Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Developing a Secure Base for Exploration
Transcript
- 0:00So welcome everybody. This is I love you keep going.
- 0:03It is Thursday, November 14th, 2024 at 7:35 PM Pacific Time.
- 0:09And tonight what I I thought that I would talk about is
- 0:14developing a secure base for exploration.
- 0:17It's one of the the things we heard back from that series of
- 0:21talks I did on exploration, which is what is the secure base
- 0:28to explore from and how do you actually go about developing
- 0:31them? And this is really a process of
- 0:36identifying who it is that might make sense to use as somebody in
- 0:42a secure base. And then understanding the the
- 0:45structure of relationships and also understanding how much
- 0:51support you need in order to feel supported in order to take
- 0:55the risks for the exploration that you need to do.
- 1:02I like to talk about it in the in the frame of Robin Dunbar's
- 1:05work. He's initially started exploring
- 1:11whether there was a physical limit to the number of faces
- 1:14that the the, the brain could store and recognize.
- 1:20And he came up with a number of 150.
- 1:24And then what he wanted to understand was how many people
- 1:31do you need to know in order to feel secure and supported in
- 1:38life and what kind of relationships those might be?
- 1:43Part of that was his interest in whether or not the number 150
- 1:48showed up anywhere in the structures of society.
- 1:52Did we just sort of take that in?
- 1:55So what he noticed is that a lot of police departments evaluate
- 2:00the number of officers they need based on the number 150 that the
- 2:04the Roman legions. Originally the the one of this
- 2:08group sizes was 150. In corporate structures, often
- 2:15divisions of the company are 150.
- 2:19And in looking into that, what he thought was that in because
- 2:26we have the capacity to recognize 150 faces.
- 2:32If you live in a small enough community where you actually can
- 2:35recognize everyone in the community, there's no need for
- 2:39outside organization or outside intervention because you just
- 2:43recognize everybody and what everybody is doing.
- 2:48But there needs to be some disciplining or some correction
- 2:52and particular group members. The group can handle it at that
- 2:56level. But once you get beyond the 150
- 3:00where you don't recognize everybody, then there needs to
- 3:03be some kind of structure that's imposed so that order within the
- 3:08community can be maintained. But do we need to know 150
- 3:15people well in order to be happy, in order to have a sense
- 3:20of being supported and connected into the world?
- 3:23And So what he began to do is explore the the structure of
- 3:29relationships. And he came out originally with
- 3:34research that suggested that there were A relationships, B
- 3:37relationships, C relationships and D relationships, and that
- 3:42these correspond to your engagement in the world.
- 3:46So above the line and below the line.
- 3:48So A&B relationships are above the line and C&D relationships
- 3:52are below the line. In and above the line.
- 3:58Orientation in a relationship, you tell the other person
- 4:02everything about your experience.
- 4:04And So what does that actually mean that you that we all carry
- 4:08around the phone that's packed with evidence of every horrible
- 4:13thing that we've ever done. And we make somebody go through
- 4:15the phone and check off every picture to make sure that they
- 4:20they have a sense of who we are. Or is it more likely that we are
- 4:26willing to express our experience of the present moment
- 4:30in a complete way so that they understand our experience of the
- 4:35present moment? And that the if there is a an
- 4:41abandonment fear that activates us as a result of expressing our
- 4:48point of view that we are still able to do it, that making
- 4:52sense. One of the things that you may
- 4:55notice about interpersonal relationships is there's a sense
- 5:01of connection and a sense of abandoned.
- 5:03And the more important the person is for our sense of
- 5:07connection, the greater the risk that we would face if we were
- 5:11abandoned by them. And when you recognize that your
- 5:16experience of something might differ from what you know about
- 5:20their the way that they experience things, that can
- 5:22cause a spike in abandonment terror.
- 5:26Then if you find that the the thought of losing them exceeds
- 5:32your capacity to manage it, then you might find yourself limiting
- 5:37or spinning or incompletely representing your experience of
- 5:43the present moment. Does that make sense?
- 5:47So what we think is that if you have a solid A or B
- 5:52relationship, that is to say you have a relationship with
- 5:56somebody where you tell them everything.
- 5:58That means that even if there is some sense of abandonment risk,
- 6:02you're able to overcome it and express yourself so that they
- 6:06really have a sense of what you're experiencing.
- 6:10The reason that this is so important in relationships is
- 6:13because our sense of being seen by somebody, being known by
- 6:17somebody, being understood by somebody actually depends on our
- 6:22willingness to accurately represent our experience.
