Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Title VI Shared Ancestry Harassment with Beth Gellman-Beer & Amy Niedzalkoski
Transcript
- 0:02Hi, everyone. I'm Brianna Rucker, Diversity and
- 0:06Inclusion Committee Chair of the Beverly Hills
- 0:08Bar Association Barrister's Section, and I'm
- 0:11delighted to introduce today's speakers, Beth
- 0:14Gilman -Bier and Amy Needlestolkowski. Beth Gelman
- 0:21-Bier is an experienced civil rights attorney
- 0:23who's been 18 years with the U .S. Department
- 0:25of Education's Office for Civil Rights where
- 0:28she investigated and led high profile cases involving
- 0:31discrimination and harassment under Title IX,
- 0:35Title VI, Section 504 and related statutes. She
- 0:39now co -leads Evergreen Education Solutions,
- 0:42a consulting firm that provides independent investigations,
- 0:45policy guidance and training for schools. Mrs.
- 0:48Gelman -Bier also previously served as a subject
- 0:51matter expert on Title IX enforcement and compliance
- 0:54for multiple national educational initiatives.
- 0:58Amy Needle -Stilkowski is an education and civil
- 1:01rights attorney with over two decades of experience,
- 1:05including nearly 20 years at the Department of
- 1:07Education's Office for Civil Rights, where she
- 1:09served as chief regional attorney. There, she
- 1:12investigated and resolved hundreds of discrimination
- 1:15complaints and provided extensive training to
- 1:17schools and OCR staff nationwide. In 2025, she
- 1:22co -founded Evergreen Education Solutions, where
- 1:25she now offers independent investigations, policy
- 1:28consulting, and training for K -12 and post -secondary
- 1:32institutions. And now without further ado, let's
- 1:35get started. Hi everyone, thank you so much for
- 1:39joining us this afternoon for this CLE about
- 1:42the rights of students who have been subjected
- 1:45to shared ancestry harassment and the responsibility
- 1:49that schools have to those students. I'm going
- 1:52to use the term schools today, but when I'm using
- 1:55that term, it can mean a variety of different
- 1:57kinds of schools. So public K through 12 school
- 2:00districts, charter schools, post -secondary schools,
- 2:04whether it's a college, a university, a trade
- 2:07program or anything along those lines. So we
- 2:11have a lot to cover today in just an hour, but
- 2:14I quickly just want to share with you what we
- 2:16are going to be talking about today. We'll start
- 2:19with an overview of Title VI, which is the law
- 2:23that prohibits discrimination on the basis of
- 2:26shared ancestry, including in areas such as Islamophobia
- 2:30and anti -Semitism. We're going to talk about
- 2:33the types of conduct that constitute shared ancestry
- 2:36discrimination and harassment and how you and
- 2:40your staff can identify it as well as the applicable
- 2:44legal standards when these kinds of incidents
- 2:46arise at schools. We'll cover how schools should
- 2:51respond to shared ancestry, discrimination and
- 2:54harassment. And this is important for schools
- 2:57so they know how to respond. And it's also important
- 3:01for community members to have an understanding
- 3:03so they know the type of response they're entitled
- 3:07to if they should experience this type of conduct.
- 3:11We're going to share recent shared ancestry harassment
- 3:15cases with you in order to illustrate how Title
- 3:19VI works in real life examples. And we're also
- 3:23going to talk about the current legal enforcement
- 3:26landscape, including options for pursuing claims
- 3:31of shared ancestry harassment. Because Beth and
- 3:42I both come from the U .S. Department of Education
- 3:44Office for Civil Rights, we wanted to take a
- 3:47few minutes to talk about OCR because we'll refer
- 3:51to some OCR decisions during the CLE today and
- 3:55also because OCR still plays a very important
- 3:58role in addressing shared ancestry discrimination
- 4:01and harassment in schools. So, the Office for
- 4:05Civil Rights is a federal law enforcement agency.
- 4:08It's responsible for enforcing Title IX, which
- 4:11prohibits discrimination on the basis of sex,
- 4:15Section 504 and Title II of the ADA, which prohibit
- 4:18discrimination on the basis of disability, as
- 4:22well as Title VI, the law that we're here to
- 4:24talk about today. Generally, OCR has jurisdiction
- 4:28over recipients of federal financial assistance
- 4:31from the U .S. Department of Education. So public
- 4:35school districts, charter schools, colleges,
- 4:38universities, post -secondary programs, including
- 4:41even private colleges or universities, as long
- 4:45as they participate in federal financial aid.
- 4:49Generally, OCR is complaint -driven, meaning
- 4:51an individual or an organization files a complaint
- 4:54or at times OCR will be aware of something that's
- 4:58happening and it's out in the public and on its
- 5:00own, it has the ability to open a directed investigation
- 5:03and decide on its own that an investigation is
- 5:06warranted. No matter how the complaint comes
- 5:09to OCR, assuming it has jurisdiction and it's
- 5:12going to move forward, it'll conduct an investigation.
- 5:15So it's going to interview witnesses, review
- 5:17relevant documents and data. It'll make a determination
- 5:22based on that investigation. And if it finds
- 5:25that a law has been violated, it'll enter into
- 5:28what's called a resolution agreement with the
- 5:30school. And then it monitors that school's implementation
- 5:33of the agreement until the school is back into
- 5:37compliance with the law. So our focus today.
- 5:42is schools, no matter what kind of school, it's
- 5:46on education. However, we do want to acknowledge
- 5:49that shared ancestry harassment takes place in
- 5:53a variety of settings. It certainly is not limited
- 5:56to schools. And there are laws in place, both
- 5:59federal, state, local laws, to address this type
- 6:04of conduct when it happens outside of schools.
- 6:06But today our focus is going to be in the educational
- 6:09space. So that leads us to the question of why
- 6:14is it important for this training to take place
- 6:16today, especially now? In other words, why are
- 6:19we here? There's a variety of reasons. The first
- 6:22being that in the past two years or so, there's
- 6:25been a quantifiable increase in the number of
- 6:28shared ancestry discrimination and harassment
- 6:31cases. Although this is not a new problem, we've
- 6:35seen a real uptick in the number of incidents
- 6:38and cases and complaints. It's also important
- 6:42because of the harm that it can cause on a campus.
- 6:46So it's harmful to students, right? If a student
- 6:49is being harassed at school, they don't feel
- 6:51safe at school. They may have anxiety about going
- 6:54to school. We see things like decrease in their
- 6:57academic performance. decrease in attendance.
- 7:01So it's important to address from a student perspective,
- 7:04but it's also important to address for the school
- 7:07employees perspectives. It's harmful to teachers,
- 7:11administrators and staff. They also can be fearful
- 7:13of their workplace. We've seen in cases a decrease
- 7:18in employee morale or an increase in employee
- 7:22turnover, which isn't good for the stability
- 7:24of a school. And finally, it's an important topic
- 7:28to because schools that don't take action to
- 7:32address incidents of shared ancestry and discrimination
- 7:35in a timely and appropriate manner, they can
- 7:39be subject to liability, whether it's through
- 7:42an OCR complaint, a lawsuit. or bad press and
- 7:47bad publicity, which is also not good for a school.
