Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / The War Against Medical Debt with Robert Hertz
Transcript
- 0:27Welcome to this very special edition of the cage, a
- 0:30masterclass life. The show, which ensures that you
- 0:33profit from your time. Spent here with experts, either
- 0:36through the industry, insights information, or simply learning
- 0:40from them. And today we have Bob hurts
- 0:44retired, Health, General, Insurance agent and full-time
- 0:47advocate for health reform and he discusses how individuals can
- 0:51deal with and prevent medical death.
- 0:54And he also proposes serious legal before Firms that will
- 0:57reduce the scandalous medical debt that surrounds us today in
- 1:02the US and many places across the world.
- 1:05Welcome to the show, Bob. Thank you very much AJ.
- 1:09You are welcome to the show, Welcome to India, and I'm sure a
- 1:13lot of people across the world will benefit from your advice.
- 1:17So we'll be talking about how to deal with medical debt other.
- 1:22You have waste a war against medical date.
- 1:26So first to understand from you, what's the reason behind this
- 1:30passion, the war on medical debt.
- 1:33I was an insurance agent for health coverage for for during
- 1:40my working life and I got tired of seeing the pain that was
- 1:46caused to people and I saw ways to reduce it.
- 1:51So my goal is to advise people when they have debt advice
- 1:57people how to minimize the debt and if possible suggest remedies
- 2:04for the American medical debt, Right.
- 2:07Right? And I'm sure a lot of these
- 2:09remedies in one form or the other will also be applicable to
- 2:13other places across the world because many a times this Health
- 2:17Care System. The government system is not
- 2:20able to cope with and private insurance, you know, or any sort
- 2:24of insurance, especially health insurance.
- 2:27Not everybody has been covered on with that and even then,
- 2:31there are so many things in that whole aspect of, you know,
- 2:35coverage and still They are getting that enough coverage or
- 2:39whether or insurance companies are able to honor that coverage
- 2:43when the time comes so be that as it may, Bob help us
- 2:48understand in terms of if anybody is is not able to use
- 2:54insurance. Or if the insurance is less for
- 2:57for whatever reason, the medical debt, how can one make sure that
- 3:01they do not have this medical debt especially in their lives?
- 3:06You talk about Out several points.
- 3:08So I thinking straight maybe come to that.
- 3:11Yes, there are a series of things that you have to do in
- 3:16any Nation. To limit your medical debt,
- 3:22number one, where possible ask what the procedure is going to
- 3:28cost. We have all been somewhat
- 3:31spoiled that we all, but many of us in America have been somewhat
- 3:36spoiled by having comprehensive coverage.
- 3:39And we never had to ask, and it takes a little gumption.
- 3:43We don't like to ask that of doctors, but there's really no
- 3:48choice. Ice.
- 3:49You have to ask what? It's going to cost.
- 3:52Number to document. What you are, told because
- 3:58doctors aren't perfect. Clinics aren't perfect.
- 4:01They might make a mistake or something might happen during
- 4:06your procedure. But if you have documented what
- 4:09they told you, You have a step up.
- 4:15Number three, don't pay the first bill.
- 4:20Clinics and hospitals will send out a bill.
- 4:25Sometimes the day after you're done and it's done from a
- 4:30computer. No one sat down to pick on you
- 4:33and it may not be accurate. You may be billed for things
- 4:39that we're never done for you. I won't go into the detail of
- 4:43how the bills are made, but it's a series of computer
- 4:48instructions and is not individualized.
- 4:53Number four. if you have insurance ask, if the bill has
- 4:59gone to your insurer, Some clinics knowing that insurance
- 5:04companies. Delay payments will send you the
- 5:08whole bill right away in the hope that you will be scared and
- 5:14we'll pay it all. And then if the insurance
- 5:16company comes in a month later and it's a little less well too
- 5:20bad they've got your money so you should make sure the bill is
- 5:28going to your insurance. The next thing, once you've
- 5:33cleared up these initial issues, Is to keep open a line of
- 5:40communication. It's very understandable that in
- 5:45the aftermath of a medical procedure and you may be feeling
- 5:50You may still be healing depending on how serious it was.
