Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Adults with Severe Mental Illness and Additions in Elderly Care Facilities and Statement Admissibility
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for the latest with Barrister and Solicitor, with Mulligan Defene Lawyers Legally Speaking on CFAX with Michael Mulligan.
- 0:06Adam Stirling: Morning, Michael.
- 0:06Adam Stirling: How are we doing?
- 0:07Adam Stirling: Hey, good morning, I'm doing great.
- 0:09Adam Stirling: Always good to be here.
- 0:10Adam Stirling: Some interesting things on the agenda.
- 0:12Adam Stirling: First topic I see young adults with mental health and addictions placed in long-term care homes in Victoria and Nanaimo.
- 0:19Adam Stirling: I know this is something that's been in the news.
- 0:21Adam Stirling: What are your thoughts on this and the legal implications this is?
- 0:25Michael Mulligan: something that's been in the news.
- 0:26Michael Mulligan: What are your thoughts on this and the legal implications?
- 0:27Michael Mulligan: Sure, so the background of it involves reports of two long-term care facilities, which are intended for seniors who have complex long-term care requirements.
- 0:40Michael Mulligan: The government has apparently now for some time been placing young adults with serious mental health and often drug addiction issues in the same facilities on troubling behavior, including frequent drug use and weapons, alcohol and violence with respect to staff and others, and the concerns about that ought to be obvious ones.
- 1:17Michael Mulligan: But in terms of the legal circumstance, there are some special rights and protections that are intended to apply to residents in hospitals and other care facilities, and we do have in British Columbia a thing which is entitled the Residence Bill of Rights, and it has a number of sort of rights that I think most people would agree are sensible and good things.
- 1:42Michael Mulligan: They include, for example, an adult person or sort of their rights to things like safety and dignity, like an adult person has a right in care, to the protection and promotion of their health, safety and dignity, including the right to be a, to be treated in a manner and to live in an environment that promotes his or her health, safety and dignity.
- 2:08Michael Mulligan: So it seems like a pretty good thing among others.
- 2:13Michael Mulligan: And there's actually a legal requirement.
- 2:15Michael Mulligan: Those have a legal source, they're not just positive things to say, and indeed we have in British Columbia an act called the Hospital Act and that act actually makes it a legal requirement that that patient's Bill of Rights, including those rights to safety and dignity and so on, be prominently posted in places like hospitals and long-term care facilities like the ones we've been talking about.
- 2:43Michael Mulligan: The practical trouble is that when you have a, even if they tell you that you have a right, and even if I make it a legal requirement that that be prominently posted somewhere, there isn't much by way of an enforcement mechanism to ensure that those things are in fact going on.
- 2:58Michael Mulligan: And that's particularly a problem when we're dealing with facilities like these ones.
- 3:05Michael Mulligan: The two particular facilities one is called the Summit, which is in Victoria on Hillside Avenue, and there is another similar facility I think it's Dufferin Place or words to that effect up in Nanaimo and the population there.
- 3:19Michael Mulligan: When you look at who would be in, for example, the Summit in Victoria, look at who would be in, for example, the summit in Victoria.
- 3:28Michael Mulligan: It's a 320-bed facility and the average age of people that are there is 84.
- 3:30Michael Mulligan: And the people that are there are people that are dealing with sort of complex problems dementia and so forth, and it would seem to most people, I think, obvious that combining that with young adults who are suffering from mental health and drug addictions and so on is unlikely to be a very satisfactory state of affairs.
- 3:52Michael Mulligan: And based on the reports from staff, that clearly appears to be so.
- 3:57Michael Mulligan: One of the staff members has reported as talking to it, speaking of it as operating like a homeless shelter with no rules or specialized staffing to deal with drugs, weapons, alcohol and violence, and so combining those things seems like an awfully poor idea.
- 4:13Michael Mulligan: The trouble is that even if that might be in violation of that patient's bill of rights, which is required by the Hospital Act to be posted, best of luck to the on average 84-year-old person dealing with dementia to try to take any step to have that enforced.
