Latest / 🔴SPORTS JEDI NETWORK, MAY THE SPORTS BE WITH YOU! / Mining in Space: Who Owns the Moon and Asteroids? | Space Law Expert Güneş Ünüvar
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: © transcript Emily.
- 0:20Speaker 2: Beynon Welcome, everyone, to Garden of Thought, the weirder show
- 0:33Speaker 2: on the Sports Jedi Media Network and the Sports Jedi
- 0:36Speaker 2: Network everywhere else. Of course, the most normal show on
- 0:38Speaker 2: the Garden of Thought Network because it's the only show
- 0:41Speaker 2: on the Garden of Thought Network, unless you count the
- 0:44Speaker 2: Gospel of Thomas Book of Black and things like that.
- 0:46Speaker 2: But they're also, you know, sort of not normal. Anyway,
- 0:49Speaker 2: we're going back into the world of law, but we're
- 0:51Speaker 2: going beyond the world. We're going, well, still intrastellar, but
- 0:56Speaker 2: let's see where it takes us. My guest today is
- 0:59Speaker 2: Ganesh Unnavar. I hope I did that even close to proper. Perfect.
- 1:05Speaker 2: Thank you. He is a senior lecturer in law at
- 1:08Speaker 2: the University of Exeter in Britain. Yes, that Exeter, not
- 1:12Speaker 2: the private school in New England. So we're going all
- 1:14Speaker 2: the way. Legal advisor, Moon Village Association, managing editor of
- 1:19Speaker 2: the Journal of World Investment and Trade, Space Law Policy,
- 1:23Speaker 2: and International Law.
- 1:25Speaker 3: Okay.
- 1:25Speaker 2: We're going straight to the top here. A, we're going
- 1:28Speaker 2: to Britain, which obviously adds class and dignity and authority
- 1:33Speaker 2: to everything. And the titular topic today is space law
- 1:39Speaker 2: involved in mining and harvesting resources, which, you know, doesn't
- 1:44Speaker 2: necessarily mean mining, but we'll use mining as shorthand. But first,
- 1:48Speaker 2: we're going to welcome our guests. Should I call you professor?
- 1:51Speaker 4: You can just call me Ganesh if that's not a
- 1:54Speaker 4: bother to pronounce my name repeatedly.
- 1:57Speaker 2: I can say Ganesh. Perfect. I am very versatile. That's
- 2:02Speaker 2: what I tell people. I'm strangely versatile. So, yes, thank you, Ganesh,
- 2:05Speaker 2: for being here. Please correct and embellish upon any introduction
- 2:09Speaker 2: I gave or tell anyone your background story if you like.
- 2:13Speaker 4: I mean, that was a very great summary, actually, Jeff.
- 2:16Speaker 4: Thank you so much also for having me on this show. Indeed,
- 2:21Speaker 4: I'm currently a senior lecturer at the University of Exeter
- 2:25Speaker 4: Law School. I work on international space law, European space law.
- 2:32Speaker 4: Prior to my current position in Exeter, I was in
- 2:37Speaker 4: Luxembourg actually, which is very much the country that sort
- 2:42Speaker 4: of catapulted me into the space resources business. So I
- 2:47Speaker 4: spent some years there. But, I mean, I actually come
- 2:51Speaker 4: from a very different legal background. It wasn't space law
- 2:54Speaker 4: at all. It was about a decade or so. But
- 2:58Speaker 4: before that, it was dispute settlement arbitration, investment arbitration in particular.
- 3:04Speaker 4: So the whole thing really picked up speed when I
- 3:07Speaker 4: moved to Luxembourg about six, seven years ago. Six years ago. Yeah,
- 3:15Speaker 4: and I've been in the UK in the past six months.
- 3:18Speaker 4: It's a sort of new position, new chapter, but I
- 3:21Speaker 4: still do. I continue working on space law and I
- 3:24Speaker 4: sort of blend it with my international investment law background.
- 3:29Speaker 4: Among other things, focusing on how private actors act in
- 3:33Speaker 4: space and how states sort of react to the private
- 3:37Speaker 4: actors' presence and behavior in space. So most of my
- 3:41Speaker 4: research sort of focuses on that. So it does manifest
- 3:45Speaker 4: in different ways, obviously. And yeah, I also have another role,
- 3:52Speaker 4: another hat at the Moon Village Association. As you said,
- 3:56Speaker 4: it's an NGO that focuses on lunar governance, lunar policy,
- 4:04Speaker 4: and mostly about sort of multi-stakeholder dialogue between different actors
- 4:09Speaker 4: that are involved in lunar activities, you could say. It's
- 4:14Speaker 4: quite a comprehensive NGO. It's one of the biggest, if
- 4:17Speaker 4: not the biggest NGO that's related to the moon in
- 4:21Speaker 4: existence today. It's about 10 years old. And we are
- 4:26Speaker 4: also permanent observer at the UN Committee on the Peaceful
- 4:29Speaker 4: Uses of Outer Space. So in that capacity, I also
- 4:33Speaker 4: go to Vienna every year during the legal subcommittee, sometimes
- 4:36Speaker 4: also scientific and technical subcommittee and the plenary session later
- 4:41Speaker 4: in the year. So, you know, just basically these two
- 4:45Speaker 4: among a few other hats, they sort of allow me
- 4:48Speaker 4: to do some academic work, but also see how that
- 4:51Speaker 4: could actually benefit the real life implications of this very
- 4:56Speaker 4: interesting field.
- 4:58Speaker 2: Yeah, I see a lot of things. First of all,
- 5:01Speaker 2: if you were a young lawyer, we're thinking about it.
- 5:04Speaker 2: I think that space law is amazing because it's an
- 5:06Speaker 2: emerging area. Imagine being a maritime trade lawyer if you
- 5:10Speaker 2: were in Portugal in the 1400s. So there's that. The
- 5:15Speaker 2: other part is, as someone who used to go to
- 5:18Speaker 2: a lot of business conferences, they.
- 5:20Speaker 3: Have conferences constantly and they're all going all over the
- 5:23Speaker 3: place to fabulous European cities and to Abu Dhabi and to,
- 5:29Speaker 3: I can't remember the name, Baku in Azerbaijan. I mean,
- 5:33Speaker 3: if you want to go to conferences and you can't
- 5:35Speaker 3: get into the Davos 300 and you can't, no, but
- 5:39Speaker 3: if you want to go to fabulous conferences, this seems
- 5:42Speaker 3: like a way to get it.
- 5:43Speaker 2: Now, listen, this is probably not a reason to choose
- 5:46Speaker 2: a career, but it's not a reason to choose a career.
- 5:50Speaker 4: Yeah, it does help. It does help.
- 5:52Speaker 2: The other thing I heard from you, and I really
- 5:54Speaker 2: like the way you framed it, is that you were
- 5:56Speaker 2: talking about private actors and how governments react.
- 5:59Speaker 3: And I think that 15 years ago, maybe sooner, people.
- 6:03Speaker 2: Would phrase that the obvious. Not the obvious, the opposite.
- 6:08Speaker 2: That governments are the ones that control going into space
- 6:12Speaker 2: and that private actors would react to that or supplement it.
- 6:16Speaker 2: And that doesn't seem to be the case anymore. And
- 6:21Speaker 2: this slips into my fear when I started this sort
- 6:24Speaker 2: of series looking into space law some four or five
- 6:28Speaker 2: years ago. One of my fears was that we were
- 6:33Speaker 2: going to repeat the British East India Company or the
- 6:35Speaker 2: Hudson Bay Company. And sure enough, that seems what we're doing.
- 6:39Speaker 2: I mean, they haven't yet requisitioned whatever Space Force Marines
- 6:44Speaker 2: are called. I know they're called Guardians. That's what soldiers
- 6:48Speaker 2: in the Space Force are called. I mean, I don't
- 6:50Speaker 2: know if there's more than 50 of them, but anyway,
- 6:52Speaker 2: that they have a name. And when you have governors
- 6:58Speaker 2: and the military works with them, which is coming, they're
- 7:02Speaker 2: going to need to have something up there to keep
- 7:04Speaker 2: away the Chinese or the Russians, or the Russians are
- 7:07Speaker 2: going to have something to keep away the Americans, and
- 7:10Speaker 2: the Americans may be SpaceX or Blue Origin or whomever
- 7:17Speaker 2: it is. In any event, Enough of my ramblings. We
- 7:21Speaker 2: talked a little bit in pre-show that you were aware
- 7:23Speaker 2: that that was it. But it's interesting how you phrase
- 7:26Speaker 2: it that way. And I guess the question after my
- 7:29Speaker 2: little soliloquy is, is that the reality right now? Is
- 7:33Speaker 2: it governments reacting to the private sector more than the opposite,
- 7:36Speaker 2: sort of on a worldwide basis?
- 7:39Speaker 4: I mean, in a way, yes. But there are multiple
- 7:42Speaker 4: sides to the story, of course. One of the sides
- 7:46Speaker 4: to this story, this fascinating story, is that governments have
- 7:51Speaker 4: obviously dominated space activities for most of the 20th century. Basically,
- 7:56Speaker 4: the states were the only actors, effectively. And you sort
- 8:02Speaker 4: of see that in the architecture of the international legal framework, right?
- 8:06Speaker 4: The Outer Space Treaty is all about what states shall
- 8:09Speaker 4: and shan't do. So you don't really have a lot
- 8:12Speaker 4: of mention of commercial entities. They're not mentioned at all.
- 8:18Speaker 4: The only way The only context in which they're mentioned
- 8:20Speaker 4: is non-governmental entities. States are also responsible, internationally responsible, internationally
- 8:30Speaker 4: liable for the actions of non-governmental entities.
- 8:35Speaker 2: May I interject for a second there? Because that's an
- 8:40Speaker 2: important question or an important point, because I'm aware of that,
- 8:44Speaker 2: and we have covered that. But I've also learned even
- 8:47Speaker 2: the answer to that isn't as clear as one might
- 8:50Speaker 2: think because it hasn't been battle tested all that often.
- 8:54Speaker 2: And so here's a scenario, and it's a realized scenario.
- 8:59Speaker 2: The Russian space program is still mostly entirely located in Kazakhstan,
- 9:03Speaker 2: which is not part of the Soviet Union anymore. But
- 9:06Speaker 2: the space program remains there. So if Russia sends something
- 9:10Speaker 2: up from Kazakhstan, is it Russia that's responsible? Or is
- 9:14Speaker 2: it Kazakhstan that's responsible? And worse than that, If it's,
- 9:18Speaker 2: let's just say it's an American rocket, or a British.
