Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Scarce Assets E014: Matthew Pines – Technological Evolution & State Power
Transcript
- 0:00Let's be clear, Bitcoin is an international asset.
- 0:04We are spending like drunken sailors.
- 0:08Bitcoin is the only economic entity.
- 0:10Where? The supply is unaffected by the
- 0:13demand. If you want to preserve.
- 0:16Your wealth, you have to convert that.
- 0:18Currency into an asset that's scarce, desirable, portable,
- 0:23durable, and maintainable. Hello, my name is Andy Eckstrom
- 0:33and I'm happy to welcome you to the 14th episode of Scarce
- 0:36Assets, a show that examines scarcity, the most fundamental
- 0:40driver of economics and markets and the scarcest asset of all,
- 0:43which is Bitcoin. Delighted to be here with my Co
- 0:46host Jesse Myers and our guest Matt Pines.
- 0:50I am especially pleased to be talking with Matt because he's a
- 0:53true expert on geopolitics. And frankly, much of geopolitics
- 0:57is about how nations position themselves to control scarce
- 1:00assets. So Matt is Director of Security
- 1:04Advisory at Sentinel One, which is a leading cybersecurity firm.
- 1:08He's a fellow at the Bitcoin Policy Institute, and he's
- 1:11published a number of papers on Bitcoin and national security
- 1:14and related topics. I especially recommend the one
- 1:17entitled Bitcoin and US National Security, in which he did the
- 1:21important work of articulating how Bitcoin enhances US National
- 1:25Security while also acknowledging its risks.
- 1:28And Matt also holds a master's of philosophy and public policy
- 1:32from LSE. And he holds a bachelor's in
- 1:35physics from John from Johns Hopkins.
- 1:39And he's also a novelist. His novel Expectation Value was
- 1:42published last year. I just ordered my copy and I'm
- 1:45looking forward to reading it. So Matt, thank you for coming on
- 1:48scarce assets. How are you I'm.
- 1:51Doing well you know, just enjoying the long holiday week.
- 1:54Happy to chat. Yeah, well, thank you for
- 1:57sitting down with us. I'm really looking forward to
- 2:00this chat. I actually want to start this
- 2:02conversation with a short story. It was April in 20/22.
- 2:09It was a Saturday night and I went to a party which was
- 2:12graciously hosted by Peter McCormick and it was at this
- 2:16amazing opulent mansion, OnStar Island, which is this man made
- 2:21island next to Miami Beach. And there was a huge outdoor
- 2:25open bar and a DJ and a dance floor and it was on the
- 2:29waterfront and the weather was beautiful.
- 2:31Has perfect conditions for a party with one exception.
- 2:35There must have been 1000 people at this party.
- 2:38And this party had one extremely scarce asset which was a single
- 2:42bathroom facility. It was one of these mobile
- 2:45bathroom trailer things, and I think there might have been 2:00
- 2:48rooms in it. And the line to use it was
- 2:52breathtakingly long. And moreover, there were
- 2:55security staff crawling all over this place, so they were
- 2:58actively preventing people from relieving themselves elsewhere,
- 3:03either on or near the property. So I had received Nature's call
- 3:07and was stuck waiting in line, and I'm not exaggerating for
- 3:10over an hour, but guess who was in line next to me?
- 3:13Matt Pines. So I got to meet Matt and I got
- 3:17to pick his brain for over an hour and I'm so glad I get to do
- 3:21get to do it today. So how do you remember that
- 3:24night, Matt? I remember you and me were maybe
- 3:27in worse shape than me. See, I timed it so that 'cause
- 3:29I, I saw the how long the line was.
- 3:32So I was sort of like, I need to position myself for when the for
- 3:35when I would get to the front. And so, yeah, I think we were
- 3:38able to have, you know, a conversation in moments of
- 3:41varying exigency. But yeah, that was a good, that
- 3:44was a good intro. Yeah.
- 3:46Well, fortunately, you had a lot of great and interesting things
- 3:49to say. So you know, the time for me
- 3:52passed quickly, notwithstanding the urgency of my situation.
- 3:56But but we'll, we'll leave that one.
- 3:58We'll leave that one there for now.
- 4:00I love the different approach to to that situation.
- 4:04Yeah, once in time delivery inventory management from Andy
- 4:08and then Matt with the T + 45 sort of approach.
- 4:13You know, I'm, I'm always about assessing risk in any
- 4:15environment. And that, that, that that was a,
- 4:18that was an acute risk I had to mitigate.
- 4:21Yeah, I should have known he was.
- 4:22He was thinking strategically from from the beginning.
- 4:26At On Ramp, we believe that Bitcoin is the most important
- 4:29asset of the 21st century. The hard part is securing it
- 4:32right There are shortcomings with keeping your coins on an
- 4:36exchange, but also with setting up your own self custody
- 4:39arrangement. On Ramp solves for these
- 4:41concerns. Our multi institution custody
- 4:44solution maximizes security and minimizes counterparty risk,
- 4:48ensuring that your Bitcoin remains securely in your
- 4:50possession and provides built in inheritance planning to ensure
- 4:54your family is protected as well.
- 4:56On Ramp provides Peace of Mind for your Bitcoin journey,
- 4:59whether for your whole stack or for part of it, as a complement
- 5:02to your existing self custody setup.
- 5:05For more information, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 5:09Well, this, you know, the show is called Scarce Assets and I
- 5:13wonder if you'd be willing to zoom out to the big picture and
- 5:17maybe frame up the last, I don't know, couple centuries or
- 5:21whatever time period you feel is useful.
- 5:24And and you know, maybe it's a much shorter time period, but
- 5:28can you take us to the current global competition for scarce
- 5:32assets, you know, maybe including particular resources,
- 5:38including and especially computing resources?
- 5:43Yes, I think fundamentally the monetary orders downstream of
- 5:48the geopolitical order and the geopolitical order is a function
- 5:51of state power and state power is a function of, you know,
- 5:55technology capabilities marshalled and services
- 5:58strategic objectives. And so this is fundamentally
- 6:01science and technology set the framework for what states can or
- 6:05can't do technologically in projecting power, defense or
- 6:08defense against each other's power.
- 6:10And so the predicate of state relations is often what is the
- 6:13prevailing technical and scientific paradigm until we've
- 6:16seen that unlock new capabilities, whether it's when
- 6:18the agricultural revolution generating large standing armies
- 6:21that can go out with Spears and just hack each other to death
- 6:24all the way through industrial revolutions where now you can
- 6:26create steamships. Now you can create large, large
- 6:29standing armies with more advanced armaments and you can
- 6:31serve, you know, do industrial scale warfare.
- 6:34And so like, you know, this is not a, a novel observation, but
- 6:36that's kind of the basic like foundational predicate for
- 6:39everything else we talked about. And in the 20th century, I think
- 6:43we've seen kind of the relationship between geopolitics
- 6:47and the money system become much more acute.
- 6:49You know, in, in times past, kind of the systems of global
- 6:52relations had an inherent relationship between money kings
- 6:56and kind of the, the relationship between sort of the
- 6:58capital provision in the merchant class and different
- 7:01political orders. And those were sort of stretched
- 7:05out in time. So those, those dynamics did
- 7:06change, but from the perspective of, of history, it took a lot
- 7:09longer. The 20th century took that same
- 7:12sort of pattern and it accelerated it.
- 7:14I think we're in an additional period of acceleration.
- 7:16I think the 20th century was a period of particular
- 7:20acceleration and that has had cascading effects.
- 7:23We're still living within and the formation of a different
- 7:26type of state system that really was forced by competitive
- 7:30pressures in World War Two to sort of create vertically
- 7:33integrated state, your bureaucratic structures to
- 7:36control and Marshall, you know, continental scale resources and
- 7:41populations to fight and win X central wars.
- 7:43And then also to leverage ground breaking understanding of the
- 7:47natural sciences to deploy novel weapons and technologies in
- 7:52those state conflicts. And so that birthed kind of the
- 7:54modern security environment we exist in today.
- 7:57So out of World War Two, we got of course nuclear weapons, but
- 8:00we also got radar. We got kind of the basics of of
- 8:03of computing and and computational systems.
- 8:07We got, you know, a whole raft of sort of electrical
- 8:11innovations, proximity fuses. We got a whole bunch of stuff,
- 8:14but those came out of state directed innovation pipelines
- 8:18and that really birth the kind of bureaucratic system that kind
- 8:22of was in its renaissance, essentially in the post war era,
- 8:26especially the American version of that.
- 8:28But it forced the kind of, you know, competition around the
- 8:31world for OK, now we need to create state institutional
- 8:34bureaucracies to sort of fight these these resource wars and
- 8:39and and and and wars of geopolitical influence.
- 8:42World War Two was a Crucible for state institutional creation
- 8:46that we sort of live within today.
- 8:47Kind of creation of the modern security state.
- 8:49The Defense Department, sort of the apparatus of government that
- 8:52was sort of formed first out of the sort of the impulse of the
- 8:55of the New Deal and then sort of became sort of regularized.
- 8:59And then of course, forged in the Crucible of World War Two is
- 9:01sort of what we live within today.
- 9:04And that really, you know, was kind of the high watermark of
- 9:07kind of this institutional power that was state directed, that
- 9:11was an alignment of military, defense, scientific,
- 9:14technological power. And that was sort of the high
- 9:16watermark of American institutional and global global
- 9:19power. And like all institutions, sort
- 9:21of Francis Fukuyama has this sort of characteristic analysis
- 9:24of how institutions are born with the sort of energy of
- 9:28creation, reach a certain maturity, usually within the
- 9:31first or second generation as they kind of adapt to the, you
- 9:34know, to to the environment and grow.
- 9:35And they have a sense of, of, of purpose and the sort of a
- 9:39novelty and the sort of energy of the, of the first kind of
- 9:42forebears. And the then the second
- 9:44generation, they sort of hand that baton to.
- 9:46And then there's sort of like a characteristic sort of peak and
- 9:49then slow decay as the second and third generations kind of
- 9:53take over that existing system which has been around for a
- 9:56while. And now kind of what they grew
- 9:57up within. It's kind of their basic
- 9:59predicate. And then the third and 4th
- 10:01generation is kind of like the Neil Howe sort of 4th turning
- 10:03idea, you know, tend to sort of forget how to maintain the
- 10:07systems that they were that they have inherited and tend to also
- 10:11approach it more like a 0 sum competitive dynamic to extract
- 10:15personal benefits out of this legacy system.
- 10:17Which once it starts, you know, getting into this reflexive
- 10:20feedback loop of decay, the sense of of of I need to just
- 10:24get what I can out of it before it totally fails, starts to
- 10:28dominate kind of the more collective orientation of the
- 10:31initial phase where it's all about contributing to a higher
- 10:34goal. And I think, unfortunately, I
- 10:36think that's a version of a story you could tell for the
- 10:39American institutional system over the past 80 or 90 years.
- 10:43And it has a dimension that is a stretch across not just our
- 10:48geopolitical sort of story, but about in our political system,
- 10:52but about like a monetary system too, right.
- 10:54So they, there are, you know, basic predicates of what sorts
- 10:58of systems you need to support a certain power structure.