- 7:50So our goal today is that everybody leaves today
- 7:53with an understanding of not just what shared
- 7:57ancestry harassment is, but also steps that schools
- 8:01can take to proactively address it to create
- 8:04a better environment for their students, their
- 8:06employees, and to decrease their liability. Next
- 8:11slide. So the title of our presentation today
- 8:16is Title VI, Shared Ancestry Harassment. So the
- 8:19first thing we need to talk about is what is
- 8:22Title VI? So I mentioned briefly, it's a federal
- 8:26law that prohibits discrimination on the basis
- 8:29of race, color, and national origin by recipients
- 8:33of federal financial assistance from the U .S.
- 8:36Department of Education. You'll notice that nowhere
- 8:39in the statute or in the regulations enforcing
- 8:42Title VI does the term shared ancestry appear.
- 8:47However, courts as well as OCR have long interpreted
- 8:51Title VI prohibition of national origin discrimination
- 8:55to include shared ancestry, such as Islamophobia,
- 9:00anti -Semitism. It's important to pick out that
- 9:04there's a distinction though between this Title
- 9:06VI prohibition of shared ancestry discrimination
- 9:09and religious discrimination. Title VI does not
- 9:13prohibit discrimination on the basis of religion,
- 9:16though there are other state federal and local
- 9:20laws that do. Our focus today is on the shared
- 9:24ancestry component. So I think if religious discrimination,
- 9:28for example, if a student is not allowed to join
- 9:31a particular club at school because they're Catholic
- 9:35or Muslim or Jewish or whatever the religion
- 9:37may be, that would be something that falls squarely
- 9:40within a religious discrimination context. So
- 9:43what we're talking about today isn't that it's
- 9:46something that's slightly different and we'll
- 9:48spend some time defining and giving examples
- 9:51of what we mean by shared ancestry discrimination.
- 9:56Next slide please. All right, so when we're talking
- 10:01about shared ancestry discrimination, on the
- 10:05screen, there's a list of examples. I'm gonna
- 10:08break some of them apart for us today when we're
- 10:11talking about it. So the first one we have is
- 10:14citizenship in a country with a dominant religion
- 10:17or distinct religious identity, or someone who's
- 10:21perceived to be of a particular citizenship or
- 10:24national origin. So this includes things like
- 10:28making stereotypical assumptions about somebody
- 10:31based on where they're from or saying derogatory
- 10:34things about a person who's from Israel or majority
- 10:37Muslim Middle Eastern country based on stereotypes
- 10:41or just based on that geographic or ethnic origin
- 10:44that they may have. Second on our list are racial
- 10:49ethnic or ancestral slurs or stereotypes. I don't
- 10:53want to give any specific examples of those.
- 10:55I think we all know what I mean by that, but
- 10:59we see this type of behavior come up quite frequently
- 11:03when we're talking about shared ancestry. Another
- 11:08one, third on our list, is how a person looks.
- 11:11So things like their skin color, their physical
- 11:13features, their style of dress, if it reflects
- 11:16their ethnic and religious tradition, and this
- 11:20one can be sometimes very clear. But at other
- 11:24times, it can be a little bit confusing for schools
- 11:27to address, because the context really matters.
- 11:31So the behavior matters, but as does the context.
- 11:35So I'm going to use my own child as an example.
- 11:38My son recently got what I consider to be a ridiculous
- 11:41haircut called a modern mullet, where it's kind
- 11:44of bushy on the top, a little bit longer in back,
- 11:46and sort of shaved on the sides. He did that
- 11:49and he's in high school and friends of his kind
- 11:52of joking, but they made fun of him for his haircut,
- 11:55which I completely understand. I can see where
- 11:58in a different context, if it hadn't been joking,
- 12:01that could have turned into maybe an incident
- 12:03of inappropriate behavior at school, some sort
- 12:06of bullying or something along those lines, which
- 12:09in the context for what happened to him, it was
- 12:12not, but I can see where that would have happened.
- 12:15There's clearly no shared ancestry component
- 12:18to that. it was just a bad haircut. Now, if you
- 12:21have a student who seek, who does not cut their
- 12:24hair, who may wear a turban over their hair,
- 12:27if they are made fun of because of their hair,
- 12:31if they are made fun of because of their head
- 12:33covering, that veers into shared ancestry harassment.
- 12:39And we can see where, yes, both of those incidents
- 12:43pertain to a student. and it pertains to their
- 12:47hair and how they wear their hair, how much hair
- 12:49they have, those sorts of things. But when you
- 12:52look at the underlying context, we end up with
- 12:55two very different situations. Like I said, the
- 12:58situation about my own kid, that might fall somewhere
- 13:01under a school's code of conduct and some disciplinary
- 13:05action there. But there's nothing that would
- 13:08implicate Title VI or a school's responsibilities
- 13:12under Title VI. As opposed to the second example,
- 13:16because of its tie -in to that student's ancestry
- 13:19or ethnic characteristics, that very well may
- 13:23invoke a school's Title VI responsibilities.
- 13:28Another way that shared ancestry discrimination
- 13:31and harassment can come up are students who may
- 13:34speak with a foreign accent. or have a name that
- 13:38is not a typical American name that they're being
- 13:41made fun of, or maybe names that are commonly
- 13:43associated with a particular ancestry or ethnic
- 13:47characteristic. It can also come up if students
- 13:50are speaking a foreign language at school, maybe
- 13:53of a population of students who share the same
- 13:56ancestry, and when they're together they will
- 13:59speak in a different language other than English.
- 14:02If they are being picked on, made fun of, harassed
- 14:05for that, you may have a Title VI shared ancestry
- 14:08situation that you need to address. And we are
- 14:12going to talk in a few minutes about how to determine
- 14:15if something needs to be addressed under Title
- 14:17VI. But right now, I just want you to keep these
- 14:20sort of general categories in mind. And we spend
- 14:24a lot of time talking about these examples and
- 14:27how shared ancestry comes up in schools, because
- 14:30often it's going to fall to staff to recognize
- 14:34behavior that's happening. Sometimes, oftentimes,
- 14:38students may not feel comfortable reporting something.
- 14:41It'll be staff that see it or administrators,
- 14:44and they have to determine how to address it,
- 14:47whether it's a discipline under code of conduct
- 14:50or this heightened shared ancestry Title VI standard.
- 14:55I also wanna spend a moment talking about where
- 14:58based on my experience and Beth's experience
- 15:01in investigating these kinds of cases, where
- 15:05we see this type of behavior frequently occur.
- 15:09Kids can be sneaky, right? They're not gonna
- 15:12usually harass another student in front of a
- 15:14teacher in plain view. So we see a lot of these
- 15:17incidents when classes are changing in the hallways
- 15:20at lunch, at recess, on the bus. sometimes, you
- 15:25know, after school at an extracurricular activity,
- 15:28we certainly see social media activity, whether
- 15:32it's, you know, as well as text messages, but,
- 15:35you know, whether it's through Snapchat, just
- 15:38Instagram messaging, whatever it may be. So the
- 15:41short answer is it can occur anywhere, but the
- 15:45lesson or the takeaway is just because it's not
- 15:47happening in plain view doesn't mean that it's
- 15:51not happening. At the post -secondary level,
- 15:54it can be the same places that we talk about
- 15:57with K through 12. However, sometimes we have
- 16:00seen incidents that can rise to the level of
- 16:03shared ancestry harassment within a classroom,
- 16:06right? So you're balancing that academic freedom
- 16:08and First Amendment issues sometimes with where
- 16:12does it cross the line and veer into a Title
- 16:15VI problem. Certainly, we see it at protests,
- 16:18which also requires a careful balance with First
- 16:22Amendment rights and protections, but there is
- 16:27often a line where those First Amendment protections
- 16:30that line is crossed and it becomes something
- 16:33that's more of a harassing behavior. So all of
- 16:37these cases always turn on a case -by -case analysis.
