Latest / No Way Out / Conceptual Spiral Redux: John Boyd’s Blueprint for Thriving in Complexity with Chet Richards
Transcript
- 0:20Mark McGrath: So well, chet, as you know, we've transcribed the video of John Boyd speaking at SpaceCast where he presents Conceptual Spiral.
- 0:32Mark McGrath: We've fused that with two things from you the excellent foreword that you wrote that we want to talk about here with our audience, and also to the restored and sort of remastered slides of that presentation.
- 0:45Mark McGrath: And the great thing about the transcription is that what Boyd is actually saying goes perfectly with your slides.
- 0:55Mark McGrath: The one thing that's really cool at the end, the Q&A all the questions were unintelligible but Boyd's answers are brilliant.
- 1:03Mark McGrath: So what we're hoping for is kind of like we were talking about here before we started recording.
- 1:08Mark McGrath: What we're hoping for is to continue to keep these ideas fresh and relevant and in the minds of leaders and teams and as we continue to develop and build on top of what Boyd left for us because, as you know, he left all of this open for us to do exactly what we're doing and continuing to grow and revise and refine that and then, most importantly, show people how to integrate that into their lives, both personally and professionally, because, as we all know, it's universal and it applies wherever humans are making decisions and complexity.
- 1:44Ponch Rivera: Hey, mark, I want to add one thing here For our listeners.
- 1:48Ponch Rivera: In our show notes you'll be able to find a link to where you can download the PDF.
- 1:52Ponch Rivera: I'm certain that Chet will put it on his website as well.
- 1:56Ponch Rivera: Slightly East of New that will be out there as well.
- 1:58Ponch Rivera: We'll put the links on there.
- 1:59Ponch Rivera: It doesn't matter where you download it from, but we encourage you to download that.
- 2:03Ponch Rivera: And one if you can download it and listen to this podcast, that should be a nice way to do it.
- 2:08Ponch Rivera: If you can't go ahead and listen to this podcast and let's go download it and you're going to need to come back and listen to this again.
- 2:14Ponch Rivera: So very excited to talk about this with both of you.
- 2:18Mark McGrath: Chet, just you know we've had you on the show before and we've significantly increased our subscribers since then.
- 2:25Mark McGrath: And just why don't you give us at a very high level who you are, how you met John Boyd, and then we'll dive into why conceptual spiral is important?
- 2:33Mark McGrath: But give us some background on your experience with John Boyd.
- 2:37Chet Richards: I'd be happy to.
- 2:37Chet Richards: I first ran across the name when I was a very, very, very young, right out of grad school staffer in the I guess it had become program analysis and evaluation.
- 2:47Chet Richards: It was the descendant of McNamara's old systems analysis group and they had evolved.
- 2:55Chet Richards: It was still called systems analysis when I joined it, but then it got its name changed to program analysis and evaluation or program analysis and evaluation and I was in the TAC Airshop and I showed up and the vacancy they had was in the Air Force Fighter program.
- 3:14Chet Richards: So here I am, graduate student mathematics, graduated in mathematics, and you know I couldn't tell an F-4 from an F-15 from.
- 3:23Chet Richards: You know it may have quite.
- 3:27Chet Richards: I had a private pilot's license from the Army but the Army didn't.
- 3:29Chet Richards: I mean they helicopters basically, and that's what I would have flown if I had gone on active duty.
- 3:33Chet Richards: For a variety of reasons I didn't Ended up as a civilian and in that shop Air Force fighter programs had the F-15, also had the F-14, which was not an Air Force program, but it was already pretty much out of production, it was out of our ability, and the A-10 went for a different guy.
- 3:56Chet Richards: It had the lightweight fighter program which of course became the F-16 and the F-8.
- 4:01Chet Richards: We had a couple of things here To the extent we did anything with the F4, that came under the roof.
- 4:05Chet Richards: Of course, if we're talking about the F15 and getting into F15 and F16, you ran across EM stuff and you ran across the name John Boyd.
- 4:15Chet Richards: But you know it was kind of a level of detail below what we deal with at the Office of the Secretary of Defense and basically we were concerned with all right.
- 4:30Chet Richards: Given that DOD is going to have X amount of budget, it's going to roughly be split among the various departments.
- 4:37Chet Richards: What's our advice to the Secretary for what he should put in the President's budget for the various service programs?
- 4:46Chet Richards: You can't just take the service wish list and put them all together and send that over to the White House because it exceeds the national budget.
- 4:55Chet Richards: It might even exceed gross domestic product if you let them run full blast.
- 5:02Chet Richards: The Air Force originally basically wanted to have F-15s refill every role in the Air Force.
- 5:06Chet Richards: Literally they're going to buy like 2,500 of those things, which is, I think, similar to their plan for the F-22 if they'd had their way.
- 5:15Chet Richards: But we're right, obviously that wasn't going to happen.
- 5:17Chet Richards: The Navy wanted to do the same thing with the F-14.
- 5:20Chet Richards: They strong-armed the Marine Corps into buying the F-14.
- 5:22Chet Richards: They strong-armed the Marine Corps in buying the F-14, and they were going to use F-14s for everything.
- 5:26Chet Richards: But numbers just don't add up.
- 5:28Chet Richards: So the Secretary, who is generally a civilian not always Lloyd Austin, was retired Army and may or may not have a background in defense at all needs somebody he can turn to and say you know what do I do?
- 5:44Chet Richards: And that's why McNamara set up the Office of Systems Analysis and why Mel Laird, who was Secretary of Defense when I came on, kept it on as PA and I had that little slice of fighter, third-air fighter programs.
- 5:57Chet Richards: So that's why I came across the name John Boyd.
- 5:58Chet Richards: And then the guy who was running the office at the time got a two-step senior executive service promotion and went on to other things and there was a little gap in there.
- 6:07Chet Richards: And then John Ahern, who was the principal deputy assistant secretary, deputy director of program analysis and evaluation, walked in one day and said well, you guys got to be boss.
- 6:20Chet Richards: And he's Tom Christie.
- 6:21Chet Richards: And I knew that name because energy maneuverability paper was by John Boyden, tom Christie.
- 6:25Chet Richards: And I knew that name because Energy Maneuverability Paper was by John Boyden, tom Christie.
- 6:28Chet Richards: I had no idea who he was.
- 6:29Chet Richards: Anyway, tom shows up and Tom says hey, let's go meet John.
- 6:33Chet Richards: And I'm trying to remember I'm not sure whether he had been officially confirmed yet or not At some point John went Actually, this may have been just before Tom came on.
- 6:41Chet Richards: John went overseas to command the NKP in the Air Force US Air Force component ofa Thai air base and we'd walk in and there he was, this tall guy in an Air Force uniform.
- 6:54Chet Richards: We all said hi and all that.
- 6:55Chet Richards: And that was probably no later than 1973.
- 7:01Chet Richards: I have to go back and look at the course.
- 7:02Chet Richards: It may have been late 70s.
- 7:04Chet Richards: So I forget all about Boyd.
- 7:05Chet Richards: And in 75, after Boyd retires, I get this phone call from him and say hey, I need a mathematician to come look at some work I'm doing here and I was wondering if you could come over and take a look at it.
- 7:17Chet Richards: He said sure, john.
- 7:18Chet Richards: And he said meet me at happy hour Monday night, wednesday night.
- 7:21Chet Richards: I said okay, meet me at happy hour Monday night, wednesday night.
- 7:23Chet Richards: I said okay.
- 7:24Chet Richards: So that's how things were done back then.
- 7:26Chet Richards: So I show up and he shows me some of the drafts that he's working on.
- 7:29Chet Richards: He says here it is.
- 7:30Chet Richards: I'm using Gödel's theorem.
- 7:31Chet Richards: I want you to make sure that I'm using it properly.
- 7:34Chet Richards: So I read it.
- 7:36Chet Richards: My degree wasn't in foundations or mathematical logic, which is where Gödel's theorem usually appears.
- 7:46Chet Richards: But all graduate-level mathematicians, particularly if they're going into the more theoretical science, which I have done are familiar with Gertrude Stern, and we're praying to God that they never actually saw it in the wild, because it basically mentions everything that, if you run across it, that everything that you've done up to that point is total BS.
- 8:02Chet Richards: Fortunately, it's very, very difficult to run into it in real life, so it's kind of like a black hole.
- 8:11Chet Richards: You know they're out there, but you really don't want to run across one if you can help it, so anyway.
- 8:16Chet Richards: So I looked and there was no mathematics in the way he was using it.
- 8:20Chet Richards: His statement of it was okay, it's not the way we would have stated it because we'd use a lot of cruel symbols and everything and but, but yeah, but he was applying it to a problem in the field that I couldn't figure out.
- 8:33Chet Richards: What in the world it was all about.
- 8:35Chet Richards: He was talking about close, open systems and if you're inside a system and trying to examine it for yourself, you'll pop up confusion and disorder and all that.
