Latest / The Koerner Office - Business Ideas and Deep Dives with Chris Koerner / Deep Dive on $200K/Year Local Newsletter ⏐Ep. #217
Transcript
- 0:00I think there's a lot of opportunity, especially for
- 0:02someone that's looking for the first business.
- 0:04It's a really easy business to start.
- 0:06You can easily run this whole business on 15 hours a week.
- 0:09Every aspiring entrepreneur, they know that having an
- 0:11audience is powerful but 95% of them have no desire to get in
- 0:17front of the camera. It sucks.
- 0:18I feel like this is a great loophole where you can just
- 0:21through Claude, through ChatGPT, use emails to build an audience.
- 0:2435,000 people in a city is more powerful than a million TikTok
- 0:29followers that are world why it is a. $144,000 a year in revenue
- 0:33just on our newsletter ad Instagram.
- 0:36It's 2800 for one post. It's essentially a business that
- 0:39can't lose. The longer I'm in the business,
- 0:41the more money I'm going to make.
- 0:43If I wanted to, in three years, I could run for mayor.
- 0:48Now only the OG fans of this podcast will remember this, but
- 0:52a whole year and a half ago when I first started this podcast, it
- 0:55originally began as a question and answer show and it was live.
- 0:59People would call in, ask me questions about their business
- 1:01or their business idea and I would answer it on the spot.
- 1:03Well, in one of those first episodes, this guy from Canada
- 1:06named Jazz called and he was thrown around this idea for a
- 1:09business and I gave him some advice.
- 1:11He took the advice and now a year later he has a profitable 6
- 1:15figure business on his hands and he just launched another
- 1:17business that's already profitable that piggybacks on
- 1:20that first business that I helped them launch.
- 1:23This is a business that literally anyone could start
- 1:25with almost no money. The path to growth is very clear
- 1:28and outlined in this episode. So let's go I.
- 1:30Think there's a lot of opportunity in local
- 1:32newsletters, you know, especially for someone that's
- 1:35looking for the first business even I would say, right, it's a
- 1:38really easy business to start. And honestly, as step by step as
- 1:42it gets right, Like, yeah, like you're just basically replacing
- 1:46the traditional media and people are looking for something new,
- 1:49so. OK, so why don't we start by you
- 1:51telling me about your local newsletter?
- 1:53Where's it based? How many subscribers do you
- 1:55have? And yeah.
- 1:57Yeah, for sure. So in my local newsletter, it's
- 1:59called Winnipeg Digest. It's most people don't know
- 2:02about Winnipeg, but it's like a cold city here in Canada, in the
- 2:05middle of it. And so I started it here.
- 2:08I've been here for about 11-12 years, you know, and I was
- 2:11looking for my first business to start on my own.
- 2:14Beforehand I had some experience like growing social media
- 2:18followings to like 100K or something when I was 14, selling
- 2:22them to e-commerce companies like theme pages and things of
- 2:25that nature. So wanted to start a business.
- 2:27Had seen Ryan Sneddon, who does it in Annapolis do it and had
- 2:32wanted to start it for a while honestly.
- 2:33And so I thought, OK, it can't really be too difficult.
- 2:37Started it in last year April, so 2024 April and then since
- 2:43then we now reach over 100,000 Winnipeggers.
- 2:46That's a combination of media and newsletters.
- 2:49So we have both 73,000 followers on social media.
- 2:53There's like 800,000 people in Winnipeg right?
- 2:55Yeah, it's about 800 K and then our newsletter is at about
- 2:5835,000 people now, so. OK, so 70 something on social
- 3:0335,000 on newsletter. Yeah, yeah.
- 3:06OK, so that's. Split now and yeah, it's good
- 3:09and we're now trying to start other businesses off of work
- 3:11though. OK, we'll get into that.
- 3:14Trust me. I'm very curious about that now.
- 3:16You live in Winnipeg, right? Yeah, yeah, I live here.
- 3:20How well do you know the market? How long have you been there?
- 3:23I've. Basically grown up here, like
- 3:25I've been here for over 1213 years now.
- 3:27So I know the market fairly well, you know, and Winnipeg
- 3:30isn't necessarily a tech savvy city.
- 3:32I could, you know, it's I kind of make the joke here that I can
- 3:35copy anything off of Twitter and paste it here and it would do
- 3:38well, Yeah. So it's like not a tech savvy
- 3:40city at all, like Calgary or something in Canada.
- 3:44And so, you know, it's a really easy market to start any
- 3:46business here. And so there's low competition.
- 3:49How successful would you be if you took a let's say Austin, TX
- 3:53800,000 people give or take? How successful would you be if
- 3:57you would have taken the exact same playbook and done it in
- 4:00Austin? Austin might be a bad example
- 4:02because they probably have like 100 local newsletter.
- 4:04So ignoring that, just the fact that you were not a local, how
- 4:09would you have done? Yeah, I mean, if I were to
- 4:11personally start it, I would start it somewhere where you do
- 4:14have a first movers advantage, you know.
- 4:17So that's what Winnipeg did so well for me is because there was
- 4:20no not even an Instagram account that just filed all the events
- 4:23here, right, Let alone having a newsletter based on it.
- 4:27So it was a really easy market for me to kind of take a
- 4:31monopoly over. And The thing is now, if anyone
- 4:34else starts at local news that are here in Winnipeg, their cost
- 4:37for acquiring a subscriber is automatically going to be much
- 4:39higher, right? So I would highly recommend if
- 4:42someone is starting one. So I know a few people in Texas
- 4:45that are starting one and they are now targeting suburbs around
- 4:49Austin rather than the actual city of Austin.
- 4:52Yeah, so gun to your head, if you had to choose between a city
- 4:56you were very familiar with but didn't have a first mover
- 4:59advantage and a city that you weren't familiar with but did
- 5:02have a first mover's advantage, which would you choose?
- 5:05Yeah. I mean, I think there's multiple
- 5:06models to go about this. So you can definitely even
- 5:08partner up with someone in another city.
- 5:11I would probably go with the place where I have the first
- 5:14mover's advantage just because acquiring the acquisition cost
- 5:18per subscriber will be much lower, right?
- 5:21Like my house acquiring subscribers for $0.15 Canadian,
- 5:25right? Oh, so like 12-11 cents US?
- 5:29Yeah. So even today, like even today
- 5:30I'm acquiring subscribers for like Max like $1.30 or something
- 5:34like that. Yeah, so.
- 5:37What is your subscriber worth, give or take?
- 5:40Yeah. So they're worth about if I am
- 5:42able to sell every single odd slot in my newsletter for the
- 5:45year and we only do 1 odd slot per newsletter, About 8 to $9 a
- 5:51year is kind of what they're worth at different open rate we
- 5:53have. Per year too and I'm guessing at
- 5:57your normal open rate they're probably going to be around for
- 6:00like 5 plus years. Yeah, easily.
- 6:02Like we have a 0.05% unsubscribe rate or something like.
- 6:07That, jeez, that's so good. So it's like you kind of
- 6:11created, slash, invented this money machine that turns a
- 6:14dollar into 40 or $50 as long as you're willing to be patient.
- 6:18You don't get that immediately. It takes five years to get the
- 6:21LTV lifetime value, but nonetheless, like you created
- 6:25this template and now put in one get out 50A. 100% I mean, it's
- 6:29obviously much easier said than done.
- 6:31Like I think the biggest problem that local newsletters run into
- 6:34is not is not building the audience.
- 6:37Anyone can build the audience. Anyone can turn on Facebook ads
- 6:40and put out in product. The thing that you most likely
- 6:43end up will will have problems with is getting sponsors is
- 6:47selling local businesses on a whole new concept of
- 6:50advertising. Yeah.
- 6:51So I think that's the biggest problem that most folks run into
- 6:54is definitely the anyone can get to 10 to 15,000 Subs anybody.
- 6:58It's just that acquiring sponsors for 10 to 15,000 Subs.
