Latest / Worderella Reads with Belinda Kroll / 18 | Wait, what if Mr. Bennet wasn’t ever the good parent? #morallygray
Transcript
- Hello, kindred spirits.
- Welcome back.
- I just wanted to remind you that this and all episodes of Wordarella Reads is sponsored by my patrons over at the Society of Kindred Spirits.
- If you're a patron, thank you.
- I love you.
- If you're new here, I recently simplified my patron tiers to three, five, and $9.
- So take a look, The $9 tier get occasional mailers, like character art, art prints in the mail, stuff like that.
- Go take a look It'll be fun to see you in the community.
- Okay, so I need you to sit with me for a second because I'm about to say something that might ruin your childhood or at the very least ruin your mental image of Mr.
- Bennet as the fun, sarcastic dad of Pride and Prejudice, because I've actually been wondering lately I don't think he's a good guy, or I don't think he's the good guy.
- Maybe that's the way to say it.
- It's not that he's a bad guy, but I don't think he's the good guy in the story.
- I think he may actually be one of the worst parents in the book, and I say this as, someone who has quoted, "For what do we live but to make sport of our neighbors?" But to make sport for our neighbors, more times than I care to admit.
- I love Mr.
- Bennet, but he's got some work to do.
- Okay, so here's the thing.
- Mr.
- Bennet is funny.
- Ms.
- Austen writes him as this dry, witty escape hatch from Mrs.
- Bennet's nerves and the general chaos at the house.
- And I think because he's funny and because Mrs.
- Bennet is written to be the obviously ridiculous one, we tend to think of him as the reasonable parent by comparison.
- But, which, is a low bar, I suppose.
- But he kinda clears it in her head.
- And I don't know, clearing the bar of Mrs.
- Bennet having a nervous fit about Muslim is not the same as being a good dad.
- And when you track what he actually does in the book and what he says, that gap is enormous.
- I actually think about it, today.
- If you had a mother or you knew a friend, like a couple, they have five daughters, and the mother of the five daughters has anxiety, and she's working through it, she's doing the best that she can, and the husband is essentially checked out.
- That's kind of Mr.
- Bennet in this instance.
- Like he has five dollars, and he has no savings plan for them.
- The estate is entailed away, which, okay, fine, that's not his fault.
- That was the law of the day.
- But he had years to prepare for what happens to five girls with no inheritance when they lose their father when he dies.
- And he didn't do anything.
- Not only did he not do anything, he made jokes about it repeatedly in front of his daughters.
- He took their uncertain future as his, for his own amusement, which is a little cruel and mean if you think about it.
- And it's not just that, He lets Lydia go to Brighton.
- Lizzy, who's his favorite and he actually respects her judgment, she tells Mr.
- Bennet specifically that this is a bad idea, that Lydia is reckless and unsupervised, it's gonna end badly, and he waves it off because keeping the peace, avoiding the argument, avoiding effort, is easier than parenting.
- And then it does end badly, in a way that probably would have ruined all of his daughters' lives, not just Lydia's.
- I actually think that this is, a toxic Enneagram nine, right? Like, he's trying to keep the peace and he wants peace so badly that he's willing to do anything to maintain his peace, even at the risk of hurting others, because his peace is paramount.
- Which again, not great parenting.
- And then the thing that kind of bugs me is when Lydia's whole situation goes the way that it goes, I don't know why I'm acting like this is a spoiler.
- This book has been around for, 200 years.
- But, Mr.
- Bennet is devastated, like wrecked, but it's still really passive, you know? It's like he's sad that it happened, but he's not really gonna do anything to change his behavior or be- become a more engaged parent, having learned his lesson with Lydia.
- For five minutes, he's basically, snaps at Kitty, because she says she wants to go do a thing, and he's like, "No, I have learned my lesson.
- You're not gonna do anything.
- You're gonna sit in this room and do your cross-stitch with your mother, and that's it."
- But it's very much, new year, new me that, is faded by February.
- By the next chapter, I feel like Mr.
- Bennet is right back to his old tricks.
- But then Mrs.
- Bennet, and we're meant to expe- or like we're meant to see her as embarrassing, and, she is embarrassing, but her whole embarrassing project and all of her anxiety is wrapped around, "I have to get my daughters somewhere safe because no one else is going to do it."
- And she's shrill because she has no other tools.
- No one is listening.
- No one is paying attention to her.
- No one is seeing the severity of what could happen to her and her daughters if she does not get them married off.
- Because women did not have many avenues, at this time, especially if they were middle class.
- If you were, like, a farmer's daughter, you know, there was a potential that you could, maintain the farm, right? But this is a middle-class family, and the daughters weren't really trained to do anything productive physically.
