Latest / Together 4 Good: Making Sense of Life and Faith / Can Faith and Doubt Belong Together in Church? A Conversation with Jane Ritterson
Transcript
- 0:00Coming up on the Together for Good podcast, I'm talking with
- 0:03Pastor Jane Ridderson. She's a retired Presbyterian
- 0:07minister and she attends services here at Bethany as well
- 0:11as working with our senior ministries program.
- 0:14And we talk about her career in the church, her career before
- 0:18that, and more importantly, about her role as a mom and what
- 0:23that meant for her kids and her husband when she made this
- 0:26second career shift into the ministry.
- 0:28What it's like for me with my kids in the ministry.
- 0:31And really, it's a conversation about thin spaces and the ways
- 0:35that the sacred seems to show up in all sorts of unexpected ways.
- 0:40It's an awesome conversation. She was so much fun to have on.
- 0:43I can't wait to share it with you.
- 0:45Here we go. Welcome to the Together for Good
- 0:46podcast, a podcast created by Bethany Lutheran Church in
- 0:50Cherry Hills Village, Co and hosted by me, Pastor Nate
- 0:54Pricinger and Together for Good. Our goal is to provide
- 0:57practical, engaging content that supports you without
- 1:00expectations. Whether you're feeling
- 1:03disconnected from traditional religion or simply exploring
- 1:06what faith means in your life, we are here to walk alongside
- 1:10you. No matter where you are on your
- 1:12journey of faith, we're glad you're here.
- 1:14Welcome to Together for Good. Well, hello Jane.
- 1:18Welcome to the podcast studio. I'm sitting here with the
- 1:21Reverend Jane Riddersen and she helps coordinate our senior
- 1:26ministries at Bethany. But you and I have known each
- 1:28other for a long time. It feels like you just started
- 1:30doing the senior ministries piece this fall.
- 1:33That's correct. But you've been kind of hanging
- 1:36out at Bethany. Since when?
- 1:37So, Nate, I retired from my last position as the Presbyterian
- 1:41pastor in July of 2020, and as soon as church was open again, I
- 1:47started attending Bethany because I was real clear that I
- 1:51wanted a separation from the Presbyterian Church.
- 1:53Not because you have anything against the Presbyterians.
- 1:56Now I. Love the Presbyterian Church.
- 1:58I just wanted to experience something new and different and
- 2:02go someplace where I didn't know anybody and I could just sit in
- 2:05the Pew and worship. I appreciate that.
- 2:08I think when I retire, I might do something similar.
- 2:11I've just let's see what else is out there because I know this
- 2:14Lutheran space so well. But tell me, I'm just curious,
- 2:18given the timing of all that, July 2020, was that the plan for
- 2:23a long time? Or did you get 3 months into
- 2:26COVID and say that's it? I'm done with this because it
- 2:29was not an easy time to be a pastor.
- 2:31That was a really hard time to be a pastor, and that's a really
- 2:34good question. I was scheduled to retire at the
- 2:38end of September 2020. I turned 65 in October 2020 and
- 2:44John and I had a month long trip to Europe planned that that got
- 2:49rescheduled for a couple years later.
- 2:51But I was starting to babysit my grandchildren three days a week,
- 2:56who were at the time were three and five.
- 2:58And it became very clear to me that I could not be an almost
- 3:02full time pastor plus babysit three days a week and survive.
- 3:07And because things at the church were a little bit different than
- 3:10they had been, I asked if I could opt out just a few months
- 3:14early. And it worked out great for
- 3:16everybody. No, that's good to hear.
- 3:18I'm I'm curious. I've never actually heard the
- 3:20full kind of itinerary of your career.
- 3:23So, so if you'd be willing, just tell me where you served and
- 3:27when I know we both have Pennsylvania connections and
- 3:30that most of your career was out there.
- 3:32Is that or Delaware? Delaware.
- 3:33Yeah. Yeah.
- 3:34I'm a native of Delaware and I moved here 10 years ago.
- 3:38I'm a second career pastor. I went to seminary when I was in
- 3:42my 40s. OK.
- 3:44I went to Lancaster Theological Seminary in Lancaster, PA, which
- 3:49is an institution of the United Church of Christ.
- 3:52And that worked out really well for me because it was about an
- 3:55hour from my house and I lived up there three days a week.
- 3:59And my first call was to a small church in Newark, DE, right
- 4:07outside of the University of Delaware, called Head of
- 4:09Christiana, which means when it was found that it was on the
- 4:12headwaters of the Christiana River.
- 4:14That's a That's a very strange name.
- 4:16Yes, it is. No kidding.
- 4:18And when I was there, the summer during my tenure there, we
- 4:21celebrated our 300th anniversary.
- 4:23No. Way.
- 4:24Isn't that crazy? 300th.
- 4:27Anniversary 300 years and that church split over the issue of
- 4:31slavery. What?
- 4:33Oh, so that had a lot of history.
- 4:34Behind that kidding. I mean, that's a part that a lot
- 4:37of people in Colorado just don't have the the metric for us how
- 4:40old things are on the East Coast.
- 4:44I grew up in Albany, NY, and the oldest Protestant church is
- 4:48First Lutheran in Albany, NY, which when I was out there
- 4:52celebrated its 360th anniversary or something like that.