- 11:02And the monetary system is a critical component of that.
- 11:04And and if you look at, you know, history, you know,
- 11:06decisions about changing the monetary, you know, regime are
- 11:12fundamentally geopolitical and political decisions.
- 11:14They're not made by the bureaucrats within the Federal
- 11:17Reserve. The Federal Reserve or the
- 11:19equivalents in other countries are meant to sort of maintain an
- 11:22existing system. They're meant to operate within
- 11:25very, you know, well established norms and sort of institutional
- 11:28frameworks. Any changes usually to the
- 11:30systems don't come from within, they come from without.
- 11:33And usually they resist those changes until the exogenous
- 11:36pressure sort of reach a tipping point and then they change
- 11:38pretty dramatically. And so, of course, you had FDR
- 11:42kind of, you know, go through this in the 30s where he was
- 11:45willing executive power and sort of fixed the gold price and then
- 11:49Nixon shock in the 70s. And then you could argue that,
- 11:52you know, there were various attempts between the Plaza
- 11:55Accord and the Louvre Accord to one, weaken the dollar and then
- 11:58strengthen the dollar, respectively, that were made
- 12:01essentially by executive mandate.
- 12:03Essentially the hierarchy of decisions was the White House to
- 12:06the Treasury Department to the Fed, in that order.
- 12:08And I think we're reaching a point in the global system where
- 12:11I think the, you know, combination of stresses,
- 12:14institutional decay of legacy systems is going to lead to a
- 12:17similar sort of of of, of threshold decision point.
- 12:21And I would expect this sort of historical template to be to be
- 12:26mirrored and how we how, how you would expect the system to
- 12:29adjust going forward. So that's like the US centric
- 12:31version. I think the geopolitical order
- 12:35is sort of a main driver of that.
- 12:37So there's like in my mind, there's like, you know, the
- 12:39basic dynamic of the global system is essentially that in
- 12:43the post war era has been especially post 70s has been the
- 12:47West, specifically the US as sort of the global military
- 12:50hegemon is the financial sort of provider of capital and and
- 12:56final end user sort of consumer demand for global goods that are
- 13:01the result of production in Southeast Asia, specifically
- 13:03China that is matched up with sort of raw commodities coming
- 13:07out of OPEC plus. So since you have this three
- 13:09legged stool that's like, you know, financial capital and sort
- 13:13of matrix of sort of military power and and territorial exit,
- 13:17territorial imposition of our, of our legal codes, you know,
- 13:20through sanctions and O FAC sort of regulations on the dollar
- 13:24system. That's like the one keynote is
- 13:26the US power. Now the keynote is sort of OPEC
- 13:29plus. It's kind of this loose
- 13:31affiliation of, of countries that dominate commodity market,
- 13:36specifically oil and then China, which has been essentially the
- 13:39the main power horse for global manufacturing.
- 13:41And as long as those like 3 system through three points of
- 13:44the global system, we're in kind of like a frenemy mode.
- 13:46You kind of got globalization, you got, you know, what we see
- 13:50is like the last 30 or 40 years of sort of economic global,
- 13:53global order. And I think that system is now
- 13:57in a process of like slow decomposition.
- 14:00And so you can see different examples of like the relations
- 14:03between that on that triangle is like Russia's sanctions is like
- 14:07taking a major whack between like the US dominated finance
- 14:10capital node and and a version and a subset of the OPEC node.
- 14:14You see the technology containment strategy between US
- 14:17and China as A and sort of this idea of decoupling or de risking
- 14:22as like a taking an axe and stressing the link between
- 14:26finance capital in the US and it's it's key trading partner in
- 14:31manufacturing supplier in in China.
- 14:34On the other hand, you're seeing kind of growing relationship
- 14:37sort of an an improvement of the bond between OPEC plus and China
- 14:41manufacturing centers through things like alternative currency
- 14:46sort of arrangements innovations with sort of cross bridge CBD,
- 14:49CS and sort of an increasing security alignment around things
- 14:53like SCO and the bricks. So that's like, you know, if I
- 14:56zoom out like there was a global order, it was sort of stable
- 15:00under a certain regime. And now it's getting perturbed
- 15:03pretty strongly. And we don't exactly know how it
- 15:06will continue to evolve, but you should expect potential
- 15:09significant change. So I'll stop there.
- 15:11That was a bit of a of a of a rant, but that's kind of my
- 15:14zoomed out view of where we are on a certain perspective.
- 15:19Yeah, that, that was awesome. That was a fantastic summary of,
- 15:22of where we're at and so thought provoking.
- 15:24I, I can't help but find it so interesting that the same
- 15:27problems that, you know, the classic archetype of like a
- 15:31family making a fortune and then trying to propagate that through
- 15:34generations and having that just natural inevitable decay of the
- 15:38meaning and skill set necessary to maintain that position is
- 15:43what happens to a country to, you know, you get to that
- 15:46position of power and then you just inevitably enjoy that
- 15:51position and lose this, the, the, the qualities that were
- 15:56necessary to establish that position in the 1st place.
- 16:00I want to ask, though, about. So the changing World Order by
- 16:04Ray Dalia was for me a very helpful entry point into
- 16:08questioning the future trajectory of the, you know, the
- 16:11global world order, globalism in general.
- 16:15And and you know, that the sort of stuff you learn about in
- 16:19Business School, they sort of projected a mentality like the
- 16:23world is going to become more and more unified.
- 16:26And then the changing world order was kind of the first, you
- 16:30know, really polished and well respected finance name that I
- 16:36was aware of really challenging and questioning that.
- 16:40But it felt like in, in Ray Dalio's thesis, the sort of
- 16:45implied take away was that the US is going through this natural
- 16:49decay. As you know, you're only you're,
- 16:52you're the dominant reserve currency for 100 years.
- 16:55And then inevitably a rising power takes your place.
- 16:59And the implied take away for me at least, was that China was the
- 17:03ascendant world power going forward.
- 17:06But it, it felt wrong. It still feels wrong to me
- 17:09because it feels to me with the Bitcoin lens like the Internet
- 17:13is that rising power that can be, you know, the, the, the new
- 17:18place that people turn to for trust in the currency.
- 17:21What are what are your thoughts on the on the changing world
- 17:24order thesis ideas? What does Ray Dalio get right or
- 17:27wrong? Very curious.
- 17:30Yeah, I, I, I certainly respected and have gained a lot
- 17:33from reading his analysis. And I think, you know, he's does
- 17:36a good historical review and I think he's making a conservative
- 17:41projection essentially just to saying, you know, holding all
- 17:44those equal, this is the past pattern.
- 17:47We should see indicators of that past pattern repeating itself.
- 17:50And so I'm just going to sort of follow the trends lines that
- 17:52history tells me are are it should be expected.
- 17:57I think, you know, there's like quote UN quote, like this time
- 17:59isn't different, but this time is different.
- 18:01Like fundamentally, technology has changed civilization and we
- 18:05are becoming a digital civilization and increasingly
- 18:07state power is mediated through digital systems.
- 18:12In fact, you could argue most of the state competition we see is
- 18:15happening sort of through over and aunt and and against
- 18:20essentially each other is digital networks, right.
- 18:22So whether it's subsea cables, you know, space transmission,
- 18:26you know, downlinks to the Arctic, whether it's digital
- 18:28currencies, whether it's AI computing, you know, clusters,
- 18:33this is sort of the the frontier of of state competition.
- 18:37And like power in a digital society is essentially network
- 18:40power. And network power has two
- 18:42different kinds. You have choke point and and
- 18:44surveillance power. So like the equivalent in and
- 18:47financial networks is, you know, choke point is like OFAC, you
- 18:51get the block and sort of excise, you know, participants
- 18:54out of the network. And that gives you a lot of
- 18:55power If you are the dominant, if you control most of the nodes
- 18:58in that network and if you control most of those in the
- 19:01network where you have, you can influence most of the nodes in
- 19:03the network to follow your rules.
- 19:04That gives you a lot of surveillance power.
- 19:06So you can get bank secrecy, Bank Secrecy Act reports out of
- 19:10every institution in the world. You can impose your
- 19:15extraterritorial sanctions, you know, through those, through
- 19:18those relationships, through through the dollar clearing
- 19:20system. And so you get immense amount of
- 19:22power. So US still has an immense
- 19:23amount of power that comes from just having legacy dominance of
- 19:27these existing networks. And China is trying to
- 19:31construct, they're trying to do 2 things.
- 19:32One is they're trying to mitigate how much exposure they
- 19:36have, you know, immediately to being coerced by the legacy
- 19:40system because they don't have an equivalent global
- 19:43hierarchical, you know, correspondence banking system
- 19:46that the United States has sort of organically supported the
- 19:48development over the past 80 years.
- 19:51And so they're trying to essentially block how much they
- 19:53can be coerced while trying to basically create their
- 19:55alternative sort of rails as like a failover backup.
- 20:00But that's in the financial space where like EU s s legacy's
- 20:03still dominant and China essentially is a is trying to
- 20:06sort of carve out some autonomy while putting in back up plate
- 20:09plans in trade and sort of manufacturing.
- 20:12China's already dominant. So China's by far the largest
- 20:14trading partner for most countries in the world.
- 20:17They're climbing the value chain pretty aggressively and it's
- 20:19triggering kind of panic in the West, whether it's E VS
- 20:22photovoltaics, 5G, etcetera. And I see my analysis of kind of
- 20:28the overall dynamic here is sort of a network competition playing
- 20:34out over all these different types of networks that are all
- 20:37that are all sort of interrelated.
- 20:39And there's like a value system piece of it that's built in in
- 20:44the sense that China's value proposition and their version of
- 20:47kind of digital technological governance is, you know, we need
- 20:52your resources, you know, you need our capital and our
- 20:56technology. And this is the deal.
- 20:58We'll give you essentially Huawei 5G, we'll give you CTE
- 21:01surveillance, we'll give you all of our state owned enterprise
- 21:06and, you know, construction capacity.
- 21:08And we'll sort of help you develop your economies, you
- 21:11know, become more digitally native.
- 21:13But it'll be on sort of our platform, right?
- 21:15And that will sort of help keep your regime in power and will
- 21:18help ensure that those resource deals and those geopolitical
- 21:20deals are secured. So I think that is with the
- 21:24dynamic playing out is like a competition over global
- 21:26influence that's over and through these digital networks.
- 21:30And I think it's not necessarily the same old story of, you know,
- 21:33systems just inevitably collapsed because of some
- 21:35historical projection. You know, his main focus is on
- 21:39debt. And so just to like zoom in on
- 21:41that is like, OK, some folks look at you as debt load as
- 21:44essentially an existential burden for the United States.
- 21:47And I think it is a critical burden, but, you know, there are
- 21:51sort of levers that the hegemon still has.
- 21:54And so you would expect that not to just go down quietly, right?
- 21:58And an important lever is that in in a world that's
- 22:00increasingly geopolitically risky, where conflict,
- 22:03especially great power conflict, looks like it's, you know,
- 22:06creeping up in terms of the probabilities.
