Latest / The So What? / Coalitions – Important Shifts
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to the So What podcast, in which political economic analyst JP Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of South Africans. You can find a written
- 0:16version of this content on JP's website, jplandman.co.za. I am Ruda Landman and I am your host.
- 0:28These first few recordings were done at our dining room table, but we will soon be moving
- 0:33into a studio. Hello and as always a very warm welcome to this conversation which accompanies
- 0:42JP's latest newsletter. This one is dated the 14th August 2023 and it's titled, Coalitions:
- 0:51Important Shifts. JP, you wrote about the coalitions for the first time in May, but
- 0:57you say that three developments have happened since then. Tell me about that. Yes, absolutely.
- 1:04Since May, three important developments or shifts. The first is that on the 11th of July,
- 1:11the Incartum Freedom Party and the DA signed an agreement to cooperate in coalitions at
- 1:17the local government level in the province of kwaZulu Natal. It's a unique agreement
- 1:23in the sense that it's fairly detailed. It spells out 13 commitments that the parties
- 1:29make and 15 priorities that they set for those municipalities where they will come into power.
- 1:36The 13 commitments are very interesting. There's the normal stuff of commitment to the rule
- 1:41of law and so on, but they're also interesting new noises or new approaches. For example,
- 1:49they say that there will be a strict separation of party and state. All appointments will
- 1:56be merit based. Then the normal thing which everybody says nowadays, corruption will be
- 2:02eradicated and opposed and there will be a non-negotiable commitment to the rule of law
- 2:07and constitutionalism. I think it is important in coalition politics that you set out what
- 2:14the values are in which you base your coalition and that you have to agree on those values.
- 2:19That they've done in their agreement. But then they go a step further beyond their commitments
- 2:24and they list 15 priority areas where they will work in municipalities where they capture
- 2:29the power. Now again, there are obvious things like water, waste management, sewage, public
- 2:35transport and so on, but they're also more unusual items. For example, there's a very
- 2:42clear commitment to spend 8% of the value of municipal assets on maintenance. Now this
- 2:50is breaking new ground as far as local government levels go. We all know that maintenance is
- 2:55a huge problem and this kind of commitment is essentially the thing that addresses that
- 2:59deficit. There's also a clear commitment to review organograms of all municipalities,
- 3:07to review staff complements and reviewing salary scales downwards before filling vacant
- 3:14posts. So that is addressing another big problem that we have with local government and that
- 3:18is that salaries and wages just gobble up all the available money. So the fact that
- 3:23the DAA and IFP came to these agreements in respect of course to the Natal, I think is
- 3:30quite an important step. Basically it meets the test that we articulated in May. What
- 3:37we have to do in coalition politics in South Africa is to focus not on who will govern
- 3:44but how we will govern. Those letters need to be switched around. This agreement between
- 3:50the IFP and the DA takes us very far on the road to how government will take place instead
- 3:57of who. When or how will this be put into practice? Well currently the IFP and DA are
- 4:05controlling 13 local governments in KwaZulu-Natal. So it has already started. The second development
- 4:12that you refer to? The second development happened at the end of July, the last weekend
- 4:16in July, when the ANC Veterans League had the national conference which was attended
- 4:22by some 460 delegates from branches from all nine provinces. So the Veterans League have
- 4:29really in the last while established themselves by setting up branches. Now to be a veteran
- 4:36of ANC you must be over 60 years of age and you must have served the organization for
- 4:4140 years uninterruptedly. So it's quite a test. They had a national conference, the
- 4:48president went there, he called the Veterans League the loud start of the ANC, but what
- 4:54is very important is that they stated that a coalition between ANC and EFF is an unethical
- 5:00coalition. Now those are very strong words to use and for a senior body like that to
- 5:07say that explicitly and that unambiguously I think was also quite a strong development.
- 5:14Since we've written this note in the last week, Fekili Mbalula, the secretary general
- 5:19of the ANC was asked about this decision by the Veterans League conference and what was
- 5:25very interesting is he handled it very diplomatically, something for which he is not known. And he
- 5:31just said you know it's the view of the Veterans League and the views of all parts of the ANC
- 5:35will be taken into consideration, but he did not denounce the statement by the Veterans
- 5:40League that a coalition between ANC and EFF is unethical. So clearly it tells you that
- 5:47there's movement, there's fluidity. The third development took place on the first
- 5:53weekend in August, I think it was 4 and 5 August, when deputy president Po Maschettile
- 6:00convened a conference on coalitions on the campus of the University of the Western Cape.
