Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Defending ADA Claims: What Every Business Lawyer Needs To Know
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:06Defending ADA Claims, what every business lawyer
- 0:09needs to know. I'm Alla Policastro, Director
- 0:12of Education and Professional Development at
- 0:14Beverly Hills Bar Association. And I'm delighted
- 0:17to introduce our speakers today, Matthew Kenefick
- 0:20and Hilary Johns. Hilary is a civil trial lawyer
- 0:23and a very active member of the Beverly Hills
- 0:25Bar Association who is going to provide introductions
- 0:28for Matthew. So Hilary, over to you. Yeah, and
- 0:32good morning, and I'm going to introduce my friend
- 0:35and colleague, Matthew Kinnepeck. Matt is a hiring
- 0:37partner at Jeffers Mingles and Mitchell, and
- 0:40Matt litigates in a lot of areas in complex matters,
- 0:46but in particular, part of his practice involves
- 0:48defending ADA claims, and he has a very impressive
- 0:51list of clients. So I think given the current
- 0:55political climate and legal climate, a lot of
- 0:58business lawyers, a lot of litigators are seeing
- 1:00these claims based on accessibility and other
- 1:03claims. So I think these are things that every
- 1:05business lawyer should know. So Matt is going
- 1:08to review all of these with you. And I'm really
- 1:10looking forward to this presentation today, Matt.
- 1:12We also want to say a special thank you to Jeffers,
- 1:15Mangels, and Mitchell for these fantastic materials
- 1:18that you have. Some of you have seen the slides,
- 1:20some of you have seen the materials, and Matt's
- 1:23team for putting this together. Matt. Well, thank
- 1:26you for the introduction and thank you for having
- 1:30me here. Let me see if I can go ahead and put
- 1:32up on the screen the slideshow. So there we go.
- 1:38Alright, so that's the introductory slide and
- 1:42the title of the program. So here's the agenda
- 1:45and we're going to go over all the different
- 1:48items here throughout today and we'll try to
- 1:52move through them. So first of all, the introduction,
- 1:59the ADA and the overview about the scope of it
- 2:03in general. So we want to talk about that. So
- 2:08what is the ADA? So the ADA is a civil rights
- 2:14act. It's intended to provide protection individuals
- 2:19with disabilities just the same as you would
- 2:21see protections be given under other civil rights
- 2:24context such as race. Color sex national origin
- 2:29age religion etc the idea is it's it's to provide
- 2:35equal opportunity to persons with disabilities
- 2:38to participate in society there was a time where
- 2:43people with disabilities. really couldn't participate.
- 2:47They couldn't leave their house. They couldn't
- 2:49go to dinner with their family because, you know,
- 2:51because of stairs or other issues at public accommodations.
- 2:55And the idea of the ADA was to try to bring these
- 3:00issues out, give some guidance to public accommodations
- 3:04and to other businesses in other areas. We'll
- 3:06talk about the scope of the ADA and to integrate
- 3:09these individuals with disabilities into society.
- 3:12As a remedial statute, that means it's gonna
- 3:15be broadly construed towards its intended purpose.
- 3:19So we see that a lot in judicial construction
- 3:22of accessibility. The other thing about it is,
- 3:27it's intended to give a comprehensive set of
- 3:29guidelines. It's one thing to say, okay, you
- 3:32can't discriminate against persons with disabilities.
- 3:36But it's another thing to tell somebody how to
- 3:38do that. And the ADA tries to do that. And there
- 3:43are similar state laws that try to do that as
- 3:45well. Now, there is a regulatory framework for
- 3:50this that serves as sort of a guideline, I think,
- 3:53for attorneys and some very high -growth areas
- 3:55that I know you're going to also discuss. Yes,
- 3:59let's talk about that. So we have basically five
- 4:04sections of the ADA. The first one goes to employment.
- 4:12And the second one goes to public services, that's
- 4:15state and local governments. The third one, which
- 4:19today we'll primarily focus on, is Title III,
- 4:21and that's public accommodations. And we'll talk
- 4:24about what a public accommodations is. IV is
- 4:27a little more esoteric, it's telecommunications,
- 4:29but we'll touch on that a little as well. And
- 4:32then Title V is just the... middle is just a
- 4:36miscellaneous catch -all. Title III, as I said,
- 4:40public accommodations, we'll talk about that,
- 4:42but it's really just any place of business that
- 4:46is open to the public. There can be a lot of
- 4:50discussion about what is and isn't public accommodation,
- 4:53but that's definitely one of the key focuses.
- 4:57And that's the next slide here. And so we have
- 5:02a whole list of examples that are codified. Hotels,
- 5:06restaurants, convention centers, pharmacies,
- 5:11even a law firm, golf courses, beaches, et cetera.
- 5:17These are all places where they have private
- 5:23entities or under Title II, public entities,
- 5:27where you have areas that are accessible to the
- 5:32public in general. Obviously, it's because you
- 5:37remember the commerce clause. It's supposed to
- 5:39affect commerce, so that's how Congress gets
- 5:41to attach it for its federal powers. There is
- 5:47obviously some dispute over how far that goes
- 5:50because sometimes there's some nuances. We talk
- 5:54about private clubs by way of example. We talk
- 5:57about private businesses. And we'll see that
- 6:00sometimes, let's say by way of example, you have
- 6:03a private club that's not open to the public
- 6:06or a private business that's not open to a public,
- 6:08but they open it periodically, right? For, you
- 6:12know, I worked at one very, very large campus,
- 6:16corporate campus, one of the largest in the country,
- 6:21where they would open it up periodically, once
- 6:24a year, twice a year for large political events.
- 6:29Well, it becomes a public accommodation. Same
- 6:32thing with those clubs, that country club that's
- 6:34not open to anybody, or the yacht club that opens
- 6:38up for a wedding, or you can rent it out for
- 6:44a bar mitzvah. Those places likewise become public
- 6:50accommodations. So we talk a lot about What do
- 6:56we get as ADA lawyers? What do we get as lawyers?
- 7:00Well, a lot of people come into the accessibility
- 7:02context with urban legends, right? And so I want
- 7:08to list some of them here. So the first one,
- 7:12of course, is grandfathering. We've all heard
- 7:14the concept of grandfathering. And that is, you
- 7:17know, my building was built in a certain time
- 7:19period, so new laws don't apply. And we'll hear
- 7:24that from clients. And grandfathering does apply.
- 7:27It absolutely does apply in certain contexts.
- 7:30And we'll talk about that, primarily under the
- 7:33building code. And then we do get some safe havens
- 7:40under the ADA, but primarily a building that
- 7:45predates the enactment of the ADA. It's, you
- 7:48know, 1992 actually, talking 1993 for public
- 7:53accommodations for the for January is the effective
- 7:59date. But the reason why it still applies is
- 8:03because there is readily achievable access barrier
- 8:06removal. We'll talk about that. But the fact
- 8:09is, just because you're building predates, the
- 8:13ADA, doesn't mean that you do not have an obligation
- 8:16under the ADA to remove barriers to access. We
- 8:21have another urban legend. Hey, look the light
- 8:26license architect or building department approved
- 8:28it That's that's a false Assumption you can still
- 8:34be liable. There are some protections for a brief
- 8:38window of time 2008 to 2016 when we had Casps
- 8:44that certified access specialists embedded in
- 8:46the building department and you have a reduction
- 8:48in damages there. We'll talk about that It's
- 8:52a little more complicated, but you're still liable
- 8:55under the ADA and also state regulations. We
- 9:01hear this sometimes, say, look, I don't own the
- 9:03place. I'm just the operator. You're still liable.
- 9:08Somebody who owns or operates a place of public
- 9:10accommodation is liable. There are distinctions.
- 9:14There is a case that I personally took to the
- 9:17Ninth Circuit and created a new law on. It's
- 9:20called Kohler versus Bed Bath and Beyond. I represented
- 9:23Bed Bath and Beyond in that. And that case held
- 9:26that a tenant was not responsible for violations
- 9:34in the common area parking lot. They're responsible
- 9:37for their tenant space jointly and separately.
- 9:39And we know that a landlord and tenant can separately
- 9:43allocate responsibility contractually amongst
- 9:46themselves for the financial component, but they're
- 9:48still both jointly liable to an ADA plaintiff.
- 9:53This is intended to prevent the, you know, the
- 9:56nun shell game that people could do. But the
- 10:01reason why a tenant in like a multi -tenant shopping
- 10:04center is not liable for violations in the parking
- 10:08lot, even if the tenant pays into a common area
- 10:11maintenance pool. meaning that their dollars
- 10:14go towards fixing that area, is because they
- 10:17do not own and control that area. They do not
- 10:19lease that area. You could enjoin them all day
- 10:22to say, all right, tenant, you're enjoined to
- 10:25go fix that parking lot. The tenant can't fix
- 10:28it. It's not their right. They have a license
- 10:32for their guests to park in that parking lot,
- 10:36but that's not part of their leased premises.
- 10:39under the lease. And then we did that. We argued
- 10:42that. I argued that. I briefed it and argued
- 10:44to the Ninth Circuit. And that case is widely
- 10:48relied upon throughout the country. And it makes
- 10:51sense. How can you enjoin somebody to fix a parking
- 10:54lot that they're not leasing? It's no different
- 10:57than asking them to fix the parking lot up the
- 10:59street. The next one is I can refuse service
- 11:04to anyone. We hear that a lot from small businesses.
- 11:07That's false. If you refuse service to somebody
- 11:11based upon a protected category, such as they
- 11:14have a disability, that's discrimination. Just
- 11:16the same if you said, well, I don't like this
- 11:18person's skin color, so I don't want them to
- 11:20come into my facility. Similarly, retaliation
- 11:24is a big issue. Somebody sues you, makes a claim,
- 11:27and you say, all right, you're cut off. You can't
- 11:30come in. That's retaliation. that is a violation
- 11:35of accessibility laws. So we know the business
- 11:40case is that a lot of people in our US population
- 11:45do have disabilities, estimated about 30%. We
- 11:53all probably know somebody who has some form
- 11:55of disability if you don't have one yourself.
- 11:58A lot of those individuals with disabilities
- 12:01have obtained them through military service.
- 12:04We have a high disability rate amongst our veteran
- 12:08population. So it's a common thing that affects
- 12:14a lot of people. The business case, of course,
- 12:16is persons with disabilities, their money spends
- 12:19just the same. And if somebody is in a wheelchair
- 12:23and can't access your restaurant, then they and
- 12:27their family are going to a restaurant that is
- 12:29accessible. so you can get their money. We talk
- 12:33about website compliance, right? ADA website
- 12:40issues are very common, and that is an issue
- 12:45that we'll talk about. And also, when we talk
- 12:50about public accommodation, there's always been
- 12:52a little controversy about whether or not websites
- 12:55constitute public accommodations. But either
- 12:59way, there was a survey of the top 1 million
- 13:02website pages by WebAIM. That's a company that
- 13:07does accessibility testing, and they found that
- 13:1095 % of those top 1 million pages have access
- 13:14barriers. So it's a very common issue affecting
- 13:17a lot of people. We always say compliance is
- 13:22a legal obligation, but also a business growth
- 13:24opportunity. It really depends what you do with
- 13:26it. I met with some I met with some CEOs and
- 13:32general counsels of some very, very large companies,
- 13:35some of which have told me, look, we do this
- 13:37because it's right, not because it's the law.
- 13:40It's part of customer service to make sure all
- 13:42of our customers, including those with disabilities,
- 13:46are able to use our facilities. They're able
- 13:50to use our website. So it's obviously a corporate
- 13:54culture issue, but it's a business opportunity.
- 14:02So one of the components of access is physical
- 14:08access. And that's when we think about physical
- 14:11access, you're talking about places that you
- 14:13access in the real world, right? Not on the website,
- 14:18not on your phone, not via a communications device.
- 14:21And this is probably one of the most developed
- 14:25areas of ADA law. And we talked about where you
- 14:30want to get clear guidance for businesses and
- 14:34public accommodations on what they can do and
- 14:37how to comply. Well, there are some very well
- 14:41-developed physical access requirements. They
- 14:44give you minimums and maximums and scoping requirements,
- 14:47measurements, very clear guidance on what to
- 14:50do and how to comply. And does it mean that just
- 14:56because your facility meets these dimensions?
- 14:59And that if they're gonna be 100 % accessible
- 15:02to all people, of course not. Every disability,
- 15:05every person's disability is a little bit different.
- 15:07Some people have multiple disabilities, but this
- 15:10is what has been determined through extensive
- 15:12research and outreach to the accessibility community
- 15:16to be common standards that help. By way of example,
- 15:21you may have a path to travel with. They look
- 15:23at what, you know, that's where people would.
- 15:27traverse into internal traffic of, let's say,
- 15:29a store. They figure out the average width of
- 15:33a wheelchair. They figure out the turning radius.
- 15:35They figure out other items, right? Because wheelchair
- 15:38is not the only mobility access device. It could
- 15:41be a walker. It could be a cane. It could be
- 15:44a scooter. So they look at all these different
- 15:46items, and they come up with standards that are
- 15:48supposed to be able to meet that. And those reside.
