Latest / Deep Dive / The New Aristocracy: How the Upper Middle Class Hoards Opportunity
Transcript
- 0:00You know, usually when we talk about a heist, there's an
- 0:03expectation of a clear, easily identifiable villain.
- 0:07Think of like any classic movie setup.
- 0:10Right, the guy in the black mask.
- 0:11Exactly. The bank vault is empty, the
- 0:13alarm bells are ringing, and the grizzled detective points a
- 0:16finger at the shadowy mastermind.
- 0:18You know, the guy in the tailored suit who just flew away
- 0:21on a private jet? It is incredibly comforting to
- 0:25have a single bad guy to blame. I mean, human beings naturally
- 0:29want our large, complex societal problems to have a face.
- 0:33Yeah, it makes it simple. It makes the world feel
- 0:35solvable. If we just catch the bad guy,
- 0:37everything is fixed. But then you start looking at
- 0:40the reality of the American Dream and, well, the actual
- 0:43wealth distribution of the middle class, and suddenly that
- 0:46tidy movie script falls completely apart.
- 0:49It really does. We are looking at a modern
- 0:51economic landscape where the vault of upward mobility is
- 0:53definitely empty for a lot of people.
- 0:55But when we go looking for that mastermind in the private jet,
- 0:59the evidence points somewhere a lot more uncomfortable.
- 1:01It points directly at the detective.
- 1:03Or, more accurately, it points at a very specific, very
- 1:07comfortable slice of the everyday population that most
- 1:11people interact with constantly. Welcome to this deep dive where
- 1:14we are going to explore a genuinely uncomfortable truth
- 1:18about the American class system. Because the American Dream is
- 1:21not actually dead. No, it's not.
- 1:23It is just being hoarded. And today we are going to ask
- 1:27you, the listener, to look at the evidence and maybe look in
- 1:30the mirror. We are primarily pulling our
- 1:32insights from Richard V Reeves's deeply researched book Dream
- 1:36Hoarders. It's a fantastic, really eye
- 1:39opening source. It really is.
- 1:40Now I will admit, I tried to pull some supplementary
- 1:43international data from the OECD website to really round up the
- 1:45context for this discussion, but I actually got blocked by a
- 1:49Cloudflare security wall treating me like a malicious
- 1:51bot. Oh, no, seriously.
- 1:52Seriously, it even threw up a literal Ray ID code ends in CC
- 1:5788 if any tech folks are listening just to humiliate me.
- 2:01So because I was barred from the international data by a very
- 2:03aggressive security algorithm, today's deep dive is going to
- 2:07stay strictly focused on Reeves's data and arguments here
- 2:11in the States. Which is plenty to dig into,
- 2:13honestly. OK, let's unpack this.
- 2:15Whenever politicians get on a debate stage, who is the
- 2:19villain, it is always the top 1% versus 99% that is the movie
- 2:23villain we were just talking about.
- 2:25But Reeves argues this is a total distraction from the real
- 2:28issue. It is a massive distraction.
- 2:31The real divide, like the actual mathematical chasm in our
- 2:34society, is between the top 20%, the upper middle class, and the
- 2:39other 80% who are being left in the dust.
- 2:41And this deep dive is going to encourage you to really evaluate
- 2:44where you stand in that dynamic. Because when we talk about the
- 2:47top 20%, we aren't talking about eccentric billionaires of super.
- 2:51Yachts or space programs? Exactly.
- 2:54We are talking about households making over $112,000 a year.
- 2:59We are talking about professionals, managers,
- 3:01journalists, software engineers and academics.
- 3:04So if you are listening to this on a commute from a nice suburb,
- 3:08this is likely about you. Yeah, it probably is.
- 3:11We really can't understand how the American dream is being
- 3:13hoarded until we look at the bank accounts of the people
- 3:16doing the hoarding. And that money isn't just
- 3:18sitting in offshore accounts in the Cayman Islands.
- 3:20Right, it's much closer to home. It is in our own backyards.
- 3:24Let's look at the income growth between 1979 and 2013.
