Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / #Channel-Do we have a moral responsibility as gamers
Transcript
- 0:00I'm ready this time, right, Yeah, I've got my character sheet here,
- 0:03right, I've got my dice. I've been thinking about how I want
- 0:07to pursue the adventure into the village of Hamnet Hamlet Hamlet, yep, right,
- 0:15I'm so excited that we're finally doing this. Did you take on the
- 0:18prep? Like the so it takes me about fifteen minutes to cycle over here
- 0:22from work? Yeah, so like the bit from like the park to here?
- 0:27What is that? Like two minutes? Maximum? Two minutes? But
- 0:31that's like a lot longer than I normally think. You've got a very dense
- 0:33brain, so your two minutes is like someone else's. So yeah, but
- 0:37it's only the two of us here where it's everyone else. Well, because
- 0:39Steve, So, we're gonna play a little quiz what show we're recording right
- 0:44now? Five G for D and D? No, it's not that one?
- 0:48Fuck what every time this happens to me? Why? Because? Well,
- 0:52I mean you're old. But anyway, what else? Come on?
- 0:54Okay, we're not doing the movie show because we didn't watch a movie today.
- 0:57You do remember we didn't watch a movie your memory? Yeah, yeah,
- 1:00I know, we didn't watch a movie and we need to do that.
- 1:03What was that leave? We don't have a game set up. No,
- 1:07so it's not about reform. So it's either news or hashtag Channel.
- 1:10Yeah, exactly, so, but would you would you say that Hashtag Channel
- 1:15is the sexiest show in the world. Is the hashtag channel a public one
- 1:19or is the news one on the main feed? Ye? Both on the
- 1:23everything's on the main feed. You're my main feed. This is Hashtag Channel,
- 1:30a podcast about discord with Ben and Steve. Well, actually, a
- 1:36hashtag means it's a channel. All right, Well, hashtag channel, Steve.
- 1:46Here we are we get to the part I always so I'm sorry,
- 1:53sorry listeners. I was just enjoying and a feat beverage. I'm gonna have
- 1:57a sip of this Japanese rice wine. Oh god, that's really good to
- 2:04actually yeah, actually sake. Sake is brewed, not fermented. It's not
- 2:09really accurate to call it rice wine. Well, so why was I speaking
- 2:14in that tone of voice, Dave? Because it's saki, because I had
- 2:19I had a sip of saki. Yeah, so it only works in your
- 2:23country. You know, we don't say sarki in the US. You know,
- 2:24you do have rhotic accents though Southern American is quite rotic, we don't
- 2:29say SARKI. I bet some of them, do you know? My favorite
- 2:31one was of those of like misunderstandings people people not understanding the pronunciation of something,
- 2:38and where I'm from in England this is this happens quite a lot.
- 2:42What's that? Some guy was talking about Indian food and he was like,
- 2:45yeah, I love going to sleep on it, and I'll get it,
- 2:49Like, what the fuck are you talking about? I love going to sleep
- 2:52on it. I have like a bolty and then that pillar rice and don't
- 2:55get it like pee love yeah, but he he's it was pronounced pillar and
- 3:02that's how people from my area say pillow. He was making like a gag,
- 3:07A gag yeah, pillow rice. Yeah, you always loves that pillar
- 3:09rice. So you have to be intelligent enough to get the gag, but
- 3:13dumb enough to think that peelof could be pronounced pillow or always say pela rice
- 3:17pilau. We say peel like, but what are there regions of the world
- 3:22where they say pilau. Where I'm from, you could say pillar rice.
- 3:27Yeah, and a pillar is what you sleep on at night. Now where
- 3:29I'm from, only certain parts of the country, even though its sarcasm is
- 3:34right, well, none of none of the parts of the country really well,
- 3:37the part I'm from a little bit, the part I'm from you kind
- 3:39of like kindergarten is when it comes to sock, very very sarcastic all the
- 3:43time. In fact, the thing is, I think you get positive reinforcement
- 3:46in the UK for sarcas. Oh yeah, we get we get the highest
- 3:50form of wits. We generally get negative reinforcement for it in the US.
- 3:53I have been told in the past, Rusty Beams, I've been told I
- 3:57am. I am entirely too sarcastic to SARKI yep. Oh, Bless the
- 4:02Americans. They think they know things, don't they. Anyway, See,
- 4:05we get to this part of the show where what does it say on the
- 4:09structure my eyesight's not a see famed board game designer Isaac shud No no no
- 4:14no is for some reason his name his name's underlined. Is that because you
- 4:17like him a lot. The beginning bit it says the intro talk about something,
- 4:21talk about something, all right, So that's something I want to talk
- 4:25about. Let's talk about this. I shall clap because I so are you
- 4:29gonna trick yourself into editing this out just for the listeners. When we do
- 4:31sections, I clap in between sections, so I have editing points, and
- 4:35if I actually clap, that means that I might edit something out. Anyway.
- 4:39You can at a little bit of how the sausage is made for the
- 4:41listeners. Well, you kill a pig, yep, you drink its blood
- 4:45metaphorically speaking, metaphorically speaking, and you become a ware pig, and then
- 4:49you become the ware pig of sausage town. I really hope the listeners are
- 4:55clapping though, I mean, especially for that fucking brilliant that wasn't even like
- 4:59a joke like that was like, that was like tableau. That's why I'm
- 5:01the greatest DM in the world. It's that kind of fantasy world that I
- 5:04built. Steve Yeah on the Spot too, on the Spot. And I
- 5:08also want to give an honorable mention to your ability to come up with character
- 5:11names for MPCs that without having put any thought into them whatsoever. For him,
- 5:15Bob Johnson, John Bobson, It's like it's like you have a fucking
- 5:19database of characters, unique character names in your head that you carry around and
- 5:26then you just fucking pluck one off the queue. I was listening to the
- 5:29the five G F, D and D podcast today and do you know what
- 5:31the first character name I came up with in the episode was? The first
- 5:34one in the whole episode? Is sub bloke who came to criticize you about
- 5:39your fire making? Is that? Was? That? Was that young Bob?
- 5:41Or Bob was young Bob was the guy who was trying to crack onto
- 5:44Sam? So was it? Was it just Bob Johnson? His name was
- 5:46John Smith? Oh yeah, John Smith. That's very It's a very,
- 5:50very fantasy. It's a bit of a departure for you though exactly. It's
- 5:54original anyway, So what do you want to talk about? So? I
- 5:57recently started a new job at a new company, and one of the selling
- 6:01points, as it was presented to me, and I thought of it this
- 6:05way at the time, was that the team really enjoys playing board games.
- 6:10They actually set aside, wait for it, every Thursday afternoon for board games.
- 6:15You could like to a marathon session, Yeah, basically the game night.
- 6:18Yeah. And apparently lots of other people in the company like board games.
- 6:23In fact, this is a great way to get to know people at
- 6:25a new company. By the way, you just join the special interest groups
- 6:28where people share your hobby in common, and you immediately have something to talk
- 6:30about because everyone else is so sick of them, they're desperate to meet the
- 6:33new people, right exactly. I went into the board game channel on Slack
- 6:39and it slacks like the Slack's like the Tory discord, right, yes,
- 6:43yeah, yeah, well, I mean Microsoft Teams is probably the Tory discord.
- 6:46But isn't Slack. Slack is like the teams like Zoo. I think
- 6:49Slack is the lib Dem discord. Isn't I thought Slack? I thought I
- 6:53thought Teams was like Zoo. No, Teams is like Slack. Oh right,
- 6:57okay, Teams is Microsoft's attempt to compete with Slack, which was purchased
- 7:00by Salesforce, by the way, right, So I mean, actually they're
- 7:04all kind of lib dem right at this point? Anyway, what was I
- 7:08saying? So I joined the channel and we're talking about favorite games, and
- 7:12this one guy says, yeah, I played a really great game recently.
- 7:14It's like, now one of my favorites of the year. Horseless Carriage,
- 7:16yeah or whatever, slow coach, carry on. I don't know what.
- 7:23Anyway, he mentioned horseless carriage. That's the important point here, he mentioned.
