Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / #Channel Episode 2-Is Kickstarter Ruining Gaming
Transcript
- 0:00Wow, wow, wow wow. This is hashtag channel a podcast about discord
- 0:06with Ben and Steve. Well, actually, a hashtag means it's a channel.
- 0:15Here we are Steve. Yeah, the first episode of the brand new
- 0:19ceed Hunter show. That's right. I really think he should take over,
- 0:23just because Ceedee Hunter has done one fucking podcast on the five GF at each
- 0:27oel. It was a bravura performance, I use such a word with that's
- 0:31as maybe, But you're saying he should take over? Who's so if if
- 0:35Cede Hunter? Right, yep, he's he's coming in. Who's going out?
- 0:41It's just he's so charming. I mean, like from what he posts
- 0:44on the discard, I thought he was. I mean, he's a fucking
- 0:47jaffa. That's redundant actually because jaffa means just another fucking aucklander. But do
- 0:51you and yet and yet he was poised and articulate and generous, and I
- 0:55have a brief clip of him from the episode kind of right, won't play
- 0:58it. I'm gonna play it do to correction from people who are knowledgeable,
- 1:04Ben, would you say that you're always open to correction from people who are
- 1:08more knowledgeable? Absolutely, I'm completely always correct. Yeah, you have a
- 1:12you have a demonstrable history of that, right. Well, we're going to
- 1:15find out on today's episode of Hashtag Channel, aren't we. Yeah? So,
- 1:19because I don't think anyone, anyone in that absolute magisterial torrent of responses
- 1:25to your question, agrees with you. What do you mean, Well,
- 1:27I haven't put my the things I ever read them. Of course I have
- 1:32all of them. Yeah, of course, but you know I have nothing
- 1:34else to do. But you, you know, you weigh in and you
- 1:37put your points across. I wait until the fucking episode. Okay, So
- 1:40should I not be weighing in? I'm trying. You can do what you
- 1:42want. I'm trying to be a rainmaker. It's it's a free bloody world.
- 1:46You can do what you want. But all I'm saying is I hold
- 1:48my powder dry until the episode. You know you're not going to get Ulie
- 1:53Blenneman weighing into the conversation without me, like, you know, engaging a
- 1:57little bit, creating that spark that flegen. What is it with Julian You
- 2:00fucking love him? Do you just want to be him? No? Absolutely,
- 2:06I do not want to be on the grass right now with a magnifying
- 2:08glass making sure blade is the same height. All right? Anyway, So
- 2:14yeah, just as an introduction, this is hashtag channel. This is where
- 2:19we go to the five gf D Discord and we ask the listeners for their
- 2:24points on a monthly topic. And before we go into the topic, Steve,
- 2:29how do the listeners join the discord if they were going the way in
- 2:32and have their opinions aired live on the podcast like Ceedie Hunter does all the
- 2:38time, like Cedie Hunter does. So Ceedie Hunter has gone from like annoying
- 2:42troll on the internet to fully fledged five G for D cast member. You've
- 2:46launched. You have to invite him to the holiday party exactly. So do
- 2:50we agree that the holiday party will be held this year in Auckland, New
- 2:53Zealand. That's right, And I guess he's probably going to have to fly
- 2:55us there he is. Yeah, yeah, but I mean it's his turn.
- 2:59It's his turn. Yeah, we did it last year. Last year
- 3:01the holiday party was Steve's Ice in Berlin. Yeah. I paid for the
- 3:06trap. I offered to pay for but everyone had a month ticket so it
- 3:10wasn't necessary, wasn't exactly? Yeah, And I think the year before that
- 3:13was me. Yeah, I think it's Ceedie Hunter's turn. It is Ceddie
- 3:16Hunter. He keeps putting it off, which I think is like a bit
- 3:20it's a bit cheek. So yeah, I mean he's only paying for you
- 3:23me, miss Sam. I suppose. Yeah, because she's been on the
- 3:27show. Yeah, I think Teresa has coughed in the background. Yeah,
- 3:30Pee's been on the show. Yeah, who else? Janna Il though she's
- 3:35not here anymore. She she's been on the show fire and from London.
- 3:38From London. We might have to charter a private chet for this, I
- 3:40think. Yeah, just get a logo on the side. Yeah, he's
- 3:46willing to pay for the logo to be amazing. I mean he's bussy.
- 3:49I mean you know he said he's willing to be corrected. Well correct,
- 3:53you're fucking the correct thing to do. Refusal to pay for the five D
- 3:57Christmas passing. Now you're a fully paid up member. Yeah, well look,
- 4:00you don't just appear on the show and then shrut your responsibilities to the
- 4:02organization. Absolutely so. So how many Christmas parties have you five years of
- 4:06five D to day? How many Christmas parties have you arranged? How many?
- 4:11At least one, at least one? I mean I've done at least
- 4:14four Yeah, Cede Hunter none none, zero? What the fuck? Why
- 4:18do you even have him out? Did you talk to him about this before?
- 4:20I didn't actually meant I'm a little scared of him. He's you know,
- 4:24he's a vicious intellect, so it's a little scary. He even did
- 4:27the bumper for this series, didn't he? And as as payments for that,
- 4:31he gets to flys out to Auckland. Yeah, all right, well
- 4:34we're going to see you there. I think I guess you probably want to
- 4:38move on at this point. Yeah, anyway, So so what I wanted
- 4:40to do before we went on this pointless fucking our digressional are entirely the point.
- 4:46So how do people join the discord so I can then go on and
- 4:50write comments in the monthly topic and get on the hashtag channel show. Well,
- 4:56I think you've got a discord dot com and then it's probably like there's
- 5:00like an you know, how to do this this portal. It's like kind
- 5:02of shod this one hundred times. I assume the five GFD discord is like
- 5:06in the top ten. You can only join a discord if you're invited.
- 5:10Why is that? I deny because they want it, you know, to
- 5:12be exclusive and that you know, so you can't make it public. I
- 5:15don't know. I don't know why I haven't looked. Maybe you wouldn't want
- 5:17it or you wouldn't get spammed and like exactly like Russians posing as stars since
- 5:23Elon took over Twitter. Yeah, I've got a lot of ladies sending me
- 5:27dms offering me sexual favors. Yeah, and I've responded to loads of them,
- 5:31right, and you know then I gave them my credit card, but
- 5:33I haven't heard from jokes on them, jokes something, yeah, exactly,
- 5:36then missing out. So you got a five games for do you know?
- 5:41Do you know why I hate doing this? Bend? Why the inconsistency?
- 5:44Okay, you have to spell out the five and the four? Should I
- 5:46pay for five gf D dot com as well? Yes? Yes, do
- 5:49you think it's available? I have no idea. Yeah. I think you
- 5:53need to. You need to brand yourself consistently across all of your properties,
- 5:56right, talk to CD hunter about this. He can probably arrange for like
- 6:00copyright of the logo of the name, maybe your face, yeah, if
- 6:04it was on a boat, if I was a pirate radio station, needs
- 6:08a bloody he's a bloody maritime lawyer. Yeah, that's very I was saying
- 6:12on the discord very arrested development season four, if you remember, not the
- 6:15best season, But I think the maritime law angle was very funny. Now
- 6:18he said that you can actually create a contract between two people about anything.
