Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Once a Student, Always a Bankrupt? The Supreme Court Weighs In
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for our regular segment, joined as always by barrister and solicitor, with Mulligan Defence Lawyers.
- 0:05Adam Stirling: It's Michael Mulligan, legally speaking, here on CFAX 1070.
- 0:08Adam Stirling: Afternoon, michael, how are we doing?
- 0:09Adam Stirling: Hey, good afternoon, I'm doing great.
- 0:12Michael Mulligan: Always good to be here Some really interesting stories on the agenda.
- 0:14Adam Stirling: Today I'm reading a case from the Supreme Court of Canada to do with student loans and bankruptcy.
- 0:20Adam Stirling: That grapples with, among other things, the question do you stop being a student and, if so, when does that happen?
- 0:27Michael Mulligan: Do we ever really stop being a student?
- 0:28Michael Mulligan: Maybe not.
- 0:29Michael Mulligan: So this is a really interesting case.
- 0:33Michael Mulligan: It just came out this morning from the Supreme Court of Canada and it's a case that originated in British Columbia and the case involves how the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act works.
- 0:44Michael Mulligan: And I should say that in Canada bankruptcy is a federal jurisdiction.
- 0:48Michael Mulligan: It's right there in the Constitution Act, even though most other sort of property-related things are provincial, and so that act the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, the idea behind it, is to allow people basically at some point Involvency Act the idea behind it is to allow people basically at some point if they get in so far over their head they're never going to be able to pay off their debts to kind of get a clean break.
- 1:10Michael Mulligan: You get to start again, right.
- 1:11Michael Mulligan: But we have some exceptions to that, and one of the interesting exceptions is an exception that prevents government student loans, government being important.
- 1:23Michael Mulligan: I guess Student loans are private ones, aren't covered by this, but government student loans the presumptively going bankrupt doesn't wipe out a government student loan, unless it's.
- 1:36Michael Mulligan: You've not been a student for seven years Now.
- 1:40Michael Mulligan: The reason for that, or one of the policy reasons for that, might be, of course, you know, if somebody you wouldn't want, somebody, for example, you know, going to school for many years, becoming a I don't know medical doctor after many years of education, taking out huge student loans, and then, as soon as they finish university, with no assets and a giant student loan debt, just saying I'm bankrupt, and then having that all wiped away, you might say, well, that's not fair.
- 2:04Michael Mulligan: You're going to have the benefit of that education for a very long time.
- 2:08Michael Mulligan: And so the bankruptcy and insolvency act provides that if somebody has been a student within the past seven years, you don't.
- 2:21Michael Mulligan: Your student government student loans don't get wiped out by a bankruptcy.
- 2:25Michael Mulligan: Now sounds clear, but human affairs are, of course, complicated, and here's this fact pattern with the British Columbia connection.
- 2:35Michael Mulligan: The person who entered into a consumer proposal under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act had taken a bachelor's degree between 1987 and 1994, got student loans for that and then immediately did a teaching diploma.
- 2:49Michael Mulligan: Student loans for that.
- 2:50Michael Mulligan: Okay, so far, so clear.
- 2:52Michael Mulligan: Now a number of years went by with working and then the person decided to pursue a master's in education and did that between 2006 and 2009.
- 3:09Michael Mulligan: And for that they took no student loans.
- 3:12Michael Mulligan: Okay, they then entered into this consumer proposal in 2013 to go bankrupt.
- 3:19Michael Mulligan: So here's the question it's been more than like well, more than seven years from the time this person took out the student loans to do their bachelor's degree and their teaching diploma, but they'd gone back to school, part-time, self-funded, to do this master's degree.
- 3:36Michael Mulligan: Were they a student?
- 3:39Michael Mulligan: Have they passed seven years?
- 3:41Michael Mulligan: And the argument they made is they said well, you know, this should be analyzed from.
- 3:46Michael Mulligan: You know different dates.
- 3:47Michael Mulligan: And they argued well, you know, we're talking about student loans for this degree from back in you know the teaching diploma that ended in 1995.
- 3:55Michael Mulligan: And so that's more than seven years from 2013.
- 3:58Michael Mulligan: Why should the fact that they went back to do another degree mean that, once again, the student loans have become exempt from bankruptcy?
- 4:08Michael Mulligan: Well, that's the issue that got to the Supreme Court of Canada and it involved a statutory interpretation of the wording there.
- 4:15Michael Mulligan: And the Supreme Court of Canada split.
- 4:17Michael Mulligan: It's an example of tough decisions.
- 4:19Michael Mulligan: Right, the Supreme Court of Canada split 6-3, and three of the judges in dissent said well, you know that doesn't make any sense, that the fact this person went back to school to do another degree, which they paid for themselves and didn't borrow any more money, would then reset the time period.
