Latest / Bloomberg Law / Weekend Law: Meet the Trump Jury & Jan 6 Obstruction Charges
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:09Speaker 2: In a jury selection is largely luck. It depends who
- 0:12Speaker 2: you get.
- 0:13Speaker 1: Donald Trump is right that luck does play a part
- 0:16Speaker 1: in jury selection, as well as a host of other
- 0:19Speaker 1: factors considered. During four days of wadir in the hush
- 0:24Speaker 1: money trial of the former president, the trial judge, prosecutors,
- 0:27Speaker 1: and defense attorneys vetted almost two hundred prospective jurors to
- 0:32Speaker 1: weed out people who might be biased one way or
- 0:35Speaker 1: the other, and a jury of five women and seven
- 0:38Speaker 1: men has been sworn in to hear the historic case
- 0:41Speaker 1: in which Trump is accused of falsifying business records to
- 0:45Speaker 1: conceal a sex scandal before the twenty sixteen election. The
- 0:49Speaker 1: jury includes a teacher, a software engineer, an investment banker,
- 0:53Speaker 1: a speech therapist, a security engineer, a physical therapist, a
- 0:58Speaker 1: retired wealth manager, and two lawyers. Joining me to take
- 1:02Speaker 1: some of the mystery out of jury selection is former
- 1:05Speaker 1: federal prosecutor Robert Mintz, a partner McCarter in English, Bob.
- 1:09Speaker 1: Before we get to these jurors, I want to talk
- 1:11Speaker 1: about jury selection in general. So in this case, they
- 1:14Speaker 1: started with a large pool of prospective jurors, and about
- 1:18Speaker 1: half said they couldn't be fair and impartial, So right
- 1:21Speaker 1: off the bat, the judge dismissed those jurors. Then eighteen
- 1:25Speaker 1: of the remaining jurors were seated in the jury box,
- 1:28Speaker 1: and the prosecution and defense each got a half an
- 1:31Speaker 1: hour to question them individually. That's unlike federal court, where
- 1:35Speaker 1: the judge does the questioning. So tell us, as a
- 1:38Speaker 1: trial lawyer, when you're questioning the jurors individually, what are
- 1:42Speaker 1: you trying to do? Assess their honesty, make a connection.
- 1:46Speaker 1: What's your goal?
- 1:48Speaker 3: Well, what you're trying to do is find jurors who
- 1:50Speaker 3: may be sympathetic to your side. So you're looking for
- 1:54Speaker 3: every sign that you can about how they might view
- 1:58Speaker 3: the case, whether they're going to be rule for, whether
- 2:00Speaker 3: they are going to be somebody who's going to be
- 2:03Speaker 3: more guided by their emotions, whether they're going to like
- 2:06Speaker 3: your client if you're on the defense, and if you're
- 2:08Speaker 3: the prosecution, whether or not they're going to like the
- 2:11Speaker 3: government's case. So it really is much more of an
- 2:14Speaker 3: art form than it is a science, because jurors don't
- 2:18Speaker 3: tell you everything about them, and what they say may
- 2:21Speaker 3: or may not be true. It really is a bit
- 2:23Speaker 3: of luck in selecting the jury, and ultimately it is
- 2:27Speaker 3: a guessing game for lawyers to try to pick curers
- 2:30Speaker 3: and try to make sure they're going to pick somebody
- 2:32Speaker 3: who is going to be fair to their respective side.
- 2:35Speaker 1: Now to jury challenges, you have four cause challenges for
- 2:40Speaker 1: when you think a juror can't be fair or impartial,
- 2:43Speaker 1: but the judge has to rule on whether you'll get
- 2:45Speaker 1: a four caused challenge. Then you have peremptories, which means
- 2:50Speaker 1: you can challenge a juror for any reason except for
- 2:54Speaker 1: reasons of race, sex, ethnicity, and the like. But those
- 2:57Speaker 1: peremptories are limited, and in this case, each side had
- 3:01Speaker 1: only ten. How do you decide how to.
- 3:04Speaker 3: Use those, Well, that becomes very tricky. You're looking at
- 3:07Speaker 3: this jury pool and you have your ten parentory challenges,
- 3:11Speaker 3: which you are essentially challenges that you can ask the
- 3:14Speaker 3: judge to remove agur for almost any reason. As you say,
- 3:17Speaker 3: you cannot remove ajuror based upon their race or ethnicity
- 3:20Speaker 3: or some kind of improper reason, but for just about
- 3:23Speaker 3: anything else. You don't have to explain why you want
- 3:26Speaker 3: to remove them. So you want to use those sparingly
- 3:29Speaker 3: you want to move somebody off the jury if you
- 3:32Speaker 3: really think they're going to be bad for your client.
- 3:34Speaker 3: But once you run out of your peremptories, then you're
- 3:37Speaker 3: basically stuck with that jury unless there is what's called
- 3:41Speaker 3: a four cause reason, and that is much more difficult.
- 3:44Speaker 3: That's where you have to convince the judge that the
- 3:46Speaker 3: juror cannot be fair, and that is a much bigger challenge.
- 3:50Speaker 3: So you guard those peremptory challenges very carefully, trying to
- 3:53Speaker 3: save at least one until near the end, so you
- 3:56Speaker 3: make sure you're removing anybody who you think is going
- 3:59Speaker 3: to be not good for your client, but you have
- 4:01Speaker 3: something left in case somebody comes along who you really
- 4:03Speaker 3: don't like. But eventually you do run out of those
- 4:06Speaker 3: and then you're pretty much stuck with the jury unless
- 4:08Speaker 3: you can show that this curor simply cannot be fair
- 4:11Speaker 3: to your client.
- 4:12Speaker 1: And I think that's what happened to the defense here,
- 4:14Speaker 1: because one juror who works in product development said this
- 4:18Speaker 1: about Trump. I don't like his persona, how he presents
- 4:22Speaker 1: himself in public. He seems very selfish and self serving.
- 4:27Speaker 1: And when the defense lawyer said it sounds a bit
- 4:30Speaker 1: like what you're saying is you don't like him. She
- 4:33Speaker 1: responded yes, and the defense attorney asked for her to
- 4:37Speaker 1: be dismissed for cause, and the judge refused. But the
- 4:41Speaker 1: defense had no peremptories left.
