Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Final Settlement: Bitcoin Is Money for Enemies
Transcript
- 0:00What's the form of money that you don't have to trust that
- 0:01will always do what you need? Make a mistake about it.
- 0:04We're in a bull market for all that.
- 0:05What else will be settled in that?
- 0:07And what else will the market wake up to that this asset
- 0:09really has? This spokesperson says Bitcoin
- 0:12payments can't be traced, which isn't exactly right.
- 0:15They can be traced on chain. Pseudonymity is different than
- 0:18anonymity. The take away there is like
- 0:21that, actually. That doesn't stop it from being
- 0:24seizure resistant, right? Like you can still use Bitcoin
- 0:28in this context, have it be censorship resistant.
- 0:31Nobody can freeze a Bitcoin transaction mid settlement,
- 0:34can't reverse the transaction. So even if those funds are being
- 0:37traced, you know nobody can really do anything from do
- 0:42anything about it. From a sanctions perspective, it
- 0:47all comes down. To computers, communicating the
- 0:51information superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps and
- 0:54off ramps. Bitcoin is worthless artificial
- 0:59gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 1:02Probably rat poison squared. We need to get into the world of
- 1:05OK, this is actually foundational technology.
- 1:09What the Internet of Money does is it.
- 1:11Creates a single network which can do a microtransaction to a
- 1:17giga transaction. The Internet is going to be.
- 1:22One of the major forces. For reducing the role of gun,
- 1:27the one thing that's missing that that will soon be developed
- 1:31is a reliable E cash. All righty gentlemen, welcome
- 1:38back to another episode of Final Settlement.
- 1:39Today is Monday, April 13th, 10:35 AM Eastern Standard Time.
- 1:46Middle of the hour, not top of the hour.
- 1:49Gentlemen, how are we doing? Lots going on in the world.
- 1:52I would say just to start, like the amount of things that have
- 1:56happened that I would consider massively bullish tailwinds for
- 2:01Bitcoin just in the past few weeks.
- 2:03Like if you, if someone was in a coma for the past three years,
- 2:07you woke them up, told them the things that happened the past
- 2:09few weeks, many of which we'll get into here today, and you
- 2:13asked them what the price of Bitcoin was.
- 2:14I think they would say like half, half, $1,000,000 a coin,
- 2:18which isn't to say bitcoin's broken, it's to say that markets
- 2:22are inefficient and information not evenly distributed around
- 2:26what Bitcoin is, how it works, and what a lot of these
- 2:29tailwinds mean. I would say the biggest one from
- 2:32the past week is that there's been various reporting around
- 2:38what's happening in Iran, the Strait of Hormuz, the closure
- 2:41that the sort of toll system that's being implemented by
- 2:45Iran. Originally about two weeks ago,
- 2:48there was reporting in Bloomberg that both stable coins and
- 2:52Chinese yuan were being used to pay this toll.
- 2:55And then about a week ago, the Financial Times reported
- 2:58something similar, but with a slight twist in that Bitcoin was
- 3:02specifically reported as being used to pay these tolls.
- 3:06So we can get into some of the details, but maybe just at a
- 3:08high level, the significance of this in the sense that Bitcoin
- 3:13being used for settlement, particularly for, you know, oil
- 3:16tankers in a conflict zone, I think it speaks to a lot of the
- 3:22use case that Bitcoiners have talked about for a long time.
- 3:25And when someone says, you know, Bitcoin has no use case, it's
- 3:28it's pretty hard to rest on that case at this point.
- 3:32When you see something like this emerging, whether or not it's
- 3:35happening, you know, at scale or not, just the fact that it's
- 3:38even being thought about or considered in that context, I
- 3:42think is significant. So, thoughts, gentlemen?
- 3:46How are we doing today? Doing good, crazy world.
- 3:50Maybe we'll get into the price action or non action.
- 3:54I think just leading up to this, we forget all the weird
- 3:59inorganic or just interesting things from the October 10th
- 4:02that nobody's ever been able to explain to kind of maybe the
- 4:04potential front running of this Iran conflict with the retrace.
- 4:08And then I think what supports that is the price being
- 4:12relatively strong with what's happened.
- 4:14But independent of that, going back to the IRA and stuff, I
- 4:17think it's easily one of the most fascinating angles that
- 4:23have happened over the past year, like right up there with
- 4:25Morgan Stanley. And the reason why is because to
- 4:28your point, Brian, these are the things that have been talked
- 4:30about forever. When you go back to even, you
- 4:33know, a lot of the blog post and writings from health any there's
- 4:37a lot of things that are being described around banks and E
- 4:39cash, but it's been widely understood from the beginning.
- 4:42If Bitcoin is going to work, it has to be censorship resistant.
- 4:45You have to be able to anybody can trade with it.
- 4:48And I think it's a fascinating dynamic where I was just
- 4:53thinking about the the enemy of my enemy is my friend is the
- 4:55money of my enemy is my friend and that anybody can use this.
- 4:58And something as geopolitically significant as oil and energy,
- 5:04you were always going to end up in this state where you needed
- 5:08from your enemies to transact in any kind of trade in a form of
- 5:11money that you can receive and you can't, you can't reverse.
- 5:16And there's a lot of properties that tie into Bitcoin that allow
- 5:19for this to be done in even more dynamic way.
- 5:22We talked about multi institution net settling, having
- 5:25different custodians holding the keys.
- 5:27And as you validate that oil or whatever it is moves out, you
- 5:30can tranche out via real governance that you just don't
- 5:33have in the traditional world or with gold.
- 5:37But there's also really underpins the whole dynamic of
- 5:39why you want to hold the underlying because like this is
- 5:42obviously on the most hyperbolic extreme example.
- 5:44We still don't know for certain if they are or if they're
- 5:47trolling the the government, but I can promise you that this will
- 5:51continue. It already has continued or
- 5:54occurred for the 1st 17 years of bitcoins history is people that
- 5:56needed things were transacting in with Bitcoin when they
- 6:00couldn't use dollars. And so this idea, whether it's
- 6:04AI agents, compute, transacting and trade in a world that starts
- 6:09to breakdown with trust, what's the form of money that you don't
- 6:11have to trust that will always do what you need.
- 6:14And it's exactly that. And there's no shortage of like
- 6:16conversations out there of like, why do you want to hold Bitcoin?
- 6:19Don't you want any ETF? Don't you want proxies?
- 6:22And independent of like all of the counterparty risk and risk
- 6:25associated, you're going to want the money that you can actually
- 6:29leverage when you need it most. So you and your family can eat
- 6:31or you can get those resources. And we just live in such a
- 6:36especially Western because it shows predominantly US based,
- 6:39but we live in such a the, you know, comfort.
- 6:44And we just haven't seen all the things that emerging markets
- 6:48have seen around sanctions, bail, insurance, just where our
- 6:51money is needed to. It's always worked effectively.
- 6:53We'd had little blips with like the OA crisis or SDSVBI, call it
- 6:57little blips, GFC. But the point being is we just
- 7:00don't really feel the need for this notion of like outside
- 7:03money. And I think we all agree here
- 7:05and, and the market needs to to to pay attention to this is that
- 7:09like where we're going is in this very volatile period in
- 7:12place where you there's going to be a appreciation and a premium
- 7:18on that, especially because it's, it's the obvious thing to
- 7:23us, but it's not obvious to the market.
- 7:24And so the paper wrap around Bitcoin is the in vogue thing
- 7:27right now. But as the market gets more
- 7:30volatile, counterparty risk and just trust breaks down in the
- 7:33society we're and make no mistake about it, we're in a
- 7:35bull market for all of that. And so, yeah, I just thought
- 7:39that this is a very like Canary in the coal mine of where this
- 7:42is all going. And if people are selling oil
- 7:45and that significant of a commodity in Bitcoin or even the
- 7:48discussions there, what else will be settled in that and what
- 7:51else will the market wake up to that this asset really has
- 7:54value? Well said.
