Latest / Newcomer Pod / State of Substack (w/Casey Newton)
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome, silicon Sally. All right, we're here with dead
- 0:14cat. This is Eric newcomer, Tom and
- 0:17Katie are here, and we have fellow sub, stacker Casey Newton
- 0:21of platformer. We're gonna sort of just fun
- 0:25episode talk about a couple different things.
- 0:28Interesting piece in the new At times about sub stack failing to
- 0:32raise funding, which Casey is written about snaps stock is
- 0:36down, 45%, in the last month, another interesting happening in
- 0:41the sort of social world. And then I feels like we haven't
- 0:45talked about Elon Musk on this podcast.
- 0:49Another nice, you know, we thought about other things, even
- 0:54though that is the dominant story and rating, some dips,
- 0:57their PCS also got right. You got to do Ilan again.
- 1:01Casey welcome, thanks. Thanks for coming, on to the
- 1:04show. Thanks for having me gang.
- 1:06How are all things that? How are things in platformer
- 1:08World these days since we're going right into sub stack?
- 1:11What's, what's the latest from the platformer?
- 1:12Which I don't read, by the way. Thank you.
- 1:15But my understanding is that it's like some sort of French
- 1:17language newsletter. That covers like Algerian
- 1:21startups doesn't basically it you guys broke the big news
- 1:24about flanking cajuste. Okay yeah if you want all the
- 1:28latest on sort of The Tick-Tock behind the Flint.
- 1:31Could you deal go to platformer dot news and subscribe things
- 1:35are going really well. Platformer like I truly do wish
- 1:39I could go back and talk to the version of myself that was
- 1:42thinking about leaving my job and starting a sub stack and
- 1:45just explaining like here's everything that's going to
- 1:47happen after you do this and it would have made the decision, a
- 1:50lot easier. So very happy to be doing this
- 1:54independent thing. Well, I can't remember talking
- 1:56to that version of you is I called I forget if I You know,
- 2:00we got no phone Casey out because you had your newsletter
- 2:04The Verge and I, you know, I was a Bloomberg and so I got on the
- 2:09phone with Casey and honestly I had no idea.
- 2:11He was about to start platformer though, it made sense.
- 2:14And I was like, oh yeah, I think I'm gonna quit my job in like,
- 2:17start a sub stack. Like, do you think that's crazy
- 2:19in case? He's like Icy Hot.
- 2:21I'm sure. I feel like they're pretty
- 2:27different both, right? About tech broadly, but I'm very
- 2:31money-oriented, you're very platform oriented we have sort
- 2:34of are different enough spins that we don't feel like
- 2:39competition. But we also have names worth,
- 2:41ER, yes. Casey, do you feel competitive
- 2:45with Eric? Like tell us that she's dumb.
- 2:47Yeah. And so the whole reason I came
- 2:52on this podcast is, I want people to hear my voice.
- 2:59Products. This is doing the upright, need
- 3:02to run the disinviting competition on.
- 3:04We need your in the sort of New York Times style daily.
- 3:07Add, you know, the daily is free.
- 3:10But what really pays for this is if you subscribe, so subscribe
- 3:14to newcomer and then if you're already a subscriber newcomer
- 3:18you can subscribe to platformer. Yeah.
- 3:21So Katie and I are collecting nothing from this.
- 3:22I thought that out there now it is I mean, just like be a little
- 3:27bit serious about this. Yeah, I grew up reading the LA
- 3:29Times had a lot of really great columnist there and I just
- 3:32basically lucked out that I lived in an area that the LA
- 3:35Times Like delivery trucks reached.
- 3:38And as a result I got access to these great columnist.
- 3:40They're all these people. Now the you know, particularly
- 3:42now that the newspaper industry is going through such a hard
- 3:44time, the don't have access to those people but we have the
- 3:48internet and so you can just find the columnist that is right
- 3:51for you and you pay them what I think is a pretty reasonable Low
- 3:55monthly rate and you keep a columnist that you love and
- 3:59business. So like I just love that that
- 4:01model of the world that we're living in, and then the people
- 4:04who are really good at it, are like able to live lives beyond
- 4:07their wildest dreams now, does it sad and you though that this
- 4:10might be gutting? Your beloved LA Times it?
- 4:14Yes. I know I'm very sad about, you
- 4:17know, what's happening to newspapers.
- 4:19I also as somebody who worked in newspapers for the first 10
- 4:23years of my career was Frustrated by how slowly they
- 4:27were evolving, right? Even though the writing was on
- 4:29the wall, you know, some Publications.
- 4:31Like the New York Times in particular, I would say, Adam
- 4:33incredible job of remaking themselves and, you know, more
- 4:36recently Publications like the Washington Post, I think have
- 4:39really kind of risen to the challenge.
- 4:41So I think you can do it but it's a lot easier for the big
- 4:44national International Publications to do it than the
- 4:46local pubs about. And is it really zero-sum?
- 4:49Like Katie? I feel like that's sort of the
- 4:51media old newspaper sort of framed you You see this?
- 4:56Like do you think really like a dollar going to a sub?
- 4:59Sack writer is a dollar loss to to a newspaper.
- 5:03Something that's how I would formulated.
- 5:05I was just saying that the idea of people getting news from
- 5:08places other than traditional media, right?
- 5:10And at large siphons away, well on the local newspaper, look at
- 5:13everything that the thing that sustained them for the longest
- 5:16time was the sports section, right?
- 5:18Like that was, you know, people had a relationship to the beat
- 5:20writer for the teams that they followed and the columnist
- 5:23there. And then there was that awful
- 5:25period. For the athletic, when they were
- 5:26on their way up and the CEO. Alex Mather said, fairy
- 5:30inelegantly to the New York Times, you know, our goal is to
- 5:33bleed all of the local sports, you know like all the local
- 5:36papers from their Sports sections, right.
- 5:38At least he's like believes will go like they're trying the New
- 5:41York Times about the athletic. Yeah.
- 5:43How did nobody like make that connection when that whole deal
- 5:45was going down? It was hysterical.
- 5:48I mean and I like Alex a lot but like it was like this bull
- 5:51moment of like, well I guess you didn't believe the right
- 5:53personality to frame the news. Which is really a, not news
- 5:57story, The New York Times, Ben Mullen reported that, you know,
- 6:01subset had been out trying to defend Muslims and already
- 6:05making waves of the times they're media reporter.
- 6:07Yeah. And the you know they've been
- 6:08trying to get valued at 750 million to a billion and the
- 6:14round and come together that they had Revenue about 9 million
- 6:18in 2021. And you know, I think important
- 6:22contacts for this is increase in Horowitz as Invest in both sub s
- 6:26clubhouse, right? And Clubhouse which has like no
- 6:30Revenue, raised it, a four billion dollar valuation was
- 6:33extremely Buzzy and sub stack is sort of been sort of I don't
- 6:38know. Ugly stepchild I'm sure they'd
- 6:40hate that but you know just isn't as glamorous hasn't got
- 6:43the attention but I mean subjects producing revenue and
- 6:46has seems to have more staying power than Clubhouse.
- 6:50Anyway so Casey is written about this.
- 6:52He is relieved. Maybe that Sack didn't didn't
- 6:56get the money. So Casey what sort of your
- 6:59argument there? Yeah.
- 7:00I mean you know, we've all read the stories about startups that
- 7:04raise too much money and investors hopes got too high and
- 7:08then the investors started to metal and gave them a bunch of
- 7:10horrible ideas for what they should do next.
