Latest / The Lives They're Living / Jack Lynch on Bryan Garner
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome to The Lives They're Living.
- 0:08I'm your host, Ben Yacoda.
- 0:10The podcast is about people who have done amazing things and who,
- 0:14at this point in their life, are flying a little bit more under the
- 0:17radar than they really deserve to be
- 0:29My guest today is Jack Lynch.
- 0:32Jack is a distinguished professor of English at the University of
- 0:35Rutgers Newark, and distinguished in both his official title and it's
- 0:40an accurate description of him.
- 0:43, In addition to many scholarly publications focusing on 18th century British
- 0:48literature, notably Samuel Johnson, Jack Lynch has written widely and
- 0:54brilliantly for a general audience in books including, and, and these are a
- 0:58bit of a mouthful so bear with me, uh, the, the subtitles, that is, 'cause you
- 1:02have to have a long subtitle nowadays.
- 1:05It's a law.
- 1:06Becoming Shakespeare, colon, The Unlikely Afterlife that Turned a
- 1:10Provincial Playwright into The Bard.
- 1:14You Could Look It Up, colon, The Reference Shelf from Ancient Babylon to Wikipedia,
- 1:19and ju- just three of his many books, the third being The Lexicographer's
- 1:24Dilemma, The Evolution of, quote, "Proper English" From Shakespeare to South Park.
- 1:31And as I understand it, and you can correct me if this is wrong,
- 1:35you are currently working on a book about the greatest reference book
- 1:38and perhaps the greatest book of all time, The Oxford English Dictionary.
- 1:43Correct?
- 1:44That's right.
- 1:45I, I hope I'm finishing it up over the summer.
- 1:48Oh, I can't wait.
- 1:50Well, Jack, welcome to The Lives They're Living.
- 1:53Thank you so much.
- 1:54It's really a treat to be here.
- 1:56, Is it accurate to say that your work on Samuel Johnson, compiler of the first
- 2:02great dictionary, led you to writing about reference books and battles over proper
- 2:08English and usage, and from there to the subject of this episode, Bryan Garner?
- 2:14Yeah, I think it did.
- 2:15I'm an English professor.
- 2:17I've always been interested in the language.
- 2:20I've been reading books about language since, oh, probably middle school,
- 2:24been reading them compulsively.
- 2:26But professional study of matters linguistic and lexicographic came,,
- 2:34once I was in graduate school, I became really interested in Samuel
- 2:38Johnson for a bunch of reasons.
- 2:40, But that also, that involved digging into his dictionary in a serious
- 2:45way, which I'd only flipped through before, but I spent a long time-
- 2:49Yeah, yeah ⦠reading it closely and, and getting to know how it worked.
- 2:53And that got me really interested in dictionaries generally
- 2:57beyond the way I usually had.
- 3:00As it happens, it was a Johnson-related event that, , led
- 3:04me to meet Bryan for the first time.
- 3:06I don't remember the year, but once a year, the nerdiest thing I do is attend
- 3:13the Johnsonians, a black tie dinner where we raise a toast to the immortal memory-
- 3:21, and one year Brian was there as a guest, and that's when I first got to meet him.
- 3:26Of course I knew his books, , but that's the first time we met.
- 3:29That must be a wild party at that, that Johnsonians, I'm telling you.
- 3:32Uh- You know, you say that facetiously, and yet.
- 3:37Okay.
- 3:38Yes.
- 3:38No, I believe that.
- 3:39I believe that.
- 3:40Let me just back up, and I, I've been interested in your comment
- 3:43that you started reading books about language in middle school.
- 3:47Can you remember the first or one of the first such books you read?
- 3:52I probab- I don't remember specifics.
- 3:55I think I came to the fascination with language through puzzle sorts of books.
- 4:01Hmm.
- 4:01I wasn't much of a, ⦠Do you know the, here's a good
- 4:05dictionary word, cruciverbalist.
- 4:08A crossword player.
- 4:10I've never been much of a crossword player, but other kinds of puzzles- Hmm
- 4:15really fascinated me, and some of them were language-based.
- 4:19Can you think of a word that does this?
- 4:21Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.
- 4:21Or why is this word this way?
- 4:23And that got me really fascinated in middle school.
- 4:27And then by the time I had, I'd made it to high school, , it was kind of an
- 4:31obsession, reading usage guides- Mm-hmm
- 4:34and, , and things like that.
