Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Spiel des Jahres Special-Lukas Zach and Michael Palm on Dorfromantik
Transcript
- 0:00So in the second of my Spielders Yaris interviews, I talked to Lucas Sach
- 0:05and Michelle Palm. Yes, the pretentious Germ pronunciations are necessary about their game
- 0:11Door Romantic, how it came about, and their hopes for the Spielders Yarus.
- 0:15Hope you enjoyed. So I am honored in this Spielder's jaras special to
- 0:20have the designers of Dwarf or Mantique the board game. We have Michelle Palm
- 0:25and Lucas Sak. Gentlemen, welcome to the podcast. Thank you, thank
- 0:30you. Yeah, no problem at all. So the first question I've got
- 0:35is can you give us I was I was looking on your BGG page this
- 0:38morning and it's sort of it's seventy five games long. Can you can you
- 0:42give us a history of who you are, what you've done in the board
- 0:45game industry, what brought you into the world of game design. Yeah,
- 0:52well, first of all, maybe it's interesting to say that Michael has a
- 0:59shop for board games and comics, or several shops in the in the Lake
- 1:04of Constant area, and in oh over twenty years ago, I was there
- 1:14at the shop and bought a game from him because I was on holiday there
- 1:19on vacation, and a few years later, so it must be twenty five
- 1:26years ago. Actually, I was designing board games as a hobby, so
- 1:34very at the very start of my career, so to speak, and I
- 1:40was lost. So I decided to to grab a random game from my board
- 1:48game shelf and decided to write the designer an email. And this was Michael.
- 1:55So it was a contact by chance, if if you want, and
- 2:01I contacted him and asked him if I can ask him some questions about board
- 2:07game designing because he already did some titles. And we met at a board
- 2:15game convention in Hamburg, and that was the starting point, I guess,
- 2:21and from that point on we designed all our games together. And so,
- 2:28Michael, what was what was your memory of this, getting an email from
- 2:30a total stranger asking to steal your ideas? Yeah, I did, I
- 2:37did some games before, but I'm a I'm a I think I'm a team
- 2:40player, and it was a chance to to have a partner with same ideas
- 2:47and same possibilities for the business. And then we met each other and he
- 2:55was not only a stranger, he was a friendly stranger. So we tried
- 3:00it. He Lucas visited us here at home and we thought about some games.
- 3:07Then the Quid Fart at the Coach right to the Devil's Castle came out
- 3:13in Germans. That was our first game together and so we worked then every
- 3:20week two days two days a week together since today with we are type and
- 3:28UM and of course it's a great possibility to make your hobby then to to
- 3:37to a profession. And so Lucas, what do you think it is about
- 3:42you two that makes you such a good partnership. I think it's um.
- 3:51There are several layers that really fit together. UM. I think first of
- 3:59all as the personal layer, we are we are good friends. We have
- 4:03the same humor, We have UM a similar way to design games, which
- 4:12is normally coming from the setting, from a topic or coming from feelings that
- 4:17we want to create and then create the mechanics. You can do it all
- 4:23also the other way around, create the mechanics first and then play, then
- 4:28take a setting and put it on top of it. But we we we
- 4:31are designing from from the atmosphere, from the feeling and m and the other
- 4:38thing is that um, we really fit together. Yeah, we have different
- 4:45backgrounds because Michael comes from from the from the selling side, so to speak.
- 4:54So he really has the the overview over the market of the new releases.
- 5:00He is really connected to all kinds of people. And for me,
- 5:09I'm a video game designer as well, and I have I think a good
- 5:15insight into the really details of mechanics and the layout too, and yeah,
- 5:24and also the visual aspects of presenting games. So yeah, it's really it's
- 5:30a natural fit. So that's why we are designing games for over twenty years
- 5:34together now. And so Michael, you've sort of touched on it a little
- 5:43bit, but how do you split up the duties between each other? And
- 5:47do you ever get into a situation where you know, you get to a
- 5:51point where you just have an argument. Did you say we need to go
- 5:56away for two weeks and not speak to each other and then come back and
- 5:59start working on our games against most of the things we are doing together.