- 4:29Michael Mulligan: And so that's the likely explanation as to why that's now been going on apparently for the past two years, and it's only been a result of staff members there reporting on that completely unsatisfactory state of affairs that there's now some movement to try to remedy the problem and in fact Island Health has posted a call for proposals for other facilities for people who are not seniors.
- 4:57Michael Mulligan: But that doesn't close until the middle of next month, and so hopefully something will occur that will have the desired effect, so that the residents of those kinds of facilities described as frail elderly aren't being housed in the same place where young adults dealing with serious drug addiction and mental illness are being placed.
- 5:19Michael Mulligan: No doubt they both need care right Not to minimize any of that, but you know, it's just a matter of whether it's appropriate to have those things combined, particularly where there aren't special controls to make sure that when you have young people who are suffering from those sort of problems aren't interfering with what is supposed to be a legal right to things like dignity and safety of the elderly population that are otherwise being helped there.
- 5:49Michael Mulligan: So clearly a problematic state of affairs.
- 5:53Michael Mulligan: It's fortunate that eventually it's come to light as a result of staff members speaking about it and hopefully there's some solution arrived there soon so that the Residence Bill of Rights, which is legally required to be prominently posted, actually has some meaning apart from simply posting it on the wall and hoping for the best.
- 6:14Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking.
- 6:17Adam Stirling: We'll take our first break here and return in just a moment Back on the air here at CFAX 1070,.
- 6:23Adam Stirling: Legally Speaking continues with Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 6:26Adam Stirling: Up next, shell casings from a 2001 murder conviction, tested with new DNA technology.
- 6:33Adam Stirling: What's happening?
- 6:34Michael Mulligan: Well, there's a lot going on here.
- 6:36Michael Mulligan: The background of this case it's a BC case and it involves a man who was, in 2001, convicted of murdering his then partner and it was a shooting.
- 6:45Michael Mulligan: In 2001, convicted of murdering his then partner and it was a shooting.
- 6:50Michael Mulligan: And the first interesting thing about the case is that the basis for the conviction was what's referred to as a Mr Big operation, and we've spoken about those a little bit in the past.
- 6:57Michael Mulligan: A Mr Big operation involvesa whole bunch of undercover police befriending the suspect and then eventually claiming to be part of a criminal organization where they try to lure the person into the fake organization.
- 7:12Michael Mulligan: Having them do things like transport bags of diamonds for money and do other things make the person feel important, and then eventually they say some version of this to the person.
- 7:22Michael Mulligan: They say look, if you want to be a part of our great, profitable criminal organization, we need to be able to know you, trust you, know we can trust you and so we need you to confess to committing a crime.
- 7:33Michael Mulligan: And then they managed to get the person undercover to confess to doing something and that becomes the evidence against them.
- 7:40Michael Mulligan: That's how they this man was convicted back in 2001.
- 7:44Michael Mulligan: Interestingly, those kinds of operations are prohibited in many countries, including the United States and Great Britain.
- 7:50Michael Mulligan: We allow them here, but since 2001,.
- 7:54Michael Mulligan: Rules have tightened up in terms of when those kinds of confessions can be used, because we've had multiple examples of where people who we eventually find out to be innocent wind up confessing because either they're afraid of the fictitious Mr Big or they want to be part of some group that's befriended them, and so we know it leads to false confessions, and so we've introduced some special rules about that.
- 8:18Michael Mulligan: So that was the basis.
- 8:20Michael Mulligan: The man was convicted.
- 8:21Michael Mulligan: But the other element of this case involved these shell casings from the murder weapon, and there was evidence that these matched a particular gun and there was also evidence that they had DNA on them.
- 8:32Michael Mulligan: But it wasn't possible with the technology that existed at the time and indeed the technology the RCMP still have now to analyze that DNA to figure out whose it was.
- 8:43Michael Mulligan: And this man?
- 8:45Michael Mulligan: After his jury conviction, he appealed it to the BC Court of Appeal, unsuccessfully.
- 8:50Michael Mulligan: It exhausted his appeals and you don't get to just go to the Supreme Court of Canada because you really want to.
- 8:56Michael Mulligan: They're only dealing with cases of national importance and this likely doesn't cut it.