- 16:41Sometimes you can have the same set of facts,
- 16:44but they occur at two different times and can
- 16:46lead to two different outcomes depending on the
- 16:50context. Next slide, please. Okay, so now we
- 16:59know about Title VI, and we know about the types
- 17:03of conduct that might rise to the level of shared
- 17:06ancestry harassment. The next thing that's really
- 17:09important for us to understand is when does conduct
- 17:13that's based on shared ancestry rise to the level
- 17:16of unlawful harassment or discrimination? And
- 17:20when does a school become liable for that harassment?
- 17:23Or said another way, how does a school avoid
- 17:27liability? So if you've done this kind of work
- 17:31in the past or done it for a while, you know
- 17:34that traditionally OCR used a different standard
- 17:38than the courts did for evaluating or analyzing
- 17:42cases involving Title VI harassment issues. And
- 17:47all of that changed on May 22nd, 2025 when OCR
- 17:52in conjunction with HHS released a decision letter
- 17:57involving Columbia University. So prior to May
- 18:0222nd, the first thing we would look for is did
- 18:06a hostile environment exist, meaning was there
- 18:08unwelcome conduct that subjectively and objectively
- 18:12one would find offensive and it was so severe
- 18:14pervasive that it limited a student's ability
- 18:17to access the education program or activity of
- 18:21the school. If that occurred, we then would look
- 18:25to see, did the school have actual or constructive
- 18:28notice of that conduct? Meaning, did they know
- 18:30about it or should they have known about it?
- 18:33You know, if there was all these rumors going
- 18:35around about something that happened, a school
- 18:37couldn't just say, well, nobody filed a complaint
- 18:39if a reasonable person would have known that
- 18:42that harassing conduct was occurring. And then
- 18:45third, once we had the harassing conduct, once
- 18:49we knew the recipient knew about it, We would
- 18:51look to see if a recipient took prompt and effective
- 18:55action that would end the harassment, eliminate
- 18:57the hostile environment and its effects, and
- 19:01reasonably prevent it from reoccurring. In the
- 19:05Columbia letter, OCR adopted the standard that
- 19:10courts use in deciding these cases. And that
- 19:13really changed the analysis of the facts. So
- 19:18now for the first prong, and I'm over on the
- 19:20slide on the left -hand side. We still look to
- 19:23see if there's a hostile environment that existed,
- 19:26though it's defined slightly differently. We
- 19:28now look to see whether individuals who are associated
- 19:31with the school were subject to severe or pervasive
- 19:34harassment that was motivated at least in part
- 19:37by their race, their color, their national origin,
- 19:40their shared ancestry. Generally, under both
- 19:45standards, one incident is not enough to get
- 19:49to that severe or pervasive standard. I said
- 19:53generally though, it really does depend on the
- 19:56severity of the incident. So for example, one
- 20:00incident of graffiti may not be enough, but one
- 20:04incident, if you have a student who's been physically
- 20:06assaulted because of their shared ancestry, that
- 20:10would arguably be more severe than that one graffiti
- 20:13incident, and that may be enough. to get you
- 20:16over the hurdle for to find that there's a hostile
- 20:19environment. Like I said, the most important
- 20:21thing to keep in mind, these are case by case
- 20:24example of situations for you have to analyze.
- 20:27So every time it happens, you're sort of starting
- 20:29from scratch thinking about how you're going
- 20:31to make these determinations. The second thing
- 20:35now that we've moved over to the court standard
- 20:38as of May 22nd is in order to be liable, the
- 20:42school has to have actual notice. So it's not
- 20:46enough that they should have known. We're really
- 20:49looking that somebody in the school knew what
- 20:52happened. Doesn't necessarily mean that a student
- 20:55has to go and fill out a complaint form and say,
- 20:58I was discriminated against on the basis of my
- 21:00shared ancestry. But the facts have to be known
- 21:04to the school in order to trigger their obligation
- 21:07to take action under Title VI. Third, The school
- 21:13has to have the ability to exercise substantial
- 21:16control over the harassers. This is usually pretty
- 21:19simple in the K through 12 environment because
- 21:22the school is going to have control over their
- 21:23students, over their teachers, over their administrators.
- 21:27It's often not that difficult in a college or
- 21:30university setting, but it can become complicated,
- 21:33especially if we're talking about issues that
- 21:37arise during protests. Often we've seen that
- 21:42students will protest, but they will be joined
- 21:44by non -students. So for example, Beth and I
- 21:47are located outside of Philadelphia. There was
- 21:50recently, towards the end of the spring semester,
- 21:53a school in this area where there was a protester
- 21:57sitting on campus, areas of campus were being
- 22:00blocked, entrances to buildings, those type of
- 22:02things. The police were called in in order to
- 22:07move the protester so people could gain access.
- 22:09to the campus spaces. But in reading about the
- 22:13police when they came and arrests were made,
- 22:15of all the people who were arrested, only one
- 22:18of them was actually a student of that school.
- 22:21So you can see where you might, if you're in
- 22:23the college and university or post -secondary
- 22:26setting, you really need to parse out who did
- 22:29the school have control over at the particular
- 22:32time the incident took place. The fourth prong.
- 22:37And this is the biggest change from the prior
- 22:40standard is if you look on the right, we used
- 22:43to look to see if the school took specific actions
- 22:46in response to an incident or a hostile environment,
- 22:49right? We look to see that they take action to
- 22:52end the harassment, to remedy its effects, to
- 22:55prevent it from reoccurring again. The standard
- 22:58for establishing liability now is what we call
- 23:02the deliberate indifference standard. And this
- 23:05is arguably a much lower bar for schools to have
- 23:10to show. There's not a uniform definition of
- 23:15what deliberate indifference means, but generally
- 23:18speaking, if we go through all the cases and
- 23:20we were to put together an explanation, we would
- 23:23say we were looking to see was the school's response
- 23:26clearly unreasonable in light of known circumstances.
- 23:31And from what we've seen in cases that look at
- 23:37the deliberate or the facts under the deliberate
- 23:39indifference standard, that bar just is not as
- 23:41high as it was under the previous standard. For
- 23:45example, in the Eastern District of Pennsylvania,
- 23:48there was recently a lawsuit against Haverford
- 23:51College. In that complaint, there's a number
- 23:54of examples of alleged shared ancestry harassment
- 23:59that took place. One of which was an incoming
- 24:01freshmen who was part of a group chat of incoming
- 24:06freshmen. And because of comments that were made
- 24:09during that group chat, this particular freshmen
- 24:12decided not to matriculate into the college.