- 5:53It's about the last thing you want to do is to challenge or
- 5:57read or discuss a medical bill and perhaps you have a spouse or
- 6:03a friend or an advocate or someone like me to advocate for
- 6:07you but whatever it is open a line of communication with the
- 6:13provider. it's not widely known, but the worst Problems with
- 6:21medical debt including lawsuits bankruptcies.
- 6:27Legal issues. Do not come from the provider.
- 6:31As a rule, they come from the print, the doctor or the
- 6:35hospital is to some extent on your side because they have been
- 6:42patients themselves and they don't want to harm you.
- 6:46They need money and they have to operate, but they don't
- 6:50necessarily want to beat you up. And the worst instances, the
- 6:57most tragic and sad case has come when the person has ignored
- 7:03the provider. And just let the bill sit there
- 7:06for a month or two months or three months, in hopes that the
- 7:11provider will forget about it. But they won't.
- 7:15And if the provider gives up on you, and sends you to what's
- 7:21called a debt-collection agency. That's when the ugly stuff,
- 7:26really starts debt, collection agencies are impersonal.
- 7:32And uncaring, they're paid by how much they collect.
- 7:36They don't care about you, they'll call you the harass you
- 7:39they'll sue, you and they will report you to credit.
- 7:44Rose, which is in America, a whole nother problem.
- 7:47So open lines of communication with the provider, the doctor or
- 7:53the hospital doesn't have to be the actual doctor.
- 7:57They've got other things to do, but someone at the clinic next
- 8:03item is once you've decided if your charges were Fair, They
- 8:11just high but they're Fair asked to open a payment plan by that.
- 8:16I mean if a bill is 10,000 dollars, Ask if they'll accept
- 8:22three hundred dollars a month. That would be 36 hundred a year
- 8:27and be paid off in three years. In many cases, they will because
- 8:31here's a little secret. They may not get money.
- 8:34Any other way, doctors and hospitals, collect less than 15%
- 8:40of their overdue bills. That's why they hire collection
- 8:43agencies. They don't collect a lot.
- 8:45So if, if you're willing to pay over time, they'll often accept
- 8:50that. But you should not do
- 8:53incidentally. And this is tempting.
- 8:56Is to put the whole ten thousand dollar, bill on a credit card.
- 9:01As you may have a good credit card.
- 9:04But the problem there is If you ever miss a payment the interest
- 9:11rate goes way up and even without a best payment you may
- 9:15be paying 1215 even 25% interest.
- 9:21So you're ten thousand dollar. Bill will cost you a lot more
- 9:26than it should have. Yes, you'll have the
- 9:28satisfaction that it's all off. your credit but then now you
- 9:33have to pay that credit card bill and So I wouldn't I would
- 9:40not be tempted, I'd be tempted but I would not use a credit
- 9:46card. Keep things with with the
- 9:50provider. That's very important.
- 9:54Now what about an extreme case? I recently in one of my blog
- 10:01articles documented a case the finally what to the Colorado
- 10:05Supreme Court It involved the lady who had a surgery was not
- 10:11cheap. It was spinal stabilization.
- 10:14Surgery cost? I believe about 50,000 dollars
- 10:19and her insurance paid almost all of it.
- 10:22Her only obligation was her deductible.
- 10:27Well, the hospital did not accept the insurance company's
- 10:32money. They sent her a bill for 300,000
- 10:35dollars. And she didn't know what she was
- 10:38going to do. And was desperate.
- 10:42And she did my next recommendation which is in
- 10:46extreme cases. Go public.
- 10:49Go to the newspaper. Go to the State Medical Society.
- 10:55Go to the agency that. Certifies and licenses
- 11:01hospitals. Will they change it for you?