- 6:26And if we're not willing to do that, it is accompanied by a
- 6:31backlash of feeling unseen, unknown and misunderstood.
- 6:38Makes sense. So then we might talk about the
- 6:42difference between A&B relationships and understand
- 6:46that secure functioning relationships, the main purpose
- 6:50of the relationship is to support you in your primary
- 6:55pursuit of meaningfulness in your life, not to provide the
- 7:00meaningfulness of your life. And So what you really need from
- 7:06somebody is them supporting you to actually take the risks that
- 7:10you need to, to discover the things that you want to know.
- 7:17And Alex, did you get a haircut? Trying to figure out what it
- 7:30was, But that finally hit me. Sorry to throw you off.
- 7:35Yeah, it's it's much shorter. All right, good to know.
- 7:48So in discussing A&B relationships, it's partly the
- 7:52the level of care that you provide and partly the
- 7:56orientation of exploration in the relationship.
- 8:00In a primary relationship and a relationship, we're really
- 8:06looking at committing to taking care of somebody on a daily or
- 8:09an every other day basis, quite a substantial commitment.
- 8:14And then we're also agreeing to move our primary exploration
- 8:18from first position into second position and moving the needs of
- 8:22the relationship into first position.
- 8:25And what that means is that if there's something that you're
- 8:29interested in exploring, something that you're interested
- 8:31in committing to, and it's going to in some way compromise
- 8:37agreements that you have in your primary relationship, then you
- 8:41need to negotiate with your partner how that might be
- 8:46incorporated rather than simply having the freedom to say yes or
- 8:51no to it. That making sense.
- 8:54So I'll give you an example. All your life you've worked for
- 8:58this opportunity that you want and you finally get an offer for
- 9:02exactly what you've been working for your whole life and it's in
- 9:07New York and you live in Los Angeles with your partner.
- 9:10You could not say yes to that position without discussing with
- 9:15your partner how it was going to affect them particularly in
- 9:20fact, included moving across the country or you moving across the
- 9:23country and them staying where they are.
- 9:27And it might even be that that that you can't come into an
- 9:30accommodation that will preserve the relationship.
- 9:34And so you might actually end up in preserving the relationship
- 9:38not being able to take the opportunity.
- 9:41So that level of commitment is quite substantial.
- 9:46And I think that in most of the difficulties I see in my work
- 9:52with couples is that one person is in a a relationship and the
- 9:58other is in AB relationship and they're not willing to
- 10:02compromise their exploration for the needs of the relationship
- 10:05and the their partner who is resents them for it.
- 10:09And often it doesn't. The relationships don't survive
- 10:12that one when it's a substantial change like the one I mentioned.
- 10:21In AB relationship, it's really more weekly or every other week
- 10:25that you're seeing the person. I'd like to say in person, it
- 10:29didn't used to be. It's something that had to be
- 10:31qualified, but now it is because of this, even this experience on
- 10:37Zoom, you have to be able to be within the electrical energy of
- 10:41the other person in order for the emotional Co regulation
- 10:45experiences to work really well. Zoom is not adequate.
- 10:49The telephone is not adequate for that.
- 10:52It can be a stopgap measure that you employ until you actually do
- 10:57succeed in connecting, but it doesn't in itself work well
- 11:01enough. And so in AB relationship you
- 11:06also keep your primary exploration in first position.
- 11:10So that if you got that offer and you wanted to go accept it,
- 11:13you would just inform everybody that you were moving to New York
- 11:16and that they, they, we would need to adjust how that was
- 11:20going to go in terms of the obligations of the relationship.
- 11:27Then we have the line of, of Full disclosure.
- 11:30And in C relationships, you disclose some things, but not
- 11:34everything. Now you may find that there is
- 11:37somebody who is demonstrated that they're trustworthy and you
- 11:40do want to express everything to them, but there isn't the
- 11:47requirement of that in in C relationships.
- 11:52So you're really talking about somebody you see monthly or
- 11:55quarterly or often C relationships are people that
- 11:58you see in your work life and you tell them some things, but
- 12:05not everything. And typically for people who are
- 12:10of working age in, in our culture, the the C group is 30
- 12:17or 40 people. Is that making sense now?
- 12:22It's I don't know how these numbers might have been affected
- 12:27post COVID as because the the order of how work people's work
- 12:34lives is quite different than it was when we started D
- 12:40relationships are everybody else.
- 12:41So what you're really looking at is 100 people or so in the D
- 12:47group, which is our people that you you recognize and know some
- 12:52things about that you encounter in your ordinary maneuvering in
- 12:58life at least once a year. Is it surprising too, that a lot
- 13:04of people keep their families in the D group?
