Latest / WonkyFolk / Vol 12 - A Rising Tide Lifts All Wonks
Transcript
- 0:02Jed: Hey, Andy, how you doing?
- 0:03Andy: Hey, Jed, what's up?
- 0:05Jed: Not a whole lot, you know, in my deck of the world woods, but there's
- 0:11sure a lot going on in education policy and charter school policy.
- 0:14Liked your post today on the latest piece of scores and all those things,
- 0:19lots of stuff we could dive into.
- 0:21Andy: You're dating us already for listeners.
- 0:23So we record.
- 0:24We're recording this on a Friday.
- 0:26It'll come out sometime next week.
- 0:27So who knows what'll happen between now and then.
- 0:30So you have to take everything with that, with that caveat.
- 0:33Jed: But, I thought that maybe we would dive in today having a visitor
- 0:38from Fordham, who's just finished a great new piece on the effect of
- 0:43competition in the charter school space.
- 0:45So any other introductory comments you want at the end,
- 0:50you want to just dive into stuff.
- 0:52Andy: Well, if I don't think that's a good idea, it's a little late now, right?
- 0:56Jed: Yeah, stop it.
- 0:57Stop.
- 0:57If you've got something else on your mind, whatever I, you know,
- 1:01Andy: No, I think it's actually, it's a really interesting study.
- 1:05It's good to have a guest, although people seem to really like the last, I got a
- 1:07lot of feedback on the last podcast.
- 1:09But I think it's great to have a guest and I'm super glad that this particular
- 1:13person was able to take time of the study just came out this week, was able to take
- 1:16time out of their busy week to join us.
- 1:19Jed: Let's bring David in.
- 1:20David Griffith is joining us, who has written several reports now for Fordham.
- 1:26David, thank you for being with us today.
- 1:28David: Hey guys, thanks so much for having me.
- 1:31Andy: And David, that is a fantastic house you have.
- 1:33What is Mike paying you guys over there now?
- 1:36David: This is my whole house in DC.
- 1:39Everything that you see is a hundred feet away.
- 1:43Jed: Well, I already asked him before we started recording whether he
- 1:46plays piano and he doesn't, right?
- 1:48So, that piano looks like it needs to be used by somebody in the family there.
- 1:54Andy: That makes two of us.
- 1:55Do you play an instrument, Jed?
- 1:57Jed: I was just saying that my grandmother sent me her grand in the
- 2:00last year of her life, remembering that when I was eight years old, I played
- 2:03piano and not knowing that I'd given up piano playing for like 25 years.
- 2:09So I got it and I felt so shamed by it.
- 2:11I got some lessons and now I play well enough to irritate the neighbors.
- 2:16Andy: That's fantastic, though.
- 2:18My wife's a very good musician.
- 2:20She's in a band and so forth and like.
- 2:22But I am, she's one of these very musical people.
- 2:25I am not.
- 2:26So, like, when we do, like, our concerts and stuff, I do the business and logistics
- 2:29side because I, you know, everyone's saying, you talk to musicians, they're
- 2:32like, it's not true that everyone can't be a musician or has two left feet or
- 2:35whatever, but I actually think it is.
- 2:37I'm living proof.
- 2:38My lived experience is that's actually true.
- 2:41David: I'm good at listening to music, guys.
- 2:43Andy: Yeah, exactly.
- 2:44Consuming it.
- 2:46Jed: Well, I could go on on piano playing forever, but let's dive into,
- 2:51you know, David, your new report.
- 2:53Look, I've just liked how Fordham has kept the All Boats Rising
- 2:58story a central piece that you're coming back to again and again.
- 3:03If I recall, Your all boats rising or something titled something similar
- 3:08to that came out in like 2019.
- 3:11I think it was a great piece.
- 3:14I am constantly reminding charter folk that, you know, we need to be
- 3:18able to talk about how all of public education is improving as we grow.
- 3:24It's so important that I think the other side knows that the counter
- 3:29narrative is their most valuable one.
- 3:31I think in Massachusetts, when question two was voted down, basically the voters,
- 3:36after the fact, we did an autopsy.
- 3:39They bought that charter schools in Massachusetts were actually doing a
- 3:42better job with kids, but they had been convinced that the growth of charter
- 3:45schools somehow makes all other schools worse, and so they voted it down.
- 3:49And for me, all of our advocacy has to pass the question two test.
- 3:53Yes, we're doing a great job with kids, but as we're growing, everything
- 3:56is getting better and the competition piece is one of these, these
- 4:01ideas about how things get better.
- 4:03And now you've come out with this new report, which really focuses
- 4:06on, focuses in on competition.
- 4:07Why don't you share with our listeners to begin with, you know, what's the study?
- 4:11What are the main findings and what you think the significance is?
- 4:15David: Yeah, well, thanks so much for that sort of segue and
- 4:20laying the table like that.
- 4:22The gist of the study is that we wanted to look as comprehensively as possible at the
- 4:30level of competition that school districts around the country are facing and in
- 4:35particular the big school districts and there's obviously a lot of overlap between
- 4:39competition and school choice, but we chose competition as our lens because it's
- 4:44very very hard to quantify school choice comprehensively as i'm sure the two of you
- 4:47know there are so many different kinds.