- 24:15That was one of the examples the plaintiffs provided
- 24:18in support of their complaint. The judge in that
- 24:23case though found that the college did not act
- 24:26with deliberate indifference because once the
- 24:29student notified the college that they were not
- 24:31going to matriculate a dean called the student
- 24:35and said we heard you're not going to come we
- 24:37heard why we wanted to let you know you can file
- 24:40a complaint against that the student decided
- 24:43not to file the complaint and that they were
- 24:45not going to enroll. Here the court said that
- 24:48was enough to show that the college did not act
- 24:51with deliberate indifference because somebody
- 24:54did call the student, let them know that they
- 24:56had an option to file a complaint if they wanted
- 24:59to. There the college wasn't obligated under
- 25:04this court decision to look into what had happened,
- 25:07to take action if it was warranted. against whatever
- 25:11was said in that group chat. So we really are
- 25:14working with a lesser burden now for schools.
- 25:19Next slide, please. So what does a school need
- 25:25to do or what should they do in order to show
- 25:28that they're not deliberately indifferent when
- 25:30an incident arises? Likewise, if you're a victim
- 25:35of of shared ancestry harassment, what can you
- 25:38expect from your school as a response? So the
- 25:42short answer is Title VI doesn't specify the
- 25:45steps that a school has to take in response to
- 25:48conduct or allegations of shared ancestry harassment.
- 25:52But we can look to previous OCR decisions or
- 25:56court decisions for guidance and best practices.
- 25:59Something else to keep in mind, this deliberate
- 26:03indifference standard is really the floor. it's
- 26:05not saying that you can't do more, and we would
- 26:10recommend as a best practice that you do do what
- 26:13you, as much as you can to address the incident,
- 26:17keeping in mind those steps of the previous standards
- 26:20about stopping the harassment, taking action
- 26:23to prevent its reoccurrence, remedying the effects
- 26:27on the victim of the harassment in the first
- 26:31place. You know at the end of the day you have
- 26:32a school to run and we think about those early
- 26:36points that I made about the effect that this
- 26:38type of conduct can have on students, can have
- 26:41on staff, can have on your school environment.
- 26:45So the first thing we would expect to see once
- 26:48an incident arises is that the school's going
- 26:51to interview the complainant, interview the respondent
- 26:55or the accused student to the extent that there
- 26:57is an identified respondent, as well as any witnesses.
- 27:02That interview should really focus on the who,
- 27:04what, where, when, why, and how about the incident
- 27:07and follow up on what you learned. If Beth makes
- 27:11a complaint and in interviewing Beth, she says,
- 27:14well, Amy was there when it happened. then you're
- 27:17going to want to reach out to Amy and talk to
- 27:19Amy. Or if Beth makes the complaint and says,
- 27:23this particular respondent has done the same
- 27:25thing to five other people, we'd recommend trying
- 27:28to talk to those five other people to get a sense
- 27:31for what is happening here. It's also vitally
- 27:35important that you document your interviews and
- 27:38your efforts for future use. possible that an
- 27:43OCR complaint or a lawsuit will come at some
- 27:46point in the future. And you need to be able
- 27:48to show that you weren't deliberately indifferent,
- 27:50that you did take action. And the best way to
- 27:52do that is through documenting all the steps
- 27:55along the way. Make sure you collect evidence
- 27:58from anywhere it may exist. Pictures are very
- 28:01important. Screenshots of social media posts,
- 28:04those kinds of things. You'll want to review
- 28:07relevant recordings. We always recommend, if
- 28:10there is video, to get that video, backup that
- 28:13video, and save it. Often school video, bus video
- 28:18will... kind of run on a loop and re -record
- 28:21after a relatively short period of time, so it's
- 28:24very important to preserve that early. Same thing
- 28:26with social media posts, text message exchanges,
- 28:30if you have swipe card records of when students,
- 28:32you know, swiped into a building or swiped into
- 28:35a classroom, those sorts of things to keep, get
- 28:38all of that early and just preserve it. Once
- 28:42you've gathered all of your facts, you're going
- 28:44to need to make a determination about whether
- 28:47a hostile environment existed, right? Through
- 28:50your investigation, did you find that this conduct
- 28:53was severe or pervasive that requires a response
- 28:57under Title VI? You might find that it doesn't
- 29:00require a response under Title VI, but it may
- 29:03be violated another provision of your Code of
- 29:05Conduct, in which case you should feel free to
- 29:09discipline that way. You know, maybe it was inappropriate
- 29:11language. Maybe it was something else that violates
- 29:16the Code of Conduct but didn't rise the level
- 29:18of Title VI harassment. You could still take
- 29:20action for that. And finally, notify both parties
- 29:23of the outcome of the complaint. If there is
- 29:27any appeal rights, based on your school's policy,
- 29:30those sorts of things, right? Students need to
- 29:32know what happened to the complaint after they
- 29:36reported it. One other thing I'll point out very
- 29:39quickly is that sometimes students and even parents
- 29:42are reluctant to report. They're afraid of retaliation.
- 29:45They're afraid of making noise. I just want to
- 29:48point out that Title VI also has a retaliation
- 29:51provision. So if somebody makes a report of alleged
- 29:56Title VI harassment, It's imperative that retaliatory
- 30:01actions aren't taken against them. And if they
- 30:03are, or if they report there was retaliation,
- 30:06that that is investigated as well. So with that,
- 30:10I'm going to turn it over to Beth. Good afternoon,
- 30:14everyone. So now that Amy has discussed with
- 30:19you what the appropriate legal standard is to
- 30:21apply to these complaints and the importance
- 30:24of conducting an investigation and making a determination,
- 30:26I want to talk about What's next? So you've collected
- 30:30your evidence, you've done your interviews, you've
- 30:32made a determination, and you have determined
- 30:35that the incident that is the subject of the
- 30:38complaint has created a hostile environment.
- 30:40What's the next steps? On the screen in front
- 30:43of you are some of the best practices that Amy
- 30:46and I have identified through our work in negotiating
- 30:49resolution agreements with schools that we investigated
- 30:52for shared ancestry, harassment, and discrimination.
- 30:55Now remember, Amy talked about this deliberate
- 30:58indifference standards. So what we're going to
- 31:00talk about right now are some of the steps that
- 31:02you can take to show to OCR, to show to a court,
- 31:06to show to any other administrative agency that
- 31:09you haven't been deliberately indifferent in
- 31:11the face of shared ancestry harassment or discrimination.
- 31:15These are all provisions that Amy and I have
- 31:18included in resolution agreements. But like Amy
- 31:21said, you are not limited to these provisions.
- 31:24You can certainly take other steps that you see
- 31:27fit in a particular case. And as you will see
- 31:30in the case materials that we provided, we provided
- 31:35several resolution agreements. The provisions
- 31:38in those agreements, they do look similar, but
- 31:40they're not identical for every case. And that's
- 31:43because the facts of each case are really unique.
- 31:45which requires a unique response to those facts.
- 31:49So I'm going to talk about some best practices,
- 31:51but again, you don't have to implement all or
- 31:54you can implement all and some others as well.
- 31:57So I'm going to dive right in. The first best
- 32:01practice that I want to talk about is discipline,
- 32:03but I want to add two caveats to that best practice.
