Latest / Film And Whiskey / 1917 (2019) / Hirsch The Departure American Single Malt Whiskey
Transcript
- 0:00In 2019, director Sam Mendes and star George Mackay gave the
- 0:05world a singular take on the Forgotten War.
- 0:08In 2025 we try an American single malt from a new to US
- 0:12brand. The film is 1917.
- 0:16The whiskey is Hirsch the departure.
- 0:19And we'll review them both. This is the.
- 0:23Film and Whiskey podcast. Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 0:45podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 0:48glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 0:51I'm Brad Gee. And Brad Gee, we are starting to
- 0:53wind down Season 9 of this podcast.
- 0:58You and I have been working behind the scenes, working on
- 1:00Season 10. And before we give away what
- 1:03Season 10 is about, Brad, we got to get through these last four
- 1:07movies here. And I am freaking pumped to talk
- 1:10about 1917, one of my very favorite movies of the last
- 1:15decade or so. A movie that I was significantly
- 1:18pumped for you to go see in the theater and then super bummed
- 1:21that you didn't love it as much as me.
- 1:24We'll, we'll revisit all of our feelings on this movie here in a
- 1:27bit. Brad, what are your general
- 1:30impressions of season #9 how's this been for you?
- 1:33I think it's been a lot of fun. You know, we obviously have
- 1:38traversed the decades in this podcast.
- 1:42I think what gold Rush from 28 is our. 25 I think the gold
- 1:47rush. Oh, that was 25 S Yeah, yeah.
- 1:50So from 1925, we have now come up to 2024 as our most recent
- 1:56film. So I, I was a very big fan of
- 2:00sticking to, you know, 2004 to 2024 for a whole season because
- 2:06I do think it helps us flesh out what does it mean to be Classic
- 2:12Cinema in the modern era. I I, I think it's been a really
- 2:16fun experiment. Yeah.
- 2:17And folks, if this is your first time joining us, welcome into
- 2:20Film and Whiskey. We review movies.
- 2:22We review whiskey. The premise of the show is that
- 2:25I grew up a huge movie nerd. Brad is new to a lot of these
- 2:29movies, but the two of us met in college and in grad school.
- 2:34We've done a ton of work on textual criticism.
- 2:36We love diving deep into, you know, for us, it was the books
- 2:39of the Bible. Now we're applying that same
- 2:41logic to films. So it's been fun ride going
- 2:44through these nine seasons with you.
- 2:46This season we've been looking at films from the last 20 years
- 2:50and asking the critical question, is this movie a modern
- 2:53classic? Now, in order to determine that,
- 2:56what we've been doing is going through 4 criteria.
- 2:59Is this movie a Best picture nominee?
- 3:02Did this movie make $100 million at the US box office?
- 3:05Is it in the letterbox to top 250?
- 3:07Is it in the IMDb top 250? Brad, I don't think this is a
- 3:11letter boxed movie, but I am pretty sure the three other
- 3:15boxes are checked for 19/17. Yeah, it made a lot of money at
- 3:21the box office for us, you know, kind of a quiet esque drama
- 3:26military film. It made 446,000,000 worldwide.
- 3:31159 of that was domestic. Pretty good for a World War One
- 3:36movie that World War 1 is a very slept on time in military
- 3:41history. I feel like, you know, super
- 3:44overshadowed by World War 2. And that's primarily because I
- 3:47think that like, I mean, obviously World War Two more
- 3:51recent than World War One, but the, the American involvement in
- 3:55World War 2 has become such a part of like the American myth.
- 3:59Like we really hold on World War 2 and, and our involvement in
- 4:04that on a pedestal. And I think World War One by
- 4:06comparison, it, it feels like a much more European conflict,
- 4:10which is silly to say, But like even this movie, it's about
- 4:13Brits fighting in World War 1. And I, I just don't think that
- 4:18we have a lot of great World War One examples in cinema,
- 4:22especially in the last, you know, 50 years.
- 4:26Yeah, it feels like a yeah, a forgotten war, but you're right,
- 4:31World War 2 at the end of the day, I think one of the reasons
- 4:36is it's a lot cooler to. It sounds like a power ranking
- 4:41wars here. We are 100% Vietnam War is below
- 4:45these two, you know for sure versus somewhere in the middle.
- 4:48Here's the thing. World War 2 is cooler to depict.
- 4:52Like World War 1 is a bunch of trenches and mud and barbed
- 4:58wire. And like the technology
- 5:01difference between like the biplanes of World War One and
- 5:05the fighters of World War 2 is so vast that like dog fights are
- 5:10way cooler in World War 2 than they would have been in World
- 5:13War One. And so even from a media
- 5:16standpoint, it's like, yeah, sure, it's it's a little easier
- 5:20to make a film or write a book about World War 2 then it would
- 5:24be about World War One. Well, I think you bring up a
- 5:26really great point that kind of introduces to huger points we
- 5:31have to discuss today. Anytime we talk about war films
- 5:34on this podcast we always bring up the famous Truffaut quote
- 5:37where he talks about how it's impossible to make an anti war
- 5:40film just because the medium of film makes things so
- 5:44entertaining that by even depicting the horrors of war
- 5:47you're so bought into it that in some ways it is participatory
- 5:52and you become a champion of war.
- 5:54I don't know if either of us fully agrees with that, but I
- 5:57think that what we've seen in the last, you know, 25 ish years
- 6:01is that in order to try to mitigate that, film makers take
- 6:05a very neutral stance on the politics of war and instead just
- 6:09try to depict the day-to-day lives of the soldiers.
- 6:13This was a major point in our Saving Private Ryan episode
- 6:16where we were trying to argue against the read on that film
- 6:19that it's just kind of jingoistic.
- 6:21And I think Sam Mendes does something similar here and the
- 6:24way that he does that, the second point is, you're right.
- 6:28World War One, super boring conflict to portray on screen
- 6:32because you're just in a ditch the whole time.
- 6:34Like it's trench warfare. And so in order to fight against
- 6:38the boredom and the repetitiveness and the visual
- 6:42lack of interest there, he does this thing where he's like, I'm
- 6:46going to make a one shot movie. And I think Brad, that kind of
- 6:50sets us up for, Brad explains. Because I want to get to the Sam
- 6:53Mendes of it all after you kind of cast the vision here.
- 6:57So let's throw over to our first segment of the day, which we
- 7:00call, Brad Explains. Brad's going to give us the
- 7:02movie plots with only 60 seconds sticking on the clock, so let's
- 7:06go ahead and do your take with this little segment that we
- 7:09call, Brad explains. Brad Explains is the part of the
- 7:12show where Brad breaks down the plot of the film that he has
- 7:16just seen, often for the first time.
- 7:19I am pretty sure I'm remembering this correctly.
- 7:21You saw this in the theater, right?
- 7:23I sure did. And and you have not seen it
- 7:26since. I've not seen it since.
- 7:28This is my first time since 2019 I think of the best picture
- 7:33nominees. I saw this and JoJo Rabbit in
- 7:36theaters. We have really been knocking out
- 7:38the 2019 nominees across the seasons here.
- 7:41It was a heck of a year. Man, what a great year.
- 7:43Ford V Ferrari, yeah. Parasite Marriage Story 1917
- 7:49Like it a darn good year for film.
- 7:52Parasite was such a good movie man.
- 7:55Oh, I love that. Movie.
- 7:57I know you do, man. I was pulling for 1917 and I
- 8:00know that I I am like persona non grata by taking this movie
- 8:05over Parasite, A beloved classic of world cinema.
- 8:08But I've said multiple times my weird experience watching
- 8:11Parasite has kind of forever tainted it for me.
- 8:14So this was a much purer experience in the theater for
- 8:17me. And I got to say, man, the world
- 8:21cinema, Correct. British director, British
- 8:24director. It's an it's an American movie,
- 8:26though, Like this is this is very much backed by America.
- 8:30And so Brad, you've seen it twice now.
- 8:32I don't really think this is a movie that requires 60 full
- 8:35seconds. But the minute is yours to spoil
- 8:38the events of this film. Folks, if you have not seen
- 8:411917, I would highly recommend going and watching the film and
- 8:44then coming back and joining us for the rest of the episode.