- 4:36Well, I can, I can relate.
- 4:38, You know, looking into Bryan Garner, who we will get some of
- 4:41his biography in a minute, but he is a prolific author of- Oh, boy.
- 4:48Yeah ⦠many, many books.
- 4:50I would say most notably a book- That's gone through a number of editions.
- 4:54It started out being called Dictionary of Modern American Usage, and now it's called
- 5:02Garner's Modern English Usage, which is, uh, clearly a reference to Fowler and his
- 5:10famous Dictionary of Modern English Usage.
- 5:13And, and I think you'll agree with me that, that Garner deserves
- 5:17that, American Fowler or Fowler successor garland for Garner.
- 5:22Do you, you think that's fair?
- 5:24I think that's fair.
- 5:25I think he's got just the temperament.
- 5:28Yeah.
- 5:28There have been attempts to modernize Fowler and to adapt Fowler, but
- 5:33most of them miss Fowler's spirit.
- 5:36Yeah.
- 5:36I think Bryan's got Fowler's spirit and quirks down, Well, I, I think I
- 5:42can say I'm one of the few pe- well, I was gonna brag that I've read Fowler
- 5:46word for word, and that's not exactly true, 'cause there was some skimming.
- 5:50But I wrote a long essay about that book on its 100th anniversary- Yeah
- 5:56for The New Yorker last year.
- 5:57I'll put a link to it.
- 5:58And yes, so I, I think I, I do agree with you, and I think part of that
- 6:05is it- it's Fowler's a personal book and Garner is a personal book.
- 6:11At the same time, authoritative and, you know, scholarly, but
- 6:18the personality comes through.
- 6:20That's just it.
- 6:21It's not an objective, neutral compendium of facts, which
- 6:27so many reference guides are.
- 6:29Right.
- 6:29And I just used the, the singular antecedent it, but I'm really
- 6:33talking about both books.
- 6:35They have a voice.
- 6:36Both writers know an awful lot.
- 6:39They're not just ignorant prejudices, but they are very much
- 6:44filtered through personalities.
- 6:47Uh, likes and dislikes come through clearly.
- 6:50Mm-hmm.
- 6:50Mm-hmm.
- 6:50And but for both of them, a kind of playfulness with language,
- 6:54which I've always loved.
- 6:54Yeah.
- 6:55Well, you're playful, and I gotta say, and I have it in front of me,
- 6:58um, if this were a video podcast, which it isn't, I would show it.
- 7:02Well, the last numbered page is 1,276, the, which is the final page of the
- 7:09select index of people mentioned.
- 7:11Then there's un-numbered 1277 pronunciation key.
- 7:15There's a ⦠It's not a slim, it's not a slim volume.
- 7:19Just a little biography on, on Mr.
- 7:22Garner, who I call that way, in part 'cause I've never
- 7:26met him, part out of respect.
- 7:29He's, uh, in, in his late 60s.
- 7:32He was born in Lubbock, Texas, which I associate- Yeah ⦠with,
- 7:37you know, Waylon Jennings and Buddy Holly and people of that ilk.
- 7:41I think his family might have moved away,, when he was fairly young.
- 7:45And he went to the University of Texas in Austin, and this is a little factoid
- 7:52that I found that I kind of love.
- 7:54His senior thesis Shakespeare's Latinate Neologisms.
- 8:01I, I don't even know if I pronounced that right, but, you know, he
- 8:03was obviously to the manner born.
- 8:05He was, l- like you and, and like me, he was interested in
- 8:09this stuff fairly early on.
- 8:11Very much so, yeah.
- 8:12He's, he's talked about that project, , and how it, it lit up a lot of things in
- 8:18him to, to be able to write , that thesis.
- 8:22And then he went on to law school and I, I guess his early career, and tell,
- 8:29tell me if this is correct, focused and concentrated on legal writing,
- 8:34, language, , argumentation, rhetoric.
- 8:38I, I was interested that he took up the cause of footnotes in legal
- 8:48writing, and he, uh, was against what he called or what might be called
- 8:54interlarding of the footnotes and wanted them separated out, which, y-
- 8:59that sounds good as far as I know.
- 9:01⦠of his many, many books, the first bunch were about legal
- 9:06writing, legal language, right?
- 9:08Yeah, very much so.
- 9:09They were written by a lawyer for lawyers about legal language.