- 7:12And that almost always comes at the expense of the the user
- 7:15base, right? And you know earlier this year
- 7:18sub stack released an app by default that app turned off
- 7:21email notifications. So like if you downloaded the
- 7:24sub stack app, you would know Her got platformer in your
- 7:26inbox. The whole reason I wanted to do
- 7:28this line of work, was I had this direct connection with my
- 7:31audience. You could already see that
- 7:33potentially going away after, you know, I and others wrote
- 7:36about this sub stack. Wound up walking that back, they
- 7:39just a match. Stripe people who got the out
- 7:42from email, which was insane. Like, I agree, but they reverse
- 7:46course, but you can imagine. You can imagine a world where
- 7:50they were suddenly, you know, they had an extra hundred
- 7:53million dollars of venture capital and two years go by and
- 7:55their investors are getting really nervous and they say, you
- 7:58know what, actually I think it's time for us to take 20% of your
- 8:02revenues or like whatever. It's so I think that like,
- 8:05they're still in this and all of a sudden then platformer is
- 8:08writing on another platform, you know, instead of an email that
- 8:11that's the risk, right? You know, I'm actually think
- 8:14that over the years subjects had percent cut has come to look
- 8:18more and more reasonable compared to what other people
- 8:20take wishing is maybe something we could talk about.
- 8:22But, you know, basically, I'm relieved that they Raise this
- 8:26money because I think they have sought some basic structural
- 8:28questions to ask themselves about what they're doing to get
- 8:32the combat kind of core model working, and I don't think you
- 8:35need another hundred million dollars to do it, right.
- 8:38Like, they need to figure out how to live within their means
- 8:41and, and really figure out how to grow that base of users and
- 8:44get themselves to like sustainability.
- 8:46I strenuously disagree with, you know, I mean, it feels like for
- 8:50once the media business had a chance to have blitzscaling at
- 8:53its back and then we don't even Even, we don't get the money.
- 8:57I mean, I mean, what how, what would they do to blitzscale?
- 8:59They would just go out and pay like 5,000 more people.
- 9:02A hundred thousand dollars to see if they would turn into,
- 9:04right? Well, let me see, did she was in
- 9:05the? I didn't read the full story but
- 9:07what was the as is my signature on this show?
- 9:09But what was the plan with the money?
- 9:11I mean, what did they sort of see as the value?
- 9:13And I don't know that that was reported.
- 9:15I do I think a key point is that sub stack has said that they're
- 9:20toning down their sub stack Pro program.
- 9:23Their VP of comms was on a Twitter spaces with me.
- 9:26And she, she said that, and I think that's interesting because
- 9:30I was really, I mean, I didn't I didn't get money from them, they
- 9:33offered me like a weird small loan.
- 9:36That was definitely not like a sign of strong, belief and
- 9:39newcomer. But, you know, I think it's sort
- 9:42of incentivizes, you know, sub Stacks that don't have sort of
- 9:47business front center to start and then potentially not
- 9:51succeed. But but to answer the question
- 9:53of how I'd like money to be spent to, To build ways for them
- 9:56to drive audience, which is the thing that they haven't haven't
- 9:59done really. Yeah.
- 10:00So you know you can work out a couple interesting numbers based
- 10:03on what we know about sub stack so they just passed a million
- 10:07paid subscribers in November, I believe.
- 10:11And we now know, according to Ben and Ben's reporting that
- 10:15they had about nine million dollars in Revenue.
- 10:18So 9 million in Revenue, I mean just back-of-the-envelope that
- 10:22assuming 5 million of that is coming from Barry Weiss.
- 10:26Maybe two million is coming from, like the bundle of
- 10:28newcomer platformer Glenn Greenwald a Matt Taibbi.
- 10:33The rest is probably Alex Berenson is that mostly the
- 10:36revenue breakdown. They have they have more
- 10:39Publications make making more money than I that I think people
- 10:43like Ken and your own evening Barry White's.
- 10:45Barry Weiss is number 6. I just don't want to unfairly
- 10:48compliment her because letters from an American Kevin and
- 10:52Heather Cox Richardson is one on politics.
- 10:55The dispatches to Matt Taibbi, these three the bulwarks for
- 10:58Glenn greenwald's five and she's six.
- 11:00Anyway, just fact check there. But if you look at the numbers,
- 11:04what that means is that most people who subscribe to a public
- 11:08subset publication or only subscribing to 1, right?
- 11:10Because most of these things are somewhere in the like 70 to 100
- 11:13bucks a year range. But you know, it's subsets whole
- 11:16eating. One of their big promises is you
- 11:19come be a part of this network and we're going to make it so
- 11:21easy for you to get customers because they will likely already
- 11:24be a customer of another sub stack.
- 11:25From there, it's just a couple of TAPS and all of a sudden, you
- 11:28know, we charge their credit card for yours as well, you
- 11:31know, and they even will show you like a graph of where your
- 11:33people come from and, you know, to hear sub-sect elat.
- 11:35There's suddenly a lot of like, existing subset customers but
- 11:38wait a minute, by the way, maybe they are, you know, like, I'm
- 11:40not saying that I doubt them, but it doesn't seem like most
- 11:42people are having that experience and they do think
- 11:44it's like a long-term risk to them.
- 11:46Hmm. What I mean, we've sort of seen
- 11:49this particular game play out so many times in the media of
- 11:52building up a subscriber base. And everyone's looking for the
- 11:54next wave Going to help you grow the business.
- 11:57And the obvious one is just bundling, right?
- 12:00It's all the same Playbook and I'm assuming you're talking
- 12:03about growing audience growing subscriber base, that's clearly
- 12:05going to be on the table. They're going to try to bundle
- 12:08you guys with with other people of similar topics or maybe even
- 12:11have like a diverse bundle. So you skeptical, I don't think
- 12:14it's a great idea to be honest. I think it's a way to juice
- 12:17numbers without juicing Revenue. A key.
- 12:20A key feature that they've rolled out is recommendations
- 12:23where instead of Sort of viral algorithm writers can recommend
- 12:28other writers and that's been driving a bunch of subscribers
- 12:32to people including myself as a great, great organic feature
- 12:37where Riders can decide what they want to do.
- 12:40That's like sort of more like on the right hand side of the page.
- 12:43I have the blog's I think too long which was kind of like the
- 12:49pre it's sort of like it's Preparing People psychologically
- 12:53for bundling Well, yeah, because think about how this has played
- 12:58out with cable right there was cable.
- 13:00Everybody hated it. Like, why do I have to have all
- 13:02this garbage just to get you some pain?
- 13:04And then there was like Netflix and Paramount plus and Amazon
- 13:08video and then people woke up one day and they're like, I'm
- 13:10paying, wow, hundreds of dollars a month for all these individual
- 13:15stripping networks, and that has to come to an end at some point.
- 13:18And so how that comes to an end, and how it shakes out is still
- 13:21being worked out. And I think that for direct to
- 13:24consumer News. It's sort of a similar idea.
- 13:28So if I'm paying $150 for newcomer and Casey whatever case
- 13:32he's charging me $100, it's an insane bargain I probably giving
- 13:36anything away, it's 33 percent off the newcomer price and so I
- 13:41haven't I'm helping people so you got money like I am
- 13:44publishing decks from billion dollars that's $250, just
- 13:49between the two of you, it's $250 that's my retirement
- 13:53account and every company case he writes about And say that I
- 13:56also want to pay Heather Cox Richardson and I also want to
- 13:59pay you know, Matt Taibbi suddenly I'm like why am I
- 14:02paying a thousand dollars a year for news but like Casey said,
- 14:07most I not could I not just pay less money and subscribe to the
- 14:11Wall Street Journal? I mean, so that's sort of where
- 14:14you cut what you come to which is why bundling feels like the
- 14:17natural certainly comes from the New York Times Reporter.