- 8:47Brad, one minute and go. 1917 is a film that follows Lance
- 8:52Corporal's Blake and Schofield as they travel through No Man's
- 8:57land during World War One in order to try and stop Sherlock
- 9:01Holmes from sending his men to certain death.
- 9:07I like how even on the subject of war, you can find a way to be
- 9:11a little cheeky in the way that you do things, Brad.
- 9:16Yeah, you're welcome. Who?
- 9:17Who? Me.
- 9:17I know in 1917 and another way of explaining it is like two
- 9:21young British actors share the screen momentarily with every
- 9:26major British actor. You know what I mean?
- 9:28Like it's. Every male.
- 9:30Every male, right? Yeah.
- 9:31Then Tilda Swinton doesn't show up in this one anywhere, but she
- 9:35probably could have if she wanted to, you know?
- 9:37I it wouldn't surprise me, Bob. All right, let's dive into
- 9:41talking about the film itself. And I think that we kind of have
- 9:44to go out of order a little bit today because it's necessitated
- 9:48by the type of movie this is. I I said a little bit ago, the
- 9:51movie is filmed and presented as if it is done in one shot.
- 9:55There are some cleverly designed transitions between shots, but
- 9:58this is a repairing of Sam Mendes and the cinematographer
- 10:02Rodger Deakins. And I think when you present a
- 10:06movie as if it's done in one shot, a la Birdman, and you're
- 10:10the director of a movie, you are inviting any attention that you
- 10:15get as a result. Like you're clearly asking for
- 10:19people's attention. The camera becomes a character
- 10:22in the movie, and you as the director are really putting
- 10:25yourself out there saying, look at what I can do.
- 10:28And the interesting thing with Sam Mendes is that a lot of
- 10:31critics do not like this guy. I don't know a ton about his
- 10:35personal life. So I don't know if there's, you
- 10:37know, maybe he's a terrible person in real life.
- 10:39But I think kind of unfairly, Sam Mendes gets shot on by the
- 10:43critical community because this is a guy that's made a lot of
- 10:46really good movies. And I've struggled for a long
- 10:50time to try to pin down exactly what it is that critics hate
- 10:54about the guy. And I think I'm like, I'm
- 10:57starting to have it click into view.
- 10:59Brad, are you familiar at all with the sort of critical
- 11:02campaign against Sam Mendes as a director?
- 11:06The Mendezian angst that exists within the film critic
- 11:09community. Is it Mendesian?
- 11:12Mendesian perhaps? No, I'm honestly not.
- 11:18I have. I'm trying to think if I've seen
- 11:21any of his other films than American Beauty, Skyfall in
- 11:251917. I mean, I is that a good
- 11:28representation of his filmography, would you say?
- 11:30I think so too. I mean like the only other two
- 11:33films that I would say we really should watch at some point for
- 11:36the podcast would be Road to Perdition with Tom Hanks and
- 11:40Jarhead with Jake Gyllenhaal. Those are probably like his big
- 11:435 movies I would say. Now I will say Jarhead for being
- 11:49what I would imagine is a loss to Time like just another war
- 11:54movie easily has one of the best marketing campaigns of any film.
- 11:59Because I still remember the previews for Jarhead.
- 12:04And the reason I bring that up is I think one of the reasons
- 12:071917 made so much daggone money is because it had a killer.
- 12:12Just the the the trailers for 19/17 were so freaking cool
- 12:19dude. And and I think that that kind
- 12:21of gets me back to the like, what is it that people don't
- 12:24like about Mendez? Because as I remember the 1917
- 12:27trailers, they had like a sort of ticking clock effect going on
- 12:31in the background, very reminiscent of like The Dark
- 12:33Knight and Inception. And I kind of wonder, you know,
- 12:37I, I think they were trying to position this movie as like
- 12:39Christopher Nolan esque coming off the heels of Dunkirk, which
- 12:43people really didn't love. And this is like, hey, this is a
- 12:46much more down the middle, suspense driven race against the
- 12:49clock movie that you wish Christopher Nolan made.
- 12:52And here is light beer version of Christopher Nolan making it.
- 12:56And I think that's kind of what I've come down on about why
- 12:59critics don't like Sam Mendes is that he he came from theater.
- 13:04He was a really well regarded director in London and I think
- 13:10that he knows how to like really mount a very handsomely made
- 13:13production. Like his movies always look
- 13:15impeccable. He knows how to use the camera
- 13:18and they always have the air of prestige.
- 13:21But even among the movies I just named like this movie Skyfall,
- 13:26American Beauty, Jarhead and then whatever the other one was
- 13:30that we were talking about. Road to Perdition Rd.
- 13:31To Perdition. Like, I don't know that I would
- 13:35call him an auteur in the same way that we talk about like a
- 13:37Tarantino or a a Wes Anderson or even a Scorsese, where it's
- 13:41like, oh, this is clearly a movie made by a guy with a point
- 13:45of view. You know what I mean?
- 13:48Totally. I, I think that American Beauty,
- 13:52of the three that I've seen, probably has the most distinct
- 13:56vibe to it that that makes it feel like it stands out from
- 14:00other films. I, I don't know if 1917 or
- 14:06Skyfall, like really shouts to the heavens.
- 14:11This is a Mendesian picture. There's Mendesian.
- 14:16It's the coolest term we've ever come up with on this show.
- 14:19Brad, easily. It's kind of similar to how Sam
- 14:26Mendes is is perceived. It's like Mendesian sounds like
- 14:29the coolest, deepest, most intricate thing you could
- 14:32discuss. And then you're like, oh, it's
- 14:33just a Sam Mendes movie. OK.
- 14:35Yeah. You know.
- 14:37Well, the the fascinating thing is you, you seem like you kind
- 14:41of agree with it when I know that you in fact don't.
- 14:44I I think it's a compelling argument and I do agree with it.
- 14:48I just don't know if it matters like at the end of the day, if a
- 14:51guy is like a really good, I wouldn't even call him like a
- 14:54journeyman director because he's not just like a hired gun.
- 14:59He he really puts care and attention into his movies.
- 15:03I don't think they have a personal touch.
- 15:05But I'm also like, he comes out with a movie and I'm like, oh, a
- 15:08new Sam Mendes movie. I'm going to see that like
- 15:11because I know that it's just going to be a well crafted movie
- 15:14that had a lot of care put into it.
- 15:16And I think that's an increasingly rare thing these
- 15:18days. It's interesting the the way
- 15:21that we are talking about him reminds me of how we talk about
- 15:26Rob Reiner. Like I although I would say Rob
- 15:32Reiner was much more of a like, we need a guy who's like a
- 15:35competent director, right? With like, that's no visual
- 15:39flair. You know, yeah.
- 15:41That's the thing though is like Rob Reiner was the hired gun,
- 15:45Sam Mendes isn't. But the way we describe the the
- 15:49output, I feel like it's kind of similar.
- 15:51Like super well competent, knows how to make a great movie.
- 15:57It just doesn't quite reach the heights or have the depth
- 16:01necessarily. That would make them a A tier
- 16:05director. Yeah.
- 16:07And yet with Mendez, he has that added prestige of like, I have
- 16:11won best picture, I have won best director.
- 16:13My films are constantly nominated for Academy Awards.
- 16:17So I think the. Push is annoyed that that he
- 16:19like won with American Beauty early in his career.
- 16:22Yeah, people really hate that movie, which I still think is.
- 16:24I like that movie a lot. I don't get it, But yeah, I
- 16:28think he's perceived as like the Oscar bait guy now, which is
- 16:31just hilarious to me 'cause you know, and isn't.
- 16:34Everybody like that would be like calling an NFL team Super
- 16:39Bowl bait worthy like. They're just setting themselves
- 16:43up to win a championship. This is ridiculous.
- 16:45Yeah. Why can't they be more like the
- 16:47Browns? Yeah, exactly.
- 16:49I I really don't understand the Oscar bait like how dare you
- 16:55play to the things you know will win you the best like most
- 17:00important award in our industry. Yeah, I don't know, man.
