every year, no negative years, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
- 50:05Alex Krainer: And then I think it was in 98, or maybe it was towards the end of 1997, he lost the whole fund in the space of just a couple of months.
- 50:16Alex Krainer: And then you had people like Bill Huang I don't know if I'm pronouncing his name, well, yeah, I remember the name.
- 50:25Mark McGrath: I'm trying to think of one now.
- 50:26Mark McGrath: I don't remember the exact instance, the other one I always think of is long-term capital management, the long-term capital management.
- 50:34Alex Krainer: Then you had Brian.
- 50:35Alex Krainer: What's his face?
- 50:36Alex Krainer: Brian Hunter, I think, the natural gas trader guy.
- 50:44Alex Krainer: He was featured in the Wall Street Journal.
- 50:46Alex Krainer: The genius math wizard, blah blah, blah blah made a billion dollars for his company it's on the top of my mind, but I can't recall the name of the fund and then the next year he single-handedly lost him six billion.
- 51:05Mark McGrath: Yeah, I mean, I think back to my asset management career.
- 51:08Mark McGrath: It seemed to me a lot of the best portfolio managers were the ones that ate their own cooking, that they did their own.
- 51:15Mark McGrath: All their life savings were in their own portfolios and yet, at the same time, I don't know the best ones that were the wealthiest, that accumulated inordinate amounts of wealth.
- 51:28Mark McGrath: They stuck to their disciplines, but also, too, they had great sales forces behind them, right that sold their product and they got a lot of, because that's the other thing that their wealth isn't and their success doesn't calculate Like, what are they making sales charges and what are they making in the fees and other things?
- 51:44Alex Krainer: Yeah, I myself found that the whole asset management industry is a little bit like Hollywood as well.
- 51:49Alex Krainer: There's a lot of talent there, but certain people do much better than most of the others.
- 51:56Alex Krainer: You have like a few dozen celebrities, a few dozen stars, Right.
- 52:02Alex Krainer: Then you have a whole lot of other people who are maybe just as good, but for some reason the markets ignore them.
- 52:10Alex Krainer: You have these celebrities where investors are throwing money at them, and you have maybe a couple of thousand others that go around begging for investment and end up managing relatively small hedge funds all the same.
- 52:27Mark McGrath: I don't have my copy here, but you know, in addition to your books on trend following, which are superb, which you make available on your website, now that they've been cleaned off of Amazon, unfortunately, michael Covell's books I like.
- 52:38Mark McGrath: I know that you've been on his show and his big, giant book on trend following I think it's just called trend following, it's just, it's like a massive book, that's, like, you know, bible size.
- 52:49Mark McGrath: It's huge.
- 52:50Mark McGrath: I want to say it's chapter 28 and it was written by two fund managers that were trend following fund managers and they absolutely, line by line, bit by bit, tore down the entire retail asset management industry and, having come from that world, I would tell people hey, buy this book.
- 53:11Mark McGrath: Guys I knew in the biz, I'd say, buy this book and go right to chapter 28.
- 53:15Mark McGrath: And invariably they'll call me back like holy shit.
- 53:21Mark McGrath: I can't think of the names of the guys that wrote it.
- 53:27Mark McGrath: I don't want to misquote them or misattribute them, but I'm pretty sure it was chapter 28 of Michael Covell's books.
- 53:33Mark McGrath: Michael Covell, I mean, he's been a leader, a public leader.
- 53:38Mark McGrath: He's probably the most public face of trend following His work on the Turtle Traders, his work on the big trend following book, work on the turtle traders, his work on the big trend following book.
- 53:49Mark McGrath: He did a documentary.
- 53:49Mark McGrath: The other one, the market wizards books.
- 53:51Mark McGrath: The guy who wrote all the market wizards books oh, Jack Schwager.
- 53:56Mark McGrath: Jack Schwager, yeah, the market wizard books are phenomenal.
- 53:59Mark McGrath: And isn't it interesting that in most cases it seems that they're almost always some kind of a derivatives trader that's doing trend following, like some kind of serious trend following, like Tom Basso and Paul Tudor Jones and others?
- 54:14Alex Krainer: Yeah, well, yes, you're absolutely right.
- 54:17Alex Krainer: And then you know, the thing that I was surprised by is that when you look into the nitty gritty of it, you realize that Benjamin Graham and Warren Buffett themselves were trend followers.
- 54:29Mark McGrath: Right, they'll never say it.
- 54:30Mark McGrath: They'll never tell you that.
- 54:32Alex Krainer: They never say it because it's much more popular to be a value investor because that's, I think, intuitively more palatable to the investors.
- 54:43Alex Krainer: But if you look at Benjamin Graham's returns, it all derives.
- 54:49Alex Krainer: Not all of it, but according to Ben Graham himself, well more than half of all his returns during his investment management career are attributable to Geico, which then means that way less than half of his returns are all these other investments.
- 55:07Alex Krainer: And you know like if you read his book the Intelligent Investor, the whole book is this.
- 55:13Alex Krainer: You know, value investing, yeah.
- 55:16Mark McGrath: Low price to earnings.
- 55:17Mark McGrath: Low price to book.
- 55:19Alex Krainer: Yeah, and then you get to the end of the book where he writes the postscript, and then you get to the end of the book where he writes the postscript, and in the postscript you see that all of that, all of that that he's teaching you, is significantly less than half of his returns, and Geico is significantly more than half of his returns, which means that his value investing actually underperformed the markets by a wide margin over his investment career.
- 55:51Alex Krainer: And then, in case of Warren Buffett, if you look at his individual investments, it's always momentum.
- 55:57Alex Krainer: He doesn't buy value companies.
- 56:01Alex Krainer: Really.
- 56:02Alex Krainer: He's buying, you know, very, very richly valued companies and it always ends up being a hit.
- 56:09Alex Krainer: And then you know you don't even need.
- 56:11Alex Krainer: It's not even such a mystery If you just look over the recent years things that have done well, how well they have done Tesla and Nvidia and so on At what point were these companies overvalued?
- 56:23Alex Krainer: Probably for a couple fold.
- 56:25Alex Krainer: And at what point were these companies overvalued?
- 56:26Alex Krainer: Probably for a couple fold.
- 56:26Alex Krainer: And at what point were they undervalued Like never.
- 56:31Alex Krainer: And you know, I looked at Tesla because it's such a staggering case.
- 56:35Alex Krainer: It comes out of nowhere and then it becomes more valuable than all the other car manufacturers taken together.
- 56:43Alex Krainer: Like what other car manufacturers taken together?
- 56:49Alex Krainer: Like what?
- 56:49Alex Krainer: And then you look at when the Tesla stock started trading or let's say, 2010, 2011, it was trading at like three, three and a half bucks and then over the next 10 years it appreciates like 370 fold.
- 57:00Alex Krainer: Is this the terrain for value investing where you might buy it somewhere?
- 57:06Alex Krainer: Because it was a loss maker for the bulk of this period.
- 57:12Alex Krainer: So there was no value.
- 57:13Alex Krainer: There was no value to buy.
- 57:15Alex Krainer: It was never a valuable company.