- 22:09Then a whole host of states that are in the periphery of you
- 22:12might call like the Dollar Imperium have an have a their
- 22:16demand for security protection goes up, right?
- 22:20And the United States as the, you know, potential provider of
- 22:22that security protection, you know, can, can do a deal, which
- 22:26is we will provide more security protection, but you have to pay,
- 22:30right? It's a traditional kind of, you
- 22:32know, old style sort of racketeering, right?
- 22:36And whether it's, you know, Trump going over the NATO and,
- 22:38you know, bullying them into paying up more or whether it's
- 22:41doing these deals with Japan and the Philippines, South Korea,
- 22:45etcetera. There's you could imagine an
- 22:47arrangement which is the world divides into sort of clubs and
- 22:50fences. And the United States sort of in
- 22:52it's, you know, while it still has some legacy power in the
- 22:56global system, you know, uses those those reserves of power to
- 22:59essentially enforce a security zone, gates the security zone
- 23:03with tariffs and then forces members of that security zone to
- 23:06essentially pay up. And how could they pay up?
- 23:08Well, if you look at historical practice, whether it's FDR or or
- 23:12Nixon, you know, usually do that via some form of financial
- 23:16repression, right? And it's never quite the same,
- 23:18but it's usually the same in effect and the same effect, you
- 23:22know, go back to FDR essentially is we're effectively going to
- 23:24either seize or devalue your, your, your, your, your gold
- 23:26hold, like your gold holdings, your gold reserves, which we
- 23:30were doing then consistently essentially post war until it
- 23:33became untenable. And then Nixon essentially said,
- 23:36OK, we're just going to flip the switch and we're going to now go
- 23:39to floating exchange rates. So that was effectively a
- 23:44devaluation, right? It was a financial oppression,
- 23:46especially of kind of our, you know, our friends and allies
- 23:49and, you know, critically, but they couldn't really do a whole
- 23:52lot because, you know, it was this Cold War block based, you
- 23:55know, division of security zones and they were in our zone and so
- 23:58they could protest etcetera. But at the end of the day, we
- 24:01have the nukes, we have the aircraft carriers, etcetera.
- 24:03So that's how we were able to enforce that essentially reset
- 24:07of the of sort of the, the fiscal position of, of the US
- 24:10government as the sort of core of this dollar imperial system.
- 24:13So the equivalent today would not be like you can imagine
- 24:18varieties of it. You can imagine instead of, you
- 24:20know, devaluing the gold content of people's reserves, it's like
- 24:24increasing the duration content of their, of their FX reserves.
- 24:29So force them to just buy longer, longer dated treasuries.
- 24:32Everyone is basically now funding very short term, whether
- 24:34it's repos or FX swap markets or the foreign repo pool, very
- 24:39short term funding bills, markets, etcetera.
- 24:42And that's not exactly expressing a whole lot of
- 24:44confidence in the long term fiscal and militaries reaching
- 24:47Hegemi, United States. So you could say we're going to
- 24:50force you to provide a vote of confidence, which is you're
- 24:53going to swap those for century bonds or longer dated treasuries
- 24:57and we'll let you swap them at the FX at, at the, at, at, at
- 25:00the sort of the FIMA sort of repo facility at the Fed, you
- 25:04know, at par, just like the, the BTFB kind of facility.
- 25:10So in, in extremists, if you need an access to dollar
- 25:11liquidity, you can take the century bonds, you can pledge
- 25:13them at the Fed and get dollar liquidity.
- 25:16And that just sort of reinforces sort of the, the network power
- 25:19of the, of the, of the Fed and the dollar system.
- 25:22And it further sort of subjugates essentially
- 25:24monetarily sort of the, the, the periphery.
- 25:28So This is why I think the story that you tell of like simple
- 25:31curves of like, you know, the dollar, the dollar debt loads
- 25:34are unsustainable. And then there'll be a bond
- 25:36revolt and that the US government will just be like,
- 25:40oh, there's a bomb revolt. I guess we're not the hegemon
- 25:42anymore. It's like, that's not that's not
- 25:45the story that I would expect as a baseline.
- 25:47There is going to be like a whole bunch of Alamos, right,
- 25:50that are going to be said, this is the last line.
- 25:53And they'll be extreme sort of choices, you know, imposed on
- 25:56our friends and allies that we will, you know, essentially look
- 26:01to financially repress and geopolitically coerce to keep
- 26:04the system going. And, you know, so that is that's
- 26:08my baseline, right? That doesn't mean that we
- 26:09everything just the wheels fall off, but it means that it as we
- 26:13were essentially fighting, but we are fighting a major
- 26:15competition with China, at least from the perspective of DC
- 26:18policy elites. That there's a certain narrative
- 26:22that has taken hold and it's got elements of truth to it, which
- 26:24is like all the bad things that have happened in the past 30
- 26:27years, whether it's a deindustrialization, you know,
- 26:30the sort of atrophy of our defense industrial base, the
- 26:33fentanyl ravaging of the working class, deaths of despair, the
- 26:37political polarization. All of this sort of has been A
- 26:42cause of neoliberal elites selling out the country to
- 26:46China, essentially adopting this, you know, Gordon Gekko
- 26:50greed and globalization is good two point O type idea and kind
- 26:54of got, you know, rich off of this recycling system, taking
- 26:58dollar surpluses from China and OPEC and then putting into fancy
- 27:01assets and Manhattan real estate and they're getting rich and
- 27:04then the middle working class gets gets hosed something.
- 27:08There's there's some truth to that.
- 27:10But at the same time, it's sort of it's it's like, well, this is
- 27:15kind of the like, you know, just flip a switch and change the
- 27:17basic structure of the global global economic system.
- 27:19Like China actually has built an industrial base that's extremely
- 27:23effective and the United States is working from a position of
- 27:27relative weakness when it comes to that industrial capacity.
- 27:31And instead we're sort of, I think living in a bit of a a
- 27:35fantasy world where we think building some more chip
- 27:37fabrications in Ohio is going to somehow magically solve this
- 27:42problem. It's great for for politicians,
- 27:44everyone gets to say, oh, we're building these in a fancy data
- 27:48centers. It's tech jobs.
- 27:49But again, it's not that many jobs.
- 27:51And once the facility's built, it's like a few, a few high,
- 27:54high skilled workers that are going to be replaced by robots
- 27:56in a few years anyways. So it's like, if for me, it's a
- 28:00version of magical thinking, it's like the biggest threat to
- 28:03the West, and this is, I'll wrap this part up.
- 28:05The biggest threat to the West isn't our debt load.
- 28:07It is our magical thinking. It's, it's, it's the fact that
- 28:11we, we don't really think certain things are problems.
- 28:14And I think, you know, it's a bit political and I've, you
- 28:16know, I've, I try to be completely agnostic.
- 28:18I'm just trying to be an analytic observer.
- 28:20But like the whole issue with Biden's performance at the
- 28:22debate was a version of this magical thinking coming to
- 28:25coming to roost. Even close folks very close to
- 28:29the president who are like staunch allies of him, had a bit
- 28:32of like cognitive shock at the fact that, you know, they had
- 28:37been laboring under an illusion of of the apparent competence
- 28:42and coherence of national strategic policy making in the
- 28:45executive office. And it was a bit of like a, Oh,
- 28:49well, like this isn't just like a right wing Republican talking
- 28:52point, right? It's just like a statement of
- 28:55fact. And it's kind of hard to kind of
- 28:57come to grips with that, right? It's like the world is a certain
- 29:00way and you telling a certain narrative.
- 29:03And we're so good at fighting information wars with each
- 29:06other. We think everything is an
- 29:07information war when there are actual material constraints and
- 29:10facts in the world that you have to eventually confront.
- 29:13And the unfortunate problem I think we we have in the West is
- 29:17we're really skilled at telling narratives and we're like really
- 29:20good expert PR, you know, narrative shaping or like
- 29:24narrative shapers. And we have a lot of endogenous
- 29:26power. You can kind of coast on that
- 29:29and you can sort of just invest a lot of your elite cognitive
- 29:32capacity in constructing really sophisticated narratives.
- 29:36But when the sort of base of actual hard institutional
- 29:40legitimacy and material power starts to erode and all you're
- 29:44good at is essentially, you know, spinning tales and stories
- 29:49for each other, then you have this sort of Roadrunner moment
- 29:52when all of a sudden you realize, uh oh, this actually
- 29:55isn't, isn't, isn't a stable foundation.
- 29:59And that's unfortunately the biggest risk I see is not that.
- 30:02And this could have cascading impacts to the debt markets is
- 30:04like, if folks feel that, you know, the basic structure of
- 30:09American power is effectively hollow, then there could be, you
- 30:13know, instability. But yeah, that that that to me
- 30:17is the biggest risk isn't like the debt load per SE, but is
- 30:21like the narrative frame that we've constructed for ourselves
- 30:24as as like is now lagging the, like material reality.
- 30:28And you need to always be in alignment with reality, whether
- 30:31it's good or bad. You just need to like like
- 30:32accept it and then come up with a plan.
- 30:35Yeah, it it does. It does strikes me in the little
- 30:38analysis I've done on this of like there are levers that could
- 30:40be pulled, austerity and and the like, but we have just no
- 30:46political will, no desire as an electorate to face that reality.
- 30:51And instead we come up with magical thinking to just kick
- 30:54the can. And then the national debt
- 30:56becomes a real problem if you're just not going to address it
- 30:58with, with, you know, reality. Well, let's talk about the let's
- 31:03talk about the reality. I want to get back to your
- 31:06concept of, you know, military power in the US, power umbrella
- 31:11over Europe, obviously, but other segments of the world.
- 31:15And I know this is you're due to your professional experience.
- 31:20Let's talk about cybernetics and let's talk about command and
- 31:22control and let's talk about, you know, let's talk about nodes
- 31:27and networks. When you look at the US military
- 31:31budget and you look at, you know, let's say big ships, big
- 31:36ships and aircraft and, you know, physical things that can
- 31:40deliver mayhem. How do how do you think about
- 31:45how that budget is allocated as compared to cybersecurity in
- 31:49general or as compared to elements of information
- 31:55technology anywhere, anywhere you want to go with that?
- 31:58I mean, this is, I think the fundamental shift in how
- 32:02American policy makers think about security.
- 32:05I mean, we, we're continental island and that has shaped a lot
- 32:08of our, sort of our, our, our mental models of security and
- 32:13defense. Also our sense of national
- 32:14identity and security that, you know, we have relatively
- 32:17friendly neighbors ever since, you know, a few 18th century or
- 32:2219th century wars with Mexico and, and, and, you know, kind of
- 32:26just sort of clear the, the, the, the, the table.
- 32:29But once we established kind of, you know, the continental sort
- 32:33of hegemonic framework for our security model, then we were
- 32:38kind of, we're riding high. And we had, you know, then a
- 32:40sense of how we could essentially leverage the fact
- 32:43that we're both the Pacific and Atlantic power to project naval
- 32:47power globally, dominate maritime and commercial trade
- 32:51networks. And that was sort of the we're
- 32:53both like, yeah, we, that was the story of the 20th century.
- 32:55We kind of just took over the world basically.
