Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Navigating the Future: Insights into Higher Education and Engineering
Transcript
- 0:05Good morning. Thank you for joining another episode of the Engineering Influence
- 0:08podcast from the American Council of Engineering Companies.
- 0:11My name is Diana O'Lear, and I am the Director of Market Intelligence here at ACEC National.
- 0:16Today, I am joined by Mike Moss, President at the Society of College and University
- 0:21Planning in Ann Arbor, Michigan.
- 0:23Mikey, thank you so much for joining me today. Of course. Thank you for having us.
- 0:28Absolutely. So just a little bit about Mike here. You know, as President at
- 0:32SCUP, Mike primarily is responsible for working with the board of directors
- 0:36on the alignment and execution of the society's strategic plan.
- 0:40In collaboration with the members of the SCUP Council, he works to create an
- 0:44environment where members from all planning types can come together to,
- 0:47you know, really share experiences and solve their stickiest challenges together.
- 0:51He has experience with nonprofits and other state and international associations
- 0:56since about 92, taking him across North and South America, Europe, and Asia.
- 1:01Maul starts his day reading blogs, listening to podcasts, catching up on the
- 1:04news, and listening to Metallica.
- 1:06An avid gardener, he enjoys spending time outdoors with his wife and son.
- 1:10So before we get started, I have to ask, Metallica?
- 1:14All day, every day. Absolutely. It's a thing. So we prepared ourselves this
- 1:19morning accordingly for our conversation. So yeah.
- 1:23Awesome. I'll have to give it a listen. So let's get into the higher education
- 1:27market because that's why we're here today. So can you tell us more about SCUP
- 1:30for those that are not aware of your organization and what your mission is?
- 1:36Certainly. So we are a professional association. So we're individuals, not institutions.
- 1:40And we also have, in addition to colleges, universities, we do have a corporate presence as well.
- 1:45So our mission is that we are a learning centric association focused on a community
- 1:50of practice for integrated planning.
- 1:51What that essentially means is that we take all departments.
- 1:54So we're a horizontal association, not a vertical discipline.
- 1:57So anybody involved in planning for their institution at any level is encouraged
- 2:02and welcome to be a member of the organization.
- 2:04And in terms of that institutional to corporate breakdown, 43% of our members
- 2:08are corporate, primarily in
- 2:10the design, build, construction fields for the physical campus planning.
- 2:14And now, when I used to work for engineering firms, SCUP was an association
- 2:19that we went to your event.
- 2:21Because if you're in business development or marketing and your engineering
- 2:25firm is doing work in the higher education,
- 2:28you know, universities and colleges, you want to go to the SCUP event because
- 2:32that's where you're going to get ideal networking and exposure to some potential clients.
- 2:36So I know we didn't plan for this, but when is your next event so we can let
- 2:40our members know if they want to join?
- 2:42Oh, that's great. That's the best marketing pitch I've heard in a while.
- 2:45So thank you. That was awesome.
- 2:46So our annual conference is in July of each year.
- 2:50And in July of 2025, we will be
- 2:52celebrating our 60th anniversary with our conference in Honolulu, Hawaii.
- 2:56Oh, well, what a terrible place to go. It's just awful. I know, right?
- 3:00So if you can't do planning well in Hawaii, then don't plan at all.
- 3:03But yeah, that's what we'll be. And then in 26, we come back stateside to Minneapolis.
- 3:07So those are the next two opportunities to join us at the annual.
- 3:11Awesome. Thanks for sharing that intel with us. So my next question is kind of forward looking.
- 3:16So what is the higher educational sector look like today? And where do we see
- 3:21it going in the next five years so engineering firms can plan?
- 3:24So where we are today is, I think, at the intersection of macro and micro trends
- 3:30that we've known about for a while.
- 3:31Taking the pandemic aside, which caught all of us in all industries probably
- 3:35surprised and some places unprepared.
- 3:38But what we're dealing with now is not things that we didn't see coming.
- 3:42It's just things that we may not have prepared correctly for.
- 3:45So if we think about the physical campus, the enrollment cliff that's coming
- 3:49that we'll talk about here in a minute was on the books for a long time.