- 15:52So we have the federal. gives the federal standards
- 15:56that federal ADA gives us standards. They give
- 16:00us the 1991 versions, the ADAG, Americans with
- 16:04Disability Accessibility Guidelines. And then
- 16:07they were revised in 2010 to the ADAS, Americans
- 16:11with Disability Accessibility Standards. And
- 16:16so those are the federal standards. And that's
- 16:19important. There's some nuances between federal
- 16:21and state standards, and we'll talk about that
- 16:23a little bit throughout this presentation. The
- 16:27other thing mentioned here is Title 24 of the
- 16:31California Building Code. We always hear about
- 16:33Title 24, right? People say, oh, I got to change
- 16:35my lights to comply with Title 24. Title 24 is
- 16:39just where in the California Code of Regulations
- 16:42where the building code resides. So it's all
- 16:44building code. Section 11B of Title 24 is is
- 16:50specifically designed to apply to accessibility.
- 16:57The reason why there is a difference and it's
- 17:01important is because when the state and federal
- 17:05standards conflict, the more protective standard
- 17:09applies. So the one that provides more access.
- 17:12So a perfect example, we have some examples below
- 17:15where there's some differences. For the most
- 17:18part, the federal standard's always been for
- 17:21a transaction counter, it should be 36 inches
- 17:24above finish floor max. And the idea is, if it's
- 17:2836 inches above finish floor, somebody in a wheelchair
- 17:31can either do front access or side access, side
- 17:33approach access, to consummate that transaction.
- 17:38Well, California has a 34 inch standard. So it's
- 17:41a little different. You're supposed to meet the
- 17:43California standard. manifests a lot when we
- 17:46have prototypical designs for a national enterprise
- 17:49and then they drop them into California. We also,
- 17:53California has its own type of braille. Less
- 17:57and less braille readers these days. Braille
- 18:01traditionally was used by people who were congenitally
- 18:05blind, but we have so many accessibility or assisted
- 18:10technologies for access that Braille is less
- 18:14and less used, but there's a westernized Braille
- 18:17that California uses that's different than the
- 18:20national standard. We talk about counter hides,
- 18:24there's ATM scoping differences. So there are
- 18:29different standards. So for the Title 24, we
- 18:35get that grandfathering. So at the time that
- 18:38your building permit is pulled, when your facility
- 18:43is constructed, so to say. That's the building
- 18:46code you apply with, comply with rather. And
- 18:49that is updated tri -annually. So every three
- 18:51years, the building codes update. And that's
- 18:54what you're supposed to comply with. And then
- 18:56your grandfather did. You only update it under
- 18:59the building code when you make an alteration
- 19:02to an area. You gotta go pull a permit. What's
- 19:05an alteration? It's something that affects usability.
- 19:08Usability of the element and the entire entire
- 19:11altered element must be modified. So there is
- 19:15always dispute over what is that altered element.
- 19:19If I need to do a slurry seal of a corner of
- 19:24a parking lot, does that mean I have to bring
- 19:26the whole parking lot into compliance? If I alter
- 19:31one ATM machine, does that mean the entire bank
- 19:34of ATMs machines need to be altered? There's
- 19:41some nuances there and remember, remedial statutes
- 19:44get construed in favor of access. Yeah, I had
- 19:47a question. Some of the, where the, the facilities
- 19:50or the accessibility has to be altered to be
- 19:53compliance to all of them have to be altered
- 19:56or does there have to be just an option where
- 19:58someone, for example, is physically disabled
- 20:01and maybe can't navigate stairs or needs a ramp.
- 20:05For example, in a building, would it have to
- 20:07be all entrances or would there have to be just
- 20:09one way, at least one way for them to get in
- 20:12and out? How would that work? Yeah, you're supposed
- 20:15to have an accessible route. You're only really
- 20:17required to have one accessible route per location.
- 20:20Location, obviously, is an area of dispute. But
- 20:25you have to have signage, right? You have to
- 20:30let people know. Usually it's done with an ISA
- 20:32sign. That's the International Symbol of Accessibility.
- 20:35We've all seen it. Blue background, white wheelchair
- 20:37in the front. Another signage saying, look, this
- 20:41is where you go. Keep in mind directional signage
- 20:44triggers Braille signage requirements as well.
- 20:49But you can have one accessible route. And we
- 20:53often find that as a common... That's a common
- 20:56solution. So by way of example, maybe you have
- 21:00a route that's being identified as not being
- 21:02accessible, but you have a different path and
- 21:05you identify that as the accessible route. Certainly
- 21:08it's not supposed to be overly circuitous. You
- 21:12don't want to send somebody on a Rube Goldberg
- 21:14path to try to get in, but we see this a lot.
- 21:18You'll see it in legacy places where you have
- 21:21a set of stairs right in front of you. that get
- 21:23you right up to the front. But on the side, there's
- 21:27a ramp. They'll work for somebody with an assistive
- 21:30technology device or something for mobility,
- 21:33such as a wheelchair. You just put the sign that
- 21:36says, accessible route this way, wheelchair access
- 21:39this way. And that way they can deal with it
- 21:42and they can get in there. Because otherwise,
- 21:46you're not going to be able to... find it. And
- 21:50that goes to the scoping component, right? There's
- 21:52a lot of different things on scoping. So parking
- 21:55lots is a perfect example about scoping. So there
- 21:58are specific ratios of how many parking spots
- 22:05need to be accessible, how many parking spots
- 22:07need to be van accessible. That's something that's
- 22:11accessible to somebody using a van. So that all
- 22:16depends on the number of spots. parking spots
- 22:19in a location. So you could very well see a large
- 22:23parking lot having a certain number of parking
- 22:27spots, and then that would require more accessible
- 22:30spots. And you could also see a facility that
- 22:32maybe has a front parking lot and a back parking
- 22:35lot. And both spots are different locations,
- 22:38and both need accessible spots for a person's
- 22:42disability. But again, the idea, the signage
- 22:46is is important for that. But that does go to
- 22:50the issue, right? So now if you have to install
- 22:53that, you could trigger the building code. And
- 22:57this is the readily achievable trap. So under
- 23:01the ADA, not the building code, you're required
- 23:06to remove access barriers. when it's readily
- 23:10achievable. That means it can be achieved without
- 23:13great difficulty or expense. And it does take
- 23:15into some consideration, such as safety and security.
- 23:20Rarely see that, but it does come up sometimes.
- 23:24It absolutely does. And so if you have an obligation
- 23:32to do a readily achievable access barrier removal,
- 23:36when you remove that barrier, guess what you're
- 23:37doing? you're altering an element. And when you
- 23:41alter the element, now you got to bring it all
- 23:44the way up to the most current building code,
- 23:46the entire element, the entire altered element.
- 23:50So that's the readily achievable trap. Again,
- 23:57there is a little bit of a safe haven, they call
- 24:00it. There were some changes between the 1991
- 24:06and the 2010. Accessibility standards, the federal
- 24:09standards. If before the effective date of the
- 24:132010 standards, which my recollection is March
- 24:16of 2012, might be off on that date, but I'm pretty
- 24:19sure that was it. If before the effective date
- 24:23of the 2010 regs, when it was there, you were
- 24:26in compliance with something in the 1991 standards,
- 24:30and those standards changed, your safe haven
- 24:32did. But pro tip here, the plaintiffs who are
- 24:37going to sue you, they're not gonna do the research.
- 24:40They're not gonna pull building permit history.
- 24:43They're not going to try to figure out whether
- 24:46or not you have some type of grandfathering.
- 24:48They're gonna look and say, they're gonna apply
- 24:51the most current standards. Either you comply
- 24:54with it or if you don't, if you don't, you get
- 24:55sued. And then what ends up happening is you
- 24:58have to pay somebody like me to prove that you're
- 25:01right. Or alternatively, but the plaintiff's
- 25:04attorneys do and we'll talk about this a little
- 25:06bit. They price their cases to settle in a range
- 25:10that's cheaper than paying somebody like me to
- 25:13exonerate you. So that's the trap. So maybe you
- 25:23don't rely upon some technicality that you can
- 25:27prove in court. and you focus on, okay, let's
- 25:33look at the barriers that we can remove. And
- 25:35we'll talk about that in the prioritization section,
- 25:38but the first thing you should really be thinking
- 25:40about is what can somebody just visually observe?
- 25:45You know, there's a lot of different standards,
- 25:47but it's really easy for a person to see whether
- 25:51or not you have parking lot striping. It's really
- 25:54easy for somebody to see whether or not you have
- 25:55the right signage. it's not so easy for somebody
- 25:59to figure out whether you have a 2 % cross slope
- 26:02or 5 % running slope on your asphalt versus 6
- 26:06% and 3%, right? That takes a laser level or
- 26:10a smart level. Very few people have that, but
- 26:13they can certainly see the other stuff. So you
- 26:15have to prioritize what the issues are and how
- 26:18to do it. I almost called to your honor because
- 26:23you're so knowledgeable. I had a question. this
- 26:27readily achievable, you mentioned great difficulty
- 26:30or expense. And it just real quickly, and I know
- 26:34we have a lot to get through. We often hear this,
- 26:37it's too expensive, we can't do it. How often
- 26:41does that actually work? I mean, in practice,
- 26:44you see this more than most people. That's why
- 26:46I'm asking. Yeah, I mean, the elevator has always
- 26:48been the perfect example. It's always been held
- 26:51to be not really achievable. I've seen, there
- 26:56was one case, it was a famous case that went
- 26:59to California Supreme Court and the defendant
- 27:00got their defendant's attorney's fees because
- 27:05the plaintiff had sued under the Disabled Persons
- 27:07Act. We'll talk about that in a little bit, as
- 27:09opposed to the Unruh Civil Rights Act. The Disabled
- 27:11Persons Act has a reciprocal attorney's fees
- 27:13clause, whereas the Unruh Civil Rights Act and
- 27:16the ADA treat the attorney's fees as being damages.
- 27:20So the only way you can get your... your defense
- 27:22attorney's fees, which I have obtained before.
- 27:26To get your defense attorney's fees, you have
- 27:27to show that the lawsuit was filed frivolously
- 27:30without foundation. And then you have to show
- 27:37that the fees that you're seeking are specifically
- 27:41allocable to the frivolous allegations. To circle
- 27:47back the so in this one case, it was a San Francisco,
- 27:51San Francisco grocery store in the mission. I
- 27:55believe it was the Mission District. I think
- 27:57it was called Rainbow Grocery. They had a step.
- 28:01That went up to get into the facility. It wasn't
- 28:05it was it was it was found by a by a court at
- 28:08trial not to be readily achievable to be removed.
- 28:11I believe the reason it was not readily achievable
- 28:14to be removed was because. It would have required
- 28:17cutting into the pathway. And we see this a lot
- 28:20in New York, in New York, the South Hampton area
- 28:24specifically, all the stores, they have foundations.
- 28:30So it's a step to get in, right? There is some
- 28:34New York federal case law where the courts have
- 28:38found. that it's readily achievable. I mean,
- 28:40you're not going to knock down the whole building
- 28:42and change out the foundation. But it was readily
- 28:44achievable to install very expensive lifts that
- 28:49were built in, $150 ,000, $200 ,000 lifts. But
- 28:53for the most part, if you don't have the room
- 28:57to do that, it's not really achievable. If you
- 28:59don't have the sidewalk area to do that, it's
- 29:02not really achievable. In those cases, people
- 29:04will do temporary ramps, which brings a whole
- 29:08other host of problems a temporary ramp is you
- 29:11know it's where you have a staff you basically
- 29:14you either have a phone number or a push button
- 29:16that somebody can press at the street or make
- 29:20an appointment then you have a staff member go
- 29:22put a move a ramp a big heavy aluminum ramp put
- 29:26it down out there hopefully they don't get hurt
- 29:28while doing it then you have a person traversing
- 29:31it to go into the facility hope that they don't
- 29:34get hurt using the ramp And you got to make sure
- 29:36you take the ramp down before somebody trips
- 29:38on it. It's a nightmare. But yeah, so rarely
- 29:42people does exist, but rarely you're going to
- 29:47get it for most conditions. People say, well,
- 29:49I'm a small business, et cetera. The counter
- 29:52argument is, look, the ADA has been in place
- 29:54since the early 90s. You have a lot of time to
- 29:59deal with this. If you own the building, Certainly,
- 30:03you can amortize it over the depreciation of
- 30:08the asset and over the life of the asset. If
- 30:12you rent the building, only certain things are
- 30:15going to be required to do, at least in California.
- 30:18Those real estate lawyers on the webinar, they're
- 30:22going to... immediately think of the Brown and
- 30:24Hadian cases that say, look, you know, you can't
- 30:27shift all the burdens of ownership to to all
- 30:30tenants. You know, so, you know, something like
- 30:33that's going to land on the landlord. And the
- 30:35landlord, of course, is no hat on the building.
- 30:39So it's a challenge. It is an affirmative defense.
- 30:42And even if you do come up with something where
- 30:46it's not readily achievable, you still need to
- 30:48provide what's called equivalent facilitation.
