Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / #154 Insights on Capital Market Trends in Credit Unions with Bill Paton of Alloya Corporate FCU
Transcript
- 0:35Markoverdub: Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another
- 0:37episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:39I'm excited today to be here with Bill Peyton.
- 0:42Bill, how you doing today?
- 0:44Doing
- 0:44Bill: great, Mark.
- 0:44Thanks for having me.
- 0:46Markoverdub: You got it.
- 0:46Yeah, you and I have chatted a little bit discovered each other, I think
- 0:50either over email or on LinkedIn.
- 0:51But, I know that you've got a LinkedIn presence and you're the
- 0:54vice president, a vice president at Aloia Federal Credit Union.
- 0:59And you and I chat a little bit about liquidity in some of our
- 1:02sidebar conversations on LinkedIn.
- 1:05I know you also do some things with subordinated debt.
- 1:08And a few other areas.
- 1:11And I'm looking forward to chatting with you today about the interesting
- 1:14year we've had in 2023 in credit unions.
- 1:18How does that sound?
- 1:19Bill: It sounds great.
- 1:20And it has been interesting for
- 1:22Markoverdub: sure.
- 1:23Yeah, it sure has.
- 1:24And, anything else about a lawyer on the front end?
- 1:26Any, anything from your Your resume you want to highlight in case my viewers
- 1:31don't aren't connected with the lawyer.
- 1:32I know a lawyer serves what about 28, 30 percent of the credit union.
- 1:36So some of them are probably well aware of you, but any other things I should hide,
- 1:40we should highlight on the front end here.
- 1:42Yeah,
- 1:43Bill: just, we're a corporate credit union, so we're a
- 1:44credit union for credit unions.
- 1:46Like you said, we serve somewhere between 25 and 30 percent of the credit unions,
- 1:49depending upon how many merged that year.
- 1:52And we do we serve them through the capital markets initiatives,
- 1:55which we'll talk about today, as well as the payments initiatives.
- 1:58That's a, it's a big piece going on this year and all through our technology.
- 2:02Yeah, we're we're excited.
- 2:03Loy is doing great things for its credit unions.
- 2:06We support, our tagline is.
- 2:08We support credit
- 2:09Markoverdub: union success.
- 2:12I like it.
- 2:12I like it.
- 2:13We support credit union success.
- 2:15I think I think 2024 is going to be interesting in that regard because of some
- 2:20of the, challenges we've had looking back and looking forward, but so let's chat a
- 2:24little bit about overall liquidity topics.
- 2:27What have you seen in credit unions and the credit unions and the clients that
- 2:31you have in 2023 as it relates to look at liquidity challenges, obviously.
- 2:37We had the banks that failed and the aftermath of that.
- 2:42But even before that, there were some challenges liquidity wise and credit.
- 2:45What is it that you've seen in 2023 that.
- 2:49That you'd like to chat about here today.
- 2:51Yeah, we're,
- 2:52Bill: 2023 was interesting is that I say is the year we
- 2:56collectively lost our minds.
- 2:58We're really back to pre pandemic levels.
- 3:01And I think we're so quick to forget.
- 3:04Just even recent history.
- 3:06And a lot of what I do is talk to credit unions throughout the country and of
- 3:09course there's issues, and so during the pandemic, all that stimulus money
- 3:13came in and it was really good timing.
- 3:15And credit unions had to do, they had all this money and they had to
- 3:18figure out what to do with it, but we're back from an aggregate level.
- 3:22We're really, high levels, historically high levels.
- 3:25we're back to where we were right before the pandemic happened.
- 3:27If you just look at the overall numbers, but if you take like a deeper dive into
- 3:31that, those overall numbers are really spurred on by the large credit unions,
- 3:37if you dig into, the different asset groups different asset sizes, I should
- 3:41say, mid and small size credit unions.
- 3:44Do have a little bit of money, right?
- 3:46They're not feeling the same pressure that the largest credit unions are.
- 3:50Now, I don't want to say that they're not feeling pressure.
- 3:52They are, they have no deposits, they're fighting the deposit battle.