- 6:03Really we're doing together writing rules and we are writing rules together, or we
- 6:11are thinking about new mechanisms together. Then of course testing games. We are
- 6:16testing the games here in the South end in the North in different groups,
- 6:21but after the testing groups, we are talking and discussing, discussing together what
- 6:29we are with, what we are happy with, and what not the contracts.
- 6:38For example, with the companies we are doing, nobody is doing it
- 6:44with a happy phase because we want to just create new games and not talk
- 6:50about contracts. So I think we are doing nearly everything together. I have
- 7:00to say that together also means we do a lot of things ourselves outside of
- 7:08the two days. So when we are when we work together the two days
- 7:11a week, we are do everything together. But besides that, we are
- 7:15creating ideas on our own, bring it up to sixty or eighty percent or
- 7:20sometimes it's only an idea, and then we engage with the with the partner
- 7:27and discuss about that. But what can happen or what changed over the time
- 7:31is at the beginning we designed really every game from the scratch together. This
- 7:39is not what we are doing currently. We're having ideas and we share ideas,
- 7:44but we also develop ideas on our own up to a certain state,
- 7:48and then then involve the partner. Because you know, everybody from us is
- 8:00able to design a game up to eighty percent, but eighty percent is not
- 8:03enough. You know you need you need then the next twenty percent to bring
- 8:07you two hundred percent to have a real good game, and you know,
- 8:13the last twenty percent is always the difficulty part of it. And for this
- 8:18part it's really helpful to have a partner because this is this is the part
- 8:24where I guess many have problems and struggle because you need another perspective on this
- 8:31to to get to the through the difficulty parts of designing games. Yeah,
- 8:39and to say how we split up the duties. And I think that's the
- 8:43point why we never or really seldom have struggles or arguments or whatever, because
- 8:56we from the beginning we really said okay on the on the side of the
- 9:03of the money, we split everything half. So it's really clear we have
- 9:09half half split and this is not changing. And what you bring into it
- 9:15is, yes, you should bring also half, but if you do more,
- 9:20it's it's okay. But you cannot request the other one to bring more
- 9:26as well, then it's it's um, it's your decision, right, So
- 9:31if one of us works in the evenings as well, then you cannot expect
- 9:37the partner is working in the evening as well. This this is our this
- 9:43is our yeah, this works. Yeah. So then sticking with you,
- 9:52Lucas, how did the idea for doing a analog adaptation of Doorful Montique come
- 10:00around. Yeah, it was during the first lockdown, and um, so
- 10:09what we did is during this period we changed our designing process to digital because
- 10:18we were not able to test within real groups, and so we design our
- 10:26games now the first prototypes only digital digital. And this was a This was
- 10:33a turning point in our designing because we are we are not working together.
- 10:39We are not meeting in person very often during the year. So what we
- 10:45what we did in the past was Michael was testing in his groups, I
- 10:48was testing in my groups, and then we were discussing. But we are
- 10:52we're not testing together, and that changed totally when we changed the process to
- 10:58digital. Now we can design every game within hours and test it instantly together.
- 11:05And um this was a key factor for Dorf Romantic because we um I
- 11:15went through the nominations for the German Computer Shieler Prize and saw that the video
- 11:24game Iron Harvest from my video game company was nominated as well as Romantic for
- 11:30Best Game Design and best Game and so on. And I was curious,
- 11:35okay, because that the two games are so different. Yeah, our game
- 11:41was a big, huge RTS game, and Dorf Romantic was also nominated with
- 11:46us. And it was so simplified and so peaceful, and it looked like
- 11:52a board game actually, and so I looked into it and I thought about,
- 12:00well, this really reminds me of a product I we have developed or
- 12:05we are have in development since a few years, which was a hex tile
- 12:11laying game, a cooperative one and it was in the in the Caribbean Sea.
- 12:18And um so I counted together and I said, well, Doc Romantic
- 12:26is an upcoming title. That so the the high it wasn't as early access
- 12:31this time. It was not It was the hype Wars beginning, you know,
- 12:37it was at the beginning of the hype. And so we we contacted
- 12:41beginsos Shpieler and asked them to um to contact to Kana, the publisher of
- 12:48Doc Romantic, and UM, yeah, that we can just make an appointment.
