Latest / Portfolio Talks / Ep 13 : Small Business Deduction Clawback, What Incorporated Doctors Need to Know
Transcript
- Vishal Gill, CFP: Welcome to episode 13 of Portfolio Talks. In this episode, we're going be chatting about passive income. And I know we've talked about it before, but what we want to do in today's episode is talk about the philosophy behind it, some issues that you can run into, and then also show the quant side of the numbers because we've had more clients being onboarded and more and more clients that don't know that they are in a small passive income problem already. So we want to get ahead and show you guys. So hopefully you don't run into this issue and you can start to identify or diagnose your problem. As a reminder, before we jump into the episode, if you gain value from the podcast, do us a big favor and share and subscribe to the podcast on whatever platform you're watching. Really trying to show further up on the rankings for these financial podcasts so that we can cut through the noise and give value to your colleagues and the next generation of doctors in Canada so they avoid the mistakes that perhaps you've made along your journey. So without further ado, let's jump into it. Episode 13, Portfolio Talks. All right, welcome back everyone. And I know right off the rip, I would just let you guys know we are behind an episode we missed last week. I was out of town, out of country actually. I was down in Utah, the Vegas, and then going to see some family in Calgary. So having been in town for a little bit, and we were thinking about doing a pseudo episode, but the layout and the the the configuration of where I was just wasn't really making much sense and and it was hot in Utah. It was actually a power the first day I was there. I think it overflowed the system and the grid. So we landed in Utah. It was like 43 degrees, and there was a powerage for the whole city in St. George. No power for like seven hours. Couldn't even get the pool cover off the jump of the pool because there was no power, it was an electric cover. so we were just cooking out there. So it was it was a weird setup and we couldn't do it. So like we'll just delay an episode and get back to you guys this week. So apologize if you did notice it. And if you didn't notice it, just ignore everything I just said. And we are here in our regularly scheduled programming with another episode for you guys. so today we really want to talk about the passive income problem that you as a Canadian doctor are running into and you might not even know you're running into it. So we're gonna chat about all that stuff. We're gonna chat about what it actually is, we're gonna chat about the numbers and and share what compounds the problem and what can help you solve the problem. And then we're gonna talk about some philosophies behind that and if you should even invest inside your corporation and and when that makes sense for you. So the first thing I guess, Tyson, if we can simplify it, passive income. It sounds weird for people to be like, I think passive income's a good thing. Why would it ever be a bad thing? you know, for for our listeners, simplify it. Passive income problem inside of a corporation, what is that? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, I I think social media has a lot to do with that. Everybody thinking that they need passive income in order to get to the next level. Whereas I mean that's not necessarily true. And then it's not always Canadian advice. So when we're talking to our medical professionals who are incorporated, so you're an incorporated professional, you're a consultant, you're a doctor, you're an OD. Inside your corporation, things that happen that are not considered active business all accumulate as passive income. And while it seems good that your money or your assets are making money for you and furthering your furthering your advance towards your growing your net worth, CRA doesn't really like that. And you don't get all of the preferential corporate tax benefits. when your passive income starts to be too successful. I don't know I have a s I have a small list of things that kind of count towards that. I don't know if we want to save that or table that, but Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, we we table we can circle back to it. but I think that's really well said is you know, the CRA likes to punish you for certain things. And I guess for you to understand the the the concept of it is the C RA doesn't love the idea of just having you leave money inside the corporation and just grow and eventually they they will get that money eventually, but it's so deferred down the road. And it's the same thing if I asked you as the audience of you have two different investments. You have an investment that would yield you money on an annual basis, even if it's not all of it, but at least you get some kind of money. On an annual basis, or you can defer everything until the very, very end. And I don't know exactly when you're gonna get that return. It could be 15 years, could be 40 years, could be 55 years. We don't really know, but eventually that money will come to you. I would say most people would always go for the first one. Like at least I get some income on an annual basis. And that's effectively what the C rate is trying to do, is they don't love the idea of people deferring all the tax that they would eventually get inside the corporation and until an indefinite date. So, what they want to do is they'll give you some deferred growth, and that's fine. However, if you're earning too much passive income inside the corp, then they want to start slapping your wrist to make you pull it onto the personal side. And in that way, they can start to collect their revenue, which is really personal income, is is when they start to generate more revenue for themselves. so for every dollar that your professional corporation earns over the $50,000 in passive investments, and again, we'll get back to like what that actually is. But for every $50,000 that's above in your your personal corporation, your pre professional corporation, the Siri is gonna slap you with a five times a multiplier. So if you have an additional hundred dollars past the fifty K, you're gonna be taking that times by five, you're reducing your small business limit by five hundred dollars, which will put you in a higher tax rate. And again, the whole point of that is the Siri wants to collect revenue on an annual basis to pay for roads and all the infrastructure that they gotta do. They don't want investment that is We don't really know the time horizon. Same as most of us would also want the same thing. But there's ways around it. So you know, there's a couple things that count towards a passive income. I think maybe let's start there of you know, why do people not know that they have a passive income problem? And I would say that probably over 10 of our clients this year in was it 2026? Yeah. In this year, over 10 of our clients that we onboarded from all different provinces. They thought that they were earning money, which they were earning great incomes, living below their means, which is awesome, and accumulating and investing inside the corporation. At a surface level, all that is check, check, check. That's what you want to be doing. but they were inefficient in doing so because they didn't even know they had a passive income problem and the repercussions on that. So, you know, for someone that may not know, Tyson, what counts towards your passive income again inside your corporation investment portfolio? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. So it's it's it's categorized in two things. One is active income. And I think we've talked about this in previous episodes. Active income is the business of doing your business. Anything that's outside of that is considered passive or it's not active income in your business. so some of the things that we see, interest income. So GICs. We used in lots of business owners that think I'm not investing the money. I'm just gonna put it in a GIC inside my corporation. I'm gonna get three percent on it. It's I I've seen up to $2 million in a GIC just cash sitting there. The interest that you earn goes against your small business deduction limit. And if it's above $50,000 of interest income, you'd have to have a lot of money to get $50,000 of interest income. But if it's above that, then you start to grind down on your small business deduction limit. rental property, rental income. So we see a lot of successful businesses and business people. They make money and then they buy real estate inside their corporation with their corporate dollars. And your real estate portfolio that you're building, if that's not your main business, that is passive income and that is potentially a grind on your small business deduction. royalties. I've had a couple of clients that had like small oil well royalties. Maybe you've got a music royalty. royalties that are pay you in perpetuity that's not active income, it's considered passive. taxable gains. So if you have a really good portfolio, stocks and bonds and other things, and you rebalance, you sold off some of your winners, take profits that year that you take profits, all those capital gains, that's considered passive income, goes against your passive income limit. Income from another business. So even if you have a main business and then you create a side hustle and you're using your corporation for it and your team didn't advise you to create a separate corporation or anything like that, your side hustle inside your corporation may count as passive income and go against your your small business deduction limit. and then things like portfolio dividends and whatnot. So if you're getting dividends that are paid to you from investments, from other things. that are not from active business goes against your small business deduction limit. And that's that comfortable, small tax rate that we like to talk about. In BC it's eleven percent. Alberta, Ontario, it's very similar. And on your first five hundred thousand dollars, you get that really small tax bill, which is really nice. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, and really when it comes down to you know, all those things it is great. Like I I think the simple rule of thumb is almost err on the side of caution. So if you have any kind of yields that are coming into your corporation, so investments that are yielding you money, meaning that you're getting income on an annual basis or you're selling something that's anything besides your active business, so if I'm a physician, you know, if I'm getting paid from MSP or or you know whatever billing system you're on that's all good but anything besides that it's almost better to just assume that that's all gonna be passive income until otherwise proven so you can always have a kind of grasp and more times than not if you think it's 50-50 it's probably gonna be in the favor of the CRA so any type of yield that's coming to you in study corporation besides you actively working is most likely going to be passive income. and you know a lot of people don't realize especially the high income earning professionals they're already over the small business limit regardless. So they're like, okay, whatever. I I guess it's just my taxable because I'm earning over the $500,000 limit. What they don't realize, and and this is only the demographic this is the only demographic story that that we've had that I know it sounds funny when you think that what do you mean people don't know they have passive income problem inside the corporation? Is because they're paying in the general rate anyway. So they don't notice that they're paying more in the general rate than they otherwise could. and it's significant savings. Like we had a client who made back $80,000 last year only, just because we rebuilt their portfolio and They were able to capture back their small business limit that they otherwise lost, but they didn't realize it because they're in the general rate, anyways, every single year. so if you're ever 50-50 about it, it's probably gonna be in the favor of the series, which is probably gonna be, you know, you having passive income. A couple of things to talk about, Tyson talked about what is included, and just to kind of quickly go on the other side of what is not included would be Tyson referenced the capital gains. So the 50% of the capital gains, half of that is gonna be passive income. half of that is not because it's just added to your capital dividend account. So it's nothing really that you would see besides just a nominal number on your your your tax side that will you use eventually in the future. You don't use it annually, but you use it eventually in the future because it costs you money to use your CDA account, but it's gonna be there. dividends from corporations. This is one that people have questions about is let's say I do have a holding company and like two operating companies, and I'm moving money back and forth between them for whatever reason to buy something or Payoff debts or whatever. intercorporate dividends do not add to your passive income because it's not income. You're just moving money from one of your corpse to the other. Same as if you're moving from your savings account to your other savings account. It's your money, it's still inside that corporate structure. So you're not pulling it from the corporate side to the personal side and the personal side to the corporate and vice versa. Your accountant would hate you if you did that. And but your bookkeeper would be pulling out the hair. But as long as you're keeping everything in the corporate structure and you're moving money from one corpse to the other, it's your money just moving back and forth. That is not passive income. That's not. Dividends that we're referring to, the dividends that we're referring to are dividends from like Apple, for example, or RBC that pays you out a dividend, that is very different. That's passive income. But a dividend that I am paying myself from one mic corps to the other is not passive income. and the other thing is if you eventually sell shares of an active business, so let's say you own multiple clinics, and then you sell your shares in one clinic and you're using the lifetime capital gains exemption, and then the rest of it is just a capital gain. Not gonna be passive income, it's gonna be taxed as capital gains because you're selling your shares of an active business. So those are just the flip numbers of what Tyson talked about. But again, as a reminder, if you are unsure, it's probably safer to assume it's gonna be passive income and talk to your planner and your accountant about what is the strategy around this. So let's talk about that strategies around passive income. So for those of you know the audience that is like, crap, this actually might be true. I might be in the passive income problem. without realizing because I'm just used to paying the general rate. so I never actually took, you know, look at the fine tooth comb. Let's actually walk backwards. So instead of fixing the problem first, how can they identify the problem? Like if they're not even sure they have passive income, where can they go to start to look and and investigate? Because there's a lot of DIYers out there. So where do they look? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, I mean for the DIYer, it's it's it's even a little more, I don't want to say dangerous, but it's definitely an area you want to flag and look at. you you want somebody to be having eyeballs on your plan, even as a DIYer, every every year or two or three. you don't want to get too far down the road. It's like navigating somewhere where you've never gone before. If you're two, three, four degrees off of target. three years down the road, that gap looks really big. But if you're checking it one year in or a year and a half in, you're not that far off target. It's easier to course correct. If you are working with professionals, talk to your investment team, talk to your accountant, have them talk to each other to figure out the number of like where are we? What's the tally that we're looking at? Maybe it's not a concern, but maybe it's something to bring up. Something that I caution DIYers about. Especially is trading inside your corporation, day trading. I mean, like red flags go up, not just for me, for CRA too, in that you're you're buying and selling, and you're making hopefully you're making capital gains or or spreads every time in the positive. that's good, and you want to be winning in that sense. But sometimes it's like a matter of where do you want to be doing that? Do you want to be doing that in your RSPs, in your tax-free savings accounts, in your corporation? What's the tax treatment? And really selecting the right tool for the right area that you're going to be doing that in. so I think just being aware of it, talking to your team, having your investment management team, your financial planner talk to your accountants or your bookkeeper and have a couple of eyeballs on the situation, which is why. You know, we really like this approach. And the industry's kind of moving this way is creating more of a family office structure for high income earners and individuals such as doctors, physicians, ODs. bring your team of professionals together and you want to have somebody be your general contractor who knows all of the people that are working on your net worth house that you're building and and what the plan is. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, really well said. And I think that is a good reminder of you know, just tracking your stuff. And I think when we look at you know, how can you find out if you have passive income? you know, let's just say you're listening to this and you're okay, I'm gonna check my stuff when I go home, you know, just pulling your statements and just seeing where this money is coming from. So if you go into your corporate accounts, let's just say you only have an operating company or like a professional corporation. That is your account. That's where your investments are held. for simplicity's sake, everything this one account, this one corporation. Just look at your statements and print your statements for the entire year and just see where this income is coming from. And you'll be able to see are are some of them being dividended out from your investment portfolio? Are there capital gains that was rebalanced that whether it was an index that that rebalanced because you know SpaceX came into play and then they sold and rebalanced. Is it a private wealth firm did that for you and they they rebalanced to to realize some gains. knowing where the money is is very, very important. And that can help you start to look at, you know, how much is coming out of it. Maybe I'll just share my screen real quick. Cause you know, our financial planning clients, we use automations to track a lot of their income. So Tesla, you can see the screen now, right? Tyson Nagasaka: Again, yep. Vishal Gill, CFP: Okay, perfect. it's always a a sketchy thing, right? You start sharing your screen, like, wait, what screen am I looking at? Especially I like a bunch of different monitors. So I'm like, wait, what Where am I at here? But you know, for example, this is a dashboard that would show you, you know, where your income is coming from. So for this client, it's $516,000 of income, $185,000 expenses, which the vast majority of that is a shareholder loan. So you can see right here, they're just pulling money to the personal side to spend on different things. and that'll be added as like a T4 income, for example. And the corporation has earned $455,000 so far. But if you look here, $57,000 has come from. Passive income from the corporate portfolio. And this is what our team does. Like when you get onboarded, this pulls Tyson Nagasaka: Sort of two other when you Vishal Gill, CFP: like all your transactions for the last few years. And then our team will go through and recategorize stuff. And you can start to see passive income. And it in this example, this platform updates annually, monthly, daily. So depending when you look at it, if you are someone that looks at it quarterly, or if you're you're really on top of your finances, you want to check it monthly, you can start to see, you know, if you're doing monthly, quarterly, yearly, you can see different numbers. and you can start to see, okay. Where is my passive income going? And for example, it is September 8th and they're at $57,000. They know that they're gonna be over the $50K. So how can we mitigate this risk? So you could either do this the old-fashioned way, which is just printing your statements and looking at each statement and you could old-fashioned highlighter and just kind of go through there and start to see, you know, the income that you're unsure of. Like if you're very familiar with a certain merchant that you see. On the monthly basis, and you know, okay, this is active income. I'm getting it again. I the example of MSP. So I'm getting it from MSP. So you can disregard that one. But if there's anomalies that you're not really sure who this person is, just highlight it, keep track of it, and then you can go through and start to look on an annual basis, how much random income is there, and then deep dive and start to find out where that income is being derived from, and you start to see are you running into passive income problems or not. and then if you're using automations, again, this is the platform that our clients use, but you can see. Passive income. So once there's a new tender, we can add it a rule so that every single time you get income from that merchant, it'll pop up automatically and add it to this pool. So it's very easy tracking on an annual basis, monthly basis, and quarterly basis to stay ahead of it. So for example, now let's talk about the fixes. So let's just say, for example, Tyson is the DIYer and they look at it and they're like, okay, I $57,000 here of passive income. I have a several months until my year and let's assume my year end is in December. You know, what can I do to resolve this issue before I start preventing it down the road? But what can I do to resolve this? I'm a fifty seven K, it's probably gonna get worse. What are my options? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, I mean you could you could increase expenses, business expenses, so that you are offsetting that. And I'm not don't mean like waste money. You could increase your salary. Instead of taking dividends for the year, you could increase your salary for the year. And that way it's a business deduction for the corporation. You're gonna pay tax on the personal side for personal income that you earn. And it's gonna kind of tip the scales a little bit. not to say that that's a fix for everything, but in in situations where we find We have anomalies, we're out of balance. Maybe we sold an asset that the corpus held forever. and it's gonna happen. So you we have to we have to have some fixes. So that's one way where you can kind of look at doing some gymnastics within the corporate finance in order to balance the scales without being hit or taking a huge bite out of your small business deduction. Vishal Gill, CFP: And if I can just jump in real quick here to show what that would look like. So let's say, for example, this is the client again, $57,000 of passive income. What Tyson's saying is they have already drawn $181,000 of shareholder loans. So when it comes time to declare these shareholder loans, and we talked about this in a previous episode, if you are the type of client who just draws money, transfers from my corp savings account to my personal checkings account and spends it, you know, you're drawing a shareholder loan. Every 12 months. It's just normal. That's kind of what happens. So so far, this person has drawn a hundred and eighty-one thousand dollars of shareholder loans. When it comes personal tax time and sorry, corporate tax time, they're gonna be in December. their account is gonna ask them, okay, we have this many draws equaling $181,000 from the corp. How do we want to declare it? What Tyson is saying is let's just say freeze in time. This is your corporate year end. You're at $57,000 of passive income. A very easy solution here, quick and dirty, would be all right, I want to be under the $57,000. So I want be under $50,000. So I'll take $7,000 or $8,000. And of the $181, I'll let's just say $10,000 I'm going to put as salary or T4 income. So that's going to create a deduction for the corporation. And then you can kind of bounce the scale that way. So it's not like you're getting additional money. I'm going to pull more money from my corp. It's the money that you've drawn. How are you going to declare it? And that's what Tyson is saying is going to be a quick fix. You got 57k. Let's get some corporate deductions. You've already drawn 181,000. Let's declare some of that $181,000 as T4 if that wasn't already the plan. And that's gonna keep us under the passive income problem. Sorry, I just wanted to share the screen there. But sorry, back to you. other other solutions. Tyson Nagasaka: some years, if you're slightly out of balance and like I said, you sold an asset or you had a portfolio, s some of our clients they have private assets, and so they don't they don't trade regularly. It might be a locked-in item for 10 years, and then all of a sudden your private real estate fund sells and you have a liquidity event. Sometimes There's not a lot that you can do in terms of maneuverability and you gotta pay some tax. so I know that's not a solution, but it's talking about what happens to you now and in the next couple of years. So sh should that happen, and you don't have the shareholder loan balance, or you don't have cash in your corporation to pay yourself salary to reduce to reduce that amount, you pay the tax hit in that year, you pay the capital gains tax on that, and it could. take away your small business deduction limit. But that's not to say your small business deduction limit is gone forever. It comes back after a few tax cycles and you get to kind of go back to equal an equilibrium, even if you're out of bounds for a year, or maybe it's spread over two tax years. once that liquidity or that sell off of those assets is done, and that's no longer a play that's in your incorporation in your portfolio. you kinda go back to business as usual. So it's not like it's all done and your your corp and your tax situation's blown up forever. Sometimes you have success and you do have to pay a tax bill. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, and you know, in ideal worlds, like you could hug it around two physical year ends, like that'd be great. we had examples of this years ago when it was more of a seller's market. Now it's you don't really have that much leverage as a seller, but we had a couple examples of people that were selling their commercial properties or selling to some of our clients. And the requests were okay, let's just say you know, September right now, my year end is December. you could ask. Hey, it's under contract, pay the deposit, but our closing is gonna be, you know, a little bit later on. So it's closer to that year end so that you get some maneuverability where instead of taking one large capital gains in one year, you can break it up and split it over two years and and you can work with your accountant, the lawyer, the the the realtor that gets it takes a whole like Tyson's reference earlier about a family office kind of style. It's it's that kind of thing to make sure there's a coordinated effort that everyone's on the same page. so that's one option as well, is if you Dyson's point, if you have, let's say, a property that just got rezoned, you owned a commercial property, now it's switched to multifamily, or you had ALR land and it's moved out of ALR land, which be rare but unreal. then yeah, like it makes sense to sell it or do something with it. and you're gonna pay that tax. But if you can plan around it and break it over two corporate year ends, that's fantastic. Sometimes you get like a sweetheart deal where it's like it's too good to say no, and you're Whatever. I'm gonna take this offer before it goes away. And because it just makes sense for somebody else, then I'll figure it out. At the end of the day, if you're making money, it's good. And and you know, we can find a way to to plan around it as best as possible. But if you can make a good ROI, take the good ROI and move on. So that's a good example. the other thing that we talked about is you know, portfolios inside the corporation are yielding returns. So they're giving money on an annual basis. it's not a solution for now. So if you are In an accidental situation where you didn't realize you're in a a higher problem than then you then you didn't realize like let's say fifty seven thousand dollars, let's say even worse. $90,000 of passive income you didn't notice because you're usually in the general rate regardless. what Tyson talked about is gonna help you in that immediate thing, which is switching to salary, trying to get some deductions. you know, but going forward, how do you prevent that from happening? a very good solution is if you don't need All that money on an annual basis that's coming out too. So if you're not in a deaccumulation phase and you're more in the accumulation phase, like you're in your late 30s, early 40s, earning much more than you need to and you're investing