- 7:59I think the aspect of just using it for oil and agents using
- 8:06Bitcoin in in a long time frame is definitely something that is
- 8:08going to happen. It's going to happen very, very
- 8:10slowly over time. It's uncertain how much has
- 8:14actually been transacted in Bitcoin to this point, mostly
- 8:18because a lot of the straight seems to be closed.
- 8:21But there's no confirmed reports this at this point, although it
- 8:25is confirmed that Iran's head of oil and gases is specifically
- 8:31requesting to be paid in Bitcoin as well as yuan and stable
- 8:36coins. But you can see where
- 8:38everything's going with all this.
- 8:39And it is very, everybody always feels like they're going to be
- 8:43able to get out of the proxy or ETF wrapper and get into actual
- 8:48Bitcoin at the last time that they need it.
- 8:50But I think it's just more prudent probably to hold the
- 8:53actual underlying just it when you see where the world's going
- 8:57and how quickly. Things are shifting 100%.
- 9:02I wrote about this in in the on Ramp newsletter last week
- 9:06because I did think, you know, as we're discussing it is pretty
- 9:09significant like and, and part of what I caveat in the roundup
- 9:12was, you know, even if not a single toll has been paid in
- 9:18Bitcoin, just the fact that it's even being considered in that
- 9:23context I think is meaningful. And just a few other details
- 9:27from the reporting from the Financial Times.
- 9:29Now if you're familiar with the Financial Times, traditionally,
- 9:33historically not a very good Bitcoin related source.
- 9:37They've been pretty anti crypto and Bitcoin historically and
- 9:41have done some pretty terrible reporting on the topic.
- 9:44In this in this instance though, they are, Liam, as you
- 9:47referenced, quoting an Iranian official, the spokesperson for
- 9:53Iran's Oil, Gas and Petrochemical Products Exporters
- 9:56Union, that's who the quote is really coming from on
- 10:00specifically the Bitcoin side. Now there's a few interesting
- 10:04things to pull out that may give us some insight to whether this
- 10:07is, you know, really happening or not.
- 10:10And those would be basically in that quote, this spokesperson
- 10:15says Bitcoin payments can't be traced, which isn't exactly
- 10:19right. Of course, they can be traced on
- 10:21chain. Pseudonymity is different than
- 10:24anonymity, but the the take away there is like that.
- 10:29Actually that doesn't stop it from being seizure resistant,
- 10:32right? Like you can still use Bitcoin
- 10:36in this context, have it be censorship resistant.
- 10:39Nobody can freeze a Bitcoin transaction mid settlement can't
- 10:42reverse the transaction. So even if those funds are being
- 10:45traced, you know, nobody can really do anything from do do
- 10:50anything about it from a sanctions perspective.
- 10:53Now compare and contrast that to if they were using stablecoins,
- 10:57which could much more easily actually be censored or seized.
- 11:00And we've seen literal examples of that over the past year or so
- 11:04where US Tether, tether funds that are associated with Iran
- 11:10have been frozen. So you're seeing sort of this
- 11:14play out in real time that people are realizing, Michael,
- 11:17to to sort of how you describe it, like what is the rail that
- 11:21if you can't trust anyone, what, what can you trust?
- 11:25You can trust this completely neutral settlement system that
- 11:29can't be seized, can't be stopped effectively.
- 11:32And you know, even if it can be traced, even if you, you know,
- 11:37your enemies know that you are using it, it actually doesn't
- 11:40matter. What's what's actually protected
- 11:43is the, you know, the property rights, effectively being able
- 11:46to transact in it, being able to accept or receive funds along
- 11:50those rails. And, you know, just at a high
- 11:54level, the other thing I called out in the piece is like, none
- 11:56of this is like pro Iran or like pro sanctions evasion.
- 12:02And you know, the common trope in Bitcoin is like Bitcoin is
- 12:05for enemies. And you sort of spoke to that a
- 12:08bit, Michael, But like, that's just the reality.
- 12:09Like no one's rooting for this necessarily, but like this is
- 12:13how it was always going to play out.
- 12:15When people realize what this thing is and, and how it can be
- 12:17used is it's going to be used by enemies.
- 12:20It's going to be used by North Korea, by Iran, because it's a
- 12:25tool. At the end of the day, it's,
- 12:26it's open source software that no one controls and people are
- 12:29going to use it as they see fit. And so, you know anything else
- 12:35there, Mike, before we move on? Yeah.
- 12:37I mean, I, I think the the only other part is there's no great
- 12:41timeline on how much transactions will happen on
- 12:45Bitcoin, whether it's via lightning, other layers for AI
- 12:48agents or specifically for geopolitical global commerce.
- 12:53But you can squint and see where this is the future.
- 12:57The best example of this is. There's.
- 13:00Probably a convergence of things happening.
- 13:02My understanding is part of the US and energy independence
- 13:07started being an exporter of oil that kind of change the dynamic
- 13:11with Saudi and what they were, you know, buying the petrodollar
- 13:17effectively started selling to China via gold yuan.
- 13:21The point being is that, and Growman talks about this a lot,
- 13:24where China, it makes zero sense if we need China's rare earths
- 13:29in manufacturing for our military industrial complex and
- 13:34they're holding our money. And so we can see that, you
- 13:37know, like you could see it just does not track.
- 13:39So you need a neutral form of money.
- 13:41And so to your point, I kind of bypassed it.
- 13:43I'm glad you brought it up. But it's like, because we're
- 13:45supportive of gold doesn't mean we're supportive of like XY or
- 13:49Z. It's just a tool.
- 13:50It's just money. But the point being is if you
- 13:52were to see this at that scale where people are moving to
- 13:54neutral assets, you can start to look in the businesses that need
- 13:58to exist. This is something that again,
- 14:01you've been thinking about for for basically half a decade at
- 14:03this point, but it will come about where whether it's Morgan
- 14:06Stanley and letting you hold spot because you need to move
- 14:09that back when and move it somewhere else or different
- 14:12products and services, the one that it seems so transparent.
- 14:16We're early but around this notion of governance within the
- 14:19custodian layer. When you move it like almost
- 14:22like an escrow service, because at the end of the day, you still
- 14:25have a problem with somebody has to send the Bitcoin, somebody
- 14:27has to send the tanker. What happens if you sent the
- 14:29Bitcoin, then you shot the tanker.
- 14:30You need to like start to create trust in layers with that.
- 14:34And so there's going to be services that get built out
- 14:37because when we talk about stable coins and we talk about
- 14:39payment rails on a long enough time horizon, these things will
- 14:43happen where your, your sensor, your funds are seized or there's
- 14:48just better. When you think about how do you
- 14:50pass like information along with payments over the, over an AI
- 14:56agentic world, you're going to have better program ability and
- 14:59tooling in an open permission less protocol versus all these
- 15:03others that are effectively walled gardens.
- 15:05And so this will just like start, I think it'll happen
- 15:08probably faster because AI is moving so fast that we're going
- 15:10to just see this like converge at the larger scales.
- 15:13I think we talked about this last week.
- 15:14There's like the barbell. So you're going to be net
- 15:15selling on these large assets and that's on chain.
- 15:18And then you're going to start to see all these other things
- 15:19proliferate because you need microtransactions.