- 17:04And I think that's a good jumping off point to actually
- 17:06talk about the movie, which exists for me outside of this
- 17:11conversation. This is just a really well made,
- 17:14almost real time race against the clock movie where you've got
- 17:17maybe the best cinematographer of all time flexing his muscles.
- 17:21And the reason I brought up the Mendez thing is that it's really
- 17:24funny to go through reviews for this movie where the praise is
- 17:29always filtered around Mendez because it's like the critics
- 17:33don't want to give him credit for anything.
- 17:35And they're like, well, this is actually a Rodger Deakins
- 17:38showcase. And the fact that Rodger Deakins
- 17:39figured out how to do all this is insane.
- 17:42And like, maybe that's true. Maybe behind the scenes Rodger
- 17:45Deakins was just like shadow directing this movie.
- 17:48I don't freaking know. But like, it's just hilarious to
- 17:51me that we want to give credit to deacons.
- 17:55And it is, you know, let's be clear, a huge accomplishment
- 17:59technically this movie. Totally.
- 18:01But like the fact that Sam Mendes was able to orchestrate
- 18:07every piece, every instrument in the orchestra here, right, and
- 18:11and not get any credit for it. I don't know that there's a lot
- 18:14of directors who are kind of shafted that way the way that
- 18:18Mendez is. Absolutely.
- 18:20Yeah, it's it feels like one of those confirmation bias type of
- 18:25things where it's like, oh, well, you know, I expect
- 18:29Scorsese to make an incredible, deep, beautiful movie, so the DP
- 18:33doesn't get any real credit for what they do.
- 18:36But Sam Mendes, Meh. Deacons did the whole thing.
- 18:42Yeah, when it comes to the movie itself, what I love about the
- 18:46gimmick, and we should just start talking about the gimmick
- 18:48here, it's a one shot movie. What I love about the gimmick is
- 18:51that it really only works if you're not trying to do a ton of
- 18:54exposition. And so from the get go it's like
- 18:57there will be dialogue in this movie.
- 18:59A lot of the dialogue is going to be like banal day-to-day
- 19:03conversation between these two guys walking across a field.
- 19:06And it that that makes it work because it really elongates like
- 19:11the boredom of walking across a field and then a shot rings out
- 19:14and now we're running across a field.
- 19:17And and I think that plopping us into the middle of both of their
- 19:21tours, if you want to call it that, too.
- 19:23It's not like they're these are privates who were showing up for
- 19:25their first day of combat. Like the movie opens on George
- 19:29Mckay's face. He's sleeping against a tree.
- 19:32And immediately the camera pulls back.
- 19:34Both these guys are revealed. And it's like, boom, we've got a
- 19:37job for you. And so like literally 45 seconds
- 19:40into the movie, the plot is in motion and now you're just
- 19:44watching the trip to execute this mission.
- 19:47It is such a bare bones plot and it's the only thing to me that
- 19:51makes the gimmick of the movie work.
- 19:54See, I I found myself kind of in the opposite place where the
- 20:02gimmick of a one shot take. Is that it allows you to really
- 20:07just like sit with people. And I think that it works way
- 20:12better when you're in like a deep, tense, dramatic
- 20:16conversation between two people and you just never get that in
- 20:21this. And I'm not disagreeing that
- 20:24like those moments where he's talking about cherry trees and
- 20:28the different types. And like, there's plenty of
- 20:31small moments that you help you fall in love with the
- 20:34characters, but I I think A1 shot movie is best utilized when
- 20:42you have just a really super compelling character who's
- 20:46really deeply wrestling with like wild internal realities.
- 20:52And and I think that that's why it works for something like
- 20:54Birdman versus something like 1917.
- 20:59To me, this kind of felt like watching a video game.
- 21:03Oh, interesting. Where it's like every once in a
- 21:06while you have, you know, a, a quick cut scene with like
- 21:11Benedict Cumberbatch or Mark Strong.
- 21:15And then the rest of it, you're following a no name character
- 21:18that you're playing as and you're trying to do your mission
- 21:22and, and, and it, it, it feels like a ton of cutscenes with
- 21:26like player engagement stuff in the middle.
- 21:31Yeah, I think that's a really good criticism of the movie.
- 21:33I don't necessarily agree with it, but that's also because I'm
- 21:35not a video game player. And you're right.
- 21:37Like, there's definitely a first person shooter kind of thing
- 21:43going on in this movie, especially in the way that the
- 21:45camera kind of floats sometimes. It'll look elsewhere, you know,
- 21:48as it makes its transitions and then it'll kind of drift back to
- 21:52our heroes. I think it's really like a a
- 21:55pretty astute criticism, Brad. And it kind of begs the question
- 21:59of like, if we wanted to do a real time movie, which this like
- 22:04is close enough to being a real time movie, we don't have to do
- 22:08a real time movie and A1 take movie.
- 22:10So it begs the question of like, why are we doing the one shot
- 22:14thing? And I I think if I was Sam
- 22:18Mendes, the way I would answer that.
- 22:19It's like I'm trying to replicate the, I don't know,
- 22:25like the, the rhythms of the day in the life of a soldier where
- 22:30it's like nothing's happening and then everything's happening.
- 22:33And I don't want to introduce cuts to kind of speed up that
- 22:37timeline. I want to give a sense of like,
- 22:40we are always on edge. There is danger lurking around
- 22:43every corner. Even as I walk across this
- 22:45field, a shot could ring out and I could be dead.
- 22:47And I want to keep the audience on their toes by giving them so
- 22:51much visual information to process all the time that they
- 22:54have to keep looking in the corners of the frame or
- 22:56whatever. I just wonder, like, does the
- 23:00gimmick get in the way of the story they're trying to tell?
- 23:04Or on the other hand, is there not enough story to tell in this
- 23:09movie? And so you noticed the gimmick
- 23:11more. All I know is as you were
- 23:15talking, something you said made me think about like, yeah,
- 23:18though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death.
- 23:21Can you imagine the trailer for this where one of the characters
- 23:24is like is overdubbing the reading Psalm 23 and like just
- 23:31slowly backs out from like a nice white flowery field to show
- 23:37like the trenches and the no man's land.
- 23:40And it's like right as AH dude, what a trailer.
- 23:42No, but it would have to be one of those trailers they do now
- 23:45where there's like a sad piano version of a song and it's just
- 23:48like one piano note that's going like, and it's got the guy
- 23:53singing like, I'm going there to see my.
- 23:58And then he's just like Benedict Cumberbatch reciting Psalm 23.
- 24:03And that's the trailer for the movie.
- 24:05Dude, and it would be epic and I don't know how we don't work in
- 24:08the industry. I Yes, we have solved every
- 24:10problem with this film already. Oh.
- 24:13Man, the gimmick, the gimmick like works.
- 24:16That's I think that's the weird thing is I don't think he should
- 24:19have made this A1 shot movie and yet I think it works like to
- 24:25capture the story that they wrote.
- 24:27I do think that this was an effective use of the camera
- 24:31because it allows you to feel the totality of what he goes
- 24:37through. It allows you to feel the weight
- 24:42of what he has seen by the end of the film.
- 24:45Man, when he meets Blake's brother, which you know, the
- 24:49Lance Corporal. Blake dies about halfway through
- 24:52the film when he meets his brother and tells him that he
- 24:55was a good man and that he told funny stories.
- 24:58Like, you feel that impact because you've spent time with
- 25:01Blake, you've heard him tell a few funny stories.
- 25:04You you have an understanding of his character and how
- 25:07devastating it would be to hear about his laws.
- 25:10Well, and I think that again, that's it's one of the benefits
- 25:13of the not ever cutting away thing that like the actor who
- 25:17plays his older brother is always in the shot there after
- 25:20the news is delivered and and Scofield kind of starts walking
- 25:23away and you watch the guy kind of receded into the background,
- 25:27but he's still grappling with the news.
- 25:29And then he comes back and and tells him he was a good man.