- 6:07And there a very interesting thing happened, again Fekili Mbalula made a speech and he
- 6:13left, he not only left the door open, he specifically said that the ANC could go into a grand coalition
- 6:21with the DA on local government level. He emphasized that afterwards in meetings with
- 6:27journalists that he was talking about local government, not about national government,
- 6:32that fact remains the door has been opened. So if you put all these developments together
- 6:37that has taken place in July and August, then I think we have seen considerable movement
- 6:43in the body politic towards what I called in May a grand coalition of the ANC and the
- 6:50DA. At the UWC meeting it was also quite clear
- 6:54that the largest parties agree on a minimum threshold before a party can be represented
- 7:02in local provincial national government. Do you see that happening?
- 7:07Yes, you're quite right, there was clearly agreement between the two biggest parties
- 7:13and of course the civilist opposition from all the smaller parties. I think that's very
- 7:17predictable. Now nobody, neither the ANC nor the DA put any numbers on the table at the
- 7:24Western Co-conference, but earlier in the year the ANC signaled that they would be in
- 7:28favor of a 1% threshold. The DA signaled that they would be in favor of a 3% threshold.
- 7:36So the number will, if it happens, it will land somewhere between 1 and possibly 2%,
- 7:41right about. Now a 1% threshold would have an interesting impact. It will eliminate 8
- 7:48of the 14 parties that we currently have in parliament, more than half. It will eliminate
- 7:54in the Johannesburg metro 9 of the 18 parties currently sitting in the metro. In Swaranday
- 8:00it will eliminate a whopping 10 of 15 parties and in Elstom and Delabay 5 of 13 parties.
- 8:08So you can clearly see small parties representing a really small minority of the voters are
- 8:14really influential because there's so many of them and that is what the reaction is against,
- 8:19also from the public and that is what the DA and ANC are trying to address. Now of course
- 8:24the ANC and the DA being the two biggest parties will benefit from such an arrangement and
- 8:30they argue that it will enhance stability, which it probably will, and it will reduce
- 8:35horse trading, which it probably will. The smaller parties again argue that it is inherently
- 8:41undemocratic and you're doing something which is not in line with the wishes of the voters
- 8:47and you deprive the voters of choice and they're also correct. So there are strong arguments
- 8:51on both sides of this threshold decision. Now it's quite interesting to see what's
- 8:58happening elsewhere. Internationally thresholds vary between 0.67, two thirds of 1% in the
- 9:06Netherlands to as high as 6% in Moldova. The most common threshold is 5% and one finds
- 9:14that in countries like Germany, New Zealand, Poland and Hungary. Denmark has a threshold
- 9:19of 2% while the threshold in Sweden and Norway are sitting at 4%. So you're talking old
- 9:26established democracies here. Scandinavian countries are hardly countries with immature
- 9:32democracies and they have 2%, 4% and 5% thresholds. So there is an international precedent for
- 9:40this. However, the question that one must ask is if you apply the 1% threshold in South
- 9:46Africa, parties like the African Christian Democratic Party and Al Jomar will be eliminated
- 9:52from parliament. Do you really want to force these people to go extra parliamentary? I
- 9:58mean that's what the consequence of a 1% threshold decision would be. Do you think that would
- 10:03happen or would their voters be absorbed in the bigger parties? They have people who support
- 10:10them. If their voters do not want to vote for other parties, then they are still there,
- 10:16they're still around. But by denying them access to the legislature or to the town council,
- 10:22you actually force them to go outside politics. And I don't think that's a wise idea. Can
- 10:28it happen in time for the 2024 election? Probably not. No, definitely not. We've got, it's now
- 10:35August, the election will probably be in May. If it is postponed for three months, that'll
- 10:40take it to August, 12 months from now. It'll be very hard to get legislation through parliament
- 10:45in 12 months. Parliament just doesn't move that quickly. So no, I don't think it'll happen.