- 14:20It's where it's gonna, I mean, it's coming guys.
- 14:22There's there's zero chance to my mind that that sub-sector.
- 14:25I think what you're under it under estimating, is the idea
- 14:28that like Niche audiences, like, how would I can make more money
- 14:32off that like I have a sustainable business now, making
- 14:34more than I make it Bloomberg, I feel like sure.
- 14:37You guys are my friend media people.
- 14:38Subscribe to a lot of newsletters because you need to
- 14:41be stay up on media, but I think you guys are the sort of outlier
- 14:44cases and subscription Behavior. Most of the people subscribing
- 14:47to newcomer, you know. Yeah.
- 14:50I published some exclusive financial information that they
- 14:52want to read and they sign up to see that.
- 14:55Like they're very they're there in sort of the VC world, you
- 14:59know they're interested in. So I just I don't think they're
- 15:02like subscribing a newcomer because they're like these
- 15:04general consumers who want want some very sophisticated VC sake
- 15:09that I think that you that it's probably a good idea and you and
- 15:13Casey obviously know this better than I do to think about the
- 15:16financial fortunes of the folks were writing for sub stack
- 15:20versus the financial fortunes of sub stack as a company.
- 15:23Sure. So it's true that you two might
- 15:25be Quite well, but how a sub stack doing overall?
- 15:28And I think that that's where the decision-making around
- 15:30something like, bundling comes into play less.
- 15:33So than how you work, a Seer personally doing, and the
- 15:36bundling aspect might not be for you, but if there are say, you
- 15:41could guess hundreds of people on sub stack writing about their
- 15:45Grandma's favorite recipes, wouldn't it make sense to put
- 15:48all those grandmas together with all their delicious recipes?
- 15:51Yes. So, I actually made the example
- 15:54that we were talking about this. In my Discord server this
- 15:56morning and food writers was the example that I use.
- 16:00So what I like to see subset consider is to offer,
- 16:04essentially optional bundling tools, so that if you are a
- 16:08recipe writer, a food, writer with a relatively small
- 16:10following you want to go in with 9 or 10 or 12 other people that
- 16:13are doing the same thing, help each other grow.
- 16:16You might actually, sort of come out ahead and all of that.
- 16:20And at the very least, I like if I were sub-sect, that's where I
- 16:23would start because, right, because if they come out,
- 16:25Tomorrow, and they say, we're introducing a Netflix model, and
- 16:27it's like all you can eat for ten bucks a month.
- 16:29You know, people like me and Eric Garner going to run
- 16:31screaming from that would destroy our business.
- 16:33Yeah, right. And remember Apple tried that
- 16:35with their news? Bundle with Apple news and they
- 16:38couldn't get almost any Publications to sign on board
- 16:40with that. I think just the LA Times And
- 16:43The Wall Street Journal, but it was a fiasco.
- 16:44They couldn't get the other big-name pubs that they would
- 16:46have wanted. But the interesting thing about,
- 16:48you know, this bundle of Niche products is that in television,
- 16:53it doesn't work. I mean like the bundle Model
- 16:55only works because ESPN is the most popular cable channel in
- 16:59the country, and it charges significantly more than any
- 17:02other network to the cable Distributors, and they kind of
- 17:06keep the whole business of float, right?
- 17:08It's like you want ESPN and we're going to bundle everything
- 17:10else in there and it's part of the kind of hard-ass
- 17:13negotiations that the media companies have.
- 17:15And, you know, with the like different skinny bundles which
- 17:17was a whole failed model there were attempts to make you known
- 17:21on ESPN bundles. There is this company still out
- 17:23there called Philo It was, you know, they would pejoratively
- 17:28refer to it as the loser bundle because it just had a MC.
- 17:31And, you know, HGTV and all the discovery.
- 17:34Other networks viewers were losers or the comp.
- 17:37Well, I'm not, I'm not casting judgment myself as to who was
- 17:40the real issue for him but but, yeah.
- 17:43And so, I mean, it's one of those rare things where
- 17:45everybody knows is, that's yeah, that happens.
- 17:47So often in media. But but yeah, I mean, I think
- 17:51the trouble with the idea, I love the idea of what you're
- 17:54proposing, Casey and it obviously.
- 17:55You see is like, you know, helping to Rising tide lifting
- 17:58the weaker boats. I don't know.
- 18:00And kind of like a much more organic way to do customer
- 18:03acquisition. Yeah, but it's just there's no
- 18:05history of it working and that's enough.
- 18:08I will say though, slightly related, if somebody offered me
- 18:11a channel and don't care how it came to me, streaming whatnot,
- 18:15that was only like murder shows. I'd be very excited.
- 18:19True Crime shows, if I could get NCIS Law and Order like CSI,
- 18:23Etc. All in one Panel how much, how
- 18:27much money do I have? I think all those shows are on
- 18:29CBS the ultimate, but what about like that shudder?
- 18:35Like, I mean, shutter is a streaming service?
- 18:38That's just horror movies, right?
- 18:39It's probably not like a massive success but I don't know it's a
- 18:42business. Yeah, it's okay.
- 18:43It's part of AMC, but but I say, I guess, the reason I bring it
- 18:46up to you guys is that like it would be a little bit strange to
- 18:50bundle newcomer with Grandma cooking blogs or or you know
- 18:53platformer with Auto blogs or something, but they kind of need
- 18:58those anchor Publications in there to kind of prove larger
- 19:02value and I think that's where the negotiation happens maybe
- 19:06eventually they will go to like the very biggest sub stacks and
- 19:09just offer them a great deal and say, you know, you're making a
- 19:12million will pay you a million and a half.
- 19:14If you're part of this bundle, you know, because we know you
- 19:16probably wouldn't make that as part of the bundle just by the
- 19:19basic math. But, you know, we want to
- 19:21incentivize more people subscribing, like, I could see
- 19:23them doing that. But, you know, We've been
- 19:25talking about this from the subset perspective, which is
- 19:27good and fine, but you think about it from The Writer's
- 19:30perspective. It's like they also just have a
- 19:32bunch of writers on their platform now who could leave and
- 19:35just do this sustainably forever and it's not clear that you
- 19:38actually need a sub stack to keep the business going right?
- 19:41Like you know journalists are so cynical and pessimistic about
- 19:45every business model that I think they a memory of under a
- 19:49now. I see it that I'm gonna just Tom
- 19:52just uh they underestimate what a great.
- 19:55Job, this can be right. You think about how big the
- 19:57internet is? If you can find two thousand
- 20:00people to pay you a hundred bucks a year, you're making more
- 20:02money than almost any Media Company would pay you for any
- 20:04reason. There's a lot of groups of two
- 20:06thousand people on the internet. So, like to me the really
- 20:10exciting thing here is, you know, I hope substract is, it
- 20:12has a long successful run, you know, I have no plans to leave
- 20:15it. It would be inconvenient to do
- 20:17so. But like, also, I'm not
- 20:18terrified about them going out of business because to me the
- 20:21model works, like I found my few thousand people and I can just
- 20:25do As long as I want to and we have a direct relationship with
- 20:27stripe. I mean, part of the reason sub
- 20:29stack has been able to recruit. Everyone has been the fact that
- 20:32you can leave II. Don't think they would do a
- 20:34bundle that would infuriate writers.