- 9:14Obviously his interests are always cosmopolitan and urbane, but they
- 9:20were very practical works early on about constructing legal arguments.
- 9:25Some of that is just the purely arbitrary stuff that legal style requires.
- 9:31How do you cite this sort of thing?
- 9:34Um, but a lot of it was motivated by the things that make legal writing special,
- 9:40which is to say great care for evidence, the need to marshal an argument precisely,
- 9:48to lay out your facts carefully- Mm-hmm
- 9:50and to be extremely precise because imprecision loses cases in law.
- 9:58So his, his early work lays all of that out, um, systematically, and
- 10:05I think from there he just kept going beyond the legal profession.
- 10:10Yeah.
- 10:10And I, I guess clearly had, had an interest in the more general thing.
- 10:14And I should note that among your many books and his many books
- 10:20is one that you co-authored in
- 10:23was published in 2024, also with a short title and a long subtitle.
- 10:29Hardly Harmless Drudgery: A 500-Year Pictorial History
- 10:34of a Lexicographic Genius's-
- 10:38Scialists?
- 10:40Scialists I'll know how to pronounce it and what it means when, when
- 10:42I'm done with the subtitle.
- 10:44Plagiarists and , obsessives who define the English language.
- 10:50Scialists are people with superficial knowledge of something.
- 10:55Uh, y- my superficial knowledge does not extend to that word,
- 10:59so I'm glad I know that.
- 11:01And the title Hardly Harmless Drudgery, now that's, a reference to a quote,
- 11:07and again, it escapes me, but wh- where does the term harmless drudges
- 11:11or harmless drudgery, come from?
- 11:13The term famously comes from Samuel Johnson's dictionary.
- 11:17, Some people who are scialists with respect to Johnson's dictionary, who know just
- 11:22a little bit about of it, about it, tend to think of it as a kind of funny,
- 11:28quirky dictionary, maybe something like, , Ambrose Bierce's Devil's Dictionary.
- 11:33It's not.
- 11:33It's a very serious, very sound, scholarly dictionary, 43,000 entries.
- 11:41The full text is three and a half million words.
- 11:44But in there, Johnson does manage to sneak in, oh, maybe a dozen jokes and
- 11:51personal, , digs that he manages to get away with, and one of the most
- 11:55famous is the entry for lexicographer the entry begins, "A writer of
- 12:03dictionaries, comma, a harmless drudge."
- 12:07Yeah.
- 12:08So this was his way of making fun of his own profession.
- 12:12It, it's, that's wonderful, and very, very meta.
- 12:15, A- another funny one that you'll tell me the exact wording on, I trust, that
- 12:21I came upon , in writing my forthcoming book about irony, that you were very
- 12:28helpful in the, , in the process of, to put a preposition at the end.
- 12:34Was his definition of irony where he got in a dig at someone, Bolingbroke,
- 12:43was- Yeah, at Lord Bolingbroke, yes.
- 12:45Yeah.
- 12:45Where, uh, I can't remember the beginning of the definition, but
- 12:49a, a use of words contrary to their applica- uh, something like that.
- 12:55Uh, but then he gives an example as Bolingbroke was a holy man.
- 13:01And Bolingbroke was famously, from Johnson's point of view
- 13:04at least, atheistic, so that's one of his examples of irony.
- 13:07That, uh, that's, that's great.
- 13:09I love that.
- 13:10Well, , let's talk a little bit about Garner as a person.
- 13:16Is, is he a drudge?
- 13:17I'm, I'm guessing not, just from his writing and seeing pictures that he has
- 13:21a little bit of a twinkle in his eye.
- 13:23But, uh- He's- ⦠what's he like to work with as a, person
- 13:27to hang out with and so forth?
- 13:29He is charming.
- 13:30He's always got the twinkle in his eye.
- 13:33Not the least hint of drudge about him.
- 13:36Um, rather than drudgery, he goes for mania sometimes.
- 13:42People like to say that I've published a mountain of books,
- 13:45and yet while I'm straightening my desk and getting ready to write the
- 13:50next one, Bryan's written two more.
- 13:53So, um, yeah, he, he churns them out- Yeah ⦠impressively.
- 13:58But it's not through drudgery by any means.
- 14:03He's just got a, a real intellectual energy that he
- 14:06brings to just about everything.
- 14:08And- And you can feel that in person.