- 7:26And of course I immediately uploaded my photo with your own and yours,
- 7:30you know, with my arms around them, and of course I got lots
- 7:32of like, you know, very positive reaction emojis. The question is this,
- 7:36do I really want to play board games with my colleagues, because there's
- 7:41work Steve and there's games Steve, and they're not completely different. There's some
- 7:47overlap, but it's sort of like there's a little bit of the George Costanza
- 7:53Keep the worlds Apart game Steve is kind of like the stuff I cut out
- 7:57of this podcast. Sure, yeah, like the the basically like literally not
- 8:01safe at work part of my personalities. It does not go out on the
- 8:05main feed. That's why I always have to ask, right, So you
- 8:09know, I, you know, become a certain type of person when I
- 8:13play a game, and I want to protect my ability to have this escape
- 8:16from work and home responsibility I can actually go out and have fun. Is
- 8:20playing games with my colleagues going to be fun in quite the same way?
- 8:26So I have a question for it, and I bet a lot of our
- 8:28listeners may have similar experiences of playing games with our coworkers. I have done
- 8:33it, and it has always been it's fun, but it's always like a
- 8:35slightly neutered experience. I have a question for you, this attitude, you
- 8:41know, wanting to keep the magisteria non overlapping nice. Has this changed the
- 8:50older you've got so, because when I was growing up, I wanted to
- 8:54be mates with my work colleagues. I thought that was what made a good
- 9:00working environment, that you work with each other and then after work you go
- 9:03out and you have pints on that and you become mates on that. The
- 9:07older I've got, I've realized I want an area where you know, I'm
- 9:13miserable essentially. I mean not at the moment. I'm currently a podcaster,
- 9:18which is great, but you know, I've worked in oviices. I want
- 9:20the extremely respectable profession. Yeah, those people over there, and then my
- 9:26mates over here, because and especially I want you. Isn't it amazing that
- 9:31it's still called a podcast simply because the iPod is what made it popular.
- 9:35Amazing? But I want you, know, I especially want you not to
- 9:39play games with your colleagues if I'm there. Oh my god, this is
- 9:43an entirely separate discussion, but we'll get onto that like mixing the groups.
- 9:46I'll explain that why in a minute. So, but has that changed as
- 9:50you've got older? Two things? More reluctant to hang out with your colleagues.
- 9:52Two things. First of all, I'm like older than everybody at the
- 9:54company, including the CEO. So probably especially in tech, everybody's really young,
- 9:58and it's just like it's awkward for me at my age to be playing
- 10:03to doing anything social with people in their twenties. I mean, they're like
- 10:07five years younger than me at least, right exactly, you know. So
- 10:09there's that kind of and I feel like I need to be the more mature
- 10:11person. I'm a manager, and there's like that kind of dynamic. So
- 10:16I think there's that. There's also and this is funny that you asked me
- 10:20this because it came up today with a guy in the office. We're like
- 10:22similar in age. He's a bit younger than me. No, no,
- 10:26no, Ben, Ben, Ben. I have to serve you first,
- 10:28do I? Yeah, you have to serve me. You hold the chulk
- 10:31go up as you pour from the tokodie, okay, lovely, And then
- 10:35I should have noticed that your glass was empty. You should have, especially
- 10:39as the host as the Yeah, maybe if you don't mind, this is
- 10:45great, this is great radio. We don't want it. We don't want
- 10:46Tom Hanks the table exactly. So so what's that from? I wasn't listening.
- 10:56I wasn't listening. What language is that I wasn't listening? Egg,
- 11:00shaky drift. I'm still not really listening. Shaky sounds like Anglo Saxon.
- 11:03It's Hungarians, it carry on hm hmm for cheers, I assume. But
- 11:11she is you glossed over completely my Tom Hanks bit, By the way,
- 11:13I didn't get it. That's why i'd lost over it. So I didn't
- 11:16want to Tom Hanks the playing service of the the What character to Tom Hanks
- 11:20portray you don't want to? Forest recently in a film about an airplane that
- 11:24went down in a river, Oh, you don't want to Sully Sully the
- 11:28table? Very good? Now? Would it have been proper Cockney slang if
- 11:33I made a rhyme on Tom Hanks, like I don't want to like Shanks
- 11:37the table. You don't want to McDonald's the table. Why you don't want
- 11:41to McDonald's flurry Sully the table. It's too complicated. Florry doesn't rhyme with
- 11:48Sully though, no rhyme? What's a flurry? Gully? You don't want
- 11:52to McDonald's flurry. You don't want to mount in the table? Why mounting
- 11:58Gully? Sully? My god? There we go carry out? So wait,
- 12:01how come Tom Hanks doesn't work well because it's a reference, it's not
- 12:05rhyming. Okay, So I don't want to Sully the table. But can't
- 12:09I like, get to Sully via Tom Hanks? What you don't realize?
- 12:13Like you could use that one, but you can't say I don't want Tom
- 12:16Hanks. It feel it feels clumsy. What you say? I don't want
- 12:20to Hanks? Yeah, I'm saying I don't want to like, yeah,
- 12:22Shanks the table, Hanks the tape. I don't want to Hanks the table.
- 12:24Don't want to just Hanks the table. Yeah, Okay, I'm learning.
- 12:26Hey, frankly, I was thinking then I was thinking, then Sully.
- 12:31That's an old fashioned word. But if cuckolds can come back into the
- 12:35modern lexicon, any word can We need to mine the past for the fucking
- 12:39humor matter of the future. Anyway, I met this guy colleague, right,
- 12:45we're talking about this because we have a team event coming up company event.
- 12:48Right, the whole company is coming together. They're flying us out to
- 12:52Spain, and we're all gonna stay together in the same hotel. Why aren't
- 12:56you hiring me to do Blood of the clock Tower? I should? I
- 13:00should? I think I missed my opportunity this time. They have a full
- 13:03schedule already. I don't know if they could really fit you in. And
- 13:07I don't think you can do blood in the clock Tower for a thousand people.
- 13:11I mean theoretically, maybe you could like run through groups of twenty one
- 13:13after the other next year, next year, for sure. So I was
- 13:18telling him, I'm looking forward to going to Spain. I'm not looking forward
- 13:22to sharing a hotel room with a random colleague. Yes, yeah, I
- 13:28mean it's like the company has got enough money to send us to Spain,
- 13:31but not so much that we each get up a single room, right,
- 13:35And you know he he felt like similarly, but he's like, yeah,
- 13:39but it'll be okay. Like my problem is I'm an introvert, which I
- 13:41identified with, and just like, after a week with everybody, I'm just
- 13:45like I need to, like, you know, crawl into bed and assume
- 13:48the fetal pocision I hate sharing a room. Yeah, I mean it's like
- 13:52the bodily functions that I'd prefer other people not be exposed to, snorting principle
- 13:58among them. This is the thing, and this thing is what people don't
- 14:00realize. People may think, Oh, you don't want to fucking smell someone
- 14:03else's fast, that's not the issue. I mean, your snoring is a
- 14:07fucking nightmare. But I don't want people like like I want to be able
- 14:11to I don't have to hold it in for fucking a week, like I
- 14:13am, to just lay there and let fucking wrist exactly exactly. I want
- 14:18to be able to go into the toilet and have diarrhea all night long because
- 14:20I drank too much, and not have to fucking be concerned that my my
- 14:24roommate is gonna exactly sending DMS to my team, like with fucking recordings of
- 14:31it, what's with shitty? Exactly. The point I'm trying to make is
- 14:35as I get older, I find that I want more and more obsessive control
- 14:41over my environment than I did when I was younger. That is so true,
- 14:43Like I am completely in You know, Samantha can attest to this,
- 14:48just like I need to control fucking everything. And I have to go to
- 14:50like a hotel that someone else booked and share a room with a random person
- 14:54for four nights. That sharing, the sharing the room is the issue.