- 15:22And I know we're not sleeping on it and the Bitcoin camp isn't,
- 15:25but it's really interesting to watch like in Silicon Valley and
- 15:28a lot of these other places, this is going to like hit them
- 15:31over the head because they're still living in kind of the web
- 15:34three world. Yeah, that's that's all well
- 15:38said. And, and it speaks to kind of
- 15:40what I allude to around like even if even if this hasn't,
- 15:43even if not a single toll has been paid in Bitcoin, like the
- 15:46message and the narrative that it sends to someone who doesn't
- 15:51deeply understand Bitcoin, it's value prop, it's mechanics, like
- 15:56just the fact that they're that it's being suggested you that
- 16:00kind of sort of that can prompt someone down the rabbit hole to
- 16:04understand why, why why maybe they wouldn't want to use stable
- 16:07coins, why it's not super feasible to use gold, why
- 16:10they're not using Ethereum or Fartcoin to do this.
- 16:13I. Don't, I don't think it's like
- 16:1475 or 80, but I would say it's greater than 50% that it's true
- 16:17simply from the fact that if you said 510 years ago, it'd be like
- 16:21maybe not. But the reality is a, they've
- 16:25been mining, right? A lot of these sanctioned
- 16:27countries like Venezuela, Iran, North Korea have been leveraging
- 16:30natural resources to use this. It's also my understanding that
- 16:33the IRGC, the different like a there's, they're going into the
- 16:37geopolitics like IRGC has had to create a very sophisticated and
- 16:42orchestrated level of financial connections across the world to
- 16:46bypass all the sanctions that have happened in a banking
- 16:50system. So they deeply understand how
- 16:52Bitcoin works. And so if they were one of the
- 16:55sovereigns that were going to do this or accept it, it would make
- 16:58complete sense. And they don't even have to hold
- 17:01it. Not necessarily saying that they
- 17:02don't want to hold it, but they would have a way, given the
- 17:05liquidity profile to go back into whatever currency or gold
- 17:08that they needed. And that would have already been
- 17:10set up. That's not something they have
- 17:11to like spin up after doing this.
- 17:14Yeah, I agree. I think it's, I think it's
- 17:16pretty likely as well. I just wanted to caveat it
- 17:19because there hasn't been a lot of like hard evidence that it's
- 17:21actually happened outside of this one spokesperson saying it.
- 17:26Liam, anything else before we move on?
- 17:29No, just say that the obvious thing is if this actually does
- 17:33happen at more scale, there are going to be other counterparties
- 17:37that just need oil and want to transact a Bitcoin as well.
- 17:41And they're going to have to go deeper down the rabbit hole, you
- 17:44know, figure out how to mine, hold or buy Bitcoin for the
- 17:48first time to get up there and get their own infrastructure set
- 17:51up. It was always necessarily going
- 17:53to happen this way where it's, you know, small scales at 1st
- 17:56and kind of almost testing and then there would be these
- 18:02different rails set up for different trading counterparties
- 18:05and it would just inevitably like seep out further and
- 18:08further across the world. So yeah, makes sense that that
- 18:11it's playing out. That's why.
- 18:12And completely agreed on, yeah, the point that we're, we're not
- 18:15necessarily rooting for this, but it was just always
- 18:17inevitable. Yeah, while you while you
- 18:20transition that, that's worth calling out like this whole
- 18:22maritime law and the fact that there's asymmetric warfare with
- 18:26drones re everyone has to rethink ports and movement and
- 18:30you already see this with the blockades that supposed to go
- 18:32into effect or when in effect an hour ago that that could change.
- 18:37Of. The blockade, yeah, the blockade
- 18:39of the blockade that really effectively could change a lot
- 18:42of the dynamic of settlement and movement and into the the
- 18:46overarching point is like regardless of its if they did it
- 18:48or not, it's the fact that it's into the like zeitgeist and
- 18:52people are talking about it that naturally has second of the
- 18:55ramifications. For sure, maybe a nice
- 19:00transition you, you briefly mentioned Morgan Stanley
- 19:03ultimately, ultimately getting to the point where they offer
- 19:07spot. But right now they're in their,
- 19:08they're in their ETF wrapper phase.
- 19:11And as we've talked about on the show in past weeks, they were
- 19:14gearing up for the launch of their spot Bitcoin ETF, which
- 19:17went live, I believe on Thursday of last week, did about 35
- 19:21million in volume on day one, and I think a little bit less
- 19:25than that on on Friday. But overall, near sort of 50
- 19:29million in trading thus far. And Morgan Stanley's head of
- 19:34digital Asset strategy was on Bloomberg towards the end of
- 19:37last week talking about it. So I'm going to play the clip
- 19:39and then we can kind of discuss significance and and takeaways.
- 19:43But let's hear from Amy Oldenburg here.
- 19:46Day of trading for any of our, I have to tell you in terms of the
- 19:49pick up we saw yesterday, the first day of trading, our best
- 19:51first day of trading for any of our ETFs since we've started the
- 19:55ETF product line a couple years ago.
- 19:58So I think that speaks to the demand that's still out there
- 20:00for the Bitcoin ETF. Almost 1.7 million shares traded
- 20:04yesterday and at 12:00 today, we are already having another good
- 20:07day. Today, as you said, there's a.
- 20:09It's a nice it's a nice week in the market, a nice day in the
- 20:12market for some pick up in Bitcoin and the markets to help
- 20:15us out there. But I have to tell you in terms
- 20:17of the. So just, you know, talking about
- 20:21the success of it relative to anything they've done in the ETF
- 20:24space historically, as we've talked about, like they're not a
- 20:27big ETF shop, so it's not like they have a huge track record of
- 20:30launching ETFs. But even relative to the ones
- 20:32that they have done, super successful.
- 20:34Great first couple days. Michael, maybe I'll hand it to
- 20:38you. When are we going to have Amy on
- 20:39the show to discuss? We need to have Amy on the show.
- 20:45We definitely get Amy on the show.
- 20:46I think I don't, I don't think I personally fully appreciated the
- 20:50Morgan Stanley stuff. I was listening to James Safer,
- 20:53who's also been on the show. We should have him back on and
- 20:56Eric, but he was talking about a few things that you've called
- 20:59out and love maybe to get your thoughts on a like just a notion
- 21:03that Morgan Stanley really doesn't launch ETFs.
- 21:06They definitely don't go for the lowest price, right?
- 21:08So that signals strategic like imperative to go for like a
- 21:12market share and pull assets there.
- 21:15As Amy called out and it was referenced, I think it's like
- 21:17top one, like global or however, you know, public markets on ETF,
- 21:22just day one, top 1% and flows best for them.
- 21:28But I think that there's another angle that's really interesting
- 21:30here, which is I heard it was Arthur Hayes where you can find
- 21:34some Nuggets. He's just been around so long
- 21:37and his his angle was like, I don't care about the ETFs.
- 21:41I don't care about the Clary Act.
- 21:42It was interesting because it kind of ties into a lot of
- 21:46things. We've talked about how this is
- 21:47an emergent asset into retail asset and retail needs a better
- 21:51form of money. They've shown that.
- 21:52That's why they had to jump through, you know, a bunch of
- 21:55hoops and hold these hardware devices with large amounts of
- 21:58capital and that the banks aren't getting in here because
- 22:02they see it as a Wall Street necessarily trade and that
- 22:05they're going to, you know, two hedge funds are going to be
- 22:07trading against each other. It's that they're going to make
- 22:09a shit ton of fees from their clients in distribution.
- 22:12And because it's a retail asset. And I say retail in a like a
- 22:15broader sense that, you know, Morgan Stanley has X number of
- 22:19high net worth individuals and family offices that leverage
- 22:23their services and those are the individuals that will be buying
- 22:25this asset. And so that, that is where this
- 22:30asset grows and how it moves is through retail distribution.
- 22:34And so seeing that they're, they're seeing that they're
- 22:37really leaned in, they understand when you think about
- 22:40equities in the 6040 and where that's going.
- 22:43And, and a lot of the things we talked about the administration,
- 22:46even the ETF getting greenlit in the very in 2024, I guess 2023
- 22:51at this point, 23 was approved and then 24 went live.
- 22:55Is that right? January 24.
