Latest / Crypto Coin Show / Institutions preparing for Bitcoin ahead of ETF Approval: Bakkt | Blockchain Interviews
Transcript
- 0:00I'm Ashen Addison from crip Acorn Show and today i'm Blockchain Interviews with Dan Opray,
- 0:04the chief product officer of Backed. Dan, welcome to the show and
- 0:07thanks for taking the time. Thanks so much for having me, Ashal.
- 0:11I'm great to be here, very welcome. Excited to dive into bitcoin,
- 0:14custody trading, what BacT is working on, and a little bit about yourself.
- 0:19I'd love to start off the conversation with just hearing a little bit about
- 0:22what you've been doing in the space and how that led up to being so
- 0:25interested in bitcoin and Backed. Sure, no, thanks very much, since,
- 0:30said Dan o Pray, chief products officer at Bank's been here for about
- 0:33two years, but time in the wider space really over the last nine almost
- 0:39ten years now. Got into bitcoin personally in about twenty thirteen after reading the
- 0:45white paper. Was fascinated by the intersection of the economic element and the technology
- 0:52element, and really the opportunity to have Internet native money just sort of instantly
- 0:58struck me as one of those who knows where it's going to go, but
- 1:00it's going to be big. But you know, ten years ago, market
- 1:06was a very different space. I just finished my last startup in the cloud
- 1:10computing space. Just left that, and I've loved to have done a bitcoin
- 1:15startup, but really didn't know, you know, if the market was quite
- 1:19mature enough for that, or if I'd be waiting ten years for the market
- 1:23to pick up. So did something adjacent to bitcoin. I started to explore,
- 1:30you know, was commonly known now as blockchain technology, looking at are
- 1:34there other applications of the underlying tech behind bitcoin that could be used for more
- 1:42traditional use cases that maybe were a little nearer term. So I started a
- 1:48company called Hyperledger, which was the first sort of open, open source,
- 1:53permissioned or enterprise blockchain. No native cryptocurrency again, really much more of just
- 2:00a technology play to allow different companies to issue assets and transfer and clear and
- 2:06settle between them, very much in a sort of compliant way, much more
- 2:10similar to how traditional systems work, but without the need for the reconciliation and
- 2:16disparate siloed systems and time delays and expense that come with a lot of you
- 2:23know, the currently siloed solutions. So long story short. Then ended up
- 2:28being acquired by a company called Digital Assert in New York, so I moved
- 2:31over here worked there for about six years, including then creating or helping to
- 2:38create hyper Ledsure at the Linux Foundation, which was sort of taking what we
- 2:45had started, but working with many large companies like IBM, JP, Morgan,
- 2:49DTCC, Accentia, Intel, and many others to really say, let's
- 2:54you know, this is all open source, this is a network play that's
- 2:59all elaborate, and try to contribute to the same code base that we can
- 3:02all leverage and build businesses around. So, as a chair of the marketing
- 3:07committee there for about three years, leaned a ton way more than I ever
- 3:12perhaps wanted to on how payments and you know, equities clearing and settlement post
- 3:16trade systems really work. But you fascinating knowledge that interestingly is now sort of
- 3:23being reapplied in some ways to the bitcoin space. But yeah, a couple
- 3:29of years ago, decided got into the space for bitcoin passion, felt the
- 3:32time was right, wanted to get back into bitcoin and bank seemed like a
- 3:37perfect opportunity to do that. Amazing. That's a great backstory, And I'm
- 3:40very familiar with the latter half of hyper Ledger and Fabric and what they've been
- 3:46working on. We've had them on the show a few times. That's great
- 3:47to hear that, you know, you were part of that inception. It's
- 3:51very cool and it's great to see that. You're also going back to,
- 3:53you know, sort of how people get involved normally in the blockchain space is
- 3:59through at least the ones early on when there wasn't a lot in the space,
- 4:01is through reading the Bigcoin white paper and looking at you know, with
- 4:05this vision of what bitcoin will become you now ten years later and hopefully one
- 4:12hundred years later and on. I feel like we're still early on. I'm
- 4:15curious on when you first read through the Bigcoin white paper and looked to get
- 4:20involved into the blockchain industry compared to what we're seeing now, you know,
- 4:25nine ten years later, do you sort of like bitcoin and the industry for
- 4:30the same reasons that you first thought of when you got into it. I'd
- 4:34say, by and large yes, you know, the title of the white
- 4:39paper being paid a peer electronic cash system really, to me personally, is
- 4:45still the most interesting application and use case an opportunity for companies in the space.
