Latest / The Team House / Chief Of The Directorate Of Operations For CIA | Jack Devine | Ep. 260
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, guys, it's Jack. I just wanted to talk to you today
- 0:02about a way that you can help support the podcast. If you're not already,
- 0:07we would really appreciate it if you guys went and reviewed us on Apple
- 0:10or Spotify. Those reviews really help people find the podcast and help it get
- 0:15recognized, and you know, if you've been enjoying the show, we really
- 0:18appreciate your support. Another thing that you can do to support the channel is
- 0:23to become a Patreon member. So we have Patreon memberships that started just five
- 0:28dollars a month, and when you sign up, you get access to all
- 0:32of our episodes add free. That's the big bonus for that. I mean,
- 0:36we also do some Patreon bonus episodes for our subscribers, but this is
- 0:41the biggest and best way that you can support the Teamhouse channel and podcast if
- 0:47you'd like to, and we really appreciate that. So go and check us
- 0:51out at patreon dot com. Slash the Teamhouse, Special Operations, SP and
- 1:02I the Team House with Your Hopes. Jack Murphy and David Park. Welcome
- 1:15to episode two hundred and sixty of The Team House. I'm Jack Murphy or
- 1:19with Dave Park, and we're very happy tonight to have in studio our guest,
- 1:23Jack Divine. Jack spent thirty two years at the CIA, postings all
- 1:27over the world and finished up his career as the head of the Director of
- 1:32Operations or the National Condestine Service. He's the author of a memoir, Good
- 1:37Hunting, and his most recent book is Spymaster's Prism. Jack, thank you
- 1:42very much for joining us. It's a pleasure fun so Jack. One of
- 1:47the ways we like to begin these stories is to ask about your story,
- 1:51about your origin story, how did you grow up and what led you to
- 1:56the CIA. Well, growing up is a good question. I was born
- 2:00in southwest Philadelphia and it was a very parochial environment. Like my cousins,
- 2:05everybody with the same background, Irish Americans thought we'd live in Philadelphia forever.
- 2:12My father was the plumbing and he business a superintendent of plumbing. As a
- 2:15son, I probably should have joined Union six ninety right now I had,
- 2:19I did some I was going to use the word we won't say that dirty
- 2:24jobs in plumbing. Yeah, my father thought it would be good to get
- 2:30exposed to that. But when I was a senior and getting ready to graduate,
- 2:37he said, oh look, here's here's a school that when you apply
- 2:44him, become a teacher. I mean, you could be a teacher.
- 2:46So that sounds like a good idea. It was as simple as that,
- 2:50right, And I went out and went to Westchester State and then later Villanova
- 2:54University. But at the time I was planning on becoming a teacher and was
- 2:59a teacher. I graduated, taught school in suburban Philadelphia in two different schools,
- 3:06and along the way I met Pat Devine and she gave me for I
- 3:16think it was birthday a book by David Wise called The Invisible Government, and
- 3:21it was a scandalous book about CIA, the deep state they call it today,
- 3:27right, the deep state, and how they were overthrowing governments around the
- 3:30world and fighting the communists. And when I was in school and I was
- 3:34taught by nuns and priests, but it was the atheist communism and we're going
- 3:38to save the world, so a sense of mission. Well, so I
- 3:42read the book and said, wow, this is fascinating. It was a
- 3:44thought about teaching. Here are practitioners of foreign policy. So Pat said,
- 3:49why don't you write? So I did. I wrote a letter and penn
- 3:53and ake and it went in after a while I got an invitation to go
- 3:57down there, I think it was twelfth in Chestnut and for an interview.
- 4:01And the fellow looked like what I thought a spy should look like, you
- 4:05know, tweet suit, wind tip shoes, hair, back pipe. Right,
- 4:12ye, Alan, that's a spy. So I left and I thought,
- 4:18I thought that one recentably well, right, And I got a letter
- 4:21saying, welcome, come to Washington. Let me fast forward for one second
- 4:27if you can tolerate it. So a few years ago, I'm talking in
- 4:30the last five years, I was doing something with the agency and they said,
- 4:34Jack, you know we have a present for you. I said,
- 4:39you do He said yeah, we have two letters, the one you wrote
- 4:43wow, and they gave me a copy of it. I read. I
- 4:45thought, I would never have hired this guy write. He can't write.
- 4:48I mean, it doesn't even know what you do. It was like,
- 4:50why, why why that letter got sent on to the next place. I've
- 4:54known that. So the second one was by the fellow who interviewed him.
- 4:58It turned out that he wasn't a spy, never been a broad, never
- 5:00met an agent. He was an HR guy. So the letter, instead
- 5:03of saying look, he really knocked the ball out of the park. We
- 5:06have to have the guy. It had a tone like, yeah, not
- 5:10bad. I thought there was doing me a favor. But it did get
- 5:15to the point, how did you How did Jack Divine get in there?
- 5:18What is he doing in here? None of his revelatives are in State Department
- 5:23or not defense. At his chaise, he's never been out of the United
- 5:27States. I have no idea to this day. All I can tell you
- 5:31is because one of the things about writing a book you do a lot of
- 5:34introspection. How did I get here? And it has more cohesiveness than you
- 5:41think when you're living in But I think at the end I would say somehow
- 5:46I had a DNA that fit that particular job that I really a summerendipitous as
- 5:51it sounds. What they saw what I didn't see work beautifully, and I
- 5:58had a I thought I had a very fortunate career. That's what's very interesting
- 6:02about it, I think, is that you know you weren't recruited. It
- 6:05sounds like on the basis of an application or an exam, but rather a
- 6:09face to face meeting with a recruiter who's like, yeah, that guy has
- 6:12something we'll be able to use right. And I think today this is a
- 6:15problem because we're in technology. So your first hurdle is you have to apply
- 6:21right, and you have to identify the job and know what job to apply
- 6:26for. Now there's more books that might help you sort it out, but
- 6:29they missed the opportunity because some people look really good in paper, right,
- 6:32and you're missing the person that has entrepreneurial energy. When I say entrepreneur,
- 6:38I don't mean about how they create a business. But they create things,
- 6:41they build it. It's not that they do their work well. You can
- 6:45test doing work well. So I think that process I was lucky. I
- 6:50think that was helpful to me, the personal, personal interview, and so
- 6:57I'm grateful. So today, when you want to apply, simply go online
- 7:00and submit your resume and fill out whatever they have on the CIA dot com
- 7:04website. When you wrote this letter, what did you put in it?
- 7:08Like? What did you think was going to capture the eye of the CIA.
- 7:12I wish I had thought of something. It just said, you know,
- 7:16you got an interesting organization I'd like to join. It was really light,
- 7:19I mean it was a page. It was with a pen and pencil,
- 7:24and they must have said, look, we feel sorry, give him
- 7:26an interview. Given this guy an interview, right, But I mean,
- 7:30I have no idea why that letter, because I'm not I'm not exaggerating this
- 7:35thing. I would not hire this guy. I would not hire him based
- 7:39on the letter. Now I've written there since then ten thousand cables, so
- 7:44my writing I could put verbs and subjects and objects together. But you know,
- 7:48it wasn't It just wasn't like I really didn't know exactly what the CIA
- 7:55did, right, and I was interested in We were talking earlier about the
- 7:59COVID act action part, the action part of the agency. And again not
- 8:03to dwell on this, but we can talk about the not the org chart,
- 8:05but you having the operational side, people that run spies, people that
- 8:11run covert action, and people that do both. The last one is a
- 8:15pretty narrow band. Most people in the CIA that are operators want nothing to
- 8:20do with covied action. Even the experienced ones don't want to do it because
- 8:26it's trouble. You can end up in a crossfire, political crossfires. Others
- 8:33joined because they wanted to be in the espionage collection business. I think where
- 8:37it was a little different is I was interested from the beginning in the covert,
- 8:43but you know, you really start doing your operations spy by spy and
- 8:48my case, I leap frog out of my first assignment by being in Chile,
- 8:54which became a huge covert action operation which has influenced my development through the
- 8:58years. And CIA, So can you since we're here, can you sort
- 9:03of tell people, like what the difference is in terms of the agency when
- 9:07it comes to espionage and covered action, how they're executed by individuals and by
- 9:13the organization. In CIA, you never use the word spy. It's elegant,
- 9:20it's case officer agent, right, But when your community communicating with outside
- 9:26world, spy means someone that's working inside a foreign government, a foreigner.
- 9:33And the second book is titled Spy Master's Prism. I was a spy master,
- 9:39not the spy. I was the person that was managing those spies.
- 9:45So that's in the espionage area, a subset of that as counterintelligence keep an
- 9:50eye out who's doing that to us? But the other part, when CI
- 9:56was being created in nineteen forty seven, COVID Action actually sat in the State
- 10:01Department. They were responsible for it, and when it was organized, they
- 10:07brought the State Department element and dropped it. In the early days, they
- 10:11fought among themselves the spying part and the action part. No, there were
- 10:16we say action. It's political actions. You know, in Italy forty eight,
- 10:22stopping the Communists from taking over, the coup, in Iran, the
- 10:26coup and Guadalmala, the Bay, all those are covert action pieces as opposed
- 10:31to spying. For Hollywood, covered action is James Bond and the spy came
- 10:39in from the cold, le care that you're spying. So you have those
- 10:43divisions. But even when I did a history, I read history on each
- 10:48of the stations before I went there. Italy when it was first form had
- 10:52two stations, two bosses, one for covert action and one for spying.
- 10:58But they became in integrated and it became a single discipline. There was you
- 11:03were going to be a case, you're going to be an operator, and
- 11:05you will do both. But I would say instinctively, many people, most
- 11:11vast majority, are more comfortable on the operational collection side than they are in
- 11:20covered action congresses. Everybody except the President of the United States, right whoever
- 11:26once in a while, and I should note this, when they created the
- 11:30CIA. In the creation of it, there's only one clause, and I'm
- 11:37not quoting it directly, but it's something like, and you shall carry out
- 11:41those special activities directed by the President of United States. Other you're spying,
- 11:46you're collecting, you're producing finished fine intelligence for decision makers. But by the
- 11:50way, if the President calls you when something done, you're going to do
- 11:54that. That became the covered action Charter. And again not to get into
- 12:01this, but as one go through history, the COVID action part often grabs
- 12:05your headlines. And whether we're talking about Afghanistan or around Contra Chile, when
- 12:13all those things involved action. The one thing that many people don't understand.
- 12:18It's a key, key point. And some of the folks that I don't
- 12:20want to talk about because I don't want to promote their books because they disagree
- 12:24with them. But one of the key things I know of no operation or
- 12:31my tenure, and I've also studied it. Other words, I've made a
- 12:35study of COVID action, and that is there's been no COVID action that wasn't
- 12:39approved by the President of United States that I'm aware of, right and in
- 12:43seventy five could be off by year it was in writing. In other words,
- 12:50if you see something in the press and someone's reading it's not the rogue
- 12:54CIA. There is no rogue CIA. It's more bureaucratic than would like to
- 13:00think, less romantic, and it is there's real oversight to it. So
- 13:05if you have a problem, you need to understand despite everything else you read,
- 13:09the President the United States has approved that. So do you think that
- 13:16one of the reasons that there's this mythos of this rogue CIA or factions within
- 13:22the CIA that go rogue is because the CIA is there to carry out these
- 13:28cover actions and then they're the president's plausible deniability, right that nobody from the
- 13:33CI I will ever come out and say, well, the President told us
- 13:35to do that. It's just, hey, guess what the CIA did,
- 13:39and that's it, right, And I think at the very beginning plausible denial
- 13:45was a key part of it. The problem is when you look at the
- 13:48reality Afghanistan, you're supporting one hundred and twenty five fighters, right, hundred
- 13:54and twenty five thousand fighters, Plausible denials deniability is low. I would say,
- 14:01it's really design. So you're not rubbing your hand in the face of
- 14:07somebody and you're provoking it, so they have to respond it's below the radar.
- 14:11Now, some covert actions never publicized, never known about, and there's
- 14:16plusible denial, but the big ones, you know, it's a stretch to
- 14:22say, oh, we're going to say that we're not helping in Ukraine today.
- 14:26I mean, it's no, it's not discredible. Yeah, you have.
- 14:30I guess maybe we'll talk about it when we get to the part about
- 14:33Afghanist. Well, actually, let's talk about it now, because you talk
- 14:37about in the beginning of the book, because like you said, your chapters
- 14:39aren't necessarily chronological but kind of thematic, and you talk about these ideas you
- 14:46have about covert action and what it takes for COVID action to be successful.
- 14:50And I thought that was really really insightful because I've never seen sort of these
- 14:56tenets I guess like summarized. And look, if you want a COVID action
- 15:03to work, these things have to be in line and sere. So you
- 15:09talk about viable partners in place. So I think it's really important. As
- 15:16I said, I was a teacher, so both books are meant to be
- 15:22learning. Let me tell you from my my view, my perspective of having
- 15:26been involved in it, how these things unfold I think policy makers before they
- 15:33and the president before he signs it. There's a thought process before the agency
- 15:37execute it. It's you know, you have to think about why are we
- 15:41doing it? And I think I'd like to think I was an original thinker.
- 15:45But this is the just war theory from the thirteenth century, right right,
- 15:50And it means, first of all, you have to have an intrinsically
- 15:54evil enemy. People don't like using the word evil, although Putin's helped bring
- 15:58it back and so a few others out there. But so you have to
- 16:00have a real enemy. This has to be threatening to your kind of other
- 16:03worries. You don't meddle in covert action to annoy some democratic government and it's
- 16:08not sharing your banana ratios and export import It has to be an enemy that
- 16:15is an applacable enemy that is coming at you. You really should try every
- 16:21other thing you know, you should try diplomasy, economic sanctions, whatever,
- 16:26before you get to your covert action. The same thing through with the military.
- 16:30You want to hold your military back as long as you can, but
- 16:33there's a step in between where it's the covert action where you're taking quasi military
- 16:38or taking political action. So you know, having a intrinsic trying everything.
- 16:45You have to have a reasonable chance of success. Don't do this if you
- 16:51well, let's give it the old College try. Maybe that's what happened to
- 16:55Chili. President United said give it the old College tribe because the Field station
- 16:57was saying, this one just can't get done. We'll give it a try.
- 17:02You have to have a reasonable sense of success. You have to minimize
- 17:08the loss of innocence. That's what they said in those days. That's how
- 17:11they talked. So today it's civilian losses. You have to limit the bloodshed.
- 17:15There has to be proportionality. You can't kill fifty thousand people to save
- 17:21three. There's something you know. You have to have a sense of proportionality.
- 17:26And then Jack Divine has his own I've added so the theologians that they're
- 17:33I'm challenging them, and I said, well, you have to bipartisan support.
- 17:36If you can't get a consensus around that this is something to do,
- 17:41then then you shouldn't. You should not enter into it. It has to
- 17:47be something that the American people, when they read about it, are comfortable
- 17:49with. And the any way they are is if they know they're representatives it's
- 17:52going through a due process. You also have to have fighter you have the
- 18:00people in the ground that want what you're selling. I'm totally opposed to force
- 18:06feeding democracy. It won't work and a lot of people are going to get
- 18:10hurt. But or if you want to fight against the common enemy, you
- 18:14have to have people that really want to fight or you will be you will
- 18:17leave the battlefield a loser. So again, you have to have a team
- 18:25on the ground. And I think that the principal considerations that there may be
- 18:29one other that will go on to me in the middle of the night,
- 18:30but if you apply those every time you're going to use force the military CIA,
- 18:37you need to be thinking about the outcomes and why now, And there's
- 18:41a process. And I believe in covert action. I'm advocating, but by
- 18:45my criteria, you narrow the number of adventures. You don't do it for
- 18:49the hell of it, right and because you're just might work. How good
- 18:55do you think Americans have been at gauging secondary and tertiary like effects of COVID
- 19:03actions? Like I think, I mean, I know, like Rack for
- 19:06instance, wasn't a COVID action was it was very overt action, But we
- 19:11really administratively misgauge what would replace Saddam and and and so in these other places
- 19:18where we do, uh, you know, conduct these covered actions. Do
- 19:23you think that the people that people have a good idea of what will be
- 19:27the end result when when it's completed. I think we'd have to run through
- 19:33history with all the different examples. But I think there's some policy makers that
- 19:37don't necessarily go through the steps, but they have like in their head,
- 19:44how will this look? When I read the Washington Post to the right right,
- 19:48I remember Bob Gates used that it is you know, if it doesn't
- 19:51feel good, you might not might not want to do it. So I'm
- 19:53not sure everyone sits back and says what happens if? Usually there's so much
- 20:02momentum. We want to get rid of them, we want to fix this
- 20:03problem, we want to get it done. And frankly, even with the
- 20:08best of brains you want to go through the exercise. It's hard to anticipate
- 20:14what's going to happen. I will tell you, for example, in the
- 20:18Chili experience, which we'll get to some point, the desire for to get
- 20:22rid of allendi, but there was an assumption that he would go and there'd
- 20:30be an interim a year and the military would settle it down and the politicians
- 20:33would come back. They had no idea that the next regime was going to
- 20:40be a dictatorship for nineteen years. Right, So even when you're thinking about
- 20:47it and you know it's you'll have reactive things. And this comes back to
- 20:52the discussion had error about conventional wisdom. Even when you're thinking about it.
- 20:56It's a soft science, but I think it should be done. I just
- 21:00haven't found it as the coin of the realm that everybody says, Well,
- 21:03now, let's talk about the downside, because you have to be very careful.
- 21:07A number of people make a career in government say no, that's not
- 21:10going to work, right, So you've got to keep them. You invite
- 21:14them in once in a while, but they can really slow the train down.
- 21:17Let's jump right into Chile. Since it sounds like that was your first
- 21:22station. Well, actually, if we can talk about because Befortunately you were
- 21:26at headquarters, and I think that it's important to talk about that because that
- 21:30was your first exposure to somebody who became quite famous from the CIA, right
- 21:36working at your working as an analyst with Ames. Then oh, no,
- 21:40well, that's when I first started with Rick Ames, but that was waiting
- 21:41to get into the training program. So we'll get the yeah for sure.
- 21:48Yeah. But my first experience well actually was on the check desk and interim
- 21:52and that it's in the spring the spring probably spring, if you will,
- 21:57which was fascinating Defense secretary come out and affected. But the first overseas,
- 22:03the first real headquarters job I had was I mean, the permanent job was
- 22:10as the It doesn't sound very interesting, but in Latin America they had a
- 22:18covert action guy and a foreign intelligence guy, and I was doing the I'd
- 22:22come in early, read all the traffic and decide what was important for the
- 22:26chief of Covert Action. They sadly at the same time the fellow that worked
- 22:33the FI was a guy named Dick Welsh, So every day I saw Dick
- 22:37great Man and he was assassinated in Athens. But that was the first job.
- 22:44But I was on the covert action chief of operations and one day said
- 22:49Jack, come with me, and he brought me down to the head of
- 22:52the Chili operation. He said, Larry, this is how the careers go.
