Latest / Bloomberg Law / Supreme Court to Rule on Guns for Domestic Abusers
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:09Speaker 2: It was spaghetti night last Wednesday at Cook's Corner Restaurant
- 0:12Speaker 2: and bar, a time when people in the tight knit
- 0:15Speaker 2: California community gathered to share a meal. But it became
- 0:26Speaker 2: the scene of another mass shooting when a retired police
- 0:29Speaker 2: sergeant came in armed with two handguns, fired at his
- 0:33Speaker 2: estranged wife, and then began to randomly shoot.
- 0:37Speaker 3: We believe he traveled from Ohio with an ongoing dispute
- 0:42Speaker 3: regarding the separation of penny divorce with his wife.
- 0:45Speaker 2: He killed three people and injured six others before he
- 0:48Speaker 2: was killed by police. More than two thirds of mass
- 0:52Speaker 2: shootings are domestic violence incidents or are perpetrated by shooters
- 0:56Speaker 2: with a history of domestic violence. That's according to a
- 0:59Speaker 2: stunted by the JOHNS. Hopkins Center for Gun Violence Solutions
- 1:03Speaker 2: and a case before the Supreme Court. This term will
- 1:06Speaker 2: determine the fate of a federal law that bar's gun
- 1:09Speaker 2: possession by people who are subject to a domestic violence
- 1:13Speaker 2: restraining order. Joining me is Second Amendment expert Eric Rubin,
- 1:17Speaker 2: a professor at the SMU Deadman's School of Law. Eric
- 1:20Speaker 2: how important is the Supreme Court case.
- 1:23Speaker 1: It's a hugely important case, and it's a hugely important
- 1:27Speaker 1: policy area because it deals with a modern day restriction
- 1:31Speaker 1: on gun possession by domestic abusers, in particular by people
- 1:36Speaker 1: found by a judge to pose a specific threat of
- 1:39Speaker 1: domestic violence and who are subject to a protective order.
- 1:42Speaker 1: And the reason why it's so important is because we
- 1:45Speaker 1: now know that women are five times more likely to
- 1:47Speaker 1: die in a domestic violence situation if a gun is present.
- 1:50Speaker 1: In fact, every month, an average of seventy women are
- 1:53Speaker 1: shot and killed by an intimate partner. And what this
- 1:56Speaker 1: decade's old law is trying to do is to remove
- 1:59Speaker 1: the ethal means of a firearm from somebody who's been
- 2:03Speaker 1: found to be violent to a spouse or someone else
- 2:07Speaker 1: in the home.
- 2:09Speaker 2: So let's remind everyone of what the test is that
- 2:13Speaker 2: was established in the landmark twenty twenty two Bruin case.
- 2:18Speaker 1: So the Bruin case, which means issued in June of
- 2:22Speaker 1: twenty twenty two, announced a brand new test for Second
- 2:25Speaker 1: Amendment cases. In particular after Bruin, the constitutionality of a
- 2:31Speaker 1: gun law like the one at issue in Rehimi turns
- 2:34Speaker 1: on whether the law is analogous in some ill defined
- 2:38Speaker 1: sense to historical gun laws and historical regulation of firearms,
- 2:43Speaker 1: and by historical the court the late seventeen hundreds or
- 2:47Speaker 1: perhaps into the eighteen hundreds at the time when the
- 2:50Speaker 1: Fourteenth Amendment was enacted. It's an unusual test. It's different
- 2:54Speaker 1: from the one that governs other individual rights contexts and
- 2:58Speaker 1: in practice, and what the Bruin case meant was that
- 3:02Speaker 1: it didn't matter at all that all of the courts
- 3:05Speaker 1: to consider the constitutionality of this domestic violence restriction before
- 3:09Speaker 1: Bruin had found it to be perfectly constitutional, because they'd
- 3:13Speaker 1: applied a different test that considered contemporary costs and benefits
- 3:17Speaker 1: and in fact litigans. After Bruin got a do over
- 3:21Speaker 1: under this new historical analogical test, not just with respect
- 3:25Speaker 1: to this domestic violence restriction, but with respect to all
- 3:28Speaker 1: weapons restrictions.
- 3:29Speaker 2: The test makes no sense to me, because how do
- 3:31Speaker 2: you judge modern weapons that the framers could never have
- 3:34Speaker 2: envisioned with a standard from centuries ago. Does it lead
- 3:39Speaker 2: to less gun control regulations?
- 3:43Speaker 1: Well, I think that that was one of the reasons
- 3:46Speaker 1: why the Supreme Court, or at least the Fist Justices
- 3:48Speaker 1: and the majority handed down this Bruin test. In the
- 3:51Speaker 1: Bruin opinion, the majority said that the lower courts were
- 3:55Speaker 1: being too deferential to legislative determinations of policy needs, and
- 4:00Speaker 1: so in effect the test cuts out, or at least
- 4:03Speaker 1: minimizes the importance of modern day assessments of what will
- 4:06Speaker 1: keep the public safe. And in this particular case, the
- 4:09Speaker 1: fifths are decided that the law contradicts the nation's historical
- 4:13Speaker 1: tradition of gun regulation. And you raise an important point,
- 4:17Speaker 1: which is, how do you actually do this analogical exercise
- 4:21Speaker 1: given how different things are today. They're different in terms
- 4:25Speaker 1: of the technology of firearms today versus back in the
- 4:29Speaker 1: age of muskets and muzzle loaded guns. They're different in
- 4:32Speaker 1: terms of our cultural norms in our legal order is
- 4:36Speaker 1: very different, and this case actually highlights these differences in
- 4:39Speaker 1: a very stark way.
