Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Shrink Next Door: Ethical Violations (2019 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:00Psychology in z Hey deserving listeners. Today it's just me and I'm gonna be
- 0:10talking about an unethical psychiatrist that they did a podcast about called The Shrink next
- 0:18Door. It's a podcast by Wondering. It's narrated and written by Joan O'sarah
- 0:23and it was the number one podcast for three straight weeks on Apple podcast charts.
- 0:29So it's all about it's I don't know, it's it's not actually that
- 0:31long. It's probably three or four hours long. It's eight episodes or something.
- 0:35It's about doctor Isaac Hirshkoff or Ike Hirshkoff. He's a psychiatrist in New
- 0:43York, I believe somewhere out there, you know, I'm in Seattle.
- 0:46Everything's just out there doctor Isaac Hirshkoff, psychiatrist currently practicing and has been for
- 0:54the past thirty or forty years or something. And the podcast is all about
- 0:58how he controlled as patients. And now it's all allegations. So I'm going
- 1:03to be repeatedly, repeatedly using the word allegedly because he hasn't been found.
- 1:08Uh you know, he hasn't had his hearing yet, which is actually in
- 1:12a next week ish and so we might have more information about that. But
- 1:19so, yeah, he allegedly committed several ethical violations and people are asking me
- 1:23to talk about it because I often love to talk about other therapists that can't
- 1:27seem to follow simple ethical codes, and so I'm gladly talking about the Shrink.
- 1:34The Shrink Nextdoor podcast narrated by Jonah Sarah about doctor Isaac Kurskoff. I
- 1:38binge this podcast as soon as as soon as all the episodes came out,
- 1:44I was I thought, woa this this wonder he makes some really great podcasts
- 1:48and I was like, man, this this podcast is right at my alley,
- 1:51and yeah, it's very entertaining. I highly recommend it. So you
- 1:55really have to listen to the podcast to get the full feeling of the story.
- 1:57I'm not going to really I'm not going to be able to encapsulate the
- 2:02way that this guy just comes across like a sleeves bag. You know.
- 2:07I'm gonna be talking about the ethical violations, and I'm going to actually go
- 2:09through the American Psychiatric Association ethical codes and analyzing how or whether or not doctor
- 2:19Hirshkoff actually violated the ethical codes. I'm gonna be doing that later, but
- 2:23you know, and the podcast, because I actually think in the podcast they
- 2:27didn't really do a good job of that, which makes sense to me because
- 2:30they're trying to conserve time and they're not clinicians, they're journalists. But I
- 2:35thought I would provide that that look at it. But just to briefly kind
- 2:38of go over the story here for those who haven't read or those who don't
- 2:42remember, the doctor, the psychiatrist just comes across like a complete sleeves bag.
- 2:47It's very similar to Donald Sterling, if you know, the Clippers owner
- 2:51in La. If you want more information on the Donald Sterling fair and scandal,
- 2:59listen to the re sent thirty for thirty podcasts for more information on that.
- 3:02I binged that as well. Then I think it's like five episodes again,
- 3:07maybe three or four hours. Donald Sterling, La Clippers owner, total
- 3:12sleeves bag. If you don't remember him, he was the guy who they
- 3:15his mistress recorded him talking about how he was really angry at her because she
- 3:23took pictures like selfies with her and Magic Johnson and other African American basketball players,
- 3:29and he was like, you know, sure you can, you can
- 3:31socialize with them, but don't take pictures with them, you know, because
- 3:35essentially Donald Sterling, this owner of a basketball team, treated his African American
- 3:40basketball players like they were slaves. I mean, it was it was gross.
- 3:45You just have to listen to the whole thing. But anyway, the
- 3:47doctor Herskoff is in that vein, not in a racist vein per se,
- 3:53but in that vein of just and they both loved to be the center of
- 3:58attention. And although that's not a very strange thing to want in the population,
- 4:04you know, one or two to three percent of people are really weird
- 4:09about that. But they both use their power, whether it was Donald Sterling
- 4:14and his money or doctor Hirshkoff and his power as a psychiatrist. They both
- 4:19they both used their power to get people to to fake like they liked them,
- 4:24so he could get people to believe that he was somebody, that he
- 4:29was a very important person. And it's when you listen to both these podcasts,
- 4:33you just get this real clear picture of that sort of narcissism. And
- 4:38they both exploited other people, and they both got away with it for so
- 4:42long. It's just crazy to hear these stories you know about you know,
- 4:47Bill Cosbian and Harvey Weinstein and these people and just decades of abuse and horrible
- 4:55behavior and all the victims. So anyway, doctor hirshkof many years thirty plus
- 5:01years or something of this kind of behavior. And also they both Donald Sterling
- 5:06and doctor Hrskoff both seemed to be massively immature and very socially awkward, which
- 5:12is this other element to it of they probably never really felt quite right around
- 5:18other people, but desperately wanted to be seen as a cool person and again
- 5:24use their power to get that. And doctor Hrskoff also seemed to have no
- 5:30emotional control because he was he must have known he was putting himself at risk
- 5:34all those years. Doctor Hirskoff seemingly had no regard for the rules or the
- 5:39standard of practice. He was way outside the norm in my opinion, if
- 5:44the allegations are correct, he completely broke you know, many critical and obvious
- 5:49ethical codes. For decades, he managed to pilfer millions of dollars and houses
- 5:55and other stuff allegedly from his patients. Meanwhile, the rest of us clinicians
- 6:00are obsessing about whether or not to accept a five dollars Starbucks card from our
- 6:04clients. And this guy's pilfering millions of dollars and getting his own kids to
- 6:10be on wills. I'll get into it. It just makes me sick.
- 6:12You know, this is a total douche bag, and it makes us all
- 6:15look bad, makes us all look bad. If these allegations are accurate,
- 6:18his license needs to be taken away immediately. And also there's a scandal involving
- 6:25the New York Department of Health, which I'll get into in a little bit.
- 6:29Basically, they didn't do anything until this podcast came out spoiler alert on
- 6:34this own podcast, And so you know, I wish there was a jail,
- 6:39not only for the Ethics Board for not doing anything about it for so
- 6:43long, but also for doctor Hirskoff. I wish there was like a special
- 6:46therapist jail where we could lock people like this up, because just taking away
- 6:50their license doesn't seem like it's enough, because he got away with it for
- 6:54so long, utilizing his license and harming people along the way. So the
- 7:00story begins with Marty Markowitz, who was a patient of doctor Hirshkoff, and
- 7:05he's the lead figure in the podcast, but there are other patients who have
- 7:10stepped forward and also provided accounts of how this psychiatrist abused his power with them.
- 7:16So, but my main look here in the podcast, The Shrink next
- 7:23Door podcast is mainly about Markowitz. Marty Marty. So, Marty was in
- 7:27therapy with the psychiatrist for almost thirty years. He from the beginning he needed
- 7:31someone to help him to be more assertive. And they are clear to point
- 7:36out in the podcast that doctor Hirshkoff really actually helped him to do that,
- 7:41that the psychiatrist is actually pretty good at his job. A lot of the
- 7:46patients who came forward and said that he was unethical were also you know,
- 7:53wanting to say, look, he helped me, he was pretty good at
- 7:56his job. But then he allegedly that the psychiatrist started to slowly manipulate people
- 8:05over many years to get Marty and other patients to give the psychiatrist to give
- 8:13himself things. You know, I just can't imagine this kind of behavior.
- 8:16I just can't imagine thinking about my own clients as people whom I am going
- 8:22to exploit for my own needs, that I'm going to somehow get them to
- 8:26give me their house or put me on their will, or give me their
- 8:31money, or give me their business. It's just absurd. Oh, by
- 8:33the way, I should introduce the podcast. This is the Psychology Stytt a
- 8:37podcast. I'm your host, doctor Kirkanda. I'm a therapist and a professor
- 8:41and hopefully ethical at that. So the allegations are that are the following.
- 8:48So one of the main allegations is that Marty the patient originally so he was
- 8:54a business owner. He had he was, you know, millions of dollars
- 8:58sort of coming in and out of his business. And he was a pretty
- 9:01rich guy. And he had a sensible home in the Hamptons. Now again,
- 9:07I'm from Seattle. I don't I don't understand what the Hamptons are.
- 9:09I get this impression that the Hamptons or this fancy place. But anyway,
- 9:15it's a neighborhood near New York or in New York something. Anyway, But
- 9:18Marty originally just owned this this sensible home, regular home in the Hamptons.
- 9:22And but the doctor Hirshkoff, his own his psychiatrist. Okay, remember that
- 9:28Marty's psychiatrist, doctor Hirshkoff, used his influence to get Marty allegedly to buy
- 9:37the fancy property next door to his sensible home in the Hamptons. This this
- 9:43very fancy home next door had a large pool with a slide, a full
- 9:48sized basketball court, a tennis court, a hot tub, modern sculpture,
- 9:52and multiple Koi puns. So it's so and it's a it's like a party
- 9:58house, you know, if you got to see picture of it online.
- 10:00But it's like a house that you would have lots of pool parties at.
- 10:05And or I don't know, a rap video or something. And the psychiatrist
- 10:11is using his influence over his patient to get his patient to buy a house
- 10:20that he doesn't need. You know, Marty Markowitz was this you know,
- 10:24quiet shy, you know, unassuming guy. What does he need with this,
- 10:31you know, multimillion dollar home. I don't know how much the house
- 10:33costs, but it's it's very expensive, right, And and so now the
- 10:39reason why the psychiatrist wanted him to buy this was because the psychiatrist wanted this
- 10:43house for himself. So just think about that one. The psychiatrist allegedly wanted
- 10:50this fancy house for himself. So he gets his rich He gets his rich
- 10:54client who originally came to him because he needed to be assertive. So just
- 10:58think about that. That the patient comes to him says, I have a
- 11:03problem with being assertive, with asserting my own needs, with drawing boundaries to
- 11:07other people. The psychiatrist helps him to draw boundaries with other people, but
- 11:11then proceeds to utilize the patient's own weakness against him to get the patient to
- 11:18buy a house he doesn't need because the psychiatrist wants the house for himself.