- 8:47Chet Richards: That's interesting stuff.
- 8:50Chet Richards: I've been in the Pentagon long enough to see it in real life, but I had no idea.
- 8:55Chet Richards: But I said, yeah, the way you stated it is fine.
- 8:58Chet Richards: I really can't comment on your application because your application is not.
- 9:02Chet Richards: But he kept sending me drafts of it and all of that and then he put it out to the extent that he published it.
- 9:09Chet Richards: He put a date on it and started giving copies of it out.
- 9:14Chet Richards: I went out to California, left the government service entirely and knocked around, went to Saudi Arabia, came back and came back to Washington in 1980 and ran back into John again and he was deep into patterns of conflict.
- 9:29Chet Richards: I think he had already quit putting work numbers on them by that time.
- 9:33Chet Richards: But the thing looked pretty much like it does now.
- 9:36Chet Richards: I have a copy from 1980.
- 9:39Chet Richards: That's sort of you know.
- 9:41Chet Richards: You can see a lot of the charts are still there.
- 9:43Chet Richards: Pretty much every chart has some word changes and there's a lot of new charts, but the basic flow of it is still the way it is today.
- 9:50Chet Richards: And so I started going to Happy Hour back and forth and all that and John's working.
- 9:55Chet Richards: I'm not particularly interested in land warfare at that time but I continued looking at graphs.
- 10:04Chet Richards: And then in 1983, I left and moved to Atlanta to go to work for Lockheed.
- 10:09Chet Richards: Kind of lost touch with John for a while in there, although we would continue to call Every now and then I'd go to Washington, arrange for me there on a Wednesday evening and go back half the hour.
- 10:16Chet Richards: He did a strategic game after in 1987, an organic design for command and control, and then he kind of went quiet.
- 10:29Chet Richards: And I get a phone call from him saying that he's kind of branching out, he's kind of this war stuff.
- 10:37Chet Richards: He sort of milked it all that he thought it was worth and all that.
- 10:41Chet Richards: And he's getting over into other stuff.
- 10:45Chet Richards: And I said I had that idea, I sent him a copy.
- 10:49Chet Richards: I didn't actually send him a copy of, I sent him the reference to Tom Peters' Thriving on Chaos.
- 10:53Chet Richards: I said, hey, there's a lot of your stuff in here.
- 10:56Chet Richards: And he read it over and he said, yeah, he said there's not the Oogloo, but you can see a lot of these ideas.
- 11:06Chet Richards: And so I wrote tom a letter just out of the blue and he was, I think, still on the faculty standard at that time and he wrote back a very nice letter, sent me an autograph copy of the book which I still have, and I think that kind of got john really thinking about how these ideas are going to leak out of defense and over into other areas, which is an idea that he comes back to in conceptual style.
- 11:26Chet Richards: As you know, this would have been probably 88, 89, and that's when I got onto the phone, the phone call list, you know.
- 11:35Chet Richards: Like two or three times a day he would call and say, hey, can you call me back?
- 11:38Chet Richards: Because I could call him on Lockheed Stein, and I did, and he would say here listen to this now, listen to this now what do you think?
- 11:49Chet Richards: And it kind of went off and what he was doing was he was exploring the ideas.
- 11:53Chet Richards: What he was really doing was reading me some of the stuff that you found, mark, there at Quantico, some of those notes.
- 12:01Chet Richards: Now that I see them in writing, I can see where he was coming from.
- 12:05Chet Richards: I want to try it.
- 12:06Chet Richards: Suppose if I said it this way would it be more clear?
- 12:08Chet Richards: I'd say, well, john, what is it you're trying to make clear?
- 12:11Chet Richards: Tell me, explain it.
- 12:13Chet Richards: He said, well, you remember I said I'm kind of getting away from this war stuff and with the Cold War kind of being over now, he said I want to look at the more general applications of what I'm doing.
- 12:25Chet Richards: And this went on probably for a couple of years and we were going back and forth and back.
- 12:31Chet Richards: So that thing at the end there where he talks about a conceptual spiral for all these triplets, ending with they all end in I inspiration, something initiative.
- 12:41Chet Richards: I can't tell you how many versions of that we went through until we finally picked three or four that we liked.
- 12:48Chet Richards: So it went kind of back and forth on this.
- 12:50Chet Richards: He would basically try stuff out on you and you would give him to the extent that you understood what he was going for.
- 12:58Chet Richards: You'd give him feedback and then he would say, okay, great.
- 13:00Chet Richards: In the meantime we were also talking over this business stuff.
- 13:02Chet Richards: I had started a region called War, chaos and Business where I was trying to, based on the fact that I'd gotten into the Toyota production system, which you'll notice, he mentions quite early in his briefing, although it doesn't show up.
- 13:15Chet Richards: I don't believe it shows up.
- 13:17Chet Richards: It does in conceptual as far as the very thing, but he talks about it quite a bit when he's talking about it.
- 13:21Chet Richards: In to it, we're talking to the space cats, dude.
- 13:27Chet Richards: And he went, he bought shigeo shingo and taiji on those books very expensive, uh, probably still is introduced by an app they call productivity press and they were the only ones that had the right to do it and if you wanted it you paid what they wanted, I think things well, over a hundred dollars, and that was in 1988, real money, you may remember.
- 13:45Chet Richards: But anyway, he read all this stuff.
- 13:49Chet Richards: He read Shigeo Shingo's book, non-stock Production, which he also mentioned in the introduction, and he was starting to see these parallels, particularly down at the cultural level.
- 13:57Chet Richards: But he was also seeing how they use time and how they compress time, and the effect that it had on the American auto industry, and he can see operating side, the oodle kind of going in slow motion, you know, taking taking years, but being the same basic process and having the same effect on on the us auto industry that he was talking about in I call it a versus b conflict, uh, where you don't have a third party, a customer, sitting on the outside, it's basically whoever wins in a round.
- 14:27Chet Richards: You understand that.
- 14:29Chet Richards: So he started to put all this stuff together, as he mentions in his introduction, and playing it over and over and over again, borrowing from stuff that he had already done, not only in Destruction and Creation but of course the abstract, the one-page abstract where he's saying this idea of taking stuff apart and putting it back together actually made all the presentations that I have in my Green Book same process, which strikes a lot of people as odd, but it's true, having been involved in the process.
- 15:03Chet Richards: It's exactly what he did.
- 15:03Chet Richards: He was taking bits and pieces and trying to fit them together and seeing what worked and seeing what direction it led him in.
- 15:10Chet Richards: Truly all of those are examples of snowmobiles.
- 15:13Chet Richards: You've seen at Quantico the various earlier versions of patterns.
- 15:22Chet Richards: You need to see how the various prototypes of the snowmobiles got built.
- 15:26Chet Richards: And so what he did was he took that process of building these earlier briefings and he abstracted it and that became essentially a conceptual spiral.
- 15:37Chet Richards: Somewhere along in there he made the explicit and I think this was very early as I was talking to him about connection with destruction and creation.
- 15:44Chet Richards: He said, you know, it's really the early as I was talking to him about connection with destruction and creation.
- 15:45Chet Richards: He said you know it's really the same thing I was talking about back in destruction and creation, gertl Heisenberg and the second law.
- 15:51Chet Richards: That was an example of synthesis and all these other things were examples of synthesis.
- 15:56Chet Richards: But in order to do the synthesis you had to first do the analysis.
- 16:00Chet Richards: And that, of course, is the theme of conceptual style, the engine that drives conceptual style.
- 16:09Chet Richards: Now, the real thing about conceptual style of course it passes along to other systems and I think I just realized it after reading the transcript was that Boyd although thinking back on it I can't remember it's been been 30 years, 32, 33 years Boyd really thought this was going to be his last movie.
- 16:33Chet Richards: I really believe that that's true.
- 16:36Chet Richards: He mentions Jack Kevorkian in there.
- 16:40Chet Richards: I thought that was funny and he knew he had prostate cancer.
- 16:45Chet Richards: But I think in 1982, he may have thought it was in remission I'd have to look at Coram's book again but I think it was more like about 1994, where it had come back.
- 17:00Chet Richards: Of course he died in early 1990s.
- 17:01Chet Richards: It may have even been 1995, about the time of Essence and Winning and Losing, and so when he was putting conceptual style together, we were going back and forth on the components of it, and I think you can see again from that last set of charts.
- 17:16Chet Richards: There it's the nature of basically comprehending, adapting, shaping inside imagination.
- 17:22Chet Richards: Initial thought he really thought this was going to be recorded.
- 17:25Chet Richards: Now he explained his entire body of work.
- 17:29Chet Richards: But this is the fascinating thing about it no theory is complete.
- 17:35Chet Richards: And I think even while he was putting conceptual spiral together, and particularly once he started getting out and briefing it and hearing himself talk about it, he realized that it was incomplete in a very fundamental way, and you guys pointed it out in your description of what's different between the linear loop and the one that John actually drew, and that's the implicit part the implicit guidance and control John actually drew.