- 7:03Well, here's a perfect example and we're going to get into this
- 7:05when you talk about how you're going to launch a business based
- 7:07on this. If I want to sponsor for this
- 7:10podcast, they're going to pay me, call it $20 per 1000 views,
- 7:14right? If I use Spotify ads, like the
- 7:17annoying ads that Spotify puts in themselves, which I turned on
- 7:21for a week just to test and I'm turning it off, it's $6 per 1000
- 7:25views downloads, which is nothing like that is pennies,
- 7:29right? So $6 from Spotify, $20 if I and
- 7:33or my agent go out and hustle to find sponsors.
- 7:36But if I build my own business that's in this niche, in this
- 7:40vertical, it's relevant to my audience and I put in an ad for
- 7:44it, it's $200 per 1000 views. It's not a, it's a 10X
- 7:49difference, right? Like a 50X difference based on,
- 7:53you know, the lazy way of just putting Spotify mid roll ads
- 7:56for, you know, Toyota, Chevrolet, local dealers, which
- 7:59I'm just not going to do. So there's so much power in
- 8:02having a business mind and having a newsletter or an
- 8:05audience because you can vertically integrate and sell
- 8:08your own stuff and not the local bakery or whatever it is, right?
- 8:11Yeah, it gets me excited, You talking about that?
- 8:14Because like when we started the newsletter, my whole idea was,
- 8:17hey, I'm going to build companies on top of this.
- 8:20And anybody I would talk to would be saying, yeah, but
- 8:22that's like an unrealistic thing.
- 8:24Like, you know, it's tough to obviously run multiple
- 8:25businesses. And I totally understand that.
- 8:28And, you know, we've obviously shifted the vision a little bit,
- 8:30but if you're going to just go sell ads on top of your local
- 8:34newsletter, it's going to be really hard to monetize.
- 8:36Like you will cap out at Max $500,000 a year.
- 8:40Like that is the absolute. Like if you have everything
- 8:43perfect and a great market, you'll still cap out at 500 KA
- 8:47year. But some people are hearing that
- 8:49and thinking I'm cool with that. It's definitely not a side gig
- 8:53or it's not a, it's not a bad place to start, right?
- 8:56But like if you're really trying to make serious money or trying
- 8:58to grow the business, you'd have to vertically integrate with
- 9:01some point. Yeah.
- 9:03OK. So 35,000 subscribers, how many
- 9:06do you send per week? We send out three times a week.
- 9:09OK. How did you land on that?
- 9:10Did you start with that or did you finish with that?
- 9:13Yeah. So I mean, we started with once
- 9:15a week. We felt that there was too much
- 9:18content for us to cover in just a one time a week edition.
- 9:21Then we went to two times a week and this was like in a span of a
- 9:24month by the way. Like this was not, we didn't
- 9:26wait too long. We started once a week, felt
- 9:28there was too much content, then went to two times a week, again,
- 9:31still too much content to cover. Did three times a week, and then
- 9:34we sometimes started running out of content.
- 9:37So we're like, OK, so three times a week cadence is like a
- 9:39good amount where even if one e-mail is shorter than the other
- 9:43two, no one's really complaining about that.
- 9:46Let's talk about your content. Is it like local news?
- 9:49Is it updates? Is it opinion pieces?
- 9:51When we started, I remember Ryan saying this one thing.
- 9:54When we started, it was everything other than crime and
- 9:57politics, and that's exactly what we have run with as well.
- 10:00So it's basically events, community updates, city updates,
- 10:05any new bylaws, anything that is happening in the city basically
- 10:08away from crime and politics is what we promote.
- 10:11OK, now I understand politics. You don't want to alienate half
- 10:15of your subscribers, right? Why not crime?
- 10:17Like we will occasionally talk about it saying something like,
- 10:20oh, the most wanted report has come out for Winnipeg, like, you
- 10:23know, just to make people aware of it.
- 10:25We don't necessarily want to talk about like, you know,
- 10:28someone getting stopped or something like that, right?
- 10:31Especially like. She's not the vibe.
- 10:32Yeah, it's not the vibe. And I mean, Winnipeg is known as
- 10:35like the murder capital of Canada.
- 10:37And so and so because of that reason, we're like, you know
- 10:42what, we're gonna change the narrative.
- 10:45And also from a retelling perspective, it sounds amazing
- 10:48when we say, when we say something like, you know, where
- 10:51everyone says Winnipeg is boring and we're trying to change that
- 10:53narrative. Yeah, I love that.
- 10:56I just had an idea. Like, if you find yourself
- 10:57running out of content, I feel like you could supplement with
- 11:00like opinion pieces like Greg from, you know, from this
- 11:03neighborhood ranks the three best ice cream shops in
- 11:06Winnipeg, you know? Yeah, 100%.
- 11:08And we are now also integrated a lot of our social, like on
- 11:12social, we'll say here the 10 best homes listed in Winnipeg
- 11:15this month or something, right. So you can integrate a lot of
- 11:19that into our newsletter as well.
- 11:21How many words on average are your emails?
- 11:23400 to 2600. So pretty long, pretty big.
- 11:27Yeah, yeah, they're fairly long, but honestly half of it is
- 11:29events because each event like a small description associated
- 11:33with it. What are your open rates and
- 11:35click through rates like today versus first couple months?
- 11:39Yeah. I mean, they've stayed fairly
- 11:41consistent. We've always been above 50%.
- 11:44Click through rate has always been in the ballpark of like 8
- 11:47to 12%. Crazy high, man.
- 11:52Yeah. So opening today is about 56 to
- 11:5560%. So it can vary obviously
- 11:57depending on the set. Yeah.
- 11:58Yeah, Now I've noticed there's like a, there's like a a law of
- 12:02newsletters where the bigger it gets, the more your open rate
- 12:05drops. Like in my experience are are
- 12:08you, have you seen that like did it start in the 60s and then
- 12:10very slowly ticks its way down? Yeah.
- 12:12I mean, it did do that. And then what we started doing
- 12:15was we cleaned our list like two or three times, but that was
- 12:19honestly kind of a mistake on our end.
- 12:21Because sometimes what ends up happening is, for example,
- 12:25Beehive in this case, might be showing that someone is not
- 12:28receiving an e-mail. And they might be sometimes they
- 12:31might be opening an e-mail that is showing that they're not
- 12:33opening an e-mail, right? So it can, so that isn't always
- 12:37fully tracked, right? And so if you start cleaning
- 12:41your list, you might start cleaning people that are
- 12:43actually reading your e-mail. I've had the same mistake.
- 12:45I set up an automation and beehive to clean the list for me
- 12:49and I would just every day I wake up and I see these drops
- 12:51overnight and it's like like is that the right thing to do?
- 12:54And I finally turned it off and I'm just going to do it manually
- 12:57like once every two months. Agreed.
- 12:59I think that's the best way to do it.
- 13:01What is your writing style like? Are are you writing all these
- 13:03emails yourself? What is the vibe of the
- 13:06newsletter? It's super casual.
- 13:08It's like a very, very casual vibe where it's almost like I'm
- 13:11talking to them, you know? It's not written in newsletter
- 13:15jargon. It's a fifth grader reading
- 13:17level, super easy to understand. Even when we're talking about
- 13:20like city bylaws being passed, we're making sure everybody can
- 13:23understand what's happening. And the feedback we get whenever
- 13:27we see a reader out in about it is that that, hey, we love the
- 13:30positive outlook that you have on the city and the
- 13:33conversational tone of your writing.
- 13:36And so that's the way that we've written.
- 13:37It's not any news, news jargon that we're using in there.
- 13:41Yeah, what about AI? Are you using AA to write this
- 13:44or to help write it? Yeah.