- 25:31He saved my life. Watching the emotions get
- 25:34processed in real time and and being forced to sit with them I
- 25:39think really does make this a a much more emotionally impactful
- 25:43movie than it got credit for. I found myself really overcome
- 25:47with emotion at the end of this film.
- 25:49And Brad, you know, before we go to break, we haven't, we haven't
- 25:52really talked about anything except Sam Mendes and the
- 25:55gimmick yet. But like, I have found lately
- 25:59that it's harder and harder for me to watch war movies.
- 26:03There's a movie that just came out this past weekend from the
- 26:06film maker Alex Garland called Warfare.
- 26:08And it is based on a true story. And it is, it's not a one shot
- 26:11movie, but from my understanding, it's a near real
- 26:14time movie that is a true story about these American soldiers
- 26:19and I believe Iraq trying to get out of being pinned down.
- 26:21And that's it. That's the whole movie.
- 26:23It's supposed to be absolutely brutal.
- 26:25And it is being hailed as one of the best war movies of the last,
- 26:28you know, 10-15 years. And I have tried to get myself
- 26:34up to seeing it the last four nights in a row.
- 26:37And I just can't do it, man. I just for some reason, I can't
- 26:40bring myself to get motivated to watch something as heavy as a
- 26:45war movie. And I think to this movie's
- 26:48credit, yes, there's a gimmick. Yes, there's a video game kind
- 26:52of element to it, but it never shies away from how emotionally
- 26:58distressing all of this is. This was a this was quite a
- 27:02challenging experience to sit through for me, Brad.
- 27:06For me, it's those moments where he, like, puts his hand inside
- 27:10of a corpse or he's crawling over the bloated corpses of
- 27:14peasants who are in the river, that when he's like, weeping as
- 27:20he crawls out of the river. Or at the end of the film, when
- 27:23he sits against the tree and like you just see him completely
- 27:26drained of life. You understand why he gave away
- 27:31his medal for a bottle of wine. You get the angst that he has
- 27:37with Blake and I this time through the first time I saw it,
- 27:42I I don't think I appreciated the relational element of this
- 27:48movie as much this time through it, it felt way more relational
- 27:53than it had there. There's that piece of youth with
- 27:58Blake that you don't have with Schofield, even though they both
- 28:01look to be the exact same age. And, and, and that was wild to
- 28:05me how young they looked. And you know, that there's all
- 28:09sorts of things that, you know, talk about sending off our young
- 28:12men to war. Like, I don't know if I'm just
- 28:15getting older. You know, I'm 34 now.
- 28:17These they look like children, like maybe 20 years old.
- 28:22Yeah, well, and, and we can talk about the performances when we
- 28:26get back from break. I will say right up front
- 28:28though, George Mackay I think is a perfect leading man for this
- 28:32movie. And how do I say this about
- 28:35someone's looks? He looks like pictures I've seen
- 28:38of World War One veterans like you.
- 28:40You know what? There's a famous one that's
- 28:41floated around of like what a guy looked like before he went
- 28:44in the trenches. And the picture they took of him
- 28:46like 4 years later and he just has like these hollowed out eyes
- 28:50with that 1000 yard stare. It's a combination of just his
- 28:54facial structure and the make up in the movie.
- 28:56But like he has that. And when they show him at the
- 29:00beginning of the movie, you can already tell just by the way
- 29:03he's presented to us looks wise. This is a guy who has seen some
- 29:07shit. And I think that there's like
- 29:09there's a real authenticity there that, you know, his his
- 29:13partner doesn't have because he's like a much more fresh
- 29:16faced, you know, and the and Scofield even tells him like,
- 29:19you weren't there when we went through this horrific battle.
- 29:23I'm telling you, dude, it's not fun, right?
- 29:26And and I think that the character design really helps
- 29:29that. Absolutely.
- 29:31I, I couldn't get over the fact that I thought I felt like
- 29:35George McKay looked so much like Alan Ruck from Ferris Bueller's
- 29:41Day Off. Like, there was something about
- 29:44his facial shape that I was just like, Oh, yeah, this is like if,
- 29:48you know, Cameron got stuck in World War 1.
- 29:52There's an actor who's come up the past couple years who's
- 29:55gotten like moderately famous working in like indie movies
- 30:00that have made a big splash. His name's Harris Dickinson and
- 30:03he's like 6 foot two in a supermodel basically.
- 30:06But he is like, I, I think he's trying to market correct George
- 30:10McKay in real time. And George McKay is also been
- 30:12trying to like make a name for himself in indie movies.
- 30:15And it's really fascinating to watch the two of those guys get
- 30:18put in movies since 1917. I really liked George McKay in
- 30:23this movie. I'm wishing good things for his
- 30:24career. Like I said, Brad, let's dive
- 30:27into the specifics of the performances after the break.
- 30:30But talking about war movies and how stressful they are has
- 30:33really made me want to take a drink.
- 30:35What do you say if we tried this Hirsch departure single ball?
- 30:39Oh, I found a few facts about the amount of alcohol that was
- 30:43like prescribed to soldiers and like, dude, if you were about to
- 30:47go over the line, it was like a double ration per day for like
- 30:52the three days leading up to it. As it should be.
- 30:56Oh man, let's drink some whiskey, dude.
- 31:04All right, so today we're looking at Hirsch Selected
- 31:06Whiskey's The Departure. This is an American single malt
- 31:10whiskey. It is the first single malt
- 31:12released by the Hirsch Company, which is owned by Hotelling and
- 31:16Company, an importer and distiller based out of San
- 31:18Francisco. They are very popular in the
- 31:21American craft whiskey scene. They were known for a long time
- 31:25for their old Potrero line. There's a there's a ton of back
- 31:29story on Hodling if you want to read about it.
- 31:31I found a very long article that was super enlightening to me,
- 31:35but probably not necessary to share the entire history of this
- 31:37company on our podcast, except to say, Brad, this is the first
- 31:41Hirsch product we've had. Like I said, they're known for
- 31:44their rye whiskey. So we're we're joining them as
- 31:49they start to branch out into other things.
- 31:50So it's it's kind of cool because I don't know how much of
- 31:54A departure this actually is for them because I'm not even
- 31:57familiar with their rise. The real question is, could you
- 32:02tell the entire history of their brand in one take?
- 32:07No, I could get close though. Oh.
- 32:09It's very interesting, yeah, yeah.
- 32:11There's a there's breweries in their past, there's name
- 32:14changes, there's different labels, they've moved locations,
- 32:17lots going on over there. So it.
- 32:19Sounds like half the new distilleries.
- 32:22Yeah, pretty much man. It says in their press release
- 32:25that they started working on this product back in 2015
- 32:28because they'd wanting to been, they have been wanting to work
- 32:31with barley for a long time. So this is 10 years in the
- 32:34making. It's obviously not a 10 year age
- 32:36stated product, Brad. It's non age stated.
- 32:39It is 100% malted barley though. I'm excited to dive in man.
- 32:43American single malt is really growing these last few years and
- 32:47this is just another welcome addition for me.
- 32:49Absolutely. I I love seeing American
- 32:52distilleries dive into new areas like American single malt.
- 32:57I think it's a brand worth pursuing.
- 33:00And I'm, I'm excited to go over this Hirsch with you, Bob.
- 33:02I've already tried it and I would I'm pretty impressed
- 33:07overall. That's my initial impression.
- 33:09All right, so here's what I'm seeing about it, Brad, and this
- 33:12is the last thing I'll say before we actually dive in.
- 33:14I see two different quotes. One of them say it says that the
- 33:17departure was aged for 6 plus years in 24 month air dried 53
- 33:23gallon American oak barrels. And then it also says that it's
- 33:27double distilled in copper pot stills and aged for six years
- 33:31and nine months in new char #3 and toasted American oak
- 33:36barrels. So there we go.
- 33:37Six years, nine months, two kinds of barrels.
- 33:40Let's freaking dive in, Brad. It definitely smells like
- 33:44American craft whiskey on the nose.
- 33:45And if you've been a fan of craft whiskey, you know exactly
- 33:48what I mean. Even at six years old, there's
- 33:52quite a bit of graininess to this.
