Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Final Settlement E006: Value 4 Value (Part I) with Oscar Merry of Fountain
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers. Communicating the information
- 0:07superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps and off ramps.
- 0:11Bitcoin is worthless, artificial.
- 0:14Gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 0:17Probably. Rat poison squared.
- 0:19We need to get into the world of, OK, this is actually
- 0:22foundational technology. What the Internet of Money?
- 0:26Does is it creates a single. Network which can do a
- 0:30microtransaction to a giga transaction.
- 0:36The Internet is going to be one of the major forces for reducing
- 0:41the role of government. The one thing that's missing
- 0:44that that will soon be developed is a reliable E cash.
- 0:51Thank you for joining us for this week's episode of Final
- 0:53Settlement, a podcast from On RAMP Media.
- 0:56On today's show, we speak with Oscar Mary, the founder of
- 0:58Fountain, a podcasting app that seamlessly aligns incentives
- 1:01between creators and listeners through the power of open
- 1:04protocols. We explore the value for value
- 1:07model of content monetization, value driven social graphs and
- 1:11discovery mechanisms, the issues with existing centralized
- 1:14creator platforms and how Bitcoin's utility upends these
- 1:17broken models by empowering both the user and the creator.
- 1:21Oscar was an early mover in the realm of value for value and has
- 1:24a wealth of knowledge on the topic.
- 1:26This episode is part one of the two-part series on the concept
- 1:28of value for value. So stay tuned for the subsequent
- 1:31episode of Final Settlement with Sam Means, the founder of
- 1:34Wavelink and now time for the show we're live.
- 1:37Welcome back to Final Settlement Podcast brought to you by on
- 1:41RAMP Media, where we take a look at Bitcoin from a technological
- 1:44perspective, the protocol layer and the ways in which Bitcoin is
- 1:48impacting society. And really, you know, talking to
- 1:52builders and looking at ways that people are using Bitcoin to
- 1:57introduce new forms of utility in the real world and improve
- 2:00upon incumbent systems. And really excited for today's
- 2:03conversation with Oscar Mary, founder of Fountain.
- 2:08Welcome to the show, Oscar. Thanks Brian.
- 2:11Really excited to be here. Looking forward to this
- 2:13conversation. Joining us from rainy rainy
- 2:17London in the late afternoon. So really appreciate it and
- 2:21excited to talk about you know what you've been working on in
- 2:25building with Fountain and really dive into the thesis
- 2:29around value for value, which I think you've done, you know, a
- 2:32great job of articulating over the years.
- 2:34And we're very early to this idea, this notion of, you know,
- 2:37Bitcoin being this really useful way to transmit value on the
- 2:42Internet and you know, streaming SATS and all of that.
- 2:45So we'll get, we'll get into the details of all that, but maybe
- 2:47it'd be good to sort of just learn a bit more about your
- 2:50background, how you even got into this space and and
- 2:53understanding Bitcoin and and how that led you to founding
- 2:57Fountain. Yeah, sure.
- 3:00Happy to give a kind of brief overview of my background.
- 3:05I've worked in tech pretty much my whole career, done a number
- 3:10of different things. And I guess the back story to
- 3:14Fountain is that it's two areas of interest to me that happened
- 3:21to kind of cross bars. And those two areas being number
- 3:25one, Bitcoin. I've been interested in Bitcoin
- 3:29for many, many years and was quite lucky to stumble across it
- 3:33quite early, but never thought that I would ever, you know,
- 3:37work in Bitcoin or or do anything with it other than just
- 3:41hold it myself as a store of value.
- 3:44But I've always been very interested in it as a technology
- 3:47and as a, you know, economic kind of development.
- 3:53And then the second area is audio.
- 3:55So I had a previous business that was in the audio space as
- 4:00well, actually working with voice technology, short form
- 4:05audio on some of the only Voice Assistant platforms like Amazon
- 4:10Alexa and Google Assistant. So I've always been passionate
- 4:14about audio as a medium and I've always loved it as a medium
- 4:19because it's unique and it's not competing for our time and
- 4:25attention with all of the other, you know, digital distractions
- 4:29that we have during the day. You know, you can listen to
- 4:31audio when you're commuting to the office or you're doing
- 4:36chores around the house or, you know, just going for a walk.
- 4:39So I've always been a massive fan of spoken word, audio,
- 4:42podcast, audio books and and always been a bitcoiner for many
- 4:47years. And so I guess the back story
- 4:49was that in 2021 I'd sold my previous business and was kind
- 4:57of you know, deciding what to do next and wanted to do some
- 5:03mobile development in the audio space and was playing around
- 5:06with a couple of things, not necessarily planning to start a
- 5:11company or or do anything too seriously.
- 5:14And at the time was experimenting with how can we
- 5:18surface the the the best moments from podcasts in a in a better
- 5:23way. I think one of the amazing
- 5:26things about podcasts as a medium is that you hear these
- 5:30incredible insights from the hosts and the guests that can
- 5:33have a profound effect on your knowledge, the way you see the
- 5:37world, how you think about things, your perspective.
- 5:40But often they're kind of, those moments are lost either in the
- 5:47long list of episodes that you have in your podcast app but you
- 5:50don't necessarily have time to listen to, or just in the back
- 5:53catalogue of of shows that maybe you've only just recently
- 5:58subscribed to or you don't even subscribe to.
- 6:02So I was playing around with that concept and kind of made my
- 6:07way towards podcasting as a space because the best source
- 6:11for this these these insights, these audio clips is actually
- 6:16the podcast medium because there's so much content out
- 6:19there and it's so easy to create a podcast and and the industry
- 6:23is booming. So just when I was kind of
- 6:26exploring all of that at the beginning of 2021, I came across
- 6:31what Adam Curry and Dave Jones were doing with podcasting 2
- 6:34Point O and the Podcast Index. And for anyone that doesn't know
- 6:38the back story to to that podcasting 2 Point O is is a
- 6:42movement to push open podcasting forward to add new features but
- 6:46also protect open podcasting from becoming centralized or
- 6:51dominated by one big tech platform.
- 6:54We've we've kind of seen Apple and Spotify both try to do that
- 6:58over the past few years. So yeah, Adam and Dave and
- 7:01obviously Adam, he's the pod father.
- 7:03He invented podcasting back in the day, back in whenever it was
- 7:0620 years ago. So I came across Adam and Dave
- 7:10and what they were doing as I was exploring the podcast space
- 7:14and and playing around with a few things.
- 7:16And then I saw what they'd done with the value block
- 7:20specification, which is basically the the part of the
- 7:25new podcasting specification that allows you to send Bitcoin
- 7:31over the Lightning Network to content creators, but do it in
- 7:36an open way where it's not just happening on one app, one
- 7:39hosting company or one platform. And and when I saw that, it was
- 7:45kind of like I guess a light bulb moment for me, which was,
- 7:49you know, I'd already been convinced on Bitcoin as a store
- 7:52of value. I believed in it as you know a
- 7:55future critical part to the way money works in the world.
- 8:01And seeing that expressed through micro payments
- 8:07specifically in a medium that I cared a lot about and was
- 8:11actively experimenting with. That was when I made the
- 8:14decision to OK take this side project, this little podcast app
- 8:19with clips in it that I was playing around with and and
- 8:22actually you know, launch it on the app stores and and turn it
- 8:26into a business and and that was the the beginning of Fountain in
- 8:302021. So yeah, that's the kind of high
- 8:32level overview of of how I ended up here and doing this.
- 8:36At ON RAMP, we believe that Bitcoin will be the most
- 8:38important asset to own in the 21st century.
- 8:41Our multi institution custody solution is the safest and most
- 8:44secure way to ensure that your Bitcoin remains in your in your
- 8:47family's possession for decades to come.