- 4:41Speaker 2: So tell us about the facts of this case and
- 4:44Speaker 2: the procedural history.
- 4:46Speaker 1: In this case. The defendant. This is an appeal from
- 4:50Speaker 1: a criminal conviction. The defendant, Zachi Raheemi, had assaulted his
- 4:54Speaker 1: girlfriend and then he actually agreed to a restraining order
- 4:58Speaker 1: that prohibited from possessing firearms. He was later caught with
- 5:01Speaker 1: a gun and in fact, he had been firing the
- 5:03Speaker 1: gun a number of occasions, and he was prosecuted under
- 5:07Speaker 1: a federal law that bar's gun possession by people who
- 5:10Speaker 1: were situated like Brahemi under a restraining order found by
- 5:14Speaker 1: a judge to pose a specific threat of domestic violence,
- 5:17Speaker 1: and he argued that that federal law violated his Second
- 5:21Speaker 1: Amendment rights. The Fifth Circuit ultimately agreed, after the Bruin
- 5:25Speaker 1: case came down that this was the Second Amendment violation.
- 5:28Speaker 1: And in terms of the procedural history, where we are
- 5:30Speaker 1: is the government. The federal government appealed or sought an
- 5:34Speaker 1: intervention by the Supreme Court, and the Supreme Court decided
- 5:38Speaker 1: late last term in June of twenty twenty three, that
- 5:42Speaker 1: it was going to acceptlicate. So last week all of
- 5:46Speaker 1: the briefs in support of the government's position in support
- 5:49Speaker 1: of the constitutionality of this restriction were due and a
- 5:52Speaker 1: lot of briefs were file. In fact, thirty eight briefs
- 5:55Speaker 1: were filed last week, which I think shows the significance
- 5:59Speaker 1: of the issue.
- 6:01Speaker 2: Did the Supreme Court almost have to take the case?
- 6:04Speaker 2: How are the circuits ruling on this issue?
- 6:07Speaker 1: Yeah, So the Supreme Court has a lot of discretion
- 6:09Speaker 1: about what cases it takes, but this case presented an
- 6:13Speaker 1: issue and a conflict that made it hard for the
- 6:16Speaker 1: Supreme Court to say no to it. In particular, it's
- 6:19Speaker 1: a federal law that was struck down in the Fifth Circuit,
- 6:21Speaker 1: and the Supreme Court tends to take cases where federal
- 6:26Speaker 1: laws are struck down. And there also is just a
- 6:28Speaker 1: lot of confusion in the lower court about this issue,
- 6:32Speaker 1: and frankly all Second Amendment issues after Bruin. So the
- 6:35Speaker 1: Fifth Circuit declared that this law was unconstitutional, but other
- 6:39Speaker 1: lower federal judges have declared it to be perfectly constitutional.
- 6:43Speaker 1: And that's reflective of what we were seeing over the
- 6:46Speaker 1: past year and Second Amendment cases where judges looking at
- 6:52Speaker 1: the same historical record or reaching diametrically opposed conclusions about
- 6:57Speaker 1: whether modern day laws or constitution or not. And I
- 7:00Speaker 1: think that's very telling that this is happening, in particular
- 7:04Speaker 1: because one of the reasons that the Supreme Court issued
- 7:06Speaker 1: this historical test was purportedly to constrain judges, but the
- 7:11Speaker 1: results of opinions that were issued over the past year
- 7:15Speaker 1: show that that's not happening so far.
- 7:17Speaker 2: As you mentioned, there are more than three dozen briefs
- 7:20Speaker 2: filed by organizations ranging from women's groups to prosecutors to
- 7:25Speaker 2: history scholars.
- 7:26Speaker 4: And I know you submitted one.
- 7:28Speaker 2: Can you characterize the nature of these briefs?
- 7:32Speaker 1: Sure? So you know the briefs I think fall into
- 7:34Speaker 1: three general buckets. Some are historical, somewhere methodological, and then
- 7:39Speaker 1: some were just policy. There are a lot of briefs
- 7:42Speaker 1: that are focusing on historical regulation, and that's because Bruin
- 7:47Speaker 1: says that the constitutionality of modern laws turns on whether
- 7:50Speaker 1: or not the laws are consistent with historical tradition. So,
- 7:53Speaker 1: for example, eighteen professors of English and American history signed
- 7:58Speaker 1: on to a brief that was talking about why guns
- 8:03Speaker 1: weren't frequently used in domestic violence situations in the founding,
- 8:06Speaker 1: and in particular just because the technology at the time
- 8:10Speaker 1: didn't make them readily available in domestic conflicts. So, no
- 8:14Speaker 1: matter what we thought about domestic violence back in the
- 8:17Speaker 1: late seventeen hundreds, we wouldn't expect to see the regulation
- 8:21Speaker 1: of guns in the domestic violence context. And that brief
- 8:24Speaker 1: also pointed out that our legal view of women was
- 8:28Speaker 1: very different. Women were not viewed as equal to men
- 8:32Speaker 1: in a legal sense, and there wasn't robust protection of
- 8:36Speaker 1: those who were abused in the domestic context, even though
- 8:39Speaker 1: there were some restrictions. So the brief and others that
- 8:41Speaker 1: fall into this historical camp are looking a lot at
- 8:45Speaker 1: what the shape of historical regulations were.