- 9:00Michael Mulligan: And so this man was in prison for a very long time maintaining his innocence.
- 9:07Michael Mulligan: But one of the interesting things here is that there is a special section of the criminal code that allows a person to apply to the federal minister of justice and if the minister of justice can be set is satisfied that there is a reasonable basis to conclude that there was a miscarriage of justice, that that likely occurred reasonable basis to conclude that there was a miscarriage of justice, that that likely occurred the Minister of Justice has the power to direct the case back to the Court of Appeal for another hearing, which is very unusual.
- 9:34Michael Mulligan: Typically it's like you have your appeal, you lost, that's it right.
- 9:37Michael Mulligan: And so in this case, the Minister of Justice was persuaded that there is a likely miscarriage of justice that occurred.
- 9:48Michael Mulligan: In this case, one of the primary issues was the nature of the Mr B confession, but also there's the secondary issue with respect to the DNA found on the shell casings, and so the case is now back in the Court of Appeal for the second time as a result of that rare provision where the Minister of Justice can order a case back there for reconsideration.
- 10:11Michael Mulligan: And the most recent issue that the Court of Appeal was dealing with is the issue about these shell casings, because they were preserved and in fact recently they were tested and it's determined there is DNA on them.
- 10:23Michael Mulligan: They were tested and it's determined there is DNA on them, but the RCMP was unable to analyze it with the technology they have.
- 10:29Michael Mulligan: And so what has just occurred was an application to ask to have the DNA samples and the shell casings provided to BCIT, and BCIT has a more advanced type of DNA analysis so that they believe they're going to be able to extract DNA from the shell casings, which would be important evidence about whether somebody else might have committed the murder if their DNA is on the shell casings used to shoot the person.
- 11:00Michael Mulligan: And so that's just what's been ordered and we'll have to wait and see what the results of the analysis produce.
- 11:08Michael Mulligan: But I thought it was an interesting case because it has those elements of that Mr Big Confession and how that has changed over time, and also the element of advancements in DNA technology, which in fact now in multiple cases has been how it's been possible to determine that those Mr Big confessions are, on some occasions, completely wrong.
- 11:33Michael Mulligan: And so that's how we've exonerated multiple people who have confessed pursuant to that kind of an operation.
- 11:39Michael Mulligan: And now the law is that those kind of confessions in a Mr Big operation are presumptively not admissible unless the Crown can show things like there being corroborative evidence that would sort of support what the person said.
- 11:54Michael Mulligan: Like the person confessed and said, yes, I did it and I buried the murder weapon under the oak tree and they go and dig it up and, yes, it matches, that might still be admissible.
- 12:05Michael Mulligan: So for this man he's very fortunate that he's going to have another hearing in the Court of Appeal and fortunate as well that DNA technology has evolved and so we can see what BCIT is able to do with the shell casings and hopefully we can have some confidence we haven't imprisoned an innocent person for many years Indeed Our next story.
- 12:27Adam Stirling: an out-of-court statement, improperly relied upon a conviction, overturned what's happening.
- 12:33Michael Mulligan: So this is a brand new case out of the Supreme Court of Canada and the background of it is important for people to know, because this is a common misunderstanding with criminal cases is that criminal cases don't operate based on statements, things people write down.
- 12:52Michael Mulligan: Criminal cases operate presumptively on live witnesses showing up and testifying about what they saw or did and then being cross-examined.
- 13:00Michael Mulligan: It's not a matter of just handing the judge a bunch of letters or things that somebody might have said outside of court, and indeed things that witnesses said outside of court are presumptively not admissible, right?
- 13:13Michael Mulligan: We want people in court under oath answering questions, not just handing up a statement.
- 13:17Michael Mulligan: So this particular case it involved a circumstance in a school where there was a charge of assault with a weapon or using an imitation weapon it might have been a pellet gun where one student alleged that he was threatened with the pellet gun in the bathroom and that the pellet gun poked into his side right, and the accused was arrested along with another student.
- 13:43Michael Mulligan: That other student, after an hour or more of questioning by the police, eventually gave a statement to the police implicating the other student who was charged the accused right, he did it, and so forth, and the police eventually went and found a pellet gun.
