Latest / On the Path / How Great Leaders Respond in Crisis
Transcript
- Steven: Well hello and welcome to On the Path, the official podcast of Concilium Inc. I am your host, Stephen Worstell, and we are delighted to have you with us today. It is Friday, august fourteenth, and joining me is our president and co founder of the ministry, Scott Brawner Scott, why don't you say hello to the folks and let them know what you've been up to? I think you've been wheels up a lot recently. Scott: I yeah, it's been a busy year. it's good to be good to be here with you. been traveling both domestically and internationally, with crisis management, security training, consulting. It's it's been a busy busy few months. Steven: Well, awesome. We're we're glad to have you with us, Scott. I think you bring some unique perspectives to our topic of discussion for today. Namely, how great leaders respond when crises strike, or I guess chaos might be better word, as it sometimes, you know, feels when those things strike. well, few people, I mean there certainly are exceptions, but few people plan or are prepared for the phone call that changes everything. Maybe it's a missionary caught in a war zone. Maybe it's a natural disaster that cuts off communication and people can't get to their people. A medical emergency halfway around the world happens, or perhaps it's a crisis much closer to home. Maybe it's a church tragedy. Maybe there's some sort of staff failure or an unexpected loss. In those moments, leaders don't really have the luxury of hitting pause, although they might need to pause for a second to take a couple breaths. But people almost immediately are looking to them for direction, for confidence, for hope. So today we're asking a a simple but important question. You know, what what separates leaders who help people move through chaos from those who might maybe just become overwhelmed by it? And Scott, so you you've this is where we come to you. You've you you've responded, you know, fix it all, Scott. you've responded to crises crises all over the world. Right. And so before we even talk about leadership, you know, when it's you know, how it's involved in that, what actually happens to people when this kind of chaos suddenly does erupt? Scott: Yeah, that's a a great question. I I'd say the first thing that we need to understand in any crisis, whether that's a kidnapping or an injury, the death of a loved one back home, is is that the first thing to understand is that crisis changes how the brain functions. I've I've I've seen this literally all over the world, domestically, internationally, and myself. Yeah, you've you've you've heard of fight flight freeze, fawn, that's that's another one. These are all physiological responses to stress. I mean we we teach on this in concilium's training when we talk about managing and processing hyperarousal. Your your heart rate increases, stress hormones flood your body, your your ability to think broadly begins to narrow. We we often call it tunnel vision. You know, we we we begin to focus on the threat, which then often causes us to miss other important information that might be happening in in the broader context of of the critical incident. Yeah, this is this is when information overload then sets in because of that that tunnel vision. You know, look the the phone is ringing, social media starts exploding. Text messages arrive in in every you know few seconds. I I can tell you in in recent critical instance that we've managed, we've had probably five to seven different platforms on which we're receiving communication and information. You know, you've got signal and you've got WhatsApp. Look, I I can't tell you how many times I've gotten a cold call off of Facebook Messenger and three And you know, the the list goes on. Telegram, where where all of this information begins to hit you. People trying to connect. So what happens in this time of high stress, leaders often begin to mistake activity for clarity. And that creates an issue. But emotion also starts competing with our reason. You know, when when when when something bad happens, it's natural for fear to arise. a fear of of what's next, what's to come, consequences of actions, anger at at whoever did this or at the situation itself, guilt. I often see denial that starts influencing decisions, especially in security and crisis consulting. But what I also see, and I might finish with this, is that I I also see often that rumors spread faster than verified information. During almost every crisis I've managed, I've watched misinformation outrun the truth. Because the reality is that look, chaos creates a vacuum and rumors rush in to fill it. Steven: Do you have examples that showcase where you've maybe just an example even where this kind of this fight or flight, this tunnel vision, this paralysis through information overload or knee-jerk reaction, you know, stuff happening ha has occurred. You got an example you could throw out? Scott: my gosh. I I've I've seen it in kidnappings. pol political unrest, natural disasters is a big one. terrorist attacks, broad regional conflict like like what we're seeing right now in the Middle East. in fact I I would use the Middle East most recently in in evacuating perhaps eighty people from twelve to fifteen organizations across five separate countries where people began making travel decisions based entirely on social media. And And and so w within just a few hours there's five different versions of what was supposedly happening across the region. Look, s some information was partially true, a lot of it was just completely false. And as as you're trying to manage and consult those organizations, which by the way, my hat is off to the concilium team and the fantastic job that they did in helping to manage the