- 15:00Yeah, nightmare. I mean I want to control everything, right, so
- 15:01I'm sure the hotel will be fine. So the fact that I, like
- 15:05will not have control over that environment is the problem for me. And our
- 15:07close friend lemon Cello are going to Prague to see a gig LC. Yeah
- 15:11wait what what when beginning of June? How come I wasn't invited? Are
- 15:16you into crosses the Chino Moreno? Have a good time, Have a good
- 15:18time. So we're going there and he sent me a message of the day.
- 15:22He's in charge of booking the accommodation. He sent me a message the
- 15:26other day saying, is sharing a bed alright with you? Like the two
- 15:31of you together? Yeah, it's like an Italian thing, right, I
- 15:35don't know, is it? And I'm like, are you out of your
- 15:37mine? No, it's not. I'd get too bad. Have we ever
- 15:39had to do that? No? I think so even if we share a
- 15:43room, I mean, that's all right, sharing a room. It's not
- 15:45my do, but it's one night I mean it's fine, it's not a
- 15:46massive issue. Yeah, come on, I have a word of yourself,
- 15:48you know what I mean. I have had to share beds with people that
- 15:52I was not, you know, intimately connected to. I mean it's it's
- 15:56like okay in the end, but it's fucking weird. Yeah, I don't
- 15:58like And so I don't even want to be in the same suite as another
- 16:03person if I'm honest. You know, when we would go to sen and
- 16:04we have the whole airbnb, Yeah, that's like that's like as close as
- 16:08I can get to being able to do that if you can close the door.
- 16:11But that's all right though, because well this is interesting, this is
- 16:15try and I know you like, I can whatever. It's transmographied into a
- 16:18different topic, but I think it's but to me it's the same topic because
- 16:22I don't feel like I have control over the environment when I'm playing games with
- 16:25cut coworkers, because I have to restrain. But it's contextual, just like
- 16:27I have to restrain the flatulence when I'm sharing the hotel room with a coustody.
- 16:32But it's contextual, right, So if you go to Essen, kind
- 16:36of part of having a few people in the airbnb. It's kind of part
- 16:41of the essen experience, right, getting people up, go into the train
- 16:44station together, go into the con together. Yeah, you know, wanting
- 16:48to strangle them after forty eight hours. You know, this is all part
- 16:51of the and so I'm willing to tolerate it. And it's more fine than
- 16:56in the situation I've just described, but it's still hard for me. So
- 17:00so what is your fundamental issue then? When you've been talking about playing games
- 17:04with colleagues? Yeah, do you do you I want to talk shit when
- 17:11I play board games. So do you feel that the current climate doesn't allow
- 17:18you the the width to say what you want? Do you feel it's the
- 17:22fact that people don't know you well enough to understand that you're being ironic?
- 17:26Is it the fact that, by your very status within the company, you
- 17:32have to have a certain level of propriety to make sure to so you don't
- 17:37under so your respect isn't undermined. What is it? All of the above
- 17:41plus add a few drinks, Because then what happened when we played D and
- 17:45D with your colleagues at the previous company. I almost said the company's name,
- 17:49the previous company that you worked at? You seemed fairly unrestrained. I
- 17:56was a bit if you recall when we started it. At the very beginning,
- 18:00I was very you know, I was a bit hesitant to do it.
- 18:04And then I think I had to tell you, you know, it's
- 18:07got to be like this way, and you would say things to me like,
- 18:11you know, I don't mind if you I don't mind if you take
- 18:15the piss, but keep it within respectable bounds, professional bounds, because I
- 18:19didn't know how it would go. And then as time went on and I
- 18:22became more confident in my role, I actually became closer to these colleagues.
- 18:26I probably stopped giving a shit as much. Then it was fine. And
- 18:30actually the people that we played with, I became like so close to them,
- 18:34like they're friends now outside of work. And it doesn't it wouldn't even
- 18:38matter. But in any other scenario, it would still make me very uncomfortable
- 18:45to do that, like role playing with colleagues, especially people support to me,
- 18:49the listening vaguely uncomfortable. So for the listeners, the Teefling Wizard,
- 18:55during one of the sessions, and this was quite a way into our D
- 18:59and D thing, did something that kind of took the piss and then rolled
- 19:03badly. So it resulted in them having explosive diary and shooting themselves, which
- 19:08I think you'll agree was pretty funny. Yeah. Yeah. Would that have
- 19:15been as funny not empty? Would that have been as funny within the first
- 19:19two weeks of us playing as it was after a year? I mean possibly,
- 19:26But you know, at the back of your mind, like I'm not
- 19:30European, right, at the back of my mind is always like something is
- 19:36going to go wrong, and someone's gonna get offended, and something's gonna get
- 19:37back to my boss or the company, and I'm gonna get reprimanded or fired
- 19:41or something. Also, fundamentally, does it mean even if it's not like
- 19:45a realistic possibility. Also fundamentally does it mean that because I so my girlfriend
- 19:53is a business type, you're a business type. She's probably more so than
- 19:56me, though, right, I mean she works in markets, you work
- 20:00in management. I don't think there's a lot of difference. But essentially tech
- 20:03is much less serious than a lot of other sure, But one thing she
- 20:07said to me is when she goes on a business trip, it's like,
- 20:11oh, that's cool. You get to go to another place. And she
- 20:14says you don't understand. You don't get to go to another place. You
- 20:17get to go to a convention center or an office building in a city you
- 20:21don't get to. You don't get to see the city and have a trip.
- 20:25And then in the evening you have to go to dinner with people at
- 20:27work. So you're actually working when you're not being paid to do so because
- 20:33you have to restrain yourself and can't relax. Is yes, I'm going to
- 20:38be at work the entire time because I'm going to be around colleagues. So
- 20:41is playing board games. If one of your colleagues turned up to our game
- 20:45night and said, oh, I'd love to play with you, that would
- 20:48be cool. Is that then an extension of the workday? Oh yeah,
- 20:52I mean well, if I were just a developer, maybe maybe it would
- 20:56be okay. Maybe, But as a manager, like and this is is
- 21:00this a person who reports to me? Yeah? For instance, I don't
- 21:03think I could just treat it like there any other person. I think I
- 21:07would have a hard time getting there. Is it because you never know?
- 21:10People gossip? This is true? People gas? I don't Is this because
- 21:15you think you're better than everyone? Yeah? Must be after altogether too?
- 21:21Much consultation with the greatest minds in the world of topics, we present this
- 21:33So who we asked the main topic. You're gonna hate this topic because I
- 21:37know you hate. So we're not doing nicknames, right, No, that's
- 21:41the Blessing News show. Okay, so we're just doing uh, patron questions
- 21:48or something. I stole the structure of this show from Very Bad Wizards,
- 21:52and we're doing the very Bad Wizard structure. We have the opening bit opening,
- 21:56but except they talk about a scientific page. Peopleth have PhDs, I
- 22:00mean I almost have. I have a degree? You do? I do?
- 22:03And then non subject? What a pretending to be someone else? Honors,
- 22:12a BA honors, theater studies, bracket, fucking acting options, fucking
- 22:18how many credit hours does it take to learn to hold up a skull?
- 22:22I tell you what, though I'm not lying to here. I had a
- 22:25forty eight hour week at university. Present at university forty eight hour week,
- 22:30Yeah, because they marked you present, And that's not as much as they
- 22:32gonna don't do. No, but how many students, how many university courses
- 22:37have a forty eight hour presence? I don't know how to compare this to
- 22:41the United States. So I guess if you take a three credit course in
- 22:45the US, how many lecture hours do you have a week? A week?
- 22:49So we typically would take I guess fifteen credits of courses. I think
- 22:55that's a normal amount. Eighteen would be a lot. So that would be
- 22:59six classes a week. How long is a class ninety minutes? So you're
- 23:03looking at what do the mass? Well, if it's six classes a week
- 23:10and each one's ninety minutes, then it's nine hours. Yeah, so I
- 23:14was forty eight hours a week, right, doesn't make any sense. It's
- 23:17like a full time job. Yeah. Nine When do you study? Well,
- 23:19basically nine till nine till eight? Yeah, we didn't study, did
- 23:25we We pranced around in time like twelve hours exactly like, but we have
- 23:30to get up like a match. It's not because it's not real coursework.