- 11:05Not often but hospitals, hate, bad publicity.
- 11:11And if you go public, Then you will have a chance that they
- 11:17will reduce the bill on their own just to keep you quiet.
- 11:23It's kind of a shame and it doesn't always work.
- 11:28American hospitals. Not all most American hospitals
- 11:32have a certain Financial cushion where they have money that they
- 11:38don't always tell us about it, but they have money put away is
- 11:42put away for expansion. Is put away for emergencies and
- 11:46they can absorb A reduced built. In fact, The Affordable Care Act
- 11:52which was with no also known as Obamacare requires nonprofit
- 11:58hospitals to consider people for financial.
- 12:03Bill reductions all the way up to about 80 thousand dollars of
- 12:08family income and almost. Nobody knows about that and very
- 12:11few people use it partly because it's hard to get.
- 12:15You have to file a lot of paperwork with the hospital's.
- 12:19They don't make it easy for you. But they will abide by it.
- 12:22So it is it is doable. So, go public.
- 12:28And my final basic recommendation and we can talk
- 12:30about public policy as well. Is.
- 12:36When you're healthy, put some money in the bank.
- 12:40You can call it a health savings account, you can call it a
- 12:43medical savings account, you can call it just a plain old savings
- 12:47account. I'm not a specialist nor would.
- 12:51I worry terribly about the The type or the legal
- 12:59classification. Savings is savings Americans.
- 13:04Again have been somewhat spoiled by having all Medical Care paid
- 13:10for. And if you get to Medicare age
- 13:13which of which I am then, it almost all is paid for.
- 13:17And so I was lucky, I sort of got away without ever saving
- 13:22much for medical care but many of my friends did not and so put
- 13:29some money aside. As the saying goes, you'll be
- 13:33glad that you did. So I'll take a pause here and
- 13:38ask if you have any questions or if I should discuss some
- 13:42solutions. Broad solutions to the problem.
- 13:47Right right. Thanks for all the points Bob
- 13:51and those are very helpful. One thing I wanted to ask about
- 13:55was that you talked about, the keep the communication lines,
- 13:58open with the health care provider or maybe the doctor,
- 14:02the clinic, or, or the hospital. Now what do you mean by this?
- 14:07Keeping the lines open. Communication lines hard
- 14:12obviously, they are not friends. So how do you just you can
- 14:16deterrent? Just keep on dropping an email,
- 14:18a how are you? And I am just so, you know,
- 14:20being in touch with you and or even with the doctor means you
- 14:24may have follow-ups but after some time they are also very
- 14:27busy. They are system is busy.
- 14:30Even if they are not busy for the patient, it always looks
- 14:33busy. And like I don't say, it's only
- 14:36in the u.s. made, I don't know much about the us, but even in
- 14:40India, even a lot of private hospitals.
- 14:43People are you smart that they are sometimes?
- 14:47Many, a times active, but it's actually very busy.
- 14:49Or maybe they just don't have that gap between one patient to
- 14:54another. I don't know this whole Health
- 14:56Care system seems to be good with all those medical
- 14:59facilities. But in terms of the human to
- 15:02human interaction that has reduced a lot, even in India.
- 15:06That's, that's right. It is a challenge.
- 15:10India has become somewhat famous, as I'm sure, you know,
- 15:14for what dr. Shetty has done there, which is
- 15:19to do operations very fast, do them safely but very fast and so
- 15:26it's a very lean Operation American Medical Offices.
- 15:31Tend to be have more Personnel. So what I'm saying may have to
- 15:36be adapted, but in any event You don't again, the doctor gives
- 15:42probably the worst person here because they're busy, they don't
- 15:47like doing this negotiation, some will.
- 15:50But at any rate, go to the business manager of the clinic
- 15:56and document your communication, it has to be by a little male.
- 16:02It's my mail, if it's, by mail call week later, did you get the
- 16:06mail if it's by telephone right down?
