Latest / The Morning Rundown / Tennessee's Execution Fallout, a $90 Senior Check, and an Oil Deal in the Ukraine Talks
Transcript
- 0:14[Maya] Okay, I'm on my second coffee, and my brain is just now
- 0:17[Maya] clocking in.
- 0:18[David] Second?
- 0:19[David] I'm on a refill of the first.
- 0:20[David] Mine's gone lukewarm, and I'm drinking it anyway.
- 0:23[Maya] Respect.
- 0:24[Maya] So I'm Maya, this is the Morning Rundown, and David is stuck
- 0:27[Maya] with me again.
- 0:29[David] Lucky me.
- 0:30[David] Today, we've got a Tennessee execution that did not go as planned.
- 0:34[Maya] A senior check where the headline and the fine print don't match.
- 0:38[David] And an oil deal floating around the Ukraine talks, which makes you
- 0:41[David] ask who actually wins.
- 0:44[Maya] Wait, oil?
- 0:45[Maya] Okay, hold that thought.
- 0:47[David] Gladly.
- 0:47[David] We're first.
- 0:48[Maya] Let's start with the story out of Tennessee that's still unfolding.
- 0:52[Maya] Christa Pike was given two doses of pentobarbital on Wednesday, and she
- 0:57[Maya] survived.
- 0:58[David] Survived, as in witnesses said she was snoring, alive and snoring.
- 1:03[Maya] That's what CBS News reported from the witnesses.
- 1:06[Maya] I'm not going to joke about this one, David.
- 1:09[David] No, and nobody should.
- 1:10[David] This is a state that set out to carry out a sentence
- 1:12[David] and could not complete it.
- 1:14[Maya] Two doses, David, not one.
- 1:17[Maya] The reporting says two doses of pentobarbital, and she still survived.
- 1:22[David] And that's the part that makes people stop.
- 1:25[David] Whatever you think about capital punishment, the one job here was a
- 1:28[David] defined procedure, and the reporting says it did not end the way
- 1:31[David] it was supposed to.
- 1:33[Maya] Right.
- 1:33[Maya] And I want to be careful about what we know versus what
- 1:36[Maya] we don't.
- 1:37[Maya] What we have are the witnesses' account of her snoring and the
- 1:41[Maya] lawyers later filing, not a full explanation of why.
- 1:45[David] Which is the honest place to start.
- 1:47[David] The reporting we have doesn't lay out a cause.
- 1:50[Maya] And the timing makes it stranger.
- 1:52[Maya] The US Supreme Court had cleared the execution earlier that same day.
- 1:56[David] So every legal hurdle was behind them.
- 1:59[David] The one thing left was the procedure itself.
- 2:01[Maya] Right.
- 2:02[Maya] And then Governor Bill Lee canceled the remaining execution on the 2026
- 2:07[Maya] calendar and ordered a third-party review.
- 2:10[David] Which, to be fair, is the right instinct.
- 2:12[David] If you support the death penalty, you want it done by a
- 2:14[David] clear, competent process.
- 2:16[David] This is the opposite of that.
- 2:18[Maya] Totally.
- 2:19[Maya] Accountability matters to people on that side as much as anyone.
- 2:22[David] Wait, the remaining one?
- 2:24[David] Who was that?
- 2:25[Maya] CNN says it was Gary Sutton, scheduled for December.
- 2:29[Maya] The governor halted that too.
- 2:31[David] So that's two things stopped then, the remaining 2026 execution and a
- 2:35[David] review on top of it.
- 2:37[Maya] Right.
- 2:38[Maya] And the review is the piece that matters most over time.
- 2:41[Maya] A halt buys time, but a third-party review is what's supposed to
- 2:44[Maya] answer how this happened.
- 2:46[David] Okay.
- 2:46[David] And Pike herself, where is she now?
- 2:49[Maya] Her lawyer said in a Friday filing that she's intubated on a
- 2:53[Maya] ventilator and unconscious in a hospital in the Nashville area.
- 2:57[Maya] CNN also reported significant injuries to both arms.
- 3:01[David] Both arms?
- 3:02[David] That's not a detail I expected.
- 3:04[Maya] Same.
- 3:05[Maya] The filing also asks the court to order the state to preserve
- 3:09[Maya] evidence.
- 3:10[David] Which tells you the lawyers expect a fight over what happened in
- 3:12[David] that room.
- 3:13[Maya] And her lawyers are seeking commutation.
- 3:16[Maya] Beyond that, CNN says it's unclear what comes next legally or medically.
- 3:21[David] That's a lot of unknowns for something the state planned down to
- 3:24[David] the hour.