- 8:48Speaker 2: And I saw that one brief said that guns in
- 8:52Speaker 2: use at the time of the founding weren't great weapons
- 8:54Speaker 2: for crimes of passion because you didn't have handguns and no.
- 8:59Speaker 1: These were muscle loaded firearms. In fact, it was unsafe
- 9:01Speaker 1: to keep them loaded. There were some regulations that required
- 9:05Speaker 1: the gun, that gunpowder be stored separate from the firearm
- 9:09Speaker 1: itself because they're liable to missfire and start fires. And
- 9:12Speaker 1: so in crimes of passion and a lot of domestic
- 9:15Speaker 1: violence fits into that category, people would grab whatever is
- 9:19Speaker 1: close at hand, such as you know, sticks and rocks
- 9:23Speaker 1: and blump force objects, but not firearms which took time
- 9:27Speaker 1: to load and then use. So the historical context is
- 9:31Speaker 1: incredibly important, and these briefs are arguing that the fifth
- 9:34Speaker 1: Circuit just didn't pay enough attention to that historical context.
- 9:38Speaker 1: So that's a major thread.
- 9:40Speaker 4: And what about your brief, What where is your argument?
- 9:43Speaker 1: So my brief, which I filed with Mariva Siegel at Yale,
- 9:47Speaker 1: Joseph B. Looker at Duke, Daryl Miller at Duke, and
- 9:50Speaker 1: Jake Charles at Pepperdine, with the assistance of Don Burrilly
- 9:53Speaker 1: at Monger Toles, who was our council, was a methodological
- 9:56Speaker 1: grief more so than an historical brief, And in particular,
- 9:59Speaker 1: what we pointed out is that a lot of the
- 10:01Speaker 1: reasons there's so much disagreement in the lower courts is
- 10:04Speaker 1: because courts are not applying an even handed analysis, an
- 10:09Speaker 1: even handed historical analysis to the scope of the right
- 10:12Speaker 1: to keep and bear arms on the one hand, and
- 10:15Speaker 1: our tradition of regulation on the other. In particular, there
- 10:18Speaker 1: are some courts that are taking a super expansive view
- 10:22Speaker 1: of what the right to keep in bear arms protects,
- 10:25Speaker 1: but then applying a different lens, a narrow lens, to
- 10:28Speaker 1: the historical regulations. To the time, they'll say that all
- 10:31Speaker 1: weapons are protected by the right to keeping bear arms,
- 10:34Speaker 1: But then when looking at a regulation, they'll say, oh,
- 10:37Speaker 1: only this particular category of person was disarmed at the founding,
- 10:41Speaker 1: and that particular category of person is not the one
- 10:45Speaker 1: that the modern regulation is. This army and therefore it's
- 10:47Speaker 1: not analogous. And what we're arguing as a methodological point
- 10:52Speaker 1: is that if we're going to do this exercise, that's
- 10:54Speaker 1: set down and Bruin courts should be doing it in
- 10:57Speaker 1: an even handed way. And if they're to do that,
- 11:00Speaker 1: I think that the result in the Raheemi case would
- 11:03Speaker 1: have come out differently.
- 11:05Speaker 2: Do all the briefs accept the Bruin test and are
- 11:08Speaker 2: not trying to say that the Brewin test was wrong.
- 11:11Speaker 1: One interesting thing is that there were a couple briefs
- 11:14Speaker 1: that argued that Bruin and Heller should be overturned because
- 11:18Speaker 1: they've just proven to be inconsistent with the approach that
- 11:22Speaker 1: the Supreme Court is taking to other issues like abortion
- 11:25Speaker 1: and unworkable in practice. And so there were some briefs
- 11:29Speaker 1: that were filed in this case that argue for a
- 11:32Speaker 1: wholesale reversal of Bruin in even the two thousand and
- 11:37Speaker 1: eight decision Heller that found an individual rights to possess
- 11:40Speaker 1: a handgun in a home for self defense. But most
- 11:43Speaker 1: of the briefs that are filed are accepting the Brewin
- 11:46Speaker 1: test and then saying even under that test, the outcome
- 11:49Speaker 1: should have been different because the historical analysis in the
- 11:53Speaker 1: lower court was wrong that the Court didn't apply Bruin
- 11:57Speaker 1: faithfully because it took a different approach with respect the
- 12:01Speaker 1: rights on the one hand and regulations on the other.
- 12:04Speaker 1: And then there's some briefs that are pointing out the
- 12:06Speaker 1: important policy implications that are modern day policy implication when
- 12:10Speaker 1: it comes to domestic violence in the home.
- 12:13Speaker 2: Which of the conservative justices are these briefs trying to convince.
- 12:18Speaker 1: It's always hard to know what various briefs are trying
- 12:22Speaker 1: to do or who the specific justice is, who the
- 12:25Speaker 1: brief seeking to make their audience, But there certainly seem
- 12:29Speaker 1: to be some briefs that are focused at the more
- 12:32Speaker 1: moderate conservative justices like Kavanaugh and Amy Cony Barrett, who
- 12:39Speaker 1: might join with other justices to make a majority and
- 12:43Speaker 1: uphold this domestic violence restriction.
