Latest / Interfaiths / Secrets in Contact: Secrecy and Religious Exchange
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine two completely different religious worlds
- 0:02just, you know, colliding. OK. Let's say a 17th
- 0:07century Muslim prince on one side and a society
- 0:10of Hindu mystics on the other. Right. So two
- 0:12very distinct groups. Exactly. And by all conventional
- 0:16logic, they should just clash. Yeah. Right. Over
- 0:19their wildly different rules, their distinct
- 0:21rituals, the opposing dogmas. Oh, absolutely.
- 0:23That's what you'd expect. But instead, they forge
- 0:26this profound civilization altering connection.
- 0:29Really? Yeah. And how do they do it? Not by sitting
- 0:32down and finding safe, easily defined common
- 0:36ground. Like they don't just find a compromise.
- 0:38Nope. They did it by weaponizing the one thing
- 0:41we usually assume drives people apart. Which
- 0:43is? Their deepest, darkest, most unutterable
- 0:46secrets. Oh, wow! Right. Because when we usually
- 0:49talk about secrets, especially in religion, there's
- 0:52this immediate... Almost visceral image that
- 0:55comes to mind. Yeah, the heavy oak door with
- 0:57the iron hinges. Exactly. It's the whispered
- 1:00password in a dark alley. It's that exclusive
- 1:02esoteric mystery cult where you are either on
- 1:06the inside bathed in the light of hidden truth
- 1:08or you are on the outside. In the dark. Right.
- 1:12We inherently think of secrets as walls. They
- 1:15are the ultimate tools of gatekeeping. But that's
- 1:18what makes this so wild. It goes against everything
- 1:20we're taught about human behavior and sociology.
- 1:23It really does. Because a secret is fundamentally
- 1:25defined, well, at least in our common imagination,
- 1:28by the barrier it creates between the knower
- 1:31and the non -knower. It's an exclusionary mechanism
- 1:33by design. You build a wall to protect what's
- 1:36yours. Exactly. But then you step into the world
- 1:39of comparative religious studies and you look
- 1:41at how different faiths actually interact out
- 1:43there in the messy real world. And suddenly that
- 1:46heavy oak door starts to look a lot less like
- 1:48a wall and a lot more like a bridge, which is
- 1:50what we're getting into today. We are exploring
- 1:53this conceptual landscape where the very things
- 1:56we thought were designed to keep outsiders out,
- 1:58the deep unexplainable mysteries of a faith,
- 2:02are actually the most effective, profound interfaces
- 2:05connecting totally different traditions. It completely
- 2:08upends our basic assumptions about what a secret
- 2:11is doing when two different worldviews collide.
- 2:14It's this massive counterintuitive paradigm shift.
- 2:17Because we assume transparency builds trust.
- 2:20Right. And secrecy breeds suspicion. Right. But
- 2:22history shows us something far more complex.
- 2:25And that complexity is exactly what we are exploring
- 2:27today. We're taking a deep dive into some really
- 2:30fascinating 2026 research by scholars Philip
- 2:33Reichling and Knit Martin Stunkel. It's a brilliant
- 2:36text. It really is. It focuses on secrecy as
- 2:38a promoter of contact between religious traditions.
- 2:41So our mission for this deep dive is to unpack
- 2:44the hidden mechanics of religious secrecy. To
- 2:46move past the gatekeeping idea. Exactly. And
- 2:49discover how the blank spaces created by secrets
- 2:51actually serve as these incredibly dynamic, powerful
- 2:54interfaces for interfaith understanding and translation.
- 2:57It's a huge topic. It is. OK, let's unpack this.
- 3:00Where do we even begin when the very thing we
- 3:03were trying to study is defined by the fact that
- 3:06it's hidden? Yeah, you're hitting on the exact
- 3:08epistemological nightmare that plagues this entire
- 3:11field of study. It's a nightmare. Oh, totally.
- 3:13It's what scholars call the methodological double
- 3:16bind. Double bind. OK, how does that work? Well,
- 3:19if you want to study a secret. objectively to
- 3:23truly understand its internal architecture and
- 3:25how it functions in society you essentially have
- 3:28to break it apart right you have to look inside
- 3:30you have to expose it to the light of inquiry
- 3:32but the very moment you do that the moment you
- 3:35drag it out of the shadows dissect it and publish
- 3:38a paper on it it's destroyed exactly it is fundamentally
- 3:41no longer a secret oh man It's like trying to
- 3:45study a snowflake by holding it in your warm
- 3:47hand. That's a perfect analogy. The act of observation
- 3:50melts the very thing you're trying to observe.
- 3:53Right. Or to borrow a metaphor I've heard in
- 3:55these academic circles, if you take the secret
- 3:58house and its inhabitants to pieces just to see
- 4:00how the plumbing works. You ruin the house. Right.
- 4:03You can't live in it anymore. Exactly. Which
- 4:06creates this massive anxiety, particularly within
- 4:09the modern scientific worldview. I can imagine.
- 4:11Cicela Buck, who is a really prominent ethicist,
- 4:14makes this brilliant observation. She says scientists
- 4:17have developed what she calls a ritualistic denunciation
- 4:19of secrecy. Ritualistic denunciation. That's
- 4:23intense. It is. But think about the foundational
- 4:26pillars of the scientific method. What are they?
- 4:29Free, open, transparent communication. Peer review.
- 4:32Shared data. Reproducible results. Transparency
- 4:36is the literal oxygen of science. Right. Because
- 4:39of that, modern scholars often treat secrecy
- 4:41almost like a rival sinister religion that they
- 4:44have to actively conjure away or exercise. Wow.
- 4:47Yeah. They view a secret purely as a withholding
- 4:50of truth, you know, an obstacle to human progress.
- 4:53Which is incredibly ironic when you think about
- 4:55it. Well, so. Well. The scholars are treating
- 4:57the concept of the secret with the exact same
- 4:59ritualistic fervor and absolute dogma as the
- 5:03religious adherents who are keeping the secret.