- 32:08First, in the work that Amy and I have done,
- 32:11not just in the shared ancestry space, but for
- 32:15all complaints of harassment. We have seen on
- 32:17a number of occasions that in response to a hostile
- 32:20environment, the natural step that a school will
- 32:23take is to discipline the respondent or the offending
- 32:26parties, which is a good first step. However,
- 32:29what we often also see is that that's the last
- 32:32step for a lot of schools. And in our experience
- 32:34in working these cases for decades, Discipline
- 32:39alone is rarely sufficient to end a hostile environment.
- 32:43So while it is a good first step, it's really
- 32:45important to think about other steps that you
- 32:48need to take to remedy that hostile environment.
- 32:51The other caveat that I want to add is that there's
- 32:54a threshold matter of coding your incidents correctly.
- 32:57So I'm going to talk about a case later on where
- 33:00students were clearly engaging in antisemitic
- 33:03behavior and the school coded the disciplinary
- 33:07sanctions as inappropriate behavior rather than
- 33:11as harassment. The sanctions for inappropriate
- 33:14behavior were much less severe than the sanctions
- 33:17would have been had they been coded as harassment.
- 33:20So while discipline is a really important best
- 33:23practice, before you get to meeting out your
- 33:27discipline, you must make sure that you're coding
- 33:30these incidents properly so that the disciplinary
- 33:33sanctions you impose match the offense. The next
- 33:37best practice is no contact order, safety plan,
- 33:40separation and housing, dining, work, et cetera.
- 33:44The only caveat that I will add to that is you
- 33:46can implement a no contact order or a safety
- 33:49plan at any point during the investigation. But
- 33:52if you're going to take a step that places a
- 33:55burden on the respondent, like moving them out
- 33:57of their housing or moving them out of their
- 34:00work schedule, it's really important first to
- 34:03make a determination that that respondent has
- 34:05engaged in a hostile environment. The next best
- 34:08practice is a message from the president or the
- 34:11superintendent condemning the incident or the
- 34:16behavior. It seems simple enough, but this is
- 34:18actually one of the most well -received steps
- 34:21that a school can take by the community. The
- 34:25next best practice is actually one of my favorites,
- 34:28training. The training should address various
- 34:31groups. So first, training for students, so they
- 34:35understand what shared ancestry harassment looks
- 34:37like, so they understand what the consequences
- 34:40are for engaging in that kind of behavior, so
- 34:42they understand what the school's policies and
- 34:44procedures are under Title VI, and they understand
- 34:47where and how to report this kind of conduct.
- 34:50The next is training for your staff, so they
- 34:52also understand what shared ancestry harassment
- 34:54looks like. So they understand what the school's
- 34:57policies and procedures are and what are the
- 34:59school's obligations for responding to Title
- 35:01VI incidents. And last but really important is
- 35:05training for your investigators and your decision
- 35:07makers so they too have a firm understanding
- 35:10of what constitutes shared ancestry, harassment,
- 35:13and discrimination. They understand how to do
- 35:15a fulsome investigation like the one that Amy
- 35:17just described. They understand that they need
- 35:20to make a determination and notify the parties.
- 35:23They understand the appropriate legal standard
- 35:26to apply, severe or pervasive, objectively offensive.
- 35:30And they understand what their obligations are
- 35:32to respond to a hostile environment under Title
- 35:35VI. The next best practice is education for the
- 35:39respondent. We see this take a variety of forms,
- 35:43most often asking the respondent to write an
- 35:46essay on Title VI shared ancestry, write an apology
- 35:50note to the victim or the victims. or engage
- 35:52in very specific targeted Title VI shared ancestry
- 35:55training and the like. The next best practice
- 35:59is my favorite. It's a climate survey. This is
- 36:02where you're going to distribute some kind of
- 36:04questionnaire to your students and your staff
- 36:06asking about generally the climate at school.
- 36:09The questions we would expect to see is to ask
- 36:12them Are they familiar with Title VI? Are they
- 36:15familiar with the school's policies and procedures
- 36:16addressing Title VI? Have they experienced Title
- 36:20VI shared ancestry harassment? Do they know somebody
- 36:22who's experienced it? Where did it occur? Who
- 36:26did it? Did they report it to the school? If
- 36:28not, why not? If they did report it to the school,
- 36:31were they satisfied with the school's response?
- 36:34You can do this kind of questionnaire any way
- 36:36that you want. Traditionally, schools do this
- 36:39through a questionnaire that's sent out through
- 36:41email, but you don't have to do it that way.
- 36:43You can do focus groups. You can do interviews.
- 36:47Whatever method you choose, it's really important
- 36:50information that's going to give you a bird's
- 36:53eye level view of the culture at your school
- 36:55and of the areas that are problematic. And this
- 36:59information is going to especially inform the
- 37:01individual at your school who is tasked with
- 37:03coordinating responses to Title VI complaints
- 37:06to have information so that they can act proactively
- 37:10rather than always reactively to complaints,
- 37:13meaning they will have information showing what
- 37:16are the areas of concern at their school, and
- 37:18they can develop outreach, education, other kind
- 37:21of preventive measures to tackle this proactively
- 37:24rather than waiting to receive a complaint. The
- 37:28next best practice is some kind of individual
- 37:30remedy for the victim and not just the person
- 37:34who's filed the complaint. What we often see
- 37:37when you conduct an investigation is that you'll
- 37:39learn that there's more than one victim beyond
- 37:41just the person who filed the complaint. So for
- 37:43any victim that you've identified in your investigation,
- 37:47you should be offering some kind of individual
- 37:49remedy to that individual. Typically, that's
- 37:52counseling, reimbursement for past counseling,
- 37:55academic support, reaching out to a student's
- 37:58professors to coordinate extensions for assignments,
- 38:02tuition, academic reimbursement, and the like.
- 38:05The last best practice is to take a close look
- 38:08at your policies and procedures, make sure that
- 38:11they adequately address Title VI shared ancestry
- 38:13harassment. Do they describe what Title VI shared
- 38:16ancestry harassment looked like? Do they describe
- 38:19the sanctions available for engaging in this
- 38:22kind of conduct? Do they explain what steps the
- 38:25school will take to respond to Title VI complaints
- 38:28and the like? Now, before I move on to the next
- 38:33slide, I just wanna make a few points that Amy
- 38:36Tuftshawn might be as well. First, there are
- 38:39going to be incidents, particularly in the shared
- 38:42ancestry space, where free speech is at play
- 38:45in an incident. And this is an area where we
- 38:47have noticed a lot of problems in terms of the
- 38:50way that the school responds. Meaning, what we
- 38:53often see is when there's an incident that involves
- 38:56free speech, oftentimes, The schools won't touch
- 39:00the incident. They won't investigate. They won't
- 39:02resolve. They won't make a determination because
- 39:04it's free speech. And that's not the appropriate
- 39:07response. There's one limitation when there's
- 39:11an incident that involves free speech. That limitation
- 39:14is that you cannot discipline the respondent.