- 22:57Larry, I think you should have Jack. So I thought, well,
- 23:00maybe it's getting rid of f right. But it was to put me
- 23:03in the middle of what was then created the Chili Task Force. And they
- 23:07brought their best people. Not me, I mean I was I was a
- 23:12note taker. Again we'll get to that. But they brought the best officers
- 23:15that they thought could do COVID action and put them in there, and their
- 23:19job was to execute the policy of stopping Illendi from taking office. So I
- 23:26went from that covert action studious reading and studying to being involved in the task
- 23:33Force. And part of my job was to read all the traffic so I
- 23:36have a good sense of what happened, and I learned a lot is and
- 23:40again we could go point by point, but I learned a lot, and
- 23:42then that naturally led to me going to Chile. Right in being going covert
- 23:48action, there was a little bit was it a different training pipeline after the
- 23:52form because because you went to the forum and then jungle warfare like demo school
- 23:59where let's talk about jump training, jump training, So jump training. They
- 24:04I was married and had three kids at the time, Right, I'm a
- 24:07little older than normal, but I had been teaching five six years as chairman
- 24:11department, and you know, so if you didn't jump, you had two
- 24:18weeks off. So I thought, what the hell, take two weeks and
- 24:19go to the beach, right, and Pat said, oh, Jack,
- 24:23you're going to miss the camaraderie. And I said, it's true, it
- 24:27is, and it was. It actually was more true than I thought.
- 24:30And I said, I'll take a pass. And then the base commander came
- 24:36over and said, look, I see you're not jumping. You know you
- 24:38should jump. It's it's better than sex. So well, and I looked
- 24:42at it and thought maybe what he has in mind. And so I'm still
- 24:48not signing up. I want this two weeks. I need a break here,
- 24:51but I so I go back to headquarters and my first interview is with
- 24:56the chief of COVID Action Operations. Now I thought that's where the action.
- 25:00It actually was the media piece, right I wanted to be And I didn't
- 25:04realize about Chile, but I thought that. So I walked in and he
- 25:07had parachute paraphernalia around the room. His name was Utova. And I walked
- 25:14in and before I said anything, so Jackie, if you jumped yet?
- 25:18And I said no, but I'm looking forward to it. So I didn't
- 25:21jump for camaraderie. I didn't jump for sex. I jumped for career.
- 25:26That I made five jumps, but it was the right thing, the right
- 25:30thing to do, but I ended up not going to covert action. This
- 25:34is a really important vignette because my current counselor was a guy named Jerry Drower.
- 25:45Elias was bender. I can say this because he's out in the public
- 25:49and he was not involved the Bay of Pigs. He was. He jumped
- 25:52behind the lines and putting the resistance together in France, right, But he's
- 25:57sitting there with a cigar when he could smoke a cigar in the building and
- 26:00it's alicide. And he said, you're too big to go to the Russia
- 26:03division, Because I said, I want to go to Russia. That's where
- 26:06the spy is, you know, that's the operation. The truth is,
- 26:08that isn't where the action is because you're running very dark operations the middle of
- 26:12the night to find a place where you can put a note in a tree.
- 26:15Right, That isn't what I was thinking of, because you're too tall
- 26:18to be a spy. Come with me. So he took me over the
- 26:22Chief of Latin America and he said, Bill, I think you need Jack,
- 26:27Jack, you've belonged over here, so yeah, your here' That's how
- 26:33the applying process went. And then I sat there there, Wait a minute,
- 26:37I'm too tall for Russia, but somehow I'm going to blend in and
- 26:41Latin America. Then what I find out is he was recruiting for Latin America.
- 26:45I was his next hit. So he brought me over. But couldn't
- 26:48have been a better thing because I think, and let me just put a
- 26:53footnote, the spying isn't about being seen. The whole trick is to be
- 26:57operate in visible. There was not good enough to be four foot three.
- 27:02You can't be seen, so it doesn't matter whether you're five five six or
- 27:06six five. So but it was fortuitous, and that when I get back
- 27:11to the book again, when I look at I wonder if it was fortuitous.
- 27:15I wonder whether there was cosmic energy pulling me somewhere and then pulling me
- 27:22because it had more of a pattern than just hopping around. But that unscientific.
- 27:29Because I had a fellow, the worker, I got a five year
- 27:30plan. I'm gonna do this. I'm gonna do this, I'm gonna do
- 27:33That's not what's going to happen to know what's going to happen. But you
- 27:37can have all the five year plans you want. The system is going to
- 27:41bring you along. So I would I would say that was interesting, how
- 27:44the the invisible hand fratuitously I ended up doing something I really belong doing in
- 27:51my view, So you and I meant that theme that like a fiction writer
- 28:00could have written this book because it because it's it's a story. The way
- 28:04you're saying it is that it's it's it seems like it's threaded, even if
- 28:11it's not. You know, the people who you work with, how things
- 28:15keep coming back, it's amazing. But you go to Chile and we're talking
- 28:18about you know, there's Nixon wants a coup in Chile, right, So
- 28:25it actually starts before I go when I'm on the task for it, until
- 28:27I know what took place there is I know. Again, remember I'm a
- 28:33lieutenant maybe right, that's the rank, so I'm not I'm not the big
- 28:37policy general chiefst. I mean, no, I'm a lieutenant, second lieutenant.
- 28:44But the what I was doing is reading the traffic so I could see
- 28:48the correspondence down to the chiefest station saying Yandy had been elected by a plurality
- 28:56thirty nine percent. There wasn't a majority there or two other parties, and
- 29:00it was unanticipated and he was going to be put in office with approval of
- 29:07Congress, you know, sixty days later. So they did very little to
- 29:11block him from getting elected. So they missed a better opportunity to do COVID
- 29:17action. But President Nixon was very concerned about the Red Sandwich Chili on one
- 29:26end, Cuba and the other castors coming down there visiting in Chile, and
- 29:30you and people have to realize back then the idea that Latin America could go
- 29:34communist was a reality. So his decision was stop it from happening. And
- 29:41the chief of station was an old timer European oss Well, and he said,
- 29:48look, we don't have enough time, we don't have the infrastructure.
- 29:49It's going to be bloodshed, and I don't think we can get it done.
- 29:52Sounds like some of my issues. And the answer was do things,
- 29:59give it a t and if you're not prepared to do it, I won't
- 30:07use his name, well, use first name Can. Can will be down
- 30:11on the next plane with a ticket for you to come back. Now,
- 30:15Ken is the fellow that I worked for in the COVID action, so I
- 30:18know this story well, and his advice to Washington was accurate, and the
- 30:25decision made by policymakers. Now this comes to me later as I begin to
- 30:29reflect on It's not like I was sitting there understanding all of this, and
- 30:36in the end it turned out to be a fiasco. They tried several different
- 30:41silly things and none of it worked. But unbeknownst to the station, there
- 30:48was another. There was a retired colonel, Colonel Bideaux, and he initiated
- 30:57kidnapping the commander chief the Armed Forces, who was killed in the process.
- 31:02Oh my god, and the entire country said that's enough, and Allendi came
- 31:07in on a wave of popularity. That's that's the coup that failed. We
- 31:11were not part of that, but we were trying. There was very specific
- 31:15I'm not again not talking out of school. I'm very careful with what I
- 31:18said. But the Senate did an investigation, and at the time I thought
- 31:22it was outrageous that the Senate would investigate what I did on my tour,
- 31:27And then I read it years later and I realized they did a really good
- 31:30job. So it's you know, you can have all the theories in this,
- 31:33but they did a good job. And what happened is you fast forward,
- 31:38but we get the seventy three. I'm now very experienced in that station
- 31:42and know a good deal about what's going on. The real coup came,
- 31:48the US was not involved in the coup, and the record will show that.
- 31:52Now there's people that will die believing that that's the case. I'm just
- 31:55here to tell you I was there, I saw it. I know what
- 31:59happened. I know exactly what happened, and the military moved on its own
- 32:04for its own reasons. And I can elaborate, but I don't want to
- 32:07do the whole Chili story. One answer for it. Are you allowed to
- 32:10elaborate on what the agency's plan was? You know that it sounds like they
- 32:15got events overtook that plan. You mean in the first the Yeah, No,
- 32:20it's the remove I ended. It was called Track two. It's documented
- 32:25the thing. The other thing that was stupid. Well, I don't want
- 32:29to be so crushed, but I think it's unwise to cut out the ambassador.
- 32:32And I know of no other case. I'm sure there are others,
- 32:36but in this particular case, the ambassador didn't know that that was the agency's
- 32:39policy. Oh wow, and he was unhappy found out. Sure, are
- 32:45is are the How are the relationships between ambassadors and station chiefs or ambassadors and
- 32:52the agency? Are they often contentious or is it varied? Well, they
- 32:58were very problematic after the war or because many countries the most powerful person in
- 33:04the country was the chief of station because he had brought in Italy. The
- 33:10government that brought the power was thankful to the CIA because they provided the funding
- 33:16and support. And you wers can get in people's head. Ambassador's the president's
- 33:24representative, so there was tension, but in seventy five there was an agreement.
- 33:30The president said the ambassador is in charge. So then it becomes an
- 33:35issue of every chief going out and state same thing. If you have a
- 33:39problem, you bring it back to us. Right. Well, when I
- 33:44was lecturing, speaking before the chiefs going out, I would say, listen,
- 33:49they'll tell you that, but don't come back with that message because we're
- 33:52going to send you one saying you fix it out there. So there's an
- 33:55incentive for people to make it work in the feel and the better ones,
- 34:01the best of the lot. Their job is to find and wise ambassadors this
- 34:07is an arm. This is an arm that can be very helpful to you,
- 34:10and you can and your responsibilities make sure the ambassadors fully brief. So
- 34:15I don't think there's big problems. It's not one of the key issues.
- 34:20If you go down on this, it probably doesn't meet number twenty. If
- 34:23I can't even I don't even think it's an issue of any merit. Yeah,
- 34:29now in Chile, because one of the things you mentioned in your book
- 34:31is that you were not necessarily a natural case officer. You weren't really an
- 34:36extrovert. I hope it didn't dwell too much on it. No, no,
- 34:40but essentially because when you mention your wife's like sort of her ability to
- 34:49be a social lubricant in a lot of those situations. So it's worth down
- 34:52at the farm. You have events where you pretend you're at a cocktail party,
- 34:57but I was never at a cocktail party in my life. I've been
- 35:00in the basic basement with twenty aunts and uncles singing, having but that was
- 35:05not socializing in a diplomatic setting. I'd never been in a setting like that
- 35:09that isn't I've never been in a country well, I was in a country
- 35:12club one it's a friend of mine had money and we went to the country
- 35:15club one. But my point was I wasn't used to that and socializing out
- 35:21of your out of your clan, right. Yeah, but I'm not even
- 35:24thinking this way. I just thought everybody's the same in I just not really
- 35:29zero zeroed in on it. So for an embassy, you arrive and Pat
- 35:36goes over to the ambassador's wife, and you have white gloves and you put
- 35:38the card down. This is this is not Jack, this isn't my world.
- 35:43Right. So you go to a cocktail party. Jack is the wallflower
- 35:47on there, right, But then the the white tornado comes in and whirls
- 35:53around the room and you know, grabs everybody, talks to every and then
- 35:58says Jack, give this guy your card inviting the lunch. So after a
- 36:02while, you know, I adapt and peop will adapt. And I got
- 36:07the rhythm. I understand the drill, but it did not it didn't come
- 36:09naturally needed to the first recruitment. Yeah, I wanted to ask you about
- 36:14your first recruitment because I thought it was I think it was a great lesson
- 36:16of how, you know, people could they get better at things? But
- 36:21you know, well, I think there's two sides. I mean, it's
- 36:22just you get better, but you have to get started. Yeah, right,
- 36:27right. And there's another thing when I did the book that I felt
- 36:30bad about, and that is we interviewed a lot of people, my staff
- 36:36did because I thought they'd be more comfortable. I would set it up,
- 36:38call the person and then the staff would interview and we can talk about some
- 36:43of the bizarre answers that came back. But what was really interesting when I
- 36:51went back through the book, every time I left, I said, thanks
- 36:54boss, it was a good tour, right, appreciate it. Learned a
- 36:59lot. But when I started doing the book, I began to realize that
- 37:04I had been mentored job after job after job after job very different people.
- 37:12And they call a trade craft and the whereas people don't think it's a trade.
- 37:15It's like you're a goldsmith, you're a plumber. You know, as
- 37:17you learn a trade, you get your you get out of their apprenticeship and
- 37:22then you go to work with the journeyman and then you become a master and
- 37:25your craft. And that was what was happening to me. So when you
- 37:30get to the first recruitment, the deputy, I was slow out of the
- 37:35starting box that I was meeting people, but I wasn't closing any deals.
- 37:38So he was a very experienced officer, a go to guy, and he
- 37:44said, Jack, I want you to meet this our agent, you know,
- 37:52and we had a number for him, but I will just say X,
- 37:54right, meet X, because he thinks he might have a recruitment for
- 37:59out there that you could just handle that. So I meet the guy and
- 38:04we have a lunch together. It's X and why Why is a senior member
- 38:07in the Communist Party. So we're having lunch and the lunch is going on,
- 38:13and I'm talking about the political dynamics of the world of this and they're
- 38:15serving a resos, which, if you have them, are all you got.
- 38:20You gotta this. This is a this is a real test of me.
- 38:23So I would have another glass of wine and have another reso, and
- 38:28finally, excess to me, Jack, just tell the guy you'll give them
- 38:31a thousand dollars and he will agree to work for you. So I said,
- 38:36we don't mind working for uncle. A good idea. So the point
- 38:39was it was a setup. But then after a while, what you realized
- 38:44was when you get to these situations, you almost have you have to create
- 38:47the dynamic that you already have the recruitment in place. And it's like selling
- 38:52any product. There are a lot of people that can do that. They
- 38:53can't close the deal. So I was taught how to close the deal.
- 38:59After you do that, you want to close deals. Okay, So again
- 39:04it's part of the training and maturation of a professional. But when you look
- 39:09back on it, you laugh. You have to laugh, But then you
- 39:14realize people are going out of their way to make you better, make you
- 39:20a professional. And that was a different generation. I'm not saying it doesn't
- 39:23happen. I certainly hope it happens today. I believe in it. It
- 39:28tried to do it myself. But it is so valuable to have people in
- 39:34a service who are looking at you and you know, and they cut me
- 39:37a lot of slack. That's the other thing I wouldn't have put up with
- 39:40me. They were understanding. I thought I knew more than I did,
- 39:44right, But actually there's one report and I'll leave it at the size.
- 39:47So it was in Mexico and the fitness report said he has this smidgeon of
- 39:52arrogance, right, So if you had that, you should be you should
- 39:59be crestfalling. Right. Oh yeah, that's good. That's how average.
- 40:02And I was though I thought that was good, but I got I got
- 40:07away with it. And but he puts smidget fairness, he puts Smidgeen in
- 40:10it. By then I thought, you know, I have second tour.
- 40:13I really knew how right. I had so much to learn. I mean,
- 40:15it's but that role is so critical when we have services. I'm sure
- 40:22it's true in the military and it's special special groups. You just have to
- 40:24have that. It's interesting in a way in an at testament to like the
- 40:30people who didn't mentor you in a way though, because in the military you
- 40:32have mentors, but they are mentoring their direct team members that they are going
- 40:39to work with. Where I think in the inn see a lot of times
- 40:42even though you're the same team, it is also a very individual effort in
- 40:45a lot of ways. So it's it is people really taking their time out
- 40:51to ensure that you become better at your job. I think that's absolutely right,
- 40:58that it was a conscious effort to make me better and they could have
- 41:02done something else, or some people don't even want to see you succeed.
- 41:07I mean, it's like I got my own thing. You're here, you're
- 41:10a hotshot. You go do your thing. So when we would interview people,
- 41:15you know, it gave me a chance. When I made the first
- 41:19call, I know, I said thank you, but you know what you
- 41:22did mean, So I mean it meant a lot to me. So I
- 41:24felt I felt like I was somehow closing in the deal. But some of
- 41:28them had passed on. But let me tell you one story about one guy.
- 41:32So he was a good boy from Iowa or someone out in a farm
- 41:35somewhere. He retired. He was my deputy in Iran, and he was
- 41:38a seasoned running expert and I was new from Latin America and he was really
- 41:45help help sustain me, to make sure I didn't step on a landmine.
- 41:50So I didn't spoken to yours because I had moved on. He had moved
- 41:54on. He moved out, said io, So the wife is there,
- 41:59and she said, it's Jack the Vine on the phone. I literally heard
- 42:00him go. He got an off. He said, Jack, what's up?
- 42:07And I said, look, I just wanted to talk to you about
- 42:09our time in a round. He said, oh god, I thought we
- 42:12were getting another big investigation. He said, anything he touched was going to
- 42:15be trouble. So so I was thinking, I was, you know,
- 42:20he's going to be a treat that talked to me. This was like,
- 42:22oh my god, he's back. So the book allowed me to do some
- 42:29of that, to reach out, yeah, and to like connect a lot
- 42:32of that. So, you know, we talked about your first or one
- 42:36of your first recruitments or your first recruitment. You also mentioned one of your
- 42:38first meets and how that didn't quite go U when you were in the vehicle
- 42:43and the U source just handed you a bunch of stuff. You god,
- 42:47I forgot that story. Yeah, well there's a couple of rough first ones.
- 42:52So I was very conscientious coming out of training. I had introduced in
- 42:57my operations high tech and all of this stuff, and you know, clean
- 43:04yourself before the operation, and you have everything worked out. And it was
- 43:07going to be a car pickup. You know, I was picking a guy
- 43:12up a certain pursuise. It was beautiful, right. The prop is he
- 43:15got the he got in the car and he had a pile of documents and
- 43:19I was, what am I going to do with these documents. We've got
- 43:22a hostile government if I get stopped with these documents. But I had them
- 43:25right, and as far as he was concerned, here they're yours. So
- 43:31we we drove and I got out of the car and I forgot what triggered
- 43:39it, But as I was going down the street, I was attacked by
- 43:44a pack of wild dogs. Right, So think of the movie, right,
- 43:47here's your big spy chasing being chased down the streets by these wild dogs.
- 43:53And I was the first tour office, so I happened to see that
- 43:57was going to be passing the GS fourteen out and we got I guess a
- 44:00light colonel, and I'm knocking on his door and the door opened and I
- 44:06said, look, I'm being attacked by back a wild dog. Said okay,
- 44:08Jack, calm down. Now you have to imagine what that guy must
- 44:13have felt like. Here's our guy being chased by I said, look,
- 44:15you got to get me back to my car, right because I couldn't get
- 44:20in the vehicle. And so we go back and thank god, there's a
- 44:23dog like literally on each side of the car. So he gets out of
- 44:30the car and walks everywhere and the dog licks his ast. So he turns
- 44:36to me and he said, listen, I bet you have cats. Well,
- 44:38let's say I didn't hear them laughing, but I'm sure in the office
- 44:42said, boy, we have a hot shot with us. Right. So
- 44:45what I was there's a lesson in it is you can prepare your plants and
- 44:50your operations and the flukiest thing can happen. You got to you got to
- 44:54be prepared. So I think there's a moment before you complete the operation.