- 4:51Perhaps the narrative around Bitcoin in particular has shifted a little bit more,
- 4:57part out of necessity, part out of lack of scaling capabilities. Towards this
- 5:00sort of digital gold by it hold it weight inflation hedge mechanism, which it
- 5:10wasn't just intended to be a non custodial bear instrument or gold equivalent. It
- 5:16was meant to be used for payments. So I think that narrative over the
- 5:20last five years has been the primary one around Bitcoin. I think that's still
- 5:25perfectly valid and a use case, and bitcoins half a trillion. Gold's what
- 5:30thirteen trillion or eight trillion, something like that, so there's still a lot
- 5:33of growth just in that particular use case, but money and payments is many
- 5:40trillions. So part of what I'm hoping we can do it back is help
- 5:45shift that narrative from just the digital gold use case to the actual use it
- 5:49utility provide everyday value use cases. Yeah, you're completely right. I feel
- 5:56like it has that promise of being like a digital gold, but it also
- 6:00has so much more. And looking through the white paper and when Bitcoin didn't
- 6:04have a lot of infrastructure behind it, trying to envision how we could get
- 6:10to that level of adoption of something that is multi trillion dollar market cap,
- 6:14I feel like we need companies like backed to have those custody solutions or different
- 6:20ways to trade and hold and actually provide other utility as a form of money
- 6:26for bitcoin. Yeah, I mean I sort of see us simply as trying
- 6:30to be an on ramp for the next one hundred million normal users. Right
- 6:35there are early adopters and enthusiasts and people like ourselves and likely our listeners that
- 6:42are happy to go out of their way to learn new technologies and what they
- 6:46want to do with it. But the reality is, you know, ninety
- 6:49five plus percent of the world want to solve a problem. They want to
- 6:54have convenience, they want to save money, they want something to be faster.
- 6:58They don't want to have to to you know, understand monetary theory before
- 7:02they decide to use something. They just want to make a payment in it
- 7:06to work. And so in order to do that, I think, you
- 7:11know, we're going to have to enable options and make it more convenient,
- 7:15more trusted somewhat ironically, but trusted on ramps through entities that are regulated,
- 7:25licensed and ordited in order to bring that next wave of mainstream adoption, and
- 7:31then perhaps they then a subsection of them graduate to more crypto native capabilities.
- 7:41And I feel like a lot of people have seen BACKED in headlines with regards
- 7:46to whether it's ETF futures things like that, but there's a lot too backed,
- 7:51and maybe you could explain for people that have just seen the headlines and
- 7:55they don't really know a lot about Backed, what are sort of the different
- 7:58product lines that you guys are used on and what you all do. Yeah,
- 8:01sure, I mean the first thing is, you know, we're a
- 8:03platform company, so you know, mainstream consumers probably won't see a name,
- 8:09you know that often we were kind of the infrastructure, the plumbing behind a
- 8:13lot of companies that are providing these services to the end consumers, and we
- 8:18kind of want to be behind the scenes to some extent in that front.
- 8:20So rather than being a vertically integrated exchange where we are the consumer brand,
- 8:28we're powering multiple different brokerages, FinTechs, neo banks, one day traditional financial
- 8:35institutions as well, so that platform behind the scenes for them. You know,
- 8:39we're handling the liquidity, providing the trading integration with multiple different market makers.