- 4:43Speaker 3: You would use your peremptory for someone like that if
- 4:46Speaker 3: you have any left, And that's exactly the type of
- 4:48Speaker 3: jury you would want removed. You don't want somebody sitting
- 4:52Speaker 3: on the jury who has told the court that they
- 4:54Speaker 3: don't like your client, if you're a defense lawyer. But
- 4:57Speaker 3: in this case, that is not, at least in the
- 5:00Speaker 3: of the judge a basis to remove somebody. You're not
- 5:03Speaker 3: going to find a lot of jurors who have no
- 5:06Speaker 3: opinion about former President Trump one way or the other.
- 5:09Speaker 3: And if you use that logic, then somebody who liked
- 5:12Speaker 3: him would be removed by the prosecution, and anybody who
- 5:15Speaker 3: didn't like them would be removed by the defense. So
- 5:17Speaker 3: the judge has said there has to be something more
- 5:20Speaker 3: than that. If they say that, regardless of what their
- 5:22Speaker 3: personal feelings are about him as president or as a person,
- 5:27Speaker 3: they can put that aside and make a decision about
- 5:29Speaker 3: his guilt or innocence based solely on the evidence that's
- 5:32Speaker 3: presented a trial, the judge is going to leave them
- 5:35Speaker 3: on the jury. No question that the defense is not
- 5:38Speaker 3: thrilled having that curor on the jury, but at that
- 5:41Speaker 3: point they had no peremptory challenges.
- 5:43Speaker 1: Let's look at some of the others who were selected
- 5:45Speaker 1: to be on the jury. What strikes me first is
- 5:48Speaker 1: that there are two lawyers, a civil litigator and a
- 5:51Speaker 1: corporate lawyer. And there used to be a time when
- 5:54Speaker 1: lawyers weren't allowed to sit on juries because jurors might
- 5:58Speaker 1: turn to them as the thought already on the law.
- 6:00Speaker 1: You know, what, do you think, you're a lawyer.
- 6:03Speaker 3: Yeah, it's totally uncommon to have even one lawyer sit
- 6:06Speaker 3: on a jury led alone, too, because basically, whether you're
- 6:10Speaker 3: the prosecution or the defense, you really don't want a
- 6:14Speaker 3: lawyer sitting on that jury because they're going to have
- 6:17Speaker 3: outsized influence. Other jurors may defer to them. So we
- 6:21Speaker 3: really don't know what kind of influence a lawyer could
- 6:24Speaker 3: have on the other jurors. And unless you're one hundred
- 6:27Speaker 3: percent certain that that lawyer is in your camp and
- 6:30Speaker 3: that lawyer is going to be favoring your client, whether
- 6:33Speaker 3: you're the prosecution, or the defense. You don't generally want
- 6:36Speaker 3: to put that much power in the hands of one juror,
- 6:40Speaker 3: and what you really want to do is make sure
- 6:42Speaker 3: that everybody on the jury sort of has an equal stay.
- 6:44Speaker 3: They all bring their collective backgrounds to the deliberation process,
- 6:48Speaker 3: rather than having one person who will convince other jurors.
- 6:53Speaker 3: But the prevailing view is that two lawyers on the
- 6:56Speaker 3: jury might actually benefit the defense more than the prosecution
- 7:00Speaker 3: because of the defense strategy here is to try to
- 7:03Speaker 3: convincedures that there's a technical error in this case, that
- 7:08Speaker 3: this is really just a technical violation, that it really
- 7:11Speaker 3: doesn't rise to the level of a crime. A lawyer
- 7:14Speaker 3: on a jury may find that more persuasive than somebody
- 7:17Speaker 3: who's not a lawyer. So it's possible that these two
- 7:21Speaker 3: lawyers may actually help the defense more than the prosecution.
- 7:25Speaker 3: But having said that, at the time that these two
- 7:28Speaker 3: lawyers were still being questioned by both sides, both the
- 7:32Speaker 3: prosecution and the defense still had parentary challenges left. In
- 7:35Speaker 3: other words, either side could have removed one or both
- 7:39Speaker 3: of those lawyers, and neither chose to do it. So
- 7:42Speaker 3: what that tells us is that the prosecution on the
- 7:44Speaker 3: defense viewed those lawyers in completely different ways. The prosecutors
- 7:49Speaker 3: thinking that a lawyer will actually be good for their case,
- 7:53Speaker 3: somebody who will follow the judges instructions carefully, who will
- 7:57Speaker 3: look at the facts analytically rather than emotionally, while the
- 8:01Speaker 3: defense looked at the singing two lawyers and thought they'll
- 8:04Speaker 3: be good for the defense because they may be able
- 8:07Speaker 3: to cut through the emotion of the case. Look at
- 8:09Speaker 3: this case as much more of a technical violation that
- 8:13Speaker 3: is not sufficient to convict the former president.
- 8:16Speaker 1: Several jurors have college educations, plus two have master's degrees,
- 8:21Speaker 1: one has a doctorate, two the lawyers have jds. Isn't
- 8:25Speaker 1: that what the prosecution was looking for.
- 8:27Speaker 3: The prevailing view in terms of jury selection going into
- 8:31Speaker 3: this case is that prosecutors would be looking for a
- 8:34Speaker 3: more educated jury. In other words, they would probably want
- 8:38Speaker 3: to steer away from more blue collar workers, they'd want
- 8:42Speaker 3: to steer away from civil servants. They'd be looking for
- 8:45Speaker 3: a jury that included perhaps more educated jurors who would
- 8:50Speaker 3: look at the case carefully, analytically, who would be able
- 8:54Speaker 3: to follow the judge's instructions, because at the end of
- 8:57Speaker 3: the day, following the instructions of the is going to
- 9:00Speaker 3: be critical for the prosecution if they're going to get
- 9:03Speaker 3: a conviction here. So when you look at this jury
- 9:06Speaker 3: and you look at the educational background of this jury,
- 9:08Speaker 3: you would think that the prosecutors are very happy with
- 9:12Speaker 3: these twelve jurors.
