Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Duggar Family Deep Dive (Chapter 10)
Transcript
- 0:00So Burto, I thought we would take a break from playing Balder's Gate three
- 0:05and actually do chapter ten in our deep dive on the Dugger family and the
- 0:11Christian cult, which is IBLP and other topics related to that. What do
- 0:15you say, Burto? Why don't we do it while we play? This
- 0:18is the Psychology and Seattle Podcast. I'm your host, doctor Kirk Conda.
- 0:22Psychology and Seattle. Is the shirt that you can get that shirt online on
- 0:27our merch page. Situation and who are you? Berto? My name is
- 0:32and I watch the Watchers so very recently, just yesterday, a story broke
- 0:38about a YouTube vlogger family vlogger who was arrested for child abuse. And at
- 0:47the time of this recording, it's it's September one, and I'm guessing they'll
- 0:50be subsequent details that will be released that we don't know about at this date.
- 0:55But since we talked at length about child labor laws in general, and
- 1:00then child labor laws in Hollywood, and then the lack of any child labor
- 1:04laws in reality TV and in YouTube vloggers and influencers, I thought it was
- 1:11fitting that this that we talk about this since since it just happened and it
- 1:17very it's you know, the other situations might be a little the gray area.
- 1:22This is not in the gray area. This one is the If we
- 1:26want to hold up one story as why we need these laws and these regulations
- 1:33and these regulating institutions of government, it's highlighting this case. And as we
- 1:40go through this, take note that this is the one that got caught and
- 1:44the one that is famous enough to be noticed. You know, the the
- 1:48amount of other families that are going through stuff like this around the world.
- 1:52I mean, imagine when this starts to and probably already has infiltrate places where
- 1:57children are much more exploitable, and there's even fewer institutional oversight, and you
- 2:02know, just imagine the exploitation that can happen. Not to mention this other
- 2:07than the recent this has been going on for years, this one with people
- 2:10reporting them constantly, right, So let's get into it. So we're of
- 2:15course talking about Ruby Frankie, who is the mother of this and the main
- 2:21producer of this YouTube channel called eight Passengers. It is a family vlog.
- 2:27It's her, Ruby and her husband Kevin, and their six children, their
- 2:30Mormon their white blonde blue eyes. You know, that's kind of the trend
- 2:35on YouTube. I'm guessing they're the ones that rise at the top if you're
- 2:38you know, ultra mainstream, white and wholesome kind of seeming. For some
- 2:44reason, I think they become more popular. I think someone commented somewhere because
- 2:50I, you know, I mentioned that some of the other vloggers were white
- 2:53and blond, and they're like, is there something wrong with being white and
- 2:55blonde? No, there's nothing wrong with being white and blonde. My mom
- 2:59is white and blonde, blue eyes, so there's nothing wrong with that.
- 3:01It's just that it is I think important to situate it within society because you
- 3:07know, being white and blonde and blue eye, there's something wrong with you,
- 3:12of course, but the way in which you're responded to, the signaling
- 3:17that these vloggers will often engage in regarding that they're the real Americans or they're
- 3:25wholesome because of the way that they look, the kind of things that they
- 3:30emphasize, the associations that people have with them. You know, it is
- 3:34part of the story, right, But yeah, I mean, just being
- 3:38white and blonde and blue eyed. Yeah, it's it's you're it's great,
- 3:43let's celebrate it. Sony eight Passengers, Ruby Frankie two and a half million
- 3:47subscribers at one point, and the content often involves their activities, their travels,
- 3:54and homeschooling, and they come across as very wholesome and family or orianted.
- 4:00There were some controversies in the past where Ruby transitioned away from her channel
- 4:05to be with another channel called Connections. And this channel, and this business
- 4:11called Connections was with another woman named Jody. Her last name is escaping me
- 4:17right now, it's in my notes somewhere. But so Ruby and Jody were
- 4:23running this YouTube channel and it's about offering parenting advice and training, and seemingly
- 4:29they were espousing a model of parenting that was harsher than the mainstream American way.
- 4:38Like, for example, she talks about there's this video of her she's
- 4:43taking a selfie video. She's in her car and her child forgot to make
- 4:46lunch for school, one of her teenagers, I think, And the school
- 4:53what, no, it's one of the little ones. Oh okay, well
- 4:56yeah, okay, So one of the little children forgot to make lunch for
- 4:59school, and the school called Ruby the mom saying, oh, you know,
- 5:03your kid forgot to make or it doesn't have a lunch, So how
- 5:06about you bring a lunch? And so Ruby makes this video saying that she's
- 5:12she's going to teach her child a lesson essentially by not bringing a lunch to
- 5:15her and that the fact that she's going to be hungry will teach her a
- 5:20lesson that she needs to comply and make. You know, she was supposed
- 5:24to make a lunch in the morning. And the and Ruby Frankie is saying,
- 5:28I hope that no one gives her food because that will negate the punishment
- 5:32if you will. What do you what do you think about that? So
- 5:38you know, it's happened to me where I drop off my seven year old
- 5:42and when I'm getting home, I'm realizing, oh gosh, darn ittt I
- 5:47you know, we forgot to put our lunch box in the bag or whatever.