- 30:51So you still got to provide access. You just
- 30:53use alternate measures. Maybe the alternate measure
- 30:56would be that portable ramp that we talked about.
- 31:00If there's not room, let's say the place is just
- 31:03too small. I ran into this in some places in
- 31:07some beachfront area in LA where all the shops
- 31:11were very expensive, but they were very small
- 31:15because real estate is so expensive. They didn't
- 31:17have the room to put all the right transaction
- 31:20counters and things like that. So they came up
- 31:21with ways of dealing with it came with a policy
- 31:24that they that they'll hand the receipt to or
- 31:30the transaction receipt to an individual in a
- 31:32wheelchair on a clipboard by way of example or
- 31:35they'll fold down transaction counter or you
- 31:38know rather than have a point of sale device
- 31:40on the counter they have one that's you know
- 31:43attached to a phone or a pad. So you still have
- 31:47to do it. You still have to achieve access. Readily
- 31:51achievable, though, is available, not being,
- 31:56as a defense, saying it's not readily achievable.
- 31:58But you're rolling that rock uphill. It's not
- 32:01an easy haul. So something that bootstraps to
- 32:07this, real estate lawyers, you know the Civil
- 32:09Code Section 1938. In your leasing documents,
- 32:12you have to disclose access. Again, so that's
- 32:16just something that bootstraps to that. But the
- 32:20real thing that's keeping people busy these days
- 32:23a lot is websites and websites access. And it
- 32:30probably take up a lot of this presentation.
- 32:33So let's talk about that a little. So first of
- 32:36all, ADA website lawsuits. In 2025, there were
- 32:45about 4 ,000 of them. That's lawsuits. That doesn't
- 32:51include arbitrations. A lot of people have ARB
- 32:53clauses on their websites. Doesn't include demand
- 32:57letters. And you can see it's just grown and
- 33:00grown. It's interesting because when I first
- 33:03started doing this stuff, I think it was 2001,
- 33:072002 when I was in law school, As the editor
- 33:12-in -chief of a law journal, I published an article
- 33:14about website access. And we didn't look at the
- 33:19ADA. We looked at FCC regs and other laws because
- 33:23the ADA was considered back then to not apply
- 33:27at all to websites. About 2008, 2009, I believe,
- 33:32was the time period that the Ninth Circuit Target
- 33:34case came out. And we'll talk about what constitutes
- 33:38that. But our argument historically was always,
- 33:43websites are not public accommodations because
- 33:45public accommodations always contemplated physical
- 33:49connections. Because in 1992, how many people
- 33:54had computers, let alone internet access? I know
- 33:59I certainly didn't. I was in high school or graduating
- 34:03high school that year. I didn't have a computer
- 34:05for many years. But in any event, so we look
- 34:08at the geographic concentration, and you'll see
- 34:12four states have 86 % of them. California, Illinois,
- 34:21New York, Florida. So California is up. California
- 34:26has, we'll talk about it, they have the UNRWA
- 34:29Civil Rights Act, which provides minimum statutory
- 34:33damages. New York has Civil and State Civil Rights
- 34:37Act that provide damages as well, but Illinois
- 34:42and Florida don't, but we'll see a lot of rise
- 34:46in that. Illinois has grown the most. The interesting
- 34:50thing about the Illinois cases, the Chicago cases,
- 34:54is the people filing are New York lawyers. And
- 34:58the idea is they kind of worn out their welcome
- 35:00in New York. They filed so many lawsuits that
- 35:05New York has a very, very, very active and sophisticated
- 35:08bench, as do all states. But New York in particular,
- 35:14they caught up with it. they were out to welcome.
- 35:18So you'll see a lot of the New York firms that
- 35:21traditionally were filing federal court in New
- 35:23York are now filing in state court. And the state
- 35:27courts been catching up with them as well, or
- 35:28they just moved to Chicago. Although this, in
- 35:33my experience, the Chicago judges are also getting
- 35:38a little fed up with them. And they've been pretty
- 35:40tough on some of these ADA plaintiffs. So So
- 35:48we can see that, you know, there are mills doing
- 35:51it. We'll see 250 plaintiffs are the ones who
- 35:55did all 4 ,000 of them. You know, 50 % of them
- 35:59were just the top 30. We have Michael Sandoval,
- 36:03who has 241 suits. He's represented by, he's
- 36:07a California guy represented by a California
- 36:09firm, the Manning Law Firm primarily. So we can
- 36:14see it's concentrated, 16 firms make 90 % of
- 36:20them, Equal Access Law Group, 600 cases, Manning,
- 36:24600 Steinstacks to primarily New York, same with
- 36:27Equal Access, they're doing Chicago. Manning's
- 36:30California, Manning does more than just websites,
- 36:34they also do physical access and they do other
- 36:37things. And we can see, like I said, a lot of
- 36:42these firms are switching to state court. And
- 36:45state court has some protections on that. So
- 36:48they toggle back and forth. We'll talk about
- 36:49that. But we see it's a cottage industry driven
- 36:53by a small number of deep filers. We have some
- 36:56pretty good case law out there talking about
- 37:00this industry. A little bit older. I think it
- 37:03was Judge Rafidi who wrote the Molsky case in
- 37:07the Central District, if I recall correctly.
- 37:10And he had some very strong language. He said
- 37:13the ADA cases were a money -making scheme by
- 37:18the plaintiff's attorneys intended to use the
- 37:24plaintiffs as shills and manufacture. you know,
- 37:28fees for the plaintiffs firms. But that said,
- 37:31we got to juxtapose that against the other side
- 37:33of it. And that is there's a lot of public accommodations.
- 37:39Congress made it clear, look, there's no way
- 37:41that the DOJ who's charged with enforcement of
- 37:45the ADA is going to have the resources to go
- 37:48after all these public accommodations. So they
- 37:50create a private right of action. Some of the
- 37:53fictitious standing for a certain to a certain
- 37:55extent. And so you have these plaintiff's attorneys
- 37:59running around terrorizing businesses. And the
- 38:03idea is that this should encourage people to
- 38:10do self -compliance. And let's not forget that
- 38:15even though we see 4 ,000 lawsuits, these are
- 38:20professional plaintiffs. They know what to look
- 38:23for. the odds are if they're filing suit, they
- 38:27probably found violations of law. So again, it
- 38:32doesn't justify or confer meritorious standing
- 38:37or benefit or claims to these individuals. But
- 38:40there are two sides to the argument. And that's
- 38:44why a lot of reform legislation doesn't go very
- 38:47far. Not I had a question, I know some of these
- 38:50could be not if there really is a planning there,
- 38:52we've got some expert or tester. I mean, we've
- 38:56had cases like that. What do you say an instance
- 38:59is like that? I mean, obviously, if they find
- 39:01out it's a problem, but it's. Yeah, there are
- 39:05ways of dealing with that. So the 1st issue is,
- 39:07is for federal court, we have to have article
- 39:093 standing. you know, that's where you have to
- 39:12have a legitimate injury, right? An injury in
- 39:16fact. And to get, you see the ADA doesn't provide
- 39:19damages. It provides to a private plaintiff.
- 39:23What it provides is, you know, attorney's fees,
- 39:27expert fees. We talked about that. It also provides
- 39:31injunctive relief. And to obtain the injunctive
- 39:35relief, there needs to be a remedial benefit.
- 39:38meaning that a reasonable likelihood that the
- 39:42plaintiff will benefit from the injunction. And
- 39:45if you don't do it, there will be a future injury.
- 39:48So that means that there needs to be an intent
- 39:50to return. That means that it's reasonably likely
- 39:53that this individual is going to return the facility.
- 39:58And the case law developer says there needs to
- 40:00be a particularized and concrete intention to
- 40:05return. So that whole standing doctrine, is where
- 40:08you can attack a lot of federal people. People
- 40:12do attack that a lot. I have successfully done
- 40:15that more times than I can remember, especially,
- 40:18you know, I have one individual who would literally
- 40:22he lived in Arizona. He post a plane. He's still
- 40:26out there. He he jumps in his car and will drive
- 40:31from. Arizona through California, and in two
- 40:34days hit like 10 hotels and 15 stores and file
- 40:38lawsuits over all of them. And the question is,
- 40:41are you really going to drive past 50 of the
- 40:47same exact branded stores again to come back
- 40:50and go to that store in Sacramento? Are you truly
- 40:54staying in three hotels in one night? That's
- 41:01the intent to return, that's the standing, the
- 41:03injury in fact. And a lot of cases get kicked
- 41:05out on that. On state court, and also state court
- 41:11damages, California has required for physical
- 41:16access that the plaintiff can show difficulty,
- 41:19discomfort or embarrassment, or the fact that
- 41:21they were deterred from a facility. deterred
- 41:27from returning. They would have gone there but
- 41:29for their knowledge of the barriers. And there
- 41:34is a duty to mitigate damages under the UNREACT.
- 41:37So you can't just keep going back to the same
- 41:39facility without giving them notice and racking
- 41:42up damages. Although there is a case out there,
- 41:46an older case, where a person liked going to
- 41:48movies once a week and they went after claims
- 41:52for 52 weeks a year of deterrence. And that was
- 41:57not thrown out. But the point is you can attack.
- 42:03You could say, look, if you really are, if you
- 42:06didn't really show up in my facility, if you
- 42:11knew about these barriers and just came to document
- 42:14it, there's no legitimate injury. There's no
- 42:17legitimate difficulty, discomfort, or embarrassment
- 42:22that you suffered. So you can absolutely attack
- 42:26it on all those fronts. And you do. You absolutely
- 42:30do. At the very least, you should do it in your
- 42:32negotiations. If you are settling, you can point
- 42:36that out. And again, we've seen it a lot where
- 42:41cases get dismissed on a federal level, and then
- 42:46people just refile and state just for the damages.
- 42:50So what we do see, Just moving forward real quick
- 42:55targeted industries on the websites. Everybody's
- 42:57subject to it, right? But we got you know, we
- 43:01you know, we have restaurants food beverage,
- 43:04you know We see that being 30 % fashion and apparel
- 43:08about 25 % beauty care. Yeah, I do represent
- 43:12Cosmetics and beauty industry and I think we
- 43:15do get a fair amount of those but not not as
- 43:17much as we used to more SIPA these days you know,
- 43:23you know, home furniture health, we see that
- 43:26we do see, you know, it's generally e commerce,
- 43:31but we have seen some b2b, which is which I always
- 43:34say, wait a second, why are you? Are you are
- 43:37you legitimately a consumer? Are you going to
- 43:39go back? Why were you on this website? Why are
- 43:41you going back? So one of the things that that
- 43:46comes up is, you know, we look at the different
- 43:50the the different types of website platforms.
- 43:53It's spread across all of them. We have one third
- 43:56going to the custom, Shopify, which I think is
- 43:59the number one e -commerce platform in the world.
- 44:03I think something like one third of all e -commerce
- 44:05websites are Shopify. Those are getting hit,
- 44:09WordPress are getting hit. So one of the challenges
- 44:14you face is most people when they develop their
- 44:17websites, they use templates. So these one, you
- 44:20know, it may be three or four templates throughout
- 44:23maybe let's say 15 pages of content and 15 pages
- 44:26a pretty robust website, but still let's say
- 44:29you have that You have errors on one you have
- 44:33those same errors may pervade throughout all
- 44:35of those So it's really easy to duplicate. I
- 44:39work for some companies have multiple brands
- 44:41and we have one back office So he's the same
- 44:44template maybe, you know on 10 or 15 different
- 44:47brands So one error, you know, transcends for
- 44:50all these different brands, and the plaintiffs
- 44:52know it. And so you usually get sister claims.
- 44:57So one of the things that came out a while ago
- 45:00is accessibility widgets or overlays. Initially,
- 45:08the plaintiffs bar pushed back heavily. They
- 45:11said that they said that they didn't work. But
- 45:13in large part, they don't like the idea that
- 45:15if you could just literally, because the idea
- 45:18about websites is they're difficult to fix. They're
- 45:21always be your website contents being updated,
- 45:23you know, on a daily basis, if not more frequently.
- 45:27So every time it's updated, it's just an opportunity
- 45:30for you to have a mistake or a problem. And,
- 45:34and, you know, if you have this, this overlay
- 45:38that fixes automatically puts the plaintiff's
- 45:40bar out of business, so they target it, the overlays
- 45:44don't work. perfectly. And so probably one of
- 45:47the larger ones out there was a company called
- 45:50Accessibee. And Accessibee had some very, very
- 45:55bold marketing statements. Marketing statements
- 45:59used to say things effectively that if you were
- 46:03to buy their product, you would be compliant
- 46:07and not be exposed to lawsuit exposure. Well,
- 46:11the FTC didn't like those statements and access
- 46:15to be got hit. And I believe it was a settlement,
- 46:19maybe a consent judgment, but definitely a settlement
- 46:21where they had to pay a million dollar penalty
- 46:24over those claims. And 424 suits, 40 % of the
- 46:36widgets websites. were accessible. In fact, I
- 46:41talked to some plaintiff's attorneys early on,
- 46:42and they were targeting any website that had
- 46:44an overlay. They said, we don't believe in overlays.