- 39:18But as you can see from the slide, there are
- 39:22a myriad of other responses that you can take
- 39:25in the face of an incident that also invokes
- 39:29free speech. You have an obligation as a school,
- 39:32even when there's free speech, to determine whether
- 39:35that free speech incident created a hostile environment
- 39:38at the same time. And if so, take steps to address
- 39:42that hostile environment, the only limitation
- 39:44being one of those steps cannot be disciplined
- 39:47against the respondent. The other thing that
- 39:50I wanted to mention that Amy touched on as well
- 39:52is that even if an incident doesn't rise to the
- 39:55level of a Title VI hostile environment, there
- 39:57may be other provisions of your student code
- 39:59of conduct that you should pursue. So for example,
- 40:03in an entire year, your school had one incident
- 40:05of graffiti that's probably not going to be sufficiently
- 40:09severe, probably not going to be sufficiently
- 40:11pervasive, but. you do have a provision of your
- 40:15code of conduct that addresses vandalism and
- 40:17you should pursue that vandalism and charges
- 40:20for it under the appropriate code of conduct
- 40:22provision. The last thing that I wanted to mention
- 40:25is that a lot of these incidents also involve
- 40:28law enforcement and oftentimes law enforcement
- 40:32will ask you to pause your Title VI investigation
- 40:35while they complete their critical fact gathering
- 40:38and that's okay. You can pause your investigation
- 40:41but your investigation pause should not be inordinately
- 40:45delayed or indefinitely paused. And you should
- 40:49not rely upon the police determination for your
- 40:54Title VI determination. Meaning, even when the
- 40:56police is involved, even when the police dismisses
- 40:59a complaint, you still have an obligation as
- 41:02a school to conduct your own independent Title
- 41:05VI investigation and resolution. The reason being
- 41:09that the legal standard of proof for crime is
- 41:11very, very high. the legal standard of proof
- 41:14for Title VI violation is much, much lower. You
- 41:17should not be applying this really high legal
- 41:19standard to the Title VI realm. You can use the
- 41:24evidence that the police gathered for your fact
- 41:26gathering, but you should not use their determination
- 41:29as a substitute for your Title VI determination.
- 41:35Okay. Moving right along, I'm going to delve
- 41:38into some case reviews. The first three are cases
- 41:42that Amy and I helped to investigate and resolve
- 41:45while we were at OCR. The last one that Amy had
- 41:48already mentioned is the first of its kind coming
- 41:50out of OCR, a violation letter addressing shared
- 41:54ancestry harassment. So the first case I want
- 41:57to talk about is the Red Play Consolidated School
- 41:59District. This is a K through 12 public school
- 42:02district. The basis for the complaint was an
- 42:04incident where three students created a paper
- 42:06airplane with writing in red ink that stated,
- 42:09blood of the Jews. with red ink splattered onto
- 42:12the airplane to mimic blood, and there were several
- 42:15swastikas drawn onto the plane as well. One of
- 42:18the students stood up in front of an entire classroom
- 42:20of students, threw the paper airplane at a Jewish
- 42:22student, it hit her leg, and it fell onto the
- 42:25floor. The incident was captured on video recording,
- 42:28which was provided to OCR, which OCR reviewed
- 42:30as part of its investigation. But also, once
- 42:33the incident was brought to the complainant's
- 42:35attention, she asked the school to go back and
- 42:37take a look at a longer portion of the recording.
- 42:40to see if anything occurred before or after the
- 42:43paper airplane incident. And in reviewing that
- 42:45video footage, the school discovered that there
- 42:48was in fact another incident that occurred shortly
- 42:50after the paper airplane incident in which the
- 42:53same three students stood up and did a high Hitler
- 42:55salute directed towards the Jewish student. As
- 42:58Amy mentioned, by the time this incident was
- 43:01discovered and by the time OCR initiated our
- 43:03investigation, that recording was gone and we
- 43:06were unable to review it. The investigation that
- 43:10OCR conducted also revealed that there were repeated
- 43:12incidents of spastic avandalism, several of them
- 43:15directed towards the Jewish student herself and
- 43:18others just more generally throughout the school
- 43:20building. In response to the incidents, several
- 43:24of the offending students were disciplined, the
- 43:27victim met with the school counselor, the school
- 43:29separated the students. At some point, some of
- 43:32the offending students were removed from the
- 43:34victim's classroom. The school implemented a
- 43:37safety plan, a daily check -in for the respondent,
- 43:40and the school also held class assemblies on
- 43:43behavior and bullying generally. OCR identified
- 43:47some concerns in the school's response to the
- 43:50incidents. First, several of the incidents were
- 43:54not documented and provided to OCR during OCR's
- 43:58investigation. So OCR asked for all documentation
- 44:01of the school's investigation and resolution
- 44:04of shared ancestry complaints within a specific
- 44:07time frame. The district gave some, but not all
- 44:11of the documentation because they simply didn't
- 44:13have it. OCR obtained that documentation from
- 44:16other sources. And so this goes back to what
- 44:19Amy said earlier. the importance of documenting
- 44:22your investigations and your determinations so
- 44:25that when OCR or a court or another administrative
- 44:28agency is looking at your school and how it responds
- 44:31to shared ancestry complaints, you can provide
- 44:34documentation showing that you were not deliberately
- 44:36indifferent in the face of these incidents. Another
- 44:40concern that OCR identified is that the offending
- 44:45students wore discipline for some but not all
- 44:48of the incidents. So for example, the three students
- 44:51who threw the paper airplane, they were disciplined
- 44:53for that incident, but they were not disciplined
- 44:56for the high Hitler salute incident. Also, as
- 44:59I mentioned earlier, for almost all of the incidents,
- 45:01they were miscoded as inappropriate behavior.
- 45:04So the disciplinary sanctions didn't match the
- 45:07offense, but also it impeded the school's ability
- 45:11to see the sum total of all the incidents in
- 45:14the aggregate. to see whether or not there really
- 45:16was a pervasive environment of harassment on
- 45:19the basis of shared ancestry, because they weren't
- 45:21coding the incidents properly. Also, the school
- 45:25implemented a safety plan, but that plan wasn't
- 45:27implemented until about two months after the
- 45:30behavior started. And even when it was implemented,
- 45:33it wasn't always enforced. So the respondent
- 45:35violated that safety plan on a number of occasions,
- 45:38creating a very uncomfortable environment for
- 45:40the victim. Last, OCR reviewed the discipline
- 45:45records for the students that were engaging in
- 45:47this behavior and observed that these were not
- 45:50isolated incidents, that these students have
- 45:52been engaging in harassing behavior on all bases,
- 45:56racial harassment, sexual harassment, shared
- 45:58ancestry harassment for over a year. And so clearly
- 46:01the steps that the school was taking to address
- 46:03these students is not effective. The remedies
- 46:07that OCR negotiated through the resolution agreement
- 46:10are many of the same that we discussed in the
- 46:12prior slide, counseling and reimbursement for
- 46:15counseling for the victim. OCR asked that the
- 46:18school publish an anti -harassment statement
- 46:20on its website and also notify the community
- 46:23through email of that anti -harassment statement.
- 46:26OCR asked the school to revise their policies
- 46:28and procedures and conduct Title VI training
- 46:31for staff and students and distribute a climate
- 46:33survey. Also here because OCR identified concerns
- 46:37with their record keeping practices, meaning
- 46:39they weren't sufficiently documenting their investigation
- 46:42and resolution of incidents. Another provision
- 46:45in the agreement was to ask the district to develop
- 46:48some kind of record keeping process or procedure
- 46:51and provide documentation of its investigation
- 46:56and resolution of complaints under that procedure
- 46:58for a two year period moving forward. OK, the
- 47:03next case that I want to discuss is Muhlenberg
- 47:05College, which is a post -secondary case. The
- 47:09basis for this complaint was a professor's conduct
- 47:12in the classroom and on social media following
- 47:15October 7. In total, there were eight complaints
- 47:19that were filed against this professor by both
- 47:21students and staff over about a six -month period
- 47:25alleging shared ancestry harassment through her
- 47:27conduct in the classroom and on social media.