- 3:28The top 1% saw a $1.4 trillion gain in pre tax income.
- 3:34That is a huge number. Obviously it is.
- 3:36But let's look at the 19% just below them.
- 3:38That upper middle class. They saw a $2.7 trillion gain
- 3:42over that same period. That's nearly double.
- 3:44Yeah, for every extra dollar going to the Super rich, $2.00
- 3:48went to the upper middle class. And that completely upends the
- 3:51traditional narrative of who is accumulating the nation's
- 3:55wealth. Yeah.
- 3:55Furthermore, that top 1% isn't even a static group of
- 3:59generational oligarchs. Wait, it's not.
- 4:01No, the data shows it is actually a revolving door. 20%
- 4:05of the population will spend at least one year in that top
- 4:08bracket over the course of their lives.
- 4:09Oh wow, had no idea. Yeah, maybe they sell a house or
- 4:13get a massive one time bonus or cash out some stock options.
- 4:18It is not a permanent aristocracy of the ultra rich.
- 4:21It is mostly just the upper middle class having an
- 4:23exceptionally Goodyear. Exactly.
- 4:25It is almost like the top 1% acts as a political lightning
- 4:30rod. They stand at the very top of
- 4:32the economic building, absorbing all the anger, all the media
- 4:35attention and all the protest chants about inequality.
- 4:38Which is very convenient for everyone else.
- 4:39Right. Meanwhile, the other 19% are
- 4:42safely inside that same building, quietly buying up the
- 4:46neighborhood, maximizing their retirement accounts, and
- 4:49pretending they're just, you know, regular middle class.
- 4:52What's fascinating here is that when you look at the bottom 80%
- 4:55of the country, there hasn't really been any major increase
- 4:59in inequality among themselves over the last few decades.
- 5:02Really. So the bottom is fairly even.
- 5:04Yes, the gap between the truly poor and the traditional middle
- 5:08class has remained relatively stagnant.
- 5:11The break point, the place where the economic graph just detaches
- 5:14and skyrockets, is exactly at the 80th percentile.
- 5:18That is wild. The real chasm isn't between the
- 5:21poor and the middle class, it is between the upper middle class
- 5:24and everyone else. So what does this all mean?
- 5:27They have the money, but how does that money translate to
- 5:30physical life? That's the crucial part.
- 5:32Because this economic separation doesn't just sit on a
- 5:35spreadsheet in a Vanguard index fund.
- 5:38It physically alters how people live, who they fall in love
- 5:41with, and literally how long they survive.
- 5:43Yeah, it dictates everything. The upper middle class has
- 5:46essentially used this wealth to build biological and geographic
- 5:49fortresses. Let's start with who we marry.
- 5:52The source uses the phrase assortative mating.
- 5:55Which sounds very scientific. It does.
- 5:57Back in 1960, only 3% of marriages featured 2 college
- 6:01graduates. By 2012, that number was up to
- 6:0322%. The text explicitly notes that,
- 6:06and I quote Love is biochemistry's chief assistant.
- 6:10And this compound advantage exponentially.
- 6:14Think about the mechanics of that.
- 6:15You take 2 high earning, highly educated professionals.
- 6:19They don't just combine their incomes to buy a nicer house.
- 6:22They combine their professional networks, their cultural
- 6:25capital, their stress management resources and their health
- 6:28habits. So health becomes a factor too.
- 6:31It becomes about health as a form of human capital.
- 6:34Upper middle class individuals have the time and resources to
- 6:37exercise more. They smoke significantly less,
- 6:40and they largely avoid the environmental factors driving
- 6:43the obesity epidemic. That makes sense.
- 6:45They have access to better food, safer walking paths, all of
- 6:48that. Exactly.
- 6:50The source points out a staggering statistic.
- 6:52A man born in 1950 in the top 20% lives on average three years
- 6:57longer than a man born in the middle 40%.
- 7:00Three whole years. Yes, they're literally hoarding
- 7:03years of life. So if you look at the mechanics,
- 7:05modern upper middle class marriage isn't just a romantic
- 7:08endeavor anymore, it is functionally a corporate merger
- 7:11of human capital. That's a great way to put it.