- 13:46I mean, if we like started writing this whole thing on our
- 13:48like just ourselves, it would probably take like 8 hours a day
- 13:51or something. So we do definitely use like
- 13:54Claude and ChatGPT. And then I have two VA's who are
- 13:57kind of responsible for, one is responsible for events, the
- 14:00other ones responsible for writing and they kind of do
- 14:03everything, everything for me. So that's why it's a little bit
- 14:05automated. So it was like the first draft
- 14:08through Claude slash JJBT and then a human goes through and
- 14:11cleans it up. Yeah.
- 14:12So they do that and then I go through and usually like late at
- 14:16night, probably 11:12 PM, I'm usually going through final
- 14:19draft, an hour of me looking over, making final changes.
- 14:23It's funny you say like it would take 8 hours a day, but up until
- 14:25two years ago that's what everyone did, right?
- 14:28Yeah, yeah. It's been super helpful for us.
- 14:32We haven't gotten into like automating things just yet, like
- 14:34completely automating things. But that's something that, you
- 14:37know, we're looking into. What is your time involvement
- 14:39per week on this? Because of sponsors, like
- 14:42bringing in sponsors and sending ad drafts and things of that
- 14:45nature. Like it ends up being probably
- 14:47close to 20 hours a week. It used to be a lot more 'cause
- 14:50I used to write every edition and also make a social post and
- 14:53stuff. When we also were growing our
- 14:55social media following, it was very heavy video reels.
- 14:58So it's going out and recording them, editing voice overs.
- 15:02Now we've shifted to completely just carousels, and so that's
- 15:06made our life a lot easier as well.
- 15:08What is your revenue like your monthly revenue today?
- 15:11Yeah, today it's about you can range from 12 to 15,000
- 15:14currently. So that's the general revenue
- 15:16and then amazing. Yeah, it's good.
- 15:18Like we've grown a decent amount out in the last like six months
- 15:22is where a bunch of it's starting to compound now.
- 15:26I always like to use like a rough $0.50 per month per
- 15:29subscriber. It sounds like you're kind of
- 15:31close. Well, actually you might even be
- 15:33above that because that's at $0.05 per week.
- 15:35Yeah. So if you were to extrapolate
- 15:37that out, you'd be probably closer to 60 or $0.70 per
- 15:40subscriber per month if it was 5 per week, right?
- 15:42Yeah, that's about the average that we try and go for.
- 15:45We also haven't explored any of the like negative tabs and
- 15:49things of that nature. Like I think that's something
- 15:51that we would you want to explore eventually.
- 15:53I just haven't gone around with this yet.
- 15:55And for those listening or watching negative CAC is
- 15:58negative customer acquisition cost where instead of paying
- 16:01Facebook for your leads, like you're getting paid for your,
- 16:05your new subscribers, right? And is that kind of like from
- 16:09what I understand that to be you pay Facebook $1.20 for a
- 16:12subscriber and then they go through a flow like they
- 16:15subscribe and then you say hey, check out these newsletters and
- 16:17then once that's done, it's like hey, fill out this form and then
- 16:20you can kind of sell those leads you.
- 16:22Can do that. The way we would most likely go
- 16:24about doing it if we did, it was like let's say if we sold a
- 16:28discount card or something, right?
- 16:29Like go buy this discount card for $20 and get 10% on these 20
- 16:34restaurants or something, right? What what we would do is let's
- 16:37say if we're getting a subscriber for a dollar, right?
- 16:41And so even if one in 10 people convert, right, we're basically
- 16:45making money every single time we're paying Facebook, right?
- 16:49And that's without going to sponsorships at all.
- 16:51That's just like just for seven days basically.
- 16:54Yeah, I think people also call it self liquidating ads, right?
- 16:59Where you make money for acquiring customers and then you
- 17:02you show them ads and make more money.
- 17:03That's the gold standard. Yeah, but it takes time.
- 17:06Like, there's a lot of things at play, right?
- 17:08A. 100% and I mean a lot of things are local newsletters,
- 17:11unlike traditional newsletters where you can just plug other
- 17:14newsletters and you know get them to subscribe to that.
- 17:17The downside with local newsletters is that you can't
- 17:19just plug any any other AI newsletter or something, you
- 17:23know, start making money off of that.
- 17:24It's true, you almost need local offerings that you can offer
- 17:28these readers so it doesn't feel like you're a foreign company or
- 17:31something like that should feel. Yeah, I feel like someone needs
- 17:34to build a Spark loop for local newsletters and for those
- 17:38listening Spark loop. Spark Loop is like a a referral
- 17:41engine for newsletters where you subscribe to the what's the name
- 17:45of your newsletter? Winnipeg Digest.
- 17:48The Winnipeg Digest and then you get a pop up five other
- 17:51newsletters. What you're saying is that there
- 17:53aren't. You don't want to compete with
- 17:54yourself in Winnipeg, so you don't even want to refer them AB
- 17:58there's no one else to refer really.
- 18:00So if there was like a spark loop that could aggregate all
- 18:02the restaurants or auto repair businesses in Winnipeg and you
- 18:06could sell them leads for every time they check that box, right?
- 18:09Wouldn't that be an interesting business?
- 18:11I think that's a really good business, especially because,
- 18:14well, we can also promote other local newsletters, right?
- 18:16Because they're completely different cities and someone
- 18:20living in Winnipeg doesn't care about Austin, TX, right?
- 18:24So that's why I think that's a big problem for at least solving
- 18:28that negative tack issue for us is the, you know, you kind of
- 18:31have to make a custom offering just for your subscribers.
- 18:36Yeah. But like, if I could subscribe
- 18:38to your newsletter and then get like $20 in Kohl's cash for
- 18:42checking a box, therefore become being added to Kohl's e-mail
- 18:46list, that could be pretty valuable for Kohl's and for you,
- 18:49right? Agreed.
- 18:50I think, I think that's a that's a good idea.
- 18:52And then you would obviously have to just put in the put in
- 18:54place those partnerships, right? Yeah, yeah.
- 18:57If you weren't chasing after sponsors, which I know is like
- 19:00most of your time right now, how much time would it be taking per
- 19:03week to run this? Man, like 7 hours a Max
- 19:08probably, yeah, it probably takes about an hour a day for
- 19:13reviewing content for Instagram sending, you know, making sure
- 19:17the content is good for the news that are and things of that
- 19:19nature. Yeah, about 7 hours a week.
- 19:22OK, outside of Claude Chacha Petit, what does your tech stack
- 19:25look like for this? Yeah.
- 19:26I mean, we use Beehive for sending a lot of things Beehive
- 19:30does, right. So I would say analytics and
- 19:33everything we get from Beehive sponsorships, I track everything
- 19:36in Notion. I don't, I haven't really
- 19:39invested in any specific CRM for tracking sponsors.
- 19:43So I've built kind of a semi custom one in Notion.
- 19:47Yeah. Other than that, it's just
- 19:48chassis BT Claude and nothing really other than that.
- 19:52And Instagram is, yeah, nothing significant, Canva.
- 19:55I mean, Beehive is amazing. Do you use like their boost
- 19:59features or any of their other like monetization features?
- 20:01I don't because again, those apps that don't apply to local,
- 20:05it's not a good experience for the reader at the end of the
- 20:07day. And yeah, like we want to make
- 20:09money based, like using the reader as future customers for
- 20:13other businesses. So if we start providing a bad
- 20:16experience, they're going to start opening less.
- 20:17And it's just, you know, downward spiral from there.
- 20:21How much are you testing? Your subject lines or your
- 20:23preview lines, if at all. Yeah.
- 20:25So we're usually, I mean, now I've gone pretty good at
- 20:29basically knowing which ones are going to do well In the
- 20:32beginning, we should test them almost every edition.
- 20:35Now we don't really test them because I know that I
- 20:37automatically almost know which one's going to do better or not.
- 20:41Yeah. Have you noticed that like on
- 20:43the whole shorter just does better shorter subject lines?
- 20:46100% under 5 words like time should be in there.
- 20:49Something like this weekend new. Urgency.
