Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / The Great Electric Rivalry: Tesla Redwood vs. Volkswagen ID.2all
Transcript
- 0:10Imagine walking up to a brand new $25,000 car.
- 0:14You pull the door handle, slide into the driver's seat, reach
- 0:17out your hands and realize there is no steering wheel.
- 0:20Right. Just nothing there.
- 0:21Yeah, nothing to grab, just a screen and an empty dashboard.
- 0:23I mean, it sounds like a scene from a sci-fi movie, but today
- 0:26we are looking at a literal arms race in the automotive industry
- 0:30to make that exact scenario a reality.
- 0:33It's happening a lot faster than people realize, too.
- 0:35Exactly. So our mission for this deep
- 0:38dive is to unpack this this ultimate clash of automotive
- 0:42philosophies. We're exploring the race for the
- 0:45Holy Grail of electric vehicles. The sub $25,000 mass market car.
- 0:49That's the one, and we've got a fascinating stack of sources to
- 0:53guide us today, including translated inside insights from
- 0:56Europe on Tesla's secretive project Redwood and Volkswagen's
- 1:00highly anticipated ID .2 All. Plus, we've got some brand new
- 1:04industry reports detailing the massive strategic moves
- 1:07happening behind the scenes. It is a phenomenal juxtaposition
- 1:11to study because you have two massive entities looking at the
- 1:15exact same problem, right? How to make a truly affordable
- 1:18electric vehicle that people actually want to buy, right?
- 1:20And they are arriving at completely opposite solutions,
- 1:23like we are watching Silicon Valley disruption collide head
- 1:27on with European automotive tradition.
- 1:30It's wild. So if you've been waiting for
- 1:31electric cars to finally become affordable without feeling like
- 1:34you're driving a, you know, a glorified plastic golf cart,
- 1:38this is the deep dive for you. We're going to break down how
- 1:42these companies plan to literally cut the price of a new
- 1:45car in half. And to do that, you can't just
- 1:48build the same car with cheaper materials.
- 1:50You have to completely reinvent how a car is made from the
- 1:53ground up. Yeah, you have to tear up the
- 1:55rulebook. So let's start with the
- 1:56disruptor. The sources indicate Tesla's
- 1:58approach with Project Redwood, which everyone is calling the
- 2:02Model 2, is doing exactly that, tearing up the rulebook on
- 2:05manufacturing. Yeah, the reports frame this as
- 2:08an extreme engineering experiment.
- 2:11I mean, for over a century, the entire auto industry has
- 2:14worshipped at the altar of the Henry Ford assembly line.
- 2:17Right, the moving conveyor belt. Exactly.
- 2:20You start with a bare chassis, it rolls down this massive
- 2:23linear track and hundreds of robots and workers bolt things
- 2:27onto it piece by piece until a finished car drives off the
- 2:30other end. Tesla is throwing that entire
- 2:33concept in the trash with what they call the unboxed process.
- 2:37The unboxed process. I was looking at the diagrams
- 2:40for this and it honestly reminds me of building a massive Lego
- 2:43set. Oh, that's a good way to look at
- 2:45it. Yeah, because instead of one
- 2:46person building the whole spaceship on one table from
- 2:49start to finish, you have like 5 different people in five
- 2:52different rooms building the sub assemblies, the front, the back,
- 2:55the sides, the interior floor. Then you only bring those
- 2:59completed chunks together into one room to snap the big pieces
- 3:03together at the very end. Which is brilliant because by
- 3:06breaking the car down into separate parallel modules you
- 3:09completely change the footprint of the factory.
- 3:11Because you don't need that massive long line.
- 3:13Exactly. The sources indicate this
- 3:15unboxed process reduces the required factory space by 40%.
- 3:1940% that is a massive reduction in real estate.
- 3:22Huge. When you eliminate that miles
- 3:24long linear footprint, you dramatically reduce overhead.
- 3:28Heating, cooling, maintenance. It all drops.
- 3:31The ultimate goal outlined in the translated reports is to cut
- 3:35manufacturing costs by a staggering 50%.
- 3:38Half the cost. Half that is the baseline
- 3:40requirement to even approach a $25,000 price tag.