- 5:50Right, The thought has never in my live crossed of thinking, well,
- 5:58I mean, one day, it's not going it's obvious not to mention,
- 6:01like the school would be horrified, like what how could I show my
- 6:06face there? Again? So I don't understand it's comprehensible to yeah, it's
- 6:13the tipathy eyes. And to be clear, this video was posted way before
- 6:17she was arrested this and this was just out there. And what this tells
- 6:23you along those lines of what you're saying, is like, well, if
- 6:25this is what she's willing to do in front of public, the public and
- 6:30the school, which will be likely to push back on this, imagine what
- 6:35she's doing behind closed doors. And also imagine you know, even if you,
- 6:40as a parent, thought that this would be a good idea, which
- 6:43would be horrible. But if you thought this was a good idea, most
- 6:46people would say, well, but I don't want the school to think I'm
- 6:49a horrible I don't want them to call in CP. Yeah I think so,
- 6:53yeah, so So the arrogance and the self assuredness that you would have
- 6:58to possess in your personality, and the disregard for disapproval from other people,
- 7:04you know, this is in the direction of a personally sort I don't know
- 7:08that, but you know there are signs later on. But anyway, another
- 7:12by way, she made a video later talking about a parent teacher conference and
- 7:15how and she's like, well, you know, the teacher, of course,
- 7:18brought up the whole lunch thing, and you know there's these questions like,
- 7:24oh am I being you know, am I being a bad parent?
- 7:27Am I being abusive? No? I'm not? Yeah, end of story.
- 7:30Yeah yeah, yeah. So it's there was that video that she posted,
- 7:36and again this is her reporting it herself. She's she's proud, and
- 7:44her whole thing on the internet is that her family is perfect and that she
- 7:48is an expert on parenting. Another example is that she punished a child by
- 7:54taking away his bedroom, one of the teenage boys for seven months and he
- 7:59slept on the floor in the family room. And now we don't know the
- 8:01circumstances around that, but the way that it is discussed in this video that
- 8:07was actually on the Philip the Franco reporting it, it just well what did
- 8:11you think of it? So my understanding is that the older son played a
- 8:18prank on a younger one of the younger siblings, telling him that they were
- 8:22going to go to Disneyland and then they weren't. Okay, well, don't
- 8:24do that. That sucks. So can I see a punishment? Sure,
- 8:30like, okay, you're not watching TV tonight, Like that's ridiculous. Don't
- 8:31do that to your kid, brother, That's mean, that's mean. How
- 8:35would you like? You like that kind of thing? Yeah? Or no
- 8:37punishment? You sit down with him and be like, how would you feel
- 8:41you, Yeah, how would you feel if someone did that? I'm seeing
- 8:45that even charitably because there's a different perspective, which is like I don't even
- 8:50know if the prank was like was carried out in a way that was that
- 8:52bad, Like it might have been like maybe the kid was crying. I
- 8:54don't know, right, but there could also be like it literally was just
- 8:58we're going to Disney, like what I'm just kidding. I don't know,
- 9:01right, But what are the case may be as you're saying, maybe punishments
- 9:05not even but even if you punish like I'm thinking like, okay, no
- 9:07TV tonight whatever. Right. The thing is they took his bedroom away.
- 9:11Yeah, that is such a thing, like like it's you, it's your
- 9:15like not only you know, sharing a bedroom, you don't have any bedroom
- 9:20and not a bed either because he had to sleep on a beam bag.
- 9:22Yeah. So of course, well they're also saying you stepped on the floor.
- 9:26Okay. So there's a lot of things we might bring up, like
- 9:28for example, of the thing about not eating for a day that of course,
- 9:31there are people in this world right now suffering that don't eat for days,
- 9:33weeks, whatever. They these are real problems. So but in this
- 9:39case, it's not about like, oh how hard is it to sleep on
- 9:41floor? It's the fact that for that child, in their relative environment,
- 9:46all these things are so damaging, like I'm so worthless that basically one transgression
- 9:54means I lose everything I own, right, And I wonder where he learned
- 9:58harsh behavior. It's your family miners, you know. So yeah, okay,
- 10:03so these things are happy again. Ruby transitions away kind of mysteriously from
- 10:09her just regular vlogging channel to this Connections channel mostly, and according to the
- 10:15Connections website, they say that connections is a different modality of healing that psychotherapy
- 10:20cannot offer you. And then there's all these like claims that you'll be joyful
- 10:26and happy in it. So I was, really it's one thing if they
- 10:31offered some sort of parenting advice. It's another thing when they say that Connections
- 10:37can heal you in a way that psychotherapy cannot. I mean, I don't
- 10:41know, but that you know that smells like always smells culty. It's it
- 10:46smells like super conservative where you're just like secular psychotherapy is wrong, where they
- 10:54teach everyone to be trans and and sexually abusing girls in the bathroom, you
- 10:58know, like literally, there's these beliefs and so I don't know that,
- 11:01but it's just the next thing, you know, the theeten meters are coming
- 11:05out right. It's just and plus this is their topic sentence, yea.
- 11:09In their topic sentence of their mission statement, they're saying psychotherapy sucks and we
- 11:15can help you, you know. And they also say healing, And I'm
- 11:18like, healing. I think you're you're talking about parenting. Okay, to
- 11:20be charitable, let let me let me flip it around a little bit and
- 11:24say, well, okay, I can imagine you you have a way that
- 11:28you want to train people or whatever, and you want to make a statement
- 11:33that, look, you might be going to psychotherapy already. I think we
- 11:37offer something beyond that, something additional, something different, whatever, Right,
- 11:41Fine, it may or may not be real. You may or may not
- 11:45have any data, probably don't. But the thing that's agreges about it is
- 11:48that they and I know it's only in retrospect, but knowing now what we
- 11:54know, it's like the worst thing possible. They're offering parental advice, eschewing
- 12:00additional psychotherapy and replacing it with like abusive methodology. Right, it's so toxic.