- 11:26So then slowly over time again, this is years months going by, just
- 11:30a psychopathic plan that the psychiatrist has allegedly to get into that house. So
- 11:39it wasn't just like you know, session one he said, oh, you're
- 11:43rich, buy this house. You know, it's very slow, methodical,
- 11:46premeditated. The psychiatrist gets into he buys the house. The psychiatrist. Now
- 11:54I should say from the top that the psychiatrist has give an official statement saying
- 11:58that he didn't do any of these things. And it's possible that there's another
- 12:03side story, but there's so many, so many arrows pointing in the direction.
- 12:07It's sort of like, yeah, I guess all of Bill Cosby's victims
- 12:09could be lying. I guess that's possible, but you know, not likely.
- 12:15So so anyway, the psychiatrist starts to use this fancy property for himself.
- 12:22Not only does he use the property, but he moves in to the
- 12:26house as his own Hampton's fancy house. He acts like the house is his.
- 12:33Marty, the owner of the house, lives basically as the property's gardener
- 12:39in an outbuilding. And basically the psychiatrist makes his patient act as if it's
- 12:46not his house. You know, it's like, okay, you bought the
- 12:50house, but now act like it's not your house, and make sure when
- 12:52you invite. And then he proceeded to have all these parties which I get
- 12:56into and say, but he completely redecorated the house. He eliminated all traces
- 13:01of Marty living there. He put all of his pictures all over the place.
- 13:07The psychiatrist loved. And this is another just super sleeves bag thing that
- 13:11he would do. He would sort of force himself on celebrities or anyone important
- 13:18and make sure that he got a picture with them. You know, this
- 13:20is before selfie, so you'd have to get someone to take a picture,
- 13:22and often it was actually Marty, his patient. He would, you know.
- 13:26So one time one of his fancy pool parties, Gwyneth Paltrow was there,
- 13:31Brookshields, O. J. Simpson, and and other sort of events
- 13:35that the Hirshkoff would the psychiatrist would go to and he would get Marty or
- 13:41other people to make sure that he had a picture with them, even though
- 13:45he might have just met them for two seconds. He was always like,
- 13:48I need a picture with you. And so he would get this picture and
- 13:50then he'd frame it and put it on his wall, and it made you
- 13:54know, it's like, look, I know Gwyneth Me and Gwyneth Paltrow are
- 13:56best buddies. And meanwhile he bumped into her at a fund raiser for three
- 14:00seconds. The psychiatrist allegedly made Marty do all sorts of jobs like gardening,
- 14:07organizing parties, book keeping. The psychiatrist would tell Marty to type up his
- 14:13manuscripts for twelve books that he wrote. So just imagine that one for a
- 14:18second. Let's imagine me as a therapist who was working with a client who
- 14:22has trouble with being assertive and boundaries, and I make him, you know,
- 14:30type up my manuscripts for twelve of my books without any kind of payment.
- 14:35But even if I did pay the patient, this is a clear violation
- 14:39of ethical codes. Now for some of you out there who are not clinishes
- 14:43might be like, well, what's the big deal. You know, if
- 14:46Marty the patient didn't want to do it, he could have just said I
- 14:50don't want to do it, So why did he do it in the first
- 14:52place. Well, here's the thing. When you're in the therapists we know
- 14:58this, and psychiatrist no different. When we have a patient, especially in
- 15:03talk therapy, as Marty was with doctor Hirschkoff, that is a very special
- 15:09relationship and there are very specific ethical guidelines, for example, when it comes
- 15:15to dual relationships, meaning that you you want to be extremely cautious about creating
- 15:20other kinds of relationships with your patients because it could interfere with the treatment,
- 15:24it could harm the client. For example, let's just go with this,
- 15:28this situation when the psychiatrist asked his patient to type up his book. The
- 15:37patient is sort of dependent on a psychiatrist in some ways, you know,
- 15:41the patient needs the psychia. The patient might be like, there's really no
- 15:46one else around that can help me the way this guy can, and I
- 15:48don't want to start over with someone else, so I'm sort of locked in
- 15:52with this person. I don't I don't want to lose this person. And
- 15:56I really respect this person. I like this psychiatrist. I want his help,
- 16:00I need his help, and I can't really say no to him,
- 16:06because if I say no to him, maybe he'll be upset at me and
- 16:08he'll fire me as his patient, and then I'll be flapping in the wind.
- 16:12Maybe I'll never find another psychiatrist as good as this one. I don't
- 16:15know. So when you put someone in a position where they it's hard for
- 16:22them to say no, you have potentially you're exploiting your client. Essentially.
- 16:26The other thing is is, let's say the patient learns things about you that
- 16:32are very intimate, you know, like they learn sort of background information,
- 16:37like my psychiatrist is a sleeves bag who likes to take pictures with Gwyneth Paltrow
- 16:41and act like he knows her when he doesn't. So knowing that about your
- 16:45psychiatrist is going to harm your idea of your psychiatrist, and thus it'll harm
- 16:51the treatment because you lose respect for your psychiatrists and all that kind of stuff.
- 16:56And so I could talk for a long time about that, but I
- 17:00hope you get the picture that when us clinicians are working with clients, we
- 17:06have to be very cautious about creating these other relationships like moving into their house,
- 17:12that kind of thing, because again, it could harm treatment, which
- 17:15is the do no harm mandate on all medical and psychological professionals. So the
- 17:26doctor Hirshkoff did this a lot with Marty, created a lot of other relationships.
- 17:30Now, sometimes we can create other relationships, and as long as we're
- 17:36very cautious and we're not doing it for our own gain, and we inform
- 17:41the client about it and give them the choice, and we consult with other
- 17:45people and we get supervision, and you know, it's not like we can't
- 17:48have other kinds of relationships, but we definitely want to avoid relationships that are
- 17:53avoidable. Like there were other people who could have typed up his manuscript right
- 17:59Pably, there are professionals that he could have hired or I don't know who,
- 18:03just could have asked anyone else. Why did he have to ask Marty?
- 18:04Why Because the psychiatrist allegedly knew that Marty Markowitz would not say no and
- 18:11that Marty would do whatever he said. And you know, the psychiatrists like
- 18:17I need someone to type up this, you know, I need someone to
- 18:19give me a fancy house in the Hamptons. You know, it might as
- 18:23well be this patient because I know that he has a hard time with boundaries
- 18:26and a hard time with being assertive, and I know that he really depends
- 18:30on me as a psychiatrist. That's just really sick to think about, right,
- 18:33So so yeah, so doctor Hirskoff did this for many, many years.
- 18:41Now, let's get into his parties. This is a pretty big part
- 18:44of the podcast. Doctor Hirskoff, the psychiatrist was famous for these elaborate parties
- 18:52he had at his fancy Hampton's house. He would have like one hundred to
- 18:56two hundred people bust in, you know, important people, famous people.
- 19:02It was a very you know, it was a big deal kind of a
- 19:03party for important people, I guess. And he made Marty, his patient,
- 19:10the owner of the house, deal with all the fancy invitations, acting
- 19:15as though acting as though this wasn't in his house. And this was going
- 19:18on for years and years. Everyone assumed that Marty was the hired help,
- 19:22not the owner of the house, and definitely not a patient of doctor Hirshkoff's.
- 19:27And at these parties, the psychiatrist invited his own patients. He didn't
- 19:33he wasn't just exploiting Marty for this purpose of this house and the invitations and
- 19:41blah blah blah. But he also invited many of his patients to these parties,
- 19:45which is a massive dual relationship issue that could have easily been avoided by
- 19:52let's just say it. Don't invite your own patients to parties. Now,
- 19:56this isn't a massive violation. You're not gonna go to my therapist prison for
- 20:03this sort of thing. I would definitely advise against it, and I would
- 20:07and if I knew anyone who did this sort of thing, I would definitely
- 20:10think they were a hack therapist. But it's it's, you know, in
- 20:14the grand scheme of all the other things that he was doing. It's just
- 20:18another example at these parties some of his patients, because there were a lot
- 20:22of women that people attractive women patients that he would invite and they would come
- 20:29to the pool party and they would wear a bikini, and there's pictures of
- 20:30doctor Hirshkoff touching his patients while they're in bathing suits in the pool. Allegedly,
- 20:38he introduced his patience to his friends. He introduced patience to each other.
- 20:44This is a big no no there. I will be just a give
- 20:48high idea if you're not a clinician, about how rigid these rules are.
- 20:52Again, to protect the patient. To protect the client, I will have
- 20:57say, two co workers coming to me and they both know that the other
- 21:03coworkers you know, coming to me as the therapist, and they'll say,
- 21:07oh, you know, I ran into Jane and she said she had a
- 21:12session with you yesterday that went really well, and you know, so that's
- 21:17really great. I in that in situation that, because I cannot break people's
- 21:22confidentiality, I will say to my client, I'm sorry, I can't acknowledge
- 21:29the person. You can't. I can't respond to what you just said because
- 21:32I have to protect people's confidentiality. So I can't even acknowledge that I'm seeing
- 21:40people, even when someone knows that I'm seeing them. So let's give another
- 21:45situation. Let's say I'm seeing a sixteen year old girl and the parents call
- 21:51me up and they say, so, I want to talk talk with you
- 21:55about Jennifer's therapy. I have to say I can't without a written concer,
- 22:00I can't acknowledge that I even know who you're talking about it's very rigid,
- 22:03very important for the client's treatment. If clients are going to trust me with
- 22:08telling me whatever they're going to tell me, they have to know that I'm
- 22:12not going to just throw away their confidentiality. So that's how rigid it is.