- 5:05Ah, that's so true. It's a clash of fundamentalisms.
- 5:08The scientist says everything must be illuminated
- 5:10and the mystic says some things must remain in
- 5:13the dark. Right. It's two completely incompatible
- 5:16approaches to truth. But before we get too deep
- 5:19into how these shadows actually connect people,
- 5:21we need to define our terms. In everyday conversation,
- 5:25we blur a lot of lines, but there is a crucial
- 5:28distinction we need to make here between a mystery
- 5:31and a secret oh this distinction is absolutely
- 5:33foundational right yeah we toss those words around
- 5:36interchangeably all the time but conceptually
- 5:39they operate on entirely different planes of
- 5:41reality jan assman an incredible scholar of egyptian
- 5:45religion provides a really clarifying framework
- 5:47here okay let's hear it so a mystery is something
- 5:50that is fundamentally unfathomable it's rooted
- 5:53in the very nature of the cosmos or the divine
- 5:56It is not hidden because a group of priests decided
- 5:58to lock it in a gold box and throw away the key.
- 6:02It's hidden because the human mind is neurologically
- 6:05conceptually incapable of fully grasping it.
- 6:08So like the origins of time, the experience of
- 6:11death, the absolute. Essence of a creator. Exactly.
- 6:15Those are mysteries. Right. Whereas a secret,
- 6:17which sometimes gets called an arcanum in these
- 6:20historical texts, is something that is just hidden
- 6:23from most people by strategic human action. Yes.
- 6:26It's something that could be perfectly known
- 6:28and understood by a human brain, but it is intentionally
- 6:31concealed by a group or an individual. That's
- 6:33it. And Immanuel Kant gives us a really useful
- 6:36threefold taxonomy to break this down even further,
- 6:39which really helps clarify the stakes here. Okay.
- 6:41What's Kant's breakdown? First, Kant says there
- 6:44are secrets of nature, the arcana. These are
- 6:47things like the laws of quantum mechanics, dark
- 6:49matter, or the cure for certain diseases. Things
- 6:52we just don't know yet. Right. They're currently
- 6:54hidden from us, but through scientific discovery
- 6:57and time, they might one day become known. The
- 6:59universe is hiding them, but they are discoverable.
- 7:02Okay, so arcana are puzzles waiting to be solved.
- 7:05Correct. Second, there are political or strategic
- 7:08secrets, the secreta. These are state secrets,
- 7:12military troop movements, the recipe for Coca
- 7:14-Cola or your bank password. The stuff humans
- 7:17actively hide. Exactly. These are facts deliberately
- 7:20hidden by humans from other humans. If I steal
- 7:24the recipe, I understand the secret completely.
- 7:27Makes sense. And third, Kant identifies the holy
- 7:30secret of religion, the Mysterium. Ah, the mystery.
- 7:34Yes. This is the substantial secret that is forever
- 7:37beyond human capacity to unravel, no matter how
- 7:40much science advances or how many spies you hire.
- 7:43Okay, let me make sure I'm mapping this correctly.
- 7:45A secret, the arcanum or the secreture, is like
- 7:48a stage magic trick. Okay, I like that. If I
- 7:50go to Las Vegas and see a magician make a tiger
- 7:52disappear, I'm amazed. But once I pull back the
- 7:55velvet curtain, go backstage and see the trap
- 7:58doors and the mirrors, the illusion is totally
- 8:00gone. The magic is dead. Right. It's just mechanics.
- 8:03The secret is dead. But a mystery. The Mysterium
- 8:06is like the mathematical concept of infinity.
- 8:08Oh, that's good. Even if I explain the math to
- 8:11you, even if I write the equation on a chalkboard
- 8:13and you memorize it, it still completely blows
- 8:16your mind. You literally cannot hold the entirety
- 8:19of infinity in your physical brain. That is a
- 8:22great way to delineate them. The Mysterium retains
- 8:25its power even when it's placed right in the
- 8:27center of the fully lit room. But here is my
- 8:29pushback. This is the exact thing that was tripping
- 8:32me up as I was looking through this research.
- 8:34What's that? If a mystery is inherently unknowable
- 8:37to everyone, how can two different religions
- 8:39ever use it to understand each other? If a Muslim
- 8:43and a Christian are sitting across from each
- 8:46other and they both have this core mysterium
- 8:48that they literally cannot articulate, aren't
- 8:51they just staring at each other in the dark?
- 8:53That's a fair point. How do you build a bridge
- 8:55out of something neither of you can see or describe?
- 8:58It's the most logical question to ask. And it's
- 9:00the hurdle that has stumped interfaith dialogue
- 9:02for centuries. Right. To understand how that
- 9:05bridge is actually built out of the unknowable.
- 9:07Yeah. We first have to deconstruct how we have
- 9:09traditionally misunderstood the social function
- 9:12of a secret. OK. We have to look at why we've
- 9:15always assumed secrets are just walls. And that
- 9:18brings us to the foundational sociology of secrecy.
- 9:21If we want to look at the traditional view, we
- 9:23have to talk about Georg Simmel. Right, Simmel.
- 9:25If you're studying the sociology of secrecy,
- 9:27Georg Simmel is the godfather of the field. He
- 9:30really is. He wrote a cornerstone text back in
- 9:32the early 20th century, and he essentially viewed
- 9:34the secret as a tool of what he called egoistic
- 9:38individualization. It was all about group isolation.
- 9:42Yeah, Simmel was obsessed with how societies
- 9:44form boundaries. He argued that the primary function
- 9:47of a secret is to form a protective border. He
- 9:50used a very specific German term of Scheidungsfecht,
- 9:53which translates roughly to the aim to separate.