- 3:44Wow. And they are applying that same
- 3:46ruthless logic to the battery too.
- 3:48The sources mentioned something called a battle battery.
- 3:50The LFP battery, yeah. Right.
- 3:51Specifically an LFP chemistry. Now we hear a lot of alphabet
- 3:56soup when it comes to EV batteries.
- 3:58What makes LFP so crucial for a cheap car?
- 4:01So LFP stands for Lithium Iron Phosphate, and to understand why
- 4:05it's a game changer, you really have to look at what traditional
- 4:08EV batteries use. They use nickel, manganese and
- 4:11crucially, cobalt. Cobalt, the expensive one.
- 4:15Super expensive. Cobalt is heavily bottlenecked,
- 4:18the supply chain is notoriously complex, and it is
- 4:22overwhelmingly expensive. It's really the primary reason
- 4:25EVs have historically been luxury items.
- 4:28Great. It drives the price way up.
- 4:29Exactly. So LFT chemistry swaps out those
- 4:32expensive metals for iron and phosphate, which are two of the
- 4:36most abundant, cheap and easily accessible materials on the
- 4:39planet. So it's basically made of dirt
- 4:42and rust compared to rare metals.
- 4:44Pretty much, yeah. But there has to be a catch,
- 4:46right? I mean, why haven't we always
- 4:47used iron and phosphate if it's so much cheaper?
- 4:49Well the trade off is energy density and LFP.
- 4:52Battery is physically heavier and holds slightly less energy
- 4:56per pound than a premium cobalt battery.
- 4:59OK. So less range for the same
- 5:00weight. Right, but what it lacks in
- 5:02density, it makes up for an extreme durability.
- 5:05Because of the way the iron and phosphate atoms bond, the
- 5:09chemical structure is incredibly stable.
- 5:11Stable, meaning it doesn't degrade as fast.
- 5:13Exactly. You can charge an LFP battery to
- 5:16100% every single day without degrading the cells, whereas
- 5:21traditional batteries prefer to hover around, you know, 80% to
- 5:24stay healthy. Oh right, like how your phone
- 5:26tells you to stop charging at 80%.
- 5:28Same exact concept and the reports show these LFP cells
- 5:32boast a lifespan of over 1,000,000 kilometers. 1,000,000
- 5:35kilometers I mean. So the car itself might fall
- 5:39apart before the battery ever dies.
- 5:41That fundamentally changes how you view a car's lifespan.
- 5:44Totally. And the mechanical overhauls
- 5:47don't stop there either. There's a major section in the
- 5:50reports about Tesla moving to a 48 Volt electrical architecture.
- 5:55Most cars run on a standard 12 Volt system, right?
- 5:57Yes, standard since the 50s. So why does jumping to 48 volts
- 6:01matter to someone sitting behind the wheel?
- 6:03It really comes down to basic physics and raw materials.
- 6:06So think of electricity flowing through a like water flowing
- 6:10through a garden hose. Voltage is the water pressure
- 6:13and current is the volume of water flowing through.
- 6:16If you want to deliver the same amount of power, say to roll
- 6:19down a window or turn on the stereo, but you increase the
- 6:22pressure of the voltage up to 48 volts, you need significantly
- 6:26less current. And less current means you can
- 6:28use a much skinnier hose, or in this case much thinner wiring.
- 6:32Exactly the mechanism at play. By eliminating traditional thick
- 6:36low voltage wiring and using a 48 Volt communication network,
- 6:39Tesla slashes the amount of copper required throughout the
- 6:42entire vehicle. And copper is heavy.
- 6:44Heavy and expensive. So less copper means less cost
- 6:47and a lighter vehicle, which in turn means that heavier LFP
- 6:51battery doesn't have to work as hard to move the car which
- 6:54extends the range. It is a cascading effect of
- 6:56efficiency. Man, it is brilliant
- 6:58engineering. But here's where I have to push
- 7:01back a little on this whole Silicon Valley playbook, OK?
- 7:03Let's hear it. Extreme efficiency, minimalist
- 7:06wiring, unboxed parallel assembly lines.
- 7:09That all sounds incredible for a corporate balance sheet, but as
- 7:14a driver, As someone actually sitting in the cabin, does this
- 7:18extreme minimalism actually make for a good car?