- 8:49Multi institution custody maximizes security and minimizes
- 8:52counterparty risk. Leveraging Bitcoin's native
- 8:54properties to eliminate single points of failure that have
- 8:57historically complicated Bitcoin ownership on RAMP provides Peace
- 9:01of Mind for your Bitcoin journey.
- 9:02For more information, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 9:06Oscar, can you share something I'm genuinely curious about?
- 9:09Is like just podcasting in general?
- 9:11Like, it's obviously a great medium and without knowing much
- 9:15about less about the genesis, but like what?
- 9:19What has it gotten right so far and what has it gotten wrong,
- 9:22right? Like, we know, you know,
- 9:23Facebook and Twitter are great examples of like this first
- 9:26version of the Internet and it was massive centralization and
- 9:29and it worked for a while until all the natural effects from
- 9:32centralization happen and then it starts to not work.
- 9:34When it comes to censorship and all the natural things,
- 9:37podcasting is less kind of like straightforward from somebody on
- 9:41the outside. I'm sure it's for you.
- 9:42You, you and others that are focused on it see different
- 9:46things that work really nicely and then others that don't, you
- 9:49know, I think of like ads as one of them, right and like how do
- 9:51you actually monetize and attribution, but like anything
- 9:54that you can share the existing like status quo I think would be
- 9:57helpful. Yeah, sure.
- 10:00I think there's a lot there to talk about.
- 10:03I think in terms of what podcasting has got right as an
- 10:08industry over the years, I think the first is that it's open.
- 10:13It's one of the kind of last mediums of media on the Internet
- 10:18that is truly open. If you think of it in comparison
- 10:21to video or short form text which are both highly
- 10:27centralized on the big social media platforms and including
- 10:31YouTube and that podcasting has always remained open.
- 10:35And the phrase wherever you get your podcast has kind of stuck
- 10:39with how people describe the podcast and it's podcasting is
- 10:44not associated with one particular company.
- 10:47And so I think that's probably the biggest thing that's gone
- 10:52right in the industry. And then I would also say you
- 10:55mentioned ads, I think that the format of a podcast, the way the
- 10:59apps work in the the listener is kind of in full control.
- 11:04They'd never have to listen to the ads.
- 11:06Has kind of isolated podcasting in a positive way where the
- 11:13medium has maintained A distraction free experience
- 11:20where you can just go and enjoy the the content without having
- 11:24to sit through ads or without having to, you know, wrestle
- 11:29with your time and attention because there's some other
- 11:32surface on the app you're using that's pulling you in a
- 11:35different direction. So yeah, I'd say those two
- 11:38things are probably, you know, the biggest reasons why people
- 11:42love podcasting so much and why it's continuing to grow.
- 11:47I think 1 area where it has fallen slightly behind is some
- 11:53of the social features that exist within other mediums that
- 11:58they have positive effects and they also have negative effects.
- 12:03And I think whilst we want to be careful that we don't replicate
- 12:07some of the negatives that we see on other social platforms,
- 12:11there are incredible positives around making media consumption
- 12:16social. You know if you respect somebody
- 12:19a lot and they recommend something to you that's that's a
- 12:23high signal thing and and it's a way that you discover great
- 12:25content. You know, I'm sure you guys and
- 12:28I know I have and I'm sure everyone listening has
- 12:31discovered great content, whether it's on Twitter or
- 12:34another social media platform that has been really interesting
- 12:37and valuable to them. Whereas with podcasting still to
- 12:41this day and you know we're trying to change that with found
- 12:43thing, can talk more about that in a bit.
- 12:44But still to this day, the way most people hear about podcasts
- 12:49is just kind of like word of mouth and there's no real
- 12:53scalable kind of discovery mechanism other than what exists
- 12:59on the other social platforms. But there's a whole bunch of
- 13:02problems there in terms of friction, which I can talk
- 13:04about. So yeah, I think the social
- 13:06features is one thing that's held podcasting back slightly
- 13:10and that's a big part of what podcasting 2 Point O is trying
- 13:14to change by introducing some of the the the kind of the
- 13:22infrastructure to allow us to create social features like
- 13:25you'd see on YouTube or like you'd see on Twitter within
- 13:28podcasting. But in a way that it works
- 13:30across the different apps and in an open way where not one
- 13:34company kind of owns all of the data and controls the the
- 13:39algorithms and things like that. Yeah, no, that makes a ton of
- 13:43sense in terms of, you know, creating social graphs, if if
- 13:48you will. Or you know value ranking
- 13:50signals that are are generated not by a centralized entity and
- 13:55you know creating a a for you page that they think you should
- 13:58should watch but instead actually having the users in the
- 14:01audience Dr. That ranking system I think is a super fascinating
- 14:05part about what what you guys are building and really just
- 14:08what Bitcoin and and the ability to stream value enables.
- 14:12But maybe might be worth taking like a step back and just
- 14:15talking about sort of the value for value thesis at a high level
- 14:18and and drilling down into into what that means and and why
- 14:22that's been sort of integral into the rest of the the rest of
- 14:25these capabilities in terms of improving the way that people
- 14:29monetize their content and also listen and you know absorb
- 14:32content. Yeah, 100%.
- 14:37So the the phrase value for value was absolutely coined.
- 14:42And currently again, who who is one of the inventors of
- 14:46podcasting and it's a philosophy whereby content should be freely
- 14:54available. You shouldn't have to pay for
- 14:57the content that you consume. But then you if you choose to,
- 15:01you should give value back to the content creator based on
- 15:06what you think that content is worth.
- 15:09And I'll say right off the top that this is a very new concept.
- 15:14It doesn't really exist on the Internet at that big of a scale
- 15:20right now. I think Patreon is probably the
- 15:26closest example that we have to a value for value platform,
- 15:30although there's a whole bunch of problems with the way that
- 15:33they do it because they push creators to actually put their
- 15:37content behind a paywall. So yeah, value for value is
- 15:41about giving value back to the content creators that you've
- 15:46received value from. And a great way to understand it
- 15:50or think about it is through the analogy of the other things that
- 15:54you spend your money on. So the example I like to use is
- 15:59if you go for a walk and you buy a cup of coffee, maybe that's $5
- 16:04and you get a certain amount of enjoyment out of that cup of
- 16:07coffee. How much enjoyment do you get
- 16:11from listening to your favorite podcast or a great podcast
- 16:16episode that taught you something about a topic that you
- 16:18care about? Is it the same as that cup of
- 16:21coffee? If it is, then why wouldn't you
- 16:26send value back in the form of a payment to that content creator?
- 16:30It's not the way that we're used to consuming content on the
- 16:35Internet. Normally, it's either you pay
- 16:38and you consume that content after you've paid or you are
- 16:43monetized through ads and essentially you become the
- 16:47product and then that leads to a whole load of downstream
- 16:51negative incentives. So yeah, that's high level what
- 16:56value for value is. I'll also mention that value for
- 16:59value is not just about money. It's also about giving value
- 17:06back in other ways. So again, Adam Curry uses this
- 17:09great phrase called time, talent and treasure.
- 17:13So you can contribute value back with your time by, you know,
- 17:17making a little bit of effort to, to help share that content
- 17:21or add to the content in some way, whether it's through
- 17:24curation or adding additional context.
- 17:28You can contribute your talents through, you know, helping on on
- 17:31a project or or helping out some way and then of course treasure
- 17:35through the the payment system that we have.
- 17:38So yeah, that's a high level overview of value for value.
- 17:42And I guess the the challenge in pushing this philosophy forward
- 17:48is making it easy for people to actually send value back.
- 17:53And if you look at that, I use the example of Patreon.
- 17:57It's incredibly difficult to sign up to Patreon.