- 9:56The aim to separate. Right. In Simmel's view,
- 9:59the secret unites the in -group, the people who
- 10:01possess the hidden knowledge, by creating a rigid,
- 10:04impermeable wall against the out -group, the
- 10:07profane masses who don't know. Right. Us versus
- 10:10them. Exactly. The shared secret gives the in
- 10:13-group a sense of intense prestige, deep trust,
- 10:16and mutual protection against a hostile outside
- 10:18world. There's a metaphor from researchers Paul
- 10:21Christopher Johnson and Hugh B. Urban that perfectly
- 10:24encapsulates this traditional view. Oh, the revolving
- 10:28door one. Yes. They describe secrecy as a revolving
- 10:32door of information that keeps some information
- 10:35and some people in and others out. It's a great
- 10:38image. It's just a sorting mechanism. You walk
- 10:41up to the revolving door. If you have the password,
- 10:43it spins you into the lobby. If you don't, it
- 10:45spits you back out onto the street. Exactly.
- 10:47And if we stop there, Simmel's view makes total
- 10:50pragmatic sense. Secrets divide us. They create
- 10:53factions. But this newer research proposes a
- 10:57revolutionary pivot in how we look at this. It
- 11:00really does. They argue that to understand historical
- 11:03interfaith contact, we have to stop obsessing
- 11:06over the hidden content of the secret. We have
- 11:08to stop trying to pick the lock to see what's
- 11:10inside the vault. And instead, we need to look
- 11:12at the form of secrecy as a social practice.
- 11:15And that pivot changes everything. Think about
- 11:17it. If we accept Kant's premise that the content
- 11:20of the Holy Secret, the Mysterium, is ultimately
- 11:23unknowable anyway, then as scholars or even just
- 11:27as neighbors trying to understand each other,
- 11:29obsessing over the content is a complete dead
- 11:32end. Because you can't know it anyway. Right.
- 11:34You're trying to solve an unsolvable math problem.
- 11:37Instead, you have to look at the act of keeping
- 11:39a secret. Secrecy isn't just a passive absence
- 11:43of information. It's a highly active, dynamic
- 11:46social practice. How so? Well, the historian
- 11:48Daniel Jute points out that secrecy actually
- 11:51generates a dynamic market. A market. Yeah. When
- 11:54a group claims to have a secret, it doesn't represent
- 11:56a decline of open knowledge. Rather, the very
- 11:59act of hiding something creates a claim to authority.
- 12:02Oh, I see. It creates an aura of prestige. It
- 12:05creates a highly emphasized, energized space.
- 12:07By drawing a curtain around something, you are
- 12:10signaling to the entire world what is behind
- 12:12here is incredibly valuable. Right. And paradoxically,
- 12:15that energized space. becomes a genuine zone
- 12:17of contact. People are drawn to the curtain.
- 12:19Here's where it gets really interesting. Because
- 12:21if we start viewing secrecy as a dynamic economy
- 12:25or a type of currency, rather than just a locked
- 12:28vault that we can't open, we can start to see
- 12:31how different religions historically traded,
- 12:34negotiated, and interacted using this very specific
- 12:37currency. It's not about what the secret is.
- 12:40It's about what the secret does when it enters
- 12:42the marketplace of human interaction. That is
- 12:45the exact mechanism. And when we look at history
- 12:48through this lens, we see a really robust taxonomy
- 12:52of how this plays out. Like different categories
- 12:54of interaction. Exactly. We can break down the
- 12:57mechanisms of interfaith contact involving secrets
- 13:00into a few distinct scenarios. But before we
- 13:02look at how different faiths collide over secrets,
- 13:05we should briefly touch on why groups create
- 13:07secrets internally in the first place. What the
- 13:10research calls endogenous secrets. Yeah. Let's
- 13:12explore that, because internally, a religious
- 13:15group usually secretizes something for survival,
- 13:18right? Right. They're either trying to protect
- 13:20their members physically, or they are trying
- 13:22to preserve the absolute purity of their spiritual
- 13:25experience from being deluded, co -opted, or
- 13:28mocked by the outside world. And history gives
- 13:31us incredibly powerful examples of this internal
- 13:34protection. Let's look at taqiyya in Shi 'i Islam.
- 13:38Okay. This isn't just a theological concept.
- 13:40It was a gritty life -or -death survival tactic.
- 13:43Taqiyya is the practice of concealing one's faith
- 13:46or dispensing with ordinary religious ordinances
- 13:49when under threat of death or extreme persecution.
- 13:52Wow. Yeah. For centuries, minority Shi 'i populations
- 13:55lived under hostile rulers. By creating an endogenous
- 13:59secret, By hiding their true allegiance and rituals,
- 14:02they ensured the physical and communal survival
- 14:04of their faith against an oppressive majority.
- 14:06The secret was a literal shield. Another incredibly
- 14:10striking example of this comes from the Christian
- 14:12tradition, specifically during the rise of totalitarianism
- 14:15in the 20th century. Think about Germany in the
- 14:171930s. You have the Nazi regime rising to power,
- 14:20and Nazis have functioned very much like a rival
- 14:23religion. It had its own absolute dogmas, its
- 14:26own rituals, its own demand for total devotion.
- 14:30It was an all -encompassing ideology. Exactly.
- 14:33So in response to this, the German theologian
- 14:36Dietrich Bonhoeffer, who eventually died in a
- 14:38concentration camp for resisting Hitler, called
- 14:41for the church to return to what he called an
- 14:44arch and discipline. A discipline of the secret.
- 14:46Yes. Bonhoeffer looked around and saw the Nazi
- 14:50regime trying to co -opt. Christian language,
- 14:53trying to merge the church with the state. Right.
- 14:55He argued that the Christian church needed to
- 14:57actively hide its most profound mysteries. They
- 15:01needed to stop throwing their deepest sacraments
- 15:03and theology out into the public square because
- 15:06the public square had been poisoned. That makes
- 15:08total sense. He wanted to protect the Mysterium
- 15:10from being profaned, cheapened, or twisted by
- 15:13the totalitarian ideology of the state. He wasn't
- 15:16hiding the faith because he was embarrassed by
- 15:18it. He was hiding it because it was too precious
- 15:20to be left out in the open where the Nazis could
- 15:22weaponize it. It's an immune system response.
- 15:25In both the case of Takiyah and the Ark in Discipline,
- 15:28the secret is an internal defense mechanism.