- 9:21Speaker 2: I think Virgin's out of the game, but let's go
- 9:24Speaker 2: with Virgin and say Virgin. Is it Britain that's there
- 9:30Speaker 2: because it's a British-flagged space vessel or a British company,
- 9:35Speaker 2: assuming that Virgin still is? It doesn't matter. The point
- 9:38Speaker 2: is to say that there's three different states that are
- 9:42Speaker 2: theoretically involved in that, And what if the entire cargo
- 9:46Speaker 2: of the British rocket is all American? So now we
- 9:49Speaker 2: have four states that might be doing it. Which state
- 9:52Speaker 2: is the state that's responsible? I mean, in regular lawsuits,
- 9:56Speaker 2: you just sue everyone and let them worry about it
- 9:58Speaker 2: and hope there's insurance. But apparently there aren't that many
- 10:01Speaker 2: space insurers and it's not that easy to get. So
- 10:04Speaker 2: is which state is liable? Is that settled or far
- 10:08Speaker 2: from settled?
- 10:09Speaker 4: Well, I think we need to separate, first of all,
- 10:12Speaker 4: the question of international responsibility, international liability. Uh, in the
- 10:17Speaker 4: way that they're used in the Outer Space Treaty. International
- 10:20Speaker 4: responsibility usually, not exclusively, but typically refers to one state
- 10:27Speaker 4: sort of authorizing and continuously supervising a particular space activity.
- 10:33Speaker 4: And this can be any of those states that you
- 10:35Speaker 4: mentioned that in the scenario, for example, that a Russian
- 10:38Speaker 4: spacecraft being sent into space from Kazakhstan, then Russia and
- 10:43Speaker 4: Kazakhstan can decide which one will be responsible for that
- 10:46Speaker 4: particular spacecraft or for that particular operation. But international liability,
- 10:52Speaker 4: we have a more expressed and prescribed formula for this.
- 10:57Speaker 4: We have the definition, the concept of a launching state,
- 11:01Speaker 4: which can, under the Liability Convention, can either be the
- 11:03Speaker 4: procuring state, in this case it would be Russia, and
- 11:06Speaker 4: the state from which the space object is launched, in
- 11:10Speaker 4: that case, Kazakhstan. So they would both be liable in
- 11:13Speaker 4: case of an accident. So responsibility in the way that
- 11:16Speaker 4: it's used, it does include liability, which is a more
- 11:19Speaker 4: sort of situational manifestation of responsibility, if you can call
- 11:22Speaker 4: it that, in case there's a damage, right? Then you
- 11:26Speaker 4: talk about liability. But I mean, there are different configurations
- 11:32Speaker 4: of how a particular non-state operation, non-state space operation could
- 11:41Speaker 4: create responsibility for a state or not. This is, again,
- 11:44Speaker 4: usually in the context of regulation or authorization and continuous supervision.
- 11:51Speaker 2: Interesting. Okay. So I think probably a good place to
- 11:56Speaker 2: start as framing for the audience is where you start
- 12:00Speaker 2: with the international treaty on space and whatever other laws
- 12:06Speaker 2: that the are the framework of what's supposed to be
- 12:09Speaker 2: the right way to do things.
- 12:12Speaker 4: Well, I mean, the starting point is, as is all
- 12:15Speaker 4: things international space law, is the Outer Space Treaty. But again,
- 12:19Speaker 4: as is all things international space law, it's rarely the
- 12:21Speaker 4: end of the discussion. It's usually the beginning of the discussion.
- 12:25Speaker 4: And I'm sure other guests on your show here talking
- 12:29Speaker 4: about space law in particular, maybe they've also referred to
- 12:32Speaker 4: Outer Space Treaty. It's really difficult to avoid it. And
- 12:36Speaker 4: another thing to be said about Outer Space Treaty is
- 12:41Speaker 4: that it's quite a general framework. It's almost, sometimes it's
- 12:45Speaker 4: called like this quasi-constitutional framework that really gives us the
- 12:49Speaker 4: overview of, or rather the general principles that really need
- 12:54Speaker 4: to trickle down to regional or national systems in a
- 12:57Speaker 4: more concrete way. And I think that's the key here, right?
- 13:02Speaker 4: Outer Space Treaty... Some people call it outdated. I think
- 13:06Speaker 4: it's just a general treaty, but I don't think it's
- 13:09Speaker 4: necessarily outdated. I don't think it's incompatible with what's going
- 13:13Speaker 4: on right now. It just needs proper contextualization. It starts
- 13:18Speaker 4: with saying everyone is free to use and explore outer space.
- 13:22Speaker 4: There's nothing outdated about that. And it also says no
- 13:25Speaker 4: one can own space, basically. You cannot appropriate space. There's
- 13:30Speaker 4: also nothing outdated about that. We just need to, of course,
- 13:34Speaker 4: assess that against the contemporary reality of state actors are
- 13:40Speaker 4: sort of collaborating and in certain cases being outdone by
- 13:49Speaker 4: private actors, right? Especially we see this in the launch sector,
- 13:53Speaker 4: for example, after the rise of SpaceX, but it's It's
- 13:59Speaker 4: the common story, but that's certainly not the end of it.
- 14:03Speaker 4: There are many, many different commercial entities that really popped
- 14:07Speaker 4: up in the past decade.
- 14:08Speaker 3: And a half.
- 14:11Speaker 4: And that, again, sort of creates the question. So when
- 14:13Speaker 4: these private actors start operating in space, how are we
- 14:20Speaker 4: going to bind their activities and how are we going
- 14:24Speaker 4: to see to it that states actually live up to
- 14:27Speaker 4: this international responsibility that is in outer space treaty. And again,
- 14:31Speaker 4: I don't think the international responsibility question or the international
- 14:34Speaker 4: liability question, I don't think these are outdated either in
- 14:38Speaker 4: the way that they're regulated. But if you try to
- 14:41Speaker 4: look at that question from the perspective of the 1960s,
- 14:46Speaker 4: of course, you're not going to be able to give
- 14:47Speaker 4: a satisfactory answer because it doesn't really answer these questions
- 14:52Speaker 4: from the lens of 2026. Many things that are happening
- 14:56Speaker 4: today were not really foreseeable for the negotiators of the
- 15:01Speaker 4: Outer Space Treaty, but even though there's a huge time difference,
- 15:05Speaker 4: it's been decades, right? Even when you consider that, I
- 15:09Speaker 4: think their foresight was quite impressive in the way that
- 15:15Speaker 4: the Outer Space Treaty is too relevant, it's still active,
- 15:18Speaker 4: it's still being interpreted, everything that's done, guidelines, non-binding instruments,
- 15:24Speaker 4: national laws, they all refer to Outer Space Treaty. They
- 15:27Speaker 4: all build upon Outer Space Treaty. So I think the
- 15:30Speaker 4: better way to see it is really not that it's outdated,
- 15:33Speaker 4: but it's just general and it's the foundation upon which
- 15:37Speaker 4: we need to build.
- 15:37Speaker 2: Yeah, well, it's interesting you say it wasn't foreseeable. It
- 15:42Speaker 2: was foreseen by people like Robert Heinlein and Arthur C.
- 15:46Speaker 2: Clarke and others.
- 15:49Speaker 4: They weren't the ones who negotiated the Outer Space Safety.
- 15:53Speaker 4: I wish they were.
- 15:55Speaker 2: Exactly. You'd think that diplomats should read a little bit
- 15:58Speaker 2: more science fiction and then sort of more grounded science
- 16:01Speaker 2: fiction because they tend to be... I mean, the difference
- 16:05Speaker 2: between what's called a futurist and a science fiction author
- 16:09Speaker 2: is often very blurred, or just a philosopher, so... And
- 16:14Speaker 2: now apparently there's a job title called Futurist. So other
- 16:17Speaker 2: than U.S. Ambassador to Greece, which is self-appointed, I'm also
- 16:20Speaker 2: going to call myself a Futurist as well. And since
- 16:24Speaker 2: you're a professor, you can make that very formal. And
- 16:28Speaker 2: I know there's also the Treaty on the Moon. And
- 16:32Speaker 2: I'm sure that of all the treaties, I'm sure not
- 16:34Speaker 2: every country on Earth ratified it. I'm sure that about
- 16:37Speaker 2: 60 new countries have emerged since the original treaty was made.
- 16:42Speaker 2: And There's plenty of other things here on Earth for
- 16:45Speaker 2: people to worry about than that. So I'm not saying
- 16:48Speaker 2: that everyone's being short-sighted and there's always priorities, and there are.
- 16:57Speaker 2: So I get it. I mean, anyone who's ever been
- 17:00Speaker 2: in a homeowner's association gets it or should. There's like
- 17:03Speaker 2: a million different factions. It's just the scale of it. However,
- 17:08Speaker 2: my country, the United States of America, recently pulled out
- 17:12Speaker 2: of a few treaties. And also there were a few
- 17:14Speaker 2: executive orders signed, which what power they have, I don't know,
- 17:17Speaker 2: because Congress is supposed to ratify treaties. And by the way,
- 17:22Speaker 2: nobody here actually knows and nobody here is really talking
- 17:25Speaker 2: about it because nobody's sure about the answers. And we
- 17:27Speaker 2: got plenty of our own problems and we just had
- 17:29Speaker 2: pretty major elections with pretty major ramifications. But one of
- 17:34Speaker 2: the things that's been quietly is like sort of the,
- 17:36Speaker 2: I don't know if you know wrestling terminology, but the
- 17:38Speaker 2: heel turn is of the U.S., not just in a
- 17:41Speaker 2: lot of ways, but towards space. I mean, there's been
- 17:43Speaker 2: executive orders saying the United States and any company from
- 17:47Speaker 2: the United States can claim, can use celestial bodies for resources. Well,
- 17:55Speaker 2: that means the moon and beyond. Now, when we encounter
- 18:03Speaker 2: the Andromedans and the Vulcans and the Klingons, they'll have
- 18:06Speaker 2: a say in it as well, but until Until we
- 18:09Speaker 2: run into somebody else that's at the same or superior
- 18:13Speaker 2: level to us, no one's going to stop it. And
- 18:17Speaker 2: then the other is really the British East India Company
- 18:20Speaker 2: and the Spanish Empire with colonialism revisited. Though I guess
- 18:25Speaker 2: who knows which way the germs go. In any event,
- 18:29Speaker 2: those things aside, and by the way, Orson Welles predicted
- 18:33Speaker 2: that one in the 1920s with War of the Worlds. So, again,
- 18:37Speaker 2: these negotiators, you know, lacked a full frame of reference.
- 18:43Speaker 2: But how does the world respond when there's an executive
- 18:46Speaker 2: order in the, you know, what is right now the
- 18:48Speaker 2: most powerful country in the world, or at least top
- 18:51Speaker 2: two with the top space program in the world, saying,
- 18:57Speaker 2: and the private companies, which are going to space regularly,
- 19:01Speaker 2: existing in the United States, saying, eh, do what you want.
- 19:06Speaker 2: As long as you do it for United States of America,
- 19:09Speaker 2: it's cool. Harvest all the helium or palladium or lithium
- 19:15Speaker 2: or tungsten you can find. I don't know what's out there.