- 3:56They have to pay up for, their deposits and, they continue to see high levels
- 4:00of loan volume, but in general, it's probably not as bad as maybe You know,
- 4:11the headlines say, it doesn't mean that, the top 20 largest credit unions aren't
- 4:17seeing really heightened liquidity.
- 4:18They are, but they're in, they're really driving the overall numbers.
- 4:22If you took a deeper dive, it's not that bad.
- 4:25Now I'll say this.
- 4:26I was chatting with a credit union was maybe 200 million and they were telling me
- 4:30that they were having a liquidity issue.
- 4:34said, okay what's your loan to share ratio?
- 4:36And they said, 60%.
- 4:37It's okay it doesn't sound like a liquidity issue to me, 60%.
- 4:41And I said historically, we run at 50%.
- 4:43And so we're up, that's 20%, over, what we're up.
- 4:46And we're just not used to that.
- 4:49We like to be at 50%.
- 4:50Okay that's a different problem.
- 4:52But I would say liquidity really isn't a major issue for you're
- 4:55running a little bit higher.
- 4:56And so That's probably the same.
- 4:59If we were to just have that conversation with most credit unions, regardless of
- 5:03size across the board, it's probably the same answer we're going to get.
- 5:07They're feeling a pinch, but probably not that bad.
- 5:10No, a couple of very large ones.
- 5:14Not withstanding, right?
- 5:15That's a different story.
- 5:16Markoverdub: Sure.
- 5:17It's a function of, okay, you got six, you were normally at 50 percent loan
- 5:21to assets, we're now at 60%, and what did they do with that other 30 or 40
- 5:26percent during the last five years?
- 5:29Did they go long with investments, or did they keep it short?
- 5:34And how do they compare, if you rack and stack them that way?
- 5:38But it's good that they're Concerned about the liquidity side of things,
- 5:42even if it's that they don't have upside down investments and didn't
- 5:45go along and they're just wishing they had a little bit more cash.
- 5:49It's good that they're thinking about it because NCA clearly is hitting it.
- 5:53And hitting it hard in nearly every exam, regardless of, what asset size.
- 5:57So
- 5:58Bill: I've been doing this for going on 18 years now, and she will always
- 6:03hit it, has always said liquidity.
- 6:05It's always important.
- 6:06It's never not going to be important.
- 6:08Even during the COVID years, they hit it right because, Hey, when
- 6:11is the money going to come out?
- 6:13Those things.
- 6:13Yeah it's always going to be at the forefront of the NCOA's
- 6:16mind and should always be at the forefront of credit union's mind.
- 6:19It's pretty good job security, from from that perspective, I say that,
- 6:22knocking on wood, but it's fun to be in the liquidity space because
- 6:26there's always something right.
- 6:27And I think more than anything, 2023, to.
- 6:32Your point, right?
- 6:32Credit unions historically stay short in their investments.
- 6:36Again, there's some credit unions that have gone long, things of that
- 6:39nature, which, which have hurt.
- 6:40But in general, credit unions do a really good job of managing their liquidity.
- 6:45Comparatively they stay short.
- 6:47Sometimes that hurts their net income, but that's okay.
- 6:50It's better for the liquidity.
- 6:51And so again, I think credit unions are a little bit better off than maybe
- 6:55even they'll say, if you get them off to the side and really have a, a
- 6:58heart to heart with them, they might say, it's not all that bad it ain't
- 7:01great, but it's, it's not where it wasn't, March of 2023, when we thought
- 7:07the world was ending and SVB was, was failing and all those banks are failing.
- 7:11Yeah, it's tight, but
- 7:13Markoverdub: we will get through this.
- 7:14And along those lines, I saw I haven't read it yet, but I saw another
- 7:18podcast that was talking about an O.
- 7:21C.
- 7:22guidance on what their focus is going to be on in 2024 and N.
- 7:26C.
- 7:26U.
- 7:26A.
- 7:26comes out with that mid January for credit unions.