- 4:39Michael Mulligan: And they said well, it could lead to absurd results.
- 4:59Michael Mulligan: What if somebody did like a degree and then 20 years passed and they still hadn't paid off their student loan for some reason, and then they went back to school for six months?
- 5:02Michael Mulligan: Are they then captured by that provision?
- 5:03Michael Mulligan: They said that's legislation.
- 5:04Michael Mulligan: They pointed out that the legislation uses the term student and loan singular, which doesn't seem to comport with the idea there could be different time periods for different student endeavors.
- 5:14Michael Mulligan: And the other interesting thing that the Supreme Court of Canada the majority pointed to is the fact that in Canada federal laws are all both in English and French and they are equally authoritative.
- 5:27Michael Mulligan: But language is really subtle, particularly legal analysis, and in this case the French version.
- 5:34Michael Mulligan: The language was more restrictive than the English language.
- 5:39Michael Mulligan: Like in a related provision, the French version said the borrower it translated to English must not have been a student under the applicable law for the preceding number of years.
- 5:49Michael Mulligan: And so they said well, that's equally authoritative and that's more restrictive.
- 5:54Michael Mulligan: And so the majority determined that no, if you have become a student, whether full or part-time and that's the other interesting thing this person who went bankrupt they had been working and they did their master's degree, part-time, paying for it themselves, but that's still student because it's full or part-time.
- 6:14Michael Mulligan: And so the effect of this is that, even though it was well past seven years the time of the bankruptcy from the time the money was borrowed, the fact that the person went back to school to do the master's degree meant that the student loans were exempt from the bankruptcy proceeding and they will have to be repaid.
- 6:30Michael Mulligan: And so, while we all may be students for a very long time, that may have a real impact.
- 6:36Michael Mulligan: If somebody finds themselves in a position where they can't pay their debts presumptively, those student loans are not going to be covered by the bankruptcy proceeding, and so going back to school has a real impact, even if that's for a short time, and even if you don't borrow any more money.
- 6:54Michael Mulligan: It means that those other loans are going to stick with you, according to the six judges from the Supreme Court of Canada.
- 7:02Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest this morning from the Supreme Court of Canada on how bankruptcy is affected by being a student.
- 7:09Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking, will continue right after this.
- 7:13Adam Stirling: Back on the air here at CFAX 1070 Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking.
- 7:18Adam Stirling: As we continue, what's next on our agenda today?
- 7:21Adam Stirling: Michael?
- 7:22Michael Mulligan: Next on our agenda is a notorious Victoria case and an appeal decision on it.
- 7:28Michael Mulligan: It's one that I think many listeners would be familiar with.
- 7:31Michael Mulligan: This tragic case from 2019, where those two men broke out of William Head Penitentiary and it eventually resulted in the murder of a man in his own home.
- 7:42Michael Mulligan: So just a terrible local case.
- 7:45Michael Mulligan: Just to review some of those facts which will be important to this appeal decision.
- 7:50Michael Mulligan: The case involved the man's house being broken into.
- 7:54Michael Mulligan: Case involved the man's house being broken into, and then it would appear that the people were in the home for an extended period of time, throughout the day, and there was evidence in the home of things, including a Google search for one of their names on the person's computer while they were at work and looking at local news reports to, I guess, see whether there was information about the escape on there.
- 8:15Michael Mulligan: News reports to, I guess, see whether there was information about the escape on there.
- 8:19Michael Mulligan: And then, eventually, in the home, various things, along with the deceased, who was found with his hands duct taped.
- 8:23Michael Mulligan: Various things were found, including two axe handles, two pairs of bloody gloves, two walkie talkies and various other things, and the trial proceeded, with one of the men choosing to plead guilty after the trial has started, but the other man continuing with the trial that man, as it happens, was one of them, who was when he was arrested a day later was found wearing the ball cap of the deceased and carrying his backpack.
- 8:50Michael Mulligan: Not good, no-transcript, no-transcript.
- 9:24Michael Mulligan: You know, make sure you apply the law as I describe it to you, because if I'm mistaken, if I'm wrong and you do what I'm saying, that could be fixed on an appeal, but if you do something else, we can't fix that.
- 9:35Michael Mulligan: That's one of the things that judges will tell juries.
- 9:37Michael Mulligan: Right, listen to me on the law, right.
- 9:39Michael Mulligan: And so appeals are often an analysis of what did the judge tell the jury to do and was it correct?
- 9:46Michael Mulligan: Did they give them proper instructions?
- 9:48Michael Mulligan: Because we assume that juries are going to do what they're told and follow the laws the judge laid out for them.
- 9:52Michael Mulligan: And the other interesting element of this some people may not know about, but most people would be familiar with the idea that in a criminal case, a jury has to be unanimous.