- 6:24I'm gonna get five g FD dot com. It's only nine thousand, seven
- 6:28hundred and seven dollars and fifty cents. Do you think you've pimped the value
- 6:31of this? Uh? Who wants five g f D? I mean,
- 6:34I don't know, but you know ten grand? No problem? Yeah,
- 6:39I guess you're not getting it. But do you think you and I theoretically
- 6:42could have a contract where I'm not allowed to appear on any other podcast?
- 6:46Do we have such a contract? We do? So, it's it's very
- 6:48much like the British Constitution. It's unwritten exactly, just assumed. It's like
- 6:53a matter of convention exactly. The whole thing falls apart if we don't observe
- 6:56convention exactly. And as we have pointed out, the most important convention that
- 7:00we have in this organization is five g f D Convention in Auckland, New
- 7:05Zealand exactly his Christmas holiday party. Get honest. Major sponsor Cede Hunter.
- 7:10He works for this really posh sounding law fer. So they'll stump up a
- 7:15few quick maybe do a free advert for them. Unlike his boss is a
- 7:18board game. Apparently, we'll get both of them on. I mean,
- 7:21I think they're both welcome to finance this trip exactly, both welcome to finance
- 7:26the trip. I don't ceedee Hunter doesn't necessarily do spend all of his money.
- 7:29You can get some of his company. That's fine. Yeah, yeah,
- 7:30we'll do Okay, who pays. As long as someone pays, we'll
- 7:32do EPPS from there, we'll do like live from fucking bag End exactly about
- 7:36it, Cedie Hunter. Imagine what you could make happen anyway. Anyway,
- 7:41we've got a basically is a hobbit. We've got on another sidebar of fucking
- 7:46trying to black Sea back. How do people join the discord five games for
- 7:50Doomsday dot Com? Okay, this is a uurl M uniform resource locator.
- 7:56I don't know what that means. Yeah, it's like how you find things
- 8:00on the internet. You think, you turn on your computer and you type
- 8:01in an address and like by magic. Your computer, your browser knows how
- 8:05to get there. There's actually a whole series of steps that have to take
- 8:09place where that name has to be looked up in a DNS registry, which
- 8:13is then matched to an IPA drive. I assume what the computer does is
- 8:16just go and knock on various doors. So it knocks on this door,
- 8:18and there's two people shaggy knocks on this door too, people shaggy, yes,
- 8:20but very very clear people shagging very quickly. And then and then eventually,
- 8:24after twenty seven million dollars exactly. U. So, yeah, you
- 8:31got a five games from doomsday dot com and apparently there's a pinned post.
- 8:35There is technology that you have availed your space, and the pinned post contains
- 8:41within it a link, which is the aforementioned invite link that you are required
- 8:46to use. It's another one of these URLs to join the discord. And
- 8:48then you are in the party, and you know what, show up and
- 8:52say something, because not enough people say something. Now some people say far
- 8:56too much exactly, And we're not mentioning any names. No, no,
- 9:01we you know, well, we'll stop mentioning names. If people did we
- 9:05mention did we mention that Ulli Blenniman is on the discord. He is,
- 9:09and he sometimes comments. He does, and his comments are cod You know
- 9:11who else is sometimes on the discord? Who your own? Right? If
- 9:18I if I mentioned him, he shows up in like five seconds. That
- 9:22guy, He's just ubiquitous, exactly. So thank you for that, Steve.
- 9:26We got there eventually, only nine minutes into the show. Let's move
- 9:30on to after altogether too much consultation with the greatest minds in the world.
- 9:37Topics represent all right, Steve, So I'm going to read out this month's
- 9:50topic and then you're gonna give your opinion. We're going to have some spicy
- 9:54back and forth before we get into the comments to the listeners. Let's do
- 9:58it. If you know it, I put this fucking stupid voice when I'm
- 10:01recording. Yeah you really like you go into like poorly trained actor mode.
- 10:05Yeah, And I mean I wasn't poorly trained. I went to one of
- 10:07the best drama schools in the country, and I mean I'm not very good.
- 10:09I mean, you can't polish a third Steve, as we all know.
- 10:11But why did you just not try very hard? I mean, what
- 10:15do you mean Like you always claim that you went to one of the best
- 10:16acting schools in the country. You also claim that you're not very good.
- 10:20But is that just like British false modesty. No, no, no,
- 10:22not very good. I don't know. I don't know. You know,
- 10:24I went to some I went to drama school with some people who are absolutely
- 10:26wonderful, and I went to drama school with some people who are worse than
- 10:30me. Like I would say, like, your characters all have a kind
- 10:31of similarity to them. What do you mean, well, you like like
- 10:35it do a king? Just like say something? A king would say,
- 10:37all right, as it going? No, where's my dinner? Okay?
- 10:41Now? Like what would a peasant farmer say? All right, how's it
- 10:43going? Where's me dinner? Okay? Now? How about a shopkeeper?
- 10:48Okay, ingaling, all right, how's it going? Where's me dinner?
- 10:54All right? How about like a ship's captain. Come on, there's got
- 10:56to be something different here, all right? Kind I think obviously you've you've
- 11:07got yourself entire I went to Sean Connery School of Acting. Oh, we
- 11:11just did the same thing every time, but like we didn't have the same
- 11:15successful outcome unfortunately, could have done yet yet, Yeah, that's true.
- 11:18Who knows some people are late bloomers, but who knows. I might do
- 11:20this play that I'm doing in the fucking autumn and be discovered. But to
- 11:24be fair, though, stave, I'm a forty six short man. I
- 11:26went to drama school and I left in two thousand. Do you know how
- 11:31it's something like something like seven percent of trained actors remain in the profession seven
- 11:39percent something something. I mean, I am pulling that figure out my ass,
- 11:41but it's a very low amount. And so you know, it's like
- 11:45I told you the other day, Beethoven's fifth and ninth Symphony is premiered on
- 11:48the same night and it was considered a failure that concert. Yeah, exactly.
- 11:52It really makes you think, doesn't it. Yeah, I mean,
- 11:54you know, you might finish your thesis one day. Anyway, this month,
- 12:00stopping channel is and I'm going to read out what I can't hear the
- 12:05stare these kickstarts are ruining gaming? Is it increasing the price of games,
- 12:11making them hard to get due to kickstart to exclusive titles, compelling publishers to
- 12:16water down designs due to the need to have loads of expansions at release.
- 12:18To what degree does kickstart to affect the rest of the industry, will it
- 12:22blow itself out? Let us know your views on this and anything else you
- 12:26want to say about crowdfunding. So Steve, come on, kick us off.
- 12:31Okay, So when you first posed this question, I didn't think I
- 12:35could not have expected it would have elicited the response that it did in the
- 12:39hashtag channel channel. I mean, it's a very like basic question. It's
- 12:43not like completely original. It's been asked before. But how many responses did
- 12:48it get? I mean they must have like one hundred messages in this Yeah,
- 12:52people got impassionate. I mean quite a few of them were people fucking
- 12:54having a flame war. And yeah, I'm pretty sure that several relationships were
- 12:58ruined during this conver station. So I felt myself going back and forth a
- 13:03bit because I didn't put loads of thought into it up front. I kind
- 13:07of I don't know how strongly you feel about it, but I felt at
- 13:11the time you asked the question, like, yeah, it kind of seems
- 13:13like a lot of games are becoming very sami, Sami. They're becoming more
- 13:16expensive, more plastic, more bullshit. It's just like deluding the hobby.
