Latest / Humanise The Numbers - for ambitious accountants in practice / Martin Bissett, Founder of Bissett Group Holdings
Transcript
- 0:05Paul Shrimpling: Welcome to the Humanize the Numbers podcast series.
- 0:08Paul Shrimpling: Leaders, managers, and owners of ambitious accounting firms sharing insights, successes, and issues that'll challenge you and connect you and your firm to the ways and means of transforming your firm's results.
- 0:21Martin Bissett: They were fond of asking the question, where do you want to be in five years' time?
- 0:25Martin Bissett: And I asked them to flip it and then ask the question, five years ago, did you think you'd be where you are now?
- 0:33Martin Bissett: Because what that elicits in the business owner is the response of, yeah, pretty much.
- 0:38Martin Bissett: Which would allow the accountant to go, and what happens next?
- 0:42Martin Bissett: If the business owner goes, no, actually, we thought we'd be a bit further on, well, there's an opportunity.
- 0:47Martin Bissett: If the business owner answers, actually further on than I thought we'd be, we're doing better.
- 0:52Martin Bissett: The accountant has the opportunity to ask, great, how do we keep it that way?
- 0:55Martin Bissett: So any answer was an opportunity.
- 0:58Martin Bissett: If you ask the question in that sense.
- 1:00Martin Bissett: But you're absolutely right.
- 1:02Martin Bissett: Those initial seeds of relationship development form, as you rightly say, the nature of the engagement, the nature of the relationship, the nature of the fees, the nature of the profitability, the nature of the cross-selling opportunities, and everything that goes with that.
- 1:19Paul Shrimpling: Without crystal clarity about what your clients value from working with your firm, you're unable to communicate that value.
- 1:29Paul Shrimpling: And on this podcast with Martin Bissett, who's worked with the profession for 30 years, we dive deep into how do you, yes, deliver the accountancy service work and deliver the answers your client expect, but also how do you establish a trusted, a deeper trusted advisor role by asking the right questions.
- 1:55Paul Shrimpling: What questions?
- 1:56Paul Shrimpling: That's exactly what Martin and I are unpacking on this podcast.
- 1:59Paul Shrimpling: Let's get to Martin now.
- 2:01Martin Bissett: Hi, I'm Martin Bissett, founder of Bissett Group Holdings, which serves the accounting profession in several different ways and in several different platforms and has done for the last 30 years.
- 2:11Martin Bissett: Prior to that, I was an author and speaker on the accounting circuit.
- 2:16Martin Bissett: And when not doing this kind of thing, I like to be out in the hills in the Rossendale Valley where I'm from.
- 2:23Paul Shrimpling: Brilliant.
- 2:24Paul Shrimpling: So the um brand of walking boot, then, Martin.
- 2:29Paul Shrimpling: That's a strange place to start, isn't it?
- 2:30Paul Shrimpling: It's just I'm in the market for some new walking boots.
- 2:32Martin Bissett: Brandon walking boot.
- 2:34Martin Bissett: Well, round here you do well to buy anything other than regattas.
- 2:37Martin Bissett: And that's sort of the brand of choice for all the local stockists.
- 2:40Martin Bissett: But I actually go with North Faces.
- 2:42Martin Bissett: Oh, right, okay, cool.
- 2:43Martin Bissett: That's what I like to use.
- 2:44Martin Bissett: However, if we're going to do brand associations, I will also big up sketches at the moment because they've moved out of the comfortable old man's shoes market.
- 2:54Martin Bissett: And I have tried a pair of their walk-in boots, and they're actually pretty good.
- 2:58Paul Shrimpling: All right, okay.
- 2:59Paul Shrimpling: Well, well, that's there's something for the listeners, isn't it?
- 3:01Paul Shrimpling: So let's get deep into this, given that um how how you could possibly have been in the industry for 30 years looking the way you do strikes me as a bit strange.
- 3:11Paul Shrimpling: So started at 14, I guess, but let's pass on that one.
- 3:14Paul Shrimpling: Martin, I know you've worked with lots of accountants.
- 3:17Paul Shrimpling: You've been on stage a lot of times, but I'm really interested in the firms that you've worked deeply with.
- 3:25Paul Shrimpling: And when you consider the insights and lessons you've learned from those firms, what's your interpretation of the phrase humanize the numbers?
- 3:35Martin Bissett: That's fantastic.
- 3:36Martin Bissett: The very first thing that comes to mind, Paul, is a quote from John Thompson.
- 3:43Martin Bissett: Now, your listeners at Stroke Watchers who are of a certain vintage will remember John, and I think the younger ones won't.
- 3:50Martin Bissett: But John blazed the trail for many, many years on what we might call the added value or advisory side of accountancy.
- 3:57Martin Bissett: And his phrase was always, yeah, but what does the client want?
- 4:01Martin Bissett: And over and over again, and I would say right up to the modern day, that is still the very last question to be uh considered by your run-of-the-mill accounting practice.
- 4:14Martin Bissett: We worry about what the depth of reports say, we worry about what the partner's gonna say, whether we're PE backed to worry about what the shareholders are gonna say and the KPIs that we've got to reach, and so on and so on and so on.
- 4:26Martin Bissett: But very rarely in practice over the years did I ever find anyone in leadership ever say, Yeah, but what's in the best interest of the client?
- 4:35Martin Bissett: So when it comes to humanizing the numbers, um, I take that to mean, in my own interpretation, I take that to mean how do we take the factual and turn it into the lifestyle?
- 4:46Martin Bissett: How do we make that client's life better?
- 4:49Martin Bissett: How do we keep the wolves from the door in the case of survival?
- 4:52Martin Bissett: Or how do we get them to reach their ultimate professional and personal aspirations in the case of thriving?
- 4:56Martin Bissett: Um, and I don't know too many in the Academy profession who chose to adopt that as their mantra.
- 5:02Martin Bissett: Of course there are some, but in the wider picture, not the majority.
- 5:08Paul Shrimpling: Sure.
- 5:09Paul Shrimpling: Sure.
- 5:10Paul Shrimpling: So if a firm is to get the humanized, this is me trying to repeat back what you're saying, so I've got it, is if if firms are going to effectively humanize the numbers, they've got to move from facts to life improvement to use your words, in order to help them fight off the wolves and achieve their goals, personal ambitions, whatever they are.
- 5:34Martin Bissett: Kind of, yeah.
- 5:35Martin Bissett: I'll expand it by um comparing it to a Richard Dawkins theory.
- 5:39Martin Bissett: Wherever uh yeah, I don't know how many times you guessed have done that.
- 5:43Martin Bissett: Um Richard Dawkins holds a very broad theory that if you were brought up in Middle England, it is very likely that if you have any religious affiliation, it's going to be Christian or Catholic.
- 5:54Martin Bissett: You know, if you were brought up in Israel, it is very likely that you're going to default to Orthodox Jewish religion or Judaism.
- 6:02Martin Bissett: If you were brought up in India and so on.
- 6:04Martin Bissett: Okay.
- 6:04Martin Bissett: Yeah.
- 6:04Martin Bissett: And if you're an accountant and you've been trained to get to trial balance level and that's it, and not to ever ask the client, but what are you trying to do?
- 6:12Martin Bissett: But what are you in business for?
- 6:15Martin Bissett: But what is this all about?
- 6:17Martin Bissett: But what happens if you don't?
- 6:19Martin Bissett: Okay, if you're not trained to ever think that way or ask those questions, you're not gonna.
- 6:23Martin Bissett: And so the training that brings you into practice in the first place avoids stuff like that, uh, or has done it historically, and as a result, you're not going to default to that way of thinking, you're gonna default to being technically accurate.
- 6:39Paul Shrimpling: So I get that, I get that.
- 6:42Paul Shrimpling: Uh, there's um we're pre-conditioned ourselves, our training has also added to those conditionings, if I can use that phrase.
- 6:52Paul Shrimpling: And uh the environment in which we're working confirms those conditioning or that conditioning, and so we continue to be a trial balance report builder expert as opposed to a humans.
- 7:04Paul Shrimpling: Uh so we're a numbers expert, not a human expert.
- 7:08Martin Bissett: Absolutely, and there's a mismatch from day one, right?
- 7:11Martin Bissett: Okay, because the accountant goes into the client meeting or the prospect meeting going, I'm here to make sure you're technically compliant and maybe take over from your existing accountant if you don't already have one.
- 7:21unknown: Yeah.
- 7:22Martin Bissett: And the business owner is going, I need help.
- 7:24Martin Bissett: Okay, and there's a fundamental mismatch, but neither of them voice the those that that's their starting point.
- 7:33Martin Bissett: And as such, we have a mismatch from moment one onwards because the accountant never corrects the position understanding of what an accountant can do.
- 7:41Martin Bissett: Yeah.
- 7:41Martin Bissett: And the business owner doesn't understand how to vocalize what it is they actually need.
- 7:46unknown: Right.
- 7:46Paul Shrimpling: Okay.
- 7:47Martin Bissett: So from there onwards, we default to a compliance relationship.
- 7:49Paul Shrimpling: Cool.
- 7:49Paul Shrimpling: So that's so the the business owner doesn't know what they don't know, so they don't know how to winkle that out of the accountant.
- 7:56Paul Shrimpling: Yeah.
- 7:56Paul Shrimpling: Exactly.