- 46:48Trying to use overlays, we're going to sue you.
- 46:50So these people were ironically paying money
- 46:53for these services. And then not getting what
- 47:00they're bargaining for, getting in trouble, getting
- 47:03sued. I've actually had some disputes on behalf
- 47:07of some of my clients with some of these overlay
- 47:08companies, where we said, hey, wait a second,
- 47:12you made all these promises. It doesn't, we're
- 47:15sued because of your widget, what are you gonna
- 47:17do? And they said, look at the limitation liability
- 47:22in the terms of services, you're on your own.
- 47:24So that is a trap. Eventually, I suspect that
- 47:30overlays will get there, especially with AI these
- 47:34days. Somebody's just gonna have Claude Code
- 47:37write something really good, but it's not there
- 47:39yet. So you see some letters here, WCAG. So what's
- 47:45WCAG? Web Content Accessibility Guidelines. It's
- 47:49a acronym for some principles. guiding principles,
- 47:55not the law, but guiding principles by the World
- 47:59Wide Web Consortium, W3C, that are intended to
- 48:04help people achieve accessibility, just like
- 48:08those standards that you would achieve through
- 48:12physical access. The problem is some of them
- 48:15are conceptual. It's not widely adopted. We have
- 48:19had California, through the Ninth Circuit, say,
- 48:24look, these are, WCAG may not be the law for
- 48:30Title III, but it can be considered by a court
- 48:34as evidence of noncompliance and absolutely a
- 48:36court can order you in its injunctive and equitable
- 48:40discretion to comply with it as part of its injunctive
- 48:43house. So we look at WCAG 2 .2 is the, is the
- 48:50most recent version. Obviously, the versions
- 48:53go up. And there's three different levels, A,
- 48:57AA, AAA. Those are what they call success criteria
- 49:01factors. AA is where most people stick. AAA is
- 49:05so strict that it impairs website functionality.
- 49:10Single A is very permissive, so you may not achieve
- 49:14access. The WCAG has the four principles, perceivable,
- 49:20operable, understandable, robust. This is just
- 49:24generally to describe all the many different
- 49:27regs that they put in there or suggestions. Perceivable,
- 49:32something that can be perceived, something that
- 49:33can be presentable to users with disabilities.
- 49:36That could be all kinds of different things,
- 49:38whether it's alternative text for images, whether
- 49:42it's headings. which also does go into the next
- 49:45one, operable. User interface components must
- 49:49be operable and be able to be navigated. And
- 49:52what that means is, so what we look at with our
- 49:56mouse, that's a graphic interface, right? You
- 50:01use a mouse to interface with your website and
- 50:04that's how you navigate. Well, how does somebody
- 50:06who doesn't have vision or has low vision work
- 50:10with that? Well, think about how would you do
- 50:14it if you turned off the monitor? Well, one of
- 50:17the assistive technologies is called screen reader
- 50:19technology. It reads what's on the screen, and
- 50:23it gives an audible version of that. And the
- 50:26way that people navigate that generally are either
- 50:29with the arrow keys or the tab function, and
- 50:31you go from heading structure to heading structure.
- 50:34So by way of example here, it would just read,
- 50:36you know, this was a website, you know, WCAG
- 50:402 .2, AA, the poor principles, and then it would
- 50:45go through each bullet point. And you can imagine
- 50:48that's the way most websites are structured.
- 50:51And so you have to make sure that the code behind
- 50:55the scenes on the website is compatible with
- 50:59that screen reading technology. So we talk about
- 51:03some of the low hanging fruit, the quick tips,
- 51:06heading structure right there. Boom, that's important.
- 51:09Heading structure is an easy way to have a hard
- 51:14stop. Somebody can't navigate your website if
- 51:17you don't have the right heading structure. So
- 51:20that's a big issue for them. Color contrast.
- 51:25So what does that mean? So this is a high contrast
- 51:28slide on the main. Our main text, we'll see it's
- 51:33dark Navy on a gray background. But if you look
- 51:36in the lower right hand corner, you'll see it's
- 51:38a gray, a dark gray on a light gray. That's low
- 51:41contrast down below or lower contrast. And the
- 51:46issue is somebody who's low vision has a hard
- 51:49time seeing that. You can imagine, I don't know.
- 51:52if I'm the only person on here who needs glasses
- 51:56or is a little bit older didn't always need reading
- 51:58glasses but you know they they call I think they
- 52:02call them 45s for a reason when you hit 45 you
- 52:05have to start using them but but the point is
- 52:09is if I'm at a restaurant at night and it's a
- 52:11dimly lit restaurant I'm not the only guy there
- 52:14busting out my phone to turn on that flashlight
- 52:16so I can read that menu. It's the same thing
- 52:19on a website. So low contrast. The irony is almost
- 52:23every single person who alleges that they're
- 52:26blind in a lawsuit also asserts color contrast
- 52:32issues. I don't think you can get them both.
- 52:35I mean, obviously you'd be legally blind, but
- 52:37if you are truly blind, color contrast isn't
- 52:40going to help you. But we look at that Another
- 52:44one is alternate text for meaningful images again.
- 52:48So let's say you're going through a retail website
- 52:50has shoes, you know, you a person who's not sighted
- 52:55is not going to be able to see what those shoes
- 52:56that you're looking at shoes. So the image needs
- 53:00to have a description meaningful text. It could
- 53:03say, you know, red shoes or, or, you know, I'm
- 53:07probably butcher this but but women's pumps or
- 53:12or wedges with with leather up or something like
- 53:16that, you know, describing that and in a way
- 53:19that's meaningful as you know, something that'd
- 53:23be unmeaningful, take it to the exact opposite,
- 53:25the end of the spectrum, you know, something
- 53:27to put on your foot or something like that, that
- 53:29would be meaningful. Colour contrast, we talked
- 53:32about that keyboard navigation, video captions,
- 53:36video captions and interesting things. So for
- 53:38pre recorded video, not live stream, but pre
- 53:43-recorded video, you're supposed to have captioning.
- 53:47And so you can see a lot of websites. We saw
- 53:49this with cosmetic surgeons for some reason,
- 53:52they have a lot of video content and they were
- 53:55hit really hard on a wave of claims because they
- 53:59didn't have captioning. So that the persons who
- 54:03were deaf or hard of hearing, they couldn't hear
- 54:07what was being said. One of the things that they
- 54:11recommend, it's a tip, is that if you don't have
- 54:14an audible component, you could put a caption
- 54:17that says, there's no audible component of this.
- 54:26That's pre -recorded content. Live content, it's
- 54:29not required, it's recommended. However, we can
- 54:32see that that manifests in the... auxiliary aids
- 54:37and communications. You can imagine if you're
- 54:40at a college watching a class, certainly under
- 54:45those circumstances, captioning can be something
- 54:48that you request, either real -time captioning
- 54:51or a sign language interpreter. We talked about
- 54:55updating templates. You've got to be aware of
- 54:58third -party code, right? So some people use
- 55:01third -party code or embedded third -party content.
- 55:04You can get in trouble that way because it's
- 55:06stuff you can't control. And also, if you want
- 55:08to bring it into remedial standards, you may
- 55:12not be able to. And overlay tools are not verboten,
- 55:17but they might get you sued and equally fundamental.
- 55:20I wouldn't rely on them alone. The framework,
- 55:25we'll go through this real quick. It's very similar.
- 55:27You know, we look at the Title III of the ADA,
- 55:31public accommodation. One of the problems is
- 55:33there's no express statutes governing website
- 55:39access. There's some stuff out there that they're
- 55:41trying. It's almost going through Congress. We'll
- 55:42see what happens. DOJ and courts have expanded
- 55:48the application to websites. We talked about
- 55:50that target case. So it's a little bit of a split.
- 55:53Not just on circuit courts, but actually within
- 55:56the, not just within circuits, but actually within
- 55:58district courts themselves. Some courts, the
- 56:05first and the seventh circuit have held that
- 56:08websites, including website -only businesses,
- 56:11are places of public accommodation. I believe
- 56:12the first major opinion was the Scribid case
- 56:16in the first circuit. Scribid's just like a website
- 56:18you go get content on. They don't have physical,
- 56:22they have no physical brick and mortar facilities,
- 56:25Second Circuit, they're mixed. Some of the judges,
- 56:28absolutely, you'll get in there on a website
- 56:30access case, like in the Southern District of
- 56:33New York, and the judge will issue you a warning
- 56:36notice. Says, look, it's part of their standing
- 56:39order. They say, look, if you're a website access
- 56:42defendant, just know that I am not going to entertain
- 56:46any arguments that it's not a public accommodation.
- 56:52The third, sixth, ninth, and 11th, they generally
- 56:56require some type of nexus to physical location.
- 56:59We did have a case in the 11th Circuit that was
- 57:05very favorable towards defendants on that, but
- 57:08it was vacated, the decision was vacated. But
- 57:12we do generally have the argument that it needs
- 57:15a little bit stronger of a connection. Like maybe
- 57:18it gives you store hours or location to a physical
- 57:22store. The DOJ has taken the position for a very
- 57:26long time that websites are public accommodations,
- 57:30regardless of nexus. And the WCAG really is the
- 57:35de facto standard, even though it's not formally
- 57:38adopted for Title III. Legal developments. you
- 57:43know, we, you know, with each administration,
- 57:45we see that pendulum swing different ways. The
- 57:48current administration is not as proactive in
- 57:53accessibility in a lot of contexts, not just,
- 57:57not just the ADA, but also education. You know,
- 58:01if anybody is encountering that, you can, it's,
- 58:05it's controversial. But, you know, General, so
- 58:08for Title II, They did adopt WCAG. DOJ withdrew
- 58:16some guidance documents in 2025. We do have HR
- 58:233417, which was introduced and is still live.
- 58:28It hasn't passed. It's a website software applications.
- 58:35Accessibility Act. It doesn't include a Notice
- 58:38and Cure Safe Harbor provision, and that's one
- 58:40of the most controversial things that people
- 58:42want, is they say, look, I want a free shot.
- 58:45Before a plaintiff can sue me, they need to give
- 58:47me a warning. It doesn't include that, but it
- 58:49does say that digital spaces are covered under
- 58:52Title III. We know that Europe, their Accessibility
- 58:56Act is effective. Canada has their own, I believe,
- 59:02Ontarioans, if I butchered that word. Please
- 59:06forgive me, I'm not Canadian, but the Ontarioans
- 59:09with Accessibility Act has been around for a
- 59:11while, and that's been, you know, that's been
- 59:15pretty aggressive. And we already talked about
- 59:16accessibly. So one of the things that we get
- 59:20a lot on, you know, we talked about this, you
- 59:25know, the standing component, one of the big
- 59:28defenses is always look, we fix our website,
- 59:30we fixed it, we fixed our public accommodation.
- 59:33So the plaintiff's claims are moot. And this
- 59:35is a solid, legitimate defense that's been recognized
- 59:39just about everywhere, not just for ADA, but
- 59:43for everything that we're trying to get injunctive
- 59:46relief, right? But one of the arguments that
- 59:51the plaintiffs will target is they say, we're
- 59:54not targeting your website. We're targeting your
- 59:56policies related to your website because you
- 1:00:00lack adequate policies and procedures. to be
- 1:00:03able to promote access, to ensure access going
- 1:00:06forward. And some courts buy off on that. So
- 1:00:10it's important to have policies and you're required
- 1:00:12to do policy modifications. We'll talk about
- 1:00:15that in a little bit. But one of the keys is
- 1:00:18I always recommend have a forward stating, outward
- 1:00:22stating or forward stating accessibility policy
- 1:00:25on your website. I wrote one, I think maybe a
- 1:00:29pretty solid one about 10, 15 years ago. that
- 1:00:33I've seen maybe 1 ,000 times since put back at
- 1:00:36me from other people copying it. It's really
- 1:00:39important to do that. You want to tell everybody,
- 1:00:43look, this is our commitment. I like having a
- 1:00:50channel for consumers and visitors and guests
- 1:00:54to make complaints and accommodation requests.
- 1:00:58The reason I like that is because I've had to
- 1:01:03deal with Department of Justice investigations
- 1:01:05for some very high traffic businesses. I've had
- 1:01:10businesses that have had hundreds of millions
- 1:01:13of consumer contacts a year, very, very, very
- 1:01:17large businesses, some of the largest that have
- 1:01:19been the subject of DOJ investigations. And the
- 1:01:22DOJ says, we want to know about every instance
- 1:01:25where you received an accessibility complaint
- 1:01:28or modification request. Well, certainly you
- 1:01:33don't want to have to audit hundreds of millions
- 1:01:35of interactions. And certainly even at the slightest
- 1:01:41level, if you were on a smaller business getting
- 1:01:43a similar request. But you could definitely prove
- 1:01:46a negative if there is a checkbox for every customer
- 1:01:52service representative or a dedicated channel
- 1:01:55for them to receive and track. consumer complaints
- 1:01:59or guest complaints or accommodation requests,
- 1:02:02if you have that open channel and it's conspicuously
- 1:02:05displayed and you got none, then that is a pretty
- 1:02:10good piece of evidence to compel or compelling
- 1:02:14evidence to say, look, we're not receiving any
- 1:02:17negative feedback. And I think that's about as
- 1:02:21good of a piece of evidence as any consumer survey
- 1:02:24would provide. Obviously, you want to have policies
- 1:02:29letting your employees know how to accommodate
- 1:02:33customers with disabilities and guests with disabilities,
- 1:02:36how to interact with them. There's a whole bunch
- 1:02:38of etiquette on how to do that, how to discreetly
- 1:02:42offer assistance without pushing, never touch
- 1:02:47the guests, never inquire about their disabilities.