- 14:10Yeah, yeah.
- 14:11I would think also, , work ethic, clearly, and a facility.
- 14:17I mean, he, he can't be the kinda person who's laboring over just
- 14:20the mot juste and the right word.
- 14:22As you say, churns them out, . Yeah, I mean, that's a lesson I've learned
- 14:28from a few good writers I have worked with, that, that writer's
- 14:32block is often just an excuse.
- 14:35Mm-hmm.
- 14:35Get something on the page.
- 14:37Mm.
- 14:37Even if it's not good yet, put something down and fix it later.
- 14:43So by no means does Bryan or does any good writer get it right the first time.
- 14:48, In fact, Bryan and I are now co-writing another book, and we're
- 14:52bouncing the typescript back and forth revising each other's work.
- 14:56, So there's an awful lot of revision that goes on, but he
- 15:00doesn't let anything paralyze him.
- 15:03When it's time to write, he sits down and he writes.
- 15:08Right.
- 15:08Right.
- 15:09, In the world of the usage guides that you started reading in high
- 15:15school , and are still out there, there is this duality, uh that is-
- 15:26Framed in, in these two words, the descriptivists and the prescriptivists,
- 15:32and that's an overgeneralization, but there's some truth to it
- 15:37that, , people in this world tend to be on one of those two sides.
- 15:44The prescriptivists being the ones tend not to be, the academic linguists,
- 15:50but more the William Safire and Edwin Newman type who say, "Don't
- 15:56say hopefully to mean I hope that.
- 16:00Don't say decimate to mean anything other than eliminate
- 16:0410%," and so forth and so on.
- 16:07And, and anyone who reads about language comes uponâ¦
- 16:10Well, anyone who kind of works, walks around in the world comes around people
- 16:14like that, , who tsk-tsk at the sign in the supermarket that says 10 items or
- 16:21less- Yes ⦠in this aisle, which, which Garner actually defends interestingly.
- 16:27So those are the, the prescriptivists, the sort of finger-wagging.
- 16:30And then the descriptivists are the often academic linguists or grammarians,
- 16:37like someone that I've worked with, Geoff Pullum, author of- Sure
- 16:41the Cambridge Grammar of the English Language, it's even longer than, than
- 16:46Garner's book, who supposedly, and this is an overgeneralization as well,
- 16:52is sort of like whatever is is right.
- 16:55, They just want to describe the way the language is used and changes-
- 16:58Yep ⦠and so forth and so on.
- 17:00So where would you put Garner in that scale of prescriptivist, you know, on
- 17:08the one hand, descriptivist on the other?
- 17:11I think most people in the biz would put him very solidly on the prescriptive side.
- 17:19And as you say, a lot of people with an academic background
- 17:22view that as a shortcoming.
- 17:27But this is something Brian and I have discussed.
- 17:29I think I'm pretty much on the same place on the spectrum.
- 17:33Actually, I'm gonna say spectrum is the wrong, wrong metaphor because I think
- 17:41fully informed prescriptivism will look like fully informed descriptivism.
- 17:50They, they wrap around and meet at the other end.
- 17:54When most people talk about the the shortcomings of prescriptivists,
- 18:01the problem with prescriptivists is they're giving advice, they are
- 18:04prescribing, they're giving orders, but they're not based in facts.
- 18:11They're not based in what people actually do.
- 18:14, There may once have been a day when saying you may not use decimate to mean
- 18:21anything other than the destruction of one in 10 was a useful injunction.
- 18:26It's not now.
- 18:28That's simply not what the word means, and to be fair, I don't think many
- 18:33of us have occasions to refer to the destruction of one out of 10 of anything.
- 18:39No.
- 18:39It's not something that happens often.
- 18:41Bad prescriptivists are the ones who make those proclamations without
- 18:48any attention to actual usage.
- 18:51Mm-hmm.
- 18:53Good prescriptivists end up giving just a longer version of the
- 19:00descriptive argument, which is that this is the way people use them,
- 19:06and they just describe a bit more.
- 19:09This is sort of the social effect- Sure ⦠of these words.
- 19:14A full description of any word, any usage, any grammatical construction
- 19:21has to include the way it is received in the larger world.
- 19:26So a full description would have at least implicit in it some prescription.
- 19:33Sure.
- 19:34Which is to say, if you do this, this is how you're going to be received.