- 57:17Alex Krainer: Nevertheless, it went up 370 times and there wasn't a point in time that you say, like you know, this appreciated 20.
- 57:25Alex Krainer: So now you know, as a, as a conservative value investor, I'm going to sell this and wait for the next value opportunity.
- 57:34Alex Krainer: No man, it's a trend.
- 57:36Alex Krainer: You sail with the trend and then you catch these windfalls, these completely insane price rallies.
- 57:45Alex Krainer: And it's not just Tesla, it's.
- 57:47Alex Krainer: The three guys from London Business School went and looked at the stock prices going back from 1900, so more than 100 years and they published this study in 2009.
- 58:04Alex Krainer: And then they simply compared investing in the best performing stocks versus the worst performing stocks.
- 58:11Alex Krainer: You know, like the top 20%, the bottom 20% and the middle 60%, and so, over these 100 years, the bottom 20%.
- 58:22Alex Krainer: I have to explain Meaning.
- 58:25Alex Krainer: They recalculated the portfolio every month and they always allocated money into the stocks that, over the last 12 months, had the best performance.
- 58:36Alex Krainer: All right, and the same with the worst 12, the ones that had the worst performance over the last 12 months.
- 58:45Alex Krainer: And then every month, they recalculate and they rebalance the portfolio.
- 58:48Alex Krainer: So it's not like they just calculate the returns on the worst stocks over the last 100 years and the best stock over the last 100 years.
- 58:56Alex Krainer: The portfolio is constantly being changed, but the point is that investing in the ones that have appreciated the most over the previous 12 months turned £1 in 1900 to £2.3 million in 2009.
- 59:19Alex Krainer: , whereas investing in the let's call it value companies the bottom 20% turned £1,900 into £49 in 2008.
- 59:32Alex Krainer: So the difference is absolutely staggering.
- 59:37Alex Krainer: But again, it suggests that following trend works, because what you're buying actually you're buying things that are going up right, and you're doing that systematically, and so that generated a return of, I think, something like 18% per annum compound, whereas the bottom ones generated less than 10%.
- 1:00:03Mark McGrath: And that's again.
- 1:00:04Mark McGrath: It goes back to these sort of intellectual turf wars in the investing space where people say, oh I'm a value guy, oh I'm a growth guy, oh I'm this guy.
- 1:00:12Mark McGrath: But the reality is, if you're doing things right and well and you're able to disconnect from the psychological or the emotional aspects of it, you'd be a trend follower.
- 1:00:23Mark McGrath: You'd be a systematic trend follower.
- 1:00:25Alex Krainer: Yeah, exactly, and I always ask myself how come everybody isn't a trend follower.
- 1:00:30Alex Krainer: And then I realized that the bulk of the professionals in the finance, financial services industry they kind of look down on trend followers like we do some kind of a voodoo reading of goat entrails or something like this.
- 1:00:50Alex Krainer: And I promise you, I published an article on Zero Hedge a couple of years ago and it was very interesting because I wanted to make a point about technical analysis and so I was looking at the price of Bitcoin one day and I thought this looks like Bitcoin is due for a sharp correction.
- 1:01:13Alex Krainer: And then I published that article and the comments many people were like so what do you read?
- 1:01:21Alex Krainer: Also tea leaves and monkey bones and you know, I don't know what else they put in there, but basically it was taken with derision and I think that most people in the financial services industry are kind of in that same school of thought where you know, trend following is just not sufficiently rigorous.
- 1:01:44Alex Krainer: It's not real science.
- 1:01:44Alex Krainer: It's not real science.
- 1:01:45Alex Krainer: It's not real analysis, it's just kind of a joke.
- 1:01:48Alex Krainer: But what happened is that I think a day or two after I published this article, bitcoin actually did have a sharp correction and it even went to the price target that I said it should reach, and I think it went from $50,000 down to about $30,000, $32,000, something like that Pretty big fall.
- 1:02:17Alex Krainer: But what happened is that the price of Bitcoin completed a head and shoulders pattern, that the price of Bitcoin completed a head and shoulders pattern, and so I said there's a head and shoulders pattern, here's the neckline.
- 1:02:28Alex Krainer: The price just broke the neckline.
- 1:02:30Alex Krainer: Now it might go down.
- 1:02:34Alex Krainer: And it wasn't even about making the prediction, it was that.
- 1:02:37Alex Krainer: You know, at that point, technical analysis allows you to make a trade in which you said like, okay, I get in here.
- 1:02:48Alex Krainer: I think I have the profit potential down to here and I think that I have a stop loss that I can put over here, so that if I'm wrong, I'm going to lose this much.
- 1:03:00Alex Krainer: If I'm right, I'm going to make that much, lose this much, if I'm right, I'm going to make that much.
- 1:03:10Alex Krainer: So you know.
- 1:03:10Alex Krainer: Technical analysis and reading the chart allows you to make these decisions, that you can decide how much to lose if you're wrong, and you can kind of project how much you should make if you're right.
- 1:03:20Alex Krainer: And it allows you to make these trading decisions so that when you make money, you make more than what you lose when you lose.
- 1:03:28Alex Krainer: And then if you're going to be a systematic trend follower, then you just have to pack that knowledge framework into algorithms that can do that for you every day, systematically.
- 1:03:41Mark McGrath: Yeah, well, one of the things I've learned in reading about trend following and interacting with traders is like, if you don't position size and that's another thing that's lost on most people is you just described position sizing right?
- 1:03:55Mark McGrath: If I had something properly well, I guess maybe you had it like stopped or triggered or whatever, but also, too, to have that thing effectively position-sized.
- 1:04:03Mark McGrath: Yeah, that's essential.
- 1:04:05Mark McGrath: That people are putting everything on one thing, because they think it's going to go up or whatever.
- 1:04:10Alex Krainer: Yeah, I see.
- 1:04:11Alex Krainer: Okay.
- 1:04:12Alex Krainer: So this is another thing where I'm kind of opinionated.
- 1:04:16Alex Krainer: I try to persuade people investors, people who read my newsletters to target 20% returns, who read my newsletter to target 20% returns?
- 1:04:23Alex Krainer: Because throughout my career I've read a lot about successful investment managers, traders.
- 1:04:31Alex Krainer: I've digested a lot of empirical data about these performance dynamics and pretty much it turns out that the best of the best among the active investment managers top out at around 16% or 17% net net of fees.
- 1:04:54Alex Krainer: Right, so they charge fees, but over the long run that's kind of the speed limit and I think that's extremely respectable.
- 1:05:03Alex Krainer: But if the best of the best achieve that and so let's call it, on the gross basis, low 20s.
- 1:05:08Alex Krainer: So if you're making 70% net of fees, let's call it you're making low 20s on the gross basis.
- 1:05:17Alex Krainer: So I think that any individual trader should not attempt to generate more returns than 20%.
- 1:05:25Alex Krainer: That's what they should target.
- 1:05:27Alex Krainer: And so, looked over a year, 20% is a respectable return.
- 1:05:32Alex Krainer: That's pretty good.
- 1:05:34Alex Krainer: You'd like your investment manager to generate you that much.
