Latest / Pedagogically Speaking / 7 Classroom Management Strategies That Work
Transcript
- Ilana: What if the problem with classroom management is that we're spending too much time telling students what not to do and not enough time teaching students what to do instead? Because we aren't just about rules and consequences. It's about creating an environment where students know how to participate, learn, and work together. My name is Alana Huffer, I've been teaching for sixteen years and I'm an inclusive education teacher now. Let's get into the strategies to keep your classroom calm so that you're not going home with a headache every day. Classroom management isn't a two page document. You can have beautifully worded rules and still spend your entire day putting out fires. Stop talking. Put that away. Keep your hands to yourself. We're not doing that right now. If that sounds familiar, you know how exhausting it can be to constantly redirect behavior. The issue isn't necessarily that students don't know the rules. Sometimes students They don't know what the expected behavior actually looks like in that particular situation. And when we only tell students what not to do, we leave a lot of room for guessing. And that's where routines come in. Not just routines for lining up, but routines that help students understand. How to learn and how to be together in a classroom. Okay. So there's three kinds of routines. And I think when people talk about routines, teachers are focusing on like the practical things. Where to put your backpack, how to get a pencil, what to do when you need the bathroom, or how to line up. Those are absolutely important. And I think of them as housekeeping routines, right? They help the day run smoothly. But it's just one piece of the picture. We also need social routines, you know, how we interact with each other, how we respond when someone's speaking, how we handle disagreement, and what do we do when our classmates are struggling to stay focused? You know, we also have instructional routines, you know, how do we participate in discussion? What does partner, work look like and sound like and How do we move through a scientific investigation? Or what do we do when we're working independently and we get stuck? And those routines are more than just keeping students, you know, quiet or orderly. They help students understand how to participate in the learning itself, which is really important because we're at school to learn. And one thing I definitely struggled with was getting students to have productive partner conversations, you know, w when you kind of are like, okay, let's talk to like our elbow partner or let's turn to your partner and show your thinking. And suddenly the room would get really loud and you know, the same students were doing all of the talking, the same students weren't saying much. And you know, sometimes then the students are also off topic. And I realized I was asking the students to do something That I'd actually never taught them what to how to do it, like what to do in that situation. And of course I was reaching for the advil. So I started to break it down. You know, I showed them what it looked like to turn to someone and talk. We discussed like the volume and like how you don't need to yell when someone's right next to you and how what does it mean to take turns? what does it mean to actually listen to each other? And I started using my working clock for this as well. And we practiced with simple fun questions before moving on to like conversations about our learning. And I did have a few sentences that I put up on the board f to help them get started. Because this is a learning. We're learning how to do these things, right? And yes, it absolutely took time. and I had to remind them and we were practicing it over and over again, which was great. We got a lot of, you know, class discussions happening and a lot of partner talk and a lot of group talk. It was actually quite a rich environment for learning with each other and from each other, which was great. and eventually it did become part of how we worked together and we didn't need to practice it and the students understood what to do. I brought it up after every term break, of course, but I also noticed that more students were actually participating. The conversations were more focused, and we could get into our learning much more quickly. And I do still put up those conversation starters. I have a couple of things to kind of get things going, and it works really well. I think the biggest thing that I learned was that I couldn't just tell students to work with a partner and expect them to know how to do it. Right? That looks different in every single classroom. How to work with a partner in P is gonna look different with how to work with a partner in a science lab and it's gonna look different with how to work with a partner for a group project, you know? And I had to teach them w what it looked like in my classroom and give them the time to practice and be very patient while they figured it out. Once we had that routine in place, though, partner talk became something I could absolutely rely on. We do it multiple times a day, and it was great because I didn't have to manage it anymore. They could do it for themselves. My third strategy is turn don't into do. Have you ever been like in the hallway and a kid is booking it like maybe the r recess bell rang or they're they want to get to the library, whatever it is that they're doing, they are running down the library and you hear, don't do that. And it doesn't work, right? Because you're not telling the student what to actually do. I'm always like, we use our walking feet, slow feet, elephant feet, which sometimes backfires because then they start stomping, but at least they're not running anymore. And so I just really think we need to stop telling students what to stop doing and tell them what to do instead, right? Instead of don't play with the scissors, you know, scissors are for cutting. when you're finished, put them away. It gives the students, it tells the students the behavior that you actually want them to do. you know. instead of like don't make a mess, we'll think like, well, what does done look like? You know, what does done look like? Scraps go in the bin, materials go away, chairs are tucked in, tables ready for the next person, right? Like I just think that's so much more important than saying like what not to do, stop describing what you don't want and start giving students a clear picture of what success looks like. strategy number four. Redirection should point back to the expectation. You know, so once students know the expectation, use that instead of just narrating the problem back to them, right? So instead of stop calling out, you need to try what's the expectation when you need help? You know, rather than like repeating the rule yourself, you need to put the responsibility back onto the students, you know? That's where it belongs. So Imagine one of your students is working independently and then they immediately call across the room for help, right? Miss, I need help. So if you've taught a stuck routine, if you if the students already know what to do when they're stuck because you've taught it, you can simply ask, What do you do when you're stuck? Right? This student might need to reread the instructions or check an example or try a strategy or If you've got ready do done, they can check what the done looks like, you know. maybe there's a help signal that you've taught, right? So you just need to put it back onto them. And if you haven't established that routine, this could be a good time for you to maybe get that going so that you don't have all those kids calling out for you when it's done. And yes, I understand that it's still a redirection, but redirection isn't like teaching. It's just like the reminder after the teaching has happened, right? So you're just like reminding them that that exists already. And yeah, of course, sometimes a student really does need your help. You can use your professional judgment. Not every moment does need a clever question. but the goal is less telling and more prompting. And also if you if you do have