- 7:57Paul Shrimpling: And the accountant hasn't connected the dots with what really matters to the client, so they're not posing questions and creating a conversation that then puts on the table the things that the client really values.
- 8:08Paul Shrimpling: Have I understood that?
- 8:09Martin Bissett: Absolutely right.
- 8:10Martin Bissett: Yeah, and and not, I would also say not naturally disposed to being empathetic either.
- 8:17Martin Bissett: Disposed to being technically correct.
- 8:21unknown: Yeah.
- 8:21Martin Bissett: You know, as as as the old joke used to go, you know, people go into marketing to sorry, go into accounting to avoid a career of sales and marketing.
- 8:30Martin Bissett: You know, the worst joke is that, you know, the first entrance into the uh profession requires a charisma bypass operation.
- 8:37Martin Bissett: Now, of course, that's a bit cruel and harsh, but its stereotypes exist for a reason.
- 8:42Martin Bissett: You know, and it's why are people forming those opinions in the first place?
- 8:47Martin Bissett: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 8:48Martin Bissett: You know, because if it because if you are a sales and marketing type, hey Paul, how are you?
- 8:53Martin Bissett: Great to see you today, you're looking great, you lost some weight, and all that kind of stuff, which we might go, oh that's BS, but nevertheless, yeah, it is engaging, it is proactive, it is energetic.
- 9:03Martin Bissett: That's not the norm in a meeting with an accountant.
- 9:07Martin Bissett: Okay, all right.
- 9:09Paul Shrimpling: So uh, and one could call that an asset in that accountants are good at cutting to the chase.
- 9:16Paul Shrimpling: But if cutting to the chase is only connected to the trial balance to the report, to the audit review report, whatever, then that's only part of the value equation because clearly clients are buying payroll, audit, management accounts, annual accounts, bookkeeping, etc.
- 9:31Paul Shrimpling: etc.
- 9:32Paul Shrimpling: They're buying the services, the products, but that's only part of the value equation that you're talking about, isn't it?
- 9:38Paul Shrimpling: From the client's perspective, and the level of fee, if we can go introduce that into the mix, the level of fees connected to the perception of value.
- 9:48Paul Shrimpling: And if all we're talking about is the trial balance, the audit report, the the bookkeeping outputs, and so on, we're missing a huge uh piece around delivering greater value to the client so that they stay loyal, recommend you more, and buy more from you, but we're also leaving money on the table, aren't we?
- 10:07Martin Bissett: Yes, we are.
- 10:08Martin Bissett: So you've seen the end from the beginning there.
- 10:10Martin Bissett: So you've described you know the entire client relationship and what Alan Weiss refers to as thinking of the fourth sale first.
- 10:15Martin Bissett: Um and also um a rather now forgotten 80s and 90s comic called John Hedgely always talked about comedy and said, if you want to dissect comedy, remember that the first thing you've got to do is kill it.
- 10:29Martin Bissett: You know, and and as such, though, if you cut, if you just cut to the numbers, which is the first thing you said in that summary there, if you cut to the numbers, then we're ignoring all the reasons for the numbers.
- 10:40Martin Bissett: And why it's not, well, your profit was 28%.
- 10:44Martin Bissett: Well, yeah, and good or bad compared to getting to where I need to get to, you know, on track or behind or in in advance.
- 10:52Martin Bissett: And I remember years and years ago doing a session with an accounting firm, and they were fond of asking the question, where do you want to be in five years' time?
- 11:02Martin Bissett: Um, and I asked them to flip it and then ask the question, five years ago, did you think you'd be where you are now?
- 11:09Martin Bissett: Because what that elicits in the business owner is the response of yeah, pretty much, which would allow the accountant to go, and what happens next?
- 11:18Martin Bissett: If the business owner goes, no, actually, I thought we'd be a bit further on, well, there's an opportunity.
- 11:24Martin Bissett: If the business owner answers, actually further on than I thought we'd be, we're doing better.
- 11:28Martin Bissett: The accountant has the opportunity to ask, great, how do we keep it that way?
- 11:32Martin Bissett: So any answer was an opportunity, if you ask the question in that sense.
- 11:37Martin Bissett: But you're absolutely right.
- 11:38Martin Bissett: Those initial seeds of relationship development form, as you rightly say, the nature of the engagement, the nature of the relationship, the nature of the fees, the nature of the profitability, the nature of the cross-selling opportunities, and everything that goes with that.
- 11:53Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, and and and like you said earlier, the you know, the the people get into accountancy not to sell.
- 11:59Paul Shrimpling: And so you and I are merrily having this conversation about all the merits of you know a value conversation so we can better help the client and help them buy more stuff from us, and everyone's listening to not everyone, but you know, people listening to goes, you know, yeah, but we're not very good at that, and we don't want to do that.
- 12:16Paul Shrimpling: Maybe, maybe, maybe, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 12:18Paul Shrimpling: Um, but uh you you said um it's the reasons for the numbers that really matter, um and and you if you can build this out, that would be great.
- 12:32Paul Shrimpling: But I when uh and I know you've work and continue to work with accountants in this space, um we're the same.
- 12:38Paul Shrimpling: Uh, in terms of how do we better connect the accountancy team, the client managers in particular, anyone who's got client management responsibility uh to what really matters to the client, that connection, that but building stronger connections in that space is better for the client, better for the client manager and their career, and better for the firm because the results will follow.
- 13:02Paul Shrimpling: Um, and so there's some simple things that a non-empathetic, to be if we've been brutal, or less empathetic is probably fairer.
- 13:12Paul Shrimpling: Less empathetic, yes.
- 13:13Paul Shrimpling: Less empathetic is fairer, a less empathetic, less desiring of having commercial conversations, but probably, and this I'm firmly of this opinion, I'd value your insights in this.
- 13:26Paul Shrimpling: There's a real determination to help the clients in their way, and it's just oh, can we influence their skills to help the clients?
- 13:35Paul Shrimpling: How do we best have a conversation now, Martin, about the key skills?
- 13:40Paul Shrimpling: Like, you know, driving a car is a skill, riding a bicycle is a skill that's learned over a number of lessons and time, and as you get better and better, you might advance to downhill than jumping and all the rest of it.
- 13:53Paul Shrimpling: Um, what are the fundamental get brilliant at the basic skills that anyone dropping into a client meeting, even though they've never done it before, could apply this skill which would elevate the client value perception?
- 14:10Martin Bissett: Wonderful question.
- 14:11Martin Bissett: Back in the autumn of 2017, you and I were in San Jose, California, uh, for a QuickBooks Connect conference, as I recall.
- 14:20Martin Bissett: Yeah.
- 14:21Martin Bissett: Um during the uh speaking engagement that I did, I talked about controlling the BBC.
- 14:27Martin Bissett: And the BBC, in my case, referred to beliefs, behavior, culture, which outlined the supposition that the culture is a result of the behaviors that you find inside the organization.
- 14:43Martin Bissett: The behaviors that you find inside the organization is as a result of the beliefs.
- 14:48Martin Bissett: And therefore, does leadership start from top down, bottom up, or in the middle?
- 14:53Martin Bissett: It starts from top down.
- 14:54Martin Bissett: And so if leadership have a belief system as to what the practice will be, you better believe that the behaviors of the firm will be encouraged to be compliant to that.
- 15:05Martin Bissett: The culture of the firm, in its marketing, its communications, its client relationships, and so on, will follow suit as a result.
- 15:12Martin Bissett: Therefore, to change the culture, change the behavior, to change the behavior, change the beliefs.
- 15:16Martin Bissett: So, in order to do what you've just suggested, there, ultimately, the belief of what the accounting practice is there for has got to be clearly defined and get buy-in on.
- 15:30Martin Bissett: Because only when that happens do you see senior managers, client directors, and so on buying into anything other than a paycheck as a result as a reason for being at that firm.
- 15:42Martin Bissett: And when there's a vision, when there's a uh communique from the top as to how we run this place, then we see behaviors change, and you can't fake that.
- 15:53Martin Bissett: I've seen lots of firms trying to fake that and be different and be zany, and no one buys it.
- 15:57Martin Bissett: But what I do recall is a firm up in the Northeast.
- 16:01Martin Bissett: Um, only time I ever saw this, you went upstairs to get to them, and at the top of the stairs was almost like a Ten Commandments, it was a mantra as to what you know, you don't you don't have to be daft to work, everybody else type stuff.
- 16:17Martin Bissett: A outline of this is what makes a great employee of this organization, and what they did this it was only there, I mean it could be there for clients and prospects, I suppose, but it was there for recruits.
- 16:31Martin Bissett: And the idea was that you were to stand in the holding area looking at this thing, somebody came to see you and said, so-and-so be with you in five minutes to interview you for the role you're here for.
- 16:43Martin Bissett: Familiarize yourself with that in the meantime.
- 16:46Martin Bissett: If you feel that that's not you or you don't want it to be you, just let yourself out.
- 16:50Martin Bissett: No need to tell us.
- 16:51Martin Bissett: Let yourself go.
- 16:52Martin Bissett: When we come back and we see you're not here, we'll realize what happened.
- 16:55Martin Bissett: But if this is you, then you're gonna make a great start in this interview.
- 16:58Martin Bissett: I only ever saw one firm do that.
- 17:01Martin Bissett: But straight away, they were controlling the beliefs, behavior, and culture of that firm from the very first moment that a new recruit entered the building.