- 12:46Speaker 2: Even in the Bruin case. Was it the Chief Justice
- 12:48Speaker 2: in Kavanaugh who wrote a concurring opinion?
- 12:51Speaker 1: Even Coded Derek wrote an opinion a concurring opinion, as
- 12:54Speaker 1: did Kavanaugh and Chief Justice Roberts, And the concurrence by
- 12:59Speaker 1: the Chief Justice and Justice Kabanah was interesting because it
- 13:03Speaker 1: went out of its way to emphasize that the Brewin
- 13:07Speaker 1: test even though it's a novel test is not a
- 13:09Speaker 1: straight jacket, and that it still permits ample regulation, and
- 13:14Speaker 1: that opinion even went through a list of presumptively lawful
- 13:18Speaker 1: regulations such as disarming people who've been convicted of a
- 13:21Speaker 1: felony and other restrictions that was in Heller, but Justice
- 13:26Speaker 1: Thomas did not include in the majority opinion in Bruin.
- 13:30Speaker 1: So it's possible that some of the amiki who are
- 13:34Speaker 1: submitting briefs are focused on justices like the Chief Justice
- 13:38Speaker 1: and Justice Kabanagh who took the time in space to
- 13:43Speaker 1: emphasize the limits of the Bruin decision back in twenty twenty.
- 13:47Speaker 2: Two, And we have yet to see the responding briefs
- 13:49Speaker 2: in this case. That should be interesting as well. Thanks
- 13:52Speaker 2: so much, Eric. That's Professor Eric Rubin of the SMU
- 13:55Speaker 2: Deadman's School of Law. Michael Bloomberg, the founder and majority
- 13:59Speaker 2: owner of Blue LP, the parent company of Bloomberg Radio,
- 14:03Speaker 2: is a donor to groups that support gun control, including
- 14:06Speaker 2: Every Town for Gun Safety. The National Labor Relations Board
- 14:12Speaker 2: handed unions of victory with a decision allowing unions to
- 14:15Speaker 2: represent workers without a formal vote. The NLRB's Democratic majority
- 14:21Speaker 2: created a new test that resurrected elements of the standard
- 14:25Speaker 2: from the board's nineteen forty nine ruling enjoys silk mills,
- 14:30Speaker 2: But unlike that earlier test, the new framework doesn't turn
- 14:33Speaker 2: on proving that employers had a good faith doubt that
- 14:37Speaker 2: unions have majority support in order to require them to
- 14:40Speaker 2: recognize and bargain with unions. Instead, the new framework calls
- 14:44Speaker 2: on employers to recognize a new union or promptly file
- 14:48Speaker 2: for an election when the union asks for recognition based
- 14:52Speaker 2: on a majority of workers showing support. My guest is
- 14:55Speaker 2: labor law expert Anne Marie Lofasso, a professor at West
- 14:58Speaker 2: Virginia University College of Law and a former NLRB attorney,
- 15:03Speaker 2: And do you want to give us a little background
- 15:05Speaker 2: on This is one of the.
- 15:07Speaker 3: Most difficult areas of law, so I've simplified it. So
- 15:11Speaker 3: there are two main ways for a union to get recognition.
- 15:14Speaker 3: The first way is that the employer can voluntarily recognize
- 15:17Speaker 3: the union based on a card check and that would
- 15:20Speaker 3: mean a majority of authenticated car or the employer can
- 15:24Speaker 3: reject the union's demand for recognition, and then the union
- 15:28Speaker 3: has to petition for the election, and then the election
- 15:31Speaker 3: is typically held within five weeks. Okay, so those are
- 15:34Speaker 3: the two main things, at least up until this case.
- 15:37Speaker 3: So now, during the critical period, and that's the time
- 15:40Speaker 3: between the petition for the election up to the election,
- 15:43Speaker 3: the employer will typically hold something called captive audience speeches
- 15:47Speaker 3: to explain why employees should not vote for the union.
- 15:50Speaker 3: And studies show that if the employer holds five of these,
- 15:53Speaker 3: the union has almost no chance of winning, so something
- 15:55Speaker 3: like ninety four percent chance of losing the election. But
- 15:59Speaker 3: even one captive audience speech substantially lowers the union's chances
- 16:02Speaker 3: of winning. Now, why you might ask, it's because one
- 16:06Speaker 3: these speeches are intended to dissuade employees from voting for
- 16:10Speaker 3: the union. The union has no right to reply. And
- 16:13Speaker 3: although these speeches are not per se unlawful, they often
- 16:16Speaker 3: contain threats and other coercive conduct. So there's this big
- 16:19Speaker 3: case called Gissel that's in nineteen sixty nine, goes to
- 16:22Speaker 3: the Supreme Court, and Gissle presented the paradigm fact pattern
- 16:25Speaker 3: that is in this case. So what's the paradigm fact pattern?