- 4:57I think it's now unfortunately closed, but yeah, everything is
- 5:00so much older out east. Everything is so old out there
- 5:04and that church was really cool because it had a cemetery
- 5:06attached to it and I love to walk around there and look at
- 5:10the graves and read them. You know people, 1700s people
- 5:13had been resting there's. No.
- 5:16Was that so? That was your first call.
- 5:18Did you serve other congregations?
- 5:20Yes, I did. I worked as a Hospice chaplain
- 5:23for a couple of years, which was fascinating, put me up close and
- 5:28personal right with death and dying, and I learned so much.
- 5:32And then I was in the Presbyterian Philadelphia for
- 5:36five or six years at a church called Aston Presbyterian, and
- 5:40it was a small church, 100 members.
- 5:42I was a solo pastor there, Presbyterian Philadelphia.
- 5:46I don't know if I said that. Yeah, what part of Philadelphia?
- 5:48Was it so South, OK, like South of the airport, probably.
- 5:55Probably 10 miles South of the airport.
- 5:57OK, Yeah. Really close to Delaware.
- 5:59Delaware County, Yeah, it was only 15 minutes from my house.
- 6:02Gotcha. OK.
- 6:03Yeah. So we were just in different
- 6:04parts I was in. You were in the way north.
- 6:06Right, Right. Germantown, Mount Airy, the
- 6:08northwest corner of Philadelphia.
- 6:10So and. Then when I moved here, I worked
- 6:13at Columbine United Church in OR.
- 6:16I served the Columbine United Church over in Littleton, which
- 6:19is a conglomeration of the UCC, the United Methodist and the
- 6:23Presbyterian. Wow.
- 6:25Which is a nightmare with Colony.
- 6:30OK, enough said, but I will say the Presbyterians were more
- 6:34controlling than the other two. Destination.
- 6:38What? What did you do prior to this?
- 6:41What was your first career? Oh, gosh.
- 6:43Well, when I graduated from college, I had a degree in
- 6:48business, and I worked in business for a number of years.
- 6:52And then I had children, two kids who are now older than you
- 6:55are, Nate. I forget that a lot.
- 6:58I know they're, I guess they're 41 and 44.
- 7:01And I was home with them for a number of years.
- 7:03Good for you. And then I was super active in
- 7:05the Presbyterian Church that we attended.
- 7:08You know, I was there practically every time the doors
- 7:09were open. Yeah.
- 7:10Yeah, yeah. Volunteering for everything and
- 7:13then went to seminary when I was in my 40s.
- 7:16As you look back on your career in ministry, what what were your
- 7:21favorite parts like? What did you love about the
- 7:23role? Death and dying, really.
- 7:28I love funerals. I love visiting people in
- 7:30hospitals. I love visiting people in their
- 7:34homes, hearing their stories. And what's very interesting
- 7:37about being in a small church rather than a big church, I
- 7:40mean, Columbine was medium, I guess.
- 7:42But when I was in my church and Aston, I knew every single
- 7:45person really, really well. And I think there, there wasn't
- 7:50a church member where I hadn't been inside their home.
- 7:52And not only did I know them, I knew their families, their
- 7:55stories. And I attended anniversary
- 7:57parties and birthday parties and really became involved in their
- 8:01daily lives, and I thought that was so sacred.
- 8:05Absolutely. Well, and and say more about the
- 8:07the sacredness of death and dying, because that's what
- 8:10you're right. Your knee jerk response was the
- 8:12death and dying and being there. And then you kind of expanded on
- 8:15that to say all of the sacredness of being invited into
- 8:18people's lives. But but but what is it about
- 8:20funerals in particular? You think that just was so
- 8:23special? I think because when people are
- 8:25are entering those last days, hours or weeks of their lives,
- 8:29yeah, everything is so real. People aren't putting on faces.
- 8:34It's where a minute, it's where the rubbery meets the road and
- 8:37ministry. People live down their defenses
- 8:40and they allow you to hear their stories without a lot of
- 8:44elaboration or false faces put on.
- 8:47Yeah. How, how would you approach that
- 8:49as a pastor when you were invited into those spaces?
- 8:53Like what? What was your tact or tactic, if
- 8:56you know to use a crass word? That's a good question.
- 9:00I listen more than talk sometimes.
- 9:04When I didn't know what to say, I didn't say anything.
- 9:07And then they would say you said exactly the right thing.
- 9:10And I'm like, wait a minute, I didn't say anything.
- 9:14Or I would just sit next to somebody and put my hand on
- 9:18their arm and just allow them to know I was there.
- 9:21One of my most sacred, very sacred moments with death and
- 9:25dying was when I was a Hospice chaplain.
- 9:27I was visiting a woman, and it was her last week of life, and
- 9:30she had grown up in the Roman Catholic Church.
- 9:33And one of her dying wishes was to receive the sacrament of Holy
- 9:36Communion. And so I was able to serve her
- 9:40communion. And tears were streaming down
- 9:43her face. And she said, I never thought
- 9:45that I would receive communion again.
- 9:49And then we kind of laughed. I said, well, you do know this
- 9:51is Presbyterian communion and not Catholic communion, she
- 9:56said. It's all the same.
- 9:58Good for her. Yeah, that's really.
- 10:00And I said that it is all the same.
- 10:02This is a gift from God for the people of God.
- 10:05This does not belong. This doesn't belong to the
- 10:07Presbyterian Church or the Catholic Church or even to the
- 10:11Lutheran Church. But it belongs to God, right?