- 17:10Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 17:10Paul Shrimpling: Okay, I might maybe take issue with a control word, but certainly influencing.
- 17:16Martin Bissett: Influencing.
- 17:17Martin Bissett: And so as a result, just like anybody in a typical compliance firm will behave in a typically compliant way, that organization or that particular practice, which was acquired for a lot of money, by the way, um developed its own unique culture of individuals who weren't trying to be different, they were trying to be true to the core beliefs of leadership.
- 17:42Martin Bissett: And the core beliefs of leadership was that the client was the only reason that they're in business in the first place.
- 17:48Paul Shrimpling: Okay, so there's a there's a client focus piece, there's a behavioural standards piece in that list of Ten Commandments, there's beliefs showing up in those uh Ten Commandments.
- 17:59Paul Shrimpling: You know, we're in that values and behavioural standards space.
- 18:03Paul Shrimpling: Um the um I when you were talking about BBC, you know, beliefs first, behavior second results in the culture, which is the behaviour you see of every hour, of every person, of every day is is what culture is, is we're going to know.
- 18:16Paul Shrimpling: Um I just I'm just thinking of um when I first got behind the steering wheel of the first car I ever sat in.
- 18:26Paul Shrimpling: Um and I just wondered if the driving instructors, do you believe you can drive this car?
- 18:31Paul Shrimpling: And I go, Well, yeah, eventually.
- 18:33Paul Shrimpling: So I've got an eventual belief.
- 18:35Paul Shrimpling: Um, but there'll be many people if they really looked at it and went, man, do you believe you can drive this car?
- 18:42Paul Shrimpling: And I go, no, no, I don't really think I can, because I've never driven it.
- 18:45Paul Shrimpling: You know, they're in that fixed mindset.
- 18:46Paul Shrimpling: I haven't driven it, therefore I can't learn to.
- 18:48Paul Shrimpling: Um, but then they work not on their beliefs, they work on the behaviours, which builds the beliefs, don't they?
- 18:56Martin Bissett: Oh, it strengthens them, I guess.
- 18:58Martin Bissett: But they've got the beliefs they've got to pre-exist.
- 19:00Martin Bissett: Interesting, you mentioned driving instructors.
- 19:03Martin Bissett: When I passed my test on the seventh attempt of doing so, right, okay, which was strictly speaking only six because one was abandoned.
- 19:12Martin Bissett: Um, that they the um the uh examiner said, I'm pleased to say, Martin, you've passed.
- 19:21Martin Bissett: And I said, Dennis, you've no idea how happy that makes me.
- 19:24Martin Bissett: He said, Martin, you've got no idea how happy that makes me.
- 19:26Martin Bissett: I never have to believe see you again.
- 19:28Martin Bissett: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 19:29Martin Bissett: Okay.
- 19:29Martin Bissett: And the fact that I can remember that 20 odd years on is a ring up.
- 19:34Martin Bissett: The belief was never ever have to come back and do this again.
- 19:39Martin Bissett: You can drive.
- 19:40Martin Bissett: Now go drive.
- 19:41Martin Bissett: Drive a lot, get practiced at it.
- 19:44Paul Shrimpling: Learn to properly drive.
- 19:47Martin Bissett: His own way of saying to me, okay, don't be in this position ever again.
- 19:50Martin Bissett: Okay, you took long enough to get here, you can now do it.
- 19:53Martin Bissett: Go do it.
- 19:54Martin Bissett: Believe to behaviour.
- 19:57Paul Shrimpling: Um, I'm just arguing that it's it's a uh it's probably a circle.
- 20:00Paul Shrimpling: And I don't think it matters where it starts.
- 20:02Paul Shrimpling: You know, you can um, you know, try asking this question.
- 20:06Paul Shrimpling: Well, I don't believe I can ask this, well, just ask it because it's a behavior.
- 20:09Paul Shrimpling: Or you know, I can't balance on the bike, we'll have a go.
- 20:12Paul Shrimpling: I don't think I can balance on the bike, have a go.
- 20:15Paul Shrimpling: There's you know, oh I don't think I can ask a how question in a client, or you know, what's the what was the reasons you set the business up in the first place question?
- 20:24Paul Shrimpling: Well, can you say the words?
- 20:26Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, I can say the words.
- 20:27Paul Shrimpling: Well, just say the words a few times and then have a go, and then sit, and then afterwards your beliefs flipped into, oh yeah, I can ask that question.
- 20:34Paul Shrimpling: So I think it there's a um I think there's a circular piece going on here rather than a linear piece, maybe.
- 20:40Martin Bissett: Well, important distinction there as well, because if you're in a business where you have non-recurring work, then you have no question if you wish to pay the mortgage and pay the salaries, but to ask the how question.
- 20:50Martin Bissett: If you're in an accounting firm and you don't ask the how question, nothing changes.
- 20:54Martin Bissett: You go back to your desk and life continues on your gross recurring fee model.
- 20:57Martin Bissett: Sure.
- 20:57Martin Bissett: So until something takes over.
- 21:00Martin Bissett: Well, it ever will.
- 21:03Martin Bissett: Um but nevertheless, you know, we've we've lived 40 years with value pricing and it never ever took hold.
- 21:09Martin Bissett: You know, we've lived what 45 years with the paperless office, and we might start to get there in the next five.
- 21:18Martin Bissett: That's half a century's worth.
- 21:20Martin Bissett: You know, we've we've lived a hundred no 97 years with the there's no future in compliance message, which was first uh uttered at the Chicago Technical Institute um by McKinsey.
- 21:34Martin Bissett: Um, but here we are still doing it.
- 21:36Martin Bissett: Because it turns out that bureaucrats in Whites all like to come up with new laws all the time to keep the house busy.
- 21:41Martin Bissett: You know, so as a result of this, you know, there is no commercial imperative on the accountant to change belief or behavior.
- 21:51Martin Bissett: Because if they do nothing at all, which is the most comfortable way of doing things and the least path of resistance, they'll be fine.
- 21:58Martin Bissett: Recurring work, refresh.
- 21:59Martin Bissett: Girls, happy days, all is well.
- 22:02Martin Bissett: They will complain about pain in the backside clients.
- 22:04Martin Bissett: They will complain about low margins and price sensitivity, but ultimately they can still afford the Jag and the golf course and the holiday and the nice house, so all is great.
- 22:13Martin Bissett: And that's why I think private equity has been very good for this profession, not in the way that we perhaps might suggest in terms of independence of practice.
- 22:23Martin Bissett: That hasn't been good, but it's woken everyone up to a commercial reality, and a firm has gone and taken the devil's bargain of 60% up front, and all of a sudden found themselves reporting to a regional director who's got some sales figures to hit.
- 22:37Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 22:37Paul Shrimpling: And those imperatives are there, yeah.
- 22:40Martin Bissett: Yeah.
- 22:40Martin Bissett: And now it's like, oh, this is how the clients feel.
- 22:43Martin Bissett: I hadn't realised for the last 45 years that was the case.
- 22:46Martin Bissett: But now I'm having to live the experience myself.
- 22:49Martin Bissett: So from that point of view, I think it's great.
- 22:51Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah.
- 22:52Paul Shrimpling: And I think you're right.
- 22:53Paul Shrimpling: I think if there's if the if the accountant leaders leader leadership team are ambitious enough to challenge the status quo, as opposed to no, we're happy with the status quo, then they're likely to have the imperative, the drivers, the motivation to do something different from the norm and establish a set of 10 commandments or whatever it is, that is this is how we do it here, to take a line from Michael Gerber, um, around the client meetings and the client calls and the team's calls with clients, in order to ensure that they see where the real value is, because we've done the work to understand the real value for the client.
- 24:32Martin Bissett: Yes, and for balance and perspective as well, I would also throw in that while we do all these complaints, it's also worth noting that ICAW did not relax guidelines on what you could and couldn't market on the basis of till November 2001.
- 24:49Martin Bissett: So practisers were never free to extol their virtues until that point, anyway, if they were members of the ICAW.
- 24:58Martin Bissett: ACCA were a little bit faster, I think, as I recall.
- 25:01Martin Bissett: But nevertheless, um, the vast majority of practicing accountants in the UK would be ICAW members and therefore not free to do so.
- 25:09Martin Bissett: So the the seatbelt only came off in November 2001.
- 25:12Martin Bissett: So we're only 25 years on from that.
- 25:14Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, only 25 years on the only 25 years on.
- 25:19Martin Bissett: Come on.
- 25:19Martin Bissett: In the perspective of the evolution of the profession that is several hundred years old and haven't come very far in that time.
- 25:25Paul Shrimpling: Glacial movement.
- 25:26Paul Shrimpling: That glacial movement, do you think that's getting quicker?
- 25:30Martin Bissett: Yeah, it is getting quicker.
- 25:31Martin Bissett: And and I'm and because I'm about to contradict myself, I have to point this out.
- 25:37Martin Bissett: I came into the profession at a time when speakers would stand up in conferences and they would do something like this.
- 25:44Martin Bissett: In today's fast-paced, ever-changing, hyper-connected world, everyone's going to use the fax machine.
- 25:48Martin Bissett: You know, and that same garbage of fast-paced, ever-changing, hyper-connected, it's not the same as it was at nine o'clock this morning.