- 15:31Right. But the truly groundbreaking part of analyzing
- 15:34secrecy comes when we move from those internal
- 15:37immune responses to exogenous contact. External
- 15:41contact. Exactly. What happens when two completely
- 15:44different religious traditions, both possessing
- 15:46their own profound, heavily guarded secrets actually
- 15:50collide in the marketplace. This is the core
- 15:53of the deep dive. Yeah, and this research outlines
- 15:55a few historical scenarios that are just fascinating.
- 15:58Let's look at the first one, which we might call
- 16:00mutual secrets. Okay. This is where the shared
- 16:02practice of secrecy literally unites diverse
- 16:05groups, leading them to search for a philosophia
- 16:08perennis. A perennial universal philosophy that
- 16:11they believe underlies all distinct faiths. Precisely.
- 16:15This historical example they give completely
- 16:17blew my mind. We're going back to 17... century
- 16:19Germany, specifically to the small Salzbach court
- 16:23of Count Palatine Christian August. That's a
- 16:25wild historical moment. It is. And to understand
- 16:28why this is so radical, you really have to understand
- 16:30the context. This is the 1600s in Europe. They
- 16:34have just gone through the meat grinder of the
- 16:36Thirty Years' War. Oh, yeah. Which was essentially
- 16:39a continent -wide slaughter driven by rigid,
- 16:43dogmatic, religious differences between Catholics
- 16:47and Protestants. millions of people died over
- 16:50defined theological boundaries. The trauma of
- 16:53that era really cannot be overstated. The semiospheres,
- 16:57the atmospheric bubbles of meaning and truth
- 17:00that these different groups breathed were completely
- 17:03toxic to one another. Completely. If a Catholic
- 17:05and a Protestant interacted, it was usually,
- 17:07you know, at the end of a pike. Right. So into
- 17:10this blood -soaked environment steps Christian
- 17:12August. He is incredibly forward -thinking, and
- 17:15he decides to deliberately bring together Catholics,
- 17:18Protestants, and Jews at his court in Salzburg.
- 17:21He even sets up a printing press to publish their
- 17:23combined works. Yeah, but he didn't just invite
- 17:26them to sit around a table and debate their dogmas.
- 17:28He knew that would just lead to another war.
- 17:30Instead, he brought them together to study the
- 17:33deeply secret, esoteric knowledge of the Jewish
- 17:36Kabbalah. alongside other occult philosophies
- 17:39this is the absolute genius of the move he didn't
- 17:41ask them to compromise on their bright clearly
- 17:44defined daytime dogmas he invited them into the
- 17:47shadows wow yeah he used the shared pursuit of
- 17:50deep, complex, inherently hidden secrets as the
- 17:54foundation to foster a utopian ecumenical community.
- 17:58They were united by the fact that they were all
- 18:00seekers of the hidden truth. So they bonded over
- 18:03what they didn't fully grasp yet. Yes. The Christian
- 18:05scholars believed that hidden within the Jewish
- 18:07Kabbalah were the secret, uncorrupted truths
- 18:10of early Christianity. And the Jewish scholars
- 18:12were eager to share and elevate their mystical
- 18:15texts. It's a beautiful example of the secret
- 18:17as a bridge. Because the content of the secret
- 18:20was so obscure, so difficult to grasp, and required
- 18:23intense collaborative study across different
- 18:25languages like Hebrew, Aramaic, Latin, the actual
- 18:29process of seeking the secret forced them into
- 18:32cooperative contact. Yes, the process itself
- 18:34is what united them. They had to rely on each
- 18:36other. to decode the mystery they built a micro
- 18:40society of religious tolerance based entirely
- 18:43on the premise that none of them had the full
- 18:46transparent truth it's incredibly moving but
- 18:49unfortunately history isn't always a utopian
- 18:52court in sulzbach right more often than not religions
- 18:55don't want to hold hands and seek a shared perennial
- 18:57philosophy they want to win yeah human nature
- 19:00and that brings us to the second scenario of
- 19:04exogenous contact one secret One explanation.
- 19:08The battle for supremacy. Exactly. This is what
- 19:12happens when religions compete in a shared marketplace.
- 19:14And instead of merging or cooperating, one tradition
- 19:17aggressively tries to explain away the other
- 19:20tradition's secret. This is basically intellectual
- 19:22colonization. Right. You aren't killing the other
- 19:25group. You're just claiming that their deepest
- 19:27mystery is actually just a footnote in your theology.
- 19:30We see this vividly in the early centuries of
- 19:33the Christian church, when Christianity was trying
- 19:35to establish dominance in the Roman Empire. Right,
- 19:37because at the time, the Roman world was full
- 19:40of these incredibly popular, highly secretive
- 19:43mystery cults, like the cult of Mithras. Yeah,
- 19:46the cult of Mithras was a massive rival to early
- 19:48Christianity. They had secret initiation rites.
- 19:51They had sacred communal meals involving bread
- 19:53and wine. They had themes of salvation and rebirth.
- 19:57To an outside observer, they look uncomfortably
- 19:59similar to Christian sacraments. Very similar.
- 20:03So how did the early Christian writers handle
- 20:05this? You have a figure like Justin Martyr looking
- 20:08at the Mithraic mysteries. He doesn't say, oh,
- 20:11wow, look at this. We share a similar mystery.
- 20:13Let's achieve concrescence. No, definitely not.
- 20:15No, Justin Martyr goes on the offensive. He claims
- 20:18that the secrets of Mithras are actually demonic
- 20:20imitations. Demonic imitations. He argued that
- 20:23demons had foreseen the coming of Christ and
- 20:26they planted these fake copycat mysteries in
- 20:28the Roman world to confuse people and steal souls.
- 20:31It's a ruthless rhetorical strategy. It really
- 20:34is. Or you have writers like Lactantius who looked
- 20:37at the ancient, highly revered secrets of Hermes
- 20:41Trismegistus, which were foundational to a lot
- 20:44of Hellenistic philosophy and mysticism. Lactantius
- 20:47argued that those ancient secrets weren't demonic,
- 20:50but they were just a flawed preliminary overture.