- 13:59Michael Mulligan: Now flash forward to the trial.
- 14:01Michael Mulligan: At the trial, that student the one who provided this information to the police after an hour of questioning claimed that he didn't recall any of those things happening.
- 14:12Michael Mulligan: And so what the Crown tried to do or did do at trial is well, we want to use the person's statement.
- 14:18Michael Mulligan: Right, when they said that he saw the other boy do this with the pellet gun, we want to use that.
- 14:26Michael Mulligan: And in Canada there are some circumstances where an out-of-court statement can be used in a criminal case.
- 14:31Michael Mulligan: There are some things which are sort of enumerated common law exceptions to that general idea that the out-of-court statement can't be used.
- 14:39Michael Mulligan: We've spoken about some of those before.
- 14:41Michael Mulligan: They include things like a dying declaration, like if a person knows they're just about to die and they yell out you know, adam shot me.
- 14:48Michael Mulligan: Utterance might be admissible on the basis that why are you lying about that?
- 14:54Michael Mulligan: You know you're just about to die?
- 14:56Michael Mulligan: Yeah, maybe they really didn't like you.
- 14:57Michael Mulligan: That'd be a really awful prank.
- 14:59Michael Mulligan: That's a very, very bad prank.
- 15:01Michael Mulligan: Don't do that.
- 15:02Michael Mulligan: Uh, your final guess.
- 15:04Michael Mulligan: But there is a, a principled exception they call it to that.
- 15:08Michael Mulligan: Um, you know that idea.
- 15:11Michael Mulligan: You can't use that out of court statement.
- 15:12Michael Mulligan: But and that isn't one of the enumerated things there's also another exception called res gesti, like a person who immediately has asked something like hey, that bike's stolen.
- 15:23Michael Mulligan: Who immediately says without any thought no, it's not, I just bought it from Bob down there.
- 15:28Michael Mulligan: That might be usable as well, but there's also a generalized exception to that.
- 15:34Michael Mulligan: But there's also a generalized exception to that.
- 15:35Michael Mulligan: But one of the things that is required is to show that there is some circumstantial that.
- 15:40Michael Mulligan: First of all, it's necessary to use it.
- 15:41Michael Mulligan: Right, the statement like the person's dead, we can't bring them into court.
- 15:45Michael Mulligan: Or the person claims they can't remember what happened in the bathroom, right, that might qualify, because how else do we get that evidence?
- 15:51Michael Mulligan: But in order to use it, a judge also has to find that there's some circumstances surrounding what was said that would provide some evidence that it's reliable.
- 16:04Michael Mulligan: And so like, just like in the Mr Big example, let's say, somebody said something that nobody else would know unless you were there.
- 16:13Michael Mulligan: Right, you know, like, whatever something is confirmed in that way, that might be some circumstantial evidence of reliability.
- 16:21Michael Mulligan: Here, what the judge relied on, the trial judge relied on, was the fact that eventually there was a search and a pellet gun found.
- 16:29Michael Mulligan: Now, that was the basis upon which the judge said well, that's some evidence of reliability.
- 16:34Michael Mulligan: If it didn't happen this way, how could there be a pellet gun?
- 16:36Michael Mulligan: Right, and that even survived on appeal.
- 16:40Michael Mulligan: But by the time it got to the Supreme Court of Canada, the Supreme Court of Canada said that's not really evidence.
- 16:47Michael Mulligan: That would suggest that everything this person is saying about what happened in the bathroom is reliable.
- 16:53Michael Mulligan: Right, because, after all, there could still be a pellet gun, even if what happened in the bathroom was nothing like what that person claimed to the police happened.
- 17:01Michael Mulligan: Bearing in mind, of course, one of the issues for the police was like well, who was doing this?
- 17:05Michael Mulligan: You or the other guy?
- 17:06Michael Mulligan: Right, the theory was this person was involved with it, and so somebody in that circumstance would have all kinds of motivation to, for example, lie about what happened, to try to, you know, minimize things for themselves.
- 17:19Michael Mulligan: Right, it wasn't me, it was Bob with the pellet gun, right?