- 8:46We provide the custody or a New York Department of Financial Services trust charted
- 8:50trust company where we have an independent company, independent board of managers that not
- 8:56just custodies crypto on behalf of our end partners retail consumer users, but also
- 9:03directly for institutions as well. So custody and trading are our kind of two
- 9:09core services that we do to really enable the infrastructure. But then we're a
- 9:15publicly traded companies, so all of our financials are audited, We're traded on
- 9:20the New York Stock Exchange, and we have licensing across money transmission and bit
- 9:26license across the entire of the US. So really is sort of one stop
- 9:31shop for non crypto companies who want to provide some form of crypto services to
- 9:37their users. Very cool, And I was going to ask further about,
- 9:41you know, back being a public company. I feel like if there are
- 9:45institutions that are looking to get involved in dipping into bitcoin, there's probably a
- 9:50certain criteria list on what they're looking for in what kind of custody partner they
- 9:54would want to use. Maybe you can talk about backed as a public company
- 9:58and also just the criteria that you guys are living up to to become that
- 10:03chosen one for them. Yeah, And I think that's a really interesting point,
- 10:07right because on the spectrum you've got sort of crypto native startups that are
- 10:13pure crypto and really trying to be sort of disruptors. And then you've got
- 10:16the trade fi entities who are adopting and leveraging crypto or getting into crypto,
- 10:22and you know, there are pros and cons of each, but back is
- 10:26kind of in that sweet section, in the sweet spot in the middle of
- 10:31We are a crypto native independent company, but we span out of the Intercontinental
- 10:35Exchange ICE, who are actually the owners of the New York Stock Exchange and
- 10:39many other exchange groups, and so we have that trade FI market infrastructure,
- 10:46pedigree and approach, particularly to custody and the operational processes and regulatory compliance that
- 10:56comes with that, whilst still having the crypt donative knowledge, skill sets and
- 11:01innovation that comes with being an independent company. Then, as you mentioned,
- 11:07being publicly traded gives institutions a lot of confidence or financials are public and audited.
- 11:15Being regulated by the NYDFS, one of the most stringent regulators and sort
- 11:20of gold standard of regulation in the world, again is super helpful. The
- 11:26separation between I think in the crypto space that vertical integration I mentioned earlier,
- 11:33where exchanges are also custodians and also brokers and also sometimes prop traders. Right.
- 11:41FTX and Alamedo were kind of everything all in one, and I don't
- 11:46need to explain why that was an issue. Whereas in the traditional market structure
- 11:52and equities, you know, you'll see as many as like thirteen different companies
- 11:56being involved in clearing and settling just a sting golf stock trade. Right.
- 12:01So ironically, traditional markets are actually a lot more decentralized in their market structure,
- 12:07at least than the very tightly coupled, vertically integrated crypto companies. So
- 12:11again back to back, right, we have a separate trust company chaired by
- 12:16the chairperson of the New York Stock Exchange, separate order managers on that and
- 12:22wesselves are not an exchange or engaging in any sort of proprietary position risk activities.
- 12:31So yeah, many more reasons why backed, but those I think are
- 12:35some of the main ones. Uh huh. And with the regulatory environment in
- 12:41the United States for bitcoin, do you see it as tough to keep up
- 12:48with comply? Is it easy? How do you guys handle you know,
- 12:52the constant evolution as Big One continues to grow on how the regulatory environment is
- 12:56changing. Yeah, I think you know distinction there between sort of bitcoin and
- 13:01crypto or the wider crypto space, in that at least with bitcoin, we
- 13:07do have regulation regulatory clarity between the SEC and the CFTC that other than bitcoin
- 13:13don't seem to agree on a whole lot yet, but do both agree at
- 13:18least that Bitcoin and possibly it's forks our commodities. So that certainly makes dealing
- 13:24with bitcoin and our partners who deal with bitcoin a lot easier. And then
- 13:28also, you know, to the earlier point on utility and payments and money,
- 13:33a key property of money is being commodity like versus being a security,
- 13:41and so you know, we are on the more conservative end of the spectrum.
- 13:46We try to be not just reactive to regulators and the changing climate,
- 13:50but pre empt and you know, be as compliant as we think we should
- 13:56be, not just we need to be. So that's led to us reducing
- 14:01the amount of coins that we offer on the platform to more of a reliable,
- 14:07responsibly curated selection, and certainly bitcoin being the most dominant and most regulatory
- 14:16certain coin of all. Definitely, Yeah, there's the further down the rabbit
- 14:22hole. I guess you could call it that you go, the more uncertainty
- 14:24there is with there's so much innovation happening in the crypto space beyond bitcoin,
- 14:30looking for different ways to provide utility, and I think bitcoin is really that
- 14:33safe space. And we've seen the phrase recently, the flight to quality.