- 7:21I mean the rumor suggests it's going to look cyber truck ish.
- 7:24Blending the curves of a model Y with sharp angles.
- 7:27Are we just getting a cheap empty metal?
- 7:30Box. Well, that tension is at the
- 7:31very core of Tesla's philosophy. For them, the physical car, the
- 7:36seats, the doors, the dashboard is increasingly just a vessel
- 7:39for the software. Yeah, they aren't trying to
- 7:42build a traditional luxury cabin with plush leather and intricate
- 7:45dials. They are prioritizing raw
- 7:47utility, extreme physical lifespan, and creating a blank
- 7:50platform for their technology. Which brings us back to that
- 7:53wild scenario we started with. The most radical rumor in these
- 7:56sources regarding Project Redwood is that Tesla is
- 7:59actively evaluating selling specific variants of the Model 2
- 8:02without a steering. Wheel right specifically aimed
- 8:04at the robo taxi market. I mean, if you view a car as a
- 8:07traditional possession that you drive for pleasure, removing the
- 8:10steering wheel sounds absurd. It really does.
- 8:13It sounds like selling a smartphone without a physical
- 8:15keyboard. I mean, it sounds completely,
- 8:17completely unthinkable right up until the exact moment someone
- 8:20actually does it and changes the entire.
- 8:22World. That's a great comparison.
- 8:23But let's be real for a second. Think about your own driveway,
- 8:27your own morning commute. Are everyday consumers really
- 8:30ready to just be cargo? Or is Tesla massively
- 8:35miscalculating human psychology here?
- 8:38To understand the missing steering wheel, you have to look
- 8:40at the software road map detailed in the industry
- 8:43reports. It hinges entirely on the
- 8:46imminent release of Tesla's Full Self Driving, or FSD version
- 8:5014.3. The reports note this new
- 8:53version is heavily integrating something called reinforcement
- 8:56learning. How does that actually change
- 8:58the way the car drives compared to the current software?
- 9:01Well previous iterations of self driving software were largely
- 9:04rules based. Programmers wrote millions of
- 9:06lines of code telling the car if you see a red Octagon, stop, if
- 9:10you see a pedestrian break. Right, like a massive flow
- 9:12chart. Exactly.
- 9:14But the real world is too chaotic for rigid rules.
- 9:17Reinforcement learning changes the paradigm completely.
- 9:20It's much closer to how you might train a dog or how a human
- 9:25learns to play a video. Game.
- 9:26Oh, interesting. The AI is put into millions of
- 9:28simulated driving scenarios and give it a reward signal when it
- 9:32navigates smoothly and a penalty when it makes a mistake.
- 9:35So instead of just following a textbook of rules, the car is
- 9:38like developing an intuition. It's learning the unwritten flow
- 9:42of traffic by trial and error in a supercomputer.
- 9:45Yes, the goal is to add actual reasoning and logic to the AI is
- 9:49decision making process. Yeah, because current users of
- 9:51FSD often complain about wonky navigation choices or lack of
- 9:56assertiveness at busy four way stops.
- 9:57Yeah, being too timid. Right.
- 9:59Reinforcement learning is designed to solve that by
- 10:02allowing the car to reason its way through a complex
- 10:04intersection just like a human would.
- 10:06Tesla's planning for a future where the car is a service.
- 10:08And if the software crosses that threshold of reliability?
- 10:11Then the steering wheel becomes an obsolete legacy piece of
- 10:14hardware, taking up precious cabin space.
- 10:17Wow, so that is the disruptors vision.
- 10:20Tear up the the factory, strip the car down to a software
- 10:23vessel, and take away the driver's controls entirely.
- 10:27That's the Silicon Valley way. But if Tesla is betting
- 10:29everything on a steering wheel less automated future, it begs
- 10:33the question of what the alternative is.
- 10:36And that leads us to Volkswagen. They are looking at this exact
- 10:39same sub $25,000 market and they are doing the exact opposite.
- 10:45The polar opposite. They are literally putting the
- 10:47buttons back. The contrast is incredibly
- 10:49stark. Volkswagen's entry into this
- 10:51race is the ID .2. All the translated insights show
- 10:55they are aiming for a starting price around €22,500, with
- 10:59production slated for 2025 at their Martyr plant in Spain.