- 18:01So you may have heard a podcaster that you listen to
- 18:05say, hey guys, if you really like the show, come and support
- 18:08me on Patreon. The act of doing that has a
- 18:11large amount of friction because you have to leave the app that
- 18:16you're consuming the content in, go to Patreon, sign up to
- 18:20Patreon, figure out what subscription tier you want to
- 18:24pay for, and then make that financial decision on an ongoing
- 18:29basis. Which doesn't make sense for
- 18:32consuming content on the Internet because we consume,
- 18:36especially in the modern day, so much content and so much varied
- 18:41content that the idea of paying a subscription for all of your
- 18:47favorite content creators just doesn't work.
- 18:49It doesn't add up. People are already going through
- 18:53the kind of subscription hell challenge with the the TV
- 18:57streaming platforms and so value for value from a product
- 19:02perspective and this is what we're trying to do with Fountain
- 19:04is making it as easy as possible from the moment that you receive
- 19:10that value and you think wow that was incredibly insightful
- 19:13to actually send a bit of value back.
- 19:15And so the open protocols in RSS, Bitcoin, Lightning and also
- 19:22now Noster as well, that's about making it easier.
- 19:26And then the pay the micro payments that we get with the
- 19:30Bitcoin Lightning network, that's about, that's about
- 19:33reducing the friction in terms of the amounts that you have to
- 19:36send because you don't have to send that much to make it
- 19:40impactful. Even if you send, you know, 100
- 19:43Sats, 500 Sats, 1000 Sats, you know, across a podcaster's
- 19:49audience that can really add up. And so designing the product and
- 19:55designing the interactions in a way where making the payment
- 20:00feels like there's no friction to it and it doesn't even really
- 20:02feel like a payment, it just feels like a normal social media
- 20:06interaction is is also a big part of reducing that friction.
- 20:10But yeah, high level value for value is just, it's a philosophy
- 20:14and it's about a two way value exchange that's voluntary and
- 20:21it's about. Yeah, rewarding the content
- 20:25creators giving back to them when they provide value to you.
- 20:28And we believe that ultimately that will lead to a better
- 20:32Internet if we can get this right, rather than an ad driven
- 20:36Internet or an Internet that's driven by attention algorithms
- 20:43that essentially try to hook you into the platform through
- 20:48whether it's shock or, you know, anger or outrage or or just just
- 20:56negative discussions. If all media consumption is
- 21:00driven by those algorithms, then we're going to end up in a
- 21:03really bad place. And so, yeah, it's a philosophy,
- 21:05but it's also about changing the way content is surfaced on the
- 21:08Internet. Yeah.
- 21:11I think it's, you know, not to We hear podcasts and it's like a
- 21:16light word in the sense of like media entertainment.
- 21:19But what you just described you can go even high level and think
- 21:22about this as building more prosperous productive world.
- 21:26Because you referenced early in the pod about you find the
- 21:28profound sentiment on a on a on a clip and then you're forced to
- 21:33figure out how to do it. And like anybody that knows me
- 21:35that listens or you know, even Brian, like yeah, I'm forced to
- 21:38like do an iPhone kind of like screen recording and then you're
- 21:41sending it in an iMessage and it's just clunky all around.
- 21:45But the notion of this idea of people from all over the world
- 21:50for the first time have specialized, unique knowledge
- 21:53and rather than tell the person that's at the corner of their
- 21:55street or coffee shop and let them learn from them, they can
- 21:58still do that. But a bunch of other people from
- 22:00all over the world can can learn that.
- 22:02And the one that's most relevant just because of listeners, this
- 22:05pod is like Bitcoin. Because I think about Bitcoin,
- 22:08like, imagine Bitcoin not existing with the Internet and
- 22:11not from, like the telecommunications protocol and
- 22:14transferring Bitcoin, but from the idea of the dissemination of
- 22:17information, like how fast it was able to happen because of
- 22:20podcast and Marty, who's a big proponent and friend, right?
- 22:24Like back in the day, and this is even probably middle period,
- 22:28because back in the day there's probably very much a desert.
- 22:30But like, think about like 17/18/19.
- 22:32There was only so much signal in the Bitcoin space.
- 22:34And you had Marty and Matt week after week talking about, you
- 22:38know, Bitcoin. And when you're out alone, now
- 22:40there's a lot more people, there's more meetups, but when
- 22:42you're not, there's nobody there.
- 22:43You're like listening to this stuff and you're picking up that
- 22:45signal when you would have normally not been able to pick
- 22:47it up. And that allows people to learn.
- 22:49That allows people to go build and then also start to
- 22:51contribute. And that wouldn't exist without
- 22:53podcasts. And then if that filter wasn't
- 22:55there or the way to monetize for those individuals weren't there
- 22:58then maybe they could only do it for X long or maybe Marty would
- 23:01had to figure out how to walk a dog or whatever he you know he's
- 23:03he's known to try to do back in the day.
- 23:05But it's it's just it's a very important function in in what's
- 23:09really compelling about the whole thing is it's so brand new
- 23:12that we don't know like what the right way is.
- 23:14That's why I asked earlier about like, what did they get right
- 23:17and wrong? Because this is the first time
- 23:19it's ever existed to be able to like put these kind of disparate
- 23:22individuals with specialized information together.
- 23:25And then how do they monetize and how do we make them, you
- 23:28know, how do we make it all make sense and how do you find the
- 23:30attribution? Finding is just so like if we're
- 23:33still in the early stages and you can see how its importance
- 23:36is relevant, it's just now how do you figure it out?
- 23:40Yeah, exactly. And I think using Bitcoin as an
- 23:43example of a intellectual topic that people are interested in,
- 23:49they want to learn more about. But there's an incredible amount
- 23:52of subtlety to it that takes time to understand.
- 23:57Podcasting is such a great medium for that and I think
- 24:00that's why so many people will tell you that, you know, they
- 24:04discovered Bitcoin or they went down the Bitcoin rabbit hole
- 24:08through listening to podcasts. And another example that I
- 24:11always think about is, especially back in, you know,
- 24:1620/17/2018, if you were to go and search for Bitcoin on
- 24:20YouTube, the stuff that you would be presented with would
- 24:25take you in a totally wrong direction.
- 24:28It would take you towards some kind of, you know, trading
- 24:32course or it would take you towards some kind of coin that's
- 24:37been invented out of nowhere. The case on YouTube, right.
- 24:41Like, I don't think that's really improved that much.
- 24:45Yeah. Yeah, it it.
- 24:46Still is the case. And I think the contrast between
- 24:49that and having, you know, long form discussions with hosts that
- 24:55you trust, that bring on guests with different perspectives, you
- 24:59still get to learn different ideas.
- 25:01But the contrast between those two things I think is stark and
- 25:05it really highlights why it's such an important medium.
- 25:09And and Bitcoin is just one, yeah, intellectual topic that is
- 25:15incredibly valuable to learn about.
- 25:17There's others like, you know, health or you know technology
- 25:22and other areas that are so important for you know, the the
- 25:25world developing in a positive way.
- 25:27And I think, yeah, the medium is just is so good for that.
- 25:31But, but again, we need to number one, help content
- 25:35creators that are thinking about things in the right way and not
- 25:39just thinking about, you know, how can they grow their audience
- 25:43short term with the right thumbnail, with the right click
- 25:47bait headline, with the right guest.
- 25:50That's kind of of the moment and you know, it's going to generate
- 25:54some buzz this month, but maybe over the long term we'll deliver
- 25:58less value. We need to help content creators
- 26:02to be able to shift the way they think about content production.
- 26:05And the great thing about value for value is that the incentives
- 26:08are completely aligned because the only thing you're optimizing
- 26:12for as a content creator is the value that you're delivering to
- 26:15your audience, nothing else. And then the second thing, as I
- 26:19said is the discovery, the the way that we allow the signal to
- 26:23actually travel through not just Fountain, but through other
- 26:27apps. And and we're still a long way
- 26:29off that, but making some initial initial roads.
- 26:34Yeah. No, absolutely.
