Latest / The Marketing Meeting with Itir Eraslan / 44. Why Marketers Need to Embrace Better Media with Tom Denford
Transcript
- 0:00Tom Denford: Media is such a simple idea that's been made incredibly complicated.
- 0:04I feel sad sometimes when marketers don't find media interesting
- 0:07because the principle of taking your product or your brand to
- 0:10customers should be very exciting.
- 0:12I think we've got collectively, we've got to confront it
- 0:14and we've got to embrace it.
- 0:16And it ultimately comes back to the marketer who gets to decide, who
- 0:20gets to set the tone, who gets to tell everybody what's important.
- 0:25Itir Eraslan: Hi, this is the Marketing Meeting and I'm your host, Itir Eraslan.
- 0:29Every two weeks I meet with experts and we talk about topics related to
- 0:33brands, marketing, and businesses.
- 0:36And we sometimes add random lifestyle topics too.
- 0:39I hope you enjoy the show.
- 0:46Welcome to the Marketing Meeting Podcast.
- 0:48My guest today is Tom Denford, cEO and co founder of ID Comms, uh, ID Comms
- 0:54is a global management consultancy specializing in media and advertising.
- 0:58Welcome Tom.
- 0:59Tom Denford: Thank you.
- 1:00Well, I really appreciate joining the marketing meeting because we love being
- 1:04in marketing meetings, so thank you.
- 1:06Itir Eraslan: The reason that I started this name was we used to have at Nike,
- 1:10we used to have these Tuesday sessions.
- 1:12Uh, and Tuesday mornings were dedicated to the marketing meeting
- 1:15where everyone was talking.
- 1:18So it just started from there.
- 1:20And then at the beginning, I was recording on Tuesdays.
- 1:23Only I know the reason to that.
- 1:25So there's nothing special about Tuesdays, but, uh, the website
- 1:29of ID Comms opens with the header brands deserve better media.
- 1:34Tom Denford: Yes.
- 1:34Itir Eraslan: And I know that you talk a lot about the quality of media nowadays.
- 1:39What does better media mean for you and your team?
- 1:43Tom Denford: It's a good question.
- 1:44Well, when we say brands deserve better media, that's just acknowledging
- 1:47that for most marketers in your marketing meetings, you don't really
- 1:53want to be talking about media.
- 1:54You want to be talking about brands and you want to be talking about your
- 1:56consumers and you want to be talking about your products and how you
- 1:59serve the needs of those consumers.
- 2:01And, In the last decade, marketers probably feel they've spent too
- 2:05much time worrying about media.
- 2:07It's a huge distraction.
- 2:08It's become really complicated.
- 2:11And sadly, it's kind of full of more risk and a lot of money.
- 2:16And so, as you said, we're a management consultancy that advises
- 2:19brands on media and advertising.
- 2:22And we feel that's our mission to bring to a CMO or a marketer that motivates
- 2:28my team is that we can help your brands Get a better result in media.
- 2:31And what we mean by that really is just, it's more effective.
- 2:34You know, we want your brand to be disproportionately more effective than
- 2:39any other brand in its category in media, which is a big part of your investment.
- 2:45Uh, it's a big headache that you want to go away.
- 2:47And so we call it untangling and de risking.
- 2:50So if we can untangle media for you, just to make it.
- 2:53Transparent.
- 2:53And so you can see actually what's happening, remove some of the waste and
- 2:57the risk, and you've got more marketing firepower from your media budget,
- 3:01and that should help grow your brand.
- 3:03So better is a very broad, you know, that's a quite subjective
- 3:09measure, but better acknowledges that it's not good enough.
- 3:13And then actually it can be a lot better.
- 3:16And what, what we like about that phrase particularly as well
- 3:18is that it's a kind of binding narrative for the whole industry.
- 3:22You know, media has become very, very fractured brands, accusing their
- 3:27agencies of lack of transparency and agencies kind of fighting with
- 3:30publishers about these kinds of things.
- 3:32And it's not the sweet harmony that we, that we want in the industry.
- 3:36And so.
- 3:37We try and remind everybody as well, that we're all in service of a common thing.
- 3:42We're all in service of the brands that we love, and that sounds a bit kind
- 3:45of woo woo, but like we have to remind ourselves, like, let's just come to
- 3:48the table because we're just trying to serve brands at the end of the day.
- 3:51Itir Eraslan: Um,
- 3:52Tom Denford: and that's a uniting, that should be a uniting force.
- 3:55So if we can get everybody together, understand each other's point of view a
- 3:58bit better, maybe we can all work together to give brands a better result for
- 4:02media and that's really what they want.
- 4:04So that the brand managers can go off and do far more important things.
- 4:08Itir Eraslan: So in that case, you are in between the media agencies and the brands.
- 4:13So you should make sure that they just hold hands correctly.
- 4:18Is that what I'm understanding?
- 4:19Tom Denford: Well, yeah.
- 4:20I mean, we, we don't put ourselves in between because when we don't
- 4:24want to be in between the marketer and anybody really, um, you know,
- 4:27their relationship with their agencies or any external partners.
- 4:30So we look at not just.
- 4:32media agencies, we look at creative agencies, we look at technology and
- 4:35some direct to publisher relationships between brands and publisher.
- 4:39Um, our ambition is not to get in the middle of those, but just to
- 4:44make sure that we construct highly productive and profitable relationships
- 4:49between those two, that's just really transparent and in service of the brand.
- 4:54Itir Eraslan: So you see yourself closer to the brands.
- 4:57Tom Denford: Yeah.
- 4:58Well, we work, yeah, we work for marketers.
- 5:00So our business is.
- 5:02Solely focused on the marketer.
- 5:04Um, we maintain good understanding and constructive dialogue
- 5:10with all of their suppliers.
- 5:12So all of the different media and creative agencies.
- 5:15Um, but our customer is the marketer, is the CMO or the brand manager
- 5:20or the procurement lead within the marketing org of an advertiser.
- 5:24Itir Eraslan: I'll come up to that part of, you know, the agency
- 5:27pits and so on, because we got connected through the agency pits,
- 5:31uh, through one of your posts.
- 5:32Uh, but, uh, I'm going to ask a broader question now, because for
- 5:36example, right now, based on Nielsen, the median age of TV is 70 years old.
- 5:42Uh, and for prime TV is 65.
- 5:45I mean, I'm not sure it's exactly 70, but, uh, where are young people now?