- 19:38If you do this, this is how you're going to be received.
- 19:41And fully engaged prescriptivism should know everything the descriptivists know.
- 19:49So that's the sort of spot Bryan aspires to.
- 19:52Yeah.
- 19:53He has no hesitation about giving advice, but always tries to ground it
- 19:58in what are people actually saying.
- 20:02And, you know, nowadays in the digital age, we can make generalizations about
- 20:07that with a lot more accuracy- Yeah
- 20:09than we ever could before.
- 20:11I, I think that's exactly right.
- 20:12I, I'll add one thing to it, which is- One of the differences between those
- 20:20two camps is their internal clock.
- 20:25When language changes, no one can deny that, no one can dispute that.
- 20:31Yeah.
- 20:31But wh- at what point in the process of change is that usage, is that
- 20:39word, is that meaning okay or kosher?
- 20:42Yeah.
- 20:42And the prescriptivists tend to wanna wait longer.
- 20:47Like, uh, a word like disinterested- Right ⦠which traditionally
- 20:52meant, , something along the lines of impartial or, uh, did, did not have an
- 20:56interest in the outcome of something.
- 20:59And, and just looking up Bryan's, uhâ¦
- 21:03Now, now I'm calling him Bryan.
- 21:04I feel like I'm his buddy now.
- 21:06, Yeah, he's got one, his columns are, are quite long.
- 21:09He's got a long column on disinterested and uninterested.
- 21:13, But to start off, just to give a taste of the way heâ¦
- 21:16, well, before I read him, I'll say what I was gonna say, that the prescriptivists
- 21:20are much longer to disapprove of disinterested to mean uninterested.
- 21:26Yeah.
- 21:27And the prescriptivists, it's okay with them sooner.
- 21:30Eventually they're all gonna come around and- Yeah ⦠like
- 21:33decimate is a great example.
- 21:35Hopefully might be there.
- 21:36And I'll say another thing about Bryan Garner, two brilliant innovations
- 21:42or discoveries or things he did.
- 21:46One is for every one of these usages, he's got a language change index.
- 21:54Yes.
- 21:54Which is a scale of one through five- That using some of those tools that you
- 22:00mentioned, Ngram Viewer and all sorts of other corpora and databases, he will
- 22:06label the usage one is rejected, two widely shunned, three widespread but
- 22:15dot, dot, dot, f- stage four ubiquitous but dot, dot, dot, five fully accepted.
- 22:21Yeah.
- 22:22And it- that's a really helpful ⦠And it's grounded , in
- 22:26his research , and studies.
- 22:28, And the other is a term he coined I think back in 1998, and this
- 22:33relates to something you were saying earlier, a skunked term.
- 22:37So it's okay, it's been established, but certain people are gonna
- 22:43look at you funny if you use it.
- 22:46I was just waiting for the chance to get in and say Brian coined
- 22:50this great term, skunked words.
- 22:53It's, it's a wonderful idea.
- 22:56Just as the smell of a skunk, once, once it's on you, ain't never coming
- 23:01off, there are some words that, you know, are perfectly justifiable
- 23:07by all of the rational reasons, but there is a hatred of them.
- 23:13Yeah.
- 23:14And a smart writer should at least know that, um, if you're going to use some of
- 23:19these words or some of these constructions or usages or whatever that people get
- 23:25upset about, at least do it knowingly- Yeah ⦠because you're going to be judged
- 23:31for it whether you want to be or not.
- 23:34And I don't know about you, but I do the I, I'll f- I'll haul out a skunked
- 23:39term knowingly just to kinda- Of course
- 23:44get their goat or whatever.
- 23:46Yes, and that's something worth bearing in mind.
- 23:49Um, so many of the so-called rules of English have certain
- 23:54assumptions about them.
- 23:56You and I have both taught writing to college students.
- 24:00And we've both probably taught rules, so to speak, that we routinely break
- 24:06just because, well, people know enough about us, the fact that we're publishing
- 24:13things or our professional position or whatever, to know, look, if we use those
- 24:19words, we're doing it intentionally.
- 24:22We're doing it wittily or with a wink.
- 24:25, Whereas a 19-year-old who hasn't yet earned that assumption from the
- 24:32world has to be careful with it.
- 24:34Yeah.
- 24:34So sure, I, I love using skunk terms and all sorts of constructions that
- 24:39make people grind their teeth and so on, but yeah, that's just playing.