- 26:35I So let's let's talk about Fountain more specifically and
- 26:39and you know creating this sort of two side 2 sided value
- 26:44marketplace. If you could speak to you know
- 26:46how you've gone about designing the app really you know on both
- 26:51sides. So for creators and also for
- 26:52listeners and and those incentives you mentioned just
- 26:56sort of you know for for listeners who may not be
- 26:58familiar with for with Fountain and how it works, it would be
- 27:01helpful to just sort of walk through on both sides how it
- 27:04works for creators and listeners.
- 27:07Yeah, sure. So yeah, just to start off, I
- 27:11guess I'll just say that Fountain is a podcast app like
- 27:15all of the other podcast apps. If you are coming from Spotify
- 27:20or Apple or Overcast or Pocket Casts, the app should feel very
- 27:25familiar. We've worked incredibly hard on
- 27:27on just getting that core listening experience really good
- 27:31because obviously it is the primary thing it Fountain is a
- 27:34tool and the primary thing that it does is enable you to listen
- 27:38to podcasts. For me personally as well, I
- 27:41used to listen on Overcast, so I was a big fan of Overcast.
- 27:44And so a lot of the kind of design is influenced from that
- 27:50and I guess that was the primary focus for us in in the first
- 27:55kind of year or so is just building the best podcast
- 27:58listening experience we we could because ultimately app on
- 28:03Spotify are great apps. You know, they've got great UX,
- 28:06they've got great design, they've got massive teams.
- 28:09And so if you're asking someone to switch from an existing
- 28:13product that works well, you need to deliver on the basics.
- 28:16And so despite the fact that I'm incredibly excited about, you
- 28:22know, Bitcoin, Lightning, micro payments, some of this discovery
- 28:27stuff that I'll talk more about, really we wanted to just focus
- 28:31on getting the listening experience as good as we we
- 28:36could and I think we're in a really good place there.
- 28:39So yeah, it's a normal podcast app.
- 28:41And then the the key differentiator from a listener's
- 28:45perspective is there's two things.
- 28:47The 1st is you can support your favorite creators, your favorite
- 28:51podcasters and also now musicians.
- 28:53As we've added music, you can do that directly from the player as
- 28:58you're listening. You can either send a one off
- 29:01payment with a message which is called a boost or you can stream
- 29:06stats for every minute that you listen.
- 29:09And interestingly, the streaming stats is is quite a high
- 29:13proportion of the payment volume that we see to creators.
- 29:16And so it's a very interesting kind of passive contribution
- 29:21mechanism that doesn't involve a subscription, doesn't involve a
- 29:26pay, a payable. The second differentiator for
- 29:29the listener is the social features that we have.
- 29:32So we have a social graph in Fountain, you can follow people.
- 29:36So if you were to follow me and I'll send a payment to an
- 29:41episode saying this was a great episode, I learnt a lot on this.
- 29:45You would see that in your feed on Fountain, and that's how we
- 29:49use the payments as a signal to drive Discovery in terms of
- 29:54what's worth listening to. We also have charts that are
- 29:58based on the value rank as well. So yeah, Fountain, from a
- 30:02listener's perspective, is just like any other podcast app, but
- 30:06you can pay your favorite podcast and you can follow
- 30:09people to this to see what they're finding valuable in
- 30:12terms of great episodes. We also have some other features
- 30:16like clips and playlists and stuff, but I won't go into that
- 30:19in too much detail. And then on the content creator
- 30:23side, again everything we're doing is built upon open RSS.
- 30:28So the features that exist within Fountain, they exist not
- 30:33just within Fountain. There's other podcasting 2 point
- 30:36O apps that do the same thing. There's podcast hosting
- 30:40companies that offer, you know, creators the ability to get set
- 30:44up. But obviously when we started,
- 30:47there wasn't much of this going on, so we did actually decide to
- 30:51build tools for content creators as well.
- 30:54So we do actually offer podcasters a wallet where they
- 30:57can get set up to receive Bitcoin, to receive Sats over
- 31:01the Lightning Network, and also give them features like
- 31:05analytics to see how much they're earning, which episodes
- 31:10are bringing in the most income. Again that's a great signal for
- 31:13them to to help them understand which content is my audience
- 31:19resonating with the most as opposed to the traditional
- 31:22metrics like downloads or even on you know Twitter or YouTube
- 31:26likes anything like that. That the payment metric is, is a
- 31:30much stronger one than the than the like metric.
- 31:34Because you know, if if all three of us on this call were to
- 31:40like a tweet on Twitter or like a YouTube video, that's just,
- 31:45that's a single data point and our like signal is worth the
- 31:48same. Whereas one of us may have found
- 31:53that content profound or really you know, it really resonated
- 31:58with us. It changed the way we see the
- 32:01world in some way. And so with a dynamic payment
- 32:04signal, you can express that value and you can, you know,
- 32:09propagate that signal, whether it's back to the content creator
- 32:13or more broadly for whatever platform is capturing that
- 32:17signal to surface content to other users.
- 32:20You can do that now that you have the dynamic value signal.
- 32:23So yeah, we we, we help podcasters, we onboard them, we
- 32:27give them a Lightning wallet. And yeah, we've had a number of
- 32:31podcasters be pretty successful with that.
- 32:34So yeah, that's high level how it works, both from the listener
- 32:37side and the creator side. And I do think, you know, long
- 32:40term we, we want to be focused more on the listener side.
- 32:44We want to help podcasters where possible.
- 32:46But the great thing we're starting to see is more of the
- 32:49hosting companies are are providing the tools to, you
- 32:52know, connect to wallet, get set up directly as you're actually
- 32:56publishing the podcast. Yeah the the notion or idea of
- 33:02app first or podcast app is so important in the sense of like.
- 33:04I still don't think there's a perfect in the regular world
- 33:09podcast app like you have. You mentioned Apple and Spotify
- 33:13dominate and you you you said overcast.
- 33:15I've used Castbox for a very long time and and gives these
- 33:20ideas of like favoriting to go back to just like books or
- 33:24folders or playlists. Like all these things are still
- 33:28not like baked in and and even Castbox recently kind of like
- 33:31crapped the bed and they like did something weird.
- 33:33So I like I've been looking for a new one you can like export, I
- 33:36forgot what the file is called, but you can export the playlist
- 33:38and I think Fountain does this now where you can absorb it and
- 33:42then kind of like have your your playlist there.
- 33:46But I think that's just like core, right, Because that's
- 33:47what's the table stakes to start with is how do you actually like
- 33:50manage all of like the content and then adding these other
- 33:53layers. How much have you seen is like a
- 33:57dance between you guys providing like on the Fountain side,
- 34:00content creators with some of the ways to how do they think
- 34:03about monetizing or kind of crafting the art, the pod to map
- 34:08to value for value versus some of the creators saying, hey,
- 34:12have you guys imported this or have you guys thought about it
- 34:16Like a good example and I don't even know if it exists yet, is
- 34:18like a Patreon model but based on like an actual podcast.
- 34:22So like you have a pod like this and we go and we end and then we
- 34:25say if you want to listen to the last 45 minutes on the specific
- 34:28pod, here's this kind of like invoice and you can pay that.
- 34:32Has that come up like in like these ideas?
- 34:34Because it feels like that's like the natural middle ground
- 34:36between having to pay for a subscription on this other site
- 34:39versus just like hitting that ZAP to be able to listen to the
- 34:41remainder of the pod. Yeah, that's such a good
- 34:45question. And it's something that we've
- 34:47thought a lot about, and it's something that podcasters have
- 34:51asked us about as well, because it's so equivalent to maybe what
- 34:56they're already doing on Patreon for.
- 35:00For me personally, I think that putting your content behind the
- 35:06paywall as a creator is the wrong strategic thing to do.
- 35:12And there's a few reasons why. The first reason is that you
- 35:17know the the best content that you ever produce might be in the
- 35:2410 minutes that you put behind the paywall.