- 3:52We saw that coming. and how that may manifest itself in physical space,
- 3:57programming, and curriculum. Those things are where we are currently sitting
- 3:59and trying to figure out what might that look like for the next 10 years when
- 4:03the true impact of an enrollment change happens.
- 4:05We're also sitting, as we'll talk about a little bit, I'm sure,
- 4:08here too, at an administration change in Washington, which will have impact on higher ed.
- 4:14And overall, where we're sitting currently is that we're doing pretty well historically,
- 4:19right? So we've had our peak.
- 4:20The enrollment peak was in the 2010. But what we are sitting now is that despite
- 4:25the news, despite the conversations, which are real and important,
- 4:29the value of higher ed is still pretty consistent.
- 4:32We're still putting out qualified individuals and students for the workforce.
- 4:36We're very focused on STEM.
- 4:38So where we might imagine that going in five years with all the things we're
- 4:42about to talk about trend-wise is that we might see a few more institutions close.
- 4:46We'll probably definitely see a few more institutions merge.
- 4:49We might see some programming changes, and we're absolutely going to see the
- 4:52impact of space modification, multi-use, hybrid, more fluid, and agile buildings.
- 5:00We're going to see changes in where the demography shifts.
- 5:04Not all states will have a declining population. Not all states will have declining enrollment.
- 5:09So we'll see a lot of shifting over the next five years as we get into the 2030s,
- 5:13which is about right halfway through this enrollment cliff. Yeah.
- 5:16Was caused by the declining birth rates at the last reception.
- 5:20So I'm hearing it's still a really good market. It's strong.
- 5:23It's going to anticipate, even with some other trends that might impact it negatively,
- 5:29it's still a market worth being in. Is that right?
- 5:32Yeah. And there's some truths that we need to be really paying attention to,
- 5:35especially as employers, right?
- 5:36So if we take the employer approach for your firms, is that there are changes,
- 5:41not just in the birth rates for the demographic changes, but also just in choosing to go to college.
- 5:47So males in particular are choosing less to go to two and four-year institutions
- 5:52and are choosing different career paths through the trades and other sorts of
- 5:55post-secondary opportunities.
- 5:57And graduation rates have changed. They've gotten longer. So when you see published
- 6:01graduation rates, those are based on six-year graduation rates,
- 6:04not four. So you're going to see some shifts there.
- 6:06So what we have to pay attention to is not just, and I don't say this to be
- 6:12funny about things, but the top 100 football schools are probably fine.
- 6:16So the major institutions are probably going to do okay.
- 6:19When we look at the institutional enrollment in the country,
- 6:22half the institutions in our country have less than 2,200 students.
- 6:26Of those, a third of them have less than 1,000 students. Those are the institutions
- 6:30that don't have big non-tuition opportunities for revenue.
- 6:35They don't have growing enrollments. They don't have large endowments.
- 6:38So they have different pressures on them. And that's a lot of what we've seen
- 6:41in the last couple of years is coming out of the pandemic, those schools are
- 6:45under financial duress differently than other institutions that might have a
- 6:49little bit longer financial pipeline just because of size.
- 6:52Right. Really good intel to have there. I wanted to take a step back to the
- 6:57physical design elements that you kind of had touched on there.
- 7:00You know, what new things are trending?
- 7:03When we spoke earlier, you had mentioned multidisciplinary buildings and how
- 7:07they're high in demand right now.
- 7:08So what are those buildings and what are the, you know, the demand?
- 7:12What's the most interesting right now that everybody wants to have?
- 7:16That's a great question. So two things are true, right? We have space needs
- 7:20and we will still need to build new spaces.
- 7:23The technology changes to support STEM programs and other disciplines.
- 7:26We have to keep up with the ability to be at the leading edge of those disciplines.
- 7:31So we might see the combined use buildings for multiple disciplines because
- 7:34of hybrid learning or other sorts of learning models that may come out of the institutions.
- 7:38And then at the same time, we have the ironic problem of excess space.
- 7:43So there's a couple of studies out from different organizations that would cite
- 7:47that 60% of the campus is actually used on the daily basis.
- 7:51I mean, 40% of the space is unused on a daily basis. Is that because of situational
- 7:55programming? Is it because of curriculum changes?