disequilibrium of of these situations. And that's really what you're doing is managing the disequilibrium. what I found across each of those organizations and those evacuations is that the organizations that slowed down long enough to verify information generally made it well made better decisions than those who are reacting emotionally to every new report that was coming in. Steven: So you mentioned many organizations and you referenced regions, different locations. This whole concept of how humans just, you know, what we've been talking about with how we initially respond to the chaos. Is do you find that pretty pretty typical across different cultures, across different people, across different contexts? Are these sort of universal, you know, responses? Scott: It it can be universal. Look. Culture affects how emotion is expressed, but every person ha is is predisposed to the way that they manage stress. I mean, look, all the way back to the garden, we we see through the Old Testament and the New Testament how how individuals in a time of crisis manage their stress, respond to the incident, and and do it all within the the sovereignty of God. You know, so some people become very vocal, others can be very quiet, others try to take command, others defer to the command. Hey, others challenge authority. But but underneath all those differences human beings are remarkably similar. Right? We we all see certainty When well, let me back up. We all seek certainty when uncertainty appears. Steven: So leaders though, you would say are immune to all of this, right? This doesn't impact them. Scott: Ha ha Don't man, sorry, I shouldn't even laugh at that. Yeah, yeah. Beginning with me, right? Beg beginning with me. Steven: Right. Scott: Yeah. Yeah, no problem at all here, brother. no. Steven: So really, truthfully, leaders are just as susceptible then obviously to all of this this whole picture you just painted, there. Scott: Yes, but but but I would say that that that leaders often experience additional pressure because everybody's watching them. Steven: You're on the stage in front of everybody. And that's it. Scott: Yeah, or or you're in the crisis room or or you're on the call and and and people are fearful, they're scared, some are angry. You know, again you're dealing with all of those different emotional responses to the stress and and you're trying to to manage all of this. look th the I have met leaders whose hearts were racing just as fast as everyone else's. In fact, there's there's been times where I've I've just had to had to say to people, breathe. And I remember one time I said, f fill your fill your carotid artery, fill your feel your pulse right now and and where we're at in this. Look, the the difference isn't that that that leaders don't fear. It's that good leaders refuse to let fear make their decisions. Does does that make sense? Steven: It does. And it's a perfect segue, I think, to the next kind of point as we discuss and kind of peel this back. It's in addition to that fear comment, when you look back on all of these you sort of referenced them already, these different crises that you've been involved with, what are some of those other characteristics that consistently separate, you know, effective leaders from ineffective ones? Now, after you said that fear one, I think that was a great one. What what else could you maybe expound on on on that? Scott: Yeah, that's that's a lot lot to process. I j just just thinking back over twenty plus years of doing crisis management. I I would say the best leaders are calm, but that doesn't mean that they're passive. It it means that that they're emotionally well regulated. And and this is important to understand in in leadership before, during, and after a crisis, because people borrow emotional stability from their leaders. And so again, you you you come in I I I remember doing a critical instant stress debrief after a group came out of out of Ukraine. So we were sitting in Poland and this group has just come out and just the insanity of trying to evacuate Ukraine when millions of people are trying to get out of the country, literally, and and sitting down and and trying to maintain that emotional regulation with people who are you know e exhausted Scared, upset, angry, angry at each other. look that emotional stability that's demonstrated by leaders helps to guide and regulate the the the broader organization or or the I should say the team that that may be responding to the crisis. It's it's so important. But but secondly, I I think that leaders have to communicate honestly. They don't pretend to know what they don't know. And again, I've seen this many times where because someone feels like they shouldn't should have control or should know everything that's happening, in reality you can never know. Steven: Yeah, Scott: Then they they they act in such a way that that they would portray that they have information when they really don't. But in reality, look, people can handle uncertainty far better than they handle deception. Because once there's an appearance Steven: Yeah. Scott: of deception, trust is lost. And throughout crisis management, Steven: Okay. Scott: you have to be able to maintain trust. And that trust is tied to respect and that that respect is tied to how you you you manage yourself in the incident, including what you know and you don't know and how you're honest in in in what you share about what you have concerning the situation at the time. Thirdly, I Look, okay, yeah, this is important. You you have to separate facts from assumptions. This is critical. In fact, it kind of goes back to pretending to know what I don't know, right? Is that I have to be able to separate facts from from my assumptions. So in every cr crisis, I'm I'm trying to ask some basic