- 10:14And we are. We are merely the the vehicles
- 10:16that God uses to administer the sacraments.
- 10:20And it and it can just mean so much to individuals, especially
- 10:24at those those crucial moments in life, which I think speaks to
- 10:28the fact that it's not owned by anyone entity, right Like that.
- 10:31There's just something more happening in that moment of
- 10:35sharing communion with someone that yeah, go ahead, go.
- 10:40Ahead into one of those spaces that we call a thin space,
- 10:44right? Like between, like where heaven
- 10:46and earth are just this close and you're not really quite sure
- 10:50exactly where you are. It's just this sacred thin place
- 10:53and where you're above and beyond time and space.
- 10:58No, I mean, I'm it's funny to hear you reflecting on all of
- 11:01that. As you might remember, it's been
- 11:03almost a year now since my mom passed away.
- 11:06And that, like everything is hitting me really weirdly now
- 11:09because it's been a year. And this was the moment it was
- 11:12right, you know, towards the end of February last year when I
- 11:17went out there to to spend time with her because we knew she was
- 11:19moving to Hospice. And as I just think about all of
- 11:22those sacred moments that I was able to share, like I'm so
- 11:26grateful to Bethany for giving me the time to just spend those
- 11:30three weeks with her and all of the memories that are again,
- 11:35just so fresh and percolating up.
- 11:37And it's funny how I didn't know what to say.
- 11:41And yet for me, it was constantly, you know, like one
- 11:44of the things my mom and I always shared was just that our
- 11:47faith was really important. And I went to church with her
- 11:50every Sunday because my dad was out.
- 11:52He he was a pastor, but he worked for the sin.
- 11:54And so he was never with us on Sundays.
- 11:56But those are the things that we both kind of leaned on.
- 11:58It's like, all right, like, let me say these prayers.
- 12:00Let it, let's sing this song because I didn't, I had no idea.
- 12:04And it's such a massive moment in someone's life.
- 12:08What do you say? And it was neat that like, our
- 12:11shared faith is what gave me the language to, to to offer at that
- 12:16moment. Have you ever had an experience
- 12:18like that? Or I mean, Lutheran's, we have
- 12:20this little red book we bring with us for services,
- 12:23accommodation. Is there something similar that
- 12:24the Presbyterians have that you would rely on, or would you kind
- 12:29of leave it in the car? Well, I mostly leave it in the
- 12:33car. Good for you.
- 12:35And it would just be more free prayer.
- 12:37But however, you know, that would be when I was working in
- 12:40the church, when I was working as a chaplain for Hospice, you
- 12:44know, it was pretty clear to try to find out what the person's
- 12:47background was and meet them where they were.
- 12:50So I had a little Episcopalian prayer book.
- 12:52I didn't have a Lutheran one which is probably pretty
- 12:54similar. Episcopalian ones probably
- 12:56better anyways. They're good with language, They
- 12:58really are. And so, you know, you have to
- 13:00meet people where they are. Yeah, yeah, exactly, Exactly.
- 13:05Wow. Well, So what now?
- 13:07Do you love that you're retired? Like what's bringing you joy
- 13:11these days? So what brings me joy?
- 13:14Golly. First off, we have 4
- 13:18grandchildren that are kind of the light of my life.
- 13:20They are two that live here in Denver, two boys that are 9:00
- 13:25and 11:00. Well, they are.
- 13:26They are a little cuckoo because there's two of them and they're.
- 13:30Mail and they're 9:00 and 11:00. Right.
- 13:31And they're 9:00 and 11:00. And then the two out east are a
- 13:36girl's 6 1/2 and a boy 4. So we don't see them as often as
- 13:40we like, but when things are good, we see them, you know,
- 13:42probably a half dozen time a year, which is pretty good
- 13:45considering how far away they are.
- 13:47And then John and I, we love to Pike.
- 13:50So I would say usually at least once a week we're out, you know,
- 13:54somewhere in the foothills. Good for you.
- 13:56We enjoy bike riding. He is an avid fly fisherman.
- 14:00And I think that's where he finds his connection to the
- 14:04divine. And the sacred is out in the the
- 14:07stream and in the woods. And I love, you know, I have
- 14:11some really, really good friends that I like to spend time with
- 14:14neighbors, walking. It's a full life.
- 14:17And then, yeah, full life. I wonder how I had time to work.
- 14:21And then I love, you know, I love coming to Bethany on
- 14:23Sundays. Like, honestly, I don't come
- 14:25here every Sunday because I do a lot of guest preaching and small
- 14:29little Presbyterian churches. And I occasionally attend
- 14:33another a couple of other local churches, mostly kind of
- 14:36depending on time and what's happening in my life.
- 14:39But I've learned so much about the liturgical life here,
- 14:42Bethany. Because you're, yeah, you're not
- 14:45as familiar as a Presbyterian, I'm sure, with all the insurance
- 14:48and outs of yeah, our liturgy. Exactly.
- 14:52I mean, I like how you mentioned your husband finding the
- 14:54connection to the divine through fly fishing.
- 14:57Do you find connection to the divine through a worship
- 15:00service? Sometimes, but not always.
- 15:02OK, what does it look like when it happens?
- 15:07So what most often happens would not be on a Sunday morning, but
- 15:11in smaller gatherings, maybe Ash Wednesday, Maundy Thursday, Good
- 15:16Friday, when the group is smaller, the music is a little
- 15:21bit more meditative. And then I occasionally enter
- 15:24again into this thin space, you know, where the where the heaven
- 15:29and earth are so close together. I would have to say, and I would
- 15:33like be like to ask you the same question.