- 9:13Speaker 1: During the jury selection, the defense spent a lot of
- 9:16Speaker 1: time delving into jurors social media posts going back years.
- 9:21Speaker 1: What do you think the defense was looking for in
- 9:23Speaker 1: a juror.
- 9:24Speaker 3: Yeah, I think from the defense side, what you don't
- 9:27Speaker 3: want is a zeal it. You don't want somebody who's
- 9:29Speaker 3: politically active. You don't want someone who is going to
- 9:32Speaker 3: go into this trial as a way to try to
- 9:35Speaker 3: even the score for what they believe to be any
- 9:38Speaker 3: kinds of injustices that were committed by former President Trump,
- 9:42Speaker 3: having nothing to do with the charges here. So I
- 9:44Speaker 3: think they were scouring social media. They were asking jurors
- 9:48Speaker 3: questions about where they got their news. Did they watch MSNBC,
- 9:51Speaker 3: did they watch Fox News? How much do they know
- 9:54Speaker 3: about this case? And they basically want somebody who may
- 9:57Speaker 3: not know that much about it, who will come to
- 10:00Speaker 3: this trial with an open mind, and someone who will
- 10:03Speaker 3: hear their case because what's going to happen here is
- 10:06Speaker 3: we're going to see dueling stories here. We're going to
- 10:08Speaker 3: see conflicting stories being told by the defense and the prosecution.
- 10:12Speaker 3: The prosecution is going to say this is a serious case.
- 10:16Speaker 3: It's not simply paying off former peign stars. This has
- 10:20Speaker 3: to do with potential election interference. The prosecution is going
- 10:24Speaker 3: to stay that this case is all about trying to
- 10:26Speaker 3: make sure the public was not aware of these relationships
- 10:29Speaker 3: leading up to the twenty sixteen election, because former President
- 10:33Speaker 3: Trump and his campaign believed that if this became known
- 10:36Speaker 3: that he might lose the election. The defense, on the
- 10:38Speaker 3: other hand, is going to paint a very different story
- 10:41Speaker 3: for the jury, and they are going to say these
- 10:42Speaker 3: are simply technical bookkeeping violations, that this case is politically motivated.
- 10:48Speaker 3: The judge will only let them get so far with
- 10:50Speaker 3: that defense, but if they don't stay expressly, they'll certainly
- 10:53Speaker 3: infer to the jury that this is a minor violation
- 10:56Speaker 3: and should never have been a criminal case from the start.
- 11:00Speaker 1: That's probably an unfair question, but I'm going to ask
- 11:02Speaker 1: it anyway. From what we know, can you tell if
- 11:05Speaker 1: this jury is better for the prosecution or better for
- 11:08Speaker 1: the defense.
- 11:10Speaker 3: Well, I think We can say from the get go
- 11:12Speaker 3: that the defense was never going to be thrilled with
- 11:14Speaker 3: this jury because this is a venue that is not
- 11:17Speaker 3: particularly favorable to former President Trump. It's obviously in New
- 11:20Speaker 3: York State. More than that, it's in Manhattan, where former
- 11:23Speaker 3: President Trump is not particularly popular. So I think the
- 11:26Speaker 3: defense is looking at this as an uphill climb. They're
- 11:29Speaker 3: probably looking realistically to try to get at least one
- 11:33Speaker 3: juror who'd go to a quit and then they get
- 11:35Speaker 3: a mistrial, the case has to be tried all over again.
- 11:38Speaker 3: They're probably also looking to try to trip up the
- 11:41Speaker 3: judge to create an issue on appeal, and at the
- 11:43Speaker 3: end of the day, the defense's best play here is
- 11:46Speaker 3: going to probably be to create a record that they
- 11:49Speaker 3: can take up on appeal, because I think most people
- 11:51Speaker 3: believe there will be a condition at the end of
- 11:53Speaker 3: this case.
- 11:54Speaker 1: We will learn more on Monday when opening statements take place.
- 11:58Speaker 1: Thanks so much, Bob Robert Mints of maccarter and English.
- 12:02Speaker 1: Coming up those January sixth obstruction charges, I'm June Grosso.
- 12:06Speaker 1: When you're listening to Bloomberg, Federal prosecutors have brought obstruction
- 12:11Speaker 1: charges against more than three hundred and fifty defendants in
- 12:14Speaker 1: January sixth cases, including two counts against Donald Trump for
- 12:19Speaker 1: his efforts to overturn his election loss in twenty twenty.
- 12:23Speaker 1: But during oral arguments on Tuesday, several Conservative Supreme Court
- 12:28Speaker 1: justices like Neil Gorsich express skepticism about the potential scope
- 12:33Speaker 1: of the charge and the kinds of conduct it could criminalize.
- 12:36Speaker 2: Would a sit in that disrupts a trial for access
- 12:41Speaker 2: to a federal courthouse qualify? Would a heckler in today's
- 12:45Speaker 2: audience qualify? Or at the State of the Union address,
- 12:49Speaker 2: would pulling a fire alarm before vote qualify? For twenty
- 12:56Speaker 2: years in federal prison.
- 12:58Speaker 1: The obstruction law has a broad catch a provision that
- 13:00Speaker 1: makes it a crime to corruptly, obstruct, influence, or impede
- 13:04Speaker 1: any official proceeding, and Joseph Fisher, a former Pennsylvania police
- 13:09Speaker 1: officer and January sixth defendant, argues it was intended to
- 13:13Speaker 1: prevent evidence tampering, not an insurrection. Justice Clarence Thomas, whose
- 13:18Speaker 1: wife Ginny is a conservative activist, who was at the
- 13:21Speaker 1: rally on January sixth, asked the US Solicitor General, Elizabeth Prelager,
- 13:27Speaker 1: if prosecutors had ever used this statute for other violent protests.
- 13:32Speaker 2: Have you enforced it in that manner?
- 13:34Speaker 4: We have enforced it in a variety of prosecutions that
- 13:36Speaker 4: don't focus on evidence tampering. Now, I can't give you
- 13:39Speaker 4: an example of enforcing it in a situation where people
- 13:42Speaker 4: have violently stormed a building in order to prevent an
- 13:44Speaker 4: official preceding a specified one from occurring, with all of
- 13:47Speaker 4: the elements like intent to obstruct, knowledge of the preceding,
- 13:51Speaker 4: of having the corruptly mensraa. But that's just because I'm
- 13:54Speaker 4: not aware of that circumstance ever happening prior to January sixth.