- 32:59And that gave us a sense of like, domestic in
- 33:01invulnerability. No one could plausibly invade
- 33:05the United States, you know, you know, no one was ever going to
- 33:08take over or invade us, unlike other countries which have to
- 33:10worry about, you know, armored divisions on their on their on
- 33:13their border. And that like it's a Nikkeep
- 33:15threat that has to frame their whole approach to security.
- 33:17And this is not a novel observation.
- 33:20But you know, of course, cybersecurity, the fact we
- 33:22became digitally connected civilization, our society then
- 33:26was exposed to threats from, you know, other actors globally
- 33:32distributed in a way that cyber that, that those physical
- 33:34borders really were, were rendered moot.
- 33:37And that has taken a while to sort of shift the overall
- 33:42strategic mindset in the United States.
- 33:44And it has come in like 2 different directions.
- 33:45Like one is ransomware has really dramatically shifted the
- 33:49threat landscape for private companies and started to come to
- 33:53become a point where private companies are essentially kind
- 33:57of like, you know, normally you exist within a territory of a
- 34:00sovereign, you know, state and they provide, you know, certain
- 34:03common goods. And one of those is like
- 34:04collective security that we don't just, you know, let anyone
- 34:07just come in and rob you, you know, blind.
- 34:10We don't just like we enforce some basic rules of law and, and
- 34:14a security order around the private sector so they can do
- 34:17business, right. You're sort of saying like in
- 34:21cyberspace, there's a version of piracy emerge that's extremely
- 34:25lucrative and that it's sort of becoming like strategically
- 34:28important, especially in certain targets like say Colonial
- 34:31Pipeline or change healthcare, where now I realize there's
- 34:34certain private entities that are critical infrastructure for
- 34:37society and it doesn't require China or Russia hacking them.
- 34:41It can just be a bunch of 18 year old kids in Belarus that,
- 34:45you know, pick the right target at the right time and take down
- 34:49a provider that's critically comport important to an entire
- 34:52sector of the economy. And then everyone loses their
- 34:54minds. You know, it seems like every
- 34:56week now there's a version of this, whether it's in the energy
- 34:58sector, in the health sector, pharmaceuticals and even even
- 35:02car dealerships were like in chaos a few weeks ago because a
- 35:06critical company that provides all the software to all these
- 35:08car dealerships, you know, got got got ransomware.
- 35:10So we're sort of waking up to the fact that there's a the
- 35:14basic shift in the security paradigm for, for private, for
- 35:16private enterprises that are essentially just bundles of SAS
- 35:20applications in the cloud. And they're they're, you know,
- 35:23the security provider for their business is no longer the state.
- 35:27It's essentially that cloud provider, whether it's Microsoft
- 35:29or Google, whoever, or a bunch of other third parties.
- 35:33And so now they really rely more on the security practices and
- 35:37obligations or responsibilities of these private sort of tech
- 35:40conglomerates, which are not great, right?
- 35:42Microsoft essentially sells security as an up, as an upsell.
- 35:47So you know, you're kind of like you're kind of on your own,
- 35:50especially if you're a small company or even a medium sized
- 35:52business. But the US government is it's
- 35:55has faced a similar version of its own problem, but against
- 35:58larger scale actors, right? So it's it's, you know,
- 36:00ransomware has hit some federal agencies, but really the the
- 36:03major threat that keeps the government up up at night.
- 36:06And this is your point question about the balance of like how
- 36:08much we spend on like hard physical assets like aircraft
- 36:11carriers, which are $13 billion a pop or multi billion dollar
- 36:14spy satellites. Is that the cost differential
- 36:18for strategic, you know, platforms has dramatically
- 36:22changed, right? And so this this is manifested
- 36:25both in like the hard physical domain, like drones, for
- 36:29example, where the Houthis can build a fifteen $20,000 drone
- 36:32and can block a major global choke point for maritime trade
- 36:35and essentially force for months.
- 36:37The rerouting of massive trade volumes, you know, around the,
- 36:42around the, around the Horn of Africa doesn't require, you
- 36:45know, anything more than a bit of support from Iran in terms of
- 36:49manufacturing and then using Chinese components, which can
- 36:51give you really effective since you precision guided missiles.
- 36:56And that, that is not something that like we baked into our
- 36:58calculations. We were building these fleets of
- 37:00destroyers and, and carriers, you know, 20-30 years ago.
- 37:04And in cyber, it's the same thing where it's, you know,
- 37:08there's, there's been, this has been reported now as a, as a
- 37:10group that's affiliated with the People's Liberation Army.
- 37:15There is a theater command called Volt Typhoon, which is
- 37:19embedded itself in American critical infrastructure networks
- 37:23both overseas in Guam and Hawaii, but also in, in the
- 37:26continental United States. And they're looking in, you
- 37:29know, they're, they're already embedded in critical
- 37:31infrastructure networks, so telecommunications, ports,
- 37:34certain energy transmission systems, as well as, as well as
- 37:37water systems. And so we now wake up to this
- 37:40moment of like, OK, our the systems upon which we rely on to
- 37:44ensure civil order, economic functioning, even our military
- 37:49mobilization and readiness are can be sort of held at risk at a
- 37:52distance from an adversary purely essentially using very
- 37:57clever tricks to get in. And, and it's not like an easy
- 38:01solution to get them out. And that is, that is a different
- 38:04form of security environment than you had in the, in the,
- 38:07throughout the Cold War where it was basically like the missile,
- 38:10you know, the missile counterforce balance and, you
- 38:13know, hard power, like, OK, how much air defense do they have?
- 38:15Can we knock it out? Could we, you know, go in there
- 38:18and take that territory? Now it's a much more dynamic
- 38:21regime of, of coercion in advance of conflict.
- 38:25Cause the whole premise of these actions by, for example, this
- 38:29group, well, Typhoon isn't really to win a war if when
- 38:33we're fighting it, it's to deter us from escalating our
- 38:36involvement in a conflict, say in Taiwan, because our domestic
- 38:39political decisions, we'll focus on keeping order here.
- 38:43And it will change the calculation of leadership when
- 38:46everyone is, you know, freaking out about water and power,
- 38:49etcetera, in various urban environments and not, you know,
- 38:52stuff half around the world in Taiwan.
- 38:54And so that is a dramatic shift seeing this in space as well,
- 38:58right? I mentioned like the multi
- 38:59billion dollar super spy satellites.
- 39:01Well, you can get some of the capabilities for much cheaper
- 39:03now and they're not as vulnerable targets like a multi
- 39:06billion dollar platform we put into orbit.
- 39:09You know it's vulnerable up there, right?
- 39:11And so if instead you can put many different low cost, highly
- 39:15effective capabilities are much more what they call attributable
- 39:18or sorry attributable, then that's a big shift the United
- 39:22government is trying to move to. But I agree, it's to back to
- 39:25where my magical thinking, the Defense Department has put about
- 39:29a billion dollars towards something called the Replicator
- 39:31initiative. And this has been like much
- 39:34ballyhooed big strategic pivot and how we think about fighting
- 39:37wars about much more about mass quantities of low cost, you know
- 39:42relatively effective autonomous systems and how we just churn
- 39:46these out swarms, right undersea smart minds, you know swarm
- 39:51based drone systems for ISR as well as precision strike
- 39:55satellite based swarm self fueling mesh communications
- 39:57networks etcetera, etcetera. Again looks really good on a
- 40:00PowerPoint slide, right. But when we actually turn to our
- 40:03defense industrial base. And we say, oh, can you build
- 40:06100,000 of these things? They laugh in your face and they
- 40:09say, OK, like you need to pony up up upfront capital cost of X
- 40:14amount. And then maybe I can turn this
- 40:15out. And by the way, I can't
- 40:17guarantee you that I can source all those electronic, you know,
- 40:20chips and critical just sort of, you know, basic components from
- 40:24anywhere that is in China. What I can do is really good.
- 40:28Like, you know, he's really good at at creating exquisite top of
- 40:31the end, you know, super spooky capabilities that no one else on
- 40:34the planet knows about. But again, how many do we have?
- 40:37And are those going to be things that are going to be winning,
- 40:39you know, a fight that's could be like, you know, a matter of
- 40:43political will and industrial capacity, Whereas China is
- 40:46that's all that they're doing focused on is just how to churn
- 40:48out hundreds of thousands of these units.
- 40:51And they have a whole industrial ecosystem to turn to, to, to do
- 40:55that. And that again, magical thinking
- 40:57is like, oh, we'll, we'll write a check, we'll create a big
- 41:01program and we'll just rely on the competence of these
- 41:04industrial players and the bureaucracies in the Pentagon to
- 41:08kind of like make it happen. And but like the, the foundation
- 41:12of how much that worked is like, that doesn't exist anymore.
- 41:15Like we had the Ford and GM, we had the industrial capacity
- 41:19before World War Two that we could convert into making tanks
- 41:22and planes. We don't have that like, latent
- 41:25capacity to convert now. It's just a lot of talk.
- 41:29There's a lot of like, yeah, we should do this.
- 41:31And there's some, you know, promising initial attempts.
- 41:36But is it sufficient to like to meet this to, to, to, to, to
- 41:40cash the check that we're writing?
- 41:43I, I don't know. I think I need to see you more
- 41:45than I've seen today. Does your Bitcoin custody set up
- 41:48keep you up at night? Maybe you still have coins
- 41:51sitting on an exchange. Worried about hackers?
- 41:54Or maybe you've set up your own self custody but don't feel safe
- 41:56with your Bitcoin savings stashed on a little plastic
- 41:58device in your desk drawer? Gain Peace of Mind with Onramp
- 42:03and our multi institution custody solution.
- 42:06Here's how it works. Onramp creates a dedicated multi
- 42:09sig vault just for you. 3 separate institutions each hold
- 42:12a key, Onramp bit go and coin cover, but none can move funds
- 42:17unilaterally. Instead, only you have control
- 42:20over your coins with on ramp's multi institution custody.
- 42:25You'll sleep better at night knowing your Bitcoin is stored
- 42:27with best in class security on chain with fault tolerant multi
- 42:30sig. If you believe your Bitcoin is
- 42:33going to be worth a lot someday, don't jeopardize that future by
- 42:36exposing your coins to hackers on exchanges, $5 wrench of tax
- 42:40in the real world, or perhaps most importantly, the risk that
- 42:44you might screw something up with a highly technical self
- 42:47custody set up. Onramp's multi institution
- 42:50custody eliminates single points of failure, reduces your
- 42:53personal attack surface and technical burden, and provides
- 42:57access to financial services that allow you to confidently
- 42:59secure your Bitcoin, including inheritance planning, insurance
- 43:03backed warranties for all balances and transactions, low
- 43:06cost trading and more. Bitcoin is a once in a species
- 43:10asset. Secure it right.
- 43:12Learn more at onrampbitcoin.com. It's hard to replicate, you
- 43:17know, an industrial base like Shenzhen, right within the
- 43:23United States after there's been all this offshoring of that
- 43:26industrial capacity. We really are in a different
- 43:29world today. Well, I there's a couple of
- 43:32directions I want to go with here.
- 43:33I want to return to your comment about Microsoft.