- 10:51In any case, even if it does happen, the legislation will be challenged in the constitutional court.
- 10:56I mean, there's no doubt about that. Does our constitution say anything about this?
- 11:00Yes, it does. In section 46 of the constitution, it says that an electoral system must in general
- 11:07result in proportional representation. Now, what does in general mean? Is 1% does that
- 11:13satisfy the in general requirement or 3% does it satisfy that requirement? That is something
- 11:20on which the constitutional court will have to pronounce. And obviously they'll have to
- 11:25consider it carefully. So no, I think the parliamentary agenda, the parliamentary timetable,
- 11:32as well as constitutional challenges can make us fairly certain that it will not happen,
- 11:37that there will not be legislation on the statute before next year's parliamentary elections.
- 11:46You published this note on the 14th of August, but because of circumstance, we are only recording
- 11:53this conversation on the 21st. The moonshot backed convention has now happened. Thoughts?
- 12:00Yeah, it happened on 16 and 17 of August. For the parties participating, it was a huge
- 12:07success. They proclaimed it as such. Seven parties. Seven parties in total. From my point
- 12:13of view, I think there were some encouraging signs. The parties accepted the principle
- 12:19that your representation in the coalition government is based on the votes that you
- 12:24got. So there's a clear relationship. If you got 60% of the votes, then you will have
- 12:2960% of the government. You got 30% of the vote, you'll get 30% of the government. Until
- 12:34now, there was a lot of toing and froing about that. So having developed a consensus about
- 12:41that, I think is quite a good thing. The fundamental problem remains how these seven parties will
- 12:49get to 50% plus one. That is really the issue. If you take the current parliament, which
- 12:55I think one must accept is no longer representative, but if you take the current parliament, their
- 13:01total vote come to less than 30% of those seven parties. Only three of those seven parties
- 13:08are sitting in parliament. The other four are outside parliament. So they must still
- 13:11prove that they can actually get votes. We tend to forget that. We focus on the seven
- 13:16and not on the three that have already made it into parliament. But I think it's fair
- 13:22to say that ANC will get less votes than what they got in the present parliament. They currently
- 13:28in the present parliament have 57.5% of the vote. Their share will probably drop below
- 13:3357.5%. So will the other parties then pick that up? Where will it go? I can't see the
- 13:42current seven parties going much higher than 35%. Not on current poll data as we have it
- 13:49now. Obviously anything can happen in the next nine to 12 months, but I can't see them
- 13:54going much higher than 35%. Now, if you want to take over the government, you need 50%
- 14:00as one. And that's really the basic problem that faces the moonshot coalition. In May
- 14:06you said that the most probable outcome would be that the ANC gets high 40s and that they
- 14:13can then go into coalition with the IFP, which will take them over 50. Is that still your
- 14:21view? Yes, I still think that's a possibility. But what has developed since then is this
- 14:26agreement between the DA and IFP on the local government level. And one wants to now ask
- 14:31the question, if you are a formal coalition partner in one province on the local government
- 14:36level, can you in the national government go into coalition with somebody else? That
- 14:42strikes me as a bit messy. And that strikes me as a bit sending confused signals to the
- 14:48electorate. So I'm not so sure that that is as obvious as it was in May. In May, I think
- 14:55it was quite clear that the ANC would prefer to take the IFP. I've never shared the view
- 15:00that they will go to the EFF, which was in May the dominant theme from the chattering
- 15:04classes. I just don't think I didn't think it then. And I still don't think so. I think
- 15:10events have shown to us there's a lot of opposition to ANC EFF coalition. So I'm not sure that
- 15:18they will necessarily get the cooperation of the IFP. And then the question is what else
- 15:24they will do. But as I said in May, it all depends on the numbers. If you get 47, 48%,
- 15:32well then two or three percent are enough to get you over the line. If you get towards
- 15:3740%, well then it becomes much more difficult. And then the idea of a grand coalition certainly
- 15:43comes to the fore much more strongly. But then the grand coalition would, following
- 15:48your logic, would have to include all three of those parties, the ANC, the DA and the
- 15:54IFP. Because what you said now about working with the IFP going into a coalition, or the
- 16:02other way around actually, the IFP going into a coalition with the ANC at national level,
- 16:07the same holds true for the DA. Absolutely. Yes, and I think you're right. I think the
- 16:12ANC would also like to have the protection, if you want, of the IFP in a national, in
- 16:19a grand coalition. They don't want to be exposed, have exposed flanks to the EFF and other parties
- 16:29who can then attack them. So it is quite possible that it goes that way. But you know, it's
- 16:34a year away. It's early days. It's very, very early days. Very early days. Just in almost
- 16:41theoretical terms, the German ambassador was a guest speaker at the UWC conference. And
- 16:48he made interesting points about how coalitions work best. Yes. So the German ambassador,
- 16:55they made a speech and he relayed lessons that the Germans have learned of coalitions.