- 35:27And then that content is not going to reach as many people as
- 35:33it otherwise would have if you put it out for free.
- 35:37And so, you know, one thing I know for sure is content
- 35:41creators, the number one thing that they care about is growing
- 35:44their audience because it's the most obvious metric to them.
- 35:49Obviously, you know, eventually we want to replace that with a
- 35:52value metric, but right now that's what they care about.
- 35:55And if you have your content behind a paywall, you're
- 35:58inherently limiting your reach. And I think the the best example
- 36:03of this is Joe Rogan. So when Joe Rogan went exclusive
- 36:07on Spotify, his reach and his influence massively declined.
- 36:14He used to be without a doubt the biggest podcaster in the
- 36:17world with the the biggest influence, the biggest ability
- 36:23to bring on high profile guests. And when he went exclusive
- 36:27because he all of a sudden limited his audience to, you
- 36:31know, 30% of all podcast listeners, which is what
- 36:34Spotify's market share roughly is that that reach, that
- 36:40influence, that ability to bring on important guests declined.
- 36:45And I think that you've seen other podcasters like the Lex
- 36:49Friedman's that Andrew Huberman's kind of step into the
- 36:53role that Joe Rogan traditionally kind of.
- 36:59I think you can see this as well in the fact that in his latest
- 37:03deal, the exclusivity course has been removed and I think he's
- 37:07recognized it. I think Spotify have also
- 37:09recognized it that you know that this wasn't really working.
- 37:14So for that reason personally for me any feature that is tied
- 37:19to putting content behind the payroll is not something that we
- 37:24want to encourage and and also those tools already exist.
- 37:29You know you can use Patreon to do that, you can use some of the
- 37:33other ones. I forget the names.
- 37:35For me, I think it's it's much more powerful for creators to
- 37:41have that content be free and open and accessible to anyone
- 37:46and then have a mechanism whereby the audience that do
- 37:49discover it and can send value back are able to do that and are
- 37:53able to do that in a way that there's no friction.
- 37:58Those are really, really good points.
- 38:01One question I have going back to sort of what we were talking
- 38:05about around discovery and social graphs and the ability
- 38:09for this new model to really like break those algorithmic
- 38:14dynamics of existing creator platforms.
- 38:17Could you drill down into like what that what the implications
- 38:20of that are? And and you know, highlight the
- 38:24issues with existing platforms in terms of dampening or or you
- 38:30know, impacting a creator's actual ability to create what
- 38:34they want in the sense that if they're just thinking about
- 38:37feeding the algorithm that actually would influence the,
- 38:41the content they put out and why this model actually improves
- 38:44upon that and allows people to actually just create valuable
- 38:47content. Yeah, I think there's a couple
- 38:51of quite striking examples that we see on YouTube.
- 38:58I think we've all had this experience where we go on
- 39:02YouTube and we find a video that we think is exactly what we want
- 39:07to watch and learn about. But that video ends up being
- 39:11double the time that it should be.
- 39:14It's filled with kind of like pre explainers and fluff or you
- 39:19know segments that don't need to be there.
- 39:22And the reason for that is because YouTube creators get
- 39:26paid based on watch time. If you create longer videos then
- 39:32you're going to get paid more by the the YouTube algorithm.
- 39:35So there's just a natural incentive there to create videos
- 39:40that are longer than they need to be.
- 39:42There's another one which is creating videos regularly.
- 39:46Now this doesn't apply to every YouTube video, every content
- 39:52format, but it does apply to a lot of formats whereby the
- 39:56algorithm rewards you for having regular content.
- 39:59So the more you have a regular pacing to your content, the more
- 40:04likely it's going to be surfaced in the algorithm to new
- 40:08audience. So whether it's.
- 40:11An incentive to create longer content or an incentive to
- 40:16create more content on A at a higher frequency.
- 40:21The the ad driven model where the relationship between view
- 40:26time or watch time. Essentially how much attention
- 40:30are are people paying towards the content and the amount the
- 40:33creator earns. That's the thing that I think
- 40:38is, you know, not a good thing for the content on the Internet
- 40:42because I mean, YouTube is the place that humans go to learn
- 40:47things today. You know, there's nowhere else
- 40:50that we really go. We type stuff into Google and we
- 40:53type stuff into YouTube and we watch the one of the videos
- 40:57that's presented to us. And so if you think about it,
- 41:00it's actually such a drain on everybody's productivity and
- 41:06ultimate, you know, advancement in terms of how much knowledge
- 41:11they have, how much wisdom they have when they have to kind of
- 41:15either sift through the four or five click baity headline videos
- 41:19that are presented to them when they make that search or have to
- 41:23sift through a video that's twice as long as it needs to be.
- 41:26Or maybe there's a real, really subtle version of this where
- 41:31there's a content creator that actually does provide a lot of
- 41:34value to you week in, week out. But because of those subtle
- 41:37incentives around content duration or frequency, you're
- 41:42just kind of like putting a little bit too much time into it
- 41:45than you otherwise maybe would have had to.
- 41:49And maybe the content creator doesn't actually want to be
- 41:52doing that, that they're just incentivize too.
- 41:55And I think, yeah, for me, YouTube's the biggest example
- 41:58where we see this every day. But I also think it exists on on
- 42:01Twitter or or XI think we'll always call it Twitter maybe is
- 42:06Yeah, you see it there too with, you know, people being driven to
- 42:13create long form tweets now that they've launched that feature
- 42:17because that's, you know, driven up in the algorithm more or
- 42:22creating threads rather than a single tweet because threads do
- 42:26well. And so, you know, the social
- 42:29media gurus I guess are advising content creators to do that.
- 42:35And so, yeah, my view is that these negative incentives with
- 42:40media on the Internet, they exist on every single platform.
- 42:44And it's fundamentally driven by the fact that the creators and
- 42:49the platforms monetize through your attention through
- 42:53advertising. And so that I think if we can
- 42:57change that, it's just going to be massively beneficial to the
- 43:01world and the way we learn information online.
- 43:05So I'm really excited about that and and obviously that's why
- 43:07we're doing what we're doing. But it is still super early with
- 43:11this stuff and I think you know being in the the kind of Bitcoin
- 43:16bubble it's, it's very easy. We have a lot of people very
- 43:21excited about what we're doing. We have a lot of users within
- 43:24the Bitcoin community that you know love Fountain and find it
- 43:28really easy to use because they are educated on Bitcoin.
- 43:31They know how it works, they know what the Lightning network
- 43:33is. But the reality is that for the
- 43:35average person out there on the street, you know Bitcoin and
- 43:39Lightning is still incredibly complex and you know off putting
- 43:46difficult to use, difficult to onboard to.
- 43:50So there's a long, long way to go to to change these things,
- 43:54and I think the onboarding to Bitcoin is actually the biggest
- 44:00challenge here. But what's great to see is
- 44:02obviously there's so many different companies working to
- 44:06make this easier. Whether you're a seasoned
- 44:08bitcoiner or brand new to the asset Class, On RAMP provides a
- 44:11best in class private client experience.
- 44:13To ensure that your Bitcoin remains accessible, secure, and
- 44:16in your control, you'll have a dedicated advisor to guide you
- 44:19every step of the way. If you want to meet in person,
- 44:22we now have on RAMP branches in New York, New Jersey,
- 44:25Philadelphia, Nashville, Dallas, Austin, Houston, Los Angeles and
- 44:30Denver with more on the way. Check out on
- 44:33rampbitcoin.com/branches to learn more and get connected
- 44:36with our team. One thing that's super
- 44:39fascinating that you just references.
- 44:42I don't personally think and I haven't thought deeply about
- 44:45this, so I may be putting my foot in my mouth, but like that
- 44:47we get away completely from ads and but I think we get better
- 44:51ads. And what's always been
- 44:53interesting from an external perspective is if you can
- 44:55provide more signal and attribution, whether it's via
- 44:58pod listens or what you're referencing.