- 5:51Tom Denford: Where are they?
- 5:52Well, I mean, Media is different now.
- 5:55These audiences we talk about are fragmented across lots of different
- 5:59types of media and different channels.
- 6:02And for the last 20 years, The internet has enabled that to
- 6:06happen is that people can find, you know, more niche communities.
- 6:10Essentially, we all used to watch the same TV programs at the same time on the same
- 6:14TV channels or select a few TV channels.
- 6:16Of course, now there's hundreds or thousands of different places
- 6:19that you can spend your media time.
- 6:22Now, that should be a good thing for a marketer ultimately, because as people
- 6:31gather around particular types of content, if you're really into, I love
- 6:35sailing, so if you're, you know, if I, if I read sailing magazines or go on
- 6:38sailing websites or follow, you know, accounts on social media that to do with
- 6:42sailing, I'm there to, you know, you could sell me sailing things, right?
- 6:46So it's a really good way of understanding audiences, their media behaviors,
- 6:50and, When they're fragmented out, that should be a really good thing.
- 6:53Um, actually it's quite difficult.
- 6:55It has been quite difficult for brands to, to do that.
- 6:58Uh, which I'm thinking some of the complexities that we've
- 7:00probably come on to talk about.
- 7:02But that's been the major change is that where we spend our time is just fragmented
- 7:07into these like far smaller pieces.
- 7:09And so you have to do, there's a lot more analysis required to understand
- 7:13how people are consuming, what type of content, and as a brand That segmentation,
- 7:20media segmentation, and understanding who to target as, as potential valuable
- 7:25customers is a big industry now in itself, you know, doing an analysis of
- 7:29media consumption data and trying to link that back to your target customers.
- 7:33Itir Eraslan: Um,
- 7:34Tom Denford: but it should, in theory, be more, you know, effective
- 7:37because we can target people around their areas and topics of interest.
- 7:42Itir Eraslan: Some people say that, uh, especially lately, uh, as I
- 7:46reading the news around, uh, podcasts and marketing and election, I think
- 7:51I've read three news about that young people, they are consuming podcasts.
- 7:56Not TV or anything else, which I would doubt because that type
- 7:59of a generalization is too big.
- 8:01You know, you cannot assume that everyone is listening to the podcast.
- 8:05Uh, what's your thoughts on that in terms of medium, like other than TV
- 8:10or prime TV, um, or, uh, streaming platforms, where do you see brands
- 8:16putting more money behind right now?
- 8:18Is it podcasts, which Well,
- 8:22Tom Denford: I think after this, I think more, more brands will
- 8:24be putting money into podcasts.
- 8:25I hope.
- 8:26Uh, no, but you're right.
- 8:28The consumption of podcast media is, has grown hugely in recent years.
- 8:34And it's a, it's a really significant now advertising platform.
- 8:39You know, go back five years, it was kind of seen as somewhat of a niche and
- 8:42you'd have brand mentions and maybe some podcast hosts would be in a trialing
- 8:49product or recommend certain things.
- 8:50But now these are reaching large audiences, regular and predictable
- 8:54and sustainable audiences, which is really what the brands want.
- 8:58What they want are scale audiences to reach lots of people
- 9:01in predictable and safe ways.
- 9:03And that's podcast is, has grown really nicely into that space.
- 9:08It's really just radio.
- 9:10But a bit extra, you know, I talked to a lot of marketers sometimes
- 9:13about actually what types of media, what they do, you know, podcast.
- 9:20I really love because it's a very intimate type of media is what
- 9:23we would call like a me media.
- 9:24When I'm listening, it's just me listening.
- 9:27Yeah.
- 9:27Like maybe you grew up listening to the radio.
- 9:30You know, when you listen to your favorite station on a radio station,
- 9:34the host of that is talking to you.
- 9:36I know that you know that lots of other people are listening, but it's a very
- 9:39intimate thing and you may have like headphones on or you're listening whilst
- 9:43you're in the car or something like that.
- 9:44It's normally a mediates consumed.
- 9:46Individually on your terms and typically around something that you like a topic
- 9:53you like, or a host that you like, or somebody telling a story that you like.
- 9:56And that's a really lovely environment to put your brand in.
- 10:00And the way that can be activated on podcast is beautifully creative because
- 10:05you can have On air mentions, which are always really effective because
- 10:09you have a relationship with the host that's talking to you and when they talk
- 10:12about a brand that comes with an extra special wrapping of endorsement and just
- 10:16running traditional ads like pre, during or post a podcast is an understanding
- 10:22of the listener that that's how you get content, you know, we, we are used
- 10:25and we do accept ads running before the things that we want or in the things
- 10:30that we want, because we understand that we get those things for free.
- 10:34Yeah, as a result.
- 10:35So it's a very pure type of media and I'm not surprised that it's grown.
- 10:40It's a very on demand version of radio.
- 10:44Um, and that, so it's got a, it's got a particular feel.
- 10:48I think it's interesting for, for marketers to really think about
- 10:51podcasting as a, as a really powerful platform to now get reach.
- 10:56It's different to TV, but as it potentially is impactful as a TV.
- 11:00I mean, that's why it's grown so much.
- 11:02Itir Eraslan: When I think about the format of the contents, uh, you
- 11:06know, everybody's talking now it's video, you know, you have to really
- 11:09come up with video ads or video video as a format is on the rise.
- 11:14And we used, we were used to creating ads for printed media.
- 11:2010 years ago, let's say now we are getting used to, we already
- 11:24got used to creating content for video, a cycle for video format.
- 11:27Of course, video was with the TV.
- 11:29Also it was in our world, but now is podcast is completely a new format.
- 11:35Considering that radio was quite small 10 years ago.
- 11:39I'm just thinking about the fact that brands now need to learn.
- 11:44How to create right formats for audio as well, because it's
- 11:47a completely different world.
- 11:49One of your posts, uh, it got my attention.
- 11:51So I'm going to read the first few lines, uh, and then we're
- 11:54going to, we can talk about the media agencies pitches and so on.
- 11:58It says, are we living in a city of discounts who set the low,
- 12:02low bar for the media quality?
- 12:04How did we end up giving up on context, placement, environments, partnerships
- 12:09as important media concentrations?
- 12:11Uh, I think you.
- 12:13Talk about the race to the bottom and then reversing it to the race to the top.
- 12:18Can you talk a bit about this?