- 12:07Right, Given what we learned later, the rejection of psychotherapy is probably
- 12:13a signal or a belief that, well, you know, therapists and quote
- 12:18unquote experts in parenting, they're going to tell you to be nice to your
- 12:22children and listen to us. Well we know better. Yeah. So fast
- 12:26forward to twenty twenty two. Sherry, the oldest child, who was an
- 12:31adult by this point, has moved out of the house and she posts on
- 12:35Instagram that she's no longer in contact with her family and she does not support
- 12:41the quote unquote extreme beliefs of connections, with meaning that the oldest girl,
- 12:46Sherry is saying that my parents, in particularly, I think my mom and
- 12:52this Jody character are bad parents, and I, as a result, I
- 12:58don't even talk to anyone in my family anymore. But by the way,
- 13:01can you imagine what it must how bad it must be for someone that was
- 13:05in it too at a very young age, still realize how bad it was?
- 13:09Yeah, and get out of it? Yeah? Yeah, And talk
- 13:13about an indictment on your model that the first chance your oldest kid could get
- 13:20away from you, they did, and they publicly are speaking out against your
- 13:24parenting. Like imagine if you were selling, you know, burgers, I
- 13:28specialize in burgers. Yeah, and your first customer dies of food posing.
- 13:33The other thing is that again I don't know, but with Ruby's personality,
- 13:37she knew about this, presumably in twenty twenty two the Instagram post, but
- 13:43also of course she knew that her oldest daughter was no longer in contact with
- 13:48her. You would think that you would adjust something, but it appears that
- 13:52for Ruby she held fast on her point of view and maybe even doubled down,
- 13:58which you can imagine, right, You can imagine that she's like,
- 14:00well, I wasn't harsh enough on Sherry, the oldest kid, so I
- 14:05have to be extra harsh on the kids that I still have under my control.
- 14:09That exhibits something going on with some I don't know, but there it's
- 14:15a red flag of someone that has a particular kind of personality hard enough.
- 14:20I don't know. If you saw one of the videos that she had that
- 14:24it was about talking about giving advice to someone else and the person had written
- 14:28in or whatever and was concerned that they were being overly harsh with their children
- 14:33or their child, and this Ruby person was basically saying there is no limit,
- 14:39there is no harsh enough when it comes to truth. So there was
- 14:46this thing about like, hey, as long as you're grounded in truth,
- 14:50there are no limits. There is no harsh enough. So then she said
- 14:54you are probably not being hard enough or harsh enough. And this idea of
- 15:00like, yeah, she's built this philosophy that like, this is so common.
- 15:05We've seen this a lot of times. They believe they have this grain,
- 15:07this kernel of wisdom that they've garnered from the universe and that now entitles
- 15:11them to have no limits on what they can do or should do. Yeah,
- 15:16and the premise that their mind is perfect and that they know the truth
- 15:24right, Yeah, because that it all depends on that I know better than
- 15:28everyone else, right, And I have determined that the truth is that the
- 15:33kids did something wrong and they need to not do those wrong things. Therefore,
- 15:39all bets are off when it comes to punish, all be's no limits.
- 15:41Think about that philosophy, yeah, and think about anything in the would
- 15:46have to go wrong with your own childhood and your personality that that would be
- 15:50your impulse as a parent. You know, it's one thing if you're in
- 15:54a restaurant and there's a loud group of kids next to you and there you
- 15:58know, it's like, you know, get those kids your own children,
- 16:03that you would feel this animosity towards this hostility, towards this entitlement, towards
- 16:10this lack of compassion. You know, like something was wrong there anyway.
- 16:14So what happened last or yesterday or a few days ago in our time because
- 16:19it's September first for us right now, in twenty twenty three, was that
- 16:23Ruby and Jody were arrested for child abuse, two accounts of aggravated child abuse
- 16:30intentionally or knowingly, meaning that the charges you knew you were abusing the children
- 16:36and you did it anyway. But what was it like they were yelling a
- 16:40little too much. So, by the way, this is in Utah Mormon,
- 16:44not that Mormons do the sort of thing, but I don't know,
- 16:47I just providing context. But you could imagine that for some Mormons, and
- 16:52I'll say some that they're indoctrination and brainwashing of their church members and the elders
- 17:00that the outside world is sinning and they're all going to hell and we're special
- 17:06and we're better. You know, that allows bad ideas to grow without any
- 17:11any outside influence, you know, and with this notion of just like well,
- 17:15of course the secular world is going to say that this punishment is wrong
- 17:18because they're they're stupid and wrong and devilish about everything. You know. It
- 17:22is a destructive indoctrination that you'll commit on your people. But so the arresting
- 17:29documents said that, and I'm guessing we'll get more details in the future or
- 17:33not, but there's a lot of holes and maybe you found out more.
- 17:37But the arresting documents, according to Philip Franco, said that one of the
- 17:42children, one of Ruby's children, climbed out of a window in Jody's house.