- 22:21But this psychiatrist was inviting his patients to his own party, introducing them
- 22:26to his friends, to other patients, revealing them as patients allegedly. You
- 22:33know, this is way outside the standard of care. There's many accounts of
- 22:40him being a massive sleeves bag, name dropping famous people all the time,
- 22:47obsessive about getting pictures with famous people and framing them. As I was talking
- 22:51about, there's these accounts of them showing up to parties really late on purpose
- 22:56so he can make a big splash. I mean, again, it's hard
- 22:59to know the accuracy of these stories. But again, when you look at
- 23:03all the stories in this podcast together, it points towards a particular sort of
- 23:07personality. Marty said that the psychiatrist isolated him from his family. So this
- 23:15is when we start to get into like whoa premeditation basically grooming. If you
- 23:22understand what grooming is, when a sexual predator wants to abuse a child or
- 23:30someone else. They will groom, they will target someone, they isolate them,
- 23:36they figure out the way to get access. And the psychiatrist seemingly followed
- 23:42this grooming process with Marty and other people. There's actually two main patients that
- 23:48they talk about that they talk with on the podcast, both of whom the
- 23:52psychiatrist purposefully isolated the patients from their family because they knew. Because the psychiatrist
- 24:00knew probably that if he didn't isolate the patients, the patients families would say
- 24:07like, wait, you're putting your psychiatrists in your will. Wait, you're
- 24:11giving your psychiatrists millions of dollars Like that doesn't make any sense, and the
- 24:18psychiatrists do that. So the psychiatrist did things to and basically used therapy like
- 24:25you know, you need to assert yourself with your sister, you need to
- 24:29assert yourself with your parents. Your mom is an evil person, you have
- 24:33to cut her off. That kind of thing, and it could feel like
- 24:37therapy, even though I've never been that way with my clients. I've had
- 24:41clients who have had abusive parents, and I've never said cut yourself off from
- 24:47your parents. Now, if someone wants to cut themselves off from their parents,
- 24:51and I am one hundred percent support of that, But I would never
- 24:53know the right answer to that question. Families are complicated, relationships are complicated.
- 24:59Recovery from a abuse and history and grief as complicated. So I would
- 25:03never I would never suggest one way or the other and that because I don't
- 25:08know the answer those questions. I don't know those answers in my own life,
- 25:12So how am I supposed to know about it in other people's lives anyway.
- 25:15So Marty said that the psychiatrist isolated him from this family. These are
- 25:22some quotes from him in the podcast. He got my sister and her children
- 25:26and all of my blood relatives and close friends out of my life. He
- 25:33got my sister and her children and all of my blood relatives and close friends
- 25:38out of my life. Wow. Another quote, If my sister contacted me,
- 25:47he instructed me to bring all those things into him. We would listen
- 25:51to it together and he would interpret it. So he's not only getting all
- 25:56these people out of life, but he would say, Okay, if if
- 26:00your sister calls you and leaves a message, bring that into me and I'll
- 26:03interpret it, presumably seemingly to manipulate Marty to see it as a negative thing
- 26:11and to cut him off from his support system. He wanted to control Marty.
- 26:18This is like all all good cult leaders do this. All effective cult
- 26:26leaders know that along the way, a crucial step is you have to separate
- 26:33people from their families. You have to separate them from the voice of reason,
- 26:38otherwise you risk losing control of these people who are susceptible to being controlled.
- 26:45You know, it's like you might even know people like this, or
- 26:48you might even be someone like this. You're around a very charismatic person and
- 26:52you're just like, WHOA, I really believe this person. And then you
- 26:56leave that person, you go to an opposite respective and that person's talking and
- 27:03you're like, WHOA, I believe this person. Now, you know,
- 27:04there's just some people, based on their defense mechanisms developed in response to difficulties
- 27:11growing up that make them extremely susceptible to other people's influence. And Marty,
- 27:17admittedly even he had talked about this in the podcast, was one of those
- 27:22people. And the doctor knew that obviously because he's a expert in, you
- 27:29know, treating people and personality, and proceeded to help these patients to assert
- 27:37themselves, but then took it another you know, it was for the first
- 27:41bit, it was probably helping Marty to draw boundaries and assert his needs and
- 27:47whatnot. But then that's when he gets his hooks in and he's like,
- 27:49Okay, now we're going to take this to the next level. Now you're
- 27:52going to cut these people off. Now you're gonna do Now, you're gonna
- 27:55do all these other things that I want you to do. And he,
- 27:59you know, hid all of this stuff as if it was helpful to the
- 28:03patients when it was just exploiting them. Marty said that his psychiatrists used therapy
- 28:11to manipulate him to hand over control of his business and his money. Here's
- 28:15some quotes from Bartie. A constant mantra from him was he'd say, you
- 28:22can't handle the truth. You're passive aggressive, and you can't handle confrontation.
- 28:26You're going to screw up the business and lose customers. So this is the
- 28:32psychiatrists telling his patient, your passive aggressive, you can't handle confrontation, you're
- 28:40going to screw up business. Why do you give me your business and I
- 28:45will take care of it for you. That's just incredible. Another quote here
- 28:51there was nobody, certainly in my family that could slap me across the face
- 28:55and say what are you doing? Are you out of your mind? So
- 28:59there's Marty saying there was nobody because he had cut me off from my family.
- 29:03There was no one around that could slap me across the face and say,
- 29:07do not hand over your business or the because this was a family business
- 29:11that had been passed down through the generation. Do not give the family business
- 29:15to your psychiatrist. You know, what are you doing. But because the
- 29:18psychiatrist had come off from his family that he couldn't do that. He made
- 29:23Marty fire people from his business. He managed to get millions of dollars out
- 29:29of Marty allegedly. Now it wasn't directly to the psychiatrist, but the psychiatrist
- 29:34set up this or the psychiatrist had Marty set up this charity or some other
- 29:41kind of organization. It was basically a seemingly allegedly a front for the psychiatrist
- 29:48to get the money directly, and then Marty would give money to this organization.
- 29:53But the psychiatrist was the main controller of this organization and would actually withdraw
- 30:00money for himself. That kind of thing. He bullied Marty. So as
- 30:06the relationship starts to progress. So one my impression was that with Marty again
- 30:12this was almost thirty years of time. In the beginning, the psychiatrist is
- 30:17actually helping him to be assertive and helping his self esteem that kind of thing.
- 30:22Then it entered this other phase where the psychiatrist was now trying to infiltrate
- 30:30Marty's life and try to get Marty to hand over his business and his money
- 30:33and his house and making him subservient, and that was very effective, getting
- 30:40him, you know, separated from his family. Then there was this third
- 30:42phase where the psychiatrist seemed to be letting his guard down or something, or
- 30:52or maybe Marty was starting to wake up, because there starting to be conflict
- 30:56between Marty and the psychiatrist. Marty started saying like, I don't know if
- 31:00I want to do that, and the psychiatrist stopped paying as much attention to
- 31:04Marty, and over time they started to fight. And when that happened,
- 31:12the psychia and the psychiatrist was losing control of Marty. It seemed as though
- 31:18psychiatrists decided, well, I'm just going to bully Marty into doing what I
- 31:21want. And for a while Marty would do it now. Again, it's
- 31:26important to remember that his patients, many of them thought he was very helpful.
- 31:32You know, many would think that they would. If you're listening to
- 31:37this story or listening to the podcast, you might be like, well,
- 31:41I would never see a psychiatrist like this, you know, I would see
- 31:45it a mile away and I'd just be like, screw you. Well,
- 31:51one in the beginning that the psychiatrist was very helpful. Apparently he's very charismatic.
- 31:56He has a sharp mind for understanding personality and helping people navigate that,
- 32:01and he used that against them eventually, But in the beginning, he was
- 32:06very helpful. And uh, it's and I know a lot of you out
- 32:10there are actively looking or have given up looking for a therapist that you really
- 32:17click with. You know, you've tried looking for a therapist it didn't really
- 32:22work out, or you had a therapist that you clicked with and the therapist
- 32:27moved out of the area, retired, or you tried to replace that person
- 32:30that never really worked out. It's hard to find someone you really click click
- 32:34with. Well, these patients really really clicked with him, and so it's
- 32:40not as easy as just saying like well, I don't like what my psychiatrist
- 32:45is doing, and so I'm going to move to another psychiatrist. It's it's
- 32:49actually something that's a bit of a problem in our in our industry. It's
- 32:52sort of like a these like little mini monopolies exist in our in our field.
- 32:57Not in every community, but it's kind of like that where you know,
- 33:01if you're at a McDonald's and you see a fly in your French fries,
- 33:08you'll you'll stand up and go like, hey, something's wrong with why
- 33:13French fries? And if the management doesn't rectify the situation adequately, you'll just
- 33:20go to Burger King next door, or a different McDonald's across town owned by
- 33:22someone else. A lot of businesses are like that, you know, coffee
- 33:27shops, grocery stores, dry cleaners. Some businesses aren't like that, like
- 33:34Amazon is buying up a lot of things. But anyway, my point is
- 33:37is that some businesses, the consumer has a lot of control. You also
- 33:44know who to talk to. You can just stand up and yell, or
- 33:46you can tweet about it or something you know that you have a bad Yelp
- 33:51review, for example. There's things that you know as a consumer that you
- 33:54can do to get justice. I mean, you might not necessarily get just
- 34:00but you just have a general sense of what you can do when you're a
- 34:01patient or a client of a mental health professional. One there's so much stigma
- 34:07around getting treatment, getting help from a therapist that a lot of clients they
- 34:13don't want to even acknowledge to anyone, especially publicly on Twitter, that they're
- 34:16even in therapy, so they're not going to necessarily post it online. They
- 34:22don't necessarily know where to go to complain, even though it's in our disclosure
- 34:27statements. Your should be in every clinicians disclosure statement. It should say something
- 34:31like you can go to the Department of Health and complain about this person.
- 34:37A lot of people forget that it's even in there, and they're just like,
- 34:39well, who do I even talk to if I do have a problem
- 34:43with my therapist? And as we'll find out later, the Department of Health
- 34:47doesn't always respond. In fact, a lot of times they don't in my
- 34:52experience, so or at least they don't in the way that people want anyway.