- 15:35When I was a worship leader, I hardly ever felt the presence of
- 15:38the divine on Sunday morning because I was so worried about
- 15:41logistics and the clock and am I going over and was the handsome
- 15:45too long? Was children's time too long?
- 15:47Was the sermon too long? How is that for you on Sunday?
- 15:51Morning. You, you.
- 15:52You nailed it. I am constantly calculating.
- 15:57Yeah. How long are things taking?
- 15:59And I mean and, which is silly because it's not like we can
- 16:02change it once it happens. You know, like.
- 16:06Maybe we can talk. Later, right?
- 16:09Right, and we're not going to cut anything because it it would
- 16:13take too much coordination to be like, hey, like we're running
- 16:15over. So let's just skip this him
- 16:17like, how am I going to get that message to Rick?
- 16:20And and like, wouldn't everyone be confused when they get to
- 16:23that point in the bulletin? And then we just continue
- 16:25onward, like there's no way to change what what's happened?
- 16:28The buses left the station, like you said.
- 16:30And and yet what I'll say because I really like being a
- 16:35part of a staff, because some Sundays I have very little
- 16:40responsibility and I can just be more present there.
- 16:44And I really love being a part of a church where the music is
- 16:48consistently really, really good because those can often be my
- 16:52little moments of thin space, as you say, when the when the choir
- 16:58singing the offertory anthem or on the off chance that I don't
- 17:04have to serve communion and I can just receive communion and
- 17:06sit down and appreciate the anthem and that moment.
- 17:10Those are good. Those are good times.
- 17:14What I really love and miss is getting to sit with my family.
- 17:20And so every once in a while, like my wife and I are just
- 17:24chickens with our heads cut off because we're taking our kids
- 17:27constantly for this thing and then that thing.
- 17:28And so there's been a few random Sundays where it's like, well,
- 17:31like, she's got to take one kid to all the basketball games that
- 17:35happened at 10 AM on a Sunday morning.
- 17:37What's going on? And so then I get to sit, you
- 17:40know, I was like, all right, like my two daughters, you're
- 17:42going to just sit in the front Pew with me.
- 17:44And we're just going to like, because we need a place to store
- 17:47you for the next. But that that's really
- 17:52meaningful for me is when I can be with my family and in a
- 17:57worship service together just because.
- 18:00Yeah. Well, I mean, maybe it's because
- 18:02of my. But as I've talked to her like
- 18:03it's my memories too. Like I had such fond memories
- 18:05and connections of that with my mother growing up.
- 18:09And not, not always fond. Like I went kicking and
- 18:11streaming some Sundays as well. I'm sure you did.
- 18:15You are a normal person. Correct.
- 18:18But now I really appreciate it. And so just like trying to
- 18:20cultivate those types of sacred moments with my kids now is
- 18:25something I really when it can happen.
- 18:27I think that's a sacrifice that pastors make right, that I don't
- 18:31think often the people in the Pew are aware of.
- 18:35Yeah, I mean it. It just makes the whole life of
- 18:38faith very different for the family, don't you think?
- 18:42Oh, absolutely. I.
- 18:43Mean and you got to experience both parts of that, right?
- 18:46Like because you were raising your kids just as you know, the
- 18:50family that went to church and then all of a sudden, oh, mom's
- 18:52a pastor. What what was that like?
- 18:54Do you do you have any reflections on?
- 18:55Like for them, yeah. And.
- 18:57For your whole family, yeah, for both of.
- 18:59You First off, I didn't go to my kids were in high school when
- 19:02when I went to the seminary. So by the time I was ordained,
- 19:05they were out of high school and in college.
- 19:07Gotcha. And they mostly just rolled
- 19:10their eyes. I thought it was about the
- 19:13strangest thing they'd ever heard of.
- 19:15No way. And then and then John, who my
- 19:20spouse, he his when I told him about this call I was
- 19:25experiencing and I was going to go to seminary, his the first
- 19:29words out of his mouth was are you kidding?
- 19:31Because finally, we can have weekends without games and you
- 19:34want to work every weekend. For him.
- 19:39So I said, yeah, sorry. And so our pastor at the time
- 19:45said, like, I really think you guys should see a counselor, you
- 19:47know, for, for a few times to kind of iron this out because he
- 19:50wasn't counting on this. And it's a big lifestyle change.
- 19:54Yeah, absolutely. To go from raising kids and just
- 19:58having a more traditional life and then all of a sudden you're
- 20:01married to a pastor. Did Were there a lot of
- 20:04expectations placed on him by the congregation?
- 20:06No. OK, that's good.
- 20:08That's really good. That's definitely been an
- 20:10interesting part of my wife's experience as well.
- 20:13I mean, I've served in three different churches now and just
- 20:16the varying expectations of like what the the pastor's wife
- 20:20should do because she won't play those games.
- 20:23No, I've never met your wife, but I sure would like to meet.
- 20:26Her. Yeah, you would.
- 20:26You would really like her. What did she have expectations
- 20:31put upon her in any church? Absolutely.
- 20:33Absolutely. And I mean, she didn't care, but
- 20:36it, it's certainly existed. And it's been something we've
- 20:39continually tried to figure out and have a gate.