- 16:28Speaker 3: Hotly contested election campaign, union obtains a card majority, the
- 16:33Speaker 3: employer refuses to recognize the union based on the card majority,
- 16:37Speaker 3: lots and lots of unfair labor practices. Many of those
- 16:41Speaker 3: unfair labor practice are called hallmark unfair labor practices. Then
- 16:45Speaker 3: what happens is the union loses the election even though
- 16:48Speaker 3: it had a card majority, because of all these unfair
- 16:51Speaker 3: labor practices. So if the Board finds that the severity
- 16:55Speaker 3: of these violations makes them likely to have a lasting
- 16:59Speaker 3: inhibitive effect on a substantial percentage of the workforce, thereby
- 17:03Speaker 3: making a fair rerun election unlikely, then it can issue
- 17:06Speaker 3: what's called this gissle bargaining order. It's now the problem
- 17:10Speaker 3: with the disl bargaining order. Even though the Supreme Court said, yep,
- 17:14Speaker 3: this is fine, this is okay, by the late seventies
- 17:18Speaker 3: and eighties, the courts aren't actually enforcing these orders, so
- 17:22Speaker 3: they get harder and harder to enforce, so that they're
- 17:25Speaker 3: almost never issued anymore. The Board doesn't even try so
- 17:28Speaker 3: tell us.
- 17:28Speaker 2: About this case and the procedural history.
- 17:32Speaker 3: This case is the same fact pattern of gissel. There's
- 17:37Speaker 3: a card majority, everyone agrees, there's a card majority, and
- 17:40Speaker 3: then there's tons of unfair labor practices. So the union
- 17:44Speaker 3: loses the election. These unfair layer practices are all hallmark violations,
- 17:49Speaker 3: so really scary things that are going to reverberate through
- 17:53Speaker 3: the bargaining units. The board says, we're going to overrule
- 17:57Speaker 3: Linden Lumber. So when the un and asked for recognition,
- 18:01Speaker 3: the employer no longer can say no. It has two choices.
- 18:05Speaker 3: It has to either say yes or the employer has
- 18:10Speaker 3: to file an election petition. Those are only two choices.
- 18:14Speaker 3: It doesn't have to say no and then make the
- 18:16Speaker 3: union do it. It has to say either yes or
- 18:19Speaker 3: say no. No good faith out doesn't have to have
- 18:22Speaker 3: a good faith out. I'm going to do the election.
- 18:24Speaker 3: And the reason this simplifies the whole thing is because
- 18:28Speaker 3: joy Silk was very difficult to enforce. Because the good
- 18:32Speaker 3: faced out standard is very difficult to enforce. How do
- 18:35Speaker 3: you figure out if the employer really has a good
- 18:37Speaker 3: faced doubt gift is hard to enforce. Here, you're just saying,
- 18:40Speaker 3: at the moment that the union says to the employer,
- 18:45Speaker 3: we want recognition, here's our card majority, the employer has
- 18:48Speaker 3: to make a choice recognize or go to an election,
- 18:52Speaker 3: and it can't dilly dally. The election has to take place,
- 18:55Speaker 3: and if it refuses to do that, that's an unfair
- 18:59Speaker 3: layer of practice. That's what this case is about.
- 19:01Speaker 2: So does this restore the practices of the Obama administration?
- 19:07Speaker 3: No, it doesn't. It actually changes the whole thing. This
- 19:11Speaker 3: is not a case that is restoring something that Obama did.
- 19:15Speaker 3: This is something that is different from anything the board
- 19:20Speaker 3: has ever done. It's completely new. And what's important here
- 19:25Speaker 3: is not so much whether the employer recognizes or not
- 19:28Speaker 3: the voluntary card check, or they there's an election. The
- 19:32Speaker 3: really big problem is what happens when the employer engages
- 19:35Speaker 3: in all these unfair labor practices that make a fair
- 19:38Speaker 3: election impossible or nearly impossible, very difficult. What's the remedy.
- 19:43Speaker 3: So the remedy here is to go at that moment
- 19:47Speaker 3: when the union asks. The Obama administration would have said,
- 19:52Speaker 3: when the union asks, the employer can say no and
- 19:56Speaker 3: then just sit on its butt and do nothing. And
- 19:59Speaker 3: then the un it has to file all the election paperwork,
- 20:02Speaker 3: and then there's all these hearings. There's all this stuff, right,
- 20:06Speaker 3: and that was the way it was for a long time,
- 20:08Speaker 3: and then after several years, if there's finding that there's
- 20:12Speaker 3: all these unfair labor practices. Once the union files the
- 20:16Speaker 3: election petition, then you might get this thing called the
- 20:19Speaker 3: Gistol bargaining order. Here, the employer has to say yes
- 20:23Speaker 3: or no, has to commit, and if it says no,
- 20:26Speaker 3: it has to file the election petition, and if it
- 20:30Speaker 3: does anything during that time, it's an unfair labor practice.
- 20:34Speaker 3: So it's actually a cleaner rule. It actually simplifies the
- 20:38Speaker 3: whole rule. It makes it easier. I think it's going
- 20:41Speaker 3: to be easier to enforce in the courts, which these
- 20:44Speaker 3: other two they're very difficult to understand and they're very
- 20:46Speaker 3: difficult to enforce.
- 20:48Speaker 2: So this was two to one decision, and the Republican dissented.