- 4:49We don't have sort of universal access to student level data that
- 4:53allows us to follow kids, you know, wherever they're going.
- 4:56So basically you can't quantify school choice comprehensively,
- 5:00but if you limit yourself to places, you know, to homeschooling.
- 5:05to charter schools and to private schools, which are sort of these truly independent
- 5:10institutions that are not creatures of the district then you can make a run at it.
- 5:15And so that's what we tried to do.
- 5:17To my knowledge, nobody has really tried to do this before.
- 5:21But we tried to tell the story in the 125 biggest districts in the country
- 5:25of how many kids were not attending district schools, how that number varied
- 5:33depending on which group you belong to and how it had changed over time.
- 5:37And there are four big findings, but I think the one that I don't
- 5:42want to overlook is the first one, and that is basically, that the
- 5:47death of traditional public schools has been greatly exaggerated.
- 5:51There is this media narrative, and I identify center left, but it
- 5:55is a media narrative, right, that public schools are dying, right?
- 6:02And as with so many stories, there's sort of a grain of truth to that, right?
- 6:08But it also is exaggerated.
- 6:10And so when you look at the biggest school districts in the country, despite
- 6:15the growth of charter schools, despite the growth of voucher programs, despite
- 6:18the growth of homeschooling, you know, your typical big district, 80 percent
- 6:22of kids are still, still, still, attending traditional public schools.
- 6:28And so all of the sort of Sturm and Drang that surrounds school choice is really
- 6:33about the move from about 15 percent to about 20 percent of kids who are not in
- 6:40your standard issue district run school, so it's just, you know, it's overblown.
- 6:45And if you take the view that competition is good, that choice is good then
- 6:51we still have a lot of work to do.
- 6:55Andy: Okay.
- 6:56So, staying on that for a second, I do think that's really interesting.
- 6:59We'll get like, but let's just stay on that thought for a second.
- 7:01I think a parlor game you're hearing more and more with this, because you do
- 7:05have some places that are now saturated with choice and people are like, Oh
- 7:08my God, this guy's going to fall.
- 7:09But like among like serious analysts, a parlor game that you hear a lot is okay.
- 7:13Like in a really saturated environment.
- 7:16So with like ESAs, charters, some significant penetration of private
- 7:21and parochial schools, like what number do you actually expect to see?
- 7:26And if you ask sort of, you ask that question on Twitter, people are like,
- 7:29Oh my God, public schools are dying.
- 7:30only 10 percent of the kids will be left.
- 7:32But like in reality.
- 7:33People who study this are giving really pretty high numbers, which doesn't
- 7:37mean that's not a problem from a school finance standpoint or won't be disruptive,
- 7:40but it's not the bottom falling out.
- 7:42So say, just say a little bit more about that cause I think that's
- 7:44like just a super important piece of context here just to start with.
- 7:49David: Yeah.
- 7:49So let me just say, first of all, I don't have the magic number, right?
- 7:54I don't think we really know how many parents are truly, truly dissatisfied
- 8:02with their traditional public school to the point where they would walk?
- 8:05And I think, I think the answer really, it depends so much on context, right?
- 8:10It depends on, like, are the alternatives fully funded, right?
- 8:13Or are you going to take a hit in your pocketbook, right?
- 8:17I mean, is there a, is there sort of a culture of school choice that has
- 8:20existed for a decade and a half, right?
- 8:22I mean, to some people, the idea is scary or strange, right?
- 8:25But it's not to people in Arizona, right?
- 8:27It's not to people in DC or Louisiana.
- 8:29So there's a sort of acculturation piece to it as well.
- 8:33just to sort of put some context on it though.
- 8:35I mean, I think folks in the field understand that at this point, New Orleans
- 8:39is for all practical purposes, right?
- 8:42A hundred percent school choice, whatever you want to call it.
- 8:46After that, right, you've got, uh, D.
- 8:49C.
- 8:49which is maybe at about 50%, right?
- 8:53Detroit, San Antonio is higher than people think.
- 8:57But your standard, your standard district is still somewhere in
- 9:02the low 20s or the teens, right?
- 9:04And I personally, I just find it hard to believe that if you really
- 9:09put all schools or all options on an equal playing field, right?
- 9:15That 80 percent of parents would pick, you know, their sort of district run school.
- 9:22if charters had full access to facilities funds, right?
- 9:26If, you know, per people funding were identical, if you had sort of a good
- 9:31centralized enrollment system that was easy to use that didn't, you know,
- 9:35sort of implicitly preference, just doing what everybody else was doing.
- 9:39I just find it very hard to believe that 20 percent is the ceiling.
- 9:42So I don't know what the ceiling is but I don't think it's 20%.
- 9:47Andy: So I think I get another way to say it might be like, if you have that off of
- 9:51that environment, enrollment will be less than it is now, but it will probably not
- 9:53be as catastrophic as the naysayers claim.
- 9:58David: Yeah.
- 9:58So look, there are some, I think there are some hard, like, let's be real here.
- 10:02Right.
- 10:02Transportation is an issue, right?