- 22:57Yeah. The fact is that inflation is
- 23:01going to run and outside of gold and Bitcoin, all these assets,
- 23:06the reflexivity prices everyone out of the market.
- 23:08So real estate, we've already seen what's happened from a
- 23:10socio economic perspective. We see kind of like the stock
- 23:12market, the multiples that these guys know it, they're
- 23:16sophisticated and they know this asset fixed supply is going to
- 23:19be this vehicle, this battery for people to store their well.
- 23:24So very bullish for what's happening there.
- 23:25But also just an interesting take that at the end of the day,
- 23:28this will be like a retail driven phenomenon because it's a
- 23:30better form of money. They'll be able to move in much
- 23:32greater size and institutions and it's good to see Morgan
- 23:37Stanley recognize that. And these banks all compete with
- 23:40each other. So it's just a matter of time
- 23:43before others do. And then the the last thing is
- 23:45about the fees. It was referenced that on the
- 23:49margins, if you're at Black Rock, I think there are 2425,
- 23:53you may stay there. There's a deeper like option
- 23:57pool and like it's more liquid. But if you're a long term buy
- 24:01hold like financial advisor, you're trying to get those that
- 24:04lemon bits eats into that underline over time and that it
- 24:09can really be a mover for financial advisors and others to
- 24:12move flows their way. So it'll be interesting to see
- 24:14how that plays out. It'll be interesting to see how
- 24:16BlackRock responds if they do and then others.
- 24:20But I think like the, the embedded subtext to all of it is
- 24:23that and something we've been talking about, there's only 21
- 24:26million of these and there's really there's much less than
- 24:28that. That the real game here long
- 24:30term is how do you wrap your arms metaphorically your
- 24:33financial service business around those underlined because
- 24:36as it appreciates that's when the financial services will
- 24:39start to come about. And I think that is embedded in
- 24:42a lot of their strategy. For sure.
- 24:45Yeah. Lots to pull out there.
- 24:46I think just to sort of add a little bit of nuance around the
- 24:51the notion that they are not a big ETF provider.
- 24:54It kind of goes even further than that in the sense that the
- 24:57ETFs that they have historically launched, they do it under sort
- 25:02of sub brands, so Calvert Parametric to name a couple,
- 25:08where they're basically managing and and issuing the ETF, but
- 25:12it's through a sub brand investment management business
- 25:15that is distinct from Morgan Stanley.
- 25:17So in terms of like actual ETFs that have the Morgan Stanley
- 25:20name on them, I think this is the third or fourth ever the
- 25:25Morgan Stanley Bitcoin Trust. And so that is super significant
- 25:30just from the perspective of, yeah, they they're serious about
- 25:33this. The other thing that tells you
- 25:35they're serious is, is undercutting the entire complex
- 25:38on fees. And I think part of the notion
- 25:41there is like they also know that, you know, they played it a
- 25:45little slower, a little closer to the best for the past two
- 25:47years as these things existed. And now they're, you know, they
- 25:51have some, some ground to make up in terms of I bit, you know,
- 25:55haven't looked at the numbers in the past week, but anywhere, you
- 25:58know, 60 to 70 billion of assets in in I bit as we sit here
- 26:03today. So they've got some ground to
- 26:04make up. And so in order to do that,
- 26:06you've got to you basically had to undercut on fees.
- 26:09And then I think the the second prong of their strategy is, is
- 26:13going to be active solicitation across their network of 16,000
- 26:16advisors. And so that's the other unique
- 26:18part about this, that it's not just another asset manager.
- 26:22This is a bank with a massive, if not the biggest wealth
- 26:27management client base in the world.
- 26:30And about a year ago, they had sort of a recommended allocation
- 26:34for crypto digital assets of 0 to 4%.
- 26:37So you can do the quick math and, and say that, you know, if
- 26:41if they get any, any, anything in that range for any sort of
- 26:47subset of their, you know, 9 plus trillion client base, it's
- 26:50going to be meaningful in terms of flows.
- 26:52And so I think last week is a a drop in the bucket in terms of
- 26:57what what we could see into that product over the next few years.
- 27:01Yeah, to that point too on just lower fees, I think it's also
- 27:04baked in there that they're going to move over the custody
- 27:06to their own in house custody that they're developing as well.
- 27:09I know that that's something that they've at least said that
- 27:12they're developing and planning to launch later this year.
- 27:15And would imagine that to Michael's point on just a
- 27:18competitive nature of where this is going, BlackRock, I, I'm
- 27:23going to go ahead and say that they're probably not going to
- 27:26lower their fees just because they have 97% of options volume.
- 27:29They may, but I could see Fidelity doing it because they
- 27:33aren't there and they have their own custody in house.
- 27:35They probably have the margins to support it.
- 27:38And then everybody else is still outsourcing to Coinbase.
- 27:42So they're going to be in a little bit of a tougher spot on
- 27:46where they actually go with these.
- 27:49But to to the broader point too, I think this is just we're going
- 27:53to see similar to what we saw with Larry Fink after the
- 27:57initial launch of their Bitcoin ETF.
- 28:00There's this is just a much broader slew of people who are
- 28:04going to go out and just really start to educate the market in
- 28:08general and have massive distributions on really the
- 28:11benefits of Bitcoin. And these are going to be some
- 28:14of the largest, you know, folks who who can educate people with
- 28:18serious capital. They have built in distribution,
- 28:20super serious high net worth clients in their network.
- 28:24So definitely going to be going to be big for Bitcoin as a
- 28:28whole. Yeah, that's a great call
- 28:31reading into the the pricing strategy that they'll ultimately
- 28:35own that custody. So that's, you know, embedded
- 28:38margin and also really the fact of how fast they moved.
- 28:44I think that is a big aspect to this because rather, regardless
- 28:49if it's a traditional ETF in the amount of time, you know,
- 28:52generally taking two to four years for somebody to turn it
- 28:55on, once they've done the diligence and understand,
- 28:57understood it Bitcoins a little bit different because it's just
- 29:00it's just holding BTC, but you still have to get comfortable
- 29:03with it to push it to your clients, let alone launch an
- 29:05ETF. So to move so fast into the ETF
- 29:09space, undercut the market, work on custody and other assets
- 29:13really puts them in a different lens.
- 29:15When you think about similar to Fidelity owning that vertically
- 29:18integrated approach where a lot of these other firms are going
- 29:22to send this stuff out to Coinbase.
- 29:23Now TBD if firms are going to really lean in and develop their
- 29:28own custody. But I know we agree here.
- 29:30It's like it makes complete sense why you wouldn't want to
- 29:33be disintermediated and send that underline to a third party.
- 29:36There's like the business case around what you want to do with
- 29:40that asset, the logistical kind of asset management level.
- 29:46But I think that second order, the 1st order is like, well, if
- 29:49you're sticking your neck out there and something happens to
- 29:51the third party, that's your whole business, right?
- 29:53That's all the trust into, why would you want to put the trust
- 29:57into a third party? It just signals a deep
- 30:01understanding of what's happening there, right?
- 30:03And Fidelity's already understood that for a long time.
- 30:06And so I think that's what we're going to see more and more.
- 30:08You'll start to understand who really appreciates and
- 30:10understands this asset class because they'll think deeply on
- 30:14the underline. We don't have to go deep there.
- 30:15But this is always like been the premise on the digital asset
- 30:19treasury trade is we can talk about all the 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th
- 30:23and 6th order effects on why they may not make sense.
- 30:26But the first premise and the base lever is the custody.
- 30:29Because to assume that the custody will always be there is
- 30:33a flawed assumption because it hasn't been there for 17 years.