- 19:18Speaker 2: But how does the world react to something like that?
- 19:23Speaker 2: How does it stop it? And is there a framework
- 19:25Speaker 2: specifically on space law and mining or harvest resources? Because
- 19:31Speaker 2: That is what I said the title of the show
- 19:33Speaker 2: was going to be, so we should probably talk about
- 19:35Speaker 2: it at some point.
- 19:37Speaker 4: Yeah, that's quite a few questions. Let me start again
- 19:40Speaker 4: from the top. So, again, the entry point. I did
- 19:46Speaker 4: mention already the first two articles. of the Outer Space
- 19:50Speaker 4: Treaty that are the, let's say, the constitutional rules on this, right?
- 19:55Speaker 4: The first one is Article 1 of Outer Space Treaty
- 19:58Speaker 4: that says everyone can freely use and explore outer space. Like,
- 20:04Speaker 4: that's really the starting point.
- 20:07Speaker 2: For peaceful and scientific purposes right i mean.
- 20:11Speaker 4: It says like peaceful purposes but i mean it doesn't
- 20:14Speaker 4: necessarily say that you can only use it for scientific
- 20:16Speaker 4: purposes but scientific uses highlight it as an important let's
- 20:21Speaker 4: say type of activity but it doesn't really say that
- 20:24Speaker 4: it has to be used so it's not.
- 20:25Speaker 2: Exactly a mirror of the antarctica treaty it's it's sort
- 20:29Speaker 2: of based on it but it's a little more limited
- 20:31Speaker 2: okay it's.
- 20:31Speaker 4: It's really i mean it's not a mirror at all
- 20:34Speaker 4: it's uh it is uh it's In certain ways, it's adjacent,
- 20:38Speaker 4: I would say, but I think there are some really
- 20:40Speaker 4: fundamental differences between them. They're used comparatively sometimes, also in scholarship. But,
- 20:48Speaker 4: I mean, the context is completely different, one being, again, space,
- 20:52Speaker 4: the other being terrestrial continents. But, yeah, I mean, there
- 20:59Speaker 4: are also comparisons with the law of the sea, and,
- 21:01Speaker 4: you know, these are very commonly sort of recurring comparisons,
- 21:04Speaker 4: but I think there are certain issues with those comparisons, which,
- 21:09Speaker 4: you know, we might come to that later, but focusing
- 21:12Speaker 4: on sort of the mining part of it. So the
- 21:15Speaker 4: overarching rules are freedom and exploration, article one, and article
- 21:18Speaker 4: two says that, okay, you can use it for, you
- 21:21Speaker 4: can use it freely. You can use it, you can
- 21:23Speaker 4: explore it freely, but you cannot claim ownership of it.
- 21:28Speaker 4: You cannot claim ownership of outer space. You cannot go
- 21:30Speaker 4: to celestial body and say, this is mine now, or
- 21:33Speaker 4: you cannot just go on the moon and and put
- 21:35Speaker 4: a barbed wire around an area on the moon and say,
- 21:38Speaker 4: this is now, let's say, US or Chinese or Indian territory.
- 21:42Speaker 4: So this is quite clearly impossible in international law. It's
- 21:48Speaker 4: a legal impossibility, basically. Now, this might seem straightforward. At
- 21:54Speaker 4: least legally speaking, it might seem straightforward. But what's unclear
- 21:58Speaker 4: is what happens when you move a chunk of that
- 22:00Speaker 4: celestial object, leaving the celestial object otherwise intact. if you
- 22:05Speaker 4: just go to the moon and remove some stones from it,
- 22:09Speaker 4: the moon is still there. You're not really appropriating it
- 22:11Speaker 4: in any form or shape. You're just moving some pieces
- 22:14Speaker 4: of it. And if you scale that to an industrial,
- 22:17Speaker 4: if you put it to an industrial scale, if you
- 22:19Speaker 4: imagine that there's a mining facility there and they're basically extracting,
- 22:22Speaker 4: let's say, water ice or helium-3, so can you own that?
- 22:26Speaker 4: Is that a prohibition under Article 2? Are you appropriating
- 22:30Speaker 4: outer space? Or where do we draw the line between
- 22:34Speaker 4: appropriating a celestial object or appropriating a part of that object.
- 22:37Speaker 4: For example, what happens if it's a small enough asteroid
- 22:39Speaker 4: that you could mine it out of existence, right? At
- 22:43Speaker 4: what point do you only mine the celestial object and
- 22:46Speaker 4: at what point do you actually appropriate the whole thing?
- 22:49Speaker 4: So that border between, that line between appropriating a celestial
- 22:55Speaker 4: object and removing chunks from the celestial object, it's not clear,
- 22:58Speaker 4: it's not obvious. And obviously we're far from actually doing
- 23:03Speaker 4: this technologically. So at the moment, it's more of a,
- 23:09Speaker 4: let's say, science fiction question for a lot of people,
- 23:11Speaker 4: but it's a very real legal question, right? So where
- 23:16Speaker 4: do we draw the line? The answer is we don't
- 23:18Speaker 4: really know. We don't really have an answer. We don't
- 23:20Speaker 4: really have a clear treaty-level, legally binding answer to the question,
- 23:25Speaker 4: can you own space resources? Can you own chunks of
- 23:30Speaker 4: things that you remove from outer space. The one thing
- 23:34Speaker 4: that we have is obviously since 1960s, we've been bringing
- 23:39Speaker 4: back samples from the moon, right? More recently, we also
- 23:43Speaker 4: brought back some samples from asteroids. Jackson did this. We've
- 23:48Speaker 4: brought samples from the far side of the moon in
- 23:51Speaker 4: 2024 with the Chang'e mission. So it's something that we
- 23:54Speaker 4: do already. And even though there's no clear, explicit rule
- 23:59Speaker 4: internationally that says that, okay, it's legal or it's illegal,
- 24:04Speaker 4: the question still remains to be answered. Someone has to
- 24:11Speaker 4: answer that question. But for the samples, there has been
- 24:15Speaker 4: a silence, that we've been removing these samples, we've been
- 24:18Speaker 4: basically bringing these samples back, and no one was really saying,
- 24:22Speaker 4: you cannot do that, it's illegal, that's not an appropriation, right?
- 24:25Speaker 4: So there appears to be, at least for scientific purposes,
- 24:28Speaker 4: for these sample collection purposes, there seems to be a
- 24:33Speaker 4: certain acquiescence of some sort that the Americans bring a
- 24:37Speaker 4: sample and the Chinese are silent about it and the
- 24:40Speaker 4: Chinese bring a sample, the Americans aren't really protesting it.
- 24:43Speaker 4: So you can sort of see, okay, at least we
- 24:46Speaker 4: have this implicit understanding that at least we can bring
- 24:52Speaker 4: samples and even though it doesn't really clarify the property
- 24:55Speaker 4: ownership question, it at least tells us those things can
- 25:00Speaker 4: be brought back and be kept for scientific purposes. And
- 25:05Speaker 4: nobody really goes and tries to take away the samples
- 25:07Speaker 4: from the Chinese, right? Saying that this is illegal. But
- 25:11Speaker 4: if you sort of scale it up to an industrial facility,
- 25:15Speaker 4: a mining facility on the moon, I think the question
- 25:17Speaker 4: will be much more pressing. And you'll see that the
- 25:21Speaker 4: same silence will not necessarily apply that, that there will
- 25:25Speaker 4: be certain pushback. And what the US did, because there
- 25:29Speaker 4: has been this decades-long status quo, that gray zone, basically,
- 25:33Speaker 4: can we own space resources, the ones that are extracted
- 25:37Speaker 4: in the future? Because there is no clear-cut answer to
- 25:40Speaker 4: that question, some states, including the US, Luxembourg, Japan, United Emirates,
- 25:48Speaker 4: the four states at the moment, I think Brazil is
- 25:50Speaker 4: in the phase of preparing a law as well, but
- 25:53Speaker 4: they don't yet have a law, if I remember correctly.
- 25:57Speaker 4: They basically tried to address that question unilaterally because, again,
- 26:02Speaker 4: going back to the initial thing that I said, the
- 26:04Speaker 4: first thing that I said at the beginning of the stream,
- 26:08Speaker 4: states react to this commercial presence in certain ways. And
- 26:13Speaker 4: this is a great example of this phenomenon. States want
- 26:20Speaker 4: to accommodate, some states at least, want to accommodate commercial
- 26:24Speaker 4: actors within this sphere of outer space activities. And one
- 26:30Speaker 4: way of doing that is to give them some sense
- 26:32Speaker 4: of legal, a sense of legal security. And that's why
- 26:37Speaker 4: in the absence of this multilateral understanding on whether space
- 26:41Speaker 4: resources can be owned or not, some states wanted to
- 26:44Speaker 4: maybe get ahead of the curve a bit and say, okay,
- 26:47Speaker 4: There is a multilateral gridlock at the moment. We cannot
- 26:50Speaker 4: decide on this issue. At least if we unilaterally, nationally
- 26:55Speaker 4: regulate and say our investors or our companies can own
- 27:00Speaker 4: them as far as we are concerned, maybe that's going
- 27:03Speaker 4: to help give the commercial actors some breeding space. They
- 27:09Speaker 4: will be more inclined to actually continue their investments, continue
- 27:14Speaker 4: their research and development into this field at least they
- 27:17Speaker 4: will have the semblance of legal security. And I think
- 27:20Speaker 4: that's largely the rationale behind the 2015 law in the US,
- 27:26Speaker 4: even though it's not only about space resources, it's a
- 27:29Speaker 4: very important part of it, it's a very noble part
- 27:31Speaker 4: of it. Certainly, this was the rationale for the 2017
- 27:35Speaker 4: space resources law in Luxembourg. Luxembourg had this very express
- 27:42Speaker 4: policy that it was building to become the European hub
- 27:45Speaker 4: for space resources, space resource activities. They wanted to invite
- 27:51Speaker 4: space resource companies into their jurisdiction. They wanted to also
- 27:55Speaker 4: sort of create European space resource companies, basically, or rather
- 28:01Speaker 4: facilitate the creation of space resource companies in Luxembourg. And
- 28:04Speaker 4: they had to give something to this fledgling sector. And
- 28:10Speaker 4: one thing that they did was, look, we have a law,
- 28:13Speaker 4: Space Resources Law, and it's Article 1 says space resources
- 28:17Speaker 4: are capable of being owned, and Article 2 and following
- 28:21Speaker 4: articles are basically a licensing regime for space resource operations.
- 28:25Speaker 4: So what does that mean for the rest of the world?