- 10:04When you get out of the ivory tower and you talk to like actual parents,
- 10:08they don't particularly want to drive an hour and a half across.
- 10:12town just to go to a school that maybe scores at the 62nd percentile
- 10:18for school growth instead of the 60, you know, instead of the 60th, right?
- 10:24Like nobody's going to do that.
- 10:25And so I, you know, I do think that the sort of end state may have a fair number
- 10:31of traditional public schools in it.
- 10:33Um, but I don't think it's 80%.
- 10:36Yeah.
- 10:36Okay.
- 10:37That's good.
- 10:37I don't want to, I don't want to believe, but I think it's this important
- 10:39context because This debate can quickly get, like, you know, unhinged
- 10:44or hysterical around, like, school choice, and I do, I don't know that
- 10:48we're playing between the 40 yard lines, but we're definitely not playing
- 10:50between the, you know, the whole field.
- 10:54Jed: David, can you talk a little bit more about the effect of competition?
- 10:57This was a part of the the study and you basically did a survey of the field
- 11:01and you showed that the vast majority of research seems to suggest that competition
- 11:05is in fact, as common sense would suggest a positive force within public education.
- 11:11But I think it's 1 that we have to keep revisiting because there are
- 11:14some people out there that would identify competition within public
- 11:18education as being the big boogeyman that we want to try and keep out.
- 11:21However, we possibly can.
- 11:26Andy: Just quickly, I think that's really important.
- 11:27I want to talk about that real quick for me when I had a chance to read it yet.
- 11:31Like when I'm at the top 125 and so forth, just give us, I mean, I think people think
- 11:35of like a New York, LA, Chicago, but a lot of these districts are not necessarily.
- 11:39So just.
- 11:39people haven't had a chan just kind of understand what are we talking about here?
- 11:44David: Yeah, so Colombus makes the cut, right?
- 11:49So it's true, but there's a very quick falling off after the top 5 to 10
- 11:54districts start talking about a lot came.
- 11:56Andy: That's the least we
- 12:01David: He went patrolling and I cannot escape from football talk.
- 12:06Yeah, I mean, so we're talking about a lot of like medium sized districts, right?
- 12:10Inner ring suburbs like Arlington, Fairfax, you know, Wake, it's
- 12:17not necessarily Chicago, right?
- 12:20So, but it's not small towns either.
- 12:24Andy: Great.
- 12:25And then obviously to Jed, so the Jed's question, if I had a competition and
- 12:27you guys have a lot, the demographic breakouts, I think are super interesting.
- 12:31David: Yeah.
- 12:32Well, let me just, let me speak a little bit to just the research on competition.
- 12:35I like any literature, right?
- 12:37It is nuanced when you really start to dig into it.
- 12:40So I will try to summarize it without doing too much violence
- 12:43to that or going on for an hour.
- 12:47Overall, the research is positive.
- 12:51Somewhat interestingly, at least to me, it's actually more positive
- 12:54for vouchers and for private school choice than it is for charters.
- 12:59And I think there's a reason for that, and, or at least this is
- 13:04where my gut feeling is on it.
- 13:06I think that there are probably some transition costs associated with
- 13:12dropping an entirely new school into a community that hasn't had it before.
- 13:17And so I think, you know, when you're talking about like, a sort of a
- 13:21smaller suburban, or rural district, there could be some transition costs.
- 13:27But I think over a 10 year time period, right?
- 13:31I think, which is kind of what many of the studies are looking at.
- 13:36I think there's just no question that competition on average is positive.and
- 13:43I think it's also really important to just note, like people, you say
- 13:47competition and people, you know, they picture like, I don't know, some
- 13:51sort of cutthroat test factory, right?
- 13:53But there's no reason that you only have to compete.
- 13:56over tests, right?
- 13:58I mean, you can compete to see how safe your school is, right?
- 14:01You can compete to see how nurturing it is, right?
- 14:04You can compete to see who has the most fun recess, right?
- 14:08So that's kind of where I always start, is like, look, when we talk
- 14:12about competition, Rationally, most parents, I mean, most parents do
- 14:18not care about test scores, right?
- 14:20What they care about are these other things, right?
- 14:23Is it a kind of place where you'd want to send your kid, right?
- 14:26And so rationally, when you're in competition, right, with
- 14:31another school, you should want to make your school attractive.
- 14:35Based on those metrics, right?
- 14:36You should want to make it, a place that anyone would want
- 14:39to send their kid, right?
- 14:41And so, I think it's important to try to get past , this sort of very
- 14:46sterile view of competition as just kind of inherently dehumanizing.
- 14:52I don't think that's true at all.
- 14:56Jed: I think I bring some advocacy lens to this that may not be right to spend
- 15:02too much time on for this conversation, but something I think is a reality
- 15:06is that in some, at least some places, um, where the establishment has huge,
- 15:12huge power, they essentially believe that they don't have to compete.
- 15:17That they can literally just stop.
- 15:19So when a UTLA strike happens in Los Angeles, they can basically say,
- 15:25we refuse to compete and we got the political power to make sure that there
- 15:31will be no further competition here.
- 15:33And so, you know, I think it's a different orientation that a lot of, you know,
- 15:38these establishment protectors are taking at this point, which is we refuse to
- 15:42compete with you and we're not going to.
