Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Negotiate a Severance Package
Transcript
- Lucas: You get laid off. A week of shock, a few sleepless nights, and then HR slides a piece of paper across the table: your severance offer. Most people sign it because they just want the pain to end. But that piece of paper is a negotiation — and you probably have more leverage than you think. Luna: It feels so final in the moment. Like, they already took your job, you don't want to fight for scraps. Lucas: Right. And that's exactly what they're counting on. So let's take a real example. A marketing manager at a midsize B2B software company — let's call her Jenna — was laid off in a restructuring round. The initial offer was two weeks of severance pay, plus COBRA coverage for one month. Standard boilerplate. She was forty-two, had been there four years, and had just bought a house. Luna: Two weeks for four years of work? That's brutal. Lucas: It is. But here's the thing: the company was in a hiring freeze, and they needed to reduce headcount quickly to satisfy their board. That gave her leverage. She asked for a week to review the agreement, which is a reasonable request — and legally, under the Older Workers Benefit Protection Act, if you're over forty, you're entitled to at least twenty-one days to consider a waiver of claims. So she bought time. Luna: And what did she do with that week? Lucas: She called an employment lawyer — cost her about four hundred dollars for a one-hour consultation. The lawyer identified three things. First, the general release of claims was overly broad. Second, the non-disparagement clause prevented her from saying anything negative about the company, even in a private reference check. Third, she had unvested stock options that would expire ninety days after termination. Luna: The non-disparagement clause is a big one. I know someone who signed one and then couldn't even tell a recruiter why she left. Lucas: Exactly. So Jenna went back with a counterproposal. She asked for three months of severance — which is roughly one month per year of service, a common benchmark. She asked for COBRA to be fully paid for six months. She asked for the non-disparagement clause to be narrowed to only cover intentional false statements. And she asked for her unvested options to accelerate vesting, or at least extend the exercise window to twelve months. Luna: That's a pretty aggressive ask. Did they just laugh her out of the room? Lucas: They came back at eight weeks of severance, three months of COBRA, and a six-month option extension. She countered again at ten weeks and four months of COBRA. They settled at ten weeks, four months of COBRA, and a nine-month option extension. That's roughly eighteen thousand dollars more in cash value plus the option window. And the non-disparagement clause was narrowed. Luna: So she ended up with more than double the original severance. That's a huge win in a situation where most people just take what's offered. Lucas: And she did it without burning the relationship. The HR contact actually thanked her for being professional. That's the key: you're not adversarial, you're just asking for what's fair. The company has an interest in a clean, quiet exit too. Luna: What are the other common leverage points people miss? Lucas: Outplacement services. Many companies offer a six-week career coaching program, but they'll often extend it to twelve weeks if you ask. Also, a flexible end date. If you're being laid off in a group, they might want everyone out by Friday. But if you ask to stay on payroll an extra two weeks — even without working — that's two more weeks of health insurance and a later start date for your unemployment clock. Luna: And unemployment — does signing a severance affect that? Lucas: It can. In many states, severance pay counts as wages and can delay the start of unemployment benefits. So if you have a choice between a lump sum and salary continuation, salary continuation might be better because it stretches the income and keeps you on the company's health plan longer. But you have to check your state's rules. That's another reason to talk to a lawyer. Luna: Okay, so let's say someone gets laid off tomorrow. What's the immediate action plan? Lucas: Step one: don't sign anything in the room. Say 'Thank you, I need time to review this.' Step two: ask for a copy of the employee handbook and any stock plan documents. Step three: call a lawyer — or at least check if your company offers a legal benefit through an EAP. Step four: inventory what you have — unvested stock, bonuses, unused vacation time. Step five: figure out your minimum acceptable outcome before you counter. Luna: And what about the emotional side? It's hard to negotiate when you feel like you've been punched in the gut. Lucas: That's the hardest part. I think it helps to frame it as a business transaction. The company made a business decision to let you go. Now you're making a business decision about the terms. It's not personal. And they expect you to negotiate — HR negotiates these things every day. The person who stays quiet is the exception. Luna: Speaking of business decisions, I want to mention something that a few listeners have asked about. If we've helped you think through a career move or a tough conversation like this one, there's a way to keep the show ad-free and sustainable. A small group of listeners already chips in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's literally what funds making this many episodes possible. No pressure, but if it's useful, that's how it works. Lucas: Yeah, and we appreciate every single person who does that. It lets us keep the episodes focused on the advice, not on selling you something. Alright, back to severance — one more thing I think is worth covering. The general release of claims. Luna: What is that exactly? Lucas: It's a paragraph where you agree not to sue the company for anything — discrimination, harassment, wrongful termination, breach of contract. In exchange, they give you the severance. But the scope matters. Some releases try to waive claims you don't even know about yet. A good lawyer can narrow it to claims arising from your employment only, or exclude certain claims like vested benefits or unemployment. Luna: So you're not giving up your right to collect your 401k or file for unemployment. Lucas: Exactly. And if you're over forty, the release also has to comply with the OWBPA, which requires you to be given at least twenty-one days to decide and seven days to revoke after signing. If the company doesn't follow those rules, the release might be invalid. That's a big protection. Luna: What about severance for people who are laid off in a group? Does that change the negotiation? Lucas: It does, because group layoffs often come with a standard formula — like two weeks per year of service, capped at twelve weeks. But even then, you can negotiate. If you have specialized knowledge or a unique role, you might argue that your departure creates more risk for the company, so a higher severance is warranted. Also, if the company is trying to avoid a class-action lawsuit, they may be more willing to sweeten individual deals to keep things quiet. Luna: So the more inconvenient you can make it for them, the more leverage you have. Lucas: Within reason. You don't want to threaten them. But you can point out, factually, that you have access to confidential information, or that your departure could disrupt a key client relationship. Those are legitimate business risks they might want to mitigate. Luna: Let's talk about references. Can you negotiate for a good reference? Lucas: Absolutely. You can ask for a pre-agreed reference statement in writing. Something like: 'Jenna was a valued employee who contributed to X project and left due to a restructuring.' That way, when a future employer calls, HR sticks to that script. You can also negotiate that the company will not contest unemployment benefits — that's a big one. Luna: I've also heard of people negotiating for a longer end date to line up with a new job start. Lucas: Yes, if you're close to landing something, ask to stay on payroll an extra two or three weeks. It keeps your health insurance active and gives you a clean transition. The company might say no, but it costs them almost nothing. And if you've been a good employee, they often agree. Luna: Alright, so we've covered the big pieces: don't sign right away, get a lawyer, ask for more time, negotiate the release, COBRA, equity, reference. Anything else? Lucas: One more: if you have unused vacation time, make sure you get paid for it. Some states require payout by law, but others don't. In those states, you need to negotiate it into the severance. Also, check if there are any bonuses you've earned but haven't been paid — like a quarterly or annual bonus. You can argue that you should receive a prorated amount. Luna: So the checklist is: severance weeks, COBRA, equity, vacation, bonus, reference, non-disparagement, and release scope. That's a lot, but it's all on the table. Lucas: It is. And the key is to prioritize. You might not get everything, but if you go in knowing your top three, you can trade the lesser items. For example, if they won't budge on severance weeks, maybe they'll extend COBRA or give you outplacement. Be flexible but know your floor. Luna: I think the biggest takeaway is that you have more power than you feel in that moment. A layoff is not a personal judgment — it's a budget line item. And you can negotiate a better exit. Lucas: Exactly. And if you do it right, you walk away with dignity and a better financial cushion. That makes the next job search a lot less desperate.