- 34:57So as we start to get into this other phase of therapy or relationship
- 35:01between Marty Markowitz and doctor Hirskoff. Now we're up to about twenty ten,
- 35:07so about nine years ago, and Marty slowly realizes that the psychiatrist really wasn't
- 35:14on his side, and he started to get really hurt by how much the
- 35:17psychiatrist was bullying him. And Marty ends the relationship with his psychiatrist. He
- 35:23just ends it. Twenty ten years later, six years later, twenty sixteen,
- 35:30Marty finally realizes, Wait, I think that I think my psychiatrist really
- 35:36kind of screwed me up. I thought he was helping me, but looking
- 35:39back, I think he really messed me up. He violated my trust,
- 35:45he took away my money, he manipulated me. It was like being in
- 35:52an abusive relationship. So Marty, after all these years, comes forward and
- 35:59files a plaint with the New York Department of Health. And this is exactly
- 36:04what you're supposed to do. And Marty said that the psychiatrist had acted unethically,
- 36:08which I agree with, and that he had harmed him with his bad
- 36:12boundaries, which I agree with. And Marty alleged that the psychiatrist had taken
- 36:15control of almost every aspect of his life, where he lived, what he
- 36:22spent his money on. His entire business who we talked to. You know,
- 36:25this is an abusive relationship. Marty Markowitz had even written a will giving
- 36:31his multimillion dollar a state to a foundation he had started with the psychiatrist.
- 36:37That's what I was talking about earlier. So, and the psychiatrist would have
- 36:42controlled that money after Marty had died. If Marty died, then the psychiatrist
- 36:47was going to control that money himself. The psychiatrist became a joint owner of
- 36:53Marty's Swiss bank account and used his used Marty's house free of charge, and
- 37:02made Marty perform hundreds of hours of secretarial services. The document that he sent
- 37:08to the New York Department of Health also includes allegations of inappropriate physical touching of
- 37:16different patients of the psychiatrists, because you know, Marty saw his psychiatrists touching
- 37:23other patients at these parties. Right, Okay, so pretty you know,
- 37:29pretty convincing allegations made to the New York Department of Health. I mean,
- 37:38at the very least, the New York Department of Health should have looked into
- 37:42it, right, They should be like, well, you know, sometimes
- 37:44some patients they complain when there really isn't any grounds but wow, you know
- 37:50this, This one patient is saying that this psychiatrist took over every aspect of
- 37:54his life. That he made him write him into the will, that he
- 38:00took away his house, that he got into his bank account, and he
- 38:04used his house for free and made him do hundreds of hours of secretarial services.
- 38:08That sounds crazy that he's touching other patients, that this patient knew about
- 38:15other patients. I mean, there's so many things to say. This needs
- 38:20to be looked at. But guess what. The New York Department of Health
- 38:24did nothing for years. They did nothing. Again, let's review the allegations.
- 38:36A patient has said that a licensed psychiatrist in their state has done the
- 38:39following things. In the best of language, he influenced a patient to do
- 38:45a lot of odd things, and the worst of language, he abusively manipulated
- 38:52his patient to do a lot of odd things. But we'll say influenced.
- 38:55He influenced him to buy a house. He influenced him to let him move
- 39:00into the house for decades. He influenced the patient to act as if the
- 39:06house isn't the patient's house. He influenced the patient to act as if he
- 39:10was the gardener of the house. He influenced the patient to live in a
- 39:15different building other than his house. He influenced the patient to give him and
- 39:19his family a lot of money, including putting him in the patient's will.
- 39:22He influenced the patient to reject his family members and friends. He influenced the
- 39:28patient to hand over his multimillion dollar business. He invited his patients to his
- 39:34house parties, He touched his patients while they were in bikinis, and he
- 39:37introduced his current patients to his friends and to his other current patients. And
- 39:44the New York State Department of Health did nothing. And I've seen this before,
- 39:51my friends. I've never recalled you my friends before, but I'm doing
- 39:54that right now. I've seen this before, my friends. I have seen
- 39:59department mints of health, state departments of health do nothing. Now I don't
- 40:05know why they do nothing. I suspect they are overworked, one underpaid two.
- 40:16I also think that there's not a huge incentive for them to actually take
- 40:22things seriously because it would require more work for them. Right. You know,
- 40:27if they took every allegation seriously, they would have to work eighty hours
- 40:31a week, right, But they don't have time for that. I also
- 40:37think that sometimes Department of Health has like connections with people that they don't want
- 40:42to burn those bridges, you know, because they might actually have some kind
- 40:45of connections that with the elite, because you know, the psychiatrist is in
- 40:50this elite class and the patient is not, at least in certain circles.
- 40:54I'm guessing, so maybe that was a factor. Again, I don't know,
- 41:00but here's my impression of people who work for these departments. They wake
- 41:05up in the morning and they go to their government job, and you know,
- 41:10I don't know how much they love their job, honestly, because I've
- 41:15interacted with people in my state in this capacity, and of course they're not
- 41:19all like this, but many of them are where I'll I'll reach out to
- 41:22them with a question or some kind of concern and they won't even they won't
- 41:29even write me back, or I'll hound them for months, just just ask
- 41:35a simple question. I'm just be like, so, I just have this
- 41:37simple question about procedure, and maybe I'm barking up the wrong treat but they
- 41:40don't even reply with like, no, you need to be talking to so
- 41:43and so. This is our government, my tax dollars paying for these people.
- 41:47These are people that are, you know, issuing my license to practice
- 41:52in my state, and yet I can't get a response from them. And
- 41:58again, I'm not email the President of the United States. I'm emailing my
- 42:01local government's licensing body. You know, they have all the control, they
- 42:07just don't have to respond. And so, you know, it's it's sort
- 42:13of like when you go to the DMV and you get that real cranky person.
- 42:16It's it's like, what are you gonna do. There's no there's no
- 42:19DMV next door that you can go to and say, screw you, guys,
- 42:22I'm going next door. My cat wants to weigh in on this.
- 42:27You know, all of us can't go to another department of health. We
- 42:30have that one department of health, and that's you know, it just kind
- 42:35of breeds that sort of I don't know, incompetence or something. Now,
- 42:38again, there could be more to the story than I realize. Obviously,
- 42:45I'm just listening to a podcast and reading what's on the internet. But it
- 42:49sure smells bad. It sure smells like a situation where you had a rotten
- 42:55psychology or rotten psychiatrist and then a rotten to partment of health that did nothing
- 43:01to help the people that they're supposed to help to do exactly what the taxpayers
- 43:07pay them to do. They did nothing. So and for years, and
- 43:14Marty would call them and be like, so, I sent you, you
- 43:17know, the allegation. It sounded like Marty even got a lawyer to type
- 43:22up the thing to make an official and Marty would call, So, what's
- 43:25happening with you know, doctor Hirskoff is still practicing? What's going on here?
- 43:30And they, Oh, it's under investigation. Six months later callback,
- 43:34Oh, just wondering what's going Oh, it's under investigation. Six months later,
- 43:37Callback, Oh, you know it's been along. What have what are
- 43:42you investigating? You know, I'm the harmed party here. Shouldn't you be
- 43:45telling me what the hell is happening right now? Oh, we're still investigating.
- 43:51Now, who wants to take a bet that they weren't investigating? Crap?
- 43:55So then we get to twenty eighteen, two years later, and then
- 43:59I think this is about when the podcast started. At the podcast producers and
- 44:02Jon O Sarah, they start to investigate, and they reach out to Marty
- 44:07Markowitz. They reach out to doctor Hirshkoff and actually, you gotta listen to
- 44:14the podcast The Shrink next Door, the Marty or the doctor Hirshkoff interacts a
- 44:22lot with jon No Sarah because he because Jonah Sarah was a neighbor. Actually
- 44:25that's how we met him. Anyway, it's a long story, but so
- 44:30the Shriek the Wonder. He starts to work on this podcast, and then
- 44:34the podcast comes out this year twenty nineteen, I think in the summer,
- 44:38just a couple of months ago. Again, it becomes the number one podcast
- 44:44on Apple almost immediately for three weeks straight. That's a big deal. There's
- 44:47I don't know, hundreds of thousands of podcasts, a lot of good ones
- 44:51out there. The Shrink next Door becomes number one soon after. Guess what
- 44:57happens? Super popular podcast, All this discussion about this massively unethical psychiatrists laying
- 45:07out all the details, interviewing all these people, and at the end,
- 45:13at other podcasts they talk about how Marty made this complaint years ago and kept
- 45:17following up and nothing happened, and guess what happened? Guess what happened?
- 45:23Marty immediately starts receiving several phone calls from the New York Department of Health.
- 45:31I mean, what do you have no shame. This is a massive scandal.
- 45:38The Department of Health did nothing for years, seemingly. I have no
- 45:45doubt they did nothing until the podcast came out. Now again, maybe I
- 45:50don't have all the details. Maybe we'll learn more, Maybe the New York
- 45:52Department of Health will have an excuse like it fell under the desk and we
- 45:57couldn't find it, or we had ten thousand other cases that were even more
- 46:01important than Marti's. And then coincidentally, when we finally had more time,
- 46:07it was at the peak of popularity of a podcast that was making us look
- 46:12like shit. Maybe you will find that out, but boy does it smell
- 46:16rotten. So the podcast again, they interview other patients who come forward,
- 46:23they start making allegations to the New York Department of Health. Department of Health
- 46:29finally, just you know, weeks ago, finally posts a number of allegations.
- 46:36And by the way, the Department of just so you understand how the
- 46:38landscape works, the Department of Health, these these charges, they're not criminal,
- 46:43they're ethical. Their their standard of practice issues, and so mostly it's
- 46:49about his license to practice. So there's going to be there's a hearing set
- 46:52for September twenty four, twenty nineteen, which is just next week, doctor
- 46:57Hirshkoff will be able to contest the allegations. But I can't imagine this going
- 47:02very well for him, given all the investigations by the podcast and all the
- 47:08publicity. I can't imagine that the New York Department of Health wants even more
- 47:14bad press by letting the psychiatrist off the hook. But we'll see people have
- 47:21looked into it and they found that since the podcast came out, the psychiatrist
- 47:24is no longer listed on the New York University's Medical School's website. So he
- 47:30claims that he resigned voluntarily from the New York University Medical School. He has
- 47:37resigned from his board position on so get this. For many years he has
- 47:43been on the board on the Fellowship at Auschwitz for the Study of Professional Ethics.