- 43:37You know, one of my sort of mental models economically for
- 43:41Microsoft is it's a business that runs a monopoly, that
- 43:45extracts monopoly rents in terms of revenue while, you know,
- 43:51while off boarding all the liability associated with
- 43:54insecurity. And so no wonder it's a
- 43:57wonderful business, right? No wonder it's one of the most
- 44:00profitable businesses in history.
- 44:02Now, of course, it's new, you know, the the cloud dynamic is
- 44:07it's a little bit of a different business that changes the model.
- 44:10But one of the things I always loved about Bitcoin was that it
- 44:14actually privatized the cost of insecurity, right?
- 44:19For the first time ever. For the first time ever,
- 44:23companies that were running insecure software actually had a
- 44:27price potentially associated with it.
- 44:29Now, I don't know where that ends up from a policy
- 44:32perspective. I sometimes imagine that the
- 44:36only real solution is that most are all critical.
- 44:41Infrastructure, at least on the private side, needs to run on
- 44:44open source software just because it'll maybe actually be
- 44:47secure. That might be ambitious or
- 44:51unrealistic. Do you have any thoughts in in
- 44:54that regard? Yeah.
- 44:57I mean, there's a lot there and certainly this is close to what
- 44:59I do day-to-day is, you know, when you think about what a
- 45:03private company is as like, like the basic systems that run a
- 45:07company, it has finally changed last 15 or 20 years.
- 45:10It used to be, you would have, you know, servers in house run
- 45:13quote on Prem maintained by your own in house IT department and
- 45:19responsible for securing to do that like intranet.
- 45:22And it was like kind of a walled garden.
- 45:24And it was really focused on, you know, security in that model
- 45:26was about ensuring that like, you know, you could kind of
- 45:29monitor the the boundary of that of the enterprise network.
- 45:32And it was firewalls and it was authentication systems and
- 45:35encryption, etcetera. What has dramatically shifted in
- 45:38the last 10 or 20 years, really in the last 10 years has been
- 45:41the shift to the cloud, right, where and increasingly what the
- 45:45company is, you know, in terms of the data, the systems, the
- 45:48process, the tools, the, you know, but the administrative,
- 45:52you know, functions are essentially provided by third
- 45:54parties, you know, SAS applications, whether it's Slack
- 45:58or your major, you know, enterprise, you know, sort of
- 46:01hosting provider, mostly Microsoft or Google Cloud or
- 46:04AWS, etcetera. And so a company is just kind of
- 46:06a bundle of SAS applications with, you know, a certain tax
- 46:10registration and, you know, globally distributed employees
- 46:13that can log in to perform their different functions.
- 46:16And so security, you think about securing that sort of thing, the
- 46:19security model for that sort of company is very complicated now
- 46:23because there's been a proliferation of more complex
- 46:26technical stacks. Kind of the legacy stack is
- 46:28still sometimes mixed in with kind of this cloud stack.
- 46:31We haven't shifted like a new model, but you can imagine like,
- 46:36you know, like imagine that essentially if the trend
- 46:38continues, you can see most companies could look like
- 46:41essentially, you know, they're kind of like surfs in like a
- 46:45digital sort of feudal system, right?
- 46:47Like their whole data were just exists and all the services
- 46:50exist hosted on say, you know, a single provider, say Google
- 46:54cloud or, or Microsoft Azure and or now, you know, could be like
- 46:59hedge between multiple, like sort of multiple clouds, but
- 47:02usually it's like a handful of them.
- 47:03And so your security model is essentially their security
- 47:05model, right? They have all your data.
- 47:08Your operational systems are dependent on their functioning
- 47:11cloud infrastructure. Your customer's data is hosted
- 47:15on their servers. And so the security model for a
- 47:17private company now is essentially contingent on the
- 47:21security practices of these big tech conglomerates.
- 47:24And so, you know, there's certain things individual
- 47:25companies still responsible for, like provisioning access to
- 47:29their employees, ensuring they have multi factor
- 47:31authentication. They often develop a whole bunch
- 47:33of their own business applications.
- 47:35They're going to make sure that those applications are secure,
- 47:37the whole sort of dev SEC OPS stuff.
- 47:40And of course AI is changing that as well.
- 47:42So it's not like it's still a very mixed bag.
- 47:45But I would say to your point, like private companies do not
- 47:49work like an economic super efficient machine, right?
- 47:52Sort of like sort of the Cosian analysis of like there's a price
- 47:56signal from ransomware and therefore that price signal will
- 48:00translate into, you know, certain security response.
- 48:04I think you're seeing that, but it's not necessarily sufficient,
- 48:08right? So like the threat of ransomware
- 48:11has forced companies to raise the profile of security
- 48:14considerations, you know, up. And so budgets have also gone up
- 48:18to a certain extent. But but it's also kind of like
- 48:21human beings are very much especially corporate CE, OS and
- 48:24senior, you know, sort of chief financial officers.
- 48:27You know, security is a cost center, right?
- 48:29The rest of the company provides revenue and so if you ever hit a
- 48:34speed bump, you're coming up on quarter end and you're looking
- 48:37ways to save money. Cost centers always take the hit
- 48:40first. And so you see security kind of
- 48:42come in, the security spend. It kind of comes in these pieces
- 48:45and troughs and it's very sector specific or like if there's a
- 48:47very high profile event that hits a certain sector and it
- 48:51looks like maybe the feds are going to start to regulate it.
- 48:53Like, for example, in healthcare, you know, there's a
- 48:55whole push now after the change healthcare stuff to potentially
- 48:59pass like mandatory security requirements.
- 49:02And of course the health sector is very resistant to that
- 49:05because it wood forest them to spend more than they want to
- 49:07spend, often at their own collective expense.
- 49:11So this is the problem of like human beings is like, you know,
- 49:14we tend to unless we have a, is it like a principal agent
- 49:17problem here? This is like the corporate CE OS
- 49:18get judged on fiscal perform, on financial performance in, in, in
- 49:22sort of equity returns and their stock and their pay packages are
- 49:24directly related to that. And so there's like this Turkey
- 49:27problem of like, yeah, they could be hit by ransomware, But
- 49:31if they do, if they just do enough to look like they did the
- 49:34right things and they still get hit, you know, they kind of
- 49:39cover their, they kind of cover their ass, right.
- 49:42So there's a big problem of how to trans as a.
- 49:44You know, a lot of conversations I have is like how to translate
- 49:47not just cyber risk, but geopolitical risk, which are to
- 49:50a certain extent like unquantifiable.
- 49:52You know, there's been some attempts to sort of quantify
- 49:53cyber risk, but my, my perspective, they're just, you
- 49:57know, they're only usually applicable in like very narrow
- 50:00domains. And even then they're not that
- 50:02great. Like cyber insurance is like not
- 50:04a very ineffective market at the moment.
- 50:07And that's just like a proof of kind of this.
- 50:09They haven't been able to price that risk effectively, right.
- 50:11Usually if you can price the risk, you should be able to buy
- 50:13an insurance product to mitigate it.
- 50:16And there there's not great. The cyber insurance market is
- 50:19just not not very effective at the moment.
- 50:22So yeah, that was just a yeah. So we're kind of in not a great
- 50:25spot when it comes to cybersecurity and the modern
- 50:28enterprise. And it's it's compounded by the
- 50:30fact that you're seeing the financial incentives, you know,
- 50:35as Bitcoin goes up, right, the financial incentives for for
- 50:38ransom actors goes up as well. And you're increasingly seeing
- 50:43some sophisticated threat actors, like a nation state
- 50:46level kind of masquerade as ransomware crews.
- 50:51It's a very clobber. In fact, we, we just put our
- 50:52report on this of a Chinese group that was sort of, you
- 50:55know, making themselves look like in conducting ransomware
- 50:58attacks 'cause we just want to steal some stuff.
- 51:01Yeah. It used to be that.
- 51:03It used to be the government hackers were a cost Center for
- 51:08governments. But now that they now they can
- 51:09get paid, they can make Bitcoin, right?
- 51:12Well, I mean ransomware. I mean, North Korea's lies Worth
- 51:15group, which is essentially their they're the cyber cyber
- 51:19element of their military intelligence wing.
- 51:21But the party is, you know, full time cyber criminals.
- 51:25And yeah, they're very effective at, you know, not just hacking
- 51:28and stealing, you know, weakly coded D5 protocols and cross
- 51:31bridge protocols, but actually infiltrating employees into
- 51:35these protocols, you know, as programmers, as as developers.
- 51:38And then once they get to a certain size, you know, they get
- 51:40access to to the keys and they're just poof, they're ours
- 51:43now. Or they just building
- 51:44vulnerabilities that some other unit exploits.
- 51:46So we're seeing it's kind of this, you know, you know,
- 51:50Cryptonomicon, you know, kind of kind of kind of system.
- 51:54Yeah. I don't see it reaching like a
- 51:55healthy equilibrium at any, at any point soon.
- 51:59It's, you know, kind of an, an arms race between offense and
- 52:03defense. And I think at the end of the
- 52:06day, you're going to see something like, you know, if the
- 52:08security provider, if the monopoly security provider can't
- 52:11effectively defend private companies, private companies are
- 52:14going to eventually kind of defend themselves.
- 52:16And, you know, this idea of like, you know, private
- 52:20companies hacking back is technically against the law.
- 52:23But at a certain point, I could imagine the norm shift enough
- 52:27that that's what happens. Or, you know, certain certain
- 52:31U.S. policy makers make a decision that we're going to
- 52:33impose cost on certain groups that cross cross a red line.
- 52:39And, you know, we've drone strike terrorists.
- 52:41We haven't drone strike any, you know, ransomware crews.
- 52:45But I don't know, I, I'm not advocating as a policy, but I
- 52:48could see that like you, you could see us on a trajectory
- 52:51where where that gets considered.
- 52:53So yeah, this is a new dynamic and the the boundary lines
- 52:57between the public and private sector are dramatically
- 52:59shifting. And one of the keys to put on
- 53:02Microsoft back to like the point of like digital sovereignty and
- 53:05and, you know, the changing nature of of warfare.
- 53:09So in the early weeks of the Ukraine conflict when Russia
- 53:13came in, is, you know, Ukraine government was worried about
- 53:17their basic government services and data which was locally
- 53:20hosted. And so Microsoft offered and did
- 53:23essentially redeploy all of those services to their Azure
- 53:30infrastructure in the UK, You know, free charge.
- 53:32It's like a few $100 million worth of, you know, digital
- 53:34services equivalent. And so that's like a digital
- 53:36government exile, right? It's a concept we didn't really
- 53:38have before where like all the government records and, you
- 53:42know, services, whether it's tax records, draft records,
- 53:45government services of all kinds were essentially being hosted,
- 53:49you know, out of the country by a private company.
- 53:51And this idea of like, you know, national sovereignty, you know,
- 53:55starts to become more, more more sort of complicated, right?
- 53:59It's like, OK, a a sovereign government is relying on
- 54:01essentially the goodwill of a private company to protect its
- 54:05basic, you know, functioning as a state.
