Latest / SWOP Behind Bars Advocacy from the Margins / When Pregnancy Becomes Evidence: Hospitals, Police, and Privacy
Transcript
- 0:00The Pregnancy Police, When a Medical Crisis Becomes Potential Evidence At what
- 0:04point did a pregnancy become potential evidence?
- 0:07A woman miscarries at home and goes to the emergency room.
- 0:11A pregnant patient tells her doctor she has been using drugs and wants help.
- 0:15Someone manages an abortion outside the formal medical system and later seeks
- 0:19care because she is bleeding.
- 0:21A woman delivers a stillborn baby and suddenly finds herself answering questions
- 0:26not only from doctors but from police.
- 0:28None of those situations necessarily begins as a crime, but increasingly,
- 0:33that does not mean they remain outside the criminal legal system.
- 0:36Pregnancy Justice documented at least 412 criminal cases related to pregnancy,
- 0:42pregnancy loss, or birth, during the first two years after Dobbs,
- 0:46from June 2022 through June 2024.
- 0:50Its earlier research identified nearly 1,400 cases of pregnancy-related criminalization
- 0:55between 2006 and the reversal of Roe.
- 0:59Importantly, the cases are not limited to abortion. Pregnancy loss,
- 1:03birth, and allegations of substance use during pregnancy make up a substantial
- 1:08part of the landscape pregnancy justice has documented.
- 1:11That should force us to think about reproductive health in a different way.
- 1:15The question is no longer only whether someone can obtain an abortion.
- 1:19It is also whether pregnancy itself can change how the law sees her.
- 1:24When the patient becomes the suspect, medicine depends on information.
- 1:28Doctors need patients to tell them what happened, what they took,
- 1:31what symptoms they experienced, and what they are afraid to say out loud.
- 1:36That is especially important during a miscarriage, overdose,
- 1:39pregnancy complication, or psychiatric crisis.
- 1:43Criminalization changes that relationship. If someone believes that admitting
- 1:47drug use could trigger a child welfare investigation,
- 1:50that a pregnancy loss might be questioned, or that information disclosed during
- 1:55emergency treatment could eventually become part of a criminal investigation,
- 1:59telling the complete truth no longer feels like a purely medical decision,
- 2:03it becomes a legal calculation.
- 2:05That concern is not hypothetical, if, when, how identified 61 cases between 2000 and 2020
- 2:13in which people were criminally investigated or arrested for allegedly self-managing
- 2:18an abortion or helping someone else do so across 26 states.
- 2:22Its research found that police were often brought into cases by people the patient
- 2:26encountered or trusted, including health care providers, social workers, and acquaintances.
- 2:32The organization also makes an important distinction that is often lost in public debate.
- 2:37People have faced criminal investigation even where the conduct prosecutors
- 2:41were examining was not itself expressly prohibited by an abortion statute.
- 2:46Existing criminal laws can be interpreted or repurposed in pregnancy-related cases.
- 2:52That is how a healthcare encounter can begin to look like evidence collection.
- 2:56Fetal personhood changes more than abortion.
- 2:58One of the legal ideas shaping this landscape is sometimes described as fetal
- 3:02or prenatal personhood, extending legal recognition or protections to embryos
- 3:08or fetuses in ways that may affect the pregnant person's legal rights and obligations.
- 3:13The implications can extend far beyond an abortion clinic. Pregnancy Justice
- 3:17reports that prosecutors have used child neglect, child endangerment,
- 3:21and other criminal laws in cases involving substance use, pregnancy loss, and birth.
- 3:27In its analysis of cases between 2006 and 2022, more than three-quarters of
- 3:33the cases occurred in a relatively small group of states that had expanded legal
- 3:37definitions to include fetuses, embryos, or fertilized eggs.
- 3:42The legal landscape continues to evolve. Pregnancy justice reviewed more than
- 3:46730 bills during the 2025-2026 legislative sessions,
- 3:51and identified proposals both expanding prenatal personhood concepts and in
- 3:56other states, attempting to strengthen protections for pregnant people,
- 4:00including people with substance use disorders or adverse pregnancy outcomes.
- 4:04That matters because once the fetus is treated as a potential victim independent
- 4:08of the pregnant patient, ordinary medical behavior can be examined through a
- 4:12criminal lens. What did she take?
- 4:15Did she follow medical advice? Did she use drugs? When did she know she was pregnant?
- 4:20Where did the miscarriage occur? What did she do with the remains?
- 4:24Why did she wait before seeking medical attention? Pregnancy justice reported
- 4:28in 2026 that people have been investigated or prosecuted following pregnancy
- 4:33laws for conduct as varied as miscarrying in a toilet,
- 4:36burying fetal remains, disposing of remains, or bringing them to a hospital.
- 4:41At some point, we have to ask what happens to healthcare when grief itself can
- 4:46become something a person may later have to explain to police.
- 4:49The hospital is not always a wall between you and the state.