- 33:53There's quite a bit of raw grain, and it smells a bit
- 33:56young. I get a bit of yeast on this.
- 33:58But other than that, this is right in line with what we've
- 34:01come to expect from American craft whiskey, I would say.
- 34:04Absolutely. I think the nose has a lot of
- 34:08barley It it reminds me of like Cheerios there.
- 34:13There's a little bit of like a cherry stone fruit cordial kind
- 34:17of vibe. There's it gets a little bit
- 34:19nutty for me. There's some almonds going on
- 34:22here. I really like this.
- 34:24For me, it's not especially crafty, if you will.
- 34:30It like it has a little bit of that craft whiskey vibe, but not
- 34:33nearly enough to derail it. I'm going to give it an 8 out of
- 34:3610 on the nose. Yeah, I think I'm in a 7 1/2,
- 34:39but this is very positive because, and I don't know if
- 34:42it's just because they're used to working with rye, which is a
- 34:44very tricky grain to work with, but this, this has that sort of
- 34:48youthful note on the nose. But underlying it, they've
- 34:51gotten some really nice baking spices.
- 34:53There's a lot of caramel here. It smells like a a sweeter rye
- 34:57whiskey on like what's underlying that grain.
- 35:00I get a little bit of like, oat as well, which is the grain that
- 35:03we don't often get in our mash bills.
- 35:05But yeah, Cheerios was a really good note here, Brad.
- 35:07It's both like a little bit yeasty bready, but also like a
- 35:11sweetened breakfast cereal. 7 1/2 I think is a good baseline
- 35:15for this. When I got into the palate, all
- 35:18the things we talked about were there.
- 35:19It turned the fruitiness turned into like an apricot vibe.
- 35:24There's a little bit of cocoa. The overwhelming note I got on
- 35:28the palate was green tea. There's like this, this thing
- 35:33was like a green tea bomb with like a little bit of a glaze of
- 35:40kind of like a caramelized apricot like jam almost a really
- 35:47interesting combination of like a fruity green tea.
- 35:51I thought it was very fascinating.
- 35:52Not necessarily like my favorite flavor.
- 35:56Wheelhouse Green tea is not my go to but I I I do still like
- 36:01it, I'll give it a 7 1/2 out of 10.
- 36:04I really like this man. I, I'm not getting the green
- 36:06tea. And let me ask you this because,
- 36:08you know, tea is often used to explain to people like what
- 36:11tannins are and how a a wine or a whiskey can have that tannic
- 36:15effect where it kind of sucks the moisture out of your mouth.
- 36:18Did you have that effect drinking it or was it more just
- 36:21flavour? No, it was just the flavour.
- 36:23OK, OK, like it. It really reminded me back when
- 36:26I lived in Philly, I would occasionally drink green tea
- 36:29because that's the only thing we had in the house.
- 36:32And I just, it's I didn't dislike it.
- 36:35Like it was good enough that, you know, you had a little honey
- 36:37in there and it's a nice winter drink.
- 36:42It's just not my favorite. It's not, it's not in my
- 36:45wheelhouse preferred. So the flavor was there.
- 36:49Not my favorite, but it was definitely noticeable for me.
- 36:53I really like this man. And I'm not quite getting the
- 36:55same notes you are. I'm not getting as much stone
- 36:57fruit and I'm definitely not getting green tea.
- 36:59Your note of Coco, I think is like the predominant thing for
- 37:02me. I want to say, oh man, four or
- 37:05five seasons ago we tried a specialty bourbon from Woodford
- 37:10Reserve that was made with what they called like chocolate malt.
- 37:13And I, I don't remember getting a lot of chocolate on that, but
- 37:16that's kind of what this is for me.
- 37:17It's chocolate malt. It's it's lots of interesting
- 37:20grains coming out. I'm getting that oat again.
- 37:22I'm getting like when we first tried watershed distillery and
- 37:27they were using spelt like it just tastes like a bunch of
- 37:30funky grains went into this. I know they obviously didn't,
- 37:33but it it has that sort of vibe where it's like this is
- 37:36something completely different flavor wise.
- 37:39And we've layered over that really dark cacao nibs and then
- 37:44like a ton of cinnamon and like cayenne pepper.
- 37:47It's almost like a Mexican hot chocolate, but unsweetened and
- 37:50then like layered over raw grains.
- 37:53Super good. I'm going to give it an 8 out of
- 37:5410 on the palate, Brad. And then on the finish, I think
- 37:57it's more of the same. It's a really mouth watering
- 38:00finish. There's a ton of tingle on the
- 38:03tongue with this, like it's real spicy and at coming.
- 38:06Jingle, don't you, Bob? Yeah, I do, man.
- 38:08It comes in at 98 proof, and I think a drink's actually a
- 38:11little bit hotter than that. Not in a bad way, but you could
- 38:14have convinced me this was like 100 and five 107 proof.
- 38:18I'm a huge fan of this, Brad. I'm going to give it an 8 out of
- 38:2110 again on the finish. I'm with you on the finish.
- 38:24Eight out of 10 for me. The barley really like sits
- 38:27there and just lingers for a long time.
- 38:31The apricot sticks around, the green tea sticks around, the the
- 38:35cacao almost turns into like a creamy dark chocolate the longer
- 38:40it sits on my palate, which I really like.
- 38:43So like I said, I'm an 8 out of 10 there balance wise.
- 38:46I think I'll give it a 7 1/2. I think that they this takes you
- 38:51on a very interesting journey. I don't know if it all works
- 38:55perfectly together, but I do like where it takes me overall.
- 38:59So 7 1/2 for me on balance. Yeah, I'm going to give it a 7
- 39:021/2 as well. I and I don't think that it's an
- 39:04indicator that like anything's off here.
- 39:07And what I really love about American Single Malt Brat is
- 39:09that from distillery to distillery it, it's almost like,
- 39:14I don't know, like when you go to a winery and you're like,
- 39:16what's your house wine, right? Like what do you make here?
- 39:18What, what like what's your specialty?
- 39:21There's a distinct flavor and taste.
- 39:24And I don't know if it's a terroir thing, but like from the
- 39:27ones we've tried from up in like Oregon, Washington, to this one
- 39:31in San Francisco, to some on the East Coast, they're just very
- 39:35different flavor profiles. And I like that a lot.
- 39:38And this is carving out its own unique niche.
- 39:40So I'm giving it a 7 1/2 here. Now on the value, the MSRP on
- 39:45this is 7499, which is a little bit pricey for a six year
- 39:50whiskey. But again, single mold is tricky
- 39:52to work with. It's a new entry in America, you
- 39:56know, relatively new. Obviously, I don't think this is
- 39:59exorbitant. I think I'll give it a 7 out of
- 40:0210 on value. I'm right there with you 7 out
- 40:05of 10. This is a really interesting
- 40:08whiskey that like, I love being curious about whiskeys, Bob.
- 40:14Like we it's been a while since we had a whiskey that really
- 40:17piqued my curiosity. I'm coming to a 38 out of 50.
- 40:22I'm in the same spot, 38. I think that if I have to give a
- 40:26caveat on this, this is the kind of whiskey that you and I pull
- 40:29off the shelf because it's like a fascinating whiskey.
- 40:32Like we've tried 5 or 600 whiskeys over the course of this
- 40:36podcast. This one I'm going to remember,
- 40:39right? Not because it's bad, but it's
- 40:41just different. And I don't know that I would
- 40:43give this to somebody who's getting into like single malt of
- 40:46any variety for the first time. It's not like it's just not a
- 40:49good entry point because it's so far outside the wheelhouse of
- 40:53what you typically expect. All that said, I'm nearing a 40
- 40:57on this. This is like a no brainer.
- 40:59Thumbs up for me. If you get a chance to try this
- 41:01and you're feeling adventurous, go all the way in on this man.
- 41:06Yeah, I'm with you 100%. This is a really interesting
- 41:10whiskey. Hirsch, I think has departed
- 41:12well. At the very least, the beginning
- 41:15of their adventure is going well.
- 41:17So well done, Hirsch. The departure American Single
- 41:21Wall is a product to be proud of.