- 12:20Tom Denford: Yeah, of course.
- 12:21Um, I mean, this is all in the spirit that brands deserve better media.
- 12:24And I think one of the things that we talk to marketers often about, um, because
- 12:31often the start point is, you know, where are we and where do we need to get to?
- 12:35And often the blunt truth to a marketer is where you are right
- 12:39now is that you probably don't have Transcribed enough visibility of,
- 12:44of what's happening in your media.
- 12:48It's really opaque and complicated.
- 12:52And for most marketers, what they spend on media, I mean, for those listeners that
- 12:58are not marketers that haven't touched the kind of the budgeting challenges
- 13:01of marketing is that 60, 70, sometimes 80 percent of your money is media.
- 13:06And it's typically the area they know least about, but it's
- 13:08the largest single investment.
- 13:11And for a lot of companies, it's the largest or one of the largest
- 13:13single investments companies make across all of their costs.
- 13:17Um, so media is really important, but it's The starting point
- 13:21is it's generally great.
- 13:24And there's a couple of reasons for that.
- 13:26One is that it's so complicated and they don't really understand and they
- 13:28can't see what's necessarily happening.
- 13:31And secondly, they're working with a very complex supply chain that really
- 13:35is trying to do one thing and that's deliver cheaper and cheaper media.
- 13:39So most brands have been trying to treat media as a commodity really, and trying
- 13:45to buy as much, as many media impressions as they can for the least possible cost.
- 13:51And when we talk about the old fashioned media, you tended to
- 13:55kind of know what you were buying.
- 13:57Now, it's got so complicated, you often don't know what you're buying, you don't
- 14:00see it, you don't have a sense of it, you just see it on a spreadsheet or a report,
- 14:04and opens up lots of risks to very low quality media, fraudulent impressions.
- 14:12You know, websites that will take your money and then issue hundreds or
- 14:16thousands of banners on a particular site.
- 14:18For example, we have these, these phenomenal called made for advertising
- 14:21websites, which are, have a very, very heavy ad load, which is a little bit
- 14:25of content and tons of ads around it.
- 14:27You've probably seen these kinds of things and lots of things pop up and you have
- 14:30to keep clicking to refresh the page.
- 14:32These sites are really just designed to take advertisers dollars and they're
- 14:35not effective at driving any kind of.
- 14:39Actual customer response.
- 14:42Um, so the marketer beware a lot of your money is being wasted.
- 14:46The reason that I kind of wrote this post is because as an industry, we've
- 14:50become a bit obsessed with trying to get under this low bar of cost.
- 14:54And I think some things are to blame.
- 14:55I think one of the things is, is the traditional kind of audit community
- 14:58of media have just turned media into this commodity that you have to kind
- 15:02of measure in terms of how cheap it is.
- 15:04And that's the only thing.
- 15:06And marketers have been told that cheaper media is better media.
- 15:10But like anything in life, you know, you get what you pay for.
- 15:14So if you want, if you continually want cheaper media, then the
- 15:18quality of that has to degrade.
- 15:19And the way it's degraded is that there are more ads on pages.
- 15:24Ads are loading behind other pages.
- 15:27There are bots that create ad clicks on banners.
- 15:30They're not even real people.
- 15:32And marketers are buying this stuff.
- 15:33They're paying for this because they want cheaper.
- 15:36What we want to do is And what we try to do as a business is shift in the
- 15:40marketer's mind, this idea that you have to get media under a low bar of cost.
- 15:45And set a high bar of quality, which might cost a bit more, but we have
- 15:50to show to the business that that's effective at driving some kind of outcome.
- 15:54And then if you can show that and you get the marketing organization thinking
- 15:57more in that way, then you're more likely to continue to invest in media
- 16:03that drives an outcome in the business and you'll see the impact of that.
- 16:07Itir Eraslan: When I think about the discussions that I do with clients or
- 16:12the discussions back in the days when I was working for a brand and we used to
- 16:17buy ads, uh, the discussion starts always with the return on investment per ad.
- 16:22It's okay.
- 16:23How many people saw it and then what's the price per viewer.
- 16:29If you want to twist this and we say that we would like to go to the quality
- 16:35What's the starting point there?
- 16:37I mean, rather than starting the discussion, okay, look how cheap I
- 16:40got uh, views or impressions with.
- 16:44What should be the narrative from the marketer's side?
- 16:46Tom Denford: Yeah.
- 16:47I mean, I love the way you use the word narrative because often
- 16:50that's, it starts with that.
- 16:52And if we're sat with a CMO or a marketer and they ask that question,
- 16:56you know, what's the start point?
- 16:57We say the start point is you.
- 16:59Okay.
- 16:59And what I'm from the marketer, you set the tone of the rest of the marketing
- 17:03organization, and then your narrative carries through the whole supply chain.
- 17:09Okay.
- 17:09Brands invest collectively over a trillion dollars a year, each year in advertising,
- 17:14a trillion dollars that puts advertising in the top 20 countries by GDP.
- 17:19That's a lot of money.
- 17:21And about 60 to 70 percent of that is media.
- 17:24Okay.
- 17:25And how that gets applied and deployed comes back to you as the CMO.
- 17:31Okay.
- 17:31What standards and what narrative will you set for media?
- 17:37Because if the narrative is, It should be as cheap as possible.
- 17:40Then that pervades across this entire complex landscape.
- 17:43And every, everybody is trying to get the CMO a better, cheaper media, right?
- 17:48Keep a deal immediate.
- 17:49If the CMO says, actually, we care about media.
- 17:54We care where our brands show up in the world.
- 17:59Really important.
- 18:00You have to tell people that you care about media.
- 18:04And you care where your brand shows up in the world because media is
- 18:06where your brand is going to show up.
- 18:09Media is how your brand behaves in the world.
- 18:12So it's actually really important.
- 18:14So you don't want to spend too much time getting into the details of CMO.
- 18:18We just want to know there's less risk and that.
- 18:22It's working as hard as possible.
- 18:24So if you can get the CMO to say, and be prepared to say publicly or it's within
- 18:29their organization and direct this long tail supply chain, actually, we care
- 18:34about standards here that goes a long, long way of changing the behavior of a
- 18:39big, big, long supply chain, uh, because the pervading and the conventional
- 18:44wisdom is that media needs to be as cheap as possible to keep markets happy.