- 17:47So the kids were a couple of the kids were in Jody's house and
- 17:52one of the children managed to escape out a window and ran to the neighbors
- 17:56for help. The child asked the neighbor for food and water. The neighbor
- 18:00noted to the police that there were duct tape on There was duct tape on
- 18:07the child's ankles and wrists. The child was emaciated and malnourished, and there
- 18:11were open wounds on the arms and the legs, maybe from the bindings and
- 18:15the neighbor called the police and the child was brought to a hospital and treated.
- 18:19Later, I think the police went to the home, found the other
- 18:25child and also observed the child was malnourished and brought that child to treatment as
- 18:30well. So that's what when involved the police, and then that's what led
- 18:34to the arrest. By the way I heard, I didn't hear the whole
- 18:38thing is very long, but I heard a lot of the police recordings when
- 18:41they were, you know, doing this, and it's so telling and sad.
- 18:47You know, these are professionals, they deal with a lot of stuff,
- 18:49right, but you can tell how not normal encountering something like this is.
- 18:56They were talking about the wounds, right, and it was like the
- 19:00one cops says like, well, what you know, what are the leges?
- 19:03How do the legs look or something like that, and the cops says,
- 19:06oh, is get they're good, like good as in really bad,
- 19:10you know, like basically the child wasn't just duct tape like it was like
- 19:15like the open wounds because of the this is so bad. It's so extreme.
- 19:21Yeah, but again, when you have no limits to discipline and the
- 19:25other one of the either officers or one of the works the social workers was
- 19:30visibly shaking or shaken according to the Proficer. So the personality possibilities are,
- 19:37of course, psychopathy, any social meaning that Ruby. We don't know about
- 19:41Kevin the husband, by the way, yet at this point. There's just
- 19:45a kind of a blank spot as to whether he was fully involved or even
- 19:48orchestrating, or only kind of involved. I'm sure he's implicated to some extent
- 19:55because he would have observed these things and could have intervened obviously, but it's
- 19:59hard to know if he was trying to you know, push back or who
- 20:02knows. But it's just a big blank spot. But at the very least
- 20:04for Ruby, given what we're hearing and given the level of what we imagine
- 20:11is happening, I mean, this kind of story is usually the story of
- 20:15a child has been abducted, a person has been abducted other yeah, by
- 20:22like some sadistic psychopath who has you know, people locked up, you know,
- 20:27like the movie Room, yeah, or Silence of the Lambs or something
- 20:30like right, and and then somehow, thank god, the victim escapes to
- 20:37the neighbors. That's usually what we're it's not the parents themselves that we get
- 20:41the story. Now, I want to be clear, there's a lot of
- 20:45kids that are being abused in this way and they probably have a harder time
- 20:48getting out, and even if they do get out, the parents can say
- 20:52like, oh, he's just acting up, so it's not like this doesn't
- 20:55happen. But but anyway, So the personality profile that one would hypothesize as
- 21:00an investigate if there was that need, and there might be that need,
- 21:04is that one psychopathy any social media that you don't have empathy, you don't
- 21:08care, and you might even want to step on other people to get your
- 21:15own goals. You know, like if she believes Ruby believes that her career
- 21:21depends on her establishing a niche of attracting essentially abusive parents, but maybe also
- 21:26parents who are disaffected by psychotherapy or mainstream advice or dealing with a kid that
- 21:32is very difficult and they have no answers and they're just looking for it.
- 21:36You know, if she's trying to establish that niche, then she might think,
- 21:41well, you know, the best thing to do here is to experiment
- 21:45on my own children or something, or really establish full control over these kids
- 21:49so that I can give that advice to other people, you know, who
- 21:52knows what the motivation was. But but the other personality profile is sadism,
- 21:56sadistic personality, sorder. It's no longer in the DSM, or it might
- 22:00not have ever been. But just because something is in the DSM doesn't mean
- 22:03it doesn't exist. Not every human condition psychologically as in the DSM. And
- 22:10it's well understood and well researched in scientific literature that there is a personality profile
- 22:15of sadistic personality where the person gets off and gets tremendous pleasure by causing other
- 22:22people to suffer. These individuals can engage in the causing of the suffering for
- 22:27their own pleasure, or they love watching other people make other people suffer,
- 22:33so they vicariously are you know, they get joy or maybe so they're sexual
- 22:38sadism as well, which is a type of sadism. But general sadism is
- 22:41just watching people and maybe animals suffer, and who knows. But there's a
- 22:49stronger case for the psychopathy because the lack of empathy that you would have to
- 22:53have as a personality trait to engage in these kinds of things. You know,
- 22:56because if you're a parent, you understand that you can never even come
- 23:00close to these kinds of behaviors because you have a heart, you have compassion,
- 23:03you have empathy, you care. So how could you do that if
- 23:10you had empathy? Well maybe there's no empathy or access to it. But
- 23:14the other aspect, you know, when we hear the level of these punishments,
- 23:18I mean it sounds as though there were multiple instances who knows of children
- 23:25being bound and duct taped not only by Ruby but also by Jody. I
- 23:30mean that they're a team and they work together, and they're being denied food
- 23:36and water. I mean, this is torture and who knows what else has
- 23:40happened, right, So, you know, it's one thing to say I'm
- 23:45going to establish control over this child, I'm going to be dominant, I'm
- 23:48going to punish that. It's another thing to engage in punishment scheme that lasts
- 23:53days. Maybe it's you know, with the wounds that we heard about,
- 23:56it could have been going on for who knows, and that that level that,
- 24:03you know, the longevity of it often is fueled by someone who actually
- 24:08wakes up in the morning. And you know the way that if you're if
- 24:11it's the first day of your vacation and you wake up and you be like,
- 24:15oh, I can't wait to be not working and go to the beach
- 24:18or have fun with my friends. Like that feeling that you have, that's
- 24:22what sadists feel about harming other people. They wake up and they go,
- 24:26I can't wait to make other people suffer. And they will engage in,
- 24:30if they can, long term suffering, and it'll escalate because the suffering that
- 24:37they cause one day will not satisfy them months later, so they have to
- 24:41make it worse and worse and worse. So I'm not diagnosing from far,
- 24:44I don't know, but you know, there's a chance that if there is
- 24:48a chance to evaluator, that the evaluator will consider these constructs any thoughts.