- 25:55Martin Bissett: That message is used to create urgency and fear from a marketeer to a professional.
- 26:00Martin Bissett: Yeah.
- 26:00Martin Bissett: And I'm against that.
- 26:01Martin Bissett: So I hate that.
- 26:04Martin Bissett: However, now the contradiction comes.
- 26:06Martin Bissett: In terms of what has gone before, yes, we are now in a relatively speaking, fast-paced, hyper-connected, ever-changing environment.
- 26:17Martin Bissett: Because every week, literally, every week, and that is not an overstatement, that is an actual statement of fact.
- 26:25Martin Bissett: Literally, every week, there is a new consolidator that arrives that has got some form of backing from somewhere, whether it's angel investors or private equity or something, some fund from somewhere, and they want to buy some practices, please.
- 26:38Martin Bissett: Who's for sale?
- 26:39Martin Bissett: That is happening every single week, and that was never the case in the past.
- 26:44Martin Bissett: The rate at which automation can do basic compliance tasks is faster than it used to be.
- 26:51Martin Bissett: Has it taken over?
- 26:53Martin Bissett: No.
- 26:53Martin Bissett: Will it?
- 26:54Martin Bissett: Dunno, jury's out.
- 26:55Martin Bissett: However, it is faster.
- 26:58Martin Bissett: Has the demographic of who is an accountant changed?
- 27:02Martin Bissett: Yes, massively.
- 27:04Martin Bissett: I don't know the stats on average age, but I'd be very interested to know what they are these days.
- 27:08Martin Bissett: Um, at what point do you make partner now?
- 27:10Martin Bissett: I think that's probably changed as well.
- 27:12Martin Bissett: So, yes, things are changing faster than they ever have before.
- 27:18Martin Bissett: I concede that, but I stopped short of jumping on the interest have connected, every changing fast pace.
- 27:25Martin Bissett: Uh yeah, all right.
- 27:26Martin Bissett: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 27:26Martin Bissett: It's you can still get away with being a compliance provider even now.
- 27:29Martin Bissett: So it's not that fast-paced.
- 27:31Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, no, and I think you know, I'm in a we're in a a similar space.
- 27:35Paul Shrimpling: Uh over time, the the the rate of change is increasing.
- 27:39Paul Shrimpling: Is but are we at that part?
- 27:40Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, it's speeding up part of it curve.
- 27:42Martin Bissett: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 27:44Paul Shrimpling: That's moving.
- 27:44Paul Shrimpling: Um, but I like that.
- 27:46Paul Shrimpling: I like the Jeff Bezos um phrase in an interview, I think it was 2017, where Germanists says, Go on then, Jeff, you're in you're leading the most technology savvy uh business on the planet with more cash than you can shake a stick at.
- 27:58Paul Shrimpling: Um, you know, what's gonna what do we all need to be aware of that's gonna change over the next five, ten years?
- 28:02Paul Shrimpling: And Jeff went, Well, that's interesting.
- 28:03Paul Shrimpling: You asked that question.
- 28:04Paul Shrimpling: But at Amazon, we design our strategy around the three things stable in time that really matter to our customers, not what's changing, it's what really matters to our customers.
- 28:15Paul Shrimpling: So, my question to to you, Martin, is because this has been very much a what's the the the humanize the numbers piece is let's get better connected to our clients as human beings and clients as business owners leaders?
- 28:28Paul Shrimpling: Um, what do you, given that you almost certainly have bought accounting services, as given that you're running a business, um and you've been exposed to more accountants than most in a deep way and in a big broadcast way on stage and so on.
- 28:43Paul Shrimpling: What do you think makes up the value equation in a business leader's mind when it comes to looking at an accountancy firm?
- 28:50Paul Shrimpling: What are the elements of value that really matter to you, to me, to most business leaders when it comes to working with the accountant?
- 28:58Martin Bissett: Well, let's do the boring stuff first of all, and then we'll get to the interesting stuff second.
- 29:01Martin Bissett: Okay.
- 29:01Martin Bissett: So the boring stuff is that there's certain things that haven't changed.
- 29:05Martin Bissett: So, from a business leader perspective, how do I minimize my tax liability?
- 29:11Martin Bissett: Will always be in your top three somewhere.
- 29:14Martin Bissett: Depending on the evolution and life cycle of the business that we're discussing, it may well be how do I ensure that I can afford my tax bill when it comes and withdraw what I need and pay the salaries and meet my obligations.
- 29:31Martin Bissett: So I think there's a layer of Maslow in there, hierarchy of needs, you know, security first.
- 29:36Martin Bissett: Yeah, yeah.
- 29:37Martin Bissett: Security first.
- 29:39Martin Bissett: Okay.
- 29:39Martin Bissett: But then the most common question of a business owner to an accountant that I ever heard in my time was what am I missing?
- 29:51Martin Bissett: And it was always that that they were going to evaluate whether they changed accountants or not.
- 29:56Martin Bissett: Not how much are you, or what is your full extent of service provision, please?
- 30:02Martin Bissett: But what I feel like I'm missing a trick.
- 30:06Martin Bissett: I don't know from my accountant often.
- 30:09Paul Shrimpling: This is a question from the business leader to the account.
- 30:11Martin Bissett: Business owner to the accountants.
- 30:12Paul Shrimpling: Right, okay, okay.
- 30:13Paul Shrimpling: What am I missing?
- 30:14Martin Bissett: Yeah, and it was always, I don't speak to my accountant often.
- 30:18Martin Bissett: You know, there must be something else with no evidence for it.
- 30:23Martin Bissett: Or I see other organizations making faster progress than me.
- 30:28Martin Bissett: What is it I'm not doing?
- 30:31Martin Bissett: And they were always looking for, I wouldn't say the magic wand necessarily.
- 30:38Martin Bissett: I'd probably go stop short of saying that.
- 30:40Martin Bissett: But basically they're asking, what is it I don't know?
- 30:44Martin Bissett: Yeah.
- 30:45Martin Bissett: You know, and that was generally where an accountant would shine or fail in that moment in the eyes of the business leader as to whether they actually evaluated them as being worth breaking the loyalty barrier to the existing accountant and coming to them.
- 31:00Martin Bissett: It wasn't about price, as I'm often told it is.
- 31:02Martin Bissett: No, it's not.
- 31:03Martin Bissett: It's about what insight to get me to where I want to be do you bring that they don't?
- 31:11Martin Bissett: Because there's not a lot of incentive for me to change otherwise.
- 31:15Martin Bissett: Okay.
- 31:15Martin Bissett: You know?
- 31:16Martin Bissett: And that was always the main question.
- 31:19Martin Bissett: You know, what am I missing?
- 31:20Martin Bissett: Was the business owner's question.
- 31:22Martin Bissett: And so I can't see that changing anytime soon.
- 31:26Martin Bissett: Because you still you still to this day go into business in order to achieve certain lifestyle goals, even if it is keeping the walls from the door.
- 31:34Martin Bissett: That's still what you do.
- 31:35Martin Bissett: You hate your boss, you want to go alone, great, you go alone, but you still got to keep the walls from the door, even at that level.
- 31:41Martin Bissett: So an accountant then remains with all the cliches that we've heard about all these years, most trusted advisor.
- 31:49Martin Bissett: Yeah, still, even now.
- 31:51Martin Bissett: Yeah.
- 31:51Martin Bissett: Chat GPT might be catching up, but right now it's still the accountant for the time being.
- 31:55Martin Bissett: You know, are they most intimate with the numbers?
- 31:59Martin Bissett: Yeah.
- 32:00Martin Bissett: And also, COVID, I never forget this in COVID.
- 32:04Martin Bissett: You know, I remember, I will not I will spare the the blushes of the guilty, I will not name who it was.
- 32:10Martin Bissett: But I still remember a practitioner that said, This has been great, this COVID thing.
- 32:16Martin Bissett: I've had to get close to my clients, and now I really understand what they're trying to do.
- 32:22Martin Bissett: Yeah.
- 32:23Martin Bissett: Which, if you say the bit they didn't say, is had there not have been a global pandemic, I would never have asked the question in the first place.
- 32:31Martin Bissett: Yeah, yeah.
- 32:32Martin Bissett: You know?
- 32:34Paul Shrimpling: The drivers have changed on really.
- 32:36Paul Shrimpling: The drivers have changed, indeed.
- 32:38Paul Shrimpling: Where's the imperative?
- 32:39Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, where's the imperative?
- 32:40Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah.
- 32:41Martin Bissett: Where's the imperative?
- 32:41Martin Bissett: So I think from a business owner perspective, you know, on the Jeff Bears us, what do our we plan our shot on what do our customers want?
- 32:48Martin Bissett: Our customers want security layer first, arm around the shoulder that we're doing the right thing second.
- 32:53Martin Bissett: And what is it?
- 32:54Martin Bissett: I don't know, progress third.
- 32:57Paul Shrimpling: Oh, reassurance, the magic word.
- 32:59Paul Shrimpling: So clients, clients want reassurance about something they're not intimate with, which you are intimate with, which is their numbers.
- 33:07Paul Shrimpling: But you say also that um the good ones, the ones that are going to value what you do, want insight.
- 33:13Paul Shrimpling: They don't want insight for the sake of insight, they want insight so that they can make better decisions.
- 33:18Paul Shrimpling: Is that what you're inferring here?
- 33:20Paul Shrimpling: Oh, probably not better insight.