- 20:53He claimed they were just breadcrumbs leading
- 20:55up to the true and final revelation of Jesus
- 20:58Christ. So they are dissolving the rival secret.
- 21:01By claiming to have the ultimate decoder ring.
- 21:04Precisely. Justin Martyr and Lactantius are looking
- 21:07at the pagans and saying, we know what your secret
- 21:10actually means better than you do. It's a way
- 21:13of asserting total dominance over the rival's
- 21:16meaning -making world without ever having to
- 21:18engage on its own terms. And while that's an
- 21:20aggressive strategy, there is a third scenario
- 21:22of interfaith contact that might be the most
- 21:24fascinating of all. Oh, this was my favorite.
- 21:26Yeah, this is when the contact between a religion
- 21:28and a surrounding culture actually forces the
- 21:31religion to generate a new secret. just to survive.
- 21:34I found this part of the research so compelling,
- 21:36it totally flips the script. It does. Because
- 21:39usually we think of religions slowly abandoning
- 21:42their superstitions and secrets as they become
- 21:44more modern and rational, right? That's the secularization
- 21:47theory, yes. But the research points out that
- 21:49sometimes when a religious tradition is enveloped
- 21:52by a highly rational, secular, or philosophical
- 21:55culture, it has to invent or heavily emphasize
- 21:59a secret. to avoid being completely assimilated.
- 22:02And if you look at early 20th century liberal
- 22:04Judaism, you see this exact survival mechanism
- 22:07playing out brilliantly. Okay, set the scene
- 22:09for us. You had brilliant rabbis and thinkers
- 22:11like Leo Beck and Max Wiener, and they were operating
- 22:14in the long wake of the Haskalah, which was the
- 22:17Jewish Enlightenment. For decades, the Haskalah
- 22:19had heavily emphasized reason, universal ethics,
- 22:22and rational philosophy. The goal had been to
- 22:25show that Judaism was perfectly compatible with
- 22:28modern, enlightened European thought. But thinkers
- 22:31like Leo Baik looked around and realized they
- 22:33had a massive problem. The danger was that Judaism
- 22:36was becoming too explainable. Too rational. Exactly.
- 22:40If you strip away all the mystery... all the
- 22:43paradox, and you reduce a thousands of years
- 22:46old faith only to a set of good ethical postulates
- 22:49like be kind to your neighbor and pursue justice,
- 22:52then it just dissolves into generic secular ethical
- 22:55philosophy. Right. Why be Jewish if it's the
- 22:58exact same thing as being a secular humanist?
- 23:00Exactly. It loses the very ground that supports
- 23:02it. So to counter this hyper -rationality, Baik
- 23:05and others executed a brilliant philosophical
- 23:08pivot. They aggressively re -emphasized the secret
- 23:12and the inherent unresolvable paradox of Judaism.
- 23:15You leaned into the mystery. They argued that
- 23:17true religion must contain a core that defies
- 23:20human logic. They weaponized the mystery as a
- 23:23survival mechanism. By asserting that there is
- 23:25a profound irrational secret at the heart of
- 23:28the faith, they built a fortress that secular
- 23:30rationality couldn't penetrate. They saved the
- 23:32distinct identity of the religion by plunging
- 23:34its core back into the dark. Okay, so let's synthesize
- 23:37where we are. We have seen secrets act as literal
- 23:40shields for physical survival, like Takiyah.
- 23:42We've seen them act as shared utopian projects
- 23:45in Solspach. We've seen them used as battlegrounds
- 23:48for intellectual supremacy by early Christians.
- 23:50And we've seen them utilized as life rafts against
- 23:53the rising tide of secularization in liberal
- 23:56Judaism. It's a very dynamic tool. It is. But
- 23:59I keep coming back to the listener. If you are
- 24:02listening to this deep dive and you are sitting
- 24:04in a room with someone of a totally different
- 24:06faith, say you are a Christian and they are a
- 24:10Buddhist or you are a Muslim and they are a secular
- 24:12humanist, logically it sounds like avoiding the
- 24:16deep unexplainable mysteries of your respective
- 24:18worldviews would prevent a real connection. Which
- 24:22is what we're always taught. Right. We are taught
- 24:25to find common ground. We are taught to find
- 24:26the things we can clearly define and agree on.
- 24:28How on earth do we connect over something neither
- 24:30of us can articulate? What's fascinating here
- 24:33is that the research argues the exact opposite
- 24:35of our standard intuition. Okay. The inability
- 24:37to articulate the secret is not a bug in the
- 24:40system of human communication. It is the ultimate
- 24:43feature. A feature, not a bug. Yes. The fact
- 24:46that the secret is conceptually empty of defined,
- 24:49rigid, exclusionary dogma is exactly what makes
- 24:53it the perfect interface. And this brings us
- 24:56to the conceptual core of this entire framework,
- 24:58the theory of the secret as a blank space. The
- 25:02blank space. The German word used in the research
- 25:04is Leerstell. Right. And what's wild is that
- 25:07the authors borrow this concept not from theology,
- 25:10but from a literary theorist named Wolfgang Eiser.
- 25:13Now, Iser wasn't writing about religion at all.
- 25:15He was writing about how human beings read books.
- 25:17Right, literary theory. And Iser argued that
- 25:20in any piece of literature, there are blank spaces,
- 25:22things the author deliberately leaves unsaid,
- 25:25undetermined gaps in the narrative. Think about
- 25:27reading a novel. The author doesn't describe
- 25:30every single leaf on a tree or every single microscopic
- 25:32facial expression of a character. They leave
- 25:35gaps. And Iser pointed out that these blank spaces
- 25:37aren't just empty voids where the author got
- 25:39lazy. They are an active, highly charged matrix.
- 25:44They are the elementary conditions of communication
- 25:47because they force the reader to use their own
- 25:49imagination, their own memories, their own life
- 25:53experience to connect the dots. The blank space
- 25:55invites the reader into the text to co -create
- 25:58the meaning. Exactly. If the author explains
- 26:00every single detail, the reader is just a passive
- 26:03observer. But if there is a blank space, the
- 26:06reader has to step up and participate. Precisely.