- 17:00Now, you must remember the Germans have had coalitions for a very, very long time, many
- 17:06decades, and not just on the national level, but also in the land in the provinces. So
- 17:11they know about coalitions. And the ambassador shared that with the conference. And I think
- 17:17a couple of them were very important. He said coalitions is about the politics of inclusion,
- 17:22not exclusion. And I think that's a very important point for us in South Africa. We tend to emphasize
- 17:28who we will not work with, not who we will work with. So that's a strong point. Coalition
- 17:36is the art of negotiation, not the art of war. It sounds absolutely right, but a lot
- 17:41of people don't practice that. Again, in our country, we like to go to war and use war-like
- 17:47language instead of negotiating. Issues first, appointments later. In other words, how, not
- 17:55who. Issues first, how, not appointments, who. That was an important message from him.
- 18:01And then concrete policies must be agreed on in advance. Now that's exactly what the
- 18:06IFP and the DA agreed in respect of KwaZulu-Natal local government authorities. A concrete program
- 18:13of action, concrete policies that they will pursue. And then of course, trust is absolutely
- 18:18critical. And for that you need transparency and openness. And again, that is where we
- 18:24can learn from the Germans. Another interesting point about Germany, Rudi, is that after the
- 18:29last elections, when Chancellor Schulz eventually became the Chancellor, the elections were
- 18:35held in September. The government only took office and Chancellor Schulz was only inaugurated
- 18:43in December. So there was a long time lag between the elections when the results were
- 18:49known almost immediately and actually taking office. So what happened in that long time
- 18:54lag? The parties negotiated agreements on how they are going to govern. Exactly the
- 19:00kind of thing that we saw in respect of KwaZulu-Natal local government. So in South Africa, our
- 19:07constitution at the moment only allows 14 days. 14 days after the election has been
- 19:12certified by the Independent Electoral Commission, parliament must meet and at its first meeting
- 19:18it must elect a president. The constitution is quite clear on that. So we've given ourselves
- 19:2414 days or we have 14 days in terms of our constitution, while the Germans have taken
- 19:29a couple of months to form a government. So that's something that we will have to also
- 19:34keep in mind as we approach the possibility, not the inevitability, but the possibility
- 19:40of a coalition government at national level. Can I just make one more point about coalition
- 19:46forming? You know, I think it's quite clear that the majority of South Africans are not
- 19:51radical. We see that from opinion polls, but we also see it from, we also saw it in the
- 19:582021 July unrest and we've seen it in various areas of our national life. Yes, there are
- 20:05people who do violent things and do radical things and so on, but when the tire hits the
- 20:11tire, South Africans are the middle of the road a lot. Now that implies that large numbers
- 20:17of political party supporters are also middle of the road people and the logical conclusion
- 20:24that a number of ANC supporters are also middle of the road people and therefore I think the
- 20:29German message of coalitions is about inclusion, not exclusion. It's an extremely relevant
- 20:37and important one. Bring together those people that can reinforce the democratic model. It
- 20:44doesn't really matter in which parties they sit and they sit in most parties, not all
- 20:49parties but in most parties. Bring them together. That is the message that we must take from
- 20:55opinion polls and other data that tells us that South Africans are not really a radical
- 21:01bunch. Many people worry, they are afraid, they have a fear that the junior partner in
- 21:09a coalition will be swapped and in the next election just wiped out. Especially I think
- 21:17DA supporters fear that. Is it legitimate? Well as one DA supporter said to me, the DA
- 21:24will be dragged down by the ANC and I think that sentiment is fairly widespread. Yes,
- 21:29I think it is legitimate. We saw it happening in the United Kingdom when the liberals went
- 21:34into a coalition with the Tories and in the subsequent election the Tories trounced and
- 21:39the liberals were wiped out. The counter example you find on the continent of Europe, Germany
- 21:45for example, where there are small parties like the free democrats who regularly fall
- 21:51below the 5% threshold, then they fall out of parliament, next election they come back
- 21:56and they are above 5%, so they are represented and then they normally, not always but quite
- 22:02often form part of some ruling coalition, yet they remain, they retain, they remain
- 22:08independent and they retain an independent identity and political programme and so on.