- 13:58Speaker 1: Joining me is former federal prosecutor Jessica Roth, a professor
- 14:01Speaker 1: at Cardozo Law School. Jessica explain what the issue is here.
- 14:06Speaker 5: So the issue here is how to interpret the Obstruction
- 14:11Speaker 5: of an Official preceding Statute, which is one of a
- 14:14Speaker 5: series of statutes that address obstruction of justice in various forms.
- 14:18Speaker 5: It's a particular provision that was enacted in two thousand
- 14:21Speaker 5: and two as part of the Sarbanes Oxley Act following
- 14:25Speaker 5: the Enron scandal and the revelation of significant accounting fraud
- 14:29Speaker 5: on the part of the accountants for Enron, and the
- 14:32Speaker 5: revelation that although those involved in the shredding of documents
- 14:37Speaker 5: related to Enron were prosecuted, that there was essentially a
- 14:42Speaker 5: gap in the obstruction of justice statutes because it was
- 14:46Speaker 5: not possible to charge somebody for destroying evidence essentially on
- 14:50Speaker 5: their own. The statutes required that a person direct or
- 14:55Speaker 5: somehow get another person to destroy documents. And so it
- 15:00Speaker 5: wasn't that there was so much a problem charging in
- 15:02Speaker 5: the Enron case, but that it was identified that this
- 15:06Speaker 5: could be a problem in future cases. And so the
- 15:08Speaker 5: particular statute that was charged here against mister Fisher, that's
- 15:12Speaker 5: been used against over three hundred defendants who are charged
- 15:15Speaker 5: arising out of the January sixth insurrection, and that also
- 15:18Speaker 5: is the basis for two of the charges against Donald
- 15:21Speaker 5: Trump and the January sixth case against him. And the
- 15:24Speaker 5: question is whether or not that statute can be used
- 15:27Speaker 5: to charge a person for obstructing and a proceeding, including
- 15:31Speaker 5: a proceeding of Congress, where the destruction of evidence or
- 15:35Speaker 5: tampering with evidence per se is not part of the
- 15:38Speaker 5: factual allegation.
- 15:40Speaker 1: Did it seem during the oral arguments that the Conservative
- 15:43Speaker 1: justices were skeptical about the Justice Department using the obstruction
- 15:48Speaker 1: charge against Fisher and the other January sixth defendants.
- 15:52Speaker 5: There were clearly some justices who were skeptical of the charges.
- 15:56Speaker 5: I would say Justice Alito was the one who seemed
- 15:58Speaker 5: most clearly skeptical. Chief Justice Roberts also expressed some concerns,
- 16:03Speaker 5: although he did not ask that many questions. Justice Gorschitz
- 16:06Speaker 5: had some concerns about the breadth of the potential application
- 16:09Speaker 5: of the statute if the Court were to rule for
- 16:12Speaker 5: the government. There were several justices who seemed much more
- 16:15Speaker 5: inclined to rule for the government, notably Justice Soto, Mayor,
- 16:20Speaker 5: Justice Kagan, and Justice Katangi bron Jackson all seemed supportive
- 16:24Speaker 5: of the interpretation of the statutes that the government was advancing.
- 16:28Speaker 5: But then there were several justices who seemed sort of
- 16:30Speaker 5: in the middle and open to persuasion. So I can't
- 16:34Speaker 5: say with any confidence how this case is going to
- 16:37Speaker 5: come out.
- 16:37Speaker 1: Let's talk about some of the concerns of the very
- 16:41Speaker 1: conservative justices on the far right of the court. So
- 16:44Speaker 1: Justice Neil Gorsich said, would a sit in that disrupts
- 16:48Speaker 1: a trial or access to a federal courthouse qualify would
- 16:51Speaker 1: a heckler in today's audience qualify? Would pulling a fire
- 16:54Speaker 1: alarm before a vote referring to an incident in Congress
- 16:57Speaker 1: that happened recently qualify for twenty years in federal prison.
- 17:01Speaker 1: So they were questioning the breadth I guess of this.
- 17:05Speaker 5: A number of the justices asked questions and post hypotheticals
- 17:09Speaker 5: that really were geared at testing the outer limits of
- 17:12Speaker 5: the construction of the statutes that the government was advancing,
- 17:16Speaker 5: and those did include hypothetical protests, for example, or somebody
- 17:19Speaker 5: in some way disrupting an official proceeding, such as protesting
- 17:23Speaker 5: outside a courthouse or pulling a fire alarm, and the
- 17:27Speaker 5: justices wanted to know, well, would the government charge that
- 17:30Speaker 5: person with obstruction of an official proceeding under its interpretation?
- 17:33Speaker 5: And this Lister General responded by saying there are a
- 17:37Speaker 5: number of safeguards in the statute that would preclude a
- 17:41Speaker 5: prosecution in those circumstances. She said, the obstruction or the
- 17:47Speaker 5: impediment of the official preceding in a sense must be
- 17:50Speaker 5: more than dominionists. It has to actually, in some way
- 17:54Speaker 5: that is not insignificant impair the proceeding, and so that
- 18:00Speaker 5: would be something that might preclude a prosecution for somebody
- 18:03Speaker 5: who pulled a fire alarm that caused a disruption that
- 18:06Speaker 5: was only a matter of minutes, or that would preclude
- 18:09Speaker 5: prosecution of protesters who only minimally disrupted a proceeding inside
- 18:15Speaker 5: a courthouse, perhaps where things had to quiet down for
- 18:17Speaker 5: a few minutes, just to make sure that the protest
- 18:20Speaker 5: was moving on and was peaceful. The second thing she
- 18:22Speaker 5: said is that the men's rea requirement of the statute,
- 18:25Speaker 5: which is that the person has to act corruptly, also
- 18:28Speaker 5: would preclude prosecution of people in some of these hypotheticals,
- 18:32Speaker 5: because it would be unlikely that the government could prove
- 18:35Speaker 5: that those people acted with corrupt intents, that is, doing
- 18:38Speaker 5: something knowing that it was wrong and contrary to law.