- 18:47But that's, if you sit with a marketer, And you say like, here are the
- 18:50implications of that is buying counterfeit impressions, maybe fund funding, you
- 18:56know, disinformation, misinformation.
- 18:59You're pulling budgets out of funding, quality journalism.
- 19:02You're buying your, your, I mean, this is where your money goes, right?
- 19:06It goes into the hands of crooks who are using a selling fraudulent advertising.
- 19:13Marketing budget is flowing into these places.
- 19:15They probably don't want, you know, your ads are showing up in, you know,
- 19:18On websites and around videos that you don't want them to be associated with.
- 19:23So if you care more, you tell everybody that you care more, you
- 19:27set a higher standard for everybody.
- 19:29And then often companies like us will come in and actually set specific
- 19:32guidelines that everybody can follow that are quality thresholds.
- 19:36And then we measure, forensically measure every dollar that's spent,
- 19:39every impression that's acquired, and then we grade it according to
- 19:43that, to those quality thresholds.
- 19:44So.
- 19:45You can continually see what's the poorest quality or the poorest
- 19:50performing media inventory cut that reinvest it back in the brands.
- 19:54And so you're continually optimizing and doing better work.
- 19:57And that's that's where it starts.
- 19:58But it has to start right at the top with the marketer.
- 20:02Itir Eraslan: I find it really interesting, especially, you know,
- 20:05marketers spent a lot of time and budgets and also thinking to produce.
- 20:11Good quality content, not everyone, of course, but like, we are obsessed with
- 20:16the, you know, creative, it's how it looks and how it's gonna, what's the copy.
- 20:21But then you deliver that copy.
- 20:24You don't mind delivering this copy or like this visual, this ad,
- 20:27beautiful ad to, you Uh, very low, you know, quality media channels.
- 20:32So I feel that as much as we consider, uh, creating good content, uh, and good
- 20:38ads, uh, I think it's important that we deliver them to the right places, which
- 20:43is like, uh, the narrative doesn't start with the, uh, price narrative starts
- 20:48with who's going to see this and which platforms are we going to show this,
- 20:53um, done in that case, like for a brand.
- 20:56To do media investment, trust is a very important because you talk about
- 21:01fraudulent ads, uh, about places that, you know, you get impressions, but actually
- 21:06it's the bot who is weaving your ads.
- 21:09How can we solve this?
- 21:11I mean, like, is it to go to the right media agency then,
- 21:14or what's the solution to that
- 21:16Tom Denford: it's really solvable, but it comes back to this
- 21:20direction that a marketer must give everybody that they care.
- 21:25So the whole media, when I call it the media supply chain, that is like the
- 21:28agencies, publishers, platforms, all the buying technology, all the ad, different
- 21:33dips of ad tape, they go through all the way through to publishers and then
- 21:36maybe an impression or a page or an ad that a customer, your future customer may
- 21:40see, or your current customer may see.
- 21:42Um, that's what we call the supply chain.
- 21:45That's really, it's grown.
- 21:48To optimize on price.
- 21:50It exists to generally optimize on prices, to get you something as cheap as possible.
- 21:55The irony is, is that there are often dozens of different companies
- 21:59that are then touching your money through that chain and they all
- 22:02take a little bit of it as well.
- 22:03So what gets to the end is, is actually a lot what you thought.
- 22:07Um, and there's some good analysis that's going on with the trade associations,
- 22:11kind of looking at that supply chain and where some of those losses are.
- 22:14And we try and.
- 22:15Uh, guide marketers to reduce that, reduce all the different
- 22:18touches, uh, on their money.
- 22:19That's maybe not adding value.
- 22:21So right now that supply chain is really optimized to find lower cost.
- 22:29And as a result, it's become pretty untransparent.
- 22:34If you as a marketer flip that and you tell your supply chain, you tell
- 22:38your media agency and you tell your media vendors and your publishers
- 22:41that you care about quality, you care where your brands show up in the
- 22:44world, then what happens is that that.
- 22:47Whole supply chain becomes engineered around putting the right brands
- 22:50against in the right places to reach the right people back to what it
- 22:53should be so we can get there and we are seeing movements towards that.
- 22:57And I'm optimistic that that's the way, but it's just got
- 22:59to start with that narrative.
- 23:01Your media suppliers are not going to.
- 23:03be focused on quality if you're still focused on reducing price.
- 23:08So you've got to first off change that narrative.
- 23:12Marketers have lost trust in their media supply chain, but they've lost
- 23:16trust because it's got so complex.
- 23:18They don't understand it.
- 23:20And they often feel like they can't get a straight answer out
- 23:22of anybody about how it's working.
- 23:24And so perhaps that's why companies like us exist.
- 23:26We're independent and objective observers of what's happening.
- 23:30And we work for them.
- 23:32To tell them and unpack what's happening so that they can see it and maybe have a
- 23:35bit more confidence in what's going on.
- 23:39Um, but trust is the currency of our, of any business.
- 23:43And when a marketer doesn't trust with their media suppliers enough,
- 23:48then I think that's a problem.
- 23:51Needs to be addressed and it only gets addressed any relationship is that you
- 23:58have to build trust over time and it comes from consistent positive behavior.
- 24:03And so if the supply chain is more transparent, can give the market a more
- 24:08visibility of where their money goes and what works and what doesn't, and
- 24:12they can optimize to their ambition to.
- 24:15Optimized for quality and not cost.
- 24:18And I'm confident over time that trust will be rebuilt, but it's really
- 24:24difficult at the moment because.
- 24:26You know, marketers being asked to now trust, not just trust a supply
- 24:29chain, but also trust a supply chain with a layer of AI on top of it,
- 24:33which makes it more complicated.
- 24:35Uh, it's another layer of complexity, which is giving marketer a headache.
- 24:42What we find is that they tend to do one of two things probably like most
- 24:46people is that you either reach in, you lean in and you take control as a
- 24:51marketer, and there are some very great.
- 24:55You know, Mark Pritchard at P and G is a, there's a leading marketer
- 24:58and a big advertiser, major advertiser, hugely influential.
- 25:02He and his organization have rolled their sleeves up.
- 25:05They've leaned into media complexity.
- 25:08They've unpacked it themselves and they've taken control really, and
- 25:12they've built some internal capabilities to manage media and they've demanded,
- 25:17you know, transparency and alignment of their, of their supply chain.
- 25:21And there's a few other brands that are doing that.