- 1:02:50That's private medical information. certainly
- 1:02:56do not try to frame or discourage any requests.
- 1:03:01And the reason that's so important is in the
- 1:03:04event that you have an adverse consumer interaction,
- 1:03:09which will most likely be documented on somebody's
- 1:03:13phone, I've had that plenty of times. And I had
- 1:03:19people come up to hotels and request accessible
- 1:03:21rooms and be told no. and then I get videos of
- 1:03:25that from a plaintiff's firm. But if you have
- 1:03:28those negative experiences, you can say, well,
- 1:03:32you know, that was an errant, an aberrant, one
- 1:03:34-off situation. That was not the standard. In
- 1:03:38fact, we train. Otherwise, here are our policies.
- 1:03:42They reside in our learning management system.
- 1:03:44People who are onboarded are told about this,
- 1:03:46and it's always here for them to look at. It
- 1:03:50resides on our intranet or in our policy binders,
- 1:03:54and we teach people not to do this stuff. So
- 1:03:58that way, you can show that this was not some
- 1:04:01type of practice, but instead just a one -off
- 1:04:05situation. Or alternatively, if they say, what
- 1:04:08do you have to prevent this? You have that. For
- 1:04:11accessibility testing for your websites, content
- 1:04:16changes, technology changes, always important
- 1:04:19to test, automated tools and manual checks. So
- 1:04:23we really didn't talk about that. There's a lot
- 1:04:24of automated tools out there to test whether
- 1:04:27your website is accessible. It's not dispositive.
- 1:04:31The tools are very flawed, but they'll catch
- 1:04:35some things, but they give you a lot of false
- 1:04:38positives and false negatives. Manual testing
- 1:04:41is the best way to do it. That's where you have
- 1:04:43persons with disabilities actually use the websites
- 1:04:46with assistive technologies. That said, most
- 1:04:52plaintiffs and most plaintiff's attorneys are
- 1:04:55doing automated testing. I have a question. We
- 1:05:01all get these clients who go, just tell us what
- 1:05:03to do. They want the answer. or the magic bullet
- 1:05:06that's going to make sure this never happens
- 1:05:08again. I'm never going to get sued. Tell me I'm
- 1:05:12never going to get a claim. And as litigators,
- 1:05:15we all know different judge, different day, different
- 1:05:18ruling, different day. What do you say to these
- 1:05:23clients when they ask you to see? There are no
- 1:05:25guarantees, right? They can do all this stuff
- 1:05:27and still get sued. Yeah, absolutely once you're
- 1:05:30sued doesn't matter whether you're right or wrong
- 1:05:32you're dealing often with people who are extortionists
- 1:05:35and Their business model is to get you to pay
- 1:05:37a nuisance fee and they don't care about the
- 1:05:40merits unfortunately, but what you What you could
- 1:05:43do is what you tell your tell your client what
- 1:05:46I tell them, you know Just bootstraps right in
- 1:05:49what you're saying about the automated tests.
- 1:05:51So I tell them work, you know work with your
- 1:05:53development team to comply with all instances
- 1:05:57of violations identified by your automated test,
- 1:06:01including false positives. Why? Because you get
- 1:06:06sued over a false positive. A plaintiff's attorney
- 1:06:09may just run an automated test, and probably
- 1:06:15a free one. All right, because they're not investing
- 1:06:19that much money. Not all of them are like that,
- 1:06:21but most of them are. And they're not investing
- 1:06:23all the money into testing. So you may get sued
- 1:06:29over a false positive. And then you have to argue
- 1:06:31with them that this automated test is right or
- 1:06:35wrong. And you're talking to a wall at that point.
- 1:06:37So I often tell clients, you work with your website.
- 1:06:41Consulting your contractors development team
- 1:06:43internally or externally to do this if you're
- 1:06:46internally you may want to suggest it for larger
- 1:06:48corporation had development guidelines. I know
- 1:06:51where they say look we're going to develop content
- 1:06:54pursuant to this these standards especially like
- 1:06:57so with a larger. enterprise. And I've worked
- 1:07:01on those a lot over the years, and they do work.
- 1:07:04And they look great if you ever have to show
- 1:07:06them to a plaintiff. But the thing is, yeah,
- 1:07:11if you have automated tools telling you that
- 1:07:15you got false positives, it's probably cheaper
- 1:07:18just to fix it than argue over it down the road.
- 1:07:24You know, so and you can have some people they
- 1:07:26use accessibility consultants to review the situation.
- 1:07:31I used to be a situation where. Nobody knew website
- 1:07:35access. None of the developers knew it was even
- 1:07:38part of the training. So what would happen is
- 1:07:41either you. Either either you would hire somebody
- 1:07:46who is very expensive as a consultant or you
- 1:07:48would rely on what the plaintiffs provide you.
- 1:07:51But but now a lot of the developers. they're
- 1:07:55familiar with these concepts. They know how to
- 1:07:57work with it and they know how to help you achieve
- 1:08:00compliance. So service animals. We all love our
- 1:08:08pets, but let's talk about service animals. So
- 1:08:12what is a service animal? So there's a federal's
- 1:08:16definition and we're in California, so we'll
- 1:08:18talk about California's definition as well. Federal,
- 1:08:21a service animal, and service animal is a specific
- 1:08:25term. It's a legal definition. In federal, dogs
- 1:08:29and miniature horses only. You're not going to
- 1:08:32get a snake as a service animal. You may get
- 1:08:35a snake as an emotional support animal. We'll
- 1:08:37talk about that in a second, but not as a service
- 1:08:41animal. These are individually trained to perform
- 1:08:44tasks that assist a person with disabilities
- 1:08:46with their activities of daily life. A lot of
- 1:08:53people say miniature horses, what's up with that?
- 1:08:55Miniature horses, they have a longer lifespan,
- 1:08:59they're stronger. Generally, they can help a
- 1:09:02person, a heavier person with disabilities. So
- 1:09:08they are recognized. They're less common. You
- 1:09:11don't see them as much because they require more
- 1:09:13care, but they are there. Comfort and emotional
- 1:09:16support animals are not service animals under
- 1:09:18the ADA. here, you know, the rub is is So a lot
- 1:09:25of people Have cognitive disabilities they hide
- 1:09:29in plain sight You know, you can't see somebody,
- 1:09:32you know somebody What's that? I think you froze
- 1:09:36there a bit. Oh am I am I still frozen? No, I
- 1:09:39think you're good now. Oh, well, thank you. Sorry.
- 1:09:41Sorry about that Only thing reliable about technology
- 1:09:45is that it's not reliable. So but we're But yeah,
- 1:09:50so some people have cognitive disabilities. They
- 1:09:55have autism. They have mental health issues.
- 1:09:59They have severe anxiety. So you could have a
- 1:10:02person with a cognitive disability that has a
- 1:10:07service animal that's trained to help with those
- 1:10:11issues. Autism, you could think about elopement.
- 1:10:14You could think about somebody who is epileptic
- 1:10:17who has seizures. you could think about somebody
- 1:10:20with severe anxiety and mental health issues.
- 1:10:23So that is not the same as a comfort or emotional
- 1:10:27support animal. Those are still trained service
- 1:10:30animals. But again, the challenge is where it
- 1:10:34starts and stops. That's always a fringe issue.
- 1:10:37California, we have service animals being guide
- 1:10:42dogs or signal dogs, service dogs. They limit
- 1:10:47it to dogs. and there are broader state protections
- 1:10:50in federal. One thing that is worth noting is
- 1:10:54that it is a misdemeanor in California to misrepresent
- 1:10:59an animal as a trained service animal. The issue
- 1:11:04is there's also some controversy over training
- 1:11:07because there is no guidelines on training. So
- 1:11:11we've all heard about these. These institutions
- 1:11:16where they train animals, they breed them and
- 1:11:20train them to be service animals. And some of
- 1:11:22them spend a tremendous amount of resources.
- 1:11:25A lot of them are, they're nonprofits. They lose
- 1:11:28a lot of money because the amount of money that
- 1:11:30goes to train these amazing dogs is just, it's
- 1:11:35a lot of work. And then we've all seen that they're
- 1:11:38the dropouts. the dogs that just don't make it.
- 1:11:41And there's, there's a 10 mile long list of people
- 1:11:44waiting to adopt them, because they're, you know,
- 1:11:46they're beautiful dogs, they're wonderful animals.
- 1:11:50You know, and, but there's controversy, because
- 1:11:53you can do self training as well. And there's
- 1:11:56a lot of controversy between the communities,
- 1:11:59you know, the individuals who spend, you know,
- 1:12:02three to five years training an animal to be
- 1:12:05specifically placed. I've had the luxury of working
- 1:12:08with some of these institutions. It's really
- 1:12:10amazing stuff. It really is. The dogs choose
- 1:12:15their owners, the owners don't choose their dogs.
- 1:12:19It's really great stuff. But there's controversy
- 1:12:22because what's self -trained? A self -trained
- 1:12:24dog or self -trained miniature horse may not
- 1:12:28have the same skill sets. and may not be able
- 1:12:30to assist with the activities of daily life such
- 1:12:32as a trained one, but they're still trained and
- 1:12:34they're individually trained. So you have an
- 1:12:37accessibility inquiry that you can make about
- 1:12:40these animals. It's really dangerous because
- 1:12:46you can ask them, you can ask a guest, hey, look,
- 1:12:49do you need this animal because of a disability?
- 1:12:51What tasks is the animal trained to perform?
- 1:12:56But you can't ask for proof of training. There
- 1:13:00are no certificates. You can buy one online or
- 1:13:03invest online. That's fake. There is no certificate.
- 1:13:10You can't ask about the nature of the disability.
- 1:13:13And you certainly can't charge a pet fee to somebody
- 1:13:15because it's not a pet. It's an accessibility
- 1:13:18issue. So you may have a pet fee for a hotel
- 1:13:21for somebody to bring a pet, but not a service
- 1:13:24animal. So that inquiry level is very challenging.
- 1:13:29I always tell my clients, look, if you're going
- 1:13:32to be having that inquiry, you're going to have
- 1:13:35some stressed out guest who feels defensive because
- 1:13:42you're asking about their service animal. Be
- 1:13:45asked by some some customer service representative
- 1:13:52who probably deals with this issue once a year,
- 1:13:56either somebody is going to say something wrong
- 1:13:59or they're going to think that somebody said
- 1:14:02something wrong, you're going to have a problem.
- 1:14:04So if you are going to have the inquiries, probably
- 1:14:06best to have it in writing. The misrepresentation
- 1:14:12is a misdemeanor. That's only to the service
- 1:14:14analysts. Correct. Yeah. Not emotional support
- 1:14:19because that's not covered under the ADA. I just
- 1:14:23keep thinking back to when these emotional support
- 1:14:26animals, you know, you can go online and get
- 1:14:28some supposed therapist to deem one. I think
- 1:14:31it was United Airlines that someone who wanted
- 1:14:33to bring a peacock on board the plane because
- 1:14:37it was an emotional support animal. Keep in mind
- 1:14:41that for airlines, there's a completely different
- 1:14:44set of guidelines. Their transportation guidelines
- 1:14:48are completely different. And the emotional sport
- 1:14:52animals, that is a legitimate and real request
- 1:14:55that can be made. We'll talk about that. in a
- 1:14:58second. But that's a legitimate request you made
- 1:15:01in certain contexts, employment and housing.
- 1:15:04So you can charge for actual damage, you can
- 1:15:07remove an animal that's not under their owner's
- 1:15:09control, that is violent. And in certain circumstances,
- 1:15:12there have been a situations where they say,
- 1:15:14look, it's just not, it's not, it's not reasonable
- 1:15:18to have the animal in these situations, it's
- 1:15:21not going to be safe. One circumstance was a
- 1:15:25that I'm aware of was a hotel pool. They didn't
- 1:15:29want the dog in the pool for various reasons
- 1:15:32because it's just not safe to have a service
- 1:15:35animal in the pool. You could imagine maybe some
- 1:15:39type of, you know, some type of maybe food manufacturing
- 1:15:43facility or something like that. You're not going
- 1:15:46to want a service animal in there, you know,
- 1:15:50because there might be some food safety issues.