- 45:00Okay, I've got all the X and wise, you know, put in
- 45:02place, but you have to think what going to your earlier question, you
- 45:07know, be ready, what happens if things fall apart? And I think
- 45:10later in the book, I talk about picking up an agent who we thought
- 45:15might have been under hostile surveillance and he just he'd been tortured and so on,
- 45:22and that turned out to be quite That's that's still enjoy because that's after
- 45:25Pinochet takes over, right, correct, Yeah, so can you tell us
- 45:30about so actually you received the call about the coup from your wife? Correct?
- 45:36Is that right? I was in a fine Italian restaurant and Chili,
- 45:39they had great restaurants, right, And I was developing somebody that I thought
- 45:44could be of interest, not a clandestine spy, but somebody who was useful
- 45:49in the government as a wittying contact, and I thought the lunch was going
- 45:53well, and all of a sudden I looked up and there's a guy from
- 45:55the office standing over my shoulder, and thank good, because what had happened?
- 46:02He said, listen, you have to go home. So I'm thinking,
- 46:05you know, medical emergency, right, So I excuse myself and said,
- 46:08yeah, Pat's call and said you've got to get home. She's got
- 46:12something for it. So what had happened. It was shortly before the three
- 46:16or four days before the CO and I had an agent who was very well
- 46:20placed and had the first report of an organized CO. But he couldn't find
- 46:24me. So he knew where the fine pad and he went over. So
- 46:28I'm leaving and I'm heading to the airport. So here's what's going to happen.
- 46:34The Navy's going to start in Valparaiso. There's going to be a radio
- 46:37announcement on radio on TWA it's seven, it turned out to be eight,
- 46:40and then this will happen, and that'll happen. It wasn't very long.
- 46:45It might be a paragraph. It's still a matter of history because it's in
- 46:47the Senate's Intelligence investigation, and so Pat got it and knew how to reach
- 46:55this fell. Unfortunately she couldn't go into it. He had enough energy to
- 47:00say, listen, this sounds important, went and got me. I got
- 47:05the report, brought it in, talked to the Chief. We sent it
- 47:08out as a critic message, which again not to get in the categories of
- 47:15priorities and immediates. But a critic oversees everything. In other words, it
- 47:17stops all communicator just flies through. It goes right into the White House and
- 47:22other places. And if you send a normal cable, even with some high
- 47:25precedent on it, it goes through the and rightfully so through the analytical process.
- 47:30This went right in. So the first news of the coup came from
- 47:34Pat, not they, but vicariously I valued it. Washington didn't believe it,
- 47:43and the analyst, particularly because there hadn't been you know, they had
- 47:45democracy one hundred and fifty years. That wasn't going to happen. He's going
- 47:50to weather the storm, and so it was. They didn't disseminate it through
- 47:57the normal channels, but it didn't matter in the end because everything overseated.
- 48:00But that was the first first message. I was in the embassy, the
- 48:06Chief and I, and there was a communicator because you couldn't bring everyone in,
- 48:10and we were waiting for the announcement on the radio. And I think
- 48:16the announcement, I said, was an hour late, and nothing was happening
- 48:20without a huh God, the analysts were right right, you know, and
- 48:22then you know, the tanks literally rolled. We could I could see the
- 48:28tanks coming down the street and I did have a TDY, a temporary fille,
- 48:34and I sent them over across the street to the Carrera Hotel and he
- 48:37could see the palace. We were blocked from the palace a big block.
- 48:42There was a plaza there, but he could see out to win the report
- 48:45minute by minute. So it was. There was another report that came in.
- 48:51This was not an official report, but shortly before maybe forty six hours
- 48:57or even less, a person that we had met years ago said they were
- 49:04going to tell us that something happened, called their guy, and this was
- 49:07the official you know, a couple pages of exactly what was So they wanted
- 49:10the United States government to know ahead of time, but the United States government
- 49:15was not involved in the planning. This is this is where people confused the
- 49:19first incident and this incident. The Track two with this, Yes, and
- 49:24people just don't believe CIA was not involved with the military. But I'm here
- 49:29to tell you I know differently. Were we involved in supporting the parties and
- 49:34the media. Yes, it's all a matter of record. We're not trying
- 49:37to hide that. And we were trying to resist Allende, trying to crush
- 49:40the elements that we thought were aligned with us and so on. But with
- 49:46the military, we had no real ties with the coup plotters. So when
- 49:52when Nixon was pushing for Track two to overthrow, was there a a plan
- 50:00of who to replace him with? Were Well, let me let me tell
- 50:04you how it actually came down, because it was the way it started is
- 50:08the Navy was the initiator. They were the most aggressive. So the head
- 50:14of the Navy, Adamiral Marino, wrote a note to uh and this was
- 50:21it was days before the coup, or before the coup actually, And it
- 50:23went to the Air Force commander, who was the second most outspoken about the
- 50:29need to do something, General Lee. And then it went to the cabin
- 50:31area, which were the police force, the security National Police, and it
- 50:37went to Pinochet. Last. The conventional wisdom in the US government that would
- 50:44Pinochet did not have what it takes to lead a coup. I mean that
- 50:47was the official line. Okay, people who know him, Madame, they
- 50:51decided it up. And so he's when it got to him. He said,
- 50:53Okay, I'm in but i'm I'm in charge. The army is the
- 50:59biggest service. We're in charge. I'm the boss. And so that's that's
- 51:04how that came down. And we didn't know they had agreed. We did
- 51:09not have a report that they had agreed. It actually started again. I
- 51:15don't want to go on, but there was something that triggered that we could
- 51:20talk about at some point. Well, we can talk about it, okay,
- 51:22yeah, I mean this is fascinating. We never talked about. So
- 51:25what happened is in the summer, you could feel the tension in the country,
- 51:30right. But just because you have tension and instability and demonstrations and food
- 51:38for it doesn't mean you're gonna have a coupe. It means you have a
- 51:40very unstable environment. But there were a group of tank commanders that felt so
- 51:49outraged by the end of the government. They were drinking too much and they
- 51:52drove half a dozen tanks right up to the front door of the palace right
- 51:55they were going to have it was called a tank Kaso. Now there was
- 51:59a tank, because they thought they would start it and everybody would follow in.
- 52:04But the Commander in the Chief of the Armed Forces card was Pratt,
- 52:07went out and talked them back in. They said, listen, boys,
- 52:10you had a nice night. You're going to go take the tanks out.
- 52:14So our official our reaction, my reaction was Allendi just stood down the coup.
- 52:22That's it. The military stood with him. You now know that now
- 52:27this is where your conventional wisdom gets you in trouble. That was not the
- 52:30reaction to the military leaders. They went back and said, we are losing
- 52:34discipline in our armed forces. So it wasn't the democracy, it wasn't the
- 52:39economy. It was the military was falling apart, and if we're going to
- 52:44have our troops mutiny, we're going to do this ourselves, and we're going
- 52:50to do it right. That's when the coup. So the coup must have
- 52:52started the planning somewhere between June and July. No, there wasn't long in
- 52:58the making, but you know it took place on September eleventh. So I
- 53:04think the sense of the country at the time was where people were not anticipating.
- 53:10We're not thinking about, well, whoever comes in, they'll be the
- 53:14leader. And there was a general sentiment among our side, but all the
- 53:19people we were dealing with this is a democratic country. This is just a
- 53:22temporary interlude, and the military commands stabilize the country, get the economy up
- 53:30running again, maybe a year, maybe eighteen months, and then we'll have
- 53:34elections again, right, and prchies that that's not how that's going to go.
- 53:38And the problem was we knew the political side of the country, we
- 53:43knew the economic side, we knew the business people. The Chileans knew each
- 53:47other in the economic, political, cultural right. Well, the military was
- 53:52outside of Chilean life, so we really didn't know how military people thought and
- 54:00did not know how they were going to respond in the mindset. So I
- 54:04don't think there was any predictive you know, to your point earlier repercussions.
- 54:09I don't think there was an awareness at that time of how this was going
- 54:15to play out, right, and you know, because you mentioned it,
- 54:20you didn't initially the Americans didn't understand what the Pinochet regime was like until you
- 54:27like for you like meeting with that source, right, was your first sort
- 54:30of introduction to that, No, that was by then I knew what happened
- 54:35in the very early days. First of all, there was a curfew and
- 54:42everything was shut down. You couldn't move around town. And I was in
- 54:45the embassy with three or four officers because they lifted the curfew temporarily and people
- 54:51were allowed to leave because we thought we were gonna it was going to stay.
- 54:55Then I volunteered to stay behind chief and maybe one other person, and
- 55:02the problem was a couple hours later we had a curfew and I couldn't get
- 55:07home for three or four, three or four days and the country was was
- 55:12really shut down. Pat. We had to have an emergency pickup for Pat
- 55:17because we learned that there was going to be attack on the house next to
- 55:23us where there were Cubans, and the Cubans were, you know, enemies
- 55:29of the military. So I was able to go to radio one of my
- 55:32friends with helicopters flying above, not knowing whose friend, and phone through Pat
- 55:37and a family dog and five kids in the car, and you know,
- 55:43they were guests of my friend for a week. So you know, in
- 55:46that environment, it was very hard to look over the horizon and see what
- 55:52was coming ahead? Was there? You know, the Cubans were the enemy
- 55:58and Allende was the enemy. Did but did Pinochet? Did you feel safe
- 56:05like with Pinochet running things? Well, that was actually going to be the
- 56:09end of that that common because when did we figure it out? Once you
- 56:15had once the curfew started, you know that we knew there was bad things
- 56:20happening in the city, right you didn't know how bad what they were doing.
- 56:23They had a list, they were rounding up people, and there was
- 56:27a stadium and one of my friends was one of the two people that working
- 56:32in the consulate that went to the stadium. They were looking for two Americans
- 56:38that had been kidnapped, Taruji and I'm trying to remember the other fellow's name,
- 56:44but Jack Lemon was in a movie missing Well, I forget the name
- 56:47of the title, but with feedback, but in the what what happened when
- 56:53he went to the stadium? I mean it was visible that you had rounded
- 56:59up a lot of people and bad things are happening and a lot of people
- 57:04were killed. So we knew that this was not that gentlemen's coup were Okay,
- 57:09everyone go back to their quarters and you know, this became they really
- 57:15were determined to destroy the communists and people that they thought were communists not and
- 57:21that included a lot of people those that they thought right. So there were
- 57:25days when we realized we had this was not this was not what was foreseen,
- 57:30and we were going to have a problematic relationship with the government. And
- 57:37so what happened with the American president did they like, did you guys get
- 57:42pulled out or did you guys remain there, remain in place and try to
- 57:45establish relationships with well the embassy state. Yeah, you had normal relations business
- 57:52communities came back and and but you were living in an autocratic government. But
- 58:00if you're carrying a black password, if you're a diplomat, and there's it's
- 58:05rare that anyone's going to in Latin America. I don't know of any country
- 58:08where the harash other than Cuba and maybe now in Nicaragua. But back then
- 58:13you were safe. I don't think you felt where there was the terror was
- 58:17during the immediate hours of the coup and then they said, you know,
- 58:22pat I was in personally in some jeopardy. So but after that you were
- 58:30You're just dealing with the dictatorship which you know, you don't say anything,
- 58:34it don't do anything right, but life goes on. So the US government
- 58:37maintained its official relationship, and I fortunately left six months thereafter. I had
- 58:45actually written that we should. This is where covert action taken to a little
- 58:51bit over the top. The new chief said, well, you're leaving,
- 58:53but you know a lot. Tell me your best thoughts of mine was we
- 58:57are to start working on getting rid of Pinochet. That's not how it works.
- 59:00If you go back to my principles, that was not realistic. It
- 59:05would not be achievable. So there was a person who was not happy with
- 59:10what he saw. I was hoping we'd get back to the democratic process.
- 59:15I had no idea when I left that it would be years before they returned
- 59:20to some normal political life. There was also an incidentally, though, since
- 59:23it's sort of your formative years, because you wanted to write the letter on
- 59:29like the socialists, right, And I think this is a really good example
- 59:32about the ideas about the agency going rogue, but you being basically kind of
- 59:40you know, stopped by a supervisor for something that was outside of today we
- 59:46live with disinformation. We could spend hours my last podcast, which it is
- 59:51on disinformation, which Americans really didn't invest in it. We use the white
- 59:55story that we'll tell you about Russia. That's all you need to know,
- 59:59right. We weren't really a lot of tricky disinformation, but you always thought
- 1:00:04that that would be a good idea, and so many of them were developed,
- 1:00:07but no one ever put a stamp and mail them. I thought I
- 1:00:08had my moment. I thought I had one of the great covert actions of
- 1:00:13her So I had the typewriter and Communist Party material, so I thought,
- 1:00:17well, we could have you know, one of our Communist Party sources write
- 1:00:22a letter, you know, something that's derogatory and be uh, you know,
- 1:00:28making the coup look better. Right, So I thought I was helping
- 1:00:31the cause, and you know, I had my assotle set and then I
- 1:00:36went in to see the chief and it was a great guy. Again another
- 1:00:38one of my meney got you crazy, This has to be approved by the
- 1:00:43president. You can't be doing this because then that gets out there. You're
- 1:00:46going to change history. You get out there and get that back. So
- 1:00:52so you know, you go back and beg, hey, listen, I
- 1:00:53you know that typewriter. We found a flaw. You know something but that
- 1:00:59almost when it almost went into the policy makers, and it almost ended up
- 1:01:04in the UN but we get stopped. But it was also going to be
- 1:01:07tied to a rumor which was not correct, that Allende was going to have
- 1:01:12his own code, that there was no information to support that. But it
- 1:01:15became folklore, and it's even folklore today by those who, you know,
- 1:01:21want to find the happier, those that felt that the decision with Pinochet was
- 1:01:25you know, had positive, inevitable outcomes. So I just I saw nothing
- 1:01:31to support it that but I was maybe working with the Communist Party to help
- 1:01:37it. And you know, thank god, I'm not part of history,
- 1:01:39and my book would be much shorter. That might have been the last chapter
- 1:01:44in the book. But that's what happens when you're in your first tour and
- 1:01:46you need you need you know, you need real prose watching and you can
- 1:01:52get it was a great idea, there's no question about it. It just
- 1:01:57didn't have policy approval. Find your little detail, right, So so you
- 1:02:02leave Chile and what's your next assignment? Then well, it's interesting because I
- 1:02:08know this because I knew the people involved years later when I was a little
- 1:02:13more c But basically, They had a Chief of Station conference and they bartered,
- 1:02:21I'll give you two red ones for one green one. Right, So
- 1:02:23I was bartered. You know, they were boring people to go to Argentina.
- 1:02:28But what they said, and the bartering is, look, well,
- 1:02:30we're going to take jackets from a COVID actually put him in a traditional uh
- 1:02:38country. So that's what that's what, that's how that that came about.
- 1:02:45So you went to Argentina as I went. I didn't go into Mexico.
- 1:02:49Mexico as a more traditional case officer. And and how was that for you?
- 1:02:53How was that and how is it different than Chile? Well? I
- 1:02:57think you know they it accomplished its purpose, which is you go back into
- 1:03:02the espionage part. But I would be disingenuous of I said, you know,
- 1:03:12I suddenly had this high about that. In other words, we came
- 1:03:15off of arguably the two biggest covert action operations. One was Vietnam and the
- 1:03:20other one was Chilly. I mean, that's they that's what the President of
- 1:03:22the United States was focused on in terms of covert action. So to go
- 1:03:27to any station, whether it be Paris or New Guinea, whatever it was
- 1:03:32going to be, you're taking down your tempo of activity right, right,
- 1:03:37you're going to make meetings at night. You're going to look more normal.
- 1:03:42So the I mean, it was enthusias for sure, but it took a
- 1:03:47while to work it through. And this is true when you get into these
- 1:03:51covert action operations, is it's harder to wind them down. And it's also
- 1:03:55the higher it's harder to wind down individuals to get back to it right,
- 1:04:01right, So how does it happen? Do you do you naturally wind out
- 1:04:08or do you have all these great ideas at a new station where they're not
- 1:04:13actually needed and people needed, you know, like people need to say,
- 1:04:15hey, like this isn't Chile or this isn't Like no, I don't well,
- 1:04:23I think you don't even bother with the COVID action because you know there's
- 1:04:26no finding right, there's no right. So when you arrive, you'll be
- 1:04:30given okay, here's the Cuba target, the Russia target, and you will
- 1:04:33be doing those things that you learned and working with people. But now you're
- 1:04:39once you're over that first tour. In fact, when you're in the end
- 1:04:41of year one, you're you're supposed to be able to stand on your own
- 1:04:45that doesn't mean the mentoring stops, but it's not like how you tie your
- 1:04:48shoes mentoring. So when you get to your second assignment, you're now a
- 1:04:53seasoned officer. I would say you're a journeyman. You're a master, right,
- 1:04:58but your your a journey And did you find that to be true for
- 1:05:01you? Did you feel more comfortable with your recruitments and your meetings? Right?
- 1:05:04I think I felt because there was enough of that. It wasn't a
- 1:05:09whole COVID action right because I was making clandestine meetings with sources that were action
- 1:05:14oriented. So by then you know we were We weren't spending time on running
- 1:05:21operations against the Russians in Chile. That wasn't the big The biggest investment was
- 1:05:27trying to stop the government from from crushing the democratic composition? And then was
- 1:05:34there anything else? Like really notable for you in Mexico? This is your
- 1:05:40problem in telling stories because once you get to the espionage part, there's not
- 1:05:45a lot I can say. So when you read the book, it really
- 1:05:48is a book that I can write a lot. Many of my colleagues can't
- 1:05:54write anything, and they've done wonderful things, but I can't write about it.
- 1:05:57It was all in the espionage world. Then you have others that have
- 1:06:00done one assignment, right. But the novelty of mine this comes back to,
- 1:06:03was the magnet Pollimer or was I running towards it? And that is
- 1:06:10I can read a lot because I touched a lot of COVID action, right.
- 1:06:14But when you're touching COVID, you're also running Clindestine ops. It's not
- 1:06:17like you're still mating Clindestine meetings and you're paying opposition. You have to use
- 1:06:24the same skills and what people don't realize that some of our very best sources
- 1:06:30came from running covert action operations. Let's say you have Colonel X and you're
- 1:06:35running some operations, you go away, you come back five years later,
- 1:06:39he's chief of military intelligence, right, or he's commander, your chief of
- 1:06:45an important unit. So covert action many of the people then become prime ministers,
- 1:06:51and so it is a feeding ground for some of the higher quality rests.