- 23:33I fucking dare you? How dare you? I had to learn all of
- 23:37the positions in fencing. It's like it's not a subject. It's like a
- 23:41craft. Right, it is a craft yet, but the thing is you
- 23:45only get funding to study it in Britain. Well back in my day if
- 23:48it was accredited as a university call. But is this where you honed the
- 23:52crystalline perfection of that accent. Yes, the only reason I keep you around.
- 23:57Also, I honed my particular ability to title podcast episodes correctly, such
- 24:06as task cola, task color. I was actually thinking about that. I
- 24:11didn't want to bring it up. I didn't want to embarrass you. Like,
- 24:14so we've already established that. You don't even like, look at what
- 24:17you've typed. Just you hit enter, you fucking you bought. It's like,
- 24:22I'm all about the moment, baby, Yeah, where angels fear to
- 24:25tread you. You know what, like task color. This is some sort
- 24:30of like productivity board game exactly, I have fixed. It's like we're in
- 24:33the arena together and you can fucking get through all their chores. Oh god,
- 24:41I've got to tabulate these figures. That's a business. Yeah, sure,
- 24:45And I'm over here just fucking like, all right, did that spreadsheet,
- 24:48did this document? Did that performance review? And you're just like,
- 24:51fuck this game. Did you know there's a World Championship of Excel. No,
- 24:55there is there's a and it's in Vegas. I will, I'm already
- 24:59already surprise. It's just like take this data and create a report. It's
- 25:03something on that charts and Fuvo's fascinating anyway, So should be a board game
- 25:07called pivot table, Isaac, get on it. So I decided I wanted
- 25:12the world is burning down around our ears. So I decided I would ask
- 25:18a contentious question. So the format is you ask a question. This is
- 25:23the hashtag channel. You ask a question, we get responses, we talk
- 25:27about them. Is this the one where we pick the poster of the month.
- 25:30Yeah, boom, nailed it, sir. That's it though, right?
- 25:33Nothing else? Is there an outro? Yeah? No, Well we
- 25:37talk about stuff, so it's very meta. So I wrote, I'm going
- 25:41to read you the full question. Right, do we have a moral obligation
- 25:45as gamers, a moral obligation to do what? As gamers? Should we
- 25:48care where our games are made, the moral of political stances of those that
- 25:52make them. I saw you how people are paid within the industry, if
- 25:56they leverage modern technological advances to diminish the number of people employed in a company,
- 26:00or is it just the quality of the game and the experience it delivers.
- 26:03That is the paramount of paramount, That is of paramount importance. So
- 26:08before we get to the paramount, pictures has been in the news lately,
- 26:11exactly before we get to the thing. So I feel like we've covered this
- 26:15ground so many times, though, but I think I think it's I mean,
- 26:18usually it's about like the components and manufacturer and China and that kind of
- 26:22thing. So the reason I'm asking this question, I think, is because
- 26:26we are constantly and I think social media is the accelerator of this. We
- 26:32are constantly, more than ever before, being asked to make a moral judgment
- 26:37on things we needn't have made a moral judgment on before. Right, you
- 26:41live in Berlin. I live in Berlin, and it is it feels incumbent
- 26:48upon us to have a view on Israel, Gaza, yep, what's yours?
- 26:56It feels us to have a view on the British general election, the
- 27:00American general election. It feels like and and I think this is born out
- 27:04of people. So I took a flight six months ago from Berlin to Cologne.
- 27:12Right, how do you feel about that? I mean, I think
- 27:15you should have taken the train, but I couldn't have. The schedule wouldn't
- 27:19have worked anyway. So the thing is, we, as normal people,
- 27:25more than more than ever before in history, are being asked to a pine.
- 27:30And I think it comes out of my issue with social media is I
- 27:34think it's pub talk transmitted to the world. Right, go to the publia
- 27:40mates, have a couple of pints, chat about world events, and you
- 27:44say something and you think, oh, that sounds clever, and maybe the
- 27:48people around the table nod their heads and say, oh, that was a
- 27:52pretty good point, right, And that has just become social media. Rather
- 27:57than say it to a person you happened into your phone, you put it
- 28:00up on Facebook or Twitter or wherever, right, and then it completely changes
- 28:07the impact of what that is. I think. I think, maybe I
- 28:11disagree because a lot of pub chat is just like bullshit. It's like bullshitting.
- 28:15I don't know, do you like? Well, well, so I
- 28:18think that may then imply what I think about people's political views on Twitter,
- 28:23right, Yeah, I suppose it could. I think people, I don't
- 28:27know to what extent people believe in what they're saying when they opine on topics
- 28:34as trivial as I'm gonna get shipped for saying it's trivial right where their board
- 28:38games are manufactured or the labor conditions under which they are I think it's I
- 28:44think they want to be seen to be having that opinion. Well, this
- 28:48is the point, right, That's that's what's important, like what they actually
- 28:51believe and the the sort of the impact of their opinion is beside the point
- 28:55because having the opinion doesn't change anything in the world. Pub talk is exactly
- 28:57the same thing. I don't see Wellmbia University students protesting the conditions of workers
- 29:03at board game factories in China, which they may well do. So the
- 29:07point is, right, when you're in the pub, when you say something,
- 29:11it's not what you think necessarily. I mean it may be, I
- 29:14mean, you know everything, but it's just like it's like trial balloons and
- 29:17it's it's banter and it's sort of exactly. But I guess what social media
- 29:22does is social media makes that much more regimented beyond social media for any length
- 29:30of time, and you will be asked to choose a tribe and you will
- 29:34be asked to follow that tribe in whatever, in which is not what happens
- 29:40down the pub. No, I think that selection has happened before. And
- 29:45I asked about the flight to Cologne because look, would I prefer it if
- 29:48everything I consume were produced under whatever the optimal conditions are that we could agree
- 29:56on as far as like environmental standards, labor standards, et cetera, et
- 29:59cetera. Of course, most of that I can't control, and even if
- 30:03you know it were, I don't even know if it's possible to control it
- 30:07to that extent. As has been pointed out in one of the responses,
- 30:10I think to this, to this question, like the same thing with this
- 30:15this trip to Cologne, right, it just so happened that that particular trip
- 30:17there is no possible way I could get there by train. I also don't
- 30:19trust Deutsche Bond to get me anywhere reliably. And you know, if this
- 30:26sort of flight were banned, is I think the EU is shortly to do,
- 30:29which I hope they do. Yeah, me too, Like you know
- 30:32what, please create regulations that prevent me from being able to do the wrong
- 30:36thing right right, and that I think that is the only way to do
- 30:38anything about the whatever injustices of the world is by like large scale regulatory reform,
- 30:45not like individual choice, putting it upon individual actors to make these kinds
- 30:51of decisions, because you're going to get some who do, many who don't,
- 30:53and the ones who don't just want to broadcast the world the fact that
- 30:56they don't, as if that is valuable when it isn't, as if that
- 31:00is a tactic of persuacation. I will choose not to play this board game
- 31:04out of some deference to a value or a virtue or a moral principle that
- 31:11has absolutely no impact on the world at all. And firstly, people will
- 31:15say, oh, individual choices do matter, and this is where I would
- 31:17say, they don't. Only collective choices matter. Sure, and so and
- 31:21so. I think you have an issue. And part of asking this question
- 31:26is interesting because I think it implies Sorry, I didn't mean to make the
- 31:33sound of an empty choco hitting a coaster. Oh what what are you supposed
- 31:37to say? Now? Just go ahead and go ahead, poor chuto choto
- 31:41choto chuto, chuto choto chutto. That's for those who aren't Japanese. You're
- 31:45supposed to say, no, I don't want anymore. I don't want anymore.