- 30:37And so if one thing goes wrong at any of the custodians, all of
- 30:41it goes away. And that is just lost in the
- 30:44whole sauce of the of the thing. So if somebody who's deeply
- 30:47understood that they would start there and then they would start
- 30:50to layer on above that. And so again, Morgan Stanley,
- 30:54kudos to them for understanding and and working on the like very
- 30:57base level of the Valley prop. Check out early riders.com for
- 31:00all the latest in Bitcoin investment research.
- 31:02Now back to the show 100. Percent maybe moving on here the
- 31:10other big headline from last week again, if you woke up from
- 31:13a coma from three years ago would be pretty wild to see the
- 31:19US Treasury Secretary writing an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal
- 31:24basically clamoring to get legislation passed that gives
- 31:27the digital asset crypto Bitcoin industry more clarity.
- 31:31The Clarity Act that is. So this was written by Scott
- 31:34Percent last week, basically calling on Congress and, and
- 31:40everyone, everyone in the mix who's kind of held this up to
- 31:44some extent to get this across the line.
- 31:47And So what are your guys thoughts on this?
- 31:50I know we've talked about the Clarity Act and sort of the back
- 31:52and forth on stable coins, the yield stuff, but what do you
- 31:57make of this Scott's op-ed? Is there a TLDR?
- 32:02Did you read it? I didn't read it.
- 32:04OK, so I didn't read it either. But I mean, I think we can
- 32:07surmise that you wrote an op-ed pro digital assets, pro clarity
- 32:12of the clarity. I think we forget because this
- 32:17happened when Trump was elected. You know, there was a lot of
- 32:19things he promised and this is definitely not pro Trump.
- 32:23This is just more of the status of things and the way they turn
- 32:26out is Bitcoin is still a very small asset.
- 32:29Digital assets are still very small as compared to global
- 32:32finance. And it's specifically gold,
- 32:34which is really the the sovereign reserve currency,
- 32:37right? And so I think that the
- 32:39understanding was back then and a lot of BPI and you know, shout
- 32:44out to Matt Pines called a lot of this is no longer there.
- 32:47But it's really the realization that there's a geopolitical
- 32:50weapon in Bitcoin and digital assets in the sense of the
- 32:53proliferation of the dollar and the debt, that this is
- 32:57geopolitically strategic for the US to really lead here from
- 33:03dollar dominance. But also because Bitcoin has,
- 33:07you can go into speculation on how the the genesis of it, but
- 33:10the point being is that empirically a large percentage
- 33:13of the Bitcoin sits here, whether it's the hash rate or
- 33:16it's the actual underlying from Americans.
- 33:18And now you have the publicly traded companies that are
- 33:20holding it along with ETFs. And so in a world where we don't
- 33:24know how much gold China is stacking and Russia, but we can
- 33:28see this world where we're going into a multipolar world where
- 33:31there's different reserve currencies and, and you have
- 33:33these dollars and maybe you want and stable coins that are moving
- 33:36around to transact, but the underlying is really not
- 33:39settling gold at this point. Well, what better way to
- 33:43counteract that than to create the right construct for Bitcoin
- 33:47to proliferate and grow, especially if the US is holding
- 33:50X and then U.S. citizens by proxy are holding Y.
- 33:54What does that mean for GDP dominance in a digital world?
- 33:58And so I think you Add all that together and A, it makes
- 34:01complete sense why percent so pro here BY clarity was always
- 34:05going to get done. We've been talking about that
- 34:06for the whole year. And then C, why you just got to
- 34:09hold on tight that hold the underline and Bitcoin will do
- 34:13its thing. It's just a matter of time, a
- 34:14matter of if not when. And again, it's not a popular
- 34:18sentiment because it sounds like coke, but I just feel like the
- 34:21price has been in this band because it's meant to be in this
- 34:23band. And when it's ready to
- 34:24rock'n'roll, it'll be ready to rock'n'roll not a second before.
- 34:28Yeah, I, I think that's, you kind of said.
- 34:31The quiet part that I think the Senate can't really say too
- 34:35loudly here in like a piece like this is that they're going to
- 34:40want and allow Bitcoin to monetize, act as a sponge like
- 34:45gold has for liquidity for the money that they're going to have
- 34:49to print. I think the way he frames it in
- 34:51here, just doing like a quick three read through, it's like
- 34:54this line that I have highlighted here, the promise of
- 34:56genius can't be realized without clarity support.
- 34:58So it's, it's much more stablecoin focused, I think
- 35:02outwardly and how they're talking about the need to get
- 35:06clarity done. Because if you want to tokenize
- 35:08the world, if you want to do all these other things on these new
- 35:11rails, basically you need these broader green lights from
- 35:16government to to be able to enact a lot of these things and
- 35:18force things that have already been passed like the genius Act.
- 35:23And so I think that's how they're they're sort of
- 35:25outwardly talking about it is like it's stable coins, it's
- 35:27tokenized assets, It's, you know, tokenize real world assets
- 35:31getting, you know, the stock market on chain, however you
- 35:35want to phrase it. But I think behind the scenes,
- 35:38you're totally right. It's like we need clarity on all
- 35:40this stuff, no pun intended, in order to allow basically Bitcoin
- 35:45to be normalized as the premier store value for U.S. citizens
- 35:49and allow them to preserve their wealth in this new sort of
- 35:53multipolar digital world. Yeah, it's it's.
- 35:57Go ahead, I was. Just going to say like it also
- 36:00we don't have to overcomplicate it.
- 36:01I mean, this is really where I, I kind of turned very bullish on
- 36:05stablecoins is realizing Tether, when you look at it from a
- 36:08correlation from the amount of Tether you printed to the amount
- 36:10of Bitcoin, right? Like you're effectively creating
- 36:12this bridge into Bitcoin from a physical world and dollar being
- 36:16physical. And that in the same way, if
- 36:19you're going to create this Clarity Act, you're going to
- 36:20bring this bridge into digital assets, you're going to
- 36:23proliferate even the stock market via tokenized assets to
- 36:26anybody in emerging markets to get exposure.
- 36:29And then that flow will move into a hard asset with a fixed
- 36:32supply. It's really that
- 36:33straightforward. And so it's just again, the
- 36:36function of time and also the function of like he writes us
- 36:39op-ed. I would imagine some of it is
- 36:40because there's naturally different factions within a
- 36:43government, they're dissenting, there's problems.
- 36:45So you have to go and appeal to your constituents into the
- 36:48broader market to put pressure on those individuals to get this
- 36:50done in a in a time frame that is palatable for what their
- 36:54goals and objectives are. Yeah.
- 36:57I think similar to the banks trying to get as much of their
- 37:00arms around the Bitcoin and in their own custody as possible.
- 37:03I think that the US is trying to get as much Bitcoin into the US
- 37:06as possible. Trying to get all businesses
- 37:09back in the US domiciled and show that they're friendlier to
- 37:14what is actually going on to both businesses and individuals
- 37:18who will ultimately invest their Bitcoin into businesses too and
- 37:22then just grow GDP as you mentioned.
- 37:24But yeah, in addition to that, obviously this would be a big
- 37:27boon for stablecoins because it's the other side of the pair
- 37:30of all digital assets. And having any more digital
- 37:33assets in the US and and tokenized assets, it's going to
- 37:36be good for both stablecoin volumes and, you know, total
- 37:40outstanding balances. And then inevitably it will all
- 37:42flow into Bitcoin. It's just that simple.
- 37:47Well said. OK.
- 37:49We've got a few headlines around sort of similar to to what we're
- 37:53just been discussing around the convergence of traditional
- 37:57banking and crypto and Bitcoin. I think the regulatory side is,
- 38:01is not just AUS centric sort of narrative or storyline.
- 38:07We had this headline late last week out of Japan that they are
- 38:11moving to classify Bitcoin and crypto as financial instruments
- 38:14under a new bill. Anything on this one?