- 7:30But the teaser on the podcast that I wanna listen to and I wanna re read the OCC
- 7:35report basically said they're, they've shifted their top concern from liquidity
- 7:41to asset quality and delinquency.
- 7:44So that's a shift in banks.
- 7:45I'm very curious to see, NCA has talked about that, and N NCAA's
- 7:49chairman has talked about loan quality and concerns there.
- 7:53The, in, the trends in that.
- 7:56While the numbers collectively are not bad, the trends have been going in the
- 8:00wrong way, which isn't really a surprise.
- 8:01I'm thinking, I'm curious to see what OCC has to say.
- 8:04I'm looking forward to see what NCOA has to say in that regard, which kind of,
- 8:08gets us to a follow up question to that.
- 8:11So 2023, we talked about what you've seen there.
- 8:14So what do you, so from where we're at, where do you see, what do you see on
- 8:19the vision for 2024 for credit unions?
- 8:22Said another way, where do you think we're going?
- 8:24In that regard, and either liquidity or anything else on your radar.
- 8:28Yeah, so
- 8:30Bill: I think liquidity will normalize a bit.
- 8:33I think it's going to be up right.
- 8:34I think I don't think we're going to see, an average loan to share
- 8:37ratio at 70 percent or 68 percent whatever it was in 2020 or 2021.
- 8:43I forget what number it was, but it was down significantly.
- 8:46But I do think, we'll get some ease from the liquidity standpoint.
- 8:50One of the great things that happened in 2023, 2023.
- 8:54Is more and more credit unions got creative, right?
- 8:58In terms of how they they get access to liquidity and manage their balance sheet.
- 9:03And the main thing that comes to mind is securitizations, right?
- 9:07And that's a hot topic seemingly every month or every other month, new credit
- 9:11union will come out with a securitization.
- 9:14And I think there's been nine of them or 10 of them in a
- 9:17recent industry publication.
- 9:20And they talked about how they expect more to come and we're seeing the same thing.
- 9:23, but it's when times are tough, ingenuity and creativity comes right.
- 9:28And I think we're seeing that in 2023.
- 9:31So securitizations, I think more and more credit unions
- 9:33will continue to go that route.
- 9:35I think more credit unions will continue to do interesting things.
- 9:40There is two credit unions in Texas.
- 9:42They were doing a deposit swap and that became a real big thing for a while.
- 9:47I don't know how, if that will continue to be of importance to credit unions.
- 9:52But I just highlight those things to say credit unions
- 9:55will continue to get creative.
- 9:58As they need to manage your money in their balance sheet.
- 10:00And right now, so what we're talking about right now, there's going to be a
- 10:03new creative solution that some credit unions will be bringing to the table
- 10:07in 2024 that we don't even know about.
- 10:09And I think more than anything over the last 3, 4, 5 years, we've seen some real
- 10:14creativity across the whole board and I expect that to continue to happen.
- 10:18So I expect more credit unions to issue securities.
- 10:21Or should go through the securitization process.
- 10:24I think more and more credit unions will look for outlets to
- 10:26sell some of their assets as they continue to originate loans, right?
- 10:29I'm excited for I think it's great for the industry.
- 10:32It's very intriguing.
- 10:34It's, it, and it can only be good things for us
- 10:38Markoverdub: for down the line.
- 10:40Yeah, those are it's interesting.
- 10:42I've got.
- 10:44I've had some conversations with the, with a couple of credit unions that
- 10:47are now into securitization and It's not it's not super simple to do it.
- 10:55You've got to have a lot of bandwidth to do it.
- 10:57And, there's groups out there that can help you with that.
- 10:59Is that something that a lawyer particularly is involved with, or is that
- 11:03something that you guys can assist people with or point them in the right direction?
- 11:08Bill: Sure.
- 11:08Yeah.
- 11:08So we were fairly plugged in within the industry, right?
- 11:12So a lawyer is working on I would say a more scalable program for securitizations.
- 11:19So some of the big list of getting into securitization is right.
- 11:22You have to have your data.
- 11:23Correct?
- 11:24You talk to anybody involved with that.
- 11:25That could mean a lot of different things.