- 14:39You know, many people have mentioned it, and it's great to hear that,
- 14:43you know, people are considering bitcoin of flight to quality. I'm curious
- 14:46on what the traditional investors in the outside world outside of Web three their perception
- 14:52and how it's changing in terms of Bitcoin and you know it, the quality
- 14:56of it compared to other assets traditional financial intruments. I'm curious on your thoughts
- 15:01on that statement and where we're seeing the perception of bitcoin going as more people
- 15:07start to move into it. Yeah, I think a lot of the lessons
- 15:11over the last couple of years within the crypto space has sort of led to
- 15:13people being a bit more discerning and looking for more key properties just within the
- 15:20range of crypto assets, and Bitcoin being by far the most decentralized, most
- 15:24secure, being the top traded, top market cap coin since its inception,
- 15:31certainly has the and then the regulatory clarity that we mentioned certainly gives institutions a
- 15:37lot more comfort relative to other coins that are coming and going in the top
- 15:41ten every couple of years. And so yeah, within the crypto space,
- 15:46I think bigcoin's carving out a bit of a unique characteristic. We've seen many
- 15:52of the institutions recently, particularly around spot ETFs, looking at bigcoins starting with
- 15:56bitcoin. I think institutional funds, sovereign wealth funds, even potentially nation states,
- 16:03right, they all start with bitcoin first and bitcoin only first. Perhaps
- 16:08after that they will they'll move beyond it. But bitcoin is the safest,
- 16:14surest, most secure entry point for institutions. But then relative to traditional assets,
- 16:21you know, I think bitcoin sort of surprisingly to many myself included would
- 16:26be had been correlated with traditional equities and the stock market versus being being that
- 16:33safe haven or that hedge. So that's maybe starting to change and that people
- 16:40are starting to see it more as a as a hedge or safety should traditional
- 16:48assets for even now, the currencies inflation wasn't something that most in the West
- 16:53really worried about or talked about significantly. That that has changed over the last
- 16:59couple of years as well, So I think, yeah, it's starting to
- 17:03become more of a general sort of risk, you know, based asset that
- 17:07the institutions are looking at seriously. Yeah, it's a great point, Dan,
- 17:11and twenty twenty three overall, you know, bitcoin had quite an explosive
- 17:17start to the year for the first month or two. But I feel like
- 17:21overall this year it hasn't been to retail investors in the outside. It hasn't
- 17:26been in the news, and hasn't been talked about as much, although there
- 17:30are many developments going on with bitcoin, but I feel like institutions and companies
- 17:34like backed that are, as you said at the beginning, sort of working
- 17:37in the back end. You don't really hear about them too often. They're
- 17:40obviously paying attention and they're probably pulling the trigger on different moves in their assets
- 17:45as well. I'm curious if you have any insight into you know, more
- 17:49institutional adoption and you know, increased buying pressure or people looking ahead at maybe
- 17:56maybe these potential ETF approvals and saying, hey, we should probably be getting
- 18:00bitcoin while it's not in the news rather than when it is at the top.
- 18:04Yeah. No, I think that's you know, as the as the
- 18:07product guy, the old saying sort of bear marketer for builders is great because
- 18:12you know, last year and the year before, there was a lot of
- 18:15flashy distractions and you know, innovations and new things and fads and yeah,
- 18:22hype and over exuberance broadly in the market. Whereas this quieter time, companies
- 18:26like US and institutions who are looking to take the enter the space, it's
- 18:32a lot more clear on where the long term value is and where to make
- 18:36those investments and then give giving some time to actually build out that infrastructure and
- 18:41make those those longer term plays as well. So I think, yeah,
- 18:45as you say, right, you know, debate over whether the ETF approval
- 18:49is priced in or not, probably probably not, given it still uncertain.