- 18:42Speaker 5: If people thought, for example, they were engaged in peaceful
- 18:45Speaker 5: protests protected by the First Amendment, in some circumstances, they
- 18:48Speaker 5: might be wrong about whether their activity was protected by
- 18:51Speaker 5: the First Amendment, but their belief that it was might
- 18:54Speaker 5: preclude a finding that they acted with the requisite corrupt intent. So,
- 18:58Speaker 5: in other words, she said, the court could rule in
- 19:00Speaker 5: the government's favor on its interpretation of the statute as
- 19:04Speaker 5: applied to official proceedings and not be worried about some
- 19:08Speaker 5: of the sort of pervade of horribles that the court
- 19:11Speaker 5: seemed to be concerned about.
- 19:13Speaker 1: A couple of justices seemed concerned about the stiff possible
- 19:17Speaker 1: twenty year sentence this charge carries, and Justice Brett Kavanaugh
- 19:22Speaker 1: brought up the six other charges that Fisher is facing.
- 19:26Speaker 6: Why aren't those six counts good enough just from the
- 19:31Speaker 6: Justice Department's perspective, given that they don't have any of
- 19:35Speaker 6: the hurdles.
- 19:36Speaker 5: I thought the Slisser General's response to that question was
- 19:39Speaker 5: actually quite compelling. She said, yes, he was charged with
- 19:43Speaker 5: other counts, but that those other counts did not fully
- 19:46Speaker 5: capture the harm of his conduct, and that it was
- 19:49Speaker 5: important that the charges reflect the harm that his conduct
- 19:53Speaker 5: allegedly inflicted, which was impairing the official proceeding of the
- 20:00Speaker 5: congressional certification of the electoral College vote, and prosecutors frequently
- 20:06Speaker 5: charge a number of offenses for one set of conduct
- 20:10Speaker 5: in order to have the charges fully reflect the seriousness
- 20:14Speaker 5: and the scope of the conduct. It is important to
- 20:18Speaker 5: note that Fisher has not actually been tried yet, so
- 20:21Speaker 5: I should qualify all of this with he is alleged
- 20:23Speaker 5: to have done all these things. This charge was dismissed
- 20:26Speaker 5: by the trial court before it went to trial, and
- 20:28Speaker 5: then that went up to the DC Circuit Court of Appeals,
- 20:32Speaker 5: And so there's actually a factual dispute among the parties
- 20:35Speaker 5: about what exactly it is that Fisher did and how
- 20:37Speaker 5: violent was he at the capitol.
- 20:40Speaker 1: If the court finds for Fisher here, what happens to
- 20:43Speaker 1: the one hundred and twenty or so January sixth defendants who
- 20:47Speaker 1: have been convicted and sentenced under the same charge.
- 20:51Speaker 5: So I'm fairly certain that no defendant associated with January
- 20:55Speaker 5: sixth has been charged solely with this obstruction statute, that
- 20:59Speaker 5: there were other charges for each of them. So those
- 21:03Speaker 5: other convictions would stand even if the court were to
- 21:06Speaker 5: rule against the government here, and the court were a
- 21:08Speaker 5: rule that this obstruction statute cannot be used in the
- 21:11Speaker 5: context of January sixth because it didn't involve the destruction
- 21:14Speaker 5: of evidence, So the defendants in those other cases would
- 21:18Speaker 5: be resentenced.
- 21:19Speaker 1: And even if the court rules for Fisher, Trump is
- 21:21Speaker 1: facing two other charges, so the election interference trial against
- 21:25Speaker 1: him could go forward. Jessica, what are your thoughts? Is
- 21:29Speaker 1: the prosecution stretching the law with these January sixth the
- 21:33Speaker 1: obstruction charges.
- 21:35Speaker 5: I think if you look at the statute and you
- 21:38Speaker 5: follow the government's argument about how the statute can be
- 21:42Speaker 5: read as applying to any means of obstructing an official
- 21:47Speaker 5: proceedings so long as the person acts with corrupt intent
- 21:51Speaker 5: and this requisite nexus is satisfied, I think it is
- 21:55Speaker 5: a fair interpretation of the statute that it applies to
- 21:57Speaker 5: these facts. It is unprecedent, but that I think speaks
- 22:02Speaker 5: to the fact that there's been no similar fact pattern
- 22:06Speaker 5: where people have attempted to and did obstruct for a
- 22:10Speaker 5: time and official proceeding through such acts of violence. So
- 22:14Speaker 5: it is novel, but I don't think that it is
- 22:17Speaker 5: beyond the pale of what is covered by this statute.
- 22:22Speaker 1: The government could try something else, and just as Amy
- 22:25Speaker 1: Cony Barrett asked Fisher's lawyer about whether the government could
- 22:29Speaker 1: argue that there was evidence being tampered with and that
- 22:32Speaker 1: evidence was the certifications of the vote.
- 22:35Speaker 7: So in the hypothetical, I'm giving you it's evidence related
- 22:38Speaker 7: because it's focused on their certificates, but it's obstruct, obstruct
- 22:44Speaker 7: or impede, say the certificates arriving to the Vice President's desk,
- 22:48Speaker 7: insofar as the goal was to shut down the proceeding
- 22:51Speaker 7: and therefore interfere with the evidence reaching the Vice president.
- 22:54Speaker 5: I do think we'd be getting into some very interesting
- 22:57Speaker 5: territory if the Court were to say that it's finding
- 23:01Speaker 5: for Fisher and the statute cannot be read beyond applications
- 23:05Speaker 5: involving evidence, and whether the government then seeks to apply
- 23:10Speaker 5: the statute so limited to the facts presented here. The
- 23:14Speaker 5: government said in a footnote in its brief, and it
- 23:17Speaker 5: reiterated at the argument that it would like the opportunity
- 23:20Speaker 5: to argue that, even under such a narrowed construction, that
- 23:24Speaker 5: the facts can meet that construction because the proceeding before
- 23:30Speaker 5: Congress involved the counting of the electoral votes, and that
- 23:34Speaker 5: involved essentially the evidence of the votes presented to Congress.