- 11:27But ultimately, at the end of the day, you have to be able to pull
- 11:30your data from your systems correctly on time to report to investors.
- 11:36So when you issue a securitization and you're dealing with, the SEC at
- 11:40that point so it can be a little bit more, more of a constraint the cost
- 11:48associated with securitizations is massive for lack of a better term.
- 11:54And it's a great tool.
- 11:56It's an incredible tool for a handful of credit unions.
- 12:01And so I'll say this, I talked to a 300 million credit union.
- 12:05Last week about this because they were interested in, Hey, we hear about this.
- 12:08We should, we want to sell like securitization.
- 12:12And I had to take, 30 minutes just to give them a high level
- 12:14overview of this is what it entails.
- 12:16And these are the costs 300 million credit union probably shouldn't
- 12:19be doing a securitization.
- 12:20And there, there's a lot that goes into that, but that doesn't
- 12:23mean that there isn't a creative solution that we can create.
- 12:29That will allow for more credit unions to access that.
- 12:31And that's what we're looking at right now.
- 12:33We don't have a solution ready to come in and say, Hey, give me a call.
- 12:37But that is something we are actively looking at and working on.
- 12:39But we're pretty plugged in with most of the players.
- 12:42And if you're interested in it now and you want to learn more, give me a call.
- 12:46I'll tell you all the players who's involved right now.
- 12:48I'll be happy to introduce you to them.
- 12:50And we can, we can educate on that perspective as well.
- 12:54But yeah, securitization is what will continue to be that and as more and
- 12:58more credit unions do it, they'll talk to one another, they'll share
- 13:02good information with one another.
- 13:04So every new credit union that comes along that does it, it'll be
- 13:08an easier lift for the next credit.
- 13:09That's how those things
- 13:10Markoverdub: work.
- 13:11That's the beauty of how credit unions are truly cooperative, right?
- 13:15So they share that wisdom.
- 13:17And then as you're talking through that, I'm thinking maybe down the
- 13:20road this sounds like a credit union service organization or QSO that,
- 13:24that might be able to help people pool and share the costs potentially.
- 13:28So there's,
- 13:29Bill: There's something there.
- 13:30We'll figure somebody will figure it out.
- 13:31Markoverdub: There's that.
- 13:32Yeah, somebody will figure it out.
- 13:33There's a lot of smart people out there that that, and that,
- 13:36and like you said, on a crisis,
- 13:38new ideas are born.
- 13:40As everybody was doing the loan participations for so long and then
- 13:44the tide went out and the liquidity tightened up that wasn't there and it
- 13:48made people a little bit tighter and and the securitization is a good option.
- 13:52Now you mentioned deposit swaps.
- 13:54When I hear that, is that the type of scenario where you can.
- 13:59Double the amount of insurance because you're sweeping it over
- 14:02to another institution or is it something different than that?
- 14:05Bill: I don't want to apply it on that just because I'm not an expert.
- 14:09I just remember reading about it and thinking, wow, this is really cool.
- 14:13And I've heard of other ways around how credit unions are trying to get
- 14:17extra insurance and, or trying to skirt where they're taking in, I don't know,
- 14:24a million dollars and then they're flowing off, 750, 000 to keep it.
- 14:28And I, I don't know if those are, if that's legit, so I don't want
- 14:32to give anybody bad advice here.
- 14:34Deposits are not my cup of tea.
- 14:36That being said, I thought it was super interesting.
- 14:38And so I just want to, I like that.
- 14:40Go, Hey, Freddy's are going to do interesting things and they're going
- 14:44to continue to do interesting things.
- 14:46Cause they have
- 14:46Markoverdub: to, cause they have to.
- 14:48Yeah, that's right.
- 14:49Very good.
- 14:50Another thing that in the long term potentially could impact credit unions,
- 14:55banks life insurance companies is the recent 100 year report from the F.
- 15:01H.
- 15:01F.
- 15:02A.
- 15:02on the federal home loan bank system and the whole.
- 15:07role that they play.
- 15:09I know that I interviewed Ryan Donovan, who's the head of
- 15:12the the trade associations for the federal home loan banks.