- 47:49So forget that it's a weird name, but basically understand that this is
- 47:52an organization that specializes in general ethics, not just ethics and psychiatry, but
- 47:58general ethics. Think about the irony and that this guy's on the board of
- 48:04an organization that specializes and advocates for ethics. So just to make it clear,
- 48:12and they didn't make this clear on the podcast at all. The possible
- 48:15consequences to the common consequences that a Department of Health will dole out to clinicians
- 48:23who they deem to have been acting outside the standard of practice is to suspend
- 48:29their license, which is just you know, suspended for a year, revoke
- 48:35their license, take it away for good, to give them fines which aren't
- 48:40usually that much, to require training to acquire supervision, and to require not
- 48:46working with particular kinds of clients. So what I suspect will happen given all
- 48:54the publicity, is that the Department of Health Health will voke his license and
- 49:00they will impose some fines, but it won't be that much now, which
- 49:07I think will be some justice. But again we're talking thirty years of abuses
- 49:13by this guy to multiple patients. Again, I just wish there was a
- 49:20prison for therapists like this, But there's a possibility that he'll just get a
- 49:23slap on the rest. I've seen this before. I've seen therapists. I
- 49:29was a consultant on a case not too long ago in which the therapist essentially
- 49:36had sex with his client. Well, I shouldn't say that the therapist was
- 49:43in session having sexual contact, fondling, not genital, but caressing and blah
- 49:51blah blah, very romantic cuddling. Let's just call it romantic cuddling over multiple
- 49:57sessions and that and the patient came forward made a complaint and that therapist just
- 50:06had a suspended that. So what happened to that therapist. I thought the
- 50:08therapist was going to lose their license for sure. I mean the therapist had
- 50:13no documentation that justified it, had no training, had not consulted, admitted
- 50:17to all the allegations. And I was like, whoa, this is slam
- 50:22dunk. Just revoke his license. I mean, that's what the Department of
- 50:24ELD this for. Right, You're supposed to like police these kinds of things.
- 50:29And what happened in this case was they suspended his license for a little
- 50:32bit of time. And so he so saying and they said in order for
- 50:37if he could start practicing again. I think he might have had some fines,
- 50:40I'm not sure, but all he had to do he had to go
- 50:44to some training, I believe, and he had to be supervised for a
- 50:46time. Supervision could be very effective, meaning that you know a supervisor like
- 50:53make sure that you follow the ethical guidelines, they observe your work with your
- 50:59patients, that kind of thing. But you can also get a supervisor that's
- 51:01super relaxed and just be like, yeah, you know, let me know
- 51:05how things are going, and I'll take your word for it. And you
- 51:07know, usually it's that supervision is because it's hard to observe people working because
- 51:14you have to be in the office with them, which a lot of patients
- 51:15don't want you to be, right. So, so it's possible that the
- 51:22psychiatrist doctor Hirshkoff will get this minor slap on the wrist, like again,
- 51:27suspended license until he gets some training, maybe supervised practice for a couple of
- 51:31years. And you know, when I think about this in terms of actual
- 51:37justice, it's not a terrible outcome because in all likelihood doctor Hirshkoff's days of
- 51:45manipulating clients are over. You know, he'll probably avoid this sort of behavior
- 51:50in the future if he is allowed to practice. And you know, he
- 51:54was reportedly an effective helper, so if he just kept within the lane of
- 52:00the standard practice, he might actually do some good in the world. But
- 52:05it would it would be good to have a harsh punishment, in my opinion,
- 52:08to deter others from following in his footsteps. You know, this is
- 52:14rare. I just want to if you're not a clinician out there, this
- 52:16is rare. This doctor is a rare cookie. This almost never happens.
- 52:23Like I said, most of us clinicians will will you know, adamantly refuse
- 52:30a five dollar Starbucks card at Christmas time? You know, your patient gives
- 52:36you a card and there's a Starbucks card. Oh, I'm sorry, I
- 52:38can't accept this. Like you knows, most therapists are extremely rigid about these
- 52:45kinds of boundary violations or crossings. It would never invite their clients to a
- 52:51party, would never manipulate their clients to buy a house and then move into
- 52:55that house. You know, But it happens. These things do happen,
- 53:00you know. Like I said, I've been a consultant on cases like this
- 53:04before, and there's a lot of cases like this each year in the United
- 53:07States and around the world. And it would be good if a Department of
- 53:12Health came forward and said, look, if you're going to cross the line
- 53:15that far for that those many years, you're done. We have enough psychiatrist
- 53:20in the Northeast. We don't need you, and we need to send a
- 53:22strong message to all you other Yahoo's out there that are thinking about doing stuff
- 53:27like this that we will follow through if you make a podcast about it.
- 53:32Now, there are similar cases to this that I want to get into.
- 53:36Gloria Vanderbilt for example. For instance, she was a socialite, rich lady
- 53:40from the mid twentieth century. She actually just died recently a couple months ago,
- 53:45at the age of ninety five, lived a good, long life.
- 53:49Earlier in her life she had a psychiatrist and it was a very similar situation
- 53:53to Marty in that her psychiatrist exploited her because she was very rich, and
- 54:00long story short, she sued the psychiatrist and one one point five million dollars.
- 54:07So there's the Glory of Vanderbilt case, which is similar to the to
- 54:10the Marty Markowitz case with doctor Herskoff. But the story that this really reminded
- 54:16me of, which I'm sure it's reminding some of you of, is Brian
- 54:20Wilson of the Beach Boys. So Brian Wilson was the main songwriter of the
- 54:25Beach Boys, a genius and Paul McCartney's muse in some ways in the nineteen
- 54:34So this is a case in the nineteen eighties. But and if you really
- 54:37want to learn about this story, watch Love and Mercy with John Q.
- 54:43Sack and what's that kid's name from There Will be Blood Anyway, twenty fifteen
- 54:52movie Love and Mercy. I really liked the movie. Me and Bertoll liked
- 54:55it. So basically, Brian Wilson, he started to suffer from severe mental
- 55:00illness starting in the sixties, and his life really took a downturn. He
- 55:08was depressed, he was I think delusional. I think he had Schizzo effective
- 55:14disorder. And he was holed up in his in his house in the dark,
- 55:20and you know, really suffering, gained a ton of weight, wasn't
- 55:24doing any music anymore. And then in the eighties he hires this therapist named
- 55:30Eugene Landy. In the movie Love and Mercy, he's played by m Paul
- 55:38So anyway, the guy who played Samuel Adams anyway, or president asked Samuel
- 55:46Adams, not Samuel Adams anyway, God pull me out of this dive here,
- 55:52Okay. So Eugene Landy was Brian Wilson of the Beach Boys. His
- 55:58therapist in the eighties, and he manipulated Brian Wilson in a similar way to
- 56:01the way doctor Hirshkoff allegedly manipulated Barty. So Brian Wilson's father was abusive,
- 56:08so the Beach Boys guy, Brian Wilson, his father was very abusive.
- 56:14And Brian Wilson's defense mechanism to this involved being very influenceable, very susceptible to
- 56:22manipulation from other people. And you know, I suspect that Marty Markowitz had
- 56:27a very similar past to Brian Wilson, and this makes me so angry.
- 56:31You know that a therapist Eugene Landy and doctor Hirshkoff, they would both use
- 56:37their patient's issues against them. You know, both of these clinicians absolutely understood
- 56:44that their patients had issues with past abuse, with issues of assertiveness, and
- 56:52they just decided or unconscious, I don't know what the pathway is, but
- 56:59they youzed that issue, that weakness and their patient that they learned the patient
- 57:06came to them for help to manipulate them. Eugene Landy manipulated Brian Wilson to
- 57:09make Eugene Landy his business manager. Landy manipulated Brian Wilson to make Landy co
- 57:19songwriter. So apparently Eugene Landy, this therapist, fancied himself a songwriter in
- 57:28the eighties, and and he whenever Brian Wilson wrote a song, Eugene Landy
- 57:32made Wilson, you know, make him the co writer. So these songs
- 57:38will be written by Brian Wilson and Eugene Landy. So just imagine again,
- 57:43just step out of this madness for a second. Let's imagine I had a
- 57:47you know, a famous musician patient, and I manipulated my patient to because
- 57:57I'm a musician and I'm manipulate related this patient to make me a co songwriter
- 58:02to one of their songs so that I could make millions of dollars from royalties.
- 58:07Imagine that. Just imagine that for a second. I mean, my
- 58:13god. Eugene Landy co produced Wilson's debut solo album in nineteen eighty eight,
- 58:20again probably not because he's a good producer, but because he manipulated Brian Wilson.
- 58:27He also was a co producer on an unreleased follow up album called Sweet
- 58:34Insanity in nineteen ninety one. So I think about the irony of that that
- 58:37album named Sweet insanity by Brian Wilson. It wasn't released. He also ghost
- 58:45wrote portions of Brian Wilson's memoir from nineteen ninety one. Landy put him on
- 58:51a bunch of drugs that he probably didn't need. He essentially prescribed him drugs
- 58:57even though he can't prescribe drugs. So he's like me, Eugene Landy,
- 59:00He's like me. He's not a medical professional, but he manipulated the system
- 59:04to in essence, prescribe drugs to Brian Wilson. And he should have spent
- 59:10time in prison for doing that. In my opinion. He manipulated Brian Wilson
- 59:15into making him the primary beneficiary of his will. I understand this. You
- 59:21know, it's like one of the go to thing things of these cult like
- 59:23psychiatrists and therapists to make their patients, you know, change their wills.
- 59:30He lived in one of Brian's house's rent free, similar to doctor Hirskoff.
- 59:35He changed Brian Wilson. He changed Brian Wilson almost a million dollars per or
- 59:39charge. Sorry, I have my notes, I have a I have a
- 59:43type of He charged Brian Wilson almost a million dollars per year for his treatment.