- 10:06Michael Mulligan: They all have to agree on the verdict guilty or not guilty but juries don't have to agree on how they reach their decisions and Crown counsel are permitted to have more than one theory of the case, which is also really interesting.
- 10:19Adam Stirling: Yeah.
- 10:20Michael Mulligan: And here the crown had more than one theory.
- 10:24Michael Mulligan: Uh, the, the crown's first central theory was the idea that these two men committed the murder together.
- 10:31Michael Mulligan: Right, um, and they, they were both participants in the killing.
- 10:33Michael Mulligan: Looking at things like, hey, there are two ax handles and there are two pairs of bloody gloves and all all of this, right, and they were both participants in the killing.
- 10:37Michael Mulligan: Looking at things like, hey, there are two axe handles and there are two pairs of bloody gloves and all of this, right, and you were.
- 10:40Michael Mulligan: And the plan and their theory was that they did it together.
- 10:43Michael Mulligan: And their theory, their primary theory, was that the it was first degree murder because it was planned and deliberate.
- 10:52Michael Mulligan: Most people are familiar with that idea too.
- 10:53Michael Mulligan: Right, that's one of that's the most common way that a murder can go from second degree to first degree the idea that it's planned and deliberate.
- 11:01Michael Mulligan: We view that as more serious rather than something kind of happening on the quick.
- 11:04Michael Mulligan: Right.
- 11:05Michael Mulligan: It's the most serious thing If you've sat around, schemed about it all day, got your axe heads ready, got your gloves ready and then did something right.
- 11:13Michael Mulligan: That's more serious than just, you know, something snapped.
- 11:15Michael Mulligan: So that was the first theory that the Crown argued to the jury and the judge instructed them on that.
- 11:22Michael Mulligan: But the Crown had a backup theory.
- 11:23Michael Mulligan: Their second theory was a first-degree murder was okay.
- 11:26Michael Mulligan: Well, if you're not persuaded beyond a reasonable doubt that these two people had planned together the murder They've both done that Then there's another way, or there's more than one way, you can get to first degree murder.
- 11:42Michael Mulligan: And one of the other ways you can a murder can become first degree rather than second is if the murder is caused by somebody, well, they are also committing another offense.
- 11:56Michael Mulligan: And there's a list of other offenses.
- 11:58Michael Mulligan: They include things like hijacking an aircraft, sexual assault or the one relevant here, kidnapping or forcible confinement and the reason that and that's a different way a murder can become first degree rather than second.
- 12:15Michael Mulligan: And the Crown's alternate theory was well, even if you are not satisfied that this man was involved in planning and deliberation, because there was some evidence that was less strong against him, like, for example, the man who pled guilty.
- 12:30Michael Mulligan: He was the person whose name was being searched on the computer that day, right, and his fingerprints were found in the house.
- 12:36Michael Mulligan: The other man no fingerprints in the house and no indication.
- 12:37Michael Mulligan: He was searched on the computer that day, right, and his fingerprints were found in the house.
- 12:38Michael Mulligan: The other man no fingerprints in the house and no indication he was searching on the computer.
- 12:40Michael Mulligan: So one of the arguments made by the defense was well, maybe he'd been outside, maybe he'd been somewhere else in the walkie-talkie, you know, maybe he'd only showed up there after the murder had occurred, right?
- 12:51Michael Mulligan: But the Crown's alternative theory for this man was it's still first-degree murder on the basis that the man had been, it would appear, clearly forcibly confined.
- 13:01Michael Mulligan: He's duct-taped, right.
- 13:03Adam Stirling: Yes.
- 13:03Michael Mulligan: And so the Crown's argument was well, look, even if you're not persuaded that the man who continued on trial was involved in planning and deliberation, you know, maybe he'd been outside, maybe he was on the walkie-talkie who knows on the walkie-talkie, who knows?
- 13:17Michael Mulligan: You know, if you're not persuaded by our argument that he likely did it because there are two of these things in there, right then you should still convict him of first-degree murder on the basis that he caused the man's death while there was a forcible confinement going on, and so the judge provided that to the jury as an alternative.
- 13:32Michael Mulligan: Well, if you're not satisfied it was planning and deliberation by this man as well, then you need to go on to analyze that theory of it.
- 13:42Michael Mulligan: Now here's the interesting thing about that different way you can get to first-degree murder.
- 13:44Michael Mulligan: When you that subsection that deals with how you can get to first degree murder while committing other offenses uses the language that the death is caused by that person while committing or attempting to commit an offense, Supreme Court of Canada has said well, caused by that person, because that language is used there.
- 14:12Michael Mulligan: That means something more than just like some minor contributing factor.
- 14:17Michael Mulligan: Right, the parliament has seen fit to use the language caused by the person, right?