- 15:45And until we can, like, figure out a theory of change.
- 15:50That again still results in, you know, all boats rising where we
- 15:55don't necessarily have a cooperative partner who's willing to like compete
- 15:59in a very traditional type sense.
- 16:01you know, I think our world is not going to have the bearings that we
- 16:05need to win the advocacy fights of the next, you know, next decade.
- 16:11Andy: And this is hard to do, right?
- 16:12So like.
- 16:14The tie the last part of the conversation this part saying you said
- 16:17like it's new entries and so forth.
- 16:19It's hard.
- 16:19We're working Bella is working in Texas.
- 16:21We're creating 25, working with existing and new providers.
- 16:25There are 25 new charters.
- 16:28It'll be either a, you know, A or B charters and their accountability system.
- 16:33And it's just, it's a ton of work.
- 16:35I think there's also like, this idea that it's like.
- 16:38Even this far in that it's like easy to open schools and all this.
- 16:42And so like getting to competition and building like
- 16:45high quality schools is hard.
- 16:47People respond differently to competition.
- 16:49I mean, you, you were saying the literature is complicated and I do, I
- 16:51think it's the idea that schools just immediately respond, like this is a
- 16:54very political context, which I think points to the third thing that I wanted
- 16:59to ask you about is the politics.
- 17:00So like I looked and not surprisingly.
- 17:04Schools in Virginia don't fare well on that.
- 17:06Cause we don't like, Virginia's not a strong school choice state.
- 17:09There was an article in the times recently that was like, basically
- 17:12saying like if Republicans had done well in the, in the Virginia's midterm
- 17:15election, like there was something gonna be a lot of choice, which is just.
- 17:19It's one of those things people say, but it's actually not true.
- 17:22If you understand the political demographics of the state,
- 17:25Texas is the same way.
- 17:26They've had this huge fight over school choice.
- 17:29So like, what are your inferences just in terms of like States you would
- 17:33think would be stronger on choice, but are simply where it's like,
- 17:37it's still like a huge uphill fight.
- 17:42David: Yeah, well, I don't have all the answers, let me just say that right
- 17:46up front, I completely agree in one sense, like, there's this sort of mystery
- 17:51when you look at the states that have seen a lot of charter growth or a lot
- 17:55of vouchers, I mean, it's not obviously red states or blue states, right?
- 17:58I mean, the last states that don't have, charter schools, for example,
- 18:03are places like Nebraska and Montana, and so those are not blue states.
- 18:12So what's going on?
- 18:13I think, I, I'm not sure I want to tackle that so much as, as I want
- 18:18to address your question of like how we should view strategy and the
- 18:22fight moving forward and where we should really be putting our eggs.
- 18:26My personal take, right.
- 18:28Is that.
- 18:29Moving forward, it is largely a defensive effort, and this may not be
- 18:32true in Virginia, sorry, but outside, in other places, you take Texas, right?
- 18:38Texas has a pretty strong charter school law at this point.
- 18:41It has an enormous Latino population, right?
- 18:45And if you look at the numbers, that is the place where the saturation
- 18:48narrative has the least traction, right?
- 18:50I mean, it's just obvious that there is room for growth there.
- 18:55And so what do we need to do in Texas?
- 18:56Well, mostly we need to prevent any legislative rollback, right?
- 19:00And we need to keep doing what we're doing and the charter of school
- 19:06movement will continue to grow.
- 19:08And so that's sort of, It's a boring answer, right?
- 19:12In some sense, but one of my pet peeves is the way that the funding community
- 19:17and the reform community and all these people who frankly, make money by
- 19:23talking, right, tend to be attracted to the next shiny thing, right?
- 19:29When in reality, the most important thing we can do might be to, you
- 19:33know, just keep doing what we're doing, right, and, and execute.
- 19:37And so I, that's sort of, for me, part of the point of the report, part of where I
- 19:41come from to this, is like, look, we made a lot of progress between 2010 and 2020.
- 19:47And then all hell broke loose, right, and we had this sort of world
- 19:50changing pandemic, and everybody, you know, has a different haircut now.
- 19:54Right?
- 19:55And we're all trying to get our bearings again.
- 19:57And it's understandable that we've sort of lost the plot a
- 20:00little bit as a result of that.
- 20:01But guess what?
- 20:03We made a lot of progress between 2010 and 2020.
- 20:06And let's get back to that, right?
- 20:08Let's just keep doing the thing that we were doing because it's not about some,
- 20:13you know, great innovative new idea.
- 20:15It's just about doing the things that we know work.
- 20:17Right?
- 20:17And so that's why I personally come from, there are some big States
- 20:21where there's a lot of headroom.
- 20:22And if we can just, keep things from going off track, I think
- 20:26we can keep making progress.
- 20:28Andy: Well, that's basically one of Jen.
- 20:29That's one of our themes.
- 20:30There's always new opportunities waiting around, around the
- 20:33corner, waiting to meet you.
- 20:35So, but talk a little bit more, if you would about like
- 20:40strategy then for advocates.
- 20:42So you're saying execution, the forward of the report talks about, well, okay.