- 1:06:57So it is the intelligence there. You have a real The Brits actually
- 1:07:02do this. I think they combine an officer all three a couple of different
- 1:07:08traits. You have to be FI and covert, but you also have to
- 1:07:11be reports writer where we have a cone where people just give them the raw
- 1:07:15stuff they turn into reports. And I think the early days they didn't have
- 1:07:19that cone. And I think the British is they're a little bit leaner in
- 1:07:26terms of their resources. So there's no reason why you can't do all three.
- 1:07:30Yeah, can you talk a little bit about how the finding process happens.
- 1:07:35Does the president just kind of come up with them or does the CIA
- 1:07:40sometimes say hey, we'd like a finding for this so we can achieve this.
- 1:07:45So the etchton Stone sort of position of CIA is we do not form
- 1:07:54policy. Okay, we're not the policy maker. You make it. So
- 1:07:59this is up to state president, defence to look at a problem and say,
- 1:08:05okay, we're going to call CIA. Now that is the structure.
- 1:08:12But when you're at the table and you're talking about, look we have a
- 1:08:15problem in Haiti and the government is you know, they just throughout the democratic
- 1:08:19government and the military is there, So the question who is any ideas?
- 1:08:24Right? So it's not that you're in the policy making, but when you
- 1:08:29get in those meetings you're making contributions about it's often the CIA person briefs and
- 1:08:36that's supposed to be the end of it. But if the President looks down
- 1:08:40the hall and says, well, what do you think do you think we
- 1:08:43could make some progress over here? So you answer the president you said,
- 1:08:46well, so, I only I don't talk to you about it. You
- 1:08:49engage in it. So but I don't think it's what I'm trying to make
- 1:08:54clear. Though. It's not like the CIO goes to, hey, look,
- 1:08:56we got this great idea. I don't know if I don't personally know
- 1:09:00a case where we went to them saying you should do this. I've been
- 1:09:06told that the findings also have, like when the President signs them, a
- 1:09:10whole slew of different things, all the way from you know, black propaganda
- 1:09:15to lethal operations. But there's this caveat in there that the agency has to
- 1:09:19go back to get special permission even though it's in the finding for that particular
- 1:09:25activity. Well, I think they were simpler at the beginning, right,
- 1:09:29because everything becomes more legalistic with the hardening of the arteries, So the findings
- 1:09:35should be very specific. You're authorized to do expiency, and sometimes it'll be
- 1:09:42spelled out. You can do this part of code. You can do media,
- 1:09:45but you can't do political action, right, and if it's not in
- 1:09:49the finding, because people don't realize I had a lawyer for about the last
- 1:09:54ten years of my headquarters life at my elbow reading everything to say we can't
- 1:10:00do that. So but the point is, if it's not there, you
- 1:10:06have to seek you have to seek your approval for it. And one of
- 1:10:13the issues later on we fast forward to Iran is the chief of the division,
- 1:10:18insisted on seeing it, and he said, the reason I wanted to
- 1:10:23do that is because I want to follow to the letter. What we wanted
- 1:10:27to do is see that piece of paper that it exists. But I mean,
- 1:10:30having said that, you still need this. It's a limiting document.
- 1:10:35But if it says you want to overthrow a government, that's that's that's pretty
- 1:10:40pretty profound. So a few words can cause a lot of trouble or be
- 1:10:45very beneficial. I mean, how is if the president gave a finding,
- 1:10:55would there ever be a case where you know, a senior level member of
- 1:10:58the c would say, hey, if you want this done, we actually
- 1:11:02need the finding to be worded more like this. I think that would be
- 1:11:06inappropriate. I mean, I think the president, you work for me.
- 1:11:15Hopefully there's a coordination process So this isn't just the President goes to Justice Department.
- 1:11:18State people have to sign up to and when you don't do that,
- 1:11:24you have a good chance of having a flap because State will say, look,
- 1:11:28we've got equities over here. You're not even thinking about these equities or
- 1:11:30defensive Look if I have to do that, I have to move. So
- 1:11:33there's a coordination process around the finding that doesn't have to be. There wasn't
- 1:11:39any on the Chili one that was straight right out of the White House in
- 1:11:43the Sandiao station. The lesson from Chili was get the ambassador involved, make
- 1:11:48sure congresses are on board, you know, make sure you make sure you
- 1:11:53have the lawyers. If you can't get by it while you're filling with you're
- 1:11:55going to pay a price at the end. And there's a reason why they
- 1:11:59do it so right. You know, not every everybody get tabled, generally,
- 1:12:02not generally. I just haven't been a table where they didn't have the
- 1:12:05US interest at heart. In other words, it wasn't curious. I mean
- 1:12:09it, people in at least in my experience, come to the table serious
- 1:12:15about the mission. That doesn't mean they have to agree, They just point
- 1:12:18out what shortfall that doesn't mean they're not being part of the part of the
- 1:12:24team, right, but the finding process is critical and for people to understand
- 1:12:30that. And so then after after Mexico, what weird? What year do
- 1:12:38you leave Mexico roughly? Do you remember? Yeah, sure, seventy six,
- 1:12:42seventy six. And then after Mexico, where do you go from there?
- 1:12:45I went back to Washington and I had a series of branch chief jobs
- 1:12:49that thinks you could be the I had, like, maybe I couldn't keep
- 1:12:54a job for why I did the Andes right, and then I did the
- 1:12:57Southern cons So I think what I was getting experience, it's the face that
- 1:13:03deals directly day in and day out with the field station. Right. So
- 1:13:08I was going back and I enjoyed it because I was getting to know I
- 1:13:12was not I'm not a Latin American expert, as I said, I just
- 1:13:15oh, you're too tall, So I'm my credentials. Would I fit in
- 1:13:18in Latin America? So I didn't have the expertise. There's some people study
- 1:13:23it for years. I had to go to school or in Spanish, and
- 1:13:26I mean so it was an opportunity to understand Latin America and become more expertise
- 1:13:31in it, but I wouldn't. I mean, over time I became,
- 1:13:35my view, an expertea, but not in the way that a scholar might.
- 1:13:39Right, although I shouldn't say that you really get into it after a
- 1:13:42while. Did you mention the endies? Like what is what are some of
- 1:13:46the interests of the agency outside of what I think people would traditionally think the
- 1:13:51interests of the agency are when we're looking at maybe smaller countries or countries where
- 1:13:57there's not as much political action. This is my personal view, and there's
- 1:14:01been times in history where we've condensed our presence abroad. I think we should
- 1:14:05have the flag everywhere because you don't know whether the yem and E's are going
- 1:14:10to do it or the hate. Next thing big issues for Clinton's first issue
- 1:14:14is Haiti. I mean who you know? You have to tend to go
- 1:14:16back to these places more than once. Yeah, right, so you have
- 1:14:20to have people that know ed someone's there, right. But what you have
- 1:14:25in every country it isn't that HATI may not be interesting, but the people
- 1:14:30that are there. There may be a un group where the Iranians are there
- 1:14:33and you can't get to them in the north Koreans. So no, there
- 1:14:36is, there's a reason to be everywhere, but you should keep your you
- 1:14:42should be country knowledgeable really because you can put your hand up and say it's
- 1:14:47not going to work, or let me tell you something's going to happen,
- 1:14:50or you know you need something done. You need to get somebody out of
- 1:14:56the country that the Russian is just affected from Russia. You need tax in
- 1:15:00relationships. So I'm for the flag everywhere. In my I did a not
- 1:15:04be ed, which I'm pleased with somewhere I'm pleased than others. But it
- 1:15:12was about the AMAS attack in Israel, and my argument is human intelligence there
- 1:15:25is I'm all for Ai, I'm for ever. As I said, my
- 1:15:28first assignment had gadgets that no one else wanted to use. But coming out
- 1:15:32of training, I've always tried to apply technology. At one point I actually
- 1:15:35wanted to run the director of Technology, but there was a passing moment and
- 1:15:41they didn't think it was a good idea. But I've always be intrigued by
- 1:15:44it. Having said that, if you we've grown so accustomed to using all
- 1:15:48the technology, and two Wars led us into targeting, which is it's collecting
- 1:15:56information, so you take out the terrorists. That's not collecting intelligence on Russia's
- 1:16:02infrastructure, right, So what you know, what what I'm what I'm saying
- 1:16:10is human sources were underinvested. They say, Jackie, when somebody in one
- 1:16:15hundred and seventy countries or whatever. Yeah. Yes, So what I did
- 1:16:21in the article, which I don't think some of my friends will like,
- 1:16:25I'm saying we're underinvested. And why because in Hamas two hundred people must have
- 1:16:31known what was going on. I mean, not the full thing, but
- 1:16:33enough that you've got a tip that something's coming down. Let's get you know,
- 1:16:38we've got to get right. That's my rough estimate. But I think
- 1:16:43you know, the Israelis got caught out, but we got caught up because
- 1:16:45you know, we should know, iron we should know what's going on,
- 1:16:47right that everybody misses this. And what I was saying is if you took
- 1:16:53all the spies, not the spy masters, but the people that are actually
- 1:16:58spies, human sources of NATO, Israel, the United States, you couldn't
- 1:17:03staff an aircraft carrier, you know, to say you're going to staff people
- 1:17:11in every country, that's a small investment. Other it's out of if you're
- 1:17:14a multi billion dollar operation in the US business world, or a billion dollar
- 1:17:17you don't say, well, you know, I've got two thousand people.
- 1:17:23That's what I've got running Amazon, Right, you don't do that. And
- 1:17:28then the price, how much money do you spend on spying? And I
- 1:17:31put in the article they published it that what it costs for the two teams
- 1:17:35that played in the Super Bowl, not the game. But how do you
- 1:17:39fund those two teams? I said, it's more that we pay all the
- 1:17:44spies in the world. Now, I will tell you so much is less
- 1:17:46than that. But when you think about the investment and what's your human collection,
- 1:17:50how much you're really putting it, how many people on site? And
- 1:17:55so I've been arguing, I'm not arguing. I've been an advocate for bringing
- 1:18:00back, not bringing back, resetting and investing in human sources. So coming
- 1:18:10back to he said, well, there's a sleepy country. Yeah, sleepy
- 1:18:12country. Learn how to do learn how to learn how to operate. Right,
- 1:18:15it's considered a training program. So this is gonna take us a little
- 1:18:20bit out of order. But because we're here, I have to ask you
- 1:18:23because you mentioned Dewey Clerage and we've had other people on before who have talked
- 1:18:28about about clerage and you know, he's he's kind of legendary and the fact
- 1:18:30that he basically after he got he's not only legendary for what he did,
- 1:18:34but he got out and built a almost a secondary intelligence agency, right or
- 1:18:42had assets and resources. Do you feel as though that the United States should
- 1:18:48leverage that type of like private interest to maintain you know, sources, assets,
- 1:18:56things like that around the world. Well, should we talked about doing
- 1:19:00sure? Please please tell us you Dewey was and you know, I just
- 1:19:03I will just touch off a couple of points. So Dewey wasn't flamboyant.
- 1:19:10In fact, he talked about legend you know, the importance of folks.
- 1:19:14You have to have some bazaze. Now, he came out of Italy and
- 1:19:17he had silk handkerchiefs, right, And I have this feeling that, you
- 1:19:24know, c like they follow the leaders. Right. So when uh Jimmy
- 1:19:30Carter came in, everyone was wearing the quarter Rodian sweaters. Right. Then
- 1:19:34Reagan comes in, it's a suit and tie and even a brown suit.
- 1:19:38Right. So Dewey came in with the handkerchief right next meeting he got five
- 1:19:42chiefs five wearing hankery and the handkerchief, so so Dewey, he'll deny this,
- 1:19:48but I I swear by it. So we're up in the executive dining
- 1:19:51room. When you put a monocle in, Now that's what I did.
- 1:19:56I said, I'm not going to use the exact language because we have other
- 1:20:00company here that there might be environs. But I said I might put a
- 1:20:04self, but I'd rather die than put a monocle on. And he got
- 1:20:08very huffy. Right, I'm convinced if he started wearing a monocle, five
- 1:20:13or six people be wearing monocles before you know it. I would not be
- 1:20:15one of them. I'll put the handkerchief in. So the point was,
- 1:20:19I think he had really good leadership skills and the dynamic about it, but
- 1:20:26and he I agreed until we didn't agree, and part of that was how
- 1:20:30we were going to handle Central America and that sort of thing. So,
- 1:20:33but I think one thing you'd have to say about doing was he exluded leadership
- 1:20:40skills. And we've talked about manator leadership and he and they were interesting discussions.
- 1:20:46Your business proposition is a really interesting one, and you know we've outsourced
- 1:20:57worse. I mean, we've als. Is that the right answer? I
- 1:21:00don't know. I don't know how I want to call this one other than
- 1:21:04you know, is it finances, is it slots? But I would have
- 1:21:10preferred if we had a world where we didn't have to outsource so much.
- 1:21:14Okay, so that your institutions did it. I don't think you should outsource
- 1:21:19COVID action now we do succumb people from That's different than outsourcing. In other
- 1:21:27words, you have a relatively small power military group, but when something happens,
- 1:21:33you need younger people you get like in Afghanistan. You have. The
- 1:21:38difference is CIA has command and control right now. That's I thought the government
- 1:21:43should have command and control, and I think the military should have commanding control
- 1:21:47over protecting their sites and not hiring a company that then hires Ugandan servir so
- 1:21:54and I don't know the dollar costs, I'm not going to do it.
- 1:21:56I'm just saying I'm not a big advocate of that, and COVID I is
- 1:22:00so tricky. I would not outsource it right now. But when you get
- 1:22:04into a where you're actually running a war with COVID action, that's not a
- 1:22:10great idea. In my view, right then you might as well just go
- 1:22:13all the way. Now. The beauty of the Afghan program, right was
- 1:22:18what we did is we had a small group, less than a two hundred,
- 1:22:23but the Afghans wanted to fight, and our job was to provide the
- 1:22:28wherewithal. It wasn't to go in shoulder the shoulder fighting with them. Right.
- 1:22:32If you have to do that, maybe you don't go in. So
- 1:22:36I think there's probably some practicalities about it that have never been clear to me.
- 1:22:41Why we went so big in outsourcing. Understand technology, you did it
- 1:22:45in the building, you can do it. There's so much being done that's
- 1:22:47more sophisticated, faster, better, So you outsource technology. So on the
- 1:22:53people side, I don't think that's a good idea. I also I think
- 1:23:00there's a dilemma on the human side, and that dilemma is we can't operate
- 1:23:06the way we did. It isn't whether Jack Divine is too tall. If
- 1:23:11I walk out of any embassy, I won't be invisible, right and you
- 1:23:15know, because there will be a drone, there'll be censors. In other
- 1:23:18words, how do you get clean? How do you assure you? How
- 1:23:23can you can't assure yourself to clean. So the structure there were users,
- 1:23:27So how do you build your human networks? So my view is I would
- 1:23:32announce source the work, right, I would learn how to do the work,
- 1:23:36and I would build a new career service. Now this is radical conversation
- 1:23:42that I'm sure someone that will object to it. So my first supposition because
- 1:23:48I'm a human source, like that's my career that's in service. But I
- 1:23:54believe you need those sources. And Hamas is a good example. There's several
- 1:23:58in Russia. We were outstanding and predicting the war in Ukraine, but we
- 1:24:03did not have a good fix on the state of the army. We didn't
- 1:24:06have a good because we thought Selenski would have to be flown out, you
- 1:24:10know, and you know, I don't want to get into the twenty sixteen
- 1:24:15election too much. But we have a Muller investigation. The Miller investigation spend
- 1:24:21thirty two million. They established the Russians are doing intelligence. But of course
- 1:24:26they're doing it. They've been doing it since I was a kid, and
- 1:24:29they've been doing this in nineteen seventeen and hopefully we're doing The outrageous thing was
- 1:24:35they went into our political system, and we had an understanding not to do
- 1:24:40that. But why where was the source that said, why are you doing?
- 1:24:45Let me tell you exactly what we did and why we did it.
- 1:24:47So I worry about We might have great sources that tell us for the sun,
- 1:24:53but are we missing big things because we're not invested in human and the
- 1:24:59same way human is. Technology is hard, but human is hard. Human
- 1:25:05interaction that's real hard. You were talking about my early struggles and how to
- 1:25:12learn how to do it? How do you interact with human? How do
- 1:25:15you get and it's untidy, you know, worry about ethically, there's all
- 1:25:20these other issues because headaches. Let's not do that. We'll just put a
- 1:25:26sensor there. And when you do targeting, you're collecting information with a kinetic
- 1:25:33ending. You're not developing relationship with somebody that you're going to run for a
- 1:25:38long time. So if you have a generation of large percentage of your workforce
- 1:25:42there, I have to worry. So my message it's a love letter.
- 1:25:45I don't know if they've received it as is. You know great, you
- 1:25:50know, a great institution, but human. I believe human's coming back in
- 1:25:55all many walks of life because I think people are unsure about the reality,
- 1:26:00and now I need my own network sources. So your point is about outsourcing.
- 1:26:04I'm saying, give them the money, get the but you need to
- 1:26:11figure out how to do it different than you're doing. But you need to
- 1:26:14cover every country and you have to have it has to be broader. Right,
- 1:26:16they'll come back, I'll tell you. I'm not if they'll come back
- 1:26:19and say we have the best source. Yeah, but you do, but
- 1:26:23they're in these channels. Do you can you cover? Do you cover the
- 1:26:27world and all the pieces moving in it? And the policy not so much
- 1:26:30it would be my my and studied guess, and not even like out of
- 1:26:35the way places like you know, we'll get to Afghanistan where you were,
- 1:26:39you know, where you were quite involved, and then you know, twenty
- 1:26:43thirty years later, we have nobody there and we have to completely re establish
- 1:26:46Afghanistan, you know, completely the same right, right, right, a
- 1:26:51little older older too, but your point is right, right, we pull
- 1:26:56up, yeah, and we start all over. Every time we started cover
- 1:27:00Actually it's like we're starting we've never done one before, right, Yeah.
- 1:27:03It's like, oh, and you were just saying earlier, well, we've
- 1:27:06been here before, so there's and that's why I write and trying to remind
- 1:27:14people that there are things. There's a segment. I think it's in Good
- 1:27:17Hunting. One of the guys I worked for was Tom Polgar. Tom was
- 1:27:23the last chief in Vietnam, last helicopter out of there. He was my
- 1:27:28boss at one point. And you know, Tom, Tom was a great
- 1:27:34writer. Was second language, but he wrote better than anybody knew in English.
- 1:27:39But he was writing all these messages to Washington every week, telling them
- 1:27:43how they ought to do their job. I'm not sure that was the best
- 1:27:45thing. But he did say something to me once, and I'll get the
- 1:27:48Vietnam in a second. I said, Tom, why are you writing all
- 1:27:53these things? I mean, you're just annoying everybody, said Jack, when
- 1:27:57you get this certain position, it's not that you have a responsibility to speak
- 1:28:03out, you have an obligation. I mean, that's powerful. Mean.