- They were only moderately trained to do things productive, uh, intellectually.
- So they're really in a tough spot.
- Think about today, I know on Instagram I see a lot of these posts or, reels, little videos of, women who It seems like they lash out and, "Oh, no, the divorce came out of nowhere," right? But then when you look back, it's like, no, no, this lady has probably spent years of being ignored or dismissed or not listened to, and so that's why she has turned into this shrill harpy.
- Because the only way she gets attention is when she is a shrill harpy.
- And I totally see that in Mrs.
- Bennet, because Mr.
- Bennet just hides in his library and is like, "Why are you talking to me? I just wanna read my book."
- I think after that fifth daughter, I think he just, like, called it quits.
- But it's hard, 'cause, like, she doesn't have anywhere to escape to.
- The only thing that Mrs.
- Bennet gets to do is, have her nerves and host her dinner parties.
- And Mr.
- Bennet, being the actual landowner, he gets to do whatever he wants.
- And I think we let him off because it's clear that Ms.
- Austen likes him better.
- He gets the good lines, he gets Elizabeth's love, he gets to be narratively charming, even though he's, functionally absent.
- And I think that's...
- It's an interesting comparison.
- I think today it's that whole, you know, someone sees a dad and two kids in the grocery store and it's like, "Ah, man, that's so nice that you're babysitting the kids."
- He's not babysitting his own children.
- You babysit other people's children.
- You take care of your own kids.
- But it's that same sort of logic, I think.
- And so this is kinda where, Jane Austen, shows her brilliance.
- She's showing you how charm can, hide neglect, and how just because Mr.
- Bennet is not embarrassing, like his wife, that that can become a stand-in for being a good dad, and that's really not the same at all.
- This is coming from...
- I first read Pride and Prejudice when I was nine.
- It was and still is like my most prized Scholastic Book Fair purchase.
- I have no idea, how I ended up in the Jane Austen aisle of the school book fair, but I can tell you exactly why, and that was Wishbone.
- That little dog in the tiny cravat convinced me that I needed to read this book, and I did, and I loved it.
- And I thought at the time Mr.
- Bennet was the cool parent.
- He was the one who got it, the one who'd let me sit quietly in the library and ignore all these interpersonal dramas and politics happening in middle school.
- But, now that I'm decades older and a parent myself, and getting to read, different variations of Pride and Prejudice and seeing other authors' interpretation of Mr.
- Bennet, it's given me an opportunity to say, "Now wait a minute, so he saw this coming and then he let it happen anyway? You could have not..."
- That is the pet peeve of my life, honestly, is seeing a train wreck coming down the tracks.
- You have the opportunity to flip the switch to go down a different track and avoid the crash, but you don't do it because, well, gosh darn it, this is the path I was going to go down and nothing's gonna stop me.
- Well, sometimes the crash is gonna stop you.
- But anyway, so I just thought that was interesting and I wanted to share that with you guys.
- It's one of those, weird, emotional and intellectual moments where you realize, rereading the, the book itself doesn't change, but you have changed it between reads, and it can completely change how you interpret the same words that you did even a week ago.
- So I don't know.
- I mean, I don't think Jane Austen meant for Mr.
- Bennet to be hated the way, like, Wickham is hated.
- I don't think he's a harmless, funny dad either.
- He is a dude who has, who had the power to protect his family and mostly chose his own comfort instead.
- It's, that's not villainy, but it's also not nothing.
- It's neglect at, at minimum.
- So anyway, this is what I would love to hear from you.
- I would love to know, do you think this read is too harsh on Mr.
- Bennet? Is there a version of Mr.
- Bennet that you'd defend? Come on over to the Society of Kindred Spirits, that's my Patreon, and tell me.
- I do read every comment, and honestly, I love being told if I'm wrong, especially if you've got the receipts.
- I love a good citation.
- And if you're curious what a good Jane Austen father looks like, you know, to contrast against Mr.
- Bennet, I also have thoughts on Mr.
- Gardiner.
- And that might either be my next pod- ca- podcast episode, or it might be, one of my little essay rant things that I've decided I'm gonna start doing on the Patreon, because I have thoughts about things that no one really cares about anymore, and I have to put them down somewhere, so why not write them for your entertainment? Anyway, so that's it for me this week.
- If you wanna keep up with everything I'm doing, the newsletter, the community, the books, all of it, the easiest place to find everything is wordorella.com/links.
- It's got every way to stay in touch with me in one spot so you don't have to go hunting.
- Thanks again for listening, Kindred Spirits.
- I will talk to you next time.