- 20:54Speaker 3: Actually even the Republican right, even the descent agrees, this
- 20:58Speaker 3: is egregious. What's this employer did is egregious. And so
- 21:01Speaker 3: he says, why are we even deciding this because either
- 21:04Speaker 3: way they get a bargaining order. And the majority says, well,
- 21:09Speaker 3: because this presents the question and we can do that.
- 21:12Speaker 3: So he doesn't even want to reach the question. But
- 21:14Speaker 3: he doesn't like it anyway. He thinks it's a bad idea,
- 21:17Speaker 3: But I actually think it's a brilliant strategy. Obviously, I
- 21:20Speaker 3: can see why he's dissenting if you're on the Republican side,
- 21:24Speaker 3: But from the pro employee pro union side, it's a
- 21:28Speaker 3: brilliant strategy because if it's enforceable under either rule, the
- 21:33Speaker 3: Supreme Court won't take it because it doesn't squarely present
- 21:36Speaker 3: the issue. So that means they're going to have to
- 21:38Speaker 3: wait for other cases to percolate. So it's actually a
- 21:42Speaker 3: really smart strategy to allow this to kind of mature
- 21:45Speaker 3: among the different courts of appeals to see how they
- 21:49Speaker 3: deal with this.
- 21:50Speaker 4: Do you think this will be appealed?
- 21:52Speaker 3: Oh, definitely, no doubt. This is such a big case.
- 21:56Speaker 3: There'll be a petition for review immediately.
- 22:00Speaker 2: What were some of the things the company was accused
- 22:02Speaker 2: of doing that were so terrible in the Labor Board's eyes?
- 22:06Speaker 3: They threatened job loss. When you threaten people with jobs,
- 22:10Speaker 3: they don't vote for unions that they get really really scared.
- 22:15Speaker 3: They got rid of the main union organizer threat Those
- 22:18Speaker 3: are the main ones. But they also did coercive behavior
- 22:22Speaker 3: almost daily during this election campaign. They would, you know,
- 22:28Speaker 3: constantly do things like we won't provide you with help,
- 22:33Speaker 3: They wouldn't support the employees. They did everything they could
- 22:36Speaker 3: to make the employees' lives very difficult. They said the
- 22:40Speaker 3: employer violated the Act when it deployed security guards at
- 22:45Speaker 3: numerous plans for two weeks before the election, at all
- 22:48Speaker 3: the polling places. That's intimidating. If you wanted to change
- 22:52Speaker 3: the rule, this is the case you want, because even
- 22:56Speaker 3: your most conservative board member is going to say, yeah,
- 22:59Speaker 3: this is a gift. And any court is going to
- 23:02Speaker 3: uphold a ghistle bargaining order here because it's so egregious. Now,
- 23:08Speaker 3: there are two ways that the ghistle bargaining order might
- 23:12Speaker 3: not be upheld. And this is where the problems come in.
- 23:16Speaker 3: Is if there's like a lot of turnover, then a
- 23:19Speaker 3: lot of courts are really persuaded by that argument that oh,
- 23:23Speaker 3: there's all this employee turnover or there's lots of supervisory turnover.
- 23:28Speaker 3: And the problem with that is that the ghistle bargaining
- 23:30Speaker 3: Order was supposed to attach back when there was a majority,
- 23:34Speaker 3: and so they go, well, this is the future now.
- 23:36Speaker 3: And that's why.
- 23:37Speaker 1: Unions love this.
- 23:38Speaker 3: I think the unions will love this anyway because it says,
- 23:41Speaker 3: at that moment, the employer has to make a choice, yes,
- 23:44Speaker 3: we will recognize you or no. We're not recognizing you,
- 23:47Speaker 3: but we're going to the election, and once it does
- 23:50Speaker 3: anything to then interfere with that election, it's an unfair
- 23:54Speaker 3: layer practice. So it's sort of bringing it back to
- 23:57Speaker 3: the moment that things are happening. It's harder to make
- 24:01Speaker 3: the arguments that have been successful in getting rid of
- 24:03Speaker 3: these gifts of bargaining orders. And remember, what's the whole
- 24:06Speaker 3: point of having an election. The point of having election
- 24:09Speaker 3: is not to win the election. It's to win the
- 24:12Speaker 3: election so that you can then get a collective bargaining agreement.
- 24:16Speaker 3: So the whole point of the election is to get negotiations.
- 24:18Speaker 3: So what the player is doing here in these cases
- 24:22Speaker 3: is it's basically terrorizing its employee workforce with threats of
- 24:26Speaker 3: job loss and things like that so that they don't
- 24:29Speaker 3: vote for the union. And then there's a finding that
- 24:32Speaker 3: they didn't vote for the union, not out of ree choice,
- 24:35Speaker 3: but out of fear, so it was inhibited votes and
- 24:38Speaker 3: so therefore there wasn't really this freedom of association which
- 24:43Speaker 3: is guaranteed expressly by the Act in the words of
- 24:45Speaker 3: the Act.
- 24:46Speaker 4: So how important is this decision?
- 24:48Speaker 3: Then this is a very stunning decision because it does
- 24:53Speaker 3: something the board has never done before, and it grounds
- 24:56Speaker 3: it in the statutory language, which remember the Supreme Court,
- 25:00Speaker 3: it's textualists.
- 25:01Speaker 2: Thanks so much for being on the show. And that's
- 25:04Speaker 2: Professor and Marie La Fosso of the University of West Virginia.