- 11:03That's. Right around the corner, yeah.
- 11:04And their philosophy is not about disrupting your life.
- 11:07It is entirely rooted in nostalgia and reassurance.
- 11:10They're calling it the Electric New Polo.
- 11:12And my absolute favorite anecdote in these sources is
- 11:15about the physical buttons. VWCEO Thomas Schaefer publicly
- 11:20admitted that removing physical buttons on the early electric
- 11:22models was a massive mistake. People hated it.
- 11:26Hated it. The extreme touch sensitive
- 11:29minimalist screens. They were impossible to use
- 11:32while keeping your eyes on the road.
- 11:34So the ID dot wall is bringing back the physical volume wheel.
- 11:39It's bringing back tactile, backlit buttons.
- 11:42It honestly feels like a rare victory where everyday customers
- 11:46actually won against futuristic design trends.
- 11:49It really does, because Volkswagen recognizes that they
- 11:51aren't selling a spaceship, they are selling psychological
- 11:54comfort. That makes a lot of sense.
- 11:56They understand there's a massive demographic of consumers
- 11:59who just want a normal car. They don't want to rethink how
- 12:03to turn on the windshield wipers or adjust the air conditioning
- 12:05through a touch screen menu. No, you just want to reach out
- 12:08and turn a knob. Exactly.
- 12:09They just want a reliable, familiar vehicle that happens to
- 12:12be powered by electricity instead of gasoline.
- 12:15And they are leaning into that emotional familiarity with the
- 12:18software, too, instead of using the dashboard screens for
- 12:21complex autonomous driving visualizations showing you like
- 12:24every traffic cone on the road. Right, like the Tesla display.
- 12:27Yeah, instead of that, the ID .2 all has a Time Machine feature.
- 12:31You can literally change your digital speedometer to look
- 12:34exactly like the analogue dials of a classic 1970s Golf or a
- 12:39vintage Beetle, complete with the retro font and cassette tape
- 12:42graphics. It is a brilliant psychological
- 12:44anchor. They're taking this new,
- 12:46potentially intimidating electric technology and wrapping
- 12:49it in decades of beloved European automotive heritage.
- 12:52It's. So smart.
- 12:53But they've backed up that emotional appeal with some very
- 12:57clever engineering underneath too, using an upgraded modular
- 13:00platform called MB Plus. Right, the MB Plus.
- 13:03I was looking at the dimensions on this thing, and the packaging
- 13:06magic here is wild. The car is only about four
- 13:10meters long, which is roughly the length of a tiny VW Polo,
- 13:14but the interior space is equivalent to a much larger
- 13:16Golf. Yeah, it's bigger on the inside.
- 13:18How did they pull that off without breaking the laws of
- 13:20physics? It all comes down to the
- 13:22architecture of an electric skateboard chassis.
- 13:25In a gas car, you know you have to design the entire front half
- 13:28of the vehicle around a massive hot engine, a transmission, and
- 13:32an exhaust system running down the middle of the floor.
- 13:34Taking up all that room. Exactly, but in the ID top 2 all
- 13:38the motors are tiny and the battery is completely flat under
- 13:41the floor. This allows engineers to push
- 13:44the wheels out to the absolute service corners of the chassis.
- 13:48Oh, I see. You minimize the hood and
- 13:50maximize the wheelbase, stretching the usable cabin
- 13:53volume over a much smaller physical footprint.
- 13:56And that leads to a ridiculously huge trunk to the sources
- 13:59highlight a double floor in the rear cargo area that is deep
- 14:03enough to comfortably hold a tall crate of drinks upright.
- 14:07It's such a perfectly European, fiercely practical detail.
- 14:11Like, of course you need space for a crate of drinks, but
- 14:14they're also utilizing a different kind of battery
- 14:17structure to make this work, right?
- 14:19The industry reports mentioned VW using prismatic battery
- 14:22cells. What does that actually mean for
- 14:24the person trying to charge this thing?
- 14:26So traditional EV batteries, including many of Tesla's, use
- 14:29cylindrical cells. Imagine thousands of a A
- 14:32batteries packed together into a giant box.