- 15:17And there's acts that would require acts of Congress.
- 15:20There's acts that would require regulation changes by the FHFA.
- 15:23And then there's guidance that they could put out, but any thoughts on
- 15:28what you've read relative to that whole arena and how things, how.
- 15:33How a lawyer works with credit unions versus federal home loan
- 15:37banks or with or any Intel there or you have on that whole arena.
- 15:43Yeah, so
- 15:44Bill: like the FHLB, a lawyer is a lender, right?
- 15:49In that regard.
- 15:50So all your corporates, all the corporates, I think there's.
- 15:53nine or 11 of us at this point.
- 15:55But all of us are lenders, right?
- 15:56And we're really an aggregator of deposits.
- 15:58And that's why we were created.
- 15:59And we were the, to my knowledge, I believe we were the first QSO, right?
- 16:03Like corporates were the first QSO, they were kicked out of banks, and to go
- 16:07access the Fed and then provide liquidity.
- 16:10So to this day that we still hold those two truths, we just do those
- 16:13things a little bit differently.
- 16:14So just like the FHLB, we are a lender.
- 16:18What I would say is we are a lender basically on a day to day perspective.
- 16:24We can provide term lending and we do and I think it's a great option.
- 16:28We have competitive rates most of the time.
- 16:31But we're not a federally guaranteed, company like the Federal Home Loan Bank.
- 16:35So I'll, credit unions will say my, my rate is much lower at the FHLB.
- 16:39That's true because, the cost of funds is essentially zero.
- 16:43And so to say all that, so a lawyer is a lender and that's one of our
- 16:49main components of what we do.
- 16:51We do it in a different way in general.
- 16:54We do it on a day to day basis.
- 16:56So if you need.
- 16:58If you can't hit payroll or a large deposit came out and, and you
- 17:02have an investment coming in the next week or two, you're probably
- 17:06going to borrow from a corporate.
- 17:07It's just tends to be a little bit easier.
- 17:09FHLBs, from what I can see, generally, that's a little bit more of your
- 17:15Your planned borrowing, right?
- 17:17You need money for X amount of time.
- 17:20You're going to go to FHLB.
- 17:21You're going to do that, or you're going to take advantage of maybe some down
- 17:24rates at the FHLB and some up rates and then arbitrage opportunity elsewhere.
- 17:29That was a big thing for two years that credit unions did.
- 17:32All that to say credit unions typically don't use the FHLB as an emergency source
- 17:39of liquidity, which if you look at that, the hundred year report, which you're
- 17:44referencing, and all the stuff that happened with SVB and all the other banks,
- 17:49they were using that as an emergency.
- 17:51The FHLB system as an emergency source.
- 17:53So I do think that there will be some changes in how financial
- 17:58institutions can borrow from the FHLB.
- 18:01I don't know what that's going to be.
- 18:03And regardless, I don't believe how credit unions access the FHLB is the same way
- 18:11is really what makes the FHFA worried that being said, they are, they're a
- 18:17community financial depository, right?
- 18:19The likely are going to, there's going to be some.
- 18:25sOme instance where whatever is changed through the FHA, it's going to play a part
- 18:30in how the credit unions access to FHLB.
- 18:33What that is, I don't know.
- 18:35I hope it's not much, but I am anticipating at some point,
- 18:38something's going to change.
- 18:39And, who knows what that is.
- 18:41Maybe, they'll restrict borrowings in some way.
- 18:44I've heard, and I didn't listen to Ryan's podcast, but maybe I've heard
- 18:48along the lines of, they want the FHLB to go back to its original form, which
- 18:54was basically just for mortgage lending.
- 18:58That would have drastic impact on the industry if they did something
- 19:02of that nature, which would put more pressure on the corporates
- 19:05to be an even greater liquidity
- 19:07Markoverdub: provider.
- 19:09Yeah, that's a theme of that report for sure.
- 19:11So I think, to me, the takeaway is it's good to have options.