- 13:06They see them four times a year for holidays or whatever it is,
- 13:09and there's no intimacy really at all in the expression of the
- 13:14and no real care in what happens in the family.
- 13:23Then what Dunbar looked at was how many people do you really
- 13:28need to know? How many As do you need?
- 13:30How many BS do you need, how many CS, how many DS?
- 13:36And what he discovered was that not everybody likes to have an A
- 13:39relationship. Some people like it, drive on
- 13:43it, and some people prefer BS with benefits.
- 13:47There's a whole Poly world out there and spectrum between
- 13:53monogamy and polyamory, but because of the intensity of the
- 14:02resources that the A relationship take, most people
- 14:05like to have one a relationship if they they want to have them.
- 14:10And then B relationships, people you keep up with on a weekly or
- 14:13every other week basis that you know everything about, that you
- 14:16tell them everything about and really are important in
- 14:20supporting your exploration. Between two and five was what
- 14:27the the research demonstrated. So what we're really talking
- 14:34about in terms of developing a secure base is between 2:00 and
- 14:385:00 or six relationships. Do you have bandwidth to do
- 14:43that? Now, some people are parents,
- 14:46some people have kids. Kids are not included in this
- 14:48matrix because as the parent of a child, your obligation is to
- 14:54take care of them, not to obligate them to reciprocate
- 14:58care for you. It's supposed to be more one way
- 15:03in that sense. And we have a term for when
- 15:07caregivers involve their children, which is role
- 15:12reversing involving and role reversing.
- 15:15And it has a fairly a harmful effect on children when you put
- 15:22them into that position. But this should be quite
- 15:26distinct from the experience of a child being having a parent.
- 15:36Let the child know who they really are and what really
- 15:40matters to them. Sometimes in, in in
- 15:43relationships to parents, it's very role based and, and you
- 15:48don't really know anything about them.
- 15:50You don't know anything about their childhood experiences.
- 15:53You don't really know about what why they made the decisions that
- 15:58they made. You just really experience them
- 16:01in the role of of providing the care that they provide.
- 16:05But it is also very helpful for children to have a sense of who
- 16:09their caregivers are without any obligation then to take on care
- 16:19responsibilities for the caregiver.
- 16:22That you really have a sense that you are.
- 16:26You know who your caregiver is and they're interested in you
- 16:33and they know you. Is that making sense?
- 16:42So what do you need a secure base for?
- 16:45And this really is the thing about exploration.
- 16:54How do you know what your qualities are as a person?
- 17:00How do you know what your interests are as a person?
- 17:04How do you know what's meaningful to you as a person,
- 17:09particularly starting in childhood?
- 17:11And how you know that is by reflection of the caregiver of
- 17:18their experience of you. So, you know, starting in
- 17:24infancy, we, we just really are expressive.
- 17:28And what we're hoping for is a sensitively attuned enough
- 17:34caregiver who connects to us empathetically, who explores our
- 17:39expressions in order to understand what it is.
- 17:43And then somebody who takes that in, interprets it correctly,
- 17:50reflects it back to us so that we really understand it,
- 17:55understand ourselves and that reflection.
- 17:58We don't have the capacity as human beings to understand
- 18:03ourselves with any kind of accuracy if we have only our
- 18:09internal experience of ourselves.
- 18:12We really do need to know from the reflection of, in the, in
- 18:18the beginning, of course, it's the small number of caregivers
- 18:21that we have. And then as autobiographical,
- 18:26the capacity for autobiographical memory
- 18:29develops. And we're really talking about
- 18:32four or five or six here before it really becomes particularly
- 18:36fluid. And then we can begin to have a
- 18:40conscious recollection of the different reflections that were
- 18:45offered to us. We begin to know ourselves in
- 18:51the reflection of the other person, and we begin to build a
- 18:54working model of ourselves based on that reflection.
- 18:59Now, if you have a sensitively attuned caregiver who is able to
- 19:06empathetically connect you and has enough interest in you that
- 19:11they're able to see you, then what they reflect back to you is
- 19:16an accurate representation of who.
- 19:20But if you have a caregiver who misses to you, who's chaotic and
- 19:24is unable to track this for very long, who creates a represent an
- 19:30internal representation of you in within themselves, that is
- 19:34not particularly accurate. What they reflect back to you is
- 19:40also not particularly accurate. And so we come to know the
- 19:45reflection of who we are and whether it is actually accurate
- 19:50of who we are based on those reflections.