- 7:58Or is it just space that's now non-functional towards the main purpose of the
- 8:02institution, which is its academic plan?
- 8:04So as we look at all those things and balance that out, what's really interesting
- 8:07is the need and conversations around flexible learning spaces.
- 8:11So taking a multidisciplinary approach is one thing, but also having curricular
- 8:15changes where I'm meeting hybrid, I'm
- 8:18meeting only in the classroom for collaboration, like a flex classroom,
- 8:21or I'm looking at today it's configured for lecture, tomorrow it's configured
- 8:25for lab, and on Friday it's configured for open learning.
- 8:28How is your physical space going to be able to take in those different requirements,
- 8:32all of which require technology support?
- 8:35Really good insight to have there for our members. There's another topic that
- 8:40goes kind of leading in really heavy into our conversation.
- 8:44And, you know, it is the word cliff, which just sounds really terrifying.
- 8:48So, you know, we keep an eye on population trends here at ACEC to see how that
- 8:53might impact the markets that engineers work in.
- 8:56And we reported in our last market intel brief about births dropping in 2007,
- 9:02which means that now, of course, approaching 25 and 26, they should all be in
- 9:07that enrollment grade and going into colleges and universities.
- 9:11So I've heard the term coined the enrollment cliff for 25 and 26.
- 9:17So tell us more about that and how that's going to impact the market.
- 9:21Yeah. So in general, the data is going to support about a 15% drop in graduating
- 9:26seniors to go into post-secondary school, right? So it's not insignificant, right?
- 9:32Yeah. But what we might offer is that changing cliff to just enrollment changes
- 9:36because at the same time with the workforce challenges that we all have in all
- 9:40industries, including my own in the nonprofit industry, workforce challenges
- 9:43are real, labor shortages are real,
- 9:45upskilling, reskilling is real, is that we might see a lot of institutions starting
- 9:49to pursue the non-traditional age-powered students.
- 9:52So the traditional age being 18 to 22, we may see a lot of folks coming back
- 9:56between 25 and 35 or 35 and 45 even, coming back for that upskilling, reskilling.
- 10:02So your marketing that you did so well for Scott, by the way,
- 10:06that marketing pitch that we'll be doing as a higher ed field might look a little
- 10:11bit different to mitigate a little bit from the traditional aid students who
- 10:14are just mathematically, there's less of them.
- 10:17And then, you know, all things are tied to all systems, right?
- 10:20So when we're having these conversations, the other part that comes in there
- 10:23is it also goes, you're assuming that the same rate of people graduating still go to college.
- 10:28And as we just mentioned a minute ago, with the workforce changes and choice
- 10:32changes and the value conversation of higher ed, we might imagine that even
- 10:36there's less graduating and then less choose to go to secondary school,
- 10:40post-secondary school.
- 10:41So there's a lot of factors in there in the cliff beyond just the birth rate changes.
- 10:45It's also going to have to do with career choices, workforce development.
- 10:48And that's why we like to offer that the enrollment changes might be that perspective
- 10:53change that your primary audience might shift from being 18 to 22-year-olds to 18 to 35-year-olds.
- 10:59What about, and I don't think I brought this up earlier when we spoke,
- 11:03international students.
- 11:04I know in U.S. it's a much smaller percentage than, say, Australia.
- 11:07It's like a really huge number, like between 20-35%. Do you think that's something
- 11:13that could supplement for this decline in enrollments?
- 11:16Absolutely. Yeah. And I think that's going to be discipline and program specific.
- 11:21When you think about the curriculums that attract someone to come a half a planet
- 11:24away to school, you know, I think there was a lot more effort in the institutions
- 11:28doing recruitment in those markets as well.
- 11:31Yeah. And that alone comes with a lot of other opportunities for engineers,
- 11:35because think about on student or off campus housing, excuse me,
- 11:39they're going to need housing more than maybe someone that might be in state.
- 11:42So a lot of more opportunities surrounding those schools.
- 11:45I want to talk about AI. Everyone wants to know how it's impacting markets.
- 11:49How do you think it's going to, I mean, it's already in the educational market,
- 11:53but how do you think it's going to change campus planning and the way our engineers might be interested?
- 11:58Well, I think we'll talk about AI, not generative AI, right?