- 7:13Two highly educated earners pool their resources to create this
- 7:17impenetrable economic fortress. And the kicker is, once they
- 7:21build this fortress, they don't just enjoy it, they use local
- 7:24laws to pull up the drawbridge so no one else can get in.
- 7:27Right, the zoning laws. Yeah, they use NIMBY Not in my
- 7:31backyard zoning laws. This is a crucial mechanism to
- 7:34understand. Exclusionary zoning means local
- 7:36residents lobby their city councils to block high density
- 7:40housing like apartment buildings or duplexes from being built in
- 7:43their neighborhood. And they usually say it's about
- 7:45trafficker aesthetics, right? They argue it's about preserving
- 7:49neighborhood character, but mathematically, by restricting
- 7:52the housing supply, they keep home prices artificially high.
- 7:56Creating a literal barrier to entry.
- 7:59Exactly. If a lower income family cannot
- 8:01afford to buy a single family home in that zip code, they are
- 8:04locked out. And because public school
- 8:06funding and assignment are tied to local property taxes and zip
- 8:09codes, locking them out of the neighborhood means locking them
- 8:13out of the best public schools. And the broader society
- 8:17literally subsidizes this fortress building.
- 8:20Homeowners get a $70 billion annual benefit from the mortgage
- 8:25interest deduction. That is a massive subsidy.
- 8:28Huge. It's a tax write off that
- 8:30overwhelmingly favors the wealthy, who are taking out
- 8:33massive mortgages on expensive homes while renters get
- 8:36absolutely nothing. If we connect this geographic
- 8:39and biological segregation to the broader picture, it creates
- 8:43what sociologists call an empathy gap.
- 8:46An empathy gap? How so?
- 8:48Well, when you live in a striply zone neighborhood where every
- 8:51single person on your street is an educated professional just
- 8:54like you, your worldview shifts. I can see that you just assume
- 8:58everyone lives like that, right? You look around, you see
- 9:00everyone working 50 hour weeks, and you start to assume your
- 9:03success is purely based on your own hard work.
- 9:06You completely ignore the systemic advantages like the
- 9:09zoning laws and the TAP subsidies.
- 9:11They're literally embedded in your zip.
- 9:13Code. It creates an echo Chamber of
- 9:14merit. You think, well, I worked hard
- 9:16to get here without realizing the road was paved for you while
- 9:18others had to climb a dirt hill. Which leads to the next big
- 9:21question. Once these parents have secured
- 9:24these geographic and economic fortresses, what happens inside
- 9:28them? The focus shifts to the kids.
- 9:30Right. They turn their homes into
- 9:32highly efficient greenhouses for raising children who are going
- 9:35to absolutely dominate the labor market.
- 9:38And the data shows this starts before the kid is even born.
- 9:41It's incredibly planned out. Women in the top 30% are half as
- 9:46likely to have an unintended pregnancy compared to those in
- 9:48the middle. They are planning human
- 9:50development like a military operation.
- 9:53The book shares an anecdote about a concept called Project
- 9:56Melissa. It perfectly encapsulates this
- 9:59phenomenon. Project Melissa isn't just about
- 10:01reading a bedtime story. It's way more intense than that.
- 10:04It is a relentless 25 year parent LED campaign.
- 10:08It starts with specialized prenatal vitamins, then
- 10:10transitions into highly curated educational games for toddlers,
- 10:14expensive tutors, specialized sports coaching, SAT prep
- 10:18courses. And it just keeps going.
- 10:19And finally, calling in favors to secure plum networking
- 10:22internships. It is 1/4 century project
- 10:25designed to guarantee a child's success in a competitive
- 10:29economy. And the results of this 25 year
- 10:31project are staggering. By age 3, there is a 30 million
- 10:36word gap between children raised by professionals and children
- 10:40raised in poverty. 30 million words.
- 10:42Just let that sink in. Just from the sheer volume of
- 10:45conversation and vocabulary happening inside that
- 10:48greenhouse. And then we hit the ultimate
- 10:50inequality machine. College.