- 47:31So on one incident, she took a picture of a display
- 47:33on campus that was developed by Hillel. She posted
- 47:37on her social media account and made derogatory
- 47:39statements about the students who made the display.
- 47:42In another, she made a repost to her social media
- 47:45stating that Zionists should be shamed and not
- 47:48welcomed into your spaces. The evidence also
- 47:51showed that the professor and her partner engaged
- 47:53directly with students on her social media in
- 47:56a derogatory manner. During OCR's investigation,
- 48:00OCR also reviewed 25 other reports of shared
- 48:04ancestry discrimination and harassment, including
- 48:07swastika vandalism on student doors, social media
- 48:11postings, chalkings on campus, and tearing down
- 48:15posters of hostages on student doors. The investigation
- 48:19did reveal that college administrators met several
- 48:22times with the professor to discuss her conduct.
- 48:26but OCR nonetheless identified some concerns.
- 48:29First, it appears that they considered each report
- 48:32in isolation instead of looking at all of the
- 48:36complaints together to assess whether the conduct
- 48:39was sufficiently pervasive to have created a
- 48:42hostile environment, even if one incident alone
- 48:45was not sufficiently severe. So remember, the
- 48:48standard is severe or pervasive. So even if an
- 48:50incident is not severe enough alone. If you look
- 48:54at the aggregate of the complaints, you might
- 48:56start to see a pattern of pervasive harassment.
- 49:01Also, OCR identified concern in that the college
- 49:05did make a determination about the professor's
- 49:07conduct and whether it created a hostile environment,
- 49:09but only in two of the eight complaints that
- 49:12were filed against her. And in the two complaints
- 49:15where the college made that determination, it
- 49:17used the wrong legal standard. So to determine
- 49:20whether or not the professor had created a hostile
- 49:22environment, the college looked at whether or
- 49:25not she was directly targeting students. That's
- 49:28not part of the legal standard that Amy described
- 49:31earlier. Also, the emails. did reflect that college
- 49:35staff acknowledged and recognized that the professor's
- 49:39conduct was interfering with students' ability
- 49:41to access the educational environment. But other
- 49:43than speaking with the professor on a few occasions,
- 49:46there really wasn't much evidence to show that
- 49:48the college addressed that impeded educational
- 49:53environment. So the resolution agreement is also
- 49:56in the course materials that we provided, includes
- 49:59a lot of the same provisions we talked about.
- 50:01Title VI training, climate survey. And in this
- 50:05particular case, OCR asked that the college provide
- 50:08documentation of their investigation and determination
- 50:11for all of the remaining complaints made against
- 50:14the professor and all of the other incidents
- 50:16that were reported to the college in a specific
- 50:19timeframe. You will also see that this agreement
- 50:22is a little smaller than some of the other agreements.
- 50:24And that's because OCR did recognize that the
- 50:27college took many important steps. So for example,
- 50:31The president emailed the college community to
- 50:33address shared ancestry harassment. Administrators
- 50:37provided direct support and check -ins with the
- 50:39Muslim, Palestinian, and Jewish students. The
- 50:42college created a brochure about doxing and distributed
- 50:46it to the college campus. They also distributed
- 50:48a five -minute video outlining the college's
- 50:52Title VI process, and they conducted training
- 50:54for staff and students. You'll also notice in
- 50:56this particular resolution agreement, OCR did
- 50:59not ask the college to revise their policies
- 51:01and procedures, and that's because OCR determined
- 51:04that those policies and procedures were sufficient
- 51:07to address Title VI shared ancestry harassment.
- 51:11I am so sorry for speaking so quickly. I'm trying
- 51:13to get through all this material. Okay. The next
- 51:16one is Lafayette College. It's another post -secondary
- 51:19case. The basis for this complaint was a protest
- 51:22that occurred on campus on October 25th. 2023,
- 51:26administrators knew about the protest, so they
- 51:28attended it to observe. And while they were observing,
- 51:31they saw a student holding a poster that read,
- 51:36From the River to the Sea. Following the protest,
- 51:39they identified the student, and the college
- 51:41chaplain spoke to the student on a number of
- 51:43occasions to explain to the student why that
- 51:46phrase could be offensive to Jewish students.
- 51:49The college president also issued a statement
- 51:52shortly after the protest. saying basically the
- 51:54same. During OCR's investigation, OCR also looked
- 51:58at 11 other complaints of shared ancestry discrimination
- 52:02and harassment, those mostly focused on social
- 52:05media postings. OCR did identify concerns, but
- 52:10interestingly here, OCR did not identify a concern
- 52:14with the protest or how the college responded
- 52:17to the student that was folding the poster. So
- 52:19for example, this is a good example. of a college
- 52:22addressing a potentially hostile environment,
- 52:26even where free speech was involved. So the student
- 52:28held up a poster that invokes free speech. The
- 52:31student was not disciplined, but the college
- 52:34chaplain did speak to the student on a number
- 52:37of occasions, and the college president did issue
- 52:39a statement to the college community addressing
- 52:42it. The concern that OCR identified was actually
- 52:45in the way that the college responded to or in
- 52:48fact did not respond to private social media
- 52:51postings. The college had a categorical policy
- 52:55to not address allegations of harassment on private
- 52:58social media or off -campus conduct, which is
- 53:01a misunderstanding of its obligations under Title
- 53:04VI. So schools must assess whether conduct that
- 53:08occurs off -campus or on private social media
- 53:11creates a hostile environment that spills over
- 53:14into the college community. You'll see that the
- 53:18remedies and the resolution agreement here are
- 53:21much like the Muhlenberg College Resolution Agreement.
- 53:24It's a smaller agreement, and OCR also acknowledged
- 53:27that the college took positive steps like the
- 53:29email from the college president, increased security
- 53:32around religious spaces. The president and the
- 53:35chaplain met with Hillel on a number of occasions,
- 53:38and they had meetings with the student who held
- 53:40the poster. So the remedies here were a revision
- 53:43of policies and procedures, investigator training,
- 53:46staff and student training, and file reviews.
- 53:50Okay, so the last case I want to discuss is Columbia
- 53:54University. Amy and I had no involvement in this
- 53:56case. So what I'm going to discuss is really
- 53:58just based on our review of the letter and our
- 54:00knowledge of OCR processes. This is the first
- 54:04violation letter on the basis of shared ancestry
- 54:06coming out of OCR. It was a joint letter from
- 54:10HHS OCR and Ed OCR on May 22nd, 2025 following
- 54:16a three month investigation. Since the preparation
- 54:19of this PowerPoint, there's actually been another
- 54:21letter issued against Harvard University that
- 54:24was not jointly issued. That was issued solely
- 54:27by HHS OCR, and that was published on June 30th,
- 54:312025. That letter is very, very similar to the
- 54:34Columbia University letter. The most important
- 54:38takeaway from this letter is, as Amy discussed,
- 54:41a significant shift in the legal standard that's
- 54:44applied in Title VI Hostile environment cases.