- 19:15Life is about maintaining options and having a good relationship with the
- 19:18corporate, having a relationship with the federal home loan bank, the Fed,
- 19:22if, your asset size allows for it, the CLF even, it's good to have options.
- 19:27And and of course the corporates being part of the cooperative
- 19:30system are always a great one to have in your toolbox for sure.
- 19:35Bill: Sure.
- 19:35Yeah, the CLF is something that I don't think enough credit unions
- 19:38look at, if I were to sit here on a soapbox, I would say I would seriously,
- 19:42furiously suggest looking at it.
- 19:44Markoverdub: I know that, yeah, I know NCOA would agree with you and
- 19:48it's always on the list to get a little bit of regulatory change and
- 19:51small credit unions have some more liquidity challenges as that way.
- 19:56That whole system is set up.
- 19:58And I know the corporates have covered for the small credit unions.
- 20:02In some of the crises, these are the past and recently.
- 20:04Agree with you that, CLF is a good thing to check out and see if it makes
- 20:08sense for the individual credit unions.
- 20:10I don't recall that non member deposits have talked about non member deposits yet.
- 20:15I know that they play a role.
- 20:17Is that something that Aloia assists with?
- 20:21Or is that just a trend that you've seen in credit unions out there?
- 20:24Any thoughts on non member deposits and how credit unions are using, how
- 20:28credit unions are utilizing non member deposits as part of their liquidity tools?
- 20:33Bill: Yeah.
- 20:33It's something that a lawyer assists with.
- 20:35We are an owner and a QSO primary financial, which, they
- 20:39have the simply CD program.
- 20:41It is a massive piece of the liquidity toolkit.
- 20:44And one of the real cool things that we've seen, and this will
- 20:47be, going into your question 10 minutes ago or five minutes ago.
- 20:51What do you see on the horizon?
- 20:52I see more assets.
- 20:55of the system.
- 20:56And r they have allowed this ye bit last year was credit non member deposits who m
- 21:06To be able to hit the DTC market, which effectively allows them to go
- 21:11get other institutional investors in those non member deposits.
- 21:17And, I've talked to a lot of Non credit union investors
- 21:21over the last year and a half.
- 21:23Credit unions are wonderful for other institutional investors.
- 21:28They hit the ESG threshold that that investors are looking for.
- 21:32So if you're a credit union, specifically low income, low income designated
- 21:37and you do not have, you're not set up yet to access the DTC market.
- 21:42It's a great opportunity for you to to go and do that.
- 21:46It's exciting in a couple of pieces of paper, right?
- 21:49But now you're able to access this huge market of institutional investors and
- 21:53not just other credit unions, right?
- 21:55Markoverdub: And and DTC NCOA itself, we were always really good
- 21:58at acronyms, but if someone doesn't know what DTC stands for, could you
- 22:03Bill: Yeah, it's depository trust company.
- 22:05Ultimately it's just a way it's an acronym.
- 22:08That's the company that basically puts the QSIP on it.
- 22:11Again, maybe I'm messing this up, but I believe it's the one that puts the
- 22:15QSIP on it and allows them to go and access the other institutional investors.
- 22:20Markoverdub: Got it.
- 22:20Got it.
- 22:21Makes sense.
- 22:22I should know
- 22:23Bill: more about that.
- 22:24I had a little
- 22:25Markoverdub: homework for me after this.
- 22:27There you go.
- 22:28There's always, that's the sharpening the saw, the continual learning,
- 22:31learning that that those those of us that that love this industry,
- 22:35there's always something to learn.
- 22:36That's for sure.
- 22:37Yep.
- 22:38One of the challenges I mentioned in 2023, there are a handful of credit
- 22:43unions out there that, That reached for yield as it related to investments.
- 22:47And, you gave an example of a credit union.
- 22:49That's normally at 50 percent loan to assets and they're feeling a
- 22:52little tight because they're at 60.
- 22:54There are other credit unions that that didn't and there's banks, quite
- 22:58frankly, a lot of banks too, that maybe where it's a little slow at
- 23:03pricing their loans during 2023.