- 16:10Who you talk to? I talked to mr.
- 16:12Or mrs. Smith at 8:15 a.m. on May 7.
- 16:20And so, it's a, it's a chain of custody if you will to document
- 16:26what you have done. So communicate and document and
- 16:32it's not easy, there was a In a way, we should be thankful.
- 16:39We can communicate. It was a sad story from an
- 16:43African nation. I forget if it was Nigeria or
- 16:47Kenya, it was a nation which doesn't have much money for
- 16:52medical care. And in that country if you can't
- 16:55pay your hospital bill, They will keep you in the hospital.
- 17:01There are people who have been in the hospital for 40 days and
- 17:06they were cured in two days but the hospital is waiting for
- 17:11their relatives to come pay the bill.
- 17:14So be thankful for paperwork, it's better if I'm being held in
- 17:19the hospital. Right.
- 17:22Right. Right.
- 17:24Go Bob now, it isn't it a very different sort of the situation,
- 17:29you know, that this whole medical profession or the
- 17:32Hippocratic oath and all that stuff.
- 17:34It seeing being a doctor in the medical profession is in.
- 17:40It is called a noble profession and and somehow, this whole
- 17:44system has got Twisted with. I don't know what's.
- 17:47What's the reason? Maybe corporate money coming in
- 17:49investor money. Camellia.
- 17:51It is. It has certainly brought much
- 17:53more efficiency within the system in somewhere man, but a
- 17:57lot of things have not you know are not up to the mark in many,
- 18:00many places that's right. And I will talk about the
- 18:06financial aspect. And I'm going to refer to
- 18:09America. But what I say may be applicable
- 18:13in closed form in other nations, here's what's happened?
- 18:19Medical insurance keeps costing more often because we have new
- 18:25procedures that are good. They save lives, but they cost a
- 18:29lot and insurance covers them, and so Insurance costs more The
- 18:37reaction to that, since no one wants to pay extra money there,
- 18:43as we used to say, there's no place in heaven for the person
- 18:46who played too much for their insurance.
- 18:47People want to spend less on insurance public or private.
- 18:51And so, one way to spend less on insurance is to increase what
- 18:57are called the deductibles, which is the first 2,000 3,000,
- 19:024,000 dollars of your bill that you pay yourself and On a
- 19:0710-thousand dollar bill. The insurance company only has
- 19:10to pay six or seven thousand so that should lower your insurance
- 19:16premium and people like that they like lower premiums.
- 19:20However, if you're perfectly healthy all year you win, you've
- 19:26had the lower premium. You could ignore the deductible
- 19:30because you never got sick. But to some extent you're
- 19:33betting against yourself because if you are sick, you face that
- 19:39deductible. So it's a conflict that I don't
- 19:42blame on the doctors. I don't blame it on the
- 19:45insurance companies. They have to, they have to
- 19:48break. Even we don't want them to go
- 19:50broke. They have many flaws but they
- 19:53need to collect. And so there's a conflict and in
- 19:58truth it may take Government money to smooth this over.
- 20:08In the Affordable Care Act, which is only a portion of
- 20:11American Health Care. There is a government program to
- 20:16help reduce your deductibles. So if the deductible is three
- 20:21thousand dollars, a government program will come in and pay two
- 20:25thousand dollars, if you get sick.
- 20:29Medicare has the same thing, although it's more complicated
- 20:33and you have to pay for that privilege and not everybody in
- 20:37the Affordable Care Act. Yes.
- 20:38So I won't go into all the details, but there may be no way
- 20:43to resolve this other than some government money.
- 20:47And so I always if someone if someone says oh we're spending
- 20:54too much on health care, I always say slow down, let's read
- 20:59what we are spending and maybe it helps people to the point
- 21:04that it's worthwhile spending. Absolutely.