- 26:09And the absolute genius of Reichling and Schrunkel's
- 26:12work is taking Iser's literary theory and applying
- 26:15it directly to religious secrecy. It's a huge
- 26:18conceptual leap. It is. They argue that a religious
- 26:21secret acts as a linguistic and conceptual blank
- 26:23space. It is an empty frame. By lightly declaring
- 26:26this is our deepest unutterable secret, a religion
- 26:29is conspicuously indicating that something is
- 26:31absent from everyday language and understanding.
- 26:33But because that frame is technically empty of
- 26:36rigid, easily debated dogma, It actually invites
- 26:39the other tradition to step up, look at the frame,
- 26:42and relate to it using their own vocabulary.
- 26:45To help us visualize this, because it's a heavy
- 26:47concept, the research uses a brilliant analogy
- 26:50from art history, the hitomasia, or the empty
- 26:54throne. Oh, this is such a good visual. Right.
- 26:56If you look at religious and political art across
- 26:59vastly different cultures throughout history,
- 27:01you see this recurring motif of an unoccupied
- 27:05seat of power. It's everywhere once you know
- 27:08to look for it. Let's look at Buddhist art. You
- 27:10might see an intricately carved beautiful throne
- 27:13with absolutely no one sitting on it, perhaps
- 27:15just a set of footprints resting on the footstool.
- 27:17Right. In that specific cultural context, the
- 27:20empty throne symbolizes the Buddha's enlightenment,
- 27:22his absolute transcending of the physical form
- 27:25into nirvana. But then if you travel across the
- 27:28world and look at Roman art from a similar period,
- 27:30you see another empty throne. Maybe this one
- 27:32is draped to the specific purple cloths or has
- 27:34a diadem resting on it. In the Roman context,
- 27:37that empty throne. symbolizes the invisible,
- 27:40omnipresent, unchallengeable power of the emperor.
- 27:44And if you move forward in time and look at early
- 27:46Christian Byzantine art, you see the exact same
- 27:49visual, an empty throne, perhaps with the cross
- 27:52or a book of gospels resting on the cushion.
- 27:54And what does it mean there? In Christian theology,
- 27:56this symbolizes the parousia. the intense apocalyptic
- 28:00anticipation of christ's return to judge the
- 28:03living and the dead so it is the exact same visual
- 28:06nimble an empty chair right but because the throne
- 28:09is empty because the central defining figure
- 28:11is missing because it's a literal blank space
- 28:14It acts as a universal interface. Different faiths,
- 28:18different empires, different worldviews can look
- 28:20at the exact same image, the exact same blank
- 28:22space, and translate it perfectly into their
- 28:24own spiritual or political vocabulary without
- 28:26violating the image itself. Mark Tawin, a scholar
- 28:29cited in the research who studies Japanese religion,
- 28:31has a wonderful way of describing this dynamic.
- 28:33He calls the secret a vacuum displayed in a conspicuous
- 28:37place. A vacuum? Yeah. And because nature and
- 28:40human psychology abhors a vacuum, this conspicuously
- 28:44placed blank space has what he calls a black
- 28:48hole potency. A black hole potency. It irresistibly
- 28:52attracts people, theories, and interpretations
- 28:54from all sides. It pulls you in because you naturally
- 28:57desperately want to fill the void with meaning.
- 28:59I was trying to think of an everyday analogy
- 29:01for this, something that clicks instantly and
- 29:03it hit me. It's exactly like a blank tile in
- 29:06a game of Scrabble. Oh, I love that. Let's break
- 29:08that down. Think about how Scrabble works. Every
- 29:10other letter in the bag has a rigidly defined
- 29:13value and identity. An A is an A. A Q is a Q.
- 29:16They are dogmatic. Right. They can only be played
- 29:18in specific, limited ways. If I have a Z and
- 29:21you have an X and we are trying to build a word
- 29:23together, we are probably going to clash. The
- 29:25linguistic structures are too rigid, too incompatible.
- 29:27That is a phenomenal analogy. The rigid letters
- 29:30are the defined dogmas of a religion. The dietary
- 29:33laws, the historical claims, the specific rituals.
- 29:36Exactly. But the blank tile has no inherent letter
- 29:40printed on it. It has no strict identity. And
- 29:43because it is completely empty, because it is
- 29:45a Leerstell, it can be whatever letter the player
- 29:49needs it to be to connect their word to the rest
- 29:51of the board. It adapts. The blank tile is the
- 29:54ultimate interface. The secret, the mystery,
- 29:57is the blank tile of interface dialogue. It allows
- 30:01two entirely different words, two entirely different
- 30:03worldviews to intersect on the board. And this
- 30:06leads us to the most profound relevation of this
- 30:08entire framework. What happens when two different
- 30:11religious traditions essentially play their brank
- 30:13tiles at the exact same time? Right. We get a
- 30:16dynamic process of coming together, of shared
- 30:18meaning making that doesn't erase the distinctiveness
- 30:21of either tradition. Which brings us to the final
- 30:23major concept of the research. And it's a word
- 30:26we really need to unpack carefully. Concrescence.
- 30:29The authors specifically. and firmly warn us
- 30:32against using the word hybridization when we
- 30:34talk about this kind of interfaith contact. Yes,
- 30:36they do. Why is hybridization a dirty word in
- 30:39this context? Because hybridization implies mashing
- 30:43two distinct things together into a diluted soup.
- 30:46It implies a compromise where both sides lose
- 30:49a bit of their unique historical identity to
- 30:52form a new, generic, watered -down middle ground.