- 24:52Yeah, so a couple of things. One of the things that was very
- 24:56common in their channel, as I've come to understand, and definitely the father
- 25:00was involved as well. Oh really, oh yeah, in the channel,
- 25:03in the videos that they would make, is that they would purposely show very
- 25:11embarrassing difficult moments from the kids, things like needing to shave your legs for
- 25:18the first time if you're a girl or teenage things, or being rejected by
- 25:22someone romantically so or so. Side note in our deep dive portion tangent on
- 25:29this topic. We talked about that how that's the problem with these with this
- 25:34kind of content, is that the producers and the parents are the same people.
- 25:40The money makers and you know, the capitalists if you will, are
- 25:45the parents. So there's no checks and balances, and this sort of stuff
- 25:48sells, you know, if you have someone's first administruation or shaving their legs,
- 25:53that sort of thing not only is titillating to people or new content,
- 25:57but also to predators who wants that kind of content for about children. Absolutely,
- 26:03and no one is there, you know, because if you're on a
- 26:06reality TV show or you're in a you know, on a TV show like
- 26:10a fictional TV show, at least maybe the parents are They're like, hey,
- 26:14you can't do that too much in this situation. In fact, you
- 26:18see the child begging, begging, mom, don't please, don't film,
- 26:22please don't film it. Yeah, and so tell me this. So in
- 26:25the video that they showed him, Philip de Franco's wonderful YouTube channel that I
- 26:30depend on to learn to learn to learn all things contemporary you know, boxies.
- 26:37Yeah, and I love his point of view, I love his delivery
- 26:40yeah. But he was showing a clip of where that teenage boy was talking
- 26:45about how he doesn't have a bedroom and the mom has the biggest grin.
- 26:49Oh yeah, anyone yet. I don't know what that means, but there's
- 26:53a chance that that grin is that sadism, is that pleasure of like oh
- 27:02yeah, Well there was a mix because the way it looked to me is
- 27:04initially she's like, oh, we hadn't mentioned that, but then then it's
- 27:07like that enjoyment of like, well let's talk about it. Yeah, And
- 27:11there's with that same son he was talking about how he doesn't have friends because
- 27:17in another thing, I was hearing about how, essentially because of a lot
- 27:19of these videos they'd put out, they were also bullied at school the kids
- 27:22were because but it said they were homeschooled, so I don't know. It
- 27:29said like they were bullied or maybe not at school, maybe in the neighborhood.
- 27:32I don't know. And then they asked the sun would talk about how
- 27:34it doesn't have friends, and she's like, well, why don't you hang
- 27:37out with your friends? Like I don't have friends. They was talking to
- 27:40one of the girls like and she was like, I don't even know where
- 27:44they live, like I don't know. And also they could be isolated and
- 27:49socialized by their parents to exclude that sort of activity because that would allow or
- 27:55that would yeah, that would allow the kids to get power or outside of
- 27:59pans about things that the parents don't want. My question was, say,
- 28:03note, was in the other videos you watch, did the mom and dad
- 28:06seem to get pleasure when these humiliating or harmful things app It's hard to know
- 28:11because first all, I certainly did not know this channel before this, and
- 28:15so I've only seen as much as I've been able to see over the last
- 28:18day. And there is some plausible deniability because it's in a lot of those
- 28:23videos. You could say, well, it's just a misinformed or misguided parents
- 28:29trying to produce interesting content and putting a happy face for the camera while their
- 28:33child is squirming and saying please don't mom. So it's hard to know,
- 28:37is like, is she getting us a distic feeling from it, or that
- 28:41she's focused on money making and fame right, and it eclipses her noticing what
- 28:47the child is so totally obviously rather than waking up in the morning and saying
- 28:51I can't wait, it's hard to humiliate my child. Okay, so from
- 28:55from what I've seen, it's hard to tell. Now what isn't hard to
- 28:56tell is the conviction of her beliefs about how harsh punishments are totally fine.