- 31:48I don't want any more. It's a social game, So I think
- 31:51it's interesting. I think it's interesting. My biggest my biggest problem with social
- 31:56media is that I think you imply a virtue you don't possess. You imply
- 32:04a moral perfection that you don't possess. I have often said that I think
- 32:07these times feel very much like the Victorian times, where if you talk about
- 32:14the characterization of the Victorian Age, what it is is about a public show
- 32:17of virtue and a private a private desire to do whatever you want. Now,
- 32:23I think the big fundamental difference between today's age and the Victorian age is
- 32:29that the public propriety was coming from the right and the Victorian age and it
- 32:32comes from the left of the modern way. So I started off by disagreeing
- 32:35with you. Now I'm going to agree with you, but in an interesting
- 32:39way. I was listening to a different podcast recently where they were talking about
- 32:43this very subject, and they mentioned that in the early days of social media,
- 32:47it really did feel like it was like you're down the pub, right,
- 32:52like you really could just sort of like joke around and banter and share
- 32:59off color jokes, blah blah blah, and eventually it morphed into what you
- 33:02just described. It wasn't always like this, but for whatever reason, the
- 33:07trajectory brought it to like the brink of ruination or like actually you would have
- 33:15expected social media to somehow be a reflection of society, and social media has
- 33:17now it's been flipped. Social media has now perverted society. Yes, we
- 33:22have become reflections of the algorithms themselves. Right, should you become more and
- 33:27more extreme in every way? Should you be fired by the stupid shit you
- 33:30say in the pub? And I'm a believer regardless of what that stupid shit
- 33:35you say in the pub is that you should not What people don't there are
- 33:39there are exceptions, but they're like, it's very much off. Like the
- 33:45thing is the extrame thing is. I think what people don't realize is that
- 33:49in social media, it's you are speaking in a public sphere. It's not
- 33:53people who know you and like you and respect you and understand your having a
- 33:57law. It is strangers who will get a moral bump from calling you out
- 34:05on your bullshit, which is no way to it, which is no way
- 34:07to conduct a relation. And the problem with that, that's why relationships on
- 34:10social media or psytoxic. And the problem with that is that the Internet once
- 34:15was a wonderful vehicle for bullshit. Well, bullshit is not the worst thing
- 34:22in the world, Like you go down the pub and like it exists,
- 34:23So that you can bull in the Harry Frankfurt definition of bullshit. It still
- 34:28is, but it's like very sincere bullshit. It's not like bullshit of the
- 34:30proper variety. And the reason I know this is because we're in like the
- 34:34post postmodern age where the ultimate bullshitter on the planet is like the ultimate non
- 34:39like people people hold Donald Trump in sincere esteem, even though he is the
- 34:47world's greatest bullshitter, right, I mean, I don't even know how to
- 34:51compute that. He's not just a liar, it's also bullshit. He is
- 34:53a complete bullshitter. I don't even know the lies because he would have to
- 34:57have some reference to the true would have to be obtained. So for the
- 35:01can you please explain your definition of bullshit? Harry? What's his face?
- 35:06Excluding Harry Frankfurt on bullshit. So, a liar is someone who knows what
- 35:13the truth is and is actively trying to deceive you. A bullshitter is simply
- 35:16trying to produce a certain kind of effect in the listener without regard to the
- 35:21truth whatsoever. Yeah, So, like when you and I like like have
- 35:24our banter, whether it's out on this podcast or at the bar, that's
- 35:30like bullshit because like there's no like you know, it's like you know,
- 35:34like you know, when you're telling like a fucking like a tall tale,
- 35:37it's just like, oh my god, it's like he was fucking ten feet
- 35:40tall, right, and just like obviously he wasn't. Nobody's ten feet tall,
- 35:45right, I am bullshitting like the truth is not what's important. I
- 35:47was watching trying to amuse you. I was watching The Foote the other day
- 35:51and Mohammed Salah was literally on five yeah for example, right, like this
- 35:54is this is this is in the realm of bullshit. So okay, let's
- 35:58let's let's we talked around the subject. Do you think you, as a
- 36:02consumer of salespeople bullshit constantly because they're trying to develop a relationship, not convince
- 36:08you that something that isn't so is or something that is isn't. That person
- 36:13who commented I tried to listen to the show and stage just interrupted me all
- 36:16the time might have a point. Anyway, sir, that was the first
- 36:20time in this episode. So let's talk about the question in hand. So
- 36:25I'm gonna ask two questions and I want you to answer them both. Firstly,
- 36:30do you think we should care about board games being. The reason I
- 36:35asked this question is something came up on a discord a few weeks ago in
- 36:38which some board game company got a lot of shit because they developed an international
- 36:45relationship with a board game company in Russia, and everyone on the discord agreed
- 36:52that that was a dodgy thing to do, like this is special pleading.
- 36:55Right. Then someone brought up the point, but we may board games in
- 37:00China, which is equally as much of a totalitarian state as Russia. Fucking
- 37:05vegetarian vegan argument, should we should we hold people who produce games in China
- 37:10to the same standard as people who have a deal with a publisher in Russia.
- 37:16I'm not as good at these ethical questions as a CD hunter, So
- 37:21the question is should we in the broadest term, you, as a person
- 37:24who buys and plays board games, should the moral owners be on you to
- 37:31know where it is produced, how the company the company compensates theirs, how
- 37:38the company compensates their staff, what the owner of the company thinks on certain
- 37:45political issues. For instance, should you care that during twenty twenty the owner
- 37:52of a board game company didn't make a statement on BLM and should that be
- 37:55a reason for you not to buy their product, or that the owners of
- 38:00the Chick fil A company in America are far right Christian evangelicals who fund them
- 38:06table and I think and I think they're homophobic as well. I don't remember,
- 38:10well, it was a controversy. At some point they closed on Sundays,
- 38:15which is not unheard of in America. America. Yeah, yeah,
- 38:19excuse me. Actually chotto is all that's left. I'm afraid that's fine.
- 38:27Your turn. So when I was in my twenties, I was scrupulous about
- 38:34everything I bought. I only bought organic cotton or hemp clothing. I like
- 38:38only bought like organic fruits and vegetables. I bought locally, like everything,
- 38:44every single purchase. I thought like I had to have these concerns because I
- 38:47thought all or nothing, right, I I am an extremist in this regard.
- 38:51But then I went the other way where I thought, like, you
- 38:52know, I can't actually be that pure. So if it's not going to
- 38:57be all, it's going to have to be nothing. At a certain point,
- 39:00you realize that simply by being a Western subject, like we're weird,
- 39:06weird, being like Western educated, industrialized sorry, western educated industrial industrialized are
- 39:19democratic right, I forget what the r st. I forget what the art
- 39:23stands for. Someone will point it out to us and that you can look
- 39:29it up while I'm talking. Actually, this is like a thing in sociology,
- 39:30right, So we take up so many of the resources of the world.
- 39:36It's like it requires I don't know, one hundred and twenty acres of
- 39:38land on Earth just to support my resource needs, irrespective of what I choose
- 39:45to consume on the margin, it's not it doesn't apply to many, but
- 39:47apology, it applies to you, western educated, industrialized, rich and democratic.
- 39:52I mean, you're rich compared to a lot of other people in the
- 39:55world. Like anyway, carry on, So so like, what of what
- 40:04moment is it if I choose to care about these like I don't want to
- 40:06say I don't care, Like like I said I would, I would love
- 40:08it if you know, all of the games were produced in an environmentally sustainable
- 40:13way. But is that even possible? They got to ship them at some
- 40:15point, right, Like, the most environmentally sustainable thing I can do is
- 40:19die so that I'm not consuming that one hundred and twenty acres worth of resources
- 40:23that was required to support me. Even before we add in the marginal amount
- 40:28of additional resources required to deliver task. Kolar to me, So, do
- 40:31you agree with FBD Isaac Shalev, who says yes, should we yes?
- 40:37Should we care? Yes? Does that rise to the level of moral obligation?
- 40:43No? Well, what is a moral obligation? When so I should
- 40:46care? But moral obligation implies what what is the obligation the obligation if it's
- 40:51a if it's a moral wrong to cease that activity? I guess. Do
- 40:54I get out of this simply by buying games only on the secondary market exclusively?
