Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Compact Electric : Lynk & Co 02 vs. BYD Atto 2
Transcript
- 0:10Welcome back to the Deep Dive. It is great to have you here
- 0:12with us. Today.
- 0:14We are looking at something that it feels a bit like a shift in
- 0:19the tectonic plates of the Automotive World.
- 0:21It really does you. Know for years, whenever we
- 0:23talked about the Chinese invasion of the European car
- 0:25market, the narrative was always the same.
- 0:28Right. It was always about price.
- 0:30The headline was always cheap and cheerful.
- 0:33You know, the idea was that these cars were just coming to
- 0:36undercut the legacy brands. Exactly.
- 0:38Just budget options for people who needed four wheels and a
- 0:41steering wheel and that. Was it?
- 0:43But today we're looking at two cars that prove that era is
- 0:47well, it's already evolving into something much more complex.
- 0:50Oh, absolutely. It's not just about being cheap
- 0:52anymore. It's about divergent
- 0:54philosophies. We are putting 2 compact Chinese
- 0:58SUV's head to head the BYG at O2 and the Lincoln Co O2 and.
- 1:03What makes this so fascinating is that on paper they look like
- 1:06direct rivals. I mean same size, both electric
- 1:09SUV's, both from these massive Chinese parent companies.
- 1:12They're not really rivals at all, are they?
- 1:13Not in philosophy, no. When you peel back the layers,
- 1:17and we have a lot of layers to peel back today, they are trying
- 1:20to do 2 completely different things.
- 1:23We've sort of dubbed this battle the pragmatist versus the
- 1:26stylist, A. Good way.
- 1:27To put it so, our mission today is simple.
- 1:30We're not just going to read spec sheets to you.
- 1:31We want to help you figure out which one of these fits your
- 1:34life. Right.
- 1:35Are you the urban potterer who just needs to get the groceries?
- 1:38Or are you the long distance cruiser who wants a bit of flair
- 1:42and fun on the open Rd. It's a battle of logic versus
- 1:45emotion in a way, and despite all the technical specs, we're
- 1:48going to keep this simple. We want to get to the heart of
- 1:50what it's actually like to live with these cars.
- 1:53On a Tuesday morning in the rain, that's the real test.
- 1:56Exactly. So let's unpack the first
- 1:58contender, the pragmatist, the BYD at O2.
- 2:03T at O2 now BYD stands for Build Your Dreams which is a a lovely
- 2:07sentiment but they are a battery giant first and a car company
- 2:112nd. And that context is really
- 2:14important, isn't it? It's crucial their approach to
- 2:16building cars is very, well, industrial.
- 2:20The sources have a unique way of describing the vibe of this car.
- 2:251 review called it generic. Huh.
- 2:27Yes, anonymously handsome was another one I saw.
- 2:30Which is a polite way of saying it's a bit bland.
- 2:32It is a bit safe design wise. If you look at their other cars
- 2:36like the BYD seal, those have a lot of distinct personality.
- 2:40The add O2 is just. It's restrained, it's
- 2:44functional, it blends in. There was this analogy in one of
- 2:47the reviews that just made me laugh out loud.
- 2:49They compared the Atto 2 to buying a clever all in one
- 2:52coffee table from Timu. That is a brutal, but I have to
- 2:56say an incredibly accurate analogy, right?
- 2:59It does the job perfectly. It has storage, it looks decent
- 3:02in the pictures and the price is amazing.
- 3:04But the fit and finish maybe isn't quite up to IKEA
- 3:07standards, let alone a designer furniture store.
- 3:09Exactly. It's practical, but it's not
- 3:11premium. And that Timu feeling, it
- 3:13extends to the driving philosophy.
- 3:15Yeah. This car is designed explicitly
- 3:18as urban furniture. Urban.
- 3:19Furniture. I like that.
- 3:20It is meant for the city. It's not trying to be a sports
- 3:23car, it's trying to be a comfortable shuttle.
- 3:25So if I'm just pottering around town, popping to the shops,
- 3:28doing the school run, this is my car.
- 3:31Ideally, yes, the suspension is tuned to be very, very soft.
- 3:35We call it compliant in the industry.
- 3:37OK? So if you're hitting speed
- 3:39bumps, potholes, all those terrible broken city streets, it
- 3:42just soaks it all up. It's like driving on a
- 3:45marshmallow. A little bit, yeah.
- 3:47And the steering is incredibly light.
- 3:49You can spin the wheel with one finger while parking.
- 3:52Plus you sit quite high up so visibility is excellent.
- 3:55So a stress free environment. As long as you aren't trying to
- 3:58drive it aggressively, yes. And we have to the party trick.
- 4:01It wouldn't be a BYD without the screen.