- 19:53So if we get a distorted perception of ourselves
- 19:56reflected to us, we begin to develop a sense of who we are
- 20:01that is quite distorted from who we are.
- 20:05And so you'll notice in a lot of internal conflict that arises
- 20:09from that if that's what's happened.
- 20:12Who did George, can you give? An example of this reflection
- 20:16piece. I think theoretically I
- 20:18understand, but when I imagine a caregiver and a kid playing what
- 20:24is meaningful to the kid, that doesn't make it's hard for me to
- 20:27imagine so. I'm, you know, I always think
- 20:37back to my own childhood for examples.
- 20:39And I didn't have a good childhood, so I don't have good
- 20:42examples. But I have an example, which is
- 20:45not a good example, which I can tell you when I was growing up,
- 20:51for the first couple of years of my life, my mother, she wanted a
- 20:58girl. So she dressed me up like a
- 21:00girl, mostly. And then when my sister was
- 21:04born, I flipped into being the male kid I was all along, but it
- 21:13was accompanied by a constant reflection back to me that my
- 21:18gestures were too effeminate. So from my earliest memories of
- 21:24my mother, it was always a correction for being too
- 21:28effeminate over and over and over again.
- 21:32But she was the only one who perceived me that way.
- 21:36Nobody else thought that. And so I became incredibly
- 21:42self-conscious about any gesture that I made because I, I the
- 21:47spontaneous stuff, if she was around was a terrible mistake
- 21:51and and painful that making sense.
- 21:56So her. Acceptance or or not acceptance
- 22:06of what you think of yourself. Was it's a little more primitive
- 22:15than that. Her response to me was that my
- 22:17gestures were too effeminate and so she constantly corrected me,
- 22:22which she thought was an appropriate thing for her to do.
- 22:25There was no insight beyond that.
- 22:30But in her reflecting back to me, these gestures, you know,
- 22:35ordinary gestures of a child long before any sense of gender
- 22:41identity, I became self-conscious about every
- 22:46everything because I wasn't sure how it was going to be
- 22:53interpreted by someone else. And it was very clear to me that
- 22:56I had no idea how to do any of that.
- 22:59So there was a what it ended up doing was completely undermining
- 23:04any chance of spontaneity, any chance of really understanding
- 23:11what any of that would have been, what if meant, or what any
- 23:17authentic preference of mine might have been in terms of the
- 23:20way that I wanted people to know.
- 23:25And later it was accompanied by not a correction, but an
- 23:31embarrassment and turning away. And so I also began to associate
- 23:37these faults of mine, which I was confused about and couldn't
- 23:40identify with a loss of affection.
- 23:43Is that making sense? Because it feels.
- 23:49Like a lot of mothers would do that for kids where they would
- 23:52say don't do this, don't do this like a million times a day.
- 23:56Right. Is that the same thing or where
- 23:59the kid is just being naughty and he wants to do touch
- 24:01everything or and there's a stopping him from doing what he
- 24:07wants to do? Right.
- 24:09And so at what point does that create a working model in
- 24:14yourself that is inhibitatory? And even in the way that you say
- 24:22naughty, it suggests to me that a lot of the spontaneous things
- 24:27that you might have enjoyed doing got classified in the
- 24:29naughty category. And so then how inhibiting of,
- 24:34of that is of your exploration, if you, you anticipate that
- 24:40response is really what we're talking about, how free are you
- 24:45and how supported and encouraged are you to explore something?
- 24:51And at what point do I, I do misidentify things that might be
- 24:56really interesting to you as the wrong category, right?
- 25:00Because it's in the category of the caregiver who's reflecting
- 25:04it to you. Is that making sense?
- 25:10So, and it doesn't matter so much whether they were right or
- 25:17not because we just adopt the the reflections.
- 25:22We don't have the cognitive mind to evaluate whether they're
- 25:25right or wrong or whether it's helpful or not helpful.
- 25:30We do understand how they respond to us and we do
- 25:35understand how we have to behave in order to elicit the responses
- 25:39that we need from them and to feel taken care of.
- 25:43Is that making sense now? What happens if one of the
- 25:52things that you find exciting about exploring drops into the
- 25:56naughty category? How do you get it out of there
- 25:59in order to be free to explore it and it, whereas it's simply
- 26:04abandoned in childhood because the reflections that you receive
- 26:10made it problematic, so it's never explored beyond that.
- 26:15This is one of the things that this process of exploring what's
- 26:18meaningful is how did you derive what was meaningful and useful
- 26:24for you to do that would be worth the time, energy, and
- 26:27resources that it would take to explore it.