- 59:50It's something like seven hundred, eight hundred thousand dollars a year. Uh
- 59:57what you know, how many how much per hour would that be? He
- 1:00:01controlled almost every aspect of Brian Wilson's life, when he would eat, what
- 1:00:07he could eat, who he could talk to, what he could say to
- 1:00:10those people. Brian Wilson was terrified of him. He basically, he basically
- 1:00:15became an abusive father to Brian Wilson. And Brian Wilson, given his issues
- 1:00:21and given that he's basically disabled, because he had to get so effective disorder,
- 1:00:24Brian Wilson just let him do it. And Eugene Landy managed to separate
- 1:00:29Brian Wilson from all of his support system and would make sure that he never
- 1:00:32had anyone that could help him. So in nineteen eighty nine, there was
- 1:00:38a you know, a complaint given to the Department of Health of California and
- 1:00:44as license was revoked. Landy got later got a license to practice in New
- 1:00:49Mexico and Hawaii, and he continued to practice until his death. So just
- 1:00:52think about that for a second. So Eugene Landy, one of the most
- 1:00:57famous manipulated a pulative abusive therapists does all these horrible things to one of the
- 1:01:07most famous people on the planet in the twentieth century, and the allegation has
- 1:01:13come out, lots of people come forward. The Department of Health says,
- 1:01:16yep, we believe you. You don't have a license to practice, Eugene
- 1:01:20Landy. You're done well, then Landy just goes to just goes across the
- 1:01:24state line, gets another licensed practices. To me, that seems like a
- 1:01:30broken system, does it? Doesn't it sound broken to you? It'd be
- 1:01:32like someone murders someone. You catch them, you have you have on videotape,
- 1:01:38you convict them, and then they go, oh my bad, and
- 1:01:42then they just cross the state line and then they murder someone else like you
- 1:01:45just you just let them go, like they can just do these horrible things
- 1:01:50to other people. Now, who knows. Maybe Eugene Landing did wonderful work
- 1:01:53after that, but again, there's a lot of therapists out there. We
- 1:01:55don't need people like this. And it just doesn't seem like justice. It
- 1:02:00doesn't seem right. If I was Brian Wilson and I knew Eugene Landy was
- 1:02:06just across the border, you know, a couple of states over in New
- 1:02:08Mexico practicing and you know, live in the high life. You know,
- 1:02:13my past patient was Brian Wilson. I really helped him. If I knew
- 1:02:16that that would that would break my heart to think that the government didn't have
- 1:02:21an appropriate response to people like this. It's just awful, all right.
- 1:02:25So let's get into the ethical codes. So this is just my take,
- 1:02:30and it's based on the stuff from the internet, the allegations, So I
- 1:02:34can't obviously know what really happened. All the information I have is from this
- 1:02:37podcast, from what's on the internet, which everything on the internet is based
- 1:02:43on what's on the podcast. So I really just don't have any idea.
- 1:02:46And if I were involved in the hearing, I'm guessing I would hear a
- 1:02:52lot more nuance, a lot more details. Now I might if I was
- 1:02:57a part of the hearing, I might consider that neegations to be even more
- 1:03:01worse, and doctor Herskoff could look even worse because other patients might be coming
- 1:03:05forward. I don't know, but I don't know who knows. Maybe I
- 1:03:07would see it differently in a way that would make doctor Hrskoff look not so
- 1:03:10bad. So this is all just based on Internet stuff. You always need
- 1:03:15to take then in consideration from any sort of Internet person commenting on Internet stuff.
- 1:03:21So these are the American Psychiatric Association, which he you know, needs
- 1:03:24to adhere to the Principles of Medical Ethics twenty thirteen edition. So I pulled
- 1:03:31out the relevant ethical they're they're they're relevant principles. They don't. I guess
- 1:03:37they don't call him ethics, they call him principles. I'm not really quite
- 1:03:39sure. So I'm an expert in mental health, barried family therapy, counseling,
- 1:03:46psychology, ethical codes. I'm not a huge, obviously expert in medical
- 1:03:52ethics because I'm not I'm not in the medical field. But I think I'm
- 1:03:57understanding their documents right Section one, it says a physician shall be dedicated to
- 1:04:04providing competent medical care with compassion and respect for human dignity and rights. A
- 1:04:10psychiatrist shall not gratify his or her own needs by exploiting the patient. Now,
- 1:04:15barring the fact that they're using binary gender issues here, let's look beyond
- 1:04:20that. A psychiatrist shall not gratify his or her own needs by exploiting the
- 1:04:26patient. It is it looks pretty clear from the allegations in this podcast that
- 1:04:32doctor Hirshkoff was absolutely gratifying his own needs by exploiting his patients. Doctor Hirshkoff
- 1:04:41wanted a fancy house. He manipulately he exploited his patient to buy a fancy
- 1:04:45house so he could move into it. Doctor Hirshkoff wanted to have fancy parties.
- 1:04:48He exploited his patient so he could have fancy parties at his patient's house.
- 1:04:55Doctor Hirshkoff wanted to act like a rich guy who owned a fancy house,
- 1:05:00so he exploited his patient to make it seem like he owned the house
- 1:05:03instead of his patient owning the house. Doctor Hirshkoff seemingly wanted a lot of
- 1:05:11money, so he exploited his patient so that he could get a bunch of
- 1:05:14his patient's money. Doctor Hirshkoff wanted someone to type up his twelve book manuscript
- 1:05:19scripts, and so he exploited his patient to get him to do that.
- 1:05:27So I think that's that's pretty clear. Section two of APA Principles of Mathematical
- 1:05:32Ethics, a physician shall uphold the standards of professionalism, be honest in all
- 1:05:39professional interactions, and strive to report physicians deficient in character or competence, or
- 1:05:45engaging in fraud or debception to appropriate entities. The psychiatrist should diligently guard against
- 1:05:51exploiting information furnished by the patient, and should not use the unique position of
- 1:05:57power afforded him or her by the psycho therapeutic situation to influence the patient in
- 1:06:01any way not directly relevant to the treatment goals. So that's a long way
- 1:06:05of saying that psychiatrists should not use the patient's issues against them the psychia if
- 1:06:16the psychiatrist learns, for example, at their patient is very manipulatable and has
- 1:06:21a hard time asserting themselves and is easily manipulatable, that the psychiatrists would not
- 1:06:28use that material against their patient for their own needs. Right, pretty obvious.
- 1:06:32Psychiatric services, like all medical services, are dispensed in the context of
- 1:06:39a contractual arrangement between the patient and the physician. The provisions of the contractual
- 1:06:45arrangement, which are binding on the physician as well as on the patient,
- 1:06:47should should be explicitly established. So the reason why I'm including this when in
- 1:06:53my discussion here is that whenever we engage in our professional relationship with our alliance
- 1:07:00and patients. The patient needs to know what's happening, and the patient needs
- 1:07:04to consent to that. And so if for example, so let's say I
- 1:07:13so I'll I'll give an example. So I have a supervisey, Christy,
- 1:07:17and she's going to be on the podcast soon. So she doesn't mind.
- 1:07:21She's already said it's okay for me to talk about her. She listened to
- 1:07:27the Schema Therapy episodes that it did. There's a lot of buzz, not
- 1:07:31buzz. It sounds like important. There's a lot of response that I'm getting
- 1:07:36to. So I did these patron only episodes that are available only the patrons
- 1:07:41on Schema Therapy that I have, and I'm as I'm getting more into the
- 1:07:45theory, I'm finding it to be extremely helpful and useful way to very quickly
- 1:07:49understand one's issues and how to deal with them. And so I put out
- 1:07:56the call. I said, Hey, anyone out there who wants to come
- 1:07:58on the podcast and talk about their scheme. Is so that people in podcast
- 1:08:01land can learn about different kinds of scheme as different kind of personalities and maybe
- 1:08:05relate to you and learn from you know, your issues and you know,
- 1:08:12learn from the conversation that you have with me. If you want to come
- 1:08:15on the podcast, we can do that. And so my my supervisee,
- 1:08:18Christie Forrester, she emailed me today and she's like, yeah, I'd like
- 1:08:23to come on the podcast. And so I said, okay, so this
- 1:08:26is a dual relationship because you're a supervisey of mine. She's a clinician who's
- 1:08:30under supervision. I'm supervising her private practice, So this would be a dual
- 1:08:34relationship. I told her that. I said, so not only would you
- 1:08:39be my supervisey, but you would also now be on my podcast. That's
- 1:08:43that's a dual relationship. And I said, so you just have to understand
- 1:08:48the risks involved in that, and I laid them all out in written form,
- 1:08:54and I said, and understand that you don't have to do this.
- 1:08:59You know, know that just because of you're my supervisey doesn't mean you have
- 1:09:02to volunteer for things that I ask for you to do. You know,
- 1:09:04I have other people that will volunteer you don't. You know, you don't
- 1:09:06have to do You don't have to put yourself a risk. And the risks
- 1:09:11are you know, things like on the podcast, she might reveal things to
- 1:09:15me that she wouldn't want her supervisor to know. She might reveal things on
- 1:09:24the podcast she doesn't want everyone to know, and will worry about telling me
- 1:09:29to edit it out because I'm her supervisor and I have authority over her that
- 1:09:32kind of thing. And so we laid all that out and she said,
- 1:09:35YEP, I understand those risks, and I'm not worried about him, and
- 1:09:40I trust you, Kirk, that you'll, you know, work with me
- 1:09:44if I have a problem and that sort of thing. And so so we
- 1:09:48basically we don't have a contract officially, but we had a written and you
- 1:09:54know, communication back and forth of what we're getting into here, and so,
- 1:10:00you know, it says just reading this principle here, psychiatric services,
- 1:10:05like all medical services, are dispensed in the contacts and the context of a
- 1:10:10contractual arrangement between patient and the physician. The provision of the contractual arrangement,
- 1:10:15which are binding on the physician as well as on the patient, should be
- 1:10:17explicitly established. So there needs to be a binding agreement established and followed.