- 20:52Yeah, urgency. And so you know, I would say
- 20:54under 5 words kind under 5 words in under 40 characters.
- 20:58I love that people just want to say everything but it's like
- 21:01you're you're not leaving anything to the imagination.
- 21:04The more you say, the less reason they have to click
- 21:06because you're answering their question, the subject line.
- 21:10I think today's was something like new Winnipeg Costco
- 21:13location. That's it.
- 21:15They click because they want to know where when, right?
- 21:19You could put like, hey, on the corner of X and YA new Costco
- 21:22location opening, you know, August 3rd.
- 21:25How small is too small for a market?
- 21:27Because I know you're in Winnipeg, but you're you live
- 21:29this world, you're talking to other local newsletter
- 21:32operators. What is your experience?
- 21:34Anything under 100K is too small.
- 21:37I would say even 150K you know I would say anything under that is
- 21:41almost too small. So you want to then broaden out,
- 21:43Maybe do your county or something like that.
- 21:46Anything over a million, I almost find it's too much
- 21:49because then you have a weight rich to cover unless you're
- 21:51doing 5 * a week. If you're doing five times, you
- 21:54maybe be able to get away with it.
- 21:56But over a million, you're pretty much pushing it with the
- 22:00amount of things that you can add in there.
- 22:02And it's almost over a million people.
- 22:03The city is so spread out that let's say, I'm not sure with
- 22:07Austin, but someone living in South Winnipeg is probably not
- 22:10going to care about things happening in North Winnipeg.
- 22:13It's like a different world. Exactly.
- 22:14It's almost the different cities at that point, so if you're over
- 22:17a million you should almost have two different newsletters for
- 22:20like splitting the city in half or something like that.
- 22:23Yeah, yeah. What are some other creative
- 22:25customer acquisition strategies if if paid ads just aren't your
- 22:29thing? Yeah.
- 22:30I mean, honestly, like you're like, if you're going to spend
- 22:33$100, I would say $90.00 should be spent on just Facebook ads.
- 22:37You know, if you're going more the creative Rd.
- 22:39Instagram obviously helps you read great success to whether
- 22:42using many chat. We haven't fully explored that
- 22:45Channel. That's something we're now
- 22:46exploring. Referrals are huge though having
- 22:49for example, for us, we do restaurant guides and hiking
- 22:53guides and we change those according to the season that's
- 22:55about to come up. So let's say with the winter,
- 22:57it's going to be top 50 things to do in Winnipeg this winter,
- 23:01right? And so we kind of change that up
- 23:03according to the season. And so referral guides are huge
- 23:06for us as well. Are you more interested in
- 23:09growing horizontally and adding more local newsletters or
- 23:13vertically and just going to five days a week More sponsors
- 23:16like more vertical integration by launching other businesses
- 23:19that you promote with this. Yeah, I mean ideally.
- 23:21So I've kind of considered both channels or both kind of ways.
- 23:26If you go vertically, if you go horizontally, there are other
- 23:30companies that do this like 6:00 PM City and things like that.
- 23:33But I just want your CPMS drop really drop a lot just because
- 23:38then you start having national brands which are not going to
- 23:41pay you $100 per 1000 views, right?
- 23:44And so if you start working with Nike, they're all looking to,
- 23:46they're just going to pay you a lump sum, which is going to be
- 23:49like $10 CPMS, if that. So that's why I find that rather
- 23:53than just going horizontal, I would rather prove out a money
- 23:56model in my own city, right, then go to other cities.
- 24:00So for example, if I start a business on top of this, right?
- 24:04And I know that OK, on average, each subscriber to me, rather
- 24:08than being worth $7.00 now is worth $15 a year, then I'm
- 24:13competing on a whole different game when I go to another city,
- 24:16right? Like let's say if I slap them to
- 24:18Calgary, what's going to happen is when my competitor can only
- 24:22acquire subscribers for maybe $2.00 a sub, I can acquire them
- 24:26for five and still have a great row as on on the customer
- 24:30acquire. OK, Row as return on ad spend.
- 24:34Yeah. And those of those things you,
- 24:35you mentioned CPM, the amount of money you can charge per
- 24:39thousand opens, right? Not per thousand Subs, but opens
- 24:42right. What are you charging nowadays
- 24:44for ads? Where about 70 something dollars
- 24:46like probably $75 CPS wow to for local that's huge for local
- 24:50advertisers and then a lot of them.
- 24:52So we sell annual spots like that's kind of our business
- 24:55model is we sell exclusivity like if anyone is looking to
- 24:59sell sponsorship, don't sell one off sponsorships.
- 25:01You're not going to make money. You want to sell annual
- 25:04sponsorships on an exclusivity basis.
- 25:07So if we work with one HVAC company, we're not working with
- 25:11any other HVAC company for that full year, right?
- 25:14And so you're trying to sell exclusivity is what your main
- 25:17thing you're trying to sell is. So now when we go to a sponsor,
- 25:20we say, hey, you're basically getting a monopoly over 100,000
- 25:25and it's the only form of advertising that lets you do
- 25:28that. And you said only one ad per
- 25:30newsletter, so 19,000 opens per send times 75.
- 25:35You're looking like 1400 for one cent.
- 25:38That's our cost for a one time advertiser.
- 25:42So if if someone's coming in just a one time ad, like they
- 25:45have an event coming up or something, that's what they'll
- 25:47pay. For our Instagram it's double.
- 25:50So it's 2800 for one for one post.
- 25:55Yeah. And then obviously if they're
- 25:56annual subscribe or if they're annual sponsor, they get much
- 26:00better ad rate than $70 per per thousand cents.
- 26:03How much better? Yeah.
- 26:05So right now we're charging about $12,000 for 12 news that
- 26:08arrived, so one per month. One per month, OK.
- 26:11That way you don't like over saturate yourself.
- 26:14They don't see it too often. Yeah, yeah, 100%.
- 26:16And, and what ends up happening is, you know, so we send out,
- 26:19give or take, let's say 12 newsletters per month, times
- 26:23that by $12,000 a month. So that's I think $144,000 a
- 26:28year in revenue just on our newsletter ads.
- 26:31That doesn't even include our Instagram, right.
- 26:35And so, you know, we're kind of looking at in the ballpark of
- 26:37about 200 K when when you kind of combine everything together.
- 26:41And then we're, yeah, we have some other like local markets
- 26:43and stuff that we end up running throughout the year.
- 26:45Yeah. If someone's launching this,
- 26:48like what types of local businesses, local sponsors
- 26:51should they target? Because you probably learned
- 26:53like this. I'm sure this isn't accurate,
- 26:55but like an auto repair store, it may be much more likely to
- 26:57give you money but not get much ROI out of it.
- 27:00So they're not ever going to do a long term thing.
- 27:02Whereas a local bookstore might be really hard to convert, but
- 27:06they see a really big return on investment and therefore could
- 27:08become like a highly recurring customer.
- 27:11What kind of things like that have you learned about the types
- 27:13of sponsors that are best for local newsletters?
- 27:16I would say probably like event venues are great, right.
- 27:20So we have an event venue who is our annual sponsors.
- 27:22They do I think this year they're going to be spending
- 27:24$40,000 a year with us, right? So they're a huge they're
- 27:28probably our biggest advertiser. Other than that I just tell
- 27:31people tell people on LTV just say that hey for.
- 27:35Lifetime value. Yeah.
- 27:36So if let's say a dentist is coming to you or you're talking
- 27:38to a dentist, you have them, right?
- 27:40What's on average a customer worth to you?
- 27:42A customer is worth $5000 to me. Great.
- 27:45So if you're going to spend $10,000 with me, I just need to
- 27:47get you 4 customers for you to double your return on that spend
- 27:51with us, right? And you're telling me I can't
- 27:53get you 4 out of 35,000 people, right?
- 27:57So it's an easy sell to make. Oh, I love that.
- 28:00And honestly, a dentist, a customer for a dentist is
- 28:04probably worth a lot more than that, right?
