Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA Changes Exam Frequency: Or Regulatory Theater?
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03I am flying solo today, and I'm going to be talking a
- 0:06little bit about NCUA's budget.
- 0:08Not much, because people actually aren't interested in that as much
- 0:11as the trade associations are.
- 0:14But the budget did have a couple of interesting topics, one of which I'm
- 0:18going to highlight in this podcast.
- 0:21And that is that they are changing or they are announcing that they
- 0:25are changing their policies on their examination cycle, which is something the
- 0:30trade groups have asked for some time.
- 0:33And specifically, they're going to make some changes to credit unions over
- 0:361 billion and less than 10 billion.
- 0:39There are roughly.
- 0:42420 some credit unions that fit into that category.
- 0:45And until recently, those credit unions were required to be examined annually
- 0:52and actually are right now because they have to finalize this, finalize it at
- 0:57their budget meeting in December, which is on Tuesday for a rare situation.
- 1:05It is on December 17th Tuesday, the N.
- 1:09C.
- 1:09A.
- 1:09Board meeting.
- 1:09So they will finalize their budget.
- 1:11And by the way, they announced these changes to the exam cycle
- 1:16in their public budget briefing.
- 1:19Sometimes they call it a hearing.
- 1:20It's technically a briefing because the federal credit union was accurate.
- 1:24Has changed to say that they needed to do a briefing, and it's a public briefing
- 1:29where, staff presents their budget, which has already been pre cleared
- 1:34by the board chairman and discuss it.
- 1:37And then they invite people to speak and trade groups come.
- 1:40America's credit unions came.
- 1:42The West Coast credit union came, the defense council credit union came.
- 1:48And I think there was another group that also came and gave presentations.
- 1:51They're speeches about the budget.
- 1:53Essentially, the budget's too high, costs should go down because mergers happen.
- 1:57That's essentially what the trade groups generally say.
- 2:00Now, in this instance, NCUA dropped something in there that, when I
- 2:04saw it, it caught my attention, going, wow, this might actually
- 2:06be some relief for credit unions.
- 2:08And I think I'm going to call this podcast, what's, either,
- 2:11What's the Sound of One Hand Clapping, or Regulatory Theater.
- 2:15Haven't decided which one I'll use, Because they both have a special
- 2:19ring to what actually happened here.
- 2:21So what did happen or what is about to happen?
- 2:24Let me get to those details.
- 2:27So NCUA.
- 2:29At the budget briefing did a PowerPoint and the PowerPoint has a slide that I
- 2:34will have on my blog story relative to this and I'll post it on LinkedIn as well.
- 2:42But they mentioned that they're going to make some changes to their exam cycle.
- 2:46Basically, if you're a code 3, a code 4, or a code 5 credit
- 2:49union, nothing changes NCUA.
- 2:52will do their exams.
- 2:54Their policy will be that they will do their exams in the same timelines.
- 2:57And that is for a code for code five.
- 3:00You're gonna have contacts every excuse me, you're gonna
- 3:02have contacts every 120 days.
- 3:04If you're code three every 180 days.
- 3:07And that's from measured from the close of the last exam to the
- 3:13start of the next exam now where the changes are being proposed.
- 3:17And because they've been proposed again, they're going to be made.
- 3:20They would not propose them if they were not going to do them.
- 3:23This is for all credit unions between a billion.
- 3:27And 10 billion, if you're over, if you're over 10 billion, you're
- 3:32going to get an examination that starts between 8 and 12 months.
- 3:35And that's the too big to fail theory, right?
- 3:38Credit unions of that size would impact the insurance fund so
- 3:42dramatically that NCUA needs to be in there once every calendar year.
- 3:46Now they don't have to finish the exam every calendar year, which is what
- 3:49it was required long ago, back before Rick Metzger as NCUA Board Chairman
- 3:55made some changes that allowed it to be measured based on start date.
- 3:59But where the theoretically big meat of the change is in
- 4:03credit unions between a billion.
- 4:05And 10 billion.
- 4:06And currently, those credit unions are in that same category.
- 4:10They need to have exams done between an 8 and 12 month period.
- 4:14Under the proposal, if you're in that category, 1 billion to 10 billion, and
- 4:21you are a CAMEL credit union of a code 1 or 2, and when I say CAMEL, CAMELs,
- 4:27Camel credit union of one or two.
- 4:28That means the C.