- 1:15:54But emotional support animals. So let's talk
- 1:15:58about those because you see it right everywhere
- 1:16:01if somebody has a vest people You know, you know,
- 1:16:06sometimes they're just you know, there's these
- 1:16:07cute little, you know purse dogs, you know Yorkshire
- 1:16:10Terrier or whatever But so what are they they're
- 1:16:13not trained to perform specific tasks related
- 1:16:16disability. They're not service animals And they
- 1:16:20have no public accommodation access right but
- 1:16:23we have housing providers and employers, they're
- 1:16:29covered under the Fair Employment and Housing
- 1:16:31Act and also the Federal Fair Housing Act. There
- 1:16:36you have to, that's a whole different inquiry.
- 1:16:40Residential housing is a completely different
- 1:16:42inquiry. You have to make reasonable accommodations
- 1:16:46that are necessary. to afford full and equal
- 1:16:51access. There's standards about who pays for
- 1:16:54what and the consideration. There's an interactive
- 1:16:57process. The employment lawyers on this call
- 1:17:02definitely know about where you are required
- 1:17:06as either the employer or as the housing provider
- 1:17:11to have an inquiry, an interactive process where
- 1:17:16you request information and you try to figure
- 1:17:18out and evaluate things. That's not public accommodation.
- 1:17:22That's a whole different ballgame. That's a whole
- 1:17:25different presentation. I will let you know that
- 1:17:28there was a lawsuit in 2025 that I'm aware of
- 1:17:31and that I touched about a service animal at
- 1:17:36a real estate open house. There were A lot of
- 1:17:40things being asserted there, the Disabled Persons
- 1:17:42Act, the Civil Rights Act, the Fair Employment
- 1:17:45and Housing Act. The Fair Housing Act is Fair
- 1:17:47Housing Act, does have some protections for that.
- 1:17:52And that just demonstrates that even a single
- 1:17:56incident can cause problems. So you got to be
- 1:18:01careful about that. Something that used to be,
- 1:18:05that comes up Not as often as the other ones,
- 1:18:08but they're really important because, again,
- 1:18:11we talked about the DOJ being an enforcement
- 1:18:13agency. They step in on some things, and they
- 1:18:17used to be very, very active in this arena. We're
- 1:18:21at 1115. I know we have several. I know we talked
- 1:18:25about before the presentation started because
- 1:18:26this is such a packed with information. We may
- 1:18:28not be able to get to all the subjects today.
- 1:18:31Yeah, but I know we have some California law,
- 1:18:34risks and procedures, class actions, small business
- 1:18:37protections, and some defense strategies and
- 1:18:40recommendations, as well as the telecommunications
- 1:18:43that we have here. Do you want to pick and choose
- 1:18:45what you'd like to talk about the next 20, 25
- 1:18:48minutes? Sure. We will get through everything.
- 1:18:51And again, to everyone viewing today, there are
- 1:18:54some more information on telecommunications policies
- 1:18:58and procedures and things like that. And cast
- 1:19:01protections in your materials, but given the
- 1:19:04extensive amount of content to get. Do any kind
- 1:19:07of real justice to it, you know, we can't get
- 1:19:10through all that in an hour and a half or a little
- 1:19:11more. Yeah, let's let's skip over really quickly
- 1:19:14and we'll speed up and thank you for pointing
- 1:19:17out the pace here. Yeah, telephone communications
- 1:19:21and relay that's basically refers to telephone
- 1:19:25telephone. Telecommunications relay services,
- 1:19:28and that generally is a way that people communicate
- 1:19:32who can't hear or speak or have difficulty doing
- 1:19:37either. They communicate, and it's important
- 1:19:39that that's provided. And there are services
- 1:19:44that people do that. They use a communications
- 1:19:47assistant. You can't deny that. A lot of people
- 1:19:50have been hit very hard by the DOJ on that, a
- 1:19:53lot of financial institutions. Auxiliary aids
- 1:19:56and services, that bootstraps into the website,
- 1:19:59but as well, you must provide at no cost auxiliary
- 1:20:03aids and services to achieve effective communication.
- 1:20:07That can show up from braille materials upon
- 1:20:11request, interpreters, captioning screen readers.
- 1:20:15Again, it's a communication device. Policies
- 1:20:19and procedures. So this is important. So this
- 1:20:23is a catch -all. You must make reasonable modifications
- 1:20:26to policies, practices, and procedures to achieve
- 1:20:30access. And so somebody says, look, I want you
- 1:20:36to change the way you're doing your business
- 1:20:37to help me achieve access. You have to consider
- 1:20:40that and make the policy modification. You know,
- 1:20:46if it's going to fundamentally alter your business,
- 1:20:48you don't have to do it. But that is the catchall.
- 1:20:52And it applies a lot to a lot of things. And
- 1:20:55we see that that's a big issue for the DOJ. Interaction
- 1:21:00etiquette, that's just how, you know, we talked
- 1:21:02about training your people on how to interact
- 1:21:06with persons with disabilities in a correct manner.
- 1:21:11A lot of it's just intuitive. but it's a person
- 1:21:14with disability, things like that. And then there's
- 1:21:17also some things that there's a false etymology
- 1:21:21out there that the word handicap refers to persons
- 1:21:28with disabilities panhandling with that cap in
- 1:21:31their hand. Historically, that's false. That's
- 1:21:35false etymology. I've researched that. But it's
- 1:21:39a trigger word for some people. even though the
- 1:21:42word handicap shows up all throughout our statute.
- 1:21:45You know, and disabled persons act again, you
- 1:21:48know, not a person with disability put the disability
- 1:21:51first and that it's throughout the statutes,
- 1:21:54but people interactive at interaction etiquette.
- 1:21:58It's something to look at something to train
- 1:21:59on to maybe deescalate and avoid some type of
- 1:22:04negative interaction. California, we're in California.
- 1:22:10This, you know, California, everybody always
- 1:22:12talks about California laws. For access, it's
- 1:22:15real. So we have the UNRWA Civil Rights Act.
- 1:22:18UNRWA Civil Rights Act protects more than just
- 1:22:23accessibility. It protects against pretty much
- 1:22:25just about any identifiable characteristic. And
- 1:22:30it incorporates under Section 51. F, the civil
- 1:22:36code, any ADA violation, it becomes under a violation.
- 1:22:42But just so you know, most courts say that doesn't
- 1:22:45give you a basis to remove the case to federal
- 1:22:48court. You've got to be careful about that. A
- 1:22:50lot of central district judges have said that's
- 1:22:53not a basis. It's $4 ,000 minimum per incident.
- 1:22:57The most I've seen that on statutory damages.
- 1:23:00is $150 ,000 for one incident. It applies to
- 1:23:04business establishments, not just public accommodations,
- 1:23:09broader term. Even the definition of disability
- 1:23:13is broader. So we look at ADLs, activities of
- 1:23:18daily life. It just has a limitation on activities
- 1:23:24of daily life as opposed to substantial under
- 1:23:26the ADA. Very broadly construed. We talked about
- 1:23:31the Disabled Persons Act. Again, not the greatest
- 1:23:34terminology there. It has $1 ,000 per incident
- 1:23:38statutory damages. A lot of people stopped suing
- 1:23:41under that because the mutuality of the attorney's
- 1:23:44fees clause that we talked about. Risk and noncompliance.
- 1:23:50Look, you can get hit by administrative enforcement
- 1:23:52actions. They're real. You can get company -wide
- 1:23:57lawsuits. We have seen class actions. I have
- 1:24:01handled class actions. And the statutory damages
- 1:24:07make a class action much, much, much easier because
- 1:24:12you're doing damages class. So if you're doing
- 1:24:14an injunctive class, you got to think about who
- 1:24:17has standing to assert what. what barriers right
- 1:24:20so you have you have classes and subclasses and
- 1:24:23sub subclasses um and if you're doing it across
- 1:24:26a business enterprise you know you have who has
- 1:24:29the intent to return to what area and you know
- 1:24:31so that so an injunctive class is challenging
- 1:24:35i've been i've had injunctive classes but they're
- 1:24:39challenging uh to find one injunctive issue that
- 1:24:42affects everybody the same is challenging but
- 1:24:45damages not so much So if they can certify a
- 1:24:51damages class, it hits there. Almost every plaintiff's
- 1:24:57attorney files his class. I mean, when you're
- 1:25:00filing 500 class actions a year on a two -person
- 1:25:05shop, you know they're not taking those to class
- 1:25:07cert, but they do that. Again, we know it's a
- 1:25:12very, very prolific area. So talk about pendulum
- 1:25:16swinging earlier. California has tried to protect
- 1:25:21against some of these cases with the pendulum
- 1:25:25swinging in the defense for a little while. So
- 1:25:28talk about high frequency litigants. So what's
- 1:25:30a high frequency litigant? Somebody who has filed
- 1:25:3210 or more construction related accessibility
- 1:25:36complaints in the preceding 12 months. Or an
- 1:25:39attorney who's represented 10 plus plaintiffs.
- 1:25:43And what this does is it puts additional requirements
- 1:25:47and burdens on these individuals. It requires
- 1:25:50them to do a verified complaint. They have to
- 1:25:57pay an extra $1 ,000 in filing fees. They have
- 1:26:00to include allegations that you ordinarily wouldn't
- 1:26:03see in notice pleading, such as a plain explanation
- 1:26:06of the barriers, the dates of each encounter.
- 1:26:09the reason for the number of complaints filed,
- 1:26:12the reason for being in the geographic area,
- 1:26:15the reason for accessing the business. Certainly,
- 1:26:18these are hoops they can jump through, but these
- 1:26:20are things that most people would ask for in
- 1:26:22discovery, and you get it through the complaint.
- 1:26:25If they don't do it, it can get stricken. The
- 1:26:27workaround is they file in federal, and then
- 1:26:30there's an argument that these are procedural
- 1:26:34components. They don't apply. The way some judges
- 1:26:36have dealt with this is they have declined to
- 1:26:40extend supplemental jurisdiction over, at least
- 1:26:44in central districts, sometimes southern district,
- 1:26:47over the plaintiff state law claims on the basis
- 1:26:52that they're using it to, they're using the federal
- 1:26:56court to circumvent the high frequency litigate.
- 1:27:00component and it's a standard order that some
- 1:27:04of these judges just signed. It's designed to
- 1:27:09curb abusive litigation practices. It hasn't
- 1:27:13really done that. It's supposed to still allow
- 1:27:18legitimate claims to go through. Certainly a
- 1:27:22legitimate claim is not going to be limited by
- 1:27:25these because a legitimate claim doesn't really
- 1:27:29have these problems. We do know that, you know,
- 1:27:32Hillary, you mentioned the word tester. Testers
- 1:27:35still are subject to the same standing requirements
- 1:27:37under Article 3. So this will apply to them as
- 1:27:41well. Another thing that came out that California
- 1:27:46came out with to try to protect individuals was
- 1:27:48the CAST program, Certified Access Specialist.
- 1:27:52These are people who are registered and certified
- 1:27:55by the Division of the State Architect. These
- 1:27:58individuals can help you figure out whether or
- 1:28:01not your facility is compliant. And it's really
- 1:28:06important because I've worked on projects, major,
- 1:28:09major construction projects, hundreds of millions
- 1:28:12of dollars in scope of work on arenas, by way
- 1:28:15of example, where all these amazing architects,
- 1:28:21some of the best architects in the world, and
- 1:28:24the biggest architectural firms in the world.
- 1:28:26have given us plans. And then we submit it to
- 1:28:29a CASP architect who finds hundreds if not thousands
- 1:28:33of accessibility violations that these super
- 1:28:37top -notch architects just didn't have on their
- 1:28:40radar. So it's important to have these individuals
- 1:28:44out there. They can come and they can inspect
- 1:28:47your facility. They can give you a report. you
- 1:28:50can have them come back and certify as meeting
- 1:28:54all applicable standards, which again gives you
- 1:29:01protection. So what are the protections? It can
- 1:29:03reduce your damages. It reduces the plaintiff's
- 1:29:05damages. In all fairness, what the plaintiffs
- 1:29:07do is then they shift their demands to attorney's
- 1:29:10fees. We do have some protections as well for
- 1:29:14small businesses. We talk about that here a little.
- 1:29:19If you have a CASP inspection, you may be entitled
- 1:29:22to a stay of litigation and early neutral evaluation,
- 1:29:25which you're generally entitled to anyway under
- 1:29:28most courts. Central District came up with a
- 1:29:31program like that. Northern District, California,
- 1:29:34we have a. a general order 56, which provides
- 1:29:39pretty much a stay on litigation while people
- 1:29:41figure out access barriers. Some courts have
- 1:29:44been very active involved, actively involved
- 1:29:48in trying to deter these cases. I think Hillary
- 1:29:51and I talked offline about one particular judge
- 1:29:55in the Southern District of Florida, who before
- 1:29:58you file, he gives you a standing order before
- 1:30:00you file your answer. One week before you tell
- 1:30:03the judge whether or not You can see there's
- 1:30:06barriers, whether or not you agree to fix it,
- 1:30:08and if you agree to pay a plaintiff's attorney
- 1:30:11a reasonable attorney's fees for bringing the
- 1:30:15lawsuit. If you do all the above, this particular
- 1:30:19judge, Judge Gales, he would stay the lawsuit.