- 20:37I think they would have to do it in a sort of additive way and I
- 20:41want to talk about other things, but I do think the long tail
- 20:43issue is going to be a problem for sub stack.
- 20:46If I had to make my business case against them, I think you
- 20:49know in anything you know, influencer economy, sort of
- 20:53celebrities win and That's the top sort of get sort of really,
- 20:59really rich and everybody else is sort of screwed.
- 21:02I mean I feel like I'm sort of I mean we're you can analyze like
- 21:05the sub stack lists and sort of see and I do think there's a
- 21:09sharp drop off you know from 1 2 3 4 5 and then by 10 it's
- 21:16probably much lower and so if they can't get the long tail to
- 21:20make good money then they'll have less fewer sort of new sub
- 21:24sex coming in. The shot at being sort of the
- 21:26celebrity writer or I don't know, Casey, what's your view on
- 21:29that small. So let's talk about the long
- 21:30tail. The number one sub stack.
- 21:32Publication is a guy that writes about how to manage your career
- 21:36as an engineer. Basically, if you pitch is that
- 21:39Homer one overall. Yeah.
- 21:41I'll technology contact. Yeah.
- 21:43And so if you were to pitch that column to any mainstream,
- 21:46publication that said that's way too nitzsche get out of here.
- 21:49Our readers would hate it and this guy's this guy's easily
- 21:51pragmatic engine 450, 500 thousand bucks a year, right?
- 21:55So if there are more niches like that, then I think the long tail
- 22:00is actually going to be really successful.
- 22:02Now you know we could talk about the characteristics that these
- 22:04really successful businesses. Have they write for rich people,
- 22:07continuing education for rich people.
- 22:10They tend to be something that you can expense, right?
- 22:13They tend to be something that helps you make more money.
- 22:16So look not, you know if you're if you want to write a poetry
- 22:18diary it's probably not going to succeed to the same degree but I
- 22:22think it's much more productive to think about this in terms of
- 22:25like What sorts of Publications could work and who, you know,
- 22:28who is the person that could write the publication?
- 22:30And at that, I think you'd have a bunch more people.
- 22:32Make him half a million bucks. Here, I one thing that I really
- 22:34liked about this part of the conversation is that it shows
- 22:38that you can be really successful in an online platform
- 22:41where you have a broad audience for anybody can access you
- 22:45without being sensationalist and insane person fighting with
- 22:49people and just being generally wretched.
- 22:51Aka the Twitter model. Where is he instead?
- 22:55It's like, use, if you just want to nerd out with a bunch of
- 22:57people who have your general nerdy interest, that's great.
- 23:00And actually, I don't know that a poetry version wouldn't be
- 23:03successful because there's a part of me that's like, well, if
- 23:06it were Edna st. Vincent Millay.
- 23:07Maybe I would give them a little bit of money, but that's so
- 23:10great. That makes me so happy.
- 23:12And one of the biggest viral hits on sub stack of the year
- 23:15has been someone who's just sending out chapters of Dracula?
- 23:20Like, I don't know, if it's want, like, a couple times a
- 23:22week or every day, but it's become a huge Tumblr meme,
- 23:25because First Dracula was, or I believe, it's an epistolary
- 23:28novel, you know. And so, you know, people are on
- 23:30Tumblr because, you know, because they know what's going
- 23:33to eventually happen to the narrator are just sort of like,
- 23:35don't tell me are having and we won't spoil it here on the
- 23:38podcast, but people are having a lot of fun, just sort of in the
- 23:42in the lead-up to this met again, you know, that's just
- 23:44like a public domain work that some ways that record-breaking
- 23:47bunch of money and I don't know if they're monetizing it or not.
- 23:50I mean you know it's a public doing work but they still could
- 23:54be up, you know, people are Being creative with it.
- 23:56And I appreciate Katie bringing up the fact that like, you know,
- 23:59we as journalists who live on Twitter all day, you can come to
- 24:03believe that Twitter is the only way that you could ever do media
- 24:06and that every single story has to have the elements of Scandal
- 24:10and outrage, dialed up, as far as they can, possibly go to have
- 24:13any chance at all of getting attention and like meanwhile
- 24:16like I don't know, just like go look at the headlines on the
- 24:19stories that Eric and I right there like beautifully boring,
- 24:21like they never over promise anything, I try to make them
- 24:24more board. It's just I don't have a very
- 24:28yeah I'm not no salacious no I don't like that.
- 24:31You're most Reds by the way. Just out of curiosity.
- 24:34Every time there's a battle or is the battle its signal, or
- 24:38like the war over. What was that?
- 24:41Other the company you covered so well base camp.
- 24:43Yeah, exactly. Yeah.
- 24:45I mean, look, I, you know, and I've written the, the stories, I
- 24:49would argue that the material in there justifies the headline.
- 24:52Yeah. But I think like the trick is
- 24:54just Not to constantly over rotate.
- 24:56Like I think we could all name Publications.
- 24:58That just always sort of put the most absurd headline on
- 25:02everything and it and it just shows their deep insecurity that
- 25:05there's actually enough material and there to get anyone to
- 25:08justify cooking. Also works for yeah.
- 25:10Listen. Sometimes we have to A/B test
- 25:13those headlines to find out which is the most absurd but we
- 25:16know when we've hit it I will say something you know just to
- 25:20both of you guys and generally where the industry is gone over
- 25:23the last few years. That I also find very hard Thing
- 25:25is the rise of the reported column.
- 25:28I think is very much attached to the sub stack model.
- 25:31And, you know, we saw people at like, Ben Smith at the New York
- 25:33Times, do a great job at this, but I actually think it's a
- 25:36great direction for journalism to go because I don't think
- 25:40there's any turning back the clock on people's opinions being
- 25:43out there as journalists. I mean, Twitter is fundamentally
- 25:46broken that and it for for most reporters, I think.
- 25:50But what I like so much about, you know, newcomer and case a
- 25:54murder when you Started, I think before it was called platform or
- 25:57when you started your newsletter and you basically laid out like
- 26:00here's the way, the Kira here are my views on the world of the
- 26:03internet and like I believe that Facebook has caused a huge
- 26:06amount of harm. I think Fox News has caused
- 26:08more, you probably have other tenants in your, you know, you
- 26:11know, your Hadith that explains it more in depth but I think
- 26:15that's an important thing that has come out of this whole
- 26:19Trend, which is, you know, you can still allow yourself with a
- 26:23political or social world view. But also get like, you know,
- 26:26General General Nutrition from it, that is valuable to at least
- 26:30like supporting your worldview and like maybe giving you
- 26:33opportunities to think about things.
- 26:34So there's my, there's Michael absolutely can thank you, thank
- 26:38you for saying that. But by the way, that idea of
- 26:39sort of, like, laying out, Here's Where I Come From.
- 26:41That's an idea that I stole from Jay Rosen and why you Professor
- 26:45anyone can do it. I highly encourage journalists
- 26:47to think about doing it. It's, you know, it's enormously
- 26:50clarified to just like look it up blank Google doc until like
- 26:52what do I actually think about the world?
- 26:54Just try to write it. Down and once you have I think
- 26:57it just it brings real Integrity to your work.
