Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S3 Ep1: GRD029: What’s the Single Biggest Mistake Retirees Make?
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, I'm Ed Slott and I'm Jeff Levine.
- 0:02And we're two guys who just love to talk about retirement and taxes.
- 0:06Look, our mission is simple to educate you, the saver, so that you can make
- 0:10better decisions because better decisions on the whole lead to better outcomes.
- 0:14And here's how we're going to do that.
- 0:15Each week, Jeff and I will debate the pros and the cons of a particular
- 0:20retirement strategy or topic.
- 0:22With the goal of helping you keep more of your hard earned money.
- 0:26At the end of each debate There's going to be one clear winner You a more
- 0:30informed saver who can hopefully apply the merits of each side of the debate
- 0:34to your own personal situation To decide what's best for you and your family.
- 0:38So here we go.
- 0:39Welcome to the Great Retirement Debate All right, Ed welcome back.
- 0:44We're back for season three of the great retirement debate That's right.
- 0:48So what are we kicking it off with?
- 0:49We've got an interesting topic today.
- 0:51One for discussion.
- 0:52We're going to talk about what's the single biggest mistake retirees
- 0:56make besides retiring besides that.
- 0:59So you know what?
- 0:59That is a fair point.
- 1:01Like maybe retiring is indeed a mistake for some people, but all
- 1:04right, let's, let's, let's get out.
- 1:05Let's get right to it.
- 1:06Ed, we got.
- 1:07You know, Season 3, let's get right into the meat.
- 1:09What's, in your opinion, the single biggest mistake that retirees make?
- 1:13Well, I had three, but if I had to pick one, paying too much in taxes.
- 1:17I'm shocked.
- 1:18Shocked, I tell you.
- 1:19Look at the, look at the sense of shock on my face.
- 1:21All right.
- 1:22So, paying too much in taxes.
- 1:23What are the other two, out of curiosity?
- 1:25Well, uh, beneficiary forms and rollover mistakes.
- 1:27Okay.
- 1:27All right.
- 1:28What would you have picked?
- 1:29Uh, overconfidence.
- 1:30Overconfidence.
- 1:31Overconfidence.
- 1:32I'll unwrap that later.
- 1:33I'm gonna leave, I'm gonna leave our listeners on the edge of their seat
- 1:36for a little bit while we unpack taxes.
- 1:38So taxes, you say, are the single biggest mistake overpaying taxes in retirement.
- 1:43Give us some more.
- 1:44Because we're trained.
- 1:46With RMDs, they keep pushing the age back.
- 1:48Now it's 73.
- 1:50Just keep putting it off and putting it off.
- 1:52But, the account doesn't stop growing, all of a sudden you've, you're putting
- 1:56it off, you're putting it off, and the account is growing, and I'm
- 1:59worried about future higher taxes if Congress ever does anything about it.
- 2:03I've been saying that for years, and they've never done anything about it.
- 2:05Well, they've helped grow it.
- 2:06create more of a problem by lowering taxes even more right but i don't think taxes
- 2:11will ever be lower so the biggest mistake is not using up all the brackets leaving
- 2:17money on the table in the 12 22 24 low percent brackets because they just want
- 2:23to take the bare minimum when they're At RMD age, say at age 73, and not doing
- 2:28anything before that, even though they may be retired, because they don't have to.
- 2:32Yeah, I certainly agree that Congress has, has given everybody what they call a
- 2:37break, but it's not really a break, right?
- 2:39If people push off those RMDs, it could create a larger problem.
- 2:42You know, your comments there reminded me of two things I'm fond of saying.
- 2:46One is, Your goal shouldn't be to create the lowest tax bill in any one year,
- 2:51but to create the lowest lifetime tax.
- 2:53That's the winner of the game, right?
- 2:55And actually with retirement accounts, sometimes we have to go
- 2:58beyond the lowest lifetime tax bill.
- 3:00Sometimes it's the lowest multi generational tax bill because that tax
- 3:03liability on like a brokerage account doesn't go away when someone dies, right?
- 3:07It goes to the beneficiary.
- 3:08The other thing it reminded me of is, uh, when we're looking at
- 3:12individuals, right, and they're so happy they paid no tax, right?
- 3:15Like, oh, I paid no taxes here.
- 3:16Yeah, it means you didn't use any of the brackets.
- 3:18That's right.
- 3:19When I, when I meet someone not, and look, there are a lot of people in this country
- 3:23who are, who are working, who, uh, because of the way our tax system works, they,
- 3:28they don't earn enough to pay any tax.
- 3:30And that's fine.
- 3:30Like that's one set of individuals, but there are a lot of other people with,
- 3:33uh, Substantial wealth who still look to try and pay as little as possible.
- 3:38And when I meet one of those individuals who looks to me and says,
- 3:41Hey, I paid almost no tax last year.
- 3:44You know, they're, they're thinking like, Oh, that's a CPA.
- 3:46He's gonna be so proud of me.