- 28:29Speaker 4: I think that's also an important thing, and that's part
- 28:31Speaker 4: of your question as well. What does China care about
- 28:35Speaker 4: a Luxembourgish national law about space... resources and the property
- 28:42Speaker 4: rights attached to them. And the scenario is that I
- 28:44Speaker 4: also give the scenario, this example in class, imagine you're
- 28:48Speaker 4: a Luxembourgish company, right? Luxembourg had invited you in its
- 28:51Speaker 4: jurisdiction and you were very happy to see that there
- 28:54Speaker 4: was a law and you went there, you invested there,
- 28:57Speaker 4: you sunk hundreds of millions of dollars. And it's also
- 29:01Speaker 4: like a small country, obviously. So it's the space agency
- 29:04Speaker 4: is very approachable. The ministry is very approachable. You can,
- 29:07Speaker 4: you can meet people very easily there. It's also a
- 29:09Speaker 4: small community. So it does give this impression of a
- 29:13Speaker 4: very friendly ecosystem. And it is, it is. I'm still
- 29:18Speaker 4: part of that ecosystem and I really like the people there.
- 29:21Speaker 4: But the legal question is another question. So imagine you're
- 29:25Speaker 4: a Luxembourgish company or a foreign company that invested in Luxembourg,
- 29:29Speaker 4: moved their operations in Luxembourg, you established there and you
- 29:33Speaker 4: were largely influenced, let's say, by the fact that, again,
- 29:37Speaker 4: there's a very reactive, very responsive space agency. And there's
- 29:41Speaker 4: a law that says you can own your extracted material
- 29:46Speaker 4: from the moon. That's going to give you a very
- 29:48Speaker 4: positive impression. But in practice, if you're on the moon
- 29:52Speaker 4: and if you're mining, confident that the Luxembourg law will
- 29:55Speaker 4: protect you, What happens when a Chinese company or a
- 29:59Speaker 4: Chinese operator or an American operator or an Indian operator
- 30:03Speaker 4: or a Japanese operator, a non-Luxembourgish operator, right, comes right
- 30:07Speaker 4: next to you and starts operating next to you and
- 30:12Speaker 4: even maybe takes away some of the material that you've extracted?
- 30:16Speaker 4: How can you assert your property rights or other rights
- 30:21Speaker 4: that stem from, for example, the use rights, right? how
- 30:26Speaker 4: do you assert those rights against an international entity? They
- 30:29Speaker 4: might simply say, I sympathize with you that there is
- 30:32Speaker 4: a law in Luxembourg, but as far as I'm concerned,
- 30:36Speaker 4: in China, we don't have a law that says you
- 30:38Speaker 4: can own space resources, let alone a Luxembourgish company asserting
- 30:43Speaker 4: that claim against me based on a Luxembourgish law. So
- 30:48Speaker 4: how do you, in real life, how do you enforce that?
- 30:52Speaker 4: How do you activate that law that purports to have
- 30:57Speaker 4: a certain legal effect. So that's the big question. And
- 31:01Speaker 4: in terms of unilateral national legislation that says you can
- 31:05Speaker 4: own things, I think the Achilles heel here is that
- 31:09Speaker 4: there is no multilateral consensus. There is no understanding globally
- 31:15Speaker 4: that space resources can be owned in the same terms.
- 31:22Speaker 4: according to the same parameters that are defined under the
- 31:24Speaker 4: Luxembourg law or the U.S.
- 31:26Speaker 2: Law.
- 31:27Speaker 4: So unless there's some multilateral global common ground as to
- 31:32Speaker 4: how we're going to deal with space resources, how we're
- 31:36Speaker 4: going to extract them, what happens to them when they're extracted,
- 31:39Speaker 4: I think this reality will perpetuate uncertainty even when there
- 31:47Speaker 4: are laws in specific countries. I think that is the
- 31:50Speaker 4: primary issue here. must again start from the multilateral sphere.
- 31:57Speaker 4: This can be the United Nations Committee on the Peaceful
- 32:01Speaker 4: Uses of Outer Space, UNPOPOS. This can be some other fora,
- 32:06Speaker 4: as states wish. And then it sort of trickles down
- 32:11Speaker 4: from there based on what those common denominators are. I
- 32:16Speaker 4: think that is the key here.
- 32:19Speaker 2: I have an existential question. It's not an existential question.
- 32:23Speaker 2: it's a question about an existential question, and I might
- 32:26Speaker 2: be using the wrong term. But is anyone in academia,
- 32:30Speaker 2: and I understand that you're not a spokesperson for all
- 32:32Speaker 2: of academia, but you're probably aware of what the major,
- 32:37Speaker 2: you know, fields of study are or thought in the area.
- 32:41Speaker 2: Has anyone considered that the laws of Earth don't apply
- 32:45Speaker 2: beyond the Earth, or at least beyond our, you know,
- 32:48Speaker 2: our lower orbit or, you know, to I mean, on
- 32:53Speaker 2: the Earth, international treaties are enforced through economic sanctions, peer pressure,
- 33:00Speaker 2: non-peer pressure. Used to be the U.S. Navy.
- 33:03Speaker 4: Yeah, I'm.
- 33:06Speaker 2: Going to stop right there on that. But in space,
- 33:11Speaker 2: there is no one to enforce it. And I understand
- 33:15Speaker 2: right now everybody's assets, and they're still very much tied
- 33:20Speaker 2: to here. But it's something that could theoretically train. But
- 33:24Speaker 2: I mean, just as a matter of law, there's actually
- 33:26Speaker 2: a bizarre case out there that was filed pro se
- 33:31Speaker 2: somewhere in the U.S. Federal Court where somebody sued Satan.
- 33:34Speaker 2: And the federal courts dismissed it saying, we don't have
- 33:38Speaker 2: jurisdiction over a non-citizen of the United States, let alone
- 33:43Speaker 2: the earth. We have no jurisdiction over Satan. Basically a cop-out,
- 33:47Speaker 2: but it's precedent somewhere. in U.S. federal law, which probably
- 33:53Speaker 2: makes it pretty close to international law. Some court at
- 33:57Speaker 2: some point is going to have to wrestle with the
- 33:59Speaker 2: question is, how do the laws of earth bind anything
- 34:04Speaker 2: that's beyond it? I mean, at some point, you're outside
- 34:08Speaker 2: the jurisdiction, or theoretically, unless we all agree they were
- 34:13Speaker 2: within jurisdiction. And my question presupposes that that somebody is
- 34:18Speaker 2: going to disagree. And it's probably going to be a
- 34:20Speaker 2: private actor, but probably a private actor with the blessing
- 34:23Speaker 2: of a state actor. And I'm not asking you to
- 34:26Speaker 2: answer the question as what to do about it. I'm
- 34:28Speaker 2: just asking you to answer questions. Is anybody thinking about that?
- 34:31Speaker 2: Is anybody writing that? Is that a treaty that's being negotiated?
- 34:38Speaker 4: I mean, first, just let me go back to the
- 34:43Speaker 4: initial assertion that the laws of Earth don't apply to
- 34:48Speaker 4: outer space, that we must qualify that statement. Because, yes,
- 34:52Speaker 4: maybe if you are an astronaut happily hopping about on
- 34:57Speaker 4: the surface of the moon, yes, maybe the question of
- 35:01Speaker 4: jurisdiction becomes a little less clear. But let's say you
- 35:05Speaker 4: are in a space object, right? Or that you're perhaps
- 35:09Speaker 4: in a research facility on the moon that has been
- 35:14Speaker 4: built by the United States. So as long as you're
- 35:17Speaker 4: within that research facility, the US laws will apply. The
- 35:21Speaker 4: US has jurisdiction on that space object. So if you
- 35:29Speaker 4: imagine that some hypothetical space station that is owned only
- 35:33Speaker 4: by the United States, everything that happens in that space
- 35:36Speaker 4: station would be subject to US jurisdiction. So if you
- 35:42Speaker 4: There is Tiangong, for example, right? China has a space station.
- 35:45Speaker 4: As far as that space station is concerned, everything that
- 35:48Speaker 4: happens inside happens in China with regards to jurisdiction. So
- 35:54Speaker 4: ISS has a certain, for example, configuration, a certain, let's say,
- 36:02Speaker 4: certain arrangement as to what laws and what jurisdiction can
- 36:07Speaker 4: be asserted on what part of the ISS. But Again,
- 36:11Speaker 4: if it's a space object that is owned by a
- 36:15Speaker 4: state or a non-actor of a state, that jurisdiction will
- 36:20Speaker 4: apply there. So if you kill an astronaut in a
- 36:22Speaker 4: space station in Tiangong, a Chinese taikonaut kills another Chinese taikonaut,
- 36:27Speaker 4: Chinese criminal law will apply. If you invent something, if
- 36:32Speaker 4: you develop a software on Tiangong, that will be protected
- 36:39Speaker 4: by whatever law protects software ownership in China, right? Industrial,
- 36:46Speaker 4: maybe it's a patent, maybe intellectual property. So that is
- 36:51Speaker 4: certainly the case. The second thing is, again, according to
- 36:55Speaker 4: Outer Space Treaty, this is also according to Outer Space Treaty,
- 36:58Speaker 4: but another rule that Outer Space Treaty has is that
- 37:00Speaker 4: international law applies in outer space. So it's not just
- 37:03Speaker 4: these outer space treaties or outer space treaty and the
- 37:06Speaker 4: other space treaties like reliability convention, registration convention, but international
- 37:11Speaker 4: law applies in outer space in general. So if you,
- 37:17Speaker 4: human rights exist in outer spaces as well, wherever you go, right? So,
- 37:22Speaker 4: I mean, we have to qualify that. We have to
- 37:24Speaker 4: qualify that statement for sure. But yes, if you are
- 37:28Speaker 4: on the surface of the moon, then no state can
- 37:30Speaker 4: say that In this territory, U.S. law will apply. That's
- 37:34Speaker 4: not possible. But as far as we're talking about the objects,
- 37:37Speaker 4: the situation is a little bit different.
- 37:41Speaker 2: Okay. They'll probably be treated like embassies, basically.
- 37:45Speaker 4: Yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean, in a certain way, yes, absolutely.
- 37:48Speaker 4: They're basically like little pockets of jurisdiction. You can call
- 37:53Speaker 4: it that.
- 37:54Speaker 2: Yeah, so folks, it's probably not best to make me
- 37:56Speaker 2: a justice on some sort of international space court, because
- 38:01Speaker 2: I would probably dissent. I would say that you're out
- 38:04Speaker 2: of your jurisdiction. Once you get past our magnetosphere, I
- 38:09Speaker 2: would probably be that guy. Maybe. I don't know. We'll see. Well,
- 38:14Speaker 2: we won't see, because it's not going to happen. Okay,
- 38:20Speaker 2: so a private actor, and since I've been calling him
- 38:25Speaker 2: a supervillain since before it was cool to call him
- 38:27Speaker 2: a supervillain, Elon Musk, SpaceX, talked about going to Mars.
- 38:31Speaker 2: He sort of abandoned that. Now he's on the moon.