- 20:46Like this is probably a roadmap, but like, if you're thinking in terms of
- 20:50advocacy, which obviously, you know, Jed thinks about all the time, like
- 20:56maybe these states that are in these places that are sort of deserts, they're
- 20:59deserts for a reason, and so you ought to be doubling down on the places with
- 21:03the strong laws and that your strategy should be going to places where there's
- 21:09a more fertile opportunity, or should it be, okay, this is a roadmap to places
- 21:14where there's not a lot of competition, particularly, I don't want to lose, I want
- 21:17to come back to some of the demographic stuff, particularly for kids who often
- 21:20are most underserved by schools today.
- 21:23So that's that is the place to go have that fight.
- 21:26David: Yeah, I think you can argue it either way.
- 21:28I think the most obvious opportunities are in sort of districts that
- 21:33are sort of school choice deserts within states that have strong laws.
- 21:39So, you know, I mean, personally, I was surprised when I looked at
- 21:41Arizona, for example, I my sort of in the back of my head, right?
- 21:45I'm always seeing that long list of school choice programs in Arizona.
- 21:49I just assume Arizona is super saturated.
- 21:52It's not clear that it is.
- 21:53If you look at the number, right, if you actually look at the
- 21:55numbers, it's not clear that it is.
- 21:56And I think that's probably also true of places like Florida
- 22:01that are growing so quickly.
- 22:02It's like, there's no way that the school choice movement could possibly keep up.
- 22:05Right.
- 22:06I think there are a lot of sort of hidden, I don't want to call them hidden
- 22:12gems, but I think there are a lot of places that we've overlooked particularly
- 22:17in sort of inner ring suburbs that are, there's plenty of headroom left
- 22:24and I, I do, I think it's the places where, choice is, um, happening, but
- 22:30it's not happening everywhere and it's not happening as much as it could.
- 22:33Andy: Jed, what about you?
- 22:34Let's turn, let's turn the tables.
- 22:37That's the question.
- 22:40Jed: Well, I mean, look, I think that the story in places like Texas, where
- 22:46people presume that that everything is rosy for charter schools, that
- 22:50is actually not been the case.
- 22:52And they have struggled to get new charters approved at the state board and
- 22:58they've had cities that have been blocking the building of new school buildings
- 23:02and the association tries to run charter friendly legislation in the state capital.
- 23:10And who is it that kills it, but 25 Republicans.
- 23:13So they had to build the political strength, and they changed, you
- 23:17know, who, what those Republicans.
- 23:19We're in the legislature and now they're able, you know, to get bills through the
- 23:24legislature and they're, and they've also won elections at the state board race.
- 23:28So, yes, I think Texas is perhaps ready to step into that space where we can
- 23:33have the pace of growth that I think parents actually demand but it requires
- 23:40diligence, even in the red states.
- 23:42And when we talk about Arizona, I mean, Arizona is fascinating . They projected
- 23:46that their voucher program was going to cost 65 million bucks a year, and now it's
- 23:50projected at 900 million, 900 million.
- 23:54That's how many additional people.
- 23:55Now, some of it is just the people that were already in private
- 23:59school are just getting a subsidy and all that kind of piece.
- 24:01But, you know, I think we see that, you know, there are a
- 24:06huge, there's huge demand there.
- 24:08The question is, can we get the breakthrough, you know, policy
- 24:12changes that we want and then do those policy changes actually
- 24:15increase competition and choice?
- 24:17Because you could argue that hey you let universal vouchers happen, but
- 24:22people can top it off with you know additional tuition payments and they
- 24:25can screen out special ed kids like they can in arizona and they're going
- 24:30to screen out low performing kids.
- 24:32Well, You know, it may very well be that the kids that were most focused
- 24:37on getting better opportunities to are actually going to be given new
- 24:41choice and new competition with the new things that we're bringing forward.
- 24:46Andy: Let's stay on that because I thought that was some of
- 24:47those interesting overlays.
- 24:49You did, David.
- 24:50Like looking at the demographics.
- 24:52I think one of the things that really came through, you know,
- 24:55it's another one of these places.
- 24:57And there are way too many of them where the rhetoric around the
- 25:01sector and all these debates is like equity and equity commitments.
- 25:05And then you look at how these policies play out and you're like
- 25:07the kids who need this the most.
- 25:09So in particular, you know, low income kids, black kids, Hispanic kids, who
- 25:13are most underserved special ed kids, as well, as Jed mentioned aren't
- 25:19actually seeing the benefits of this.
- 25:20And it seemed like there's a lot of places where there's a lot of
- 25:23competition for upmarket white kids.
- 25:26And so, like, talk about that.
- 25:28Because that is given, like the rhetoric we hear from all the foundations
- 25:32and what everybody cares about.
- 25:33And then you see this disconnect.
- 25:35It's curious.
- 25:37David: Yeah, well, I think there is a sense that with the growth of
- 25:45like the charter school movement and private school choice that
- 25:48we've equalized the playing field,
- 25:51and we haven't.
- 25:53That's the short version.
- 25:55If you look in the typical big district, you see a very old, very familiar story,
- 26:04which is that white kids have more access to alternatives, in large part
- 26:10because they have more access to private schools, one assumes, because they
- 26:17have more, wealth or income, right?