- 17:22Michael Mulligan: Yeah, you know, I was just standing there, I was telling him to stop.
- 17:26Michael Mulligan: And so the fact that you found the pellet gun, well, I guess it's sort of consistent with something having gone on.
- 17:34Michael Mulligan: It's not enough to confirm that what the person's saying is true.
- 17:39Michael Mulligan: It's not like the hold back evidence or dig under the tree or something else, which would necessarily mean that the whole version that's being given is accurate.
- 17:51Michael Mulligan: And so the Supreme Court of Canada here disagreed both with what the trial judge found and what the Court of Appeal found and said that in order to use this sort of a statement at trial, it's necessary that there be evidence which would provide some circumstantial reason to conclude that it's true, and just something in the statement which might match up with some physical thing.
- 18:18Michael Mulligan: Is not that?
- 18:21Michael Mulligan: Now, the other thing that's important to know about all of this and this goes to a common misunderstanding when I'm dealing with people involved with criminal cases is oftentimes people involved with the criminal justice system, because of course, when they're dealing with police, they're concerned about getting statements and writing out police reports and doing all of these sort of things.
- 18:40Michael Mulligan: Oftentimes people think, well, that's really what the judge is going to look at, and so people often have a misunderstanding of the import of those things, thinking, oh, it's that statement that's going to somehow count.
- 18:54Michael Mulligan: And people also have mistaken beliefs that, for example, a person could revoke their statement or withdraw it or do something like that, when that's not the basis upon which a criminal case would operate at all.
- 19:08Michael Mulligan: The criminal case will operate based on that person showing up as a witness, swearing to tell the truth and testifying in court.
- 19:16Michael Mulligan: And you can see things like a statement that a person gave to the police being referred to in court, but it's usually only being referred to in court if, for example, what the person claims happened is not consistent with what they told the police happened.
- 19:31Michael Mulligan: I see, you know, like if a teller at the bank robbery says you know, yes, the bank robber was six foot two, with blonde hair and blue eyes, and shows up a year later in court and says, yes, that's a bank robber over there.
- 19:44Michael Mulligan: He's five, five with brown hair and brown eyes.
- 19:46Michael Mulligan: Yeah, I see the cross-examination will be look, you gave a statement to the police.
- 19:50Michael Mulligan: Yes, you weren't lying to them.
- 19:51Michael Mulligan: No, you know this is your statement.
- 19:54Michael Mulligan: Yes, let's look at page two.
- 19:55Michael Mulligan: Here you say that the bank robber was six foot two, with blonde hair and blue eyes.
- 19:59Michael Mulligan: Is that correct?
- 19:59Michael Mulligan: Yes, that's right.
- 20:00Michael Mulligan: So not this man over here.
- 20:02Michael Mulligan: No, it's not that guy.
- 20:04Michael Mulligan: So you can see in court statements being used and they are relevant in criminal cases because they tell people you know what's that witness likely to say, but they're not themselves evidence, and so this case makes that clear and also makes clear that when you have some witness show up who would have a motivation to lie, as this person did, and claims, oh no, I have no memory of what I said previously to the police, you can't just fall back and say, well, let me just slide in a copy of what was said back then, unless there's some other thing you can point to.
- 20:42Michael Mulligan: To conclude yes, this is why we can rely upon that previous statement, and more is required than something in your statement seems to accord with some piece of physical evidence.
- 20:52Michael Mulligan: That's just not enough to accomplish that.
- 20:55Michael Mulligan: That's the latest from the Supreme Court of Canada.
- 20:57Michael Mulligan: The gun in the bathroom and why it is.
- 21:00Michael Mulligan: What's said in court is what matters, not what was written down in a statement to the police.
- 21:05Adam Stirling: Fascinating Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers during the second half of our second hour Every Thursday here on CFAX 1070,.
- 21:11Adam Stirling: I learn new things every week and I'm sure many members of our audience do as well.
- 21:15Adam Stirling: Michael, pleasure as always.
- 21:17Adam Stirling: Thank you so much.
- 21:18Adam Stirling: Always great to be here.
- 21:19Adam Stirling: All right.
- 21:20Michael Mulligan: Take care, talk to you next week.