- 18:03Chet Richards: And that's the implicit part, the implicit guidance and control.
- 18:05Chet Richards: He had said way back in Strategic Game circa 1987 to emphasize it implicit over explicit in order to gain a favorable advantage etc.
- 18:15Chet Richards: But as you guys mentioned, there's hardly anything, nothing implicit about the linear loop, and yet he had said to emphasize.
- 18:24Chet Richards: But on the other hand, about the linear loop, and yet he had said to emphasize.
- 18:27Chet Richards: But on the other hand, the linear loop, that loop kind of thing really did seem to explain a big piece of what he was talking about, besides an engineering part.
- 18:40Chet Richards: But if you read Conceptual Spiral except for a few little I don't know references it's probably not even allegations near the end.
- 18:52Chet Richards: There are no adversaries in it.
- 18:53Chet Richards: In science and engineering we have adversaries.
- 18:57Chet Richards: You can see other people trying to publish.
- 18:59Chet Richards: You know idiots in the journal who keep rejecting your moronic reviewers who didn't understand the brilliant points you were making.
- 19:10Chet Richards: But those adversaries only have an analogous sense.
- 19:13Chet Richards: Conceptual spiral is not about conflict in that sense.
- 19:17Chet Richards: It's not about what I call ADB conflict.
- 19:21Chet Richards: It really talks about that circular portion of the loop that has hypothesis test back to observation and orientation.
- 19:31Chet Richards: It's that component of the loop, that conceptual spiral is talking about and all that John talks about in his verbal remarks.
- 19:43Chet Richards: The term never appears in conceptual style in the actual part of the book, although there's lots of loops in it.
- 19:50Chet Richards: And I think that began and he was getting much heavier now into the Oriental stuff.
- 19:56Chet Richards: At this point he had already read Tom Cleary's Japanese Art of War and of course he was very familiar with Sun Tzu.
- 20:02Chet Richards: But in the Art of War, cleary's Art of War, and some of the things that were referenced in there, particularly stuff by a guy named Takuan, they keep talking about, there's not enough time to do this analysis.
- 20:14Chet Richards: Everything just has to flow.
- 20:16Chet Richards: You know you fight with what you got, and I think he started to think about what he did as 42nd boy and there wasn't any sit down and say okay, gee, you know he's pulling three degrees to the right, he's got 20 degrees head up.
- 20:28Chet Richards: Now what should I do?
- 20:29Chet Richards: Well, I could do.
- 20:30Chet Richards: You know, I could do an emblem on.
- 20:31Chet Richards: I could do this, I could do that.
- 20:33Chet Richards: All right, if that stuff is happening, it's all happening deep somewhere else in the brain and you have to infer it because you don't see it.
- 20:42Chet Richards: It's better to say that it's flowing directly from your orientation, which has been pre-primed by all the training you did.
- 20:50Chet Richards: You notice, in his remarks he talks about his critique of the US training program, where he said you know, back then we killed more people in Korea in training than we killed in Korea, but that's why, once we got to Korea, we were on wheels.
- 21:20Chet Richards: They kept telling us Korea's going to be easy compared to what you're going enough people.
- 21:23Chet Richards: So anyhow, do that as it may.
- 21:28Chet Richards: He realized that the A versus B part, the implicit part, which is absolutely required for A versus B type of conflict, was missing in the conceptual spiral.
- 21:40Chet Richards: But it was missing in the sense that it wasn't explicitly called out, I think.
- 21:44Chet Richards: The more he thought about it and we did talk about it he said you can't use this implicit part if it's not already there, because you fight.
- 21:54Chet Richards: You know, once you get engaged, you fight with what you got.
- 21:57Chet Richards: For the most part.
- 21:58Chet Richards: If you try something new that you really don't have fingerspits in yet, for there's a really good chance you're going to mess it up and at least not accomplish your mission, probably get yourself hurt.
- 22:10Chet Richards: So he said the foundations for it are there, but I didn't really bring it out.
- 22:17Chet Richards: So you notice.
- 22:18Chet Richards: The next brief Essence of Wedding and Losing starts out with our implicit repertoire and I think between the end of conceptual spiral and the start and the work about two years later it seems like about 94, which is where we started working on that and I was very, very heavily involved in that is where he tried to complete that last piece of the puzzle, which was to take conceptual spiral, which had basically how you put yourself in position to win and essence of winning, losing in there, where you actually then apply it to win, um and and one thing about that chat.
- 22:57Mark McGrath: When you mentioned essence of winning and losing, that's the only time that he ever illustrated the ooda loop with the help of chuck spinney, correct?
- 23:05Chet Richards: that's a very, very, very good point, Mark.
- 23:07Chet Richards: In fact, if you go back and read the transcript and I'd forgotten about this he's still talking the circular loop in the transcript.
- 23:14Chet Richards: If you read it very, very carefully, you can see, maybe, that it's beginning to understand that that's not complete.
- 23:26Chet Richards: That's not how he actually operated, and the more that he read about how the samurai operated, he realized that wasn't how they operated either.
- 23:36Chet Richards: Now, if he had ever wandered down to any halfway respectable dojo, karate or kung fu or whatever, even judo, jiu-jitsu, anything, any martial arts thing, and gotten some training in martial arts, he had realized it immediately, because that's foundational, of course.
- 23:55Chet Richards: And that's why, when I'm talking with martial artists, they say, well, we don't understand the big deal here.
- 23:59Mark McGrath: They say, well, it's martial arts for organizations doesn't it also doesn't it also show ch and we've pointed this out before with other guests on the show that Boyd's own thinking evolved and it didn't stay static, absolutely, and he was unique.
- 24:14Chet Richards: Perhaps that he realized that.
- 24:16Chet Richards: That's how he realized that energy maneuverability was fine but it was incomplete and it would get you in position but it didn't.
- 24:25Chet Richards: Actually, you know, take you to find it didn't get in really inside the opponent's mind like he, uh, like he was, like he was trying to do, and then he got off onto onto land warfare, and land warfare is interesting.
- 24:40Chet Richards: But land warfare, in a sense perhaps, is more like business than it is martial arts, in that the time scale can be much longer.
- 24:49Chet Richards: Even in a squad or platoon engagement you're talking at least conglomerations of seconds or minutes.
- 24:57Chet Richards: You do have time to maybe get your platoon, you know, bring your platoon sergeant over a couple of squad leaders and say, okay, here's what's going on, here's what I think we're doing.
- 25:08Chet Richards: Anybody got any ideas?
- 25:09Chet Richards: You know, if they work together real quick.
- 25:12Chet Richards: There's some interesting videos of the Germans actually trading the deal.
- 25:15Chet Richards: So seconds and minutes, whereas in the martial arts it's fractions of a second, and that's what Cleary was so adamant about when he was talking about how the Japanese operated.
- 25:27Chet Richards: But they built the capability to do that via what he was describing as the conceptual spiral, and so when he went on to Essence of Winning and Losing, he embedded the conceptual spiral into his Oodaloo sketch.
- 25:41Chet Richards: But then he has the two implicit guidance and control wings going on the outside and got arrows going in every which direction, not just one, set going around a linear circle or a linear spiral, for that matter.
- 25:55Chet Richards: So that's the big, big fundamental difference when you change the topology, you change the time scale.
- 26:01Chet Richards: The Sherpa shifts, during the engagement itself, from defeating the opponent in this engagement to more and more over to learning from what's going on and applying that learning as the battle, as the war, as the operation, marketing campaign, whatever you're into the product development as it continues to evolve.
- 26:26Chet Richards: So even the fastest systems he may have mentioned this the fastest development systems at the time for developing cars, for Detroit was in the 45 year stage.
- 26:42Chet Richards: Chrysler tried once in the 50s to compress it down to three years and turned out some beautiful pieces of junk, but they weren't gorgeous, but they couldn't manufacture them, which allowed GM then to catch up in 1958, having an extra year with their company.
- 27:56Ponch Rivera: I'm laughing at the beautiful pieces of junk.
- 28:00Chet Richards: You got a 57 Chrysler product.
- 28:02Ponch Rivera: Okay, that's great, love it.
- 28:03Ponch Rivera: Thank you, chet.
- 28:06Chet Richards: You know, somebody once called the Jaguar the world's most beautiful, loudest car, and I think there's probably.
- 28:15Chet Richards: I've never owned a Jag.
- 28:16Chet Richards: I would love to drive one sometime, but I'm not sure I would ever want this ownership.
- 28:21Chet Richards: Response to one of these things.
- 28:23Ponch Rivera: What kind of car is that?
- 28:24Ponch Rivera: Again A Jaguar, a Jaguar, hmm, interesting yeah they were noted for.
- 28:29Chet Richards: Even today, the Jaguar Land Rover products typically rate right down on the bottom of the list, along with the Stellantis, I guess for a lot of people.