- 28:05Because they might stay with him for 5 or 50 years. 100% so
- 28:08dentist, HVAC, plumbing, roofing.
- 28:11High ticket stuff, anything or highly recurring.
- 28:14Exactly. And like what we do is we
- 28:16actually run a survey. The second someone signs up,
- 28:18they get straight sent to a survey that they fill out what
- 28:21part of the city they live in. Do they own a home?
- 28:23Not are they looking to sell a home, buy a home, upsell down.
- 28:27Like are they looking to what are they looking to do
- 28:30essentially like what is their current household income?
- 28:33And so that then allows us to go to advertisers and say, hey, 75%
- 28:37of our audience are homeowners. Yeah, that's a very valuable
- 28:41audience for you. So I highly like you know it
- 28:43with it will end up working out for you.
- 28:45What percentage of your subscribers fill out that
- 28:47survey? About 87% like completion rate.
- 28:51Are you serious? 87% fill out the survey.
- 28:54Yeah, So what? That's insanity.
- 28:56Yeah, that is. And how many questions are in
- 28:59it? 8.
- 29:01Holy cow. I would have thought 5%.
- 29:04Yeah, I just. You think local newsletters are
- 29:07built different. They're just so loyal, and
- 29:09they're just like you're contributing to the community.
- 29:12They're like being a good citizen by contributing to your
- 29:15capitalism. Right?
- 29:16But you're not complaining. I mean, I mean, to be, to be
- 29:19fair though, I think if anyone is starting one, please take
- 29:22this from a perspective of when you're bringing on advertisers,
- 29:26don't bring on casinos or clubs. If that's not the vibe you're
- 29:28trying to set right. Short term you might be shooting
- 29:31yourself in the foot returning down revenue, but long term your
- 29:35readers really do appreciate that, you know that they don't
- 29:38have to. Cause your readers are mainly
- 29:40going to be 70% females, 80% females between the ages of 35
- 29:45to 65. They're all looking to learn
- 29:47about clubs and casinos. So you're much better off just
- 29:50like actually hand picking the advertisers that are going to
- 29:54add value to their right as well.
- 29:56But I'll tell you what, that demographic that you just named
- 29:58is like the most valuable demographic.
- 30:00Those are the the spenders in the household.
- 30:02They are right. And that goes back to like the
- 30:05new business that we're starting and how why we have picked that
- 30:08business as well. I'm going to get to that.
- 30:10I'm saving the best for last. What survey tool do you use for
- 30:13that survey? Beehive so you can build a
- 30:15survey Beehive Yeah, it's the it's fairly.
- 30:18Easy. I don't.
- 30:18I have a survey on my newsletter.
- 30:20I feel like an idiot, like I should totally do.
- 30:22That, yeah, that and polls, I think those two are the most.
- 30:25I do polls. Yeah, those are the most used
- 30:27like things that you should probably do in in way if you're
- 30:29running a new site. How successful are you in
- 30:32finding sponsors in your subscriber base?
- 30:34Like putting an ad in there for yourself saying you know your ad
- 30:37here. Does that work?
- 30:38It does sometimes, but for smaller companies, I would say,
- 30:41you know, and that's not really your target audience, though a
- 30:44lot of the larger advertisers are relationships you're
- 30:47building or they'll reach out or something like their marketing
- 30:51coordinator is some 23 year old that follows their Instagram and
- 30:54has no idea that even our news that are even exists.
- 30:57So they'll reach out wanting a feature on the Instagram.
- 31:00I'll hop on the car with them, sell them this whole new world
- 31:03of newsletters, and then actually that's where I get the
- 31:06ad dollars from them from. So it's usually like the foot in
- 31:10the door is like some 23 year old marketing coordinator who
- 31:13was like on their team and thinks it's the cool idea to be
- 31:15featured on Instagram. Are there any like other perks
- 31:18like local perks like priority seating or you ever get
- 31:22recognized any intangibles like that?
- 31:24Yeah. So I mean, when I had my face
- 31:26associated with the brands in the beginning, we did a lot of
- 31:29reels. That's how I grew the Instagram
- 31:31following pretty heavily. We did a lot of reels, a lot of
- 31:34restaurant reviews and things of that nature.
- 31:36So I would be recognized like 5-6 times a day.
- 31:39That's amazing. Yeah, like I would be at the
- 31:41gym. Was that cool?
- 31:41It was. Cool.
- 31:42For sure. But then I kind of it was also
- 31:45concerning at the same time because I was like, OK, if I
- 31:49sell this, if I ever want to sell this thing, I can't have my
- 31:51face associated with it. So that's why we switched more
- 31:54to carousels, a way where I disassociated my face from it
- 31:58and then I can it's becomes a sellable asset at the end of the
- 32:01day. Yeah, that's fair.
- 32:03All right. So you're dabbling in Christmas
- 32:05lights, is that right? That's the new business we're
- 32:07starting out. OK.
- 32:08Yeah. Well, is that the business or
- 32:10have you done other like vertically integrated businesses
- 32:13for this? No.
- 32:14So that's like our first business on top of this.
- 32:17Yeah, it was the thinking behind it was it's seasonal, it works
- 32:21great. It doesn't, we forget about it,
- 32:23right. Second thing is, is that it's
- 32:26high LTV customers. So let's say it's a leasing
- 32:28model, so you don't sell the Christmas lights, right?
- 32:31So when we lease the Christmas lights out to them, they're
- 32:33usually staying with us for another four or five years,
- 32:36right? Or even like let's say three
- 32:37years. So we end up making a lot more
- 32:39money on them in the following years.
- 32:42And then if it works out great, then a natural upsell into it
- 32:46would be permanent lights. So those are the lights that go
- 32:49in your under. Jellyfish.
- 32:50Yeah, Yeah. So would be the permanent lights
- 32:53that kind of go underneath your gutters and stuff like that,
- 32:55right? And so that's kind of the plan
- 32:57is OK, if it works out great. Come next spring, we're going to
- 33:00start the permanent lights business.
- 33:02And then also we have a lot of females obviously, that are
- 33:04readers. That's our primary reader.
- 33:07And I was like, man, if I go and start a HVAC or roofing company
- 33:10or something, you know, if someone's heat goes out, they're
- 33:12not going to say, let me pull up Winnipeg Digest and find the
- 33:16plot, like, you know, find the HVAC tech.
- 33:18So Christmas lights, it was great because I feel like
- 33:21females are primarily the ones making that decision and that's
- 33:24exactly what's happened as well. So we started running some ads
- 33:27in the Winnipeg Digest have already sold like 5-6 jobs
- 33:32before the season has even started at all before the main
- 33:35season kind of kicks in. So.
- 33:37One piece of advice, take it or leave it.
- 33:39I have a friend that has a Christmas light slash, roofing
- 33:41slash. He has several different
- 33:43successful big home service businesses in Pennsylvania and
- 33:47he says like stay away from permanent lighting, stay away
- 33:50from jellyfish. He says he only installs it if
- 33:54someone like demands it and he can't have them as a customer
- 33:56any other way because it's just a one time thing And then he's
- 34:00sometimes he has to go out there and maintain it and fix it and
- 34:02he just hates his life every time he he says if he could have
- 34:05it his way, permanent lights were never installed and he only
- 34:09does Christmas lights on the leasing program every year.
- 34:11All right. So when you put this ad in your
- 34:14own newsletter for your other business, are you calling it
- 34:17your other business? Or is it does it seem just like
- 34:19a third party entirely? Yeah, right now, I mean, we
- 34:22ended up doing. So what we did is we ran a
- 34:25giveaway. I had heard it in some like Alex
- 34:27or Mosey video or something where he mentioned run a
- 34:30giveaway, give one thing away and call everybody else and say,
- 34:33hey, you get $150.00 off for just entering the giveaway.
- 34:36So with that got about 300 entries or something like that.