- 14:35OK, lots of little tubes. Right.
- 14:37Prismatic cells, on the other hand, are large, rigid
- 14:40rectangles. Think of them like hardcover
- 14:43books standing upright on the bookshelf.
- 14:45Oh, OK. Because they are flat and
- 14:47rectangular, they pack together much more densely than
- 14:50cylinders, which always leave little empty gaps between them.
- 14:53Because you can't perfectly stack circles.
- 14:55Exactly. So you can squeeze more raw
- 14:58battery material into the exact same space under the
- 15:00floorboards. Precisely, and their flat shape
- 15:02allows for highly efficient thermal management plates to be
- 15:05sandwiched between them. Which helps with cooling.
- 15:08Yes, better cooling means the battery can accept electricity
- 15:11much, much faster without overheating.
- 15:14This is why the ID .2 all, despite being a budget car, is
- 15:18capable of charging speeds up to 200 kilowatts.
- 15:21Wow, that's SAS. Yeah, you get your 20 minutes of
- 15:23charging and you're back on the road.
- 15:25The irony of the showdown is just incredible.
- 15:27Tesla's innovation is futuristic AI and removing parts, while
- 15:32VW's innovation is literally going backward to physical dials
- 15:36and clever packaging that work decades ago.
- 15:38It really is two different worlds.
- 15:40But is nostalgia in a deep trunk really a strong enough weapon to
- 15:43fight off a tech juggernaut? Well, you can never
- 15:46underestimate the power of ubiquitous mass market appeal.
- 15:49I mean, the Golf hatchback was the best selling vehicle in
- 15:52Europe for decades because it fit perfectly into daily life.
- 15:56By pricing the ID .2 all so aggressively, and even planning
- 16:00an even cheaper ID .1 model by 2027, Volkswagen is attempting
- 16:04to flood the zone with sheer accessibility.
- 16:07For under €20,000, right, exactly.
- 16:10So if Tesla's betting on the software ecosystem and VW is
- 16:13betting on psychological comfort, how does that actually
- 16:16translate to the hardware you get for your 25 grand?
- 16:19Let's look at the specs. They cater to very different
- 16:22driving dynamics. Tesla's Model 2 is expected to
- 16:25be rear wheel drive, optimizing for efficiency and targeting
- 16:28around 400 kilometers of range. Volkswagen's ID tattoo all will
- 16:32be front wheel drive, feeling much more like a traditional
- 16:34compact car, boasting up to 450 kilometers of range on the
- 16:37European testing cycle. So VW edges them out a bit on
- 16:41range. And VW is even actively courting
- 16:44people who enjoy the physical thrill of driving.
- 16:47They've confirmed an electric GTI based on this exact.
- 16:51People are very excited about that.
- 16:53But here's the thing to win this war, it's not just about the car
- 16:57itself anymore. It's about the entire ecosystem
- 16:59supporting it. And this is where Tesla's
- 17:02broader strategy, which is detailed in these latest
- 17:05industry reports, operates on a scale that is almost difficult
- 17:08to comprehend. It really is staggering.
- 17:11The reports outline a recent $2.9 billion bet Tesla is making
- 17:15on American infrastructure. Billion with AB.
- 17:17Yes, they are purchasing massive amounts of solar manufacturing
- 17:21equipment to build a 100 GW annual solar supply chain in
- 17:25Texas by 2028. Think about that.
- 17:27Imagine your local power grid for a second.
- 17:29Our grid is already straining under the weight of summer heat
- 17:32waves. Oh absolutely.
- 17:33Now add millions of new electric cars plugging in every night,
- 17:36plus the massive energy hungry AI data centers popping up
- 17:40everywhere. The electrical grid simply
- 17:42cannot handle that future. As it stands today, Tesla
- 17:46realizes that selling you a cheap electric car is pointless
- 17:49if the grid collapses when you try to charge it.
- 17:51Exactly, this is a textbook vertical integration play.
- 17:55Tesla isn't just an automaker anymore, they are an energy and
- 17:58AI company. They are aggressively building
- 18:01the solar infrastructure to generate the power, the massive
- 18:04mega pack batteries to store it, the supercharger network to
- 18:07distribute it, and finally the $25,000 car to consume it.