- 25:07Speaker 4: School of Law.
- 25:10Speaker 2: Hawaiian Electric is being sued not only by victims of
- 25:13Speaker 2: the Lahnea fire, but also by Maui County and investors.
- 25:18Speaker 2: They claim the utility didn't cut power and take safety
- 25:21Speaker 2: measures to contain the raging flames that engulf the city
- 25:25Speaker 2: of Lahine. Joining me is Bloomberg Legal reporter Joe Rosenblatt
- 25:29Speaker 2: explain the County of Maui is suing Hawaiian Electric for negligence.
- 25:35Speaker 4: Explain what their claim is.
- 25:37Speaker 5: The county is the latest entity to file a lawsuit
- 25:41Speaker 5: against Hawaiian Electric, which is unusual. In all the California
- 25:45Speaker 5: wildfires that I've covered, I've never seen a county. You've
- 25:48Speaker 5: seen in a district attorney, for example, but not the
- 25:50Speaker 5: county sue the utility, and they're suing the utility saying
- 25:55Speaker 5: it started the fire. I understand from a little bit
- 25:58Speaker 5: of reporting that this is a special unusual in Maui,
- 26:01Speaker 5: where there's a sense of community and everybody's trying to
- 26:05Speaker 5: operate together, especially in an emergency like this. But to
- 26:08Speaker 5: have the county turn on its own utility on that
- 26:12Speaker 5: island is unusual and potentially problematic. But the claims are
- 26:16Speaker 5: the same as the other lawsuits that have been filed
- 26:18Speaker 5: or similar to them, that the utility started the fire,
- 26:21Speaker 5: and the utility is responsible, and.
- 26:24Speaker 2: Tell us a little more about the specific claim of negligence.
- 26:28Speaker 5: The power lines blew down and started sparked a wildfire
- 26:32Speaker 5: in the grasses that then grew larger. There's an interesting
- 26:38Speaker 5: ripple here because the utility has in fact responded by saying,
- 26:43Speaker 5: you know what, it's actually the county's fault, because the
- 26:47Speaker 5: utility is acknowledged that their power lines did indeed start
- 26:52Speaker 5: a fire, which is unusual. That's unusual. That was news.
- 26:55Speaker 5: But then what they say is that the fired the
- 26:58Speaker 5: initial fire. Firefighters work for the county. They put the
- 27:01Speaker 5: fire out, but they didn't extinguish it. The winds came
- 27:05Speaker 5: and blew those fires into what became the fires that
- 27:08Speaker 5: destroyed Lahina.
- 27:10Speaker 2: Have you heard what the response of the plaintiff's lawyers is.
- 27:14Speaker 5: I have, and the lawyers who have already filed these
- 27:17Speaker 5: suits have said that doesn't matter because you started the
- 27:20Speaker 5: initial fire that became the fire that burned down the
- 27:24Speaker 5: town of Leahina, and I should have said that. The
- 27:27Speaker 5: negligence claim is based on this argument that the utility
- 27:31Speaker 5: knew these high winds were coming and should have, as
- 27:35Speaker 5: is now done often in California, should have turned off
- 27:39Speaker 5: its power knowing that the high winds were going to
- 27:41Speaker 5: come and potentially blow down the power lines. So they're
- 27:45Speaker 5: charging forward. They don't care, and they also the explanation
- 27:48Speaker 5: is a bit convoluted, and I don't know that the
- 27:50Speaker 5: utility has empirical evidence that they indeed didn't start the
- 27:55Speaker 5: fire that did all the damage.
- 27:56Speaker 2: So is it unusual to have the lawsuits before the
- 28:00Speaker 2: official cause of the fire is determined.
- 28:04Speaker 5: Well, I've covered wildfires in California. I've covered the litigation
- 28:09Speaker 5: from those wildfires, and based on that experience, hardly unusual
- 28:12Speaker 5: at all. I mean, now, in California, if there's a wildfire,
- 28:15Speaker 5: it's a race to the courthouse. There's always multiple suits filed,
- 28:18Speaker 5: and I think lawyers in this area, I mean I
- 28:21Speaker 5: actually know all the plantiffs lawyers now who are suing
- 28:25Speaker 5: Hawaiian Electric, and they're in many cases, the same lawyers
- 28:28Speaker 5: have sued PGNE in California. So no, it's not surprising
- 28:32Speaker 5: they file suit at this point expecting that the utility
- 28:36Speaker 5: is liable.
- 28:38Speaker 2: And when you look at the numbers, I mean, it
- 28:41Speaker 2: seems as if Hawaiian Electric is found negligent in all
- 28:44Speaker 2: these cases, they're going to go bankrupt, just as pg
- 28:47Speaker 2: and E did.
- 28:48Speaker 5: That's correct. The lawyers don't really pay that much attention
- 28:53Speaker 5: to the long term health of the utility, and there's
- 28:57Speaker 5: a good reason.
- 28:58Speaker 2: Now.
- 28:58Speaker 5: There's a model for them now in PGE, which indeed
- 29:02Speaker 5: was pushed to bankruptcy but then got back on its feet.