- 29:04All that stuff seemed completely genuine. But I just don't know. I have
- 29:10no idea, based on what I've seen, whether she was legitimately getting some
- 29:14pleasure from the torture I was thinking though. There was apparently a statement she
- 29:18released after arrest or something like this, saying something like the children that were
- 29:23found should, under no circumstances be around other children. And this is really
- 29:30interesting. I'm wondering if as a result of trauma and all these things,
- 29:36these children are not properly socialized, they might even do harmful things to other
- 29:40childs. And then in her wacky mind, it's like, well, now
- 29:44I need to go to if I was at eleven, now I need to
- 29:47go to a twenty one. And therefore, in her mind she justifies like,
- 29:51well, yeah, of course I'm gonna have to bound them and keep
- 29:53them because they're a danger to society's. It's incredible, but you could see
- 30:00that progression, how damaging the children over time, damages the children. Yeah,
- 30:06and then dad would justify even harsher punishments. Yeah, I mean,
- 30:10the thing I'll say, and again we're it's just all speculation. But the
- 30:15typical progression to this that I've treated is that when you have an individual a
- 30:19parent who especially when you have two parents, I mean, that's a bad
- 30:22combo because there's no one there to say, hey, let's pull back a
- 30:26little bit. And you know other family vloggers that were found to be abusive.
- 30:33We're seemingly along those lines as well. The daddy of five, both
- 30:37parents seem to be in on it, which is just awful. And the
- 30:42abuse, I mean, the the damage done to these children and the damage
- 30:48that will continue to be done. It's just it's up there, right,
- 30:51and I just feel so so bad for these kids. And you know,
- 30:56it's one thing to be abused, it's another thing to be paraded around on
- 30:59YouTube and to know that your mom is being praised for this and God,
- 31:04I mean, and to be homeschooled and completely cut off from other people.
- 31:07I mean, the and who knows what kind of Mormon sort of indoctrination or
- 31:12brainwashing they've been through. I mean, just the years of recovery and therapy
- 31:17and healing and confusion and pain and sadness and distrust and it's it's just it's
- 31:23heartbreaking and it's it's so unnecessary, and it's like, why does this happen?
- 31:29By the way, another terrible thing is I found videos that were like
- 31:33two years old from YouTubers already yeah, speaking out talking about this. Apparently
- 31:38this goes back to like twenty eighteen too, but yeah, yeah, So
- 31:41along these lines, Sherry, the oldest child, who lived in the family
- 31:48and has been at least for a year or two, been trying to tell
- 31:55people what's going on, and that their own child, who apparently they support,
- 32:00who has first. Yeah. So she posted on Instagram yesterday. We've
- 32:05been telling the police and CPS for years about this and I'm so glad that
- 32:08they finally decided to step up. Ruby's the woman, the mom, her
- 32:13siblings posted, her own sisters posted on Instagram. For the last three years,
- 32:17behind the public scene, we have been we have done everything we could
- 32:22to try and make sure the kids were safe. So, you know,
- 32:24there were multiple reports to the police, to CPS, and there was one
- 32:30investigation by CPS, but it was just you know, determined that there wasn't
- 32:35any thing actionable. There are no laws about the YouTube stuff right well,
- 32:40and underfunded agencies, under powered agencies, right because if you you know,
- 32:47in the deep dive that we did about this, my suggestion would be that
- 32:51there would be tax dollars at allocated for these institutions, CPS or maybe a
- 32:55different organization, but you know, trained individuals who have the power to monitor
- 33:00and to intervene, and one of the things that they could fund. Because
- 33:05it's all about tax dollars. It's all about money and paying people, you
- 33:08know, to do these sorts of things. But if they received enough reports
- 33:14or a report that was concerning, or they even just observed because they might
- 33:19watch these channels themselves, these professionals that work for the government, they could
- 33:22actually go on site and just hang out, you know, and just say
- 33:28we're you know, because of these red flags, we now have the law
- 33:34on our side, and you have to comply. You know. The best
- 33:37analogy I can come up with is is food safety in restaurants. Yeah,
- 33:42I don't know exactly how it works, but I've seen it enough. And
- 33:45moves in TV, yeah, and inspector comes by like in the Bear for
- 33:50example, you start watching it. Yeah, uh yeah, a little bit.
- 33:53But anyway, so the inspector has the power to just randomly show up
- 34:00or something like that. And the business owner, even though it's it's not
- 34:04public property, right, it's they could say get out of here, right.
- 34:07They can't say that to the to the inspector, and if they do,
- 34:09then there are consequences. The inspector could literally shut the restaurant down.
- 34:14They could call the police and say you have to make this restaurant stop,
- 34:17you know, and they get a look around and they get to hang out,
- 34:20and you can't do anything about it. As a restaurant. You just
- 34:22have to let it happen. Well, that sucks because it, you know,
- 34:27fringes on our rights as citizens, but it's a public good and it's
- 34:31better for everyone. It's better for the restaurant because a lot of times there's
- 34:35an educational process, you know, the inspector says, hey, actually that
- 34:39is a hazard and here's how you can fix it. You know, it's
- 34:43not adversarial all the time. And when it comes to these uh, these
- 34:46sort of channels, these YouTube channels, imagine if we had you know,
- 34:52and you wouldn't need that many people because there's not that many channels, you
- 34:54know, especially the big ones, especially the ones that have this kind of
- 34:58content where it's question. So that would be able to reduce the rate,
- 35:04you know. And I still think like these platforms, they're making money out
- 35:06of this. So just if we pass the law that says you can't host
- 35:09this content unless you provide this you know. Yeah yeah, so yeah,
- 35:15it's awful. I feel so bad for the kids, who knows what will
- 35:22come out in the story eventually. It's pathetic and sad that their own child
- 35:29has been calling the authorities yea, and nothing has happened. I mean,
- 35:34something's wrong there. I got this extreme. I mean, a child was
- 35:37gonna die if they haven't, if a child hasn't already died in this process,
- 35:40children were gonna die at some point. Yeah. I Mean, if
- 35:44it's one thing that I think people can agree upon is that abused children deserve
- 35:51action, they deserve protection. And for an abused child Sherry to call the
- 35:59authority frequently and for their be video evidence that the mom and dad are posting
- 36:06themselves and nothing is happening. I mean, these children have maybe even a
- 36:14lawsuit on their hands, right, like, like, yeah, we try
- 36:17y'all. Uh failed, Yeah, because there was more than enough justification for
- 36:27something. I mean, there's so many things. You know, people think
- 36:30of CPS is like they come in and take kids away. Yeah, that's
- 36:31one of the things they do after a whole series of things that happened before
- 36:36that. But there's a lot of things that CPS can do. CPS used
- 36:39to hire me to go into the home to actually well, one of the
- 36:45things they wanted me to do was to have eyes on. There was a
- 36:49phrase that they used to do it. I think it was just have eyes
- 36:51on, eyes on the situation, meaning that I would be CPS's eyes.