- 26:20And this is where the school choice movement gets a lot of
- 26:23its moral force, and it's a deep and powerful and important point.
- 26:30And I don't want to oversell it because we have made progress.
- 26:33And actually, if you look at figure one in the report, you can see that we are
- 26:38close nationally, to actually closing the gap between white kids and black kids.
- 26:44But then when you look in within these big districts, it actually looks different.
- 26:47And I'd actually want to dig into that more, cause I thought that was sort
- 26:51of intriguing, but when you look in the big districts often, you see that,
- 26:56that it's not, you know, we haven't achieved anything resembling equality,
- 26:59but a picture is worth a thousand words.
- 27:02That's part of why we did the report, honestly, is because you can
- 27:05say this, but people don't really get it unless they see the image.
- 27:08And so, you know, I would encourage people to go on the report page.
- 27:11I think I'd be remiss if I didn't tout the report a little bit, we have these great
- 27:16graphics, and they allow you to look at every big district in the country, for
- 27:21every major demographic group, and you can see exactly what I'm talking about.
- 27:25And you can see how, you know, access to sort of alternative schools either
- 27:30has or hasn't, been equalized over time.
- 27:34And you can even look within particular groups.
- 27:39Jed: Do you have any suggestions, David, on how we should be thinking
- 27:42about the design of future choice programs such that, you know, we can
- 27:47actually get more of the low income African American and Latino kids?
- 27:52I mean, it seems to me as though the way that we design ESAs and
- 27:56vouchers really matters a lot, and we're at this moment where a lot
- 28:00of new ones are getting approved.
- 28:01I also think there are new things that we can be doing in terms of,
- 28:04you know, stimulating the creation of charter schools that would actually
- 28:08be attractive to a larger percentage of middle class and white parents.
- 28:12It just hasn't historically been a huge focus for us.
- 28:15What are you thinking about, you know, the right things to be focusing
- 28:18on terms of getting the right mix of choice and competition right now?
- 28:24David: Yeah, there are tradeoffs.
- 28:26I think my personal view is that, if you funded it only a fraction
- 28:33of what we spend on schools, right?
- 28:36Then you're inevitably going to get middle class parents who are sort of just
- 28:40topping off their private tuition, right?
- 28:44So my personal view is that I would rather have a smaller
- 28:48program that's fully funded, right?
- 28:50So that everybody can take advantage of it.
- 28:52In other words, I want, you know, the full cost of the private school
- 28:55or the charter or whatever it is, to be covered so that somebody doesn't
- 28:59have to be sort of glancing at their wallet when they're thinking about
- 29:02school choice in an ideal world, right.
- 29:05We would have, you know, a universal progressively weighted voucher that
- 29:11gets taken everywhere, and, you know, we would have to engage in a thousand and
- 29:15one conversations about regulation and testing and all sorts of things like that.
- 29:19That's probably where we're headed in 2050, right.
- 29:22But there's a lot of grounded cover between there and where we are right now.
- 29:27So, I think that's the most obvious trade off for me, right, is at a political
- 29:31level, I think there's a lot to be said for getting more folks inside the tent,
- 29:37and I think that the school choice movement has paid a price, politically,
- 29:42for the fact that it's often viewed as a way of helping black and brown kids.
- 29:47At the same time, I think that the more thinly we spread whatever dollars
- 29:51we're talking about, the less access, real world access traditionally
- 29:56disadvantaged communities are going to have to these alternatives.
- 29:59So there's a real trade off there.
- 30:01Andy: Can we pause?
- 30:05Jed: I'm sorry, what?
- 30:06Andy: We just have to pause just for a second.
- 30:07I think this does not, the perverse irony that the movement is seen as
- 30:12disproportionately benefiting Black and Hispanic kids by White people who have,
- 30:19for the most part, been able to find ways around the problems of public schools,
- 30:23either by where they live or sending their kids to private school, hectoring the
- 30:27rest of us about how much they actually care about black and hispanic kids, while
- 30:33the system continues to underserve them.
- 30:36It's sort of a really perverse puzzle that I think we just have to like,
- 30:40and again, some of it I think shows up in this report is politically just
- 30:44pause on, I mean, we could do a whole, we'd be here all afternoon talking
- 30:47about all the sort of perversities in our political discourse right now.
- 30:52But that is one that's like hard.
- 30:54It is hard to miss.
- 30:55And I We almost say it like it's unremarkable, but it's like, if you stop
- 30:59and think about it, it's very unusual.
- 31:01Jed: Well, andy, let me ask you, you asked me a question, I'll put one back to you.
- 31:04So, I mean, What do you think?
- 31:08So the mode of all charter folk is keep our heads low as, you
- 31:12know, Republicans are doing their universal voucher stuff right now.
- 31:17And that's what we did in Arizona, and now we're on the other side, and the charter
- 31:23people are coming back to the association and saying, wait a second, this voucher
- 31:28design program, it's simply not fair.
- 31:30Right.
- 31:30And it's not, it's not skewed toward advantage, advantage in the advantage.
- 31:36So what is your thought here?
- 31:39Should we be like charging into buzzsaws and asserting our concerns?