- 26:59You know, I get so frustrated by all these really talented
- 27:02reporters that I follow on Twitter, who's like, whole mode
- 27:05of engaging. With the world is just like,
- 27:07basically, quote tweeting stuff with LOL and LMAO like, that's
- 27:12that's their only. If you're a reader of those
- 27:14Publications and that's all you see those reporters doing.
- 27:17It's really hard to believe that they're there to do anything,
- 27:21you know, about the world. But laugh at it.
- 27:23And I think that that actually Mine's The credibility of
- 27:26Journalism. So I appreciate what you said
- 27:28Tom And yeah, I'm a huge fan of the reporter column, like Ben
- 27:31Smith is basically my North Star.
- 27:32Every time I pick up the phone. Whoa, same band, but I think he
- 27:39would love to hear that. I told him the other day and for
- 27:44me I mean Casey a little further along in his career but for me
- 27:48like, you know, I don't know if I would have been able to get a
- 27:51reported column job and so this was a way to sort of Force the
- 27:55issue. And thankfully you know I got
- 27:57enough subscribers to justify it but it allowed, you know, that's
- 28:01a job that's part of in some ways not the case with been but
- 28:04for a lot of reporters given to reporters once.
- 28:06They're tired of reporting a little bit but happy to have it
- 28:09sort of a little earlier in my career that I might have been
- 28:12able to a traditional media Outlet also you know beyond just
- 28:16the reported column. We also support the just very
- 28:19good and informative column which maybe could transition us
- 28:22to heal on time and and Matt Gene's continuing domination the
- 28:26most so good, analyses of whatever bullshit Elon is
- 28:31throwing out us on a weekly basis.
- 28:33It comes in armed with facts. That's what makes me not really
- 28:36different from Ela. Will you trust him?
- 28:39And I like more than the financial system or report, you
- 28:42know, it's like oh that's guys the decider of what how the
- 28:45world works and I read it anyway, what should we say about
- 28:48Elon? Should we, should we go into it?
- 28:49Should we save it for the end, I sort of jump to it but you know,
- 28:52we let's do that. I mean, I think it's maybe like
- 28:54the Or C, Elon thing has been the biggest recent development.
- 28:59I mean, Casey has a close Watcher of Twitter, like what
- 29:03the, what's wrong with Jack Dorsey?
- 29:05I mean, he like, I mean, he's basically betraying the guy he
- 29:09put in as CEO. It's like, Prague has been CEO
- 29:13for. I don't, I don't know of the guy
- 29:15maybe is bad but like he's been in it for like a couple months
- 29:18and now Jack's. Like I'm glad that were none of
- 29:20us can. Remember prague's name, we have
- 29:22a yeah. Jack dorsey's position is
- 29:27ideally. Twitter would be controlled by
- 29:28no one and it should be this utopian and artistic world.
- 29:33But since we can't have that, let's have fascism of Elon Musk
- 29:37on Twitter instead and Only the strongest Among Us can rule,
- 29:41like, what if the guy has the most in coherent worldview?
- 29:45Why? I feel like that was so
- 29:46crystallized. When after the Elan deal was
- 29:48finally announced and Jack posts, a link to radiohead's
- 29:52everything in its right place as like some sort of Arrival point
- 29:55for this whole deal and is like, do you read the lyrics to that
- 29:58song? Have you ever listened to that
- 30:00song before and didn't just look up?
- 30:02You know, a song name that has the right in it because I would
- 30:05not call that the, like the utopian ideal of, like, any
- 30:08situation, why? Yeah, it's, this is makeup
- 30:13sucking on a lemon. I mean, it's like radiohead's,
- 30:17just stop it, you know, kid a record.
- 30:20Nothing is positive that would be referenced in that song or
- 30:23album, but go. Off check.
- 30:26There's like also this beautiful Symmetry and just like Jack and
- 30:29Elon using their companies to just like by things that please
- 30:34them whether it's Elon using Tesla to buy Solar City or Jack
- 30:39having Square by title. Like to stick like using these,
- 30:42like public companies is piggy banks.
- 30:44But you know, as far as like what is Jack thinking?
- 30:47You know, I talked a lot of people about this the best
- 30:49theory that I've heard is basically Jack was all but
- 30:54forced out of the company, right?
- 30:55These activist shareholders came on, they said you're not hitting
- 30:58any of these targets. And so last November, he's
- 31:01basically told, like you, it's time for you to go, you're not
- 31:05even trying to do any of the things that you promised to do.
- 31:08And so he leaves and tells the world that I do, you know, it's
- 31:10my choice. I'm stepping down and he did get
- 31:13to Pam pick a successor. And so he picked parag who had
- 31:16played a big role in this blue sky project, which is, you know,
- 31:19try to turn Twitter and to some kind of decentralized protocol.
- 31:22So at the time it seems like Jack thought parag was the Spat
- 31:25to create the Twitter of his dreams, but then a few months
- 31:29later, he hears that Elon is acquiring stock and his interest
- 31:32in the company. And of course, they've been
- 31:33friends for a while. And so, you know, Elaine starts
- 31:37Gathering, you know, a position of the company.
- 31:39And then, if you look at the proxy statement, like the day
- 31:42after they reach a standstill agreement for Ilan, to stop,
- 31:45buying shares, and Twitter, Jack goes to heaven is like, why
- 31:48don't you just buy it? And so like Jack according to
- 31:51the regulatory filings is the person that upset The apple cart
- 31:55and and triggered this whole thing.
- 31:58And it's because he really wants to get this thing off the public
- 32:01market. And I think that's because he
- 32:04has all this scar tissue from the fact that he was forced out
- 32:06of his own company twice. And so it's like if he can't run
- 32:09it, that no one can. And so it is this very emotional
- 32:13reaction. Wonderful, there does seem like
- 32:16this view from Jack through his tweets that like he was the CEO
- 32:22but he couldn't really do what he wanted.
- 32:23Because ultimately Sort of there are there are obviously moves
- 32:27you have to make if you're doing things for the public markets
- 32:30and so you do those and like you just can't be as crazy as he
- 32:34would have one. I mean that sort of capitalism
- 32:37you know but like is he still going to be under capitalism as
- 32:40a private company? Or I don't know, I guess the
- 32:43question here is, how much do you let jack off the hook for
- 32:46the idea that he wasn't able to do what you truly wanted to CEO?
- 32:51Because he had to be sort of a good Steward of the company as a
- 32:54public, Company's CEO, right? But I mean that it's such
- 32:57nonsense, you know. Know it had more of an
- 32:59opportunity that Jack Dorsey to shape the future of Twitter.
- 33:01You know, he co-founded it. He was CEO of it twice.
- 33:05You know, most recently for six years, he was also chairman of
- 33:08the board. So for this guy to come out
- 33:09after all of that and just be like yeah, like what about you
- 33:12know, Twitter never became what it should have.
- 33:14Its like that is literally or well that could not be more your
- 33:17fault. Right.
- 33:18Right. It would be kind of like, if
- 33:19Dean baquet were like God, well, I was running this show.
- 33:23We really never did what we should.
- 33:25Crazy sounding that would sound insane.
- 33:28Completely. Unlike Jack just gets a past
- 33:30even though he's, you know, he was he was at halftime CEO which
- 33:32was also his choice, right? Like that was that's what makes
- 33:35me even more galling. Why does he get a pass?
- 33:37It fascinates me so much more than any other executive of any
- 33:42industry I've ever covered. He gets a pass every time.
- 33:46Well, I mean, so Elon also gets this pass, right?