- 23:06and especially if they maybe did some, they had the parameters
- 23:09set with, their their loans, they did indirect loans, et cetera.
- 23:14And they had them priced and they were a little slower to change and move them up.
- 23:21And then they booked a little bit, their loan to assets, let's say went from 75 to
- 23:2490 before they could turn the spigot off.
- 23:27And then, delinquencies are spiking up a little bit.
- 23:29And those loans aren't were priced at a.
- 23:34For a market that was 200 basis points ago.
- 23:37Any thoughts relative to 2024 how people should be approaching loan
- 23:42pricing in conjunction with the fact that they might be, you said they're
- 23:47back generally where they were coming into COVID liquidity wise.
- 23:52Any thoughts on that arena from what you've seen and
- 23:55what we might expect in 2024?
- 23:58Yeah, one
- 23:59Bill: thing that I think more and more credit unions are getting attuned
- 24:03to is Liquidity management really is starting at the loan pricing.
- 24:08Like it's starting at loan origination.
- 24:11And to your point, Mark, credit unions were a little slow on doing that.
- 24:14And those that were in tune with the market because liquidity loan
- 24:19sales, whether it's participation or securitization were a piece of their
- 24:24liquidity management toolkit, they had to reprice basically every day, which is.
- 24:29A very smart way to go about doing things.
- 24:32More credit unions, regardless of size, are repricing.
- 24:37Their loans and being a little bit more competitive on a
- 24:39regular basis, which is great.
- 24:41So I, you know My advice to any credit union is to price competitively and
- 24:48I get some pushback with that from credit unions rightfully so which is
- 24:51hey We're here to serve our membership.
- 24:55And if that means giving a car loan at 2.
- 24:5799 we're doing the best we can and I would say you are and that's great And
- 25:03if your balance sheet can handle a 2.
- 25:0599 car loan for however long it's going to stay on, because it's
- 25:09probably not going to, reprice or get sold off or anything of that nature.
- 25:13Great.
- 25:13Continue to serve your membership.
- 25:15You're doing exactly what you're supposed to be doing.
- 25:17But if you need to sell loans at any time, you need to
- 25:21understand where that market is.
- 25:24And so the best thing to do is follow those markets and the loan sale market.
- 25:30Can follow, different benchmarks across the board.
- 25:33The easiest way to do it is to just understand where the treasury market
- 25:37is and price somewhere around that for your consumer loans, right?
- 25:41Mortgage loans are going to be something different.
- 25:43Commercial loans are going to be something different.
- 25:45So wherever your benchmark is on your loans that you need to have that make
- 25:50sure you're just you're following those and you can price your loans accordingly
- 25:54as for anybody who's sitting on loans that are quote unquote underwater right now.
- 26:00tHat's a tough conversation.
- 26:02Does it make sense for you to sell loans at a loss?
- 26:05At what loss does that make you make sense?
- 26:08That is a conversation we have with credit unions every day.
- 26:12And one that we'll continue to have and sometimes it makes sense, right?
- 26:16You can take that those, that money, you can pay off some high,
- 26:20higher debt you can reinvest it and another type of, investment.
- 26:25You can make new loans at market rates, right?
- 26:28So you have to figure out what the best is going to be for you,
- 26:31or you just sit on them, right?
- 26:32Most credit unions don't like taking losses ever.
- 26:35Most of the time they just sit on them.
- 26:36Markoverdub: Conversation to have and that might not, it might be the right decision.
- 26:40It might not be the right decision, but it's easy to, it's like when you buy a
- 26:43stock and it goes down and you want to wait for it to get back to the price
- 26:46you paid for it and it might never.
- 26:48Sure.
- 26:48But also that's the beauty of.
- 26:51Liquidity, right?
- 26:52Liquidity, you can manage your way through it as long as your asset quality
- 26:57holds, if the, if you bought triple a treasuries that are just upside
- 27:02down because you went a little bit long, if you have the ability to hold
- 27:05that, you'll get them paid back fully.
- 27:07And if you have the ability to hold those car loans they'll do the same, that
- 27:12doesn't mean repositioning might make sense, like you said, cause you can get
- 27:15the money out earning at a higher rate.