- 4:29A.
- 4:30M.
- 4:30E.
- 4:30L.
- 4:31And S.
- 4:31All have to be a one or two.
- 4:33So if you have a three in any of those categories, say earnings or
- 4:37liquidity or sensitivity, you're going to be under the 8 to 12 month cycle.
- 4:42Every component must be a one or two.
- 4:46And then also they need to have had the same CEO that
- 4:50was in place in the last exam.
- 4:52So if your exam your file, not a follow up exam, your full exam.
- 4:55I'm taking this to me.
- 4:57Your code 10 exam as NCUA would call it in their systems.
- 5:01If that was as of June of last year, and the same CEO is there and at that contact,
- 5:09that examination contact, everything was a 1 or a 2, you are eligible to instead
- 5:15of having an 8 to 12 month cycle, you're going to have a 12 to 16 month cycle.
- 5:21And then credit unions below a billion, they're actually
- 5:24going the other direction.
- 5:25They're taking away a little bit of, a little bit of relief.
- 5:29Under the current policy, those credit unions have a cycle of 14
- 5:34to 20 months, and they're proposing changing that to 14 to 18 months.
- 5:39So they trimmed two months off there.
- 5:41They added four months on those well run credit unions for the lack of a
- 5:46better term where they, that are between the 1 billion and the 10 billion.
- 5:51They actually then went on to say that there are exam hour savings.
- 5:58Of doing this of 21, 000 hours.
- 6:02I think that's the number.
- 6:03Yes.
- 6:0421, 000 hours in a year of examination time saved.
- 6:09Now I'm going to explain why that's wrong based on the other
- 6:14information that they talk about.
- 6:16And based on the role I used to have at N.
- 6:19C.
- 6:19U.
- 6:19A.
- 6:20where I would participate in these budgets coming up.
- 6:23And then the budget's being approved.
- 6:25But N.
- 6:26C.
- 6:27U.
- 6:27A.
- 6:27In the explanation talks about the fact that there are 10
- 6:30examiner positions from the field.
- 6:33Those would be the regions that are going away.
- 6:35And essentially, it's 9 examiners and 1 supervisory examiner.
- 6:39You could argue that supervisory examiner isn't productive time and it's not in
- 6:43the way that they do math, but it's easier to track to their erroneous
- 6:47number if you include it in the math.
- 6:49So they mentioned 10 examiner positions going away.
- 6:54To figure out how they got to that 21, 000 hours.
- 6:58You take those 10 examiners times 52 weeks times 40 hours a week.
- 7:03And so any one person, if they work 52 weeks, they will have 52
- 7:09times 40 hours is 2080 hours per full time equivalent per person.
- 7:15So 2080 times 10 is 20, 800 hours.
- 7:21So they rounded up when they gave the soundbite to 21, 000 hours.
- 7:25But those are not all exam hours.
- 7:27So what happens is NCUA, essentially, when they budget, unless they've changed this,
- 7:33and if they've changed it, they've changed it to make their individual employee
- 7:39less productive in their assumptions, as opposed to more productive, because
- 7:43they're always adding things that are non productive hours, like going to
- 7:47DEI events, going to training events.
- 7:50But I digress, and What happens is the NCUA books every hour that an examiner
- 7:56does, and they book it to your credit union, or they book it to annual leave, or
- 8:01they book it to sick leave, or they book it to training, or they book it to office
- 8:06time, or they book it to a training event for the software skills that they have
- 8:11in place, like the DEI that I mentioned, but when you get to the end of all that
- 8:16math, Each examiner only contributes about 1, 000 hours of exam time.
- 8:22In some years, it might be 1, 020.
- 8:23In some years, it might be 9, 950, but that's what they budget to.
- 8:27And remember, this is what we're talking about.
- 8:29We're talking about their budget.
- 8:32So I did a little bit of math.
- 8:33And if you take.
- 8:36If you take what they talked about there and you look at those credit
- 8:42unions, so there's roughly 420 credit unions that fall into that category.
- 8:46So first you adjust, it's not 20, 000 hours, as I mentioned.
- 8:50It's about 10, 000.
- 8:52But if you take a look at how many credit unions fall into that category,
- 8:56remember that I've talked about here frequently how NCUA has been showing
- 9:03that code three, fours and five exams are going those credit unions coded
- 9:07three, fours and fives are going up.