- 54:08And that didn't, you know, that's not a constant that
- 54:10existed 30 years ago. And so I think you're seeing
- 54:14that power dynamic play out. And Microsoft is a key example
- 54:17of this, where you're doing these arrangements around the
- 54:20world. You can sort of model Microsoft
- 54:24as like a quasi sovereign entity that has its own strategic
- 54:27objectives, which is build more data centers, more places to
- 54:31suck in more data, to like just digitally colonize as much of
- 54:35like the digital territory as possible.
- 54:37Like that's its objective. Its objective isn't to like do
- 54:39good things for America or do good things for China or do good
- 54:42things for the Emirates. It's to like grow more data
- 54:45centers, get suck in more data and like colonize more of the
- 54:48digital territory and have more companies and governments
- 54:50essentially pay rent on its digital land, right, If that's
- 54:54the metaphor. And so then it has this
- 54:56incentive to go in all these places and do deals that like
- 54:59G42 and the Emirates and now doing this sort of data center
- 55:03build out in Kenya that from one perspective look like, Oh, this
- 55:06is great. This is now an American tech
- 55:09company, you know, colonizing this digital, you know, land and
- 55:13and not a Chinese company. It's not Alibaba cloud,
- 55:15etcetera, or or, you know, there's there's no hallway, you
- 55:18know, towers there. It's all going to be, you know,
- 55:20Microsoft and open AI data centers and AI.
- 55:23But the other said perspective, it's like, well, Microsoft is a
- 55:27fair weather company. Like they they are responsible
- 55:29for their shareholders. And at the end of the day, you
- 55:32know, we don't have a whole lot of coercive influence over
- 55:35Microsoft. In fact, a government like a new
- 55:38government board called the Cyber Safety Review Board
- 55:40totally ripped into Microsoft like a month or two ago because
- 55:44it was their basic security failures that led to the pretty
- 55:47deep compromise of U.S. government, you know, agencies.
- 55:52And, you know, it was like China and Russia kind of leveraging
- 55:57Microsoft's poor security practices.
- 56:00And because, you know, they didn't have the incentive to
- 56:02prioritize that and it created a big PR thing.
- 56:06But at the end of the day, like the US government, you know, can
- 56:09sort of use the bully pulpit and maybe can find them.
- 56:13But we're in this new world where these private big tech
- 56:16companies do have essentially almost quasi sovereign power.
- 56:20And see if your point about Bitcoin, I think that's where
- 56:22it's it's really fascinating because there's, you know, not
- 56:25too many like novel institutions that are globally, you know,
- 56:30distributed that have a sort of a self-sustaining endogenous
- 56:34stability to them. But they're not, you know, like
- 56:37these existing systems of kind of neo feudal digital
- 56:39capitalism. They're kind of a much more
- 56:41different form of system. And I think the implications of
- 56:44that, you know, should be modeled into how you think
- 56:47about, you know, the development of these digital societies and
- 56:51whether you're going to swing towards this techno
- 56:52authoritarian, you know, neo digital feudal model or where
- 56:56they're going to have a more decentralized liberal
- 56:58traditional, you know, sort of small D democratic, sort of
- 57:02political and economic system that's now digitally mediated.
- 57:05And that's, that's doesn't be the battle lines for, you know,
- 57:08the next decade or two. Wow, so much embedded in there.
- 57:12I always, you know, in that vein as it relates to corporate
- 57:17sovereignty, Matt, I sometimes think about the AI boom and I
- 57:22think about owning equity in, I don't know, in via Google or
- 57:27Microsoft or whoever one of these AI places.
- 57:29And I think to myself, what does that mean exactly?
- 57:33Like, how do I feel about my status as a minority shareholder
- 57:38in an entity that may already, or at least in the near future,
- 57:44you know, possess so much power that it may somewhat exist
- 57:49outside the classical boundaries of property rights that
- 57:55investors, you know, have come to depend on, at least in the
- 57:58United States over the last over the last few centuries.
- 58:01You know, like what? What does that look like?
- 58:04Do you have any thoughts? Do you have any thoughts on
- 58:06that? I mean, the lesson in history is
- 58:09that the plebs always get hosed, right?
- 58:12You know? The masses are always just the
- 58:14exploited, you know, physical labor or grunts for the for the
- 58:18for the meat machine on the front.
- 58:21It's like lesson history is that most most systems of power don't
- 58:24care what you think, Andy, Most systems of power run over you
- 58:28like a bug underneath the tire, right?
- 58:31It's like only in like a sort of a relatively recent window of
- 58:34human history have there been systems of government where the
- 58:37systems of power have to essentially be accountable and
- 58:39checked by, you know, the median voter.
- 58:42And I think the conditions that enabled such political
- 58:46conditions to obtain were were coincidence that kind of was
- 58:51kind of lucky, right? It was kind of, you know,
- 58:54coincidence of the fact that it was it was a relatively liberal
- 58:58English, you know, parliamentary system that discovered coal and
- 59:02became like an industrial powerhouse for global trade and
- 59:05then impose their common law norms and English language
- 59:07around the world and colonized America.
- 59:09What had this massive abundance, kind of a one shot massive, you
- 59:13know, natural resource, kind of like, you know, treasure house
- 59:16that could, you know, import that system of democratic rule
- 59:20and common law adapted for the frontier, you know, democratic
- 59:23ethos and created modern, you know, created America.
- 59:27Like those were like contingent historical kind of like lucky
- 59:30strikes. And you know, I think, you know,
- 59:34I'm not like I'm not a pessimist, I'm an optimist.
- 59:37I'm sort of just like there's historical deterministic, like
- 59:39determinating conditions about like what political conditions
- 59:42are possible under certain economic and technological
- 59:46conditions. And unfortunately, I think we
- 59:48could be heading to an environment where, you know, the
- 59:51like this. I don't believe this fully, but
- 59:55you can tell a good argument that, for example, like the Goss
- 59:58plan of the Soviets, you know, was practically infeasible from
- 1:00:02the, you know, same sort of, you know, like hayeacking a
- 1:00:04knowledge argument that you just can't centrally plan a complex
- 1:00:07economy. There's a certain strain of
- 1:00:10technocratic belief. That actually with AI you can do
- 1:00:14two things. One, you know, you can, you can
- 1:00:18do more complex, you know, real time analysis of the economy.
- 1:00:21In fact, the Bank of National Settlements, it's like one of
- 1:00:24their main policy sort of tool programs is to like how to do
- 1:00:28like now casting with AI to actually try to see the the
- 1:00:32economy in real time and try to do these fine-tuned adjustments
- 1:00:36to steer and manage the economy. That's how I did do it.
- 1:00:39But the other hand, there's other subset of stakeholders
- 1:00:41that don't say this publicly, but they also believe AI is
- 1:00:44really good. You know, OK, there's too many
- 1:00:45preferences, there's too many diverse sets of beliefs and
- 1:00:48attitudes in society. We seem to like manage that
- 1:00:51diversity down to controllable system.
- 1:00:55And so you can use AI not just to calculate preferences and,
- 1:00:58and, and wages and, you know, do the sort of Goss plan like
- 1:01:02version, but you can like take the extraneous variables that
- 1:01:05otherwise would be too complex for the AI to manage.
- 1:01:06You can just use AI to like steer them away, to suppress
- 1:01:10them away. And when everyone's beliefs and
- 1:01:11attitudes are technologically mediated and and therefore
- 1:01:14manipulatable, you could see yourself drifting into sort of a
- 1:01:17techno authoritarian AI Goss plan.
- 1:01:21And there's a lot of folks that think in that elite system that
- 1:01:23believe that's like a desirable course of action.
- 1:01:25And that would, you know, potentially lead to more safe,
- 1:01:29more more, you know, more stable economic systems, but would
- 1:01:33eventually be, you know, an erosion of what we think of as
- 1:01:35like individual liberty and, you know, democratic legitimacy.
- 1:01:40So that is like a big fear that I have sort of in this slow
- 1:01:44motion, you know, path of least resistance just to give more
- 1:01:48control up to these systems, even if they're not that good.
- 1:01:50But they form like a they form a, a shelling point, right, For
- 1:01:55sort of elite governance that OK, we all disagree.
- 1:01:57This is the system we're going to we're going to follow because
- 1:02:00it makes everything easier for us to manage.
- 1:02:01I don't think it's actually going to work, but I think they
- 1:02:05could try. And so, yeah, this is where
- 1:02:08Bitcoin is potentially very important politically in that it
- 1:02:12provides essentially a refuge, right?
- 1:02:16Because I think Europe, you know, certainly is going along
- 1:02:18this, this path where they're under so much stress of
- 1:02:21fragmentation, geopolitical economic stress that the need to
- 1:02:26try to like contain things is going to, you know, has
- 1:02:29incentives to centralized and therefore, you know, suppress
- 1:02:34diversity of thought, diversity of, of economic decision making.
- 1:02:38And usually when you're in a crisis, you know, in whether
- 1:02:42it's war or something approaching war, you tend to see
- 1:02:45things like capital controls, credit rationing, financial
- 1:02:47oppression, censorship, etcetera.
- 1:02:49And so if the, if the world power structure thinks that it's
- 1:02:53in a crisis, which it, which it is, you would expect that to be
- 1:02:56the, the, the, the trend line. That's just what history tells
- 1:03:00me, Heavy. No, of course, the, you know,
- 1:03:08the the technocratic central planning bordering on
- 1:03:12communists, you know, top down directive control.
- 1:03:16It does feel like it it will be tried because, you know, has
- 1:03:20been the dream in many circles for the last century.
- 1:03:24So in all this, Matt, you've brought so much nuance and like
- 1:03:28considered thought to both the trajectory of the future
- 1:03:33trajectory of of national security and cybersecurity.
- 1:03:37And then I'm very curious to to tease out like how do you think
- 1:03:41about Bitcoin and its role in the trajectory into the future
- 1:03:46is specifically how you think differently from the rest of us
- 1:03:49Bitcoiners who haven't layered in all these considered nuances
- 1:03:52about, you know, the complexity of how all these different
- 1:03:56levers that that the US will pull with regard to the national
- 1:04:00debt and so on. So I think for one, nothing is
- 1:04:06like historically inevitable. And if I look at history, I see
- 1:04:10a lot of like contingent decisions made by like certain
- 1:04:13individuals, like presidents actually matter, right?
- 1:04:16So like, who makes it? Just like, you know, Nixon with
- 1:04:18like, I think Kissinger wasn't there, but it was his Treasury
- 1:04:22Secretary. It was Paul Volcker, like one
- 1:04:25other guy, like Camp David in like 3 days.
- 1:04:27And they kind of just decided they were going to do, you know,
- 1:04:31the Nixon shock, right, That there was probably like there
- 1:04:33was a build up to that. There was like, I think they
- 1:04:35were triangulating around a big change.
- 1:04:37There was like a few guys went to a place, had some decisions
- 1:04:41and it was like, boom, we're going to announce it and then
- 1:04:43everyone's going to like be in a different world.