- 54:48So it used to be prompt and effective. Now it's
- 54:50the deliberate and different standard. And that
- 54:52standard is the same that's used by the courts.
- 54:55Interestingly enough, it's also the same standard
- 54:57that is written into the Title IX regulation
- 54:59for Title IX sexual harassment. So as Amy described
- 55:05earlier, there are five prongs to assess whether
- 55:11or not a school has been deliberately indifferent
- 55:14in the face of shared ancestry harassment or
- 55:16discrimination. The Columbia letter goes into
- 55:19those five prongs, and I'm going to briefly discuss
- 55:22the evidence that OCR relied upon to meet each
- 55:26of those five prongs. So the first prong that
- 55:29Amy discussed, you have to establish that there
- 55:31was a hostile environment. Was the conduct objectively
- 55:34offensive and severe or pervasive? Here, OCR
- 55:38concluded that it was, and the evidence that
- 55:40they cited too was unauthorized protests with
- 55:44threatening and intimidating rhetoric, protesters
- 55:47blocking access, disrupting a class about the
- 55:51history of Israel and using language that was
- 55:53berating to Jewish students, reports of physical
- 55:56harm to Jewish students, acts of anti -Semitic
- 55:58vandalism, harassing speech like globalized Antifada,
- 56:02death to the Zionist state, Hamas, we love you,
- 56:05and burnt Tel Aviv to the ground. First prong,
- 56:08hostile environment established through severe
- 56:10and pervasive conduct. Second prong is to establish
- 56:14that the education environment has been impeded.
- 56:17OCR cited evidence showing that the educational
- 56:20environment was impeded here through students
- 56:23inability to enter classrooms, to enter school
- 56:27buildings, to walk across campus because there
- 56:30were barricades, protests, and encampments, and
- 56:34because students had occupied certain buildings.
- 56:37Third prong is actual knowledge. And here OCR
- 56:41cited to evidence that the university had actual
- 56:44knowledge of the harassing conduct. It was established
- 56:47through complaints filed with the university,
- 56:50press reports, lawsuits, congressional inquiries,
- 56:53and the like. Fourth prong, substantial control.
- 56:58OCR concluded that the university had substantial
- 57:00control over the conduct because much of the
- 57:03conduct occurred on campus, and also because
- 57:05the university has control through its standards
- 57:07of discipline, which prohibit discrimination
- 57:10and harassment. Fifth prong, most important,
- 57:13is you have to establish that in the face of
- 57:16this hostile environment, the university is deliberately
- 57:19indifferent. And here, OCR focused on three areas
- 57:24to show deliberate indifference. First area is
- 57:27in the university's reporting process and procedures.
- 57:30So even when students reported discrimination
- 57:33concerns, they were dismissed. downplayed or
- 57:35not addressed. So in many cases, the university
- 57:39just didn't investigate complaints that were
- 57:41brought to its attention, or the university minimized
- 57:44student concerns. And in some cases, students
- 57:46were diverted to counseling rather than have
- 57:49their complaints investigated. And where the
- 57:52university did conduct an investigation, there
- 57:54was little documentation to show that the university
- 57:57had actually made a determination as to whether
- 57:59or not that incident created a hostile environment.
- 58:04OCR found deliberate indifference was in its
- 58:07response to repeated vandalism. So the evidence
- 58:10show that there were repeated incidents of antisemitic
- 58:13graffiti and that college staff had complained
- 58:16on a number of occasions about it. And the university's
- 58:19response was just to have staff clean it up rather
- 58:22than conduct an investigation, try to figure
- 58:24out who was engaging in this vandalism and address
- 58:27it through disciplinary sanctions. The third
- 58:30area where OCR found deliberate indifference
- 58:33was in the university's failure to control harassment
- 58:36and discrimination against Jewish students during
- 58:39protests specifically, in particular, by failing
- 58:43to consistently enforce the university's time,
- 58:46place, and manner restrictions on protests. And
- 58:49even when they did respond, the response was
- 58:52often delayed. And OCR also made a note that
- 58:55the disciplinary, the judicial process for imposing
- 58:57disciplinary sanctions for violating those restrictions
- 59:00were also delayed. Okay, that was a lot of information.
- 59:06Amy touched on this very briefly. As you all
- 59:09probably know, OCR has been impacted by some
- 59:13of the reductions in force. Seven of the 12 offices
- 59:16were closed. So we've seen some reporting in
- 59:19the press pondering, why is all of this important
- 59:21if there's reduced OCR enforcement? Aside from
- 59:25the obvious, which is that schools should be
- 59:27safe and inclusive for all students, as we've
- 59:29discussed here today, the government is still
- 59:31very actively investigating these cases. We now
- 59:34have two violation letters against Columbia University
- 59:37and Harvard University. And unlike prior administrations,
- 59:41this administration actually revoked funding
- 59:43even before the violation letters came out. So
- 59:45the stakes are much higher now. And OCR has...
- 59:49is still opening complaints on the basis of shared
- 59:51ancestry. It has several open directed investigations.
- 59:55Just last week, OCR announced in a press release
- 59:58an investigation against George Mason University
- 1:00:01for shared ancestry harassment and discrimination.
- 1:00:04In addition to that, there's still applicable
- 1:00:06state and civil rights laws. So for example,
- 1:00:08in Pennsylvania, we have the Pennsylvania Human
- 1:00:11Relations Commission. which has enforcement capability
- 1:00:14over Title VI and applicable state laws, and
- 1:00:17several state departments of education also have
- 1:00:19enforcement capability over Title VI and similar
- 1:00:21state laws. And as we've all seen in the press,
- 1:00:25there have been a myriad of state and federal
- 1:00:27lawsuits, and the stakes are higher there because
- 1:00:30courts can issue punitive damages where OCR traditionally
- 1:00:33does not. And then last but not least, There
- 1:00:36have been a number of high profile accusations
- 1:00:38in the press. And the last thing that a school
- 1:00:41wants is for its reputation to be tarnished in
- 1:00:43the press. This last slide just provides resources
- 1:00:48where schools can ask information or students
- 1:00:50can get recourse. I'm not going to dive into
- 1:00:52it because we've addressed most of it already.
- 1:00:56Last slide is just my and Amy's contact information
- 1:00:59in case you want to follow up with questions
- 1:01:01or concerns after this presentation. And with
- 1:01:05that, we don't have time, but Amy and I are willing
- 1:01:08to stay on if there are questions. Alrighty,
- 1:01:13well, it doesn't look like we actually have any
- 1:01:16current questions right now, but once again,
- 1:01:19of course, our members are encouraged to reach
- 1:01:21out to you if you have any questions or you can
- 1:01:24always if you somehow. Miss the contact details,
- 1:01:29you can always reach out to us and we can forward
- 1:01:31that information over to Beth and Amy. I have
- 1:01:34to say thank you so much Amy and Beth for today's
- 1:01:37presentation and thank you so much to our audience
- 1:01:39for joining us this afternoon. Have a great day
- 1:01:41everybody. Thank you. Thank you. Thanks everyone.