- 28:36Ponch Rivera: Here's an idea Maybe Jaguar Land Rover ought to come to us and ask us how to improve their quality.
- 28:41Ponch Rivera: To come to us and ask us how to improve their quality.
- 28:42Ponch Rivera: What?
- 28:43Mark McGrath: do you think about?
- 28:43Chet Richards: that.
- 28:43Ponch Rivera: It would be a great idea.
- 28:44Mark McGrath: It would be a beautiful idea wouldn't it?
- 28:46Chet Richards: They're owned by Tata Group out of India, which is, I suspect, the people in the Tata Group are familiar with these ideas.
- 28:54Chet Richards: One of them, I suspect, is there is a special Indian edition of Certain to Win.
- 29:01Ponch Rivera: Oh, there you go.
- 29:02Ponch Rivera: Thank you for that, I didn't know that.
- 29:04Ponch Rivera: It is.
- 29:06Chet Richards: Let's get that it is Full up Certain to Win there you go, there's nothing to say they jazzed it up a little bit.
- 29:17Chet Richards: I wrote a special introduction, special preface to it and got some quotes for the back.
- 29:28Chet Richards: I have no idea.
- 29:30Chet Richards: It was on sale when it came out for 395 rupees.
- 29:34Mark McGrath: So, chet, we're at this point where we're bringing out to the world conceptual spiral from a very specific point in time.
- 29:42Mark McGrath: Conceptual spiral from a very specific point in time as you're describing, this sort of bridge of his thinking laid in his life.
- 29:49Mark McGrath: What would you advise to leaders today?
- 29:52Mark McGrath: Because I say all the time, if you haven't read Destruction and Creation, you're behind, and if your competitors have, you're in trouble.
- 29:59Mark McGrath: And with conceptual spiral building off of that and then flowing right into something like essence of winning and losing, why is it so critical?
- 30:07Mark McGrath: Why would you recommend to leaders and their teams understand conceptual spiral and read this document?
- 30:12Chet Richards: One reason is that conceptual spiral is a really, really, really talks about and nails down the two big functions of the loop the circular loop, linear part of the OODA loop itself, without which you don't program your orientation and you can't develop the implicit guidance and control loops.
- 30:34Chet Richards: So without what John's talking about in conceptual spiral, you can't apply the other, you can't complete the OODA loop.
- 30:44Chet Richards: So you really do need to develop, really to study what he's talking about, because, as I mentioned in my introduction your readers will see it when I come back is that if you go back to Toyota, Toyota is more than about making a car that was better and less expensive than what Detroit was offering and developing it in less time.
- 31:13Chet Richards: They did all that.
- 31:14Chet Richards: But what Toyota is really all about is constantly evolving and improving the system that made that product possible, improving the system that made that product possible.
- 31:22Chet Richards: So there's two things you have the product and you have essentially the system, the evolving system, Because if somebody just and Detroit tried this for years, I think they still quite got it right you can exactly copy the Toyota production system down to the last bill and it won't work because the culture is not there.
- 31:41Chet Richards: System down to the last building.
- 31:42Chet Richards: It won't work because the culture is not there.
- 31:43Chet Richards: It's the orientation of the people working on the line, because they haven't been through the conceptual spiral type process to program their orientation so that they can actually operate the Toyota production system, which kites in continuous improvement.
- 31:58Chet Richards: Continuous product improvement is a process improvement.
- 32:02Chet Richards: That's a critical part.
- 32:04Chet Richards: I think it's very, very important that people, when they say, how am I going to improve my operation?
- 32:11Chet Richards: And as we just talked about, particularly with companies with commercial things, with the time spans, they may seem compressed to the people in them but compared to being in a gunfight or a knife fight or an air-to-air battle, the time spans are dragged out and learning becomes one of the key things.
- 32:29Chet Richards: And Conceptual Spiral is all about learning and unlearning and coming up with systems within your organization that allow you to do this better than your competitors.
- 32:42Chet Richards: You know.
- 32:45Ponch Rivera: I think the lean community can really take a lot from this brief, that we have this conceptual spiral brief that is going to be available on your website as well.
- 32:52Ponch Rivera: Looking at the machine that changed the world, you brought up Shingo Ono.
- 32:58Ponch Rivera: Many folks in the lean community.
- 33:01Ponch Rivera: They don't use the OODA loop correctly, in my view.
- 33:05Ponch Rivera: They use the linear approach to it, and when you go through this brief for them, they should start to see a connection that.
- 33:11Ponch Rivera: I agree with you 100%, that it's about the system.
- 33:14Ponch Rivera: How do you change the system?
- 33:15Ponch Rivera: How do you create that orientation, how do you create harmony within teams to have that shared purpose and that desired outcome, build that implicit guidance, control as team members and adapt to a changing environment.
- 33:28Ponch Rivera: And I think that there's a lot in there that the lean community can take away from this, and I hope that those that are from the lean community really pull down this brief and then reach out to Chet because, chet, you wrote about this years ago as well.
- 33:41Ponch Rivera: Let's improve the quality of how we deliver, what's behind John Boyd Doodle Doodle, and this is a great way to do that.
- 33:49Ponch Rivera: So thanks for all that, chet.
- 33:51Ponch Rivera: This is amazing.
- 33:52Chet Richards: I completely agree.
- 33:53Chet Richards: It's a very powerful observation.
- 33:54Mark McGrath: We should also point out too and I think that this is critical that slide 33, if anybody listening to this podcast or reading the work that Ponch and I are putting out on the world of reorientation, slide 33 is critical because, after Boyd goes through slide 32, explaining the features of the universe uncertainty, entropy, irregular erratic behavior, etc.
- 34:20Mark McGrath: Irregular erratic behavior, et cetera Slide 33 is that the underlying message of the entire briefing is there's no way out unless we can eliminate the features just cited.
- 34:30Mark McGrath: And since we don't know how to do this, we must continue the world of reorientation.
- 34:34Mark McGrath: So I think that everybody can understand why this briefing is so valuable and important to Ponch and I and why we really not only love teaching it and helping people understand it, but also feel it's so important that we named our podcast after it and we named our publication after it.
- 34:55Ponch Rivera: So, guys, I'm kind of wondering if we can kind of walk through, maybe, your highlights.
- 34:58Ponch Rivera: What do you find really interesting about this brief?
- 35:01Ponch Rivera: I know I have a couple of points, but I want to see from Chet and Mark when you look at this Mark just gave us a great example what stands out to you when you go through this brief that we have.
- 35:12Chet Richards: Okay, for me, slide 20 is the apex slide.
- 35:15Chet Richards: That's where he introduces novelty.
- 35:17Chet Richards: That's really what conceptual spiral is all about, and this applies to anything with the strategic content, whether competitors, customers, opponents, enemies, whatever you have.
- 35:33Chet Richards: Because if you keep doing the same old thing in the same old way, somebody will figure you out and you're leaving yourself open to somebody that does it cheaper, quicker, faster, better new features, higher quality, more reliability, whatever.
- 35:51Chet Richards: If you don't continually engage in this world of reorientation, you may be able to survive for a long time.
- 36:00Chet Richards: It depends on the competitive environment.
- 36:01Chet Richards: You are constantly leaving yourself open to, uh, to the entry of new competitors, uh, who are going to change the market and and obviously, do bad things to your market share at the same.
- 36:15Chet Richards: We've seen this so many times over the last 20, 30 years.
- 36:18Chet Richards: Um, so I think that's that's.
- 36:20Chet Richards: That's one of the key things is that, no matter how good things are going today, forget about it.
- 36:29Mark McGrath: Yeah, and he does kick off the transcript.
- 36:30Mark McGrath: He does kick off with the snowmobile experiment After he kind of pulls the audience.
- 36:36Mark McGrath: You know, okay, who's ever heard of Einstein and who's ever heard of Henry Ford, but have you ever heard of oh no, have you ever heard of a heisenberg or gardel?
- 36:45Ponch Rivera: yeah, so so, and then he goes and he goes through the, he goes through the snowmobile experience, uh, experiment which is novelty yeah, we've been looking at uh, affordances and we've been looking at kaufman's the theory of adjacent possibles, and I think what boyd does there with novelty is he points that out early and says that hey, as we create new things, the acceleration of technology is going to create more uncertainty, which allows you to find more novelty in the environment.
- 37:13Ponch Rivera: So we've had a lot of folks that study I think it's Gibson or Gibbs affordances and then you get into Kaufman's, the theory of adjacent possibles.
- 37:24Ponch Rivera: We've had people on the show to talk about that and I think that slide 20 that you brought up there makes that connection or can be a way to connect these emerging theories.
- 37:34Chet Richards: It's very important Admitting the stories of organization-like success.
- 37:39Chet Richards: As the elder Von Mölke once pointed out, victory makes us stupid.
- 37:43Chet Richards: He had a lot of crude phrases, but I like particularly like that one.