- 3:46I look and say, I'm so sorry.
- 3:48You got some bad advice.
- 3:49Yeah, right.
- 3:49Why would you do that?
- 3:51Uh, you're right.
- 3:52Like, it's all about timing, right?
- 3:54And we should sometimes bringing forward some income paying
- 3:57sooner rather than later.
- 3:59Means helping to create that lowest lifetime tax bill.
- 4:01Yeah, they leave so much money on the table overall Like you said not only
- 4:05during lifetime But then you have the ten years to beneficiaries who may be in
- 4:09their own highest earning years and the last thing they want is a big tax bill
- 4:14Given they're getting an inheritance.
- 4:17No one's crying the blues for them, right?
- 4:19Like it's a, I always think about that.
- 4:21The beneficiary, I call it like crisis planning.
- 4:23Cause the beneficiaries got the money.
- 4:25Like, what do you do now?
- 4:26But I always have to remind myself, like if you run into the office going,
- 4:29I just inherited a million dollars.
- 4:31What do I, it's like, it's not the world's biggest crisis, but you're right.
- 4:34Taxes are a big play.
- 4:35What are some other areas with beyond, let's say just the
- 4:38retirement account distributions.
- 4:40What are some other areas where you typically find.
- 4:42You know, retirees overpaying in taxes.
- 4:45Well, they don't do Roth conversions ahead of time.
- 4:48When they could have, and you can still do it after RMD age,
- 4:51required minimum distributions at age 73, but they cost more then
- 4:56because you can't convert the RMD.
- 4:58So, they miss out on those great years in their 60s where they should be sort
- 5:02of dollar cost averaging or whatever you want to call it into a Roth a little at
- 5:08a time to use the brackets every year.
- 5:10Yeah, and of course, any of those conversions done at 62
- 5:13or earlier would also avoid any of those Medicare surcharges.
- 5:16A lot of people, once they reach 65, they go on Medicare, and Medicare, because
- 5:21our system is very complicated, and people like you and I need jobs, Ed.
- 5:24It looks back two years at your income.
- 5:26So if you are converting when you're 63, that can actually impact your
- 5:30Medicare premiums when you're 65, which a lot of people don't consider.
- 5:35So effectively, converting before 63 gets you out of that, no
- 5:40matter how high your income is.
- 5:42Right, but people don't look at that.
- 5:44You know, the Medicare surcharge item is one of the really tricky
- 5:48planning items for two reasons.
- 5:50The Medicare charges don't show up on your tax return, off the tax return,
- 5:55and the other item, very hard to plan with the two year look back.
- 5:59So what are some other areas behind, let's, let's move away from
- 6:02retirement accounts for a second.
- 6:04Anything else, because, you know, I know you're not sitting down doing returns for
- 6:08a lot of people anymore, but you spent decades, you know, preparing returns for
- 6:12folks, most of them in retirement, or at least many of them in retirement, What
- 6:17were some other mistakes that you saw that typically led individuals in retirement
- 6:21to pay more tax than they should?
- 6:22Not keeping track of basis.
- 6:24What I mean, non deductible contributions for years.
- 6:27Some people made non deductible contributions, and even before the law
- 6:31changed many years ago, had rollovers of after tax funds from company plans.
- 6:36They had What we call basis already tax money that they're not filing form 8606.
- 6:41That's a form you file to take credit for money you already paid tax on.
- 6:45So if you're just paying full tax on your distribution, in essence,
- 6:49for part of that, you're paying tax twice on the same money.
- 6:51Absolutely.
- 6:52You know, and I look at it, I think.
- 6:54Another area, if we shift away from retirement accounts for a second,
- 6:58a lot of people find themselves in that 0 percent long term capital
- 7:01gains bracket when they retire.
- 7:03Because it takes a lot of income now to, to, to be out of that, right?
- 7:07If we look at, let's say, a married couple and they're in
- 7:09retirement, they're probably over 65.
- 7:12So not only are they getting the standard deduction, they're getting
- 7:14the quote unquote additional standard deductions, which even today means
- 7:18they have well over a thirty-thousand dollar standard deduction.
- 7:22The 0 percent long term capital gains bracket is up to the 12 percent
- 7:28ordinary income tax rate, which today is about 95, 000 for married couples.
- 7:33So you put those two things together.
- 7:35What you find is a married couple, even if they have $125,000 of income
- 7:41in retirement, if they just take the standard deduction, they're still
- 7:45right at the top of that 0 percent long term capital gains bracket.
- 7:48And most retirees don't have $125,000 of income a year.
- 7:52Which means they're below that 0 percent threshold.
- 7:56For people listening, what I'm trying to get at here is if you're in a
- 8:000 percent long term capital gains bracket, you can sell your appreciated
- 8:05stocks and your brokerage account.
- 8:07Uh, and you might say, but Jeff, they've gone up in value.
- 8:10I like them that they've appreciated.
- 8:11That's why I like them so much.
- 8:12Fine.