- 45:01If there's the natural mechanism to surface the right content,
- 45:04whether it's Twitter or X and and Noster or whatever, it is
- 45:11like to be able to naturally because it's in your best
- 45:14interest to and it's less best interest is altruistic.
- 45:19Provide some kind of value to showcase that there was value
- 45:23delivered. And then you can actually show
- 45:26proof of work with a finite currency to an advertiser or
- 45:30anybody that's looking to get their brand in front of this
- 45:33unique audience that this had this amount of again finite
- 45:37value, not like something you can gain.
- 45:39It helps reinforce this I the the the old adage of 50% of
- 45:44marketing goes in the dump, you know trash.
- 45:46We just, you know, I didn't know what 50% it was and now you can
- 45:49actually start to have a better Internet with the right capital
- 45:52spent. That's not wasteful And then
- 45:54nobody wants you know so he has this like natural feedback loop
- 45:57that builds a better Internet that it's always been compelling
- 46:01to me with value for value. I don't know if if you see a
- 46:04world like that or if you've thought about that from a
- 46:07because I think pods are the great example of like nobody
- 46:09really knows the numbers, right? Like it's my understanding like
- 46:11we have like ideas but there's it's only like directional, it's
- 46:14not actually like specific. Yeah, you're you're definitely
- 46:21right there. I mean the the the podcast
- 46:25advertising industry is built on download numbers, which are, you
- 46:30know, famous for their inaccuracy because of things
- 46:34like the way automatic downloads work on apps.
- 46:37So if you're advertising on the podcast, you know some number of
- 46:42the downloads are not actually people listening and and
- 46:45obviously then people skip the ads as well.
- 46:47And podcast advertisers know this and they'll factor that
- 46:50into, you know, the CPMS. But it's interesting what you
- 46:53said, because I I do believe that's correct in that, well,
- 46:58#1, if you can identify which content is truly valuable for a
- 47:04given topic or interest area or audience group, then you'll by
- 47:11default be willing to pay more for that as an advertiser.
- 47:14So by kind of flaring out the noise of content on a particular
- 47:22topic, you'd be willing to pay more, whether it's ACPM or some
- 47:27other metric to advertise against that content.
- 47:30And I think that's something that's really interesting.
- 47:33I don't believe that advertising is going to go away and I don't
- 47:36have anything against it. I just think that the it's more
- 47:42the attention driven advertising whereby the the ad spend is
- 47:50proportional to the attention that's paid to a particular
- 47:53piece of content. That's the issue not not
- 47:56actually the the selling of the advertising against content.
- 47:59So I think that will always exist.
- 48:01I think value for value gives a great alternative to content
- 48:06creators as well. So you know you don't need to
- 48:09rely on advertising as much. You know we've had some great
- 48:13examples over the past year or so of really successful
- 48:17podcasters that have embraced value for value and recently the
- 48:23podcast ad market had a bit of a downturn.
- 48:26I think it was linked to, you know the the general economic
- 48:31state with with higher interest rates and less money available.
- 48:34But there was a big downturn in the podcast advertising industry
- 48:37and for a lot of podcasters that are having success on Fountain,
- 48:41when some of their advertisers, you know, pulled out or the CPMS
- 48:44dropped, it was really great for them to have value, for value
- 48:47and direct payments as to kind of things out.
- 48:51So yeah, I don't think advertising is going to go away.
- 48:54I think hopefully if we can clear out some of the noise of
- 48:59this content and and really start assigning a more pure
- 49:04value metric to to certain pieces of content, then we can
- 49:07hopefully raise the CPMS. Yeah, that's the way I think
- 49:11about it. I think you worked through the
- 49:13last part that I I wasn't able to articulate was itself
- 49:17propelling or like the flywheel begins.
- 49:19Because if the like you reference the YouTube idea and
- 49:25the incentive model isn't to produce the best content, but
- 49:28that's the goal, right? Is ever is like produce the best
- 49:30content. So if you produce the best
- 49:31content that means you get the most zaps or the most value.
- 49:34And if you produce if you get the most value, then the
- 49:37advertiser naturally wants to put its ad there.
- 49:40But the way you consistently get better value or more value is
- 49:44producing that high level. So you have to showcase like
- 49:48signal in your advertising. It cannot be like garbage,
- 49:51right, Because then you just like basically go the opposite
- 49:53way. So it's the right, like
- 49:55incentives all the way down. And this doesn't even have to be
- 49:57podcasting. This can be almost anything,
- 49:59right? If you can attribute value that
- 50:01somebody's giving and then you can recognize that the value was
- 50:04given, that by definition means that somebody liked it or found
- 50:06it valuable. You can produce the con, the
- 50:08advertisement there. And then that person, if they
- 50:11want to continue that has to be very heavy.
- 50:14They can't basically put some crazy paw or like advertisement
- 50:17about something insane because they would go the opposite way
- 50:19and they would be basically doing what Joe Rogan did on a
- 50:23different scale. But that's an it's an
- 50:25interesting like mental model to work through on like the
- 50:27incentives in the Internet has basically been the opposite in
- 50:31that like it's incentivized the wrong like content creation in
- 50:35certain respects to monetize via clicks and and eyeballs Anyways,
- 50:40just just working through and like how that actually, you
- 50:42know, infusing finite scarcity or value can really fix a lot of
- 50:47things. Yeah, it it improves the
- 50:50incentives for sure. One one question I had for you
- 50:54Oscar is you know this is something I've I think for us
- 50:58like being in the the Bitcoin bubble as you reference like
- 51:01this makes a ton of sense, right?
- 51:02We're improving the incentive model of of content creation and
- 51:05content monetization using this finite scarce asset.
- 51:09And I think you know when I've talked to my normie friends and
- 51:13and other folks about this it is it is still such a very you know
- 51:17novel concept and not something they're familiar with like I'm
- 51:20going to pay per minute or you know pay with a comment like
- 51:24it's it's it's very the response I've gotten is well I get I get
- 51:29my content for free which like we know isn't actually true but
- 51:32that's how they think about it in their mind and their and then
- 51:35their response is well why would I pay X amount of Sats for you
- 51:39know this this content creator. So how do we, how do we, in your
- 51:43mind like, cross that chasm of getting the average person who's
- 51:47not a bit cleaner, who doesn't see the vision of this model, to
- 51:51recognize that this is just a better format for ingesting
- 51:55content? Yeah, that is the that is the
- 52:00number one question. That's what we need to answer.
- 52:05I think there's three categories where we need to drastically
- 52:10improve from where we are today. The 1st is what I mentioned
- 52:15around on boarding to Bitcoin. Where we need to get to is a
- 52:22random person downloads an app like Fountain.
- 52:26They've never purchased Bitcoin before.
- 52:30They don't own any Bitcoin. They don't know what Bitcoin is.
- 52:34They need to be able to either buy Bitcoin or send a payment
- 52:40that interacts with the Bitcoin rails without any KYC and
- 52:47without any friction. It needs to be the same level of
- 52:51friction as something like Apple Pay.
- 52:55Now that is a is a real challenge especially with you
- 53:00know the regulatory requirements, custody and and
- 53:06things like that and also on the other side the kind of current
- 53:10state and complexity of the non custodial options.
- 53:15But that is absolutely critical. I do think we'll get there.
- 53:19It it's kind of in a sense out of our hands as fountain because
- 53:23we don't you know we we use Zebedee to power all of our
- 53:28payments infrastructure. They're great, but obviously
- 53:31they're they're the ones that have the the licenses to do
- 53:34these things. I think we will get there.
- 53:37There's other companies whether it's strike or cash app or or
- 53:41some of the other companies as well that are kind of pushing
- 53:44this forward. But that is an absolutely
- 53:46critical piece. It's enabling that seamless
- 53:51onboarding to Bitcoin and onboarding to the product.