- 12:52It discussed about a video game adaptation. And what we did was we
- 13:00we did not wait for the appointment. We just started to create a digital
- 13:05doorformantic board game prototype. So when we spoke to them, UM, we
- 13:11we actually could show them the prototype directly. It was we could and we
- 13:18could play it with them. We could directly play with them, and um,
- 13:22I think this was the key factor because they they said they had been
- 13:26contacted by by a few other publishers, but only whether one pager or not,
- 13:35not nothing at all. They just say, well, we want your
- 13:39license, how about it? And so the fact that we can play our
- 13:43prototype together was was the key moment for them to say, well, this
- 13:46is great and the guys are great and yeah, and they saw they saw
- 13:52that we were thinking the same about the same game that we are won the
- 13:58Peaceful Game, All operative game, another game with this a lot of of
- 14:03um, well competition inside um and yeah, yeah, yeah, and I
- 14:15think the the the the atmosphere from the beginning was great because they are so
- 14:20gorgeous people. They are so so kind and so friendly and um, from
- 14:28the beginning, this worked quite well. Yeah. And so Michael, what
- 14:33were the challenges of making a video game into a board game. A friend
- 14:41of mine spoke to me the other day and said, actually, I've played
- 14:45the computer game and it feels like a board game. So were there problems
- 14:50converting the video game to a board game or was it very easy? Yeah?
- 14:58Well, when you see the video game, you think it's it's an
- 15:03easy way to make a board game out of it. But um, first
- 15:09of all, in the video game you have a um as many tiles as
- 15:15you want in the game. Of course, you can't sell a game with
- 15:18one thousand tiles in the box as a board game. So we had to
- 15:24think about it, Um, what are we doing with the with the number
- 15:28of tiles? Um. That was a little problem. And then of course,
- 15:37um, when you are playing, for example, Carcasson, you have
- 15:41an opponent and you could play against him or against them, and that makes
- 15:46every game round different to the to the other game days before. But in
- 15:54a cooperative game, you have to bring more um. Well, um,
- 16:00that's the OAF garden, more quests, your more tasks. You have to
- 16:06bring more tasks, more quests. That every game has a different taste.
- 16:11For example, I want to say to the to the point before with the
- 16:17creating the limited amount of tiles, this is also nothing easy because when you
- 16:25imagine, okay, we have to create we cannot create the types randomly like
- 16:30they did with a special algorithm behind in the background and so on. We
- 16:34have to create an amount of tiles let's say hundred tiles, and they all
- 16:41have six six's in common. Side sites, yes, yes, sites.
- 16:52So you have to create all the combinations, all sides, hundred tiles,
- 17:00different elements on it, how many, how many sides of river, how
- 17:04many sides of rails and so on, and the fine tuning of this really
- 17:11took a long time because we wanted a perfect experience and um, yeah,
- 17:18so this was the one, one big task of it. And of course,
- 17:22um and there in the video game, it's not about tiles, it's
- 17:26about single trees on the tiles, and so we have to convert it on
- 17:33on a tile basis and not on the icon basis. You can found it.
- 17:37Yeah, and um, what also was what we have to change was
- 17:45in the video game, your forest is growing and growing and growing, and
- 17:51you get tasks for bigger and bigger and bigger forests, and we wanted to
- 17:56break that because, um, we wanted to create not one big world with
- 18:04one or two big forests, but with several smaller ones. And we want
- 18:10to give you the opportunity to if you play smart, to prepare spots and
- 18:15you can instantly fulfill tasks when you when you draw them. And the next
- 18:22challenge was also the campaign tree. That you're playing a campaign and every special
- 18:27tile should be imbalanced to the campaign and to the points you will get and
- 18:33so on. Yeah, so that was the the hard task for the board
- 18:40game. And so you spoke about your relationship with Takana, the original publisher
- 18:47of the Yeah video game, and how nice the guys are. Input did
- 18:52they have into the creation of the game. They gave us a lot of
- 18:56freedom. Um. Of course, they wanted to to see what we are
- 19:03doing, so we played sometimes we played every two weeks the new version of
- 19:08the board game um by tabletop simulator. Um. But they gave us a
- 19:15little a lot of freedom in the in the game design of the board game
- 19:22and um sometimes they said, okay, that's a great special time. Maybe
- 19:27we will do it now in the in the video version two and so on.