- 37:48Chet Richards: Or as Hermann Bok mentions in Patterns of Conflict if you tried something and it didn't work, do something different.
- 37:54Chet Richards: If you tried something and it did work, do something different.
- 37:57Chet Richards: And that also goes back to this ancient Chinese expression that I read across every day.
- 38:02Chet Richards: That says the same thing.
- 38:13Chet Richards: But most organizations you know they get comfortable with where they are because it's so easy to get comfortable.
- 38:15Chet Richards: You know you have the office.
- 38:16Chet Richards: You know everything is working smoothly, bonuses are coming in on time, people are telling you how great you are.
- 38:21Chet Richards: You can solve the little fires that pop up every now and then.
- 38:25Chet Richards: Life is good.
- 38:28Chet Richards: The problem is that mindset leaves you vulnerable.
- 38:33Chet Richards: If not now, then maybe a long period of time.
- 38:38Chet Richards: You can get away with it.
- 38:39Chet Richards: C-130, for example, blew in 1954.
- 38:43Chet Richards: Lockheed's still cranking out the J model, you know, even to this day.
- 38:46Chet Richards: They are finally now.
- 38:48Chet Richards: Just to me it just seems like getting some credible competition, particularly on the Embraer.
- 38:53Chet Richards: What is it?
- 38:54Chet Richards: C-390, which is a jet-powered airplane that actually is a little bit bigger than the C-130, a lot faster, of course, turns a little bit more, but they're pricing it at about the same.
- 39:05Chet Richards: So it's getting to now where if you really want a C-130, it's so that you have commonality with NATO and US Air Force.
- 39:11Chet Richards: I rule out the A400M.
- 39:13Chet Richards: It's a fine airplane.
- 39:15Chet Richards: It's just too expensive.
- 39:16Chet Richards: It's not even the same.
- 39:17Chet Richards: It's not valuable, but you can.
- 39:20Chet Richards: For a long time, general Motors, ford, chrysler, other names that have disappeared from history were very successful with the model head.
- 39:28Chet Richards: Annual product updates.
- 39:31Chet Richards: Don't put more quality into the product than the customer is willing to pay for.
- 39:34Chet Richards: Don't worry about building it great, you're not going to buy it.
- 39:40Chet Richards: That's an expression of the assembly line back then, and they can operate with that philosophy for decades, until Toyota came along.
- 39:48Mark McGrath: You start to wonder what if executives at Blockbuster or Kodak or the big three, what if they had sat down and they had gone through conceptual spiral, which, of course, now that we're releasing this transcript, we're able to help people to understand that?
- 40:06Mark McGrath: Just imagine what if because those three I's at the end you know the insight, initiative and imagination.
- 40:13Mark McGrath: How else could you thrive, how else can you out-compete, how else can you out-maneuver if you don't have those things?
- 40:21Ponch Rivera: I think there's something in this for everyone too, and you know, chet brought up the slide 20.
- 40:26Ponch Rivera: And what I'm looking at is slide 10, where financial markets are really starting to look at Mandelbrot, and he doesn't really spend a lot of time talking about Mandelbrot, but he does talk about Claude Chan and there's connections to the free energy principle and all these other things that are emerging out of neuroscience, but the new orientation.
- 40:43Ponch Rivera: He also brings up socialism, or was it scientific socialism?
- 40:48Ponch Rivera: So Marxism, right?
- 40:49Chet Richards: Marx and economics.
- 40:50Chet Richards: Yeah, that was an example of something that was tried and tested.
- 40:53Chet Richards: It didn't work.
- 40:56Ponch Rivera: But he's looking at all.
- 40:56Chet Richards: It was a hypothesis and it was tested.
- 40:58Chet Richards: Therefore it's part of the conceptual spiral.
- 41:00Ponch Rivera: Right, right.
- 41:01Ponch Rivera: So this is the idea is we have to find those good practices, those good processes, improve them all the time.
- 41:07Ponch Rivera: And what we're seeing now is the even on Wall Street I'm talking to our Wall Street listeners.
- 41:13Ponch Rivera: Now there is a strong connection between Boyd Mandelbrot and, in my view, this emerging idea that we can use sacred geometry and I think Mandelbrot has a connection to that and there's other folks in there as well, but it's a new.
- 41:29Ponch Rivera: It's a new orientation on how do we understand what's happening in the external environment so we can continually adapt and and, uh, not just thrive as a species, but but you know, I'm sorry not just survive, but thrive as a species, even if we have to go to mars, right?
- 41:46Ponch Rivera: So that's uh, and I'm just bringing that up as another connection there, but I'm sure there's other connections we can make, uh, from this, uh, brief, I think you're exactly right.
- 41:54Chet Richards: Um, yeah, I don't.
- 41:54Chet Richards: I don't know.
- 41:55Chet Richards: Organizations are strange things, as you, you know, as you all know, and you could give this.
- 42:01Chet Richards: I mean, it's been out on the internet now for about 20 years since I put it up, but, uh, you've got to be willing to.
- 42:12Chet Richards: For example, you say, at the key of this is analysis and a synthesis.
- 42:16Chet Richards: Do you do you do that in your organization really?
- 42:19Chet Richards: I mean really, or are you simply generating uh, excuses, uh for what you, or justification for what you're already doing, which is certainly very common In any hierarchical organization, there's a strong tendency to tell the person above you what you think they want to hear.
- 42:38Chet Richards: Do you want to get promoted, do you want to stay employed or not?
- 42:41Chet Richards: In that sense, I think the services actually were better places to work, particularly for Boyd, than the private industry might have been, because at least they tried to do to Boyd several times.
- 42:55Chet Richards: But it was Mike Wiley who pointed it out.
- 43:07Chet Richards: You can get away with an awful lot in the military, and you guys know this.
- 43:11Chet Richards: So long as you know where the boundaries are and you operate within that system, you may get transferred, you may get put in charge of a free Canadian battalion in Alaska.
- 43:28Mark McGrath: Chet, you need to listen to the episode we just released today about the Fat Leonard scandal.
- 43:33Chet Richards: I saw that.
- 43:34Chet Richards: Yeah, by the way, thank you so much for putting up Barry Boyd's in the news, the only place I know of where she has ever been really interviewed in print or for real.
- 43:44Chet Richards: It's about time she got.
- 43:46Mark McGrath: Oh yeah, she was a great we think, too, that hearing the personal accounts of people that knew him of course his daughter knew him, and you and GI Wilson and Chuck Spinney and others it's so important because, as we were talking about before we started recording, you know, boyd is so widely misunderstood and the idea that these theories are open and meant to be developed and discussed, and that these are for helping people deal with complexity and not linear boilerplate methods that can be introduced on an infotainment stage.
- 44:23Mark McGrath: I mean, these things are practical things that are deeply rooted and grounded in the way that Cosmos actually functions and flows, and that's what Boyd was trying to help us see.
- 44:39Chet Richards: Yeah, that's absolutely correct.
- 44:40Chet Richards: Good summary, but the organization has got to want to be willing to do it.
- 44:45Chet Richards: Commercial organizations can get rid of irritants much, much easier than the military can.
- 44:51Chet Richards: Here's your two weeks to get out Right.
- 44:57Mark McGrath: I know we asked you this before, but you know, if, if John had lived another you know he died at age 70, and just say he had lived another 10 years I mean, what do you think that he was pursuing?
- 45:08Mark McGrath: You know, when you take into consideration his evolution to get to this point of conceptual spiral and then sort of his distillation of everything, with essence of winning and losing, you know, what do you think he would have done next?
- 45:23Chet Richards: There are a number of possibilities.
- 45:25Chet Richards: I know Bill Lynn and his group around 4GW, including folks like John Robb.
- 45:34Chet Richards: I don't think John ever met John, but John Robb came and was the keynote speaker at one of our board symposiums.
- 45:42Chet Richards: I believe he sort of made this point, but probably he'd gotten interested in the types of conflicts that were taking place, particularly when you got past the desert storm.
- 45:51Chet Richards: You could have gotten into the world that we're in today, if it is becoming more multipolar, where you can have a group like Hamas face down, which is generally considered, person for person, the best military in the world for over a year now, a situation that's very, very difficult to explain using conventional military measures of effectiveness, even talking about maneuver warfare.
- 46:25Chet Richards: Now John talks a lot about irregular warfare and guerrilla warfare, and so I think he would have not been surprised that it continues to live, continues to work, continues to take advantage of new technologies, that sort of thing.
- 46:39Chet Richards: I think he might well have done a series of briefings on non-conventional applications of power, both soft power and energy in hard power.
- 46:54Chet Richards: I can see him kind of working in that sphere.
- 46:59Chet Richards: I know he read over some of the drafts of Bill and GI Wilson's 4GW paper, but I don't know what kind of comments or whatever.
- 47:11Chet Richards: Of course he never used a generation war model.
- 47:15Mark McGrath: We've discussed before that John Boyd loved technology and was not a Luddite.