- 10:53The great divider. 6 out of 10 kids from the top 20% get a
- 10:57bachelor's degree. For the bottom 40%, it is just
- 11:00one in 10. But here is the crazy part.
- 11:03Because a bachelor's degree is becoming standard for the upper
- 11:06middle class, the goal posts have moved.
- 11:08They always do. The source states that
- 11:10postgraduate degrees are the new required positional good just to
- 11:13maintain your class status. Wait, I need to pause here.
- 11:16I know what a regular economic good is, but what exactly makes
- 11:19a degree positional good? That is a great question.
- 11:22A positional good is something that derives its value almost
- 11:26entirely from its scarcity and how it elevates your status
- 11:30relative to others. So it's about where you stand in
- 11:33line. Basically, yeah, If you are the
- 11:35only person in an office with a bachelor's degree, that degree
- 11:38is incredibly valuable, gets you the promotion.
- 11:41But if everyone in the office has a bachelor's degree, it's
- 11:43positional value drops to zero. I see you haven't lost any
- 11:47knowledge, but your relative advantage is gone.
- 11:50So the upper middle class now pushes their kids to get
- 11:53master's degrees and pH DS. Not necessarily because the job
- 11:57requires the knowledge, but because they need a new scarcer
- 12:00credential to stand out in the labor market.
- 12:03OK, that makes perfect sense, but I have to push back on this
- 12:06whole concept. Aren't we just demonizing good
- 12:08parenting here? It could definitely feel that
- 12:10way. Right.
- 12:11I mean, if I plan my family, if I read to my kid every night to
- 12:14build their vocabulary, if I help them with their math
- 12:16homework and feed them healthy food, that is a good thing.
- 12:19Should I be penalized for loving my child and wanting to give
- 12:23them the best possible start in life?
- 12:25This raises an important question, and it is honestly the
- 12:28ethical crux of this entire deep dive.
- 12:31Are we just punishing people for trying hard?
- 12:33Because that doesn't seem fair either.
- 12:35To understand this, Reeves brings in the philosophy of
- 12:38Michael Young, who actually coined the term meritocracy as a
- 12:42dystopia, and John Rawls. Developing market merit, which
- 12:47is the intelligence, the skills and the drive that the labor
- 12:50market rewards, is perfectly fine.
- 12:52The market needs those skills. Exactly.
- 12:55The labor market wants competent people, and that pure market
- 12:58desire for skills allows for incredible stories like JD
- 13:01Vance's rise from childhood and severe poverty to becoming an
- 13:04elite investment banker. The unfairness isn't the
- 13:07competition itself. Right.
- 13:09The labor market isn't a snob. It doesn't care who your dad is.
- 13:11It just wants to know if you can code the software or close the
- 13:13deal. Exactly, but here is the roll
- 13:15gene perspective on why that is and true fairness.
- 13:18John Rawls argued that our natural talents and the families
- 13:21we are born into are a lottery. We don't choose them.
- 13:24We don't. The unfairness is that the upper
- 13:27middle class gets to spend nights and weekends practicing
- 13:30in their well funded greenhouses for years before the starting
- 13:33whistle even blows. The source uses this.
- 13:36Brilliant, deeply unsettling analogy of a warrior society.
- 13:42Oh, walk us through that. I love a good analogy.
- 13:44Imagine a society that only recruits its leaders and
- 13:47warriors based on physical strength.
- 13:49They open the physical test to absolutely everyone claiming it
- 13:53is a pure, unbiased meritocracy. Anyone who can lift the boulder
- 13:56gets the job. Exactly.
- 13:58But in this society only the rich have enough food to grow
- 14:00strong. The poor are starving.
- 14:03So the rich look at the results and say look, we don't exclude
- 14:06people who being poor, we only exclude them for being weak.
- 14:09It completely ignores the mechanism of their poverty,
- 14:12which is exactly what prevented them from getting the required
- 14:14strength in the 1st place. Our modern society does the
- 14:17exact same thing, just with SAT scores and polished resumes
- 14:21instead of physical strength. Wow.