- 41:00Well, that's my question to you. Board game designer Isaac shally One
- 41:04remove away, But that doesn't that means you're only one removal so by playing
- 41:07the game. So I haven't contributed to the production of the game by buying
- 41:10it from the original manufacturer, right or the reseller. But I have somehow
- 41:15participated in the phenomenon of contributing to that game being okay to have been produced.
- 41:22Right, But this is like a weaker link. How far removed do
- 41:25I need to be? Like? If I find out that a certain game
- 41:28is problematic, then I should just not play it at all. But if
- 41:30everyone opts but every game is going to be problematic if you right raise your
- 41:35standard high enough everyone, If everyone opts to be the weaker link, does
- 41:38the board game industry then not collapse and everyone who's involved in it end up
- 41:45being unemployed? Do I get out of this conundrum by only playing games on
- 41:49like tabletop simulator, simulator and board game arena? Do I get out of
- 41:52this conundrum by only playing games using my imagination? So part of the reason
- 41:57I'm into board games above other types of ludological entertainment. Excuse me. I
- 42:04do play computer games, but none on the extent that I played ball games
- 42:07is because I enjoy the analog nature of them, and I enjoy the fact
- 42:09that I'm in rooms with other people. I was a game night last night.
- 42:14It was very busy, and there was four of us that I missed.
- 42:16How was it? It was great. There was four of us playing
- 42:20a game at a table, but the whole room was full of people,
- 42:22and it was part of being in a room with other people that gave the
- 42:25game I was playing. I would say, in the balance, the contribution
- 42:30that games make to sociality probably outweighs any of the negative consequences that we're talking
- 42:35about. So I think every time I see his name, it angers me
- 42:39because his nickname is not a punt, it's not related to anything. You
- 42:45just came up with it because that was a phrase that came through your head
- 42:47at the time. And now all of the five g fo D dickheads want
- 42:53you to choose their nickname. Is that serrated blade Blade. It's a great
- 42:59nickname. And what annoys me more is a great n that's no meaning.
- 43:04But serrated blade is a very you can cut my bread any day because people
- 43:07maybe at some point, like if he gets a new girlfriend or something,
- 43:12she's looking over his shoulder and she's gonna go, why why your name serrated
- 43:15Blade? Very much like the reaction of your girlfriend who our cool gamer dudes?
- 43:21Yeah, chat group, but that is cool. So I think I
- 43:23think he sort of mirrors what you're saying. There's a deep level of opacity
- 43:28that obscures the manufacturing of anything in this globalized system and makes it incredibly difficult
- 43:32to ensure ethically produced goods. You can look at a board game printed in
- 43:37Europe or the United States and be satisfied that it wasn't printed in a Weiger
- 43:40concentration camp, But where did the raw materials come from. What about the
- 43:44components that went into the machinery that printed the game, or the chemicals or
- 43:47minerals for the dyes used. I think it's impossible for a consumer to truly
- 43:52navigate the morality of this system. Aside from consuming less, that's the only
- 43:57guarantee to cause less exploitation, less environmental Look, the only the only politically
- 44:04correct stance to take is the entire subversion of the system. If you're going
- 44:07to be a fucking proper Marxist, right with living within capitalism and having these
- 44:12play bourgeois attitudes that we should be careful about what we consume changes nothing and
- 44:16does nothing. It actually maintains the prevailing power relations in the world and the
- 44:21class relations if you're like a classical Marxist, and I actually think that's very
- 44:25true. But what about the fact that China loosening their ideals and opening China
- 44:34to markets has lifted tens of millions of people out of poverty. I was
- 44:37about to say exactly that. I think China has probably done more that is
- 44:43positive for a larger proportion of the human race than most Western countries. Now,
- 44:47it doesn't mean I love the Chinese government, and they're starting they're starting
- 44:52from a point of really fucked. Yeah, But if we're gonna have a
- 44:53real conversation about it, it's like saying I'm It's like saying I'm two hundred
- 44:58kilograms and I'm now one hundred and eighty kilograms and I've lost twenty kilograms.
- 45:02That's amazing, but I'm still one hundred and eighty. But this this,
- 45:06this, this is still an incredible achievement. And I'm like, I'm not
- 45:07trying to wind anybody up, but you know, and then there are probably
- 45:10people who'd be like offended by that, and fine, be offended by it,
- 45:14but like, if you want to have a real conversation about it,
- 45:15we have to talk about what we're trying to achieve on behalf of whom,
- 45:20like, uh, is it simply like a utilitarian premise of creating more happiness
- 45:24for as many people as possible or more wealth or whatever. I don't know.
- 45:29I think I probably gonna come down on having a very like Douglas adam
- 45:31Z sort of attitude toward board games. So if you remember the description of
- 45:37the planet Earth and the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy before it was before it
- 45:42was edited. Okay, before it yeah, it was just harmless. Yes,
- 45:47and then they they forward prefect went and he did years of research and
- 45:52added like voluminous content, and in the he chuck his Guide to the Galaxy.
- 45:57He changed to the way I think it got edited down to mostly harmless,
- 46:01and I think this is more or less where I'm going to come down
- 46:04on the topic of board games. So Matt Green exclamation marks says, I
- 46:08like Matt Green. By the way, do you think because he's British,
- 46:13me saying out loud on the show that I like him makes him cringe?
- 46:16Yeah? Sorry about that, Matt. I like you so much that I
- 46:20actually feel bad that I just made you cringe. Fuck, I did it
- 46:22again. He super chatted me on my streaming the day. One of the
- 46:24most amazing things about board games is a form of expressions that the rules of
- 46:29the art, the components are transitory, and the replacement and replaceable once you
- 46:32know the rules. It's important that the game is published once the first time
- 46:37by someone produced somewhere. Then after that anyone wishing to make a moral stand
- 46:42may do so with their own time. And Ink is he is, so
- 46:46he supports big ink is he condoning the reproduction of board games without recompense to
- 46:54the original designer? You think about that way, well, you know,
- 47:00I can only lean I'm gonna I want to throw this back to you because
- 47:02I feel like I'm answering too many of the questions. I can only lean
- 47:06on my like reductio ad absurdum argument here where it's just like, we're not
- 47:09going to find a compromise within the system of capitalism and global production right Like
- 47:15it's an unwinnable game. The only way forward is to like subvert the entire
- 47:21thing somehow. So I remember there was when I was young, in the
- 47:25mid to late nineties, Lars Ulrich got a lot of shit for trying to
- 47:30close down Napster, And of course, because I was a moron, I
- 47:36kind of agreed with him, agreed with the people who were against him.
- 47:39M hmm. But you would agree with him because but there was always a
- 47:45learning to me that never really it never really made sense, because the whole
- 47:49point of Napster was circumventing royalties to because like Napster was like the young and
- 47:54hip thing to do, and Lars was already by that point seeming like a
- 47:58bit of a boomer, right, And as I've got older, the more
- 48:00I've realized that pirating of material is despicable, even and I think, and
- 48:07what we've said, the law basically detached. Can pirate anything you want as
- 48:12long as it's for personal use, and not distribute it. The older I
- 48:16become, and the poorer I become, and the more resolutely a creative person
- 48:23in the creative sphere I become, the more I realize that you need to
- 48:29pay your people, and for most people, I think there's a moral obligation
- 48:34to by gains. I don't think buying on the secondhand market is an issue.
- 48:37I don't think that's an issue, but I think there is a moral
- 48:40obligation to not take the work of others and pirate it, even if it's
- 48:46for your own personal use. You should absolutely buy the copy of the game,
- 48:53buy the book, go to the cinemataity of the movie, because you
- 48:59should be paying the people who create, because if you don't, they will
- 49:01no longer exist. And that's because you, like me, like all of
- 49:06us, like Matt Green, like every dickhead on the discord, has fallen
- 49:09prey to the false consciousness of the capitalists. Believe in the world that we
- 49:15live in Voltaire, regardless of the Voltaire. When he published his works,
- 49:22he actually condoned their piracy, and he participated in it because fucking rich was
- 49:25Voltaire well his he he was not originally he faked aristocracy. You know,
- 49:30you'd appreciate Voltais. So what's really funny is because I'm fucking poor, right,
- 49:35he but his finish, let me finish. I was going first,
- 49:40his his object, and I'm not like saying what you're saying is wrong and
- 49:44you shouldn't feel this way. It's just like it's an interesting difference. His
- 49:46goal was not like support the artists for for whatever reason, because he was
- 49:52already rich is fine, But all his goal was the message. Yes,
- 49:55his spread enlightenment by whatever means necessary, and therefore he was on the of
- 50:00the pirates, which is a luxury of the rich. I'm afraid the point
- 50:04is especially so. The reason I feel bad about asking that I don't but
- 50:09I don't feel bad about receiving is, for instance, the Patreon for this
- 50:15podcast. Right, I have no qualms with putting out stuff for free.