- 13:20So yeah, I mean Betterage's law notwithstanding, it does seem to be having
- 13:26some kind of negative effect that I didn't think deeply about this. Then you
- 13:30know, lots of you know, interesting arguments, many on the side of
- 13:33publishers, I would say, appeared in the discord, and I can I
- 13:37never thought that I'd be poacher turns gamekeeper state. I didn't think my discord
- 13:43would end up being the home of the shill you know what I mean?
- 13:46Yeah, I mean interesting given the mix of people on there. But you
- 13:52know, we have to consider the publisher's side, because as luminary as in
- 13:56this hobby, we happen to be privileged enough to be close to some of
- 14:01the independent publishers, right, Like we're friends with them, right, It
- 14:05would be hard not to look at it from their point of view. It's
- 14:07very easy as a gamer to say I only care about like the consumer side
- 14:11of things, the gamer experience, and like the concerns of publishers are not
- 14:16that interesting. The whole argument is Kickstarter provides a platform for small publishers to
- 14:22be able to reach a market, and otherwise they would not be able to
- 14:24do it. As long as quality games are coming to me, and they
- 14:26did before Kickstarter, and they probably would without it? What do I care?
- 14:31So that was an interesting argument. I haven't come down on one side
- 14:35or another. What I did start to think about, and this is going
- 14:37in a slightly different direction than I had anticipated, is what does it say
- 14:41about game design? Like does Kickstarter? If it doesn't mean like the death
- 14:46of the game industry hasn't done anything? Has it done anything like toward like
- 14:52death of the game designer, like the otour game designer, if you know
- 14:56what I mean? Because in the past, people like dim past nobody put
- 15:03their names on the boxes. Then they started to do that. But like
- 15:05the people that were familiar with Reiner, canitcie with a Rosenbergh as of now?
- 15:13But I think this is still under wraps exactly. We've signed an NBA
- 15:16with one of the great bablishes in the bold game world. I think like
- 15:20these people have a genuine voice, Like you know what you're gonna get with
- 15:24the Neuve Rosenberg game, and it's gonna be like variations on a theme and
- 15:26a theme that you know and love, Like that little bit of familiarity is
- 15:31what enables you to experience like what is different, Like the familiarity combined with
- 15:33the difference I think that this works in all forms of art, right,
- 15:37But that's what you go and see a ways, I'm just moving if you
- 15:41were way uns doesn't found it's because you essentially know what you're gonna get.
- 15:43Yeah, exactly my point. I'm gonna wrap up in a second here.
- 15:48Um, what I do think I see happening with games like they still have
- 15:50names on boxes. But I think the commercialization, which is I think abetted
- 15:56by Kickstarter, is leading to a lot of designs that are converting toward what.
- 16:00I don't know. It's like opinion poll games or something like that.
- 16:03I don't know that these games are coming from a place of distinction like that,
- 16:07there's a voice, there's just you know, will this work in the
- 16:11market? Will this cell? Like? How about some plastic here? Now
- 16:14it's a very factile opinion. It's just something I've been thinking about. Now
- 16:18after all that I threw to you. So kickstarters had a really fascinating journey,
- 16:23because I guess my journey in the gaming world it's basically concurrent with Kickstarter.
- 16:29Essentially, Alien Frontiers was the first kind of hobby game that really did
- 16:34something on Kickstarter, and bear in mind back at that time, two thousand
- 16:40and eleven, two twelve ish doing something on Kickstarter Alien Frontiers, which is
- 16:45a great game, by the way. Did some did something like about fifty
- 16:49sixty grand on Kickstarter? Right, and that was considered big of a time,
- 16:55right, it was the first big splash. But what was fascinating about
- 16:59Kickstarter back then is the Kickstarter was cons you have two roads, right,
- 17:04if you were a serious publisher who took yourself seemously as a company, did
- 17:08they diverge in a yellow wood? I don't know what that means. And
- 17:12you took the path list traveled by, and that has made all the difference.
- 17:17That's what the hell you's open about? A fucking American poem. God
- 17:19Frost, I don't know Robert Frost. I don't know Robert Frost. I
- 17:22don't know Bob Ice, I don't know William Rain. I don't know any
- 17:26of them. All right, I'm trying to bloody talk collaborative, overlap,
- 17:30collaborative twat and my lap and all like about how about mending wall? Do
- 17:33you know mending wall? Something there is that doesn't love a wall, that
- 17:36wants it down? Do you know? Do you know defenses? Defenses make
- 17:40good neighbors. Ben, Yeah, fucking do you shut out your fucking face
- 17:42make you less of a twat? Certainly fucking does. Oh I'm fucking mister
- 17:47culture. Ben Maddox hasn't even heard of Robert Frost, who gave the fucking
- 17:49inaugural address for John F. Kennedy. Oh did he poet Laurie? Oh?
- 17:53Yeah, States of America anyway, so asshole. So back in the
- 18:00day, if you were a serious publisher, like so around that time plaid
- 18:07Hack Games, Mayfair, Rio Grand, you didn't get a Kickstarter. You
- 18:14really straight to retail. So if you look at plat Hat Games, they
- 18:17explicitly didn't get a Kickstarter because it gave them a better patina. They looked
- 18:23more respectable, not just publisher. You're not just like testing the water,
- 18:27as will this cell. You're like designing. Stone Meyer for instance, started
- 18:32on Kickstarter, and as soon as he could, he went off Kickstarter and
- 18:37in straight into retail because Kickstarter still had that patina of the plucky underdog or
- 18:45not being entirely respectable. They didn't had this middle period where people started to
- 18:48get pissed off and where you had companies like Queen Games, for instance,
- 18:53who didn't need to go on Kickstarter. There was still this notion that Kickstarter
- 18:57was the cold of ideas for people who couldn't fund them. Right, you
- 19:03were kickstarting something. Kickstarter has become a word that no longer has any meaning.
- 19:07We have to we have to think back. Actually, what does the
- 19:11name of the website means. It means you were kickstarting someone's dreams extended essentially.
- 19:15And I ran a Kickstarter, you know, yeah exactly, and it
- 19:18really was like make or break. We set a goal. We weren't sure
- 19:22we're gonna we were going to hit it. And it was a thirty day
- 19:25long kickstarter and like on day twenty eight, I think something like that,
- 19:27we reached the goal, but like just barely. It was like not a
- 19:30sure thing. And back then, when you were investing in a kickstarter,
- 19:34I mean, investing is not the right word whatever. Supporting a Kickstarter,
- 19:37you weren't you weren't sure if the project was going to get funded. We
- 19:41weren't sure it was going to get funded. And it was like, do
- 19:42people want this thing to exist? Board games today they fund in five seconds,
- 19:47Well this is the thing, right, and so not all of them,
- 19:48but you know, there are quite a few sure things, and so
- 19:51it went through this middle period where you could people were railing at this notion
- 19:59of kickstarted being a pre order service. They said, no, this is
- 20:03a thing for helping people achieve their dreams. Once you get to a certain
- 20:06size, you shouldn't use Kickstarter because you're using up the oxygen of the people
- 20:11for whom this platform is intended. Right, And now we're in a place
- 20:15where Kickstarter is essentially a pre order shop and all of those earlier all of
- 20:22those earlier sort of concerns have gone away, and companies who don't need to
- 20:26use Kickstarter use Kickstarter because it assures you of something. I've got a very
- 20:33I've got a nuanced view on it, because you know, without Kickstarter,
- 20:37I wouldn't do some of the work that I do. I do voiceover.