- 30:56And religions hate that. religious traditions
- 30:58generally hate that idea yes they don't want
- 31:00to be diluted they believe the revelation is
- 31:02true so the authors borrow a term from the philosopher
- 31:05alfred north whitehead Compressors. Yes. It translates
- 31:11literally to growing together. Whitehead defined
- 31:14it as the production of novel togetherness. Novel
- 31:16togetherness. It's like two distinct vines growing
- 31:19up the same trellis. The distinct religions remain
- 31:21entirely distinct. They keep their own leaves,
- 31:24their own roots, their own rigid scrabble letters.
- 31:26But they grow together by connecting at the interface
- 31:29of their shared blank spaces. They touch without
- 31:32merging. They create a new field of mutual understanding
- 31:35without destroying their original borders. OK,
- 31:38let's look at how this concrescence actually
- 31:39works in the real world, because the research
- 31:41gives us two mind blowing historical case studies
- 31:44where we can see the blank tile being played.
- 31:47OK, let's do it. The first is the story of Muhammad
- 31:49Darashikis in the 17th century. Ah, yes. This
- 31:54is one of the most remarkable and ultimately
- 31:56tragic figures in religious history. Dara Shikash
- 31:59was a devout Muslim prince, the favored son of
- 32:02the Mughal emperor Shah Jahan, the man who built
- 32:05the Taj Mahal. Right. He was the heir apparent
- 32:08to an empire in India where Orthodox Islam and
- 32:11deeply rooted Hinduism were living side by side,
- 32:14often in deep tension. His younger brother, Arun
- 32:17Zeb, was a strict Orthodox conservative who believed
- 32:20the two faiths must remain entirely separate.
- 32:23But Dara Shik believes something different. Very
- 32:25different. He didn't try to force the two religions
- 32:28to hybridize into a generic soup. Instead, he
- 32:30looked for the blank spaces. He did something
- 32:33incredibly ambitious and dangerous. He gathered
- 32:36Hindu scholars and mystics, and he translated
- 32:3850 of the Hindu Upanishads, their most deeply
- 32:41philosophical, mystical, esoteric text, from
- 32:44Sanskrit into Persian, which was the language
- 32:47of the Muslim court. A massive undertaking. And
- 32:49he called his translation Sir A. Akbar, which
- 32:52translates to The Great Secret. And his method
- 32:55of translation is exactly what we've been talking
- 32:57about today. He didn't try to align the rigid
- 32:59dogmas. He didn't try to argue that the Hindu
- 33:02gods were the same as Islamic prophets. Right.
- 33:04He used the secret spiritual meaning as his interface.
- 33:07He played the blank tile. In his introduction
- 33:10to the translation, Darashiku argued that the
- 33:13Upanishads were, in fact, the hidden secret book
- 33:17that is mysteriously referred to within the Quran
- 33:20itself. Let's just pause and appreciate the sheer
- 33:22intellectual audacity of that move. It's staggering.
- 33:27unutterable secret of hinduism the mystical concept
- 33:31of advaita vedanta the ultimate oneness of reality
- 33:34and mapped it directly onto the unutterable hidden
- 33:37references within orthodox islam the concept
- 33:40of tahit the absolute oneness of god yes he used
- 33:43the secret as the bridge by doing so he allowed
- 33:46these two massive semiospheres to achieve congressman's
- 33:49they could remain distinct A Muslim remained
- 33:52a Muslim, a Hindu remained a Hindu, but they
- 33:54now had a shared interface, a shared blank space
- 33:56where they could actually converse about the
- 33:58ultimate hidden nature of reality. He proved
- 34:00that the mystery wasn't a wall, it was a door.
- 34:03Unfortunately, history is brutal. His Orthodox
- 34:06brother, Oran Zeb, defeated him in a war of succession,
- 34:10had Darashikas executed for heresy, and instituted
- 34:14a deeply intolerant regime. It's heartbreaking.
- 34:17It is. But Darashika's intellectual achievement,
- 34:20his translation, survived and had a massive impact
- 34:23on how Eastern philosophy was eventually understood
- 34:25in the West. And that leads us to the research's
- 34:27culminating example of this process. It is perhaps
- 34:30one of the most famous encounters in Western
- 34:32religious history. And it perfectly illustrates
- 34:34playing the blank scrabble tile, the Apostle
- 34:37Paul, at the Areopagus in Athens, as recorded
- 34:40in the book of Acts, chapter 17. This is an absolute
- 34:42masterclass in reading the sociology of secrecy.
- 34:45To set the scene, Paul is a devout Jewish Christian
- 34:48steeped in the Hebrew scriptures and the new
- 34:50revelation of Christ. He walks into Athens. Now,
- 34:53Athens at this time is the intellectual, philosophical
- 34:56and religious center of the Hellenistic world.
- 34:59It is crawling with Epicurean and Stoic philosophers.
- 35:02It is a city that loves to debate, but it is
- 35:05also a city steeped in anxiety. Right. They are
- 35:08absolutely covered in idols and temples to a
- 35:10thousand different strictly defined Greek gods.
- 35:13Zeus, Athena, Hermes, every god has a specific
- 35:17domain, a specific rigid letter in their alphabet.
- 35:20And Paul is deeply distressed by this. He looks
- 35:22around and from his perspective, it's a city
- 35:25drowning in idolatry. Now, if Paul had just walked
- 35:28into the marketplace and started arguing dogma,
- 35:30if he had just started slamming his rigid letters
- 35:32down on the board saying, your use is a fake,
- 35:35my... God is the only real God. Let me explain
- 35:38the theology of the cross. He would have hit
- 35:40a brick wall. The Athenian philosophers would
- 35:43have just dismissed him as a babbler. The semiospheres
- 35:45were too incompatible. But Paul is brilliant.
- 35:48He surveys the city and he looks past all the
- 35:50rigid dogmas. He looks for a gap. And he finds
- 35:53a literal, physical blank space in the Greek
- 35:55religious framework. He finds an altar with a
- 35:58very specific, curious inscription. To the unknown
- 36:01God. To the unknown God. It's the ultimate Hedoimasia,
- 36:06the ultimate empty throne. The Greeks, in their
- 36:09deep anxiety to cover all their bases and not
- 36:11accidentally offend some powerful deity they
- 36:14might have missed in their massive pantheon,
- 36:16had built an altar to a god they explicitly admitted
- 36:18they knew absolutely nothing about. It was a
- 36:21monument to a secret? Yes. It was an empty frame.