- 33:25Martin Bissett: Well, well, I I put a I put a LinkedIn post out at the time of recording here last week that said um what I've been asked is changed.
- 33:33Martin Bissett: I used to get asked, how do I do this?
- 33:34Martin Bissett: How do I increase my fees, Martin?
- 33:37Martin Bissett: How do I get more clients, Martin?
- 33:39Martin Bissett: How do I get more leads, Martin?
- 33:40Martin Bissett: You know, that used to be the question I got asked, and it's not anymore.
- 33:44Martin Bissett: The question I get asked now is, what would you do in the case of an I'm asked to provide an independent perspective?
- 33:50Martin Bissett: I would tell you the exact same is true of the business owner to the accountant.
- 33:54Martin Bissett: You know, if this was your business, Mrs.
- 33:57Martin Bissett: Accountant, what would you do here?
- 33:58Martin Bissett: Okay, not how do I increase my sales by 15%?
- 34:03Martin Bissett: Put your prices up.
- 34:04Martin Bissett: Oh, genius, thanks.
- 34:05Martin Bissett: You know, not that, but what would you do in this situation?
- 34:08Martin Bissett: How do I how do I you know shore up my bank account?
- 34:12Martin Bissett: What how do I build a cash reserve and not throttle my own chances of progress and growth and leverage at this time?
- 34:18Martin Bissett: Asking commercial questions to a non-commercial person.
- 34:22Martin Bissett: Therefore, I would tell you that the imperative is upon the accountant to become more commercially minded in order to be of more value to the client.
- 34:31Paul Shrimpling: Okay, so it's it's been connected to yes, the numbers that show up in the PL and balance sheet, but also the numbers that show up in the sales report and the marketing report and the HR report and the operational operational report.
- 34:42Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah, which is that's uh connected PL and balance sheet, isn't it?
- 34:47Paul Shrimpling: But um okay.
- 34:49Paul Shrimpling: So um they want clients value, want trusted advisor, want someone who's intimate with the numbers because they they are too busy doing everything else.
- 34:59Paul Shrimpling: They want someone who's going to be their um their reference point for all the key numbers in the business.
- 35:04Paul Shrimpling: Um that delivers insight, which in itself is reassurance, reassuring, uh, but also then drives towards better decision making so that they've got a better business in the future, which makes them even further reassured that they're with the right truffing accountant.
- 35:18Martin Bissett: Yeah, yeah.
- 35:19Martin Bissett: I mean, in in the olden days, when I was young and you look exactly the same as you do now.
- 35:24Paul Shrimpling: In in the olden days, ITS until I was 22, so that doesn't really matter, does it?
- 35:32Martin Bissett: We used to call that the accountant being the part-time financial director for the business.
- 35:36Martin Bissett: That's what we used to call it.
- 35:37Martin Bissett: And these days we probably call it a Ned.
- 35:39unknown: Yeah.
- 35:40Martin Bissett: You know, playing the role of a fractional, which means part-time, yeah, CFO, which means financial director.
- 35:47Martin Bissett: You know, just changing the words around to get the marketing fresh.
- 35:49Martin Bissett: That's all still the same stuff, though.
- 35:51Martin Bissett: Yeah.
- 35:51Martin Bissett: Um that that's I don't know what that has changed over the years.
- 35:55Martin Bissett: It's that, it's give me some reassurance.
- 35:58Martin Bissett: I'm very good at being a manufacturer, but I'm crap at running a business in manufacturing.
- 36:02Martin Bissett: Help.
- 36:02Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 36:03Martin Bissett: You know, I'm the best software technician there is, but I'm crap at running a business being a software company.
- 36:08Martin Bissett: Help.
- 36:09Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah.
- 36:10Martin Bissett: You know, it's the part-time CFO or the fractional CFO.
- 36:13Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 36:14Paul Shrimpling: So we've got the, you know, like you know, I like the Maslow hierarchy of needs a connection, uh, you know, minimize tax until I can pay the tax and all the other obligations about running the business.
- 36:24Paul Shrimpling: Uh, and then in the what am I missing space, um it's uh posing questions, it's as simple as that.
- 36:35Martin Bissett: And well, so long as John Thompson doesn't sue me for this, going back to John Thompson, where I started here, um, he would say that the accountant has to have all the answers, and the advisor has to have all the questions, right?
- 36:53Martin Bissett: And he would distinguish it because on a compliance technically exact basis, what is my tax liability for the next uh period?
- 37:03Martin Bissett: That needs to be an exact figure.
- 37:05Martin Bissett: You need to have the answer to that.
- 37:06Martin Bissett: Yeah, but where are you going in the next three years and what happens if you don't get there?
- 37:12Martin Bissett: What's the what's the big consequence of not getting there?
- 37:14Martin Bissett: Is an inexact question.
- 37:17Paul Shrimpling: Yeah.
- 37:18Paul Shrimpling: Well, you can't.
- 37:19Martin Bissett: And so John was put it up in those two in those two brackets, which I fully agree with.
- 37:24Martin Bissett: But we've always mastered the first, and we've never mastered the second.
- 37:28Martin Bissett: Uh but what a what an opportunity.
- 37:30Martin Bissett: Well, as it of what as it ever was.
- 37:32Martin Bissett: It was a great opportunity back then as well.
- 37:34Martin Bissett: It was a great opportunity back then, and no one's taking the place, and it's still an opportunity, yes.
- 37:39Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah.
- 37:39Paul Shrimpling: So what do you think the uh commercial differences between be uh if we're predominantly providing answers with the accountant, we're predominantly or a substantial part of what we do is the advisor we're posing the questions, and therefore we're into trust advisor, intimate with the numbers, providing insight, reassurance, and and better decision making.
- 37:59Paul Shrimpling: What do you think the commercial difference is between those two types of firms, Martin, in your experience?
- 38:05Paul Shrimpling: Just trying to put some numbers into the mix here in terms of financial merit of this.
- 38:13Martin Bissett: The commercial difference is in the profitability because and let me give a specific rather than giving a hypothesis.
- 38:20Martin Bissett: Um the last accounting firm that I worked with had a huge opportunity with an existing client.
- 38:30Martin Bissett: I won't go into details because it was a fairly technical spec, but the existing client was paying at the time, as I recall, circa 13 grand a year.
- 38:41Martin Bissett: And the practice costed it up and got all excited and got on the phone to me because they thought there was another about 70,000 of opportunity here, and they went, This is great, help us craft this into a proposal, will you miss it?
- 38:59Martin Bissett: And I took a look at it and I thought it was more like 120.
- 39:03Martin Bissett: Okay, and then we got the same old, same old of, I can't possibly charge that.
- 39:10Martin Bissett: I've never charged that before in my life.
- 39:12Martin Bissett: They'll say no to that straight away.
- 39:14Martin Bissett: I've put objections in my way before I even gone near them, etc.
- 39:18Martin Bissett: Usual scarcity mindset does.
- 39:20Martin Bissett: And so we we looked at it, and I had to make the point many, many times, not just to the particular partner that I worked with, but with the people who were going to be delivering the job, that we weren't delivering the technical specification that was in this proposal.
- 39:35Martin Bissett: We were delivering avoidance from consequence of that organization, that client, not doing what they needed to do.
- 39:44Martin Bissett: We were avoiding investigations, we were providing peace of mind, we were creating significantly increased productivity, many, many multiples of the fee we were charging.
- 39:55Martin Bissett: And I asked them to lead with that third one, and I said, please demonstrate what predict productivity capacity now exists in that business post your intervention that didn't exist previously, and have them compare that to the fee that we're charging as a result.
- 40:10Martin Bissett: So, to cut that story short, ultimately they couldn't bring themselves to go with my number.
- 40:18Martin Bissett: Okay, but they were prepared to raise their number.
- 40:22Martin Bissett: So we met kind of in the middle, and they went in at 95, and lo and behold, they got it.
- 40:29Martin Bissett: And they got it without a whimper or an objection or a pushback or a sharp intake of breath.
- 40:35Paul Shrimpling: Never a good sound, is it?
- 40:37Martin Bissett: Because the business had already worked out the thing that I was pointing out to the accountant, they already knew that, you know, and so I apologize, Paul, for bringing this down to a mere features versus benefits conversation, but it doesn't get much more complex than that, I'm afraid.
- 40:55Martin Bissett: It's not very difficult, it's just hard to do, it's not difficult to understand.
- 41:00Martin Bissett: But ultimately, as usual, the practice was focused on the time-bound mentality of the delivery of various um services, and the business didn't give a stuff about any of that and just wanted the outcome as quickly as humanly possible.
- 41:17Martin Bissett: Yeah, and they were gonna pay for a quick outcome, they were not gonna pay for the 2.5 hours we have spent on an internal audit.
- 41:25Martin Bissett: Don't care, don't care, don't care, don't care, don't care.
- 41:28Martin Bissett: Okay, means nothing to us.
- 41:30Martin Bissett: We don't understand it, we're not gonna pay on that basis.
- 41:32Martin Bissett: But tell us that we're gonna be safe and tell us that we're gonna be infinitely more productive in the next six months and take my money off me.
- 41:41Martin Bissett: Accountants to this day, I've been beating that drum, you've been beating that drum, several of our professional colleagues have been beating that drum for a very long time.
