Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Fringey Mini - Who you saving: Dave or that pack of Koalas?
Transcript
- 0:00Okay, I think it's my turn to have an opener.
- 0:03I don't know where I got this, but I could definitely tell you where it's from.
- 0:07It's from the conversation.com.
- 0:09Never heard of it before.
- 0:10Not sure where I found this article in true Chelsea fashion, February 12th, 2024.
- 0:15So probably over a year ago by the time this comes out.
- 0:18But an interesting article nonetheless, I was just flipping through articles and I'm
- 0:22going to settle on this one.
- 0:24And this one is titled, Fascinating and Troubling.
- 0:27Australians would rather save a single human life than prevent an entire species from becoming
- 0:33extinct.
- 0:34And yes, I am focusing on Australians right now.
- 0:38Need not where the tension be, but here we are nonetheless.
- 0:42I don't know who wrote this.
- 0:43Maybe it'll say at the end.
- 0:44Maybe it just appeared in the ether.
- 0:46No, I just, it just seems to be something that was sent to me at the moment.
- 0:51So we're just going to go with it.
- 0:53Oh, hold on.
- 0:54There's a bunch of authors.
- 0:55John Wanarski, Hurston Zander, and Steven Garnett, Professor of Conservation Biology,
- 1:02Professor of Environmental Economics, and Professor of Conservation and Sustainable
- 1:06Eiffelyhoods.
- 1:08Australia is in the grip of an escalating extinction crisis.
- 1:12Since colonization, 100 native plants and animal species have become formally listed
- 1:17as extinct due to human activities.
- 1:19The actual number is undoubtedly far higher.
- 1:22Studies suggest Australians want to prevent extinctions regardless of the financial cost
- 1:28when it comes to the crunch.
- 1:29How much do we really care?
- 1:31In emergency situations, there's a long held convention that official respondents such
- 1:36as firefighters first attempt to save human life, then property and infrastructure, then
- 1:41natural assets.
- 1:42Our research published today investigated whether this convention reflects community values.
- 1:48We found the people we surveyed valued one human life more than the extinction of an
- 1:53entire non-human species, a result both fascinating and troubling.
- 1:58Catastrophic events force us to make hard choices about what to save and what to abandon.
- 2:03In such emergencies, our choices reveal in stark detail the values we ascribe to different
- 2:08types of assets, including plant and animal species.
- 2:11Our priorities will become even more crucial under climate change, which is bringing worse
- 2:16bushfires and other environmental catastrophes.
- 2:19If nature is always safe last, we can expect recurring biodiversity losses including extinctions.
- 2:25The unprecedented loss of biodiversity in the black summer fires was a taste of what's
- 2:30to come.
- 2:31The fires burnt the entire known range of more than 500 plant and animal species and
- 2:35at least half the range of more than 100 threatened species.
- 2:39The catastrophe led to at least one extinction of a mealy bug species in western Australia.
- 2:45I don't know if I said that right, in English I'm pretty sure I'm at least 90% correct,
- 2:50in Australian I might be closer to 10%.
- 2:53It is a silly language.
- 2:54It is.
- 2:55It's almost like a joke language.
- 2:58The loss has prompted reflection on our priorities.
- 3:01The final report of a New South Wales parliamentary inquiry into the bushfires, for example, question
- 3:07if this hierarchy of protection should always apply.
- 3:10Our new research investigated community values on this issue.
- 3:14The findings were illuminating.
- 3:16Survey involved 2,139 Australians.
- 3:19Respondents ranked the assets they would save in a hypothetical bushfire choosing from the
- 3:23following options.
- 3:25A person not warm to evacuate.
- 3:27A person who had ignored advice to evacuate and so implicitly taken responsibility for
- 3:32their own safety.
- 3:33A population of 50 koalas of which many other populations exist elsewhere.
- 3:39One of only two populations of a wallaby species.
- 3:43The only population of a native stale species which would become extinct if burnt.
- 3:48The only population of a native shrub species which would become extinct if burnt.
- 3:52A flock of 50 sheep.
- 3:54A house shed in tractor.
- 3:56Two items of indigenous cultural significance.
- 3:59A rock art gallery and a tree carving.
- 4:02Survey respondents overwhelmingly gave the highest ranking to the two options involving
- 4:07saving a human life.
- 4:08Even the idiot who said I don't have to evacuate.
- 4:11That's literally the next sentence.
- 4:13Even that idiot who said they were repeatedly told to evacuate.
- 4:17As a consequence to that person not evacuating, a snail or shrub species became extinct.
- 4:24Saving a person who had not received evacuation warnings was rated highest.
- 4:28Ahead of saving a person who ignored evacuation advice, saving the koala population was next
- 4:34preferred, followed by saving the wallaby population.
- 4:36I'm surprised at that.
- 4:38Yeah, it's a weird hypothetical.
- 4:41What would you save?
- 4:42It's one person or 50 koalas?
- 4:44I'd be like if I'm getting in my car I'm not getting 50 koalas.
- 4:47Okay everybody in.
- 4:51You know what?