- 19:33So that was just free and great. Yeah. Basically, they gave
- 19:37us some guidelines what they want to uh yeah, how the game should feel,
- 19:45because originally they planned to do the board game themselves, but they didn't
- 19:51have the time for us so because of the success. Yeah, because they
- 19:56have too much to do. So yeah, so yeah, they give us
- 20:03a lot of freedom. And the playing test rounds were always cool and uh
- 20:11yeah, we laughed a lot, and it was a cool, a cool
- 20:15process for them. Yeah. So let's go on to the Spields jars now,
- 20:22so I would like you to be honest. Did you expect to be
- 20:29nominated for the award this year? Hmm? Hard to say. Of course,
- 20:36we read a lot, We hear a lot from journalists and players um
- 20:42in Germany and around the world about the game, and we are happy that
- 20:48the it's that the opinions are so positive. But at the end, if
- 20:56it's if it will be nominated or not, you can't say. You can't
- 21:00say, yeah, it's it's also I mean the the in the public media
- 21:06on all the reviews and and the rumors also, I mean, the nominations
- 21:12are discussed, especially in Germany very much so UM before the nomination, you
- 21:22could feel that around eighty percent of the people said, well Doc Romantic will
- 21:27be nominated for sure, and as well after the nomination now many people say,
- 21:36well Doc Romantic will be the stewdist House this year. But you know,
- 21:42this is not really helpful for us, because you know, if you
- 21:48are so excited about something, then you are really afraid of the disappointment,
- 21:53and we are not going sleep. You can't sleep at eve anymore. And
- 22:00and it's it's so so for me. If they would say, well you
- 22:07will get the price, this will not calm me down, you know,
- 22:14because I would say, yes, that's nice, thank you. But what
- 22:18about this one percent? Were both we're both role playing gamers, so we
- 22:25know the one percent could be rolled. Yeah, So because this is such
- 22:30a big thing, you know, this is I mean in the in the
- 22:33in the board game designing life. This is probably the biggest moment you can
- 22:38achieve. Yes, and uh so yeah, we are trying to keep not
- 22:45to think too much about it because then we cannot work. So yeah,
- 22:52we're just happy that we are nominated and we look forward to to travel to
- 22:56Berlin and and well it's amazing. Yeah, right, And so where were
- 23:06you both when the nominations because I've spoken I spoke to to Matthew Dunstan a
- 23:11couple of weeks ago about this when the nominations were revealed, and he said
- 23:17he was in Australia, so he sort of woke up with a thousand text
- 23:21messages where were you when the nominations were announced? We were connected with Pickers
- 23:26and Spieler. We were sitting in front of our computer, and we're connected
- 23:30with Pickers and Spieler, thirty or forty persons from the company and our families
- 23:37behind us of course, well it's behind us, right, And then we're
- 23:41looking at the video from the Spieler's artistory. And then the prize for the
- 23:48children were nominated, the games of the children, then the Kennerspiel were nominated,
- 23:56and then the Silvis came and and to be honest, before all the
- 24:02all the talks, before the nominations for Gas, I could not follow.
- 24:07I saw the first talking there and and they're explaining something about the special prize
- 24:15for Unlock. But it was really hard for me to follow. I was
- 24:19so excited, it was. It was really hard. Yeah. And then
- 24:26the first letter was opened and then the second so it was the next day
- 24:30in London and fun facts of that. That was even harder for me.
- 24:34Oh my god, it was so hard because in my head, I'm in
- 24:38my head it was okay, maybe they nominate Acropolis, maybe Stage in London,
- 24:45and maybe Hitster, yeah maybe, and maybe Sea Salt and Paper too,
- 24:52Yes, And in the last slot Hitster was still on the list.