- 27:16And that's a lot of math that goes behind that.
- 27:19I do know that N.
- 27:20C.
- 27:20U.
- 27:21A.
- 27:22and I, I've had conversations directly, with some of the regional directors that
- 27:25they've told credit unions and they've told their staff if somebody finds himself
- 27:30in that position, and they want to purge a little bit of risk, which results in
- 27:34their net worth coming down a little bit.
- 27:36Because it positions them better for the long term, that NCUA, is going to look
- 27:41very positively at a approach that that looks at it in that light and is measured.
- 27:47But it is hard sometimes for people to, say, Hey, I took a loss on this and
- 27:50they'd rather just let it ride at times.
- 27:53Bill: Sure.
- 27:54Yeah it's difficult.
- 27:55And that's the conversation that each credit union must have.
- 27:58Amongst themselves at the management level could be even at a board
- 28:01level in conjunction, I would say this in conjunction with
- 28:04your examiner not a bad thing.
- 28:06If you can do that too, right?
- 28:08At least let them know that's coming.
- 28:09If that's a decision that you are thinking about.
- 28:11Yeah, those are tough conversations.
- 28:13And those are done at an individual credit union level.
- 28:16I would never say what's good for one is good for everybody.
- 28:19Markoverdub: Sure.
- 28:20Absolutely.
- 28:21Absolutely.
- 28:22Billy, this is this has been an enjoyable conversation.
- 28:26I'm sure there's a question perhaps that I should have asked you that I didn't.
- 28:30Is there anything else you'd like to highlight here as
- 28:32we wrap up our chat today?
- 28:36No,
- 28:36Bill: I think I think we're good.
- 28:38The quicker we can get off record and start talking college basketball again.
- 28:42That's right.
- 28:42Markoverdub: Yeah.
- 28:43Yeah.
- 28:43We had a good chat about college basketball college football, and even
- 28:48teeny tiny lakes in the Adirondacks that we were both surprisingly close history
- 28:53we have with with both of our loves of the Adirondack mountains at New York.
- 28:56Very good now.
- 28:58So if someone Bill, if someone wants to reach out to you at Aloia, what's the best
- 29:03way for them to continue if this triggered some questions they'd like to ask you,
- 29:07what's the best way for them to reach you?
- 29:09Yeah
- 29:09Bill: Two ways.
- 29:10The quickest probably is LinkedIn.
- 29:12Like you said, Mark, I'm fairly active on LinkedIn.
- 29:15You can look me up.
- 29:16It's William Payton.
- 29:18I'm the one at Aloia Corporate.
- 29:20I think that there's numerous William Paytons out there, but
- 29:23I'm the one at Aloia Corporate.
- 29:24So that's my profile.
- 29:26You can shoot me a connection or a message.
- 29:28It's fine.
- 29:29As long as you're not trying to sell something and then the
- 29:32the other one is you can email me it's bill b i l dot payton.
- 29:37So p a t o n So b i l dot p a t o n at a lawyer corp dot org.
- 29:44So a l o y a C o r p dot o r g.
- 29:48So again the easiest is linkedin after that mouthful, but but
- 29:51yeah You can you know shoot me an email Shoot me a LinkedIn.
- 29:54Happy to connect however you want.
- 29:56Markoverdub: It's great.
- 29:57And I will put your your LinkedIn profile a link to your LinkedIn
- 30:01profile in the show notes.
- 30:02So if someone listens to it and goes down into the notes, they can,
- 30:06they could find it there as well.
- 30:08Bill, I wanna thank you so much for your time today.
- 30:10I really enjoyed chatting with you about all things liquidity and all things
- 30:15related to a lawyer and what you're doing there to help credit unions.
- 30:18Thanks so much for your time today.
- 30:20Appreciate it.
- 30:20Thanks, Mark.
- 30:21Have a great one.
- 30:22You got it.
- 30:22And listeners, I want to thank you for listening again.
- 30:26I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 30:27This is Mark Treichel signing off with Flying Colors.