- 20:41And then, I mean, another part of our story, I served for a
- 20:46couple of years as the director of admissions at the Lutheran
- 20:49Seminary in Philadelphia. And so that was a time when I
- 20:52didn't have Sunday morning obligations.
- 20:55I finally like just had a 9:00 to 5:00 Monday through Friday
- 20:58job like a normal person. And so I told my wife, I'm like,
- 21:02you get to pick the church, like let's find one for our family,
- 21:05but I'll go wherever you want to go.
- 21:08And that's also where I have so many fond memories of my young
- 21:10kids and us going to church together.
- 21:14We, we went to an Episcopal Church in Philadelphia during
- 21:18that time. And it was just, it was lovely
- 21:21to just be there on a Sunday morning and not be worrying
- 21:26about how long the anthem went or the sermon went or anything
- 21:28else. I'm not enjoying the moment.
- 21:31I think sexism is alive and well because I think there's much
- 21:34less, much there's less expectations placed on male
- 21:37spouses than there is on female. I think so too.
- 21:40I. Think that's true even in the
- 21:42year 2026? And just talking to clergy
- 21:45colleagues as well and hearing their stories, it seems, yeah,
- 21:49that the expectations are always on the the wife and very rarely
- 21:54on the husband, who happens to be married to a pastor.
- 21:57And John, you know, didn't when I was at the church, asked in
- 22:00Presbyterian, in the Philadelphia Presbyterian, he
- 22:02did not come to church every week.
- 22:04Sure. And people would say, well,
- 22:06where is he? And my normal answer was well I
- 22:08don't go to work with him so watch me.
- 22:11Well, that's a great. Line so he doesn't always want
- 22:14to come to work with me. I mean, and Amanda, my wife
- 22:19would have a lot to say about that, too, of just how weird it
- 22:21is some of the expectations that get placed upon her to like,
- 22:26support my job, which is like, you've never like what you come
- 22:29to the Christmas party. You know, that's, that is my
- 22:32connection to her work. Yeah, it's, it's complicated
- 22:35and. Confusing her identity, the
- 22:37pastor's wife. And what is her name?
- 22:39Amanda. So what Amanda.
- 22:41She's a real person. She's not Nate's wife.
- 22:44Well, it's so funny. Not only Nate's wife.
- 22:46My previous two congregations that I served were very small,
- 22:49so everyone knew everyone who everyone was.
- 22:53But coming to Bethany because it's such a large church.
- 22:56She can hide. Yeah, we joke about it all the
- 22:58time. It's like most people probably
- 23:00think she's just that poor single mom wrangling 3 cribs
- 23:03every Sunday because they have no idea that it's my wife.
- 23:08And I'm sitting up front and they're, you know, sitting in
- 23:11the back and rolling in. I love it because she'll text me
- 23:14too. And my favorite text, every now
- 23:18and then I get one that just says we're coming in hot this
- 23:20morning. And I know that that means.
- 23:22Somebody's misbehaved. And that they're like barely
- 23:24dressed and it was a battle. So this one's still in pyjamas.
- 23:29Like whatever you made it, it's great.
- 23:30Sounds like normal family life. Exactly, exactly.
- 23:33It's fun. Well, with one of the things
- 23:38that I wanted to bring you on to talk about is just the idea.
- 23:42There's so much written about, you know, the church is
- 23:44shrinking and less people, you know, the world is more secular.
- 23:48And you joked before we turned on the pocket.
- 23:50Nate, I've been talking about this for a really long time and
- 23:54you don't really have any answers for me, do you?
- 23:56Like, I've been talking about why don't young people come to
- 23:59church since before you were born, sitting around, you know,
- 24:02tables, Presbyterian committees, church committees.
- 24:06How can we get young people to come to church?
- 24:08And I haven't come up with an answer yet.
- 24:11I have two adult children who were raised in the church.
- 24:15Neither one of them attend worship right now.
- 24:18And I, I've asked my daughter would tell you she believes in
- 24:21God. She asked me to pray for the
- 24:23Saturn, but she does not have interest in in attending Sunday
- 24:28morning services. And my son, who and his wife,
- 24:32who grew up in a unitary universalist church, both tell
- 24:36me that they don't believe in God.
- 24:39And I'm like, huh, That's what I say.
- 24:42But what I tell myself is but God believes in them.
- 24:45Yeah, and God is looking over them, even though they might
- 24:48claim. Yeah, no, I really appreciate
- 24:51the that that phrasing of the language and I find it
- 24:54interesting just the two realities that your children
- 24:59kind of represent is like, cuz, you know, I'm sure you've read
- 25:02books and heard all the metrics of the different types of people
- 25:05who don't go to church. And there are some who just like
- 25:06don't I don't believe in God. And so ergo, what the church is
- 25:10doing is just completely irrelevant to me.
- 25:12Like I have no, there would be no reason that would bring me to
- 25:15church because I just don't believe in it.
- 25:17But then you have this other reality of a person who like
- 25:19really does believe that there's something more, but doesn't see
- 25:23any value in the way that church communities access that or, you
- 25:29know, practice that piece of it. What have you had any
- 25:34conversations with that? It's your daughter, right?
- 25:37Who's like asked you to pray for things.
- 25:39Have you have you delved any deeper into?
- 25:42I delve. Her psyche on that.
- 25:43A little bit, but I'm very careful because she can quickly
- 25:47get on the defensive and I have a strong idea that she would
- 25:52respond better to someone who was not her mother.