- 24:43I'm now remembering that
- 24:45the book I wrote that was a sort of guide to writing, I
- 24:49called it How to Not Write Bad.
- 24:52Yes.
- 24:53And literally, Jack, half the time when I'm giving a talk and someone
- 24:57introduces me, they edit the title to- Oh, wow ⦠to read, uh, How Not to
- 25:03Write Bad, or sometimes they say Badly, and they kind of don't, don't get it.
- 25:08Um- Oh, that's interesting.
- 25:10Yeah.
- 25:10I wonder how much of that is conscious and how much saving you from your
- 25:15error- Right ⦠and how much of that is just, that's just the way they see it.
- 25:20Now, the thing that would, I would think provoke people the most,
- 25:25and I, I once in a while dare to use it, is saying something like,
- 25:30"Thanks for inviting my wife and I."
- 25:33Ah, yes.
- 25:34People really hate that, but, but let's not get into that and
- 25:38stir up too much controversy.
- 25:39I- So I did wanna read just the beginning of Garner's entry on, uh,
- 25:44disinterested and uninterested, just to give a little sense of his approach
- 25:49and his, his scholarship Uh, given the overlapping nouns, writers have
- 25:57found it difficult to keep the past participial adjectives entirely separate.
- 26:02Many have given up the fight to preserve the distinction between them.
- 26:06But the distinction is still best recognized and followed because
- 26:09disinterested captures a nuance that no other word quite does.
- 26:15Many influential writers have urged the preservation of its traditional sense.
- 26:19The typically understated A.
- 26:21R.
- 26:22Orage rhapsodized over the word.
- 26:24Quote, "No word in the English language is more difficult than disinterestedness
- 26:32to define or better worth attempting to define.
- 26:34Somewhere or other in its capacious folds it contains all the ideas of ethics
- 26:39and even, I should say, of religion."
- 26:42And Garner goes on to say, "A disinterested observer is not merely
- 26:47impartial, but has nothing to gain from taking a stand on the issue in question."
- 26:52So yeah, I think that is an example of what you describe as, well, you
- 26:58didn't use the term, but kind of enlightened- Yeah ⦠prescriptivism.
- 27:02He's got a s- you know, an opinion on the matter.
- 27:05He's grounded in scholarship.
- 27:07It's not finger-wagging, but it's, it's legit Yeah, and I mean, frankly, that's,
- 27:15that's my approach to this as well.
- 27:17I would not bother to correct someone who used uninterested and
- 27:23disinterested, quote, "incorrectly."
- 27:25I don't think correct is even the right term.
- 27:27I do, however, think it's a useful distinction sometimes.
- 27:31Mm.
- 27:31It's one I choose to observe myself, and if I'm editing prose, I might
- 27:36nudge things in that direction.
- 27:37Right.
- 27:37Because as Bryan points out, we just don't have another word that does that.
- 27:42So if you really wanna make the point, you have to spell it out at great length.
- 27:48It's a similar pair of words is, is presently and currently.
- 27:53Yeah.
- 27:53I think that's a little farther down the presently accepted to mean
- 27:59currently instead of traditional meaning of shortly- Soon, yeah
- 28:04which I think meant something else originally too.
- 28:06One thing I did wanna mention is in addition to having a relationship
- 28:13with you, a professional relationship, he also had one with the, the writer
- 28:19David Foster Wallace- Yeah ⦠who originally wrote a long piece in
- 28:23Harper's about one of Bryan's, reference works, and ended up working on a
- 28:30book together, which I thought- Yep
- 28:32was kind of amazing.
- 28:33A- and the w- a term that Wallace coined referring to both himself and Garner,
- 28:40it's kind of better than prescriptivist, is snoot, S-N-O-O-T, meaning- Oh,
- 28:46yes ⦠syntax nudnik of our time.
- 28:49Yes.
- 28:49And then I'll also mention another collaboration he had with Antonin Scalia.
- 28:56They wrote at least two books together.
- 28:58They did, and yes, I sometimes like to joke, "Oh yeah, me and Nino, we're
- 29:04like this" . I'll just say there is a little bit of distance between me
- 29:10and Antonin Scalia ideologically, but yeah, um, I think we both enjoyed
- 29:17working with Bryan as a co-author.
- 29:20And both of you are stylists.