- 33:48That's true. Another thing that they have in
- 33:49common but this is a big reason. Why the activist investors came
- 33:54on in T20 to begin with, was that they were sick of it.
- 33:58And it was clear that Twitter was underperforming in part
- 34:00because they had a terrible CEO who was barely paying attention
- 34:03to the company. So it did actually wind up.
- 34:05There was a consequence for him which was that he lost his job,
- 34:09but he can't stop meddling with it.
- 34:11And, you know, now the the Twist and The Saga this week is that
- 34:14he's apparently going to roll his Equity over into the new
- 34:17Elon company, you know, and that'll probably be a big
- 34:19position and he may be able to actually, you know, continue to
- 34:22exert control on the future footer.
- 34:24Everything you just ABS is in so many ways, like very vindicating
- 34:28of the Nick Bilton book on Twitter where he describes Jack.
- 34:31Dorsey is basically like a scheming moron and it's what I
- 34:36remember when that book came out.
- 34:37People are like, that's so mean Jack.
- 34:39Such a good guy like, but I don't know.
- 34:42Like, I would say that that book is not looking so terrible.
- 34:46And I wonder what was it about Jack Dorsey that for that huge
- 34:51chunk of time people, so wanted to defend him and Text him.
- 34:55I did. I kind of don't get it.
- 34:57I mean, why don't you know when you tell Nick, Bilton, who you
- 34:59are believe them. The first time there.
- 35:03Look, there there is a tradition in of founder worship and in
- 35:08Silicon Valley. And if you go back to 2013, 2014
- 35:11Jack really did look like this transformational figure who had
- 35:15two incredibly powerful ideas, right?
- 35:17Twitter and square. And, you know, till very
- 35:20recently like square look like an even more amazing company
- 35:23than Twitter and it basically, every way, Right?
- 35:25So there's this idea that once you're lucky twice, you're good
- 35:28and by that standard, how could Jack Dorsey be anything but
- 35:31good, but I think the past five years or so, I've really taken a
- 35:35lot of Shine off of that because he's become so disconnected.
- 35:39You know, he's remotely managing these companies in between
- 35:42meditation Retreats, it is just not.
- 35:45He just doesn't seem to be as serious as a person as he didn't
- 35:49like 2013 2014. But that point of view is why
- 35:52it's probably so convenient for him to have this removed.
- 35:55Move from Twitter as you know, the CEO and kind of say why is
- 35:58it not achieving its full potential?
- 36:00What is going on here? It's like well you first of all
- 36:02are distant from the company physically for a time when he
- 36:05decided he was going to move to Africa.
- 36:07But also it's just so it's such a perfect microcosm of this era
- 36:10that people are refusing to take any responsibility for their
- 36:13actions. And instead speaking very, you
- 36:16know, for like an illusory way of how they are, you know what
- 36:20is the sphere of influence that they have on things and who is
- 36:23responsible for the largest? Sequences of the world.
- 36:26I mean, it's perfect. He is a man of our time.
- 36:28This deal is still not happening, or do you have a bet
- 36:33Casey. I mean, the stock market is
- 36:35clearly not certain it's happening but sort of the the
- 36:38odds seem like they went out this way.
- 36:40I mean it's a really weird thing about this week as last week was
- 36:43the week of chaos and Eli making it seem like the deal was never
- 36:46in happened this week. He got rid of the margin loan
- 36:50that he was going to take out against his Tesla shares
- 36:52suggesting. He was going to leave her light
- 36:54up more. People to take equity in the
- 36:56company. So, I mean, this week, it was
- 36:58like a completely different Elon Musk.
- 37:00He stopped, you know, tweeting, weird stuff about the company
- 37:02for the most part, and started tweeting about Elden ring
- 37:04instead. So, you know, if you want to
- 37:07have like a musket M, that's like, How likely is this dude is
- 37:10like this week, you know, it's sort of swung over to the end.
- 37:13Maybe it goes through side of things.
- 37:15Do you think? Is it?
- 37:16He can get outside money. Yeah, I mean, he's already lined
- 37:19up. You know, billions of equity
- 37:21been a lot of reasons is right. What's up?
- 37:24Yes. A lot of the deal was supposed
- 37:27to be done. Yeah, I think I'm a
- 37:28accommodation I've done Equity but like, I would like Andre
- 37:31some. I think was going to take
- 37:32everybody. Yeah, yeah.
- 37:33And Sequoia, but they weren't that big.
- 37:35And if you are an employee at Twitter right now, how do you
- 37:41what exactly is your commitment to this company?
- 37:43And to whatever Mission, you think you are attached to you
- 37:46right now. I just it blows my mind.
- 37:48It's one thing to sort of see the circus playing out on TV or
- 37:51wherever, but to decide that you are part of Something greater
- 37:55that there is still, you know, beyond just like clock in and
- 37:58out and, you know, pushing code like actually feeling like there
- 38:01is a light here. That's going to result in like
- 38:03the greater, good of the company and maybe even the world like,
- 38:06what, what where is your brain at?
- 38:09Well, I mean, you know Twitter is, is very important product.
- 38:11It's important every day. I mean, you know, all the
- 38:13horrible things that happened this week and how essential
- 38:16Twitter has been to understanding those events in
- 38:18real-time. So I'm sure plenty of people who
- 38:19work at the company are just happy to continue doing that at
- 38:23the same time. I also know a lot of Our people
- 38:25are looking for other jobs right now.
- 38:27A lot of other Executives have quit in the past few weeks.
- 38:30We're going to see a lot more of that in the weeks to come.
- 38:32You know, keep in mind probably had what three months running
- 38:35this company before this whole catastrophe started to unfold.
- 38:37So he didn't really have much time to rally the troops.
- 38:40And as soon as he did start talking to his troops on a
- 38:42regular basis, it was, you know, trying to manage their feelings.
- 38:45Around this guy with a kindergarten level understanding
- 38:48of content. Moderation saying he was going
- 38:50to come in and blow up the company, right?
- 38:52So Prague has not been popular among the rank and file.
- 38:55I'll just a very difficult situation, so Prague is not
- 38:59popular either. I mean he was, it was well-liked
- 39:04when he was named Twitter CEO, he's a known quantity, there
- 39:07he's been there for over a decade.
- 39:09People did respect him but he has not been able to do much
- 39:13since he got to the company in terms of improving it and making
- 39:17people feel better about their jobs.
- 39:19He's been firing a lot of people.
- 39:21We got any that's or your do you know what?
- 39:24That's cute. Always mean, I think it's fairly
- 39:27standard like new CEO comes in and cleans house a little bit
- 39:30and wants to pick their own deputies and lieutenants, who
- 39:34are more loyal to them. Great timing.
- 39:36Yeah, I mean it couldn't wait until after the deal went
- 39:38through to start accessing favored top-down univ.'s.
- 39:42That would make sense to me. I mean, you know, he eventually
- 39:44came forward and said, I have to be prepared for any eventuality
- 39:48and you know, and I think the subtext there was if this deal
- 39:51falls through. Like, do I want to squander
- 39:53three or six months while I I have these people who I don't
- 39:56really trust in these positions of high Authority.
- 39:59I don't know what give to me the most optimistic outcome.
- 40:03Like if you were to say everything, you know every Lon
- 40:06cleans up his act, the deal goes through.
- 40:08What does the ideal version of Twitter?
- 40:10Look like six to eight months from now.
- 40:13I mean I think like the best case scenario is that as Elon is
- 40:18confronted with the everyday realities of running Twitter.