- 18:11It's an all-encompassing lifestyle ecosystem, and that
- 18:14seamlessly explains the other massive advantage Tesla has over
- 18:18legacy automakers, which is the sheer tribalism of its fan
- 18:22culture. The community aspect is huge.
- 18:24The sources detail an event happening this very weekend,
- 18:27actually March 20th through the 22nd, 2026, called the
- 18:31Chattanooga Charge down in Tennessee.
- 18:33The scale of consumer engagement detailed in that report is
- 18:35fascinating from a sociological perspective.
- 18:38It's wild. You have multiple massive fan
- 18:41clubs from across 16 different states to spending on the
- 18:45Tennessee River Park. They are expecting over 100
- 18:48heavily modified cyber trucks with custom wraps.
- 18:50Wow. They are throwing rooftop
- 18:52parties, organizing massive highway convoys, and putting on
- 18:56synchronized nighttime light shows where the cars flash their
- 19:00headlights to the beat of music. I mean, think about the cultural
- 19:03weight of that. That's a whole subculture,
- 19:05right? Volkswagen has an incredible,
- 19:07storied history, but they do not have hundreds of people
- 19:09spontaneously gathering in Tennessee this weekend just to
- 19:13show off their customized hatchet and debate the nuances
- 19:16of a software update. No, they definitely don't, and
- 19:19it highlights a fundamental vulnerability in how legacy
- 19:22automakers view their products. VW relies on their cars blending
- 19:26into the fabric of everyday life as reliable appliances.
- 19:30Right, like a refrigerator. Exactly.
- 19:32Tesla, much like Apple did with the Mac in the early 2000s, has
- 19:36convinced consumers they are buying into an identity.
- 19:39Buying a car, You are joining a tribe of early adopters.
- 19:43You're buying into the supercharger network, the solar
- 19:47integration, the AI road map. It's the difference between.
- 19:50Buying a microwave and buying a lifestyle, that's a perfect way
- 19:54to put. It the battle for the.
- 19:55Affordable EV isn't just about the metal and the batteries.
- 19:58It's about whether consumers want to buy into an entire
- 20:01technological identity or if they just want a familiar way to
- 20:04get to the grocery store. Yeah, which brings us right back
- 20:06to you listening to this deep dive when it's.
- 20:09It's finally time for you to buy your next affordable car.
- 20:11Which philosophy is going to win your wallet?
- 20:14Do you want the zero maintenance, unboxed, futuristic
- 20:17gadget that might eventually just drive you around like
- 20:20cargo? Or do you want the?
- 20:21Comfortable nostalgic time machine with a volume knob and a
- 20:24trunk perfectly designed for a creative drinks.
- 20:27It is a choice. Between two profoundly different
- 20:30futures, it really is. And you know, here is something
- 20:33to Mull over as we wrap up today.
- 20:35Volkswagen is pouring resources into building an electric GTI
- 20:38specifically for people who love the tactile thrill of winding
- 20:41roads, right? Meanwhile, Tesla is actively
- 20:44trying to take the steering wheel away entirely.
- 20:47If E VS truly do become significantly cheaper than gas
- 20:50cars, but the physical act of driving becomes entirely
- 20:53automated by systems like FSD, does the concept of a driver's
- 20:57car simply become an expensive niche hobby, much like riding
- 21:00horses is today? Wow.
- 21:02A horse riding hobby. You used to ride a horse to get
- 21:05to work, now you only do it on the weekends if you own a ranch.
- 21:08That is a wild thought to end on.
- 21:10Wow. Well, we set out today to
- 21:12understand how these giants are chasing the Holy Grail of the
- 21:15sub $25,000 EV and we have covered a massive amount of
- 21:19ground. We truly want to thank you, the
- 21:21listeners, for taking this deep dive with us today.
- 21:23Yes. Thank you so much.
- 21:25We deeply. Appreciate your time, your
- 21:27curiosity, and your willingness to unpack these massive shifts
- 21:30in the world around us. So the next time a new car
- 21:33quietly passes you on the road, ask yourself, is that the future
- 21:36or is it already history?