- 1:10:25And with doctor Hirshkoff and with Eugene Landy, there was not a contractual arrangement
- 1:10:31made. As far as I can tell from what the allegations are, At
- 1:10:36no point, from what I heard in the podcast, did doctor Hirshkoff go
- 1:10:41to Marty Markowitz and say, Okay, you are about to enter into several
- 1:10:45other dual relationships with me. You'll you know, you're going to be my
- 1:10:50patient, but you're also going to be my landlord. You're also going to
- 1:10:55be my party planner. You're also going to be my gardener. You're also
- 1:10:58going to be my promotetional person. You're also going to be my business partner.
- 1:11:02You're also going to be you know, all these other worlds and here
- 1:11:05are the risks and is it? Are you cool with that? Do you
- 1:11:09understand what you're getting into? My chat has more to say about that,
- 1:11:14and from what I can tell, that was never established. Okay. Section
- 1:11:17four A physician shall respect the rights of patients, colleagues, and other health
- 1:11:24professionals, and shall safeguard patient confidences and privacy within the constraints of the law.
- 1:11:30Confidentiality is essential to psychiatric treatment. A psychiatrist may release confidential information only
- 1:11:38with authorization. Blah blah blah. So this is the confidence. It's you
- 1:11:42know, common to all mental health people, confidentiality is very important, and
- 1:11:45it seems that doctors doctor Hirshkoff absolutely broke confidentiality, often for not for clinical
- 1:11:53reasons, not for you know, treatment reasons, for his own manipulative,
- 1:11:57manipulative reasons. Section eight, the last section, i'll get into her a
- 1:12:03physician shell. While caring for a patient, regard responsibility to the patient as
- 1:12:10paramount. When the psychiatrists outside relationships conflict with the clinical needs of the patient,
- 1:12:16the psychiatrist must always consider the impact of such relationships and strive to resolve
- 1:12:21conflicts in a manner that the psychiatrist believes is likely to be beneficial to the
- 1:12:26patient. So, now this one gets a little wonky, but you know,
- 1:12:31roll with me on this one. So the psychiatrist involved, you know,
- 1:12:36doctor Hirskoff involved a lot of his outside relationships in his relationships with his
- 1:12:42patients, and along the way, whenever you do this, you have to
- 1:12:45think, well, what impact is this going to have on the treatment?
- 1:12:48What impact is this going to have on my client? And it doesn't seem
- 1:12:51like doctor Hirstkoff ever, considered that when significant relationships exist that may conflict with
- 1:12:58the patient's clinical needs. It is especially important to inform the patient or decision
- 1:13:02maker about these relationships and potential conflicts. Blah bla blah anyway, So it's
- 1:13:08there's just more language around that, and it's pretty clear that he didn't do
- 1:13:11so. So I suspect that sections one, two, four, and eight
- 1:13:15are going to be brought up in this hearing on September twenty fourth. There
- 1:13:21might be other allegations that involve other sections, but that's you know, those
- 1:13:26are a lot of sections. So I think there's only eight sections total,
- 1:13:29So he has, you know, he has major issues and four out of
- 1:13:31eight of the sections don't. Maybe there's twelve sections I don't remember, but
- 1:13:35not not a lot. So yeah, this just makes me sick to think
- 1:13:42of. It'd be one thing if this guy got away with it for a
- 1:13:45year, two years. It's another thing when Bill Cosby, Harvey Weinstein,
- 1:13:50doctor Hirshkoff, these people get away with his ship for decades, decades,
- 1:13:58And it's it's heartbreaking to think that bad actors can do this sort of stuff
- 1:14:03out in the open. They weren't lurking in the shadows, they didn't have
- 1:14:08a ninja mask on, they didn't have to mask their identity. They didn't
- 1:14:13wear you know, they didn't have their victims weren't wearing blindfolds. They just
- 1:14:18did it right out in the open. And why is that Because they knew
- 1:14:26we would let them get away with it. They knew our society and our
- 1:14:30system was set up to protect them and not the victims. They knew they
- 1:14:38could weasel their way out of it. And I know a lot of mental
- 1:14:41health not a lot, but I know mental health cases like this where it
- 1:14:45smells like manipulation. Like one of the things that mental health professionals can rely
- 1:14:53on is that society considers patients to be crazy. Right. It's like,
- 1:15:00well, you know, Marty Markowitz, he was in therapy, he must
- 1:15:01be crazy. And if he's crazy, then God knows what he's going to
- 1:15:05think and say and believe. And so the psychiatrist when they when these allegations
- 1:15:11come forward, they'll just be like, ah, you know, he had
- 1:15:13issues, he has transference issues. That's where this is coming from. He's
- 1:15:18a you know, a jilted client who has a lot of abuse in his
- 1:15:25past, and it's it's he's acting out. Don't worry about it. And
- 1:15:28there's sometimes where it seems like that is not a legit defense, and yet
- 1:15:32it flies anyway. Patients don't have as much power as clinicians do. Women
- 1:15:41don't have as much power as men do, and thus we have our society
- 1:15:48that allows for monsters to run rampant and victimize hundreds and thousands of people.
- 1:15:57Do you think that doctor Hirskoff is the only one that's doing this sort of
- 1:16:00thing out there? No. As a podcaster, and because I talk about
- 1:16:06this often, I get a lot of emails from people talking about their therapists
- 1:16:11doing horrific things. Now I'm not there, but if even ten percent of
- 1:16:17them are accurate, man, do we have a problem. And I find
- 1:16:23that a lot of therapists don't like to talk about this, and I think
- 1:16:27sort of boggles me. It's sort of like when priests back in the day
- 1:16:30and maybe still today don't like to talk about the fact that some of their
- 1:16:33colleagues are sexually abusing the kids in their church. Shouldn't priests be the first
- 1:16:42fucking people to talk out, to speak up when they find out about one
- 1:16:45of their colleagues having sex with children in their church. Shouldn't priests be the
- 1:16:51first people to speak up. Shouldn't I, as a therapist, be the
- 1:16:55first person to speak out when I find that someone is doing something unethical?
- 1:17:00Why would I want to hide that? That just makes me look bad and
- 1:17:02when it finally comes out, it makes us really look bad. Now,
- 1:17:08I want to be clear, these kinds of people are rare. As I
- 1:17:12said earlier, the vast majority of us are following the letter of the ethical
- 1:17:15codes. And like I said, you know I have supervises and colleagues who
- 1:17:21are obsessing it. Oh my god. You know I accepted this card,
- 1:17:26I didn't open it up, and you know, my patient left and it
- 1:17:28was our final session. I opened up the card later and there was a
- 1:17:30five dollar Starbucks card in there, and I don't know what to do.
- 1:17:34Do I send it back to him? Yeah, you could send it back
- 1:17:38to him, but you know, it's probably okay, it's just five bucks,
- 1:17:42like buy yourself a latte. It's probably more. It's probably not enough
- 1:17:45money to buy a latte these days, and Starbucks. You know, most
- 1:17:53of us are are really concerned about these kinds of things, and for good
- 1:17:56reason. And yet these rare individuals are out there, you know, having
- 1:18:00sexual cuddling with their clients, getting into their clients bank accounts, controlling their
- 1:18:09isolating their clients from other people so that they can manipulate them. We therapist
- 1:18:15should be the first people to stand up and say no, that cannot happen.
- 1:18:19And we need to raise awareness about this. We therapists need to raise
- 1:18:24awareness of the fact that these things are happening and that patients do not have
- 1:18:29power. And even when Marty Markowitz is a white male who had millions of
- 1:18:34dollars and lawyers and what happened nothing. So what do you think a marginalized,
- 1:18:42abused, you know, twenty five year old poor person is gonna What
- 1:18:47kind of power do you think they have? And this is something that I
- 1:18:50talk about a lot actually with my supervisees who work in agencies, is that
- 1:18:57you know, local agencies, mental health agencies, they people on medical coupons
- 1:19:02and these are poor people, immigrants, they're struggling, you know, single
- 1:19:08parent homes, uh, you know, working a lot, or you know
- 1:19:12mental health issues, addiction issues. You know, there's just a lot of
- 1:19:14issues. And what ends up happening is the rights of the patients get slowly
- 1:19:20tranced upon by the mental health agencies. Not because the mental health agencies are
- 1:19:27bad people. But because they don't remember their ethical codes and there's no one
- 1:19:32pushing back on them, you know, my cat still wants to Every fifteen
- 1:19:36minutes, my cat just starts to pipe up. The patients are poor.
- 1:19:44They might be undocumented immigrants, many most of them aren't. But let's just
- 1:19:48say you have, you know, an American citizen but struggling with low income
- 1:19:55and goes to a mental health agency and has their rights trounced upon, their
- 1:20:00confidentiality rights trounced upon. They're routinely you know, Like one of the things
- 1:20:06that I it just drives me nuts is there will be um, you know,
- 1:20:11I'll have an intern at my university, will be working at a mental
- 1:20:15health agency that has the interns go to schools, and so the intern,
- 1:20:19this intern therapist works at this high school, for example, and finds a
- 1:20:27broom closet to see their clients in, and then the teachers find out.
- 1:20:30I think my cat just wants to be let out. I'm going to let
- 1:20:32her out, right, I'm back. So let's say that this intern is
- 1:20:38working at a high school and the teachers know that some of their students are
- 1:20:44seeing this intern in the broom closet, and the intern walks out of the
- 1:20:48broom closet and a teacher walks up and says, okay, so you know,
- 1:20:51Johnny, what's going on with Johnny? Because you know Johnny's acting up
- 1:20:55in class and you know Johnny's parents are a problem. You know what's going
- 1:20:59on. And the intern feels pressured to break confidentiality and talk about their client
- 1:21:08with this teacher even though they don't have a release of information to do so.
- 1:21:13This drives me nuts, and that a lot of these mental health agencies
- 1:21:16and the supervisors they don't even blink an eye at that. They're like,
- 1:21:19well, you know, you're working at the school, work with the teachers,
- 1:21:21and it's like, no, no, we have an ethical responsibility.