- 1:28:08So there's the famous cable which is quoted in the book. When he left
- 1:28:13Vietnam, he said, you know, we don't learn from history, We're
- 1:28:15going to repeat it. And to some degree, part of how a Rock
- 1:28:21played out was not learning the lessons of the right. And I feel like,
- 1:28:28you know, Throughout the book, you showed that you sort of took
- 1:28:30Pulgar's message your heart. Also because you were you were when you disagreed with
- 1:28:35like Dewey Claridge or or or you know, it was a gauge, like
- 1:28:41when you disagreed with people who were senior to you. You you spoke out.
- 1:28:45And I think that people they generally respect, like other people may have
- 1:28:48missed her, but they generally respected you for sticking to your guns. I
- 1:28:53think this is something that people don't understand. It's more advantageous to speak out
- 1:29:00careful. Most senior people are desperate for truth. Tell me, when I
- 1:29:04took it over the Act camp, I knew so little about how to run
- 1:29:09or where to get mules. I couldn't tell a Tennessee mule from a You
- 1:29:13had to know that. You had to have people around you, so you
- 1:29:18know. I think the that experience is really important and sort of your formation
- 1:29:26when you when you get a job, you have to have people speaking out
- 1:29:30to you. And I found I found it. I mean, you have
- 1:29:33to. You can't say, look, you're a jerk and I don't believe
- 1:29:35know and I'm here to tell you what I really think. But if you
- 1:29:39speak out. I think it helps you. Now. One of the examples
- 1:29:43that stuck in my mind late in my career was on my way to Rome
- 1:29:48and they have a advanced CUS course that actually it seemed to me like the
- 1:29:53old one, but I don't know. And I saw that the eight ido
- 1:29:58was gutting in the course that he was on his way to London, and
- 1:30:02the question was why is he going into it? So I said, why
- 1:30:06alter getting this course? So we're going on and the chief of Worldwide Operations
- 1:30:11comes in and he says, this is an administrative I think your evaluation of
- 1:30:15employees should take place six months after they leave. And I put my hand
- 1:30:20up and I said, Dick, I think you have to look them in
- 1:30:23the eye. And so left the room. I got three or four calls.
- 1:30:27There's only ten people in the room saying, Jack, you know you're
- 1:30:30you're you're you're treading on the n ice here that you you know, you're
- 1:30:34challenging the video. And I didn't look at this challenging him at all.
- 1:30:38And it wasn't an aggressive tone and anything else. I just making an observation.
- 1:30:43And I actually think Dick thought, well, he's got a point,
- 1:30:46right, But that they would think. That made me concern about their unwillingness
- 1:30:53to speak up right right, because it was not dangerous, right, they
- 1:30:57saw something dangerous like I'm not a wild man, but I appreciated when people
- 1:31:03speak to me. I had a square desk, you know, the traditional
- 1:31:06G fifteen you get this square desk. I threw it out and had a
- 1:31:10circle around table because when I was doing again, I needed help. There
- 1:31:15wasn't going to be you on one side of the table, me and the
- 1:31:16other. You bring your maps in and we'll sit down because I needed it.
- 1:31:21I mean, I'm desperately So if you were slow rolling me with yeah,
- 1:31:27jack, great idea, you know you would, it would be lethal
- 1:31:30to me. So I'm working in a supposition to the talent that people you're
- 1:31:33working for are recepted to it. So I didn't think it was as brash
- 1:31:39as some think that behaviors. And I would recommend if you're thinking your career
- 1:31:44slow, maybe you want to think about how you're are you are you leaning
- 1:31:47in? Yeah? Yeah? And I mean it never obviously you know it's
- 1:31:54it never comes across as brash. It just comes across as you from either
- 1:31:59a logical or principal position disagreeing with you know, a person or a point,
- 1:32:05and obviously throughout your career getting to where you finally got to, you
- 1:32:11don't seem to have suffered too much from I think I think they also,
- 1:32:17this is Jack divine, so he's gonna he's try to say this. In
- 1:32:20other words, you then earn yourself a little tolerance. Then my guess is
- 1:32:25there's probably some guy said I don't want them. I'm going to take two
- 1:32:30green not one orange. Right, So I didn't know it, but whatever,
- 1:32:34I would rather not work for that person, So fine, I'm good
- 1:32:39with that. So I think, you know, do you just have to
- 1:32:42decide why you're in the business. And if Pulgar's words are dynamite, you
- 1:32:47have an That's why I still write today. That's the ghost of Pulgar.
- 1:32:53And people said, Jack stop, you've done enough, but I'm not done
- 1:32:56enough because when you see something, you say it. And if you I
- 1:33:00think the tone of of my opposite ads are not, I hope they're not.
- 1:33:04They don't have the same tone that you have on mass media. It's
- 1:33:09like, let me explain why I think this, and you know, and
- 1:33:13maybe I'm giving myself too much credit. But I've designated myself the defender of
- 1:33:19the faith of the CIA. I've designated I've annoyed myself. It was a
- 1:33:24jack. No one annoys you, nobody puts you around. But I really
- 1:33:27feel deep commitment to the business and the necessity to speak out. I don't
- 1:33:34think it's dangerous at all. It's actually it's kind of fun. It makes
- 1:33:40you feel good and then you worry about you Oh wow, yeah, can
- 1:33:44I get that ed back? But they're there. They were a purpose.
- 1:33:48It's not just the you don't see me on TV or I mean, this
- 1:33:51is a podcast, because I think a long conversation is a special thing that
- 1:33:57you don't get a chance to do. Often tease it out, like like
- 1:34:00who are But I'm not trying to get on TV so I can have something
- 1:34:02to say today. You'll see me when I there's some issue that I feel
- 1:34:08like I want to put two cents in. I could walk up and down
- 1:34:11the whole CIA. You know they don't let you in, but you know,
- 1:34:14I'm not confident. I probably go in and tell them what I think.
- 1:34:16Say Jack, great, okay, anybody for tea? But he right
- 1:34:20one off ed. They've got to well someone's going to call it from Congress.
- 1:34:24You got to read this. You got to read it. You got
- 1:34:26to pretend you So there's a reason behind, there's a method to the madness.
- 1:34:30But it all comes back to taking pole guard's responsibility. You don't want
- 1:34:36to be too too maybe too much in your first assignment. Although this midge
- 1:34:43of arrogance was touches on this, right, but it was tolerable and humorous.
- 1:34:47So but I think at a certain point when you have command positions I
- 1:34:54would say colonel level something like that, whatever it translates to, you got
- 1:34:58to call them the way you see. Then let the chips. You'll feel
- 1:35:00better. Yeah, it's in. Yeah, it's very interesting. Did you
- 1:35:08I think you said that you would start a new uh, a new career
- 1:35:13field or a new career. I was hoping you didn't pick up on that.
- 1:35:15Yeah, that's dynamite because everything what are they going to do. They're
- 1:35:19going to do with my job, They're going to do away with it.
- 1:35:21Every y is again service. Yeah, yeah, but I think you know,
- 1:35:28I describe to you the embassy. You can't put people abroad that way,
- 1:35:32right, So how are you gonna put what where? What? What
- 1:35:35are you going to create right, that allows you to swim in the water.
- 1:35:40And it's the people again Urroonius may not know, but unofficial cover,
- 1:35:44that's for a specialized handling of certain cases. Right. But how Jack,
- 1:35:49you're saying you want to increase our workforce by a couple of thousand people,
- 1:35:54how do you think we're going to array them? Yes, yes, you
- 1:35:59need a you know it's a bigger issue. You need to And my point
- 1:36:02is you have to do natural work, natural positions abroad and a different setting.
- 1:36:09It isn't knock. It's you have to have real jobs, doing real
- 1:36:12things out there where you are swimming in that water. That's hard. That's
- 1:36:17easy for me in three sentences today, But every once in a while I
- 1:36:20had to build a new career service. When the satellite went up, there
- 1:36:24was no technology division, I mean the directorate in CIA. They created one
- 1:36:29of science and technology. And I'm saying new world, new career service.
- 1:36:35They don't do away with all one. You still need the liaison, you
- 1:36:39still need reports, you need to handle your your training. A lot of
- 1:36:44room for you could be an eendassies around the world, but there's a whole
- 1:36:47world. If you're going to swim in all those countries and do all really
- 1:36:50get to know them. Then you have to have not some constructed credit will
- 1:36:57fall apart because to Google checks in the blown out of water. Yeah,
- 1:37:03so that's this is easy, said, big task, but you got to
- 1:37:08start at some point because you're going to suddenly find out that nobody can move.
- 1:37:13Yeah. Do you feel as though then that because it's you're not talking
- 1:37:17about a non official cover position, But do you feel that the knock field
- 1:37:24was effective for what it was for or do you feel that it was kind
- 1:37:27of like that it didn't quite achieve what it would aim was Well, I
- 1:37:32would tell you one of the the ying and yang in it, right,
- 1:37:38So you want to bury when someone so deep that they're you know they can
- 1:37:42handle the most sensitive, but they're at the most risk. So do you
- 1:37:46put your most sensitive asset with them? So it was how do you match
- 1:37:50those two up? And my view would be that you match them up,
- 1:38:00okay, But it wasn't always that. That's a real problem. You're worried
- 1:38:03about the risk and a knock potentially being thrown in prison for the rest of
- 1:38:06their life. So and then this is a question you say, well,
- 1:38:10what about Russia, what about China? And you know this may sound cavalier,
- 1:38:15but when I read, well, this is a Pandora's box, But
- 1:38:25when I read about we'll go nameless. How we do operations or did them
- 1:38:30in Russia? It was we would fly out, fly back, all this
- 1:38:34stuff and working on the embassy. Why do we just have somebody in Russia?
- 1:38:41You know? And you say, well, if you get caught.
- 1:38:44And the question is when you have the Marine battalion, they say we're going
- 1:38:47to take the hill, You're going to get you know, so does it
- 1:38:53become part of you? Remember when when they sign up, you have to
- 1:38:56say this is voluntary, right, This is not mandatory or mean, if
- 1:39:00you're in the military, is involuntary. But my point is why did we
- 1:39:04get to a position where we felt we couldn't take that risk. It was
- 1:39:12early on and I don't mean again to be cavalier, right, but if
- 1:39:15you want to cover the world, but that means you really have to have
- 1:39:20a different, a totally different way of doing it. And it's most senior
- 1:39:29officials. So let's say come from the outside and take over the agency for
- 1:39:32two years. This is so big, but don't give me this. I
- 1:39:38don't want this. It's a good idea, but we can't you know,
- 1:39:42we can't make a change. So it's it's almost you don't get paid off
- 1:39:46for years. It's not this is not I did this and now, but
- 1:39:51it wasn't that wonderful. No, there'll be a lot of heart heartburn on
- 1:39:56this one. It's hard to justify the bureaucrats that are looking at metrics everything
- 1:40:00realize like, no, this is a long term project. You'll see the
- 1:40:02dividends in twenty years. Yeah, so that's I think that's a real hurdle
- 1:40:05in some ways. Well where's their production, right, I need to have
- 1:40:11my numbers. Well, no, you understand they have to be they have
- 1:40:14to be working there. But they're going to be collecting a lot of information.
- 1:40:16But you know you you actually will get better information. But you have
- 1:40:21to look at information differently, and that is how does a private sector collected
- 1:40:27as opposed to the public The public sector, Okay, we've vetted this,
- 1:40:29and then the other private sector. I don't care where you got it.
- 1:40:32That better be true because I'm betting on this, and guess what, you're
- 1:40:35fired tomorrow, right, right, So there's there is this tension between do
- 1:40:43you really have to know exactly where a repeace comes from or can there be
- 1:40:47a lot of elicitation? But can you? But you have to be able
- 1:40:53to measure the value of that information. I'm in a private sector business and
- 1:40:58information, and my valuation is about the information itself. I don't get the
- 1:41:05first source from the first person and disseminate it. But after five years of
- 1:41:10right that information, all my work is based on referral from someone else.
- 1:41:16If you're not producing it, it's not like the US government move on to
- 1:41:19another job. You're fired, They stop hiring you, and they tell their
- 1:41:23friends. So information as a test is underweighted and too much emphasis on I
- 1:41:32need to be eyebawled the eyeball to them. Now you mentioned curveball, so
- 1:41:38you have to be eyeballed eyeball with some of them. But if you grow
- 1:41:42up with the person and they're producing information and you're able to evaluate and evaluate
- 1:41:46it and it's all panning out, then you can have a greater sense of
- 1:41:51reliability, particularly if you have multiple streams. So the reason I said is
- 1:41:57dynamite. This is you know, a headcrest wishing thing to do, and
- 1:42:01everyone's gonna say, oh, I'm going to be on the Paris next Please
- 1:42:04give me a break. But I think we've reached a critical point in time
- 1:42:10where you have to start it. You have to start. I think you're
- 1:42:14right check. And that's like something we probably should have started on ten or
- 1:42:16twenty years agow. And unfortunately it's probably gonna take our government another ten or
- 1:42:20twenty years to come to the conclusion if they And you know, you really
- 1:42:26bring up an interesting point that I've never I've never really thought about. Is
- 1:42:30it Why is an intelligence officer's life valued so much higher than that young marines
- 1:42:39like that? The marine is like you say, the Marines will be told
- 1:42:42to like take that hill or go do this because it's with it's for our
- 1:42:46tactical or strategic objectives. I don't think I wanted to undervalue that marine.
- 1:42:54As I said, I've got grandsons that are right in active duty or forces.
- 1:42:59Each one's probably every every captain, every sergeant, everybody knows that precious
- 1:43:03right And see, I should look at it's precious, not that it's valued
- 1:43:09more than it's precious. And how you manage them. Look, you're to
- 1:43:13operate here, he's going to take the hill in other words, it's the
- 1:43:16same criteria, but I just don't want there's a nuanced WED. I'm not
- 1:43:23trying to ever do it. I'm just saying they're equal right, right,
- 1:43:27and I have to be handled right way. But there shouldn't be a stumbling
- 1:43:32block from taking risk on one right. It's not the value right. Yeah,
- 1:43:36I apologize. I know that I was. Yeah, but I agree
- 1:43:41with I agree with your sentiment is that you know there there there is this
- 1:43:45idea of you know, a real I think sometimes lack of risk in the
- 1:43:51intelligence community in general, or maybe I think there's a funny aspect of that.
- 1:43:59I think we have the bravest people in our armed forces and in our
- 1:44:03now would you tell see how you first, I want to do this and
- 1:44:05you're going to trouble they say yes, I'm gonna do it, and I'm
- 1:44:09gonna talk about one person in a second, but the same person. God,
- 1:44:14the I g is coming. I got to write report. I gotta
- 1:44:15go down the hill. It's it's like that's where that's where there's perhaps more
- 1:44:23concerned than you know. And I'm not saying there's where the risk become different.
- 1:44:30It's not the it's not the physical risk because you know it. You've
- 1:44:32rubbed up against them, they rubbed up against you. But let me give
- 1:44:36you just one example, because they go into the book and it's very much
- 1:44:40part of the whole run story. So, uh the uh the When be
- 1:44:47Roupe became such a hot, violent place, we sent James Buckley out,
- 1:44:54So Casey went to him and said, listen, James, this is a
- 1:44:58voluntary assignment. You're going your single guy, but this is your call.
- 1:45:02He took. He said, I'm gone, and they kidnapped him, tortured
- 1:45:08him, and they sent the tapes back to CIA in case he could see
- 1:45:13the torture, you know, the torturing of the guy. He sent and
- 1:45:17Reagan and their heart was into the hostage deal. Now I opposed it.
- 1:45:24In other words, they were going to get him out no matter what,
- 1:45:27and that was the right sentiment. But trading hostages for a missile, that's
- 1:45:31where we had the problem. So but I can understand the heart part.
- 1:45:35But then it got it caused policy problems that then became a national national issue
- 1:45:45and even today. The podcast before dissemination I did you'll be a regular listener
- 1:45:50to mine is on hostages and the history of it and how so on.
- 1:45:55But my point was say, people do take the risk, they do go
- 1:45:59out. But uh, and so that's that's part of the game and not
- 1:46:05the game. It's part of the part of the deal. But I just
- 1:46:09don't understand, you know why we put some limitations on it, right,
- 1:46:13And yeah, like and I one agree with you in terms of the individual
- 1:46:18bravery, but I just I think because I thought that you were sort of
- 1:46:21seeing from an administrative point of view, why wouldn't the NC be willing to
- 1:46:27put somebody like deep into Russia? Because and because I would not want to
- 1:46:30be the chief of Russian ops. Right, But if you properly members,
- 1:46:34you have to send them in, right, You've got to you have to
- 1:46:38be I've done everything I can. This is this is not this is not
- 1:46:43dropping people with parachutes behind the lines in World War Two. There is if
- 1:46:46you could set that criteria high enough and get to the comfort level that this
- 1:46:50is acceptable risk, right there was I've got it so low that I can
- 1:46:55sleep at night that he's not going to get caught, right, all right,
- 1:47:00So my point is, yes, we should take we should assign people
- 1:47:06the new world. We're going to have to put people around the world out
- 1:47:09of higher risk, right, because the world is less friendly to us,
- 1:47:12so that everyone out there's going to be in a higher risk. Therefore,
- 1:47:15you need a service that is so well disciplined that the prospects of somebody actually
- 1:47:20get are down to the bare minimum, right. And if you lose,
- 1:47:25like losing Buckley, We've had someone out there, and it's painful, but
- 1:47:30you know that they're decisions you make. And when you're in combat, and
- 1:47:34whether it's cias in combat or military, there are risk and hearting. It's
- 1:47:43interesting because I think that what you're talking about is one of the things that
- 1:47:47most civilians think that the CIA is already doing well. It is, but
- 1:47:54it's not doing it in certain places, right, and the risk are high,
- 1:47:59And it may be maybe we've decided looking at it that we can't get
- 1:48:04it down to that acceptable risk. That's a difference. If you can't get
- 1:48:08it down you don't have the mechanism, then you should not do it right.
- 1:48:12Other words, you can't do it, Oh we're going to be rital.
- 1:48:14Let's send Bill out and let's hope the best there is. So if
- 1:48:17they're not, if you're not doing it because of that, I get it
- 1:48:20but I would say in the New World, we need to we need to
- 1:48:24be reevaluating the criteria to see are we good enough to get people in the
- 1:48:32North Korea and Iran that are walking around there and could be arrested and and
- 1:48:40those that that is an unpleasant outcome. Do you do you think we're going
- 1:48:46enough? Do you think that we have the potential be good enough to do
- 1:48:48that? I think we do it. Look, you start with that assumption,
- 1:48:55but you don't get arrogant and say you know you have to you have
- 1:48:59to complete the mission. I think we're I think I think Americans. I'm
- 1:49:05a you know, a real I think Americans can get America. You can
- 1:49:10get it done. I think the agency when they put their mind to it,
- 1:49:14they were really good. So it doesn't mean they aren't failures, shortcomings,
- 1:49:18not everybody, but that's that's part of the part of the drill.