- 3:25[Maya] And commutation is a big ask, so it's worth saying plainly what
- 3:29[Maya] it is.
- 3:30[Maya] Her lawyers are seeking it.
- 3:31[Maya] That's the request.
- 3:32[Maya] The reporting doesn't tell us how it will be received.
- 3:35[David] Right.
- 3:35[David] So we've got a request, a filing, and a review, and no
- 3:38[David] answers yet on any of them.
- 3:40[David] For someone following this at home, that's the honest summary.
- 3:43[Maya] There's also a name in this.
- 3:44[Maya] The Guardian reported that Pike's lawyers say the prison chief, Frank Strada,
- 3:49[Maya] oversaw five botched executions.
- 3:51[David] Five?
- 3:52[David] Hold on.
- 3:53[David] Whose number is that?
- 3:54[Maya] The lawyers.
- 3:55[Maya] That's their claim, and it's what The Guardian reported them saying.
- 3:58[Maya] I'm not putting it forward as established.
- 4:00[David] Fair, but it's the kind of claim a review has to answer,
- 4:02[David] whatever the answer turns out to be.
- 4:04[Maya] Agreed.
- 4:05[Maya] The review is the part to watch because it's independent of the
- 4:07[Maya] department.
- 4:08[David] Hmm.
- 4:09[David] And whether the state ever lets anyone see the findings.
- 4:12[Maya] And for the lawyers, that's probably the point of the evidence preservation
- 4:15[Maya] request.
- 4:16[Maya] Keep the record intact while the questions are still open.
- 4:19[David] Whatever side you come down on about the death penalty, a process
- 4:22[David] that can't be explained afterward is hard to defend.
- 4:25[David] Supporters want it competent and Accountability, and that's the standard the state
- 4:28[David] is gonna be measured against.
- 4:30[Maya] We'll see.
- 4:31[Maya] Okay, switching gears to Washington, where a payment going to Seniors has
- 4:35[Maya] a headline number that doesn't quite match the fine print.
- 4:39[David] Oh, I've been waiting for this one.
- 4:40[David] Ninety dollars sounds simple until you read the details.
- 4:44[Maya] Okay, so Trump went on Truth Social and promised nearly $100 checks,
- 4:49[Maya] Twenty Million Seniors paid out of something called the Medicare Improvement Fund.
- 4:53[David] Axios reported that, and the number on the White House fact sheet
- 4:56[David] is lower, ninety dollars a person.
- 4:59[Maya] Wait, really?
- 5:00[Maya] Nearly a hundred turned into ninety?
- 5:03[David] Ninety.
- 5:03[David] Direct deposit in early October or a paper check if that's how
- 5:06[David] you get your money.
- 5:08[Maya] Rounding is a presidential superpower.
- 5:10[Maya] I do it with my coffee budget.
- 5:13[David] Fair, though let's give this a hearing.
- 5:14[David] Seniors getting money back toward medical costs is popular.
- 5:18[David] Nobody's phone lines are lighting up to complain about a check.
- 5:21[Maya] Totally.
- 5:22[Maya] Free money, hard to hate.
- 5:24[David] But put it next to the bill.
- 5:26[David] The standard 2026 Part B premium is two hundred and two dollars
- 5:30[David] and ninety cents a month.
- 5:32[Maya] So ninety bucks-
- 5:34[David] Covers less than half of one month.
- 5:36[David] Then there are eleven more months.
- 5:39[Maya] Okay, that's a gift card to a restaurant that costs twice as
- 5:42[Maya] much.
- 5:43[David] And the total is roughly two billion dollars.
- 5:46[David] Fox Business reported that, and it also spelled out who's left out.
- 5:49[Maya] Who's out?
- 5:50[David] Folks whose premiums Medicaid already pays, and anyone paying the income related
- 5:56[David] surcharge, the one called IRMAA.
- 5:58[Maya] So the higher earners don't get one.
- 6:00[Maya] Makes sense on its face.
- 6:01[David] And Fox says Trump pitched the Medicare Improvement Fund as a Democrat
- 6:05[David] slush fund and tied this payment to his most favored nations drug
- 6:09[David] deals.
- 6:10[Maya] So the pitch is: We took the pot Democrats were sitting on
- 6:13[Maya] and handed it back to grandma.
- 6:15[David] That's the framing, yeah.
- 6:16[David] Spending it on seniors rather than letting it sit is an easy
- 6:19[David] sell.
- 6:20[Maya] I mean, come on.
- 6:21[Maya] It's a good sales pitch.
- 6:22[Maya] Where's the catch?