- 38:17I think, yeah, this is to be expected as as again, sort of
- 38:22regulators and governments move to again, provide no, no pun
- 38:26intended, more clarity around what these things are, how they
- 38:29can be used, how you can build businesses around them.
- 38:32Then you get headlines like this where Standard Chartered is
- 38:35waiting, integrating Zodia custody with their corporate
- 38:38banking arm. You, you have this continued
- 38:40convergence. And so, you know, some people
- 38:43are not going to wait for that quote, UN quote, clarity.
- 38:46They're going to start building ahead of it, but I think once
- 38:49you do get more and more sort of regulatory green lights in
- 38:53stone, you're going to have a a mad rush for people to catch up
- 38:57to a lot of these people that have already been making moves.
- 38:59So any thoughts on either the Japan headline or what we have
- 39:03up up here? Yeah.
- 39:06I think the other one, just a tie in, we don't have to pull it
- 39:07up was I think there was 5 Swiss firms and then UBS looking at
- 39:14dollar or state making a stable coin around the Swiss franc,
- 39:17which it's my understanding Swiss franc's pretty appealing
- 39:20globally just given the, I think their, their conservative level
- 39:25of like debasement and the backing of it.
- 39:27But to your point, I think it's really interesting that the US
- 39:32from a capital markets and regulation really leads.
- 39:36I don't know how much of that's game theory and how how much of
- 39:38that is just, you know, like military force and and functions
- 39:45of the past 50 years. But regardless, like post ETF,
- 39:48you saw this move instantly and it's just continued the drum
- 39:52beat around across the world. The recognition of digital
- 39:56assets, the recognition of this is going to go in One Direction.
- 40:01I thought it was really savvy with Standard Charter because
- 40:04Standard Charter set up Zodia, I would say at least like four or
- 40:06five years ago. Zodia was this like extension
- 40:09arm's length. Think of it as like a skunks
- 40:11skunk work to like labs because it was out there operating on
- 40:14its own, but backed by standard charter.
- 40:15So you got like the Intel and the business was building and
- 40:23creating in in in operating before all this stuff was was
- 40:27live and blessed. And so now they're looking to
- 40:32pull it back into the firm standard Charter is interesting
- 40:35because if you look at their global footprint, I mean, it's
- 40:38everywhere outside of the US, right?
- 40:39You look across the world when it comes to like just the rails
- 40:42and the onboarding from Fiat and where they sit, the banks from
- 40:48Hong Kong all the way to London. And so you naturally now you
- 40:51have this global bank that's bringing in custody and digital
- 40:54assets. I think it's just again, really
- 40:57a signal for where this is going globally around the movement of
- 41:00capital. And then also the largest firms
- 41:03really thinking about how do they vertically integrate and
- 41:05then obviously custody is that the base level of all this?
- 41:07So they're looking to bring in Bitcoin into their firm.
- 41:11And then they would more than likely Standard Chartered
- 41:14custody sits underneath a lot of other firms in the same way
- 41:18Bitco sits underneath other firms.
- 41:19So the bank would be able to not only get those assets, but
- 41:22they're right there next to the dollar rails to be able to cross
- 41:25collateralize, offer other financial services.
- 41:27So I think they're going to be in a really good spot from a
- 41:29global perspective. Yeah, it's a lot of what we've
- 41:32been talking about like Morgan Stanley vertically integrating
- 41:35in order to drive down costs. And Morgan Stanley went out and
- 41:38they actually invested in 0 hash and you know, I think tried to
- 41:43buy them at one point in time. And there are so many synergies
- 41:45across both the wealth management side and then them
- 41:49owning E*Trade to just offering the the trading platform to
- 41:53clients. This is obviously something
- 41:55that's going to happen more and more as all banks and large
- 41:58financial firms get more and more into digital assets.
- 42:01When you really start to see other firms go out and make
- 42:06investments, start to, you know, have these companies spin out of
- 42:11large banks, I think that's a sign that they're actually
- 42:13starting to take this seriously. Right now it's just Standard
- 42:16Charter and and Morgan Stanley, at least to a large degree,
- 42:20because any time that these initiatives are inside, large
- 42:23organizations are just going to get buried, buried with just so
- 42:27many layers of bureaucracy that it's going to be very difficult
- 42:30to actually create it inside and, and get anything to market
- 42:35and a manageable time frame. And so building them stand alone
- 42:40or investing in them stand alone is just going to allow them to
- 42:43have a little bit more way to see what's actually going on in
- 42:46the industry from the arm's length without actually just
- 42:49stifling innovation and speed from a lot of this too.
- 42:52So definitely expecting a lot of this to get ramped up, and I
- 42:56think that the Clarity Act will probably be a pretty good
- 43:00catalyst for this to start in mass.
- 43:02If something happened to you tomorrow, could your family
- 43:04access your Bitcoin? Not, probably not.
- 43:08They would figure it out with certainty.
- 43:10I thought about this a lot. You may feel confident managing
- 43:13your own keys. But are your loved?
- 43:14Ones billions of Bitcoin have been lost already because
- 43:17someone died without a plan with on ramp inheritance planning is
- 43:22built in directly into your custody setup.
- 43:25Your Bitcoin stays segregated and in your control, insured
- 43:28through Lloyd's of London and accessible to the people you
- 43:31choose when they need it. Get started in 15 minutes.
- 43:35Book a free consultation at on rampbitcoin.com on ramp secured
- 43:40by three controlled by me. Yeah, another headline sort of
- 43:46along these lines. And we've seen seen examples of
- 43:49this over the past several years where there's sort of an
- 43:52intermingling between governmental roles and then
- 43:57basically people leaving the government to work in the
- 43:59industry. So this latest example is
- 44:02Securitize appointing former SEC official as their new president.
- 44:06This fellow Brett Redfern confirms who's the former SEC
- 44:11markets and trading director. He's going to be the president
- 44:13of Securitize who's securitized just I think also last week
- 44:17announced a non binding agreement, New York Stock
- 44:19Exchange to settle tokenized securities on chain.
- 44:23So this is the real tokenization push.
- 44:26You know, you make a nice partnership announcement with
- 44:29the New York Stock Exchange and then you hire the former SEC
- 44:31markets and trading director and it's it's all a go.
- 44:34So thoughts on this one? Yeah.
- 44:38I thought it was interesting. I listened to something, I think
- 44:41it was from the securitized guys where I think that their premise
- 44:45and it makes sense. I think everyone's premise, even
- 44:47mine was like you're going to securitize and digitize like
- 44:52private markets assets because they've historically been like
- 44:55inefficient or illiquid and that was how they started.
- 44:58But they realized you still have that case of liquidity.
- 45:01And so they kind of pivoted and found the value of product
- 45:04market fit in the hyper liquid assets.
- 45:08I think A, because of the demand, but B, because of what
- 45:11we'll see around cross collateralization.
- 45:13And I'm not saying on pro this, because I can see a lot of
- 45:15velocity in transactions moving and then a lot of funds lost,
- 45:18but it's just the reality of proliferation of US equities and
- 45:23then also financialization. That's where everyone makes
- 45:25their money is in the, the velocity and in transaction
- 45:28these fees. So that makes sense.
- 45:31One other thing I want to pull up, and I'm sure let me have
- 45:33some thoughts. If there's a link for Valinor,
- 45:36if they got the, the funding came out last week.
- 45:38They're former Blackstone folks, but I didn't get a chance to
- 45:41look into them. So I, I recently listened to a
- 45:43pod that they were on breaking down what they're doing.
- 45:46They're former Blackstone guys or in gals, I guess related to
- 45:51private credit, but for for like blockchain or or stablecoins.
- 45:55And what it means is it actually makes a lot of sense.
- 46:00The the example they use is if you're familiar, we've talked
- 46:03about rain. Rain is a primary issuer of the
- 46:07only one that's a non bank that allows you to issue these debit
- 46:11cards that are on stablecoin rail.