- 1:05:38Alex Krainer: But if you're managing your own portfolio and you open an account online and you see that you can, you can leverage easily and you might see your account go up and down two, three, five percent in a day.
- 1:05:53Alex Krainer: And then you know, like, if you, if you have a couple of successful days, you think, like you know I could, I could double this in a year.
- 1:06:02Alex Krainer: Why should I go that slow?
- 1:06:02Alex Krainer: Why should I be that conservative?
- 1:06:03Alex Krainer: I can double this in a year.
- 1:06:04Alex Krainer: Why should I go that slow?
- 1:06:04Alex Krainer: Why should I be that conservative?
- 1:06:06Alex Krainer: I can double this thing.
- 1:06:07Alex Krainer: Well, all these online brokers in certain jurisdictions, they have to, on the front page, they have to disclose what percentage of their clients lose money, and so you'll see a whole lot of these online traders and if you go to them, you see that between 75% and 85% of their clients lose money.
- 1:06:30Alex Krainer: So your odds of doubling your portfolio are next to zero.
- 1:06:36Alex Krainer: However clever or confident you feel, you're going to get blown out.
- 1:06:41Mark McGrath: Is that mostly?
- 1:06:41Mark McGrath: I buy it hot, sell it cold.
- 1:06:43Mark McGrath: The phenomenon of investors' return?
- 1:06:46Mark McGrath: Yeah, exactly.
- 1:06:50Alex Krainer: And you know, psychology plays an incredibly important part of that, because you know what people do is, when they get beat up, then they become very cautious.
- 1:07:02Alex Krainer: So you take like a 20% drawdown and then you're like you know, do I make this investment, do I not?
- 1:07:09Alex Krainer: Oh, just buy a little bit.
- 1:07:11Alex Krainer: And then you know, even if you make good decisions, you're not making the appropriate gains from that, whereas if they had a successful run, then they start thinking oh man, I'm good at this, why did I just make 20%?
- 1:07:29Alex Krainer: I could have made 50%.
- 1:07:30Alex Krainer: I knew it, I knew this.
- 1:07:32Alex Krainer: So next time I'm just going to bet really heavy.
- 1:07:35Alex Krainer: And that's how 85% of them end up losing money.
- 1:07:39Alex Krainer: So I think that A you want to have a strategy.
- 1:07:42Alex Krainer: So any strategy is better than no strategy at all, because once you have a strategy and you formulated it, at least you have something to fix.
- 1:07:52Alex Krainer: If you got it wrong, you can tell what I'm getting is not what I planned.
- 1:07:58Alex Krainer: Did I get it wrong?
- 1:07:59Alex Krainer: And maybe you can improve.
- 1:08:01Alex Krainer: And then you have to apply this strategy with a certain discipline and you have to manage your risk and you have to persevere.
- 1:08:10Alex Krainer: And if you target those 20% per annum, that means that your bad trades are going to be tolerable.
- 1:08:18Alex Krainer: You're not going to be up at night just because some investment went badly.
- 1:08:24Brian Rivera: I like the idea of psychology.
- 1:08:25Brian Rivera: You know some of the folks that I follow they.
- 1:08:28Brian Rivera: So in the OODA loop, the Observe, write, decide, act loop, in orientation, you have genetics.
- 1:08:33Brian Rivera: Which genetics could contain your biases, right, your biases as a human being, your heuristics, information bias, all the biases that are out there.
- 1:08:40Brian Rivera: There's a ton of them.
- 1:08:40Brian Rivera: And then you have your previous experience.
- 1:08:42Brian Rivera: A ton of them.
- 1:08:44Brian Rivera: And then you have your previous experience and I think those two are your main four pictures within the orientation.
- 1:08:47Brian Rivera: Previous experience would be your education.
- 1:08:48Brian Rivera: Right, you go to school, you learn about value investing, you get an MBA, you learn how to value things, you learn how to value a company and all that, and you bring that lesson forward into your trading career or your finance career.
- 1:08:59Brian Rivera: And then there's other folks that go out there and they have nothing to do with finance, they have nothing to do with that, but they learn about art or they learn about underwater basket weaving or something like that, and they bring that orientation to the market and sometimes they outperform others.
- 1:09:12Brian Rivera: And that's why this is important.
- 1:09:15Brian Rivera: When we talk about strategy within John Boyd's Zootaloop, the way I explain it is you need a map, you need something that you can hold yourself accountable to.
- 1:09:23Brian Rivera: And I think that's what trend following does is right or wrong.
- 1:09:26Brian Rivera: I'm not saying it's the best thing out there, but it is a.
- 1:09:28Brian Rivera: It's a process of map provides.
- 1:09:30Brian Rivera: A map says this, tells me what I need to do, and I and I refine my process, um, and I mitigate my biases, uh, that that are inside my orientation, and that's, if I understand you correctly, alex.
- 1:09:42Brian Rivera: That's how you win right, that's how you outperform others in the market.
- 1:09:47Brian Rivera: Similarly, we've been looking at how do you map the external world in this world of finance so you can quote unquote, get an advantage.
- 1:09:55Brian Rivera: What I've seen so far is people don't do that.
- 1:09:58Brian Rivera: They use there is no map.
- 1:10:00Brian Rivera: It's like going back to your analogy, analogy when you were talking about trend following and accelerating and decelerating and all that I was thinking about.
- 1:10:09Brian Rivera: When you imagine driving in an unknown space without a map, without a GPS or anything like that, that's what you're essentially doing.
- 1:10:16Brian Rivera: You're following the crowd, they're accelerating, they're slowing down, some are turning, you're trying to figure out where to go.
- 1:10:20Brian Rivera: That'll get you somewhere, right, but wouldn't it be awesome if you had a map of that landscape to know where you are?
- 1:10:27Brian Rivera: And that's what I believe is missing in all this is nobody has a map, or maybe they do, but all maps are wrong, by the way.
- 1:10:33Brian Rivera: Right, I mean there's no accurate map of the external environment.
- 1:10:36Brian Rivera: You can't map reality.
- 1:10:38Alex Krainer: Exactly, exactly.
- 1:10:39Brian Rivera: So what I'm thinking here is by combining and you've said you've done this is it's not perfect, but it gives you an indicator of where you are.
- 1:10:46Brian Rivera: But in order to know where you are, you need a map, and that's that mapping thing that I think is really critical in all this.
- 1:10:54Brian Rivera: And I think the firm or organization or individual that comes up with a map of the external world, again, it's going to be wrong and they stay to that.
- 1:11:01Brian Rivera: They're going to increase the probability of success in a way that they Now let me throw this out there Card counting inside of Blackjack.
- 1:11:10Brian Rivera: That's a map, right?
- 1:11:12Brian Rivera: It's pretty accurate, if you will.
- 1:11:14Brian Rivera: I think it's illegal in a lot of places, by the way, so I'm not advocating for that, but it provides you a mental map of what's coming up next, or potentially what's coming up next right, right, so that could exist in the market.
- 1:11:26Brian Rivera: And that's what we're trying to explore is is who has the best map?