- 4:52Many people assume medical privacy means that whatever happens inside a hospital stays there.
- 4:57The reality is more complicated. HIPAA generally protects medical information,
- 5:01but it also allows disclosure of protected health information through legal
- 5:05processes such as court orders, warrants, subpoenas, and certain other law enforcement requests.
- 5:12HHS also states that providers generally are not automatically required to report
- 5:16someone to police simply because they suspect a self-managed pregnancy loss.
- 5:21Federal reproductive health privacy protections have themselves been contested.
- 5:26A 2024 federal rule created additional protections for certain reproductive
- 5:30health information, but a federal court in Texas vacated most of the rule in June 2025. 5.
- 5:37HS continues to provide guidance on the underlying HEPA protections and limits
- 5:42governing disclosures.
- 5:44The legal details matter, but so does the patient's perception.
- 5:48If people believe going to the hospital might expose them to police,
- 5:52child welfare authorities, or prosecution, some will delay care.
- 5:56And delayed care is not an abstraction when someone is hemorrhaging,
- 5:59experiencing an infection, withdrawing from drugs, or suffering a pregnancy complication.
- 6:05Privacy is therefore not merely a civil liberties issue.
- 6:09It can become a patient safety issue. Punishing substance use does not treat it.
- 6:13The clearest example may be substance
- 6:15use during pregnancy. Substance use disorder is a health condition.
- 6:19Yet pregnancy can change the legal consequences attached to it.
- 6:23Some states treat prenatal substance exposure as grounds for child welfare intervention
- 6:28or impose reporting requirements, creating circumstances in which disclosure
- 6:33to a medical professional may lead to consequences outside the examination room.
- 6:37The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists opposes punitive approaches
- 6:42to substance use during pregnancy,
- 6:45and argues that education, prevention, and community-based treatment are more
- 6:49appropriate than criminal prosecution or punitive testing and reporting.
- 6:54ACOG also warns that fear of consequences can interfere with prenatal care and
- 6:59honest communication between patients and clinicians.
- 7:02That should not be difficult to understand. If asking for help may cost someone
- 7:06her freedom or her children, the system has created a powerful incentive not to ask.
- 7:12The result can be exactly the opposite of what the policy supposedly seeks.
- 7:16Less disclosure, less treatment, and greater danger.
- 7:20This pattern is familiar. This is where the issue intersects with swap behind
- 7:24bars work. Sex work and pregnancy are not the same.
- 7:27Trafficking, abortion, drug use, and miscarriage are not interchangeable experiences,
- 7:33and we should not pretend they are.
- 7:35But the architecture of criminalization can look remarkably familiar.
- 7:39A social or medical problem is identified. Meaningful services are inadequate.
- 7:44Criminal law becomes the substitute.
- 7:46People with the fewest resources experience enforcement most intensely.
- 7:51We have watched that happen around sex work.
- 7:53Instead of housing, we get policing.
- 7:56Instead of economic support, we get arrests. Instead of accessible health care, we get surveillance.
- 8:03Instead of listening to the people living inside complicated circumstances,
- 8:07institutions decide that punishment is the intervention.
- 8:10Pregnancy criminalization raises the same fundamental problem.
- 8:14Once police, prosecutors, and courts become the default response to health and
- 8:18social problems, every interaction begins to change.
- 8:22People hide information. They avoid institutions.
- 8:25Professionals become potential reporters. Medical records become potential evidence.
- 8:30And people who already live closest to poverty, racism, unstable housing,
- 8:35incarceration, substance use, and heavily policed communities have the least
- 8:40room to absorb the consequences when something goes wrong.
- 8:43Care before criminalization. This does not mean every pregnancy-related death,
- 8:47stillbirth, or injury should be beyond investigation.
- 8:51There will always be circumstances in which authorities investigate suspected crimes.
- 8:56But investigation should not become the default explanation for pregnancy loss.
- 9:00Addiction should not become more punishable because the person experiencing it is pregnant.
- 9:05A miscarriage should not automatically invite suspicion, and someone entering
- 9:10an emergency room should not have to calculate whether telling a doctor the
- 9:13truth could eventually help build a case against her.
- 9:17The health care system cannot function well when patients see doctors as possible gateways to police.
- 9:23The criminal legal system cannot repair gaps in addiction treatment,
- 9:26prenatal care, mental health services, housing, or economic support.
- 9:31It can punish people after those systems fail them. That is not the same thing.
- 9:35The question we should keep asking is simple.
- 9:38When someone experiences a pregnancy crisis, what do we want her first thought to be?
- 9:42I need medical help. Or, could I get arrested for telling someone what happened?
- 9:47Women have spent years watching what happens when punishment is offered as a substitute for care.
- 9:52Pregnancy criminalization gives us another reason to insist on the opposite approach.
- 9:57Care before crisis. Services before surveillance. Support before punishment.
- 10:02Because a hospital should be somewhere you go to save your life.
- 10:05Not somewhere you're afraid you may have to defend it.