- 53:53Like one of the things we see is the retention of In Fountain for
- 53:58people that send the payment to a podcasters is is incredible.
- 54:02It's it's really, really high. It's like one of the highest
- 54:05that that you'll see out there in mobile apps.
- 54:09And so all we need to do is enable people to get over that
- 54:12first hurdle of sending the first payment.
- 54:15That's the first category. The 2nd is around what you
- 54:20touched on in terms of people's existing expectations for how
- 54:24they consume content and how they interact with content.
- 54:29And I think you're right, people don't think about consuming
- 54:35content for free and then paying afterwards.
- 54:38That doesn't exist anywhere else.
- 54:41It's a brand new concept. It's value for value.
- 54:43What's that? You know, we need to do a much
- 54:46better job of explaining that. And I actually think the way to
- 54:49explain that is not through language or words, It's actually
- 54:54by showing people how other people are doing it.
- 54:58We've started to do this in Fountain, and some of the
- 55:01features we have around this are are working quite well.
- 55:05But essentially it's social proof.
- 55:07It's showing you that. OK, somebody I already follow or
- 55:12somebody I already know has actually sent a large payment to
- 55:17this show or this episode or this artist or this song
- 55:21surfacing that right in the app. And.
- 55:23Or it could be someone that you don't follow, someone that you
- 55:26don't know. And you see, OK, wow, the
- 55:28episode that I listened to last week that I found really
- 55:31interesting. Wow, Someone just sent 100,000
- 55:33sets to that episode. And yeah, actually it was worth
- 55:37something. It was interesting.
- 55:38Maybe I'll think about doing that.
- 55:41We, we started working on some of these features, but I think
- 55:45there's so much more that we can do in terms of making it feel
- 55:48normal to send money back to content creators.
- 55:53And again, I think one of the beauties of working with Bitcoin
- 55:57and Lightning is that it's not just Fountain doing this.
- 56:01You know, we've got all of the developments happening on Noster
- 56:03as well. There's great experimentation
- 56:05going on there as well because they've got the exact same
- 56:08problem, which is how do you normalize sending micro
- 56:12payments, How do you normalize the, the jump between consuming
- 56:17content, recognizing the value and then making a quick payment
- 56:22even if it's a very small amount and then showing the social
- 56:25proof to to kind of reinforce that cycle.
- 56:29That's, yeah, that's the second category which is on the product
- 56:33side and it's something that we're continually trying to push
- 56:36forward. And then the third category is
- 56:39around the educating content creators and working with them
- 56:44to develop the ask. So one of the big things with
- 56:49value for value is that if you don't ask as a content creator,
- 56:54people aren't going to send you value.
- 56:57Maybe they'll send you a bit, but really to get the thing
- 57:00going, you need to ask people to send you value back.
- 57:03And a lot of content creators don't like doing that.
- 57:06They, you know, they either feel some kind of sense hesitancy to
- 57:13ask their audience for money, or some content creators feel like
- 57:18they're already monetizing their audience because of the
- 57:21advertising system that they think to themselves.
- 57:24Well, my audience already listened to ads, so why would I
- 57:28ask them to send me money on top of that?
- 57:30Because I'm already essentially monetizing them.
- 57:35That's something that's more subtle and it it's less about
- 57:37the product. But I think it it's just as
- 57:40important. And I think yeah, educating
- 57:42content creators about how to frame that ask and and talking
- 57:47to them about the some of the incentive stuff that we've
- 57:51covered is important as well. But also, ultimately, we just
- 57:55need more case studies of it working really well so we can
- 57:58point them, say, hey, don't don't listen to me as as the
- 58:02developer of Fountain. Like, go and check out this
- 58:05content creator who's similar to you, who's having a lot of
- 58:09success. They framed the ask in a really
- 58:12great way that doesn't interfere with their show format or
- 58:15doesn't feel strange, doesn't feel pressured, but they are
- 58:18actually having success. So yeah, those 3 categories of
- 58:22onboarding to Bitcoin, normalizing making payments
- 58:27through social features and then educating content creators on
- 58:31how to actually make that ask. They're, I think, the three
- 58:35pieces that we need to get right if we're going to make this go
- 58:41mainstream. But as I said, I'm optimistic
- 58:43because, well, we're all optimistic about Bitcoins, you
- 58:47know, future development. And I think we can see where
- 58:50that's going. And on the product side, it's
- 58:53not just fountain, it's not just podcasting.
- 58:55I believe this will happen in every media medium on the
- 58:59Internet. It's just a matter of time when
- 59:01we can all learn from each other in terms of experimentation.
- 59:06Yeah, I think the E Cash evolution is going to be an
- 59:10interesting dynamic to watch on the value for value around
- 59:14content creation. But also just like in social
- 59:16apps in general around rewards because it takes a lot of that
- 59:18friction of like opening channels and all the things
- 59:21associated that you reference needing to do a strike or buy
- 59:26versus you can actually it was really cool to do a transaction
- 59:30from Rivers Lightning node to mutiny and I sent like exactly 1
- 59:35Sat or but via E Cash, right. So I think it's just a very
- 59:39fascinating thing to that people will get to play with and that
- 59:42it's interoperable, obviously. Yeah, that's maybe.
- 59:46Yeah, that's a great. Yeah, go ahead.
- 59:50Yeah, no, I was just going to say that's a great example of
- 59:53you know with the E cash you get offline receive as well, whereas
- 59:56right now that's one issue with non custodial lightning is you
- 59:59don't get offline received. So for podcasters, that's
- 1:00:02another barrier for them, kind of, you know, running their own,
- 1:00:07having a non custodial setup. And like that that idea of like
- 1:00:11somebody onboarding and getting some Sats to play with or E cash
- 1:00:15to play with to start hosting versus having to set up a
- 1:00:18channel and all the things associated or however would be
- 1:00:20done in the wallet and also from the like, yeah, it's obviously
- 1:00:25not a good landscape to be you know running custodial lightning
- 1:00:28wallets as well so. I'm curious, you mentioned
- 1:00:33Noster a few times. What's like you know looking
- 1:00:36ahead to you know quote UN quote the road map for for Fountain
- 1:00:41and you know what you have on the plans for the Horizon are
- 1:00:44are there different ways you can integrate into Noster and and
- 1:00:48you know leverage some of the discoverability features there
- 1:00:51what else what else are you thinking on on building out
- 1:00:53whether it's you know, you mentioned music is there plans
- 1:00:57for you know audiobooks like what else is in your mind of
- 1:01:00like how this how this can grow and become even larger than it
- 1:01:03is. Yeah.
- 1:01:06So Noster is a big part of our plans because it's just a
- 1:01:12perfect fit for not just Fountain, but also for
- 1:01:17podcasting in general. You know, when we first launched
- 1:01:22the social features in Fountain, Nosta didn't exist.
- 1:01:27And so we had to build our own social graph into Fountain,
- 1:01:33which was an incredible amount of work and also adds an
- 1:01:39incredible amount of friction to the onboarding because you need
- 1:01:43to build up that follower graph from scratch.
- 1:01:47When you first download the app and sign in, you don't have any
- 1:01:50followers and we can do things like connect your Twitter and
- 1:01:54stuff, but obviously that costs a lot of money from the Twitter
- 1:01:57API. So Nosta is amazing and we're
- 1:02:00actually in the process of switching out the social graph
- 1:02:03from the one that exists today in Fountain to to Nosta so that
- 1:02:08when you download the app, you can just, you know, log in with
- 1:02:12NOSTA and all of your followers will be there.
- 1:02:15The other thing that's really, really cool about NOSTA is the
- 1:02:20interoperability between the social activity as we present it
- 1:02:27in Fountain and the that same activity surfaced in the main
- 1:02:32NOSTA client feeds. Like, whether it's Prime or
- 1:02:35Damas or Amethyst, this this is brand new.