- 1:11:30Alex Krainer: I'll throw that back to you and mark who has the best map right now, don't know, I'm not aware that anybody really has a map, but it's, uh, it's something that I'm trying to accomplish actually through trend compass.
- 1:11:42Mark McGrath: Is that like through your systems?
- 1:11:45Alex Krainer: through the system.
- 1:11:46Alex Krainer: Yeah, but uh, you know, it's a so I, 20, 25 years ago, I built the model that I still use to this day, but at the time, you know, I've, uh, I've, uh, I've conceived the whole system with me as the only user, right?
- 1:12:01Alex Krainer: So it's a windows-based application that I use every day and that's that.
- 1:12:07Alex Krainer: And then you know, let's say that if I want to formulate trading strategies for any individual market, it will take me, let's say, between 15 and 25 hours, because the way the system generates trading strategies through kind of a guided machine learning process, generates trading strategies through kind of a guided machine learning process, right?
- 1:12:26Alex Krainer: And so there's a lot of backtest simulations with various combinations of parameters, and so, because it takes such a long time, you know I've done that for about 200 markets, and so I can track about 200 markets, and so I can track about 200 markets and for every individual market I will generate, let's say, between 20 and 50, 60 trading strategies, and they're all formulated within the same framework of knowledge, right?
- 1:12:59Alex Krainer: Let's say we use moving averages, right?
- 1:13:04Alex Krainer: And so let's say if you want to trade gold maybe I'm just throwing these numbers out, don't quote me on any of it let's say that on gold, 12-day, 61-day and 112-day moving averages work right.
- 1:13:23Alex Krainer: On Dow Jones, it might be a different combination, and so there's more than one way to do trend following on an individual market, and then in every individual market, parameter combinations will work.
- 1:13:40Alex Krainer: So then I you know, having read these things about momentum investing, and you know the returns by Warren Buffett and Benjamin Graham, I thought, okay, well, in that case, you know, momentum strategy, which is just a different name for trend following in the stocks, could actually be a brilliant strategy.
- 1:14:04Alex Krainer: But it would be very difficult for me to do, because I cannot formulate trading strategies for every individual stock and every individual ETF, and there's all kinds of these market instruments.
- 1:14:17Alex Krainer: So what I want to do now is I want to convert the model from a Windows-based to web-based and I want to open it to people to formulate their own strategies for whatever market they want.
- 1:14:31Alex Krainer: And so this is where MAP comes in, because if I have maybe thousands of people who formulate strategies of thousands of securities, then I start getting a relatively high-resolution map of the market telling me what's trending up, what's trending down, and then that will be the map, let's call it, which.
- 1:14:56Alex Krainer: I may not know the fundamental reasons for why certain things are happening, but I see that they are happening.
- 1:15:04Alex Krainer: And the problem with this domain is that you know, a map in the real world is a very useful thing because the real world doesn't change very much, it's very stable.
- 1:15:17Alex Krainer: So what you draw on the map is what you find out there, whereas all we know about markets is statistics, aggregates, figures, numbers.
- 1:15:29Alex Krainer: It's really, really difficult to know what markets really are.
- 1:15:34Alex Krainer: Even it's people interacting and transacting I sell you this, you buy that, and that's the price and how much of this stuff we transacted, how fast, when that's what creates all these aggregates the GDP and the employment and the prices and the interest rates.
- 1:15:54Alex Krainer: So the terrain doesn't exist in physical format.
- 1:15:58Alex Krainer: So it's very, very hard to even conceive how to map it.
- 1:16:03Alex Krainer: Very hard to even conceive how to map it.
- 1:16:05Alex Krainer: And the way I've envisioned it is that I would, in that case, be able to maybe substitute the uncertainty of markets for a swarm of let's call it intelligent agents who navigate these markets and then, let's say, maybe have a margin of a more predictable let's call it a more predictable expectancy.
- 1:16:28Alex Krainer: So you know, that's my, with my trend following, that's the how do you call it?
- 1:16:32Alex Krainer: Maybe the summit of what I think I can achieve.
- 1:16:37Brian Rivera: Yeah, I think when you have multiple agents or people contributing to a map and if we use chaos theory for that, where they don't know each other and they don't know how they're providing that information, so they're not anchoring each other or anything like that so remove that groupthink that we talked about earlier, then you can create something Again.
- 1:16:57Brian Rivera: I don't know what this map is.
- 1:16:58Brian Rivera: I don't know how you even begin to create something like that.
- 1:17:03Alex Krainer: Yeah, it doesn't exist.
- 1:17:04Alex Krainer: It doesn't exist yet, so I don't know either, but it's one of those things that you know.
- 1:17:11Alex Krainer: Like with many, let's call them inventions, they exist in somebody's head first, and then they need to be put on paper, and then they have to be put into the real world.
- 1:17:24Mark McGrath: It's a conceptual spiral.
- 1:17:26Alex Krainer: It's a conceptual spiral.
- 1:17:28Alex Krainer: It's a conceptual spiral, beautifully said, yeah, and I hope that I would already be working on this if I was open to how do you call it?
- 1:17:39Alex Krainer: Because I talk to venture capitalists and all these types of people and if I were in my 30s I'd be jumping on that stuff, because I talk to venture capitalists and all these types of people and if I were in my 30s I'd be jumping on that stuff.
- 1:17:52Alex Krainer: But I'm 54 and I'm thinking like, do I want to deal with you people?
- 1:17:54Alex Krainer: I don't think so.
- 1:17:56Brian Rivera: I'm with you.
- 1:17:57Brian Rivera: I mean it's a noble cause.
- 1:17:58Brian Rivera: I mean there's something there.
- 1:17:59Brian Rivera: It's not entertaining, it's warfare, it's a way to figure out something.
- 1:18:03Brian Rivera: Yeah, it gives you a purpose, and all that Exactly.
- 1:18:05Brian Rivera: It keeps your brain sharp.
- 1:18:07Brian Rivera: No-transcript, no-transcript on the on the podcast and we looked at a, a mapping technique that said you know, short the housing market or how?
- 1:19:02Brian Rivera: Builders right, this thing's gonna flip over real fast and sure, sure enough.
- 1:19:05Brian Rivera: Quote, unquote.
- 1:19:06Brian Rivera: They were right.
- 1:19:06Brian Rivera: But it doesn't mean they were right.
- 1:19:08Brian Rivera: It means that the direction they were calling is correct and made some cash on it and we're getting those.
- 1:19:13Brian Rivera: What we need is an early indicator about the direction things are going to go, like those turns, and once we have that, then we can.
- 1:19:24Brian Rivera: My belief is, you can use all these other tools to take that 20% and shove it up to 60, 70%, which would be absolutely insane, right, if you're getting that type of return.
- 1:19:34Brian Rivera: Again, not-.
- 1:19:36Alex Krainer: Yeah, but you know generally you can do those things with small portfolio.
- 1:19:41Alex Krainer: You know like those kinds of returns are not scalable, so you can do it on like a niche strategy.
- 1:19:48Brian Rivera: Mm-hmm.
- 1:19:50Alex Krainer: And you know, my idea has always been to not your scale is limited to about let's call it one to two billion AUM.