- 25:23Building capabilities internally, broadly taking control of media.
- 25:27And that's one route you can go as a marketer.
- 25:29The other route is to Before
- 25:31Itir Eraslan: you move to the second one, can I ask a question on the first model?
- 25:36For big brands, uh, but they have then the buying power to have everything
- 25:41internally, you mean that everything is moved internally, meaning that between
- 25:45the ads till it reaches the customer, is there any other person sitting in between
- 25:52the brand and the customer in their case.
- 25:54Tom Denford: Well, yeah.
- 25:55So where businesses have what's now broadly called in housing.
- 25:59So in housing capabilities to plan and buy media, which is totally possible for
- 26:03major brands to do that now, they have the opportunity through the technology,
- 26:08they're much more sophisticated internally around their data and what
- 26:11their brands need from media is that they can go and buy media directly.
- 26:16Um, Is there anything in between the brand and the customer?
- 26:19Well, the, yes, there is where the ad shows up, so they still need to obviously
- 26:23have, have publishers and they may have some technology relationships and they may
- 26:29have some direct vendor relationships, so they still need some external partners.
- 26:36It's an interesting challenge.
- 26:37You know what the role is then for the media agency.
- 26:39So that media agencies themselves are having to adapt and think ahead about
- 26:43what role they play as more advertisers.
- 26:47Decide to buy media themselves or buy it directly.
- 26:49So that's a, that's an interesting challenge for the media agency.
- 26:52Um, but it's, you know, we're, we're five or six years in now to
- 26:56this in housing journey, I think it is a, it's a continuing trend.
- 27:01And I think people suggest it's some kind of pendulum swing that there's, you
- 27:04know, brands take control, then they go use agencies and they bring it back in.
- 27:07So we're singing generally that.
- 27:09It's building within brands.
- 27:11Most brands now, I think almost every brand I've spoken to in
- 27:14the last five years has some kind of internal capabilities
- 27:19Itir Eraslan: for
- 27:19Tom Denford: managing media and as technology allows them to do
- 27:24so, particularly now AI tools, I think for media, a lot of
- 27:27those will be brought in house.
- 27:29A lot of them will be.
- 27:30provided by the platforms for marketers that will make it super easy for them
- 27:34to plan and buy media, um, themselves.
- 27:37So it's, it's getting easier.
- 27:40Itir Eraslan: So in housing was the first path that a brand can take, uh,
- 27:44especially, I guess this is valid for the big brands, bigger brands, uh, what's the
- 27:49second path that I cut your words there?
- 27:52You're not
- 27:52Tom Denford: going to like the second path because the first part
- 27:55is just lean in and take control.
- 27:56Take an interest.
- 27:58Understand how it works, make some decisions.
- 28:00You know, that's what brands that we work with.
- 28:01They tend to be wanting to lean in and do something.
- 28:04They want to just get a bit more visibility and decide what bits they want
- 28:07to run, how to work with their agencies, how to raise quality and transparency.
- 28:11That's one route.
- 28:12The other route.
- 28:14It's just to ignore it and bury your head in the sand and hope it will go away.
- 28:17And it's somebody else's problem.
- 28:19And there's a lot of people still doing that.
- 28:21So a lot of marketers might listen to this and think, okay, well, that's a problem
- 28:25for another day or another year or I'll ask, I have a media team that does all of
- 28:29that or have an agency that does all that.
- 28:30I don't have to think about it, but it's shifting the issue further down the
- 28:35line, kicking it into the grass or, you know, making it somebody else's problem.
- 28:40Um, so it's definitely an option.
- 28:43We wouldn't recommend it.
- 28:45Because the risk there is that your competitors are better at media.
- 28:50You know, 60 percent of your budget, 70 percent of your budget is going in media.
- 28:55If your competitors have figured out how to do it a bit better than you, if your
- 28:59competitors media is more effective than you, if your competitors are wasting
- 29:03less money on media, then you're going to be at a disadvantage over time because
- 29:07that gives them competitive advantage.
- 29:09It's so much money absolutely comes down to where your brand show up in the
- 29:15world, how you actually connect with.
- 29:17People, it's fun to make the ads and it's great to make great ads
- 29:21and you can become a great marketer and very famous making great ads.
- 29:24At the end of the day, you've got to sell some stuff and
- 29:28you've got to change behavior.
- 29:29And so those great ads, your messages, your brands that you've built, that we
- 29:32all love, they've got to reach people.
- 29:35And media is such a simple idea that's been made incredibly complicated.
- 29:42Uh, and I, I feel sad sometimes and marketers don't Don't find
- 29:46media interesting, you know, because the principle of taking
- 29:49your product to your brand to customers should be very exciting.
- 29:54Itir Eraslan: And
- 29:54Tom Denford: it's sad that it's got so complex.
- 29:56It's such a headache that.
- 29:57A good proportion of them just want to turn away and ignore the problem.
- 30:02But I think we've got collectively, we've got to, we've got to confront
- 30:05it and we've got to embrace it.
- 30:06And it ultimately comes back to the marketer who gets to decide, who
- 30:12gets to set the tone, who gets to tell everybody what's important.
- 30:17Um, and they can have an oversized impact on making media better for all brands.
- 30:23Itir Eraslan: I feel that it's the role of a marketer.
- 30:26I mean, it's like the natural role of a marketer to understand
- 30:29media and get curious about media.
- 30:31It's not like a nice to have.
- 30:33Uh, I think it's a must have if you are spending 60 percent or sometimes
- 30:38even 40 percent of your budget, then it's your responsibility and it's your
- 30:42job to protect that budget and to make sure that It goes to the right places.
- 30:48Um, two questions here.
- 30:50One of them is you mentioned about so many touch points between the brands
- 30:55till the customers then in terms of media buying, since all the technologies,
- 31:01AI, and many of the things happening.
- 31:03And also there's like a, still a race to the bottom to decrease the prices.
- 31:08Where do you see the future of the media agencies?
- 31:11I mean, are these touch points getting less?
- 31:14Uh, or does it require like a big change in the dynamics of our, or
- 31:20how media companies structured?
- 31:23Tom Denford: Yeah, I think there's, there's two forces probably
- 31:26at play with media agencies.
- 31:27One is we touched on now, which is that more brands are taking Control of media
- 31:34buying decisions and some are doing media buying increasingly doing media
- 31:38buying themselves and that naturally is decreasing the scope or the, the
- 31:44influence of a media agency on brands because they can do a lot themselves.
