Latest / The So What? / Thoughts After a Visit to China
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to the So What podcast, in which political economic analyst JP LanDman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of South Africans. You can find a written
- 0:16version of this content on JP's website, jplandman.co.za. I am Ruda Landman and I am your host.
- 0:28This episode goes with the newsletter dated the 9th of November 2023, which you can find
- 0:34on the website under the title, Thoughts After a Visit to China. JP, getting off the plane,
- 0:42first impressions that evening, you landed at what, 11 o'clock at night?
- 0:46Yes, first impression, incredible social organisation. The efficiency with which people and your
- 0:54luggage and everything else gets processed is simply unreal. That was noticeable throughout
- 1:02our visit. I just want to make it clear, Ruda, just like one swallow certainly doesn't make
- 1:07a sw- summer, one visit to China doesn't make one an expert. Certainly not. But these are
- 1:13just my initial impressions as I experienced them. And the first one is the incredible
- 1:18level of social organisation. But the flip side of that is security.
- 1:23Absolutely, there are cameras everywhere. You've got to show your passport wherever
- 1:27you go. If you take a train trip, you show your passport or if you're a Chinese citizen,
- 1:33your ID card, when you enter the station and again when you are on a platform and you want
- 1:37to enter the train. Yes, security is very strict, no question about it.
- 1:42You were also impressed by infrastructure. Yes, again, you know, nothing really prepares
- 1:48you for it. One hears about these things, one hears about 40 and 50 and 60 storey residential
- 1:55buildings and so on. But nothing really prepares you for the physical infrastructure, for the
- 2:01buildings, the roads, the highways, the trains, the power lines. Wherever you go, you see
- 2:08power lines. We took a train from Beijing to Qijian in the Shanxi province. That's
- 2:14where the Terracotta soldiers are. It's a distance more or less from Johannesburg to
- 2:19Cape Town. The train covered it in four hours and seven minutes. It is simply unreal. Six
- 2:27years ago, seven years ago, that train line did not exist. It simply wasn't there. So
- 2:33what they've done in terms of infrastructure is incredible. What they're busy doing in
- 2:38terms of digital infrastructure is also incredible. You can move around the entire Beijing and
- 2:43never use any cash. Everything is on a cell phone, a smartphone. And people who know say
- 2:50that WeChat is much better than WhatsApp. So it's not just physical infrastructure,
- 2:58it's also digital. And all of this happened, all of this changed in 40 years. 40 years
- 3:05ago, it looked very different, one would assume. Absolutely. When Ding Xiaoping launched these
- 3:12reforms in 1978, now 45 years ago, India, China rather, was a backward, poor country.
- 3:20There's no question about it. The photographs show it, documentaries from the time show
- 3:25it, people who live show it. People who are alive can testify to it.
- 3:30Well, it was just after the Cultural Revolution.
- 3:33Yes, absolutely. It started in, as I said, in 1978. And I want to tell you two anecdotes
- 3:38that I think illustrate the point best. The first one is from a gentleman who's now 48
- 3:43years old. 40 years ago, he was eight years old. He went to school in Baozhi. Nobody in
- 3:50school had shoes. There was simply not enough money around for parents to give shoes to
- 3:55the children. Today, 40 years later, he runs a business with 10 primary schools or kindergarten
- 4:02schools as he calls them. He charges 10,000 renminbi per month per child. That's about
- 4:0825,000, 26,000 rand per month per child. And he's got 10 of these schools in Baozhi. So
- 4:15from a level of income where people couldn't have shoes to a level of income where parents
- 4:20could afford to pay that amount of money, it is simply transformational. It doesn't
- 4:27matter how you look at it, it's transformational.
- 4:29Those schools are, this is a private enterprise.
- 4:32Completely private enterprise, completely privately run, belongs to him. The properties
- 4:37where the schools are belong to him, completely private.
- 4:40He found his name in South Africa.
- 4:42Well, that he find his name was South Africa, that we copy it. He calls his schools the
- 4:47Kuro schools. Some people say indeed everything is made in China.
- 4:55And the other person you met whose story also struck you?