- 25:55Totally fair, I get that. But I think, you know, she is a
- 25:59busy full time job and like your children, her her kids have
- 26:02activity Sunday morning. Yeah, and she's tired, you know,
- 26:07or Saturday morning. And they were, they're running
- 26:09around. And it's I for her, it's like
- 26:12one more thing to do. And as far as my son and his
- 26:16wife, you say they don't believe in God.
- 26:18I don't think that should preclude going to church because
- 26:20you can enter into a caring, loving community of people who
- 26:24can love you and care for you. And maybe you're fit.
- 26:28Maybe they're questioning and their faith or lack of can
- 26:31continue to evolve. Yeah, exactly.
- 26:33I mean, there there is so much benefit, I think obviously to a
- 26:38church community, even if you don't fully believe everything
- 26:43that we always talk about. And I think that I think that's
- 26:46kind of the point of the church community.
- 26:48Is it like, yeah, like we're all still trying to figure this out
- 26:51together and we need one another because we can't buy our own
- 26:54ability firmly hold on to all of these beliefs all of the time?
- 27:00And who believes in every single word of the Apostles Creed?
- 27:03It's exactly where I want to go with it.
- 27:04Exactly. Or I don't know.
- 27:06We, I think a lot of people hear the Apostles Creed and think of
- 27:09it as like this purity test, like, OK, everyone stand up and
- 27:13you better say this with gusto because you got to really mean
- 27:16it. Whereas the way I look at that
- 27:17practice is it's more about, hey, we're all going to stand up
- 27:20and say this together because we need to believe this together in
- 27:25the sense of like, you might believe the first line and I
- 27:28believe the second line. And so together we're getting a
- 27:30little closer to being able to make the statement, but your
- 27:33faith is helping hold up my doubts and vice versa.
- 27:38And that that's more of what we like, more of what the church is
- 27:42trying to articulate and show folks.
- 27:46Bringing it back, though, just kind of one of the other pieces
- 27:49I'm reflecting on in the course of our conversation is that you
- 27:53go to church, you said, and, and often sometimes experience these
- 27:56more thin spaces where it it, you feel this deeper connection
- 28:01with something beyond yourself. And I think for a lot of people
- 28:05who believe in God but don't go to church, it's because church
- 28:09very rarely gives them that sense of things.
- 28:13Do you think that's fair? Absolutely.
- 28:15I mean, get real church can be really boring.
- 28:19It is really boring and sometimes when I was a pastor
- 28:23before I retired, I would think some worship services were
- 28:27wonderful and connected and sometimes I would think, wow,
- 28:31this isn't so great and it's not as great today.
- 28:33As it could be, Yeah. So.
- 28:35But So what do you do about that as a pastor?
- 28:37Because I also think sometimes we just have to like, keep
- 28:41showing up. And if I get too caught up in
- 28:44like, how do I market this in a really slick way?
- 28:46How do I make worship really exciting and engaging?
- 28:49Like now? Now I'm just in the
- 28:50entertainment business. Exactly.
- 28:52And that's not what we're trying to do here either.
- 28:54And if you want that, you can go to one of these big mega
- 28:57churches with a rock band. Well, and, and if if that's the
- 29:00game we're going to try and play, we'll always lose exactly
- 29:03because Netflix has an infinite number of shows that they are
- 29:07spending millions of dollars to create for us.
- 29:10Whereas I have a much smaller budget and an hour of time.
- 29:16And there's certain things that I just am supposed to do as part
- 29:19of a worship service that frankly might not feel that
- 29:22exciting this morning. But I think where I find God
- 29:25sometimes almost as much or more than in the worship service is
- 29:28in the community and the people I talked to before and after
- 29:32church. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 29:33And the connections that you make and the kindnesses that are
- 29:37offered, the prayers that are offered to one another.
- 29:40And it's interesting, since I've retired almost six years ago
- 29:44now, the people I've reflected a lot about this, the people in my
- 29:48lifetime that I've stayed the most connected to and the
- 29:51closest to are people that I have met in church or, you know,
- 29:56in my neighborhood. The people that I know are
- 29:58people of faith, but I connect to on a much deeper level than a
- 30:03neighbor who's nice, but there's no, no connection.
- 30:07Yeah, even though we might not talk about faith.
- 30:10But for example, I know my next door neighbor is a devout
- 30:12Catholic. She's in church every week.
- 30:15I keep trying to get her to come to Bethany because she's always
- 30:17mad at the Catholic Church about something.
- 30:20But she's welcome. I know.
- 30:23But there's a connection there that I feel because I know she's
- 30:26a believer and I think that she's.
- 30:29You know. I think she's doing things for
- 30:32us and John and I've had, I'll just put it out there, three
- 30:35knee replacements in a few months.
- 30:37She's gone to the store for us, brought us food.
- 30:40I think that's prayer and action embodied prayer.
- 30:43Absolutely. And yeah, just the, I mean,
- 30:45bringing it back to to the what happened with my mother last
- 30:48year, there were people from the church stopping by all the time.
- 30:51That's prayer. Embodied prayer.
- 30:54Yeah, well said, embodied prayer.
- 30:56So I think if I sit in my living room and bow my head and cross,
- 31:01you know, like my hands and just pray, that doesn't mean as much
- 31:05to me as a phone call or a cookie or a dinner or a
- 31:09casserole. The embodied prayer.