- 1:20:21Alex Krainer: There are many CTAs that are much, much bigger than that, but then what happens is that they're mostly trading bonds Because, let's say, that the commodities markets, where you would want to be as diversified as possible, are too small to accommodate the position size that they need.
- 1:20:40Alex Krainer: So I don't know.
- 1:20:42Alex Krainer: I looked at the what's it called, ahl man or Winton.
- 1:20:50Alex Krainer: Winton is one of the largest and they have something like 70% of their risk allocated to treasury futures, and then the currencies and then equities, and then their allocation to commodities is less than 10%.
- 1:21:09Alex Krainer: It was like 6%, 7%.
- 1:21:11Alex Krainer: They're just too, big.
- 1:21:13Alex Krainer: They're too big yeah.
- 1:21:14Alex Krainer: So now you've deprived yourself from that diversification, I mean they still perform okay, but it's not really the CTA in the sense that investors should be out there looking for yeah should be out there looking for, you know?
- 1:21:33Alex Krainer: Yeah, Because if you want to go into a CTA fund, you want it, among other reasons for diversification, because you already have, you know, money allocated to stocks and bonds and real estate and all these.
- 1:21:46Alex Krainer: You know, conventional asset types.
- 1:21:48Alex Krainer: So if you want to diversify, you want to have some exposure to commodity prices.
- 1:21:52Alex Krainer: Well, if you go into Winton or something like that, then you get a tiny little bit of exposure to commodity price.
- 1:21:59Alex Krainer: I think that they're still worth investing in.
- 1:22:01Alex Krainer: I'm not saying that they're not and they're good.
- 1:22:03Alex Krainer: They're very good at what they do, but they're not what they set out to do.
- 1:22:09Alex Krainer: They just became victims of their own success, which is a nice problem, it's common right.
- 1:22:16Mark McGrath: I mean, I would think that probably the best portfolios are people you've never heard of.
- 1:22:20Mark McGrath: They pull their money in together in a limited partnership or something like that and they're just doing it.
- 1:22:25Mark McGrath: Yeah for sure.
- 1:22:27Mark McGrath: They're not advertising it and you don't know who they are.
- 1:22:29Mark McGrath: Yeah, interesting.
- 1:22:32Mark McGrath: Hey.
- 1:22:36Mark McGrath: Last thing before we go we really appreciate your time and we'd love to have you back to keep these conversations going.
- 1:22:39Mark McGrath: I mean, you write some phenomenal stuff on geopolitics and you have a unique view, I guess, being on the other side of the pond from us.
- 1:22:45Mark McGrath: But you know, I've always really enjoyed your analysis and assessments of sort of the global situation.
- 1:22:53Mark McGrath: You know, tell me more, tell us more about that influence.
- 1:22:55Mark McGrath: You know, tell us more about what it is that drives you to write that stuff.
- 1:23:02Mark McGrath: And again, these are things that would challenge our assumptions.
- 1:23:06Mark McGrath: You know, these are things that would make people think, hey, I didn't read.
- 1:23:09Mark McGrath: Alex wrote this on a sub stack.
- 1:23:11Mark McGrath: I've never saw this in the news, I've never heard of it.
- 1:23:13Mark McGrath: But like guys like Ponch and I are going to like, we're going to dig deep on that and we're going to we're going to look and ask a lot of questions.
- 1:23:18Mark McGrath: Tell us more about what drives that.
- 1:23:20Alex Krainer: Well, you know, I, when I was in my early teens, I lived through the outbreak of war in the former Yugoslavia right and that made a mark on me.
- 1:23:29Alex Krainer: And then, you know, I served as a soldier in Croatian military during that war and you know the experience impressed me first in the sense of how the incredible transformation in the society that happens with war.
- 1:23:48Alex Krainer: Before the war started I think that 99% of us thought like there's no way, no, how that there could be war here.
- 1:24:02Alex Krainer: It was completely unthinkable.
- 1:24:03Alex Krainer: However, when it started, almost from one day to the next, the collective psychology completely changed and war became the predominant obsession of the whole society.
- 1:24:16Alex Krainer: And you know, you have the adversary, you have the enemy.
- 1:24:20Alex Krainer: And maybe the day before the war starts people are still discussing in more nuanced terms.
- 1:24:27Alex Krainer: And you know it's like this.
- 1:24:30Alex Krainer: But you know the other side has a point and there's no hatred there.
- 1:24:33Alex Krainer: You know the other side has a point and there's no hatred.
- 1:24:35Alex Krainer: There's no desire to harm anybody, there's no desire to go to war.
- 1:24:39Alex Krainer: And then all at once all that goes away.
- 1:24:42Alex Krainer: People kind of close ranks behind their government, even if they hate him.
- 1:24:48Brian Rivera: You know, like if the United?
- 1:24:50Alex Krainer: States ended up going to a big war while Biden was still in office.
- 1:24:57Alex Krainer: I guarantee you that a large number of Americans would close ranks behind the Biden administration.
- 1:25:04Alex Krainer: You know, it suddenly becomes patriotism, willingness to fight, willingness to sacrifice yourself, willingness to kill, and that goes on until it exhausts itself and it's very destructive.
- 1:25:26Alex Krainer: And so, you know, that left a mark on me, especially because much, much later I volunteered to go to the military.
- 1:25:36Alex Krainer: Much, much later I realized that we've been lied to practically about everything, and then you ended up volunteering to sacrifice yourself on the basis of lies.
- 1:25:46Alex Krainer: And then, you know, I thought well, you know, I'm really glad I didn't get hurt, because had I gotten hurt I'd be very resentful of all that.
- 1:25:54Alex Krainer: But a lot of people did get hurt.
- 1:25:57Alex Krainer: And so, anyway, you know, through my work in hedge funds, I came across, you know, some people that I thought were up to no good, namely this character, bill Browder, who used to run the largest foreign-owned hedge fund in Russia, which was basically a pirate raid on Russia by the Western financial interest during the 1990s.
- 1:26:20Alex Krainer: He was part of it.
- 1:26:21Alex Krainer: They made out like bandits, but I came into contact with Bill Browder on two occasions, and so I knew a little bit about his story and then in 2015, he published a book called Red Notice right, and Red Notice was, I think, ghostwritten by Lee Child.
- 1:26:42Alex Krainer: I'm convinced it's not disclosed, but I'm convinced that it was ghostwritten by Lee Child.
- 1:26:49Alex Krainer: It was told as a thriller and so it's a very good read.
- 1:26:56Alex Krainer: And so my ex-wife she gave me the book once to read and she said, like you're going to find this so fascinating.
- 1:27:06Alex Krainer: And so I read the book and I thought, oh wow, that's insane.
- 1:27:09Alex Krainer: But I was left very confused because what I read in the book and what I thought I understood about this guy, bill Browder, and his business in Russia didn't match.
- 1:27:22Alex Krainer: So I thought I don't get it.
- 1:27:25Alex Krainer: Something is very weird about this.
- 1:27:26Alex Krainer: And then I went and I read the book again and then, of course, I realized it was a pack full of lies.
- 1:27:35Alex Krainer: And the reason why it matters is because Bill Browder is the man who lobbied the Magnitsky Act through US Congress in December of 2012, practically over Christmas.