- 36:57Yeah, And I would always pushed back on that because I'm like, I'm
- 37:01a private practice, because they would I didn't work for CPS. They contracted
- 37:06me as a as a as a private outside contractor, and my you know,
- 37:10the standard of care and also my way as a therapist and ethics would
- 37:16dictate that I'm not an agent of the government. And also in order for
- 37:21the family to be able to trust me, they have to not see me
- 37:23as an agent of the cover right, they have to see me as someone
- 37:27who is on their side. I'm not going to let child abuse happen,
- 37:30but I need them to feel like I'm primarily a therapist and I will be
- 37:36reporting things at times because that's part of the contract. You would think they
- 37:38would actually make that explicit, like a good cop bad cops sort of dynamic.
- 37:43Yeah, And the best CPS workers would play it that way, but
- 37:47not everyone played it that way. And the problem is is that these CPS
- 37:52workers are overworked and they have like you know, dozens or hundreds of cases
- 37:57that they are trying to monitor and fix, and it's really helpful for them
- 38:02if there's a therapist actually in the home, because you know, CPS workers
- 38:07they have time to visit, but they don't have time to just hang out.
- 38:09And and to be clear, I didn't hang out, but the contract
- 38:13would involve maybe you know, two to five hours of therapy a week,
- 38:15so you know, in the home. And so that was one thing.
- 38:20But the other thing that I was really tasked with that actually is in line
- 38:23with my ethics in my way in the standard of care, is that I
- 38:27was there to help fix the problems such that the abuse wouldn't happen again.
- 38:31Right, So the parents, you know, halfway through the process would be
- 38:37like, you know, At first I thought of you as an invader because
- 38:39CPS sent you. But now I'm so glad that they sent you because things
- 38:44are so much better now. You know, I realized now that I was
- 38:47overstressed and I never had a good model for I didn't know how to parent
- 38:52or I didn't know how to deal with this and that. And I would
- 38:54also treat the parents in terms of you know, if possible, I'd start
- 38:59treating their trauma and their their issues. I'd start to help them with their
- 39:02their own recover from their own issues such that they wouldn't be stressed up,
- 39:06such they wouldn't impose it on the kids. So you know, that's another
- 39:08thing the CPS does. So why weren't these things explored? You know,
- 39:15it's it's not just taking away the kids. I bet you. There's a
- 39:17big difference in quality of CPS around the country. Yeah, like different regions
- 39:23also big differences even in one department among the different workers, Like they are
- 39:29all different sorts of folks, you know, like I worked with. Yeah,
- 39:34I don't know the office exactly, maybe it's a Keen Countier, but
- 39:37the Seattle offices, there's a few can imagine all sorts of politics too,
- 39:39Yeah, regionally and like well here, we don't trade our kids soul with
- 39:44kid gloves and blah blah blah. Right, or local governments that underfund or
- 39:50strip away the power. You know who knows. But you can imagine cps
- 39:53having an adversarial relationship with the police, and uh, they have a hard
- 39:59time actually getting or there's lack of communication, you know who knows. Every
- 40:02time I make a voice of like the bad politician or the bad city councilman
- 40:08or something, I'm always channeling Boss Hogs from the Dukes of Hazard. So
- 40:16yeah, it's a really horrible story. And maybe Burdo. You know,
- 40:22like with the Kugan Act of the nineteen twenties, you had Jackie Coogan,
- 40:29a young boy who was in a major blockbuster with Charlie Chaplin, right,
- 40:36and he earned a lot of money from that movie and subsequent performances and that
- 40:42paved the way, and then he and his parents ended up taking all his
- 40:45money, and then when he was an adult, he sued and then that
- 40:50eventually led to a federal act that was passed by our elected officials. Maybe
- 40:57that could come from this, that's called the Kugan Act. And a lot
- 41:00of our best laws are initiated by this kind of these kinds of tragedies.
- 41:06Unfortunately, it's it's a good thing to hold up and say, like,
- 41:09look what happened. Look what happened. Because us as legislatures, us as
- 41:15voters, us as a society haven't done anything. There's something we can do.
- 41:22But I worry berto that nothing will happen. So let's hope it does.