questions. Like what what do we actually know here? And what do we think we know? versus we know what are we simply assuming? And again, looking back at the Middle East and remembering back to some evacuations out of Israel. I mean we had two separate evacuation events with multiple organizations during the the the the conflict of the last year or so. And and and helping people to process what they actually know versus what they think they know and and and the decisions that they're making based on assumptions. Right? That simple exercise has prevented a lot of poor decisions. I maybe another one for what what makes an effective leader, I would say that leaders are visible. In in in a crisis as a leader, you don't disappear to your office. Right? You you don't throw yourself in into the email. You you have to be engaged. You walk the halls, you meet with your team members, you you answer their questions, even if the answer is I don't know, but we'll find out. Bottom line, you you have to show up. The leader's presence creates confidence in the team. Steven: Imagine that's huge. So in a different, I mean, to where is our leader doing an email? You know, I I think that that's that's massive. So calmness, honest and accurate information, being factual, don't just speculate. And then just the leader being present, being that that anchor, that, that, that support there with the team. in addition to those kind of characteristics, what what are some other things that you know help leaders be more effective in handling a crisis? Scott: Well, look you gotta understand people don't expect perfection during a crisis, they expect leadership during a crisis. That's that's important to to to clarify here. No one is ever going to be be perfect. So part of this is giving people hope through the crisis. I I remember one kidnapping in particular where there was a a lot of just fear anxiety leading to depression. that's not the time to to to build false optimism, but it is a time to build hope. And and hope in these cases is helping people believe that there's a path forward. Steven: Yeah, I think that's Scott: See, that's the difference between false optimism and and and helping them have it and and understand that there is a path forward. It may be a hard path, but it's a path nonetheless. So that that's that's why I say people don't expect perfection during crisis, they expect leadership. Steven: And I guess a big component of that as you're kind of a lot of the stuff you're laying out there, if we get into our kind of our last point to discuss, some some other things to consider about, it would seem like preparation might be something that has to be considered in advance to a lot of this. Am I off base there or am I heading in a good direction with that? Scott: No, that's that's probably the most important thing to say when it comes comes to crisis is that nobody rises to the occasion. You know, we will rise to the occasion. Look, you y you w when crisis comes, the answer really is to have preparation before a a an incident. Or to put it another way, through good preparation, you can keep a critical instant from becoming a crisis. Because again, this idea that nobody rises to the occasion, you you're actually falling back on your your preparation. You know, and and if you have no preparation, then you're you're falling back on your level of competency. And and you really need to have both in this case. You you've got to have competency for this, but you've also got to have preparation. And and so I've found that organizations that that Prepare for crisis. Steven: Well Scott: practice crisis management, you know, tabletop exercises, you know, various forms of training, these these organizations perform much better than organizations that that you know see their plan, you know, their crisis plan for the first time after sitting on the shelf. You know, for example, I I I've I've worked with with organizations to help them develop their crisis manual. Okay, their policies, their procedures, all of that Is is put into this this document, and then once the document is slid across the table, they say thank you very much, and then it ends up on a shelf somewhere, and it it doesn't get touched again. And what ends up happening is circumstances change. You know, I've I've seen this on the field, I've seen it at headquarters, where, you know, one person was diligent to create the plan, they then the the plan's created, but then they move out of that position, somebody else moves into the position, and they've never looked at the plan Steven: It's Scott: and until you know crisis comes and all of a sudden you're trying to dust off this plan. Well, here's the reality when it comes to policies, procedure, and planning. If you don't have the culture to support your policies, everyone's going to do what's right in their own eyes, regardless of what the manual says. Steven: Hmm. It's like chaos begetting chaos, you know. Scott: It can. Yeah. You can have a crisis inside of your crisis. Steven: That's a scary phrase. Scott: Yeah. Well look, you you th this is important because cr I I I say this it when whenever I'm training, people are I'm I'm a broken record on this. Crisis management is relationship management. Relationships matter. You you don't build trust during an emergency. You spend the trust that you've already built prior to to the emergency. So yeah, Steven: That's good. Scott: r real example, like real no-joke examples that we've that we have faced. We get a cold call from a missionary on the field who says, Hey, we've got a problem, we've got an incident, we we we need your help. And they're calling us Because they came through our training, which allowed them to build trust with us, you know, v through the respect that they that they they