- 4:04The famous rotating screen. Yes, a 12.9 inch infotainment
- 4:08screen that rotates from landscape to portrait at the
- 4:11touch of a button. Is this actually useful or is it
- 4:14just a gimmick? No, it's genuinely useful.
- 4:16Think about navigation apps like Google Maps or Waze.
- 4:19They just work better in portrait mode.
- 4:20Right, you want to see the road ahead.
- 4:22Exactly. Not the fields to the left and
- 4:24right. So having that vertical
- 4:25orientation is actually great for mapping.
- 4:28But it's also a bit of misdirection, isn't?
- 4:30It it is. It's the centerpiece that
- 4:32distracts you from the otherwise slightly plain interior.
- 4:36It screams high tech even if the plastics on the door are a bit
- 4:40scratchy. OK, so that's the add O2, the
- 4:42comfortable, budget friendly urban appliance.
- 4:46Now let's put it to the other side of the ring.
- 4:48The Stylist The Lincoln Co AO2. Now this is a different beast
- 4:52entirely if the BYD is the sensible, comfortable shoe.
- 4:56The Lincoln Co O2 is the trendy limited edition sneaker.
- 4:59Exactly. It's described as bold, quirky
- 5:02and youthful, and looking at it, it definitely has an attitude.
- 5:06But there's a family secret here, isn't there?
- 5:08Or maybe not a secret, but a connection people might not
- 5:11know. It's crucial context.
- 5:13Lincoln Toe is owned by Geely, and Geely is the same massive
- 5:16company that owns Volvo. OK, so underneath all that funky
- 5:19bodywork, this car is sitting on the same platform, the same
- 5:22skeleton as the Volvo EX30. So it's basically a Volvo and a
- 5:26Halloween costume. In a way, yeah, but a very nice
- 5:28costume. The sources actually describe it
- 5:30as a bigger, better looking Volvo EX30.
- 5:34That's high praise. It shares that premium DNA that
- 5:37focus on safety and solid engineering, but it's packaged
- 5:41in a way that is much more aggressive and tech forward.
- 5:45And Speaking of tech forward, the interior sounds wild.
- 5:49Let's talk about the steering wheel, or as the reviews called
- 5:52it, the squirkle. The squirkle.
- 5:54It's an Oval shaped steering wheel.
- 5:55It's not round. And instead of buttons or scroll
- 5:58wheels, it has joysticks. Yes, 2 little joysticks exactly
- 6:03like a PlayStation controller. You use them to navigate the
- 6:06menus or change the volume. That is a very bold choice.
- 6:10I can see people either loving that or hating.
- 6:12It no in between on that one. But here's the feature that
- 6:14really got me The selfie camera. Yes.
- 6:17There is a built in camera in the rearview mirror assembly
- 6:20that faces the passengers so you can take high def photos of
- 6:23yourself and your friends while you're driving because.
- 6:26If I'm not posting about my drive, did it even happen?
- 6:28Precisely. It's all about capturing the
- 6:30moment, and it ties into the sharing strap the.
- 6:32Sharing strap? What on earth is that?
- 6:35It's a physical pull strap, kind of like on a backpack near the
- 6:38steering wheel. You pull it and it activates the
- 6:41car's sharing mode on the screen.
- 6:43What's sharing mode? The whole idea is that Lincoln
- 6:46Co cars are designed to be shared.
- 6:48You can rent your car out to other people through their app
- 6:51when you aren't using it. That is fascinating.
- 6:54And even if you never use that feature, having a physical strap
- 6:58for it is a massive statement. It says I am part of the sharing
- 7:01economy, I am flexible, I am modern.
- 7:04It's lifestyle marketing engineered right into the
- 7:06dashboard. 100%. And then there's the front.
- 7:09The front trunk. Right, most TV's use that space
- 7:12for cables, but the Lincoln Co has a hidden message in there.
- 7:15It does. When you open the plastic cover
- 7:17there is text stamped into it that says Nope, no engine here.
- 7:21I love that a bit of cheeky humor.
- 7:22It shows they're having fun with it.
- 7:24So it's got the looks, it's got the quirks, but does it have the
- 7:28muscle? It definitely has the muscle.
- 7:30Remember, the BYD is front wheel drive with about 200 horsepower.
- 7:34The Lincoln Co is rear wheel drive, which is already
- 7:37sportier, and it packs 272 horsepower.
- 7:41Whoa, that's a big jump. It is.
- 7:44It does zero to 100 kilometers per hour in 5.5 seconds.
- 7:49The BYD takes nearly eight. In the electric car world, 5.5
- 7:54seconds is properly quick. That is a significant difference
- 7:58in zip. So the BYD is for getting to
- 8:00bingo and the Lincoln Co is for getting away from the police.
- 8:04Or just merging onto the highway with absolute confidence.
- 8:07Which brings us to the critical differences, because they behave
- 8:10very, very differently once you leave the city limits.