it, switching to more of a growth portfolio as opposed to a yield portfolio is really what you want to do. And then you can control when you're selling your positions, but you're not having annual dividends being kicked out. So we've had clients that are in SEG funds and those are being kicked out. Annually. We've had clients that are in GICs. We've had clients that are in portfolios that are rebalancing often that didn't even realize until we start looking at their statements and they're getting T-slips that they didn't even notice because they just get it in that we at it, they just send it to their accountants. so if that is you and you don't need the income, then switching your portfolio and rebuilding it to a growth portfolio is is great. and it's good to do that if you're already in the tax problem because For the most part, you're gonna have sell your positions to buy other investments. So just switch from a yield portfolio to a growth portfolio, you might have to sell stuff and realize some capital gains. So if you're already in the passive income problem, we won't go too much into RDTOH, but it it may be worthwhile just to, you know, take a big butt of that apple, take your medicine, and then you can start to benefit it from the year after because you have a RDTOH, we'll get into a different episode, but you can start to get back some of the the pain points that you had before. But being more growth focused is you know definitely a good thing for you to do to prevent that from happening on an annual basis. Keeping in mind you're gonna compound that problem till later on because you're gonna have a really big portfolio, ideally later on. which we can switch. Sorry, go ahead. Yeah. Tyson Nagasaka: Yep. I was if I could just add something there. when I was I was a mutual fund licensed advisor for sixteen years, and we used to see this and get questions on this stuff at year end all the time. Like Fashul was saying with SEG funds and with some other types of ETFs and mutual funds, is when there's success inside the fund, even if you don't sell, sometimes you're gonna get a T three or a T five at the end of the year because the fund has dispersed some of the the growth. Sometimes it's return of capital, but a lot of times it's just capital dispersion, whether that's capital gains that's being issued or something else. and it's success from inside the fund that you have no control over and you're gonna get issued a T slip. And sometimes you don't know what's happening. So the solution used to be to that corporate class mutual funds. But s around 2016, 2017, corporate class really started to leave the marketplace. the power group of companies, so Freedom 55 Investors Group, all the other ones that are kind of under that umbrella, McKenzie Investments, they took corporate class out because th it wasn't being run efficiently for the tax problem it was trying to solve. All of the banks have basically gone away from corporate class funds. So there's only a few companies left that do corporate class ETFs or mutual funds the way that they used to. And they used to do that. So you as the incorporated business owner don't have these surprise T5 and T T three slips at the end of the year. but it's not as good of a solution as it used to be where everybody had it and it worked. you have to be very selective about it. So that would be like one type of thing. And again, not to harp on DIY investors, but s just be very good at your research about picking a solution because you want to know. how it's gonna pay you your success, what type of T slips it's gonna issue you, when it might do that. and if you don't want to be dealing with all of that, that's when you involve professional money management. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. Really well said. and before we switch over to the philosophy side of things as promised, we want to talk about the philosophy and our thoughts on, you know, where you should invest and and what that looks like. two quick things we want to touch on is the potential solutions, like the the knee-jerk solutions that people have. And you know, we referenced earlier we talked to people, they didn't realize a small passive income problem. Now they do, and they're okay, well I'll other I'll just open up holding company, I'll invest inside a holding company or RDTOH, which we shortly reference and and people like okay, well I'll have just RDTOH and it'll fix the problem. I'll talk about RDTOH, I'll pass it to you for the corporate, the hold co, Tyson. But RDTOH, it doesn't, you know, get you it gets you your money back eventually, but it doesn't solve it does nothing for the small business limit you already lost. So RDTOH is a way for you to take your medicine and get it back over the next several years. So the The more you kind of pay yourself, you'll get back some of the money, kind of similar to the CDA account in a way, if you're familiar with that. but it helps you get your money back eventually. It does nothing to solve the immediate problem or the upcoming problem. It's just a way to make the medicine hurt a bit less that you'll eventually get some back, you know, the more you pay yourself. And there's a few different things that work like that. CDA is one, RDTOH is one, you know, grip balance, for example, and then there's another one I'm thinking of, the AMT. so AMT, if you have like a large share sale that you do, and the series like, well, you have an AMT tax now, it sucks, but you can eventually get it back the more you pay yourself, you'll get a credit back over several years. So those are all things that will help you get your money back eventually and and recover some, but it does nothing to solve the actual small business tax problem that you have too much passive income, too yield happening on an annual basis, and you definitely don't want to have that every single year because you're like, okay, well, whatever, it's already TOH. And we hear that sometimes because accountants will tell them, like, yeah, it sucks, but we can do R D TO H. So the client walks away from that and be Okay, it's fine, R D TOH solves the problem. It doesn't solve the problem, it's just a way for you to partially recover from the problem. But we want to solve the actual underlying condition, which is how your portfolio is built and and what your philosophy is. So RDTOH helps, but it's not an answer. Holding company, I'll pass off to you, Tyson. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, a lot of people think, well, if I have an portfolio inside my operating company, I'll just move it to another company and it'll solve my problem. we still come across a lot of people that have this idea, and I don't know exactly where it comes from. I think it is influenced by social media, and we get a lot of American financial social media here, and that stuff doesn't apply. so CRA says if you have an operating company. And you're the main shareholder, you are a shareholder of it, and you're also a shareholder of the holding company, those two companies are related. You don't get two small business deduction limits, you get one across all of your related companies or companies that you are a shareholder of. so moving your portfolio to your hold co is a good idea. Sometimes you do it for liabilities, sometimes you do it for segregation, but it doesn't. insulate you from the small business deduction grind that passive income can produce. So you still have to be aware of it. It's not a set it and forget it or put your head in the sand type of scenario. where just because it's in your hold go and it's it is a separate company, CRA deems them to be related. And I've only ever seen a few structures that involve trusts and other things where the accountant and even a tax lawyer felt that there was some degree of separation. so from the majority of people that we see, it's operating company and holding company. It's a good idea to have your portfolio in a holding company. It doesn't erase the fact that if you're too successful there, you could impact your small business deduction in your operating company. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. okay, so being aware of time, let's switch gears and talk about the philosophy of investing. So you know, that's a big overarching topic, but you know, should people just invest inside the corporations strictly and you know, avoid everything else? and then eventually they'll just defer, defer, defer until there'll be a big tax bill due later on, or should there be some money held over here, here? Like what you know, it's not a a one answer for everybody, but know maybe let's chat about the philosophies of investing and and maybe like we can start with registered accounts that's on on the personal side so as a reminder a registered account for the audience is the accounts that you hold personally TFSAs RSPs RESPs these kind of investments that the investment manager or the share that you own they don't really care how you're investing the money it's really only the CRA that cares if it's in a registered account or not because you're taxed differently so registered would be TFSA RSP RESPs Non-registered would be just like a savings account, a margin account, or investments inside your corporation because they're non-registered. They're not registered with the CRA for any kind of tax advantages. It's just investment accounts. So let's start there. What philosophy, should people invest in the registered or non-registered? Is there a point that it makes more sense for one over the other? Tyson Nagasaka: generally speaking, people want to fill their registered accounts first before they start investing in non registered accounts. tax-free savings is one of the four tax free things that we get in Canada. So you should be investing there for growth as soon as you can and leave that money to grow on compound, don't interrupt it. RRSPs. For most people, RRSPs make a whole heck of a lot of sense. It is not tax-free, but it is tax deferred. So if you're saving over your whole working lifetime and you accumulate $2 million when you go to retire, you can draw that down. And even before you go to retire, you can do some RSP meltdown strategies if you think you need a strategy with less registered money at retirement, right? But that's after you've already built up the money. RESPs for kids, great idea. Put money in there, get free money from the government, grow. It's for their education. What if they never go to school? an RESP can live for I think it's 35 years before you have to take the money out. And if the parent is the subscriber or the controller of the account, the kids never go to school, you can roll that RESP money into your RRSP. so it can go towards your retirement. You don't have to pull it out and then pay tax on it. You can actually just pay back all of the grant money, roll over the principal that you've contributed. Into the RRSP of the subscribers. So registered accounts make a ton of sense. Once those are full, if you still have money on the personal side that you want to invest, non-registered makes a whole heck of a lot of sense. the items that you can have in your non-registered account, you can be taxed for interest, dividends, capital gains, and you can also claim capital losses, which is really interesting. So if you have a portfolio with some speculative pieces in there that you might lose, if it's in your RRSPs and you lose money, you can't claim a capital loss. But if it's in a non-registered and you have a loss, you can claim that and it can go against future growth, future capital gains. so those are just some of the features, some of the benefits of the personal side. I believe you should be utilizing them to the maximum benefit. They're free to use. and there's tax advantages there for you. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, and I I would go step further and say everyone should always hundred percent be investing in your TFSA. Like for everyone listening to this podcast, you don't have a cash flow problem, you don't have an income problem. so you should be massing out your TFSA every single year. depending on what stage in your career, that that can be different. Like if you're an early career doctor and you have a lot of student debt, you don't then you don't need to be super aggressive and try and max out ASAP. Like, yes, it's compounding growth, that's tax-free, and there's a A place for that. However, if you have a risk-free rate of return of, you know, student loans that are just massive, you know, maybe that makes more sense. And that's a personalized plan of like how much you want to get out of debt and what that timeline looks like. But everybody should be massing out their TFSAs. Eventually, when you can, it makes sense for you to get a max out and then stay on top of massing it out. 100% you should be doing that. to Tyson point that could be growth focused, but you don't want to be doing speculative investments. Like you don't want be doing penny stocks that you hear about or these like, you know. Crazy, hey, this is gonna blow up and go like 50x, but it could go down to zero. And you don't want to be doing that inside your TFSA because number one, you lose that contribution room. and then number two, you can't offset gains. so just TFSA for everybody, yes, 100% you should invest into it. RRSP is where a lot of the conversation goes back and forth about the philosophy of investing. The one thing that we always say is all of you. on this on this episode and and listening to this episode are going to need the money on the personal side eventually, either you or your family. And that can be either done on an annual basis. So when you're doing your taxes and and Tyson shared that example earlier of, you know, you could just declare the shareholder loan as more of a salary and then you could open up RSP room and then put that money there instead of just losing it to the taxes inside the corporation because you just have too much passive income. And you can start to build up that pool on the personal side. and the good thing with the RSP registered is you can bypass probate, you can name a beneficiary to it. It's not going to solve the tax problem of the RSP, but you know, at least you can name a beneficiary for your account and and TFSAs, same thing. TFSAs are really good for that because that can give money directly to your beneficiaries to solve some of the tax problems and and pay for funerals and all that kind of fun stuff. Not so fun stuff, I mean. however, do you want all your money in RSPs or all your money inside the corporation? And the answer is really neither. Tyson, you talked about meltdowns. And I think that's actually a good reminder. We should probably do an episode on RSP meltdowns because not