- 4:59The other gentleman is about 45 years old and he recalls how as a young child, his mother
- 5:04sent him on a bicycle to a neighboring village to go and buy some paraffin for use in the
- 5:09house in the kitchen. There was no paraffin available in their village. And secondly,
- 5:14they needed a ration card. There were rations on all products. So he needed a ration card,
- 5:18take that with him on the bicycle, go to a nearby village, buy a bit of paraffin, come
- 5:23back. He is simply amazed that today there's no limit to the consumer goods that he can
- 5:29buy. There's no shortage of electricity, of gas, of food, of clothes. He can buy whatever
- 5:35he can afford, which is available in abundant supply.
- 5:40And it tells you what happened in 40 years. And what struck me most was that nothing that
- 5:45I read, nothing that I tried and investigated beforehand prepared me for the sheer quantum
- 5:53of what they've done in 40 years. It's really incredible.
- 5:56Well, all of this was possible because of economic growth. What's the recipe?
- 6:01Very, very interesting. I think it seems to me it comes down to two things, local government
- 6:07and embracing the private sector, or as Chinese prefer to call them, entrepreneurs. They don't
- 6:13really talk about private sector, but they do use the term entrepreneur as a substitute.
- 6:19The first point is local government. After 1978, Deng Xiaoping started with experimentation,
- 6:26allowed different local governments, different provinces to do different things. And they
- 6:32basically set up an incentive and reward scheme to reward city leaders, town leaders, to generate
- 6:40economic growth.
- 6:41But it sounds as if it's on both those levels, local government and provincial.
- 6:45Absolutely, absolutely. Strong national guidance, provincial governments and then local government.
- 6:50China, you know, is a big country, 1.4 billion people. So you have a structure of government
- 6:57throughout. And because it's a one-party state and very strong centralized political control,
- 7:05the political rewards for local leaders and provincial leaders who could generate growth
- 7:11were indeed quite substantial. So there was a competition between local governments for
- 7:15attracting business, attracting entrepreneurs, attracting capital and getting economic activity
- 7:21going. So that played a big role. That and implicit in that embracing the private sector,
- 7:26those two things made the difference.
- 7:29You came across that provincial government that you visited, you said that they were
- 7:34boasting about having business relationships with more than 100 countries in the world.
- 7:39So that province has reached out far beyond its own borders.
- 7:45Oh, absolutely. The Shanxi province, which is more or less in the middle of the country.
- 7:50So it's far to the west of Beijing. So it's not part of the prosperous eastern seaboard
- 7:56of China, not at all. It's in the middle of the country. Yet they have established businesses
- 8:01and as you've said, they established relationships with businesses in more than 100 countries.
- 8:07For a provincial government to do that, it's quite astonishing. Likewise, we went to a
- 8:12local city, about 3.3 million people, Baozhi, which is also in the province of Shanxi. Similar
- 8:19kind of story there. They reached out, they received us very generously, very hospitably
- 8:24because they want to. They want to have relations. They want to establish commercial ties. The
- 8:30one experience we had throughout was that the businessmen are very, very hungry for
- 8:35business. Back here in South Africa, I've received a couple of emails from people who
- 8:40said, we met you, these are our products. You find anybody who would like to buy these
- 8:46products, you know, please put us in touch and so on. They're the very aggressive business
- 8:51people. And in Baozhi, it sounds as if titanium made all the difference. It's a fascinating
- 8:58story. It is on a river, but it's not a navigable river. It's inland, so there's no ocean, there's
- 9:05no deep harbor nearby. Yet, they imported titanium from Mozambique, from Australia,
- 9:11from North America, and they smelt it in Baozhi. And they built up a titanium industry around
- 9:18that. It's simply incredible. They produce a range of titanium products and there again,
- 9:25there's a drive to innovate and to move up the value chain. So, they're now developing
- 9:32all kinds of products to go into electric motor cars, to go into spacecraft, that sort
- 9:37of thing. They're moving up the value chain. And because you had titanium factories, other
- 9:44industries also followed. They are currently in Baozhi, 13 motor car manufacturers, manufacturing
- 9:51or assembly complete motor cars, and more than 300 spare part manufacturers for motor
- 9:57cars. It is just big. 3.3 million, that's about half the size of Johannesburg, of the
- 10:05greater Johannesburg? Yeah, probably about half the size, yes. You say that the growth
- 10:11model is changing. What do you mean? China, based on to the world scene, as an export
- 10:18led economy, they manufactured cheap goods at cheap prices and cut that out onto the
- 10:24world markets. Over time, of course, they moved up the value chain and they're now the
- 10:29world's biggest manufacturer of electric motor cars. Tesla's biggest factory for electric
- 10:35vehicles is to be found in China. What is happening now is that they're focusing on
- 10:40three things. They're focusing on health and health services. They're focusing on green
- 10:45energy products. For example, China is the world's biggest solar panel manufacturer.