- 29:24In fact, one of the, the reasons I found it productive to work with Brian
- 29:31specifically as a co-author, not merely co-editor or something like that,
- 29:36we're both stylists and we have many, many of the same stylistic habits,
- 29:42preferences, ticks, whatever else.
- 29:45I've sometimes heard people who get busted for plagiarism, professional
- 29:52writers might get busted for plagiarism, and a common excuse was,
- 29:56"Oh, it was sloppiness in note-taking.
- 29:59I copied that passage down and then thought it was my own."
- 30:04And I always thought, "Oh, bullshit.
- 30:07You did not."
- 30:08Because I might not remember having written something of mine, but I
- 30:13always recognize my own writing.
- 30:16You could never show me someone else's writing and tell me that it was mine.
- 30:22And yet, when I look over the things Brian and I have written together,
- 30:27I often have no idea which of us is responsible for a paragraph.
- 30:32Um, that might be because it went back and forth so many times- Mm-hmm ⦠it
- 30:36just ended up an average of the two of us.
- 30:39But I think on thing after thing, we've got the same- Mm ⦠stylistic
- 30:44habits and the same sense of humor and the same register of vocabulary.
- 30:50So I sometimes honestly don't know which- Yeah.
- 30:53It's amazing.
- 30:53I've, I've co-edited a book, with, with one of my colleagues, Kevin Carrane,
- 30:58and that, that was a great experience.
- 30:59But I guess I'm- I don't know, I felt too possessive about my writing, but it,
- 31:06y- your description of finding that sort of kindred spirit is very appealing.
- 31:12May- maybe, maybe you and I could do something at some point.
- 31:15Oh, it'd be fun to try.
- 31:16Keep me in mind.
- 31:17I'd love it.
- 31:18Okay.
- 31:19I mean, the way we, the way Brian Garner and I ended up as co-authors
- 31:23is we are both members of the Grolier Club, the, the book collecting
- 31:27society based in New York City.
- 31:30Um, Brian was a longtime member.
- 31:32He has a stunning collection of books.
- 31:35I have a little amateurish collection of books.
- 31:40But he got in touch with me in 2019 and said, "Hey, would you
- 31:45like to do an exhibition on the history of dictionaries together?"
- 31:50Which would mostly come from his collection.
- 31:52As I said, he's got a remarkable collection.
- 31:55Um, and I said that'd be fun, and then we had to write a catalog for it.
- 32:00But early on I thought, , the , exhibition catalog by its very
- 32:04nature is in little discrete chunks.
- 32:07For each item, there will be a little section.
- 32:09There'll be a paragraph or two paragraphs on this book, and then you go to the next.
- 32:14So I thought division of labor would be simple.
- 32:17We would just say, "These are yours, these are mine," and they would
- 32:20essentially be not so much co-authored as just independently authored and
- 32:27interleaved or, or shuffled like cards.
- 32:31But once we did that and we started revising each other's works, we got to the
- 32:37point where at the level of almost every sentence we were, um, revising each other.
- 32:43So now we've got this book in progress which is entirely co-written.
- 32:49We did not divide sections or anything like that.
- 32:52Um, and that's a novel experience.
- 32:55I did not expect it to work well, but it, it's, it's been a treat.
- 32:59, I can't wait to see it.
- 33:01Well, Jack Lynch, , thank you so much for talking about Brian Garner.
- 33:07It's been a delight.
- 33:08Oh, it's a treat.
- 33:09Thanks for having me.
- 33:10. And now here's your moment of Brian Garner.
- 33:14Good writing, the very definition of it, uh, are two things that go into it.
- 33:21Really good ideas, number one, with really good expression.
- 33:27You must have both really good ideas and really good expression.
- 33:32If you don't have both, the writing is not, is not good.
- 33:37The ideas need to be clear, and the language you use needs to be clear.
- 33:43Clarity is the touchstone.
- 33:46A vague, fuzzy idea is going to be expressed in a vague, fuzzy way.
- 33:52A clear, solid idea can be expressed clearly.
- 33:58It's possible to write, by the way, many pages with never a clear idea.
- 34:05People who do that, and people do it all the time, but those
- 34:09people are not writing well.
- 34:10They're writing poorly.
- 34:12To be intelligible, to make yourself understood, to actually get your
- 34:18point across effectively is the fundamental aim of all serious writing.
- 34:29Thanks for listening and we'll see you next time