- 1:49:27So you mentioned Afghanistan. What was your introduction to Afghanistan? In the Afghanistan
- 1:49:35So, I was in working in the Middle East on Iranian operations. One
- 1:49:42day, I think it was the DdO said to me, you can either
- 1:49:47be Chief of Southeast Asia that's Pakistan, or we have this office doing Afghanistan
- 1:49:56as well. Afghanistan I remember reading as a kid. I had very no
- 1:50:00experience in international things as a young kid, but I remember reading Caravans.
- 1:50:05It was a bye I'm trying to remember the author's name, but it was
- 1:50:10about Afghanistan, and I had just its intriguing sense of Afghanistan. But I
- 1:50:15had no idea what the size of the scope of the operations. So I
- 1:50:16said, you know, I've run big branches before. I think this Afghanistan
- 1:50:23thing house could. So I walked behind the red door and all of a
- 1:50:26sudden, it's like, wow, we're in a war room, and guess
- 1:50:30what we need. We need nine thousand mules and we got to get over
- 1:50:32there. And by the way, we went to go over the defence and
- 1:50:35tell them we want stingers and so so what I didn't realize what was behind
- 1:50:41the red door. So it was an eye open That's what I was describing
- 1:50:45earlier why I felt I needed the chief of logistics. I mean it was
- 1:50:47a big logistical war. I needed equality people. I had quality people,
- 1:50:51Milt Milt's team, I mean we uh so it was it was well.
- 1:51:00I went to a shipbuilding a ship building conference because of my building business recently,
- 1:51:08and in the middle of this, I was negotiating contract with ship not
- 1:51:12shipbuilders, shippers. How did the weapons get there? They all had to
- 1:51:15be Soviet style weapons that were made, they were bought. This is all
- 1:51:18in the public record. How do you get this stuff? How do you
- 1:51:23do it? I was, I was out there testing weapons and the one
- 1:51:28mortar if you read about it, I'm the first one that I'm aware of
- 1:51:32the US GPS and combat right that my Afghan forces then and you know,
- 1:51:39so that's all that was all new to me. So but I needed people
- 1:51:45and how I in the case of the one twenty mortar was I had a
- 1:51:49captain mortarman and the task verse and he said, they got this thing down,
- 1:51:53that it was a p hillary. I want to show it to you
- 1:51:57and he said, see this, Captain, show them. Well, okay,
- 1:52:00you put this GPS system and see this. The mort of it said,
- 1:52:02you can never hit anything, you know, you have to keep He
- 1:52:04said, look at this, it goes right through. And I said,
- 1:52:06great. So I should have bought all the stock. I should have sold
- 1:52:10my house, you know, so everything and put it. Of course I
- 1:52:14didn't, right because to me, it was just another operation, right,
- 1:52:17So, I mean it's my job was a really hands on management, logistical
- 1:52:26making things happen. Yeah, but negotiating at a very high level of foreign
- 1:52:29governments getting weapons. I have to tell you, it's like you've suddenly been
- 1:52:34put in some advanced training, probably failed. I was learning every day and
- 1:52:40you know, so you're blessed when you get those assignments. You shouldn't run
- 1:52:44away from them. You know, you should seek those. I mean,
- 1:52:46I'm not telling everybody what to do in life, but I think when you
- 1:52:50come out of it, you know a lot more about the political dynamics,
- 1:52:56the military forces, to considerations, blood, sweat and tears. I mean,
- 1:53:01you know, I learned them so much in a very short period of
- 1:53:03time. Well, I thought one of the interesting things, and something that
- 1:53:08you don't hear talked about a lot, was actually the Chinese involvement in terms
- 1:53:12of they're they're like a cooperation with you guys, because they weren't happy about
- 1:53:17Russia being there. So what was happening. It's two points i'd make.
- 1:53:24Charlie Wilson, we haven't discussed. Charlie was a carrier Dewey. Charlie,
- 1:53:28could you know, run circles around exotic behavior. Right. So but Charlie,
- 1:53:33it wasn't his war. It was a real logistical US government war and
- 1:53:39it doesn't make a good movie. But Charlie was very useful and important.
- 1:53:44So the I'm trying to remember how I got on the poor Charlie. So
- 1:53:51the cheese. So with the the armaments, we were by or approximately sixty
- 1:54:00percent from the Egyptians, which again is the public record for the Chinese.
- 1:54:05But as I got into it, the Chinese were producing better, faster equality.
- 1:54:11So I switched it. I just Arbitralie switched it to sixty forty.
- 1:54:15I mean, that's what you do. You're going to task for us.
- 1:54:18No one has time to stay on top of everything that's happening, so you
- 1:54:21really end up running this thing. I mean it's one of those ideal jobs,
- 1:54:27you know, the director once in a while, you know, but
- 1:54:29it's no one wants to have to deal with all the different things, and
- 1:54:32they just either counting on you tell me if the house is on you know,
- 1:54:38on fire. So I switched it. It was one of the few
- 1:54:40calls where Charlie called me. It was a little tested at the beginning.
- 1:54:43He said, Jack, what how you doing your switch? You know,
- 1:54:45I'm good friends with the Egyptians. It's easy, Charlie, you know,
- 1:54:48faster better he's ayeah, okay, okay, okay, right, So we
- 1:54:53switched it. So when I would go out there, and you know,
- 1:54:57you go through a kaboogie Dan Japanese. But if you go through a dance
- 1:55:01friendship and back and forth, and then you get around to how much you're
- 1:55:05going to pay, how much? How much you're going to pay for the
- 1:55:09weapons, and we was really startling one time. They said, okay,
- 1:55:15it's one let's say one sixty, right, and we're going to give you
- 1:55:19one fifty eight. That's Chinese. Give me one fifty eight because you're fighting
- 1:55:24the Russians. And I spoke volumes. Now today they're together, but I
- 1:55:31suspect deep down inside the Chinese nor the Russians are really happy as Russians in
- 1:55:36Chinese. Doesn't mean they're not going to cooperate, but it's not a natural
- 1:55:40marriage right at all. Yeah, and so we'll see what the tests of
- 1:55:45the time, I'm not sure how thrilled she is with you know, what's
- 1:55:48going on in Russians, and it's not making his life easier because he's been
- 1:55:54he lumped himself. But I think the alliance of Russia China are on North
- 1:55:59Korea and their allies. You know, I'm not sure he's going to feel
- 1:56:03that he's benefiting economically by being tied into that balance of powers. I would
- 1:56:11say that's where he is, and he's he's going to suffer for that,
- 1:56:15and I think he is. I think their economy, I think people investing
- 1:56:19if you want to hang in that club, you know. And but at
- 1:56:24the same time, if Putin were the we hold the line and he's leaves
- 1:56:28office, then that alliance breaks. So do you what like tell us about
- 1:56:38the stingers coming online. That's a great story. Yeah, that is so.
- 1:56:43We tried everything under the sun. You know Sam's blowpipes, sweetie.
- 1:56:48Nothing was working. And the war people don't understand this nineteen eighty five Washington
- 1:56:55sentiment. I mean, you know, everybody in town. The moss denis
- 1:57:00losing, the Russians are winning. Sounds familar to Ukraine today. And there
- 1:57:02was the case because the arms were stockpiled up on the border between Afghanistan and
- 1:57:10Pakistan, because the hind helicopters had suppressed the ability to move it across the
- 1:57:14border. Nine million pounds of words was rolling up there getting backed up.
- 1:57:20So I didn't know. There was a discussion about the stinger in the government.
- 1:57:26Right. So they have a it's almost like it deputies me where everybody
- 1:57:30in Afghanistan comes into one room in the White House and one day, well,
- 1:57:34we have this demonstration. So they showed a video of a mock up
- 1:57:39helicopter coming across. You see a guy fire a missile in the opposite direction.
- 1:57:43It makes a right turn and so very dramatically. I found on the
- 1:57:46table saying we have to have this now. Everybody in the room wanted us
- 1:57:50to ask for for months, right, right, oh Jack, great idea,
- 1:57:54but I didn't know that the director wasn't thrilled with This wasn't his plan.
- 1:57:59So fortunately I think the director moved in time, but the White House
- 1:58:02wanted it right. So the issue was I was to go over the It
- 1:58:10was I know his name something not going to mention, but a great general
- 1:58:13was head of logistics and a very competent general. But I went and said,
- 1:58:16look, I've been sent here. I need X number of missiles and
- 1:58:19he said, look coming off the assembly line. Now, the boys don't
- 1:58:24have them yet, so you can't have them. If I were him,
- 1:58:28I've said the same thing. I mean, I get it. So I
- 1:58:30called the White House, so you go back tomorrow. So because President Reagan
- 1:58:35had like they approached him and convinced him that like we needed the stingers,
- 1:58:40that that was the big impetus, right coming down with the general coming well,
- 1:58:45coming down from the White House level. No, I think what happened
- 1:58:46at the meeting was they've been wanting it for a long time, but the
- 1:58:49agent said agency was saying it was going to cause World War three, right,
- 1:58:54and I'd made the calculation it wasn't good, but I was doing that
- 1:58:57unknowingly. This is like that Communist Party. But it worked out for the
- 1:59:02best. So when I went back, he wasn't happy with me, even
- 1:59:08personally. I think it was unhappy. But that's how the missiles came to
- 1:59:13be. And what happened the estimates and testing was you would have a twenty
- 1:59:20five percent hit rate. It turned out to be seventy five. And the
- 1:59:25first time it was fired I think was September twenty sixth eighty six. And
- 1:59:30there's a video. In fact, there's actually a painting in Cia. If
- 1:59:32you go down the walls where they have paintings of historic moments. They have
- 1:59:36the actual picture. It's a painting now, formal portrait type painting where the
- 1:59:42mugdine shooter stands up. He doesn't want to hide you trying to rock because
- 1:59:46that's not mainly wherever he fires it and it knocked down three helicopters. Boom,
- 1:59:51boom, boom. And we had the pictures next day, and I
- 1:59:55went up to brief casey on it and have varied members memories of the moment,
- 2:00:02but the more vivid one is however we got there, we agreed that
- 2:00:05this could be. This will change the war. Why because it wasn't going
- 2:00:10to shoot down every hell. People don't understand that they flew high the minute
- 2:00:15they started change their behavior. We poured across and I believe that day,
- 2:00:19that week the Russians that we're out of here. And if I remember right
- 2:00:26from one system changed the history. If I remember from the book, though,
- 2:00:30those you were getting, uh, you were getting pushed back about those
- 2:00:32pictures from the Russian specialists right or over from somebody. I thought somebody.
- 2:00:39I thought somebody in the agency wasn't like, didn't believe the pictures were like
- 2:00:42legitimate, No they were they were no, no, they were undeniable.
- 2:00:47There was also video. It wasn't just it was it was I think it's
- 2:00:51really interesting that, you know, when we talk about covert action and plausible
- 2:00:56deniability, that you know, we want to deny that we're participating in this
- 2:01:00action, but it becomes evident at a certain point in order to win the
- 2:01:08war, I mean, stingers in Afghanistan, we put to missiles into Syria,
- 2:01:14javelins in Ukraine. But remember plausible by the time you get there,
- 2:01:17it's plausible. Jari Wilson's running over the hills on his with his and is
- 2:01:24that why you calculated that there was a more serious calculation that I'm making a
- 2:01:30tiny bit glib. The Russians, the concern was would the technology be lost?
- 2:01:34We had sources that told us they already had the technology, so that
- 2:01:39was one of the arguments against it. And the second is plausible denial.
- 2:01:46You gotta be hitting me right at this point. So at that point,
- 2:01:53the fundamental issue is what would Russia's reaction. This is how I feel about
- 2:01:58Ukraine, by the way, So you know when you stop and say the
- 2:02:00f F fifteen's or whatever we're going to fly in. So when I said
- 2:02:06that the Russians are not what are they going to do? What are they
- 2:02:10going to do? Where are they going to escalate? Where you're going?
- 2:02:13What's the next play? Now? If you had something to destroy the staggers,
- 2:02:15okay, that's your next play. But if you don't have it,
- 2:02:18what's your next the next place? So to me, you can always soul
- 2:02:23Himani. I mean, I I think that was a very important critical move
- 2:02:29by decision or yours government take out the money. But I know the discussion
- 2:02:33was, oh that you know that's going to cause So you have that in
- 2:02:38the room, sure, and that's when things don't get done. But you
- 2:02:43can't be cavaliera and you have to sit there and say is it going to
- 2:02:45cause? What's Putin going to do? I mean, is he really is
- 2:02:49he going to get a new army because he already has it out there?
- 2:02:53I mean, what is he going to do? You know, bump someone
- 2:02:56else off? I mean it's so the name the game should be really up
- 2:03:00to the ending, right And as I said earlier on the side that I
- 2:03:04thought we got off to a good start, but you know, we need
- 2:03:08to be providing the way we were in Afghanistan, boom, keep keep keeping
- 2:03:12that pressure building faster, faster or more. On eighty five, the sense
- 2:03:16of the opinion in Washington we were losing. The decision by President Reagan was
- 2:03:21We're going to give it one more year. I don't think anybody knows this.
- 2:03:25The Russians mustn't have good sources. They all had to do is hang
- 2:03:28in for another year, and the budget went up triple. There was there
- 2:03:33was a huge push, but the agreement was you got a year now.
- 2:03:39You know, might have drifted in the year and a half, but they
- 2:03:42were looking at getting out. Yeah, and I would have thought I thought
- 2:03:45that would have been a terrible mistake. But the point was how long are
- 2:03:48we going to go on? And where is it going? And we're losing.
- 2:03:51It sounds familiar to Ukraine. And my view is, you know,
- 2:03:56you need to push the pedal to the floor, get this thing done right,
- 2:04:00and then it'll drag it out out of curiosity because you know Jack mentioned
- 2:04:05the stingers and these these other things. Out of curiosity is there when something
- 2:04:11starts out as a COVID action and it has its you know, its own
- 2:04:14budget, or it has its things. If it moves out of what we
- 2:04:17would technically call the covert realm, does it need to get reclassified or does
- 2:04:23it stay in that same place at it that it started. Well, it
- 2:04:27has to stay there because if he go to the army and then you have
- 2:04:29the US army is now involved, it's on the ground, Now you have
- 2:04:31a war. You're an army presence, the unplausible denial. You don't force
- 2:04:40that issue right there is we're not In my view, would be to the
- 2:04:45extent possible, you should always have the indigenous people. If we're attacked directly,
- 2:04:49then we respond right Otherwise, our job is to support them, train
- 2:04:56them, equip them, you know, give them the intelligence they need.
- 2:05:00And if they don't, if they're not doing it, and if they're corrupt,
- 2:05:03I mean corrupt in a sense that they're not fighting and taking the money,
- 2:05:08then then you don't do it right. You just say, okay,
- 2:05:12this is not doable. Do we put the army in and okay, let's
- 2:05:15take a look at what that means. So I think covert action is a
- 2:05:17great tool. I you know, again, I know a lot of your
- 2:05:21listeners will like this, but I wish we had stayed with the covert action
- 2:05:27effort in Afghanistan and not going in militarily and Iraq the same thing, because
- 2:05:34at the end of the day you have to make an assessment of you know,
- 2:05:38are the people going to stay and fight? And once we're in it
- 2:05:42changed the entire complexion of it plus the amount of human uh, how many
- 2:05:50people you need to run a COVID action is much smaller than any military one
- 2:05:56and the cost there reive it's really very inexpensive. COVID action just like spying
- 2:06:01is. You know, our budget was small, but I mean I think
- 2:06:05it could up around a billion dollars. But at the high point you put
- 2:06:11that in the budget. And if you're saying this is the one place to
- 2:06:15where where you're fighting the Russians and you're spending X hundreds of billions of dollars,
- 2:06:20I mean, that's the kind of reasonable investment Ukraine. I mean you're
- 2:06:25looking at that investment where your adversary is getting increasingly aggressive visa the Europe,
- 2:06:32and you want to prevent a war, you stop them, and stop them
- 2:06:35at the first place, if just if you just stall long enough his own
- 2:06:39system today the Baldi died. But you know it's not going to be a
- 2:06:45numb rising, but his own system. He's going to become a liability to
- 2:06:49the system, and the system will figure out how to deal with that.
- 2:06:55But you know, we were breathing wind back into his sales by you know
- 2:07:00or impass in Congress and are wavering on getting I mean, it's we're going
- 2:07:04to get where we're going to improve, the prospects of the war will go
- 2:07:08on and his departure will be pushed out further. So coming back to Afghanistan,
- 2:07:14there's lessons to be learned, there's going back here. There's history.
- 2:07:17We have to you know, you have to look at history and these things.
- 2:07:21You know, look what happened when the Russians went in there, brittish
- 2:07:25before them, and when we handled it, and no, now we're going
- 2:07:28to go in and do it. It's like, what did you read history?
- 2:07:30Yeah, there was I don't remember if this was during uh during the
- 2:07:36the first engagement in Afghanistan. A second thing, I remember a quote that
- 2:07:41you that you quote from somebody that that some about the Afghans don't like the
- 2:07:46afghan You the Afghans don't get conquered or the Afghans don't like something along those
- 2:07:53lines. I don't know if you remember that. I can't remember where it
- 2:07:55was. There's a couple of quotes in it. One a plaque that I
- 2:07:59have in my office from Charlie Wilson and it says a quote from the first
- 2:08:03Democratic leader and uh in Afghanistan and it says, my son, my son,
- 2:08:09never trust my last words here, never trust the rush. And the
- 2:08:16other is one from Kipling, and that is, you know, when you're
- 2:08:20you die in when you're shot in the field in Afghanistan, roll over and
- 2:08:24shoot yourself. I mean it's like, I mean, Charlie had a dark
- 2:08:30sense of humor. It wasn't I mean, it wasn't at all humorous,
- 2:08:33but it was that's the type of play. But why what's going to happen
- 2:08:37to you if you don't if you don't shoot yourself, you're gonna be you
- 2:08:39know, cutting to a hundred pieces, and you know, Jack, I
- 2:08:43think we should probably get to some viewer questions, maybe like one more topic
- 2:08:48before we go to some questions, if that's okay, okay, but sticking
- 2:08:54I'm with you, sticking, sticking with the same time frame. If you
- 2:08:56want to your thoughts about Iran contra and I know that you knew some of
- 2:09:01the main players Poindexter, see Cord Oliver North. What was your intersection with
- 2:09:07the Iran program. Now this requires a bit of a rollout. Yeah,
- 2:09:13sure, So I told you the Jim Buckley story of him being kidnapped.
- 2:09:18That was the impetus for we're going to do something. And one of the
- 2:09:24problems from the very beginning with the Ran Country affair, it was an operation
- 2:09:30run out of the White House. The White House should never run operations that
- 2:09:33I trained in at the risk of the White House. It's just bad.