students that do genuinely need help, I'm sure you've got a strategy in place for them, you know. maybe they are supposed to walk quietly to you or there's a signal, like a nonverbal signal, something like that, right? So just make sure you've got those things in place and you're not just reteaching the same Strategies over and over again, you're prompting them to remind for themselves, which is really great. It helps their brains grow, right? Okay, so strategy number five routines have to be taught, not just announced. So I think an uncomfortable truth is that telling students a routine really isn't the same as teaching it. You know, clean up before you leave, that's actually just an announcement. it's not a lesson. If you want students to independently clean up, transition, ask for help, work in groups, enter a classroom. you need to teach it what it looks like. And you need to first break that into multiple steps, right? And then model it and then practice it. Give the feedback, revisit it when needed, usually after a term break. I personally I love a quick visual. I do love having visuals around because I think it's great. They can see it. I tell them they could hear it. They have the physical thing of actually doing it. So I really like to try to hit as many of those things as possible. a visual, put the steps on the board, you know, a demonstration of what successful participation looks like can really make those like invisible things for students quite visible. you know, I do think we need to give students a lot of credit. They are navigating dozens of expectations across different classrooms. you know, like if they're with you for most of the day, they're still probably going somewhere for like PE or for music, you know, for something. and so there are just so many expectations and then the expectations around eating lunch is different, and then recess, like there's so much for students to be able to like understand and navigate and do and with different teachers and subjects and situations. And I think what can be obvious to us, because we do it all the time and we've been doing this for a long time. Is still kind of brand new for those students. And if you do find yourself saying the same thing like 47 times, consider that it might not be a reminder problem. It could be a teaching problem, which is great because you can absolutely teach those things, right? The goal isn't to create a classroom full of rules, it's to teach the routines that make the classroom run. Okay, so number six. Social expectations are really something that we build together, right? So social routines deserve particular attention because they shape how students experience the classroom. How do we listen to each other? What happens when we disagree? How do we respond when someone makes a mistake, right? How do we make room for different perspectives? And I think all of those are really really important in creating safe spaces for all students to take risks with their learning, which is what we want them to do. We want students to raise their hands whether they have the correct answer or they don't, right? Like All of that is information that we have, and we can only get that when we're building a safe community where students are allowed to make mistakes without feeling like their peers are going to laugh at them. And those are moments that need to be taught. You know, it's not just behavior management questions. It's a part of a learning community. And this is another great way where you can get your students' voice reflected in the room because you can invite students to describe what helps them feel. Feel heard, right? They can describe what helps them feel heard. what does productive collaboration look like? What makes it easier for people to participate in a discussion, especially those students who don't like to do that, right? And then work together as a room, as a community to turn those ideas into specific observable expectations, it doesn't mean that every expectation is up for a vote. You still need to have clear and firm boundaries. But, you know, allow students to have meaningful opportunities to contribute to how the classroom community actually works because they're a part of that community, right? I honestly thought that I had taught students how to ask for help. and I quickly realized that I hadn't because I had actually taught them how to interrupt me for help. And then I would call them my little armpit gremlins, you know. The routine was supposed to be try it yourself, check the directions, ask a partner, then ask me. in reality, I would barely stop giving the instructions before the hands went went up or the calling went up. I don't understand, I don't get it. What are we doing? Can you help me? And it was like an instant headache. I realized that, you know what, that's a me problem. I've I've missed the boat on something, right? And instead of getting frustrated, because it's not the students' fault that I haven't given them my expectations, right? I was like I went home and I was like, Okay, what am I struggling with? Because the students are struggling with what I haven't taught them. And I broke it and I wrote it all down and then I broke it down and then I turned it into steps and I turned it into a lesson. So we stopped and And practiced the routine before anybody needed help, right? I modeled what try first looked like. We talked about what it feels like. It can feel very frustrating. We talked about breathing through it or grabbing your squishy, whatever it is that helps you learn. We talked about what a good question sounds like. Do you know what I mean? Not like I need help. I don't understand. This part of the math equation or whatever it is, right? Be specific. They had to specifically tell me what the problem was. And it made a huge difference, right? Students started becoming more independent and they got there by the end of the term, which was great. And I stopped being like the help desk with a pulse. when students do understand the routine and and the reason behind the routine, like the purpose of the routine, and have a hand in shaping it. It can become more than just like a direction from the teacher. It becomes part of how the class works all together. All right, so number seven, consistency doesn't mean rigidity. Consistency matters, but it doesn't mean that every situation gets the exact same response, right? It means that students can understand the expectations. They know what the routine is, they've had opportunities to practice it. And they can rely on you to guide them back to it, right? With a prompt, or whatever it is. There will be days when things don't go as planned. Of course, we are all humans, students will forget, routines will need adjusting. and a strategy that's worked great with one class might not work with another, which is fine. That's information, and we do love information. You know, and the information can be like, what are students finding difficult? Is the expectation crystal clear? had they ha have they had enough practice? Does the routine actually work for the activity and the learners in front of you as a teacher? You know, classroom management is about paying attention, pivoting when necessary, responding thoughtfully, and continuing to teach. You know, think about the Part of your day that feels really challenging and ask yourself, what are students doing that makes that moment so difficult for me? You know, what do I actually want them to do instead? Have I clearly taught that expectation? Have students had a chance to practice it? And how can I remind them of that when they need support? You know, whatever you do notice in your classroom, start small. one routine, one intentional change, and then see what you learn. You know, classroom management is much more than rules or consequences or reacting to behavior. It's about teaching students how to participate in the life of a classroom, how to learn, how to work together, how to navigate routines that make all of that possible. I'd love to hear from you. What's one classroom routine you've had to rethink and what did you learn from that process? Share your thoughts in the comments. See you next time.