- 38:34Speaker 2: I don't know. I'm okay with him going to either
- 38:37Speaker 2: place just to get rid of him, but I'm sure
- 38:40Speaker 2: he'll send other people or robots. He goes. He does
- 38:45Speaker 2: whatever he wants. With the blessing of the United States,
- 38:51Speaker 2: and let's just assume that it's still the United States
- 38:53Speaker 2: sort of in the state that it is now, and
- 38:56Speaker 2: while there might be some outrage or protest that nothing
- 39:01Speaker 2: really happens, because we still have the biggest military and
- 39:04Speaker 2: we still buy the most stuff from everybody else, including China,
- 39:08Speaker 2: who absolutely loves having us buy all their stuff, as
- 39:13Speaker 2: does the rest of the world. But Elon decides from there,
- 39:21Speaker 2: He's going to send a giant grappling hook rocket into
- 39:25Speaker 2: the inner belt, and he's going to fight. asteroids that
- 39:31Speaker 2: are full of all sorts of rare earth minerals, which
- 39:35Speaker 2: is a misnomer, but they find some actual rare minerals
- 39:39Speaker 2: or elements or whatever things that are just caught, whatever
- 39:41Speaker 2: it is, things that they can attract and billions upon
- 39:45Speaker 2: billions upon trillions upon trillions of dollars Let's forget about
- 39:48Speaker 2: adjusted for inflation. Let's assume that they can control the doling.
- 39:51Speaker 2: And let's also assume that these are multi-decade endeavors. But
- 39:56Speaker 2: for that kind of money, multi-decade endeavors are worth it.
- 39:59Speaker 2: It's happened all the time throughout history. Who stops them?
- 40:06Speaker 2: How does that get stopped? Does anyone stop them? Is
- 40:08Speaker 2: there an international... lattice or framework that can do anything
- 40:16Speaker 2: about that effectively.
- 40:19Speaker 4: That's, I think that's the holy grail what you're asking
- 40:24Speaker 4: and this is also the original question that interested me. Again,
- 40:29Speaker 4: how do states deal with this rise of private entities
- 40:36Speaker 4: and the flag bearer of those private entities SpaceX, right?
- 40:41Speaker 4: This whole conversation started back in 2000s when SpaceX towards
- 40:46Speaker 4: the end of 2000s started developing these never before seen
- 40:52Speaker 4: launch capabilities nicely building their way into the 2010s. So,
- 40:58Speaker 4: I mean, when do these private actors become more powerful
- 41:05Speaker 4: than states? And this is not just a freestanding question.
- 41:10Speaker 4: The foundational presumption of outer space law is that states
- 41:18Speaker 4: are and will be the chief actors, that no private
- 41:23Speaker 4: entity could become so powerful or so rich or so
- 41:28Speaker 4: technically capable that it can outperform states. That was the presumption.
- 41:35Speaker 4: And now we are living in a different reality. This
- 41:40Speaker 4: was the presumption of the 1960s. That's why I said
- 41:44Speaker 4: maybe R2C Clark and the others would be better positioned
- 41:47Speaker 4: to negotiate a treaty so they could actually take into
- 41:49Speaker 4: account that these private actors could one day become more
- 41:53Speaker 4: powerful than the states. So that is a question that
- 41:58Speaker 4: has absolute... I don't think there's an answer to that question.
- 42:02Speaker 4: The only thing that states do right now is to,
- 42:05Speaker 4: first of all, communicate with those private actors, right? Work
- 42:09Speaker 4: with them and regulate and discipline their behavior. And the
- 42:16Speaker 4: reference that they make, of course, is, well, we are
- 42:18Speaker 4: internationally responsible for your actions. You must be authorized. You
- 42:25Speaker 4: must be supervised by us. But whether or not this
- 42:30Speaker 4: is really how it functions, whether or not there is
- 42:35Speaker 4: a hierarchy as it is prescribed in the Outer Space
- 42:37Speaker 4: Treaty is of course a matter of debate. I don't
- 42:43Speaker 4: really have an answer to that question. I don't really
- 42:46Speaker 4: know how can you stop someone like Elon Musk or
- 42:53Speaker 4: some commercial entity like SpaceX other than saying, well, I'm
- 42:59Speaker 4: the state, I'm the chief architect of international law. You're
- 43:03Speaker 4: subject to my authority and my jurisdiction, so you have
- 43:06Speaker 4: to listen to what I have to say. At what
- 43:09Speaker 4: point does SpaceX or some other company become more powerful
- 43:14Speaker 4: than the United States? At what point do they say, well,
- 43:18Speaker 4: I don't really need you anymore? I cannot really justify why.
- 43:25Speaker 2: You should... Or let's just say, theoretically, because it couldn't
- 43:28Speaker 2: possibly exist in this world, a government so corrupt that
- 43:32Speaker 2: they could easily be bought by that kind of riches.
- 43:35Speaker 2: And obviously there's no countries that fit that description that
- 43:38Speaker 2: has state programs, except practically every country that has a
- 43:41Speaker 2: state program exactly fits that description. I'm sorry, did I
- 43:44Speaker 2: just say that? That's an editorial that does not represent
- 43:48Speaker 2: the views of Gunesh at all. Actually, let's forget Elon.
- 43:53Speaker 2: Substitute Lex Luthor, substitute, you know, A well-meaning Tony Stark,
- 43:58Speaker 2: but sometimes his things go backwards. Blofeld from James Bond.
- 44:04Speaker 2: Just substitute whatever.
- 44:08Speaker 4: I don't have any problem with that, but this is
- 44:11Speaker 4: not an ad hominem. Putting aside all the crazy things
- 44:14Speaker 4: that he's been saying, this is a very objective issue.
- 44:19Speaker 4: Just coming back to Earth. Let's just forget about hooks
- 44:24Speaker 4: and asteroids for a second. Let's talk about Earth, right?
- 44:26Speaker 4: The Earth orbit. Let's talk about the lower Earth orbit.
- 44:31Speaker 4: There are more than 10,000 active satellites in lower Earth orbit.
- 44:35Speaker 4: And 75-80%, I think, I might be off a little bit,
- 44:40Speaker 4: but 75-80% of these satellites, active satellites in lower Earth orbit,
- 44:46Speaker 4: belong to Starlink. And The number is going to.
- 44:51Speaker 2: Be another significant amount have been put there by SpaceX. Right.
- 44:55Speaker 4: I mean, just, you know, the number is growing and
- 44:58Speaker 4: it's going to grow and it's growing exponentially almost. So
- 45:02Speaker 4: at some point we have to ask the question, like
- 45:05Speaker 4: what happens to all these active satellites?
- 45:08Speaker 2: Yes.
- 45:08Speaker 4: The easy answer is most of them fall back to
- 45:10Speaker 4: earth and they burn up in the atmosphere. But what
- 45:13Speaker 4: happens when they burn up in the atmosphere and what
- 45:15Speaker 4: happens for, what happens to them, what happens to that
- 45:19Speaker 4: environment in the duration that they stay in orbit, right?
- 45:23Speaker 4: How does that affect the earth environment and the outer
- 45:28Speaker 4: space environment? This might be Elon Musk. This might be
- 45:31Speaker 4: some other guy. This might be some other, it doesn't
- 45:33Speaker 4: really matter who that is, but let's call it, let's
- 45:37Speaker 4: call it, let's call him Jeff. Like if, if Jeff
- 45:40Speaker 4: has that many satellites in orbit, right? We have to
- 45:44Speaker 4: do something about that so that we do not destroy
- 45:48Speaker 4: our own collective capability to be able to send objects
- 45:54Speaker 4: into Earth and operate in orbit or operate beyond orbit.
- 45:58Speaker 4: Because if all these satellites owned by Jeff are sent
- 46:02Speaker 4: to low Earth orbit, if the low Earth orbit is
- 46:05Speaker 4: basically congested, the entire ecosystem, space ecosystem, all activities grind
- 46:11Speaker 4: to a halt. And this has nothing to do with
- 46:15Speaker 4: someone's political orientation or how unhinged they might be. It's about, really,
- 46:22Speaker 4: it's an existential question for the space, for the future
- 46:26Speaker 4: of space activities on Earth, no matter who conducts them.
- 46:29Speaker 4: So states have the primary responsibility to address this. They
- 46:35Speaker 4: have to say, look, you are sending all this stuff
- 46:39Speaker 4: in orbit, and yes, there is a certain utility to it, fine,
- 46:43Speaker 4: fair enough. But if we're going to do this sustainably,
- 46:47Speaker 4: and if we want to be able to do this generationally,
- 46:52Speaker 4: we have to find a way to do this sustainably.
- 46:55Speaker 4: And it's not enough to say that, well, I'm calculating
- 46:58Speaker 4: the end-of-life protocols, I know exactly the trajectory of when
- 47:06Speaker 4: this satellite deorbits, What happens to all these chemicals that
- 47:11Speaker 4: are released into the atmosphere? There are now emerging studies
- 47:15Speaker 4: on this as well, examining the environmental impact of burning
- 47:22Speaker 4: up satellites, burning up space debris. How do you mitigate that?
- 47:27Speaker 4: Companies have a responsibility, obviously. There's certainly a moral responsibility,
- 47:31Speaker 4: an ethical responsibility, but it comes down to states to
- 47:34Speaker 4: actually say, you cannot do this. You cannot do this
- 47:40Speaker 4: without any limits. This is not just for the sake
- 47:44Speaker 4: of regulating you or limiting you. If we want to
- 47:49Speaker 4: have space activities into the future, a decade, a century
- 47:53Speaker 4: from now on, we have to have certain regulations so
- 47:57Speaker 4: that we can sustain this, so that we don't really,
- 48:00Speaker 4: in a frenzy, use up all of our resources, and
- 48:05Speaker 4: I consider also the orbit as a resource in this context,
- 48:08Speaker 4: use all of our resources, all the available space in
- 48:11Speaker 4: low Earth orbit, and basically hinder our ability in the
- 48:15Speaker 4: future to do anything meaningful. So yes, in that sense,
- 48:20Speaker 4: states have absolutely, they have a monumental responsibility to hit
- 48:26Speaker 4: the brakes when they must.
- 48:30Speaker 2: Let's get off of my thought experiment, and let's go
- 48:34Speaker 2: into what might be a thought experiment, but maybe isn't.
- 48:37Speaker 2: Let's go with everybody is a good actor. Everybody's doing
- 48:40Speaker 2: what they're supposed to do, and you want to get
- 48:44Speaker 2: into the space mining business. How does a company or country, anyone,
- 48:49Speaker 2: any good actor, how do they do that? What's the
- 48:53Speaker 2: procedure to go about that legally, properly, under international law?
- 48:59Speaker 2: How would they do that now?
- 49:01Speaker 4: So, right now, again, there's no... clear-cut answer to whether
- 49:07Speaker 4: or not, in international law, you can own space resources,
- 49:12Speaker 4: the resources that you've extracted.