- 2:09:39So the first thing that you said in mind is the real motivation was well
- 2:09:46placed. But when I was chief of the Irunnian operations, you said,
- 2:09:50the head of the NFC was Admiral John Poindexter, and he called me down.
- 2:09:54I would say, I was like, colonel, Colonel, something like
- 2:09:58that. You're not called down to the White House one on one with the
- 2:10:01NSC director to have a private meeting. We had a private meeting. He
- 2:10:05said, Jack, I called you down because I want to talk about the
- 2:10:07moderates. But I said, what moderates? Any moderates there? You either
- 2:10:13have extremists, a real extreme, you know, super extremists and I left.
- 2:10:16But what I didn't realize, well, that was at the time that
- 2:10:20they were thought that they were moderates and that they were dealing with them because
- 2:10:24the White House, a contractor had brought in uh An Iranian who named Gobani
- 2:10:31Farm, and he said he could arrange training hostages, getting relief for the
- 2:10:39hostages. And I remember getting a called Dow. He called me. Dewey
- 2:10:45called me. He was Chief of Europe, but he knew Casey well.
- 2:10:48So he called said Jack, the director is going to call you. Say
- 2:10:52yes, okay, do he got that one h So the director called and
- 2:10:58I went upstairs and there's a group in the room and he said, look,
- 2:11:03there's this guy Gobani far and we think he has information about about the
- 2:11:09hostages and all of this. And I said, look, this is the
- 2:11:16fellow in Iowa that's out on the tractor. Before I went up, he
- 2:11:20handed me a folders saying, see this, we got two burnardices. He's
- 2:11:22a fabricator liar. So I went up and said that. They said,
- 2:11:28well, you know, maybe you should go out and talk to him anyway,
- 2:11:31because it's the hostages. So I did, and I met Ali and
- 2:11:35Gabanifar and the contract and the meeting was interesting. It starts off with him
- 2:11:41bringing four cans of caviary. He passes the cannon carri sixes. I push
- 2:11:46it back. I said, I don't take anything from anybody. Now he
- 2:11:48knew that was a message. He knows Okay, they remember me, right,
- 2:11:52they know me right, So he's going to decide he's going to do
- 2:11:56his charm. I'm going to fast forward a little bit with him. I
- 2:12:00remember later on, I'm standing in the men's room right going to THEO and
- 2:12:05he's standing beside me, and he said, Jack, you know, if
- 2:12:09you ever need money for like like special things you want to do, I
- 2:12:13mean, I can probably be healthy. I'm there, What hell is this
- 2:12:16guy? You know? I felt like turning around, and you know,
- 2:12:20so it didn't make any sense. Why because I didn't know what he was
- 2:12:22talking about. What he was talking about was what he was eventually going to
- 2:12:26do with the money in Central America Rock. Yeah, right, So this
- 2:12:28doesn't mean anything to me. So I get back and uh and I briefed
- 2:12:35directly saying, no, you don't realize this, but there's already been a
- 2:12:39shipment that was made and that you know, we've got good money for it.
- 2:12:43And he said, well, you know the hostage are really important.
- 2:12:46This is again this, So I thought I was a brilliant stroke. I
- 2:12:50said, well, I think we need a polygraphic because I knew he polygraphing
- 2:12:52in funk twice. So I did. I took him to Georgetown Hotel and
- 2:12:56security. I set it up. But I was there and we did the
- 2:13:00I didn't do it because that's a technic, techno job, but I was
- 2:13:01there and he flunked all the relevant questions and he couldn't do this. He
- 2:13:05didn't lying, but the White House person handling said, Jack, you called
- 2:13:13me when it's over. I felt like laughing. He said I could have
- 2:13:16called you. You're kidding me. I got two layers above me that get
- 2:13:20to maybe before you hear from me. And I met him in alias,
- 2:13:24so he didn't know my true name. I think today the rules would say
- 2:13:26he would have to know your true names, but that date didn't. So
- 2:13:31I get a franty call from from the ddo's office. The secretary says,
- 2:13:37he's cutting you on the line, Declaire George. He is steaming mad,
- 2:13:43and I said, well he's okay. Well, let's see what happens.
- 2:13:45So he gets to Jack, what the hell are you doing? This guy's
- 2:13:50been calling saying you beat up go Bonnie for So, I said, I
- 2:13:56wish I did. Yeah, I wish I did. But I said,
- 2:13:58lucky flanked all day. Question said, okay, hell with at the end
- 2:14:00of it, and we're out of it. We're not going to do well.
- 2:14:03What they didn't realize is we didn't get out of it. The director
- 2:14:07handed it off of the analytical side. They went ahead with the meeting him
- 2:14:11and trying to collect information. So the only thing I would say is and
- 2:14:18that was in December holiday time. In February, the Chief of the Middle
- 2:14:22East, a great guy, Tom Thweatin, who's went on to be the
- 2:14:26DdO, but a very sound operator in many ways. But coleb he said,
- 2:14:33you're not going to like this, but I've got to find e in
- 2:14:35my you know, I've seen the finding, and the finding says, you
- 2:14:39know, we need to help make those shipments take place. And I know
- 2:14:45you won't deal with Goubani for but can you make the flights go? So
- 2:14:50so I dealt with Seacourt and we made the flights. Now I'm sitting there
- 2:14:54thinking this is never going to happen is too stupid. It's not going to
- 2:14:58happen. Sending missiles out. We don't even know who they're going to.
- 2:15:01We don't know where they're going. Now, I would say, in fairness,
- 2:15:05Ali North and everybody got that plane, we're very brave McFarlane. They
- 2:15:07had no idea where they were going to go. They didn't know who they
- 2:15:09were dealing with. I mean, it was the plane taking off. It
- 2:15:13was a lesson and violens a few of your rules about COVID action, I
- 2:15:16think, like all them. But then there's a quote by George Schultz's sticks
- 2:15:22in my head. No bad idea dies in Washington. So that's a lesson.
- 2:15:28This was if I had to learn the lesson, this is it.
- 2:15:30Yeah, So the it didn't die, it went forward. So I made
- 2:15:37those those ship That's happened in the logistical part of it, and you know,
- 2:15:45were a couple of people were released, but then a couple more were
- 2:15:46kidnapped, right, And I wasn't thinking much about it until I was forget
- 2:15:52home several months later or months later, I can't remember the sequence, and
- 2:15:58I'm watching the attorney uneral on TV to announce that the announcing that we that
- 2:16:07when we we did the arms for hostages. But money that was supposed to
- 2:16:15the money that came for the missiles I got, but an equal amount went
- 2:16:18into Central America to support the war in Central America, which was against the
- 2:16:24wall because they were upselling the missiles. Well they were upsoll good money for
- 2:16:28being good. When he said to me, I can help you with money.
- 2:16:31God knows what plan he had. But the point was Congress had passed
- 2:16:37the rule no money can come into the US treasury, So that was a
- 2:16:39crime. The hostage was a policy. The president has the right. That's
- 2:16:43it, Vegan decide. I didn't it was the right move because you'd end
- 2:16:48up more hostages and the runnings you can't trust. You didn't know, so
- 2:16:54I didn't like the I didn't like it. I understood why they did it
- 2:16:56right and have compassion for that is well. But the money going to Central
- 2:17:01America was a violational law. Right, that's where the operation. Congress had
- 2:17:05pumped the brakes on the contrace. That was this like eighty six, eighty
- 2:17:09seven, This was eighty six, Yeah, it was excuse me, I
- 2:17:16can't remember. Let's see whether it was December of eighty five. It might
- 2:17:18have been December of eighty five. So so then it almost brought the Reagan
- 2:17:26administration down. Yeah, I mean this is yeah, you know, who
- 2:17:28knew what when? Then you have the courts and that I had to testify
- 2:17:33in court only. But I don't want to get into that. I mean
- 2:17:35I can, but my point was at the hearings you mean, yeah,
- 2:17:39yeah, so but the issue is covert action again. I mean, where
- 2:17:46we were we're looking, you know, did we take all the right right
- 2:17:50steps here and where we were dealing with the right people, and so it
- 2:17:54was bad covert action. The inexcusable part was the money into the contrast,
- 2:18:00right, and the agency was not involved as an agency. People get confused.
- 2:18:07Some of the officers worked with Oli North off the books. They were
- 2:18:11good officers, many of them really fine operators, but they were so committed
- 2:18:16to the cause that they didn't and they were kind of blinded. Okay,
- 2:18:22we have to help them. They believed OLLI when he said this is coming
- 2:18:26directly from the President. You need to fall in line with this. But
- 2:18:28you can't tell the agents, right, It's like it's like Chile, don't
- 2:18:33tell the ambassador once you get into those boxes and you're anywhere around that,
- 2:18:37you know you have trouble. Troubles in River City's coming tomorrow next week.
- 2:18:41But it's coming. So I feel bad about the folks that get wrapped up
- 2:18:46in it. But again, uh, you got it. There's a part
- 2:18:50in I think Spymasters President. You got to stay within the lines. Yeah.
- 2:18:52No, there's there's a really good chapter about all this in this book,
- 2:18:56and it breaks down. I mean, if you can't have a bureaucracy,
- 2:19:00you can't run at something. And because of your dedication and commitment work
- 2:19:03off the books. That's only in the movie. Yeah. Yeah, And
- 2:19:07I pour it because it isn't because it isn't a wild great thing. No,
- 2:19:13you have to do that. You're gonna have chaos, right, everybody
- 2:19:16will decide for themselves. Oh I think this is patriotic. So I'm going
- 2:19:18to run my own opera right there. So you have to have really tight
- 2:19:22discipline. And the interesting thing about it's the only case I know of this,
- 2:19:26and I've done a pretty thorough review of all COVID actions. I don't
- 2:19:31know of another where we worked off the books. Anybody worked off the books?
- 2:19:33Two and was ever became an issue. If someone did, it remained
- 2:19:39a secret forever. I guess I thought. I thought you, like,
- 2:19:43because you mentioned that Casey, you know, called everybody and when it was
- 2:19:46first reporting, he said, this all blow over by tomorrow, right,
- 2:19:50and everybody's like yeah, and You're like, no, oh, I was
- 2:19:52that you forgot? I forgot about that. Yeah, I forgot. That
- 2:19:56was a stunning moment. I won't mention who else was in the room because
- 2:20:00many of them went on the very senior positions. It was I'd forgotten that
- 2:20:03moment that you reminded me, because all blow over and I'm sitting there,
- 2:20:07are you kidding me? Yeah? I am a a I'm a colonel,
- 2:20:11you're a five star general, and you think this is going to blow over?
- 2:20:16Yeah? I and everybody else is agreeing with everyone. It wasn't agreed,
- 2:20:20it was it's different. It's different. Nobody moved a muscle. Nobody
- 2:20:24moved a muscle, and I was like, wow, Wow, I know
- 2:20:31we're we're taking up a lot of your jack. So what's jump into some
- 2:20:33of the questions here. We got one from Bill Gage, He asks,
- 2:20:41this is a historical question. Stalin was widely viewed as evil incarnate in the
- 2:20:46twenties and thirties, Yet we partnered with him to defeat the Nazis. Do
- 2:20:50you foresee any potential partnership with Putin similar to the Stalin one? For example,
- 2:20:54there's another terror attack in Israel or against the major Western country that engulfs
- 2:20:58the entire world. It pits the US or the West against the Middle Eastern
- 2:21:01countries, and the West had to ally with Putin to the funeral adversaries.
- 2:21:07So I guess I think World War two was different. In other words,
- 2:21:11you were talking about Germany going to attack Russia and attacking UK, right,
- 2:21:20I'm not sure we would need him in Israel. In other words, this
- 2:21:22was these were big European land war. Okay, I could see where there
- 2:21:28there is even cooperation now the words if there were. In fact, it
- 2:21:33was reported the other day, and I'm trying to remember the exact circumsances.
- 2:21:37We were obligated to alert, I mean, right to inform. Even with
- 2:21:43hostile countries, we will share information and work together right against the terrorist thing.
- 2:21:50So even in all this mess, maybe there's something we would do with
- 2:21:54the Russians that would be a mutual interest. It's hard for me to concoct
- 2:22:00what that might be. But it could be a terrorist event of some sort.
- 2:22:03But that is ephemeral event one that okay, but it's not We're going
- 2:22:09no way we can join arms. You can't trust them. You can't trust
- 2:22:11Stalin either. But so and his rush is not it's not the Soviet Union.
- 2:22:20It's a much smaller proposition. I don't see where they could help us.
- 2:22:24He can't even handle so far Ukraine. Sean asks, I've heard cuts
- 2:22:30force described as CIA that operates like the Green Berets. Is that accurate?
- 2:22:35What sort of team structure do they use? And are they do they have
- 2:22:39major capabilities that they've been holding back. Well, my experience with the agency
- 2:22:46is that they've have a core cadre of experienced, seasoned military officers and in
- 2:22:58a crisis, then you detail to the government people for those operations. Right.
- 2:23:07But I think when we're looking at much of what we do today is
- 2:23:11often providing support like training to other elements, and therefore you're you're not actually
- 2:23:18doing the operations, although sometimes it's pretty close in, but you're providing the
- 2:23:24training for others. And but it's not as if CI is sitting on some
- 2:23:28hitting hidden storm trooping groups that are ready to but they could be. I
- 2:23:33mean, the one of the beauties of the agency is how quickly can expand.
- 2:23:37And in the US and special forces and love they like working together.
- 2:23:45That's my understanding why because you don't have any to you don't have as much
- 2:23:48red tape. You can actually get on the plane and get going and someday
- 2:23:50you worry about the accounting. So then and they work very well. I
- 2:23:54think bringing down to the Talleban is a class example. You know, c
- 2:23:58got an, the military was waiting at the airport, they could get the
- 2:24:03approval. They were there the next week together clindestinely, covertly. They did
- 2:24:07a beautiful job. I mean. And so I'm just I'm saying, I
- 2:24:13don't think there's anything special sitting there. If we needed it, it will
- 2:24:16be some joint After there's more likely to be some jointness than than in say
- 2:24:20my time, where we would do it with they would detailed them and they're
- 2:24:24totally under my control. We might have joint ops and that's to me.
- 2:24:30You know, sensible people sit in the room if here's what's the most efficient
- 2:24:33way to do this, right, I think there's more of that today m.
- 2:24:39Corbyn, Thank you very much, thanks for coming on. Any non
- 2:24:41fiction, non Western origin readings related to the gainier side of espionage or specifically
- 2:24:50anything to do with propaganda that you could suggest, And he says, hit
- 2:24:54that like button, so hit it. But yeah, is there any non
- 2:24:58Western authors that you've read on the like in the intelligence field or propaganda.
- 2:25:09Well, I think there's two different things. One is reading people that are
- 2:25:13in the business. All right, I would say I enjoyed like Corre right,
- 2:25:16I mean, and that's not because of the techniques. It's the psychology
- 2:25:22of espionages right, and the sort of the gray area and the struggles.
- 2:25:26And you mentioned how do you how do you come to peace with it?
- 2:25:31It's quite interesting, I think, And from a nol novel point of view,
- 2:25:39I think if I, if I think long enough, there's probably something.
- 2:25:41Well the Brits have done some Christopher that said his first name or last
- 2:25:48name. But there's there's several books of the Brits have written that are good
- 2:25:54documentaries. Grideski case and so on. There's some good British materials. I
- 2:26:00don't think it would take much and I don't I'm not being evasive. It
- 2:26:03just enough pop out, but there's several good books there, but I don't
- 2:26:07know of any particular farm books. You should read Russian books about their own
- 2:26:11strategy that will help a lot. So I think that's true. Probaganda is
- 2:26:18a big subject. I think it's one that you know. I don't know
- 2:26:20if you want to tackle it now, but I think it's the hottest nation
- 2:26:24security issue right now is what do we do with this information and the Russian's
- 2:26:30ability, because I think it's far superior to the Chinese. The Chinese have
- 2:26:33capabilities, but they really haven't been into this information business until recently. The
- 2:26:41Russians have been in it since the forming of the Communist Party, and they
- 2:26:46have a lot of experience and disinformation. As they said, we're at a
- 2:26:50disadvantage. It doesn't come to us naturally. But now it's one thing when
- 2:26:54you put on that and you put something in a newspaper around the world.
- 2:26:58Quite another when you'd go into our system with the Twitter, Facebook, YouTube.
- 2:27:05I mean, you start the amount of things they did in twenty sixteen,
- 2:27:09which are relatively limited, but when you look at it, you're told
- 2:27:13millions of people were you know, snowed by information that they were putting in
- 2:27:20our election, which I found outrageous. So I think this information, I
- 2:27:24mean Tucker Cross and I've picked him on Tucker, but that was you know,
- 2:27:28two hours of disinformation, right tailored everything fitting an image, you know.
- 2:27:33So they're very good at it. But the social media provides it was
- 2:27:39so hard for us to do in close propaganda to that degree that you could
- 2:27:46hit a button and hit one hundred thousand people and be in your inbox right
- 2:27:52and disguise it. And the way that the techniques can be disguised. So
- 2:27:54I think, you know, our biggest strength is we should keep telling the
- 2:28:00Russia story. What happened to the lobby today? What are the Russians really
- 2:28:03doing? No there? I think, I don't why worry about disinformation?
- 2:28:07We should be just hammering them as we did before. The problem for US
- 2:28:11is the defensive side. How do we stop? And I just noticed the
- 2:28:15FBI had a success this last couple of days with shutting down a Russian banking
- 2:28:22operation in this field. So I think we and again there's a recent announcement
- 2:28:26say we're making a national security priority. That doesn't mean that the words will
- 2:28:31then follow, but I think they will because I think it's a real problem
- 2:28:37that our country is so divided. It's ripe for disinformation, with so many
- 2:28:43isolated groups that are around a certain set of particular interests to pit us against
- 2:28:48each other. And it is part coming back to reading books, it's part
- 2:28:52of the Russian orthodoxy that you will use disinformation in your campaign, and all
- 2:29:00around the world he's doing it. So I think it's a big issue for
- 2:29:03us. And I said, fortunately, we're sitting on a good white story,
- 2:29:09but it doesn't help defend us. So I think the best brains in
- 2:29:13the technical area are going to have to really get together with the best intelligence
- 2:29:18people and try and figure out how we get in front of it. And
- 2:29:24then M Corbyn, thank you very much. Could US policy towards massud in
- 2:29:30the late eighties and nineties have been more accommodating? What did it prevented rise
- 2:29:33of the Taliban AQ? Well, let me. When I was running it,
- 2:29:41the program came to an end, right, and Charlie Wilson and I
- 2:29:48thought we should stay in there. And I had almost like a aid USAID
- 2:29:54program mentality, we'll keep it, will do wells, we'll do when the
- 2:29:58minds of hearts of people. But the vision was we won get out of
- 2:30:01there. It's never going to get better, right, So Charlie was particularly
- 2:30:07upset. And but you know, fast forward twenty years. I sat down
- 2:30:11to myself and I said, you were wrong, Jack, it was there
- 2:30:15was no reason to stay. You couldn't. You couldn't, you couldn't change
- 2:30:20it. So we left. Okay, Again, this comes back to self
- 2:30:24determinations. The Afghans have to decide. Now. Well, people don't realize
- 2:30:28that, you know, but Laden was in It was in as ASSAUTI was
- 2:30:35in the Sudan if I remember. But then he went out there as a
- 2:30:37fighter, but no US AID ever went to him. He was a fighter
- 2:30:43out there, but he received it from other Arab states. But I once
- 2:30:46had a discussion with Milt. You ever hear this guy? He's out there
- 2:30:48with you, this guy there might have been two skirmishes, but this guy's
- 2:30:52a nobody. I mean, so he wasn't a player in the war.