- 31:49Um, but also the other thing at play is that media agencies.
- 31:54Kind of got involved in the selling of media and not just the buying of media.
- 31:57So most media agencies, not all media agencies, because some
- 32:02very rightly kind of stand up and say, we don't do that at all.
- 32:04We just do that.
- 32:05We just work for the brands and we work wholly in the interest of the
- 32:08brands, but some media agencies are, have created new revenue streams
- 32:11by taking either unsold inventory.
- 32:15Or additional things that they can negotiate and repackaging them.
- 32:18And then kind of selling those on at some margin.
- 32:22And the margin is often undisclosed, selling those back onto their customers,
- 32:26to their clients, to the advertisers.
- 32:28And that looks like it's a win win in the sense because the publisher sells
- 32:33things that maybe they couldn't sell.
- 32:35The agency gets to add some value and make some money.
- 32:38And in theory of value add, what happens is that the advertiser can sometimes buy.
- 32:44That media cheaper in these undisclosed ways than they could do elsewhere.
- 32:50So it looks like they're buying something cheaper.
- 32:53So we have this whole world where cheaper media is being again, funded,
- 32:57but everyone's making money from it.
- 32:59So it seems slightly, slightly perverse.
- 33:01Let's say that things can be cheaper and cheaper and we
- 33:04can make more money doing it.
- 33:06Um, so that's created an interesting dynamic.
- 33:09I mean, media agencies are incredibly entrepreneurial and they're always
- 33:13trying to find new ways to get.
- 33:16You know, brands in front of customers.
- 33:18And I believe that most, almost all media agencies are working
- 33:21in the interests of brands.
- 33:22They believe in this idea that they're helping brands reach customers and.
- 33:28If they can find media opportunities and package them and sell them
- 33:31to brands and that helps brands reach consumers cost effectively,
- 33:36then maybe that's not a bad thing.
- 33:38However, it's more lack of transparency.
- 33:41That's the thing.
- 33:42And so the marketer doesn't really know what they're buying.
- 33:46Or what they're paying.
- 33:47And so it's very hard to then take a judgment on, are we buying
- 33:51really what our brand needs?
- 33:54And are we paying a fair price given the impact or the quality of that?
- 33:58So it's an interesting moment for media agencies.
- 34:01I mean, I say to agency CEOs, I talk to analysts like market analysts quite
- 34:05a lot is that ultimately agencies will media agencies will have to
- 34:09decide long term whether they really want to be, you know, the buyers
- 34:13of media or the sellers of media.
- 34:14I think at the moment, a lot of agencies kind of think that
- 34:16they can do both and they're.
- 34:17Maybe it'd be quite successful doing both, but then the privately, the marketer is
- 34:22saying that's not an ideal thing, right?
- 34:26We don't really like the idea that the company that's supposed to
- 34:29be buying media is also heavily invested in selling media as well.
- 34:32Because, you know, is there a risk that they could be selling us things
- 34:35that we don't need, you know, do they put things on media plans that are
- 34:39really things that they want to sell or that they think that we should buy?
- 34:43And there's confusion there long term that's not sustainable.
- 34:48And I think in an environment where it's easier and easier every year for
- 34:51marketers to build their own media, media management capabilities internally.
- 34:57buying their own media.
- 34:59That's a big question for agencies is like, what, you know, what role are
- 35:02you going to play five years from now?
- 35:04Are you going to be a seller of media?
- 35:05Are you going to be a marketplace, which is a totally valid thing, but let's
- 35:09just be very transparent about that.
- 35:11Are you going to be a marketplace or are you going to be, you know,
- 35:13a consultative value add, uh, service that supports brands?
- 35:19in achieving their ambitions, you know, directly as an advisor,
- 35:23which is often really what the marketer wants from their agency.
- 35:27Itir Eraslan: I mean, I doubt that a lot of brands, uh, would go in housing
- 35:32the media capabilities, well, right now at least, uh, because not every brand
- 35:37is as big as the others, like as big as PG, PNG or other, some global brands,
- 35:43because when you are a big brand, you have the power to buy more because
- 35:47you are buying more and then you can.
- 35:49you know, get better deals, uh, with platforms like Google or some other
- 35:54ad platforms that you can give.
- 35:56Uh, so I'm thinking from the perspective of a smaller brand.
- 36:01So let's assume that I'm a smaller brand and I just started
- 36:05investing in social media ads, which is like a very small portion.
- 36:09And, um, Even someone at the team can do that, but there's like a path that
- 36:14you have to take once you start spending some money on media, then as you grow,
- 36:18you would need some better hands where then you just go to a media agency.
- 36:26What do you suggest for a smaller brand that is just about to
- 36:29start investing more in media?
- 36:32They just go and search for media agencies, which is.
- 36:36or should they search for companies like you or consultants like your team?
- 36:40What's the path for a smaller brand?
- 36:43Tom Denford: Yeah.
- 36:43I mean, so the first thing is to find a media agency that's right for you.
- 36:49Quite a lot of the work that we do is helping match brands
- 36:52with the right agencies.
- 36:54We run and design those processes on behalf of brands
- 36:59and the first start of that.
- 37:00And if you want to do it yourself as a small growing brand, You don't want to
- 37:04work with a consulting team like ours, you can do some of this yourself, which
- 37:08is you've just got to be really clear what you want, really be clear what you want
- 37:12from an agency, because there's, there are agencies for everybody, you know, there's
- 37:15all different types and size and scales and different capabilities and expertise.
- 37:20And the first thing is to decide actually what you need.
- 37:24And really the best way to do that is to just sit for a second and just
- 37:27think how you work internally, because really what you want is an agency that
- 37:35And enhance what you currently do.
- 37:38We look at a lot of relationships between brands, like big and
- 37:41small brands and their agencies.
- 37:42And we find that where there are issues is either because they overlap, they're
- 37:46trying to both do the same kind of thing and they get in each other's way,
- 37:49or there's gaps in scope and there's things that drop through the cracks that
- 37:54they don't, not sure who's doing what.
- 37:57And most of the.
- 37:58Kind of dysfunction, a procedural, operational things, and you just can't
- 38:03let, and there's too much at stake here.
- 38:04There's a lot riding on brands and advertising and you've got
- 38:10to have agencies or an agency that is really closely aligned
- 38:14with what you're trying to do.