- 26:32That is actually authentically you and not based on the
- 26:35reflection of the caregivers. When the caregiver is
- 26:39sensitively attuned to and identifies things that you are
- 26:43really interested in and identifies things that you're
- 26:46really good at and identifies what things you're doing that
- 26:51you derive meaning from and what things you don't.
- 26:54And then begins to support you in the direction of what you're,
- 26:58what you have the capacity to do, what matters to you, what's
- 27:01interesting to you that all the way along, those are the things
- 27:06that are valued and you develop the capacity to identify them
- 27:11and to pursue them. And when the things that matter
- 27:16to you are set aside in favor of the things that matter to the
- 27:21caregiver and they push you in the direction of what they think
- 27:25is useful to you, what ends up happening, of course, is we
- 27:30develop the capacity to explore the things that we were
- 27:34supported in exploring. And we don't value or develop
- 27:40the skills to explore the things that actually matter to us.
- 27:44And so we can easily arrive in a place where the successes so
- 27:51that we have don't really mean that much to us because they're
- 27:56actually not for us, they're for our caregivers.
- 28:02And while there is some satisfaction in your caregiver
- 28:06revelling in the things that you've achieved, if they don't
- 28:10really have a deep resonance with your yourself, they won't
- 28:13have enough meaning that would justify the difficulty of of
- 28:22excelling. That makes sense.
- 28:32I just was thinking. Of like dogs, for example Lucy
- 28:35where. She loves to.
- 28:37Bark all the time and you would just tell her to stop barking
- 28:41because it's just noise and it causes chaos.
- 28:45And so but there's other way where my friend put a collar on
- 28:50the dog that this electric shock collars to shut the dog down
- 28:56because he would used to bark so much.
- 28:59I just got reminded of that aspect where parents would not
- 29:04like a kid who's wants to make a lot of noise.
- 29:09Right, They might not. Then they would be failing their
- 29:13child. Let's not leave that part out.
- 29:18Lucy, like all reactive dogs, barks when she's frightened.
- 29:28And so really as a, as a sensitively attuned caregiver,
- 29:33one begins to explore what it is that is frightening so that you
- 29:40you can have some effect on what triggers it so that you can help
- 29:48with the down regulation, which is actually what your caregivers
- 29:51are supposed to do with you. They're supposed to identify the
- 29:55things that are upsetting to you and they're supposed to hold the
- 29:59environment so that you have a sense of safety and they're
- 30:03supposed to be able to help you emotionally down regulated or
- 30:07down regulate when you get too amped The.
- 30:15And you know, humans are quite different from dogs in that way.
- 30:23But yes, you can, you can take a child and you can punish them
- 30:31and you can be punitive and you can force them into complying
- 30:36with the edicts because they're terrified of what of what will
- 30:39happen to them if they don't. But that won't foster the
- 30:46development of security or relationships or exploration.
- 30:55Christian, I don't know George I.
- 30:59I really like Mudit's idea about the shot caller for children,
- 31:02because they won't know that it's you that's punishing them,
- 31:06they'll just attribute it to the caller.
- 31:14Start a new company. They already have inserts or the
- 31:20human body that you can shock at any time randomly from your
- 31:26phone, just so that you know that you're connected.
- 31:29That way you can get at any of your sex toy Realtors.
- 31:43Yes, that's kind of nice. Like emotionally monitoring
- 31:50emotions and then. Yeah, just thinking of you.
- 31:59I am. It is.
- 32:07I'm always overcome by the the the the level of cruelty that we
- 32:13all have to manage. What would it have been like, do
- 32:22you think, if you had a caregiver that was really
- 32:26interested in you, that was really curious about your
- 32:30thought processes, that was really actively inquiring about
- 32:36the things that mattered to you? And I was constantly reflecting
- 32:41back to you their experience of your your experience in the
- 32:49world, so that you actually had a pretty accurate picture of who
- 32:53you are and what you were good at and what what was interesting
- 32:58to you and what you wanted to do.
- 33:02And then they fostered situations where all of all of
- 33:07that was supported. So that's how you managed life.
- 33:14You looked at the world and you saw the things that it was
- 33:17offering and went after them with an abandoned because you
- 33:26knew that your caregivers would catch you if it if you fell too
- 33:31hard, you would have a a very different life than you probably
- 33:38have. Because people who can do that,
- 33:44they, they really don't come to my classes.