- 46:13So you can manage those balances.
- 46:15But what happens is there's like an inefficient amount of capital
- 46:19that has to be tied up. If you like, let's say you are
- 46:22on ramp, we're not using it, but let's just say we were and we
- 46:25our clients had balances and they wanted to leverage them via
- 46:29the cards. We have to lock up some of that
- 46:31float so they can use it. And then you like net settle on
- 46:33a daily basis. And so there's this world where
- 46:37Ballinor's stepping in understanding these like credit
- 46:40markets on stablecoid rails, where they can fund that they
- 46:42can get visibility into, you know, the assets that are
- 46:45sitting there and then they make a small bit small premium.
- 46:49And I think you're going to see more of this.
- 46:50The easiest example is on the Bitcoin back lending side.
- 46:53If you're lending in stable coins and you're able to see the
- 46:56underlying, the custody, you can get real familiar.
- 46:59I think that's where a lot of the private credit market has
- 47:01been dislocated with Bitcoin understanding the collateral,
- 47:04but also the security profile of the custodian.
- 47:07You see these high interest rates and you hear that a lot
- 47:10from the market participants like why are they fleecing me?
- 47:13Why is it so high? Whether it's let in arch
- 47:15whoever, but the reality is because there's no fed window
- 47:19stepping in to provide those dollars, it's private credit and
- 47:22private credit historically hasn't understood the
- 47:24underlying. So if they're going to put their
- 47:25capital at risk, they have to be paid that premium.
- 47:28And I think Valinor and other firms like that are going to
- 47:30step in understand the movement because that is key.
- 47:33You have to understand the movement and velocity of this
- 47:35and the risk profile or you're going to get hosed if you're
- 47:38moving around stable coins for credit.
- 47:40And so I just thought that this was really interesting and I
- 47:42have some ideas on things we can do with them.
- 47:44So anyway, I, I thought this was a cool one to pull up because it
- 47:48sounds like at face value, like what is it?
- 47:50Where's the value? But I think there's going to be
- 47:51a lot of value in bringing dollars on chain in a like
- 47:54institutional way that you can underwrite properly.
- 48:00Interesting. So it's essentially a
- 48:02marketplace for private credit to where Valinor will offer
- 48:06securitized private credit offerings to anybody who's on
- 48:09the platform as well too. It's a great question.
- 48:12I don't necessarily know if it's full marketplace.
- 48:15I would imagine a lot of the value is in their underwriting.
- 48:19And so it's probably looks more like a Blackstone model where
- 48:22you have these different funds and you're effectively offering
- 48:25different, you know, durations and premiums on the capital.
- 48:28And then they're the ones, you know, funding and managing that
- 48:32versus like tying it together. But I, I could, I mean, I could
- 48:37see maybe a marketplace, but I think the marketplace aspect in
- 48:41this world always, it's not that there's not a need for it.
- 48:43It just kind of breaks down in financial services because it
- 48:46reminds me a lot of of Airbnb early days or like Craigslist, a
- 48:52great example. It's like Craigslist had some
- 48:55value because you can aggregate like two sides, but you still
- 48:58have the quality mismatch and on both sides, right, of the
- 49:02quality of the capital and quality of the, the person
- 49:06issuing in the loans. And so if you have somebody in
- 49:09the middle that takes that expertise and effectively even
- 49:12takes their premium, there's a lot of value.
- 49:13If you have excess dollars and you have the intermediate
- 49:16intermediary that understands private credit but also
- 49:18understands the risk that's embedded in this ecosystem, you
- 49:22can make a nice business. If you can basically take those
- 49:24that, that that's where the value is, right?
- 49:27You're taking that, that margin is baked into like you being
- 49:31native to the space, but also understanding the institutional
- 49:33landscape and what those private credit people need.
- 49:36Because just being in the space, that's a big problem where
- 49:40historically, if you have hobbyists or people that are
- 49:42very native to understanding multi sig and a lot of
- 49:46intricacies of Bitcoin, they don't necessarily speak the best
- 49:49language to private credit folks.
- 49:50And so you always have this like mismatch of like, well, maybe
- 49:53it's a sound product, but if you can't actually package it up,
- 49:56you're, you're, you're still missing out on getting that
- 49:59liquidity into the market. I interpreted that headline
- 50:04maybe a little bit differently in the sense that it reminds me
- 50:06of what I brought up on the screen here is that, you know,
- 50:10it's kind of conspicuous timing to one launch credit default
- 50:14swaps on private credit for the first time ever.
- 50:17And then also let's bring it on on chain for the first time
- 50:19ever. To me, it just seems like people
- 50:22want to get out of this stuff. And by basically allowing either
- 50:27you to short it if you own a ton of it or just opening up these,
- 50:31you know, marketplaces, I think people are going to get wrecked
- 50:34If you if you're if you're looking to go long private
- 50:36credit on any blockchain. Yeah, it's like to me this this
- 50:41is just signaling how bearish private, private private credit
- 50:44markets are right now. And not, not a ton much more
- 50:47than that. Yeah.
- 50:48I mean, I would listen to the podcast and then have that take,
- 50:53especially if I said I listen to it.
- 50:55The being in the space there was a the easy example, which is if
- 51:00you started a Bitcoin back lending firm today and let's say
- 51:03you got the licenses, your biggest problem is how do you
- 51:05get the dollars right? So that's like an easy example
- 51:09of like bringing it on chain. It's not necessarily like crypto
- 51:12or some kind of crazy Ponzi. It's literally like, OK, I'm
- 51:15going to do 5040% loan to value, but I need an intermediary to
- 51:19help me source that credit. And then if you take it a step
- 51:22further and you have more banks like airborne, other firms that
- 51:25are going to be effectively banking dollars.
- 51:27I'm not saying like people won't get wrecked in the velocity, but
- 51:30there is a need for firms that actually have the acumen to
- 51:33speak to the institutional investors on the private credit
- 51:36side. And then also understand deeply
- 51:38like the value prop of a firm that is taking a very
- 51:42conservative approach to lending IEA Bitcoin back alone.
- 51:46And then there is a spread there because again, if you go to an
- 51:50Archer letting, if you're taking out a smaller loan, it's in the
- 51:5310 to 12%. If there's private credit
- 51:55markets that are looking to get 8% on their money and they can
- 51:58issue it at 9:00, they can meet that fee.
- 52:00That's where I'm going with like the value proper where I see
- 52:02something needing. Now we're going into like
- 52:05farming out and everything that happened during Define summer
- 52:08and all that like of course, but I think that they're taking a
- 52:10more institutional lens into bringing dollars into a growing
- 52:14stable coin market. Yeah, that's at least my
- 52:17interpretation of no. I think that's I think that
- 52:19makes sense on like a go forward basis, but I think there's like,
- 52:24you know, in terms of like net new loan creation.
- 52:26But I think in terms of if we're just going to put like, you
- 52:29know, more what this this hot, this headline is describing like
- 52:35more so existing loan books, just like having them be more
- 52:38tradeable, like I I don't see. Oh yeah, yeah, yeah, 100%.
- 52:42I mean. I agree with what you're saying
- 52:43like net net new having a a better connectivity and
- 52:48liquidity that that I could see as as that's.
- 52:52What they're doing, I mean, that's what they're doing, yeah,
- 52:54that's exactly what they're doing.
- 52:55It's not I don't think there's anything related to yeah, that's
- 52:58a complete other side of a coin of like private credit and all
- 53:03the things we've talked about why bullish Bitcoin and air
- 53:05pockets that there's all this money that's dead that hasn't
- 53:08been marked to market yet to bring that on chain and give it
- 53:11to, you know, the bags to somebody else.
- 53:14Like, yeah, definitely bearish on that.
