Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage a Team Member Who Always Says They Know
Transcript
- Lucas: You give a thoughtful suggestion to a direct report — you've prepared it, you've checked your tone, you're trying to help. And they say two words: 'I know.' Then silence. You're left wondering — did they actually know? Or is that a reflex? Luna: I think every manager has felt that. It's this little wall that goes up. The question is — what do you do with it? Lucas: Right. And the instinct is often to push harder — like, okay, if you know, then why didn't you do it? But that usually makes things worse. So today I want to unpack why the 'I know' reflex happens and what you can actually say instead. Luna: Is there research on this? I feel like there's always a study you're about to cite. Lucas: I do have one. There's a 2025 study in the Journal of Applied Psychology — they looked at feedback receptivity across 400 knowledge workers. One finding that stood out: about 30 percent of employees who regularly say 'I know' during feedback conversations score high on what researchers call 'defensive self-protection.' They're not being arrogant — they're protecting themselves from feeling incompetent. Luna: So it's a shield, not a weapon. That changes the framing a lot. Lucas: Exactly. Carol Dweck's work on fixed versus growth mindset is obviously relevant here. Someone with a fixed mindset hears feedback as a verdict on their ability. So 'I know' becomes a way of saying — 'I'm not deficient, I already have this.' But the interesting twist from the study is that it's not always about mindset. Sometimes it's just overwhelm. Luna: Overwhelm — I've seen that. In my consulting days, I had a teammate who would say 'yep, got it' to everything. I thought she was brushing me off. Turns out she was drowning in work and couldn't process one more thing. Lucas: That's the second variant. So you've got potentially three types: the defensive type protecting their ego, the overwhelmed type who's just trying to get through the conversation, and then there's the genuinely dismissive type — the one who actually thinks they already know better. Luna: The dismissive one is the hardest, I think. Because with the others, you can empathize. With dismissive, it feels like a power struggle. Lucas: It does. But even with the dismissive type, I've learned it's rarely pure malice. I had a senior reporter on my team years ago — super talented, great instincts. But every time I suggested a different angle or a source to check, he'd say 'I know' and then just do his own thing anyway. I was frustrated for months. Luna: What finally changed it? Lucas: I stopped focusing on what he said and started focusing on the relationship. I asked him one day: 'When you say I know, what are you actually feeling?' And he admitted he was afraid that if he didn't already know something, I'd think he wasn't qualified. He'd been hired as the expert — and he felt he had to maintain that image. Luna: Imposter syndrome wearing an 'I know' costume. That's a good reminder that the reflex often has nothing to do with the content of the feedback. Lucas: Right. So let's get practical. I want to offer three micro-interventions. Not scripts — more like moves you can adapt. Luna: I'm ready. What's the first one? Lucas: First, when you hear 'I know,' resist the urge to challenge it. Instead, say something like: 'Great — can you walk me through your thinking on that?' You're not accusing them of not knowing. You're inviting them to show their knowledge. And if they can't actually walk you through it, they'll realize they didn't know as well as they thought — but you didn't have to tell them. Luna: That's elegant — it creates a learning moment without the shame. And if they can walk you through it, then maybe they did know and you can focus on something else. Lucas: Exactly. Second intervention — for the overwhelmed type. If you suspect overload, ask: 'Is this a good time to talk about this, or should we set a time when you have bandwidth?' Sometimes the 'I know' is just a signal that the cognitive load is maxed out. Luna: Yeah, I've used that. It also signals that you respect their time. And if they say 'now is fine,' then you know it's something else. Lucas: Third one — this is for the genuinely dismissive pattern. You need to name the pattern itself, but carefully. Something like: 'I've noticed that when I offer suggestions, you often respond by saying you already know that. I want to make sure my feedback is useful. Could we try a different approach?' Luna: That's a bit more direct, but it's about the relationship, not the person. I like that it puts the onus on you to find a better way to communicate. Lucas: Right. And sometimes the answer is actually — they do know. And you're over-coaching. So the third intervention also invites calibration: maybe they need less feedback, not more. But you have to have the conversation to find out. Luna: That's a humbling thought for any manager. That the problem might be us. Lucas: It's often a mix. But I think the most important takeaway is to slow down. The 'I know' reflex triggers an emotional response in the manager — you feel dismissed. And if you react from that feeling, you escalate. If you pause and get curious, you usually find the real issue. Luna: Curiosity over judgment. That's a good mantra. Lucas: And you know, that curiosity is exactly why shows like this exist — to help us all get a little better at the human side of management. If today's episode was actually useful to you, the way we keep this ad-free is listener support. You can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure — just a way to keep these conversations going. Luna: Yeah, it really does help. We don't run ads, so listener support is what keeps us independent. And we appreciate every single person who contributes. Lucas: Alright, back to the 'I know' reflex. One more nuance I want to add — sometimes the person isn't trying to be difficult. They might genuinely believe they know, but their knowledge is superficial. They've heard the concept before, but they haven't internalized it. Luna: The difference between recognition and recall. They recognize the idea, but they can't apply it. Lucas: Exactly. And that's where the 'walk me through your thinking' intervention really shines. Because it tests whether they can actually apply the knowledge. If they can't, it's a coaching opportunity — not a confrontation. Luna: I want to add a fourth intervention from my own experience. Sometimes I say: 'I know you know this, and I'm not trying to teach you something new. I'm just offering a tool that worked for me in a similar situation.' Lucas: That's good — it lowers the stakes. You're not questioning their competence; you're sharing experience. That's especially effective with senior team members. Luna: Right. And it also signals that you see them as a peer — at least in terms of respect. That can soften the defensiveness. Lucas: One last thing — if the pattern persists despite all this, it might be a fit issue. Some people are just not open to coaching in that context. And as a manager, you have to decide: is this a development opportunity, or is it a performance issue that needs a different conversation? Luna: That's the hard call. But at least now we have a few moves to try before we get there. Lucas: Exactly. So next time you hear 'I know,' don't hear dismissal. Hear an invitation to get curious. And maybe try one of these.