- 40:22He sort of speed runs the past Decade of all of us learning
- 40:26about why content. Moderation is good for business
- 40:29and whines up not changing that much of the core product, right?
- 40:34Like when you look at what you'll want to do with Twitter
- 40:38aside from what he said about Free Speech, there are not a lot
- 40:40of big changes that he is proposed.
- 40:43So there's a world in which he runs the company and it doesn't
- 40:46change all that much. I think that's about as good as
- 40:50you can hope for like, I don't think he's going to be a
- 40:51transformational leader. You know, Twitter was working
- 40:54fine for him. He's the, you know, number one
- 40:56user on the platform is businesses or helped
- 40:58tremendously by the fact that, you know, he can promote them
- 41:01there. So why would he change it that
- 41:03much? Yeah, as a side note, that is
- 41:05why it killed me that there was like a Spate of op-ed saying,
- 41:08like, what we're seeing here is billionaires, controlling the
- 41:10media. And, you know, Elon Musk is
- 41:13going to turn Twitter. And do a megaphone is like 80
- 41:16million followers. What more megaphone does he
- 41:18need? Like, how does that pass as like
- 41:21smart analysis? Twitter has already a megaphone?
- 41:24Yeah, I do not. And the liberal worry about Elon
- 41:26Musk taking over Twitter at all. Like I just don't see what he
- 41:31does. It's so bad and I would love,
- 41:33I've said this a billion times already, but I'd love for Ilan
- 41:36to be culpable for every bad thing that happens on Twitter,
- 41:39like especially if he's burning himself, is like a Republican.
- 41:42And so, you can say, oh, this is for once, like conservative has
- 41:47to actually govern something people care about and can be, I
- 41:50even like all the Kangas and and shoots a school full of children
- 41:53and post all the photos and videos.
- 41:54Is on Twitter or something like that?
- 41:56Maybe maybe who knows be there or I don't know what's the?
- 42:00But you're saying like if he's going to loosen things up and
- 42:03let the puppies, are thinking about what they post on your
- 42:05rate and not sensor and a bunch of crazy-ass, shit shows up like
- 42:09people being beheaded over. So you always had the red, it
- 42:15cou Shawn, you know, had that whole tweet storm that was very
- 42:18popular, which basically had the idea that ultimately, you know,
- 42:22people are forced to Satisfy the consensus of the mob, right?
- 42:27Is that how you would characterize it Casey or I mean
- 42:30basically like there's just a level of public pressure that
- 42:33even the most like True Believer conservative wouldn't be able to
- 42:36stomach. Like you're saying Katie and
- 42:38therefore they would make the same decisions that the good
- 42:40Liberals are making giant. People don't want to believe
- 42:44that there is consumer demand for Content moderation.
- 42:47But there is a promise you like, consumers, love contact,
- 42:50moderation. I don't want to open a social
- 42:53media app and see. Something, insanely Dreadful.
- 42:56I don't want that in the most moderate consumers like that,
- 43:00that they're the ones who want content moderation, because they
- 43:03don't want to be annoyed by the insane extreme behavior of the
- 43:06fringes. That's what never made sense
- 43:08about Iran's you. It's The moderates Who on
- 43:11content moderation, not the far left or the far-right like this
- 43:14is all, we all know, like, just hurtling towards a scenario,
- 43:18where Tucker Carlson is, you know, arguing Lee arguing
- 43:21vehemently towards the need to see beheading videos on Twitter.
- 43:24Right. It's just going to be him
- 43:26saying, like the big media companies.
- 43:27Tell you, you don't want to see people's heads being chopped
- 43:30off, but actually you really actually want, you didn't want
- 43:33to see it. My family wants to see it and
- 43:35your family wants to see it too. Yeah.
- 43:38When the families of those who have been beheaded, they also
- 43:41want to see that again. We're thinking when I should be.
- 43:43So yeah, yeah, Casey I mean, this is like the Tom's getting
- 43:48at. I mean and you touched on this
- 43:50earlier that like you think that in your mission statement that
- 43:53fox Was worse than Facebook. And it's like, I think a lot
- 43:57about, I mean, I don't know, like, but yet, there's so much
- 44:01more interest in, like, understanding how social media
- 44:04companies behave than yeah, like fox or, I don't know, how is
- 44:08your thinking on that sort of grow?
- 44:09Well, in on this is like, in this, it is, so, we like, Fox is
- 44:12very straightforward. Like, you just have a bunch of,
- 44:14you know, people going on and like, saying horrible things and
- 44:16it's not anything other than what it pretends to be.
- 44:19You know, Facebook is not that it presents itself as a sort of
- 44:23being this neutral forum for Todd, their these algorithms,
- 44:26that rank things that are extremely difficult to
- 44:29understand people assume the worst about them.
- 44:31They're collecting a lot of data about as personally, they're
- 44:34using it to Target ads. So those are like very different
- 44:37things and it's, it should not surprise us that like Facebook
- 44:40has drawn so much more scrutiny. It's also much bigger.
- 44:42Right? Facebook's audiences like
- 44:44workers of magnitude bigger than Fox News.
- 44:46Same time, you do a study of like, what actually shifts the
- 44:49politics in a country and it seems like it's much more Fox
- 44:52News than a Facebook, you know by itself.
- 44:54Elf. So, you know, I like everything
- 44:58multiple things can be true. Facebook is a very important
- 45:00subject for study. I write about all the time, but
- 45:04I'm very leery of people that want to find very simple
- 45:08solutions, to systemic problems and like, over the past year, I
- 45:13just feel like we've seen in so many ways that our problems are
- 45:16so much bigger than freaking Facebook, like, you could unplug
- 45:19that thing tomorrow, and you would still have the majority of
- 45:22the Republican Party who's turned against democracy.
- 45:24Like you cannot solve that problem at the level of like
- 45:27putting the algorithm on GitHub, but a lot of people still tweet
- 45:31about that as if that's the case and if you want more space I
- 45:34mean sorry if you unplugged Fox News, it does feel like, I mean,
- 45:37I think we definitely want to try it.
- 45:38Yeah, we should try it. Yeah.
- 45:41Katie and I are no comments on that.
- 45:42Yeah I just I see that I'm like the worst thing in the world to
- 45:49say I'm no commenting because I actually I had somebody who Who
- 45:54watches probably a lot more Fox News than you do Eric.
- 45:57Well, I watch a lot of Tucker Clips or only, but yeah, that's
- 46:00not the same. You're defending Fox News from
- 46:02first print from your actual point of view.
- 46:05Yeah. As somebody who has to watch it
- 46:07all the time, who works with Fox news, reporters in The Newsroom
- 46:11at the justice department, who sees what they report, who reads
- 46:14their stories? I think that the blanket
- 46:17statement, let's try shutting down.
- 46:19Fox News is not something that I would actually agree with.
- 46:23Wow, now it's shocking me. There's something deeply wrong
- 46:26with what's going on on Tucker Carlson show.
- 46:29Let me point you to the 20,000 words that my colleague just
- 46:33wrote about this very issue where he talks about how Tucker
- 46:36Carlson is mainstreaming. Seen the most virulent and ugly,
- 46:39white supremacist and homophobic ideas into mainstream America.
- 46:44All happy, we should also say, like the quote-unquote news
- 46:47division of fox has done so much to mainstream ideas about, you
- 46:51know, grooming and CRT and all of these frickin boogeymen Like,
- 46:55that is not contained a Tucker Carlson, right?