- 53:16Exactly, Michael, credit to you. You called this a few weeks ago,
- 53:24Gemini takeover rumors you you had forecasted within the next
- 53:3112 to 24. It happened in two weeks.
- 53:35Thoughts on this Stock jumped 10% on takeover rumors.
- 53:38Maybe they'll break it up. Pieces of it will be acquired.
- 53:41Yeah. I mean, I think we'll see where
- 53:43it goes because my understanding is the interest is in some of
- 53:46the licenses outside of the US. The reality is like all this
- 53:52stuff is scarce. This is where I think we're
- 53:54bullish on what we're building and the firms we're investing in
- 53:56is that whether it's the talent OR infrastructure, there is a
- 54:00lot of things in place that these firms have done over the
- 54:03past five to 10 years when they were, you know, contrarian and
- 54:06not popular. And so it makes complete sense
- 54:09that you have these assets. And when you're a large firm,
- 54:12whether you're Morgan Stanley, Fidelity, Standard Charter, go
- 54:15down the list or firms that maybe can go get banking
- 54:18licenses, it's really symmetry to like tie in digital assets,
- 54:22especially now with his arbitrage that almost anybody
- 54:25can be a bank. If you're going to embed stable
- 54:26coins and account access, that a lot of this infrastructure is
- 54:30just going to have a premium even over what their multiples
- 54:33are on revenue. So I, I, I think this makes
- 54:36sense. We'll see where it goes.
- 54:38If the Bitcoin price double tomorrow, would you feel good
- 54:40about how it's being secured right now?
- 54:43Most people have not really pressure tested that and I get
- 54:45it. I have talked to people who have
- 54:47self custody for over a decade and others who stayed on
- 54:50exchanges because they could never get comfortable managing
- 54:52their own keys. Both camps have real concerns.
- 54:55That is why we built on ramp multi institution custody so no
- 54:59single company can lose it. Move it or.
- 55:01Use it Lloyd's of London Insurance inheritance planning
- 55:04built in and a team that can walk you through the entire
- 55:07setup. Get started in 15 minutes.
- 55:10Book a free consultation at on rampbitcoin.com On ramp secured
- 55:15by three, controlled by me. Agreed, nothing else.
- 55:22OK, a few minutes left. You guys want to talk about Go
- 55:25SAT's? Can you pull up the anthropic
- 55:27one? Because I think that I think
- 55:29this one's going to be interesting to watch play out
- 55:34because you click on that chart, it's just pretty insane when you
- 55:39think about Anthropic getting to roughly 30 billion an RR.
- 55:44And I think their bottom was or not bottom.
- 55:46But last I think it was like Q4 last year was at either 3 or 9
- 55:50million. I think it was 3 billion.
- 55:54And this chart showing Meta to get to that same level as 86,000
- 55:58employees versus Anthropics 2500 that it's, it's this notion of
- 56:04like total addressable market for intelligence is effectively
- 56:08infinite, right? Because it's the angle of it's
- 56:10the unknown unknown of like what can people use this for?
- 56:12And then what does it increase? And then also, I don't know how
- 56:17true this is, but my understanding is like them and
- 56:19open AI only using total data center capacity is like 1.7
- 56:24gigawatts of power. It's not like an insane amount
- 56:29and they're still have capacity coming on.
- 56:32I think that I know obviously it's getting shortened with a
- 56:34lot of the energy crisis, but I think this year was supposed to
- 56:37be like 2 to 3. But, and I actually might have a
- 56:42order of magnitude wrong. It might be megawatts.
- 56:44But the the main point is that they don't have them limited
- 56:47capacity still and they're getting more efficient with time
- 56:52as the inference cost goes down. And so I just think it's a
- 56:55fascinating model to watch play out.
- 56:57We've been super bearish on getting to some level of
- 57:01profitability and the cost, but if they can get this scale where
- 57:05every company is reliant on them.
- 57:07And I know there's a lot of positives with open source, but
- 57:10I don't think it's either or. I think that a lot of firms will
- 57:13keep proprietary data and they'll still need these firms
- 57:15to figure out how to even like, you know, calibrate open source
- 57:18for their own internal org. But if you're going to have this
- 57:21need for frontier models for some of your output, there's
- 57:24only certain firms working at this level.
- 57:27And I thought it was just fascinating to see how fast
- 57:28they're moving. Yeah, this is a fascinating
- 57:31chart. What I guess I have a question
- 57:33for you, Michael, Maybe you know the answer.
- 57:34But like because I've sort of also thought that there's going
- 57:38to be this push and pull between maintaining some sort of like
- 57:42enterprise account and also, you know, building locally open
- 57:46source. But correct me if I'm wrong.
- 57:48Like there's always going to be some lag in terms of like the
- 57:50most frontier model that Anthropic is putting out and
- 57:53then what can be run locally open source.
- 57:56And so I think you're right that maybe there is that sort of like
- 57:59you don't abandoned one or the other, but there's you're almost
- 58:02required to use both. So you have the frontier, the
- 58:04latest and greatest, and then you're also sort of like, you
- 58:08know, building your own internal repositories as well.
- 58:12Yeah, that's exactly right. I mean, and the other aspect of
- 58:14it is like, I believe roughly they're leading in the code
- 58:19space, right? They took this understanding
- 58:21like the code is the base level because the code can just go
- 58:23recreate agents and the directional understanding is
- 58:27that right now global production of code is 5% anthropic.
- 58:32So you should you still have and the estimates are that most
- 58:36engineers in whatever the time horizon and call it 2 to 10
- 58:39years, it'll be 95% of the code is created by these models.
- 58:42So I think it's just a fascinating lens to look at.
- 58:44It reminds me a little bit of the Uber analogy when people
- 58:48looked at total addressable marketing.
- 58:49It was just tabs and or black cars when it was much greater
- 58:53than that. So it'll be interesting to watch
- 58:55play out. I think the thing we know no
- 58:56matter what is whether it's coordinating economic activity
- 59:00online via Satoshi's will win out.
- 59:04But also as these firms really start to get to profitability
- 59:07and their costs go up with inflation, how quick they are to
- 59:10start putting Bitcoin on their balance sheet and see that
- 59:13flywheel spin and then that becoming an economic advantage,
- 59:17competitive advantage against the other income, the other
- 59:19purchase events or competitors. Yeah, well said.
- 59:23I think that the Tam is going to get so much bigger.
- 59:25I mean, I've written a lot more code this year and I never had
- 59:28before like 12 months ago. The Tam is everybody's going to
- 59:32be writing code. And there's a great article that
- 59:35popped back up on my radar. It was from like 20 years ago
- 59:37about the fallacy of the law of diminishing returns and how it
- 59:41only applies to resource based manufacturing and, you know,
- 59:46products in the real world and how they're actually laws of
- 59:49increasing returns and knowledge work.
- 59:52It's a it's a really fascinating article and well worth a read on
- 59:57how this can really apply to and Tropic other AI companies and
- 1:00:01just generally the type of economic world where now it
- 1:00:05really went into how teams are going to shift significantly to
- 1:00:09and kind of lines up with how Jack rebuilt block.
- 1:00:13And so I would recommend folks check that out as well.
- 1:00:17Who? Who wrote that?
- 1:00:20It was W Bryan Arthur, we can link to it in the shoutouts.
- 1:00:25Link to that. That sounds good.
- 1:00:27All right, like all the jumps. So maybe we'll we'll save those
- 1:00:30couple other links we had for next week.
- 1:00:33Liam, thanks for joining me as always.
- 1:00:34Thanks guys all. Right, see you.
- 1:00:38Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:00:40If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:00:42episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:00:45app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:00:47today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:00:50Before we finish, a quick reminder that Onramp Media is
- 1:00:52for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:00:55nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:00:58Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:01:01to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com/contact
- 1:01:04to schedule a consultation with one of our private Client
- 1:01:07Advisors.