- 31:12That's really good. That's.
- 31:14Really good, and that's what I love about the community of the
- 31:16church. Right.
- 31:17That it gives us those connections and that point for
- 31:21further embodied prayer because it feels good to live it out
- 31:24too, you know, let. Me tell you, it's really hard to
- 31:27be the receiver. Yeah, I'm sure, I'm sure.
- 31:30Well, and especially after years as the pastor showing up in
- 31:35these different sacred moments for people like that was you're
- 31:38also embodied prayer. Like you, you know, if it comes
- 31:40back around what you were describing, being with folks in
- 31:44the final moments of their life as a Hospice chaplain and not
- 31:47really saying much, but it was embodied prayer.
- 31:50Showing up as half of life, right?
- 31:52Yeah, or more. Or more.
- 31:54Yeah, and showing up for churches.
- 31:58Show people. Yeah, no, I mean, I'm really, I
- 32:04don't know, I really appreciate that the embodied prayer,
- 32:08because it's an embodied faith too.
- 32:11And that's like so much theologically of what's behind
- 32:15what we talk about, right? Like, no, no, it's not that
- 32:17God's far off and distant. God became a human being like
- 32:20that. That's the story, isn't it?
- 32:21Like that this happened in history with a real person name.
- 32:25Jesus is a real person. He suffered with us and visited
- 32:28with us, right was with us. It seems to be the continual
- 32:32message, and yet we're always so slow to pick it.
- 32:33Up and you know the Trinity is a community.
- 32:36Creator, Sustain or His Father, Son, Holy Spirit, whatever you
- 32:40call it, it's a community. It's a community.
- 32:42It's. Not just one big old God up
- 32:44there sitting up in heaven by him, by him or herself.
- 32:48Right. No, no, yeah, I, I love that
- 32:50image too, of thinking of God. We, we get so caught up and it's
- 32:53so funny, so much of church and, and the language of our faith
- 32:58when we try to just make it about belief.
- 33:01Hey, you just need to intellectually understand this.
- 33:06That's where I think it falls apart for so many people, 'cause
- 33:08it's like, what? You're, are you kidding me?
- 33:10Like 1 + 1 + 1 does not equal 1, right?
- 33:13Like what? What are you saying that God is
- 33:153 and yet one? And yet when you say like, Oh
- 33:17yeah, three people are going to get together and that's a
- 33:19community. It's like, Oh yeah, that's fine.
- 33:22When two or three are gathered in God's name, right, Right and
- 33:26so. When we make it more embodied
- 33:28and more practical and more everyday life, like just trying
- 33:32to get through the day because it's hard sometimes, I feel like
- 33:36our faith suddenly comes so much more alive when we move out of
- 33:40our heads and into our hearts more.
- 33:42You know, I've almost stopped using that word.
- 33:44I believe in God. I like to say I trust God.
- 33:47I trust Jesus. I trust that God, Jesus will be
- 33:50with me. Yeah, I really appreciate that
- 33:53too, because it's because we can't believe it all the time,
- 33:57right? I just did a lesson for the the
- 33:59high school or youth group 2 weeks ago where we talked about
- 34:03faith and doubt, and that was a point that I kind of made to
- 34:05him. It's like the opposite of doubt
- 34:10is certainty and it right, like, and and that's not what we're
- 34:15going for here. Like faith in inherently entails
- 34:20some element of doubt in it because like, yeah, I like, I
- 34:22trust this. I I believe this.
- 34:24And maybe not like totally right now, I'm still trying to figure
- 34:27it out, but I have faith that it's going to be OK, that God is
- 34:31going to act and show up. And maybe I'm not totally
- 34:34certain, but that's OK. That's not what we're looking.
- 34:36For we don't know what that looks like, right, Right.
- 34:40God could show up and and a friend, a neighbor, a stranger.
- 34:43Right. And isn't that always how it?
- 34:45Goes and somebody you don't even like that you don't want to even
- 34:48be in the same room with. And there God is the Good
- 34:50Samaritan, right? The Samaritan.
- 34:52Oh so, exactly so good that, that it's so unexpected the way
- 34:56that God's mercy shows up. And, and yet because we like to
- 35:02be in control, I feel like humans constantly try and bring
- 35:07it back to, to certainty and to just doing it the right way.
- 35:12And yet it's, it's like those thin spaces that we uncover or
- 35:16encounter that suddenly make us realize like, how like, maybe
- 35:19that's not how life works. And I really don't understand
- 35:21exactly what's going on here, but something about what just
- 35:24happened touched my soul in a very important way that makes me
- 35:29believe there's more going on right now.
- 35:31And I'd love that you're talking to the young people about that.
- 35:34Yeah. Because I think that's something
- 35:36that it's taken me decades to figure out.
- 35:39And I think it's just something that our world pushes on us.
- 35:43The the, the antithesis of that right, like of, of certainty
- 35:45and, and do the right thing. And after you're done with high
- 35:48school, you go to college and then you go to grad, right?
- 35:50Like it, everything is just so linear and.
- 35:53And we live in a scientific world too, right?
- 35:56And science is. Great.
- 35:57Right. But well, yes, my daughter's a
- 35:59scientist and she's, yeah, I mean, that's another issue, but.
- 36:05No, science is great. No, it is great.
- 36:07What would we do with that? But it keeps you up here.
- 36:10Yeah, you can't get too stuck in your head, Yeah.