- 41:23The fact that this wasn't available when we reviewed the
- 41:26departed is criminal, honestly. It is.
- 41:29It is very unfortunate. Making up for it, though, is the
- 41:32fact that we have a pretty good movie today in 1917.
- 41:35Let's get back to talking about that, Brad.
- 41:37Let's do it. All right, everybody.
- 41:42That was Hirsch, the departure American single malt, a whiskey
- 41:47that makes me want to drink more American single malts, Bob.
- 41:51Not that my desire could have already gotten much higher, but
- 41:54man, I'm excited. Yeah, I like that a lot, man.
- 41:58I do wish we had found something a little more European to pair
- 42:01it with. This is like the second week in
- 42:02a row that I've said something like that.
- 42:04It's also the second week in a row, Brad, that we've had a
- 42:06movie shot by Roger Deakins. I didn't even think about that
- 42:11till just now. Prisoners and then this.
- 42:13The Deeks. The Deeks, am I right?
- 42:19What a just what a great cinematographer.
- 42:23Yeah, he really does just create beautiful movies.
- 42:27You know what I create that is things of beauty is my record at
- 42:30the end of every season at our next game Brad, which we call 2
- 42:34facts every season, 2 facts and a falsehood.
- 42:36Brad is going to try to stump your ball. 2 are right and what
- 42:43is wrong? 2 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts
- 42:47and a Falsehood is the part of the show where Brad presents me
- 42:51with three items as fact about the making of this movie, one of
- 42:55which is a complete lie. Now I am coming off of a win
- 42:58last week, but I'm still trying to balance out the two losses I
- 43:03got the week prior due to our friend Patrick Williams
- 43:06absolutely leading me astray. On one of the greatest, most
- 43:11well written falsehood in the history of the podcast.
- 43:14I know, man, we actually had somebody write into us to tell
- 43:17us what a good job you did. And I was like, don't stroke his
- 43:20ego. Then he's going to start putting
- 43:22effort into this, and I don't want him to do that.
- 43:24I want my record to be unblemished.
- 43:27I'm excited to blemish your record again, Bob.
- 43:30All right man, hit me with those two facts and a falsehood.
- 43:34Fact #1 in order to hide the small edits throughout the film.
- 43:39Director Sir Sam Mendes. We haven't mentioned that yet,
- 43:42Bob. Oh, is there, Sir?
- 43:44He is. But how can you argue with the
- 43:47Queen of England knighting this man?
- 43:50That's right, you can't say he's a bad.
- 43:51Director once he's been knighted.
- 43:54He might have been knighted by the king, you know, that's true,
- 43:57That's true. Maybe it's a recent titular
- 44:01edition. In order to hide the the edits
- 44:05throughout the film, director Sir Sam Mendez chose to use only
- 44:10two lenses throughout the movie, The 35mm for close-ups and some
- 44:15dialogue and the 24mm for the majority of the wide angle
- 44:20arrays. Fact #2 Throughout the shoot,
- 44:25the production had four basic rigs that were always at the
- 44:28ready to be able to take advantage of the changeable
- 44:30weather conditions as well as having a chief meteorologist on
- 44:37location the entire film. Fact #3 This was the first
- 44:43prestige war film to be nominated for the Academy Award
- 44:47for Best Visual Effects in nearly 50 years.
- 44:50The last Prestige War films to be nominated were Patton from
- 44:541970 and Tora Tora Tora from 1970, with the latter film
- 44:58taking the prize. While you were reading fact
- 45:02number one, I was looking up when Sam Mendes got knighted,
- 45:062019. So it was the queen, it was Her
- 45:10Majesty. A very astute woman.
- 45:13Yeah, so I need you to re read the back half of fact number one
- 45:16for me real quick. Something about millimeters is
- 45:19all I heard. He he used the only used 2
- 45:23lenses throughout the film to keep continuity.
- 45:26Oh nice, the 35 for close-ups and dialogue.
- 45:29The 24 for like wide angle stuff.
- 45:34OK, let's see. I think #2 sounds true enough #3
- 45:41sounds a little bit dicey to me. I I can't remember much of the
- 45:47movie Patton. I don't think they had very many
- 45:49visual effects in it. Maybe it did, Maybe it.
- 45:51Was just the opening speech and patent.
- 45:53Yeah, then you come to find out that that flag entirely CGI,
- 45:58that's what got it nominated. That that was it.
- 46:02Was Saving Private Ryan nominated for visual effects?
- 46:05I don't think so. I think it's either one or
- 46:10three. I'm leaning towards 3, but I'm
- 46:14also wondering how how Rodger Deakins could have switched
- 46:18lenses during long takes even if he is floating into a close up
- 46:22or or panning back out. You know what?
- 46:24No, I'm going to say #1 is the falsehood.
- 46:27I have no idea if that's true or not, but I'm going to stick with
- 46:30#1 Brad. Bob, you are 100% correct.
- 46:34Yes, deacons used 1 lens for the entire film being a 40mm.
- 46:41Lens that makes sense because like you, otherwise you'd just
- 46:44see a hand to come in front of the camera from time to time.
- 46:47Pop the lens off. It's the hand of God just
- 46:51floating in to reorient us here. All right, cool.
- 46:55So I I am back in the win column.
- 46:58I've balanced out Patrick's mistakes once again.
- 47:01Patrick Williams, you are on the thinnest device, Sir.
- 47:04Brad, let's get back into talking about 1917.
- 47:08And it seems weird to talk about performances because this is
- 47:12just such a like, let's follow some guys walking across a field
- 47:16kind of movie. Yeah, they could have put you
- 47:18and I in there and it would have been just as good of a movie.
- 47:21I mean, George McKay is in every second of this movie, so like
- 47:25it, it's worth talking about. I think he gives a really,
- 47:29really good performance because at no point was I ever like this
- 47:33guy Seems like he's acting or he didn't nail that emotional note.
- 47:38And I think for somebody to play the spectrum of all the emotions
- 47:42he has to go through, that's that's a pretty big feat of
- 47:45acting. Dude, he nails it.
- 47:48Like I, I think Dean Charles Chapman is like pretty good at
- 47:53like I don't really have any complaints with him, but he
- 47:55didn't blow me away. I think Makai has a, you said it
- 48:01earlier, man. His face is haunted.
- 48:04And it's not just he's not just experiencing like, oh, he, he
- 48:13hasn't become cynical. It's not just like it's
- 48:16ingrained in his face, but you see the the terrible things that
- 48:20happened to him on this specific mission and journey, like deep
- 48:25in the horror, they take what he's already experienced and
- 48:30make it worse. And by the end of the film, you
- 48:33feel that in every inch of his body language, his eyes, his
- 48:38face. And yet, like the youth of
- 48:42Blake, seems to give him a little bit of hope as well.
- 48:45And he plays all of that just incredibly well.
- 48:50Yeah, no, I totally agree. And I think that the film is at
- 48:53its weakest when it gives anyone else a line of dialogue beside
- 48:57those two people. Like especially the decision to
- 49:00put prominent British actors in kind of four of the main roles
- 49:04of authority in the movie. So you've got Colin Firth shows
- 49:08up at the very beginning to give the orders, then he runs into
- 49:12Andrew Scott right before they go up into No Man's Land.
- 49:15And then halfway through the movie they run across Mark
- 49:17Strong. And then at the end of the movie
- 49:19you get Benedict Cumberbatch. And I think that having those
- 49:23four people who are extremely recognizable people at this
- 49:26point show up throughout the film really took me out of it.
- 49:31I think the, the only one that didn't was Colin Firth, because
- 49:34it's the very beginning of the movie.
- 49:36So you, you know, you're just like, oh, there's Colin Firth,
- 49:38and now he's gone. You don't have the Matt Damon
- 49:40effect. No, you don't, man.
- 49:42And like especially I think Andrew Scott as the guy who's
- 49:46like F this like going to no man's land if you want to.