- 21:08Absolutely Bob. So you were also, talking about
- 21:11seven Solutions. Are there any solutions for for
- 21:14this problem? Well, yes, one solution is to
- 21:19consider what some countries have done, Francis done.
- 21:24This Germany has done this to some extent.
- 21:29The the Scandinavian countries, if that's it, what they do is
- 21:36they Place legal limits on these deductibles.
- 21:41In Germany, the maximum deductible is about two hundred
- 21:44dollars. It's not two thousand dollars.
- 21:47It's not 4,000. in France, the deductible does not apply if you
- 21:54have a chronic illness, like diabetes or asthma, Because then
- 22:00you will have to get care every month or two.
- 22:03You should you care? You may be hospitalized more
- 22:08than once and so you're Exempted from the deductible.
- 22:14So that's one of the first things is reform, the
- 22:18deductibles a second item is has to do with liability. in
- 22:30America, when you go into the hospital, You sign a form that
- 22:36says I am liable for any charges that I may incur.
- 22:42And I understandably, I can understand why hospitals put
- 22:48that there but it's not a good form.
- 22:51It should be amended I'm not sure the legal language and we
- 22:56can take a long time. We don't have time to discuss
- 22:58that. But you should not be forced to
- 23:01agree to any bill or any charge. I would favor.
- 23:06What are I call Health courts, we have an America, many
- 23:12different types of specialty courts, we have drug courts, we
- 23:15have family courts, we have bankruptcy courts, we have
- 23:21Automobile courts. These are courts were the judges
- 23:25specialized the attorney specialized.
- 23:28I think we should have health Courts for medical bills so
- 23:33those are three things that I think would be good reforms.
- 23:37Wonderful, wonderful, nice, nice ideas.
- 23:39And even about, you know, talked about Germany and France.
- 23:43Those are those are indeed good things that can be implemented
- 23:47and should be implemented in as many places as possible.
- 23:52And I'm sure with these steps things will be better but there
- 23:55is so much to do in healthcare, you know, and this is just one
- 23:58episode and I'm sure a lot of people will learn from you in
- 24:03this episode but to know more there is so much to do learn You
- 24:07know, more from you on this. So how do people connect with
- 24:11you about what's the best way to do that?
- 24:13Yes, I have a Blog that's called forwards, the anti debt agenda,
- 24:22and you can just type those in and in your search engine and
- 24:27you'll see articles and Communications on this subject,
- 24:33I should also mention. That if this if this bothers you
- 24:38and you want to really, you want to actually help some people,
- 24:41which is wonderful, there is an organization that I'm close to.
- 24:47It's out of New York but it is Nationwide.
- 24:51It's called our IP medical debt. And this organization.
- 25:01Gets charitable contributions, usually from churches.
- 25:05And they are able to go in. It's Complicated.
- 25:08I won't go in to the mechanics but they are able to go in and
- 25:12forgive actual bills. And they try to do it based on
- 25:18people who don't have much money and who could never pay the bill
- 25:22even if they wanted to, and they can't forgive them all.
- 25:26It's a big country and their one organization, they were founded
- 25:33by a large Grant from the divorced wife of Jeffrey bezels.
- 25:39His wife, Mackenzie Scott received about 50 billion
- 25:42dollars. In the divorce and she is
- 25:45funding groups like this. So good for her.
- 25:50Good food, hot. And in fact, very good of you
- 25:52also to spread so much of wariness about this medical
- 25:56devstack stuff, and I'm sure with so much of awareness people
- 26:00will not only, you know, be aware about their rights, what
- 26:04they can do, while they are in hospital or out of it, but also
- 26:08look at the savings part that you suggested to save when they
- 26:12are healthy enough for themselves for the future.
- 26:16So with this, it's a rap on this very special.
- 26:19Addition of the cage, a masterclass life.
- 26:21Thank you so much indeed for joining us.
- 26:24Thank you AJ. I'll it was a pleasure to speak
- 26:26to your audience.