- 8:13OK, let's talk about the highway.
- 8:14This seems to be the deal breaker section of the.
- 8:16Sources. It really is.
- 8:17If you do a lot of motorway driving you need to listen
- 8:20closely here. The BYD at O2.
- 8:23It struggles at speed. Struggles how?
- 8:26Remember that soft suspension we praised for city potholes?
- 8:29Well, physics is cruel. Uh oh.
- 8:32That softness becomes a liability at 70 mph.
- 8:35The reviews describe it as wobbly and jittery.
- 8:38Oh I hate that feeling like the car is just floating.
- 8:40Exactly, it rocks side to side in the lane, it doesn't feel
- 8:42settled. The steering is described as
- 8:44darty so it's twitchy. You're constantly making these
- 8:47micro corrections just to keep it going straight.
- 8:50That sounds exhausting. It is, and there is noticeable
- 8:53wind noise. It's just not a relaxing place
- 8:55to be for three hours. And the link can go.
- 8:58It feels planted. That's the Volvo DNA kicking in.
- 9:01It's heavier, it's rear wheel drive and the suspension is
- 9:05firmer. It handles curves and lane
- 9:07changes with authority. Is there a downside to that?
- 9:10Firmness there is. On bad roads at low speeds, the
- 9:13link can feel a bit bumpy. It doesn't glide over speed
- 9:16bumps as softly as the BYD. It informs you about the road
- 9:20surface rather than hiding it from you.
- 9:22So comfort versus control, that's a classic trade off.
- 9:25But there's another huge factor for Rd. trips, isn't there?
- 9:28Charging speed. This is where the gap widens
- 9:30significantly. If you are Rd. tripping, the
- 9:33Lincoln Co is the clear winner, no contest.
- 9:36Give me the numbers. The Lincoln Co charges at a peak
- 9:38of 150 kilowatts. The BYD tops out around what, 88
- 9:43kilowatts? Translate that to real life for
- 9:45me. We're standing in a service
- 9:46station car park. It's raining.
- 9:47We want coffee. In the Lincoln Co, you can add
- 9:49200 kilometers of range in about 20 minutes.
- 9:52That is just enough time. Time to run in, use the
- 9:55bathroom, grab a coffee and stretch your legs.
- 9:58By the time you get back, the car is ready.
- 10:00And the BYD. For a similar 10 to 80% charge,
- 10:03you are looking at nearly 40 minutes.
- 10:06That extra 20 minutes feels like an eternity when you just want
- 10:09to get home. It does.
- 10:10It changes the psychology of the trip.
- 10:13With the link, the stop is a pause.
- 10:15With the BYD, the stop is an event.
- 10:18So the link buys you time, but what about space?
- 10:22I'm imagining the BYD being the furniture car might win on
- 10:26practicality. You would be right.
- 10:28The BYD packages its interior better for passengers because of
- 10:32their specialized battery platform.
- 10:34The floor in the back is completely flat.
- 10:36That's a big deal. It is if you have to squeeze
- 10:38three adults in the back. The person in the middle doesn't
- 10:40have a hump to straddle. In the boot space, the trunk.
- 10:43The BYD has a slightly larger boot, 450 liters versus 410 in
- 10:48the link, and it's a more useful boxy shape.
- 10:51If you're playing Tetris with suitcases, the BYD is easier.
- 10:54But the link has the frunk. It does a tiny 15 liter frunk,
- 10:58but it's perfect for storing a wet charging cable so it doesn't
- 11:01muck up your luggage. Which is a really smart touch.
- 11:04The BYD has no front storage at all.
- 11:06None. OK, here's a curveball.
- 11:08What if I want to tow a trailer? Then the conversation ends right
- 11:11here. You buy the Lincoln Co.
- 11:13Really. Is it that different?
- 11:15Massive difference. The Lincoln Co is rated to tow
- 11:181600 kilograms. That is a lot for a car this
- 11:23size. Enough for a decent trailer.
- 11:25The BYD? It's very, very limited.
- 11:28It's barely enough for a bike. Rack.
- 11:29So it's not designed for that kind of utilitarian life, not at
- 11:32all. Got it.
- 11:33Now, before we get to the price, there is one thing that
- 11:36apparently unites these two cars.
- 11:38Not in the good way, the bongs. Yes, the soundtrack of modern
- 11:43driving. The sources were so frustrated
- 11:44with this. Both cars suffer from
- 11:46oversensitive 8A's. The driver assistance systems,
- 11:49yeah. This is partly due to new EU
- 11:51regulations that mandate certain warnings, but the implementation
- 11:54here seems. Lacking.
- 11:55We're talking about speed limit warnings.
- 11:57Yes, if you go 1 kilometer per hour over the limit, it beeps.
- 12:02But it's more than that, it's the driver.