- 23:38Speaker 5: That's I think going to be very interesting to think
- 23:41Speaker 5: about whether that application strains the statute too much. And
- 23:46Speaker 5: that is precisely the argument that has been advanced by
- 23:49Speaker 5: some watching the Fisher case for its significance for the
- 23:53Speaker 5: case against Donald Trump, on the theory that if the
- 23:56Speaker 5: court rules against the government in Fisher and says that
- 24:00Speaker 5: acts of violence to obstruct official proceeding do not fall
- 24:03Speaker 5: within the statute. Could a sort of backup argument be
- 24:07Speaker 5: that the electoral vote being certified in the course of
- 24:12Speaker 5: that proceeding before Congress, that that could be essentially the
- 24:15Speaker 5: hook to the documentary evidence that would be required to
- 24:20Speaker 5: satisfy the statute.
- 24:22Speaker 1: That's actually an intriguing theory. If the government loses here,
- 24:25Speaker 1: we'll see Thanks so much, Jessica for your insights. That's
- 24:28Speaker 1: Professor Jessica Roth of Cardozo Law School. Coming up next
- 24:32Speaker 1: on The Bloomberg Lawn Show. Will the Supreme Court limit
- 24:35Speaker 1: a bribery law used in public corruption cases? I'm June
- 24:39Speaker 1: Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg. The Supreme Court has
- 24:44Speaker 1: consistently been making it harder for prosecutors to bring corruption
- 24:48Speaker 1: cases against public officials, and it may do so again.
- 24:52Speaker 1: In a case heard this week, James Snyder, the former
- 24:55Speaker 1: mayor of a northwest Indiana town, received thirteen thousand dollars
- 25:00Speaker 1: I'm a trucking company one month after it was awarded
- 25:03Speaker 1: city contracts in a bidding process he oversaw. Snyder claimed
- 25:07Speaker 1: the payment was for consulting services, but he was convicted
- 25:11Speaker 1: of bribery by a jury in twenty nineteen, and then
- 25:14Speaker 1: convicted by a second jury in a retrial in twenty
- 25:18Speaker 1: twenty one. But the Supreme Court, which has been having
- 25:21Speaker 1: its own problems of late with unreported gifts to justices,
- 25:26Speaker 1: seem to suggest that the thirteen thousand dollars payment was
- 25:29Speaker 1: like taking a teacher to the cheesecake factory or buying
- 25:33Speaker 1: a gift card for Starbucks. Here are Justices Neil Gorsich
- 25:37Speaker 1: and Brett Cavanaugh.
- 25:38Speaker 8: How does somebody who accepts the cheesecake factory no a
- 25:42Speaker 8: trip to the cheesecake factory for nice treatment at the hospital,
- 25:46Speaker 8: for treating my child well in school, for an arrest made?
- 25:52Speaker 8: How does that person know whether that falls on the
- 25:55Speaker 8: what you call the wrongfulness side of the equation or not.
- 26:01Speaker 6: So does one hundred dollars Starbuck gift certificate as a
- 26:04Speaker 6: thank you to the city council person who for working
- 26:08Speaker 6: on a new zoning rag. Is that corrupt or not?
- 26:14Speaker 1: Many of the justices thought there was a problem drawing
- 26:17Speaker 1: a line between gratuities given for past actions and quid
- 26:21Speaker 1: pro quo bribes paid for future actions. But Justice Sonia
- 26:25Speaker 1: Sotomayor saw the line in the Snyder case.
- 26:28Speaker 9: Here's a case in which someone is that's the allegation,
- 26:33Speaker 9: demanding money, gets it basically for no services, spends his
- 26:39Speaker 9: time giving two or three different reasons and services that
- 26:44Speaker 9: he performed which he didn't, and there's a series of
- 26:51Speaker 9: meetings or phone calls Texas, etc. Before the second contract
- 26:57Speaker 9: is awarded between these people. At some point point, can't
- 27:01Speaker 9: the jury see that as a demand for payment for services?
- 27:06Speaker 1: Joining me to answer that question and many others is
- 27:10Speaker 1: business law professor Eric Tally of Columbia Law School. The
- 27:14Speaker 1: law makes it a crime for certain state or local
- 27:17Speaker 1: officials to corruptly accept anything of value over five thousand dollars.
- 27:23Speaker 1: The word corruptly seemed to be a problem for the justices.
- 27:27Speaker 10: Yes, and the key issue on the question of corruptly
- 27:32Speaker 10: seems to be, at least in part, circulating around a
- 27:35Speaker 10: question of timing, and a lot of the Q and
- 27:38Speaker 10: A during the oral argument was all about, you know,
- 27:43Speaker 10: the timing of a payment that, let's just say, for
- 27:46Speaker 10: argument's sake, exceeds five thousand dollars. But the hypotheticals that
- 27:51Speaker 10: were being bandied about involved situations like taking someone out
- 27:55Speaker 10: to dinner at the cheesecake factory, I don't know if
- 27:58Speaker 10: you've been to the cheesecake factory lately, but I've never
- 28:01Speaker 10: run up anything like a five hundred dollars bill of
- 28:03Speaker 10: the cheesecake factory, so it wouldn't actually hit that status
- 28:06Speaker 10: tarort threshold.
- 28:07Speaker 1: Well, Kavanaugh said, you don't know if the concert tickets,
- 28:10Speaker 1: the game tickets, the gift card to Starbucks, whatever, where
- 28:14Speaker 1: is the line? So there's that vagueness. I mean, are
- 28:17Speaker 1: they really talking about a more than five thousand dollars
- 28:20Speaker 1: gift card to Starbucks?
- 28:22Speaker 10: Super odd? I mean, just so of my or brought
- 28:24Speaker 10: this up, but this question of corruptly ended up floating
- 28:27Speaker 10: around in its own mist right, independent of the dollar amounts. Look,
- 28:32Speaker 10: a lot of times in these situations there will be
- 28:35Speaker 10: either inside the statute or kind of a reasonable construction
- 28:38Speaker 10: of statute, a judge will come in and say, listen,
- 28:41Speaker 10: we're going to impose a you know, it's sometimes called
- 28:44Speaker 10: a materiality threshold or a materiality test on some sort
- 28:49Speaker 10: of suspect payment. And the definition of materiality is itself.