- 49:15Speaker 2: There's an executive order in the United States saying that
- 49:18Speaker 2: we can.
- 49:19Speaker 4: Yeah, but that's only relevant to the United States. That
- 49:22Speaker 4: was kind of my point. That's not just an executive order.
- 49:25Speaker 4: There's a law that says you can basically own space.
- 49:29Speaker 2: Executive orders don't always have the force of law. That's international.
- 49:35Speaker 2: That should be a treaty. That's a constitutional crisis issue,
- 49:39Speaker 2: which Maybe it's a different type of show, but I've
- 49:43Speaker 2: heard great thinkers here try to avoid saying that we're
- 49:46Speaker 2: in a constitutional crisis, and we've been in a constitutional
- 49:48Speaker 2: crisis for years. It's just, it feels like it's in
- 49:53Speaker 2: slow motion, even though it's not, or we're trying to
- 49:56Speaker 2: ignore it and say, no, everything is like a giant fire. Anyway,
- 49:59Speaker 2: all right, so the answer is, right now, I am
- 50:03Speaker 2: Space Mining Inc., or Space Mining LTD, out of Britain,
- 50:08Speaker 2: of course, I want to go and get permission to
- 50:12Speaker 2: harvest the moon. There's no way for me to legally
- 50:19Speaker 2: go about doing that except the quasi-legal way of petitioning
- 50:24Speaker 2: the Trump administration or the United States. Let's say that
- 50:27Speaker 2: EO doesn't get rescinded and they say, go for it,
- 50:31Speaker 2: and nobody in the United States stops them. So there's
- 50:36Speaker 2: no path.
- 50:37Speaker 4: The thing is, yes, there is a domestic path. You
- 50:41Speaker 4: can certainly be an American company, a space resources company,
- 50:46Speaker 4: duly incorporated in the United States, ready to go. But
- 50:50Speaker 4: the problem is your operations are not going to take
- 50:53Speaker 4: place on U.S. soil. And that sort of complicates things.
- 50:57Speaker 4: And that's why I'm saying that domestic law that allows
- 51:00Speaker 4: you to own space resources can only go as far
- 51:05Speaker 4: as securing those rights within that country. But operationally, since
- 51:10Speaker 4: you will be conducting those operations in space, on the moon,
- 51:15Speaker 4: where no country can assert any sort of sovereignty, so
- 51:21Speaker 4: it's not up to the United States to actually give
- 51:25Speaker 4: that right away, let's say. But what the U.S. can
- 51:28Speaker 4: legally tell you is that if you extract them, if
- 51:30Speaker 4: you bring them back, since I recognize your ownership, you
- 51:34Speaker 4: can sell them here. subject to whatever other regulations there
- 51:38Speaker 4: might be. But as far as the United States is concerned,
- 51:42Speaker 4: that's going to be a perfectly legitimate business. There's no
- 51:45Speaker 4: question there. The same is also the case for Luxembourg.
- 51:47Speaker 4: But the operational difficulty is, imagine a terrestrial mining operation.
- 51:53Speaker 4: There is absolutely no cross-border element there. If you get
- 51:56Speaker 4: a mining license in the U.S., you mine in the U.S.,
- 51:59Speaker 4: in the U.S., But if you get a space mining
- 52:02Speaker 4: license in the U.S., then you have to mine in space,
- 52:05Speaker 4: where the U.S. has no technical jurisdiction, except for the
- 52:09Speaker 4: space object exception that I mentioned. But if you're mining
- 52:12Speaker 4: on the soil, the lunar soil, that's not your territory.
- 52:16Speaker 2: Well, I didn't practice this, but you actually gave me
- 52:19Speaker 2: a thought. Maybe I should have been a supervillain, except
- 52:21Speaker 2: I have no resources or powers. But how about I
- 52:26Speaker 2: send up a ship, and in that ship, I have
- 52:29Speaker 2: made me I'm not the U.S. ambassador to Greece. I
- 52:33Speaker 2: am an astronaut slash billionaire philanthropist playboy genius and an
- 52:40Speaker 2: actual diplomat from the Secretary of State. And wherever I go,
- 52:45Speaker 2: it's an embassy. And then there's a big 3D printer
- 52:48Speaker 2: out there that used in situ resources to build me
- 52:50Speaker 2: a little dome. And that dome becomes bigger and bigger
- 52:54Speaker 2: on the far side of the moon. And it turns
- 52:56Speaker 2: out to be, you know, whatever, as big as six
- 52:59Speaker 2: data centers up there. And we call that the U.S.
- 53:03Speaker 2: Embassy because me, a diplomat, named a diplomat by, you know, whatever,
- 53:08Speaker 2: some president in the future. I don't blame the current guy.
- 53:14Speaker 2: And now it is U.S. territory. And now, you know,
- 53:19Speaker 2: and I say, hey, there's no law that says I
- 53:21Speaker 2: can't go into the ground. I'm building a bunker for
- 53:25Speaker 2: national security. and a ballroom in case I want to
- 53:28Speaker 2: host all of the future diplomats who are coming up here.
- 53:31Speaker 2: I mean, you can find easy legal loopholes to these things,
- 53:36Speaker 2: and it's sort of our job to look into those.
- 53:38Speaker 2: And I know it sounds absurd, and I know it sounds...
- 53:41Speaker 2: But if this dummy can think of that in the
- 53:43Speaker 2: course of a podcast, Stephen Miller can think of it too,
- 53:47Speaker 2: if he cared about that particular issue.
- 53:49Speaker 4: But that would still be appropriation, I think, Jeff, because
- 53:52Speaker 4: from the moment you leave the space object and into
- 53:56Speaker 4: the soil... Now, you're not in the U.S. anymore, let's
- 54:02Speaker 4: put it that way. If you build a subterranean bunker,
- 54:06Speaker 4: you're basically enveloping it with the moon. And not only that,
- 54:13Speaker 4: that facility has to still, others have to have sort
- 54:18Speaker 4: of free access to that facility as long as it's
- 54:21Speaker 4: basically built into the moon.
- 54:24Speaker 2: Anybody is free to come and visit and claim asylum
- 54:29Speaker 2: or do anything else. You can get your passport stamped,
- 54:32Speaker 2: whatever you like.
- 54:33Speaker 4: Yeah, you could use it, but you couldn't just say,
- 54:36Speaker 4: for example, now this is the American embassy and no
- 54:42Speaker 4: one else is allowed. That would directly contravene Article 2.
- 54:46Speaker 4: You cannot make out of the moon itself, you cannot
- 54:49Speaker 4: make something within the moon that says, This is our territory.
- 54:54Speaker 4: You cannot come in here. That would be exactly the
- 54:58Speaker 4: kind of prohibition under non-appropriation.
- 55:01Speaker 2: Off the record, then I'm going to leave this thing.
- 55:03Speaker 2: And I know off the record means nothing when we're
- 55:04Speaker 2: live on a podcast. Do you want to bet? Do
- 55:07Speaker 2: you want to bet?
- 55:09Speaker 4: No, no, I'm not saying this is not going to...
- 55:11Speaker 4: So the thing is, I mean, I'm not really speculating
- 55:14Speaker 4: on whether anyone's going to do this or not. I mean,
- 55:16Speaker 4: stranger things have happened.
- 55:18Speaker 2: It's just illegal as a matter of law right now.
- 55:20Speaker 4: Yeah, it just would be illegal, but it would be
- 55:23Speaker 4: certainly illegal. But again, so many things are happening nowadays
- 55:28Speaker 4: that shouldn't be happening, and they're happening anyway. So, yeah,
- 55:32Speaker 4: I mean, who's to say that someone will do it
- 55:34Speaker 4: and will absolutely get away with it? But someone will
- 55:37Speaker 4: definitely protest.
- 55:39Speaker 2: I'm in the wrong business. I really should be in
- 55:42Speaker 2: the super villain business. I mean, even if I don't
- 55:45Speaker 2: support those actions, I come up with little clever things,
- 55:50Speaker 2: especially in this world of if you push first and
- 55:52Speaker 2: say I was right to do it, half the world says,
- 55:57Speaker 2: he was right to do it. So.
- 56:00Speaker 2: This is the time to be a super villain, I suppose.
- 56:03Speaker 4: Maybe another thing is sort of a caveat that I
- 56:07Speaker 4: must add to this.
- 56:09Speaker 2: Please do. Please bring me back to reality.
- 56:11Speaker 4: No, it's just like because certain activities on the moon,
- 56:15Speaker 4: let's say a research facility or a power plant of
- 56:19Speaker 4: some sort, like there's also talk about nuclear power plants.
- 56:23Speaker 4: So certain operations require a certain capacity permanent or let's
- 56:30Speaker 4: not say permanent, but long-term presence on a particular location.
- 56:34Speaker 4: But if you establish, let's say you establish some sort
- 56:36Speaker 4: of nuclear facility on some part of the moon or
- 56:41Speaker 4: data centers or any sort of facility that is like
- 56:45Speaker 4: a brick and mortar facility, you know, imagine that it
- 56:49Speaker 4: has to stay there for some time, right? You cannot
- 56:52Speaker 4: just make everything portable, ready to go in a couple
- 56:55Speaker 4: of days or weeks or months or even years. especially
- 56:58Speaker 4: if you have like a fully fledged power production facility,
- 57:02Speaker 4: it's going to stay there for some decades at least.
- 57:06Speaker 4: I'm not really privy to the technical requirements, but I
- 57:10Speaker 4: would imagine that if you have a nuclear power plant
- 57:12Speaker 4: on the moon, it's going to stay there for some time.
- 57:15Speaker 4: So just because that stays there for some time doesn't
- 57:19Speaker 4: necessarily mean that the owner of that facility is appropriating
- 57:23Speaker 4: that territory. That's not necessarily the case. If the nature
- 57:30Speaker 4: of that particular activity requires a certain duration for that
- 57:35Speaker 4: operation to continue for a certain time, then that may
- 57:38Speaker 4: well be fine. Again, you can use that territory proportionately
- 57:44Speaker 4: to the objectives of your operations, provided that it is proportionate,
- 57:50Speaker 4: provided that you don't unduly prevent access to that space
- 57:54Speaker 4: because others also have the same freedom that you do.