- 20:41I did a voiceover for a company just two days ago. Nuanceder biased.
- 20:45Well, No, it's it's so. The thing is right, if you
- 20:49look at someone like Fantasia Games, what have they done? Endless Winter?
- 20:55Okay? And then an unconscious mind, I know them because I've worked for
- 21:00them, so I kind of know their process even though they're having big barn
- 21:03storming kickstarters. They need Kickstarter, not just though, not just to fund
- 21:11the production of the game, but as marketing. The thing is Kickstarter is
- 21:17no longer this platform for igniting someone's dreams. Kickstarter is also essentially a marketing
- 21:23platform. It's for getting the name of your game out there, getting the
- 21:27hype of your game out there. And so it's also social media. It
- 21:32is, it's social media. It's completely that, And so I don't have
- 21:37an entirely unnuanced view on it. I think it is a very useful platform.
- 21:42Where I have an issue is an aesthetic one. As you talk about
- 21:53killing the game designer, it actually they are tour a game design. Yeah,
- 21:59so it seems to me a lot of Kickstarter games are kind of no
- 22:02longer about a great solid game design. They are about how many dildos you
- 22:07can stick in a box and how many expansions that you're never going to play
- 22:12come with your base pledge. Right, And this is Simon started this,
- 22:21right, and now everybody does it. And whereas people used to say,
- 22:27oh, Kickstarter games, they're just not as good as straight to retail games,
- 22:30I feel like we're going to go in a circle with this, and
- 22:33people are going to start to say, because so much energy has gone into
- 22:37designing not just a game, but also twenty different expansion modules, and like
- 22:44very few of these games are any less forgettable for it right exactly. And
- 22:47so this is the point I think we're going to come around a whole circle
- 22:49where people are going to say the problem with Kickstarter games is that they look
- 22:53great, the productions great, but there's not a lot of substance there.
- 22:57So I'm trying to think of you kick stoled a few games recently. The
- 23:02only one that I think is genuinely excellent that I've played from all the kickstart
- 23:06because I stopped back in kick Starts ages ago. The only one that I
- 23:10think is genuinely excellent. No, no, there's been two genuinely excellent ones.
- 23:15It's way Famous at the Side Tigers, which I think is absolutely fantastic,
- 23:19and thunder Road. Thunder Road feels like a Kickstarter game to me because
- 23:25it's a very simple, structured game that you can throw a lot of expansions
- 23:27into. Something like Colleague. Just design a brilliant euro game and only twenty
- 23:34bloody expansions with your fucking silver age eurogame that we're never going to use so
- 23:40we're never gonna use And I really hate this experience where I have to have
- 23:42Fomo even before I've like made a pledge, Like why does there have to
- 23:47be a deluxe edition? Where does there have to be a super deluxe edition?
- 23:48And all these stretch goals and all these expansions and add ons. I
- 23:52mean, you know, I don't care what side of the argument you fall
- 23:55on with Kickstarter and whether or not it's been good for the gaming industry or
- 24:00the hobby, which maybe are two different things, but this is clearly some
- 24:03kind of cash crap, like adding I'm going to get loads of flat for
- 24:07this because I have no idea what I'm talking about, but like high margin
- 24:11add ons, you know, just to like pump up the price and people,
- 24:15but they go for it. I mean they gon't want it, right,
- 24:18I think it greater concern is and this is this is the classic Kickstarter
- 24:22thing, right You get all excited about the Kickstarter, you back the Kickstarter,
- 24:26and then when it comes in the post seven months later, you've no
- 24:30desire. You forget you fucking backed it, and you have no desire to
- 24:33play it, and the unboxing is too much work, and it turns the
- 24:36hobby into backing things on Kickstarter? Is the hobby not playing games? That's
- 24:42interesting, That's that's an issue, right, I think that's a dangerous thing.
- 24:45So how similar is game Found to Kickstarter? So the thing about Kickstarter
- 24:49in the early days was the possibility that your project wouldn't get funded. That
- 24:56was like the whole premise. I don't even know if people think about this
- 24:59anymore, and I'm not sure if it's a thing you have. You have
- 25:00so many companies, You have so many companies now, like do you have
- 25:03to set a goal on the game Found and if you don't get it,
- 25:06you don't get funded? Okay, but I think Game Found or is that
- 25:08Indiego Go one of them has this some varial funding thing you go go.
- 25:12You can decide if you want there to be a goal or not. I
- 25:17think, but um, you know, there was a lot of companies,
- 25:19whether they still do it or not, because I'm not tirely on top of
- 25:22kickstart it, but they would have a low goal because there's this idea that
- 25:29you know, if you see that the the project is funded, you're more
- 25:33likely to back it because you don't want to back something that's going to fail,
- 25:37right, and then that's like the opposite of what I thought it was
- 25:40supposed to be. And then there were companies they'd have a deliberately low goal
- 25:44and they'd be two hundred percent funded and call the kickstarts rock because they didn't
- 25:47get the funding they needed, which is which is just which is I mean
- 25:51under had for ours, we basically set we set a high goal, but
- 25:56we set a goal that would be meaningful, like we needed to hit the
- 25:57goal to even be bothered going through with it, right, And I mean
- 26:02it was really touching go. And this is what Kickstarter recommended. I mean,
- 26:03the idea is that you want your backers to be bought into what you're
- 26:07doing. Yeah, But the thing is what Kickstarter recommend and what the current
- 26:10meta is, because Kickstarter is fundamentally a game, what the current meta is
- 26:15a two very different things. Kickstarter is fundamentally a game. I mean,
- 26:18let's not let that go. By Ben Maddocks twenty twenty three. All right,
- 26:22So Giles Bennett has written in has he I assume Giles straight from Buffy
- 26:27the Vampire Slid, I assume with a bottle of diet coke in his hand.
- 26:33Very good. I've never seen a man drink as much diet coke in
- 26:34my fucking life. And so he says, for every ridiculously pricing, massively
- 26:41overblown, mini loaded seamon project you can point me to, I can point
- 26:45you to an excellent value project. Indeed, Justice hand you well lay him
- 26:51finish. Indeed, just this morning I saw someone who's received Aisle of Trains
- 26:53all Aboard in the UK, which reminded me I backed it twenty four pounds
- 26:57plus five pounds for shipping for the operator pledge, which wasn't even the cheapest
- 27:02pledge level. Kingmaker Tennis Trail, Raylan Ride, Snowdonia Deluxe Brass. If
- 27:07you're prudent and I'm prepared to wait, there are some excellent value purchases to
- 27:11be had with little to no risk. Well, I think nobody would disagree
- 27:15with that, right, No, And I don't think the thing is I
- 27:17don't know if it's one to one. I don't think kickstarta has risk anymore
- 27:21for games, certainly not maybe for other projects. I mean there are some
- 27:23ship games that get like no support, but these were never going to no
- 27:29a proper publisher that goes on Kickstarter, They're not going to fail like Garfield,
- 27:33Games is not going to fail. I mean, I suppose this is
- 27:34like an alternative distribution channel for them. I don't know the details, but
- 27:41there's no chance. Right, They're gonna get funded. They're gonna get funded
- 27:44immediately, and they're using the platform as like you said, this market Yeah,
- 27:47marketing pre order and why not? Why wouldn't you? And so what's
- 27:51I think what we forget right now? I have so as I said,
- 27:56my fundamental problem with kickstarta is esthetic. I think it's lowering the quality of
- 28:02games. You're a games in particular, But I think what we forget.