- 1:02:39This doesn't exist on the Internet today, which is, you
- 1:02:43know, when I watch a YouTube video, the comments underneath
- 1:02:49the YouTube video are just from random people that I don't
- 1:02:54follow. And that's because YouTube has
- 1:02:57no view into my Twitter social graph or any of the other social
- 1:03:03graphs that I actively participate in.
- 1:03:06With Noster, you'll be able to create experiences where you
- 1:03:09could go to that YouTube video and you could just press a
- 1:03:12button and it would filter out all of the comments from people
- 1:03:16that you're not following on Noster.
- 1:03:17And so you'd be able to just see like, OK, what are my followers,
- 1:03:21you know, thinking about this YouTube video?
- 1:03:24And also the comments on that piece of content don't even have
- 1:03:29to originate on the piece of content.
- 1:03:32Like if you shared, whether it's a podcast link or a YouTube
- 1:03:36video link on Twitter, that can be pulled back in and surfaced
- 1:03:41underneath the content as a comment.
- 1:03:43So there's interoperability, interoperability in a way that
- 1:03:48doesn't really exist on the Internet right now, which I'm
- 1:03:50personally really, really excited about.
- 1:03:52The the another way you can think about this is you know if
- 1:03:57you go to someone's profile on Noster, you'll see their feed in
- 1:04:02reverse chronological order and you can scroll back through
- 1:04:05their recent activity. But what if you could just go to
- 1:04:08their profile and filter on, you know, YouTube videos or filter
- 1:04:12on podcast episodes and just figure out, OK, in the last
- 1:04:15year, which podcast episodes has this person shared on social
- 1:04:20media? And that's something that we can
- 1:04:22just pull directly into Fountain and with your existing follower
- 1:04:26graph and just surface that in various different ways within
- 1:04:30the app. So that capability of an open
- 1:04:35social graph and also the ability to design formats and
- 1:04:41extend the specification to do these cool interoperable product
- 1:04:46features is why I'm so excited about Nordston and why we're
- 1:04:51integrating it. That should hopefully be live in
- 1:04:54the next month or so. So yeah, we're really excited
- 1:04:57about Monster. And then I also think just for
- 1:05:00podcasting as an industry as well, it's a great fit because
- 1:05:03again, podcasting doesn't have any of the social features that
- 1:05:06platforms like YouTube or Twitter have.
- 1:05:10It's highly fragmented. No one app has more than a 30%
- 1:05:14market share. So this concept of cross app
- 1:05:17comments, the ability for podcast comments to travel
- 1:05:21between apps and travel between hosting companies, Noster's the
- 1:05:24perfect protocol to do that. And so I'm hoping that what
- 1:05:28we're building on top of Noster into Fountain, we can actually
- 1:05:33push out into the wider podcasting industry and kind of
- 1:05:37get Noster adopted as the social layer for podcasting.
- 1:05:42So yeah, really, really excited about that.
- 1:05:44And yeah, a bit frustrated that we didn't have it when we
- 1:05:49launched because we're having to kind of like migrate our social
- 1:05:52graph, which is a bit of a pain, but we're getting there slowly.
- 1:05:56The the the other one that's super fascinating I heard and
- 1:05:59it's kind of merging a couple ideas is I heard you speak on
- 1:06:02another pod about the idea of like live streaming the pod but
- 1:06:08like being able to like because there's this thing happening
- 1:06:11right now where I think most are used to the format of one-on-one
- 1:06:15or maybe two on one. And so you see like All In has
- 1:06:17been very popular with four guests.
- 1:06:19The the last trade has three with a 4th guest, Max and DK,
- 1:06:24who've both been on this pod. They've started something called
- 1:06:26walking and taught like podcasting.
- 1:06:28Like there's these ideas of playing with the medium and this
- 1:06:31idea of like recording the pod and letting people participate
- 1:06:35in the app if they're there because that's the native
- 1:06:38experience. So if it's live.
- 1:06:40But as you were saying, you know filtering, I was thinking like
- 1:06:42well what if it was only a subset of your listeners that
- 1:06:44could participate while you're recording?
- 1:06:46So it's not live to everybody, it's only live to your your
- 1:06:49highest or you can select the highest signal.
- 1:06:52So let's say maybe it was like, you know they're the highest
- 1:06:55signal. But like let's say there was 5
- 1:06:56to 10 people, MVK, Marty, a couple people that could
- 1:06:59naturally comment if they wanted to listen in real time and
- 1:07:02interact in this episode. So it would surface in their
- 1:07:05comment versus having a bunch of people that would naturally fall
- 1:07:07on a YouTube channel that you have to sift through.
- 1:07:11That starts to make a more dynamic conversation and
- 1:07:13interesting like experience because you're letting listeners
- 1:07:17leave and they have a you. You just are able to filter and
- 1:07:20curate the dynamic of external people coming in versus it being
- 1:07:23just open to anybody. Seems kind of fascinating.
- 1:07:29Yeah, exactly. I think there's so much that's
- 1:07:32possible, those lines and I think you know again we're we're
- 1:07:36trying to get the the simple stuff done first, but hopefully
- 1:07:40down the line we can do a lot more like that.
- 1:07:43And obviously everything is just you know open.
- 1:07:46So once you have the data on NOSTA or it's kind of the same
- 1:07:52as RSS in that the podcast datas or that you can do anything you
- 1:07:56want with that as a developer. So yeah, I'm sure there'll be a
- 1:07:59lot more like that coming down the line.
- 1:08:03Also, well, this has been a fascinating conversation.
- 1:08:06I'm glad we could sort of walk through the the intricacies and
- 1:08:10and the details around value for value model and what you guys
- 1:08:13are building. It found because I think this is
- 1:08:16this is really you know a concept an idea that's you know
- 1:08:20we've talked about a lot over the past six to nine months
- 1:08:23around the goal of this podcast even to to really bring to light
- 1:08:28these other forms of utility of Bitcoin and outside of you know
- 1:08:33just digital gold story value like this.
- 1:08:35This technology is enabling things that you know as we've
- 1:08:39talked throughout this episode about like are just not possible
- 1:08:42in the incumbent in the incumbent world in the incumbent
- 1:08:45system. So super fascinating discussion
- 1:08:48Oscar, I want to thank you again for for coming on and and
- 1:08:51talking through these ideas. Where can people learn more
- 1:08:55about Fountain and start using it?
- 1:08:58Start sending boosts? Yeah, well thanks so much for
- 1:09:03for having me on guys. Really enjoyed the conversation.
- 1:09:06And yeah, if anyone wants to find out more about Fountain,
- 1:09:08you can go to fountain dot FM. The app's available on MSN
- 1:09:13Android. You can import your podcast
- 1:09:17really easily from Apple and Spotify.
- 1:09:19So yeah, give the app a try and if you have any feedback, feel
- 1:09:23free to DM me on either Nosta or Twitter.
- 1:09:27I'm happy to, you know, build what you want to make it the
- 1:09:30best experience possible. Awesome.
- 1:09:34Awesome. Thanks, Oscar.
- 1:09:35Yeah. Thanks for coming on and we'll
- 1:09:38hopefully have you on again soon.
- 1:09:40Maybe when the after the Noster integration rolls out, we can
- 1:09:43talk through how that how that's progressing because that that
- 1:09:46last part you were talking through was was fascinating to
- 1:09:48me. I think more and more people are
- 1:09:50are realizing like yeah let's integrate whatever we're doing
- 1:09:53with NOSTER. These are all open protocols.
- 1:09:55They're all interoperable. Like it's it's really
- 1:09:58fascinating to see. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:10:03week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:10:06valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:10:08rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:10:10All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:10:13notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:10:16reminder that On RAMP Media is for informational and
- 1:10:18entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:10:21investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:10:24your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:10:26Visit onrampbitcoin.com/contact. Schedule a consultation with one
- 1:10:31of our private client advisors.