- 12:03So on the AI side, right, we know for sure because we're already doing it.
- 12:06A lot of us, even us small companies like Scup are using it for analytics and
- 12:10big data analysis and helping us make the human-centered decisions are still
- 12:14human-centered, but they're being supported out of the big data sets differently with the AI tools.
- 12:19And I think institutions obviously are going to be doing the same thing, if not already.
- 12:23So as we manage kind of thinking about it from a research assistant,
- 12:26and what I might emphasize is at least for the short term here,
- 12:30thinking 25 to 30, 2030, we're still going to have human intervention a lot with the AI systems.
- 12:36And so as we move a little bit towards from AI analytics and big data sets and
- 12:41using it as a tool to help us suss out all that data, making the human interventions
- 12:46and human decision-making still, eventually we're generating something.
- 12:49So the gen AI still is going to be part of the conversations that we have to have.
- 12:54And at what point does the generative AI become reliable enough that it's not
- 12:58requiring human intervention? And what would that do to your workforce changes?
- 13:02So right now, I think most of us, I won't pick one of them, but we pick a tool,
- 13:06a large language model. We go in and we do our thing.
- 13:09We don't go straight to publish. We don't send straight to the client.
- 13:12And that's probably going to hold true for a while. But that does not mean we
- 13:16shouldn't be experimenting with the tools.
- 13:18So I think I will reference another association here that I think your members
- 13:21will get great value out of going to their website.
- 13:24It's called Educause, E-D-U-cause, Educause.
- 13:27They are the IT Association for Higher Ed, and they have tremendous research.
- 13:32A lot of it's publicly available that will go through how institutions and workforces
- 13:37are imagining using AI, both for workforce development, for analytics,
- 13:41and then eventually for generative content and where they currently stand.
- 13:45And in the current state, most
- 13:46institutions will say that they're not getting the right training yet.
- 13:49They're not getting the right support yet. So we still have a long way to go
- 13:53before AI becomes a ubiquitous tool, but it's definitely on its way.
- 13:57Thank you for sharing that resource for our members. Second to last question here.
- 14:03Any insight into how the new administration might impact the higher education
- 14:07market? Because everybody wants to know.
- 14:09Yeah. Well, I'll qualify this by saying we are not a lobbying organization,
- 14:13but obviously all of our partners are. So we have a lot of these conversations.
- 14:18And I will get specific to your question, but in general, either administration
- 14:22winning, either candidate winning, administration was going to have an impact on higher ed.
- 14:27And in both cases, we can probably presume, and now we'll just go with the administration
- 14:32that will be incoming in January.
- 14:34The next couple of years, we'll probably see a lot of litigation.
- 14:37Whether or not they determine they want to dismantle and change how they do
- 14:41the education Department, the Department of Education, is to be seen,
- 14:45requires congressional approval, and in all cases, there'll be litigation.
- 14:49So there'll be a lot of that going on. I think you'll see a movement toward
- 14:52privatization in school of choice, probably feeding into then,
- 14:55of course, a different requirements for post-secondary, that school of choice
- 15:00primarily being secondary, K-12.
- 15:02We'll see a lot of conversations around Title IX and individuals' rules,
- 15:07preferences, and rights.
- 15:08And again, that'll move into litigation and congressional policy.
- 15:12So the next couple of years, we'll see a lot of policy discussions, a lot of litigation.
- 15:17What will also be interesting is seeing how funding works. And again,
- 15:20I'll go back to regardless of which institution won, we were looking at some
- 15:24challenges around funding.
- 15:26There's a lot of movement towards feds moving back down to let the states control their funding.
- 15:32And states already had made massive changes in state funding after the last recession.
- 15:36Those funds never really came back to pre-2008 levels.
- 15:40So there's a lot. I have said nothing positive yet disrupted.
- 15:43But there is some positive in all of it. And that is, is that regardless of
- 15:47one's personal perspective, it's always good to have the conversation.
- 15:51And I think what I'm looking forward to in the next administration is that there's
- 15:54some longstanding tropes that have been positive for the most part.
- 15:58There's longstanding tropes that have been maybe more negative for certain populations.
- 16:02To be able to have those conversations now as we really look towards developing
- 16:07a workforce for the future, it's time, right? It's time for us to have those conversations.