- 41:49Martin Bissett: The message is yet to fully land in the profession.
- 41:53Paul Shrimpling: Please forgive this brief interruption.
- 41:55Paul Shrimpling: Martin and I are discussing how you and your firm can create greater clarity around the value you deliver for clients and how you better communicate that value so that you can earn better prices and do a greater job.
- 42:10Paul Shrimpling: If you want to dive deeper into this topic, please check out the business breakthrough report in the show notes.
- 42:17Paul Shrimpling: It's called Build Your Value Equation in Your Firm, and it adds to the value that you're getting from Martin's insights on this podcast.
- 42:25Paul Shrimpling: Let's get back to Martin now.
- 42:27Paul Shrimpling: And there's there's always room for improvement, isn't there?
- 42:29Paul Shrimpling: But yes, there's there's still that.
- 42:30Paul Shrimpling: And it revolves around again with that specific client that was paying 13k, could have paid 120k, ended up paying 95.
- 42:41Paul Shrimpling: Um it's connecting, they don't know what they don't know.
- 42:46Paul Shrimpling: Um, they know some stuff they're not necessarily sharing with you because you've not asked the right questions yet.
- 42:51Paul Shrimpling: Um but that aside, the QA diagnostic to understand what pain they want to avoid and what gains they want to get for the business is delivers a completely different uh proposal conversation than a time-based, which is nonsensical in the world we now live in, but uh, you know, time-based uh billing piece.
- 43:13Martin Bissett: It's it's an internal measure.
- 43:15Martin Bissett: Yeah, it's just not an external basis for for pricing, yeah.
- 43:17Martin Bissett: That's all yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 43:19Martin Bissett: Use it, use it internally all you want to track costs and operational overheads golfing of your life.
- 43:24Martin Bissett: If that's yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 43:25Martin Bissett: Yeah, but don't base it as to what the cut price is going to be to the client because that's not what they're evaluating on the basis of.
- 43:30Martin Bissett: You know, but you know, you you asked the question there about what's the commercial upside to doing all these things we're suggesting an accountant does.
- 43:38Martin Bissett: Well, in that case, a 25 grand uplift.
- 43:41Martin Bissett: Yeah, yeah.
- 43:42Martin Bissett: That should have been a 35 grand uplift.
- 43:45Martin Bissett: Yeah, yeah.
- 43:45Martin Bissett: You know, um, or even higher than that.
- 43:48Martin Bissett: Um, but that's what that's what it should have been.
- 43:51Martin Bissett: Um, but even if it wasn't, even in their scared state, still a large uplift.
- 43:59Martin Bissett: And can that be repeated?
- 44:00Martin Bissett: Of course it can.
- 44:01Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 44:02Martin Bissett: Of course it can.
- 44:03Martin Bissett: Because all we do is so go on, go ahead.
- 44:06Paul Shrimpling: No, go on, go on.
- 44:07Martin Bissett: I'm I'm I'm busy monologuing now.
- 44:08Martin Bissett: You've got me monologuing.
- 44:09Martin Bissett: Okay, okay, that's just like the same.
- 44:11Paul Shrimpling: Come on, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 44:12Martin Bissett: Yeah, yeah.
- 44:12Martin Bissett: Come on in.
- 44:13Paul Shrimpling: Uh so I'm looking at just looking for the practical how-tos in this space.
- 44:17Paul Shrimpling: So you go, if we're we step out of accountant equals answers, advisor equals questions, so out of the accountants answers into advisor questions space, uh, we're then going to be able to run a better diagnostic with every client we've currently got.
- 44:35Paul Shrimpling: If we were just to work smarter, harder, better on a better QA around what really matters to the client, and you've created that framework around what that might look like.
- 44:46Paul Shrimpling: You know, yes, questions around tax, questions around other obligations, um, and then.
- 44:53Paul Shrimpling: Prompting them to consider what they're missing if they don't ask you.
- 44:58Paul Shrimpling: Some will ask, some won't.
- 45:00Martin Bissett: Yes.
- 45:00Martin Bissett: And let's put reality into this mix.
- 45:03Martin Bissett: So your structure there is absolutely right.
- 45:06Martin Bissett: I agree with it 100%.
- 45:07Martin Bissett: The reality is that some businesses aren't going to know what they want.
- 45:11Speaker: Okay.
- 45:12Martin Bissett: And that generally leads to an impasse where the accountant goes, Oh, I haven't been trained for the scenario for where they don't know what they want.
- 45:17Martin Bissett: So I don't know what to say here, so I'll just retreat.
- 45:19Martin Bissett: Okay.
- 45:19Martin Bissett: The accountant's job in that scenario is to say, let's take a look at what you don't want.
- 45:24Martin Bissett: Yeah.
- 45:25Martin Bissett: And we'll work it backwards from there.
- 45:27Martin Bissett: But again, without that commercial sensibility, and without that real care or empathy about what the client wants in the first place, those questions will never leave the accountant's mouth.
- 45:39Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah.
- 45:40Paul Shrimpling: Excuse me, sorry.
- 45:43Paul Shrimpling: I like that a lot.
- 45:45Paul Shrimpling: So yeah.
- 45:46Paul Shrimpling: Be the questioner, the advisor about what they want.
- 45:49Paul Shrimpling: If that's not playing out so well, ask what they don't want, which is in the what do you all want to avoid space, as much as any.
- 45:56Martin Bissett: We will avoid, yeah.
- 45:57Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah.
- 45:57Paul Shrimpling: I just do what do what are what are your views on, but let's look at what others in your industry are doing achieving and see how that compares and contrasts, and then let's have a conversation about what you want, don't want.
- 46:06Paul Shrimpling: Are you in that?
- 46:07Paul Shrimpling: Would you play that game?
- 46:08Martin Bissett: Yeah, I mean, I mean, we're talking about benchmarking there.
- 46:11Martin Bissett: I'm no fan of the one size fits all.
- 46:13Martin Bissett: For example, I would never subscribe to the idea that you are both in engineering and therefore you are the same.
- 46:18Martin Bissett: You know, uh no, that's not true.
- 46:21Martin Bissett: That's not true at all.
- 46:23Martin Bissett: But if there was, for example, a geographic benchmark, businesses in your area typically are seeing 28% retained profit.
- 46:35Martin Bissett: You know, right.
- 46:37Martin Bissett: Well, that's a relevance.
- 46:38Martin Bissett: That's a relevance there.
- 46:39Martin Bissett: Everybody else all around me can do it and I can't.
- 46:42Martin Bissett: What's going on there?
- 46:43Martin Bissett: I can relate to that.
- 46:44Martin Bissett: Yeah, but you say that one engineering is the same.
- 46:47Martin Bissett: Yeah, one engineering company is the same as the other, one manufacturing is the same as the other.
- 46:50Martin Bissett: We know that's not true.
- 46:51Martin Bissett: We know that margins aren't the same if you manufacture bottles and if you manufacture, I don't know, um office equipment, you know, whatever.
- 46:59Martin Bissett: It's very it those are very different markets.
- 47:02Martin Bissett: So benchmarking those, I think, is uh red herring.
- 47:05Martin Bissett: I wouldn't benchmark those.
- 47:07Paul Shrimpling: But the same applies to the geography though, Marty, doesn't it?
- 47:10Paul Shrimpling: You know, I've got I've got retailers over here in the same geography, and I'm an engineering company.
- 47:13Paul Shrimpling: I'm gonna dismiss that out of hand.
- 47:15Martin Bissett: No, but you put social uh imperative into it.
- 47:20Martin Bissett: Okay, so I don't want to be behind my peers in the community, I don't want to be behind my mates down the club, you know?
- 47:28Martin Bissett: So you're absolutely right.
- 47:30Martin Bissett: You could point the exact same fallacy out about, well, they're not my kind of business over there anyway.
- 47:35Martin Bissett: No, you're quite right, they're not.
- 47:36Martin Bissett: And on that basis, the comparison is wrong.
- 47:38Martin Bissett: I agree.
- 47:39Martin Bissett: But the reason why the business owner will care about a geographical specific is because it plays into who drives what car around town.
- 47:47Martin Bissett: Okay.
- 47:49Paul Shrimpling: And my my overriding interpretation is that it's relevant to them.
- 47:52Paul Shrimpling: The geography element is relevant to them.
- 47:54Paul Shrimpling: If you can get the industry piece, that's really relevant to sort of one upholstery company versus another upholstery company.
- 48:01Paul Shrimpling: That's relevant.
- 48:02Paul Shrimpling: So if you can get to that place, it's just I'm just uh seeking Yeah, the the geographical one plays to the ego component.
- 48:10Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 48:11Martin Bissett: Which I kind of called the social component a minute ago.
- 48:14Paul Shrimpling: But it's really the ego component.
- 48:15Paul Shrimpling: Functional, functional, practical component, which would be the industry piece.
- 48:19Paul Shrimpling: But uh yeah, I I guess we're having a one of those um pedantic semantic conversations a little bit, but it's it's that what questions do we ask the client about what they want, what questions do we ask the client that they don't want, and what questions do we ask the client about what else is going on in their industry that then raises a level of conversation and insight that may well enable you to put a proposal together around ways of working together that moves you from 13k to 95k or maybe even 120k to use your numbers.
- 48:49Paul Shrimpling: But ultimately it's the diagnostic that leads to the proposal and the conversation with the client around the proposal that results in that client paying more.