- 14:23We don't exclude you for being poor, we exclude you for lacking
- 14:26skills. That is brutal.
- 14:27It is very harsh. But it makes so much sense when
- 14:30you look at how human capital is cultivated in these upper middle
- 14:34class greenhouses. But as the book points out, it
- 14:38would be one thing if these parents simply prepped their
- 14:40kids intensely in the greenhouse and then let the chips fall
- 14:43where they may in a truly open market.
- 14:45Right, but they don't do that. And this brings us to the
- 14:48transition from just giving your kid a head start to actively
- 14:51rigging the game, which the source calls opportunity
- 14:55hoarding. Yes, this is a concept
- 14:57originally developed by sociologist Charles Tilley.
- 15:00Opportunity hoarding is the line where good parenting becomes
- 15:03anticompetitive behavior. So it crosses a line.
- 15:06It does. It is where the upper middle
- 15:08class stops just preparing their kids for the race and actively
- 15:11uses their power to capture scarce valuable resources and
- 15:15allocate them in ways that exclude others.
- 15:18Let's look at the mechanics of this with 529 college savings
- 15:21plans. These are tax advantage accounts
- 15:23meant to help families save for college.
- 15:25A very popular tool. Right.
- 15:27The way it works mathematically is you put money in, it grows
- 15:29tax free, and you don't pay taxes when you take it out for
- 15:32tuition. But if you are a family living
- 15:35paycheck to paycheck, you don't have surplus capital to invest.
- 15:38You can't use a shelter if you have nothing to shelter.
- 15:41Exactly. You can't take advantage of a
- 15:42tax shelter if you have no money.
- 15:45O The data shows 90% of the tax benefits of 529 plans go to the
- 15:50top 25% of families. It is a government subsidy for
- 15:54the wealthy to maintain their status.
- 15:56And the political response to this is fascinating.
- 15:58Oh, it really is. When President Obama tried to
- 16:01end these tax benefits to fund a fairer system for lower income
- 16:05students, it wasn't a bunch of right wing billionaires who
- 16:08stopped him. Who was it?
- 16:09It was liberal, upper middle class Democrats.
- 16:13Politicians like Nancy Pelosi and Chris Van Holland quickly
- 16:17killed the proposal because they're affluent constituents.
- 16:19That top 20% were absolutely furious at the idea of losing
- 16:23their tax shelter. Here's where it gets really
- 16:25interesting, and I want to be clear that we are just reporting
- 16:31the data here impartially without taking any political
- 16:33sides. The source highlights a profound
- 16:36political hypocrisy across the spectrum.
- 16:38It's definitely a bipartisan issue.
- 16:40The very same voters who will loudly champion equality on
- 16:43social media, who protest for social justice and demand
- 16:47progressive taxation on the Super rich are the exact same
- 16:50people weaponizing tax free 529 plans and local exclusionary
- 16:56zoning to ensure their own children never have to compete
- 17:00on a truly level playing field. It is a very uncomfortable
- 17:03cognitive you want a fair society, but you want a
- 17:07guaranteed win for your own child more.
- 17:09Yeah, when push comes to shove. And nowhere is that opportunity
- 17:12hoarding more egregious than in college admissions.
- 17:15Let's talk about legacy preferences.
- 17:17Being a legacy applicant at an elite college, meaning one of
- 17:21your parents went there, acts like 160 point boost on the SAT.
- 17:25That is massive. And then there is the Z list at
- 17:27Harvard. I had never heard of the Z list
- 17:29before reading this. How does that actually function?
- 17:31The Z list is a deferred admission list.
- 17:34These are students who are accepted to Harvard, but they
- 17:37are asked to wait a full year, essentially taking a gap year
- 17:40before they enroll. OK.
- 17:42Why would they do that? Well, the source points out that
- 17:44a massive percentage of these zealous students are wealthy
- 17:47legacy applicants. The implication is that these
- 17:50are kids who might not have made the cut on pure academic merit
- 17:54in the regular, highly competitive applicant pool.
- 17:57Ah I see, so the university uses this backdoor list to ensure the
- 18:01children of alumni still get their spot without dragging down
- 18:04the incoming freshman classes average test scores.