they saw or or experienced, you know, through the training. So that when the critical incident comes, they're calling us for for help because the trust was already built prior to the critical incident. And I I've I've seen this happen like I said a again and again and I I've got several that come to mind right now but I don't want to share them specific specifics because it it would it would give it away but but yeah b bottom line is decision making processes prior to a critical instant should already exist. we should be building margin into decision making so that in when when crisis comes We already have some basic agreement on who makes decisions. What decisions require field approval versus having home office approval or might call d executive approval. hey, what what what decisions rightfully belong within field leadership? Because there are decisions that that rightfully belong within field leadership. But if we've never had these conversations as an organization or a team, then again, when crisis comes, everybody's going to do what's right in their own eyes. Those conversations, they need to happen before emergency, months before an emergency. In fact That's why communication plans are so important in this. These are internal as well as external communication. Look, people don't simply need information, they need consistent information. I I would add one more piece to this. Through through everything that we're talking about. We need to bathe crisis management in prayer. Look, prayer isn't our backup plan. Steven: Mm-hmm. Scott: Prayer shapes our our leadership posture. you know, again but f from from the Old Testament to the New Testament. Within God's sovereignty, you know, you you you you see these these characters in the Bible who are are are managing their crisis and and you see that there are times that where they are on their knees before the Lord. And especially when you're talking about a group of people and they're coming together asking for the Lord's wisdom, guidance, help, you know, to to make their path straight. You know, it all of that it it's it's as much about trying to turn God's ear towards our need, but but more than that, it's about shaping our le our our posture for how we lead in crisis before the Lord. It it it reminds us that we're responsible for faithful stewardship, not for the sovereign control of the situation. That's that's why prayer becomes so important. It's not just saying, hey, Lord, we need your help, but that we're acknowledging God, we can't do this without you. And in that tension between sovereignty and providence, we know that in that overarching scope of God's sovereignty, that there's a place for personal responsibility. And this is how we practically lay all of this on the altar. in order to steward well the critical incidents that we're called to manage inside of the sovereignty of God. Steven: And there's the big differentiator between the missions, the gospel that we do versus your normal nonprofit that's maybe exposed to similar things. We have a sovereign God who we seek to follow and trust all throughout. That's that's it. Scott, you nailed it, man. That was I love that. Well, I know we're getting up against the clock here. Do you got time for a couple quick rapid fire questions? All right. Here we go. Hope you got your helmet. All right. Biggest leadership mistake you have seen or even made yourself during a crisis. Scott: boy. probably under stress they begin to confuse speed with wisdom. I I I think that yeah, fast decisions are sometimes necessary, but hasty decisions rarely are necessary. Steven: Good thoughts there. I'm sure there's examples of extra fallout due to the hasty sometimes. So Scott: Hm Steven: what what's one habit every ministry leader should develop? Scott: boy. for security and crisis management, I I think we need to be asking ourselves fairly regularly what would keep a small problem from becoming tomorrow's crisis. In other words, we have to manage trends before they come emergencies. To to to put that frankly, there's a difference between having the margin in your decision making to choose to depart versus needing to flee. Steven: Maybe the difference between somebody being able to load up their van with their stuff and drive out versus waking up in the cold sweat in the middle of the night and grabbing everything you can. Scott: That's right. Because w we we we had the the permission in ourselves and in our team to ask those hard questions about, you know, looking at at what's what's the trend, what's coming down the the pike that we're concerned about, and how do we how do we manage that well so that we manage an incident before it becomes an emergency, or if something does become an emergency, that we keep it from becoming a crisis. Steven: Good stuff. Fill in the blank. A crisis is a terrible time too. Scott: Ha yeah. Well back to what I said earlier. It it's a terrible time to have to introduce yourself to your own crisis plan or or exchange business cards. here's what I mean by that. I I remember back to to my very first kidnapping, back in the in the mid two thousands. And we had very little planning in place. And I remember going to the Department of Defense, the US Department of State. I went to New York City and met with United Nations with with with with with their DSS, their diplomatic security. And coming to somebody in a time of need with your hat in your hand is is the is is the worst way to try to manage manage crisis. Look so sometimes you just gotta do what you gotta do. I mean it it is what it is. But if I can have those relationships in place prior to a crisis, now I'm not coming to somebody simply because I have a need. Now those same people might want to help me because we have a relationship and we have respect and