- 48:59Martin Bissett: I agreed, and the other thing I want to point out there, Paul, is that I gave a deliberately stark example there of how much uplift was doable, but not as a one-off.
- 49:10Martin Bissett: You know, 29 years now in this game, and I can point to as many as you'd like me to point to.
- 49:17Martin Bissett: Yeah, yeah.
- 49:17Martin Bissett: You know, examples of that.
- 49:19Martin Bissett: And I used to I used to do a keynote called Martin, you don't understand.
- 49:23Martin Bissett: Okay, because it was always it was repeating back to me what was uh, or me repeating back to the audience what they said to me.
- 49:29Martin Bissett: Ah, Martin, all very nice and well what you say, but you don't understand, it would never happen with, and then you fill in the sentence.
- 49:37Martin Bissett: It would never happen in this geography, it would never happen in with our with our managing partner, it would never happen in the audit market, it would never happen, and all of that, and I'm gonna be careful to use my language correctly here, was nonsensical, non-evidenced uh statements.
- 49:53Martin Bissett: Yeah, yeah.
- 49:53Martin Bissett: Um, and I and I used to come back with this over and over again, you know.
- 49:57Martin Bissett: And I'm saying, give me a country, give me a size of firm, give me a profile partner, and I'll give you the example of where it's worked, yeah, principally.
- 50:05Martin Bissett: And I and I and I became more and more obstinate about that because it was untrue.
- 50:10Martin Bissett: Yeah, yeah.
- 50:11Martin Bissett: It does work if you wanted to.
- 50:12Martin Bissett: If you decide it's not going to before you start, then stop fulfilling prophecy, of course.
- 50:16Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah.
- 50:16Paul Shrimpling: So to use your um just because we're in that benchmarking space, I just want to maybe shake the tree uh uh a little bit.
- 50:23Paul Shrimpling: Um I've I've been with two firms this week who've done a really, really good job, the heroic job of proper understanding the value equation in the client's mind and creating a in creating a diagnostic that whether they're an existing client or a prospect, have a diagnostic set of questions process, not too scripted because that can look a little bit you know paint by numbers, but a diagnostic that then enables them to put a uh proposal together that um enables them to convert and win work.
- 50:54Paul Shrimpling: And the firm I was with on on Wednesday, they've got a team of people who are working a 34-hour week, some of it's working from home, some of it's in the office.
- 51:02Paul Shrimpling: The owners are doing likewise, well, they're not actually because they only work a four-day week within that 34-hour process.
- 51:09Paul Shrimpling: They take 10 weeks holiday and they've got fees per FTE of 155k.
- 51:14Paul Shrimpling: Okay, and I think there's a connection between the client appreciates the value and the fees per FTE number.
- 51:22Paul Shrimpling: And I'm just fighting, and then the the the other one, they're they're in an even different space because they've got it up to 170k.
- 51:29Paul Shrimpling: And again, it's because they understand the value equation.
- 51:33Paul Shrimpling: Now, that these two are um sort of uh niche firms for want of a better label, you know, that the uh very specific services to a specific um market niches.
- 51:43Paul Shrimpling: Um, but I don't think that's relevant in the fact that they've just done the hard work of identifying what really matters to the clients, even if they don't know it matters, um, and create the diagnostic that then enables them to put a proposal together, and the conversation around the proposal means that they're actually converting work at a much higher level so that they don't have to work so tough in hard.
- 52:06Martin Bissett: Yeah.
- 52:06Martin Bissett: Well, I'm actually delighted that you're using the term proposal, because if you speak to again many firms, you'll get the word quote instead.
- 52:13Martin Bissett: And even that from a um perception point of view, a quote is for a commoditized process.
- 52:22Martin Bissett: Give me a quote for the gardens, give me a quote for the windows, give me a quote to do me drive.
- 52:27Paul Shrimpling: It's a transactional piece, isn't it?
- 52:28Paul Shrimpling: Not a relational piece.
- 52:29Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 52:30Martin Bissett: Absolutely.
- 52:31Martin Bissett: A proposal, which if we expand that phrase out, is proposal of support or proposal of assistance, yeah, suggests something much deeper, yeah, much more impactful.
- 52:41Martin Bissett: Yeah, yeah.
- 52:42Martin Bissett: But I couldn't even get the profession to change the word.
- 52:44Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah.
- 52:45Paul Shrimpling: Well, and I and I've I've very deliberately, every time I've used it, talked about a proposal conversation rather than sending it by email because that's a completely different value demonstration piece as well.
- 52:55Paul Shrimpling: Yes.
- 52:55Paul Shrimpling: Um, okay, so we're we're we're we're heading towards uh the the uh uh end game of this conversation, uh Martin.
- 53:04Paul Shrimpling: What do you think?
- 53:05Paul Shrimpling: Um uh sort of double barrel question.
- 53:08Paul Shrimpling: Uh what's the biggest opportunity, what's the biggest challenge that the accountancy has to deal with now if it's going to be relevant to their clients next year and in 2030?
- 53:18Martin Bissett: Right.
- 53:19Martin Bissett: So I'm just gonna I'm just contemplating answering a question you did not ask there.
- 53:26Paul Shrimpling: Um well that would only be you, Martin.
- 53:30Martin Bissett: You go for it, mate.
- 53:31Paul Shrimpling: You go for it.
- 53:33Martin Bissett: So, you what you asked me, what's the what was gonna be the biggest challenge and opportunity for an accountant with regard to their clients going forward?
- 53:39Martin Bissett: Um, and I always started thinking, what are they actually gonna care about?
- 53:42Martin Bissett: Because I'm not gonna care about that.
- 53:43Martin Bissett: What are they actually gonna care about?
- 53:44Martin Bissett: So I'll answer it in two ways.
- 53:46Martin Bissett: The biggest thing that an accountant should care about selflessly is the saleability of their practice.
- 53:54Paul Shrimpling: Okay.
- 53:55Martin Bissett: Um that's the thing they need to care about internally, externally or selflessly, they need to care about making sure that their relationships with their clients over a certain fee level are of such significant depth that they're not vulnerable to competitor nor technological attack.
- 54:17Martin Bissett: Right, okay.
- 54:18Martin Bissett: That's what you need to worry about.
- 54:20Martin Bissett: So ultimately, you know, when do you ever see an accountant get urgent?
- 54:24Martin Bissett: One, when there's a deadline, two, there's a big client loss.
- 54:26Martin Bissett: That's when you see urgency.
- 54:27Martin Bissett: You know, other than that, you don't see urgency.
- 54:29Martin Bissett: They'll tell you they're maxed out all the time, but you don't actually see it.
- 54:32Martin Bissett: When you go and look at the actual um, you know, offices, no one's running around anywhere, no one's in a rush, two people in the chat over there by the water machine.
- 54:39Martin Bissett: You know, um, you know, nobody's maxed out, it's garbage.
- 54:44Martin Bissett: But you do see urgency when there's a deadline or when there's a massive fee loss.
- 54:48Martin Bissett: So I think in order to provide an insurance policy for themselves to future proof against the raging AI machine, I would make sure that their relationships are of significant debt, that compliance being taken away by AI, should that ever happen, is not going to erode their business model.
- 55:05Martin Bissett: And also that when there is increased competition, be it from humans or non-humans, that business owners are choosing them for very specific reasons related to the well-being of the business owner's future.
- 55:19Paul Shrimpling: Could be.
- 55:19Paul Shrimpling: Um, build deeper relationships with your clients because there is the future security and sustainability of your existing business.
- 55:31Paul Shrimpling: Um growth as well, Martin?
- 55:34Paul Shrimpling: More better relationships with clients.
- 55:37Martin Bissett: Whether we're talking about sustainability, longevity, or profitability, the future belongs to the best relationship orders.
- 55:42Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah.
- 55:42Paul Shrimpling: 100%, 100% agree with that.
- 55:45Paul Shrimpling: And therefore, a relationship is yes, let's have a relationship, but also you've got to deliver value.
- 55:50Paul Shrimpling: So that's the rest of the conversation that we've talked about.
- 55:52Paul Shrimpling: So if we've got a good personal relationship and we deliver value consistently, that matches or is beyond their expectations, we're on a win, aren't we?
- 56:02Martin Bissett: Yeah, let's go back into the pedantic semantics.
- 56:04Martin Bissett: So for me, value is an overused term in accountancy.
- 56:08Martin Bissett: Yeah.
- 56:08Martin Bissett: Okay.
- 56:08Martin Bissett: And I have had occasionally firms going, what do you mean, what do you mean, what you mean, what do you mean when you say value?
- 56:13Martin Bissett: What do you mean?
- 56:14unknown: Yeah.
- 56:14Martin Bissett: And then I got it down to one word, improvement.
- 56:17Martin Bissett: Okay, delivering value can be interpreted as delivering improvement on their current condition, on their current situation.
- 56:24Martin Bissett: If an accountant is delivering measurable improvement as defined by the client, they're going to be fine.
- 56:34Paul Shrimpling: And every client's going to be slightly different.
- 56:36Paul Shrimpling: So with one client, it might be cash improvement because they're desperate or that that they're obsessed with that.
- 56:40Paul Shrimpling: Another one, the improvement might be the speed with which get their annual accounts because they need to make some decisions before they go on holiday.
- 56:46Paul Shrimpling: Absolutely.