- 46:57The entire news division, the entire news division is oriented
- 47:01around finding grievance bait to feed to conservatives and poison
- 47:04their minds into thinking that Democrats are, you know, trying
- 47:07to destroy civilization. I would, I would argue that.
- 47:10That's first of all, not unique to only Fox.
- 47:13But I would also say that I think that there is a difference
- 47:16between what's going on in the sort of op-ed hours the The
- 47:21Primetime hours and what's happening during the day.
- 47:23I'll only issue I take is Eric wants to say that the reason I
- 47:26don't support. His blanket statement is simply
- 47:28because I'm too afraid to say that I agree with him which is
- 47:32not true. Okay.
- 47:33I it's shocking to me. I have to meet you for it to me.
- 47:36Fox News is clearly the worst thing in American culture at the
- 47:40moment in would certainly be. The first thing I would want to
- 47:44pull the plug on with with little ambiguity and I'm
- 47:47struggling to respond to the argument style that I just need
- 47:51to watch more of. No, I'm not.
- 47:55I'm not saying to make tibia, but I'm not even saying you're
- 47:59wrong. I'm just saying I disagree with
- 48:00you but for not for the reason, you're going to say yes, one
- 48:03talk about snap to close it out. I can talk about snow Erik
- 48:07Alma's, not to say that. I refuse to say hate
- 48:09Republicans, because I'm too afraid to what Eric doesn't
- 48:12understand is that most of my family's Republican and I have a
- 48:17lot of friends who are Republicans, which is why I will
- 48:19not say out of hand. Hate all Republicans.
- 48:23I grossest thing. So I think they're diluted like
- 48:27I've spent tons of time with them like and I'm not and I'm
- 48:29just saying it, like, I guess my preference that you don't say
- 48:32something is because it's your beat makes me more comfortable
- 48:36with than the fact that I have a friend who's fine.
- 48:40Just sort of with terrible people.
- 48:42So yeah, it is a set out of a place of trying to protect you
- 48:47from saying the things that are going to make me.
- 48:49I'm spending all Memorial Day with I'm about to I'm about to
- 48:55get into a car tomorrow and go spend my whole weekend.
- 48:58It house with Republican, we Republicans can be nice to have
- 49:03his company as yeah as someone who like commits.
- 49:07Very strongly to The Fringe view that the Channel that I would
- 49:10unplug the first to CNN that is based entirely know that is
- 49:14based entirely on my having to go visit my parents all the time
- 49:17and seeing their obsessive watching.
- 49:19CNN my mom, it's not an Aussie anyway nauseating.
- 49:22It was Great talking to you. Unfortunately have to run to
- 49:25this other call but Casey was good to see you enjoyed it to
- 49:28see you Katie. Why do you want to just finish
- 49:31up like five minutes with SNAP? So we can end the episode in a
- 49:34normal Place. Casey, you're a cipher, I don't
- 49:38know what your thoughts are at the.
- 49:40No. I mean I'm ready to go.
- 49:42They got reamed after Evan Spiegel, put out an internal
- 49:46note and filed with the SEC that they are likely to fall below
- 49:50their projections in terms of Revenue next.
- 49:53Citing economic headwinds and the massive downturn.
- 49:57And look, I don't cover this company anymore.
- 50:00It's been a long time since I've talked to sources there.
- 50:02I have nothing new to Surly. Say about the current state of
- 50:05affairs, this seems like an insane over reaction.
- 50:08Yeah. It in my mind, I mean, snap is
- 50:10still a growing app, although I still don't fully understand its
- 50:15ad promise. And, and that side of the
- 50:17business is still kind of confuses me.
- 50:19It makes us at least 80% as much sense as any other digital
- 50:23media. Accompany.
- 50:24So this is kind of a crazy time where the market is really
- 50:28severely overcorrected against this company, but I don't know
- 50:33how long it'll take for stuff to normalize again.
- 50:36Yeah, I don't know that either. I'm like, you know, I have
- 50:40nothing smart to say about like why investors do this thing and
- 50:43don't do that thing. You know, like reporters
- 50:45famously, do not play the stock market.
- 50:48So we're like insulated from this and but, you know, if he
- 50:52thought that Snapchat was Like a valuable app and snap was
- 50:55valuable company. Six months ago, I don't know why
- 50:57you'd be applying a 40% discount to that today, you know, I guess
- 51:00the only argument is that like multiples of been so inflated
- 51:04for so long that it's like time for them to come back to earth
- 51:06and that, you know, maybe you're going to sort of like over
- 51:09correct. Just a little bit but yeah, I
- 51:12think I think snap is probably going to be just fine for the
- 51:15next three or five years. Yeah, there's nothing
- 51:16fundamental that changed about its business or its stickiness
- 51:20with users. I guess.
- 51:22Maybe my One criticism is like its growth is a little bit
- 51:26eyebrow-raising not like in a suspicious way but it's probably
- 51:29coming from less valuable users. That maybe don't denote that
- 51:33they're going to be able to hugely monetize them.
- 51:34But again this is like the Playbook that social media
- 51:37companies have run for the last decade so there's nothing new
- 51:40here. Yeah well I mean I will also say
- 51:42that the like Snap has been really bad at predicting its
- 51:44revenue for the past couple years, right?
- 51:46And I think that investors might just be saying the hell with
- 51:48this because they they've been so flight far from their
- 51:51guidance so many times. Are they you know first they're
- 51:54like app tracking transparency. Blake is isn't going to affect
- 51:58us but like that, affected them but like then they bounce back
- 52:01but like then they issued a, you know, corrected guidance.
- 52:04And so may just be that investors are saying, we have no
- 52:06idea what's gonna happen with this company?
- 52:07Yeah, justjust hold for a bit. You guys are much closer to it
- 52:11than I am but it does, it feels like a company, you know, that
- 52:15never wanted to run ads and never got comfortable with the
- 52:20fact that it's business is running ads.
- 52:22I don't know it like Like, yeah, I don't know, it's always going
- 52:26to be an ads business, right? Or there's no escaping this sort
- 52:28of AD situation that they've got themselves in.
- 52:31I mean, there they made a big bet on e-commerce.
- 52:34You know, like they want to make everything shoppable within the
- 52:37app and they're recording creators, which you can monetize
- 52:41in ways that go beyond ads. So, I think there's like, you
- 52:45can imagine some different businesses for them but ads are
- 52:50the heart of it, right? As I've said on this show before
- 52:52and I stand No one wants to run ads ad stink as Ur ads, make
- 52:58everything that you've ever liked worse.
- 53:00And so I had complete, you know, I related as much as I ever
- 53:05could to heaven when he believed very strongly that he didn't
- 53:09want to have ads on the platform, but at some point, you
- 53:12just have to give in to the business and every media
- 53:14business in the world consumers are cheap, you know, Netflix is
- 53:18going to do ads. Yeah, it'll be worse for it and
- 53:21we're worst world because we live in that eventuality.
- 53:26But yeah, I don't think they're going to dump as anytime soon.
- 53:29And I guess my final line here is just by now is the time to
- 53:32buy snacks full endorsement. That's my that's my my analyst
- 53:37rating. Cool.
- 53:39Casey thanks. Thanks so much for coming on.
- 53:41Everybody should subscribe to platformer.
- 53:44Yeah, nice. Nice to hear from you.
- 53:47Yes, thanks for having me on those fun the tussling with you
- 53:50all. Thanks, Casey
- 54:04goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 54:06Goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.