- 34:40This is a giveaway for free Christmas lights.
- 34:42Exactly, yeah. And then we call the OK, just
- 34:44lights the company, no website, nothing like that at all.
- 34:48But when we do do the. Brad, just.
- 34:50Lights. It's going to be the same colors
- 34:52as Winnipeg Digest. Yeah, I love that you're just
- 34:56leaning into it. Yeah, right.
- 34:57Like support. You're supporting the newsletter
- 34:59by going through me for your Christmas lights.
- 35:01You're probably going to go through Someone Go through me.
- 35:03Yeah. And then now what we're doing
- 35:05is, you know, we can run offers that kind of make it seem like
- 35:07they're exclusive for the readers.
- 35:09So we'll say something like, hey, get your Christmas lights
- 35:12done before October 7th and you get $150.00 off or something,
- 35:16right? The press point for us is our
- 35:18season doesn't start until October 15th anyways.
- 35:21So anything that we do before that is just extending our
- 35:23season more and more. Yes, yeah, yeah.
- 35:27Now are you planning on like running this?
- 35:29Like are you outsourcing it to another company?
- 35:31Tell me how the operations of this looks.
- 35:33In an ideal world, what I would like to do is kind of have
- 35:36Winnipeg Digest as a marketing arm for multiple businesses.
- 35:40So let's say I either acquire equity or I get get the given
- 35:44equity into businesses, whether that's 1520%, of course,
- 35:48depending on the size of the business.
- 35:50And we end up becoming like a fully fractional CMO type of
- 35:54situation where we, they get access to Winnipeg Digest, they
- 35:58get access to me, right? And then we handle all their
- 36:01marketing for them, right. And then in return we get some
- 36:04sort of equity share in it. That's the ideal world
- 36:07situation. But to go to a Business Today
- 36:09and a local business owner and say, Hey, give me 1520% of your
- 36:13business, that's kind of they're not going to believe in the fact
- 36:16that, hey, we can actually deliver that value for that.
- 36:19So that's why we started our own business for now at least that's
- 36:22the Christmas lights 1 where we're going to run everything.
- 36:25So I did a, my first install yesterday and the yeah.
- 36:29And so then the plus point about this is I am learning obviously
- 36:33the skill set of putting the Christmas lights and stuff.
- 36:35And then this is the only company will ideally own.
- 36:38And then after this, this kind of proves that the model that
- 36:41hey, this works for home services and then we're able to
- 36:44acquire equity into other home services after this.
- 36:47Yeah, OK. Of all the businesses out there,
- 36:50what made you think Christmas lights?
- 36:52Yeah, I mean, it's biggest thing was it's the it's seasonality,
- 36:55right, so. But most people look at that as
- 36:58a negative, right? Yeah, for me, it was, well, I
- 37:00have a primary business which is Winnipeg.
- 37:02I just, I can, I don't have to take away too much time away
- 37:07from this. It's just 10 weeks.
- 37:09I give 10 weeks. If it works out great, amazing,
- 37:11I double down. If it doesn't then I'm just
- 37:14going to forget about it like it never existed and there's no
- 37:17website or anything for it yet, so.
- 37:19OK. I like that.
- 37:20Yeah, yeah. What are the unit economics of
- 37:23these jobs? What's an average job size?
- 37:25What are you going to take home per job?
- 37:27I know it's varies from year to year.
- 37:28There's higher costs on year 1. Can you break all that down?
- 37:31Yeah. I mean this is just our
- 37:32obviously first year doing it. We've booked five job the last
- 37:35week, about $1400 is our average job right now.
- 37:40Cost of doing that job for us is most likely going to be like two
- 37:43$300.00. But like The thing is, The thing
- 37:47is we're actually doing the labor right now ourselves,
- 37:49right. So as owner operated, so that
- 37:52pricing takes into account in the future when we do end up
- 37:55hiring labor and everything like that and the following years of
- 37:59I think on average, the average is about 85% for the amount of
- 38:03customers that stay on year over year.
- 38:06Wow. OK.
- 38:06So that 2 to 300 that includes the lights or just labor?
- 38:10No 3, it's about 300 dollars, $300 is it just includes the
- 38:14lights. OK.
- 38:15So you're, you're not like counting your labor as a cost.
- 38:18All I heard is you know $6000 of net profit, you know, for on
- 38:22five jobs. Yeah, yeah.
- 38:24So it's, it's fairly high, at least right now.
- 38:27And then they take about fourish hours to do, 3-4 hours to do,
- 38:31which is not terrible for the first year.
- 38:33Second year, we've already cut them, cut the lights for them
- 38:36and already have the bulbs free screwed.
- 38:38So it's like, you know, that kind of time gets fed into half.
- 38:41What are you going to have to pay in labor to have that 4 hour
- 38:43job done once you do start hiring people?
- 38:46Yeah, I mean, they'll be just minimum wage.
- 38:47It won't be. Crazy $100 in labor per job,
- 38:50give or take. It's about $15.00 an hour, you
- 38:53know, give or take. Let's just say, you know, three
- 38:56people doing a job rate should take 3 hours.
- 38:59So yeah, like you ever take 150 bucks?
- 39:01Wow. OK, let's say year 2, you, you
- 39:05stop doing it yourself, you hire it all out.
- 39:07You basically you don't have the COGS, the cost of goods sold,
- 39:10the hard cost anymore. Now you have the labor cost, but
- 39:12it's half as much. So if you have call it 80%
- 39:15margins year one, even if you outsource all the labor year 2
- 39:19plus, you have 90% margins. Yeah, My goal is not to run the
- 39:23business myself for sure. I will definitely be bringing in
- 39:26an operator where I can get them to like best equity or something
- 39:29over a few years. Of course there'll be a whole
- 39:31new world of problems, but it'll be fun, you know, I think, I
- 39:35think it'll be fun where, you know, I don't want to run the
- 39:37Christmas lights business at the end of the day.
- 39:39Right, but I say this all the time, like it's important that
- 39:42people get to know the weeds before they outsource, you know,
- 39:45these core competencies and get out of the weeds.
- 39:47Like people are like, oh, I heard a guy on the Internet say
- 39:50I did outsourcing. This isn't this is I'm above
- 39:53this. I'm a no you, you got to know.
- 39:55Exactly what those weeds look. Like, until you're ready to get
- 39:58out of them. Exactly, which is why I decided
- 40:01to do the jobs myself this first year.
- 40:03Easily I could have like hired someone just using the cash flow
- 40:06from Winnipeg Digest like it wouldn't be too difficult.
- 40:09It's just that down the road I don't want someone saying that
- 40:12it took 7 hours when I should have taken 3.
- 40:14Like, bro, I've been on that ladder, I know what you're
- 40:17doing. Yeah, so that's why, that's the
- 40:20simple reason why I was like, you know what, first year, it's
- 40:2310 weeks. I just won't have a life for 10
- 40:26weeks. That's totally fine.
- 40:27Yeah, OK. How many jobs do you think
- 40:30you'll do this year based on what your conversion rates are
- 40:32looking like? Yes.
- 40:34I mean, we sucked that sales for the first like 7-8 quotes that
- 40:38we gave out. And then now we've started
- 40:40converting like I think in the last like 6 jobs, we have like
- 40:44we've converted four of them or in the last 6 quotes, we've
- 40:46converted four of them. I think I am very safely saying
- 40:50that we'll hit $100,000 in revenue in the first year.
- 40:54Cheers. I think so.
- 40:55At least that's not. How did you get better at sales?
- 40:59How did you suck before versus what you're doing today?
- 41:02Yes. I mean, we would just go in
- 41:03before and trying to close them on the like at the door, you
- 41:06know, and we would have a pre like we would book an
- 41:08appointment like a design consult and they would come out
- 41:12and we would literally just trying to close them there.
- 41:14And I didn't realize that, OK, that's what we shouldn't do.
