Christmas Cookies

Forever Hallmark Christmas Podcast · Mar 5, 2026 · 36m

Hallmark’s Christmas Cookies (2016) stars Jill Wagner and Wes Brown in their Hallmark Christmas debuts — but does this fan-favorite actually hold up? Rich can’t quite make sense of the central storyline, while Rene believes young Bonnie (the adorable scene-stealer) might be the movie’s secret weapon.

We break down:

• The meet cute (for the first time on the show)

• A loaded “What Would We Rewrite?” segment

• That big end-of-movie speech

• And whether Jake and Hannah would really last 12 months

For the fifth straight week, we’re split on Best Supporting Character. And when Rene makes his case…