- 1:21:26That's clear that clients have confidentiality. You cannot talk with your clients a teacher,
- 1:21:32or their parents, or their friends, or the President United States without
- 1:21:36a release of information unless you have costs to do so, which are very
- 1:21:42rare instances as mandated by law, or when there's you know, someone's going
- 1:21:46to be harmed or something, but you know, certainly not in casual conversation
- 1:21:49with the teacher. And guess what the kid probably doesn't even know they have
- 1:21:54rights. And even if they did, where are they going to go?
- 1:21:57Who are they going to turn to? And even if they did know the
- 1:21:59Department of Health, is the Department of Health going to listen to them?
- 1:22:02I don't know. According to this one case with Bartie Markowitz, noar the
- 1:22:09Department of Health. Even if you're at the top of the food chain when
- 1:22:13it comes to power, they still might not do anything. How is that
- 1:22:16okay? That is not okay, And us as therapists need to do something
- 1:22:23about that. We need to actually pressure our states, pressure patients to step
- 1:22:30forward for themselves and advocate for all everyone's rights. We as therapists need to
- 1:22:34use our power for good and actually try to bolster the complaint power system so
- 1:22:44that these bad apples can be outed, you know, years before decades go
- 1:22:50by and they've abused all these people in the same way that we need to
- 1:22:56help young women know that they can come forward and that won't be shamed,
- 1:23:00that they will be believed, and that the justice system will do something.
- 1:23:05You know, whenever these things happen, we tend to be like, oh,
- 1:23:08okay, we caught the bad guy. You know, back back to
- 1:23:12work, Everything's fine, No, everything's everything's off. When we see stuff,
- 1:23:17I guess we'd be like, whoa, how did this guy get away
- 1:23:19with it? And how many other people are getting away with it right now?
- 1:23:24If this guy got away with it for so long and someone complained and
- 1:23:28the Department of Held did nothing, and it takes a number one podcast in
- 1:23:31the world to actually get a Department of Health to do something about it,
- 1:23:35then I would say we have a problem on our hands. If Bill Cosby
- 1:23:41can get away with abusing all this, if Harvey Weinstein can get away with
- 1:23:44it, we have a problem on our hands. And catching these individuals is
- 1:23:48part of the solution, but it's one percent out of one hundred percent of
- 1:23:53what needs to get done. What we got to change our society. We
- 1:23:56got to change our systems. We got to change our justice system. We
- 1:23:59got to change our culture. We have to destigmatize therapy. We have to
- 1:24:04give more money to Department of Health. I guess we have to have watchdogs
- 1:24:09on the Department of Health. We have to have politicians paying attention to Department
- 1:24:12of Health. We have to have therapist organizations paying attention to Department of Health.
- 1:24:15We have to have education to the public from therapists saying these are our
- 1:24:23ethical codes and if one of us breaks these rules, please, by all
- 1:24:27means tell someone and will help you walk you through the complaint process because you
- 1:24:31desert you have rights, and we as therapists want to be the first person
- 1:24:36to you know, the first people to come forward and help you with this,
- 1:24:42because we don't want people like like that doing stuff like that either.
- 1:24:45And I'm not talking about the Hearst Coffs of the world. I'm talking about
- 1:24:48even minor things. You know, there are therapists that do minor things that
- 1:24:53they you know, maybe they don't need their their license to be taken away,
- 1:24:57but they might need a little bit of education, like hey, don't
- 1:25:01sexually cuddle your clients. How about that? Um Anyway, so the last
- 1:25:12few things here is people are asking online, They're like, well, you
- 1:25:15know, isn't Marty Marco what's to blame? You know? He consented to
- 1:25:18all this stuff. He consented to doctor Hirshkoff being put in his will.
- 1:25:24He consented to doctor Herskoff taking over his business. He consented to doctor Herskoff
- 1:25:30moving into his house. Isn't you know he's he's to blame you know.
- 1:25:38Um, what I'll say to that is the power that a therapist has over
- 1:25:45a client can be and is for some relationships powerful. Um. You know,
- 1:25:55it's the same thing as as saying like a boss doesn't really have any
- 1:26:00power over their employees, you know, sexual harassment or something, and it's
- 1:26:03like that just ignores the reality of things. So is Marty to blame?
- 1:26:10No, I don't blame Marty for this at all. Marty came into their
- 1:26:14relationship asking for help about a certiveness, knew that he had problems with boundaries,
- 1:26:18knew that he had problems with being manipulated by their people, and he
- 1:26:23the therapist utilizes that groomed him over time. Again, he didn't spring all
- 1:26:28these manipulations on Marty marco Witz day one. He groomed him over years.
- 1:26:32And if you listen to the podcast to get a picture of that worst And
- 1:26:35that's how these people do this kind of thing, you know, That's how
- 1:26:39they do it, is they just slowly work their way into people's lives.
- 1:26:45The other thing that's interesting is there could be a massive civil suit. After
- 1:26:49all, this is set after the hearing, you know, guessing that Marty
- 1:26:54marco witza and the other patients are thinking, you know, let's sue this
- 1:26:57guy. Let's sue him so that he isn't you know, A strong message
- 1:27:01is sent, and I would be absolutely supportive of that, because again,
- 1:27:05the worst that the Department of Health can do is take away his license and
- 1:27:11give him a minor fine that he could probably easily pay. So a solo
- 1:27:15suit would be appropriate. So in conclusion, I'll say that I can't imagine
- 1:27:24anyone ever doing something like this. I would never invite a client to a
- 1:27:29party, and have never I would never introduce a client to someone I knew.
- 1:27:33I've never done that. I've never touched a client at a party when
- 1:27:39they were in a bikini. That would never occur to me. I've never
- 1:27:43suggested that a client cut themselves off from other people in their family. I've
- 1:27:46never suggested. I've never suggested a client cut themselves off from their support system
- 1:27:50or even if they didn't like them anymore. I mean, just give you
- 1:27:54an idea. I had a patient once who was sexually abused by her father
- 1:27:59and was still socializing with them often. And although to me I thought,
- 1:28:03wow, you know that doesn't sound like it's very good for her. I
- 1:28:09never thought to myself, well, I'm going to tell her she needs to
- 1:28:13cut her father off from her life, because I'm not that stupid. I'm
- 1:28:17a therapist. I know better. I'm never going to tell someone to do
- 1:28:20something. Now. I might suggest, like I might ask questions like,
- 1:28:25how do you feel about being in a relationship with him? Do you want
- 1:28:29to be in a relationship with him? Do you feel controlled you? Do
- 1:28:30you feel like your relationship with him is benefiting you at all? You know
- 1:28:35you have a right to say no, and I don't want to see you
- 1:28:39anymore. Like you know, I'll throw that stuff out there, but I
- 1:28:41would never say like you're you know, the stuff that Marty Markowitz alleges that
- 1:28:47Hirshkov said were things like, you can't control your life, you're passive,
- 1:28:53aggressive, you don't understand how things work, you can't handle the truth.
- 1:28:58Let me tell you what to do. I would I would never do that.
- 1:29:04You know, even when people ask me for my opinion, I don't
- 1:29:06even answer it. You know they'll be like, so, do you think
- 1:29:09I should cut off my parents? You know my parents were are awful people.
- 1:29:12Do you think I should cut them off? I'm always like I don't
- 1:29:15know what. That's a very good question. Let's explore it. I would
- 1:29:20never know the answer to that question. That's too complex. I've never gone
- 1:29:26into business with a client. I've never gone into business with a client that
- 1:29:31I had twenty years if a client from I've been a therapist for twenty plus
- 1:29:35years, if a if a client came for me. You know, if
- 1:29:39a twenty if I terminated with a client twenty years ago and they came to
- 1:29:43me and they had a sweet business deal, I would say, I'm sorry,
- 1:29:45I can't do that. You're once a client, always a client.
- 1:29:47I've never asked a client to put me in their will. I've never asked
- 1:29:55a client to buy a house for me. I've never moved into a client's
- 1:30:00house. I've never asked a client to act like they didn't own their house
- 1:30:04and to act like I own the house. I've never asked a client to
- 1:30:08type up a manuscript of my book. It's never occurred to me to do
- 1:30:14these things. You know, I've had super rich, super famous clients before.
- 1:30:23I've had clients like that. You know, people with power with millions
- 1:30:29upon millions of dollars, you know that could easily afford my my fee,
- 1:30:35and it never occurred to me that I would use them to help my life
- 1:30:43or something. And what it leads to me to believe is that doctor Hirstkoff
- 1:30:46must have a giant hole in his soul that he's trying to fill. Because
- 1:30:53when I think about doing something like that, you know, when I think
- 1:30:55about like taking one of my super rich clients or my super famous clients,
- 1:31:00and like getting them to make me a part of their will, or make
- 1:31:08me into a celebrity, or make me look like I have a fancy house,
- 1:31:12the only reason why I could imagine doing that is if I was massively
- 1:31:16insecure and massively suffering deep down, and I was just like, I'm a
- 1:31:23flawed person or I'm not good enough, and the only way I'm going to
- 1:31:25be good enough is if I have a fancy house and if people think I'm
- 1:31:28famous and that I'm friends with Gretneth Paltrow. So doctor Hirshkoff must be suffering
- 1:31:33deeply, and I feel bad for him. Honestly, I don't feel bad
- 1:31:38for him enough to not take away his license and not hope that he gets
- 1:31:41sued successfully if the allegations are correct, But I do feel bad for him
- 1:31:49and that does that for that episode. Let me know what you think.
- 1:31:54Go to our website psychology st dot com fill out the contact us page.
- 1:31:58That's usually how I like people to contact me. Also, if you like
- 1:32:00this episode and you want to hear others, become a patron of the podcast.
- 1:32:04That's where all of our best episodes are. Thanks for joining me out
- 1:32:08there. Please take care of yourself and assert yourself to the authorities and help
- 1:32:15other people come forward and have the power that they deserve, because we all
- 1:32:19deserve it. We really really do.