- 1:27:45Alex Krainer: One of those things like the Federal Reserve Act.
- 1:27:47Alex Krainer: That Magnitsky Act is deemed the opening salvo in the new Cold War between Russia and the United States, and what I gathered from everything I knew about the story is that A you know Bill Browder is not like bona fide hedge fund manager, like you know private entrepreneur doing stuff for his own account, his own business, but that he was the figurehead, with a very powerful backing, of some hidden power network, and that these people are pushing us into World War III.
- 1:28:24Alex Krainer: And I thought, holy shit, you know, I already lived through the outbreak of war, I know how it goes.
- 1:28:30Alex Krainer: Somebody needs to unmask these people because they want us all to go to war against Russia.
- 1:28:36Alex Krainer: And then, you know, I thought, fine, you know, I probably know more about this than the average person on the street, so I'll write it.
- 1:28:43Alex Krainer: So I did.
- 1:28:46Alex Krainer: And then the book got banned in the space of five weeks and then it got republished by a proper publishing company and then it got banned again.
- 1:28:55Alex Krainer: But by now the whole snowball started rolling gently, with people inviting me to do interviews and podcasts, and I started writing a blog.
- 1:29:07Alex Krainer: And about two years ago I started writing on Substack.
- 1:29:11Alex Krainer: I started a YouTube channel, but the YouTube channel was called Markets, trends and Profits it's still there and I intended to talk about what we talked about today, about trading, about risk management, about strategies, about commodities, but it all kind of got pulled away because they're still pushing us into World War III, because they're still pushing us into World War III, and we are now closer to World War III than we ever were since World War II.
- 1:29:39Alex Krainer: And so, you know, writing about markets and trading and investing just kind of feels secondary, because if we end up in a nuclear holocaust then you know whether I catch this trend or that trend or have positive or negative, it won't matter.
- 1:29:58Mark McGrath: It's not going to matter all that much so yeah, that's how my hobby ended up eating up a large chunk of my day-to-day life.
- 1:30:10Mark McGrath: I love reading your stuff and I would encourage others to read it because it really does.
- 1:30:14Mark McGrath: You really do challenge the status quo and you get people.
- 1:30:18Mark McGrath: You get people thinking.
- 1:30:20Mark McGrath: You know, I was looking back on your website before we called.
- 1:30:23Mark McGrath: I had purchased your books on Amazon Grand Deception wasn't available.
- 1:30:28Mark McGrath: Yeah, they're actually in a box of the storage locker right at the moment.
- 1:30:31Mark McGrath: But I have Trimling bible and I have, you know, uncertainty and commodities.
- 1:30:36Mark McGrath: But I remember recommending them to people and then all of a sudden they're like those aren't on amazon and I'm like what the hell are you talking about?
- 1:30:44Mark McGrath: Like I just, I literally just got these books.
- 1:30:46Mark McGrath: So like I, I literally I might be the last guy to buy your books on amazon because not long after that they, they weren't.
- 1:30:53Alex Krainer: Well, for anybody watching this, both books are free on my website as PDFs, and they're not free because they're crap, but they're free because Amazon canceled me completely and then continued to sell the mastering uncertainty in commodities trading.
- 1:31:14Alex Krainer: It's something like nine.
- 1:31:16Alex Krainer: I have a screen, I have a screenshot.
- 1:31:18Alex Krainer: Something like $900 a copy, yeah, and I thought you bastards and I'm not going to see a penny of that, you know.
- 1:31:27Alex Krainer: So I thought I can't tolerate that somebody spends I mean, you know nobody's going to buy it, but like, let like, let's just think that somebody because the book ended up getting an award as the best book for commodity investors for 21 and 22, right.
- 1:31:44Alex Krainer: And so I thought if somebody spends that much money on that book, it's going to go all to the thief Amazon, nothing to me, and the person is going to be out of 900 bucks and the book was selling for 25 26, and so I thought, no, I can't take that.
- 1:32:06Alex Krainer: So I just put them both free of charge as downloads on my website and anybody can pick up a copy if they like.
- 1:32:16Alex Krainer: At any rate, you know, I didn't see any royalties anyway, because at the end, when Amazon canceled me, they also kept all the money I made and they, you know, because I didn't pay attention to this, because this is not a bestseller, this is a niche thing, so it was attention to this, because this is not a bestseller, this is a niche thing.
- 1:32:35Alex Krainer: So it was.
- 1:32:36Alex Krainer: You know, I was selling between zero and two books per month until Mastering Uncertainty got an award, and then I started selling let's call it between 10 and 15 a day, and it was only at that point that I realized that Amazon's not paying me out anything, because now I know this, because I, you know, they're showing you your royalties on your thing and then, you know, every so often you see that they go down as though you got paid out.
- 1:33:06Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:33:08Alex Krainer: But I never received a penny.
- 1:33:09Alex Krainer: So it was a period of about three years that they stole all the royalties that I earned.
- 1:33:16Alex Krainer: So if you wonder how Jeff Bezos paid for his space program and his super yachts, I helped, I helped, I chipped in, chipped in, yeah, Well, the good news is they're available.
- 1:33:31Mark McGrath: you've freed them from from that.
- 1:33:33Mark McGrath: You know, we highly encourage people to go read them and and follow your sub stack because, like I said, you know the assumptions and markets and assumptions in geopolitics should always be challenged, because if you go along with the herd, you go along with the group, um the.
- 1:33:45Mark McGrath: You know the theorists that we work with and follow.
- 1:33:48Mark McGrath: John boyd said you have to challenge all assumptions, otherwise what is doctrine today becomes dogma forever and it it's unbreakable.
- 1:33:56Mark McGrath: And we're also too.
- 1:33:57Mark McGrath: We're constant learners and every trend follower I've ever met is a constant learner and they're constantly looking at markets and they're constantly learning and revising and updating.
- 1:34:05Mark McGrath: We did a live broadcast today on X with Sean Ring, who writes the Root Awakening.
- 1:34:10Mark McGrath: Oh, yeah, yeah, you know, sean.
- 1:34:15Mark McGrath: Yeah, yeah, sean's a good friend.
- 1:34:16Mark McGrath: Maybe I knew that we had that intersection point, but he was on today and he was talking about that, about always being a learner and challenging all assumptions.
- 1:34:27Mark McGrath: It's so important.
- 1:34:28Mark McGrath: What are some of the books that influenced you?
- 1:34:29Mark McGrath: Like?
- 1:34:29Mark McGrath: Did any like you know?
- 1:34:30Mark McGrath: Like Road to Serfdom by FA Hayek or anything like that?
- 1:34:33Mark McGrath: Any like you know?
- 1:34:33Mark McGrath: Like Road to Serfdom by FA Hayek or anything like that, mark, it's always my zinger question.
- 1:34:38Alex Krainer: Okay, so Michael Covell.
- 1:34:40Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:34:40Alex Krainer: So his trend following book was actually redemption, because my team and I already went down the trend following route before we knew that trend following was a thing.
- 1:34:50Alex Krainer: Yeah, you know, coming across Michael Covell's book was beautiful because I felt like, oh okay, so I'm not crazy, this is real.