- 6:23[David] The catch is a plain question.
- 6:26[David] USA Today's Michael Loria wrote that it's unclear whether the president even
- 6:30[David] has the authority to send out the money.
- 6:32[Maya] Hold on.
- 6:33[Maya] They announced the checks with a date, and nobody's sure he can
- 6:36[Maya] write them?
- 6:38[David] That's what USA Today flagged: unclear.
- 6:40[David] Not illegal, not fine, just unclear.
- 6:44[Maya] And that's a big gap because the money comes from a specific
- 6:47[Maya] fund with specific rules.
- 6:49[David] Right.
- 6:49[David] Who can spend it and on what is the whole ballgame.
- 6:53[David] I'd want that answered before anybody frames a check.
- 6:56[Maya] Meanwhile, somebody's mailbox is going to have $90 in it or not.
- 7:00[David] Early October was the timeline on the fact sheet, so we'll find
- 7:03[David] out soon enough whether the deposits show up.
- 7:05[Maya] Either way, it's a pleasant surprise for some people and a footnote
- 7:09[Maya] for others.
- 7:10[David] Right.
- 7:10[David] And that's the honest read.
- 7:11[David] For plenty of seniors, it's welcome help, and the premium math is
- 7:14[David] just context, not an argument against getting it.
- 7:17[Maya] And if you're a senior listening, what do you do in the
- 7:19[Maya] meantime?
- 7:20[David] Keep it simple.
- 7:21[David] Nothing changes until the money actually shows up, and it's worth checking
- 7:23[David] the fine print on who qualifies first, since people on Medicaid-paid
- 7:27[David] premiums and the IRMAA group are left out.
- 7:29[Maya] Speaking of money, though, $90 is a rounding error next to the
- 7:33[Maya] next one.
- 7:34[Maya] Last, a story where the dollars are way bigger and the cast
- 7:36[Maya] of characters is a lot more complicated.
- 7:39[David] Oil and the Ukraine talks.
- 7:41[David] Buckle up.
- 7:42[Maya] Okay, follow the money with me.
- 7:44[Maya] The New York Times reported on October 3rd that the US-Russia talks
- 7:49[Maya] on Ukraine now involve an oil deal tied to Trump allies.
- 7:54[David] Wait, an oil deal inside peace talks?
- 7:57[Maya] That's the report.
- 7:58[Maya] Peace talks and a business transaction sharing a table.
- 8:02[David] Hold on.
- 8:02[David] Before we go anywhere, this is a reported deal.
- 8:05[David] Nobody has confirmed it, right?
- 8:07[Maya] Right.
- 8:07[Maya] And I'll keep saying that because the details matter.
- 8:10[David] Good.
- 8:11[David] So what's actually in it?
- 8:12[Maya] Reuters summarized the Times story.
- 8:15[Maya] It says the talks reportedly include a multibillion-dollar deal for Lukoil's global
- 8:21[Maya] assets.
- 8:22[David] Lukoil, the Russian oil company.
- 8:24[Maya] Yep.
- 8:25[Maya] And the report says the deal would benefit Middle Eastern executives tied
- 8:29[Maya] to Witkoff and Kushner.
- 8:31[David] Um, tied how?
- 8:33[David] Like they're the buyers?
- 8:35[Maya] Reuters' summary only says they'd benefit.
- 8:37[Maya] I'm not going to fill in a structure the summary doesn't give
- 8:40[Maya] us.
- 8:41[David] Fair.
- 8:41[David] I'd rather be vague than wrong.
- 8:43[Maya] Same.
- 8:44[Maya] Here's a detail I like, though.
- 8:47[Maya] Putin raised it himself at a September 5th meeting in the Kremlin.
- 8:51[David] Putin brought it up?
- 8:53[Maya] According to the report, yes.
- 8:54[David] That's interesting.
- 8:56[David] A Russian company's assets are on the table, and the Russian president
- 8:59[David] is the one pitching it.
- 9:01[Maya] Which is why people are asking who benefits.
- 9:04[Maya] A seller who needs sanctions pressure eased has one set of interests.
- 9:08[Maya] Buyers with connections to the American negotiators have another.
- 9:12[David] Okay, but let me slow us down.
- 9:14[David] Deal making near government is not wrongdoing by itself.
- 9:18[David] Nobody has established anything improper here.
- 9:20[Maya] Agreed.
- 9:21[Maya] Nothing in this reporting says a law was broken.
- 9:24[Maya] It's a question of optics and incentives, and that's a fair thing
- 9:27[Maya] to examine no matter who's in office.
- 9:30[David] Totally.