- 9:09And the last time they measured it was in September, and they basically said
- 9:14roughly 10 percent of all deposits.
- 9:17Are in 10 percent of all deposits are in code three, fours and fives.
- 9:21We want to deduct from those 420 some odd credit unions, 10 percent of the credit
- 9:27unions, but there are also credit unions that we need to deduct that might have
- 9:31a code 3 in any 1 of those categories, C, A, M, L, E, or S, or a 4, right?
- 9:37Or maybe even they have 2 3s, but they're still coded an overall 2.
- 9:41Those credit unions need to come out of the pool that might have expanded hours
- 9:46and, oh, by the way you need to take out credit unions that have a new CEO and
- 9:51there's just turnover, people retire, people get fired people get demoted
- 9:55mergers happen, et cetera, et cetera.
- 9:57The reality is when you start with that 420 and just for rough justice I'm
- 10:02going to deduct 20 percent of those 420.
- 10:05So you get down to After doing that math, you get down to about 336 credit unions
- 10:10that in any 1 year would be eligible for an examination that would not be required
- 10:18to be done in that 12 month period.
- 10:19And it would be under the new 12 to 16.
- 10:22Category.
- 10:23So if you take 10, 000 hours and divide it by 336, that's 29.
- 10:2776 hours.
- 10:30I don't like using the decimal points that long because these are, there's
- 10:33a lot of assumptions in these numbers, other than the fact that there's
- 10:36only 1000 hours of productive time.
- 10:39But some of these numbers are known and some of these numbers are unknown, but.
- 10:4230 hours of productive time, if they're only getting 20 hours a week out of that's
- 10:47roughly an examiner for a week and a half.
- 10:49But, nobody's average, right?
- 10:51Some credit unions are still going to get examined within 12 months,
- 10:54and that might be because the examiner's in the same town as you.
- 10:57That happens.
- 10:58The reality is, if they will have in town work, they want to have in town work.
- 11:01It's nuanced a little bit because of off site work that NCUA does.
- 11:05But theoretically, the exam for some credit unions could sneak or change from
- 11:12a 12 month cycle to a 16 month cycle.
- 11:15Now, that assumes that this was an actual change that was be putting in place
- 11:19because in the reality of all this, I don't think that's what's happening.
- 11:23This is more like the airline industry.
- 11:28Notoriously being late, having flights come late and the
- 11:33statistics would be reported that this airline was only on time.
- 11:36This percentage and this airline was only online on time.
- 11:39That that percentage and with a stroke of a pen, those credit those airlines.
- 11:46we're flying far more timely.
- 11:47How did they do that?
- 11:48They padded their numbers.
- 11:50They added about 30 minutes to every flight so that, of course, everybody
- 11:55was on time because we're now saying that being on late is being on time
- 11:59and they build it into the budget.
- 12:01And I believe that's exactly what's happening here at N.
- 12:04C.
- 12:04U.
- 12:04A.
- 12:05And the math proves it, and their own words prove it, because, and I've
- 12:10mentioned it here I've mentioned it in client conversations, credit union
- 12:13conversations, I've mentioned it here on several podcasts, but last January,
- 12:19NCUA approved their operating plan, and that operating plan has goals in it.
- 12:27And board member Kyle Hauptman, who, by the way, will likely become NCUA
- 12:31board chairman in January with a stroke of a pen, another stroke of
- 12:34a pen when Trump does that and makes other changes, but NCUA in January of
- 12:402024 approved their operating plan.
- 12:44And in that discussion, board member Hauptman, said that he was disappointed
- 12:50that they were only doing their code fours on time, which was the 120 days
- 12:56I mentioned 80 percent of the time.
- 12:57So One out of every five code fours wasn't being done timely.
- 13:02And they also mentioned that their code threes were not being done timely.
- 13:06And only 67 percent of the code threes were being done timely, meaning one
- 13:11out of every three wasn't done timely.
- 13:13So if code fours, which are the most risk to the fund, we're only done on time,
- 13:1780 percent and code threes, which are the next biggest category of of risk.
- 13:24And by the way, I'm skipping fives because no one's ever a five, but By
- 13:27the time they code you a five, they take you over, they liquidate you.
- 13:30So fives really don't happen.
- 13:32So fours are the worst, threes are the second, second worst, and those were only
- 13:36completed 67 percent of the time, on time.
- 13:41So what do you think?