- 50:21That's not an issue. That is the economic model in which I am participating,
- 50:25right, Especially when you start a project, because who knows if anyone's
- 50:30going to want to fucking listen, and you are essentially asserting your stuff onto
- 50:35other people. But I am. This is why I back patreons. I
- 50:40mean, not all of them, but I back patreons. This is why
- 50:44I pay my artists. This is why I don't download shit anymore like I
- 50:50did when I was younger, but my empathy hadn't grown to that extent.
- 50:54Is because I am a believer that we yes, I've bought and the false
- 51:00consciousness of capitalism. But to not buy into the false consciousness of capitalism is
- 51:05to end up sleeping under a fucking bridge. Historical context is important here,
- 51:07Like Voltaire was living at a time of extreme religious repression, and spreading the
- 51:13message actually had real material value. Downloading music or pirating board games or whatever
- 51:20kind of pirating we're talking about today is generally speaking not done on behalf of
- 51:23some higher ethical cause. Now you might imagine the scenario in which it might
- 51:29be, and then I bet you would support it. I bet if there
- 51:30were like some scenario in which the whole issue we're spreading board games to like
- 51:35some benighted population somewhere and it's gonna the whole issue. You would probably be
- 51:39behind that because you're not losing anything that you would have gotten otherwise, and
- 51:43the world is gaining from Like there's a higher virtue that you would support if
- 51:47it wasn't like threatening your livelihood. Right, But the whole issue with piracy
- 51:51is it's simply I want something for free and fuck you, and so what
- 51:55has happened? And I it's piracy in China a good thing though if it
- 52:00somehow contributes to the subversion of that regime, well a fascinating question. Yeah,
- 52:07I don't know. I mean, they're not going to buy that shit
- 52:08anyway. And the reason, like pirates is a huge issue in China,
- 52:12right, yes, powered everything in certain circumstances then maybe sure, we've discovered
- 52:19nuance indeed. But I think it's really really fascinating is we've seen I think
- 52:22Spotify is as good as piracy unless you Taylor Swift basically, and what you've
- 52:30seen I always bang this drama is that we have seen the arts become less
- 52:37and less vibrant. The reason being is because if you look at Britain now
- 52:45and you may scoff at the lowness of the prices, but for Britain.
- 52:51This is this is very high. You will come out at the end of
- 52:53a university course for fifty thousand pounds worth of debt. Right, And what
- 53:00that means is that won't reduce the number of people going to university. But
- 53:04what it will reduce is the number of people taking subjects that are not considered
- 53:08financially viable. So what you will see is a massive peak in business administration
- 53:14degrees and a massive sink in music degrees or theater degrees, I mean the
- 53:20humanities of tanks in America for And so what the only people you said to
- 53:24me maybe the wisest thing I've ever heard, when we were on a bike
- 53:28trip. You said to me once, I wish I had enough money to
- 53:31be a writer, because essentially, even if you're going to be a journalist
- 53:36for the New York Times, you can't. You don't make a lot of
- 53:38money. I know people who sold articles to the New York Times, and
- 53:42the money is fucking live. It used to be a fucking solid, working
- 53:45class profession. And so why do we have a blandification of the arts is
- 53:51because only people from one particular economic strata can participate in them, and they
- 53:55essentially do that. We're returning to We're returning to the seven teenth century where
- 54:00you have gentlemen scientists and gentleman artists because no one can make any fucking money
- 54:05anymore. And this is a direct result of hard piracy and soft piracy.
- 54:10Spotify is soft piracy, right, and we are I think if we have
- 54:15one moral obligation, it is to pay our artists. So only two things
- 54:21to say in response. One is a question, one is a statement.
- 54:23The question is if Spotify is piracy, does that mean Board Game Arena is
- 54:29piracy? So what is fascinating about this is it's things are different. And
- 54:37if you speak to most board game publishers, they will say that featuring their
- 54:45games on Board Game Arena will increase the number of hard copies of games they
- 54:49sell. Do we know that that's true because it's anecdotal. It's only anecdotal.
- 54:52It is people I've spoken to, right, I mean, this is
- 54:55what they say about music, though they have said that about music. But
- 54:58the point is, well, I can tell you how many CDs and vinyls
- 55:02I've bought since I got a subscription to YouTube music. I mean, you
- 55:06can still buy albums, but why would you, Right? Board games are
- 55:09different because they are, they're artistically different. What you do is you play
- 55:13this on Board Game Arena and go, god, I'd love to play that
- 55:15with Bob Johnston. And so you buy the hard copies so you can put
- 55:20it on one of your one of your NPC character exactly. So I'd like
- 55:22to ask the Discord dickheads if playing a game on board Game Arena has ever
- 55:27led you to buy it. I mean, this is like, you know,
- 55:30anecdata, but we can see if it'd be fascinating. And the statement
- 55:34then the statement what statements? So I said, I had a question in
- 55:37a statement, Okay, what's the statement stratum? You said strata referring to
- 55:44one I choose not to follow the laws of Latin, Severin says. But
- 55:49about the use of automation, the political stance of publishers and designers, I
- 55:52think we should engage critically, as that really does form the future of our
- 55:55hobby and its contents. We don't need to cut off those we disagree with
- 55:59politically, but we all too approach that output critically and for AI and such,
- 56:04feel free, I guess, but don't expect me to pay the same
- 56:07for you as a product. I would pay for any any media made by
- 56:09actual crafts people. So I'm a little bit lost. So he's saying that,
- 56:15he's saying we should engage with people we disagree with politically, not just
- 56:20cancel them, okay, and then secondly saying, use ai, you can't
- 56:23though, this is the problem like that that that's the kind of thing that
- 56:27only a person on one side of the political spectrum would say, because like
- 56:30people like far right, far right whack jobs you can't engage with. Of
- 56:36course far life whack jobs you can't engage with. You. Yeah, you
- 56:37know this is true. This is true, Like of course if we should
- 56:40all like want to engage with one another, but like it isn't feasible anymore.
- 56:45And it's like precisely because of what like social media the world engage on
- 56:50what basics, We don't engage with people face to face, which would which
- 56:53would result in hopefully nuanced engagements. This is like engaged with people on bloody
- 56:58social This is like engaging with people who believe in fucking aliens and fucking crabs,
- 57:01and that exists the medium. They don't exist anyway. So see the
- 57:06hunter says, and I've chosen this for one reason because I want to highlight
- 57:10a points that has been hammered home to me in the last few years.
- 57:15For me, the result is that our duty is almost one of love,
- 57:20respect and listening and engagement with the other. Is this going to be some
- 57:22kind of Kureker Guardian argument? I don't he likes he likes leving Us,
- 57:27I think and no idea. That means we do philosophers. That means we
- 57:30do not have to refrain from buying phile Eckland games just because he's a tossa.
- 57:34But we can move towards a societal system that creates more justice and less
- 57:37ignorance. Okay, I want to talk about that, because can I just
- 57:40fucking play games and I think about this shit? Well, okay, you're
- 57:44a podcast of love, so I want to talk about this, right.
- 57:47I have been doing the show for five years, and I have spoken to
- 57:52over one hundred I don't know how many shows I've done at this point.