- 1:34:58Alex Krainer: And then I want to say markets, trends and profits.
- 1:35:01Alex Krainer: But that's not correct.
- 1:35:02Alex Krainer: It's one of those books that is like the top economics books for the 20th century professor out of Chicago Stocks for the long run.
- 1:35:15Alex Krainer: No, no, no, no.
- 1:35:16Alex Krainer: No, it's economics, it's risks, it's something about managing risk and profits.
- 1:35:22Alex Krainer: And I, you know God, I don't know why I can't come up with it, because this is the book that I very, very frequently cite and now my library is in the other room.
- 1:35:35Alex Krainer: I don't want to get up now, but it's not Hayek.
- 1:35:38Mark McGrath: Decision-making and risk management.
- 1:35:41Alex Krainer: Risk.
- 1:35:41Alex Krainer: Okay, if we have a second, I'll have to look it up, because now I'm bothered that I can't come up even with the author.
- 1:35:53Mark McGrath: Gary, I'm trying to think of who is from the Chicago School.
- 1:35:56Alex Krainer: Yeah, of course I think it's Milton Friedman.
- 1:35:57Alex Krainer: It's like a 100-year-old, it's like from the 20s or 30s.
- 1:36:02Mark McGrath: Not Irving Fisher.
- 1:36:04Alex Krainer: Nope, not Irving Fisher, but we're getting closer.
- 1:36:07Mark McGrath: Let's see the Chicago School of Economics.
- 1:36:09Mark McGrath: You know that's always been.
- 1:36:10Mark McGrath: I was trained in the Austrian discipline in Chicago and Austrian schools have always had not John Bates Clark, no Frank Knight.
- 1:36:19Alex Krainer: Frank Knight.
- 1:36:20Alex Krainer: Thank you, frank Knight.
- 1:36:22Alex Krainer: Yeah, that was important Then.
- 1:36:25Mark McGrath: I read Risk, Uncertainty and Profit.
- 1:36:28Mark McGrath: Yes, Thank you.
- 1:36:29Alex Krainer: Risk, uncertainty and Profit.
- 1:36:31Alex Krainer: I mean, I've only cited Frank Knight like a 100 times in various papers and books that I wrote.
- 1:36:39Mark McGrath: The PDF is free online.
- 1:36:41Mark McGrath: Put it in Google Notebook, LM and have fun people.
- 1:36:46Alex Krainer: That's like economics, you can read and that makes sense.
- 1:36:49Alex Krainer: It's not mathematical nonsense.
- 1:36:52Alex Krainer: And then I read books by Christopher Cope on risk management, Victor Niederhofer the Education of a Speculator was very important, even though I don't necessarily recommend the book.
- 1:37:03Alex Krainer: But the whole buildup of Niederhofer into this larger-than-life speculator who is a market superstar and… Gets his clock cleaned, Then gets his clock cleaned, Then gets his clock cleaned, that was again a teachable moment in my life.
- 1:37:18Mark McGrath: Are you familiar?
- 1:37:19Mark McGrath: One of my favorites, that got me started on this whole thing, was the Art of Contrary Thinking by Humphrey B Neill N-E-I-L-L.
- 1:37:27Mark McGrath: Find the PDFs online and I'll email it to you.
- 1:37:31Mark McGrath: The underlying premise is when everyone thinks alike, everyone is likely to be wrong, and it's wise to train your mind to go contrary to the herd.
- 1:37:44Mark McGrath: And what was fascinating about that book?
- 1:37:46Mark McGrath: I got that book Ponch, you appreciate this.
- 1:37:48Mark McGrath: I was about to go on a deployment.
- 1:37:50Mark McGrath: I got to come back stateside for two weeks.
- 1:37:52Mark McGrath: I came here to Manhattan and I took a cab back to JFK.
- 1:37:56Mark McGrath: It's a bizarre hour to get back to the Far East and the guy goes you must be going somewhere exotic.
- 1:38:01Mark McGrath: It's the only time I ever had an American cab driver in New York and I told him I was in the Marine Corps and he asked what are you going to do?
- 1:38:08Mark McGrath: Stay in, get out, be a general?
- 1:38:09Mark McGrath: And I said no, I'm a history major, so I'm going to go out and go to law school because I don't want to be a teacher.
- 1:38:13Mark McGrath: And he says you're an idiot, you should go work on Wall Street.
- 1:38:16Mark McGrath: And I said I'm not good at math.
- 1:38:18Mark McGrath: He says no, no, thinking.
- 1:38:19Mark McGrath: It's.
- 1:38:19Mark McGrath: Literally.
- 1:38:19Mark McGrath: The first thing I ever bought on Amazon was that book and I took it with me on deployment.
- 1:38:23Mark McGrath: The copy that I have now.
- 1:38:24Mark McGrath: It's my second copy, because my first copy was just read so much and dog-eared and in my pocket and wet in the jungle and all this other stuff that I took with me.
- 1:38:50Mark McGrath: But I've read and reread that book probably 10 million times and you can never read it enough because our human nature, our predisposition, our cognitive biases and other things like we're constantly at war with those.
- 1:39:01Mark McGrath: And then the other thing that I did, and you'll love this I went through the footnotes of that book and I bought that.
- 1:39:07Mark McGrath: I could find Some of them are like way out of print, even the out of print ones.
- 1:39:11Mark McGrath: I was able to find almost all of the books that he refers to and many of them are out of favor or banned or whatever, because they're telling about how financial delusion and things like that, how it's all a game of psychology, it's not.
- 1:39:25Mark McGrath: You know, math is one thing, but if you have the psychology, as we're saying, if you have this trend following, to be a disciplined trend follower, it takes a lot of psychology, it takes a lot of emotional intelligence to stick to that sort of a discipline and that book is a good entree to it.
- 1:39:40Alex Krainer: In fact, I think that the books that have maybe been most important for me from this point of view, from trading and investing, have in fact been the psychology books.
- 1:39:50Alex Krainer: Yeah, I read how the Mind works by steven pinker, which is, which is a fairly good book, and then I read something called zen and the brain, which I forget the author, but it's like a pretty big book on on, you know, neuro, you know brain studies, and then there's a thing called choicesices, values and Frames by those you know, daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky, the two Israeli dudes, but they are, you know, work also is Master and His Emissary by Ian McGilchrist.
- 1:40:25Alex Krainer: It's stuff of deep fascination.
- 1:40:44Mark McGrath: Well, I think you've come to the right place with us, right Ponch?
- 1:40:48Brian Rivera: Yeah, we've actually had Ian McGilchrist recommended to us several times and then the neuroscientists we've had on here.
- 1:40:54Brian Rivera: You know, we, we talk Kahneman, we talk type zero, type one, type two, cognition.
- 1:40:58Brian Rivera: People are asking us why do you do that?
- 1:41:01Brian Rivera: I'm like, if you understand how the brain works or what, the way we imagine the brain to work, then you can, then you can really come to some good conclusions on how to navigate uncertainty.
- 1:41:10Brian Rivera: Navigate uncertainty, manage risk, and that's you know.