- 33:57And so part of this is, of course, I'm really a long way
- 34:03around to get to this is the the main thing that you're secure
- 34:09base is meant to do to you is reflect you back to you so that
- 34:12you can see yourself and you can see yourself accurately.
- 34:18And then you can begin to understand what actually that
- 34:21the things that you engage and need to you so that you can, you
- 34:26know, organize yourself in such a way that you're moving in the
- 34:30direction of the things that matter so that your time, energy
- 34:34and resources are going toward the things that matter to you.
- 34:37And you're not burning them up on things that don't matter so
- 34:40much. We, of course, live in a human
- 34:43body, which will grow old, get sick and die at some point.
- 34:46And that also means that the time, energy and resources that
- 34:50you have when you were young, you don't have throughout your
- 34:53life. And so really, the the faster
- 34:56you figure this out and the better you are at it, the better
- 34:59chance you have as you move into the later periods of life.
- 35:04If you're if you live so long, you're you're the stuff that
- 35:10really matters is that the top of the list did not just cast
- 35:13aside that all making sense. What we want to do.
- 35:23So what we need to be able to do in order for us to see ourselves
- 35:27and what matters to us and how to organize the pursuit of that,
- 35:31is to tell reliable people what our experience is so that they
- 35:37can hear it and then reflect back to us, because we will not
- 35:42be able to do that in isolation for ourselves.
- 35:48It's too easy to lose track. It's too easy to distort.
- 35:54It's too easy to let yourself off the hook of having to go
- 36:07after it. That's a good way to put it.
- 36:12Is that making sense? If you don't tell anybody what
- 36:15matters to you and they can't track whether you're going after
- 36:18it or not. If you don't have enough of a
- 36:23sense of satisfaction in your life and and you can't figure it
- 36:27out, if you don't tell somebody, they won't be able to reflect
- 36:29back to you what's happening. So you, you often are unable to
- 36:34see it, you can't see it, you can't do anything about it.
- 36:38Is that making sense? If you and you know, I, I talk
- 36:56about this often as behind people who are emotionally
- 36:59regulating because that's the, that's what you need from them
- 37:02ultimately to support your exploration.
- 37:05And the only way that somebody is going to give you that
- 37:08emotional regulation enough and freely is if you're also
- 37:12regulating for them and they can use use you that for that.
- 37:17If you don't have a good emotional regulator, you're
- 37:19going to curtail your exploration because the
- 37:22dysregulation that can come from taking those kinds of risks is
- 37:28too distressing if you don't have a way of dealing with it.
- 37:32What you'll notice in people that don't really put the energy
- 37:37into these supportive bases is that their their their risk
- 37:45taking is limited because the the consequences of healing are
- 37:51too much. They might get really good at
- 37:54secondary exploration. You often see that they don't
- 37:57take the primary exploration risks too much because it's too
- 38:01destabilizing. And then you have somebody to
- 38:08celebrate with, which is also, I think, an important aspect of
- 38:12this. You do well at something that
- 38:14really matters to you and the people in your secure base know
- 38:19about it and see that you do well and celebrate with you that
- 38:23you've been able to do it, and then you celebrate with them
- 38:27when they're able to do it. Carries you forward in life as
- 38:34life gets more difficult as you age.
- 38:39That'll making sense trying to. So then how many people do you
- 38:45need 2345? Not so many.
- 38:53How many, how many nights a week can you go out to dinner with
- 38:57people you know, how do you want to set it up?
- 39:10I'm, you know, I, I'm, I like to over commit.
- 39:12I don't say I like to over commit.
- 39:14I have a habit of over committing and, and so I like to
- 39:21have things scheduled. I have open-ended invitations on
- 39:26Sunday afternoon and Wednesday night and things I do on
- 39:33Tuesdays and Saturdays that are every week so that they just
- 39:38happen right. My closest friend I, we have
- 39:44dinner for like 40 * a year. I mean, it's it's a lovely
- 39:49thing. Or yeah, I have two, two friends
- 39:56that I have dinner with 40 times a year.
- 40:01I'd enjoy that. All right.
- 40:05What do we what do you say we do some meditation?
- 40:14The pasta or meta? Which one?
- 40:23Vipassana, yes, V for Vipassana no, it's 2.
- 40:32For the second one, meta. Oh, OK, I'm too literal or math
- 40:42is really hard. All right, we'll do some loving
- 40:52kindness practice for an easy person event for self.
- 40:55So go ahead and settle in. All right, let's go of the
- 40:59meditation. Comments or questions about the
- 41:02meditation? Who did?