a lot of people really know what that is. But from a philosophical standpoint, an RSP meltdown is let's say you were putting money to your RSP over several years of your career, and you were also investing money inside your corporation because you've earned more than you needed, and you start to map out your retirement. Let's say you're six, seven years out of your retirement, you start to map it out. If you're gonna have too much minimum income, so your RSP is gonna switch to a RIF, you're gonna have ODA security, you're gonna have CPP, you've already paid off your mortgage. so if we follow the plan naturally as the switches over, you're gonna be in a clawback scenario. So you're gonna be over the income that's allowed for old day security. So you're gonna start to lose some of your OAS, and then your marginal tax rate or your NTR is gonna be perhaps higher than it was in your work working years. That really doesn't really make much sense. So we can start to withdraw money from your RSPs leading up to your retirement to make that number make sense. and a lot of people end up hitting a sweet spot where you're pulling less annually, but you're actually netting the same or more annually because you know there's a lot of credits that you get in in retirement. You can do income splitting from your corporation for you and your spouse. There's a lot of doors that open up, but it's really a lot of reverse engineering from that. And that's what an RSP meltdown is. But when it comes to RSPs, There's usually always a sweet spot of what number makes the most sense. And most of our clients always have a hard stop with their RSPs. So, yes, we want to do it annually, but once we get to this number, we want to stop the RSPs and instead invest everything inside your corporation because you can income split from your corporation, because you can invest in a number of different things inside your corporation. And it's also working capital. Let's say an opportunity pops up. You can use that to buy into it. You can leverage against it. You there's so many other things that you can do with a capital side the corporation. But the RSP is really good because you also don't want to run into the problem. And perhaps you guys have heard this before, you've seen it with a colleague of yours or someone, you know, through conversations, is they did just the deferral strategy. So no RSPs, no TFSAs, just investing only in the corp. And none of us know when we're going to pass away. But what can happen is you can have a real bad tax situation because if you're doing that strategy, with no annual extraction method, you're gonna pass away, have to realize all those gains, pay all of it out as a dividend onto the personal side and pay a massive double tax bill. or you have to s try and spend a lot of money for a quick pipeline strategy or or something just very, very quick. But if you weren't doing annual planning, I'm assuming you probably didn't put the the the plan in place for a pipeline strategy either. so your family is just going to be absolutely hemorrhaging money on your tax bill. And that's not ideally where you want to be. So our philosophy is TFSA 100%, you should max out. you should prepare for retirement so that you know what your actual need is going to be and where you're gonna get that money from. And that can kind of point you to what your hard stop number is for RSPs. and then you can invest the rest inside your corporation or pay off your primary residence mortgage. So you do more frequent payments. So, you know, instead of monthly, you do bi weekly, you could do annual. deposit directly up to the principal or leave it as this if you're planning to downsize anyways, like there then that's a lot of different options you can do. but that's kind of the philosophy for investments. and I know there's a trade-off number with CPP that sometimes people talk about if you want to tackle that one Tyson. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, well when we've seen accounting teams that their whole practice is set up, all of their clients are advised to do dividend only, don't pay CPP, don't contribute to that, invest inside your corporation, defer, defer, defer. But then they don't tell their client to go and get help to make sure that $8,000 that you're not spending as the employer and the employee towards CPP. Yeah, they have to be directed to invest that. So just because you're not going to pay it to the CPP investment board, you are now responsible for investing that and building, in a sense, your own pension. So you want to make sure you're doing something with that capital to grow it. In spite of all of this passive income stuff that we've just said today, you do want to make sure that your portfolio is growing and you have a solution that you're building for yourself so that that money is available and you have liquidity so you can access that. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, and this actually came up in our last webinar we were doing for an association for optometrists. So we're chatting about it, and one of the questions that came in during the QA portion was about the longevity numbers. So one of the best things about CPP and OAS is it's indexed to inflation. So the reality is as a high income earner, you have more capital to buy better groceries, better food, more time off, better vacation. So more times than not, you are index to a longer life expectancy. unless you have some kind of adverse family history. But for the vast majority, you'll most likely live longer than than you know a regular lower middle class person just because you have more available to to do. So because of that, you know, one of the best benefits of these government benefits is if cost of living goes up and we saw that during COVID, like the cost of living exponentially went up. And you don't really want to run into that during your fixed income years. And you know, growing up I remember one of my first jobs serious jobs was at Best Buy. And there was only people that came in with like, I'm on a fixed income. So I'm looking for this laptop and they have a tight budget. And and that's the first time I ever heard of fixed income. But as you get older you realize like, yeah, like that would be tough if you used to have, I don't know, five thousand dollars a a month of spending money, but all of a sudden now that's three thousand dollars a month. Like you have to make some trade-offs and some changes. so one thing that can hedge that risk is government benefits. CBP and OAS are indexed to inflation. So as the cost of living goes up. your benefits also go up for the same percentage, which is great. And that's a great hedge. So that's not all of your retirement income, but at least a portion of your retirement income can be indexed to inflation without any investor risk yourself. If you make a wrong decision or you make a timing issue, you sell something wrong, you bleed money on passive income and now you know the money that otherwise would have been retained and invested is now going to the CRA because you built your portfolio incorrectly or you sold incorrectly, all those risks are gone. Money that you're already pulling on the shareholder dividend, you're declaring some of that, putting some money into RSPs, but you're really showing you know CPP and paying into that, that's a great hedge for that. but that number people