- 12:04Attention monitors. The Spy and the Dash.
- 12:06Basically, there's a camera watching you.
- 12:09If you look at the GPS screen for just two seconds to check
- 12:12your turn, the car bongs at you and flashes.
- 12:16Please concentrate. Oh wow, that's infuriating.
- 12:19It's like driving with a nagging backseat driver built into the
- 12:22car. Exactly, and here is the UX fail
- 12:26for the Lincoln Co in the BYD. You can turn it off relatively
- 12:29easily. In the link it is described as
- 12:31infernally annoying because you have to dive into sub menus on
- 12:34the touch screen every single time you start the car to turn
- 12:37them off. Doesn't save your preference.
- 12:38Nope. Reset.
- 12:39That's every single ride. That would drive me insane.
- 12:42It creates friction. You have this cool tech forward
- 12:45car but the first 30 seconds of every drive is you just angrily
- 12:48tapping at a screen to make it shut up.
- 12:50It just shows that software is just as important as hardware
- 12:53these days. Absolutely.
- 12:54OK, let's talk money. We established that BYD is the
- 12:57budget option, but how big is the gap?
- 12:59The BYD at O2 is aggressive on price.
- 13:03It starts around £27,000 to £29,000 for an electric SUV that
- 13:08is the budget king. And the link.
- 13:10It's positioning itself as premium.
- 13:12You're looking at 31,000 to 35,000 lbs, so you are paying a
- 13:16few thousand more. For that extra money, you're
- 13:18getting the horsepower, the faster charging, the towing, and
- 13:21the cool design. And the Volvo safety
- 13:23architecture underneath. But there is a twist in the
- 13:26value proposition, the warranty. OK, BYD wins this.
- 13:31BYD offers a six year warranty compared to Lincoln Co's five
- 13:35year. For that pragmatic buyer, that
- 13:37extra year of Peace of Mind is valuable.
- 13:39So let's try to land this plane. Who buys what?
- 13:42Let's keep it simple. If you live in the city, if you
- 13:44want a stress free appliance to get from A to B, if you value
- 13:47rear seat passenger space, and honestly if you just want to
- 13:50save money, choose the BYD at O2.
- 13:53It's the rational choice, the comfortable pair of sweatpants.
- 13:55Exactly. But if you care about driving
- 13:57dynamics, if you actually enjoy the active driving, or if you
- 14:00take Rd. trips and need that fast charging, or if you need to
- 14:03tow. Then you had to stretch for the
- 14:05Lincoln Co O2. You do.
- 14:07It's the leather jacket. It's a car with personality, and
- 14:10sometimes personality costs a little extra.
- 14:13You know what's fascinating to me?
- 14:15And here's where it gets really interesting for the broader
- 14:17market is that we used to lump all Chinese cars into one
- 14:21bucket, right? Chip and electric, that was the
- 14:24label. But looking at these two, we're
- 14:27seeing them diverge into very specific niches.
- 14:30BYD is taking the utility lane. Lincoln Co is taking the
- 14:33lifestyle lane. That's the key take away.
- 14:36They aren't just competing on price anymore, they're competing
- 14:38on identity. They are building brands that
- 14:41mean different things to different people.
- 14:43And that raises A provocative thought for me.
- 14:46If Chinese manufacturers are now specialized enough to offer a
- 14:49dedicated budget option and dedicated tech premium option,
- 14:54are the legacy European brands ready to fight a war on 2 fronts
- 14:58simultaneously? That is the billion dollar
- 15:00question. It's one thing to compete with a
- 15:02cheap car. You can argue quality, but it's
- 15:04another thing entirely to compete with a cheap car on one
- 15:07side and a cooler, faster car on the other.
- 15:09A pincer movement. Exactly.
- 15:11It squeezes the middle of the market.
- 15:13Well, that is a lot to think about next time you're stuck in
- 15:16traffic next to a car with a name you can't quite pronounce
- 15:19yet. Indeed.
- 15:20Before we sign off, I just want to take a moment to do something
- 15:23we probably probably don't do often enough.
- 15:26We know your time is the most valuable thing you have.
- 15:30There are 1,000,000 podcasts, a billion videos, all fighting for
- 15:34your attention. Absolutely.
- 15:36The fact that you chose to spend this time with us today diving
- 15:39into the nuances of suspension and charging speeds, it really
- 15:43does mean a lot. We seriously appreciate you
- 15:45tuning in, listening to our ramblings, and hopefully
- 15:49learning something new along the way.
- 15:50You are the reason we keep digging through these spic
- 15:53sheets and reading these reviews.
- 15:54So thank you for lending us your ears.
- 15:56It is a privilege. Stay curious, stay charged, and
- 15:59we'll catch you on the next deep dive.
- 16:01Goodbye, goodbye.