- 8:13Then sell them and then.
- 8:15Wait, you know a day or so and buy them right back If you sell at the zero
- 8:20percent long term capital gains bracket, you're paying zero percent All right.
- 8:26I want to get back to the over over confidence because you left them hanging.
- 8:30Okay, but before that Just a warning on that 0 percent capital gains rate.
- 8:35Many people see it on the tax tables but don't get it because our
- 8:39tax system works in a funny way.
- 8:41Ordinary income gets taxed first and eats into that.
- 8:44That's right.
- 8:45So many people look at that and say, How come I didn't get the 0%?
- 8:50Yeah, so if you're thinking about, Hey, does this apply to me?
- 8:53What you really want to do is take all of your regular income, the amount of your
- 8:57social security that's taxable, your IRA distributions, your interest and whatnot.
- 9:02And then on top of that, Uh, you want to layer in how much in, in
- 9:05long term capital gains and, uh, qualified dividends do I have?
- 9:09And if total, those dollars are, for a married couple this year in 2024,
- 9:15below about $125,000, you can look specifically at your own standard
- 9:20deduction, et cetera, if you're over 65 or under 65, but about $125,000, if the
- 9:26total amount of that income is below, then those long term capital gains
- 9:30and qualified dividends will be at 0%.
- 9:32And worst case scenario, 15%.
- 9:34Not the worst thing in the world.
- 9:35Not the worst thing in the world, indeed.
- 9:37Alright, overconfidence, um, hanging on.
- 9:40I'm confident that I'm going to get there, but you did mention two other things.
- 9:43So I want to make sure that we don't leave listeners hanging on that.
- 9:45You mentioned beneficiary forms.
- 9:47I'll do it quickly and we'll cover it on another episode.
- 9:48People don't check beneficiary forms.
- 9:50All right, so do that.
- 9:51Worst mistakes ever.
- 9:51That'll be a separate, separate one.
- 9:53All right.
- 9:54Wrong people get the money.
- 9:55Uh, I'll tease you for a future episode.
- 9:58We just had a case where an ex girlfriend got over a million dollars
- 10:02and he broke up with her in 1989.
- 10:05All right?
- 10:06I'll leave you hanging on that one.
- 10:07And rollover mistakes.
- 10:08People don't know how to move money from one IRA to another and
- 10:11a lot of times it's the fault of the advisor or the institution
- 10:15where they just get bad advice.
- 10:16Oh, overconfidence.
- 10:17Alright, overconfidence.
- 10:18So, to me, overconfidence is probably the single biggest risk
- 10:23retirees face because there's so much you can be overconfident about.
- 10:27You can be overconfident about, you know, When you're going to retire, if we look at
- 10:31the research, people think they are often going to work longer than they will, so
- 10:34they factor in, you know, too many years of earnings, and then they get to that
- 10:38point, and they go, I guess I can't work anymore, or we're in another scenario
- 10:42where they're overconfident that the market will do really, really well, right?
- 10:46They say, Oh, my goodness, the market, it's just going to continue going this
- 10:49good forever, or they're overconfident that the market will not do well.
- 10:54Right.
- 10:54And they say it's just never gonna be the same.
- 10:56It's not like it was when I was a kid.
- 10:58There's so many things.
- 10:59The reality is None of us have any real clue what's going to happen in the future.
- 11:06So, for me, retirees who continuously monitor their plans, retirees who
- 11:13are open to the fact that they don't control everything, they can control
- 11:16their reactions to things, and they can, uh, Uh, they can continuously monitor
- 11:21things like interest rates and inflation and their spending and their health
- 11:26and make constant course corrections.
- 11:28Those are the individuals, I think, who do best of all, but anytime
- 11:33you're overconfident in any area, it seems to always come back
- 11:36and smack you in the face later.
- 11:38Well, except for Roth IRAs.
- 11:40I'm overconfident.
- 11:41That's the best single account to own.
- 11:43And with that
- 11:45With that, you, so, all right, well, With that, I was trying to end the program.
- 11:50Oh, well, all right, well, all right, I guess we're at
- 11:51the end of our program then.
- 11:53I was, uh, I was not as confident as you that we had reached
- 11:55the end of our program today.
- 11:57So, thank you all for joining us for yet another episode of
- 12:00The Great Retirement Debate.
- 12:01Ed, Always fun.
- 12:03Okay.
- 12:03Uh, I look forward to having our next discussion soon.
- 12:05Yep.
- 12:08Jeffrey Levine is Chief Planning Officer for Buckingham Wealth Partners.
- 12:11This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only and should
- 12:14not be construed as specific investment, accounting, legal, or tax advice.
- 12:17Certain information mentioned may be based on third party information
- 12:20which may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice.
- 12:23Third party information is deemed to be reliable but its accuracy and
- 12:26completeness cannot be guaranteed.
- 12:28The topic discussed in corresponding arguments are those of the speakers
- 12:31and may not accurately reflect those of Buckingham Wealth partners.