they're willing to reach out and to work on my behalf to help resolve the the the issue that I'm that I'm managing. So yeah you get that's why you do this work before the crisis begins. Steven: Wise words. Well, real quick here at the end, how can concilium help leaders and organizations be better prepared for these types of situations that we in inevitably encounter? Scott: concilium is a a fourfold ministry and part of part of that fourfold ministry is is training and w whether it's building Strong field workers who are are are equipped with tools to be healthy on the field, effective in their ministry, resilient with the challenges that they face, to to building crisis management, security management. Consilium builds resilient leaders before the phone rings. That's that's so important here. When when when we think about th the the response to crisis or better yet, being well prepared to keep the crisis from happening in the first place. The the ounce of prevention that's worth the pound of cure. Because that's that's how we as Consilium help organizations develop practical security risk capability, you know, through risk assessments, executive coaching, tabletop exercises, as well as crisis management training. But but notice a lot of what I just said is is left of bang. In other words, it's it's it's it's what is done prior to a critical incident or is done to keep a critical incident from happening in the first place. But let me expand on that for just a minute. The number one killer of missionaries around the world is not Al Qaeda, it's car accidents. So we we know that everywhere people serve that there are inherent risks that cannot be avoided. Therefore, we have to prepare. to manage those risks when when when when trouble comes, you know, w when a when a vehicle collision takes place and we have in injuries. Well how do we build margin into decision making? How do we build resiliency to in order to manage a critical incident to keep it from becoming a crisis? Well it it it it begins with having insurance so maybe I can transfer the financial risk Of tens of thousands, sometimes hundreds of thousands of dollars that it costs to do a medical evacuation of somebody's critically injured in a car wreck. It's it's it's knowing, you know, what are the first steps that we're gonna take in a contingency plan? What are the hospitals in in the capital or in the country that that are that are best for critical care? The more of this information that I have before a critical incident, which we would call security management. the the the the the more that we're gonna be able to manage well a a critical instant to keep it from becoming a crisis. Because look ultimately as consilium we're helping leaders fulfill their biblical duty of care. You know, look I everybody hears about legal duty of care because nobody wants to get sued. Look I pfft I get it. I know I don't want to be Steven: Mm-hmm. Scott: sued But when you think of of of what we're doing, instead of through just the lens of liability, but through the lens of godly stewardship, that is leaders, the Lord has put the blood of those who serve in our organizations on our hands. In other words, we bear responsibility for their safety, their well-being, and their very lives. Because leadership in in security and in crisis isn't just about protecting people. It's about stewarding well the people that have been entrusted to us by God. Steven: That's a heavy weight and concilium exists to help share that load. Okay, describe it that way. That's good words, Scott. well, we're kind of coming up. I know you got some things coming up. We gotta let you go. But those are an immense amount of topics, lots of good insights that our listeners can glean from it. What do you have coming up next? Scott: travel. I'm I'm leaving at the end of the week for Latin America. I've I've got a security management project in in Latin America. I know we have the Risk Management Network meeting coming up in in Dallas Fort Worth area. Missio Nexus, the Mission Leaders Conference, is coming up in in September as well, just after RMN. Those are two September events. we've got a number of trainings. We have our open courses and our field security courses that take place. we have North Carolina, Michigan, Texas. I'm gonna be in Central Asia speaking at a conference. that's that's actually addressing some of the issues that we've talked about here, but but through the lens of of of of biblical well systematic the systematic theology of risk. So I'm really excited for that conference. that's taking place in in central Asia in November. Steven: Awesome. You have a full load coming up, it looks like. So we hope you have great troubles with that and that God does amazing things as you're as you're going around to those different locations. Well, we want to thank our listeners for stopping in with us. we hope you're able to learn something. we invite you to look for us on Facebook and LinkedIn. Also, go check out our website, concilium.us. We have loads of articles and resources that can assist you in ministry from our churches that are sending and supporting missionaries to to missions agencies themselves. There's information for everyone there. The deeper dives into some of the stuff that Scott just barely got into as we were talking through this together. Also, if you have any questions that you may want us to answer on our podcast, you send them our way. You can email them to us at infocconcilium.us. Just put podcast question in the subject line. Then make sure to tune back in regularly, as you never know when we may tackle your question. Maybe might even inspire an entire podcast worth of attention. Well that's all for now, and until we meet again, may your ministry be faithful, effective, and resilient.