- 49:50He was just a little bit outside of like the comfort zone of like
- 49:57what Sam Mendes was directing. He he went a little too Moriarty
- 50:00for me. And it really pulled me out of
- 50:03that scene. And I just kind of wish that
- 50:05Mendez had gone with like everyone in this movie is an
- 50:08unknown or at best like a that guy and not a person that I know
- 50:12their full name. Yeah.
- 50:14And, and honestly, Mark Strong was that for me where I like,
- 50:19he's not a famous enough movie actor for me to be like, oh of
- 50:23course Mark Strong from these 7 movies.
- 50:27His voice was familiar and like powerful enough that I thought
- 50:33he was the best of the four known actors because he has so
- 50:39much compassion even as he is leading.
- 50:43I I thought he knocked it out of the park.
- 50:47Other than that, I felt like all of them overacted and we're like
- 50:51doing too much. Colin Firth was fine.
- 50:54I I agree that he benefits from being so early on that you
- 50:58don't. It's like, Oh yeah, a movie star
- 51:00in a movie. Wow.
- 51:02It's when you get to Benedict Cumberbatch that I'm like, OK,
- 51:06like there's a million no name actors that you could have put
- 51:10here saved a bunch of money and they could have gotten a little
- 51:13notoriety. Like like Benedict Cumbrash
- 51:16didn't need this role and the movie didn't need him in the
- 51:18role. OK, here's I was not intending
- 51:21to ask a question this spicy today.
- 51:24Are we entirely sure that Benedict Cumberbatch is like a
- 51:27great actor? And here's why I asked that the.
- 51:31Between 2 Ferns. Well, he didn't have a British
- 51:36accent. Would everybody realize that
- 51:38you're a terrible actor? He's so good in Sherlock, but I
- 51:41think that he has to be in a very outsized theatrical
- 51:45performance that calls attention to himself.
- 51:47Not that he has a an oversized acting style, but I just never
- 51:53feel like he's playing a believable human being.
- 51:57I think he'd be really good doing like Shakespeare, you know
- 52:00what I mean? But like.
- 52:02Yeah. Where you where where when you
- 52:04do like Hamlet or Macbeth nowadays, you're not just trying
- 52:08to embody the character of Halen or Macbeth.
- 52:10You're also like entering into this meta conversation of like
- 52:15actors doing Macbeth. And so you're like, wow, I'm
- 52:18watching something big right now.
- 52:20I think he'd be good at that. But when you put him in a role
- 52:22like this, it's like he's just kind of trying to do like the
- 52:25Benedict Cumberbatch a little bit too theatrical type
- 52:28performance. And I don't know that I've ever
- 52:31seen him in a movie where I've been like, wow, that is an
- 52:35incredible performance from Benedict Cumberbatch.
- 52:38Here's the thing though. I will come to Benedict's
- 52:42defense for this film specifically, Let's just, let's
- 52:45just imagine something. Bob, will you go with me
- 52:48somewhere in your imagination? Sure.
- 52:50Just imagine. Benedict is sitting down in the
- 52:54in the chair, getting his makeup put on.
- 52:57Costume design, all the things. And Sam is standing between him
- 53:01in the mirror and he's like, you know, all right, all right,
- 53:04Benedict, we're, we're going to take it easy.
- 53:06We're not going over the top. You're just going to be a a firm
- 53:10commander who wants to end the war.
- 53:12You really believe in what you're doing.
- 53:14You're disappointed by what you know Makai brings.
- 53:17You sound good, Ben. Just like, yeah, you got it,
- 53:20man. And then he walks away from the
- 53:22mirror and Benedict sees the final product and he has that
- 53:27giant, stupid scar across his eye.
- 53:32Tell me that you're not going to overact if they put the most
- 53:36obvious scar I've ever seen in a movie on your.
- 53:39Face. That's true.
- 53:41That's true. As soon as I saw that in the
- 53:43mirror, I'd be like, all right, I'm ready for this.
- 53:46Yeah, you can't put a scar on my face like that and expect me not
- 53:49to be like, just. Shoe scenery.
- 53:51Yeah, exactly. Thank you for joining me in
- 53:57Imagination Station. I appreciate that, man.
- 54:00Is there anybody else from the cast that you think is worth
- 54:02mentioning? I I feel like we've kind of
- 54:04knocked it out talking about the two leads here.
- 54:07Yeah, I mean, I don't know if anybody else has enough time,
- 54:11whoever they chose to sing that song in the middle of it.
- 54:15No idea who it is, but man, that dude could belt it.
- 54:19And that was like, truly, I think that's where this movie
- 54:23succeeds, Bob. It's in those a few small quiet
- 54:27moments where you just get to see Makai be broken and
- 54:31horrified and like the the juxtaposition of the horrors
- 54:38that he has seen humans do to each other with the beauty that
- 54:44humans can bring into the world with music like that.
- 54:47It's like moments like that is where this movie just is
- 54:51incredible. Yeah, I also love the idea of,
- 54:55you know, you don't find out anything about George Mckay's
- 54:57character. And there's a moment where he
- 54:59has to escape some Germans in this shelled out town.
- 55:03And he ducks into this, like, underground apartment basically
- 55:07that's been hollowed out as well.
- 55:09Runs into this French lady who's nursing a baby.
- 55:12And she asks him, like, do you have children?
- 55:15And he just doesn't answer her. And he continues babbling with
- 55:18the baby. At the very end of the movie, he
- 55:21finally is like in safety for a moment, finds himself another
- 55:25tree to sit down at, pulls out the picture of his children and
- 55:28his wife that just says like, come back to us on the back.
- 55:32And I'm your boy was overwhelmed with emotion.
- 55:35But I love the narrative decision to make this kind of
- 55:39like a closed loop circuit, right?
- 55:41Like it ends exactly where it started, implying that like 5
- 55:45minutes from now, after this guy's wakes up from his nap,
- 55:48he's right back into it again. And I think that's again, that's
- 55:51where the movie succeeds. Does it get a little bit on the
- 55:55nose sometimes with the like I'm going to tell the French baby
- 55:58the nursery rhyme about they went to see in a sieve, Like,
- 56:02Yep, does it get a little bit on the nose and singing the hymn
- 56:05about going over Jordan? Sure, why not?
- 56:07But like, I think at the end of the day, man, gimmick or no
- 56:10gimmick, this is a really powerful and affecting movie.
- 56:14It absolutely is. There is so many moments
- 56:19throughout this film that you just feel your emotions rise
- 56:23from the quiet moments that we just talked about to the
- 56:26trailer, him running down the front line as thousands of
- 56:32British troops are going across. What a stunning piece of
- 56:37filmmaking. Like, Makai is just getting
- 56:41trucked by these other dudes and he just keeps getting up and
- 56:45running. And the music has swollen and
- 56:48it's beautiful and there's explosions everywhere.
- 56:51Like how can you not watch that and not feel moved?
- 56:55100% there are two key moments for me in this movie that I just
- 56:59feel like our absolute knockout sequences.
- 57:02And that the one is that ending sequence because, you know,
- 57:05because of the suspense that's built throughout the movie.
- 57:10It really feels like almost like a four quarter game of football
- 57:13or basketball or whatever where it's like we just need one final
- 57:17push here and you're really on the edge of your seat waiting
- 57:20for that final moment. But the other one for me is, you
- 57:23know, he's gone to this shelled out French town and got grazed
- 57:27by a bullet, fell down a flight of stairs and blacks out.
- 57:30And it's the only time in the movie where there's an extended,
- 57:32you know, sequence of black or, or a cut.
- 57:35And then he wakes up. And as soon as he wakes up, that
- 57:37Thomas Newman score kicks in with almost like a xylophone, I
- 57:40think. And it's the score that follows
- 57:43him all through this escape from this town as the flares are
- 57:47going off. And that piece of music is just
- 57:51unbelievable, dude. It's so.
- 57:53Gorgeous. You know, this lost the Oscar
- 57:56for best score to the score from Joker, which is, you know, to
- 58:00me, an OK score, certainly distinct, but I thought this was
- 58:05like one of the best Thomas Newman scores I've ever heard.
- 58:07And I freaking love that centerpiece piece of music as
- 58:10well. Yeah, if you're just making it a
- 58:12competition between this and Joker, that's a joke, like.