- 28:04Garfield Games has like two employees Queen Games that we think is this massive company,
- 28:11and I think they've their actions on Kickstarter have been problematic. I think
- 28:15their games, their their price to performance ratio isn't great. But I mean
- 28:19they're they're essentially two people. Game companies aren't. Big game companies carry a
- 28:27lot of risk, so it makes sense for them to use Kickstarter, right,
- 28:33And I think you can worry about the spirit of Kickstarter being lost,
- 28:41but that was well, that was lost a long time ago. So it's
- 28:44lamenting that we don't go around in horse and carriages anymore. I'm not a
- 28:48shareholder, but I look at, I look at. I mean, what's
- 28:52great about some Kickstarter games is they enable little games to be published. I
- 28:57love trains, I would love to have backed that, and you know Tinner's
- 29:02trail. Kickstarter enables a classic Martin Wallace game to be published, but this
- 29:07time that actually looks good. I mean, just as nice component, just
- 29:11you know, discoverability. I mean, there are a lot of games I
- 29:14probably wouldn't have found out about if it weren't for a Kickstarter game found whatever
- 29:18else people use. So so I'm going to read something from kind Fortress here,
- 29:22and that's famed board game designer Isaac and I'm pretty sure it's dripping with
- 29:26sarcasm, but as is his want indeed, But I'm going to I'm gonna
- 29:32take this as a sincere statement. I'd say the blame lies on us,
- 29:38the consumers, our ugly desire for mountains of plastic, our willingness to be
- 29:42seduced by promises from strangers instead of the boxes on the shelves of our local
- 29:48retailers or the boxes on our own shelves, and our utter lack of impulse
- 29:52control in the face of fomo and fake deadlines. Kickstarter is the mirror that
- 29:56reveals our rotten consumerist soul. I just backed his Kickstarter, did you Yeah?
- 30:03Oh nice if you're in a nag. Yeah, so so, but
- 30:06what what do you think to that? I mean, I think he's obviously
- 30:08hypocrite. I think he's being right sarcastic there. But oh, I see
- 30:11you think he doesn't mean any of that. I think he's being ironic,
- 30:15yes, okay, okay, I can't actually tell. No. I mean
- 30:18it's not always clear with him. I mean I like, I like subtle,
- 30:22I really though, Yeah, so is that subtle? Well? So
- 30:26the point is it is a vicious circle. Right. So I had backed
- 30:33one Seamon Kickstarter, I backed dingdingding ding ding ding Ding. No. I
- 30:41backed the called the Seven Deadly Sins one no idea. I can't remember.
- 30:45And it was a long time ago. Yeah, it wasn't very good,
- 30:48and I sold it for maybe ten quid less than I backed with like twenty
- 30:53expansions. Right, And I remember because Semon, I mean, Simon basically
- 31:03run a fucking it's it fuels like a casino, right, so you back
- 31:08it? And then I remember just getting home from work every day and this
- 31:12was I mustn't have had a smartphone at the time. Getting back in work
- 31:18every day, checking the internet to see how far the kickstarters, to see
- 31:22what stretch goal had been unlocked, what extra shit I was going to have
- 31:26in the pot I used to do. I used to do that when Kickstarter
- 31:27was new. It was kind of engaging, it was kind of exciting.
- 31:30And this is the problem, right, I think And as I said,
- 31:33I'm going to get a thing. Yeah, And I think that is in
- 31:37terms of supporting an art form, I think that's fatal. Well do you
- 31:41know how you know it's jumped the shark if you don't deliver on a Kickstarter,
- 31:44the comments or vicious. I mean, consumers have just become entitled.
- 31:48They expect projects to fun, for the people organizing them to be able to
- 31:52deliver promptly, and like, like you say, a lot of these companies
- 31:56are like only a few people. And look at look at Madeira. I'm
- 31:59still waiting for my copy of Well. I mean it's allegedly coming soon,
- 32:01but like I don't care. I'll come here eventually and then I'll play it.
- 32:05And why do I need it right away? So the first kickstar piss,
- 32:08the first Kickstarter I ever backed was this project for rim lights on a
- 32:14bike. Because the whole thing is when you're cycling on the road at night,
- 32:21cars can see you from behind, they can't see from the side because
- 32:23the so I bought these lights that were sort of rim lights on my wheels,
- 32:28right, so my wheels had lights, not just like a like a
- 32:30fluorescent strip. No, it was a It was a It was a fluorescent
- 32:34strip and connected to it was an ultra violet bulb. And when you started
- 32:38cycling, the bulb would kick in and it would ultra violet. Yeah you
- 32:45be You can't see ultra violet. No, but you can if you have
- 32:47a strip of tape around it that reacts to ultra violet light like a blue
- 32:52like a dark light. Right, Okay, so like a car coming flashing
- 32:54its lights on you. They were No, there was a light integrated into
- 32:59the housing of the thing. So you would put a strip of tape around
- 33:00the wheel. Yeah, and then you had this housing that you would put
- 33:04over your fault would have a black light. So when you started cycling,
- 33:07it reacted with the tape and the tape glowed. So you backed it because
- 33:12you thought it looked cool and you know, for my own safety, Stephen,
- 33:15but which one was more important? It look cool, but like the
- 33:20guy put it on Kickstarter, it funded, and then some other company said,
- 33:24mate, we have a patent for this, and so he refunded all
- 33:29the money. No, I lost my money. It just he tried to
- 33:32get it done and then it didn't happen and I lost my money. That
- 33:36was my first have a Kickstarter project, and that's part of the risk of
- 33:38backing a Kickstarter. Not anymore though, because it's a shop. It is
- 33:42er it is is not. It's a shop now. It says at the
- 33:45bottom of every ten page long project description. The risks are that we might
- 33:50not we might not fund this, you might not get your product, blah
- 33:53blah blah. But you know, there's a mentality of shifted clearly, and
- 33:57to some degree, I think, oh, I don't like the way I
- 34:01probably twas ever, thus, but it didn't feel like this when I got
- 34:06into gaming the board. Gaming has become a bad acquisition, pure acquisition.
- 34:12This is why I fucking hate people justifying their their avariciousness by using shelf of
- 34:19opportunity rather than shelf a shame. You should be fucking ashamed. I'm gonna
- 34:22say, how do you feel about shelfies. Shelf is a fine I'm very
- 34:25proud of my collection, my collection in the same way because it's curated in
- 34:29the same way that Jorge Lewis Borgez. There's a lot in that name said.
- 34:34You know, I never feel comfortable unless I'm surrounded by books. I
- 34:37haven't had my board games on a shelf for two years. I cannot tell
- 34:42you how comforted I felt. It's such a comfort. We got to play,
- 34:45key Flower, We've got to play was just going Ben exactly? Key
- 34:50Flowers amazed to play me, Ben, And so I think, I think,
- 34:53lay me Ben, Ben, Ben, I want you to play me.
- 34:57Ben. You kept me locked up in this trump So is that your
- 35:00kickstop your key Flower impression? Yeah? I mean you can speak with the
- 35:02British accent for a start. I mean, how can you tell accent when
- 35:06I'm using that voice? Because you saw let's go down to pub Den Jowey
- 35:13Governor Ben. You're an amazing linguist anyway. So yeah, And I think,
- 35:16even though I suggest Isaac is probably being disingenuous here, it's right when
- 35:22you turn an artful into acquisition, he's being self loathing. I think this
- 35:24is what this is what modern art is the game. Yeah, and it's
- 35:30heart No modern art or modern art the game the game. Okay. It
- 35:34is a brutal satire on art being turned into commodity. And I might be
- 35:40fucking massively naive here, but sit on the nose too. I mean that's
- 35:45fine, though I might be massively naive here, but I think when you
- 35:49turn an art form into a commodity, then you devalue the artful board games.