- 13:42You think code ones and twos are magically all done on time right now?
- 13:46No, because they're going to do the ones on time that have the most risk, meaning
- 13:51that code ones and code twos have already slipped, meaning that this chain that
- 13:56changed that NC way, in my opinion, Is proposing and will make is only going
- 14:01to change the policy so that it matches what is actually happening, which is how
- 14:07I get to this being regulatory theater.
- 14:10Now it's great soundbites because they can tell almost said CUNA.
- 14:14They can tell America's credit unions.
- 14:15They can tell the trade groups, look, we listen, we're changing our policy.
- 14:19The reality is the practice was that was what they were doing.
- 14:22They can't get their exams done on time and they're changing their policy
- 14:26so that they're consistent with that.
- 14:29But the slap to the regions is and we're taking 10 bodies away.
- 14:33So those people are going to go away, which means they're going to
- 14:35still have challenges coming up and meeting these times, which means
- 14:38there will be a continued elongation because they just don't have the staff
- 14:43and they're not efficient enough.
- 14:45They don't have the experience examiners enough, in my opinion, to
- 14:48get some of these examinations done.
- 14:50So that's.
- 14:51In my mind, the reality of what's happening, and by
- 14:53the way, it's very similar.
- 14:55I gave the airline industry.
- 14:56It's very similar to a credit union.
- 14:58Have a having a concentration risk policy and then hitting, let's say it's X percent
- 15:04of net worth will only be 300 percent of net worth will only be in commercial
- 15:08lending and you're at 275 and you're at 295 and then you get some really good
- 15:13loan opportunities and you go to 315 and you realize you went over your policy.
- 15:17And then you take it to the board and you change it.
- 15:20NCUA will criticize you if you do that.
- 15:23They will give you document resolutions if you do that.
- 15:26And oh, by the way I think they just did that for their exonic phone exam cycle.
- 15:30So again, bring it in line with what the reality is.
- 15:33Now that's pretty much all I want to chat about relative
- 15:37to the budget in this podcast.
- 15:38There are a couple other topics I may hit it.
- 15:41I will at least hit in a blog.
- 15:43They made some changes with some other positions that they're adding and
- 15:46oh, by the way, those positions are like an office of the secretary and
- 15:51behind the scenes types positions as opposed to mission critical positions,
- 15:56which are the examiner positions there they're taking from those positions.
- 16:00Positions and they're putting them into the central office and positions
- 16:04that have 0 percent productivity.
- 16:06And I don't say they don't get things done that are productive for the
- 16:10good of the credit union movement.
- 16:12What I'm saying is they are not productive as it relates specifically to exam work.
- 16:18So they took bodies and budget from that category.
- 16:23And that is contributing to exams and they moved them over those 10
- 16:29plus 4 others that they're adding for example, they're adding a position
- 16:34on climate and oh, by the way, I would suspect that once Kyle Houtman.
- 16:39Takes over that climate position doesn't ever get filled, even though it will be in
- 16:42the buzz it because the chairman will make sure, in my opinion, that doesn't happen.
- 16:47That's how these things work when there's a change of presidents.
- 16:50Elections have consequences.
- 16:52That's it in a nutshell.
- 16:53I hope you had a wonderful Thanksgiving, and I'll have a little bit more coming
- 16:58on some of these topics, depending on what happens at the actual budget
- 17:02hearing when they approve it skewing at the budget hearing the budget.
- 17:06Approval by the board.
- 17:08on December 17th.
- 17:10But what happens is most for the most part, most of
- 17:15these numbers are all cooked.
- 17:16If they present it, they may know that they have a little fat here
- 17:19and a little fat there, and they might make a tweak to it to show
- 17:22that they listen to the industry.
- 17:24And I expect that the budget will be mostly approved as already presented
- 17:30that these changes will occur, but all they are is the reality
- 17:36is that this is what's happening.
- 17:37So they might as well spin it and get a little bit of credit while they're
- 17:41stealing some bodies from productive time and putting it over an unproductive time.
- 17:46And as Van Morrison once said, that's what's the sound of one hand clapping?
- 17:51That's a little bit what we have here on this cycle.
- 17:53So It at first appeared like it was an exciting change and the reality
- 17:58is it's not much of anything as far as relief goes for credit unions.
- 18:03All right, that's it.
- 18:04This is Mark Treichel signing off with Flying Colors.