- 38:15And then you set up a very clear scope of what the agency does and what you do, and
- 38:20then you can work productively together.
- 38:21It should be precision engineered.
- 38:23It's worth taking a lot of time just thinking about that.
- 38:27We say to marketers all the time, please do not go shopping for an agency.
- 38:30It's like walking into a grocery store and without any idea of what you
- 38:33want, you know, what happens, right?
- 38:34You just end up buying everything.
- 38:36Okay.
- 38:36Ikea have figured that one out very well.
- 38:38Like if you don't know exactly what you want, you come back with everything.
- 38:41So the worst thing you can do is start by just calling agencies and just
- 38:45arranging all these kinds of meetings.
- 38:46And you know, it turns into a beauty parade and you don't exactly
- 38:49know what decisions you're making.
- 38:50So be clear what you want.
- 38:53And then the next stage is we typically tell a brand or help a brand understand
- 38:57What the criteria of evaluation should be, because normally it's a group decision.
- 39:06You know, it's very rare that we work with a CMO or a marketer who says,
- 39:09I'm just going to choose an agency.
- 39:11Normally there's lots of people involved.
- 39:12There's brand managers involved.
- 39:13There's agency relationships.
- 39:15Sometimes legal procurement is that they can, you know, maybe a lot
- 39:19of businesses that we work with a divisional businesses, they're
- 39:22multinational multidivisional businesses.
- 39:24And you have stakeholders, complex stakeholder sets, but even in
- 39:28a small brand, you've probably got a small marketing team and
- 39:31that you want people's opinion.
- 39:32So it's fair to the agencies participating in that, that you share with them
- 39:39how you're going to make decisions.
- 39:41It's really important for them to know how decisions are going to be made and
- 39:43who's going to be making decisions.
- 39:45And you need to know, right, what are we actually looking for?
- 39:49Agencies are really good at seducing marketers.
- 39:52They're really good at that.
- 39:54Like they're really good at getting marketers to fall in love with them.
- 39:58Agencies have wonderful people.
- 40:00In them that you want to work with.
- 40:02And we typically, we often have, you know, market to go.
- 40:05We like, we like all these agencies.
- 40:06We love all these people.
- 40:07Can't we just hire all of them?
- 40:08Um, we can't, and you can't fall in love with the individuals.
- 40:11You've got to really think that, you know, there are capability questions.
- 40:16Can the agency do what we want?
- 40:18Okay.
- 40:18Cause we've made a list of things that we want.
- 40:20Does this agency actually do those things?
- 40:22Cause not all agencies do everything.
- 40:24Secondly, is there an alignment of culture and values?
- 40:29Okay.
- 40:30Is this our kind of company?
- 40:32Those things are really important.
- 40:33Do we feel these are our kind of people?
- 40:35Okay.
- 40:36Do they work with brands that we like or that we could
- 40:39recognize that are like ours?
- 40:41That cultural fit and alignment of values is something that we spend a lot
- 40:44of time thinking about in advance, like which agencies to put on a long list.
- 40:49Um, and it's something that we encourage marketers to really, uh, look out for.
- 40:55Okay.
- 40:55And actually score on those things.
- 40:57And the third part is commercial terms, because you can fall in
- 41:00love with an agency and then you think, Oh, I can't afford them.
- 41:02Um, and you need to be really clear what it's going to cost, both in terms
- 41:06of the staffing and the fee, but also other, there's lots of other resources,
- 41:10there's increasingly technology and tools that agencies will have.
- 41:15Um, and when it comes to media agencies, of course, like how and what
- 41:18they buy in terms of media, how they, how good they are at negotiating.
- 41:22Um, so those are the three areas, the capabilities, cultural fit
- 41:26and commercial terms that we encourage marketers to think about.
- 41:30And if you've got a scorecard or some way of evaluating agencies around
- 41:34those kind of areas, then, you know, go see three, four, five agencies.
- 41:38And then make a decision, fall in love.
- 41:42Itir Eraslan: And also like, there is a lot to like, we talked about
- 41:45like what the brands should do, but there are also things that one more
- 41:50thing that they need to do is that they need to make sure the agency,
- 41:54best agencies want to work with them.
- 41:57So that's where I think the media pitches, uh, like how do we brief an agency
- 42:02comes very important because just like producing a content or producing an ad.
- 42:08If your brief is to the point is just captures the right
- 42:12things, then it's the same.
- 42:15You get a really good, beautiful ad, but for the distribution of that ad,
- 42:20if you brief the agency in the correct way, then you get better results.
- 42:23That's what I've experienced for 20 years right now.
- 42:27Tom Denford: 100%.
- 42:27It's really good advice.
- 42:28And every pitch that we ever run is.
- 42:34We always say to the client side team on the advertiser side is that often you
- 42:39have to kind of pitch yourself first.
- 42:41Okay.
- 42:42And it's more important now than ever because agencies are not
- 42:47prepared to pitch for everything.
- 42:49They are being way more discerning about which brands they will
- 42:54be prepared to pitch for.
- 42:56And that's a good thing, actually.
- 42:57Because when you run a pitch, you want agencies to really want to be
- 43:01there and to really want to win.
- 43:03Um, so half the job at the beginning is to get the marketer
- 43:07to commit to, yeah, right.
- 43:08A really good brief, be open and transparent.
- 43:11These are partners you're going to work closely with for the
- 43:12next three, five, 10 years.
- 43:15You're going to entrust them with millions of your brand dollars.
- 43:18Okay.
- 43:19Take some time to do it really, really well and present yourself in
- 43:24the best possible way, because the best way of getting the best talent,
- 43:28the best ideas, the best commercial terms, like the best agency showing
- 43:32up and being really competitive is that they want to work with you.
- 43:36And they're going to want to work with you if you present a realistic
- 43:40idea of what it's actually like and what your objectives are.
- 43:44And we encourage marketers to be really honest.
- 43:46We say like, what are the worst things?
- 43:48What are you really bad at?
- 43:49You know, how bad could it be?
- 43:52Itir Eraslan: Exactly.
- 43:53Uh, just one final question before I move on to my last two questions.
- 43:59Over which budgets do you see a smaller brands?
- 44:03Let's say over what budget they should start working with an agency.
- 44:08Is it like 100, 000?
- 44:09I'm just assuming.
- 44:10I mean, is there like a average that you see in the market?
- 44:14Tom Denford: Uh, yeah, that's a good question.