- 14:22Michael Mulligan: So the crown for that alternative theory of well, this was, well, there's enforceable confinement requires proof of more than just well, you were kind of standing by the door or something.
- 14:35Michael Mulligan: You know what I mean.
- 14:35Michael Mulligan: You have to be.
- 14:36Michael Mulligan: You caused it in a significant way, and that's sometimes referred to as like sort of an enhanced degree of participation being required.
- 15:01Michael Mulligan: And the argument made by the defense was well, that's all fine and well, that needing to be caused by that person should be applied to that the usual way that you would get to first degree murder planning and deliberation.
- 15:15Michael Mulligan: And so the argument made by the defense on the appeal was that same kind of higher degree of participation right, the sort of really caused by that person, not just some minor contributing factor to what happened, should have been what the jury was told to do when deciding whether there was first-degree rather than second-degree murder committed here on the basis of planning and deliberation.
- 15:39Michael Mulligan: And it was a novel argument, I should say, as the Court of Appeal pointed out, there's no prior case that's decided that.
- 15:47Michael Mulligan: And so the Court of Appeal went on to analyze the sort of principles why is it that we have that sort of higher degree of participation and they analyzed it in contrast with and how that fits in with other things like the idea of a person being a party to an offense generally.
- 16:06Michael Mulligan: And what is the why was that interpreted that way?
- 16:10Michael Mulligan: And ultimately the Court of Appeal found that, even though the judge did not tell the jury that for planning and deliberation there has to be, you know, caused by this sort of higher degree of participation, the Court of Appeal found that was quite proper.
- 16:26Michael Mulligan: And because those two sections right one is subsection three of section 231, the other is subsection five of section 231, only in that second one, the one that makes it first degree if you cause the death in the course of committing those other offenses, only in that occasion has Parliament used that term caused by the person.
- 16:46Michael Mulligan: And so for that reason there is no necessity that there be sort of an enhanced degree of participation that would apply to the idea of planning and deliberation.
- 16:58Michael Mulligan: And so, while it was a novel argument and that was really the only focus of the appeal, that was sort of a narrow focus on that narrow legal issue about how the judge instructed the jury that that wasn't enough to cause there to need to be a new trial and that the instructions given by the judge were correct, because those two different ways you can get to first degree murder, one has that higher provision and the other doesn't, and so that's why there will be no new trial in that local case, the tragic case of this man who was murdered in his own home.
- 17:33Adam Stirling: All right, we've got 90 seconds remaining.
- 17:34Adam Stirling: How shall we spend them?
- 17:36Michael Mulligan: Sure.
- 17:37Michael Mulligan: Final one's an interesting brief decision, also in BC, out of BC, that deals with the actually relies on a B case.
- 17:47Michael Mulligan: It's another Supreme Court of Canada judgment that deals with the issue of what is a firearm, what is necessary for a thing to be a firearm under the criminal code?
- 17:56Michael Mulligan: The fact pattern is car was stopped, gun is found in the vehicle.
- 18:02Michael Mulligan: It's a handgun.
- 18:03Michael Mulligan: The handgun at the time had a magazine in it and ammunition.
- 18:08Michael Mulligan: The police, for reasons unexplained, didn't send off the magazine or ammunition to be tested.
- 18:13Michael Mulligan: They only sent the handgun off to be tested.
- 18:15Michael Mulligan: So the lab gets the handgun and they test it using their own magazine and ammunition.
- 18:21Michael Mulligan: It works.
- 18:22Michael Mulligan: But at the trial the expert from the lab about whether this was a firearm expert from the lab about whether this was a firearm says that look, this particular handgun has a safety feature that makes it extremely difficult to fire if you don't have a magazine inserted into it.
- 18:38Michael Mulligan: And so the trial judge acquitted and said well, I'm just not satisfied, this thing is a firearm because of the definition of what that is in terms of the device being able to operate and fire.
- 18:49Michael Mulligan: But on appeal, and then eventually to the Supreme Court of Canada, they concluded that wasn't the correct approach, bearing in mind that there was some other evidence about the fact that this thing could function, or being adapted to function, readily, including the fact that the man, when he was arrested, made a comment about having previously used the firearm at a gun range, and so that was some indication that the thing worked, even without having tested the magazine, and given the fact that the way that definition of firearms works in the criminal code, the fact that it was able to work with a magazine from the testing facility was enough, and that did meet the definition of what a firearm is.
- 19:30Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest from the Supreme Court of Canada on what a firearm is, even if they don't test the thing with the actual magazine or the ammunition that it was found with.
- 19:39Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, with Legally Speaking during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 19:43Adam Stirling: Michael, thank you so much.
- 19:44Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always.
- 19:44Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 19:46Adam Stirling: Always great to be here.