- 18:55But having companies like black Rock, like vangor like Fidelity, you know,
- 19:00give their essentially stamp of validation that this bitcoin is a serious asset that institutions
- 19:07should take seriously, gives you know, all the other smaller institutions a wake
- 19:17up call that this is still something they should be paying attention to even if
- 19:19it's not in the news. But also that validation and egg cover that if
- 19:23you want to go to your boss and suggests you do something in bitcoin,
- 19:26you're not going to look crazy, because hey, Larry Fink and Blackbrock are
- 19:32doing something in bitcoin. So I think, as you say, it's that
- 19:34the quiet, a time where people are preparing and making those investments ahead of
- 19:41the next ball run, rather than reacting to the next ball run to make
- 19:45their moves. Yeah, definitely better to be proactive than reactive. And that's
- 19:51a great point about you know, going to your boss, or just the
- 19:53overall sentiment from retail investors and smaller players to say, hey, you know,
- 19:57this is something that's been validated by the big players and that there is
- 20:00an ETF available. But I feel like for those big big players, you
- 20:06know, they're probably not just waiting. You know, there's already been so
- 20:08many years of discussion on when will the ETF be approved if it and it's
- 20:14almost certain that it will be eventually. It's a matter of when, not
- 20:18if it's going to be approved. And at that point, I feel like
- 20:21those big companies are probably not waiting for the day that it gets approved.
- 20:26They've probably been already working at this for years ahead of time, maybe accumulating
- 20:30spot or other ways outside of the ETF. Yeah, I mean, as
- 20:34it's sort of building out all the peripheral products and services and infrastructure that will
- 20:40enable that. Right, you know, big coins and crypto as bearer instruments
- 20:45on blockchains are unique. Right. This isn't just a case of having a
- 20:48warehouse and putting gold in it or collecting you know, already digitize individual stocks
- 20:56into an index. There's a lot of infrastructure that actually needs to go into
- 21:00that behind the scenes. In terms of the plumbing, custody is the obvious
- 21:04piece, but how to break a dealer's deal with it? How do you
- 21:08know arias and you know, the whole end to end value chain and infrastructure
- 21:17that each of those entities need in order to support this. And we've seen
- 21:19with the SEC right a couple of their challenges to approving the ETF has been
- 21:26bitcoin being commodity trades in an unregulated exchange market, which is, you know,
- 21:33relatively centralized in the US around a few sort of large players, and
- 21:40then you know, having that separation of custody from exchange again. And but
- 21:45now I think the developments there in terms of custody, in terms of institutions
- 21:51like NASDAC providing surveillance agreements to ensure that markets are for re and fair,
- 21:59all of that is being sort of solved for and that's just taken some time.
- 22:02But as you say, this is not something that it's not just a
- 22:04case of submitting an ETF application and waiting for it to get approved and then
- 22:08building all of this right, this has been built out over many years now.
- 22:14Yeah, that's a great point that there's so many other little pieces that
- 22:17they need to come together to ensure compliance, regulation, and just a safe
- 22:22environment for new investors that are at that threshold where once it's approved, they're
- 22:27okay with investing into it. Yeah. I think once we see the approvals
- 22:33and possibly we'll see you all of them be approved at the same time,
- 22:37there will be a bit of a gold rush and one or two of the
- 22:41ETFs will take majority of the market share. So ensuring from the regulator's point
- 22:47of view, their primary goal is to ensure consumer protections and so making sure
- 22:52that those operate as desired is key. But yeah, as I said,
- 22:56I think we're pretty close on that front. Yeah, and it looks like
- 23:02there's a handful of final applications. You know, some of the key dates
- 23:07where maybe January fourteenth or fifteenth, or March fourteenth or fifteenth, that there's
- 23:12a bunch of deadline sort of at the same time. Do you think it's
- 23:15possible or a likely possibility that a lot of them once one gets accepted,
- 23:21they sort of all get accepted at the same time, and it creates more
- 23:23of a competition rather than a monopoly. And you know, maybe there's no
- 23:26reason to deny other applications that are very similar to ones that have already been
- 23:30accepted. Yeah. I wouldn't want to speculate or predict too much, but
- 23:36I think yeah, the logic there being that, as you say, the
- 23:38applications are sort of converging to very similar So I think it would be difficult
- 23:45to approve one, but not many, perhaps not all. Perhaps there will
- 23:51be some that are significantly different that don't meet the criteria, But it says
- 23:56probably more likely that we'll see several or the majority of them approved at the
- 24:00same time, given the similarities, and given that the regulators won't want to