- 4:52I'm the exact opposite.
- 4:53If I'm getting in my car I'm getting 50 koalas.
- 4:55There better be 50 koalas if there's no reason to get in there.
- 4:58There better be.
- 4:59Exactly.
- 5:00Like I'm not leaving without 50 koalas.
- 5:03Maybe our priorities are just different.
- 5:04Their remaining options had negative scores, meaning that respondents were more likely
- 5:09to choose them as least important than most important.
- 5:12I actually find this to be ranked fairly accurate.
- 5:16My qualm with it would be people would react different under the stress of it being real
- 5:23time if it was something they're reacting to within a fire.
- 5:26I wonder as well if it has to do with the pain that is immediately felt by the, I don't
- 5:34know why a wallaby would be under a koala.
- 5:37The wallaby versus koala is surprising to me.
- 5:40Maybe it's because they're more.
- 5:42But obviously the mammals are being saved first other than actually steep rank understrap.
- 5:48So I'm not sure about that one.
- 5:51Wallabies are kind of like the deer.
- 5:53They're basically small kangaroos, right?
- 5:54I'm pretty sure they're like small little kangaroos.
- 5:57Maybe they just hate wallabies there because they see them all the time.
- 6:01Yeah that could be.
- 6:02If it was deer, I would have the same thing like why would you want a deer in your car?
- 6:06Yeah exactly.
- 6:07I don't think kangaroos or wallabies are nice but I'm surprised by this.
- 6:11It seems like the things that are most susceptible to extinction were put at the bottom of the
- 6:17list pretty much.
- 6:18Looking at the list right now, a shed is actually last on the list so.
- 6:23You can't save a shed.
- 6:24It was on the list apparently.
- 6:27That makes me sick.
- 6:28I don't, that's such a weird hypothetical to ask people though.
- 6:31I feel like that's one of those like team building exercises where they say you're on
- 6:35a raft to Desert Island where you're going to spend the next 50 years.
- 6:39What do you bring with you of these things?
- 6:41Yeah my shed.
- 6:42There's a lot of good stuff in there.
- 6:45Such useful shit.
- 6:46Okay I'm just going to read a little bit more.
- 6:48Oh no I didn't want to see that poor burnt koala.
- 6:51Amongst the biodiversity assets, decisions based on conservation consequences would have
- 6:56meant the top priority with preventing the extinction of the snail and shrub populations.
- 7:02Next in line would have been the wallaby population then a relatively less consequential loss
- 7:06of koalas.
- 7:07But the results were the opposite.
- 7:09People prioritized the koalas over the wallabies with less concern for the shrub and the snail.
- 7:15Ranked even lower were the items and indigenous cultural significance saving the house and
- 7:19shed at lowest range.
- 7:22Okay well at least that makes sense.
- 7:24I think that's far enough, it does go on not that much longer but I think we get the
- 7:29gist.
- 7:30I would be interested even thinking about it right now.
- 7:33Would I rank this?
- 7:34I think I would put human who was not notified that it was sprung upon.
- 7:40Then I would do at least three snails.
- 7:43Do you have to find the snails?
- 7:45That's true.
- 7:46Why didn't we think about this?
- 7:48To prevent the snails going extinct.
- 7:51Saying that there's a huge risk, why don't we save the snails to begin with?
- 7:56I don't know snails are probably kind of hard to save.
- 7:58Instead of you know going looking for them when they're in flames.
- 8:02So I feel like I would go that person who put their safety, I don't think an entire
- 8:07two species should go extinct for a person ignoring evacuation advice.
- 8:11I'm sorry I don't.
- 8:13Because you're putting yourself before who even knows how many species you're ignoring
- 8:18evacuation orders.
- 8:20So sorry.
- 8:21I'd be admitting this on a blog.
- 8:24It's fine.
- 8:25I don't know.
- 8:26Just don't be near Chelsea during a fire.
- 8:28I think that's a reasonable thing to do.
- 8:31I think the more endangered species take the priority in this as sad as it is.
- 8:37It doesn't mean don't leave the koalas.
- 8:39It means probably find the ones so we don't wipe them off the earth first.
- 8:43And if you find 50 koalas on your way to the shrub or the snail, you might be looking
- 8:49for the snails for a long time.
- 8:51You'll probably be looking a long time and also that means you know which snails are
- 8:54endangered snails.
- 8:56Which I'm not up to date enough to know which things in my neighborhood are endangered and
- 9:00I need to save in case of fire.
- 9:02It's a good thing somebody conveniently keeps a pen of koalas who are trained to jump into
- 9:06a car near me.
- 9:07But outside of that, it's really hard to save animals.
- 9:11I love going to that person's house.
- 9:14And just open my car door and going get in.
- 9:17And then you speed around with a bunch of koalas for a while.
- 9:25But hey, you guys got 48 hours.
- 9:26Are you going to save plant, a cactus, three quarters that I found in my ashtray, or syphilis
- 9:33riddled ducks?
- 9:34You got 48 hours to figure it out before I start the fire, so that's up to you.
- 9:38Okay, bye.