- 16:13I'm hopeful that it doesn't have to be contentious, but, you know,
- 16:18people, we'll see how it goes.
- 16:20So you teed this up nicely. We're talking about funding. So I want to pivot to finances.
- 16:25You know, you mentioned to me earlier about schools closing at a rapid rate,
- 16:31which is just as scary as this enrollment cliff. So can you tell us more about that?
- 16:35Yeah. So I think all of us, especially in the field like your members have,
- 16:40is we're always talking about acquisitions, mergers. but it's acquisitions, mergers, closers.
- 16:44And it's also now going to be, I think, acquisitions, mergers,
- 16:47closers, consolidations.
- 16:49Because one of the real outcomes of the changes we're seeing is there are a
- 16:52number of institutions, about
- 16:53100, who've closed their doors post-pandemic. A lot happened in 2024.
- 16:58It goes back to the earlier conversation we had around enrollment sizes.
- 17:02Many of the small schools, many private, just weren't quite able to get the
- 17:05financial turn. We've seen a lot of mergers.
- 17:08But what we're probably going to see more of at all levels, including the major
- 17:12institutions that are arguably on pretty sound footing, is programming changes.
- 17:17So you'll see curriculum changes, programming changes, institutions making choices
- 17:22on where they're putting their faculty dollars and where they're going to let things go.
- 17:26So I'm not advocating that they'll become specialty schools,
- 17:29but they may not be as general ed broad as they've been in the past.
- 17:33So I think we'll see a lot of institutions, including the major public institutions,
- 17:39making some programming choices.
- 17:41And then, of course, that just trickles down into where parents and students
- 17:44decide and have a ability to go for the curriculums that they're choosing to
- 17:49put their career forward on.
- 17:50So I think it's going to be an interesting time. The consolidations is going
- 17:54to happen, not just in the physical space, but within curriculum, staffing.
- 17:58Higher ed is not immune to the labor shortages. A lot of facility management
- 18:02groups, for example, did not all come back at the say previous staffing levels
- 18:06as they did pre-pandemic.
- 18:08There's just this whole system of, I think, stressors that will require us to do some consolidation.
- 18:14So this question just kind of came to me, and if you don't have an answer, I apologize.
- 18:18I'm thinking about the NCAA policy that came through on the NIL,
- 18:23the name, image, and likeness.
- 18:25And because you're in higher ed, I'm just curious, are you seeing anything new
- 18:29with that? Because funding does in some way come to the schools.
- 18:33You experience that, anything happening because of it? Only on the conjecture
- 18:37and conversation side, I don't have any really good information.
- 18:40It's a great question. And a lot of us are asking that question. Yeah.
- 18:44There's some really good interviews, actually, on the various networks this
- 18:48weekend with coaches of various levels,
- 18:50both pro and college, talking about the fact that there's really only pro-style
- 18:55management now because it's really a free agency for athletes now in terms of work one season here,
- 19:01two seasons there, one season somewhere else.
- 19:04And so the whole finance game around that is going to be fascinating.
- 19:08And I don't have enough information to say what that might look like.
- 19:11There is an organization or two out there that is starting the research.
- 19:16So we should start to see some results of that here coming the next year.
- 19:19Great. Thank you. So this is about all the time we have for today.
- 19:22Listeners, please note that just before the holiday, ACEC released the latest
- 19:26market intelligence brief focused on the educational market,
- 19:30which actually includes K-12 and higher education.
- 19:33If you would like more information on this market, please sign up to receive
- 19:37the latest market briefs directly to your inbox.
- 19:39We'll include a link for that in our show notes, as well as access to download the latest brief.
- 19:45Mike, thank you so much for joining us today.
- 19:48Thank you. And I want to thank your members for continuing to hire our students
- 19:51and continuing to provide viable workforce for us.
- 19:55So I appreciate all that you all do for higher ed. And thank you for letting
- 19:57me share some insights from Scott Cudet.
- 20:00Thanks, Mike. And that is about all that time we have.
- 20:03Thank you for joining in another episode of the Engineering Influence Podcast
- 20:06from the American Council of Engineering Companies.
- 20:09I'm Diana O'Lear. Happy holidays and see you next time.