- 22:15So I think what one must learn from that is to be very clear on what you will agree to
- 22:20and what you won't agree to. What are fundamental commitments or values that you as a party
- 22:25have on which you are prepared to negotiate and which not. And again that is where the
- 22:31case that in agreement between the DA and the IFP for me is so interesting. There are
- 22:37clear commitments and there are clear priorities. That's the kind of model we need. The liberals
- 22:42never negotiated that kind of agreement as far as I know in the UK. So it's all about
- 22:47your identity and sticking with your identity irrespective of how big or small you are.
- 22:52So I think that is something that can be overcome. The whole of Europe is run by coalitions and
- 22:59there you've got big and small parties and they all face with the same problem and the
- 23:04small parties survive, they don't disappear. So no, I think it's just a new style of politics
- 23:08that we must get used to. In summary, so what? Well, for me the most important so what is
- 23:16that the free development since May indicate to me that the ground is shifting as far as
- 23:24coalitions go. Three months ago in May, a couple of months ago in May, beginning of
- 23:29the year, there was a sort of a consensus among the commentary that there will be ANC-EFF
- 23:36coalition and that is it. I don't think any of those people will now take such certain
- 23:41views or positions on the coalition issue. The ground has shifted quite substantially
- 23:48and what is happening in that shifting of the ground is that the parties of the middle
- 23:53has got an opportunity to get together and to form a grand coalition of the middle, strengthening
- 23:58the democratic centre. I think that opportunity now is bigger than what it was in May and
- 24:04certainly much bigger than what it was in January. So what for the probably most pressing
- 24:12area and that is local governments? The local government election is only in 2026, it's
- 24:18now 2023. So must we now for the next three years carry on with this stumbling that we
- 24:24have? Clearly not. So what I think is needed is an in principle agreement for a grand coalition
- 24:31or a coalition between parties of the middle and they must come together and reconstitute
- 24:37councils where you have this up and down all the time, of which our beloved Johannesburg
- 24:42is a classic example. And if we can get the parties of the middle to take hands and join
- 24:48together you can actually form very strong local governments, strong in the sense that
- 24:54they represent 70% and two thirds of the voters. Then you can have administrative stability
- 25:01and things can go forward. And that is a political agreement, you don't need legislation for
- 25:07that. What you need is the political world to do it and then doing the hard work of negotiating
- 25:12the political agreements and put them into practice. So that's the only way forward
- 25:17that I see for local governments, is to use the three years until the next election to
- 25:22establish such coalitions and then they will also have an impact the year from now when
- 25:28we have the national election, it can have an impact on how a national government is
- 25:33formed. Can I push you on do you think it might actually happen that people in local
- 25:40government form solid coalitions and come to this kind of agreement? Well, what we hear
- 25:48from the political arena is that people in Johannesburg are saying there will be a change
- 25:52in government again quite soon. We've now had what was it eight mayors, eight years
- 25:57or something, one year similar noises from Nelson Mandela Bay. It looks as if the DA
- 26:04coalition in Twane is surviving in spite of attempts to topple it. So it does seem to
- 26:11me that there is there as well, there's a kind of a shifting of the ground or shifting
- 26:16of positions rather. And I think it's quite possible that it can develop years. I'm not
- 26:21making a prediction, but you know, let's see what transpires over the next six months.
- 26:30Thank you for listening to the So What podcast. If you enjoy this content, please don't forget
- 26:35to leave a review and a rating and please consider subscribing so you don't miss any
- 26:40future episodes. Also tell your friends. Remember you can find a written version of all JP's
- 26:46content at JPLandman.co.za.