- 31:45As these things are being considered, or do we keep our heads low, get, you know,
- 31:50say that there's actually some progress if there is more choice that's created,
- 31:54and then after the fact, go in and try and refine the programs, you know, once
- 31:59they're up and going, do you have any, I mean, do you have any thoughts on
- 32:02what's the right thing to be doing here?
- 32:04Andy: Yeah, the answer is I don't know, because it is situational, I think it's
- 32:08place by place, and we should acknowledge we're in a very sort of transitory time
- 32:13in terms of how we deliver education.
- 32:15So like the charter schools had a huge adverse impact on the Catholic schools.
- 32:19Some people were very concerned about that, some people were indifferent to it.
- 32:24Some people thought that was good.
- 32:27But like it was clear it was an impact.
- 32:28And if you think the Catholic schools were sort of an important part of the community
- 32:31provided a good option, did a good job on character education or whatever,
- 32:35that was a concern, but it didn't stop us from having charter schools.
- 32:39And I feel like it's these programs.
- 32:41It's one on one.
- 32:42I think it's going to like in different places.
- 32:44It's going to Okay, we're going to have a chance to come in and refine where
- 32:47there's problems and others, we may not.
- 32:49And so when that negotiation is actually happening, you need to be at the table.
- 32:53I think it's I'd be very leery to have some unified field theory, maybe David
- 32:57does, but it just seems very situational.
- 33:00This is very situational to me in different places in different context.
- 33:04And we just have to acknowledge there will be it.
- 33:07trade offs.
- 33:07Part of the problem with the whole dialogue is every trade
- 33:09off just gets weaponized, but this is, that's just policy 101.
- 33:13There's going to be trade offs to these different approaches.
- 33:17David, do you want to, do you have a unified field theory
- 33:20on how we should handle this?
- 33:21David: I don't have a unified field theory.
- 33:25yeah, I think, in my experience, right, the average traditional public
- 33:31school teacher cares authentically about just, you know, traditionally
- 33:35disadvantaged kids, right?
- 33:37And I think that's Why we have a hard time getting through to people is
- 33:40because that's so manifestly the case if you talk to real world teachers as
- 33:45actual parents do the institutional incentives are hugely problematic, right?
- 33:51So you think about the fight for example, you know, funding
- 33:56equity within districts, right?
- 33:59I mean, arguably it's a totally rational thing to do if you're most worried about
- 34:04losing kids at the high end, right?
- 34:06the kids who might go to private schools, well of course you're going
- 34:09to put more money towards the schools that are trying to keep those kids.
- 34:13Right?
- 34:14So, you know, I think part of the challenge is that so much of this
- 34:19operates in the realm of market theory and economics, and, the average
- 34:26person's experience of school, and the average person's experience
- 34:30of teachers is very different.
- 34:31So, I don't know.
- 34:34I'm going to leave the politics to you guys, in all honesty.
- 34:36So, I'm a researcher.
- 34:38I appreciate your Bringing me into this wonderful political
- 34:42dialogue, but I am not the expert.
- 34:44Andy: Yeah, I think, well, I think it's hard.
- 34:45I don't think there's a clear answer.
- 34:46I think it's more just how do you, I do think people care a great deal, in the
- 34:52abstract and they care a great deal with the kids right in front of them, there's
- 34:56a gap and you look at the system again and again, you see that gap sort of,
- 35:01how do we translate this at any scale?
- 35:04So like, I mean, some of the divisions in your report I'm familiar with
- 35:08and like I don't think it's a lack of caring in the central office.
- 35:11They just have different priorities.
- 35:13They care about public relations, they care about the story
- 35:16that they're going to tell.
- 35:17They don't want competition.
- 35:20Yeah.
- 35:20And so I don't know that caring is the right as a political matter.
- 35:25We need to have the debate on those other terms.
- 35:29David: Yeah, when I talk to the average D.
- 35:32C.
- 35:32Democrat, right, they're remarkably convincible, but I think a lot
- 35:37of the way motivated reasoning works that people don't realize is
- 35:41it's about attention bias, right?
- 35:43People just don't seem, they don't think about this, right?
- 35:46They care about climate change, they care about whatever, right?
- 35:49They don't realize that the fact that education isn't at, you know, for poor
- 35:53kids isn't at the top of their agenda, is itself a manifestation of, sort
- 36:00of the conversation that they've been a part of what they're swimming in.
- 36:04And so the first thing you have to do is assert like, look,
- 36:06no, this matters a lot, right?
- 36:08You care about this.
- 36:10You say you care about this right now, think about it for a second.
- 36:13And so I I don't know, I have any big answer except you take them one at a
- 36:18time and you try and change their minds.
- 36:20Andy: And I think also this idea, Jed knows this, like, how do we
- 36:23get people to realize, and Jed I know you want to talk about this,
- 36:25that this lifts all boats because.
- 36:28if it's either portrayed as a zero sum or people think it's any kind
- 36:32of a zero sum, and that was one of the lessons out of Massachusetts,
- 36:35they're not going to be with you.
- 36:36And so it has to be part of like a broad opportunity oriented agenda
- 36:41that people see, like this isn't going to, this doesn't carry like
- 36:45a huge cost for me, even if it carries great benefits for others.