- 36:13What kind of science does she do?
- 36:14Molecular biology, Biochemistry, but I mean, but she but God that
- 36:19I mean God taught. I mean God gave us people who
- 36:22are doctors, nurses, teachers. And so we have to trust that God
- 36:29gave people these gifts. And I mean.
- 36:32To use for the greater good, hopefully in a perfect world.
- 36:35I'm sure too, though, that in her work in molecular biology
- 36:41she still encounters wonder course, right?
- 36:45Because when you look at the smallness of existence and yet
- 36:49how it's all interconnected and related, that that to me has
- 36:54always been a a source of faith. And I am I one of my best
- 37:00friends from college, has his PhD in physics and he studies he
- 37:04works with lasers. No, I don't even understand
- 37:07that. I have no.
- 37:08Idea. But I told I, I asked him like
- 37:09Jackson, like, let me like, do you have a, a book about quantum
- 37:12physics for like really dumb people?
- 37:15He's like, oh, yeah. Because I was, I've been, I've
- 37:18heard so much about quantum physics and I've been so
- 37:20fascinated by it, but wanted to like dip my toes in.
- 37:24And, and the, the reason being, though, is because so much of
- 37:27what I'm hearing sounds like a theologian talking.
- 37:31It's like, we don't really know why these particles, when you
- 37:34get super small, do these things and all of a sudden you have
- 37:38like scientists are like, yeah, like there's personality and
- 37:40like, Oh my gosh. Like it seems to be reverting
- 37:43back around to this incredible sense of wonder, and while we
- 37:47can figure out how some of the things work, there's a lot that
- 37:51doesn't make sense anymore that that it's just beyond our
- 37:54comprehension. There's more that we don't know
- 37:56than we do know, right? We are.
- 37:58Our human brains aren't as smart as we think they are, right?
- 38:02We can't get our head around it. Which doesn't?
- 38:04Doesn't that just point us towards towards the divine?
- 38:07Towards the divine? Oh well, we could talk about
- 38:09this all day. This is so fun.
- 38:11My main question, what I always bring it back to if you had to
- 38:14summarize, why are you still here?
- 38:17Why are you still involved in a church at all, given everything
- 38:21else that's going on? I think it's so grounding and it
- 38:30reminds me that I'm God, that I'm that God is God and I'm not,
- 38:36that God is God and I'm not. And it reminds me that when the
- 38:39going gets tough, that so much is out of my hands and I've got
- 38:44to count on I power beyond myself and however God chooses
- 38:51to be manifested, which is maybe through the still small voice of
- 38:57the Holy Spirit. But most often for me it's
- 38:59through another person who is just present and shows up at the
- 39:04right time. And, you know, when I'm in
- 39:08church, just just, I don't know, you just go into a space that is
- 39:14just sacred and not every week and not an hour every week.
- 39:19And sometimes I just, I'm looking at my watch and, you
- 39:23know, reading the bulletin and. Not when I'm preaching.
- 39:26No, not when you're preaching. I wonder why Lutheran's have so
- 39:30many endings to the service. I haven't.
- 39:37We said our men already. Yeah, right.
- 39:41I really appreciate you speaking about the humility of all this
- 39:47because it it's funny, I think our world has a really bad
- 39:51relationship with that word and we don't think that humility is
- 39:55necessarily a good thing. I feel right, like feel like so
- 39:58much points and starts like no, no, you need to do more.
- 40:00You need to accomplish more. You need to prove.
- 40:02How good you are? Pull up your bootstraps.
- 40:05Pull up your bootstraps. And yet what I hear in your
- 40:08answer there is how faith grounds you in humility.
- 40:12And that's like a good thing because suddenly now you're
- 40:16recognizing, Oh my gosh, I can like, allow someone else to help
- 40:21me. I can rely on my community for
- 40:24support and care, and even that in and of itself has its own
- 40:28experience of the divine of someone showing up with a.
- 40:31Casserole. Absolutely.
- 40:33Yeah, that's beautiful. I just turned 70 and I think,
- 40:36you know, at a certain age you do a lot of life review thinking
- 40:40about the past. And I know we want to not live
- 40:43in the past or the future, but stay in the present.
- 40:46But there is a lot of life review going on and how I can
- 40:50make these last decade, this last decade or two of my life or
- 40:55three, be the best that it can be.
- 40:57Yeah. And how can I love those around
- 40:59me without judgement and with humility?
- 41:04And with humility. That's so good, Jane, that's so
- 41:07good. This is so fun.
- 41:09I'm so glad you're here and doing the work you're doing with
- 41:12the senior ministry and that you and I can sit down and chat like
- 41:16this all the time. You always give me a hard time,
- 41:18which is why I like you. Thank you, Nate.
- 41:21Thanks for taking the time to come on and talk.
- 41:23Absolutely. Yeah, I probably enjoy this
- 41:25conversation. We're going to do it again
- 41:26because you have so much to share and so much wisdom.
- 41:28This was awesome. And you, dear listener, thank
- 41:31you for listening. Share this with family and
- 41:34friends who might be interested in this type of conversation.
- 41:36And as always, stay in peace. Thank you for listening to the
- 41:39Together for Good podcast. If you'd like more resources for
- 41:43your walk of faith, please visit our website bethany-denver.org
- 41:48or download our mobile app by searching Bethany Connect in
- 41:51your phone's App Store.