- 57:54I mean everybody differently. Over You've spoken to everybody, and I have spoken
- 57:59to many people, and I have engaged with many people like ryaner Kinitzia multiple
- 58:05times. Yeah, Alan Moon, Alan Moon, Matt leekak clouds. They're
- 58:13already listening it's not. But I have spoken to people I did hear that
- 58:20I have spoken. I have spoken to people who on Twitter are very worthy
- 58:27and when I've engaged with them, and I'm obviously I wouldn't be classless enough
- 58:30to mention now, but when I've engaged with them, I've come across as
- 58:36what's the best way to describe it? I got the distinct and I'm may
- 58:38be wrong, but I got the distinct impression is of who the fuck are
- 58:44you? I'm this top person and who the fuck are you? Especially who
- 58:50the fuck are you to ask me these particular questions? Who the fuck are
- 58:52you to take up my time I've had I thought like most of these people
- 58:57would be much more down to earth. I've had people send me emails during
- 59:00the interview, going, we really need to hurry this up. Really,
- 59:05yes, Phil Eklund? How often does ULLI do that in every episode?
- 59:12So Phil Ecklan Phil Eckland, for instance, I interviewed him, and I've
- 59:15had grief for interviewing him, which blows my mind. But Phil Ecklund was
- 59:19not only one of the politest and most gracious people I've ever interviewed, he
- 59:23was one of the most enthusiastic and one of the most open and honest right
- 59:29now, I think we have this. I think we need to understand when
- 59:36it comes to morality, local morality and macro morality. I'm mixing my metaphors
- 59:42here, but there's this idea that if you say something that people, if
- 59:45you say though politically that they don't agree with, that makes you a terrible
- 59:50person. I don't agree with Phil Eckland on a lot of what he says
- 59:53politically, but I can tell you on the local level between two people,
- 59:58he's highly respectful and highly morally what's the word I'm looking for, morally upstanding?
- 1:00:07And so I think we have this big problem about separating what people say
- 1:00:15from what people are. So a great example near my girlfriend's place is a
- 1:00:19nightclub, right, and they're all very lefty, and they're all very pro
- 1:00:22environmental. Like all the nightclubs or near your girlfriend's place, they're very they're
- 1:00:28very lefty, they're very pro environmental, they're very pro LGB, all of
- 1:00:31these sorts of things, right people, what people would say, we're on
- 1:00:35the moral side. Yet every Friday, every Saturday morning, when I go
- 1:00:39to take the train, the whole area is covered in shit broken bottles,
- 1:00:45Chris Packets fag ends all of this shit right, And so what you see
- 1:00:50is a performative moral virtue and a local moral virtue that is completely completely absent.
- 1:00:57They just don't give they give a shit about these great ideas, and
- 1:01:00they don't give a shit about the people. I experienced this too, you're
- 1:01:04called during the pandemic. Something I did to sort of, you know,
- 1:01:07pass the time and contributed it back to the software development community. I ran
- 1:01:12a meet up and I had a series of guests that I didn't interview them.
- 1:01:15They just did presentations on like whatever they wanted, and I was the
- 1:01:19host. And one of these guests was controversial in the community, but like
- 1:01:24someone that I knew personally very well, and he had some opinions that like
- 1:01:29I may or may not have agreed with them, but I think that he
- 1:01:30had an undeserved reputation. But because he had that reputation, I got no
- 1:01:36end of shit on Twitter at the time for having him as a guest.
- 1:01:39And then future of people who I had was trying to line up told me
- 1:01:43that if he was going to appear, they didn't even want to come on,
- 1:01:45And I got sub tweeted, and people they said, like, I
- 1:01:49can't believe, like this is the shittiest you know, meet up in Berlin
- 1:01:52for doing this. Right. Meanwhile, the guy, the guy that I
- 1:01:57had on as a guest, he has never been anything other than like the
- 1:02:00picture of like graciousness and gratitude. He like he paid for me to visit
- 1:02:06a conference in Boulder, Colorado. More than once, he's given me paid
- 1:02:09work to do. He's always been like a kind, generous person. And
- 1:02:14yes he has opinions about things, but he's not a dickhead about them,
- 1:02:19as far as I can tell, or as far as I think, so
- 1:02:22like I can disagree with him, and except that he's like not a heart,
- 1:02:24like a human being that I have to totally write off. And like,
- 1:02:28this is what canceling is about. Right, Let's like, let's throw
- 1:02:30away everything that is good about anybody if they simply have a few positions that
- 1:02:35we don't like because social media has reduced us all to bumper stickers. All
- 1:02:38right, on that very clean but figured it all out, Then let's move
- 1:02:43on to in an act of willful competition, we present our You're not like
- 1:02:52to Picculey, who is your poster of the month, Steve Olizios. Can
- 1:02:58I pick that guy that said all those complimentary things about me that one time?
- 1:03:01Well, the guy who said I tried to listen to the episode but
- 1:03:05Steve kept interrupting Ben so much. No, no, no, no,
- 1:03:07not that one. Not that one, because he's my poster of the week
- 1:03:12every week. The one who listened to my interview and said, like,
- 1:03:15I can't believe how how intelligent this guy is. Did he comments on this
- 1:03:20episode? He might have, He might have, So I do I have
- 1:03:23to choose from among the ones that you every months we do this. So
- 1:03:28who who is the one who said the things about we can't possibly know,
- 1:03:31like the production details of China Show? You must know? That was it?
- 1:03:36Matt Serrated blade Coats. It was Matt Serrated blade Coats. I'm gonna
- 1:03:38go with Matt Serrated blade Coats, not only for having the coolest nickname,
- 1:03:42for making astute point that I used even before we talked about that point itself.
- 1:03:46All right, so it's all points with Matt Serrated blade Coats. Post
- 1:03:51of the Month is Matt Serrated Blake Coats. That was our All right,
- 1:04:00let's wrap this up because we've been going too long? How do you join
- 1:04:02the Discord, Steve, So you go to five gfod dot com. You
- 1:04:06don't need to fucking spend your whole afternoon typing in five games for Doomsday.
- 1:04:13If you're like Ben and you try to type in a number of character like
- 1:04:15that long of a fucking string of characters, you're not gonna get to the
- 1:04:19end of that making at least three typos. Just make it short and sweet,
- 1:04:23five G, four D Numbers and letters dot com. That will lead
- 1:04:28you to Ben's blog website website which is like a blog right, well,
- 1:04:32I haven't paid the money to get it. It's like a word Press site
- 1:04:35of sword Press. And there's gonna be a post pin to the top of
- 1:04:39the page of that of that site. It's gonna have an invite link to
- 1:04:42the Discord. You could already have a nickname as cool as Matt serrated blade
- 1:04:47coats if you click on that link and go there. No, that's not
- 1:04:50how you get any name anyway. So you can contribute to the Patreon at
- 1:04:54Patreon dot com slash five G for D and next month get a cool nickname
- 1:04:59like Matt surraya blade code. And also, if you if you're the kind
- 1:05:01of person who sits in Starbucks on an Apple an Apple device. What's what's
- 1:05:06the name of the laptop MacBook Pro, MacBook of any kind, MacBook Player
- 1:05:12Pro with a sticker saying smash capitalism on it? Yep. And you want
- 1:05:15to change the world? What how could you change it? By going to
- 1:05:18tunes? You can you can leave a five star review. I think the
- 1:05:21Google play store probably has has a similar Google podcast, so it's not an
- 1:05:27issue. We want. We want five star reviews wherever you can put them.
- 1:05:30Yep. Please. And finally, I'd like to say I don't like
- 1:05:34it in the shilling, so I'm glad you do it. I'd like to
- 1:05:36say thank you to everyone who's contributed. It's been a very interesting show this
- 1:05:41week. I'd like to thank Stephen Syrek. You're welcome, my co host,
- 1:05:45and if you want to feature on this show, you want to have
- 1:05:48your points exultated, and you can go join the discord and when I put
- 1:05:58up the question you can comment to So I'd just like to say thank you
- 1:06:02to Matt s Rate, to Blake cot our post of the week, Steven
- 1:06:04Syrek and the rest of you. That was hashtag channel good job. Without
- 1:06:18you, this show wouldn't exist, so really, you're to blame, so
- 1:06:24thank you for listening and oil up your ears for the next hashtag channel.