- 18:08It is an institutional backdoor, just like unpaid internships are
- 18:11a corporate backdoor. Exactly the same principle.
- 18:13The data shows half of all jobs are found through family or
- 18:16friends and unpaid internships. Think about the mechanics of two
- 18:21equally smart, equally capable kids.
- 18:24One kid has parents wealthy enough to subsidize their living
- 18:27expenses, pay their rent in New York City and buy their
- 18:30groceries while they work for free for a summer at a
- 18:32prestigious media company or a law firm.
- 18:35A. Huge advantage.
- 18:36While the other kid who is just as smart has to spend that
- 18:39summer working at a local grocery store just to afford
- 18:42next semester's textbooks. When graduation comes, who has
- 18:46the better resume? One who could afford to work for
- 18:48free. Exactly.
- 18:49The internship is basically reserved for those who can
- 18:52afford the entry fee of working for $0.00.
- 18:55And that is exactly why it is anticompetitive.
- 18:58A spot at a top college or prestigious internship that
- 19:02leads to a lucrative career is a scarce, valuable resource.
- 19:06Right, there are only so many spots.
- 19:07When you allocate that scarce resource based on bloodline or
- 19:12personal connections or the ability to work for free rather
- 19:15than on actual merit, you are mathematically robbing a
- 19:19smarter, poor kid of a chance to rise.
- 19:22It's not victimless. No, it's not.
- 19:24You aren't just helping your child in a vacuum, you're
- 19:26actively hurting someone else's child by taking a spot they
- 19:29earned. That is the fundamental
- 19:31difference between good parenting and opportunity
- 19:33hoarding. This brings us to the hardest
- 19:35part of this whole deep dive. I want to talk directly to you,
- 19:39the listener. Think about your own life, your
- 19:41own bank accounts, and your own neighborhood.
- 19:43It's time for some self reflection.
- 19:45Are you in that top 20% making over $112,000?
- 19:50Do you have a 529 plan growing tax free for your kids?
- 19:54Do you live in a neighborhood with strict zoning laws that
- 19:57keep the housing prices high and the local public school
- 20:00exclusive? It's a lot to consider.
- 20:02It is entirely natural, biologically and emotionally, to
- 20:05want the absolute best for your kids.
- 20:08No one is denying that. But we have to acknowledge the
- 20:10reality of the data we've explored today.
- 20:12A meritocracy without mobility isn't a true meritocracy.
- 20:16It is just an aristocracy in a different outfit.
- 20:19And acknowledging that requires us to face a harsh mathematical
- 20:22reality that the source drives home.
- 20:24Since the top 20% of the income distribution can only ever hold
- 20:28exactly 20% of the population, relative mobility is a 0 sum
- 20:32game. Wait, really?
- 20:34It's 0 sum. Let me say that again because it
- 20:36goes against everything we want to believe.
- 20:37It is 0 sum. If we truly, genuinely want
- 20:41poor, talented kids from the bottom to move up the ladder and
- 20:44claim a spot in the upper middle class, somebody else's child has
- 20:47to fall out of it. That is a tough pill to swallow.
- 20:49We all love the inspiring idea of upward mobility, but upward
- 20:53mobility is mathematically impossible without downward
- 20:57mobility. Which brings us right back to
- 20:59our opening scene. We came into this deep dive
- 21:01looking for a villain. We wanted a mastermind hoarding
- 21:05the American Dream in a vault. But it wasn't the guy with the
- 21:07private jet. No, the vault isn't locked by a
- 21:11shadowy billionaire on a super yacht.
- 21:13It is locked by local zoning laws, legacy college admissions
- 21:17and tax advantage savings accounts.
- 21:19Everyday mechanisms. And the face of the person
- 21:22holding the key might just be the one we see in the mirror.
- 21:25So we leave you with this final thought to Mull over as you go
- 21:28about your day. How much of your own privilege
- 21:30and how much of your own child's guaranteed safety net are you
- 21:33truly willing to give up to make the American Dream fair again?