- 41:17So then I practiced them, a friend of mine who did, who did
- 41:21painting. So he did door to door painting,
- 41:23like student painting or something like that.
- 41:25And so he's like, yo, if you have a design console booked,
- 41:28you're going to go inside their home, sit with them, showcase
- 41:31them the mock up before and after, walk them through your
- 41:35booklet and then you're going to price anchor them to this price,
- 41:38right? They just the whole shebang,
- 41:40right? And so that's kind of what we've
- 41:41started doing now where we go in and we have the quoted like
- 41:44$3000 or something that includes all the trees and the home and
- 41:49the side of the home. And we slowly go with them and
- 41:51take out everything and it gets to like $1500.
- 41:55And then I'm like, OK, if you book before October 7th, you get
- 41:58$150.00 discount today, right now, right?
- 42:00And so that's what we've started doing now.
- 42:02Yeah. And you're closing like 6070% of
- 42:05that? That's the number that will end
- 42:06up at it after the season, right, 6070%?
- 42:09Now please tell me you're asking for referrals.
- 42:12Yeah, so would. Neighbor Neighbors names.
- 42:15So what we're doing is there is a Christmas lights person on
- 42:18Twitter, he always says this. So it's like $100 the gift card
- 42:22or something to a steakhouse or something along those lines.
- 42:25So we're not starting to offer those right now.
- 42:27We're just getting all of our stuff still printed.
- 42:29Like it's way early in the season.
- 42:31Most people start advertising for this like September 15th.
- 42:34So we're way too early anyways. Like the homes that we have
- 42:38done, we haven't asked directly for referrals yet, but we will
- 42:41when we finish the job. I mean, you have no clue.
- 42:44Your conversion rate will only get better through September,
- 42:48October, November even, right? So whatever it is today, we'll
- 42:51get orders of magnitude better. Yeah, and these are all, but
- 42:53these are like there's pros and cons because all these are leads
- 42:56coming through Winnipeg died just currently.
- 42:58So they're kind of worn leads already.
- 43:00If we start exploring Facebook ads and stuff, those leads are
- 43:03going to be a lot more colder. So our current rate should drop
- 43:07there a little bit. Are you going to do other stuff
- 43:09like that? Yeah.
- 43:10We're not just going to rely on your newsletter.
- 43:12We're going to do everything, yeah.
- 43:13We're trying to $100,000 is like what do we want to do base level
- 43:17over the weeks? If we're able to do 152 hundred,
- 43:20that would be like ideal world, yeah.
- 43:23It's blows my mind that you're going to come close to doubling
- 43:25your revenue by adding Christmas lights to a newsletter.
- 43:28Like, who would have thought of that?
- 43:29Ryan Snedden added luxury wedding bathroom trailers to his
- 43:33newsletter. And like, that became a big
- 43:35business, right, 'cause events, right, events.
- 43:38That's what you said too. I already know that you're
- 43:40thinking of the spring and the summer.
- 43:42What other kind of seasonal and or other businesses are you
- 43:45thinking for this? I know that it like very not
- 43:48like a lot of people do the whole gutter cleaning, window
- 43:50cleaning thing in the summer. And yeah, I don't want to get
- 43:53into the whole door to door hassle of it.
- 43:55Honestly, I am not a great salesperson training guy and I
- 43:59might be able to become one, but I'm not that right now.
- 44:02My bread and butter is like marketing where I do Facebook
- 44:05ads and things of that nature, but I want to explore businesses
- 44:09which I can utilize that in, you know?
- 44:11And so most likely that's why permanent lights was a natural
- 44:15sell. Also because a lot of Christmas
- 44:17light owners, what ends up happening is they'll say, hey,
- 44:20we're actually 5050 on whether we want Christmas lights or not,
- 44:24right? Because we're considering
- 44:25permanent lights and the permanent lights average order
- 44:28value is about four to 5X whatever Christmas lights is
- 44:31obviously LTV. No, but just a one time cost.
- 44:35So what we're able to do is bring in someone for Christmas
- 44:38light. So let's say first season we
- 44:40make some money on them and then say OK, if you do permanent
- 44:44lights with us the following year, you get $500 discount.
- 44:46So we're basically just pre selling customers for permanent
- 44:49lights during the Christmas light season, right.
- 44:52And rather than making that money over three years, we're
- 44:56just going to make that money over 2 years because they're
- 44:58going to do first of Christmas lights, then they're going to do
- 45:00permanent lights the following season.
- 45:02Smart. I should have asked this
- 45:04earlier, but what what has your timeline look like with your
- 45:07newsletter and like subscriber growth?
- 45:09When did you launch? How many Subs did you add those
- 45:12first few months to today? Yeah.
- 45:14I mean, in the beginning we were adding like 4000 ish Subs a
- 45:17month, 4 or 5000 actually. Now it's decreased to like
- 45:212:00-ish K, give or take, where, you know, we're still spending
- 45:24the same amount of money. So it's about $3000.
- 45:27But then, yeah, you start like saturating your market and
- 45:29things like that. So now pretty soon, I think like
- 45:32it might be time where I just turn off ads and try and spend
- 45:35that money on referrals or something.
- 45:37But if we can do whether that's giveaways or lead magnets or
- 45:40something like that for referrals and just try and get
- 45:43more subscribers that way, I think that might be the next
- 45:46thing we try to go into. So how many months to get to
- 45:4935,000? It's been, yes, we started in
- 45:51April, whatever that is. I think like 17 months or
- 45:53something like that. 16-7 months, yeah.
- 45:56That's amazing. At this time, no plans to launch
- 45:58other local newsletters. You want to keep growing this
- 46:00way. I've had a lot of interest from
- 46:02other cities for sure, just because I talk about local
- 46:05newsletters on Twitter and I've kind of, and obviously I've been
- 46:08on your part and Nick's part and stuff.
- 46:10So I've had a lot of interest of people saying, hey, can we
- 46:13franchise this out or something like that.
- 46:15It's just that I know my dollars will be much better spent trying
- 46:19to vertically integrate this currently, right?
- 46:21Like so Christmas lights took $10,000 of initial capital to
- 46:25start. If I started another location
- 46:28instead of Christmas lights, Christmas lights I might do
- 46:30$100,000 in 10 weeks. The new location would have
- 46:34taken me twenty $30,000 to then on sponsors make like fifty
- 46:38$60,000 the first year. And then once I'm able to prove
- 46:42out a money model at least in my city.
- 46:44So let's say if I know, OK, I'm going to on average make
- 46:47$200,000 from just the newsletter and then another 2 to
- 46:50500,000 from Christmas lights. I might not even explore other
- 46:54businesses after that. It might just be, OK, that's the
- 46:57business model. I'm going to go to other cities
- 47:00and start, yeah, start the media company based on the media
- 47:04company, start Christmas lights. That's it.
- 47:06Yeah, yeah, yeah. Do you feel confident that you
- 47:09could as of today with what you know now, pick another city, not
- 47:12move there, not know really anything about it and have just
- 47:15as much success? A. 100% I could, yeah.
- 47:18Like once you've been in the space for over a year, a year
- 47:20and a half. And I think for me, the USP is
- 47:24the unique selling point would be the social media aspect of
- 47:27things. So social media, if anyone is
- 47:29going to start this, don't forget about social media
- 47:32because at this point I'm a top three followed, let's say
- 47:35account in my city, right? If I reach out to an account or
- 47:39a business, they're almost obligated to reply to me.
- 47:43So it makes my cold outreach so much easier and the reply rate
- 47:47just skyrockets rather than me mailing them.
- 47:50So if you're going to go down this road also, social media is
- 47:54a great way to upsell your current sponsors into saying,
- 47:56hey, I have two different that you can reach, right?
- 48:00So that's the unique selling point if you are going to start
- 48:03one. Yeah, dude, you, you got to
- 48:05reach out to local businesses that collect emails and say,
- 48:08hey, I'll do a, I'll give you a free ad in exchange for your
- 48:11list. Like let me share your list
- 48:13basically, right, Because they're probably not using it.