- 57:58Speaker 4: But you also have the right as an operator that
- 58:05Speaker 4: you have the entitlement that others will not harmfully interfere
- 58:10Speaker 4: with your operation. So it's a balancing act. You can
- 58:13Speaker 4: freely use and explore. You can be present in a
- 58:17Speaker 4: particular place for a specified period of time. You are
- 58:22Speaker 4: entitled not to be harmfully interfered with, but you also
- 58:28Speaker 4: cannot claim to own that place. You cannot prevent others
- 58:31Speaker 4: from accessing that space, that particular location. So, you know,
- 58:36Speaker 4: whatever situation, whatever activity we're talking about in that proper context,
- 58:41Speaker 4: we have to balance different considerations and different rights that
- 58:47Speaker 4: outer space treaty and international space law lays before us. So, um,
- 58:53Speaker 4: In the example that you're giving, if there's a subterranean
- 58:56Speaker 4: bunker of some sort, there are many ways that that
- 59:01Speaker 4: could well be legal. But, for example, what's the purpose
- 59:05Speaker 4: of that bunker? What's happening in How transparent are the
- 59:13Speaker 4: operations that are taking place? How accessible it is to others?
- 59:19Speaker 4: Is it just a completely isolated, indefinitely isolated space where
- 59:24Speaker 4: some top secret stuff is happening? And top secret stuff
- 59:27Speaker 4: can happen on the moon. There's nothing preventing it. But again,
- 59:31Speaker 4: how long will that bunker be there and how long
- 59:34Speaker 4: will you insulate or isolate that space from everyone else?
- 59:39Speaker 4: You might fall on the unlawful uses or de facto
- 59:46Speaker 4: appropriation side of things, in which case things become unlawful.
- 59:50Speaker 4: So like sort of this blanket categorization of this type
- 59:55Speaker 4: of use is illegal, this type of use is legal,
- 59:57Speaker 4: I think we have to be cautious about that because
- 1:00:00Speaker 4: It really depends on the context very much.
- 1:00:03Speaker 2: I mean, dual use is also a very big issue.
- 1:00:06Speaker 2: I mean, we have it here on wars that are
- 1:00:09Speaker 2: going on right now. What's a dual use thing? I mean,
- 1:00:13Speaker 2: in space, if you have enough speed behind shooting a penny,
- 1:00:18Speaker 2: that's a weapon of mass destruction. But getting off that,
- 1:00:23Speaker 2: I'm truly a philanthropist. and I want to do all
- 1:00:30Speaker 2: the right things. Who do I ask? Do I just
- 1:00:33Speaker 2: go through my government, or is there some UN or
- 1:00:36Speaker 2: some other international body where you go, I want a
- 1:00:38Speaker 2: petition to make a nuclear power station on the moon,
- 1:00:43Speaker 2: and forget about all the issues in AI and data centers.
- 1:00:46Speaker 2: Let's just say that everyone agrees that data centers on
- 1:00:48Speaker 2: the moon is a good idea, and we need data centers.
- 1:00:51Speaker 2: I'm going to build data centers free for everyone to
- 1:00:56Speaker 2: use in the world, and It won't cause any environmental
- 1:00:59Speaker 2: damage on the Earth. And also, let's set aside that
- 1:01:01Speaker 2: we don't care about environmental damage on the moon at
- 1:01:04Speaker 2: this point. Who do you go to for that? Is
- 1:01:09Speaker 2: there some UN body? Is there some international body? Is
- 1:01:11Speaker 2: it just like you go to your country and your
- 1:01:14Speaker 2: country says, sure, or you just frigging do it and
- 1:01:17Speaker 2: you do it and see what happens? I mean, yeah.
- 1:01:20Speaker 4: I mean, I would say if you're an American company
- 1:01:24Speaker 4: or if you're an American philanthropist, You go to your
- 1:01:27Speaker 4: own government and you see whether or not you can
- 1:01:31Speaker 4: contract that project with the relevant authorities in your country.
- 1:01:35Speaker 4: For example, in Europe, you could do this via your government.
- 1:01:42Speaker 4: You could do this through some European Space Agency projects.
- 1:01:46Speaker 4: But if you have so much money, you could certainly
- 1:01:49Speaker 4: personally approach to the European Space Agency and say, look,
- 1:01:53Speaker 4: let's just build this up. Let's do it together. So
- 1:01:56Speaker 4: you don't necessarily have to follow through the regular track
- 1:02:01Speaker 4: if you have so much money, then you could potentially create,
- 1:02:05Speaker 4: carve your own path, I would say. But under normal circumstances, yes,
- 1:02:10Speaker 4: if you have an idea, if you have a commercial entity,
- 1:02:13Speaker 4: the typical thing, the first thing to do would be
- 1:02:17Speaker 4: to seek some sort of government contract, to take part
- 1:02:22Speaker 4: in one of the government contracts that are ongoing, That
- 1:02:24Speaker 4: is also in the space sector in particular. Government contracts
- 1:02:28Speaker 4: is the strongest seal of approval. It's the strongest form
- 1:02:32Speaker 4: of endorsement. If you're an up-and-coming company, that will also
- 1:02:38Speaker 4: ensure that maybe some private investors will take an interest
- 1:02:43Speaker 4: in your project. But even where you have a lot
- 1:02:45Speaker 4: of money, states will not just blindly, or maybe that's
- 1:02:50Speaker 4: just my wishful thinking, but I certainly would like to
- 1:02:53Speaker 4: believe that, they would certainly do a certain due diligence
- 1:02:58Speaker 4: before they can commit to something like that. Because, first
- 1:03:00Speaker 4: of all, who are you? What are your goals? Why
- 1:03:03Speaker 4: do you want to do what you want to do?
- 1:03:07Speaker 4: How do you plan to do it? How are you
- 1:03:09Speaker 4: going to go about it? Do you know what.
- 1:03:11Speaker 2: It's a cookbook now.
- 1:03:15Speaker 4: So, yeah, I mean, typically, yes, to answer your question,
- 1:03:19Speaker 4: I think the first place that you would go is...
- 1:03:22Speaker 4: your own government, absolutely. Even like SpaceX, right? There was initially,
- 1:03:30Speaker 4: without the US government's support and the government's contracts, it
- 1:03:37Speaker 4: wouldn't have happened. It would be a simplification to say
- 1:03:40Speaker 4: that Elon Musk just had so much money and he
- 1:03:42Speaker 4: tried and failed and he just built another rocket again
- 1:03:45Speaker 4: because he had hundreds of millions of dollars to burn,
- 1:03:48Speaker 4: which may be true, but that's only part of the story.
- 1:03:53Speaker 2: He's extraordinarily subsidized. Yeah, exactly. And through multiple administrations and parties.
- 1:04:01Speaker 4: Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:04:04Speaker 2: And you can see why. You can understand why they
- 1:04:07Speaker 2: do it because it's cheaper and NASA can't spend tax
- 1:04:14Speaker 2: dollars and experiment recklessly with rockets and have them explode.
- 1:04:17Speaker 2: The private industry, you can. You can't break a lot
- 1:04:20Speaker 2: of things to get it right if you're NASA. you know,
- 1:04:24Speaker 2: congressional oversight goes crazy. You know, but in the private industry,
- 1:04:28Speaker 2: you have, you know, whatever that version is of crash
- 1:04:31Speaker 2: test dummies are. And that's fine. Okay, so I've taken us,
- 1:04:36Speaker 2: I'm not sure if I've taken us astray or a
- 1:04:39Speaker 2: field or if I'm exactly in the right field. Oh,
- 1:04:41Speaker 2: you're shaking hands. I was going to give you an
- 1:04:43Speaker 2: opportunity to just clear the slate and take us to
- 1:04:47Speaker 2: how things are supposed to be. But if I've been
- 1:04:51Speaker 2: operating in the right ballpark, I feel pretty good about that.
- 1:04:54Speaker 2: And the reason is because I told you, between an hour,
- 1:04:57Speaker 2: you know, 45 minutes and 75 minutes is all you
- 1:05:00Speaker 2: promised me, and we're at 65 minutes. And I don't
- 1:05:04Speaker 2: know if the time has flown for you. It has
- 1:05:06Speaker 2: for me.
- 1:05:07Speaker 4: It has. It certainly has, yeah.
- 1:05:10Speaker 2: I want to be respectful of your time, but if
- 1:05:12Speaker 2: there's something that you want to put out there to, like,
- 1:05:14Speaker 2: you know, take it on a full, if everyone acted
- 1:05:17Speaker 2: the way they're supposed to do, if you want to
- 1:05:19Speaker 2: clarify that for the world, or at least the listeners
- 1:05:24Speaker 2: of this show, which of course is the world or
- 1:05:25Speaker 2: will be after this show, what would you like to clarify?
- 1:05:29Speaker 2: Did we get it all right?
- 1:05:30Speaker 4: I think even if you did lead us astray, I
- 1:05:36Speaker 4: think you've done a great job doing that as well.
- 1:05:38Speaker 4: I think this was perfect also, that the cadence of
- 1:05:41Speaker 4: everything and the sequence of subjects, it was really, really good.
- 1:05:45Speaker 4: Would I pass your class?
- 1:05:47Speaker 2: Sorry? Would I pass your class?
- 1:05:49Speaker 4: Absolutely. Absolutely you would. No, I mean, you could certainly
- 1:05:54Speaker 4: teach my class. I don't really have anything new to add,
- 1:06:00Speaker 4: maybe to sort of tidy up or consolidate a little
- 1:06:03Speaker 4: bit what we said.
- 1:06:04Speaker 2: You can use any of these hypotheticals if you like
- 1:06:06Speaker 2: in tests and things like that.
- 1:06:08Speaker 4: Yeah, yeah. I mean, this whole lunar embassy thing, it's
- 1:06:11Speaker 4: kind of giving me opinions and some ideas and opinions.
- 1:06:15Speaker 2: Almost a pretty face.
- 1:06:17Speaker 4: Yeah, maybe the next exam I do, it's going to
- 1:06:20Speaker 4: be like a hypothetical case study, what happens when a
- 1:06:22Speaker 4: state claims to own or claims to establish an embassy
- 1:06:26Speaker 4: and then asserts that the.
- 1:06:29Speaker 2: We all seek immortality however we can get it.
- 1:06:32Speaker 4: Yeah, exactly. So, I mean, the sort of overarching theme,
- 1:06:41Speaker 4: I think, is, again, the interaction... or confrontation between states
- 1:06:49Speaker 4: and private entities. That's really the essence of this, especially
- 1:06:55Speaker 4: when we talk about space mining and space resource extraction.
- 1:07:00Speaker 4: This really is going to happen as a common endeavor
- 1:07:04Speaker 4: between states and private entities. It's not going to be
- 1:07:08Speaker 4: solely conducted by states. And states are, while they still can,
- 1:07:14Speaker 4: they're sort of trying to build up a legal framework,
- 1:07:18Speaker 4: a political framework, a policy framework to ensure that this
- 1:07:23Speaker 4: collaboration will not turn into some sort of volatile conflict
- 1:07:29Speaker 4: or confrontation. And it's inevitable, I think, at this point
- 1:07:35Speaker 4: that private entities will have a role to play. It's
- 1:07:39Speaker 4: not just a matter of opinion. I think the way
- 1:07:43Speaker 4: that things are developing, not only in the space resources,
- 1:07:46Speaker 4: this nascent field, nascent sub-sector of space economy, if we
- 1:07:49Speaker 4: can call it that. We see this proliferation of commercial
- 1:07:53Speaker 4: entities everywhere in the space sector, and there's no reason
- 1:07:56Speaker 4: to believe that space resource activities will be an exception.