- 47:20Mark McGrath: What would he think of AI?
- 47:22Mark McGrath: What do you think he would feel that's a?
- 47:24Chet Richards: very interesting point.
- 47:25Chet Richards: He was actually thinking along those lines a little bit before he died, because he was talking about things that were going to be possible with the tremendous increase in computers.
- 47:36Chet Richards: I'm not talking just words of law here, but I think parallel computing was just starting to come out and become practical.
- 47:43Chet Richards: Nowadays we talk, you know, multi-core, like eh, but back then it was really software to really use multi-core devices that was still in its development and of course the devices themselves tended to be very, very expensive.
- 48:00Chet Richards: And I tried to explain to him from a mathematical standpoint, a parallel computer is still a Von Norman computer.
- 48:05Chet Richards: There's still nothing you can do with a parallel computer that you can't do with a straight processing system.
- 48:11Chet Richards: You can just do it and in some circumstances you can do it faster.
- 48:14Chet Richards: But he said well, you know, it just seems like to me that as we get more and more processing power and more and more things are happening, that it's becoming more and more like the human brain and you can't argue with that.
- 48:30Chet Richards: And that's kind of about where we, what you can see in the back of his mind, where we which you can see in the back of my hand, if I had, if I could just okay a neuron.
- 48:38Chet Richards: I can see how I can simulate neurons.
- 48:40Chet Richards: I can.
- 48:41Chet Richards: But in neural networks the concept already existed back then, so it was.
- 48:47Chet Richards: You see, he was.
- 48:48Chet Richards: It's an area he probably would have been very, very, very interested in, both from the application of it, but also from trying to cut through the hype.
- 48:57Chet Richards: I think you would have been fascinated by the problem of hallucinations, for example.
- 49:01Chet Richards: Yeah, I think that would have been.
- 49:03Chet Richards: You know, this is true.
- 49:04Chet Richards: Maybe the other side is using AI.
- 49:06Chet Richards: You know light comes on above its head.
- 49:08Chet Richards: Do you think we can do to give it more hallucinations?
- 49:11Chet Richards: Yeah, I think you would have loved that.
- 49:14Ponch Rivera: Yeah, chet, I agree.
- 49:15Ponch Rivera: When you look at the emergence of the free energy principle and active inference and we've talked about this before it really pulls on second law, thermodynamics, cybernetics, a lot of things that John Boyd was looking at.
- 49:27Ponch Rivera: Nice synthesis, yeah yeah, and even in one of your briefs you talk about it and Chuck Spinney kind of puts a boundary around it and talks about the sensory systems are the only thing that are having access to the external world as our actions.
- 49:39Ponch Rivera: And you know, there's a Bayesian process inside the OODA loop where we generate a prediction based off of orientation.
- 49:47Ponch Rivera: We kind of match that up against the signals that are coming in through our observations.
- 49:52Ponch Rivera: It's pretty powerful.
- 49:53Ponch Rivera: And we're starting to see and I'm going to share some insights here we're starting to see a divergent group of AI companies.
- 50:01Ponch Rivera: What I mean by that is there are those that follow John Boyd's linear OODA loop and try to scale it that way.
- 50:07Ponch Rivera: So that's large language models and there's this thing called Gentic AI, which I think NVIDIA is big into right now, and it's just scaling linear OODA loops, in my opinion.
- 50:15Ponch Rivera: And then you get into the active inference part, which looks more like John Boyd's real OODA loop, what he wrote about, and my view on this is the companies that look at the linear approach are about to get their butts kicked by those that are looking at the highly efficient way of doing this.
- 50:32Ponch Rivera: And that, to me, is what John Boyd gave us was a gift of.
- 50:35Ponch Rivera: Here's a simple sketch and a bunch of amazing information behind it that tells you how sentient systems deal with uncertainty.
- 50:43Ponch Rivera: Right, navigate that.
- 50:44Ponch Rivera: And the concept of free energy is really about how do you create mismatches for your opponent?
- 50:49Ponch Rivera: How do you create that disorder, confusion in the environment for them?
- 50:53Ponch Rivera: So think about sports, or basketball, or football.
- 50:56Ponch Rivera: How do you show to your defender that you're going one direction when you're actually going the other?
- 51:01Ponch Rivera: Right?
- 51:01Ponch Rivera: And then, how do you reduce that uncertainty or that free energy?
- 51:04Ponch Rivera: And you do that by updating your orientation and constantly building good practices.
- 51:10Ponch Rivera: And we're using good practice here because we know the language from the Kenevan framework is there are no best practices other in the clear domain, right, in a complicated domain.
- 51:20Ponch Rivera: We have to update them all the time, make good practices.
- 51:22Ponch Rivera: So I believe yeah, I agree with you 100%, and that's what we're trying to do here, and Mark and I are not saying we're right, we're just saying hey, given what we understand about John Boyd's OODA loop, we can look at these things that are emerging in these fields and go, hey look, this is a nice connection here, and I think the problem that we run into all the time is academics, researchers, will not look at John Boyd's work because he didn't publish anything.
- 51:50Ponch Rivera: And you know, I want to get your thoughts on that.
- 51:53Chet Richards: Well, I mean, it's actually kind of funny if you have looked at what's happening in the academic publishing sphere right at the moment.
- 51:59Chet Richards: Uh, with the well, let me back up there there was a while back may still be a satirical scientific thing called the journal of irreproducible research and it turns out now that that's pretty much all of it.
- 52:14Chet Richards: I mean, there's so many problems now.
- 52:17Chet Richards: The publisher, parish, uh, world, all of it.
- 52:17Chet Richards: There's so many problems now.
- 52:18Chet Richards: The publisher, parish world and academia has just gotten completely out of hand.
- 52:23Chet Richards: Sabina Hassenfeld, out on YouTube videos, goes into that in great detail.
- 52:31Chet Richards: She gives a lot of examples of people who had hundreds of publications, all of which have now been withdrawn and redrafted, and some of it fraud, some of it just sloppy research and some of it just, you know, human beings just make mistakes.
- 52:48Chet Richards: But because of the pressure now to publish, the incentives to cut corners, if not to downright cheat, have just gone off the scale.
- 53:01Chet Richards: But your point is right.
- 53:03Chet Richards: They wanted something that they could cite in their own research so that when they published you know their citation list.
- 53:10Chet Richards: You know, past must have looked good.
- 53:12Chet Richards: Everything had all those weird little abbreviations, language of academic references or uses.
- 53:20Chet Richards: So I think there was a lot to that.
- 53:23Chet Richards: Plus, he wasn't an academic, he didn't teach at a big, prestigious university, he didn't have that course, that power behind him, and so it just made him very easy to ignore.
- 53:38Chet Richards: It used to drive him bonkers when he said you can cite anything.
- 53:41Chet Richards: Back then he said I cited telephone calls when it just wasn't done.
- 53:47Chet Richards: So I think there is a lot to what you said.
- 53:49Chet Richards: Plus, let's face it, researchers have their own area of interest.
- 53:53Chet Richards: They have their own reputation.
- 53:54Chet Richards: They have their own preconceived, their own orientation by that area of interest.
- 53:57Chet Richards: They have their own reputation.
- 53:58Chet Richards: They have their own preconceived, their own orientation by that area of interest.
- 54:00Chet Richards: And it takes a really unusual one, I think, to break out of that and plus, and to get your paper past.
- 54:06Chet Richards: Peer review is another.
- 54:07Chet Richards: Of course, depending on the publication, peer review, just with all this fraud going on, doesn't seem to be any big speed bump anymore.
- 54:17Chet Richards: I think.
- 54:19Chet Richards: A number of factors, but I think it's starting to change.
- 54:22Chet Richards: Now you can always cite Zynga's stuff as well as more arguments.
- 54:28Chet Richards: My paper was published in a Norwegian journal, but it's a reputable academic journal and I had a reviewer who did his or her job very well.
- 54:37Chet Richards: I basically had to rewrite the entire paper.
- 54:40Chet Richards: It pissed me off to no end, but it's much, much better because of it, so I guess so that you know there are things out there now that we can publish.
- 54:50Chet Richards: I don't think we have any excuse, today you may or may not agree with it, but it's there, you can cite it, you can find it.
- 54:56Chet Richards: If you don't agree with it, great, you know.
- 54:59Chet Richards: Try to track your arguments out.
- 55:00Chet Richards: Take a look well I love you right parts of his argument are incomplete, if not downright wrong.
- 55:06Mark McGrath: So well, that's the point of the paper, your uh paper, the boyd's real oodle loop that we just wrote about and put on uh the world of reorientation, because I think I think what a lot of people do is that they limit their thinking to what they think they know at a surface level and they don't do any deep investigation beyond sort of the memes of what people think, so and so said or so and so thought.
- 55:31Chet Richards: Well, I know it's happened in mathematics too.
- 55:33Chet Richards: You get into a very, very, very, very, very narrow field and what you do is you try to, as you continue to think up and prove new theorems.