- 48:15Most companies that collect emails, they just sit there.
- 48:18They don't do because it takes work right, to regularly work
- 48:22your list. So a lot of them are going to be
- 48:24dead. But you can say I'm going to run
- 48:25them through a verifier and you can either pay them, you know,
- 48:28$0.10 per e-mail, or just say I'll give you $2000 worth of ads
- 48:32for your 20,000 person list and they have no idea what it's
- 48:35worth. Like would you just add them to
- 48:37your list like rather than I guess sending an e-mail saying
- 48:39hey, subscribe? I would just feel, feel it out.
- 48:43Yeah. Like, try multiple angles, like
- 48:45segment the list and let's say it's 20,000.
- 48:47You take four groups of 5000 to 1.
- 48:50You just say, hey, you know, I partnered with Mike's Bakery and
- 48:53I would really like you to check out my local newsletter, 5000.
- 48:57You just kind of work them into your list, segment them
- 48:59differently so you could track them, make sure they're cleaned
- 49:01and scrubbed. How many are opening?
- 49:03Well, it's not bad. OK.
- 49:04And then the other two 10,000 try different kind of creative
- 49:07things. It's a time game, right?
- 49:10Like I love this is obviously my first or second business, but
- 49:14I've heard a lot that businesses that are just a time game are
- 49:17the best businesses to be in. Because as long as I'm just in
- 49:20this business and my list keeps growing, it's essentially a
- 49:23business that can't lose. It's an audience that I can not
- 49:27only monetize through ads, but then I can run my own businesses
- 49:29on it. So it's just a time business.
- 49:32As long the longer I'm in the business, the more money I'm
- 49:35going to make. Oh.
- 49:36Man, I just kind of had a thought where it's like every
- 49:40aspiring entrepreneur or entrepreneur or entrepreneur,
- 49:42business owner, whatever, they know that having an audience is
- 49:45powerful, but 95% of them have no desire to get in front of the
- 49:50camera and to do all that stuff because it sucks.
- 49:52It's hard, and I've been there, right?
- 49:54So they don't even consider it. They're like, I know having an
- 49:56audience is valuable, but not for me.
- 49:58I feel like this is a great loophole into that right where
- 50:02you can just through the power of the written word, through
- 50:04Claude, through Chad GBT, through a virtual agent or or
- 50:07virtual assistant, you can use emails to build an audience
- 50:11without having to get in front of the camera, but you can still
- 50:13have all that power. Like it's like 35,000 people in
- 50:17a city is more powerful than a million TikTok followers that
- 50:21are worldwide. It is.
- 50:23I joke around with some of my friends.
- 50:25I'm like, if I wanted to in three years, I could run for me,
- 50:28right? Like if.
- 50:29Yeah, I could. Have enough pull in the city to
- 50:33be able to run for me, right? But yeah, I think I completely
- 50:36agree with what you said. Because the biggest problem
- 50:39people run into when looking to make content is what do I talk
- 50:42about? In this case, you already have
- 50:44what you're going to talk about because things are happening in
- 50:47your local town. Fresh content every day.
- 50:49Yeah, exactly. And this is a business at the
- 50:53very base level, the writing and all that stuff can be given out
- 50:57to one or two BAS and they can handle 90% of the business for
- 51:01you. And all you really have to do is
- 51:03deal with sponsorships. If you're not even able to, you
- 51:05know, give that up. If you were, if you are able to
- 51:08also delegate that, then good on you.
- 51:10You know, so it's not a business where you need 40 hours a week
- 51:13in the beginning of spending 40 hours a week to write and also
- 51:16do sponsorships. But as you continue to grow, you
- 51:19can easily run this whole business on 15 hours a week.
- 51:23I just feel like this, you know, under an hour video is probably
- 51:28about as tactical and specific as you could get on the Internet
- 51:31for launching a local newsletter.
- 51:34IA 100% agree and honestly if anyone is going to throw one
- 51:37they can reach out to like the local news that are community is
- 51:40fairly friendly and you can reach out to anyone and and
- 51:44other than that just go to Facebook ads library search up
- 51:48any local news that you can search up my local news that are
- 51:50Winnipeg Digest. Now, what's the 8020 of your
- 51:53best performing ads video Instagram.
- 51:55Facebook 15 second. It's simply at the top usually
- 52:00have some sort of a local monument as the background video
- 52:03or image test boats. I would say video has done
- 52:07better for me, some sort of a drone footage of a local
- 52:09monument. Then at the top it says
- 52:13struggling to find things to do in Blank city, right.
- 52:16So let's say struggling to find things to do in Winnipeg
- 52:19underneath it. Say Winnipeg Digest or Blank
- 52:22Newsletter sends you 50 plus events happening in the city
- 52:26every single week. That's it.
- 52:28That is the best performing ads that you will probably find.
- 52:32One thing I love about this business is how like, let's say
- 52:35you're once a week, you can start there.
- 52:36It's very palatable. You do it yourself, you sell out
- 52:39your ads. The easiest lever to pull is now
- 52:42twice a week. Cool, I just doubled my revenue
- 52:45three times a week. Tripled it 4-5 Why not 7?
- 52:48Let's do 7. And if you're running out of
- 52:50like current events you just do opinion pieces and if even new.
- 52:53York or something like a really large city and you don't know
- 52:56how to split things up. You can also like almost niche
- 53:00down twice. So you already niche down
- 53:02geographically and then you can do dads in New York, you can do,
- 53:07you can do. Freelancer.
- 53:09In New York, Yeah, like Freelancer in New York, because
- 53:12each of those audiences is going to be a million people on its
- 53:14own if they're more in larger cities.
- 53:18So if I lived in Austin, I would have just done something like
- 53:22Young Dads in Austin or something like that.
- 53:24Alone is probably like 1000 people.
- 53:25Or yeah, I mean, I, I'd be so bold as to say you'd be dumb to
- 53:29be in New York and just do a New York local newsletter.
- 53:32Like you're just nothing to no one in that sense, right?
- 53:34Exactly, Yeah. Like you, you could do like a
- 53:36Williamsburg moms like pick a neighborhood, pick a yeah
- 53:40demographic. 100% and just, and the higher obviously and your,
- 53:44your audience, the more, the more expensive sponsors you can
- 53:49sell, right? That's the biggest thing.
- 53:51Only downside to New Year in newsletters that will say is you
- 53:54might run out of sponsors eventually, you know, if you
- 53:58keep providing a great result, yeah, OK, you're obviously
- 54:01always going to have those core sponsors.
- 54:03So you'll have a hundred, 150, two, $100,000 worth of revenue
- 54:06coming in. But if that's your goal, go
- 54:08ahead, start one. But you should probably look at
- 54:11ways to monetize on top of the news that are eventually.
- 54:15Jazz, this was great. Where can we look for you if we
- 54:18have questions? Yeah.
- 54:20Twitter handle is creating jazz so feel free to reach out if you
- 54:23guys have any questions and happy to chat with whoever wants
- 54:26to jam on some local news that are ideas.
- 54:28Yeah, and for the 14 listeners in Winnipeg, Canada, go check
- 54:31out the Winnipeg Digest. Yeah, and reach out to me and
- 54:34maybe we can grab coffee. Yeah, OK.
- 54:37Thanks, Jess. Yeah.
- 54:38Thank you. Hey guys, if you're still
- 54:39listening to this, it's probably because you haven't had a chance
- 54:43to take your Airpods out, you're still mowing the lawn, you're
- 54:45still driving, what have you. If you're still here with me, I
- 54:48would really, really love and appreciate a five star review on
- 54:51Spotify, Apple, or wherever you get your podcast.
- 54:54It would mean a lot. If you want to go the extra
- 54:56mile, share this episode with a friend that might have an
- 54:59interest in starting a business. It would mean a ton.
- 55:02Hope you have the best day of your life today.