- 28:52Speaker 10: It's a little foggy. It usually circulates around and you
- 28:55Speaker 10: know what a reasonable person think, This is a big
- 28:57Speaker 10: payment that would change someone's judgment. But that is where
- 29:00Speaker 10: all over the place and all types of financial crimes
- 29:02Speaker 10: and financial civil actions, materiality is a very very common
- 29:06Speaker 10: workhorse that was oddly, it wasn't quite absent, but it
- 29:10Speaker 10: seemed to be suppressed pretty far down the list in
- 29:13Speaker 10: the oral argument.
- 29:14Speaker 1: Where were the justices going with hypothetical after hypothetical after hypothetical.
- 29:18Speaker 10: Much of the oral argument seems to devolve into like
- 29:22Speaker 10: kind of a non stop set of hypotheticals, each somewhat
- 29:26Speaker 10: more extraordinary than the others. And you know, that kind
- 29:30Speaker 10: of is where the two lawyers had to go.
- 29:32Speaker 6: Now.
- 29:32Speaker 10: I think the lawyer for mister Snyder was quite happy
- 29:34Speaker 10: to go there because the entire theory on the case
- 29:37Speaker 10: is it's just impossible to draw lines in this type
- 29:40Speaker 10: of situation. And the government's attorneys pretty much had to say, now,
- 29:44Speaker 10: line drawing is hard, but it's always hard, and the
- 29:46Speaker 10: Government's going to only bring these cases when it feels
- 29:49Speaker 10: like it's a good case that's consistent with public policy
- 29:52Speaker 10: associated with the anti bribery Statute. But that itself, you know,
- 29:55Speaker 10: at least to some judges and maybe to some observers,
- 29:58Speaker 10: is a type of assurance. It's really hard to check
- 30:01Speaker 10: later on, and so you know, I think the Court's
- 30:03Speaker 10: probably going to have to be forced into some sort
- 30:06Speaker 10: of a line drawing exercise here. The big issue that
- 30:09Speaker 10: was brought up in the case was in this particular scenario,
- 30:13Speaker 10: and even Kavanaugh said the facts were really good for
- 30:15Speaker 10: the government prosecutors in this case. Mister Snyder had allegedly
- 30:19Speaker 10: sort of rigged a contract bidding process when he was
- 30:23Speaker 10: mayor of Portage, Indiana, and the company that won that
- 30:26Speaker 10: bidding process he had been in consistent contact with, and
- 30:29Speaker 10: then pretty shortly after the contract was awarded to them,
- 30:32Speaker 10: they handed over a thirteen thousand dollars check, ostensibly for
- 30:36Speaker 10: consulting services to be provided in the future. And so
- 30:40Speaker 10: the line drawing exercise between his administration of the bidding
- 30:43Speaker 10: process and the thirteen thousand dollars check seems pretty direct.
- 30:47Speaker 10: But the point that his attorneys were making, they were
- 30:49Speaker 10: making quite vehemently at the court, is that, well, no,
- 30:52Speaker 10: this would have to be payments that are made before
- 30:55Speaker 10: the favor is granted and not after, and this came afterwards,
- 30:59Speaker 10: and there are too many hypothetical situations that would lead
- 31:02Speaker 10: us on. Lawyers like to talk about slippery slopes to hell,
- 31:05Speaker 10: and this was one and that's what caused us to
- 31:07Speaker 10: go into the dinner out of gratitude for your high
- 31:09Speaker 10: school English teacher at the cheesecake factory? Is that a bribe?
- 31:13Speaker 1: So the government's attorney suggested that the government typically wouldn't
- 31:17Speaker 1: prosecute fringe cases, but Chief Justice Roberts noted that in
- 31:22Speaker 1: recent cases the Court has been skeptical of prosecutors trust
- 31:25Speaker 1: us arguments. What are the justices afraid of here?
- 31:29Speaker 10: Well, I think there is a justified caution about statutory
- 31:34Speaker 10: authorizations that give prosecutors too much of a blank check
- 31:38Speaker 10: and what they're going to charge people with. If the
- 31:41Speaker 10: check is too much of a blank check, then it's
- 31:43Speaker 10: not inconceivable that political calculations may end up either entering
- 31:48Speaker 10: or being perceived to have entered into a prosecutor's decision
- 31:52Speaker 10: about whom to go after and whom to leave alone.
- 31:55Speaker 10: And so I think that that's part of what the
- 31:56Speaker 10: Court has been trying to grapple with. And you know,
- 31:59Speaker 10: in fairness, there have been several high profile cases involving
- 32:04Speaker 10: various types of applications of this and other anti bribery
- 32:07Speaker 10: or anti corruption statutes in which politics is pretty hard
- 32:10Speaker 10: to ignore. There was a twenty twenty case that involved
- 32:13Speaker 10: the infamous Bridgegate scenario in which Chris Christie was alleged
- 32:18Speaker 10: to have had his subordinates closed down at GW Bridge
- 32:21Speaker 10: in order to punish his political foes, and then the
- 32:24Speaker 10: prosecution was brought at least allegedly for political reasons, sort
- 32:29Speaker 10: of anti Chris Christy, anti Republican reasons, and the Supreme
- 32:32Speaker 10: Court ended up actually reversing that conviction, but on kind
- 32:35Speaker 10: of weird technical grounds about what was motivating these operatives.
- 32:38Speaker 10: So they sort of found maybe even unrelated fault reasons
- 32:42Speaker 10: to reverse in some of these cases. And you know
- 32:44Speaker 10: that maybe what is being put forward here this kind
- 32:47Speaker 10: of idea that well, if the payment happens after the
- 32:50Speaker 10: political favor is given, then that can't possibly be corruption.
- 32:53Speaker 10: That's a nice bright line rule, you know, as the
- 32:56Speaker 10: government lawyers were bringing up, probably correctly, is that if
- 32:59Speaker 10: you established that as a bright line rule, that will
- 33:01Speaker 10: be kind of a gold embossed invitation for how you
- 33:04Speaker 10: should structure corruption payments in the future. Right that you know,
- 33:08Speaker 10: you always have a political actor go first, wait some
- 33:11Speaker 10: requisite short amount of time, and then the payment comes second.