- 44:16There's not really, because essentially there's an, there's an agency
- 44:19that could support all budgets.
- 44:22You know, agencies don't just have to work with big budgets, but also there's
- 44:26There's a change in the industry, which kind of makes that less important
- 44:32is that historically, and you made a reference to this earlier, it's like,
- 44:35you know, big budgets can get big agencies and they have a lot of money
- 44:40so they can negotiate better discounts and all of these kinds of things.
- 44:42They can utilize the resources of agencies better if you have more money, but that's
- 44:46not really true anymore or less true.
- 44:49Because as of today.
- 44:52In a market like the U.
- 44:53S., about 50 percent of media budgets across all brands is not
- 44:58bought through a negotiation.
- 45:01It's not purchased from a vendor from a discount on rate card in the
- 45:06way that media used to be bought.
- 45:08But you'd go and you'd try and buy it a spot on a TV channel, or
- 45:10you'd buy a page in a newspaper, or you'd buy a banner on a website.
- 45:14There'd be a rate card of costs, and then you'd buy it.
- 45:16Maybe use your agencies, trying to negotiate those costs down.
- 45:20Now about 50%, this is a big tipping point now is that half of our media budgets
- 45:26are now being traded through auctions.
- 45:31And that's a whole different dynamic of the way to buy and sell media.
- 45:34So if you think about how an auction works differently, an auction
- 45:38doesn't know how much money we have.
- 45:43And the example I'll give you, which I use often with marketers
- 45:46is like, you know, think of eBay.
- 45:48Everybody knows eBay.
- 45:49You can kind of go onto eBay and you can like bid for things that you want to buy.
- 45:54Let's say you and I are both on eBay and we want to buy a new bicycle.
- 45:58Okay.
- 45:58And that bicycle is 50.
- 46:01You may be a billionaire.
- 46:03And I may literally just have 50 in my pocket, but if I want that bicycle more,
- 46:09I see more value in it than you, I will win that auction just because you can pay
- 46:15more doesn't mean that you will pay more.
- 46:17So an auction creates this perfect supply and demand marketplace
- 46:21that doesn't respect scale at all.
- 46:23So it means that actually smaller brands can be.
- 46:28Way more competitive now because the whole media is becoming completely democratized.
- 46:34You can essentially, you can go and buy almost anything as a small brand.
- 46:38You just have to decide what to buy.
- 46:42And that is an intelligence that the brands increasingly have
- 46:45inside because they start to know they buy what they want.
- 46:50What works and what doesn't work so they can want to buy more of
- 46:53the stuff that works and less of the stuff that doesn't work.
- 46:55It's a continual optimization exercise that we do for a lot of brands,
- 46:59just pointing them to things that work and optimize against those.
- 47:03It doesn't really matter how big you are as a brand.
- 47:07And over time, less and less media is going to be transacted in these large
- 47:12scale based negotiations, and more of it is going to be auction based.
- 47:17So the smarter brands will win.
- 47:20Those with the best data, those able to move quicker.
- 47:24Itir Eraslan: Yeah.
- 47:24Tom Denford: We'll win.
- 47:27Itir Eraslan: Thank you so much.
- 47:28Uh, at the end, I asked two questions to my guests, uh, which
- 47:32is exactly the same questions.
- 47:34Um, if you could recommend.
- 47:37one book.
- 47:38What would it be?
- 47:39Tom Denford: I'm gonna give you three books.
- 47:40You can quickly and you can take your choice.
- 47:42So these are, these are relatively recent books that touch on some media
- 47:47principles I think worth reading.
- 47:49One is this was came out this year.
- 47:51This is Aaron Kumar's book, The Data Deluge.
- 47:53Aaron has just been appointed head of AI at Accenture.
- 47:57He's a very smart guy.
- 47:59And this is full of terrifying stories about how brands do bad things with
- 48:03data, but it's also full of hope.
- 48:05Um, again, another friend of mine, Shalindar's, uh, Marketer's
- 48:08Guide to Digital Advertising.
- 48:11Transparency metrics of money.
- 48:12Highly recommend.
- 48:13These are quite dense reads, but they're worth it.
- 48:16And then sorry, a little bit lighter, which is quite cool.
- 48:17I think is, um, Roger's book, quantum marketing.
- 48:20You're probably more familiar with that one.
- 48:22Itir Eraslan: Yeah, I read that before.
- 48:24Tom Denford: What I love the kind of stuff that he talks about is that
- 48:27it's a mindset of the marketer and what you say is really important and
- 48:31the frameworks that you build and how you communicate to the world.
- 48:34What's important sets a tone for so much.
- 48:37Um, which really comes back to everything that we try and do around media.
- 48:43Itir Eraslan: And what's your favorite place for coffee, either in
- 48:47New York or somewhere in the world?
- 48:50Tom Denford: It's funny, my kids were asking me this exact question the other
- 48:53day because I was talking about coffee.
- 48:55Um, I live in America now and there's this terrible trend here of flavored creamers.
- 49:04If you go into like grocery store, you've probably seen these things, right?
- 49:06And they all look like shampoo bottles.
- 49:08I mean, they're very clearly marketed a certain demographic.
- 49:11Um, they've got these weird, wacky flavors and don't know why you ruined
- 49:16coffee by putting kind of, you know, strange, strange kind of maple bacon
- 49:20flavored pumpkin creamers in your coffee.
- 49:23So I was saying, I was saying to my kids, um, We're going to Paris next year.
- 49:28We're taking them to France.
- 49:29I'm like, let's just get to Paris and just let, let's have a coffee in Paris
- 49:33or let, you know, when we get to Italy.
- 49:35So, I mean, I think the best place to drink a coffee is probably yeah.
- 49:39In a square at Italy is probably like one of my favorite place.
- 49:43I mean, it's good, but it feels good.
- 49:45Itir Eraslan: Yeah.
- 49:46And also like, it looks good.
- 49:48Uh, that's experience.
- 49:49Whole experience is, it's like, feels like you're getting better coffee, even if
- 49:53sometimes the coffee here might be better.
- 49:56Tom Denford: Uh,
- 49:57Itir Eraslan: thanks so much for joining me today.
- 50:00Uh, and I hope to see you soon maybe for, uh, media buying opportunity.
- 50:05Who knows?
- 50:06Tom Denford: Indeed.
- 50:07Very good.
- 50:07It's been a pleasure.