- 36:24It was a vacuum displayed in a conspicuous place.
- 36:26And Paul seizes on this black hole potency. He
- 36:30stands up at the Areopagus, the high court of
- 36:32Athens, and he uses this exact blank space as
- 36:35his interface. He says, for as I pass by and
- 36:38beheld your diversions, I found an altar with
- 36:41this inscription, to the unknown God, whom therefore
- 36:44ye ignorantly worship, him declare I unto you.
- 36:47He plays the blank tile. He doesn't aggressively
- 36:50destroy the Greek framework. He utilizes its
- 36:52own acknowledged gap. He essentially says, that
- 36:55blank space you've left open, that mystery you
- 36:57admit you can't articulate, I have the vocabulary
- 36:59for that. He takes the secret of the Christian
- 37:01gospel, the mystery of Christ, which was entirely
- 37:04foreign and nonsensical to Greek philosophy,
- 37:07and he translates it directly into the blank
- 37:10space provided by the Athenian altar. He achieves
- 37:14concrescence by connecting his unutterable truth
- 37:17to their acknowledged mystery. It's a flawless
- 37:20execution of what we've been discussing. He doesn't
- 37:22hybridize Christianity with worship of Zeus.
- 37:25He finds the boundary where Greek rationality
- 37:27fails, where they admit a secret exists, and
- 37:30he builds this bridge right there. If we connect
- 37:32this to the bigger picture. to what this all
- 37:35means for you, the listener, because it completely
- 37:37changes how we might approach conversations with
- 37:39people who hold fundamentally different worldviews.
- 37:42Oh, absolutely. In modern interfaith dialogue
- 37:44or even just an everyday political or social
- 37:46discourse, we spend almost all our energy trying
- 37:49to find common ground in the bright light of
- 37:51day. We compare our rules, our ethical codes,
- 37:54our historical facts. We try to find the things
- 37:56we can clearly articulate and agree upon. We
- 37:59keep trying to match up our rigid Scrabble letters.
- 38:01and while establishing basic ethical common ground
- 38:03is important for a functioning society this research
- 38:06suggests that true profound connection the kind
- 38:10that builds lasting bridges between entirely
- 38:12different meaning -making worlds often happens
- 38:15not in the bright light of defined dogma but
- 38:18in the shared shadows of the ineffable it happens
- 38:21in the blank spaces exactly acknowledging that
- 38:24we both have mysteries we cannot explain that
- 38:26we both possess secrets that defy our own language
- 38:29actually provides strongest possible bond. Wow.
- 38:32The shared experience of awe before the unknown
- 38:35is a more universal language than any specific
- 38:38theology. When the Muslim prince and the Hindi
- 38:41mystic or the Christian apostle and the Greek
- 38:43philosopher admit that the universe contains
- 38:45a mysterium they cannot fully master, they suddenly
- 38:48have a place to stand together. It's a profound
- 38:50realization. We started this deep dive by looking
- 38:53at secrets as annoying obstacles. We saw them
- 38:56as the enemies of science and transparency, as
- 38:58Cicelo Bach pointed out with her concept of ritualistic
- 39:01denunciation. We saw them as typical tools for
- 39:04social exclusion and egoistic isolation. as George
- 39:07Simmel argued, the heavy oak doors built to keep
- 39:10the profane masses out. But by diving deep into
- 39:13the actual history of religious contact, from
- 39:15the eclectic scholars at the 17th century Solspot
- 39:18Court finding a perennial philosophy, to Dara
- 39:21Shiko translating the Upanishads as the Great
- 39:24Secret, to Paul preaching in the shadow of the
- 39:27Parthenon, we discovered that those oak doors
- 39:29operate much more like a revolving door. And
- 39:33even more profoundly, they operate as dynamic
- 39:35currencies. They are the blank scrabble tiles.
- 39:38They are the empty thrones. Empty thrones that
- 39:40have historically allowed totally different traditions
- 39:42to translate their deepest truths to one another
- 39:44without losing their own souls in the process.
- 39:47It requires a massive shift in perspective. It
- 39:49requires humility and an acceptance that the
- 39:52most important parts of our identity, the core
- 39:54of our worldview, might be the parts we have
- 39:56the least vocabulary for. And that isn't a weakness.
- 39:59It's the very thing that allows us to connect
- 40:01with the other. So the next time you encounter
- 40:03someone from a totally different background,
- 40:06different faith or a wildly different worldview,
- 40:08maybe don't start the conversation by demanding
- 40:11they explain everything perfectly. Don't start
- 40:14by comparing your rigid letters and arguing over
- 40:16who has the better alphabet. Definitely not.
- 40:18Maybe ask them what they can't explain. Look
- 40:21for their blank spaces. Look for their altars
- 40:23to the unknown. And offer up your own mysteries
- 40:26in return. You might find that the very things
- 40:30you thought were walls are actually the only
- 40:32bridges that can reach across the divide. It's
- 40:34a transformative way to view human communication.
- 40:37We leave you with this final, provocative thought
- 40:40to mull over. We live in an age, the digital
- 40:43age, the information age, that aggressively demands
- 40:46total transparency. We do. We expect every institution,
- 40:49every tradition, and every individual to be fully
- 40:52laid bare, totally categorized. And explained
- 40:54in simple, bite -sized, rational terms. We want
- 40:58all the lights turned on all the time. Transparency
- 41:01is our modern dogma. But if this research is
- 41:04right, if secrets, mysteries, and the unexplainable
- 41:07are the very blank spaces that allow human beings
- 41:11to connect across vast cultural and spiritual
- 41:13divides, what happens to our ability to truly
- 41:16understand each other? when we successfully eradicate
- 41:19all the secrets. If we light up every shadow,
- 41:21we might find we have lost the very canvas on
- 41:24which we draw our connections. Something to think
- 41:26about. Until next time.