- 41:29But you're right, because you know, I think a factor and we
- 41:31talked about this. I think in a previous chapter that I think society and
- 41:36legislatures in particular, I think they think of social media and YouTube as this
- 41:39like it's just kind of this weird kid thing that happens. You know,
- 41:42who cares. It's not like the real world where like because if you talked
- 41:45about this happening in a restaurant or you know, just or being a part
- 41:50of a story that didn't involve YouTube or something. But I get this impression,
- 41:53Yeah, I get this impression that like people are like, well,
- 41:58that's kind of a niche, weird thing, that's you know, that's the
- 42:00minor leagues. Yea. And for legislators, they might even think like what's
- 42:06YouTube? I mean, example, and maybe we'll have to deal with it.
- 42:08You know, it's already telling that folks are going to try to separate
- 42:14this tragedy from the fact that they were YouTubers exploiting their children. As an
- 42:20example, right now, the father is asking for custody and say, oh,
- 42:23you know, I want to But a lot of people are pointing out,
- 42:27well, I mean, you were part and parcel of the thing before,
- 42:30so maybe you aren't involved anymore, and maybe you are not involved in
- 42:35this, because my understanding is that they are separated I think, but I
- 42:38don't know. But in either case, the conversations should have to start with,
- 42:43well, the exploitation started years ago, and it was public and it
- 42:47could have been regulated. They could have been kind of stopped earlier in their
- 42:52tracks with this in this regard, especially when they were Reddit. Like just
- 42:55with the Duggers, there was a whole Reddit thing trying to do something about
- 43:00this years ago, let alone, because they didn't know how bad it was
- 43:02going to get. This was just about them explaining the children on camera,
- 43:07and there were Well the thing with the Duggers was, if I understand the
- 43:13situation right, the discussions online were pointing out factual reports that were made about
- 43:19Josh's abuse of the younger girls, and then a lot of speculation as to
- 43:23what's happening now, right, and even if the police did get involved,
- 43:28because they did when Oprah's team contacted the police, right that the statute of
- 43:34limitations were such an Arkansas that there wasn't anything they could do, whereas in
- 43:37this situation, the abuse was happening, you know currently right, and so
- 43:44the police. So you know, with the Duggers, I don't know if
- 43:47there was anything a prosecutor could have grabbed onto back then, But with the
- 43:54Ruby Frankie situation, it was just it was a case just just like a
- 44:00ripe apple just waiting to be picked, you know. True. And there's
- 44:05also still this sense of like, oh, well, what were they doing
- 44:08Well, okay, you can point to the food thing, but what were
- 44:10they doing well, they were showing stuff on camera? Oh is that a
- 44:15Is that a crime? Right? So yeah, that's another good point that
- 44:19the things that were factual were probably not actionable by CPS and the police.
- 44:27Unfortunately, the government, for better for worse, allows for a pretty wide
- 44:32range of parenting styles that some people might be kind of shocked by that the
- 44:37government would say that's not actionable because the government one doesn't have enough money to
- 44:44take action on everything, and two that the government is has a has an
- 44:49ethic, a principle that parents deserve to have rights as to how they raise
- 44:53their kids within reason, and there's a high bar for the government, you
- 44:59know, the jack boot thugs entering the home and intervening in a very severe
- 45:07way, like taking the kids away. Can I just make a request though,
- 45:09what by the point where one of your own children is desperately calling,
- 45:15and your relatives are desperately calling, and there's a whole Reddit community, I
- 45:20say, no, I know, I know it's not you. I'm just
- 45:22saying, like you would think, I because I'm a parent, I don't
- 45:25want to have like randomly the government come in and take my children away just
- 45:30because I was a little too harsh over dinner or something. The thing I
- 45:32want to allow for to throw the authorities a bone is that we don't know
- 45:38exactly what was even being reported by the older sister. So you know,
- 45:43we just don't know. But given what I imagine was being reported in my
- 45:46experience, most of the CPS workers and the police officers who work with CPS
- 45:52frequently would have absolutely taken action. So you know, because by the point
- 45:58that you have to find a starved, emaciated dog, tape bleeding child,
- 46:02yeah, we've let it the threshold be too lenient. Yeah. And hearing
- 46:08that the police actually charged Jody and Ruby, I was encouraged, and I
- 46:15noticed that I was relieved in a way that exhibited or illuminated me to the
- 46:21fact that I didn't necessarily trust that the government would do anything. Even then,
- 46:24Oh my god, you know what I mean, because can you imagine,
- 46:28because that happen sometimes. So I'm and like the ants and the daughter
- 46:36saying, I'm glad they're doing something because we've been Okay, so let's take
- 46:42a break. But after this it's going to be for patrons of the podcast,
- 46:45and we're going to pick up in the outline where I left off,
- 46:47where we're at twenty fifteen, and we're going to talk about how Josh was
- 46:53involved with Ashley Madison, which is the website that is set up for my
- 46:59favorite people to cheat on their on their partners. That's what it's for.
- 47:04And so you just thought it was a place to meet people. It's got
- 47:07a cool name. Yeah, and I've got a lot of friends on there.
- 47:09Yeah, is there an actual Ashley Madison? Is that like a human
- 47:14being? Oh, I'm sorry, I don't know. Yeah, I haven't
- 47:16met her yet. Yeah, but it's a great name. It's like Amazon,
- 47:22Microsoft, you know, Ashley Madison, you know, has a ring
- 47:25to it, but it's it sounds it's for infidelity, which is unfortunate infidels.
- 47:31So if you want to listen to us talk about that, become a
- 47:36patron of the podcast. Otherwise, please take care of yourself because you deserve it.