- 58:16I, I mean, I feel like that's. Chance.
- 58:18That's what I say when anybody compares any movie to Joker.
- 58:21So, you know, it's not much of A competition to me, man.
- 58:26Oh, totally, dude. Yeah, the the music in this
- 58:29movie, Yeah, the composition is just beautiful.
- 58:33And it feels like a movie movie. Like the costuming is unreal and
- 58:38the cinematography is amazing. And the set design, like there's
- 58:42a combination of when they're first walking through the
- 58:44trenches and even when they get into like the empty German
- 58:47frontline and you can see like the wood that they've used to
- 58:50shore up the side of the trenches.
- 58:52And it's kind of like mildewy and wet.
- 58:55And like, the color of it is so incredible, the way Deacons has
- 58:58captured it. But then just like the way that
- 59:01they erected this French town that is half shelled out, it's
- 59:05just like this feels like a big production.
- 59:09And I think that's where a guy like Mendez doesn't get enough
- 59:12credit is, especially between this and Skyfall.
- 59:15Like you can see every dollar of the budget on screen.
- 59:21Easily it's a beautiful movie that like there are some issues
- 59:26with storytelling and some of the characters, but overall man,
- 59:31I like 1917 is easily one of the best movies of 2019 and that's
- 59:37in a stacked cast. All right, man, let's get into
- 59:40our last segment of the day, which we call.
- 59:42Let's make it a double. We're near the end of the
- 59:45episode, so thanks listening to the film and Whiskey show.
- 59:48Let's have another film with this one, even if it's
- 59:51struggling. It's the final segment of the
- 59:52day. Now let's make it a double.
- 59:54Let's Make It a Double is presented by Blackwood
- 59:56Distilling Company. It's the part of the show where
- 59:58we pick a movie to pair up with this one to make the perfect
- 1:00:01double feature. I think today, Brad, like what?
- 1:00:05I love to pair this with another one shot movie, sure, or another
- 1:00:08war movie. But the the one that stuck out
- 1:00:11to me went back to that scene with the cherry blossoms as a,
- 1:00:15you know, a metaphor for the grace and peace that is lost in
- 1:00:19the fog of war. And there's another movie that
- 1:00:21features cherry blossoms quite prominently, especially from the
- 1:00:25great Japanese actor Ken Watanabe, and that is the film
- 1:00:28The Last Samurai. I don't know if it's a movie
- 1:00:31that you've ever seen. I freaking loved that movie when
- 1:00:35I was growing up. How have we not watched that?
- 1:00:37I don't know. I love.
- 1:00:38I love that movie too. When, when he just says like,
- 1:00:42they're all perfect, like, oh, dude, so good.
- 1:00:46So yeah, I I'm gonna use the cherry blossom analogy and pair
- 1:00:49this up with The Last Samurai. I think that's a a great pick
- 1:00:55for our double feature. We should watch Last Samurai
- 1:00:58sometime dude. Yeah, we really should.
- 1:01:01Oh man, although I do do I remember correctly it's like 3
- 1:01:04hours long. Yeah, but it's three hours of
- 1:01:06Tom Cruise, your favorite human being.
- 1:01:09No, I, I yeah, I'm, I'm in. I'm already bought it.
- 1:01:12Don't oversell. I'm already bought it.
- 1:01:15I think I'm going to pair this with Paths of Glory.
- 1:01:19Oh good one, I. I, I think that both of them
- 1:01:21kind of highlight the human cost of war, the futility of the
- 1:01:30military brass thinking they know everything, that there just
- 1:01:34seems like there's a lot of good comparisons here.
- 1:01:36I know that Mendez used Paths of Glory in some of his, you know,
- 1:01:43lead up preparation to make 1917.
- 1:01:46So yeah, that that that's my pick.
- 1:01:49I mentioned this movie before on one podcast or another, Brad,
- 1:01:53but there's a great documentary that Peter Jackson did in the 20
- 1:01:57tens around this time called They Shall Not Grow Old, where
- 1:02:00he and his team took a bunch of old footage.
- 1:02:03And I think through AI, you know, restored it, upscaled it
- 1:02:08to 4K, colorized it, read the lips of the people in the
- 1:02:12footage, found people from the same areas of England to like
- 1:02:16over dub what they were saying. And it just becomes this
- 1:02:19historical document of like taking this old conflict of war
- 1:02:24and really bringing those people into the present.
- 1:02:27And I I was blown away by that documentary.
- 1:02:29Like I said, there's not enough World War One content anyway, so
- 1:02:34if you're curious to watch more World War One stuff, you could
- 1:02:36do a lot worse than checking out Paths of Glory and the
- 1:02:39documentary They Shall Not Grow Old.
- 1:02:42I have not gotten around to the those documentaries, it's like
- 1:02:47been on my list for a long time that I really want to watch
- 1:02:50them. Yeah, it's super good.
- 1:02:51You should check it out, man. Well, OK, those are our pairings
- 1:02:54for Let's Make It a Double like we said, presented by Blackwood
- 1:02:57Distilling Company. No matter what you choose to
- 1:03:00pair this movie up with, you can always make it a double with
- 1:03:04Blackwood. And if you go to
- 1:03:05bourbonoutfitter.com/film Whiskey and use our code Film
- 1:03:10Whiskey at checkout, you can save on your bottle of Blackwood
- 1:03:14as well. Brad, it's time to get into
- 1:03:16final scores here. For most of this film, I was at
- 1:03:20like an 8 1/2, maybe a nine. I do think that like, it is a
- 1:03:25handsomely mounted film that feels like it just falls short
- 1:03:28of greatness for most of the runtime.
- 1:03:31And then the ending happened and I was like, this solved every
- 1:03:35issue I had with this movie. I think I'm going to come all
- 1:03:38the way up to a 9.5 out of 10 on this one, Brad.
- 1:03:41Wow. Yeah, I, I'm kind of between an
- 1:03:468 1/2 and a nine. I I think originally I was at
- 1:03:50like an 8 out of 10 when I first saw it.
- 1:03:53I think I'll come up to a nine out of 10.
- 1:03:57I don't know if this is quite Yeah, it's it's just not quite
- 1:04:03at that level of perfection that you need to be at to hit that
- 1:04:09nine and a half 10 range. But there is so much to love
- 1:04:12about this movie. And I, I would agree with you.
- 1:04:14I I think it's a little bit ridiculous that the critics just
- 1:04:22don't like Sam Mendez. Like at the end of the day, sure
- 1:04:25some of their complaints might be accurate, but he makes
- 1:04:28incredible movies and in an era where it seems like the quality
- 1:04:37of filmmaking is going down, I can't see how they are not self
- 1:04:43defeating and destroying their own industry when they nitpick
- 1:04:46about movies like 1917. Yeah, man, I think you've
- 1:04:51summarized it perfectly. So it's a 9.25 out of 10 for us
- 1:04:55on average, but we'd like to know what you think.
- 1:04:58Did 1917 accomplish everything you thought it should?
- 1:05:02Are you with us on the over 9 scale or did it not quite click
- 1:05:05for you? You can let us know on any of
- 1:05:07our social media accounts, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram,
- 1:05:11Tiktok or YouTube Film Whiskey. Or if you'd like to, you can
- 1:05:17join the conversation on our Discord server where we are
- 1:05:20there every day talking about movies and whiskey and all sorts
- 1:05:23of other things. O If you'd like to join the
- 1:05:25conversation, you can find a link at the end of every single
- 1:05:28one of our show notes. We have but three episodes
- 1:05:31remaining on the season, Brad, and we're going to shift into
- 1:05:34animated film next week to check out one of my very favorites
- 1:05:38from this century, it's DreamWorks 2010 film How to
- 1:05:42Train Your Dragon. I'm excited to dive into that
- 1:05:45one with you, man. Yeah, super pumped, dude.
- 1:05:47It's going to be fun. All right, join us next week for
- 1:05:49that. But until then, I'm Bob Book.
- 1:05:52I'm Brad G. And we'll see you next time.
- 1:06:18Music.