- 36:49Jed: Yeah, it depends on what sea, you know, we think boats are rising on
- 36:53and one of them could be on academic performance and you named David some of
- 36:56the other ones we could be thinking about.
- 36:58But I also think there's just a fairness and allocation of educational opportunity
- 37:04in more equitable ways and allocation of resources in more fair ways too.
- 37:09And, you know, I think the way that we keep people's attention on things is by
- 37:13focusing on ourselves and having policy agendas that reflect it, you know, it just
- 37:18drives me crazy that a place like Newark.
- 37:20We know what Newark is doing.
- 37:21The charter schools are growing and they're and the charter schools of
- 37:24Newark are doing a phenomenal job, right?
- 37:26The district feels the work.
- 37:28competitive pressure.
- 37:29What does it do?
- 37:30It makes a bunch of new selective admissions magnets, you know, and
- 37:33then it sucks and puts a ton of money into the selective admissions magnets.
- 37:38And then we've got, you know, a lot of schools where a large number of kids
- 37:43are in schools that are abjectly worse than as bad as any we've ever had.
- 37:48And we stand here And don't articulate that this is in fact happening.
- 37:54And so, yet again, another generation has found a new way to screw over the
- 37:58kids that need better education more.
- 38:00And I think, you know, it's a moment where all advocates, and yes, I think
- 38:04the charter school world, we need to take our share of naming that these
- 38:09things are happening and naming policy proposals that we think would make
- 38:14the situation better than it is.
- 38:18Andy: So, david, question for you.
- 38:19I mean, you can listen to us, jed and I get me frustrated at the
- 38:23unfairness of it all, all day.
- 38:25Like question for you, what surprised you with this?
- 38:26I mean, part of the fun of doing this work is like, often you're rolling
- 38:30up things empirically that you kind of either knew already empirically or
- 38:33intuitively, but then you come across something that sort of totally surprises
- 38:37whatever your ingoing hypothesis was.
- 38:39So for you, as you did this work, what are some things that
- 38:43surprised you that you found out?
- 38:47David: I was surprised by just how little private school choice had changed.
- 38:52Um, I expected.
- 38:54Uh, charter schools to be the dominant story in many of these places, and it
- 38:58was basically the only story, you know, I should caveat that by saying that
- 39:05the data we have for homeschooling and for private schooling is not quite as
- 39:09solid as the data for charter schools.
- 39:11Nevertheless, I really thought there would be some districts where, you
- 39:17know, you were seeing like some of the growth was driven by, you
- 39:20know, vouchers or private schools or whatever for the decade we looked at.
- 39:25That really wasn't the case.
- 39:26I'm sure that if we looked at say Milwaukee, you know, a couple of decades
- 39:30back, we would see that, but this decade was almost exclusively a story of charter
- 39:35school growth, and that surprised me.
- 39:37It may not be true for the coming decade.
- 39:39Um, but it was true for the one that just happened.
- 39:42Jed: Well, David, this is great research in general.
- 39:44And you know, I'm eager to see what you're going to do next.
- 39:49Andy: And, what are you going to do next?
- 39:51We pause on that for a second.
- 39:52You said something earlier.
- 39:54We're talking about some things I want to dig into.
- 39:55Is this, is there more to come?
- 39:56Give us a preview.
- 39:58David: Well, there's always more to come.
- 40:01We've got some great reports coming out in the next few months.
- 40:06I'll just say, that, you know, I always think about school choice.
- 40:11And, we're also thinking about accountability these days because we feel
- 40:15like, we've been on vacation for too long.
- 40:18So Fordham is looking for a way to restart the conversation around accountability,
- 40:24not necessarily meaning go back to no No Child Left Behind, I don't think
- 40:30anybody wants to do that, right.
- 40:31But trying to get our hands around the issue with attendance, the issues
- 40:39with great inflation, the issues with all these cultural shocks that
- 40:44happened as a result of the pandemic that we're now trying to unwind and
- 40:50get back to, you know, like holding kids and ourselves to high standards
- 40:55and sort of insisting on excellence.
- 40:57So, um, those are the big themes of the things that we're going to be
- 41:01coming out with in the next couple of years, I think, and we're just
- 41:04going to keep beating those drums.
- 41:06Andy: Excellent.
- 41:07Jed: Eager to see it.
- 41:08Share it with us when we got it, and we'll have you back for another conversation.
- 41:11This has been really great, David.
- 41:13David: I would love to come back.
- 41:14It's so nice to show you my baby grand back there, and you guys are a lot of fun.
- 41:20Thanks for having me.
- 41:21Andy: Hey, thanks.
- 41:22Appreciate it.
- 41:22Thanks for being here.
- 41:24Jed: Great.
- 41:25Well, Andy, we'll, uh, we'll wrap up for now and, you know, we'll
- 41:29hopefully get one more recording in before the end of the year, but
- 41:34we'll wrap up from here, I think.
- 41:36Andy: Thanks, Chad.
- 41:37I'll see you soon.
- 41:38Jed: Okay.
- 41:39See you guys.
- 41:39Thanks so much.