ask about, and this is what the question came up is how old do I need to be to win with the CPP decision versus I made the wrong decision because I passed away too early. And it's it's worth a strange question when that comes in because obviously none of us ever know when any of us are gonna pass away. And if that does happen, you're not gonna be on your deathbed and be like, thank God I opted out of CPP because I passed away at 76 instead of 77. and the the theory of it is if you opt out of CPP, you have more money inside your corporation and your beneficiaries get to keep that excess after tax. Whereas if you're putting money into a CPP and you pass away, There's sometimes survivor benefits, but your kids, your next generation, you know, for the most part, there's not going to be survivor benefits when you pass away and stuff like that. so that money goes back to the pool and then someone else benefits from it instead of your family. That's the theory of it. And the number is gonna be dependent for everybody. If you have less than ideal health, it's gonna be a little bit shorter, but I think somewhere around like 76, 77, somewhere around there. If you live longer than that, then CPP made more sense for you. But if you live shorter than that, then you should have just opted out and done non-registered. I would say don't even worry about trying to entertain that because none of us ever know. and for the most part, if you are a high-income earner, you're mostly gonna be pointing towards longer life expectancy, which also means that you should plan for more aggressive life expectancy. Like, you know, for our clients, we push more than FP Canada guidelines for life expectancy because you're gonna have more resources available to you. So you should just kind of build your plan, assuming that you're gonna live longer than expected. And God forbid if that doesn't happen, whatever. It doesn't really matter that you're like Well, I guess somebody left over to C V P instead of leaving all the non registered it, whatever. I wouldn't worry or educated that part too much. But some of you may see that in like your forums or your Doctors of Canada, you know, Facebook group posts and things like that. I would say philosophy wise, don't even worry about that. But I don't know what your thoughts are on it, Tyson. Tyson Nagasaka: Probably one of the most popular retirement questions that we get is when should I take CPP? What am I gonna get? What's the benefit? And everyone's trying to map, everyone thinks that they're gaming the system, but actuaries have already laid everything out. So the reality of the situation is we gotta just find out what's best for you. When do you need the cash? some people have tons of tons of investment allocations and wealth. They don't really like there's no reason for them to take CPP at 60 if you've been paying into CPP. so in those cases, a lot of times you have means, you have buckets, you have your tax-free savings, your RSPs, you have a corporate portfolio that's full, and you have lots of capital gains built up in there. it might make a lot of sense to defer till age 70. You'll get a bump in it, you get about 40% more. And then we can draw down some of your taxable positions to to reposition yourself. So that's good. The flip side of the scenario is I've got a few clients they are single. They're getting really close to retirement age. Should I defer to age 70? And I look at them and I look at their their good income, but a lot of the times it makes sense for them to just take the money now. Because if you defer or leave it and something happens to you, nobody gets the money. So you might as well take the money fill your tax free savings account up, give it to your grandkids, whatever you're gonna do, access that capital. It's just you. There's no survivor. we're not building towards anything. So I mean it there's a lot of factors that come into it aside from just the math. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yep, 100%. we are over our time. We always try and keep these around like 40 ish minutes. We're we're about 10 minutes over. So apologies for going over it, but I think it's an important conversation to have. And if you loved it, then whatever. There's an extra 10 minutes, bonus 10 minutes for you. So we miss an episode, we give you an extra 10 minutes on this episode. So let's just call it a wash. and I think it's just one of those things that you know, as far as homework or checklist for you to to do when you finish this episode is definitely look at your passive income. So either if you use a automated system that you can start to see where that income is being you know coming from inside your corporation. Do that or just print out your statements for the year. Good exercise to do anyways as you get close to your physical year end to just look at where that money's coming from. Don't just see the tax bill, especially if you're used to being in the general tax rate regardless. Don't eat, don't just look at the tax public, whatever, it's all good. I'm in the general rate and just sign off on it. Ask those questions like, you know, where's this income coming from? What's his other income I don't recognize? These these merchants or these tenders. So ask that question to find out What the underlying problem is. And if you do it earlier in your physical year, and if you do it before RSP deadline, you can start to declare some of those shareholder loans that you already drew. You can start to declare those as T4 to get a deduction inside your corporation, put that money into your RSP for yourself as opposed to just sending it off to the CRA. and then you can start to get a grasp and handle of your current problem and then start to solve that problem going forward, which is rebuilding your portfolio and be more growth focused as opposed to. annual yield if you don't even need that money anyways. some other gems in there as well some things that we talked about about you know the timing of CPP if you should do CPP if you should opt out of it if you should do RSPs and TFSAs versus just deferring and leaving everything to some corporation. Lots and lots of stuff to talk about and the answer is always it depends. It depends on what your goals are depends on what your numbers are depends what your partial tax rate is. There's a lot of figures that go into building a good plan so that everything is smooth and making sense. And if you want to know what your plan is, of course, you can always reach out to us, you know, click our booking links and book with whatever planner you want to book with and meet with. We're nationwide, we're virtual, so we make it as non-invasive as possible to get your plan started. and then we also have a link to our Facebook group in here as well that's closed and that's for doctors across Canada. So you can ask your questions, get your questions into the podcast that we'll start to answer. and then also we'll take questions from our association workshops that we do and put them in there. So if you want to keep on learning, that's the spot to go. And besides that, we will see you guys on the next episode of Portfolio Talks and we will have a guest either in the next episode or the one after that, talking about equipment purchases and for your clinic and and what that looks like. So definitely something to look forward to. and until then, have a good day.