- 55:41Chet Richards: You very carefully go those out.
- 55:44Chet Richards: You know three good, three new theorems or three new papers if you're smart and uh, so they stay and so they're.
- 55:51Chet Richards: They're looking at what they're done, what they've got, conjectures that they have in their back of the mind say, Okay, what can I do next?
- 55:57Chet Richards: That will get me another publication, because that's how you get tenure, that's how you stay employed.
- 56:02Chet Richards: That decides whether you're going to get faculty promotions, you're going to make full profit, whatever A lot of that is.
- 56:09Chet Richards: They just waive a number of publications you have factored by the prestige factor of the.
- 56:17Mark McGrath: Yeah, it seems like a lot of stuff gets suppressed or shelved and those sorts of rigid bureaucratic processes keep true knowledge from getting shared with the rest of the world that can be developed into understanding.
- 56:31Mark McGrath: I believe you're right.
- 56:31Chet Richards: That's the point that Sabina makes Hudson's elder.
- 56:35Chet Richards: I recommend her YouTube channel very highly.
- 56:37Chet Richards: Another recommendation I'd like to make to your audience here real quick.
- 56:40Chet Richards: Years and years ago, 1978 to be exact, there was a BBC series called Connections and it was hosted by a guy named James Burke.
- 56:47Chet Richards: It only had, I think, 10 episodes and then it showed up in the States in 1979.
- 56:54Chet Richards: Then in 1994, they did Connections 2.
- 56:56Chet Richards: I think TLC was the sponsor and they've done a couple follow-ons since then.
- 57:01Chet Richards: It is very, very, very much like what John is describing in charts, slides 10 and 11.
- 57:08Chet Richards: How one builds on another and another and a piece of this and a piece of that, and if your viewers can find any of those, they're very well done.
- 57:16Chet Richards: James Burke, a wonderful presenter, where he talks about such and such happened here in Greece and then a thousand years later, such and such happened here in India, and then just put together, it led to this and it led to that.
- 57:28Chet Richards: Somebody brought this in.
- 57:29Chet Richards: You can just see the process that God is talking about.
- 57:32Chet Richards: It's real pictures and all that.
- 57:35Chet Richards: So that's one thing I very much like.
- 57:41Ponch Rivera: We've been looking at a lot of woo-ish things lately, so time is not linear, that type of thing.
- 57:47Ponch Rivera: So what you just described there, this thing repeats, so maybe it's happening in parallel.
- 57:51Chet Richards: Time even exists.
- 57:52Ponch Rivera: That's right, right.
- 57:53Ponch Rivera: So what this podcast has allowed us to do is kind of go explore things that we normally wouldn't have explored.
- 58:01Ponch Rivera: Right, it doesn't mean these things are correct, it's just hey, there are people out there that have different orientations that we might be able to learn something from Exactly, and what I've seen from people that you and all of us know is they'll attack us because we had somebody on the show that brings a unique view on recently.
- 58:19Ponch Rivera: Actually, this isn't a show, but it's a Substack article we put out there about orientation on genetics, culture and previous experience and how culture is pretty darn important when it comes to seeing new things.
- 58:31Ponch Rivera: And then it gets into an argument online about you know, you guys are awful because you're bringing this person on.
- 58:37Ponch Rivera: I'm like wow.
- 58:38Ponch Rivera: And so we stopped Actually, we stopped listening to those people that pushed back on that.
- 58:43Ponch Rivera: We're like you can go live in your echo chamber all you want, go for it.
- 58:46Ponch Rivera: That's not what we're about.
- 58:48Chet Richards: Exactly no, that's a very, very good, very important point.
- 58:53Chet Richards: I think he has handled it very well.
- 58:54Chet Richards: The only other thing I would suggest is and we talked about this a little here look at those charts 10 and 11.
- 58:59Chet Richards: If Boyd was still alive today, what would he add to them?
- 59:01Chet Richards: We talked about AI as certainly one.
- 59:04Chet Richards: I think he was getting really fascinated by biology, particularly what we call neurophysiology.
- 59:11Chet Richards: Getting a pre-grows himself, complexity gets into that.
- 59:14Chet Richards: Neuroclasticity was just kind of being accepted.
- 59:20Chet Richards: They were saying all right, well, you can strengthen synapses and weaken them.
- 59:24Chet Richards: But now we're discovering it goes much, much, much farther than that, I think, boy, we're fascinated by the advances in what we're understanding now and also things like genetics.
- 59:35Chet Richards: We talked about junk DNA, remember.
- 59:38Ponch Rivera: And epigenetics, yep, yep.
- 59:39Chet Richards: Yeah, epigenetics and all and you really can inherit epigenetics.
- 59:42Chet Richards: And all that stuff and Dorp Boyd, I think, would have been fascinated by that.
- 59:47Ponch Rivera: Yeah, so to add to that, you know we brought up Carl Friston's free energy principle, active inference.
- 59:52Ponch Rivera: I think that would be one thing that we'd be added to that.
- 59:54Ponch Rivera: And then, yeah, um, a little bit more on the neurodiversity stuff.
- 59:58Ponch Rivera: Uh, mihi, cheek, semi-high's work on psychological flow.
- 1:00:01Ponch Rivera: Uh, what we're finding now is the three types of cognition that lead to, uh, flow states.
- 1:00:06Ponch Rivera: Uh, and you're familiar, familiar with this from being a yogi um with your yoga practices.
- 1:00:11Ponch Rivera: You know what the cognition zero cognition, one looks like, um in an implicit guidance control.
- 1:00:18Ponch Rivera: So I think a lot of the things that are emerging in the last 10, 15 years or 20 years, um, are additive to what John Boy was looking at.
- 1:00:27Ponch Rivera: And, and I think, when people dismiss his OODA loop and go, wow, there's nothing there, while you're just, you're recreating everything, you're going to go out there and find all these things on your own.
- 1:00:36Ponch Rivera: Why not start with something that isn't perfect but does contain a lot of connections to things like the Toyota production system?
- 1:00:45Ponch Rivera: Right, we've talked about that here.
- 1:00:47Ponch Rivera: It connects to neuroscience.
- 1:00:49Ponch Rivera: We know we looked at that early, early complexity theory, systems thinking, cybernetics, the second law of thermodynamics, a lot of concepts that people are talking about today.
- 1:00:59Ponch Rivera: They need to spend some time and just hey one, go download this brief, go look at it If you have questions.
- 1:01:05Ponch Rivera: I mean that's why we have the podcast here, that's why we have access to chat, ask questions and we'll find the answers for you here on the show.
- 1:01:12Ponch Rivera: But adding to that, you have anything else to add to the?
- 1:01:15Ponch Rivera: What else do you think Boyd would be looking at there?
- 1:01:18Ponch Rivera: Mark?
- 1:01:22Chet Richards: Go ahead, Mark.
- 1:01:24Mark McGrath: Well, I know that some of the criticism that he's received and somebody even wrote a terrible book about it that Ian Brown absolutely decimated, which was really good, but that he had a very, that he had a misunderstanding of the nuclear warfare, world War II or whatever, they really don't go into the fact that John Boyd had direct access to a lot of these guys like Balk and Rudel from the Stuka pilot and things like that.
- 1:01:50Mark McGrath: But Punch, I was just thinking because it's the fourth coming episode.
- 1:01:55Mark McGrath: I would love to be on a fly on the wall with John Boyd talking with Norman Oller.
- 1:02:01Ponch Rivera: Yeah, so Norman wrote the book Blitzed and Tripped.
- 1:02:06Ponch Rivera: And Blitzed is a book about methamphetamines and the use in World War II, nazi Germany.
- 1:02:13Chet Richards: Just now realizing it.
- 1:02:14Chet Richards: Yeah.
- 1:02:15Ponch Rivera: But I don't think we're looking back the books and we didn't see that in anything.
- 1:02:20Ponch Rivera: I don't think John Boyd saw that.
- 1:02:21Ponch Rivera: But if you think about it, what they're trying to do with the methamphetamines is increase a flow or create a flow state, and that gives you a competitive advantage over your enemy, in this case the French.
- 1:02:31Ponch Rivera: So, mark, you want to take it from there.
- 1:02:39Mark McGrath: Well, it was interesting that one of the things that Norman pointed out was that the French were drinking wine, and the Maginot wine and the Germans were coming up with innovative maneuver tactics and, at the same time, compounding their efforts with these drugs to, as you say, create a flow state or keep them awake for periods of time.
- 1:02:54Mark McGrath: And what we know about John Boyd is that when he would learn something new or come across a new fact, he wouldn't hold out to an outdated dogma or tradition or anything that he would be.
- 1:03:03Mark McGrath: I'm sure that if he were here, he would have been open to hearing norma's perspective and learning about that um, and taking a lot of interest in it, to kind of compound with the very extensive research that he did on the Blitz.
- 1:03:17Chet Richards: That's quite true.