- 1:41:13Brian Rivera: We also look at complex adaptive systems, thinking systems thinking cybernetics.
- 1:41:17Brian Rivera: We'll have some cybernetics on the podcast later on and that's something that the American government kind of pushed back on in the 40s and 50s because a lot of it was coming out of the Soviet Union then.
- 1:41:27Brian Rivera: And now we find cybernetics to feed into the world of neuroscience.
- 1:41:33Brian Rivera: And, by the way, John Boyd, you know, on the OODA loop he looked heavily into cybernetics to understand this concept.
- 1:41:39Mark McGrath: I would tell you, alex I mean Ponch and I have been talking about this for a long time and we're glad to finally have a trend follower and a trend following trader on to talk about this but the work that we do specifically around John Boyd and the work that he was doing about this, but the work that we do specifically around John Boyd and the work that he was doing and we can get you started via our sub stack and, of course, this podcast but the advantage that we believe that traders and market operators have by understanding John Boyd's theories effectively give them a competitive, creative and collaborative edge that will absolutely bury their competition.
- 1:42:17Brian Rivera: I'm going to build on that, Mark.
- 1:42:18Brian Rivera: So I think I'm glad we do this.
- 1:42:19Brian Rivera: It's a lower energy approach.
- 1:42:21Brian Rivera: If you understand, John Boyd, like what we're showing folks, you don't have to go read thousands of books, from the Tao of Physics to cybernetics, to Google, to all that.
- 1:42:33Brian Rivera: You don't have to go read all that.
- 1:42:34Brian Rivera: I mean you can.
- 1:42:35Brian Rivera: John Boyd already did it and he synthesized that for a lot of folks and if you follow us and we can do a better job explaining it, then we're going to reduce the energy organizations people spend on trying to figure out how sentient systems perceive, decide, act, learn and adapt to this complex world.
- 1:42:52Brian Rivera: So I'm glad you just brought that up, Mark, because I'm thinking about you can't go read all that stuff.
- 1:42:56Brian Rivera: Why would you?
- 1:42:59Mark McGrath: Yeah, well, we published a transcript of John Boyd's seminal brief.
- 1:43:05Mark McGrath: His critical work is called Destruction and Creation, which brings back to mind Joseph Schumpeter speaking of economists, although he called it Creative Destruction.
- 1:43:13Mark McGrath: Back to mind, like Joseph Schumpeter speaking of economists, although he called it creative destruction, but it's a dense paper that fuses entropy, uncertainty and incompleteness together of why we have to constantly challenge and break our concepts and our assumptions and we have to keep building on that.
- 1:43:27Mark McGrath: We use the term conceptual spiral.
- 1:43:29Mark McGrath: I just dropped a link in the chat.
- 1:43:32Mark McGrath: We transcribed this briefing that he had called Conceptual Spiral and you can hear him talk and deliver it.
- 1:43:37Mark McGrath: And again it goes back to if teaching this to investment advisors, to portfolio managers, to investors, to anyone that'll listen, to understand that you constantly have to break and revise and update your orientation.
- 1:44:02Mark McGrath: And we take our name for both the podcast and the sub stack and they come from the same paragraph inside of this briefing I just sent you.
- 1:44:09Mark McGrath: There's no way out of the world of reorientation that if you're not continuously updating and revising your models, you're going to be static, linear, symmetric, ossified and absolutely you'll become irrelevant.
- 1:44:23Mark McGrath: You'll become defeated destroyed.
- 1:44:25Alex Krainer: The river is slowly carrying you downstream.
- 1:44:28Mark McGrath: Yeah, that's it, yeah.
- 1:44:30Mark McGrath: And in that everything is in a state of constant flux and flow and change, more importantly, why you have there's no way out of the world of reorientation.
- 1:44:39Mark McGrath: And what Ponch and I have learned over the years, and what we've talked about with guests that we think we're opening a lot, we believe we're opening a lot of minds we know that we are is that everybody is capable of doing this if they're able to challenge their assumptions.
- 1:44:52Mark McGrath: And the people that we have on, like you and Sean Ring and others, that are doing that in a wide variety of domains in this case, investing or economics.
- 1:45:02Mark McGrath: But we have neuroscientists, come on.
- 1:45:04Mark McGrath: We have athletes, we have coaches, we have business people we have all kinds of, because these things are completely interdisciplinary.
- 1:45:10Mark McGrath: It only applies where humans act and make decisions.
- 1:45:13Mark McGrath: So, trend following, the orientation of trend following, and all the people that we described like whether it was Bill Dunn, tudor Jones, michael Covell these are people with a differentiated orientation, like yourself, which, in turn, allows you to see things differently than the vast majority of people, and our thesis and what we do with clients and what we do on the show is when you understand that, then you can build on what you're already doing.
- 1:45:41Mark McGrath: So the ultra successful people can become even more successful, because now they understand exactly why it's happening and why they're competitive and why they're more creative.
- 1:45:50Mark McGrath: Did I leave anything out, ponch?
- 1:45:52Mark McGrath: Now we're going to send people to your sub stack.
- 1:45:56Mark McGrath: They can follow you on X, I believe at Naked Hedgy.
- 1:45:59Mark McGrath: Where else would you have us send people?
- 1:46:01Mark McGrath: Alex, we're going to link to the books on the show page when this comes out.
- 1:46:07Alex Krainer: Sure, yeah, well, you know X, I'm relatively active on X and then you know I've been writing a personal Substack for two years, which you know devolved into a thing that mostly deals with geopolitics and history and things like this.
- 1:46:23Alex Krainer: But I started about a month ago.
- 1:46:26Alex Krainer: I started a market Substack.
- 1:46:27Alex Krainer: So that's Ice System Trend Compass.
- 1:46:31Mark McGrath: Oh, okay, second Substack We'll link to that as well.
- 1:46:34Mark McGrath: And if you'd love to ever join us, so we are doing X Live broadcast.
- 1:46:38Mark McGrath: We've done two or three now.
- 1:46:41Mark McGrath: Ponch with Sean Ring, yeah, so we've had Sean come on to talk about his letter, but we'd love to, if you ever want, to join us live.
- 1:46:47Mark McGrath: We're doing a live broadcast of our podcast on X now too.
- 1:46:51Mark McGrath: Yeah, broadcast of our podcast on x now too.
- 1:46:57Mark McGrath: So, yeah, why not?
- 1:46:57Mark McGrath: Cool, that'll be fun.
- 1:46:57Mark McGrath: Okay, we'll look to do that after the holidays and things like that so brilliant, okay, gentlemen, thank you.
- 1:47:00Alex Krainer: Thank you for having me.
- 1:47:01Alex Krainer: Uh, it was a very fascinating discussion, so absolutely I wish you, I wish you, a merry christmas and a good start to 2025.
- 1:47:10Alex Krainer: Hopefully the inauguration happens.
- 1:47:12Alex Krainer: Maybe we dodged a nuclear bullet.
- 1:47:19Mark McGrath: Awesome, hopefully, hopefully, stay with us one sec.
- 1:47:23Mark McGrath: We'll just stop the recording now, but thanks for coming.