- 10:53And they're focusing on digital infrastructure and digital products. Call it advanced manufacturing.
- 10:59So they still want to manufacture, but it's much more advanced than just making toys or
- 11:04the simple products that they started off with. And there's a lot of money going into
- 11:10that. Provincial and local governments and the national government give incentives to
- 11:15companies who innovate, who experiment, who come up with new ideas and new products. So
- 11:21the growth model is switching from just export led to much more advanced manufacturing and,
- 11:27as I've said, health services as well. The population is also changing, growing older.
- 11:35There will be in future, maybe already, fewer people of working age. Did you see whether
- 11:43they are adapting to that? Very much so. We went to the Geely Auto,
- 11:51Geely car company in Bauri. They started the factory there in 2016 with 1000 people. They
- 11:58now have 350 workers in the factory. Yet they produce more than what they produced seven
- 12:05years ago. Why? Robots. They've installed the whole production line. You almost don't
- 12:11see people. You just see these robots working and arms and legs of robots moving around.
- 12:19Some of those robots they bought on the market, some they've developed themselves. The price
- 12:23varied from about 2.6 million to 26 million rand per robot. There's no question that they're
- 12:30moving up the technology spectrum. That's one of the ways in which they want to handle
- 12:35the fact that the demography, as you point out, is changing quite dramatically. This
- 12:40year is the first year that I think that China's population actually was stagnant. Its population
- 12:46now is marginally smaller than India's population, no longer the world's biggest population.
- 12:52This trend will continue over the next 50 years or so. The population will over time
- 12:57get smaller. Employing robots and, of course, encouraging more people to urbanize would
- 13:03still be good big growth drivers for China. That's one of the ways in which they're trying
- 13:09to adapt. They focus on robotics to developing new layers of robots. Oh, yes. After I had
- 13:18returned, there was an article in the South China Morning Post with some very interesting
- 13:23statistics indicating that in 2022, 50% of all the robots installed in the world were
- 13:30installed in China. It is, again, just mind boggling. The same article says that according
- 13:39to some survey done by a Western Institute, there are now 8,000 smart factories, robotic
- 13:47factories in China. The scale is just incredible. When they decide to do it, they do it and
- 13:52they implement. That's really the story that we've had for long now, but certainly in the
- 13:57last 40 years. That actually leads me to my next question. You, as we've said, visited
- 14:04local government and provincial government. Impressions of how the government functions?
- 14:10The first and overwhelming impression is that all government buildings, local, provincial,
- 14:15national are modern, smart, luxurious, a place where you want to work. We were treated to
- 14:21a staff lunch in the provincial government of Sanqi. Well, I must tell you, I've never
- 14:27been to a five-star restaurant with that kind of buffet and that kind of display. This was
- 14:33on a Wednesday. It was in the middle of the week. It's the staff canteen. It's the staff
- 14:38canteen. The municipal buildings are smart. They're imposing. They make our union buildings
- 14:46look quite dilapidated. It's just a different visual environment. I think one of the impacts
- 14:55is that the people working inside those buildings, in a sense, have to live up to the standard
- 15:00of the building. That brings us to the fact that in China, for more than 3,000 years,
- 15:07people had to write exams before they could become a civil servant. If you wanted to serve
- 15:12in the court of the emperor, you had to pass an entry exam based on Confucian principles.
- 15:18They still have that. Again, after our return, there was a report in the South China Morning
- 15:24Post that this year, now in September, 2.85 million people applied to write the civil
- 15:32service exam for this year. 2.85 million people. Yeah, it's a big population. That's true.
- 15:41It also tells you how many people want to get into civil service and the loops that
- 15:45they have to go through. Apply to write. If you're accepted to write, well, then you can
- 15:50write the exam and you either pass it or fail it. That's how they built a capable state.
- 15:57They certainly have a capable state. There's no question about that.
- 16:01Why do you think our people, and I'm generalizing here, often so distrustful of China?
- 16:09I think it's us and them. I think it's because they're foreign. The language is very, very
- 16:15different. I mean, if you don't have an interpreter with you all the time, you simply cannot communicate.
- 16:22And even with an interpreter, it's difficult to communicate.