- 33:14Speaker 10: And in some ways, the ease with which one could
- 33:16Speaker 10: engineer around that type of a definition, I think it's
- 33:19Speaker 10: going to make it difficult for a majority of the
- 33:22Speaker 10: judges to ignore that the Supreme.
- 33:25Speaker 1: Court over the years has made it harder and harder
- 33:28Speaker 1: to prosecute politicians and other public officials for corruption starting
- 33:34Speaker 1: in twenty sixteen. Right.
- 33:36Speaker 10: Yeah, The skepticism goes at least back to a twenty
- 33:39Speaker 10: sixteen case, and there have been several others, both at
- 33:42Speaker 10: the federal level and the state level, and so there
- 33:46Speaker 10: is a little bit of a I guess it's sort
- 33:48Speaker 10: of a trend here where the judges have become, I
- 33:51Speaker 10: don't know, increasingly worried about the possibility that these antibribery
- 33:56Speaker 10: or anti corruption statutes are being used for political reds,
- 34:00Speaker 10: and therefore, you know, they're trying to carve back on them,
- 34:03Speaker 10: you know. I guess another factor of this is sort
- 34:06Speaker 10: of almost a meta factor June, which is that one
- 34:09Speaker 10: of the bodies of the federal government that has come
- 34:12Speaker 10: under immense scrutiny recently is the Supreme Court itself. For
- 34:16Speaker 10: whether there are friends of Justices of the Supreme Court
- 34:19Speaker 10: who bestow all kinds of valuable gifts on them out
- 34:23Speaker 10: of friendship or for people they care about, and whether
- 34:26Speaker 10: that itself is something that should trigger at least suspicion,
- 34:30Speaker 10: if not considerable handwringing amongst people who are trying to
- 34:34Speaker 10: regulate the court. There's big separation of powers issues, and
- 34:37Speaker 10: the Supreme Court itself basically decided to promulgate its own
- 34:40Speaker 10: ethics guideline, but a lot of people think it's somewhat toothless.
- 34:43Speaker 10: It is not a subtle fact that Justice Thomas, who's
- 34:47Speaker 10: been one of the people who's been at the center
- 34:49Speaker 10: of this Maelstrom, decided not to even participate in the
- 34:52Speaker 10: oral argument, but he is going to participate in the
- 34:54Speaker 10: judgment through briefs and through reading the transcript. That was
- 34:57Speaker 10: sort of an odd decision that didn't really have much
- 34:59Speaker 10: of an ext explanation. So, you know, I think all
- 35:01Speaker 10: aspects of this are in some ways delicate, and I
- 35:05Speaker 10: think the Supreme Court itself has gotten dragged a little
- 35:09Speaker 10: bit into its own kerfuffles around when are expressions of
- 35:13Speaker 10: gratitude that may have significant monetary value, when of the
- 35:16Speaker 10: appropriate and when do they trigger considerations and concerns about
- 35:20Speaker 10: corruption and.
- 35:20Speaker 1: Bribery And Eric these public corruption cases are hard to prosecute,
- 35:25Speaker 1: aren't they. You know, public officials and these kind of bribes.
- 35:28Speaker 1: They don't leave notes or emails saying thanks so much
- 35:31Speaker 1: for that, I was happy to help.
- 35:33Speaker 10: You out yeat. Typically they don't. There have been some
- 35:36Speaker 10: cases that have largely been overturned that sort of said, well,
- 35:39Speaker 10: you have to have a written contract on bribery, and
- 35:41Speaker 10: I think everyone realizes that that's an easy one to
- 35:43Speaker 10: engineer your way around. So you have to demonstrate either
- 35:47Speaker 10: a conversation or a set of conversations that establishes this understanding,
- 35:51Speaker 10: or a set of patterns and practices of behavior whose
- 35:55Speaker 10: only reasonable construction or interpretation would be Yeah, these are
- 36:00Speaker 10: acting as though they are in a quid pro quo
- 36:03Speaker 10: that they are recognizing through either their communicative acts or
- 36:06Speaker 10: hard to misinterpret action, And that makes it tough and eric.
- 36:10Speaker 1: If the court doesn't decide on a bright line rule
- 36:14Speaker 1: based on when the money was paid, how else could
- 36:17Speaker 1: the court decide this? Considering some of their concerns about
- 36:21Speaker 1: Starbucks cards and cheesecake factory meals, I think.
- 36:25Speaker 10: That most of the absurd situations involved little perks that
- 36:29Speaker 10: are kind of pocket change type perks, and that once
- 36:33Speaker 10: things got large, including the five thousand dollars trigger in
- 36:36Speaker 10: this situation, then that would be large enough to trigger
- 36:41Speaker 10: not only the explicit trigger, but also a judicial interpretation that, yes,
- 36:46Speaker 10: this is large enough that it could affect someone's judgment.
- 36:49Speaker 10: And that's one of the reasons why I feel like
- 36:51Speaker 10: the Court may well end up borrowing from a half dozen,
- 36:55Speaker 10: if not more than a dozen other areas of financial
- 36:59Speaker 10: fraud and white collar crime that all sort of turns
- 37:03Speaker 10: on materiality, and that may end up being a helpful
- 37:07Speaker 10: lever for the Supreme Court when they try to decide
- 37:09Speaker 10: this case. If they don't go with the timing part,
- 37:12Speaker 10: they're going to have to have some sort of a cutoff,
- 37:14Speaker 10: and a materiality cutoff is not a crazy place to
- 37:16Speaker 10: put it. That's why you see it so many other
- 37:18Speaker 10: areas of law.
- 37:20Speaker 1: Thanks for joining me, Eric, that's Professor Eric Talley at
- 37:23Speaker 1: Columbia Law School. And that's it for this edition of
- 37:25Speaker 1: the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Remember you can always get the
- 37:28Speaker 1: latest legal news by subscribing and listening to the show
- 37:31Speaker 1: on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at Bloomberg dot com, Slash
- 37:35Speaker 1: podcast Slash Law. I'm June grosso and This is Bloomberg