- 41:10Yeah, realized. The first thing is that feeling
- 41:13peaceful? May I be peaceful?
- 41:17It's never about feeling peaceful directly, it's about
- 41:31the intention that this person have well-being essentially.
- 41:40Right. And then the second.
- 41:42Thing I want to ask is sometimes the sense of self worth is still
- 41:47very much associated with material.
- 41:50Success, right? Not with the.
- 41:54Being itself so I'm not sure so I.
- 41:58I think of that as secondary versus primary exploration.
- 42:05Sometimes they line up and sometimes they don't, and then
- 42:10you feel cultural pressure usually, and this is one of the
- 42:14great difficulties of primary exploration.
- 42:18What happens when the culture that you're in provides a low
- 42:23evaluation to the things that really matter to you?
- 42:27How then do you justify putting time, energy and resources into
- 42:31that when you could do something else that was much less
- 42:35meaningful, that was much higher value culturally where but even
- 42:42when you achieve the the higher level, sometimes it comes with,
- 42:46you know, a whole different level of the capacity to live,
- 42:53but it doesn't provide the same level of meaning.
- 42:55How do you manage that? And how long does it take you to
- 43:04figure out that actually the IT accumulates the level of
- 43:10dissatisfaction and disappointment in pursuing the
- 43:14secondary exploration at the expense of the primary?
- 43:19And you, you might not catch it until you've given a couple of
- 43:23decades away to the cultural valued over your own.
- 43:31And it's a, it's a terrible bitterness that, yeah, I
- 43:35realize. It's not so much it's it's my
- 43:38own belief that and it's not that I mean I have more money,
- 43:43but the safety or the the feeling that you're getting from
- 43:48the material success is actually wholesome.
- 43:52It's just the cause might be different, but it's almost like
- 43:57I have to may I have it so I can pursue what I want to pursue
- 44:02that's. The idea but it but it is an
- 44:06illusion I think to suggest that you.
- 44:09I'll do just the secondary exploration now and gather all
- 44:12the resources I need, and then at some time in the unspecified
- 44:17future pursue the thing that I need to do to to have a
- 44:23meaningful life. I agree wholeheartedly that most
- 44:29of us are in a position where we have to do both pursue the
- 44:33primary meeting and the secondary, but we need to do it
- 44:37in a way that each day has a space for the primary
- 44:41exploration. You can't keep putting it off
- 44:46the, you know, you have to develop the skill of it.
- 44:49You have to get good at it. And you can't get good at it if
- 44:53it isn't something that you do consistently.
- 44:58And if you can't get good at it, of course, it blunts the, the,
- 45:01the depth of meaning that you can come to.
- 45:09That's why the the the weekend warrior isn't the approach, it's
- 45:14the daily couple of hours a day. How do you carve out a couple of
- 45:19hours a day that you can just give to the thing that you
- 45:22really prefer to do and that actually makes all the other
- 45:29stuff much easier to do. But even.
- 45:34Without pursuing meaning I can be I mean to mental self esteem
- 45:40can be or is the self love that we talked about can still be
- 45:44built right regardless of pursuing say primary exploration
- 45:49or not true. Thank you, Alex.
- 46:00Yeah. Hydroge, I had two questions. 1
- 46:03You want to talk about the PD, like the energy, so there'll be
- 46:06like physical sensations associated with that, yeah.
- 46:10Like a. Tingling or something like that.
- 46:13And then, so then I'll shut up after my second question is what
- 46:16do you think about like directing Meta like complicated
- 46:19people in our lives with complicated relationships with
- 46:21like complicated relationships with like, like family members
- 46:24with complicated relationships? Well, we we really I don't spend
- 46:28too much time except on self an easy person.
- 46:32But there is other categories. Santa Indica uses easy person
- 46:41because in the West he says that we don't value teachers, mentors
- 46:46and benefactors particularly, but in the East that they do.
- 46:51And so that's that category. In the traditional practice, he
- 46:55then uses close persons because we're less traditional.
- 47:02Society and spouses is the other one.
- 47:05So close persons are the people and I like to call them your
- 47:09A's. And B's is the next category and
- 47:13then friends and family is the next category.
- 47:17So that's who sees and D's and then difficult people is the
- 47:23next category and then old sentient beings is the last.
- 47:29So you would practice for each of the categories if you did a
- 47:33full cycle. Yeah, OK, I've I've read about
- 47:37that some in the past, but it's. To me it seems.
- 47:41Like the Yeah, the, you know, like a.
- 47:45It's apparent you have a complicated relationship with.