- 24:07be playing favorites or picking the winners, which is not Their job is to
- 24:12ensure that each of them are sufficiently well protected. So I think we'll likely
- 24:18see yeah, many, if not able, Yeah, well, we'll find
- 24:22out in the coming months. And another large event that's happening in twenty twenty
- 24:29four in sort of a part of this four year cycle for bitcoin is the
- 24:32bitcoin having event, where the supply of mining is cut in half for each
- 24:36block. That is depending on when and if the ETFs are approved. Let's
- 24:42just say that it was in the final deadlines in March. The bitcoin having
- 24:45event would be a month and a half after that. Although that is non
- 24:49information, it's potentially already priced in. I feel like normally it's a significant
- 24:56year in event for bitcoin based on the past four years cycles that having events
- 25:00create a lot of interest in bitcoin, But I'm not so sure it will
- 25:07be may be overshadowed by the ETF applications happening just prior if there is big
- 25:12news there. I'm curious on your thoughts of twenty twenty four moving into the
- 25:18having year and if there will you think there'll be some significant events. Is
- 25:22based on the fact that it is a having year. Yeah, No,
- 25:26I think it's going to be a big year, and two positive events is
- 25:30always better than one, right, But I tend to agree with you that
- 25:33the harvening, I think the next one will be less of a big deal
- 25:37than historically people have and there's always a debate about, you know, whether
- 25:41it's priced in or not. But I think the primary theory, or at
- 25:47least when bitcoin market cap was smaller and the block reward size was larger,
- 25:53the halving of the block reward means that essentially the inflation rate is cut in,
- 25:59the supply is reduced, and that was probably historically more significant relative to
- 26:04the size of the market cap and the incoming demand. Whereas as a market
- 26:10CAP's larger and the demands higher, and that will probably would be my guest,
- 26:14be less of a significant event as the number of bitcoin that's actually being
- 26:19created and put out into the market is less significant, and historically it was.
- 26:25But I think to your point, you know, it's still a media
- 26:29event. It's still gets gone as attention. It still you know, gets
- 26:33people talking and that's that's always a positive contributor as well. Definitely, And
- 26:38with you and the team at back for twenty twenty four, is there anything
- 26:44specifically that you guys are focused on in terms of growth and preparing for the
- 26:48ETFs or the happening or just further interest in bitcoin and the products that your
- 26:52team has. Yeah, I mean that two core products are custody and embedded
- 26:57trading, and we've been making significant investments in our custody solution and we'll be
- 27:03announcing a lot of expansions to that over the next coming couple of quarters.
- 27:08And as you said right, there are only a handful or a few institutional
- 27:15grade custodians that institutions alone ETFs can turn to. So very excited on the
- 27:22growth opportunities and the new features and functionality that we can add on the custody
- 27:27front with the embedded trading. I know, we continue to sign partners in
- 27:33the US, where we've been historically very focused, but we're also expanding internationally,
- 27:40and obviously given the regulatory environment in the US and just the market size
- 27:44and opportunity outside the US, that's going to be a hugely exciting piece for
- 27:49us. And then longer term and sort of my personal passion and more interest
- 27:55over the next sort of couple of year or two perhaps is what we started
- 28:00talking about earlier around utility and actually leveraging bigcoin and now layer two scaling pieces
- 28:10like Lightning. Potentially under the hood users may just see FIA currency dollars to
- 28:15dollars or dollars to euros, but actually leveraging those rails to move money between
- 28:22different entities and creating that new global, interoperable instant settlement layer. Lots more
- 28:30to come on that front too. Wow, very cool, smart move on
- 28:34the expansion. I feel like a lot of people sometimes forget that there's a
- 28:38lot of bigcoin interest outside of the US, and there's billions of people how
- 28:41you could potentially be serving as well. Bigcoin is a global currency, so
- 28:45that's exciting to hear. And on the lightning as well, I'm definitely going
- 28:49to be watching for that. What is the best way down for people to
- 28:53follow along with your updates or for back and just to learn more about when
- 28:57these updates do come out. Yeah, so back dot com, b A
- 29:03k k T dot com. I'll have the same at BacT on Twitter,
- 29:07and then at Dan Opray at d A n O B R E Y at
- 29:11Twitter as well, probably be the best places. Awesome, Thank you so
- 29:15much, Dan. I will leave those links to the socials and the backed
- 29:18platform in the notes of the show below, And I appreciate you taking the
- 29:23time your insights into the Bitcoin custody and what hopefully lies in store for us
- 29:29in twenty twenty four. All the best moving forward, and let's follow up
- 29:32in the near future. Thanks so much, Ashton, I really enjoyed it.