- 29:06Speaker 5: And oftentimes, you know, what they're looking at is that
- 29:10Speaker 5: the rate increased rates will be passed on to rate payers,
- 29:14Speaker 5: and the lawyers who are representing a lot of our victims,
- 29:18Speaker 5: they think they're going to get their money. There's some
- 29:20Speaker 5: discussion now among Plants lawyers that eventually the federal government's
- 29:25Speaker 5: going to have to step in and help this utility.
- 29:28Speaker 5: That's a possibility, and if so, for the Plans lawyers,
- 29:32Speaker 5: another target or another pocket, a real deep pocket.
- 29:35Speaker 2: Tell us about a suit in San Francisco is a
- 29:38Speaker 2: securities fraud suit.
- 29:41Speaker 5: So yeah, a variety of suits with a variety of claims.
- 29:44Speaker 5: The one in San Francisco Federal Court filed last week
- 29:47Speaker 5: is on behalf of investors. Hawaiian Electric is the parent
- 29:51Speaker 5: company which has seen its stock price just get hammered
- 29:55Speaker 5: since the fire, and that's a securities fraud suit saying
- 30:00Speaker 5: that the company knew that it had these problems. It
- 30:03Speaker 5: had this exposure that its lines could have been blown down,
- 30:07Speaker 5: they didn't disclose it to investors, and they hid this
- 30:11Speaker 5: potential problem that has ended up costing investors their entire investment. Interestingly,
- 30:17Speaker 5: the stock price has since rebounded with this argument that
- 30:21Speaker 5: we discussed previously, that the utility is putting forward that
- 30:23Speaker 5: it's in fact the county's kind of response.
- 30:26Speaker 2: So some of the plaintiffs are using a theory that
- 30:31Speaker 2: was used in the PG and E cases. That would
- 30:34Speaker 2: mean that they do not have to prove negligence.
- 30:37Speaker 5: That's to me the most interesting claim. It's called inverse condemnation.
- 30:42Speaker 5: It's a cousin of eminent domain, which is more more
- 30:46Speaker 5: understood in which the government, for a government project, usually
- 30:50Speaker 5: for infrastructure, takes private property and compensates the owner, usually
- 30:56Speaker 5: a private owner for that property. That's also another express
- 31:00Speaker 5: is that land is condemned for a project. So this
- 31:05Speaker 5: is a relative of that of that doctrine called inverse condemnation.
- 31:09Speaker 5: So you invert the condemnation and this is the private
- 31:13Speaker 5: private property owner in this case, an owner of property
- 31:17Speaker 5: that was burned by the wildfire, suing the utility for
- 31:20Speaker 5: the damage, saying, you know, electricity is a publicly provided
- 31:25Speaker 5: resource and you're using public or private land to run
- 31:31Speaker 5: your power lines on, and you caused damage that was unforeseen,
- 31:37Speaker 5: and I'm holding you liable for it. In California, you
- 31:41Speaker 5: don't have to establish negligence. That claim can move forward
- 31:45Speaker 5: without that burden of proof. And so there are lawyers
- 31:48Speaker 5: here in this case who are using the same legal
- 31:51Speaker 5: doctrine to try to sue Hawaiian Electric There is a
- 31:54Speaker 5: history of inverse condemnation in some contexts in Hawaii, never
- 31:59Speaker 5: in a wildfire contexts. Because this is completely novel, completely new,
- 32:03Speaker 5: whereas this is well established in California, these lawyers are
- 32:06Speaker 5: looking to import kind of the success of that from
- 32:10Speaker 5: California to why. We'll see it's completely untested and what.
- 32:14Speaker 2: Might be one of the hardest parts of this case
- 32:17Speaker 2: for the plaintiffs, A.
- 32:19Speaker 5: Key component, a key requirement of inverse condemnation is that
- 32:24Speaker 5: you need to be suing a government entity. That's what's
- 32:27Speaker 5: required under the doctrine. And so the fight is going
- 32:30Speaker 5: to be whether or not the utility is a government entity.
- 32:34Speaker 5: It's regulated by the government in terms of what it
- 32:37Speaker 5: can charge, but it's investor owned, right, it's a privately owned,
- 32:41Speaker 5: investor owned utility that provides a public service. So the
- 32:45Speaker 5: lawyers who have filed this lawsuit and filed this claim
- 32:48Speaker 5: feel like they're not going to have any problem showing
- 32:51Speaker 5: that this is indeed a government entity that can be
- 32:53Speaker 5: a target of inverse condonation claims. But as was the
- 32:56Speaker 5: case with pg ANDE, there's a big fight in California
- 32:59Speaker 5: over whether or not the utility is actually a government
- 33:02Speaker 5: entity purely enough of a government entity to be the
- 33:06Speaker 5: target or the identified as the defendant in an inverse
- 33:09Speaker 5: condination claim.
- 33:10Speaker 2: I know you'll be watching these cases closely to find
- 33:13Speaker 2: out what happens. Thanks so much, Joel. That's Bloomberg Legal
- 33:16Speaker 2: reporter Joel Rosenblatt, and that's it for this edition of
- 33:19Speaker 2: the Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can always get the
- 33:22Speaker 2: latest legal news on our Bloomberg Law Podcast. You can
- 33:25Speaker 2: find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at www dot
- 33:30Speaker 2: bloomberg dot com, slash podcast slash Law, and remember to
- 33:34Speaker 2: tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight at ten
- 33:37Speaker 2: pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso and you're listening
- 33:41Speaker 2: to Bloomberg