- 1:04:45And so I sort of think about Bitcoin in that way, which is,
- 1:04:48you know, it's naturally evolving, but the legacy system
- 1:04:52is still subject to like a handful of individual decision
- 1:04:55makers, whether it's the White House decision makers, ECB, you
- 1:04:58know, President Xi, etcetera. And so I think sometimes
- 1:05:02Bitcoiners, you know, think too much about sort of inevitable,
- 1:05:05just sort of trend line, you know, having cycle driven peaks
- 1:05:09and valleys and the price action as just, OK, it is the IT is
- 1:05:13the, you know, unstoppable force.
- 1:05:16And it will sort of, you know, sort of sweep away the the
- 1:05:22legacy system. It's almost like this, you know,
- 1:05:25it's kind of like a religious fervor, right?
- 1:05:27And so, you know, you need that to like have the movement spark
- 1:05:30itself. And there's a sense of like
- 1:05:33hyper optimism that you have to have right to a certain extent
- 1:05:36as being a part of any sort of political movement.
- 1:05:38I think Bitcoin sub subsets of Bitcoin are like a political
- 1:05:41movement in that respect. But I think, you know, as a pure
- 1:05:44realist, it's like there's legacy institutions and some
- 1:05:47parts of legacy institutions are going to react very hostilely or
- 1:05:50very, you know, pragmatically to to this emerging trend.
- 1:05:54And I think it's very hard to predict.
- 1:05:56But like, for example, just to make this very practical, like
- 1:05:59Trump hosting whatever it was, the 10 or 15 Bitcoin mining CE
- 1:06:03OS and a few other folks. David Bailey, kind of, you know,
- 1:06:06the ringleader of that posse down to Mar a Lago.
- 1:06:10So like, you know, big monetary shifts happen in, you know,
- 1:06:14usually like retreats or like palaces, you know, the
- 1:06:17Versailles or the Louvre or, you know, even Bretton Woods, you
- 1:06:22know. Yeah, Circle Island, you know,
- 1:06:25they're on a yacht, you know, So it's just like you, you know, a
- 1:06:27small bunch of rich people or elites or something you put them
- 1:06:30into like a fancy building and they come up with like a summit
- 1:06:34or an accord or whatever, right. And they then they change.
- 1:06:36And at least what I heard from that meeting is that there's
- 1:06:40some wild conversations happening about the potential
- 1:06:43for Bitcoin and Trump administration.
- 1:06:45No, I think some of that is just like, you know, throw it against
- 1:06:48the wall, see what sticks, right?
- 1:06:50Or just know you have an opportunity to shift the Overton
- 1:06:52window so dramatically. So you just want to blow the
- 1:06:55Overton window as far out as possible.
- 1:06:57And then knowing that it's eventually going to snap back,
- 1:06:58but it's going to snap back to a place.
- 1:07:00It's like finally shifted from where it is today.
- 1:07:02So it's probably some tactical considerations about, you know,
- 1:07:05some of those ideas. But I think not if thought goes
- 1:07:09into the, it's sort of like there's a risk of Bitcoiners
- 1:07:12like being like the dog that caught the car, right?
- 1:07:15Which is like we were so much always like thinking, oh, nation
- 1:07:18state adoption is almost here. Nation state adoption is almost
- 1:07:20here. Central banks are gonna buy it.
- 1:07:23Middle East is gonna buy it. China's gonna buy it is gonna be
- 1:07:25this geopolitical arms race. And then like, our bags are
- 1:07:27gonna be just like, you know, AD zeros.
- 1:07:31And I think not much thought is going to like what actually what
- 1:07:34actually happens when that happens, right?
- 1:07:36There's just because I think it's been painted for so many
- 1:07:39years is like this somewhat far off, but not too far off kind of
- 1:07:44somewhat utopian vision of like Bitcoin making it right and
- 1:07:47coming out of the wilderness of being somewhat of a fringe
- 1:07:49taboo, somewhat derided subclass.
- 1:07:53And there's a resentment built up and it's like there's a
- 1:07:56desire to like have that one big aha, told you so I was right,
- 1:08:00you're wrong, bend the knee, yadda, yadda, yadda.
- 1:08:03And that's all fine. That's but that's a
- 1:08:04psychological, it's not an analytical reaction.
- 1:08:07An analytical. Reaction Never felt this way.
- 1:08:09Mad Nobody listening to this, to this show has ever had these,
- 1:08:13has ever had these thoughts. I mean, it's, it's really
- 1:08:16natural and, and, and fair to a certain to a certain extent, but
- 1:08:20I think it matters exactly how that happens.
- 1:08:22Like there's a path dependency. That's why I've argued for a
- 1:08:26while now that the United States should have a Bitcoin strategy,
- 1:08:28right? It doesn't mean we, you know,
- 1:08:29have. It doesn't mean I've determined
- 1:08:31what that strategy should be. It just means we should have
- 1:08:33one. It's like someone there should
- 1:08:35be a considered national effort broad that, you know, spanning
- 1:08:38both the Treasury Department and traditional kind of economic
- 1:08:41policy, but as well as national security decision makers and
- 1:08:44policy, sort of analysts from the defense and intelligence
- 1:08:48communities as well. To say, OK, let's paint a
- 1:08:51scenario where Bitcoin and say it does monetize to the level of
- 1:08:54gold, which maybe not my baseline scenario, but it's
- 1:08:59certainly a reasonable scenario for the for the say this decade.
- 1:09:03I don't know what percentage, you know, whatever percentage
- 1:09:05you ascribe to that is probably what price you think, you know,
- 1:09:08your your break even should be. You know, you want to you want
- 1:09:12to be buying up to that point and but I see zero national
- 1:09:18policy decision making or strategy planning for that type
- 1:09:21of scenario. But that would be very
- 1:09:23disruptive monetary shake up, geopolitical shake up.
- 1:09:27And it would mean that likely Bitcoin has been, you know,
- 1:09:30incorporated into the sovereign reserves of many different
- 1:09:33countries, if not the United States, potentially many
- 1:09:36different Gulf powers, maybe maybe South Asian countries,
- 1:09:41maybe, you know, maybe Singapore, maybe China,
- 1:09:44etcetera. So how that happens, whether
- 1:09:46it's the United States that leads that sort of does it in a,
- 1:09:51you know, in a deliberative fashion.
- 1:09:54I think it's a very positive end result for both US National
- 1:09:57Security Bitcoiners as well as the sort of the fiscal position.
- 1:10:00United States. If we're going to be going to,
- 1:10:03you know, a more unstable kind of monetary environment, if it
- 1:10:07ends up being the Saudis and the Emiratis and the Chinese, then
- 1:10:10it's probably not great for the United States, right?
- 1:10:12And so I have to be like an analyst to be like, well, you
- 1:10:16know, the Bitcoin could be at the same price, but the
- 1:10:18geopolitical implications, the national implications could be
- 1:10:21very different depending on how that happens.
- 1:10:22And I think Bitcoin is just so much it just like, let's get to
- 1:10:25that level. Let's just have it happen that.
- 1:10:28And I think about, OK, what's the best possible path to get to
- 1:10:31that level, right? And not just be like, well, our
- 1:10:34only objective is to get to that level And therefore whatever is
- 1:10:38the quickest path to get there is what we should choose.
- 1:10:40So I think there's different people can have different views
- 1:10:42of that. My view is sometimes it's better
- 1:10:45to maybe take a slightly slower path that's deliberative and
- 1:10:47plan to maximize, I think the the advantages of the West then
- 1:10:53necessarily the quickest path that might also, you know, make
- 1:10:57you rich, but also could accrue power and influence to say
- 1:11:00dictators in the Middle East that I would prefer not to be
- 1:11:03relatively empowered or to China, for example.
- 1:11:06And so that's just that's like a philosophical political
- 1:11:08attitude. So people can disagree with
- 1:11:10that, certainly, But I think that's that's a conversation
- 1:11:14isn't isn't happening. It's just, you know, OK,
- 1:11:17whatever gets us there, right? And, and there's also a sense
- 1:11:21of, you know, I think some folks have this view of, well, how you
- 1:11:25get there is by having this kind of arms race.
- 1:11:28So how you get here is by essentially, you know, meaning
- 1:11:31it into existence. Like having Trump go on some
- 1:11:33speeches and talk about Bitcoin very, very positively and then
- 1:11:37whisper that actually he's going to he's going to accumulate
- 1:11:40Bitcoin and national reserves. He's going to order the Fed to
- 1:11:42buy it. He's going to do a bunch of
- 1:11:43stuff that's would be from our perspective now look, you know,
- 1:11:46like, wow, like that's like a step change in terms of national
- 1:11:49policy. But if he says that, well, then
- 1:11:51that has to send different signals that aren't being sent
- 1:11:55or hadn't been sent before to the Chinese authorities to the
- 1:11:59Gulf. And that could, you know,
- 1:12:01essentially meme this kind of geopolitical arms race to buy
- 1:12:04Bitcoin into existence, which, you know, could could be
- 1:12:08successful. But it's like, OK, if your plan
- 1:12:11is just to like spark that fire, that's great.
- 1:12:13But then the global system is extremely complicated and
- 1:12:17there's a lot of like, you know, existing systems we rely on our
- 1:12:20day to life like payment and clearing systems, you know, like
- 1:12:22we don't want things just to break overnight.
- 1:12:25And there's a risk that if you if you do it in a very
- 1:12:29disorderly fashion and there's a crisis, that the political
- 1:12:32snapback could be very counterproductive.
- 1:12:35Like Trump for all, you know, people, you know, lauding him
- 1:12:38for being pro Bitcoin. Fundamentally, he's not like a
- 1:12:41Bitcoiner, right? He's just, he's a politician.
- 1:12:44He's like, this is where I get votes.
- 1:12:45This is where I get energy, I get I get money, boom.
- 1:12:48This is my support base there. Now I'm going to do things that
- 1:12:50make them happy. But if all of a sudden this
- 1:12:53blows up in his face and it makes him look bad, it makes him
- 1:12:55look stupid or rash or it embarrasses him, he'd be the
- 1:12:58first person to do a completely 180 and turn on it and turn on
- 1:13:01turn on the community in a second, right?
- 1:13:03So I think if you, if you don't plan for that scenario, then
- 1:13:06you're not really being, you're not doing a prudent strategic,
- 1:13:10Yeah, making prudent strategic plan, right, 'cause it could be
- 1:13:14it's a very, you know, tightrope to to walk there.
- 1:13:17So that's my. Take I think it also, you know,
- 1:13:22calls to mind some of the centralization points and you
- 1:13:24know, still I don't, I don't know it's called weaknesses or
- 1:13:27risks inherent in Bitcoin. You know, perhaps centralization
- 1:13:31of the mining pools is, is one major topic lately, right?
- 1:13:35You know, who who has a Direct Line into control of those, you
- 1:13:39know, mining pools at the moment?
- 1:13:41Well, probably the CCP does. And you know, if Bitcoin were to
- 1:13:47develop very rapidly as a result of some political move like you
- 1:13:51just described, you know what, what does that do to the
- 1:13:54incentive structure for China or the CCP as it relates to, you
- 1:13:58know, Bitcoin's long term success?