- 16:25And we haven't really been exposed to Chinese culture in the way that we are to Americans,
- 16:30say. Or European. Or European. Absolutely not. Traveling to Europe, traveling to America,
- 16:36you know, it's really not a big deal. Traveling to China, not that many people have done it.
- 16:42It's completely foreign and because of the language, an alien society.
- 16:49Yeah, quite opaque. Quite opaque for an outsider. So I think the us-them dynamic is very, very
- 16:56different. And that's a great pity because they are there. They're not going to disappear.
- 17:01They're not going to get weaker. They're the world's second biggest economy. Even if they
- 17:05just remain number two, they're an important player and we have to live with them.
- 17:12May I ask an opinion on the American approach to China?
- 17:16Look, I think it's silly to declare that China is your competitor and you want to stop their
- 17:23progress. This is an old civilization going back 5,000 years. It's the only surviving
- 17:29civilization of that age on this planet. You're not just going to suppress those people. They
- 17:35can shoot themselves in the foot and in the knee. And they've done it in the past. That's
- 17:40quite possible that they do it again. But that is because of internal dynamics. But
- 17:45if you think you can come from the outside and stop people's development, I think that
- 17:51is a fool's errand. That's not going to happen.
- 17:55That is probably the first. So what? What is the bottom line? What are the takeaways?
- 18:01Well, the bottom line is that the Chinese are there and we in South Africa not only
- 18:08have to live with them, but want to live with them. They are our biggest trading partner.
- 18:11So why would you not want to have good relations with the biggest trading partner that you
- 18:16have? The United States is our second biggest trading partner and we would love to have
- 18:20good relations with them in spite of their silly ambassadors, silly comments. So be on
- 18:26good terms with the people that you do business with, both the United States and China.
- 18:33I think the second so what is if we want to build a capable state, and I think all South
- 18:39Africans want to do that, we don't have a capable state. I think we can all agree on
- 18:42that. Just look at the state of many of our local governments. If we want to build a capable
- 18:48state, it requires a specific and focused effort. It's not just going to happen by
- 18:52itself. I think the idea of entrance exams is a good idea. We started to some extent
- 18:58with that. You need certain minimum qualifications for appointment in financial positions, for
- 19:04example, but I think we can make it much, much bigger than that.
- 19:09I think this is the third so what is let's learn from the Chinese on pragmatism. They
- 19:15did not let ideology develop their economy. They let pragmatism develop their economy
- 19:21and they said to local governments, experiment, play around, see what works, attract people
- 19:27and then you reward the local governments which generate the highest growth. So pragmatism
- 19:33is the big story.
- 19:34What's that wonderful quote of Deng Xiaoping?
- 19:37Yeah, Deng Xiaoping reputed to have said, what does it matter if the cat is black or
- 19:42white as long as it catches the mice? And I think that kind of pragmatism is extremely
- 19:47important. And then lastly, as I've said, they may shoot themselves in the foot. They
- 19:51may shoot themselves in both feet. That's quite possible. They've done it before, but
- 19:57they will determine their destiny, not people outside China.
- 20:01Thank you so much. I want to end with one question for listeners who may want to understand
- 20:09something about China. What are the sources that are available to South Africans?
- 20:16Look, there are a couple of very good books available. I found personally in my own life
- 20:22that subscribing to the South China Morning Post, which I've done now for two or three
- 20:26years have opened my eyes to a different world.
- 20:30And that's available online?
- 20:32And that's available online. I read it every day and it gives you a feel for what's happening
- 20:38in the other part of the world. And there's some really good books. I started my reading
- 20:42journey on China a couple of years ago with Henry Kissinger's book on China. It's as good
- 20:50a starting point as any. And from there you can grow into other literature and learn more.
- 20:57I've also come across very good podcasts. The Economist, for example, does very good
- 21:03podcasts. They have a separate one on China. I think it's called Drum Tower. Also easy
- 21:10listening and very informative.
- 21:12Yeah, and it just gives one a different perspective and it introduces you to a world other than
- 21:17the one in which you spend your every day.
- 21:20Thank you very much.
- 21:21Thank you.
- 21:26Thank you for listening to this episode of the So What podcast. If you like it, please
- 21:31subscribe, rate and share. This is the last one for 2023. If you haven't already, you
- 21:39might want to listen to the 10 other episodes available. And we'll be back in February 2024.
- 21:47Until then, goodbye.