- 35:54I mean they were kind of always a commodity, right, yes,
- 35:58well, no with the ad event. But the point is, with the
- 36:00advent of the board game author and in German they're not called designers, they're
- 36:05called authors, we had commodic commoditization of board games probably took place in the
- 36:08twentyth century. Board games have been forever, right, but no one cared
- 36:12if they were any good in the back in the day either. But I
- 36:15think I think with the advent of the hobby ball game, the boutique board
- 36:19game, the authored board game, there was this idea that you had something
- 36:24that was not that you had to pay for, that people wanted to eat
- 36:30from. You know, that it was a career, but there was something
- 36:32that was unique and special and good and worked upon and it wasn't just And
- 36:39people complain about Awakened Realms and every Awakened Realms Kickstarter does fucking Gangbusters And yeah,
- 36:45everybody says their games are shit but their components are wonderful. Well that's
- 36:49a failure in my eyes. Well what do you think about my point about
- 36:52the death of the outour game designer? If you look at awaken Realms,
- 36:57right, A lot of the games that we play are designed by older people
- 37:00like my middle aged German middle middle age men like Martin Wallace, games with
- 37:05a Rosenberg Ryner, Knitsia. We always name these same Max Steve Sirek.
- 37:07Yeah. For example, um, coming soon the vital Aserta. I actually
- 37:13announced it. Did I announce it on the discord? No? I didn't
- 37:15announce the actual thing on that. Yeah, And I'm not saying like young
- 37:17people don't design games, but like our game's not now a bit more designed
- 37:22by committee, like harder to get published if you're not fitting into a market
- 37:24or people like are there are there younger designers you can think of who have
- 37:30the kind of voice that these older generations did and another few, maybe like
- 37:32Phillips, is it Matthew Dunston, mate him, Phillips, phil Walker Harding,
- 37:37There are people the thing is what's fascinating. So maybe it's just a
- 37:40sign of the maturation of the board game art that you have this big strata
- 37:45of commercial designed by Committee Games, the Marvel, the MCU of board games,
- 37:52and then you have these little tinkering Pete Anderson type or tours like is
- 37:59it is it eluding the hobby such that it's harder for those who do have
- 38:02a voice to like find a customer basically or turning into every kind of hobby
- 38:09where you have the commercial ship and any of the people who thumb their nose
- 38:13at those and play the boutique stuff. How do you feel about people who
- 38:15ask rhetorical questions? Do I love it? Oo Faga says, where do
- 38:22you reckon? Ou fargas from? Let me see the name ou Faga?
- 38:25Let me see, I mean that's the computer name, so you can never
- 38:28tell oo Faga. I mean it sounds like another planet. Maybe, okay,
- 38:32like Oriyan seven Ryan seven. I can do an Orian seven accents?
- 38:37Can you? Yeah? Go ahead? I personally went on a Kickstarter hot
- 38:40streak create a memory. Incidentally, they sound like someone from Britain Omega seven
- 38:47is what you said? Yes, yeah, that's what I said. I
- 38:51personally went to a Kickstarter seven. Am I gonna fucking be able to read?
- 38:54These are the coultribute to say, hey, hey, keep our personal
- 38:58relationship out of a podcast? Okay? I personally went on a Kickstarter hot
- 39:02streak about three years between twenty sixteen twenty nineteen. My interest has now waned
- 39:07and I'm a lot more discerning, perhaps because my collection has approached critical mass.
- 39:12Perhaps it correlates to the golden age hypothesis, which which I came up
- 39:15with. I believe game found is where my money where the Greeks did originally,
- 39:19But you know, yeah, you invented the idea of a golden age
- 39:22where my money has gone in the last year or so. But game fan
- 39:24feels more like a shot than a crowdfunder. Overall, I think Kickstarter has
- 39:29raised the bar for component quality and artwork and allowed publishers to really push that
- 39:32boundary. And I think that's fascinating because there is no doubt playing a properly
- 39:39published game is better than playing a prototype. Right, Sure, but you
- 39:46can have a collection of beautifully sculpted jade game pieces. If there's no fucking
- 39:52game there, it's just a load of junk, right, I mean,
- 39:55unless you're unless you're a child, they'll play with anything. I mean I
- 39:59used to design my own games like pencil and paper. But it was great.
- 40:01There were loads of fun. I mean I had fun children play they
- 40:05make play out of Was it like Steve gets kissed by a girl? Guy?
- 40:09Why do we need everything to be so polished and well produced and perfect?
- 40:13Well, well, it's interesting we played key Flower last night, right,
- 40:15Yeah, I mean this is a very mouldest production. Yes, does
- 40:19the game suffer. I mean I think a designer would probably have some UI
- 40:24complaints, But it's fine for me. Carnegie it works, Carnegie very beautiful.
- 40:30Yeah. Does the game benefit prove Yeah, you know it's it's just
- 40:36a little slidy things that go under the board. I mean it's like cool
- 40:38the first time, and then it's that thing, right, I like nice
- 40:43components, So there's no question about it. So, but the thing is,
- 40:45it kind of depends what game you're playing. And yes, Kickstarter is
- 40:47allowed publishers to get really good at componentry, probably off the back of people
- 40:52who aren't being paid very much in China, but still really good componentry right,
- 40:58and to some games it really benefits. If you had wooden little fucking
- 41:04mepal cars in thunder Road wouldn't be as good, would it, You know
- 41:08what I mean? It wouldn't be as good. But in my Euro games,
- 41:14a cube is as good as a fucking sculpted fucking dildoso in the nostalgia
- 41:19for the wooden cubed to games of your Yeah, and there's something there's something
- 41:23haptically nostalgic about would right? What other podcasts? I mean, there's words
- 41:28like haptically when I got, when I've got, you know, my wood
- 41:31in my hand, so to speak, I always feel great, you know
- 41:36what I mean, when you're being got a smile on my phone, when
- 41:37you're being haptic would exactly. Um, So I have a question apropos of
- 41:44oofa who first point? Do you? Oh, Farga, you Farga?
- 41:49Do you want to be able to ask you? He's not here, I
- 41:52can't ask him, or they're not that I don't know if them well,
- 41:54I mean you can respond on the discord later if you listen to this.
- 41:57But I've got a Penguin as their avatar. Is it okay? If I
- 42:00ask Ben for now, why am I talking to him? Ben? It's
- 42:01it okay? If I ask you direct, do you do you want to
- 42:05go in back games with the possibility that the game won't get produced, that
- 42:08you might lose your money or basically have you been totally converted and you're fine?
- 42:13I know you don't really back things anymore, but like, would you
- 42:15want to do that? Or basically it's a shop. We all accept it.