- 9:30[David] Same questions if it were any other administration.
- 9:33[Maya] And the size matters for the follow the money part.
- 9:36[Maya] A multibillion-dollar price tag means a lot of people would have a
- 9:40[Maya] reason to care how it's structured and who signs off.
- 9:43[David] Sure, but multibillion is all the summary gives us.
- 9:45[David] No breakdown, no timeline, so I'm not going to do math on
- 9:49[David] it.
- 9:49[Maya] And there's a gate.
- 9:50[Maya] The deal needs approval from both the US and the Kremlin.
- 9:54[David] So it can't just happen.
- 9:56[Maya] Right.
- 9:57[Maya] Two governments have to sign off, and neither has.
- 10:00[Maya] So that's a real checkpoint.
- 10:01[Maya] Even if everyone involved wanted it, there's a moment where officials on
- 10:05[Maya] both sides have to say yes.
- 10:08[David] And that's where the public questions may end.
- 10:10[David] When a deal needs a government's approval and the people involved have
- 10:13[David] ties to negotiators, the approval process is what people will scrutinize.
- 10:18[Maya] Who else is in the bidding group?
- 10:20[David] Todd Boehly is named and a US government arm.
- 10:23[Maya] Wait, really?
- 10:24[Maya] The government itself is in the mix?
- 10:26[David] That's what the summary says.
- 10:27[David] It doesn't spell out more than that, so I won't either.
- 10:31[Maya] I keep wanting to ask what that means in practice, and I
- 10:33[Maya] have to remind myself it's one line in a summary.
- 10:36[Maya] We just don't have more.
- 10:37[David] Right.
- 10:38[David] When the source gives you a name and a category, you say
- 10:40[David] the name and the category.
- 10:42[David] Anything past that is guessing.
- 10:44[Maya] Did anybody respond to all this?
- 10:46[David] Not in the Reuters summary.
- 10:48[David] The White House, Treasury, and Lukoil did not respond to requests for
- 10:51[David] comment.
- 10:52[Maya] So we've got a big story and a lot of Silence.
- 10:55[David] Which is normal this early.
- 10:56[David] A newspaper report lands, the principals say nothing, and the details come
- 11:00[David] out slowly.
- 11:01[Maya] Silence isn't an answer, though.
- 11:03[Maya] It just means we don't have one yet.
- 11:06[David] Exactly.
- 11:06[David] No comment isn't a denial, and it isn't a confirmation.
- 11:09[David] It's just an empty space, and we'll leave it empty.
- 11:12[Maya] Honestly, that's what I'm watching.
- 11:14[Maya] Does an approval happen, and does anyone explain who's on the buying
- 11:18[Maya] side?
- 11:19[David] And whether the talks about the war and the talks about the
- 11:21[David] assets stay separate.
- 11:23[David] That one's a good one because the story is that they're now
- 11:25[David] in the same conversation.
- 11:27[David] The Times report, as Reuters summarizes it, has the oil deal inside
- 11:31[David] the Ukraine talks.
- 11:32[Maya] Which is why I keep coming back to who's on the buying
- 11:35[Maya] side.
- 11:36[Maya] The summary says the group includes Todd Boehly and a US government
- 11:39[Maya] arm, and it doesn't say more than that.
- 11:42[David] Those are the real open questions.
- 11:44[David] We'll see what comes out.
- 11:45[Maya] We will.
- 11:46[Maya] Okay.
- 11:47[Maya] That's the rundown for today.
- 11:48[Maya] Time to wrap up.
- 11:50[Maya] Okay, quick lap around the table.
- 11:52[Maya] Tennessee tried to carry out an execution, and the state is now
- 11:55[Maya] reviewing how it went.
- 11:56[David] The senior check came with a smaller number than the one first
- 11:59[David] floated, and the Ukraine oil deal is still a reported maybe.
- 12:03[Maya] Right.
- 12:03[Maya] So what are you watching, David?
- 12:05[David] The Tennessee review.
- 12:07[David] If the state publishes findings, I want to see whether they answer
- 12:09[David] the questions the lawyers raised and whether anyone says who approves that
- 12:14[David] oil deal.
- 12:15[Maya] Mine's simpler.
- 12:16[Maya] I'm watching my mailbox for a check.
- 12:19[Maya] Probably a long wait.
- 12:20[David] Don't spend it yet.
- 12:22[Maya] Never.
- 12:22[Maya] Thanks for hanging out with us, everybody.
- 12:24[Maya] I'm Maya.
- 12:25[Maya] This was the Morning Rundown, and we'll see you tomorrow.