- 1:30:24And you'd come back in X amount of period of
- 1:30:27time, six months or whatever, and submit proof
- 1:30:31that it's been fixed. If it was fixed, the judge
- 1:30:34would dismiss the case and award the plaintiff
- 1:30:35their attorney's fees, $2 ,500, whatever, for
- 1:30:38filing the lawsuit. I've been to the 11th Circuit
- 1:30:41on that issue, and the 11th Circuit said, hey,
- 1:30:44look, judges have the ability to manage their
- 1:30:48calendar, and this is their discretion. So you
- 1:30:51see that. I wouldn't hang my hat on getting that
- 1:30:54from every judge, because these judges are busy,
- 1:30:57but some of them do. So cast steps, you know,
- 1:31:02hire them, have them review the report, remove
- 1:31:06barriers over the timeline. So there are tax
- 1:31:10credits. You know, there's tax credits that I
- 1:31:14think that's in another slide here that we'll
- 1:31:16get to talk with your CPA, but there are tax
- 1:31:19credits and tax deductions. The tax credits,
- 1:31:22I believe under Internal Revenue Code 44, I believe
- 1:31:26is what it is. It's ambiguous whether that can
- 1:31:30be used towards physical barriers only. You might
- 1:31:34be able to use it for websites. The tax deductions,
- 1:31:39I believe, are physical barriers only. But you
- 1:31:43obviously need to have your clients work with
- 1:31:45either. If you're a tax attorney, work with you
- 1:31:48or with the CPA or another tax credit tax professional,
- 1:31:52small business protections. California also put
- 1:31:55in place some small businesses protections to
- 1:31:58reduce damages and violations are corrected within
- 1:32:0130 days of service. Talked about that new construction
- 1:32:06window from January of 2008 to 2016 if you passed
- 1:32:11inspection You can reduce it if you correct it
- 1:32:14the interesting thing is There's a bunch of violations
- 1:32:19that are presumed not to cause difficulty discomfort
- 1:32:22embarrassment So difficulty discomfort or embarrassment
- 1:32:25for physical access is the threshold requirement?
- 1:32:29To get damages or the deterrence the actual deterrence
- 1:32:33Some courts have construed that very generously.
- 1:32:37Some courts have said, look, difficulty, discomfort,
- 1:32:40and embarrassment requires a physical injury,
- 1:32:43requires an emotional injury. There's one case,
- 1:32:47it was LA Superior Appellate Division, because
- 1:32:52it was filed limited jurisdiction and appealed,
- 1:32:55where they held, look, the guy said the mirror
- 1:32:59was mounted too high in the bathroom, so he couldn't
- 1:33:01see his reflection in it. But he testified that
- 1:33:06he was able to see his reflection in other surfaces
- 1:33:10and still fix his hair or whatever. No difficulty
- 1:33:14there. There's another case in the Southern District.
- 1:33:17It was a trial where the plaintiff said, yeah,
- 1:33:21the parking lot striping wasn't there. But I
- 1:33:23was able to use it just the same. I was able
- 1:33:25to navigate the parking lot. And the judge said,
- 1:33:27OK, well, based on that evidence, no difficulty,
- 1:33:30discomfort, or embarrassment. But you can see
- 1:33:32the. The other burn shifts, interior signage,
- 1:33:36exterior signage, parking signage, those items
- 1:33:39do not, they're presumed not to cause difficulty.
- 1:33:44So if you correct it within 15 days of the identification,
- 1:33:50so you can shift that. Defense strategies, we
- 1:33:56have the Article III standing that I've been
- 1:33:58talking about. They need to have, A past injury,
- 1:34:03in fact, that discrimination would continue,
- 1:34:07including the intent to return. Some courts have
- 1:34:10attacked this. The Swarovski case in the Second
- 1:34:17Circuit, that was a grail gift card case. I had
- 1:34:23the class action. I had a bunch of those. And
- 1:34:26basically said, look, you know, there was no
- 1:34:28standing and there were as evidenced by the boilerplate
- 1:34:31complaints. And the Southern District of New
- 1:34:34York, we have a case here where they were looking
- 1:34:37at, you know, in fact, they were identical lawsuits.
- 1:34:39And there's a whole bunch of intentional return
- 1:34:41cases out there that say, look, we're not going
- 1:34:44to punish a plaintiff for filing suits and being
- 1:34:48a repeat litigant. But at the same time, they
- 1:34:53need to show. intention to return. And we saw
- 1:34:58that with the such a case where they were plaintiff's
- 1:35:02attorneys were sanctioned. mootness, we talked
- 1:35:05about new mootness. You have to have a remedial
- 1:35:10benefit or you can't get an injunction. So, you
- 1:35:13know, there's a lot of cases, a lot of Supreme
- 1:35:15Court or the United States cases. I'd say well,
- 1:35:20if something is fixed, it's moot. And we've seen
- 1:35:24that throughout district courts and appellate
- 1:35:28courts. A defendant can voluntarily remediate
- 1:35:32and moot out the injunctive relief. Then you
- 1:35:34get into the catalyst for the change argument.
- 1:35:36Some courts recognize it, some courts don't,
- 1:35:39whether or not the remediation was done because
- 1:35:46of the plaintiff's claim and whether or not that's
- 1:35:48the catalyst for the change. And they get their
- 1:35:50attorney seized for that. But that's all over
- 1:35:55the place. We talk about the nexus for websites.
- 1:35:58And again, a lot of courts are becoming more
- 1:36:02and more skeptical about these claims. But not
- 1:36:05all of them. And not all of them. Judges change.
- 1:36:09So they get new judges, where some judges have
- 1:36:11particular beliefs. Some of the defense traps
- 1:36:14that we see. The overlay, we talked about that.
- 1:36:19You might get sued for using your overlay. Retaliation.
- 1:36:23Small businesses, I've seen this more than big
- 1:36:24businesses. Small businesses say, yeah, I don't
- 1:36:29want this person, I don't want to do business
- 1:36:30with them anymore. Yeah, no soup for you. But
- 1:36:35Seinfeld reference there. But that's a no -go.
- 1:36:42You'll get hit even harder over that. We'll get
- 1:36:47to and fix it later. The delay and remediation
- 1:36:49can be a problem Every day could be more incidents
- 1:36:54and even equally fundamental. He's got to understand
- 1:36:56the nature of these cases Even if you get a release
- 1:37:00from the plaintiff and maybe a notice and opportunity
- 1:37:03to cure in the settlement agreement Doesn't mean
- 1:37:06you're not your clients not going to get sued
- 1:37:08by somebody else doesn't mean they're not can
- 1:37:10get sued by the same law firm with somebody else
- 1:37:13that you can probably get a rep and warranty
- 1:37:15from the law firm that they're unaware of any
- 1:37:17other claim, but you can't do anything even you
- 1:37:20can't even suggest to do anything to restrict
- 1:37:23the plaintiff's attorney's ability to prosecute
- 1:37:26and represent their clients. You know that in
- 1:37:29itself is a violation of rules professional conduct.
- 1:37:32I have there used to be some of these plaintiff's
- 1:37:35attorneys. They got very clever and they say,
- 1:37:38well, OK, what we'll do is. once we terminate
- 1:37:42representation, you can hire me. And I'll be
- 1:37:45your consultant to help you avoid getting sued
- 1:37:48again, you pay me an annual true retainer. And
- 1:37:52and that was, you know, their protection money.
- 1:37:55Because, you know, you imagine one firm is, you
- 1:37:57know, the firm in particular, Lynn Hubbard, which
- 1:38:01his son still out there, but Lynn Hubbard himself
- 1:38:04is no longer licensed with the California State
- 1:38:06Bar. He, you know, You know, you could imagine
- 1:38:09if you hired this gentleman, you know, to do
- 1:38:14this, you know, he can't sue you anymore because
- 1:38:17he's representing you. But he may be before he
- 1:38:19had sued you 50 times in one year. The problem
- 1:38:22with that is, is, you know, it's it's a bad transaction.
- 1:38:26You don't know how it's going to come out. I
- 1:38:28had to represent a general counsel of a company
- 1:38:32once and a company once because the the federal
- 1:38:36judge had found out collaterally. through an
- 1:38:40order to show cause against the plaintiff's attorney
- 1:38:42that this guy had entered into an agreement,
- 1:38:46just like that. And then the judge figured, look,
- 1:38:51I can squeeze the businesses, the big company
- 1:38:57just as easily as I can squeeze the plaintiff's
- 1:38:59attorney for entering into this indecent proposal.
- 1:39:03And so we had to deal with that and respond to
- 1:39:05a whole bunch on that. And it was a real problem.
- 1:39:08The prevailing party attorney's fees, you got
- 1:39:12to pick your battles wisely. You could have a
- 1:39:15$4 ,000 claim escalate to $50 ,000 in fees really
- 1:39:19quickly. The more you push back, the defense
- 1:39:24strategy of making the plaintiffs earn their
- 1:39:26money is a good one. It interrupts and interferes
- 1:39:32with the plaintiff's high frequency or high volume
- 1:39:36business practice. A plaintiff's attorney counts
- 1:39:39on a huge ROI. They use a recycled complaint,
- 1:39:43they use recycled discovery, and then they get
- 1:39:46a quick buck. And you can disrupt that. You can
- 1:39:50absolutely disrupt that by making them sit through
- 1:39:53a deposition or do unique motions. The problem
- 1:39:56is, is if your client has a losing case, because
- 1:40:01they actually had violations, then all you're
- 1:40:06doing is creating a larger claim for the plaintiff.
- 1:40:12Trap five on the bottom, third party content,
- 1:40:15we talked about that. Trap six, automated testing
- 1:40:17doesn't catch everything. But again, I do think
- 1:40:19that automated testing is what most plaintiffs
- 1:40:23use. So I would make sure that you include that
- 1:40:27in your strategy. you know responding to claims
- 1:40:31pretty simple stuff all intuitive go for you
- 1:40:36know fix low -hanging fruit you know you know
- 1:40:42know that that you know you're you're you're
- 1:40:44having challenges uh with your websites so you
- 1:40:48know through the operational components holiday
- 1:40:50code lock a lot of people don't think about that
- 1:40:53any you know any g any gc on the phone for retail
- 1:40:55or they know exactly what i'm talking about during
- 1:40:58the holiday season, you're not going to touch
- 1:41:02that website. You're fixing it in a pilot test
- 1:41:05environment. You're not doing anything to change
- 1:41:08that website because you're not going to risk
- 1:41:11where they make all their money. So you have
- 1:41:14that. You got to watch out for people who have
- 1:41:20outside development teams. Again, you have a
- 1:41:26You want to quickly respond or evaluate demand
- 1:41:32letters by removing, you have two tracks when
- 1:41:35you get a claim. The first part is fix it so
- 1:41:39you can't get sued again. Second is deal with
- 1:41:42the claim. Now not all claims are going to be
- 1:41:45responded to. I know this is demand letters.
- 1:41:49You have to figure out whether or not you want
- 1:41:51to make that plaintiff send you a second demand
- 1:41:53letter. Sometimes they get sued. but sometimes
- 1:41:56you can tell like if you have one i have i have
- 1:41:59a company that has six brands and all six brands
- 1:42:02get the same exact demand letter with no plaintiff
- 1:42:04identified and they're cutting pace with the
- 1:42:06same typos you may say well you know maybe they're
- 1:42:10they're they're spamming everybody with these
- 1:42:12demand letters and only the people who respond
- 1:42:14get hit so that's a judgment call but at the
- 1:42:18same time demand letters are not a prerequisite
- 1:42:22to most lawsuits Insurance, it's difficult for
- 1:42:28physical access, it's very difficult to get insurance.
- 1:42:33There's a very old insurance case, I think it
- 1:42:35was 2000, 2001, the modern insurance case where
- 1:42:40they hold that for under CGL. There's rarely
- 1:42:45coverage because accessibility barriers are the
- 1:42:48result of intentional decisions and conduct.
- 1:42:51But you have, there's, You have other policies
- 1:42:55that might cover. You might have an ENO. You
- 1:42:59might have cyber insurance. So you need to check
- 1:43:03into that, but it's challenging. And usually
- 1:43:07these claims, you can get rid of them under the
- 1:43:11SIRs, the deductibles. So again, quick wins to
- 1:43:20the low -hanging fruits. You need to come up
- 1:43:23with a real strategy that helps you figure out
- 1:43:30how you prioritize things. Some things are more
- 1:43:33tractable. They take longer to fix. And maybe
- 1:43:35that's not what you focus on. Maybe you focus
- 1:43:37on prioritize things that you can fix. Maybe
- 1:43:40you focus on things that really are going to
- 1:43:42affect persons with disabilities and affect access
- 1:43:45or be a high target area for litigation earlier.
- 1:43:51Tax incentives, we talked about that real quick.
- 1:43:54Those are those codes, 44 and 190. Again, just
- 1:44:02some restatements of the do's and do nots. So
- 1:44:07we can switch to any questions if we have any.