- 42:17If you back a game, you're going to get it. You just
- 42:20have to wait a year. It's basically it's basically a shop. We all
- 42:22accept it. But it kind of ruins a little bit of the anticipation of
- 42:24going in places like doesn't It does? But you're seeing what you're seeing,
- 42:29which is fascinating at the moment. On the YouTube's you're seeing a lot of
- 42:32people on boxing the new deluxe castles of Bourgeon, the addition, because it's
- 42:36obviously just delivered Tobaccers right, and you're you're seeing unboxing videos, which do
- 42:40you watch those? No? I just see them. They pop up in
- 42:44my face. Weird. Fuck unboxing videos were weird, And I think this
- 42:49is the prime example of me really not given a fuck about Kickstarter. I
- 42:53love Castles of Bourbon dy. I think it's an absolutely astonishing game, and
- 42:57I love the Lea Games edition that you've got, their Deluxe edition, which
- 43:02was formed read any of the fucking symbols. All they did was just turn
- 43:07up the fucking color on the monitor. But it's such a pure, brilliant,
- 43:14clean design, and I can't help but feel that the fucking dildos and
- 43:19the plastic fucking hexagons somehow dilute that purity. And you know, it's not
- 43:27such a problem with Castles of Burgundy because there's the Elia version there for cheap
- 43:30that you can still get and the Deluxe version. If you're a crass class
- 43:36list bellat's turning. It's turning a board game into like a tabletap entertainment,
- 43:40I guess. But I mean, there are some games that I always argue
- 43:45with people about this, but there are some games you simply can't get.
- 43:49Lacerda games are problematic. They don't exist in that form without Kickstarter. But
- 43:52I don't think they need to be so beautiful, and they don't need to
- 43:54be one hundred and fifty quit. So I guess some people might say,
- 44:00what difference does it make? Maybe referring back to a previous point. Can
- 44:04both things coexist or is one actually crowding out the other and causing active harm?
- 44:08Like you said, you can still get both editions of Castles of Burgundy,
- 44:13and even if you couldn't, there's a huge secondary But there's no there's
- 44:16no addition of weather Machine. I mean, that's probably not a bad thing,
- 44:21but there's no cheap edition of weather Machine, right. Well, I
- 44:22mean, so I guess you don't have to be able to play every game,
- 44:25It's true, but then it turns a designers work into a designature of
- 44:32class, so which I think is problematic. But about okay? So then
- 44:37what about games where there's a kind of retail version and then the deluxe pimped
- 44:42Kickstarter version. Is that okay? I don't see that being an issue if
- 44:45you want to be a douchebag and spend one hundred and fifty quid on something,
- 44:49But as long as I can get it for fifty sixty quid, then
- 44:51that's that's fine by me. Yeah, I mean I have a problem with
- 44:54it. I suppose if I felt like I'm getting more of a game,
- 44:58if I go for the deluxe I would be annoyed, like, why can't
- 45:00I get the complete game experience in a simpler box. You can with castles,
- 45:06I mean depending on the game, because and you can with thunder Road
- 45:08a thing you don't don't know. It's like the deluxe edition of thunder Road
- 45:12comes with all kinds of extra shit. Yeah, but do you know if
- 45:15they're any good? So Karthi Setti, we both know, Karthik Yep.
- 45:19We usually get together in Portugal every year. Friend of the pod, I
- 45:22am going to read exactly what he wrote. Does he actually listen to these?
- 45:27I don't know. You can choose to correct his grammar. I will
- 45:30if you know such thing to mister Seti, I still believe cridfunding helps a
- 45:35lot of small publishers to get some capital upfront to publish games. Without cridfunding,
- 45:39there would be less games and publishers would take less risks. So everybody
- 45:49can use the language or they want. As long as we're understood, that's
- 45:52what counts. That's what it counts. So my example for this is the
- 45:58latest kickstarter from Dice hay Me. So Dice hat Me ended up getting bought
- 46:01by a bigger company. They did Brucrafters, right, Yeah, they ended
- 46:05up getting bought by a bigger company and then it ended up going wrong and
- 46:08Chris ended up being able to get the brand back. And he doesn't have
- 46:13disposable income. He's a tea cher. He doesn't have disposable income to just
- 46:16publish a game, right, So we went on Kickstarter with Milkman, and
- 46:21Milkman has funded. Didn't do Gangbusters, but it funded. And I love
- 46:25Dice Hatan, I love their ethos, their esthetic and the games are really
- 46:30good and so and Dice definitely hit you, Ben well, absolutely, and
- 46:35they could not work with an Kickstarter. And when you see a big company
- 46:39like Asthma Day, they don't go on Kickstarter, really, they go straight
- 46:44to retail and they flood retail. So you could argue when a company like
- 46:50Asthma Day is flooding retail and retailers are up against it. Anyway, the
- 46:55Kickstarter offers a legitimate avenue for smaller publishers to actually publish games and not get
- 47:07completely, you know, swamped by the Asthma a selection. I mean,
- 47:12then we're going in circles. Ben, let me let me ask you why
- 47:15this question? Then you know why ask is Kickstarter ruining games? Well,
- 47:19because I prompted it, because I think it animates people, right, And
- 47:22I think I think the reaction in the discord proves that it animates people because
- 47:25because I don't. Because I think there is a part of most of us
- 47:30that wants Kickstarter to be what it was originally intended to be. And so
- 47:36I think we were torn with Kickstarter. And this is the point. I
- 47:40think it's a very nuanced thing. You can't say it's entirely bad. But
- 47:46Matt Grain, oh two, I think it's. Matt says something that I
- 47:52said earlier that I genuinely agree with, which is there are no better products
- 47:55out there being sold hope. Sorry, I'll learn how to read. There
- 48:00are better products out there being sold to gamers, But I don't think there
- 48:01are better designed gains as a result of Kickstarter. Quite the opposite. This
- 48:08is a different point. I mean, I don't know how you judge these
- 48:12things. Right. Well, he's saying, he's saying that what criteria.
- 48:15He's saying that what Kickstarter does is give you a better, more polished product.
- 48:19Yeah, but it doesn't. It doesn't necessarily give you a better game.
- 48:23And he's saying it's actually quite the opposite, which is in Eurogames.
- 48:28Is where I stand. I think in Eurogames the quality is being diminished because
- 48:34of the pressure to have loads of expansions out of the games. I spoke
- 48:37to Stefan Feld a few years ago the spilders Jara ceremony in English. No,
- 48:43in German. You can speak English, though, can't not brilliantly he
- 48:46can't. No, he's German, okay, and I'm thinking of Alexander Pista,
- 48:52No, someone else anyway, So I spoke to him and he said,
- 48:57I don't like designing expansions for my game. Yeah. I like my
- 49:00games to be self contained works that I've done myself, and that is the
- 49:07beauty I think of eurogames. I think amer trash often built with expansions in
- 49:14mind, just bolting on things. Where did the notion of expansions even come
- 49:19from? Though, I mean, this was not a thing twenty years ago.
- 49:22I don't think. I know, Dominion always had lots of expansions.
- 49:24I don't know if that's what kicked this off. Well, I think I
- 49:28think it's just Carcassona I suppose had lots of expansions. Well, this is
- 49:31the point I think so Settlers a little bit. The whole purpose of expansions
- 49:36was to breathe new life into a game that you were playing a lot,
- 49:39right, Yeah, that's why big tent pole games like to get to ride
- 49:44like a Tan like Carcaus, don't have a lot of expansions, but like
- 49:45you would anticipate the expansion, you don't get the expansion with the game exactly.