- 1:08:01Speaker 4: What is important, however, is first of all that states
- 1:08:05Speaker 4: live up to their identity as states, as the regulators,
- 1:08:14Speaker 4: as the architects of international law, as they are. This
- 1:08:18Speaker 4: is also not necessarily a political declaration, but that's what
- 1:08:23Speaker 4: states are. They are the ones who create international law.
- 1:08:25Speaker 4: It's the truth. They have to seize that task. They
- 1:08:31Speaker 4: have to seize that capability and authority and create a sustainable, balanced,
- 1:08:39Speaker 4: environment where these companies can thrive, they can develop technologies,
- 1:08:46Speaker 4: they can develop capabilities that are not present at the moment.
- 1:08:53Speaker 4: But it shouldn't be regulation for the sake of regulation.
- 1:08:56Speaker 4: It shouldn't be just some show of dominance. just a
- 1:09:00Speaker 4: show of power just for the sake of it. It
- 1:09:05Speaker 4: has to serve a purpose. It has to be smart.
- 1:09:09Speaker 4: It has to be enabling the positives and restricting the negatives.
- 1:09:14Speaker 4: And the positives must build upon this presumption that we
- 1:09:18Speaker 4: must be able to continue space activities, whatever that means.
- 1:09:25Speaker 4: If we need to protect the environment to be able
- 1:09:28Speaker 4: to sustain space activities, then we must protect the environment.
- 1:09:32Speaker 4: If we must carve out certain activities from the domain
- 1:09:38Speaker 4: of private or commercial space activities, then so be it.
- 1:09:43Speaker 4: How they're going to take shape into the future, how
- 1:09:47Speaker 4: they're going to take shape as these nascent fields, subfields
- 1:09:53Speaker 4: develop that is yet to be seen. But this is
- 1:09:57Speaker 4: a very important part of not just space law, but
- 1:10:02Speaker 4: it's a very important part, it's a very important chapter
- 1:10:05Speaker 4: in humanity's story going forward. And international law or politics
- 1:10:11Speaker 4: that sort of undergird them, it's just a part of it,
- 1:10:13Speaker 4: it's just a part of that story. And states have
- 1:10:17Speaker 4: to sort of play their parts. and companies must play
- 1:10:20Speaker 4: their parts. They must adhere to what is morally, ethically,
- 1:10:27Speaker 4: and legally required of them. And it's also important that
- 1:10:31Speaker 4: we don't repeat the same mistakes that we have made
- 1:10:37Speaker 4: when it comes to Earth and how we treat Earth
- 1:10:43Speaker 4: in certain ways. So I think this requires communication and
- 1:10:49Speaker 4: absolutely good faith and a very robust and very firm,
- 1:10:55Speaker 4: concrete operational legal framework that applies not only to these
- 1:11:00Speaker 4: private investors, private capital, commercial equities, but also states themselves.
- 1:11:06Speaker 4: And commercial entities must also behave in a moral, ethical way,
- 1:11:13Speaker 4: not just focusing on extraction and not establishing any sort
- 1:11:19Speaker 4: of colonization discourse, because I hear that a lot as well.
- 1:11:22Speaker 4: Colonization of the moon, colonization of Mars. That should not
- 1:11:26Speaker 4: be part of our vocabulary going into space. It is
- 1:11:33Speaker 4: very Star Trek. It's about exploration and it's about finding
- 1:11:37Speaker 4: out what's there. It's about maybe not intervening when we
- 1:11:41Speaker 4: don't have to intervene and all that. I think this
- 1:11:44Speaker 4: should be our approach. to not just resource extraction, but
- 1:11:48Speaker 4: sort of as states and commercial entities go together into space,
- 1:11:53Speaker 4: this should be the balance. One about cooperation and not
- 1:11:57Speaker 4: necessarily confrontation or conflict.
- 1:12:02Speaker 2: I agree with every single thing you've just said.
- 1:12:05Speaker 4: I'm glad.
- 1:12:09Speaker 2: There's nothing I can or should add to that. I
- 1:12:12Speaker 2: don't know if you are someone who wants to be
- 1:12:15Speaker 2: found and followed in social media or if you have
- 1:12:18Speaker 2: a book or anything like that you sell or a
- 1:12:19Speaker 2: sub stack or anything like that. I, you know, we
- 1:12:21Speaker 2: met on LinkedIn, but if you do, this is your
- 1:12:24Speaker 2: time to plug it. Other than that, people can just
- 1:12:26Speaker 2: apply to the university of Exeter or.
- 1:12:28Speaker 4: Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. I mean, I, yeah, we have a,
- 1:12:33Speaker 4: we have a very good, uh, master's program, uh, on, uh,
- 1:12:37Speaker 4: among other things on international law, which hopefully, uh, as
- 1:12:41Speaker 4: I take root there, will also include international space law.
- 1:12:45Speaker 4: I also supervise PhD research on international law, international space law.
- 1:12:51Speaker 4: So that's something perhaps interesting to some of the listeners.
- 1:12:55Speaker 4: I'm more than happy to connect on LinkedIn, of course.
- 1:12:59Speaker 4: And one thing that is still a work in progress,
- 1:13:01Speaker 4: but hopefully in 2028, I will have a new book
- 1:13:08Speaker 4: coming out specifically on the protection or governance of foreign
- 1:13:14Speaker 4: investment in the space sector and international protection and international
- 1:13:18Speaker 4: governance of foreign investment in the space sector in a
- 1:13:22Speaker 4: book entitled Capital Beyond Earth. Again, it's a work in progress,
- 1:13:27Speaker 4: but around 2028, it should hit the shelves if I
- 1:13:31Speaker 4: can actually finish writing the book.
- 1:13:35Speaker 2: Well, you're welcome back anytime. I may reach out to
- 1:13:38Speaker 2: you if there are certain things that come up in
- 1:13:40Speaker 2: the news or on my feed that seem like they
- 1:13:43Speaker 2: are within your wheelhouse or your orbit, so to speak,
- 1:13:47Speaker 2: in your perihelion. But certainly, if not before that. When
- 1:13:54Speaker 2: your book is going to come out, we'll talk about it. Yeah.
- 1:13:58Speaker 2: I don't know how many we'll sell as a result
- 1:14:00Speaker 2: of a podcast, but hey, if nothing else, we practice
- 1:14:03Speaker 2: for podcasts where people actually buy books from podcasts. And
- 1:14:07Speaker 2: maybe they do. I really have no idea. I have
- 1:14:09Speaker 2: lots of authors that come and come back, so maybe
- 1:14:11Speaker 2: it has worked. In any event, thank you for humoring me.
- 1:14:15Speaker 2: Thank you for validating me, but thank you mostly for
- 1:14:17Speaker 2: sharing your information on this topic. There really aren't any
- 1:14:21Speaker 2: clear answers yet, in an unclear world, but there are
- 1:14:25Speaker 2: clearer answers if people, and by people I mean non-human people, states,
- 1:14:32Speaker 2: you know, act the way they're supposed to act. And
- 1:14:37Speaker 2: once again, I'll stop myself right there. All right, folks,
- 1:14:39Speaker 2: thanks for listening to Garden of Thought. If you're here
- 1:14:43Speaker 2: by accident or you're following the professor, you can subscribe
- 1:14:46Speaker 2: to the Sports Jedi Media Network on YouTube or sportsjedimedia.com.
- 1:14:51Speaker 2: Sports Jedi Network, anywhere else. You can simply also subscribe
- 1:14:55Speaker 2: to Garden of Thought Audio or at Garden of Thought
- 1:14:58Speaker 2: Pod on YouTube if you like. Hey, subscribe to them all.
- 1:15:01Speaker 2: And if you want to hear more from me, I
- 1:15:03Speaker 2: generally do this show twice a week, but sometimes it's
- 1:15:08Speaker 2: more wacky and wild if you can imagine that. But
- 1:15:10Speaker 2: this Wednesday, Mike Hilliard from the Redline podcast, which is
- 1:15:13Speaker 2: a fantastic geopolitical podcast. Unless something happens to him, he's
- 1:15:18Speaker 2: going to come on and talk about what the heck
- 1:15:21Speaker 2: is going on in Venezuela. He'll talk to us about
- 1:15:24Speaker 2: the Middle East and waterways and what's going on in
- 1:15:26Speaker 2: Ukraine and anything else that we should probably be keeping
- 1:15:29Speaker 2: our eye on in the world. Next week, I have
- 1:15:31Speaker 2: a friend, Bernie Taylor, who's going to be talking to
- 1:15:34Speaker 2: us about tales of the Berbers. So going a little
- 1:15:37Speaker 2: bit more into mythology, but he always ties things into art.
- 1:15:41Speaker 2: And if you like my wrestling stuff, 6 o'clock tomorrow, 6.05,
- 1:15:45Speaker 2: me and my best friend Mr. Thomas on the MLW
- 1:15:47Speaker 2: Files will be reviewing not only the most recent episode
- 1:15:51Speaker 2: of Fusion, but MLW's first pay-per-view in years last night, Superfight.
- 1:15:56Speaker 2: So we'll be talking about that. New world champion. Exciting stuff.
- 1:16:01Speaker 2: And all the other shows I'm on, The Padawan Awakens,
- 1:16:04Speaker 2: Tuesday Nights After NXT, and at this time I also
- 1:16:09Speaker 2: have a Thursday Garden of Thought scheduled. It's always subject
- 1:16:11Speaker 2: to change because it's a lawyer. And we're talking about
- 1:16:13Speaker 2: immigration law, and she's obviously very busy, but she's been
- 1:16:16Speaker 2: on the show before. And she comes on, and it's
- 1:16:20Speaker 2: actually a lot of fun, but it's also serious. So
- 1:16:22Speaker 2: hopefully Thursday night, Sherry Hoyter talking about the state of
- 1:16:27Speaker 2: immigration law in the United States right now on Thursday. So, wow,
- 1:16:30Speaker 2: I'm working hard. Check out the show with Brian Idol.
- 1:16:34Speaker 2: Check out the show with Nasty Leroy. Check out the
- 1:16:36Speaker 2: show with Alex Kane. A bunch of those hopefully will
- 1:16:39Speaker 2: be repeated. I'm cooking. I have no line. So there
- 1:16:43Speaker 2: you go. Thank you to the professor for sitting here
- 1:16:45Speaker 2: and listening through all this. Everyone, be well. See you
- 1:16:49Speaker 2: next time.
- 1:16:50Speaker 4: Thanks for having me, Jeff. Thank you.
- 1:16:52Speaker 2: Thanks for coming. I really do appreciate it.