- 24:56Sea Salt and Paper and Acropolis always still on the list. And this was
- 25:00the this was the time where I really get into doubt and said, oh
- 25:04my god, it could be that we are not nominated. It was so
- 25:10hard. And then you are thinking about when you're not nominated. You said
- 25:14to the thirty forty persons from Pegasus, Okay, it was a great moment
- 25:18with you, bye bye, see you next year. Maybe I think,
- 25:26I think that's the craziest thing that you have forty people from Pegasus, your
- 25:30whole family there. I mean, that's a real gamble, right, yeah,
- 25:34maybe maybe Kazuka will be nominated. And then they were very happy.
- 25:40But we both look as the mewe okay, we are going earlier on.
- 25:45The designers of Kazuka are giving each other high fives while you're crow Yeah.
- 25:52And it's even bigger in Berlin. You know, that's a big crowd of
- 25:56people, and you have this life stream and our colleagues from the companies and
- 26:02all the families and friend and test players and all are watching, you know,
- 26:08and if this moment then means and everybody says, well, yeah,
- 26:12you will get the prize. You will get the prize, and then you
- 26:15imagine the moment you get not the prize and you're looking for the next one.
- 26:19That yeah, yeah, I mean this is a bit like the Champions
- 26:26League final where then the losers are interviewed. How do you feel currently?
- 26:33I'm a Liverpool fan. I've watched US lose two Champions League finals in the
- 26:37last five years, so I get it. Yeah, So okay, I'm
- 26:41going to ask you a question here and you can choose to answer or not.
- 26:48You said you said that thing that, oh, it's it's an honor
- 26:52to be nominated, and whenever anyone says that, and with all due respect,
- 26:57it sounds to me like bullshit. It So how will you feel if
- 27:04you win? And how will you feel if you lose? Well, one
- 27:12of the best three games of the year. It's it's an honor, it's
- 27:19really an honor, and it's a great feeling. But when we are going
- 27:26to Berlin, and of course I will be said, of course, of
- 27:30course, my two boys are seven and nine years old, and that's your
- 27:38family, father, and you have to tell them on it's no problem than
- 27:44maybe next year or in two years or in three years, of course,
- 27:47but of course you will be said, I mean, you can I know
- 27:52the discussion about the Spielders yards price, especially in yeah, an expert game
- 28:00arounds, they are really international, maybe they don't care so much about the
- 28:07price because this price is a board about more the lighter games that are introductions
- 28:14to the board game hobby in general. And then you have the Kennish Spiel,
- 28:19which is a bit more advanced. But you know, many people,
- 28:23many many players that are really into the hobby would say, well, the
- 28:27Kennish Spiel already is not what we are playing. We are playing expert games,
- 28:33you know. So, but we really say it as or see the
- 28:40prize as I mean, it's the most important price you can get um for
- 28:45for for a board game designer, this has historic reasons, but also the
- 28:53price means that you will sell the game a lot, lot, lot lo
- 29:00more so, this is really a big thing for us. I mean it's
- 29:03it's really like if we will win the Champions League or if we get an
- 29:10Academy award. This is this is the comparision you. I would say that
- 29:15feels to me because yeah, I'm a word game designer. This is my
- 29:21life and if I get the biggest price, it's so overwhelming. I mean,
- 29:26this is this is, this is everything for me. So and of
- 29:32course when when I'm not getting the prize, I will be very very disappointed
- 29:37because it's it's the one I mean you to get the nomination is so rare
- 29:45and I never expected that we get a nomination, and now we have one,
- 29:53and of course now I won't win, And when not get it,
- 30:00then I really would say, Okay, did were we able to get a
- 30:04second nomination in our life? Maybe? Maybe not? So it's really big
- 30:12excellent. Well, um, I wish you both the best of luck and
- 30:18hopefully I'll be I'll be there at the ceremony and win or lose, we
- 30:22can have a drink to celebrate or commiserate. Yeah, yeah, that would
- 30:30be great. Then