- 49:51And the whole point that is not an expansion. The whole point is
- 49:53you should you should want to buy the expansion because you love the game,
- 50:00not just because all this comes with five extra boxes. And so the point
- 50:04is, the fundamental problem is is that need and it is a requirement now
- 50:09on Kickstarter to have loads of expansions out of the game. I think stops
- 50:16designers focusing into a beautiful calm machine that you can then go away and add
- 50:24expansions to. You look at through the ages, it took twenty years for
- 50:29one expansion, one expansion with a couple of cards, because you know,
- 50:35he Flash of Battle wanted this game to be perfect, and to add loads
- 50:40of ship Willie Nilly is going to upset the game. It just seems impossible
- 50:45to design a game as games that are as complicated as a typical euro game.
- 50:50How do you not break them by adding in more ship, especially like
- 50:52at that speed. Well, this is why, this is what Stefenfeld was
- 50:57saying. It's just not market tested. And also, you know not I
- 51:00don't want to say play tested, but I want to know that I love
- 51:04a game and after I'm going to eventually get an expansion for it because I'm
- 51:07excited about it. You know, why why would I want to back a
- 51:09game and then get three expansions? And then what someone I think it might
- 51:14have been, was it famed board game designer Isaac Shlev said you suld you
- 51:16should just play. Oh no, Tony Boydell the Doyana British Gaming, I
- 51:20think he's the one who said you should just play with all the expansions.
- 51:22I think it was. Actually I can hardly tell the difference between them because
- 51:27there are so much alike. Indeed, But yeah, I mean I don't
- 51:30agree because I played lots of games with all the expansion started in and they
- 51:32seem wildly in the expansions design a really tight, great game, and if
- 51:37ten years later it proves its merit in the world, I don't know,
- 51:42then make an expansion. But you say, that's the point. The Kickstar
- 51:45to Hobby is not about playing games. The Kickstar to Hobby is about buying
- 51:50games, and this fundamentally is problematic. So we so we agree Kickstarter is
- 51:54ruining the hobby in an act of willful competition. We pres and our all
- 52:04right, Stevie, So here we are with our completely unnecessary section poster of
- 52:10the month month. Well, we only released one hashtag channel? Is that
- 52:15because we haven't done this in so long? Yeah? Okay, so it's
- 52:17a monthly show. I thought you're hanging out with other people. I mean
- 52:21I was, but you know it's a monthly show, like who Bobby Johnson
- 52:23again, John Bobson, Bobby Johnson and Bob Johnson fucking always hanging out with
- 52:29them, aren't you? Yeah, the cool dudes. I fucking text you
- 52:30and it's like, I don't even get the little red receipt. No,
- 52:34it means like with fucking Bobby and Bobby and John, Bobby and John,
- 52:37Yeah, Bob, Bob Johnson and John Bobson. Why some episodes? Why
- 52:40do you do some episodes? Yeah? Maybe I fuck him Will Maybe She's
- 52:44like, get Bob and John a phone right now. Why don't you fucking
- 52:45go to New Zealand with them? Yeah? Maybe I will leave me here.
- 52:49Yeah, fucking video call me in. Who we are with? C
- 52:52Hunky? Is he garon? Mate? Yeah? So anybody's inland accent?
- 52:57So Poster of the month, Steve, This is your duty every time because
- 53:01you're the one with the taste. Okay, So poster of the month.
- 53:05Out of the ones I've read, which one do you think should qualify as
- 53:09post or of the month? Okay? I normally I like to go with
- 53:13ULI's post as the winning post. Yeah, traditionally, but you didn't read
- 53:15his I didn't, so I can't go with it. You only read like
- 53:19three I think one, two, three, four, five? Did you
- 53:23get through? Five? Went through five? Out of seven hundred thousand?
- 53:27I mean it's you know, what are you gonna do? All right?
- 53:29So poster of the month for this discussion our kickstarters ruining gaming? I think
- 53:35I'm gonna go with m green O two, but not entirely for what's in
- 53:39the post that you read, but because of the interaction the flame war that
- 53:44happened on and if you want to find that flame war, listeners, go
- 53:47to the discord and read back. So it's pick Hunt this week's poster of
- 53:53the month. Em Green O two. What do they win, Steve?
- 53:58Our enduring admiration? That was our all right? So just this is the
- 54:08outro bit, Steve. Oh, we're done already. We're done already.
- 54:12Fewty three bloody minutes A good time anyway, So how do they join the
- 54:15discord? I think we already talked about that. You've got to remind people
- 54:21top on the bottom, people only ever remember what they hear at the beginning
- 54:23of the end. Why did we just do an hour of fucking bullshit?
- 54:27Then? Because people, so as you said to me before we saw they're
- 54:30driving to work, they're still familiar with us in the fucking parasocial relationship they
- 54:34have. They just want to hear our voices. They didn't care what we're
- 54:37saying. As you said before we started recording, you don't listen to podcasts
- 54:42to enjoy them. You listen to podcasts to block out the fucking colcomphony within
- 54:46between your own ears. And you know what, I don't really prepare for
- 54:50these, ben I certainly, by the way, going back to the CD
- 54:52Hunter topic, he clearly prepared way more. I mean he's he's a much
- 54:58better guest than you are. I'm gonna lie to haven't spent five seconds preparing
- 55:01for the show. Luckily I do. So how did you join the Discorde
- 55:05five Games for Doomsday? Penn Post invite linkum blah blah blah, say hello
- 55:12to us, lovely. How do you support the show? If you'll listening
- 55:15to this and you're thinking, these guys know what the fuck is talking about?
- 55:17A little bit sexual? Okay, number number one, number one?
- 55:20I know, I know you don't want to talk about money. At least
- 55:22go and rate the fucking podcast on iTunes or where. I would love if
- 55:28someone you go and write the podcast and leave a review. Five stars would
- 55:30be great. Iven if the review is like no, it has to be
- 55:32great for Steve Sexual, Ben Zabell and that's fine. Best podcast ever,
- 55:37five stars. I don't need other board game podcasts. I think this helps
- 55:40the most. But if you're feeling a bit more generous, then go over
- 55:45to patreon dot com. Slash the number five, the letter G, the
- 55:51number four, the letter D, and Ben's gonna tell you what to do
- 55:55next. Well, I go answer the door. This is wonderful. Yeah,
- 55:58so you can go Patreon dot com forward slash five G for D.
- 56:01You can back at any level, but you can get a seven day free
- 56:07trial at the five euro a month level, and the five yuro month level
- 56:13basically gives you all of the bonus content that we've recorded over the five years
- 56:17of five G for D. This me and Steve going on camping trips,
- 56:22are biweekly battle report, my five Games for Doomsday interview which has done five
- 56:27years ago, which I'm going to have to update at some point. I
- 56:30mean absolutely loads of top quality stuff and you can do that and you get
- 56:34a free trial for seven days and if you like it, you can just
- 56:36keep it. Five dollars a mother's at euros euros well, yeah euros a
- 56:40month, yeah, five years a month. This is nothing. Nothing,
- 56:43It's like half of a flatweight in a fancy third way of coffee shop exactly.
- 56:46Actually like to thank everybody who contributed, whether your comment we're read out
- 56:52or not. There's going to be a new topic up in the hashtag channel
- 56:54channel on Discord hashtag channel channel. I'm going to go for something I think
- 56:59a bit more eulogizery in the next topic rather than I'm not going surprised but
- 57:05you have to be there to find out. Say thank you, Steve,
- 57:07Thank you Steve. Without you, this show wouldn't exist. So really,
- 57:20you're to blame, So thank you for listening and oil up your ears for
- 57:23the next hashtag channel.