- 2:30:56So there's a difference between the Mujadin and al Qaeda in that group. So
- 2:31:03when when when we when we left, as far as US policy was concerned,
- 2:31:11you know, it was over. The Taliban didn't and didn't become powerful
- 2:31:18until years later. So I and the Taliban leaders are not the x Afghan
- 2:31:24fighters and that's why we were able to go back in and use them.
- 2:31:28So I don't feel we we created the real the best fighters were not part
- 2:31:37of the Taliban. So I think there's a connection there that isn't is inaccurate
- 2:31:43and none of the the best of my knowledge, no aid ever went to
- 2:31:48the Arab country fighters there from the US. It came from other urbed states.
- 2:31:56Uh. And that is it for the questions that we have. Oh
- 2:32:01wait, uh jardline, then thank you very much. Is the CIA director
- 2:32:05being used as a negotiator common uh Burns example, Burns with Taliban now Israel
- 2:32:13Hamas I recognized Burne's background, but interesting points of view on the pros and
- 2:32:18it's an interesting using the DCIA. So I would say, first of it,
- 2:32:24his extraordinary credentials. If you look at his experience in Russia, his
- 2:32:28language, and you know he's a State Department product through a book about his
- 2:32:35experiences. So there's a lot of ways you could use as a director.
- 2:32:39In the early days, they rarely travel. Everybody traveled to them, so
- 2:32:45they didn't travel. Also, there was more cover and I remember Casey wanted
- 2:32:50to visit me in Argentina. They didn't want him to come because of all
- 2:32:54the political part that he was annoyed in some other countries, so he didn't
- 2:32:58come to anybody, was with everybody. But I think it's that clause.
- 2:33:07I'm not saying it's covert action because you're reading about it every day, but
- 2:33:11it says carry out those special activities. So one of the activities of the
- 2:33:16CIA is its relationship with foreign liaison. It's a forced faullifier. And in
- 2:33:22many countries the president is the former minister of Interior, and unlike CIA,
- 2:33:28the heads of foreign intelligence often sit in all the meetings. They are really
- 2:33:35part of the political structure. We have segregated. Rightfully, I would point
- 2:33:39out, so director Burns is the face for most cinemat for the French service,
- 2:33:50the British in other words, so when you have the world in turmoil,
- 2:33:56you know you have chiefs of stations that are really good, right.
- 2:34:00There's nothing like having the director, right, So if you're trying to mobilize,
- 2:34:05I mean, I think this is a very proper function. But I
- 2:34:11think I read recently one of his own statements. I think he's been in
- 2:34:13fifty countries. I mean fifty there's something where it's almost on the road all
- 2:34:22the time. It's brutal to your body. Yeah, and I don't care
- 2:34:24who you are. So he's doing guys where you always gonna have a great
- 2:34:28book when he's done. But I think it's a natural role for it.
- 2:34:31But you have a deputy director, you have chiefs of operations, you have
- 2:34:35people that run the different part of the world. The DCI really shouldn't be
- 2:34:39running the day to day operations of spying and so on. So it seems
- 2:34:45to me that they're putting good use to him. Now, not all directors
- 2:34:50are diplomats, right, they wouldn't lend themselves to this. But when you
- 2:34:54have someone of that experience in training, that or skill, then you apply
- 2:35:01them. But if you had someone that was a career spy and didn't like
- 2:35:05interacting with other people or whatever, well they wouldn't be they wouldn't be asked
- 2:35:13to do it. Jack. We will have you on again to talk about
- 2:35:18everything else in your post service life, but I want to give you an
- 2:35:22opportunity to tell our viewers about the Arcing group in the work you do now
- 2:35:26and where people can go to find you. Well, I think that's a
- 2:35:30very kind of a first. Don't forget to read the books. Yes,
- 2:35:33the books are good Hunting Spymaster's Prison. There you go, thanks by Jack
- 2:35:37Vine. Please check them out. They're both phenomenal. I mean it's it's
- 2:35:43history in the Every page is just a part of history. Is incredible.
- 2:35:46Well, thank you for me, both of you. I think that's a
- 2:35:50real compliment. I appreciate it. I appreciate your audience, and that's why
- 2:35:52we're we're here but the Arcing group. But what's really interesting is I'm an
- 2:35:58intelligence junkie. You figured that out, said, I designated myself to the
- 2:36:01defender of everybody's intelligence. But what I went into is private sector intelligence.
- 2:36:07And that is instead of supporting US government, it's law firms, corporations,
- 2:36:16public relations firms. And usually it's because people are in they're either investing in
- 2:36:22a company, or they invested in something went wrong, or they're in competition
- 2:36:28with somebody. They need to know what the government's doing vs. Their products.
- 2:36:31So it's more of the it is an intelligence collecting. The Justice Department
- 2:36:37has not altered me to engaging, so they took that fun way. But
- 2:36:45the difference is in the private sector. As I said, there's nuances about
- 2:36:50the collection process, and we can get into this different point in time,
- 2:36:56but it's bringing to them information that they can act on. They went grander
- 2:37:01information and act on it. And it's a high bar. I mean,
- 2:37:05I tried to produce the same style, same writing, same objectivity that I
- 2:37:09do and in the public sector, and you either hit the mark, satisfy
- 2:37:16the customer, or you're not going to be a business loan. We've been
- 2:37:18in the business over twenty years, so I think we're doing it right.
- 2:37:22I'm happy because I'm looking at countries around the world and looking at them through
- 2:37:26the business sector. But the business sector is heavily involved in collecting intelligence.
- 2:37:31They don't call themselves a collector, right, but during covered action, they're
- 2:37:35meeting people. So I'm swimming in that water and trying to organize it and
- 2:37:41focus in a way in which you know, I can bring the skill set
- 2:37:46that I have. People assume that Jack brought all the CIA friends that he
- 2:37:50calls the director and they everything That isn't how it worked. The other thing
- 2:37:54I left, I didn't leave with a single piece of paper. They hadn't
- 2:37:56give me those two pieces of paper about my volunteering to work for them.
- 2:38:00But what I did know is how you find sources around the world, and
- 2:38:03how there's people out there who are very good, very professional, train their
- 2:38:09own world. There's hundreds of them out there collecting information, and over time,
- 2:38:15I think we've gotten really good. We have a very robust network.
- 2:38:18So if someone comes in there's almost any country in the world and they need
- 2:38:24you know they're about to make a big bid. They want to make sure
- 2:38:26there's nothing that's going to bite them into proverbial. So I think we're a
- 2:38:31good insurance policy. And I don't think there's a lot of firms, but
- 2:38:37when you talk about there's a lot of firms that collect the United States,
- 2:38:41there's a lot of open source. Collecting abroad is a real challenge for people,
- 2:38:46and everybody says they can do it, but there's only really you get
- 2:38:48around on a handful of people that do it well. I think we're one
- 2:38:52of those. Have you found any niches for your company, things that you
- 2:38:56guys really specialize in. I think it is the part. First of all,
- 2:39:01you do a lot of basic blocking and tackling, or if you're a
- 2:39:05sports leg and you want to know whether the owners you do. That's pretty
- 2:39:09vanilla, right, very important. Where we're really good, I think,
- 2:39:13is looking at an adversary company so that you can protect yourself and be able
- 2:39:22to ascertain how are they operating in a foreign setting, and are they behaving
- 2:39:26by the rules? Are they undermining you? Are the what's going on with
- 2:39:31the government. So it's that high end. It's really it's very similar to
- 2:39:35our intelligence other than as I said, it's for financial protection financial insurance,
- 2:39:43where in the federal government is national security protection. Right, But the same
- 2:39:48techniques and skill sets are needed. Right. You mentioned that you also read
- 2:39:54a newsletter, So where can people go and sign up? Well, the
- 2:39:58newsletter, you'll we'll have the right to us say, can you know we
- 2:40:03have a website. Go to the website and reach out to us, and
- 2:40:05if you want to be on the newsletter, let us know. But I
- 2:40:09I don't. It's very expensive, basically free, but it's a very I
- 2:40:13think it's a very good one. We have, you know, about a
- 2:40:18thousand regular readers, but there are people that are interested. And what I
- 2:40:22tried to do, I really try to keep it nonpartisan. This is I'm
- 2:40:28telling you the way I think I could be wrong for sure, but you're
- 2:40:31going to get for me. In fact, the podcast is called straight from
- 2:40:35the shoulder, and I didn't realize not everybody ever heard that expression. But
- 2:40:39it's like a boxer, you get your maximum so called the way you see
- 2:40:46it. And that's where I think the newsletter has picked up discerning readers.
- 2:40:50And if one of your folks are interested, we'd like to make them a
- 2:40:52discerning reader. We will put a link down the description for people that are
- 2:40:56interested. I'd be super yeah. And I also want to let people know
- 2:41:01that we also have a Patreon if people want to go and support this webcast
- 2:41:05or this live stream. Five dollars a month gets you access to these episodes
- 2:41:09ad free. We really appreciate and pictures of Jack's feet. I don't know
- 2:41:16we were. Oh wait, I'm saying this, Jack, I'm not volunteering
- 2:41:18you for anything unless you unless you want to throw yourself in there. You
- 2:41:22know I meant this, Jack would I would never Uh no, let me
- 2:41:24let me tell you where the hearing was off. I told you said,
- 2:41:28it's Jack's where what you're talking? Oh we're really talking? So no listen,
- 2:41:35I mean, I look, I'm glad to be here. It's our
- 2:41:39pleasure. And I'm sorry that, you know, we covered half of the
- 2:41:43book. We never like a little bit less than half the book. But
- 2:41:46I kind of knew this going in, because you know, your story isn't
- 2:41:52just your story, but it's a story about like so many pivotal moments in
- 2:41:56the CIA, and I think that it's such for a lot of people,
- 2:42:00such a mysterious organization, and you're able to shed so much light on on
- 2:42:07what it what it really is. The purpose of the books really isn't about
- 2:42:11know me what I really it's. It's it's meant to be an educational book.
- 2:42:16I'm happy that the agency hasn't on it's reading this new people come in.
- 2:42:20I'm hoping that I explain things and how does it really really work?
- 2:42:26What are the pitfalls and what are the considerations. So I really worked hard
- 2:42:30and I'm glad you find the way. But that's you know, I've read
- 2:42:35some critics of it. Oh it's it's not like James Bond's book. No,
- 2:42:39it isn't James Bond. It's better. Yeah, So, but thank
- 2:42:45you for the time. And it was a very good. One more came
- 2:42:48in one more question. Oh, okay, last question, and then and
- 2:42:50then we have to jack go because again they what are your thoughts on the
- 2:42:56famous Ben's MOVs speed about Russian strategy of subversion via academia and other sources.
- 2:43:07I think Putin's ambitions are robust. I think Stalin's were not in the same
- 2:43:13leg because Stalin did not have the capabilities. But guess what in academia resides
- 2:43:20highly sensitive information science technology. And again I believe the Chinese are very good,
- 2:43:31but they started out in bulk. But I think the Russians effort is
- 2:43:35they're going after. They know where they're going after, and it's getting to
- 2:43:39now. Again, I don't think it's an attempt. In the case of
- 2:43:43academia. I think it's to get the information, to get the data that
- 2:43:48resides there, and the Chinese it's to get all data. But in THEIRS,
- 2:43:52it's like, let me find that weapon system and lo and Beholder's research
- 2:43:58done that place and so on. I don't think it's to try and change
- 2:44:03the influence of the educational system. It's too big. We're doing that to
- 2:44:07ourselves, so we don't need any help in messing up our educational system.
- 2:44:13I think his propaganda is really through social media. I don't think he singles
- 2:44:18out universities, but I think if you're a university professor and you're on in
- 2:44:28any of the sciences and you've got to worry about your computer system, you
- 2:44:33really have you know, passed all that. I mean, I think it's
- 2:44:37not just that. It's not just the Russians. I mean the Chinese,
- 2:44:39the Iranians, the North Korean friendly nations are doing it right. And I
- 2:44:46would hope we're as ambitious with our adversaryes right, and I think we're pretty
- 2:44:52good at it the least. Before we go, I need to ask missus
- 2:44:56divine any rebuttals or corrections before Yeah, all right, wait a minute,
- 2:45:03let me stop. When Pat says I did a pretty good job, that
- 2:45:07means outstanding. So can I finish with one pod? Story? Understand?
- 2:45:13Absolutely understand? So there's two, I'll give two. Well, okay,
- 2:45:20one story. So I'm on a stage in Paris and I'm on with Palestinians.
- 2:45:26Well, this is before I verse in the French, right, and
- 2:45:30I'm carrying the flag. No one invited me to carry the flag, but
- 2:45:33it's instinctive, right, So I actually thought i'd get a good job holding
- 2:45:37the for it, right. So I come down and there's Pat at the
- 2:45:41bottom of the steps, so I know better. I know better, And
- 2:45:43I said, how did I do? And she said, well, you
- 2:45:46mean your big fat Irish legs sticking out about your sacks. It's like boom
- 2:45:52like the air. Take it out and it's actually a good reminder, like
- 2:45:58a big guy, you know, get your feedback on the ground, you
- 2:46:01know, don't beam like it. But then she'll she'll give me a nunch.
- 2:46:05But there's another. Well, there's so many great Pat stories in the
- 2:46:09book. Yes, our marriage survived. Taking Italian class, Yes, in
- 2:46:15a high speed car if I remember going down ninety five and we had spent
- 2:46:20the day, but there were only three of us in the class. My
- 2:46:24deputy, he stayed out of the way, right, He tried to make
- 2:46:28us look good. So we're going down the road and I had the tamorraty
- 2:46:31to say, well, I think you have to use the subjunctive. The
- 2:46:35car window went down in the Italian bookout so Monday morning we had were totally
- 2:46:41unprepared for it. So I don't tangle. I don't tangle with that.
- 2:46:50Oh excuse me, you didn't hear pat she gave me a half a second
- 2:46:54to apologize for jeeki her subjunctive and how dare you not jump on that half
- 2:47:00a second? So but you know you'll, I mean you'll read about Pata
- 2:47:05here in the book. I mean yea, and I mean Jack Well,
- 2:47:11I'd love if you don't use those brass knuckles one. I'd love to schedule
- 2:47:13you again to come in and do a second interview next. Uh coming up
- 2:47:20this Monday, we're gonna have Alejandro Villanuava in studio, right d villain Okay,
- 2:47:28he was an Army ranger and then he was an NFL player, so
- 2:47:33he decided to have he also uh he also uh champion Alan Cash getting the
- 2:47:45So that's well. Tune in, yeah, tun in. Well, let's
- 2:47:48hope your audience enjoyed it as much as I did. I'm sure they did.
- 2:47:52Again, So we have a new podcast I called eyes On, hosted
- 2:47:56by Andy Millburn and Jason Lyons. Check that out on the same feet as
- 2:48:01the team house, both audio and video, so it should be very easy
- 2:48:03to get to you. Yeah, and you'll love it because it's topical like
- 2:48:09a fungal cream. But also, don't forget I have Straight from the Shoulder.
- 2:48:13That's right, just starting and I'm now going to try and model it
- 2:48:18on where where are you put? Where is where can people find Straight from
- 2:48:20the Shoulder. Well, it's in Spotify YouTube. Okay, it's out there
- 2:48:24in that world. If you get the newsletter, it's audio. It's about
- 2:48:31fifteen to twenty minutes. It's a glimpse of Oh that's it's a glimpse of
- 2:48:35an issue. And I'm interviewed by you know, a woman who's a very
- 2:48:41talented international specialist in my office, and you know, we talk about some
- 2:48:46of the current issues. Yeah, and brief snippets. But and that's great,
- 2:48:50Like fifteen to twenty minutes is a very like it's very digestible, unlike
- 2:48:56our show. No, but I think it starts different purposes as in earlier
- 2:49:00if I go on Bloomberg News, God bless them. I'm delighted to be
- 2:49:03on, particularly for the line of the work. But five minutes, seven
- 2:49:07minutes is a lot of time. And the problem is, like tonight,
- 2:49:11we've actually talked through like if we were in someone's living room and having you
- 2:49:16know, an adult discussion about issues, and people can take it for what
- 2:49:18it's worth. But we can tease it out. Yeah, I think that's
- 2:49:22that's not an easily not a readily available commodity in my view. So I
- 2:49:28came from all the way Manhattan, and we honestly we want you back.
- 2:49:33We want to like finish the rest of this because teasing this out and having
- 2:49:39these deep conversations awesome. I don't know about it. If we're deep,
- 2:49:43Jack's probably deep, but I but but having these conversations and allowing you to
- 2:49:48like talk about these is really it's why it's a formative. Yeah. So
- 2:49:52I and again there's a world of misunderstanding because it's classified. The world I
- 2:49:58was able to touch so much to became public that I can put the public
- 2:50:01stuff in perspective. So the deep spy cases are going to have to But
- 2:50:07we didn't touch on the counter intelligence spies, which you'll do well. Want
- 2:50:11to get time. What makes people betray their country? Yeah, yeah,
- 2:50:16I think, uh yeah, for your upcoming episode whenever we schedule it.
- 2:50:20Like you knew, you knew aims. I went to his wedding. No,
- 2:50:26No, I've got what I believe one of the problems. I knew
- 2:50:33a real spy, a real mole inside his CIA that's the worst thing they
- 2:50:37can happen to you as a professional, as a human being, it may
- 2:50:41not be so bad because in my life, as I start to think about
- 2:50:46the business, I actually know I actually ran up against somebody. It's not
- 2:50:52me just writing about something in the abstract and what made him tick. So
- 2:50:56there's this. I mean, you have to really look for silver lining.
- 2:51:01But treachery is a real blow one of the problems here. They never thought
- 2:51:05somebody like that would do it conventional wisdom and we could talk a lot about
- 2:51:11it because it's core the business. What makes people betray their country? And
- 2:51:18I think it will surprise you some. Maybe it's in the book, but
- 2:51:22for those who haven't read it, and maybe I've developed it more since then,
- 2:51:28what makes people like that take So they're going to be in suspense until
- 2:51:31we come all right, Well, we'll definitely get into it next time.
- 2:51:35Again, appreciate both of you coming out here. Thank you Pat, thank
- 2:51:39you Jack and everyone out there will see you on Monday, so thank you. Thanks already