- 1:44:10I'll stop presenting the slideshow. I think the
- 1:44:14only questions that we have you answered during
- 1:44:16your presentation, I will check again. I think
- 1:44:20so. But thank you because this was very informative.
- 1:44:26I've got a couple. I've got a few of them. AR
- 1:44:30readers are being rapidly adopted by vision impaired
- 1:44:32users and do not rely on the end -of -night code.
- 1:44:35Most of them are also free. What are your thoughts
- 1:44:38on this? So, screen reader technology. So when
- 1:44:43say our readers talk about screen reader technology,
- 1:44:46a lot of them are free. And look, they used to
- 1:44:48be very expensive, right? In fact, they used
- 1:44:50to have a license for one of them. And believe
- 1:44:53it or not, my stepmom back in the day, that was
- 1:44:58one of her businesses was screen reader technology.
- 1:45:03But yeah, the thing is, yeah, it's true. A lot
- 1:45:07of the assistive technologies are becoming free.
- 1:45:11Think about your Apple device that has it built
- 1:45:13in. A lot of the technology out there works very
- 1:45:20on different levels of technology, but they are,
- 1:45:23assistive technologies are free, and even if
- 1:45:25they're not free to people, there are resources,
- 1:45:28right? The regional center may provide it for
- 1:45:30you, or you may be able to get it through Medicare
- 1:45:34or Medi -Cal if you need that. But certainly,
- 1:45:38you should have your code that you create should
- 1:45:44comply with that technology and the WCAG is intended
- 1:45:50to help you create a website content that does
- 1:45:56comport and work with those various different
- 1:45:58technologies, the assistive technologies out
- 1:46:00there. Keep in mind, screen reader technology
- 1:46:03is not the only type of assistive technology.
- 1:46:06Some people don't have use of their of their
- 1:46:10hands or their fingers or their arms and they
- 1:46:13use different technologies for that as well.
- 1:46:16So how do you deal with an opposing council that
- 1:46:20constantly threatens to measure of CC five two
- 1:46:22at the trials conclusion and doesn't review mitigating
- 1:46:25documents such as appraisal letters and CSP reports?
- 1:46:30Yeah, that is that is a that is a big challenge,
- 1:46:33right? This you have a. You have a plaintiff's
- 1:46:37attorney who refuses to acknowledge or engage
- 1:46:42in a merits discussion. And we've all had that.
- 1:46:47I don't think that's unique to access. When I
- 1:46:50have that, again, it's a case -by -case defense
- 1:46:58approach, but I will sometimes go to a different
- 1:47:03side of the rid. Go to the greed. I'll dangle
- 1:47:07the carrots in front of you. Hey, look, we can
- 1:47:10get you this money now, but we can't do it if
- 1:47:11we go in the future. I will ask directed questions
- 1:47:15as opposed to push them with an argument. Let
- 1:47:21them have to answer the tough questions that
- 1:47:24show the weaknesses in their case. You may need
- 1:47:27to narrow issues through dispositive motions.
- 1:47:32Yes, it really depends. Sometimes the plaintiff's
- 1:47:34attorneys will make the decisions for you by
- 1:47:37seeking way too much money, more money than it
- 1:47:39will cost to defend the case. The reality is
- 1:47:42I have successfully defended a lot of these cases
- 1:47:45over the years, more than I can remember, where
- 1:47:48I've had them thrown out, where the plaintiffs
- 1:47:49get nothing. Because a lot of these plaintiffs
- 1:47:52are in glass houses. A lot of these plaintiff's
- 1:47:55attorneys also have high volume practices. You
- 1:48:00know i had one place attorney who had a very
- 1:48:03ambitious young associate working for them who
- 1:48:06was a pretty good attorney and he put in the
- 1:48:10work but he was a real stickler for details and
- 1:48:14played a lot of gotcha games and you know central
- 1:48:18district anybody practices they know you got
- 1:48:20the weekends and the holidays if you really want
- 1:48:23to hit somebody with a summary judgment because
- 1:48:26they don't give a lot of time on summary judgment.
- 1:48:28He tried that stuff and the federal judge wasn't
- 1:48:33impressed. She said, well, hey, wait a second,
- 1:48:36you know, you're going to play that, you know,
- 1:48:38you want to do nitpicking as opposed to merits.
- 1:48:40And I made sure that was pointed out. And she
- 1:48:42said, what's saucer the goose is saucer the gander.
- 1:48:45And she threw his case out based on some of those
- 1:48:49technicalities. So yeah, you know, obviously,
- 1:48:51I always try to take the high road on these things.
- 1:48:55You know, it's interesting. I've seen a lot of
- 1:48:57the same people over and over again in the last
- 1:48:5920 years of doing this. And some of them I've
- 1:49:03developed a really good rapport and trust with
- 1:49:06them. Some of them not. Some of them not. You
- 1:49:08know, there's some people who are just known
- 1:49:10to be difficult plaintiff's attorneys. You know,
- 1:49:13I'm dealing with one of them right now. It doesn't
- 1:49:14care about the merits. And the problem is, is
- 1:49:18some of them, they even go to them and say, look,
- 1:49:21my client doesn't have any money. You know, here's
- 1:49:23the finances. I'm more than happy to share. They
- 1:49:26view that as blood in the water. You know, I
- 1:49:29represent a big company that can defend themselves.
- 1:49:31They go away because they only know the big company
- 1:49:34is willing to pay me hundreds of thousands of
- 1:49:36dollars to put these guys out of business. And
- 1:49:38I have had rule 11 trials where I've had plaintiff's
- 1:49:40attorney sanctioned. I have had situations, the
- 1:49:44interesting thing is guess who gets the sanctions?
- 1:49:47The court. I have got the attorney's fees. I
- 1:49:51have had those cases thrown out. But the fact
- 1:49:55is smaller businesses can't always afford that.
- 1:49:58Some of the bigger businesses don't want to spend
- 1:50:00their money on that. It's a business decision.
- 1:50:04They have to figure out, hey, wait a second.
- 1:50:06I can get certainty. Now, certainly, that's where
- 1:50:08the settlement agreements are really important.
- 1:50:13If you can't get a notice and cure provision,
- 1:50:16those are great. You know some of these these
- 1:50:22settlement agreements you can also look into
- 1:50:24that. You know getting some some concessions
- 1:50:26Pursuant evidence code 622 and the recitals that
- 1:50:29help you in the future Yeah, but yeah, you never
- 1:50:33know. I mean I've had plaintiffs who literally
- 1:50:35I've had guys who sued over an entire set of
- 1:50:39Wheelchair barriers and then we checked the security
- 1:50:42footage and they're walking around the store
- 1:50:44You know and then and you know And we've had
- 1:50:49those cases dismissed, obviously. Why was the
- 1:50:53language that you mentioned posting on our website,
- 1:50:56based on policy, the accessibility? There's two
- 1:50:59components. First, I like having an outward -facing
- 1:51:02policy, lets everybody know. And I'm getting
- 1:51:06this because I'm just looking at historical Department
- 1:51:09of Justice consent decrees, what they asked for
- 1:51:14from people and what they want, what infrastructure
- 1:51:17they're looking for. Because if you are already
- 1:51:20doing what people are going to ask from you in
- 1:51:22settlement or demand from you in a lawsuit, it's
- 1:51:25going to be hard for them to see you over it.
- 1:51:28So one of the things is a policy that says, look,
- 1:51:34we take accessibility seriously. This is our
- 1:51:37policy. This is what we strive to achieve. This
- 1:51:39is what we're going to do here. Now, certainly,
- 1:51:42it has to be something you're doing. You don't
- 1:51:44want to set a bunch of statements out there in
- 1:51:47emotion that you're not actually complying with.
- 1:51:51But you take that outward facing policy, you
- 1:51:53have inward facing policies, you train off of
- 1:51:56those policies, you work off of those policies.
- 1:52:01That's how you create an environment that has
- 1:52:07a culture of compliance. The second thing is
- 1:52:11is like I said on the website, I like to have
- 1:52:14not just, I like to have communication channel
- 1:52:17where people can voice complaints or accessibility
- 1:52:21or policy modification requests. And then we
- 1:52:24track them. We have our customer service people.
- 1:52:27If you have a customer service team, have them
- 1:52:29make sure that they have a specific box that
- 1:52:32they check to track whether it's an accessibility
- 1:52:34related complaint or issue. And that way you
- 1:52:37can prove the negative. Keep in mind, If you
- 1:52:41have that, you want to make sure that if you
- 1:52:42have a telephonic channel, that you also make
- 1:52:45sure that you accept TRS and you make sure you
- 1:52:47say that. We didn't go into that too much, but
- 1:52:50obviously if somebody is deaf or wants to complain
- 1:52:54to you about the fact that you don't have captioning
- 1:52:58on your video, then you tell them, hey, call
- 1:53:01the phone. You got to make sure that you're accepting
- 1:53:03telephone relay service calls so they can communicate
- 1:53:06with you. And we have one more question too.
- 1:53:10To answer your question, I think Beverly Hills
- 1:53:12Bar Association is going to respond to whether
- 1:53:13you can get to the object credit. Matt and his
- 1:53:16partner are going to be doing a presentation,
- 1:53:18I believe, in December. Matt, is it December
- 1:53:20that you're doing your presentation with Mike?
- 1:53:23I don't know if we have the date locked down
- 1:53:25yet, but we are definitely doing it. This winter,
- 1:53:28Matt and his partner are going to be doing a
- 1:53:30presentation with the HBA, specific to website
- 1:53:33accessibility. I believe if anybody's in this
- 1:53:36subject area, I'd recommend tuning in. Thoughts
- 1:53:38on captions as a reasonable accommodation in
- 1:53:41lieu of an ASL interpreter for live performances
- 1:53:44and write -ups? Yeah, that is a very, very complicated
- 1:53:51concept, but very simple. So you have to provide
- 1:53:56effective communication. So the issue is ASL
- 1:54:02is not the same language as English. So for complicated
- 1:54:07transactions, complicated exchanges, you may
- 1:54:12need to provide ASL to be able to achieve effective
- 1:54:18communication. You can imagine a school where
- 1:54:20somebody is taking like a physics class. You
- 1:54:22could imagine where somebody is, you know, doing
- 1:54:25getting a home loan or, you know, doing something,
- 1:54:28doing an insurance application. But certainly
- 1:54:32ASL interpreters are are much more money. and
- 1:54:39then real -time captioning. Real -time captioning
- 1:54:42can be done by AI for the most part. So as a
- 1:54:46public accommodation, you are entitled to make
- 1:54:50the decision and select which auxiliary service
- 1:54:56you provide. But again, you have to achieve effective
- 1:54:59communication. So usually that the process starts
- 1:55:02is you ask the individual what their preferences.
- 1:55:06And keep in mind also, they have to give you
- 1:55:07a reasonable notice. Somebody shows up at your
- 1:55:10facility and says, hey, look, I'm here. I'm here
- 1:55:12for the training today. And you're doing the
- 1:55:16cooking class free. And I'm here to learn how
- 1:55:18to make pizza. And I want an ESL interpreter
- 1:55:22in five minutes. You can't do that, right? Because
- 1:55:25that's not reasonable notice. But if two weeks
- 1:55:28ahead of time, they say they want, they're going
- 1:55:30to show up and they want to know how to do it.
- 1:55:32You have to be able to provide to them some type
- 1:55:39of effective communication. You start with asking
- 1:55:42them, we can provide real -time captioning. Is
- 1:55:46that going to work for you? They may say yes.
- 1:55:51ASL may not be their first language. You know,
- 1:55:54if it is our first language, then we have a different
- 1:55:56situation, right? Because that, you know, it's
- 1:55:59a different language. But it may not be their
- 1:56:01first or primary language. English may be there.
- 1:56:03They may not be congenitally done. And they may
- 1:56:07say, fine, I'm fine with that. That may stop
- 1:56:10the inquiry there. But if they do say, look,
- 1:56:14I want to have it in ASL, Then you have to start
- 1:56:19the inquiry. Why? What's going on? You have to
- 1:56:22evaluate whether or not you have a transaction
- 1:56:27or an exchange that requires ASL to effectively
- 1:56:32communicate something that's very nuanced, something
- 1:56:35that has a lot of details as opposed to something
- 1:56:38that's very high level. So then some other feedback
- 1:56:43after the presentation, this should be part of
- 1:56:45the series. Matt, thank you so much. I know we
- 1:56:47stayed longer, but again, I think we're so fortunate
- 1:56:50to have Matt and his team was helping with the
- 1:56:52presentation. Matt, it's awfully extremely knowledgeable
- 1:56:54and not only very skilled, but has a lot of experience
- 1:56:57in this area. So, Matt, thank you so much for
- 1:56:59speaking today. All of you guys have a great
- 1:57:02weekend or you're seeing this on the rerun. Have
- 1:57:04a great day. And Matt, thank you. Please thank
- 1:57:07Mike in advance for his willingness to come speak
- 1:57:09with us again. This was a great job today. Thank
- 1:57:12you. Thank you, everybody. And thank you for
- 1:57:14having me. Take care.