- 1:14:00These are yeah. These are questions people
- 1:14:02should ask ask themselves. Yeah, and I think there has been
- 1:14:05conversation about, you know, state influence over mining
- 1:14:10pools for centership, you know, purposes, whether it's O FAC or
- 1:14:13whether it's sort of, you know, the implicit threat of, you
- 1:14:17know, empty blocks or whatever come from some other, you know,
- 1:14:20not financially motivated actor. I think the lesson, you know,
- 1:14:23Bitcoin community is always, you know, there's a lot of energy
- 1:14:25behind lots of things. I think relatively more energy
- 1:14:29should go into things that decentralized block production.
- 1:14:32So stratum V2 and it was kind of mixed opinions, but I think
- 1:14:36maybe more in that direction that helps ensure that the block
- 1:14:42production is as decentralized as possible.
- 1:14:46And, you know, there's just overall thinking about, you
- 1:14:49know, Bitcoins are adversarial thinkers, but it's like, OK,
- 1:14:52like if you are the dog that catches the car and Bitcoin is
- 1:14:55at the level of gold, Well, like there's going to be a whole new
- 1:14:58raft of threats in terms of not to the protocol itself, but to
- 1:15:04the say the developers, right? There's like 40-50 core
- 1:15:08developers. You know, I'm aware they have
- 1:15:10like in a meeting every every year, they sort of pick a city,
- 1:15:12they go there, they just have a conversation.
- 1:15:15It's just like a technical kind of like vibe session.
- 1:15:18And these are just like programming.
- 1:15:20They're very in the weeds where this Pip, you know, BIP BIP X
- 1:15:23versus BIP Y sorts of stuff. What's the vibe?
- 1:15:26Very personality driven sort of discussion, rough consensus.
- 1:15:30You know, at a certain point there's half of those are going
- 1:15:34to be Chinese spies, right? I mean, I, you've seen this in
- 1:15:37open source software already. In fact, there was a story just
- 1:15:42few weeks ago, I forget exactly what about for several years a
- 1:15:47maintainer who's actually using a Chinese name.
- 1:15:50But I people think it was probably the SVR, the Russian
- 1:15:52intelligence service basically could have worked on an open
- 1:15:56source library for Linux. It was a very kind of very kind
- 1:16:01of off in the weeds, very small sort of library.
- 1:16:06It was called Xe Eutels. And you know, over there was
- 1:16:10like it was maintained by 1 maintainer who had like 50
- 1:16:13different libraries. They were maintaining, you know,
- 1:16:15it was kind of getting, you know, over overworked and want
- 1:16:18to maintain his like pretty boring set of tools.
- 1:16:21And so this guy kind of kept offering to help, you know,
- 1:16:23submitted small little, you know, change requests and, and
- 1:16:28or, or, or sorry, pull requests and kind of, you know, kind of
- 1:16:31insinuated himself. It got to the point.
- 1:16:33And then there was a whole other host of, of, of anonymous
- 1:16:36contributors that were like gradually pressuring the lead
- 1:16:38maintainer to like to incorporate these changes from
- 1:16:41this other guy and be like, why aren't you listening?
- 1:16:43Like this is a simple change. You should do it.
- 1:16:45So they created a bunch of social pressure and I feel like
- 1:16:47it two years the guy made the the Anon SVR officer, the like a
- 1:16:52Co maintainer where now he could just push updates.
- 1:16:55And they got this back door built in to like foundational
- 1:16:59Linux sort of software updates. And it was like this one random,
- 1:17:05you know, autistic Microsoft engineer who noticed like a
- 1:17:08slight latency to like his normal compiling.
- 1:17:12He's like, why is this taking a little bit too long that it used
- 1:17:14to take? And just like dug in for hours
- 1:17:17and realized there was this like weird, weird change to the code
- 1:17:20and then kind of this, it all blew up.
- 1:17:24And so that tells me, OK, so Bitcoin is resistant to, is more
- 1:17:27resistant to that sort of attack than than than than Linux is.
- 1:17:30But it's, it's not entirely impervious to sort of gradual
- 1:17:34systematic, you know, manipulation of the conversation
- 1:17:38around, say certain types of dips and maybe creation of
- 1:17:41social pressure, you know, which essentially is OK, should we
- 1:17:45should we signal for taproot type type of thing, right?
- 1:17:48So that we should be more conscious of those sorts of
- 1:17:50attacks, like social layer attacks on the technical
- 1:17:53development ecosystem, you know, in general, I think that should
- 1:17:57all things considered, raise the bar for any, for any soft work,
- 1:18:02right? Because you always don't have to
- 1:18:05factor in the possibility that the, the public pressure for a
- 1:18:07certain soft work, whatever it is, just like completely
- 1:18:09abstract, could also be manipulated by some unknown
- 1:18:12purpose, right? And and that this pressure to
- 1:18:15like make a simple change could introduce us a flaw that not
- 1:18:18everyone had figured out. Of course, the whole thing with
- 1:18:20ordinals was like, you know, some people feel it was
- 1:18:22attacked, some people thought it was just basic change and
- 1:18:24whatever is the protocol is protocol.
- 1:18:26But that lesson should you should, you should draw a
- 1:18:29conclusion about that lesson that in the future that type of
- 1:18:33thing could happen again. But like not by accident, right?
- 1:18:37So like in general, I think that should change like the the
- 1:18:40default posture to to to updates.
- 1:18:44Now again, that might make me, you know, that might impose some
- 1:18:47costs, right? There might be some like simple
- 1:18:49changes that like time locks, etcetera.
- 1:18:51That would be good to have that you know that that wouldn't say
- 1:18:55that it's like inevitable and wouldn't say we say no changes.
- 1:18:57It's just whatever your current posture is to changes, it should
- 1:19:00just be slightly more resistant. Well that's great food for
- 1:19:06thought and makes me appreciate especially your style and your
- 1:19:11contributions to the space mat as someone who, as you said,
- 1:19:15assesses risk for a living. Right.
- 1:19:17This is literally your job. You do this all day every day
- 1:19:21when you're not, by the way, also writing policy papers about
- 1:19:25Bitcoin, which by the way, I highly recommend people read
- 1:19:29those papers if you want to support Matt on the Bitcoin
- 1:19:34Policy Institute website. If you really want to support
- 1:19:37Matt, by the way, buy his book, Buy Expectation value.
- 1:19:41I've ordered my copy. I look forward to to reading it
- 1:19:44soon. I want to give Jesse maybe the
- 1:19:49almost last word here and I want to be respectful of your time.
- 1:19:51This has been awesome, Matt, really appreciate you.
- 1:19:54Really appreciate you coming on scarce assets.
- 1:19:57But, but Jesse, did you have any, do you have anything you
- 1:20:01want to say before we give Matt the closing thoughts in order to
- 1:20:04reach him? Not in particular incredible
- 1:20:07contribution here, Matt to you know, I love your, your, your
- 1:20:11disparate, you know, points of view that you're bringing in
- 1:20:15from our typical Bitcoin community.
- 1:20:20Talking points are are so narrow in scope usually.
- 1:20:25And, and you break that mold, which is fantastic and and
- 1:20:28necessary and great. And, and I also, I agree with
- 1:20:31you on the sort of ossification point.
- 1:20:33I think we had VJ on the on the podcast and he made a
- 1:20:38impassioned case for the the bias towards ossification.
- 1:20:43I and I think that's an important distinction to to not
- 1:20:45be completely closed off to, to that possibility of changes in
- 1:20:49the future. But the bar certainly should be,
- 1:20:52in my opinion, higher than it has been and and currently is
- 1:20:55with regard to making changes. So I agree with you on that.
- 1:20:58But thanks so much for coming on the show.
- 1:21:00This is extremely thought provoking for for me and I think
- 1:21:04probably everyone listening. Absolutely what?
- 1:21:07Any final thoughts or information you want to leave
- 1:21:10people with? Final thoughts.
- 1:21:12Well, I'll, I'll leave without like the final kind of like
- 1:21:15mega, mega, you know, macro takes this.
- 1:21:20Yeah, I think so. Like, it's an interesting
- 1:21:22convergence this decade. A lot's gonna happen this
- 1:21:23decade. I think this is gonna be very,
- 1:21:26you know, the terrible 20s or disruptive 20s, whatever I think
- 1:21:29this is, it's true. We're kind of in the middle of
- 1:21:32it. And, you know, the the Daily
- 1:21:34News cycle, you know, depending on what's blowing up that day
- 1:21:37kind of focuses on different aspects of this sort of creeping
- 1:21:40crisis or or acceleration of instabilities.
- 1:21:45And then Bitcoin is sort of going to become one dynamic in
- 1:21:48this larger complicated unfolding of call it chaos, you
- 1:21:54call it creative destruction. You could call it, you know,
- 1:21:57whatever you want to call it. But I think it's going to be a
- 1:21:59lot of convergence, right? So and, you know, Bitcoin I
- 1:22:03think can play a potential stabilizing role throughout that
- 1:22:06sort of crisis environment. I think that's where focus
- 1:22:08should be on like, OK, a lot of a lot of the anchor points of
- 1:22:11global civilization and society are going to be sort of freed
- 1:22:16up, right? And usually when that happens,
- 1:22:18like lots of things can change and, you know, the purpose of
- 1:22:21the state and the existing social orders to kind of anchor
- 1:22:24things down and like, you know, try to keep things relatively
- 1:22:27contained. But when things start to like
- 1:22:29pop off the ground and the tent starts flying and everyone runs
- 1:22:32around like with their heads cut off, I think it's important for
- 1:22:34Bitcoiners to like, try to keep themselves grounded, try to get
- 1:22:37themselves anchored, you know, and, you know, it probably will
- 1:22:41not be the full solution to, you know, it doesn't like Bitcoin
- 1:22:45solves everything. But I think the the more that
- 1:22:47Bitcoin can play that role of a stabilizing anchor point as
- 1:22:51other things potentially get freed loose and have to
- 1:22:54reconfigure themselves for a while, you know, the better.
- 1:22:58And yeah, so I think it'll be a disruptive decade in many
- 1:23:02respects. I think we're going to end up in
- 1:23:0320 thirties in a vastly different world.
- 1:23:07Bitcoin still be around, but I think the world around Bitcoin
- 1:23:10will be very, very different. And so, yeah, just keep it up in
- 1:23:14mind. A lot of things are going to
- 1:23:15change. So yeah, that's that's all I
- 1:23:17got. That's good.
- 1:23:20That's sage advice. Be cool, big corners, try to try
- 1:23:24to stay cool. And as this wild drama unfolds,
- 1:23:29Matt will be will be keeping you updated live on Twitter, I'm
- 1:23:34sure at Matthew under score Pines.
- 1:23:37Matt, thank you so much again, phenomenal conversation.
- 1:23:41I hope to do it again sometime before too long.
- 1:23:43And I really appreciate you. And this has been scarce assets.
- 1:23:47Thanks. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:23:49week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:23:52valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:23:54rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:23:56All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:23:58notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:24:01reminder that Onramp Media is for informational and
- 1:24:04entertainment purposes only and nothing should be construed as
- 1:24:07investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:24:10your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:24:12Visit onrampbitcoin.com. Contact Schedule a consultation
- 1:24:16with one of our private client advisors.