- 47:47Is it? Do you think it would be useful
- 47:52personal development exercise to try?
- 47:55And direct. Meta at them.
- 47:57Yeah. So, so just do the difficult
- 47:59category. Yeah, yes.
- 48:02OK, now. Remember that the far enemy of
- 48:05loving kindness is anger and so you do not want to sit in the
- 48:09practice and notice that the mind is inclining to anger and
- 48:12get totally swept up in the anger would be defeating of
- 48:15practice. So you would want to back out to
- 48:19the easy person if that happened and then come back until you
- 48:24could actually hold the space without the mind getting angry.
- 48:32Thank you, I like the haircut. I realized I didn't say that
- 48:36earlier. It looks good.
- 48:38Thank you again, it's kind. $18. From an old Italian guy who took
- 48:45only cash. Really nice.
- 49:00All right, so this Saturday I'm doing 1/2 day retreat called
- 49:08Family archaeology or going home for the holidays, which I think
- 49:13is a, is a, it's just a conversation about seeing your
- 49:19caregivers and siblings and your family clearly understanding
- 49:25clearly what your needs are from them and then evaluating whether
- 49:31or not you think you could get them.
- 49:32And so adjusting your expectations.
- 49:35Often times what happens to us is that we're, we get frustrated
- 49:39and angry over the, over the, the lack of responsiveness to
- 49:43the needs that we have and that just clouds or prevents us from
- 49:51receiving from, from them what they could actually give us.
- 49:55It's very hard to overestimate the need that we have for our
- 50:00caregivers to have loved us or to love us and that if we can
- 50:05really get any sense of that, it's really very valuable to us
- 50:11as human beings. And at the same time, not
- 50:14allowing yourself to be harmed in the context of that
- 50:19relationship is important. So we're going to look at that.
- 50:22And then in December I'm going to do a, a, a shorter 3 hour
- 50:28conversation about my photographic work.
- 50:31When I did the exploration half day a few weeks ago, I got a lot
- 50:37of requests to just spend time going over the photographs,
- 50:42which I'll do on that occasion, but there won't be much in the
- 50:46way of teaching it. It'd just be a, a dialogue about
- 50:51that. And then we've arrived at the
- 50:54end of the year, so the stuff is up on the website.
- 51:01Take a look at it. I really appreciate your
- 51:03practice. I'm glad that you come and
- 51:07ioffer the teaching freely. But I do hope if your resource
- 51:10that you'll consider making a donation.
- 51:14It does help support me and the work that Medigroup is doing.
- 51:20See, I can put a link in there for that.
- 51:26Any amount is appreciated, but of course it's not required.
- 51:32You're welcome to practice. Yes, sympathetic joy practice.
- 51:47I'm seeing that there's something in the chat.
- 51:54One of the things that's really useful about getting good at
- 51:58sympathetic joy practice or Moody to practice is being
- 52:00joyful in the successes of other people is you get a lot of
- 52:04invitations to celebrate. Whereas if you're curmudgeonly
- 52:09and you're jealous and envious of other people's successes,
- 52:12you, you, you miss out on a lot of invites.
- 52:16And it's nice to engage in the world and people's a triumphs.
- 52:24Christian Georgia I. Guess I was curious, I I thought
- 52:30just in terms of what mudit was describing earlier, if like
- 52:35mudita might almost be a sort of natural.
- 52:41I see where you're going with this.
- 52:44I, I, I don't know. I I It's ironic.
- 52:50Because that's the hardest thing for me.
- 52:53I guess each of herself. The independence of each other
- 53:04and then you are on that side of me, on this side makes it very
- 53:10self oriented culture. And your money is your money,
- 53:17your my money is my money. Your like your enlightenment,
- 53:21your enlightenment and my enlightenment is my
- 53:23enlightenment. So it's very doggy dog.
- 53:32This is a. Complete tragic failure to
- 53:35comprehend Darwin because it was evident that what he was getting
- 53:43at was that it was not a doggy dog world, it was a
- 53:46collaborative world and that the species that are able to
- 53:51collaborate do way better than the species that are not able to
- 53:54collaborate. Which is why we are the apex
- 53:58predator. Not because it's dog eat dog,
- 54:02George, you don't. Think that if you had happened
- 54:04to unfortunately I'm not trying to curse you, collapse in your
- 54:09in your space here, that Lucy wouldn't eventually think that
- 54:12your face looked pretty delicious.
- 54:17Cats apparently eat you immediately and dogs wait a
- 54:22couple of days. Thank you.
- 54:34We'll see you soon. Thank you, George.