- 1:03:19Mark McGrath: I think that that's another thing about Boyd.
- 1:03:21Mark McGrath: That's a tremendous characteristic, and I think it's also characteristic of another misunderstood thinker that we had on recently.
- 1:03:28Mark McGrath: Andrew McLuhan came on to talk about his grandfather, marshall McLuhan and his work, and who I had first come into contact with with uh through John Robb, talking about uh, mcluhan and Boyd years ago, and I think that Boyd is reduced to OODA loop and Marshall McLuhan is reduced to the medium is the message, and no one goes any further than that and there's this massive misunderstanding about both.
- 1:03:51Mark McGrath: And what was interesting, one of the things that Andrew pointed out was he had went through, um, the one.
- 1:03:54Mark McGrath: The things that Andrew pointed out was he had went through one of the things that you have up on slightly east of Nuchat the archives, components of the various books and things that Boyd read, and one of his takeaways was I'm stunned that none of my grandfather's books are in here, because literally every book my grandfather had on his work is on this list and they were sort of bracketing around each other, which was fascinating.
- 1:04:20Mark McGrath: But I think at the end of the day it goes on to what Boyd was saying.
- 1:04:23Mark McGrath: It's like you can't hold on to things and McLuhan said the same thing I'm an explorer.
- 1:04:28Mark McGrath: I'm not here to tell you exactly what is.
- 1:04:31Mark McGrath: I'm here to learn and explore and develop.
- 1:04:34Chet Richards: It's certainly possible.
- 1:04:35Chet Richards: You know that if Boyd lived another ten years, that he would have gotten over into that.
- 1:04:40Chet Richards: I mean, if you look at how extensive his reading list was anyway, where in the world did he find time to even do this?
- 1:04:46Chet Richards: You can see why there's going to be things he missed.
- 1:04:50Chet Richards: He was working in a different area and put all of his time in that.
- 1:04:56Mark McGrath: His margin notes.
- 1:04:57Mark McGrath: When we've been down in Quantico and read his margin notes on, say, on War or others, it's just, it's amazing.
- 1:05:03Ponch Rivera: Yes, even his notes on Tom Peters are pretty interesting, that's right, yeah.
- 1:05:09Chet Richards: He had that one coffee with Peters in the coffee shop at the Hot in Crystal City there in Washington DC Never found out too much about what they talked about.
- 1:05:23Chet Richards: Probably His only criticism of Peter's incident was that he got too much checklist mentality.
- 1:05:30Chet Richards: But I found out later that that is almost, or was at the time, foreshown by the business press.
- 1:05:36Chet Richards: That was kind of their they wanted.
- 1:05:39Chet Richards: All right, here's the thing.
- 1:05:40Chet Richards: Now here's some things that you can do A, b, c, d and E.
- 1:05:43Chet Richards: Okay, you're an executive.
- 1:05:44Chet Richards: Now here's your best practices.
- 1:05:47Chet Richards: I totally agree with Dave on that, by the way.
- 1:05:50Chet Richards: And so yeah, and so just to get the thing, because if you look at it compared to the two before it, that book was much more lavish than writing on chaos.
- 1:06:05Ponch Rivera: So I don't know whether that was really reflective of Tom's yeah, we could reach out to Tom to see if he can join us on here.
- 1:06:11Ponch Rivera: That'd be great.
- 1:06:12Chet Richards: Oh, absolutely we can ask him about that.
- 1:06:14Chet Richards: He probably remembers me.
- 1:06:17Chet Richards: It's so occasional.
- 1:06:19Ponch Rivera: Okay.
- 1:06:20Chet Richards: For a long time we were going back and forth.
- 1:06:21Chet Richards: I learned incredible about bodybuilding, Applying these kind of topics to the world of business.
- 1:06:27Chet Richards: I give him full credit.
- 1:06:31Ponch Rivera: If I remember correctly, tom has a background in the Navy right?
- 1:06:33Ponch Rivera: Yeah, yeah, okay.
- 1:06:36Chet Richards: I don't think he retired, but he well, you still quite.
- 1:06:40Chet Richards: Yes, yeah, he's a former Navy person.
- 1:06:42Chet Richards: I don't want to get in more trouble than that person, I just don't remember.
- 1:06:46Mark McGrath: Well, the Navy missed out on Boyd.
- 1:06:48Mark McGrath: In the quorum book they talk about it that they wouldn't sit down for six hours.
- 1:06:56Chet Richards: So the Navy has had, you know, a fat lemon.
- 1:06:58Chet Richards: All you can do is offer it Lots of challenges that I think some boy type thinking could really be helpful to them.
- 1:07:06Chet Richards: I've given it to the Air Force, to the Marine Corps, several times to the Army, but never got invited to give patents of conflict to the Navy.
- 1:07:17Chet Richards: I believe that's correct.
- 1:07:19Chet Richards: If I'm wrong on that, I apologize.
- 1:07:27Mark McGrath: I don't remember being invited to the Naval War College or any of their institutions, certainly willing.
- 1:07:33Mark McGrath: Well, chet, we're really excited about making this sort of you know, this remastered transcript of John Boyd's conceptual spiral to the public.
- 1:07:42Mark McGrath: We really appreciate the foreword that you wrote, the remastered slides and you know you've gone through all the briefings and you've preserved all of the slides and all the different briefings and you could also we could also send a shout out to Dan Grazer for making that video available on YouTube, which we transcribed and combined, and we're looking forward to feedback that we get of anybody that wants to learn how to apply this, because if we're working with your competitors on it, you're not going to be happy if you didn't understand.
- 1:08:21Mark McGrath: Make the effort to understand.
- 1:08:22Mark McGrath: Conceptual spiral.
- 1:08:24Chet Richards: Yeah, I totally agree.
- 1:08:25Chet Richards: I think you guys did great work and great service in making this transcript available Because, like most of Boyd's briefings, they were never really meant to be set down and read by themselves.
- 1:08:35Chet Richards: As you know, he wouldn't even give out copies of patterns until you had the brief.
- 1:08:38Chet Richards: He was absolutely fanatic about that, so to have the transcript itself is a tremendous resource.
- 1:08:48Chet Richards: I even learned quite a bit from it and I was present at the creation.
- 1:08:51Chet Richards: But you know, you see new insights.
- 1:08:54Chet Richards: It's been 30 years since it's come out, a lot has happened and it's a chance to hear John explaining it again.
- 1:09:01Chet Richards: Seeing him explaining it again, it's a tremendous opportunity.
- 1:09:04Chet Richards: I recommend it highly to all.
- 1:09:09Mark McGrath: Awesome.
- 1:09:09Mark McGrath: Well, we're going to do our part.
- 1:09:10Mark McGrath: We know that you will help as well getting it out on Slightly East of New.
- 1:09:14Chet Richards: We don't sue you, it's available.
- 1:09:15Chet Richards: All getting it out on slightly east of noon and sharing it with you.
- 1:09:17Chet Richards: We don't sue you if it's available.
- 1:09:21Mark McGrath: And I'll let.
- 1:09:22Mark McGrath: I'll let Ponch finish, but you know we're, I know speaking for myself and for Ponch.
- 1:09:26Mark McGrath: You know we're, we're both really honored to be on this journey with you as we continue to develop the work Ponch.
- 1:09:34Ponch Rivera: Yeah, hey, I'm just going to share this with we'll share with the audience as well.
- 1:09:37Ponch Rivera: There is a possibility that John Boyd's old high school may be renamed after him, and I think Mark's going to go visit during that period.
- 1:09:47Ponch Rivera: But I just want to offer you an opportunity, chet, to maybe suggest why or recommend why that's a good idea and we can go through that.
- 1:09:58Ponch Rivera: John Boyd doesn't have anything really named after him other than I think it's the Fire and Weapons School, boyd Hall, boyd Hall, right.
- 1:10:06Chet Richards: Now the Weapons School.
- 1:10:07Ponch Rivera: Yeah, the Weapons School.
- 1:10:10Chet Richards: As far as I know, that's the only thing I would be hard put.
- 1:10:14Chet Richards: I don't know the alumni list in that particular high school, but I'd be shocked to find that there was a more deserving alumni to name the school after, so I would certainly encourage that.
- 1:10:26Chet Richards: That would be a good thing to have.
- 1:10:29Chet Richards: Yeah, that would be good to do, mark.
- 1:10:34Mark McGrath: Good luck, good stuff.
- 1:10:35Mark McGrath: We'll keep you posted on that.
- 1:10:38Chet Richards: That's great guys.
- 1:10:39Chet Richards: Thank you so much for having me on.
- 1:10:40Chet Richards: I always enjoy these, and good luck We'll get the transcript up as soon as it comes out.
- 1:10:46Mark McGrath: We'll close the recording here and thank you for coming and everyone to keep an eye out for the remastered copy of Conceptual Spiral which you'll be able to get.
- 1:10:55Mark McGrath: So thanks again, chet.