- 56:48Martin Bissett: It could be the three-day week for the owner, it could be the it could be the ability to afford better capital equipment.
- 56:56Martin Bissett: It could be anything.
- 56:57Martin Bissett: Yeah.
- 56:58Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah.
- 56:58Paul Shrimpling: Cool.
- 56:59Paul Shrimpling: Cool.
- 56:59Paul Shrimpling: Um it's uh after this podcast, this afternoon, we're doing this in on a Friday in the morning.
- 57:06Paul Shrimpling: I'm interviewing um uh Ryan Tierney, who is arguably the UK's most impactful geezer in the um lean improvement space.
- 57:16Paul Shrimpling: So it's interesting segue for this conversation into that.
- 57:19Paul Shrimpling: Um so uh and and and and lean ultimately obsess about customer value.
- 57:27Paul Shrimpling: Is how do how do we improve the speed, the quality, the depth of the relationship?
- 57:34Paul Shrimpling: Because I've been talking about that for 25 years, is the speed, the work, and the response times, the quality of the work and the depth of the relationship, and the cadence and repetition of that, you know, because relationships are um maintained but built um over dinner.
- 57:51Paul Shrimpling: Um that's my view.
- 57:52Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, I mean, and response times, Paul, still a bugbearing business illness to this day.
- 57:56Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah.
- 57:57Paul Shrimpling: Amazing, isn't it?
- 57:58Paul Shrimpling: Amazing.
- 57:59Paul Shrimpling: Uh, but I do like the way we've wrapped this up in terms of the client's definition of improvement for their business, is why you're in the room, is why you charge two and a half grand, but could charge 25 grand or could charge 200 grand.
- 58:15Martin Bissett: Absolutely.
- 58:16Martin Bissett: So it ultimately it comes down to the client's position where you found them, your intervention and the improvement it created, the end result.
- 58:23Martin Bissett: That's the value.
- 58:25Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, and that compared with the price, if there's a big difference, they'll buy from you.
- 58:28Paul Shrimpling: Even if it's 95 grand or 120 grand or more, yeah, it's colleagues.
- 58:32Martin Bissett: So if the if the return is if the return in its time scale is demonstrably multiples more than the fee that you're charging, it's called they will more often than not find it.
- 58:41Paul Shrimpling: No brainer.
- 58:42Paul Shrimpling: You're in no-brainer territory, aren't you?
- 58:44Paul Shrimpling: Uh, which is again an overuse phrase.
- 58:46Paul Shrimpling: So, of everything we've talked about today, Martin, on this uh 60-ish minute uh conversation, um, what one thing uh has made you think deeper or is the is the key that uh not the magic one, but the key that if uh the firms took it seriously, they transformed the results of their business, their firm and the capital values.
- 59:10Martin Bissett: I think if the profession, so not the individual accountants in practice, but the people who certify ever got round to putting a commercial component into the curriculum, we would see demonstrable improvements, not overnight, but within a year.
- 59:30Martin Bissett: When's that gonna happen, Martin?
- 59:31Martin Bissett: When's that gonna happen?
- 59:32Martin Bissett: Uh when there's a when there's enough parliamentary pressure on them to do so.
- 59:35Martin Bissett: And when's that gonna happen?
- 59:37Martin Bissett: Oh, well, give me about 10 years.
- 59:40Paul Shrimpling: Okay, in the meantime, then, because this is about practical what could people do now of everything we've talked about in this conversation today?
- 59:48Paul Shrimpling: What one thing is of most value to practically help the firm leader listening to this podcast improve their firm, improve whatever aspect they want to improve?
- 1:00:01Martin Bissett: I would get them to sit down and define what their BBC actually is.
- 1:00:06Paul Shrimpling: The beliefs are.
- 1:00:06Martin Bissett: And then say, is that what you is that what you thought it was going to be?
- 1:00:09Martin Bissett: You know, what is the culture of the firm?
- 1:00:11Martin Bissett: Not what you want it to be, not what you think the website says, what is the actual, demonstrable, evidenced, observed culture of this firm?
- 1:00:19Martin Bissett: Why has it got to that point?
- 1:00:20Martin Bissett: What are the behaviours that have influenced it, and what are the beliefs that started it in the first place?
- 1:00:24Martin Bissett: Is that what you thought you had?
- 1:00:26Martin Bissett: Because I bet it's not.
- 1:00:27Martin Bissett: And then get them to work from there.
- 1:00:30Paul Shrimpling: Okay, and I would um want them to narrow the focus around how that impacts the interaction with their clients.
- 1:00:38Paul Shrimpling: So the specific beliefs, behaviors, and uh and and cultural pieces of the city.
- 1:00:42Paul Shrimpling: The BBC that affects the client relationship, because ultimately that's where the value equation lies, which means that you can earn the prices, which means you've got revenue coming in in cash and you've got what you want.
- 1:00:52Paul Shrimpling: Okay, cool.
- 1:00:52Paul Shrimpling: Very good.
- 1:00:54Martin Bissett: As Drucker used to say, the objective of a business is to have a customer.
- 1:00:58Paul Shrimpling: And keep, have and keep.
- 1:01:00Paul Shrimpling: Have and keep.
- 1:01:01Paul Shrimpling: Yes.
- 1:01:01Paul Shrimpling: Well, have first of all, thank you.
- 1:01:02Paul Shrimpling: Get and keep.
- 1:01:04Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah.
- 1:01:06Paul Shrimpling: Genius, man.
- 1:01:06Paul Shrimpling: Genius, man.
- 1:01:07Paul Shrimpling: Uh, very good.
- 1:01:08Paul Shrimpling: Martin, it's um as I as fully expected, this is flown by.
- 1:01:11Paul Shrimpling: Um, uh, loved every minute of it.
- 1:01:13Paul Shrimpling: Thank you very much.
- 1:01:13Paul Shrimpling: Uh always gratitude for that.
- 1:01:14Paul Shrimpling: Um, but more importantly, uh, really appreciate you just like you know, opening Pandora's box to all of your experience around working with firms and leaders over the years.
- 1:01:23Paul Shrimpling: Uh, I can't believe it's 30 years.
- 1:01:25Paul Shrimpling: I can't believe I've been doing it for 25 years, so it's um but it is what it is, isn't it?
- 1:01:29Paul Shrimpling: Um and it's good that we've still got the energy to um to hopefully help ambitious accountants in the uh in the UK and beyond uh humanise the numbers so that we all have a better world as a consequence.
- 1:01:40Paul Shrimpling: So thank you very much.
- 1:01:42Speaker 2: Thank you very much.
- 1:01:49Paul Shrimpling: In the just short of 60 minutes on this podcast, Martin and I have unpacked and shared deep insights that we've learned from many accounting firms on getting clear on value and delivering and communicating that value to clients in a better, stronger way so that you have a more successful firm.
- 1:02:06Paul Shrimpling: If you like to investigate how you get more insight in and around those topics, you might want to consider the Accountants Growth Academy.
- 1:02:14Paul Shrimpling: You can find out more in the show notes.
- 1:02:16Paul Shrimpling: You'll find more valuable discussions with the leaders of ambitious accounting firms at humanize the numbers.online.
- 1:02:23Paul Shrimpling: You can also sign up to be notified each time a new podcast is made available.
- 1:02:34Speaker: You're about to hear a short snippet from a podcast with Hugh O'Neill of Flowcast.
- 1:02:40Speaker: To listen to the whole podcast, go to humanize the numbers.online or your favorite podcast platform.
- 1:02:46Hugh O'Neill: I I I remember talking to a customer about sales analysis, and you know, if a sales analysis report takes two or three days to do, you only do it once a month because it's not worth the effort to do it.
- 1:02:54Hugh O'Neill: If a machine can do that in 30 minutes and you can review it, who wouldn't want that every week?
- 1:02:59Hugh O'Neill: I think one of the other things as well is people spend a lot of time in a process that just evolves.
- 1:03:05Hugh O'Neill: So like processes I remember I was chatting to a guy who was working at a company and they were listed, but they they were a carve out, so they started from scratch.
- 1:03:14Hugh O'Neill: But like I've worked in businesses where I was like it was a material cause in which we were spending on office lunches.
- 1:03:20Hugh O'Neill: So like I have a spreadsheet for the office lunches, and then all of a sudden I become a more elaborate spreadsheet, and then I put all the other overheads into it.
- 1:03:26Hugh O'Neill: And all of a sudden there's a three-day process that is a concoction of like all this stuff that's appeared.
- 1:03:31Hugh O'Neill: And then somebody will say to me in the business triples in size, like, are we still like are we still counting how much we're spending on pizzas?
- 1:03:38Hugh O'Neill: Like it's just like just do you want to do an allocation journal for the pizzas, or do you just want to say roughly we bought pizza for the office and we've had a few beers and everybody's had a good week?
- 1:03:47Hugh O'Neill: So a lot of process and and things.
- 1:03:49Hugh O'Neill: I think people need to rethink what they do because the month end takes a long time because it grows arms, and it's like uh I don't know if you've seen Harry Potter like the Weasley's house.
- 1:03:58Hugh O'Neill: You start off with a little spreadsheet, and then you add this tab, and then you add that tab, and then you add this, and the other, and this, and that the and there's and it's it it's just too complicated, but that it's hard to change, and I think that's that's a challenge people have.